burnout - uab · do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life ... retrieved...
TRANSCRIPT
Lauren Nassetta MD
RIME Workshop
September 18 2015
Define BURNOUT Understand why burnout is a problem Discuss risks for burnout
Define WELL-BEING Discuss ways to increase well-being Make a plan for practicing these
1 Urban dictionary 2 Maslach C Schaufeli W B amp Leiter M P (2001) Job
burnout Annu Rev Psychol 52 397-422 doi 101146annurevpsych521397
A A person who has smoked so much marijuana that they appear slow sluggish and stupid1
B The practice of keeping a vehicle stationary and spinning its wheels causing the tires to heat up and smoke due to friction
C Prolonged response to chronic emotional and interpersonal stressors on the job2
Prolonged response to chronic emotional and interpersonal stressors on the job
Defined by three dimensions
Maslach C Schaufeli W B amp Leiter M P (2001) Job burnout Annu Rev Psychol 52 397-422 doi 101146annurevpsych521397
exhaustion
cynicism inefficacy
burnout
SCORE
0 bull Never
1 bull A few times a year or less
2 bull Once a month or less
3 bull A few times a month
4 bull Once a week
5 bull A few times a week
6 bull Every day
3 COMPONENTS
1 Emotional Exhaustion
2 Depersonalization
3 Personal Accomplishment
EMOTIONAL EXHAUSTION
I feel emotionally drained from my work
Working with people all day is really a strain for me
I feel burned out from my
work
I feel frustrated by my job
I feel Irsquom working too hard on my job
Working with people directly
puts too much stress on me
I feel like Irsquom at the end of my rope
I feel used up at the end of
the workday
I feel fatigued when I get up
in the morning and have to face another day on the job
DEPERSONALIZATION
I feel I treat some patients as if they were impersonal objects
Irsquove become more callous toward people since I took
this job I worry that this job is
hardening me emotionally
I donrsquot really care what
happens to some patients
I feel patients blame me for some of their problems
PERSONAL ACCOMPLISHMENT
I deal very effectively with the problems of my patients
I feel Irsquom positively influencing other peoplersquos lives through my work
I feel very energetic I can easily create a relaxed
atmosphere with my patients
I feel exhilarated after working closely with my patients
I have accomplished many worthwhile things in this job
I can easily understand how my patients feel about things
In my work I deal with emotional problems very
calmly
2010 study of US Physicians vs general population1
May be increasing Physician Lifestyle Report2
2013 lt40
2015 46
Variable Phys Gen Pop
P value
Emotional Exhaustion scorege 27
319 234 lt0001
Depersonalization score ge 10
193 148 lt0001
1 Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
2 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Define BURNOUT Understand why burnout is a problem Discuss risks for burnout
Define WELL-BEING Discuss ways to increase well-being Make a plan for practicing these
1 Urban dictionary 2 Maslach C Schaufeli W B amp Leiter M P (2001) Job
burnout Annu Rev Psychol 52 397-422 doi 101146annurevpsych521397
A A person who has smoked so much marijuana that they appear slow sluggish and stupid1
B The practice of keeping a vehicle stationary and spinning its wheels causing the tires to heat up and smoke due to friction
C Prolonged response to chronic emotional and interpersonal stressors on the job2
Prolonged response to chronic emotional and interpersonal stressors on the job
Defined by three dimensions
Maslach C Schaufeli W B amp Leiter M P (2001) Job burnout Annu Rev Psychol 52 397-422 doi 101146annurevpsych521397
exhaustion
cynicism inefficacy
burnout
SCORE
0 bull Never
1 bull A few times a year or less
2 bull Once a month or less
3 bull A few times a month
4 bull Once a week
5 bull A few times a week
6 bull Every day
3 COMPONENTS
1 Emotional Exhaustion
2 Depersonalization
3 Personal Accomplishment
EMOTIONAL EXHAUSTION
I feel emotionally drained from my work
Working with people all day is really a strain for me
I feel burned out from my
work
I feel frustrated by my job
I feel Irsquom working too hard on my job
Working with people directly
puts too much stress on me
I feel like Irsquom at the end of my rope
I feel used up at the end of
the workday
I feel fatigued when I get up
in the morning and have to face another day on the job
DEPERSONALIZATION
I feel I treat some patients as if they were impersonal objects
Irsquove become more callous toward people since I took
this job I worry that this job is
hardening me emotionally
I donrsquot really care what
happens to some patients
I feel patients blame me for some of their problems
PERSONAL ACCOMPLISHMENT
I deal very effectively with the problems of my patients
I feel Irsquom positively influencing other peoplersquos lives through my work
I feel very energetic I can easily create a relaxed
atmosphere with my patients
I feel exhilarated after working closely with my patients
I have accomplished many worthwhile things in this job
I can easily understand how my patients feel about things
In my work I deal with emotional problems very
calmly
2010 study of US Physicians vs general population1
May be increasing Physician Lifestyle Report2
2013 lt40
2015 46
Variable Phys Gen Pop
P value
Emotional Exhaustion scorege 27
319 234 lt0001
Depersonalization score ge 10
193 148 lt0001
1 Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
2 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
1 Urban dictionary 2 Maslach C Schaufeli W B amp Leiter M P (2001) Job
burnout Annu Rev Psychol 52 397-422 doi 101146annurevpsych521397
A A person who has smoked so much marijuana that they appear slow sluggish and stupid1
B The practice of keeping a vehicle stationary and spinning its wheels causing the tires to heat up and smoke due to friction
C Prolonged response to chronic emotional and interpersonal stressors on the job2
Prolonged response to chronic emotional and interpersonal stressors on the job
Defined by three dimensions
Maslach C Schaufeli W B amp Leiter M P (2001) Job burnout Annu Rev Psychol 52 397-422 doi 101146annurevpsych521397
exhaustion
cynicism inefficacy
burnout
SCORE
0 bull Never
1 bull A few times a year or less
2 bull Once a month or less
3 bull A few times a month
4 bull Once a week
5 bull A few times a week
6 bull Every day
3 COMPONENTS
1 Emotional Exhaustion
2 Depersonalization
3 Personal Accomplishment
EMOTIONAL EXHAUSTION
I feel emotionally drained from my work
Working with people all day is really a strain for me
I feel burned out from my
work
I feel frustrated by my job
I feel Irsquom working too hard on my job
Working with people directly
puts too much stress on me
I feel like Irsquom at the end of my rope
I feel used up at the end of
the workday
I feel fatigued when I get up
in the morning and have to face another day on the job
DEPERSONALIZATION
I feel I treat some patients as if they were impersonal objects
Irsquove become more callous toward people since I took
this job I worry that this job is
hardening me emotionally
I donrsquot really care what
happens to some patients
I feel patients blame me for some of their problems
PERSONAL ACCOMPLISHMENT
I deal very effectively with the problems of my patients
I feel Irsquom positively influencing other peoplersquos lives through my work
I feel very energetic I can easily create a relaxed
atmosphere with my patients
I feel exhilarated after working closely with my patients
I have accomplished many worthwhile things in this job
I can easily understand how my patients feel about things
In my work I deal with emotional problems very
calmly
2010 study of US Physicians vs general population1
May be increasing Physician Lifestyle Report2
2013 lt40
2015 46
Variable Phys Gen Pop
P value
Emotional Exhaustion scorege 27
319 234 lt0001
Depersonalization score ge 10
193 148 lt0001
1 Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
2 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Prolonged response to chronic emotional and interpersonal stressors on the job
Defined by three dimensions
Maslach C Schaufeli W B amp Leiter M P (2001) Job burnout Annu Rev Psychol 52 397-422 doi 101146annurevpsych521397
exhaustion
cynicism inefficacy
burnout
SCORE
0 bull Never
1 bull A few times a year or less
2 bull Once a month or less
3 bull A few times a month
4 bull Once a week
5 bull A few times a week
6 bull Every day
3 COMPONENTS
1 Emotional Exhaustion
2 Depersonalization
3 Personal Accomplishment
EMOTIONAL EXHAUSTION
I feel emotionally drained from my work
Working with people all day is really a strain for me
I feel burned out from my
work
I feel frustrated by my job
I feel Irsquom working too hard on my job
Working with people directly
puts too much stress on me
I feel like Irsquom at the end of my rope
I feel used up at the end of
the workday
I feel fatigued when I get up
in the morning and have to face another day on the job
DEPERSONALIZATION
I feel I treat some patients as if they were impersonal objects
Irsquove become more callous toward people since I took
this job I worry that this job is
hardening me emotionally
I donrsquot really care what
happens to some patients
I feel patients blame me for some of their problems
PERSONAL ACCOMPLISHMENT
I deal very effectively with the problems of my patients
I feel Irsquom positively influencing other peoplersquos lives through my work
I feel very energetic I can easily create a relaxed
atmosphere with my patients
I feel exhilarated after working closely with my patients
I have accomplished many worthwhile things in this job
I can easily understand how my patients feel about things
In my work I deal with emotional problems very
calmly
2010 study of US Physicians vs general population1
May be increasing Physician Lifestyle Report2
2013 lt40
2015 46
Variable Phys Gen Pop
P value
Emotional Exhaustion scorege 27
319 234 lt0001
Depersonalization score ge 10
193 148 lt0001
1 Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
2 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
SCORE
0 bull Never
1 bull A few times a year or less
2 bull Once a month or less
3 bull A few times a month
4 bull Once a week
5 bull A few times a week
6 bull Every day
3 COMPONENTS
1 Emotional Exhaustion
2 Depersonalization
3 Personal Accomplishment
EMOTIONAL EXHAUSTION
I feel emotionally drained from my work
Working with people all day is really a strain for me
I feel burned out from my
work
I feel frustrated by my job
I feel Irsquom working too hard on my job
Working with people directly
puts too much stress on me
I feel like Irsquom at the end of my rope
I feel used up at the end of
the workday
I feel fatigued when I get up
in the morning and have to face another day on the job
DEPERSONALIZATION
I feel I treat some patients as if they were impersonal objects
Irsquove become more callous toward people since I took
this job I worry that this job is
hardening me emotionally
I donrsquot really care what
happens to some patients
I feel patients blame me for some of their problems
PERSONAL ACCOMPLISHMENT
I deal very effectively with the problems of my patients
I feel Irsquom positively influencing other peoplersquos lives through my work
I feel very energetic I can easily create a relaxed
atmosphere with my patients
I feel exhilarated after working closely with my patients
I have accomplished many worthwhile things in this job
I can easily understand how my patients feel about things
In my work I deal with emotional problems very
calmly
2010 study of US Physicians vs general population1
May be increasing Physician Lifestyle Report2
2013 lt40
2015 46
Variable Phys Gen Pop
P value
Emotional Exhaustion scorege 27
319 234 lt0001
Depersonalization score ge 10
193 148 lt0001
1 Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
2 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
EMOTIONAL EXHAUSTION
I feel emotionally drained from my work
Working with people all day is really a strain for me
I feel burned out from my
work
I feel frustrated by my job
I feel Irsquom working too hard on my job
Working with people directly
puts too much stress on me
I feel like Irsquom at the end of my rope
I feel used up at the end of
the workday
I feel fatigued when I get up
in the morning and have to face another day on the job
DEPERSONALIZATION
I feel I treat some patients as if they were impersonal objects
Irsquove become more callous toward people since I took
this job I worry that this job is
hardening me emotionally
I donrsquot really care what
happens to some patients
I feel patients blame me for some of their problems
PERSONAL ACCOMPLISHMENT
I deal very effectively with the problems of my patients
I feel Irsquom positively influencing other peoplersquos lives through my work
I feel very energetic I can easily create a relaxed
atmosphere with my patients
I feel exhilarated after working closely with my patients
I have accomplished many worthwhile things in this job
I can easily understand how my patients feel about things
In my work I deal with emotional problems very
calmly
2010 study of US Physicians vs general population1
May be increasing Physician Lifestyle Report2
2013 lt40
2015 46
Variable Phys Gen Pop
P value
Emotional Exhaustion scorege 27
319 234 lt0001
Depersonalization score ge 10
193 148 lt0001
1 Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
2 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
2010 study of US Physicians vs general population1
May be increasing Physician Lifestyle Report2
2013 lt40
2015 46
Variable Phys Gen Pop
P value
Emotional Exhaustion scorege 27
319 234 lt0001
Depersonalization score ge 10
193 148 lt0001
1 Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
2 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Medscape Pediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 330 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
43
51
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Burnout
Men
Women
Consistent with national survey data1
Different2
Men more depersonalization
Women more emotional exhaustion
1 Medscape Physician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved 827 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015publicoverview
2 Houkes I Winants Y Twellaar M amp Verdonk P (2011) Development of burnout over time and the causal order of the three dimensions of burnout among male and female GPs A three-wave panel study BMC Public Health 11 240-240 doi 1011861471-2458-11-240
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
UAB 2nd Year Pediatrics and Med-Peds Residents
MBI
21 respondents (84)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50 30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization 3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48 36 4 (19)
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Variable Min-Max
Median
of ldquohighrdquo scores (EEge27 DPge10 PA le30)
Gen pop1
Emotional Exhaustion
14-50
30 14 (67)
234
Depersonalization
3-28 11 14 (67)
148
Personal Accomplishment
21-48
36 4 (19)
ldquoHigh Scoresrdquo
81 had at least 1 (only 4 people with none)
6 with 1 and 7 with 2
4 with all 3 Anyone with a ldquohighrdquo
score in PA also ldquohighrdquo in other 2
1Shanafelt T D Boone S Tan L amp et al (2012) Burnout and satisfaction with work-life balance among us physicians relative to the general us population Archives of Internal Medicine 172(18)
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Physicians residents amp nurses affected by burnout are more prone to
Substance misuse12
Depression13
Insomnia14
High rates of suicidal thoughts156
1 Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General Survey Factorial
validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout Research 1(3) 2 Oreskovich MR Kaups KL Balch CM et al Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorders Among American Surgeons Arch
Surg2012147(2)168-174 doi101001archsurg20111481 3 Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-
wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043 4 Vela-Bueno A Moreno-Jimeacutenez B Rodriacuteguez-Muntildeoz A Olavarrieta-Bernardino S Fernaacutendez-Mendoza J De la Cruz-Troca
JJ Bixler EO Vgontzas AN Insomnia and sleep quality among primary care physicians with low and high burnout levels J Psychosom Res 2008 Apr64(4)435-42 doi 101016jjpsychores200710014
5 Shanafelt TD Balch CM Dyrbye L Bechamps G Russell T Satele D Rummans T Swartz K Novotny PJ Sloan J Oreskovich MR Special report suicidal ideation among American surgeons Arch Surg 2011 Jan146(1)54-62 doi 101001archsurg2010292
6 van der Heijden F Dillingh G Bakker A Prins J Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout Arch Suicide Res 200812(4)344-6 doi 10108013811110802325349
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Negative impact on hospital performance
Increased turnover
Absenteeism
Early retirement intentions
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Leiter amp Maslach 2009) (Davey Cummings Newburn-Cook amp Lo 2009) (Linzer et al 2001)
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Negative impact on patient care itself
Burnout predicts suboptimal care behaviors
Serious medical errors
Across a single long-call shift
Bria M Spacircnu F Băban A amp Dumitraşcu D L (2014) Maslach Burnout Inventory ndash General
Survey Factorial validity and invariance among Romanian healthcare professionals Burnout
Research 1(3) (Shanafelt Bradley Wipf amp Back 2002) (Shanafelt et al 2010) (Lebensohn P 2013)
Stress amp Burnout
Empathy
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Burnout Depressive Symptoms
Hakanen JJ Schaufeli WB Do burnout and work engagement predict depressive symptoms and life satisfaction A three-wave seven-year prospective study J Affect Disord 2012 Dec 10141(2-3)415-24 doi 101016jjad201202043
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
How big of a problem
Over 400 Physicians commit suicide every
year1
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health reported 476 in 20112
1 Andrew L B (2014 July 17 2014) Physician Suicide Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpemedicinemedscapecomarticle806779-overview 2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from
httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
How does that compare Doctors are 187 times more likely to
commit suicide1 Suicide accounts for
About 2 of all deaths amongst the general US population2
4 of all physician deaths
1 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
2 GLOOM Top 11 Professions with Highest Suicide Rates Mental Health Daily Retrieved March 30 2015 from httpmentalhealthdailycom20150106top-11-professions-with-highest-suicide-rates
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Men or women Male physicians more than 40 higher than
the general population1
Women physicians 130 higher than the general population
278 times higher than average2
1 Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
2 Lubin G (2011 Oct 18 2011) The 19 Jobs Where Youre Most Likely to Kill Yourself Business Insider Retrieved March 31 2015 from httpwwwbusinessinsidercommost-suicidal-occupations-2011-10op=1
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Medical students
ldquoCompassion lossrdquo
Depression rates 20-301
Anxiety and burnout rates gt50
1 Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting]
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Medical students Continues into residency
Burnout rates 60-75 and higher
Depression up to 252
Lebensohn P Dodds S Benn R Brooks AJ Birch M Cook P Schneider C Sroka S Waxman D Maizes V Resident wellness behaviors relationship to stress depression and burnout Fam Med 2013 Sep45(8)541-9
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Burnout
Depression and suicide
1 Medscape survey 2015
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Medical students Continues into residency Practicing Physicians
Pediatricians
67 would choose a medical career again
51 would choose own specialty
18 would choose same practice setting
1 MedscapePediatrician Lifestyle Report 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 from httpwwwmedscapecomfeaturesslideshowlifestyle2015pediatrics1
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Web-based survey 2006-2007
UAB was one of the 7 schools
Asked about
Suicidal ideationmdash3 specific questions
BurnoutmdashMaslach
DepressionmdashPrimary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders
2248 (524) medical students responded
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Suicide
112 considered in the last year [CI 99 to 126] n=249)
69 among 25- to 34-year-olds in general US population
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Suicide
1 of 9 students
Burnout
496 met the criteria for burnout ([CI 475ndash518] n=1069)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
More likely to report SI if they had
Burnout (odds ratio 346 [CI 255 to 469] P 0001)
High emotional exhaustion (odds ratio 317 [CI 239 to 419] P 0001)
High depersonalization (odds ratio 210 [CI 159 to 277] P 0001)
Low sense of personal accomplishment (odds ratio 203 [CI 153 to 268] P 0001)
Dyrbye L N Thomas M R Massie F S Power D V Eacker A Harper W Shanafelt T D (2008) Burnout and suicidal ideation among US medical students Ann Intern Med 149(5) 334-341
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Are there factors that are protective
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
BURN-OUT
External Internal
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
What are some causes of burnout among trainees
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Scale of 0 (not at all important) to 7 (extremely important)
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Rates differ by specialty
Culturemdashprotective
Age plusmn
Family plusmn
Duty hours plusmn
IsHak WW Lederer S Mandili C et al Burnout During Residency Training A Literature Review Journal of Graduate Medical Education 20091(2)236-242 doi104300JGME-D-09-000541
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Survey of IM Residents Burnout and Achievement of
US-DHHS physical activity guidelines
Residents who met guidelines were less likely to be burned out OR 038 95 CI 0147-099
Higher BMI associated with increased burnout (OR 119 95CI 101-141)
Olson SM Odo NU Duran AM Pereira AG Mandel JH Burnout and Physical Activity in Minnesota Internal Medicine Resident Physicians J Grad Med Educ 2014 Dec6(4)669-74 doi 104300JGME-D-13-00396
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
4
16
50
30
3
24
3
17
48
32
3
23
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
gt2 DrinksDaily
1-2 DrinksDaily
lt1 DrinkDaily
Dont Drink Usedmarijuanathis past
year
Usedmarijuana
ever
Burnout No Burnout
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Good newshellip
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Program designed to reduce unnecessary stressors and increase studentsrsquo ability to deal with stress
Began a resiliency and mindfulness curriculum
Over 5 years saw a decrease in both mod-severe depression symptoms and mod-severe anxiety symptoms of MS1 and MS2 students
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Improved mean depression scores
Burnout and anxiety
Pre-change Post-change P Value
Emotional
Exhaustion 296 218 01
Depersonalization 102 64 lt01
Anxiety 506 428 lt01
Slavin S (2015 31315) [Flourishing in Times of Change Keynote Address COMSEP Meeting] Slavin S J Schindler D L amp Chibnall J T (2014) Medical student mental health 30 improving student wellness through curricular changes Acad Med 89(4) 573-577 doi 101097acm0000000000000166
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Your Body Language Shapes Who You Are | Amy Cuddy | TED Talks httpsyoutubeKs-_Mh1QhMc
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Well-being
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Is a real thing
Has particular elements
Can be attained
Can be learned
Gazelle G Liebschutz J M amp Riess H (2015) Physician Burnout Coaching a Way Out Journal of General Internal Medicine 30(4) 508-513 doi 101007s11606-014-3144-y
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
httpfocustreatmentcenterscomwp-contentuploads201503oxygen_mask_png
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
BURN-OUT
External Internal
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
WELL-BEING
External Internal
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
ldquoHappiness may be an unavoidable side effect
of cultivating emotional intelligence
Other side effects may include resilience
optimism and kindnessrdquo
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Paying attention in a particular way on purpose in the present moment and nonjudgmentally
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
The first component of mindfulness involves the self-regulation of attention so it is maintained on immediate experience
The second component involves adopting a particular orientation toward onersquos experiences in the present moment an orientation that is characterized by curiosity openness and acceptance
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Informal practice
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
How to cultivate
Formal practice
Meditation
Take one breath a day
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
How to cultivate
Informal practice
Door handle
Other-directed
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Empathy increases with perceived similarity
Create desired mental habits
Formal ldquoJust Like Merdquo and ldquoLoving Kindnessrdquo Meditation
Every time you see another person you wish for that person to be happy Becomes a mental habit
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Strength in self-awareness
Strength in empathy
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness Empathy
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Kindness drives empathy Empathy helps build
trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Kindness drives empathy
Empathy helps build trust
Trust builds relationships and teams
Build trust
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Trust begets trust Tan C-M (2014) Search Inside Yourself The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success Happiness (and World Peace) HarperCollins
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Be Kind for everyone you meet is involved in a great struggle
Practice giving people the benefit of the doubt
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Kindness is a sustainable source of happiness
Kindness exercise 1 Find one unexpected and
kind thing to do tomorrow and just do it
2 Notice what happens to your mood
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
htt
p
ww
wh
om
esb
yoys
ter
cou
kim
age
envi
ron
men
ten
viro
nm
ent_
sust
ain
able
_so
urc
esj
pg
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
When we feel love and kindness toward others it not only makes others feel loved and cared for but it helps us also to develop inner happiness and peace
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Happiness
Life satisfaction
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Cultivate positive emotions
Three good things
Gratitude letters
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and Hope
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Cultivate positive emotions
Practice forgiveness
Optimism and hope
Maximizing Happiness
is an individual Choice Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Maslach amp Leiter defined the antithesis of
burnout as Engagement
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Engagement bull Energy
bull Involvement
bull Efficacy
Burnout bull Exhaustion
bull Cynicism
bull Inefficacy
Maslach C amp Leiter MP The truth about burnout New York Jossey-Bass 1997 Bakker et al (2014) in [[Burnout and Work Engagement The JDndashR Approach]] makes the same argument as Leiter
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
Kindness
Empathy
Trust
Team
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Meaning
Belonging to and serving something bigger than the self
Purpose
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
work life
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Take a few minutes to write it on your paper Letrsquos discuss if you are comfortable sharing
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
End each day with what-went-well
and why
End rounds with WWW
or ldquoSomething I did well todayrdquo
Seligman M E P (2011) Flourish A visionary new understanding of happiness and well-being NY Atria
Positive Emotion Engagement Positive
Relationships Meaning Accomplishment
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
the ability of something to return to its original shape after it has been pulled stretched pressed bent etc
the ability to become strong healthy or successful again after something bad happens
httpwwwmerriam-webstercomdictionaryresilience
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
Creates isolation decreases accomplishment
Can be minimalized
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
1 Negativity bias
2 Maladaptive perfectionism
3 Imposter syndrome
4 Learned helplessness
httpwwwintegratedsociopsychologynetwpimageswp13376ff2_1apng
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
Requires
Metacognition and
Cognitive restructuring Understand threats and minimalize them
Emotional self-regulation
Grocery store line
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
LEARNING POINTS
Burnout is bad
We can prevent burnout
Happiness is a choice
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ
There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older
fish swimming the other way who nods at them and says Morning boys Hows the
water And the two young fish swim on for a bit and then eventually one of them
looks over at the other and goes
What the hell is waterldquo hellipthere are all different kinds of freedom and the kind that is most precious you will
not hear much talked about in the great outside world of winning and achieving and
displaying The really important kind of freedom involves attention and awareness
and discipline and effort and being able truly to care about other people and to
sacrifice for them over and over in myriad petty little unsexy ways every day That
is real freedom The alternative is unconsciousness the default-setting the ldquorat
racerdquo mdash the constant gnawing sense of having had and lost some infinite thing It is
about simple awareness mdash awareness of what is so real and essential so hidden in
plain sight all around us that we have to keep reminding ourselves over and over
ldquoThis is water this is waterrdquo httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=IYGaXzJGVAQ