bright future for pumped storage in the u.s..pdf
TRANSCRIPT
-
HYDRO REVIEW
A (Potentially) Bright Future for Pumped Storage in the U.S.
12/05/2014
Home Hydro Project Activity Pumped Storage Hydro A (Potentially) Bright Future for
Pumped Storage in the U.S.
EDITORIAL GUIDES
VIDEO
WEBCAST
WHITEPAPERS
MAGAZINE
BUYERS GUIDE
HOME
HYDRO PROJECT ACTIVITY
WORLD REGIONS
TECHNOLOGY / EQUIPMENT
DAMS / CIVIL STRUCTURES
REGULATION / POLICY
ENVIRONMENTAL
PREMIUM CONTENT
Page 1 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
There is a lot of potential for pumped-storage development in the U.S. What will it
take to get construction of this valuable generating resource moving forward again?
By Elizabeth Ingram
There's no doubt that pumped-storage hydropower is a valuable resource in the
U.S. These facilities are ideal to store energy from and balance intermittent
renewables, such as wind and solar, providing stability and flexibility to the
transmission grid. In fact, in 2012, data from EPRI indicates pumped-storage
hydropower accounted for more than 99% of bulk storage capacity worldwide, about
127,000 MW.
However, it's also an undeniable fact that there has been little new development in
this field in the U.S. in the past two decades, which seems to indicate the
atmosphere is not favorable for encouraging construction of pumped-storage
facilities. But this may be about to change. There has been a stirring of movement
lately, primarily on the regulatory side, with regard to pumped-storage hydro in the
U.S.
This article analyzes the activity to date and provides some insight into the
(potentially) bright future of this valuable generating resource.
Background on pumped storage
My research indicates the first use of pumped-storage units in the U.S. was in 1930
by Connecticut Electric and Power Co., pumping water from the Houstatonic River.
This technology actually dates to much earlier outside the U.S., with pumped
storage first being installed in the 1890s in Italy and Switzerland, according to EPRI.
Page 2 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
The heyday of this technology in the U.S. appears to be the 1960s and 1970s, with
facilities going on line in California, Colorado, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri,
New York, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia. The
3,003-MW Bath County facility, which was completed in 1985 in Virginia, is the
largest pumped-storage plant in terms of generating capacity in the world.
It seems that the most recently completed pumped-storage project in the U.S. is the
40-MW Lake Hodges plant, built by the San Diego County Water Authority
(SDCWA) at the existing Olivenhain Reservoir and completed in September 2012.
(For more on this project, see the sidebar on page 14.) However, before that it had
been more than 15 years since such a project was completed, that one being the
1,035-MW Rocky Mountain facility in Georgia, owned by Oglethorpe Power Corp.,
which began operating in 1995.
According to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), there are a 24
operating pumped-storage projects under its jurisdiction, with a total installed
capacity of about 16,500 MW. Only one of these projects was authorized in the past
30 years.
The Energy Storage Association reports that the 40 total pumped-storage facilities
operating in the U.S. provide more than 20,000 GW of capacity, or nearly 2% of the
country's electrical supply system. While these numbers may sound good, compare
the shares in Europe (nearly 5%) and Japan (about 10%). It is clear we have a long
way to go in the U.S.
However, the number of pumped-storage projects in the U.S. looks set to jump
considerably. FERC says there are about 50 active preliminary permits for these
projects, representing more than 37,000 MW of capacity. And while only a third of
the operating projects under FERC's jurisdiction are located west of the Mississippi
River, more than 80% of the preliminary permits are located west of the Mississippi,
where the majority of existing and proposed solar and wind generation is located.
The majority of the recently proposed pumped-storage projects would employ a
closed-loop system, FERC says. These projects are not continuously connected to a
naturally flowing water feature. (At this time, only one of the constructed projects
under FERC jurisdiction is closed loop.) In addition, many of the proposed projects
would use variable-speed pump-turbines that would allow for more flexible operation
than the current fleet.
What is behind the resurgent interest in pumped storage in the U.S.? According to
Debbie Mursch, chair of NHA's Pumped Storage Development Council, "Policy
Page 3 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
makers are finally realizing that we can't continue to increase the amount of
intermittent generation while at the same time removing baseload nuclear and coal
plants and not consider the need for grid-scale storage." The council was
established to provide a platform for the industry to keep abreast of the latest
developments in pumped storage, be it legislative, new technology, policy or global
trends. The council also aims to educate policy-makers and the public on the
benefits of pumped storage.
The two pump-turbines in the powerhouse of the 40-MW Lake Hodges
pumped-storage project began operating in 2012. (Courtesy San Diego County
Water Authority)
Perhaps the greatest quality of pumped storage is that it is the only commercially
proven technology available for both grid-scale energy storage and power
generation, Mursch says. Developing additional pumped storage, particularly in
areas with recently increased wind and solar capacity, would significantly improve
grid reliability while reducing the need for construction of additional fossil-fueled
generation. Grid-scale storage also could reduce the amount of new transmission
required to support many states' RPS goals, Mursch says.
Utilizing pumped-storage projects also allows utilities to follow load and respond to
rapid changes in demand for power on the grid using a non-emitting resources, as
opposed to fossil-fuel-fired units, Mursch says. This allows the utilities to run their
fossil units more efficiently and reduces carbon emissions output from these plants.
New development in the offing
There has been much recent activity through FERC with regard to proposed new
pumped-storage facilities.
Page 4 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
For example, FERC authorized construction of the 400-MW Iowa Hill pumped-
storage development as part of its August relicensing of the 637.3-MW Upper
American River project in California. Iowa Hill is to be an off-stream plant that pumps
water from the existing Slab Creek Reservoir into the new Iowa Hill Reservoir. The
powerhouse will contain three 133-MW pump-turbine units.
Many companies are involved in development of this project, including AF-Consult
of Switzerland; AMEC in London; Ascent Environmental in Sacramento, Calif.;
Carlton Engineering in Folsom, Calif.; Crux Subsurface in Henderson, Nev.; Foxfire
Constructors in San Clemente, Calif.; GEI Consultants in Woburn, Mass.; HDR
Engineering in Omaha, IEC Corporation in Sacramento; Jacobs Associates in San
Francisco, Calif.; Northwest Hydraulic Consultants in Vancouver, British Columbia,
Canada, and Stillwater Sciences in Berkeley, Calif.
In addition, FERC issued a license to the 1,300-MW Eagle Mountain pumped-
storage project in June, authorizing Eagle Crest Energy to build the project at the
site of an inactive iron mine in Riverside County, Calif. There will be a head of 1,400
feet between the reservoirs, created by adding saddle dams and liners to two
abandoned mining pits. GEI Consultants, a developing partner in the project, says
Eagle Mountain will be an "integral component of California's renewable energy
policies and its goals for reduction of greenhouse gas emissions."
The primary environmental issues associated with the project are effects of its
construction and operation on groundwater, water quality and terrestrial species
(including several sensitive bat species, the desert bighorn sheep and threatened
desert tortoise). Groundwater will be pumped from a series of proposed wells in the
Chuckwalla Basin to fill the reservoirs and replace water lost to evaporation.
With California seemingly at the epicenter of the interest in pumped-storage
development, it's not surprising I am reporting on interest in developing a third
project in the state. SDCWA is looking into adding a 500-MW pumped-storage plant
near its San Vicente Dam following the closure of the 2,200-MW San Onofre nuclear
power plant. SDCWA recently raised the dam, adding 152,000 acre-feet of water
storage capacity to the reservoir.
Another state where we're seeing interest in pumped storage is Hawaii. In August,
Paniolo Power Co. LLC announced it planned to issue a request for qualifications
seeking an engineering-procurement-construction contractor to develop a pumped-
storage project on Parker Ranch. Capacity of this project could range from 10 MW
to as much as 200 MW. The energy developer said pumped storage would allow
wind and solar energy that otherwise would be curtailed to be used to pump water
Page 5 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
that would then be released in the evening to meet peak loads being served by
expensive oil-fired generation.
Also in Hawaii, the Kauai Island Utility Cooperative is pursuing a pumped-storage
project to be located on state land on Kauai's west site. The co-op has obtained
access to two potential sites that will allow it to conduct technical studies.
Moving this development forward
FERC says good siting and consultation, as well as filing of a complete application
that addresses stakeholder concerns, are key to expediting the licensing process.
On its website, the commission has state-specific lists of potential stakeholders to
consult as a starting point. Developers should also consult with other site-specific
interested entities, FERC says. Early consultation with key stakeholders on potential
environmental impacts and other concerns, in addition to technical site evaluation,
will facilitate optimal site selection. Continued consultation on study needs and
conduct of needed studies is essential, FERC adds. Should a developer not agree
on a study after earnest negotiations with stakeholders, the pre-filing dispute
resolution process should be used, rather than taking the chance on an inadequate
application, which can delay the post-filing application process.
FERC also encourages developers to contact commission staff before filing a notice
of intent to file an application and a preliminary application document to discuss
process selection and FERC resources that may be helpful to them.
The Pumped Storage Development Council issued a whitepaper on Challenges and
Opportunities for New Pumped Storage Development. This whitepaper cites the
need for grid reliability in the U.S., provided by reliable, affordable and grid-scale
energy storage: hydropower pumped storage. With the tremendous growth of wind
and solar generation in the past decade, the grid is affected by the variability of this
supply. The whitepaper also says that "current market structures and regulatory
frameworks do not present an effective means of achieving this goal." NHA's key
policy recommendations are:
Create market products that allow flexible resources to provide services that
help meet electric grid requirements, including fast-responding systems that
provide critical capacity during key energy need periods;
Level the policy playing field for pumped storage hydropower with other
storage technologies to encourage the development and deployment of all
energy storage technologies;
Page 6 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
Recognize the regional differences within the U.S. generation portfolio and the
unique roles energy storage technologies play in different regions;
Recognize the energy security role pumped storage hydropower plays in the
domestic electric grid;
Establish an alternative, streamlined licensing process for low-impact pumped
storage hydropower, such as off-channel or closed-loop projects;
Improve integration of federal and state agencies into the early stage licensing
processes for pumped storage hydro; and
Facilitate an energy market structure where transmission providers benefit
from long-term agreements with energy storage facility developers.
NHA says the barriers that prevent new pumped storage from being developed are
slowly being recognized and reduced and/or removed. For example, Mursch says,
there is a lack of markets to fairly compensate pumped storage for the many
electrical benefits it brings to the grid. The U.S. Department of Energy recently
provided funding to Argonne National Laboratory to model/quantify these benefits.
Argonne is leading a team that is seeking to provide a comprehensive study of the
technical and market operations, economics and value of conventional hydro and
pumped-storage plants for power system operation, including their role in
accommodating a larger share of variable renewable energy sources.
Another example is the time it takes to get a project licensed as compared with other
technologies. NHA says gas plants can be licensed in fewer than two years, while
pumped storage may take five to six years. Many developers today are considering
closed-loop systems because they are more environmentally benign and FERC is
looking to reduce licensing time for these facilities to two years, as mandated in the
Hydropower Regulatory Efficiency Act of 2013.
Conclusion
"I believe the time is now or never that new pumped-storage plants will be built,"
Mursch says. With the need for grid-scale storage being greater than ever and
barriers to development slowly being removed, pumped storage's time has finally
come in the U.S., she says.
Even the U.S. Department of Energy is getting in on the act with its Hydropower
Vision plan. As part of this plan, DOE will issue a report that seeks to answer a
number of questions regarding the current state and future of hydroelectric power in
the U.S., among these how pumped-storage projects factor into America's energy
mix.
Page 7 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
***************
Pumped storage in Canada
The landscape for pumped-storage development in Canada is different from that in
the U.S. because Canada still has significant untapped potential for conventional
hydro development.
But, there has been some recent interest in bringing pumped storage to Canada.
For example, Northland Power, based in Toronto, proposes a 00 million project,
called Marmora, that would use an abandoned open-pit mine to provide a capacity
of 400 MW. The company would build a new upper reservoir for this facility, and the
powerhouse would be equipped with Francis pump-turbine units.
***************
A story of modern-day development
Development of the 40-MW Lake Hodges pumped-storage project was
accomplished at a time when new projects of this type simply were not being
brought on line in the U.S. So development of this facility was both a challenge and
an achievement for the San Diego County Water Authority in California, says Frank
Belock, deputy general manager.
Olivenhain Reservoir was impounded in 2003 as part of SDCWA's Emergency
Storage Project to protect the region from severe water supply shortages. Lake
Hodges sits 770 feet lower in elevation, leading SDCWA to decide in 2002 to add
generating capability to the pumping station that was already being designed. From
the time the pumped-storage component was included in the scope of work until the
generating station was completed, 10 years elapsed, Belock says.
The bottom line benefit in adding this pumped-storage component was estimated to
be $2 million to $3 million in annual revenue from power generation that could be
used to offset the cost of water supply and delivery. Belock says the 0 million
pumped-storage plant was cash financed.
Thanks to the success of this project, SDCWA announced in July 2013 that it was
preparing to assess the potential to develop a larger pumped-storage facility (up to
500 MW) at its San Vicente Reservoir. Construction of this facility is anticipated to
take at least five years.
Elizabeth Ingram is managing editor of Hydro Review.
Page 8 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
11/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 9
10/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 8
09/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 7
07/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 6
06/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 5
05/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 4
04/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 3
03/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 2
01/01/2014
Volume 33
Issue 1
More HR Current Issue Articles
More HR Archives Issue Articles
HYDRO REVIEW PAST ISSUES
Prev 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 Next
Page 9 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
Replacement Options for Penstocks
ITAIPU HPP: Energy Production with High Performance
MORE WHITEPAPERS
Prev 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 Next
More Hydro Review Current Issue Articles
More Hydro Review Archives Issue Articles
LATEST SLIDESHOW
Your Picture Here: Send Us
Your Dam Selfie
The selfie craze has reached PennWell's Hydro Group! Check out this slide show of selfies taken near dams
around the world. Do you see somebody - or some dam - you know?
MORE SLIDESHOWS >>
HYDRO WHITEPAPERS
Sticky Wickets: Modifying Operation of a Pumped-Storage Project
RELATED ARTICLES
Page 10 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
Owner of Welsh pumped-storage hydroelectric plant seeks to increase capacity by 50 MW
Nigerias US$1.3 billion 700-MW Zungeru hydroelectric project deals with challenges
FERC EIS endorses relicensing Drum-Spaulding, Yuba-Bear hydro projects
Construction suspended at a 23-MW hydroelectric power plant in Vietnam
At least it isn't "I Want a Hippopotamus for Christmas"
Russian US$2.6 billion investment helps put 3,000-MW Boguchany hydroelectric power plant online
MORE NEWS
INDUSTRY NEWS
HYDRO INDUSTRY FINANCIALS
Hydroworld MI 879.90 +4.42 (+0.50%)
Nasdaq 4801.77 -5.09 (-0.11%)
S&P 500 2091.00 +2.23 (+0.11%)
Page 11 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
NYSE 10990.14 +4.74 (+0.04%)
Hydroworld Market Index
IDACORP, INC. 69.83 +2.20 (+3.25%)
AVISTA CORPORATION 37.32 +0.96 (+2.64%)
TOSHIBA CORP 4.27 -0.05 (-1.16%)
E.ON SE SPONSORED ADR 17.46 -0.11 (-0.65%)
View More Companies
Powered by FinancialContent
BUYERS GUIDE PRODUCTS
Pumped Storage - High head & Large CapacityDue to TOSHIBA's advanced fluid analysis techno...
Hydro Generator-MotorsToshiba offers worldwide experiences in various...
MOST READ ARTICLES
Tunnel collapses at US$22.4 million Da Dang-Da Chromo hydroelectric project
At least 13 killed by collapse at Ecuador's Coca Codo Sinclair hydropower plant
Lockheed Martin begins work on AR1500 tidal energy turbines
Isolating DC Grounds in Modern Power Plants
High-Potential (Hipot) Testing: A Tool to Assess Stator Winding Condition
Enter Symbol or Company
RECENT COMMENTS
Page 12 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
Senate confirms nomination of Honorable to FERC
B.C. government approves 1,100-MW Site C hydropower project
Current Digital Issue
Current Digital Issue
EDITOR'S PICKS
Page 13 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
2015 National Hydropower Association Annual Conference program available online now
At least 13 killed by collapse at Ecuador's Coca Codo Sinclair hydropower plant
Russia's RDIF, India's IDFC partnering for US$1 billion hydroelectric power investment deal
BUYERS GUIDE COMPANIES
Sauer Compressors Specialists in missing Pieces. Industry R...
Toshiba Corp Power Systems CoToshiba supplies total solution for all sizes
o...
Stucky LtdSpecializes in hydropower schemes and
pumped st...
Monitor International LtdEngages in major project consulting
assignments...
Parker HannifinManufactures grid tie inverters used in small
h...
CONTINUING EDUCATION
Professional Development Hours
To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of
choice from the list below.
View All
Balance of Plant
Coal-Fired Generation
Emissions Control
Gas-fired Generation
Hydro
Nuclear
Page 14 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
Renewables
Rotating Machinery
Steam Generation
Nigerias US$1.3 billion 700-MW Zungeru hydroelectric project deals with challenges
Construction suspended at a 23-MW hydroelectric power plant in Vietnam
At least it isn't "I Want a Hippopotamus for Christmas"
Russian-backed Argentine-Spanish consortium funds US$1.84 billion, 637-MW Chihuido I hydro
Kyrgyzstan extends call for development of two small hydro projects
WORLD REGION NEWS
FERC EIS endorses relicensing Drum-Spaulding, Yuba-Bear hydro projects
Russian-backed Argentine-Spanish consortium funds US$1.84 billion, 637-MW Chihuido I hydro
Kyrgyzstan extends call for development of two small hydro projects
HYDRO PROJECT ACTIVITY
Page 15 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
HDR adds Kerr to Pacific Northwest hydropower team
Sakartvelos Banki invests US$45 million in Georgias hydroelectric future
MORE HYDRO PROJECT ACTIVITY
READ NOW PAST ISSUES
11/01/2014
Volume 33, Issue 9
READ NOW PAST ISSUES
09/01/2014
Volume 22, Issue 5
Page 16 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
FIND A HYDRO COMPANY
- 1,300 companies from throughout the world
- 6,000 hydro products and services
- Search for a specific company, product or service
Companies
Products
Dam Repair
Dam Inspection/Monitoring
Dam Construction/Repair Equipment
Dam Design
In-Place Repairs and Services
Machining
Maintenance and Repair, Miscellaneous
Instruments, Measuring
Control Systems
Project Management
Project Development
Bearings/Bushings
View more companies >>
ARCHIVED ARTICLES
2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 2011 | 2012 | 2013
Hydro Review Past Issues
HYDROWORLD.COM NEWS AND TOPICS
Page 17 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
Hydro Project Activity
World Regions
Technology & Equipment
Dams & Civil Structures
Regulation & Policy
Environmental
PREMIUM CONTENT:
Tender Opportunities, FERC News & FERC Notices
TOPICS
Advertise
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
ABOUT US
Buyers' Guide
Hydro Events
Webcast
Video Gallery
Current Magazine Issues
Hydro Review Past Issues
HRW-Hydro Review Worldwide Past Issues
Submit An Article
Power Generation University
Hydro Library
Bookstore
RESOURCES
Subscriptions
Login
Register
Forgot Your PREMIUM CONTENT Password
PREMIUM CONTENT Information
Site Map
SUPPORT
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
RSS Feeds
STAY CONNECTED
Copyright 2007-2014. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights
Reserved.PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Hydro Project Activity | World Regions | Technology & Equipment
Dams & Civil Structures | Regulation & Policy | Environmental
Premium Content: Tender Opportunities, FERC News & FERC Notices
Page 18 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...
-
Page 19 of 19Getting construction of pumped storage moving forward again in the U.S.
29.12.2014http://www.hydroworld.com/articles/hr/print/volume-33/issue-9/cover-story/a-potenti...