8/20/2019 Boysaw v Interphil Promotions Inc

1/2

BOYSAW V INTERPHIL PROMOTIONS INC

GR. NO. L-22590 / MARCH 20, 1987 / J. FERNAN / AABPAYAD

NATURE: A!"#PET$T$ONER: %&'&( B&)*"+ "( A#!& Y#&RE%PONDENT: $(!# P&'&&(*, $(3. !. "#.

DOCTRINE:  4!! &(! ") (& !&' !(!"(6 +3 ! +"* &( ) ! !'* & !"6!!'!( & !&', ! * (& !(#! & (** &( !!&'"(3! & ! 3&("3 ) ! &! "), & !3&!"'"6!* ) !"*&( & * &+( !"3.

FACTS:

• O( M") 1, 191, B&)*"+ "( '"("6! !3'

*6(! + $(!# ;!!*!(! ) %"!"#< "3&("3 & !(6"6! F#"* E#&! ( " &=(6 '"3 "R>"# M!'&"# %"' &( %! ?0, 191 & (& #"!"( ?0 ")* *&# " &*&(!'!( ! '"##)"6!! &(. B&)*"+, "33&(6 & 3&("3, *&#(& !(6"6! ( &! &* & & ! 3&(!*.

• $(!# *6(! E#&! & " *'#" "6!!'!(.

• B&)*"+ &6 "( !!"! L&* A#" ( N!"".

• !3' "**6(! & A'"& A"(!" * '"("6!"#6*, +& #"! "(*!! ! 6* & A#!& Y#&.

• %"!"# +&! & G"'!* "( A'*!'!( B&" ;GAB<

!6"(6 * *+3 & '"("6!* !3"*! !)+!!(@ (&!.

• GAB 3"##! & 3&(!!(3!* "( !3! & *3!#!! E#&!-B&)*"+ & &(

• O( N& , 191, U%A N"&("# B&=(6 A**&3 "&!.

• %"!"# &!! & '&! ! 6 & O3 28 & & !+/( ! ?0 ") "##&+"#! &*&(!'!( ( !3&("3. Y#& !*!. H! +"* +##(6 & "&! !6 &( N& &! +## ! &'&! ) " 3!"(M"'!& B!*".

•  T! 6 3&(!'#"! ( ! M") 1 3&("3 (!!

'"!"#>!.

•

B&)*"+ "( Y#& *! $(!#, %"!"# "( N!&.

• B&)*"+ +"* "&" +!( ! +"* *3!#! & "!

! +(!** *"(. L&+! 3& !*! ! "#. B&)*"++"* *## "*!( &( ! #"! "!. C& !*!. O( ! (*"(3!, " '&&( & &*&(!'!( +"* !(!.

• B&)*"+ "( Y#& '&! & " (!+ "#, +"*

!(!. H!(3!, * "!"#.

ISSUES & RATIO:WON the ofending pat! in a e"ipo"a# o$#igation%a! "o%pe# the othe pat! &o 'pe"i(" pe&o%an"e)* No+

 T! !!(3! !*"#*! " ! 3&("3 +"* "! )"!##"( B&)*"+ '*!# +!(, +& ! "&"# &3&(*!( & $(!#, ! &6 L&* A#" &( J(! 19, 191 (L"* !6"* N!"". A(&! "&( & ! 3&("3 (!*&( +"* ! "**6('!( "( "(*!, * & J. A'"&A"(!", "( **!!(#), & "!##"( Y#&, J., & !

'"("6!"# 6* &! B&)*"+ +& ! (&+#!6! &3&(*!( & $(!#. T! &+! & !*3( * 6!( & !(! "). Where the plaintif is the party who did not  perorm the undertaking which he was bound by the terms o the agreement to perorm 4 he is not entitled to insist uponthe perormance o the contract by the deendant, or recover damages by reason o his own breach U(! ! #"+ +!(" 3&("3 * (#"+##) (&"! ) "( "#3"#! "((#"!"# **&( & ! &#6& ) "(&!, !"66!! 3!& * (& &( & !"# + ! **!.H&+!!, * 3#!" " ! "!##!!*, (*!" & ""#(6

!'*!#!* & ! &&(* 6!( & !' ) #"+ & !*3**&(& !*"# & !3&6(>! ! **! &#6& Y#&, !"##)+"(! & &*&(! ! 6 "! &+(6 & "( () "E#&! **"(! ( " !3!( &. T" ! "!##!!* " ! *3"&( & !(!6&"! ! &6("# 3&("3, "3#"#)! 6 "! * (!("#! &' ! "3* "&!*"!. U(!! 33'*"(3!*, ! "!##!!* !*! & &*&(! ! 6"! 3&# (!! ! (#"+# (& (!"*&("#!.

DECISION

8/20/2019 Boysaw v Interphil Promotions Inc

2/2

4HEREFORE, !=3! & ! "+" & '&"# "'"6!* +3* !!( !#!!, ! !3*&( & ! #&+! 3& * !!)"I'!.