8/9/2019 Book Review - The Political Economy of Media - 11.23.09

1/3

@keabi Mrbbe;;$?>$?661Vrdc% K% ^pksap~gqOddg _bsab}Pjb Vdiapanki Bndedhq dc Hb`akbe`raem a~~b~) bhbrmaem `aibhhk~

Ae Pjb Vdiapanki Bndedhq dc Hb`ak *VBDH!) k oddg oq _dobrp ] % HnNjb~ebq) HnNjb~ebq hkgb~ kebzpbe~asb krmhbep cdr pjb `bv diapana|kpade dc hb`ak% H nNjb~ebq jk~ ~vbep k {krpbr nbeprq rb~bkrnjaemke` kekiq|aem pjb vdiapanki bndedhq dc hb`akki~d rbcbrrb` pd ae pja~ oddg k~ pjb vdiapanki bndedhq dcndhheankpadeae ke kppbhvp pd*vvbe pjb `bokpb obp}bblr~nedikr~ ke` k mrd}aem k`abenU% Pjb

$ $ krmhbep v p cdr}kr` oq HnNjb~ebq a~ pjkp pjb nrrbep bza~paem hb`ak ~q~pbh a~e-p ekprki ke` pjb vkpj ap, 6jk~ pkgbe pj~ ckr }k~e-p vrb`b~paeb`9%})pjbr) ap -~ HnN jb~ebq-~ ndepbepade pjkp pjb h b`ak ~q~pbh nke obNV

kipbrb` pd obebcap pjb hkldrapq dc ~dnabpq ke` edp deiq pjb cb} d}ebr~ ke` ~jkrbjdi`br~ dc hb`akae~pappade~% Ae pja~ rbsab} dc VBD H A-ii kppbhvp pd kekiq|b pjb nbeprki krmh bep~ ~bp cdrpj ke` bzkhaebpjb e`briqaem k~~hvpade~ pjrdmj ~bibnpade~ dc bsa`benb% Ik~piq A-ii rbsab} HnNjb~ebq-~ ndeni~ade~ke` pjb vdpbepaki ~dnabpki ah viankpade~ } b hkq cknb) knndr`aem pd H nNjb~ebq) ac ed knpade a~ pkgbe pdnro pjb nrrbep ~pkpb dc kcckar~ }apjae hb`ak%

VBD H a~ ordgbe `d} e aepd pjrbb ~bnpade~< ; ! rb~bkrnj k``rb~~aem ldre kia~h7 ?! nrapanki ~p`ab~ dcbndedh an vdiapan~7 ke` > ! b~~kq~ de vdiapan~ ke` pjb mrd} aem h b`ak rbcdrh hdsbh bep% Ae pjb car~p ~bnpadeHnNjb~ebq ndepbzpkia|b~ pjb bhbrmbenb dc vrdcb~~adeki ldrekia~h ae k ja~pdranki ke` vdiapanki crkhb%Jb kppbhvp~ pd bzvikae pjb cik}~ ae hkae~prbkh ldrekia~h) ~jb`~ iamjp de pjb ko~r`apq dc pjb /iaobrkihb`ak/ `bokpb ke` krmb~ pjkp ldrekia~h ap~bsiae pjb ha`~p dc k nra~a~% ^bnpade p}d a~ `bsdpb` pd pjbrbk~de~ }jq hb`ak obnkhb aejbrbepiq bndedhankiiq ke` vdiapankiiq `rasbe% Khdem dpjbr bzkhvib~)HnNjb~ebq vdaep~ pd pjb ~qhoadpan rbikpade~jav ~vdrp~ ke` hb`ak hkaepkae% /Hb`ak kppbepade cke~ pjbcikhb~ dc aepbrb~p ae ~vdrp~ ke` aenrbk~b` aepbrb~p ae ~vdrp~ }krrkep~ crpjbr hb`ak kppbepade%/ *?;>! Pjbik~p ~bnpade a~ ke khkimkhkpade dc b~~kq~ H nNjb ~ebq jk~ }rappbe ae pjb ik~p ?2 qbkr~ rbm kr`aem vdiapan~

;

8/9/2019 Book Review - The Political Economy of Media - 11.23.09

2/3

ke ` pjb hb`ak rbcdrh hdsbhbep % Jb kppbhvp~ pd vrdsa`b k nibkr ja~pdranki rbndr` dc jd} pjb hdsbhbepjk~ mrd}e ke` ~jb`~ iamjp de `aibhhk~ dc ebdiaobrkia~h ke` pjb `amapki ndhheankpade rbsdipade%

HnNjb~ebq krmb~ }b-rb ae pjb ha`~p dc pjb hd~p ahvdrpkep ndhheankpade rbsdipade ae TTc (nbeprab~% Jb obiabsb~ pja~ a~ `b pd pjb ` rkhkpan aenrbk~b ae vdvikr vkrpanavkpade ae hb`ak vdianqh kgaem%

Pja~ a~ }jq) knndr`aem pd H nNjb~ebq) ap a~ /ahvbrkpasb pjkp ndhh eankpade ~njd ikr~ bhorknb pja~ja~pdranki hdhbep ae pjbar rb~bkrnj ke ` pbknjaem%/ *=! HnNjb~ebq ndepbe`~ pjkp pjb~b ~njdikr~ ~jdi`cdn~ pjbar bccdrp~ pd `bpbrhaeb }jbpjbr pjb nrrbep hb`ak ~q~pbh vrdhdpb~ dr e`brhaeb~ `bhdnrkpanae~pappade~ ke ` vrknpanb~%

Pj b car~p ~pbv) knnd r`aem pd HnNjb~ebq) pd obaem k ~kssq hb`ak nd e~hbr a~ ndh vrbjbe`aem pjkphb `ak `d edp bzvikae bsbrqpjaem% O p ged} aem pja~ ~ahvib rbkiapq a~ deiq de b ~pbv pd}kr`~ k ikrmbrkvvrbnakpade dc pjb rdib hb`ak vikq ae dr niprb% /Re`br~pke`aem hb` ak a~ ae`a~vbe~koib pd mrk~vaem pjb}kq vd}br }drg~ ae ndepbhvdrkrq ~dnabpab~%/ *;0! ]jaib hkeq ~njdikr~ obiabsb pjb nrrbep hb`ak

-pNrg(ug4~q~pbh }k~ cdrhb` pd vrdpbnp pjb aepbrb~p dc pjb voian) /pjbq obiabsb pjb h b`ak ~q~pbh a~ pjb rb~ip dcvdianab~ hk`b ae pjb vo ian-~ ekhb op dcpbe }apjdp pjb voian-~ aecdrhb` nde~bep%/ *;?!

Ae VBDH HnNjb~ebq `rk}~ iaeb~ obp}bbe hb`ak) nkvapkia~h ke` vdiapanki vd}br% Krmaem bknjvikq~ k rdib ae pjb dpjbr~- ~nnb~~ dr ikng pjbrbdc) HnNjb~ebq ~kq~) /Vdiapanki bndedhq dc hb` ak iaeg~hb`ak ke` ndhhe ankpade~ ~q~pbh~/ pd jd} odpj bndedhan ke` vdiapanki ~q~pbh~ }drg) ke` ~dnaki vd}bra~ bzbrna~b`) ae ~dnabpq%/ *;?! wR%,,U q uU

Ki~d k``rb~~aem bh brmaem hb `ak knpasa~h k~ ap jk~ ra~be) HnN jb~ebq krmb~ pja~ `bsbidvh bep a~~pragaem ae d r pahb obnk~b pjb `amapki ndhh eankpade rbsdipade) ~vrrb` oq pjb aepbrebp ke` }arbib~~ndhheankpade ~q~pbh~) vd~b~ k `aibhhk cdr pjb vdiapanki bndedhq dc hb`ak% Pjrdmj pjbkcdrbhbepadeb` ~q~pbh~ ndhheankpade pddi~ krb hdrb knnb~~aoib pjke bsbr obcdrb ke` pjb `a~~bhaekpadedc aecdrhkpade jk~ obndhb k ~ahvib vrdnb~~% HnNjb~ebq mdb~ crpjbr k~ jb ndepbe`~ pjb `amapkirbsdipade jk~ rk`ankiiq prke~cdrhb` hb`ak) ndhheankpade) ke` ~dnabpq%

8/9/2019 Book Review - The Political Economy of Media - 11.23.09

3/3

Ldrekia~h) ~kq~ HnNjb~ebq) a~ pjb ipahkpb id~br }jbe hb`ak Undeprdiib` oq aenrbk~aembhvjk~a~ de bndedhan prahvj% /Ndhhbrnakia~h ndhb~ kp k sbrq jamj vranb ke` }apj hk~~asb-bzpbrekiapab~-%/ *?6! K~ k rb~ip) pjb~b bzpbrekiapab~) knnd r`aem pd HnNjb~ebq) bzpbe` `arbnpiq pdldrekia~h k~(lh%ahkyO3_a a~ nrrbepiq ae k `bbv ke` vrdidemb` nra~a~ k~ ndrvdrkpb npokng~ ndepaeb ke`ldrek ia~pan ~pke`kr`~ `bniaeb% *;?!

HnNjb~ebq vkaep~ k middhq vanprb dc pjb cprb }apj ja~ kekiq~a~ ke` rb~bkrnj k~ jb %ndepbe`~49\(=UKNu,, (,a ,#pjkp eib~~ nkvapkia~h a~ `rkhkpankiiq rbcdrhb`) pjbrb hkq ob eksda`koib nkpk~prdvjb~ pd pjb hb`ak $U, ~%

~q~pbh% Jb ~kq~) /Pjbrb krb aeehbrkoib dpjbr hd`bi~ cdr k vrb~~ ~q~pbh) hkeq krmkoiq ~vbradr pd}jkp bza~p~) ac }b deiq dv be v dr h ae`~ ke` bzvke` d r jdra|de~) ke` iddg pd dr d} e ja~pdrq%/ *;>Kp pahb~ HnNjb~ebq kihd~p ndhb~ dcc k~ ciavvkep ke` nde`b~nbe` aem ae ja~ kvvrdknj% /Ac ibk`br~ aeekpade~ ke` ~njdikr~ aepbrb~pb` ae pjb ~olbnp bsdpb` k je`rb`pj dc pjb bebrmq pd }drgaem de ~njvdianab~ k~ pjbq `d de prqaem pd hkgb k vbr~deki cdrpeb ae hb`ak ae`~prab~) }b } di` jksb k hdpjbrid`b dc vdianq dvpade~ pd bzkhaeb ke` `bokpb%/ *0?>! Recdrpekpbiq) }jaib HnN jb~ebq dccbr~ v hkeq dcpjb vrdoibh~ }apj h b`ak pd`kq) jb dccbr~ v ed rbki ~dipade~) ~mmb~pade~) hd`bi~ dr ~vbradrkipbrekpasb~ pd pjb nrrbep ~q~pbh% HnNjb~ebq `db~ hbepade pjb OON ikpbr ae pja~ oddg k~ k vdpbepakihd`bi cdr k hdrb l~p ke ` `b hd nrkpan hb`ak, jd}bsbr) pja~ ~mmb~pade `d b~e-p pkgb aepd knndep pjb

) $hipap`b dc hb`ake~ kirbk`q ae bza~pbenb ke ` }jkp }di` ndhb dc pjbh% W@$ $ UcU*lU -U q u u P ! uuZs/$T4pcc,^a9( PKgL< (~Q4$I(Knn dr`aem pd HnNjb~ebq) ac ed knpade a~ pkgbe pd nro pjb nrrbep ~pkpb dc kcckar~ }apjae hbkaya }b

hkq cknb vrdcde` ahviankpade~ ae pjb }kq dr bndedhq) `bhdnrknq ke ` ~dnabpq cenpade% Pjb nrrbep T c4,%hb` ak ~q~pbh) ~kq~ HnN jb~ebq) nke ob kipbrb` pd obebcap pjb hkldrapq dc ~dnabpq ke` ed p deiq pjb cb}

d}ebr~ ke` ~jkrbjdi`br~ dc hb`ak ae~pappade~% Pjb Vdiapanki bndedhq dc Hb`ak oq _dobrp ]%HnNjb~ebq a~ ke bzpbe~asb) ke ` ndesaenaem) krmhbep cdr pjb `bvdiapana|kpade dc hb`ak% R ecdrpekpbiq)}jaib HnNjb~ebq dccbr~ v h keq d c pjb vrdoibh~ }apj hb`ak pd`kq) jb dccbr~ v ed rbki ~dipade~)~mmb~pade~) hd`bi~ dr ~vbradr kipbrekpasb~ pd pjb nrrbep ~q~pbh% ##(UJP/ c,(/u,RUd

A