bingehên maleke bextewar
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
1/43
Jolkhbl gmchdh jhrph{mz
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
2/43
oo
Jolkhbl gmchdh jhrph{mz
Uhzdml6 @mmloub6Jchuuolku ai Olpogmey "^zoleo~chu iaz m bm~~y imgocy/
Mgm`hdozol {hzkhzm Dxzgmle6 :>=> Govkl
H'Gmoc6 govkoloNmac,eag
Bhg gmi ~mzmup lh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
3/43
ooo
Lmyhzad
=, @hup~dozol =
:, Mzgmlem {h o h1 0
5, ]ghp uomlhpkozpol 9
0, Jo bhy zh ~hoyl =:
8, ]ghp uomlhpkozpol =;
9, ^{hl`om dz m `o lmy fol gz h :=
;, U goipl kozlk :9
2, Vmzadl gh O :2
?, Vmzadl gh OO :0
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
4/43
=
=, @hup~dozol
Gmchdh dx co kaz `oc {h jm# { m{m jm1 Gm ihzuhl`m {h j dx bl gmchdh pofh mp jojlol1
Jhcd `hgm {h jo`pm# ~ozum {h { hy jm6 Khca gm fo ja dx `o gmchd `h mp bhjh# o cmvog h1
Hy zmupohdh phbc h dx hg bhg `ovmlol# gmcl dx pofh mp lh# khchd dg ol, @o ~ozzmlom gmcml `hkhchd emzml hz# ~hyl `hyfhl bhlh,
Fo r{h `o }m`m hz `h ~hyl hz bhh# c jhc gm ~{oup h dx gmcm gh f eobhdhzdozol jh1 Jo
zmup R{h` lmr{mvh dx gmcm gh jo `hyfhl# hz ~hyl pofh jh-
Hkhz bmc gmcm gh {hbm jh# jkxgml hy lh ue R{h` h4 lhrz# ue gh h# ogd hg bhg
kxlhbdmz ol, Bhz gozay dx p `olm# bhyl kxlhb `o `oc { `h bhh hg bhg fo vmzadpom r{h
yh lh co ih`m gozayl `ol# c co ih`m r{h `okhzol ~ hg rhgm r{h jo r{h `or{ol,
C jhc govklohdh r{h bhh6 Hkhz hg kxb r{h jo`ol zhpl R{h`# `hzihp bhh dx gmcm gh pofh
mp jojh, Jlol jhz myl r{h dx { o}mu r{h jh# hkhz lh phl `hgm dx gyml jl jm {h# `o gmcm
{h `h mp bhjh# c jhc phymbom zaf `o `oc gmcol {h `h bhvdozol mp bhjh,
@o y ~ozpd `h bl `odmzol bl jojol dm m{m bl `odmzol jo folm r{h zh# ml f jo gz r{h zh
bhz{hbm jo vmzadl r{h zh `o mpo `h jofl, Gzla# bl jo `ochdm fo rhjmpm r{h yhkhzol gmcm r{h-
Folla# mr dx gz {h yhkhzh gmc# bl lh `o lmy pozu `h jol# c jhc `oc {h { pofh mb jh, @ml
upml`olm {h { j kxbhzpol4 jolkhb `ml upml`olm {h { mb# mp bhvdozol jh4 hkhz `hyfhl ml
~hyl jol f# bl zohdh }hle jojlol dx bl ~ozukozdl r{h mzhuhz jodol,
Fo ja dx hy pop jol# jo zmup bolhd rhjmp cmvog h, Dxz @m{o` Uocgml ~m`mb `o lmy Gouocgml Eob Ghuboml `h vocmg bhzhbzhvm p bhumjdozol, [ jhzom u bhvmz umcml co uhz y hd {hbm
loyu kap6
Gmc jo hbzhvmo p mymdozol jo ig`mzo h{ p }mgdozol,
Jo vmll# a`hl { jo bhz ezh popl bfm r{h pofh `ojol, "Kapoll Uocgml :065'0/
@o ^hym R{h` `h# ml `o Dopjm ^zav `h khchd zhpl {hbm bhlh, Hkhz hg jor{mvol dx `o gmcm
gh `h mp# bhvdozol mb bhjh# `oy dx hg fo ja kxb`mzdozol mgm`h jol,
Lobm fo dhzhgm r{h {hzol# hg }hle co gmlm y kapolm Uocgml ~m`mb jolzol, Hkhz gozay jor{mvh
gmcm r{h mym jodh# hbzhvm ~{oup h, Kmym ~ f hy h6 mr dx rml p mymdozol# `oy `o `hup uhzdmz`h ~cmlm rl bhjh# `m dx h{ jovmlh dx `oy o j dozol h{ m{m j mymdozol,
mr dx bl co uhz vh{mem r{h joiodozol# ml f `hgm bl co uhz dh dxzl r{h l jhzjhrp joiodozol#
gm hbzhvmom R{h` zjhzom {h `odh# ml bl co kaz zhp m`hpl gozayml `odol1 @o `mlupml`olm
`o lmy fol gz `h khchd ig`mz cmvog h# `m dx vh{mem gh vh{mem dxz dhl gh }mg jojh,
Gm`hg dx fol gz `or{mvol bhpm `m{om fomlm r{h jo bhy zh joglol# `oy dx bol jo bol h{
bhy` }hle lmu jodol `oy dx bhz`x fo `oc eml mgm`h jol dx fo bhy` bl jojol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
5/43
:
Bhz{hbm vmll cmvog h# `m dx a`hl {ml jo rhvlhl R{h` l }hle pofh jojol, @o yml
rhvlhml `h bxzghp bhvdozol bhh, H{ fo ja gh bhgml `omzol R{h` lh,
_ml u pop cmvog ol6
=, Fo ja mymdozolm gmcm gh hbzhvmcmvog h,:, Fo ja }mgdozolm gmcm gh ig`mzcmvog h,5, fo ja dx a`hl gmcm gh jo popl }hle pofh jojol# vmll cmvog h,
Lobm jo `hupzm {h# hv `or{mvog ~ohd {h bomz jodog6 Gmchdh jhrph{mz j dh` j rhjmp
lmjh, Hkhz bl jor{mvol mbom gmchdh jo mp jojlol# `oy bl r{h jo`ol `oy bl fo ja y hd
khchd jorhjopol,
Cagm fo ja mymdozol# }mgdozol pofhdozolm gmchdh jhrph{mz# khchd ehumzhp cmvog h, H{ ehumzhp
cmvog h# ogd lh buml h dx gozay hruohp ml }hzhdpz r{h jokxbhzh, Jz jm{hz m`hpl gh
vdm fo gh zh `ojol muphlk zh{m gmcl gh vhbghpoz `odol,Ghuhch hg jfol `o gmchd `h ~op u ml mz dhml ` dxzod f `ojh, R{odl { bhz kmy `o gmc
`h co `hzyh `orhjopol# c h{ dxz fo zafm ~ yh `ojh `hcmc gmc jhcd bhz kmy bhz `mr{mvm { f p
hzdozol, ^op `hghdh dol h{ dxz { joiodozh dx h{ jo r{h hd ~ozz ghvol kozlk h,
mr dx h{ dxz folhd fo r{h zh jlh# gm bl `ojfol { buml jh dx h{ jojh gzhd }hle dx
jhz~ozuomzol r{h ~d jlh1 Vh{me dmz`hup jhz~ozuomzol vocmghd `okxbhzh# c vh{me jo r{h#
}hzhdpz hruohpm { lmkxbhzh, Jhzymfo y6 Vh{me { }hzhdpz vocmghd zmup yhmzp doi
jodh# ml { z { zmup `hzlh gh`ml,
Hkhz h{ `o vmzadpom r{h `h bl lhjjh dx m{m jozmzm r{h jo`h# h{ m{m `o gmcm r{h `h jovmlh
dx jozmz m{m pl `ml1 Hkhz `o vmzadpom { `h bhz dhu f zh kapojh# h{ o jor{mvh# `odmzh jodh#
h{ m{m bl jojh dx jo bo m}oc r{h joiodozh1
@o vmzadpom {h `h gmcm {h m{m j1 Jkxgml y hd `o fomlm {h `h jml`zhdh ~ozz ghvol co {h
dozoh-
C jhc lh phl ehumzhp cmvog h4 bhz{hbm uhjoz# ml jbliozhb f cmvog h, Hkhz fol gz jor{mvol fo
ja gmcm r{h zom R{h` bl jojol# `oy dx h{ co bhy` uhjoz jodol, M`hp# hruohp }hzhdpz gozay
`o zafhd `h lml kxbhzpol# c hkhz gozay r{h jo`h y hd# h{ pop `odmzol bol jo bol jl kxbhzpol,
C jhc co kaz jz jm{hzom gh# m bhz kozlk hy h dx gozay co bhgjhz r{h co bhgjhz folm r{h#ml co bhgjhz gz r{hfo `oc eml `oczmup `xzxup jh, Hkhz gozay zmupo fo jhz r{h jo r{h yhzh#
o ih`m { f bhh1 Hkhz gozay co bhgjhz r{h jo r{h `hzh{ml jodh# o ih`m y hd bhh1
Ghuhch hg jfol gozayhd bhh# h{ bhz uoj co lhlodhd `olzh# `m dx ~az r{h hb jodh, C ~op
`hghd h{ ` lmr{mvh co lhlod jolzh fo bolk ~ yh h{ co {lhhd r{h `olzh dx jhzom
`hb umcml bmpoh doml`ol, Jkxgml h{ f uzhp { h# c fo r{h h{ lodmzh co kaz {lh ~az r{h hb
jodh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
6/43
5
Jocm hy ~ozpd fo ja {h {hd lhlod jol# `m dx bl jodmzol jo {ml co `oc r{h jolzol, [hd dx bl
~az r{h hb `odol# bl `odmzol jo y m{m `oc {h f bzh jodol zol r{h zmup jodol,
Fo ja ph jo r{h bhz{hbm fo ja folm ph# bxzghpdozolm bhz ghvol hy h dx px `hzh{ml co r{h lhd#
r{h fo jhz r{h yhlhz jo myl yhdoz co lhlod jolz,
mr dx bl y ~ozpd jor{lol bl `o fomlm r{h `h pophd lh zmup jojlol# zmup joiodozol y
hd }hjc jodol, @o lmy gh `h px dhu pxlh dx jdgmb jh hkhz hg jor{mvol `o fomlm r{h `h ~
yh bhzol `o }hzhdpz r{h `h jojol hd kobp# `oy hg rhchp dgmbol r{h }hjc jodol,
@um hg `or{mvol kxb r{h jo`ol kapolhdh Uocgml ~m`mb, [ kap6
@hy fo jm}oco jhz`ol bl jofl4 `o zom ig`mzo `h bhzol- "Kapoll Uocgml ?69/
Hkhz hg jor{mvol ~ yh bhzol# `oy hg `hy fo popl rhzmj jhz`ol, Bhpm dx hg lhr{mvol jo myl
yhdoz co jm}ocom r{h jolzol# bhg `oc gh bhg f gmcm gh lm kxbhzpol,
[hd dx gh jhzom lobm r{hl`# gozay bhz vmlh kap6 Bhpm dx hg lhr{mvol co bhgjhz r{h co
bhgjhz l `ol fo `oc eml `xzxup `oczmup jol# hg lodmzol jofl,
Hkhz `mr{mvm {h h{ jh dx gmcm {h jhrph{mz jh zghpm R{h` jo`h doidozol# fo dhzhgm r{h bhpm
`m{om y ~ozpd jor{lol, Hg y hd lh fo ja ih`m r{h `ojfol, Hg y hd bhg fo ja ih`m {h
bhg f fo ja ih`m vmzadl {h fo ja ih`m loil dx jl `ojfol, @oy ehumzhpm gh bhjh# `oy uhjzm
gh bhjh bhg f `oy `oc gh `xzxup jh `m dx hg jodmzol volezl m`hpl r{h jo dlol, hruohpm gh
m hv~hzhup v lm kxbhzpol pmzom gmcl dx hz `hyfhl `o {ml `h bhh# j rhjmp j chjmp zalmb
lmjh,
Gh `p dx u goiph `odmzol `hzo gmchdh jhrph{mz yhdol, H{ f hy ol6 hbzhvm# ehumzhp `oczmup,Hy bhz u goiph jo pophd `ol yh koz`m lh, Gm bl `ovmlol h{ o h1 Jhzuy hy h6 hbzhvm# ehumzhp
`oczmup jo lhiujodo yh koz`m lh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
7/43
0
:, Mzgmlem {h o h1
Jhcd bol { jfol6 Jhz`cm vh{mehdh jhrph{mz ~ozz kozml h- Vh{mehdh jhrph{mz { co uhz gh khchd
jobm jouhdolh d `ovmlh# jhcd vh{mem jhrph{mz fo r{h lmjh,
C jhc {xum lhiodozol ehumzhpm r{h {ol`m lhdol- Hv khchd gozayl dx fo jup umcml jpoz h dxvh{oe lh lmu `odog hv f `o lmy {ml `h gh4 khchd fo {ml dg v`h bhz zaf fo ja folm r{h ml fol fo
ja gz r{h fo R{h` zh u~mu `odol, Bhz{hbm khchd fol gzl dx fo bhy lh `ocr{h ol f bhlh hg
`odmzol fo {ml gozayl dx dg v`h bhz zaf uoj v jo rhgkl jo pozu fo rh{ zm`ojol# bl jojol dx
ogm zh{m {ml {xum h,
Ihz} `o lmy {ml gozayml `o lmy {ml gmcml `h o h1
Jhzuy hy h6 Gozayl dx fo ja folm r{h ml fo ja gz r{h ~hul R{h` `o`ol# gozayl `ocm lh4
umrpom {ml poz h# rhjmpm {ml r{hpoz rxm `ojh vmzadl {ml f `ockh uhziozmv ol,
Gm`hg dx {xum h# gm ogm bol gozay lmr{mvol fo r{h zh y zom mjl bocjofzol# c `o zom
meovo `h `ool1
Jo zmup px dhu pxlh dx jo vmlmup fo r{h zh zom `oc bocjofzh# c `um f khchd gozay j bhg` r{h
`odhyol { zo,
Hz# zmup h# hkhz zjhz gh lhjh# v ml `hzhlk bhz dhu fo gh { jodhyh { zom meovo, Bhz{hbm
hg bhg `ovmlol dx zjhz }hp dz {ml l dx lmr{mvol kxb r{h jo`ol {# lm, Hkhz gozay
lhr{mvol `hy fo zom jhz`ol# hkhz h{ lhr{mvol fo joldhpol# jchjmp fo jbypom zafmlh rocmu
jojol# zjhz bhz }hle f lodmzh mcdmzom {ml jodh,
Jhcd bl y ~ozpd `or{lol ogd bl `or{mvol jpoz co uhz yml popml bl jojol, Jocm px dhu lh
rm~ml`ol# vh{mehdh jdgmb pxlh# c khchd fol gz bhlh dx `o vh{mem r{h `h ~ozz m lh,
@o fomlm bhz dhu `h phlkmb khchd popl vhbghp bhlh# c hkhz folm ph ml f gz ph `o yml `hz`ml
`h mcdmzom ph jodh# popl bhz vhbghp f { lh hy}mu kozml jol dx px lhdmzoj bockoz,
Kapolm Uocgml ~m`mb jlol jzm r{h, [ kap6
Gmc jo hbzhvmo p mymdozol jo ig`mzo h{ p }mgdozol,
Jo vmll# a`hl {# jo bhz ezhl popl bfm r{h pofh `ojol, "Kapoll Uocgml :065'0/
Uocgml co uhz o ezh rhvlhml kapoh1
@o eobhd `ol `h { {hbm kapoh6
Bol gozay bhlh# r{h `h{chghl` doi `odol# c pophd {ml pxlh,
Boll `ol bhlh# r{h jhchlkmv doi `odol# c h{ khchd `h{chghl` ol, "Kapoll Uocgml =56;/
_ml `h{chghl`om zmupl bhz kmy lm `pol h{ lh jo vz vy yh koz`m h, Gm kapolm ~ oml
lmjfh6 Jhzodm jhchlkmvml ymcm h# c `oc yml pofh h1 @h{chghl`om zmupl jo rhvlhl yhmzp
yh koz`m h h{ pop mp# mb# bxzghp bhvdozol ol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
8/43
8
@o gmchdh {hbm `h jhcd phchyoval pxlh jhcd hchdpzd f pxlh# c `um f pmz pxlh# ogd `o `oc
bhg gmcoml `h zalmbom zmupo h{} `o`h, Hy zalmb { bhz ~hzh fomlm {h pofh jodh,
Hv by `odog dx bl mgm`h jol fo `oc jor{mvol jorhjopol dx jo hbzhvm# vmll ig`mzo
gmcm {h j kxbhzpol# `m dx a`hl gmcm {h jo rhvlhl dx R{h` `or{mvh jo`h {h# pofh jojol,
Jhzom dx hg y `mjm jo `m{ jodol# fo dhzhgm r{h bolhd co uhz yml ~ozuml joiodozol fo r{h
jo r{h jo~ozuol6
Khca gm hg mgm`h lh dx gmcm gh lh {hd gmcl gozayl `ol jh1 Khca gm hv mgm`h gh dx hv {ml popl rhzmj l dx gol dozolh# co jhz R{h` hdhzh jodog1 Khca gm o popl dx ~zhdm gol ml gz gol `ool# `o fomlm gol `h bhlh1 Khca gm hv mgm`h gh dx hv `hy fo yml popml jhz`og1 Khca gm {h ig doz dx bl `odmzol fo ja folm r{h ml fo ja gz r{h jojol uhzdmlohdh
~zavjmbo1 Jkxgml mr dx folm ph ml gz ph `ocr{h m jh# px jo r{h f# p b v`hpoz
`ocr{h m joj,
Zmup h# hl` fo yml popml lh khchd buml lh jhcd v lml }hjcdozol# c jhc hv fo {h by `odog
dx bl jhz`h{mg jodol r{h jo`ol y hd, Hv uav `o`og {h# h{ `mjm l dx hg `o jhl dx jl
`h co uhz {ml jo~hoyol# { fo {h zh khchd jo dz jol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
9/43
9
5, ]ghp uomlhpkozpol
Jolkhb bfmp bxzghpm zmupl# zmup jo r{h h, @o `hup~d `h jhcd lh khchd vhbghp h dx hg jo
m{mhd uhz`hy }ghp jo`ol gozayhd `ol bxzghp f zh jodol# ml f fo gozayl `ol zghp jouplol# c
bol jo bol gozay { bl jojol dx hg jo r{h jo zmup m{m lh, ^op `hghd folm ph# ml gz ph { }hlejovmlh dx hruohpm ph jo zmup m{m h, Cagm `o lmy gh `h p kapol6 Dhuhd {hd fol# jo gz r{h
lovmlh, _ml px dhu {hd fol gz jo bhy` lovmlol# fo jhz dx h{ l bhz lvd bhy` lh ~hzhl
bhy ol }hle rhzmjol bhy` }hle `ovmlol,
Emzlm hg r{h jo r{h `orm~lol# `ojfol6 Hv `odmzog {xum jodog dx `oy folm gol ml gz gol
uomlhpm gol jokozh,
Ghuhch khchd gz fo r{h zh `ojfol6 mr dx hv `hzhlk `odhyog# `oy dx hv jo folm r{h zh ~ozz bo d
jog `oy hv pophd fojhzr{hdoz f zh jfog dm ogm hv `hzhlk bmpog gmc, Bolk `oy dx h{
uomlhpm gol jokozh, C jhc hg jo r{h `ovmlol dx bxzghpdozol }ghp`ml jo `mz vaz lmjh,Hkhz uomlhp fo ghejz j kozpol# h{ lh px uomlhp h, Hg `odmzol co uhz bhvdozol hl pop jfol6 Hg
lodmzol vaz co hd `ol jodol# dx h{ fo gh bhv jodh, Bhvdozolm dx fo ghejz jh# lh px bhvdozol h,
Jo zmup bol gozay bl lhjlh dx `o lmy pozu uomlhpkozpol `h ihz}hdh ghvol bhh,
Jkxgml hkhz gzhd folm r{h mypozuml` jodh# folm { lodmzh fo `oc eml bxzghp fo { zh jodh,
Ghuhch hg folhdh jogllol kxchdh u~hb6 Jo zmup h{ gz dx bod jh folm r{h mydlml` jodh# h{
jo r{h bhg jh`h{ jblr{hom folm r{h rhzm `odh folhdh {hbm lodmzh jojh uhzdmlom `ocr{h
mbom gz r{h,
Zmup h# `o bhz eoymd `h gozayml ~ymlhdh }ghp bxzghpdozol }hjc dozoh fo r{h zh dozolh m`hp,C jhc m`hp lodmzol { uomlhpm dx fo `oc eml jo`ol p kozpol# ~h`m jodol, ogd }ghp bxzghpm
zmupl lh co kaz m`hpml ol lh f jo `mz vaz h# c h{ fo `ocr{mvo pl,
Hg `odmzol glmdhdh `ol jo`ol6
Ghuhch hg jfol# vocmghd bhh dx bhz zaf fo folm r{h zh `ojfh6 Hv lvd `x ghpzml jocol` og#
ogd `o kxgmlm { `h hy hd }ghp uomlhpm vocmghd v`h `odh, C jo zmup h{ vocmg phl ghpzhd
up eg, h, Bhz{hbm h{ bhzkmy fo folm r{h zh `ojfh6 @o phymbom kxl` `h bhz jhfoljocol` hv og,
Hkhz myl folm { lh daz jol# h{ v jovmlh dx gz { `o kxl` `h lh bhz jhfoljocol` h, Gz
{ `odmzh ~cmyl r{h jocol` jodh ml `odmzh modhd jorh uhz r{h h{ `odmzh px emzml lvdvocmghd `ol kxl` r{h lhuhdolh# c `um f folm { { jovmlh dx jhflm gz { lh khchd jocol` h,
Gm jo y m{m }ghp bxzghpm gz { v`h `ojh1 Lhrz# jhzymfo y# ogd folm { { fo r{h
jo~ozuh jfh6 Khca ogm gz gol `or{mvh bhz jhfoljocol` j bhumjdozol1 ogm h{ `or{mvh r{h
jocol` jodh1
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
10/43
;
Jo zmup hg `ovmlol dx px gozay m}ocghl` pophd {hbm lmdh4 c jhc gm hy hd lh zmup h1 Hg khchd
emzml popl {hbm `oehzojlol# ogd hg `or{mvol dx rhcd }ghp `o`ol gh uomlhpm gh jokozol, Gm lh
{xum h1 Hg khchd `orhjopol# `m dx hg `o my gozayl `ol `h bfm jl `pol,
C jo zmup jo popl {hbm hg r{h jo r{h `orm~lol, @o Dopjm ^zav `h co uhz y hd {hbm `ojfh6
Jocm px dhu r{h lhrm~lh, Hkhz `o lmy {h `h hd r{h co y `olm hbzhvm bhumj jodh# jocm jm}oc
jh# `m dx hbzhvm jojh, ogdhbzhvmom y `olm co jm R{h` jm}oc h, "Dazlp O# 56=2,=?/
Hkhz hg jor{mvol jolkhb }ghp uomlhpm zmupl }hle ig jodol# `oy hg jo lhiujod }hjc jodol
dx hg khchd emzml rhzmjo `odol bhg f iodzl gh khchd emzml m rhzmj ol,
Fo ja igdozolm y hd# { }hle jh dx hg co hl` iodzl kozlk jolzol, Bol gozay `ojfol6
]ghp uomlhpm gmcm gh jo kapolm gozayl gh ezmll gh yh koz`m h, Hkhz hg `o my{ml `h jozv jol# bolk }ghp uomlhpm gh bhh, Gm khca hy zmup h1
Jml`zm gozayl lhiujod pxlh, Bvm {ml pxlh, Gm khca hy zmup h# ml lh zmup h1 Gozayl jhchlkmv lodmzol gozayl kozmljobm jol, Gm bl f {hbm `ojfol1 Fo ja dx gozay r{h zu~ `hzrh# ~{oup h dx emzlml h{ co kaz zmupo lhjfh, Gm khca co kaz jz
jm{hzom {h hy f zmup h# ml lm1
Jhcd {h jo r{h `p dx hy pop bhg lh zmup ol jo zmup {xum h, H{ iodoz bhg rhchp ol, C m{m
hg jovmlol dx iodzl {hbm rhchp ol1
Hz# gh jo r{h `p dx hy pop lh zmup ol# c fo jhz dx jhzom khchd umcml hl` gozayl hbzhvm co uhz y
`mjm kapoll zmup loyuml`olh# b jpoz hg y hd `ovmlol, Fo dhzhgm r{h kxb r{h jo`ol yml popml6
_m hd6 Ghuhch# hkhz hd gmcm gh juomlhp jodh ml f rhzmjohd co gmcm gh jodh# hg fo r{h zh
`ojfol6 Bh} gh bhh dx hg bhim r{h boclol, ogd hkhz hg bhim r{h boclhlol# gozayl `ol
{ joiodozol dx hg pozualhd ol, C jhc Gum ~rhgjhz {hbm loyuoh6
R{h` `ojfh6 Bhibocmll m gol h, Hv jhzk`mlm { jo`og, "@xjmzhdozolm hzhp 5:658/
_m `o`xml6 Lhiujod lh h{ h dx gozay bhz pop }hjc jodh, Lhrz# c gozay lhiujod }hle
`ovmlh dx R{h` o}mu ghvol h bhg gozay o}mu jod ol, Jo zmup# jo phl gozayl dx `o jm{hzo
`h rxzp ol `odmzol fo `oc eml lhiujod jol, @o lec `h co uhz y hd {hbm `ojfh6 R{h co jhz Rx`ml
lovog jodol# h{ {h jocol` jodh, "M}j 06=>/
_m uouoml6 Jhcd emzlm hg `ojfol6 Gozayhd jhchlkmv lodmzh gozayhd kozmljobm jozv jh, C
jhc Uocgml ~m`mb {hbm loyuoh6
Jhchlkmv dx `o zmupom r{h `h zyh `oh# fo `h{chghl` dx zol { r{hbz ol# poz h,
"Kapoll Uocgml :269/
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
11/43
2
_m mzml6 Bhz{hbm hg gozay# hg emzlm `ojfol6 ]hle h dx hg lhzmupo jfol hg lhrxuozol, C
jhc @m{o` ~m`mb {hbm loyuoh fo R{h` zh {hbm `ojfh6
Bhz dhu dx byom r{h jo ph yh koz `o`h# lm hzgdozol,
C jhc h{ l dx j uh`hg rmlpo `odol# { jl hzgdozol, "Vhjz :865/
Hkhz hg co fomlm r{h jolzol# gm hg co uhz yml popml o jfol1 Khca hg `o fomlm r{h `h co kaz
kapoll ~rhgjhzml `odol# ml hg co kaz jz jm{hzom r{h co kaz m`hpl jmy dmcml `odol1
Co uhz yml popml }hle joiodozol6
=, Khca gm hg mgm`h lh dx hg r{h jo`ol {ml popl dx jo `oc R{h` lh zghp `o`ol {1Hkhz fo jhz y hd gmcol gh ml ezmll gh# gh dg jojlol# bolk hg o jodol1 "_m zmup
h{ h# jocm gh dg jojlol,/
:, Khca gm folm hd fo gh `odmzh fo `auphd gh zh jfh6 Gz gol khchd lhiujod h-15, Hkhz hd fo ph jhchlkmvpoz jh# gm `um f {hd dx px fo hd `ol zh bxzghp `od# px fo { zh f
bxzghp `od1
0, Jhzom dx hg zzh jl `hzroupol# gm lh poz h dx hg `hzh{ml jodol1Hy iodoz# iodzl khchd gozayml ol# c jhc `oy jo hdhzh j kapol6 ]ghp uomlhpm zmupl fo ja {ml
gozayml h l dx `o lhiujodo `h `oczmup ol,
Hz# zmup h# khchd emzml rhcd bxzghp fo gozayhd vaz`mz ~avjocol` zh `odol# c jhc h{ `o `oc r{h
`h fo { lhizhp `odol lh jo `oc r{h jo jozmzl { zmv `ojol# c fo jhz dx h{ fo bzu vaz`mzom {`opozuol# jozmzl { }hjc `odol, Uocgml ~m`mb co uhz y hd {hbm loyuoh6
Jhzom {zmljl# `oc gozay }xzh `ojh# c jhzom zghp# lhiujod p, "Kapoll Uocgml =26=:/
Jhzom {zmljl# }xzhp jhzom dhpol# zxb ~avjocol`o p, "Kapoll Uocgml =96=2/
@hzum yml bhz`x mhpml doi h6 ]xzhp bhymc {zmljl h# c lhiujod `aup }ghp uomlhp h,
Emzlm gozay jhcm bhcmdjl plol uhz gmcm r{h# ogd h{ lmr{mvol r{h co jhz R{h` lovog jodol
lmr{mvol co uomlhpm zmupl# ml co uomlhpm dx R{h` `o`h# jokhzol, C jhc hy rhchpohdh ghvol h#
ogd R{h` co bhgjhz ~avjocol`ml `ouhdolh, "M}j 069/
Uocgml ~m`mb y hd hz `odh `ojfh6Rx`ml gmcm ~avjocol`ml boc`o{hlh# c h{ ulaz folhjo `o~mzvh, "Kapoll Uocgml =86:8/
Hz# hkhz hg jo zmup jojol gozayl jozv bxzghpdmz# vmzadl gh fol ml gz gh f { zvm gh#
ml uomlhpm gh# jokozol,
Gozay jozv d h1 Jhzuym y hd khchd uoyod h6 Gz jo uomlhp h{ h dx fo R{h` `opozuh folm
jo bxzghp h{ h m dx fo R{h` `opozuh, Zohdh `ol pxlh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
12/43
?
Hj `o Dopjm ^zav `h {hbm kapoh6
R{h` fo gozayml zh kap6 Ym h# pozum Rx`ml hbzhvm h `zdhpolm fo rhzmjo ig`mz h,
"Hj :26:2/
mr dx gozay pozum R{h` bl jojh `hup ~ jodh dx fo R{h` zh bxzghp jodh# po phd lh{mvh
`ojh, mr dx px fo `oc eml fo R{h` jopozu# `o fomlm ph `h pophd p kxbhzpol6 Bolk pop dx `o my
R{h` `h }hle h# { `o my ph `h f }hle jh, @mr{mvl R{h` { jojol `mr{mvl ph fo lod yh p
jojl dx px `o zom ~zavjmbo `h `o,
Jo pmjhp `o Dopjm ^zav `h co uhz pozum R{h` m zmupl khchd popl kozlk pl kapol, Ghuhch `o
Vhjz `h {hbm `ojfh6
R{hv jo bhz dhu dx fo Rx`ml `opozuh `o zom { `h `oh-
P jhz dh`m `hupl r{h jor{4 p r{hvod`mz j { fo ph zh }hle jh,
Folm ph { `o gmcm ph `h {hd g{hdh jhz`mz jh4
Dxzl ph { co `az uoizm ph {hd opocl vhpl jol,
Hz# vocmg dx fo R{h` `opozuh# {xum { j jogjmzhddozol, "Vhjz =:26='0/
Jlh jhz my r{h h{ ~zavjmbom dx R{h` jlh uhz ph uhz gmcm ph { o}mu }hle jh- Hz# R{h`
`or{mvh gh ~zav jogjmzhd jodh# c fo ja y hd `oy dx hg zhp phgjbl { }hjc jodol co kaz
{ml jodol, R{h` jo `hup @m{o` ~m`mb co uhz y hd `o Vhjz `h {hbm loyuoh6
Hv ph ~hz{hz`h jodog hv ph bl { zom dx p ~ yh jo jodog,
Hv zhpml co ph jodog mylzom ph jodog,
Lhjol {hd bhu~ ml bupozl jig,
Hkhz fo ja kozpolm {ml pmrogm bhiumz cormjml lhjol#H{ jhz jo ph yh lml,
Dh`hzl rhzmj khchd ol#
C jhc dx co R{h` h{ch `ojh#
Dhzhgm R{h` bm{oz`azm { zm`o~h, "Vhjz 5:62'=>/
Hkhz hg `o zom R{h` `h jool fo R{h` `z lhdhyol# hg jojol gozayl bxzghpdmz, Jkxgml
R{h` gozay lhmiozml`olh# dx h{ jo phl uomlhpm bhy jokozol4 lhrz# { gozay miozml`olh# `m dx h{
jhz bhz pop uomlhpm R{h` jokozol f zh bxzghp jodol,
C jhc hg kxlhbdmz ol mr dx hg kxlhbml `odol# hg uomlhpm R{h` lmkozol hg lmy {jbxzghp `odol, @h emz `oy dx hg o jodol1
odoz fo R{h` zh# gmcm { mym jh- Fo ja dx gh fo y hd rocmu jodh# R{h` z fo gh zh yhdoz6
@m{o` `o hl vhjz `h {hbm `ojfh6
R{hv jo { dx co lhbh}ol { bmpoh jobzpol kxlhb { bmpoh lorxgml`ol,
R{hv jo { gozay dx Rx`ml fo { zh rhzmjo bhumj lmdh `o `oc { `h bch pxlh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
13/43
=>
mr dx gol kxlhbl r{h hdhzh lhdozol# phymbom zaf bhupol gol fo lmclm gol ch{mv jl,
Fo jhz dx hy zaf `hup ph co uhz gol kozml j4 phzjlom gol j {hd vx{mom bmyl,
T@o `m{o `hW gol kxlhb r{h fo ph zh kap lhbh}om r{h yhlhmzp,
Gol kap6 Hv v`hkmyom r{h fo Rx`ml zh hdhzh jodog,
px co ue kxlhb gol jobzp, "Vhjz 5:6='8/
Jo zmup igdozolm yml kapoll @m{o` ~rhgjhz lh khchd vhbghp h# c jhc mr dx hg jodhyol
rhiodm ~avjocol`o# hg lmr{mvol kxlhbl r{h hdhzh jodol, C jhc hkhz hg kxlhbl r{h yhzol#
hg bhg `o my R{h` `h bhg f `o my gmcol r{h `h bxzghp uomlhpm r{h {ol`m `odol,
Fo r{h hg lodmzol zmupo ldmz jodol ml yhzol hkhz hg {xum jodol f# hg `ovmlol dx bvm gh
`oh# hg uoup zhjhl `ojol hg uomlhpm R{h` lmkozol, Jo phl hkhz hg fo R{h` zh bxzghp jodol#
hg bfm lh dx fo gh zh bxzghp j dozol,
Hg by`mz ol dx bl `ojlol# }ghp uomlhpm zmupl fo ja {ml gozayml h l dx fo `ochd zmup
uomlhpm R{h` `okozol, Khchd gozay y hd ig lmdol# c jhc Uocgml zmupohdh kozlk plh jzm gh
`ojfh6
Bhg zol gozay `o my { `h ~m}of ol# c jhc Rx`ml `oc zmgmll gozay `o{hvollh,
"Kapoll Uocgml =96:/
Hz# R{h` co `oc gh# ml co lp `mr{mvl gh `olzh hkhz kapol dozoll gh lh fo `ochd ~m}of
`hzdhyol# hg r{h jo r{h `orm~lol,
Hkhz hg co uhz m r{h jouhdolol jfol6 @oy dx folm gol fo gol zh bxzghp jodh# bolk hg gmlm
bxzghpdozol m zmup# pmg {ol`m `odol# ogd gh `p dx bhg bhvdozol bhg f bxzghpdozol jo `mz vaz
lmjh,
Lobm hg glmdhdh `ol jo`ol6
Ghuhch hg jfol vocmghd jhchlkmv `oiodozh fo r{h zh `ojfh6 ]ghp bxzghpm gozay jo
`h{chghl`om { yh koz`m h, Hkhz ghm gol v`hpoz jojh# folm gol { b jpoz bxzghp fo gol zh
jodh, emz h{ `hup ~ `odh# h{ fo uoj v bhpm jhzymz `orhjoph r{h jo dh`m r{h `o{huplh# c bhi
gormjol folm { f zh o jfh f# h{ `oiodozh dx h{ }hp uomlhpm { lmkozh, Cagm h{ meov `ojh zaf jo zaf
bzum { v`h `ojh zaf jo zaf `mr{mvm { m dx ~op rhjmp yhkhzh gmc jm folm r{h# dgpoz `ojh,
^op `hghd folm { f `hup ~ `odh# fo r{h zh `ojfh6 Gz gol bhz kmy meov `ojh zaf jo zaf v`hpoz
bzu `odhyh, Jkxgml ` h{ fo gol bhv lmdh, Hv m{m uomlhpm vocmghd {hbm jokozog1
Fol `or{mvh dx gz {# fo { bhv jodh }ghp jo`h { gz f `or{mvh dx folm { fo { bhv jodh
bxzghp f zh jodh ml h{ fol gz bhz`x f bh{eh`mz bhvdozolm zmupl ol,
Jkxgml fo ja dx h{ mjazm r{h jodol# ~hzh fo {ml zh cmvog ol# c b v`hpoz h{ bh{eh`mz bhvdozol
uomlhpkozpolm bhy` lh, Hkhz h{ bhvdozol uomlhpkozpol `o vh{mem {ml `h lhjh# bolk v mb { fo
`oc {ml jozhyh, Jhzom h{ bl jojol dx h{ m{m jo m{mhd dz fo bhy bhv jodol# h{ bol jo bol fo bhy
`z jodhyol bhz hd fo {ml { `o `oc r{h `h jo zom r{h yh bhzh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
14/43
==
mr dx gyml jl# jhcd h{ fo fol zh jfol6 Jo zmup# gz ph khchd uhziozmv h jhcd h{ fo gz
zh jfol6 Folm ph khchd fbmp h- Gmcm {h mym h- H{ joiodozol dx `o y gmc `h bhz pop }hle r{h
h# c hg `ovmlol dx `o y gmc `h khchd `ocumz phlkmb bhh,
Jo zmup }hp uh`hg pxlh dx bmc zh{m gmchd {hbm jh- C jhc mr dx hg fo `hzh{hd jm{hz
jodol# h{ `hzh{ bol jo bol ghvol `ojh# ~ `o lmy fol gz `h ~opzh `o phymbom gmc `h jhcmy `ojh
bhz pop rhzm `odh,
Co uhz yml bhz`x rmcml emzhdh `ol }hle joiodozol6
=, zhpm ~6 _m gz zbhcmc# hkhz px ` bh{ jodmz uomlhpm folm r{h jokoz# fo R{h` jor{mvhdx h{ mcdmzom ph jodh# `m dx px fo l yh fo folm r{h bhv jod, _m folm `hcmc# hkhz ` px bh{
jodmz }ghp jo` gz r{h px uomlhpm { lhkoz# fo R{h` jor{mvh dx h{ mcdmzom ph jodh#
`m dx px fo l yh fo gz r{h bhv jod, Bl bhz`x fo R{h` by jodol dx h{ `oc {h jokxbhzh#
ogd `oy dx mzhuhzom y ~ozukozd ~ `o `oc {h `h `hup ~ jodh,
:, zhpm `o`xml6 Hkhz ph jo bod fo gmcol r{h `or{hup dx h{ bxzghp fo ph zh jodol# r{h co jhzR{h` lovog jodh fo gmcol r{h cjobzpol jor{mvh# ogd ph lobm hy zmupom dx `ojfh6
Bh} px dhu pxlh dx jo vaz jor{mvh uomlhpm { j kozpol# ig doz, Hkhz px jor{mv dx
gmcol ph bxzghp fo ph zh jodol# `oy fomlm ph zmup bxzghpdmz jh, Jolkhb fomlhdh jozv
}hzhdpzhd bxzghpdmz# `ochd zmup# lhiujod pozum R{h` h,
Hg `um co `mjmm }ghp uomlhp jolzol# c ~ `oy dx hg jmcm r{h jo`ol `mjmhdh `ol6 Khca
`oy dx hg m{m jo bhy zh jo~hoyol1
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
15/43
=:
0, Jo bhy zh ~hoyl
@o Dopjm ^zav `h# ml `o lec `h hy mhp bhh# {hbm `ojfh6
Jocm bhz gozay `o jobupol `h jo chv jh# `o ~hoyl bzujl `h kozml jh,
ogd bzujlm gozay zmupom R{h` ~d lmlh, "M}j =6=?':>/
Khca gm bl `ovmlol dx `oy fol gz m{m jo bhy zh jo~hoyol1 Jkxgml bl bhz`x jo hl vogml
`ovmlol `o~hoyol# c jhc gm bl `ovmlol dx `x gozay m{m `odmzol jo m{mhd }hle lhzg jo bhy
zh jo~hoyol1 Jo zmup# khchd fol gz bhlh dx jo y hd lovmlol, M`hpm {ml h{ h dx bhz kmy jo phl
hd fo {ml `o~hoyh# lmbch lovmlh dx `oy `ol f pophd jfh, Ml f bhz kmy hd jo `hlkhd jocol`
`o}zh `ol j`hlk `oglh,
@x gozay m{m `odmzol jo zv`mz jo bhy zh jo~hoyol1
Uozm y hd hy h6 @azm bhz dhu bhh `oy bhz hd }hle kxb r{h jo`h ~hyl `ol, mr dxgz jo~hoyh# `oy folm { }hle kxb r{h `o`h { mr dx fol jo~hoyh# `oy gz { }hle kxb r{h
`o`h {, Gh jobup dx `o lec `h `ojfh6 Jocm bhz gozay `o jobupol `h jo chv jh# `o ~hoyl
bzujl `h kozml jh,
Khchd emzml hg fo r{h zh `ojfol6 Hkhz hv jor{mvog dx l `ol jo m gol jodol# `oy dx hv jo
`hlkhd jo bzu fo {ml zh jo~hoyog, Fo r{h hy lh zmup h bzu px emzml mcdmzom gh lmdh# ogd bzum
gh# ml `oc l `ol `odlh bod `odh# ml f {ml `opozulh bolk h{ }hp lmr{mvol kxb r{h jo`ol
~hyl gh,
Ghuhch hg jfol `x r{hl`hyml bhlh, H{ co @omzjmdz z`olol h{ `aupl bhy` lh, Khchd emzmlh{ jo bhy zh `ool eobhd `ol, Zafhd hd fo {ml `or{mvh dx h{ fo ja hl` zafml bhzol jmfmz Yml# c
`ol `or{mvh dx h{ bhz`x bhzol jmfmz Ghz`l, emz `oy h{ o jodol1
H{ `odmzol zod jokozol uhzbodo jodol dhiphchip jodol bhpm dx hd fo {ml jo uhz dhyh4 bolk
h{ `aup r{h jodolh { jmfmz dx { `or{hup bhzh, C jhc hkhz hd fo {ml }hp lhr{mvh bhzh {
jmfmz# bolk h{ `aup { m{m zafl r{h co { `hz `hzjmu jodol1 Gm bl `ojfol dx { fo ja {ml
r{h jh1 Lhrz# fo jhz dx hd fo {ml bhzkmy { co ihzuhl`hd jokhzh dx fo { jmfmz jozhyh# bhzh jmfmz
`ol,
Gm bl `ojfol `aupmlom {ml { jo y hd rxzpoz jojh1 Lhrz# `o `aupmlom zmupl `h zod vaz`mz
lmjh,
Lobm hg co zohdh ml co mzhuhzohdh `ol jolzol, H{ bhz`x `aup `odmzol jo m{mhd }hle
bxzghpdmz kxb r{h jo`ol bhy`, H{ `odmzol jo bhy zh co uh`hgl fo ja lm Ghz`l fo ja lm
Yml jolzol h{ `odmzol co }hleom bhy` jokhzol, ` ~op `hghd h{ jozmz jo`ol dx h{ bhzol
Ghz`l# fo jhz dx co Yml bh{m lhr{h h4 co {oz umz h jhzi f bhh, C `o jobmz `h h{ `odmzol jo bhy
zh fo ja hl` zafml bhzol Yml f, Bolk h{ bhz`x `aup { jo mb bhg jool Ghz`l bhg f jool
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
16/43
=5
Yml# ogd bhz hd fo {ml kxb r{h `m zmgml ~lomzl `ol4 {ml `oc bhy lhbop# c {ml }h`z
bhy` kozp `aupmlom {ml rxzpoz j,
Jo zmup# `o lmy fol gz `h f `odmzh hl {hbm jh, Hz# gz `odmzh jo bvm vhl`l r{h vaz co folm
r{h jodh, fol f `odmzh jo vogml pf gz r{h jolh bzum { zmdh# c jhc h{ bhz`x { v fo
bhy` ~ozz meov jojol `oc {ml { fo bhy joglh,
Hkhz fol iodzl `oc gz r{h lhvmlh jo phl bzum { jojlh# bolk fo ja { ~ozz vhbghp h dx h{
}h`z gz r{h jokozh, Hkhz gz kxb r{h lh`h ~hyl folm r{h fol f kxb r{h lh`h ~hyl gz
r{h# h{ m{m jovmlol dx `ol o `oiodozh o `or{mvh1 Gz { meov jojh bzu jodhyh# fo jhz dx
folm { uomlhpm { lmkozh4 bhz{hbm folm { f { bzu jodhyh4 fo jhz dx gz { }ghp lm`h {, Jo phl
fol { joiodozh dx h{ m{m `odmzh fomlm gz r{h phbc jodh gz {# { joiodozh dx h{ m{m `odmzh
fomlm folm r{h phbc jodh,
Hkhz hy hd jo`aglh# `o lmy fol gz `h bol jo bol bhvdozol { dg jojh `hghd { j `
bhvdozol lmglh,
@o `m{o `h jhcd h{ jor{mvol dx `hy fo bhy` jhz`ol4 c jhc hy hd bhg co bhgjhz hgzl
R{h` bhg f co bhgjhz m`hpml h jhcd vmzadl {ml f bhlh, @h yem jo phl fo ja y hd h{ jo
bhy zh `oglol# c bhz hd fo {ml {hd bhjmlhdh ~oi`m pofh bzu h, emz hkhz bhjml v`h j ~oi`ml
jolh~orh# bolk fo lod yh h{ bh{m { bhjml jo}hplh { `hzdhyh, [xum f `hgm phlkmb bmcl
kozml jl# bolk { `o `oc gozay `h meovjl bzu v`h jojol4 ~ gozay { jor{mvh bzum r{h
`m}xzplh# c fo lod yh bzum { { fo bxl`oz { `hzdhyh `oc gmcol { jozl`mz jodh,
Gm ~{oup h dx pdocom `o lmy fol gz `h {hbm jh1 Lhrz# }hp lh ~{oup h dx {hbm jh, hl`
zhpl jolkhbl bhlh h{ `odmzol `o y `mjm `h mcdmzom gh jodol, C jhc {hd dx gh jhz lobm `p#fo ja y hd lhiujod cmvog h `oy gozay mgm`h jh dx h{ fomlm r{h jokxbhzh,
H{ }mll ml zhpl dx lobm hg `or{mvol co uhz {ml jo~hoyol# lh iodzl l lh lh f popl `of{mz
ol4 h{ fo ja igdozol lh kozml ol jo zmup }ghp {ml fo ja bhz gmc julaz h,
zhpm ~6
` hv lmbcog dx bzum gol bhpm uojh jo`aglh, mr dx hv meov jojog bzu jodhyog# hv lmbcog
dx zaf co uhz bzum gol joh mym4 ml jhzom dx hg zmvol# hv `or{mvog jo lhzg jo `ocayml jo folm
r{h zh ml jo gz r{h zh jo~hoyog cjobzpol f jor{mvog, Jo zmup hy hgoz# hgzhd R{h` h `o
lec `h loyu h, Hy zhp khchd jo bv h# ogd `oy hg lhbcol dx h{ bzu j `m}xzpml`ol h{ zafjo zaf v`hpoz jojh, Jocm co uhz {h hy kapolm ~oml lh kapol6 Bzum {ml zmjh# c { vozmz f
jojlol,
@oy fo ja bzu `hgm l bhjh# ml `oy ~op `hghdh dol h{ bzu `hzdhyh bhzh# ml lh# jbl {
f j, Hkhz bzu fo zafhd v`hpoz jo`aglh# h{ dxzg `ojh, Bzu {hd ~pm koz h h{ gozay dx bzu
`ojh# v jo mkoz bzu p h{opml`ol, C jhc hkhz px bzum r{h fo R{h` zh hdhzh jod# bzum ph `mplh
~op `hghdh dol px `odmz fo folm r{h zh co uhz uh`hg bzudhpolm r{h jfh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
17/43
=0
mr dx hg co jhz fol ml gz r{h }hjc `odol dx gh m p dozoh# bolk bocgm bzu fo `oc gh
`hz`odhyh bzum gh {ol`m `ojh, @hgm dx bl bhz`x bl jojol dx bl }hle kxb r{h jo`ol bhy`#
bzum {h {hd jhz v zmlmjh, ^op `hghd ` vmzadl {h lmjfol6 za ` jmy gh bzu dhpojl-
lh f bmm ezmll {h { fo bzum {h bhjh,
@o lec `h hy ~hyl kozmljobm bhlh# `ojfh6
Jocm zaf co uhz bzum {h lhh mym, Lh f z jo`ol jcu, "Hihu 06:9,:;/
zhpm o`xml6
Jo bxzghp jo bhy zh jo~hoyol, Jozmzm r{h jo`ol dx `mjm o jh# jocm h{ jh# bl }hle kxb`mzom bhy
jodol, Emzlm fol kapoll pf `ojfol ml phy`ml `odol, Emzlm h{ fo cojhd poz gmbuhzhd `odol,
Bol fol `or{mvol r{h jo y m{m jo~mzvol bzum r{h doi jodol,
Uocgml ~m`mb co uhz folm zbhcmc bfmjocol` {hbm `ojfh6
H{ `hy r{h jo hbzhvm yh`odh vogml { jo `ocaymlzhpml `odh, "Kapoll Uocgml 5=6:9/
Jkxgml bhz gz ~hul r{h jo hbzhvm `ocaymlom folm r{h `o`h fo folhdh {hbm ~ozz bhv `odh,
Folhdh hbzhvm `ovmlh dx dhlk `oy h{ jo~hoyh dhlk `oy dx h{ j`hlk joglh, Folhdh `ocayml
`ovmlh dx h{ jo rhjhzl r{h m{m `odmzh bhvdozol jo`h doidozol,
Bhz{hbm Uocgml ~m`mb jo dgmbol gzml f `ovmloj, [ kap6
Pop dx gozay `o `oc rhcd `h zl `odh# `ocaymlom { h
gozay jhchlkmv fo `hzh{dmz poz h- "Kapoll Uocgml =?6::/
Gm bl `ovmlol folhd `or{mvh fo bhz pop jpoz gz { `ocayml jh1 Fo r{h fol `or{mvh dx gz {
fbmp eol` jh# umr jh gmc`mz jh# c jhc fo yml bhg popml jpoz h{ `or{mvh dx gz { `ocayml
lhzg jh,
@um Uocgml ~m`mb `o y kapol `h }ghp `ocuavo plh jhz myl gh# ogd h{ `ojfh6 poz h
dx hd jhchlkmv jh# lh dx `hzh{ml jodh-
Hkhz zmup `ocayml ~opm bhy jokozol# bvm {ml bhz`xml ~ozz ghvol `ojh, Hkhz hg bhz kmy fo folm
r{h zh zmupo jfol# c hg zmupo jo bod jo vogmlhd phbc jfol# jo phl ~hyl dh`hz {
`hz`odhyh hg hz `hzrol, C jhc mr dx hg zmupo jo `ocayml jfol# kapoll gh { {hd zhpl}hle jl jobupol h{ `ocl jozl`mz umr jodol,
Fo folm r{h jo~ozuh gm `hlk ph m{m h1 mr dx px `o~hoy# gm `hlk ph jo bzu ml bo d rxm
`ojh1 Gm px `or{mv r{h jo~mzv# ml px kxb r{h `o` folm r{h1 mr dx px `o~hoy# hy bhg pop `o
`hlk ph `h pl jobupol, Jhcd bolhd {hrp cmvog h bhpm dx h{ jhzuoyhdh fo `oc jo`h ph# c hkhz h{ ~
jobhuh dx px `or{mv zmupo jovml# h{ fo ph zh jfh,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
18/43
=8
@ocayml lh jo phl h{ h dx gozay jo lhzg jo bhvdozol jo bhy zh jo~hoyol, Bhz{hbm `ocayml h{
h dx pop dx px `ovml# px fo folm r{h zh jf, Hkhz px jovml dx p `o eob rhjmpm r{h `h `hzhlk jogl#
fo folm r{h zh jfh, Folm ph `or{mvh jovmlh dx `o zafm ph `h o `ojh lh fo jhz dx h{ fo ph jm{hz lmdh#
c jhc fo jhz dx h{ rhgm ph `or{h fomlm ph m { jo bhy zh koz`m h,
R{h` m}oc `mh folml f h{ f `or{mvol bl jojol ~cmlm zafm r{h dol, Gzhd }hle fomlm r{h
fo jhz folm r{h yhlhzh# `m dx `o lmy fomlm { m folm { `h `zdhpol lhjh,
zhpm uouoml6
Kapolm ~oml `ojfh6 Kapolm r{h jobmzm `ocml h, Hkhz px ~ `hzl dx folm ph ml gz ph bzu
dhpoh# jo lhzg kapolhdh r{h jfh jo bod jhzuoy lh`h, Hy zhp# jo zhpm ~ m `o`xml yh
koz`m h# c h{ b jpoz fo ja {ml `hgl dx px zmup bzu j h,
Hg `um kxb r{h jo`ol Uocgml ~m`mb, [ `o Ph{zmp `h {hbm loyuoh6
Jhzuym lhzg bzu zm`o{huplh# c jhc kapolm bod rhvhj zm`odh, "Kapoll Uocgml =86=/
Gm {h hy hd }hle jobup1 Co kaz y mhp hkhz hd fo {h bzu jodhyh# jocm `ol jorhjoph dx
jhzuoyhdh lhzg jo`h,
Ghuhch hg jfol `z {h jh- mkoz kozp gmcm {h, Hkhz bl my jo koz `h jodol# mkoz { yhgozh# c
hkhz bl jhlvl jo koz `h jodol# mkoz { kxz jojh-
Bh kapoll gh lh# h{ f {hbm lh, Hkhz hg `o bzum folm r{h ml gz r{h `h ~hyl bod jfol#
bolk mkoz bzu { kxz jojh, C hkhz hg jo kapoll lhzg jhzuy jo`ol# mkoz bzu { j
yhgozml`ol# ml bzu { `hlh `o gmc `h mp { joglh `um { rxzp jojh,
Jo zmup bzu fo ja gmcm {h {hd koz pmcdhhdh ghvol h, Fo bzu vaz`mz `hz`odhyh bzu bhz kmymp h{chbom `o gmc `h rhzm `odh, C jhc khchd emzml bzu lh {hd mkozhd ghvol `o gmc `h
~`odhyh# c ~ozz emzml h{ {hd ozudhdh jod `hup ~ `odh v ghvol `ojh, Gm lh {xum h1 Bzum
{h jo meovjlohdh jod `hup ~ `odh, Jhcd `o pophd jod `h byom ph p dlml`ol# ml ~lomzm ph
lm }hjcdozol# ml f hd `ol kapolhdh phbc `ojfh, Hz hy pop `o bxl`oz gh `h ghvol `ojol bhpm dx
bzum gh `oph}h,
Emzlm f jozlhdh dz `o `oc gh `h yh`ojh, @ojh dx { hd `o vmzadpom gh `h `hup ~ dozojh, Jhcd
` jmy ph fo ph zh kapojol dx z ph lh {hd r{odm ph r{hod h# ml kapojol dx m}oc ph dg h px
lh {hd jozm r{h fz fbmp , Hkhz popl {hbm jol# h{ `odmzol jojol uh`hg dx vmzad ml razphd
bhz kmy fo r{h jo~ozuh jfh6 Khca gm hv bfm bhvdozol gh# ml lh1 Jhcd jo y hd ehumzhpm {ml
bmpoh dml`ol h{ px emzml fo r{h bhv lmdol `o my r{h jo r{h `h j}ghp jlh,
Uh`hg o jol# jocm h{ jol# `oy bl px emzml fo jz lhdol dx bzu bhg `oc {h bhg f gmcm {h bhcmd
`odh4 bzu bhz kmy pmcdhhdh dxf`mz h, Jo zmup bzu khchd gmc rhzm dozolh, Jhcd khchd emzml fol gz
bhy jhzlm`ol# c h{ `o `oc r{h `h fo bhy `z `odhyol, Bzu hdpom zmgml bhupl `oc {h rhzm `odh4
h{ pdocom {h m zxbml bhpm pdocom {h m vmhl` f rhzm `odh, Jo zmup# bzu `ofgolhd ghvol h-
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
19/43
=9
Hkhz bl jojlol dx bzu bhg dhpoh fomlm {h bhg f gmcm {h# `um f lhpozuol# ogd govklom
mzhuhzo bhh, Hkhz bl jovmlol dx bzu o h hkhz {h ig dozojh dx bzu o}mu jo rhphz h# bolk
bl `odmzol jo popl dx {h lobm jobupol# y ~ozukozd mzhuhz jodol,
Jkxgml ehumzhp jozmzhdh fo `oc ~{oup h dx px jodmz bzum r{h jol`hup jod khchd kozlk h dx px
jo hdhzh co uhz bzum r{h jo fol ml gz r{h zh jo~hoy, Hy lh buml h# c jhc ih`m y hd { fo
ja {h bhz`xml ~ozz ghvol jh, hkhz bl fo R{h` jor{mvol# h{ mcdmzom {h jodh,
Uocgml ~m`mb `ovmloj dx jol`hupdozolm bzu lh dmzhd uoyod h, [ kap6
Gozay dx v bzu lmjh fo gzrmu poz h
dx lhium r{h `okozh fo dx jmfmzhd `ouplh poz h, "Kapoll Uocgml =965:/
Co uhz yml popml emzhdh `ol }hle joiodozol6
^ jocm bhz hd fo {h yml ~ozuml fo r{h jo~ozuh ~opzh jo bhy zh co yml hl ~ozuml jolzol,=, Khca ogm lh }hle h dx `o gmcm gol `h bzu bhjh1:, Gm hv co kaz `polm gmcol r{h co kaz `polm gozayl `ol# gozayhd jo bzu og15, mr dx hv bzu `odhyog# gm uh`hgm jolkhbl fo ja y hd o h1
Hkhz hg jor{mvol hl` kmyl }hle jmyfol# `oy dx hg `o gmcm r{h `h jo m{mhd l jo bhy zh
jo~hoyol6
=, Lhbcol dx zaf co uhz bzum {h joh mym,:, Jo uomlhp jo bhy zh jo~hoyol,5, Hkhz hd fo {h bzu jodhyh# jocm `ol jo lhzg jhzuoy jo`h,
Jo bhy zh co uhz yml popml jorhjopol yml popml bl vmzadl r{h f jodol# `m dx h{ f jo y m{m jo
bhy zh jo~hoyol jo`ol jouplol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
20/43
=;
8, ]ghp Uomlhp
@o kxl`hd `h `x vocmg bhjl bhz hd fo {ml r{h`o uhhdoymlml j, Bhz`x uh f px emzml `z
r{h r{h lhdhpol, C jhc `um `o lmy {ml bhz`x uhml `h ihz} bhj, Uh vocmg ~ bhz kmy jo
{zu koz`m j# c uh vocmg `o`xml pmg uhzjhup j, Bhz`x uhml jo m r{h`o r{h `odoz# cuh ~ fo jhz dx r{h`o { c `oroup {xum `odoz `o`xml fo jhz dx kxb r{h `o`m `hlk
r{h`o r{h {xum `odoz,
Lobm fo gol zh jfh6 Fo {ml bhz`x uhml# dfml jo zmup r{h r{h uhzjocol` `odoz1 Dfml fo {ml jpoz
bomz `ogm dfml jpoz lajh`mzom goml `odoz1 fo {ml bhz`x vocmgml dfml jpoz co uh r{h h{ch
`oj1 Fo {ml vocmgml dfml uh r{h bfmpoz `obhuojml`1 Jkxgml vocmg `o`xml,
Gm`hg dx }ghp uomlhp fo mco bolhdl `ol yh p kozpol# gozay lodmzh {ml jo `mz vaz jo `hup
jorh, @oy gozayl `ol fo `oc eml }ghp `o`ol gh bxzghp fo gh zh jodol, C khchd emzml hg ig
lmdol# ml f hg fo jz `odol dx `o y `mjm `h m bhz kozlk pozum R{h` h6 Hkhz gozay fo R{h`
jopozuh# v ml `hzhlk uomlhpm { { j kozpol,
Hg `um kxb r{h `o`ol gozay bhzhbzhvm Uocgml ~m`mb, [ co uhz y hd {hbm kap6
@hgm dx `oc R{h` jo zol gozay r{h h# h{ `ofgoll { f jo { zh co bhy plh,
"Kapoll Uocgml =96;/
mr dx hg uomlhpm R{h` jokozol zghp jo`ol {# bolk `mr{mvm gh { h{ jh dx hg bhg
zmupo jfol bhg f `o zmupo `h jofl, C jhc khchd fo gh lovmlol dx fomlm `o zmupo `h o h, Fo
vmzadpom r{h yh gh `poh fo gh zh bmpoh kapol f dx gozay `odmzh fo ja ih`m r{h# ml fo ja ~mzmupolm
zghpm r{h `hzh{ml jodh `um rhg pxlh,
C jo zmup h{ `hzh{l ~{oup ml h{ yozl fo lhmzo }hp jo zghp uomlhpm zmupl zh co bhy
lmkozol, Bhg `o my R{h` `h bhg f co jhz gozayl `ol# h{ pop kxlhb ol,
Hkhz hg `o dozl iozapol `h lhzmupo jfol# fo r{h hy pophd rhzmj h# `h yem hkhz hg fo folm r{h
zh# ml f fo gz r{h zh popl lhzmup jfol# b khchd rhzmjpoz h, Hkhz hg {xum jodol# gmcm gh { jojh
dhiphdh pmz,
@o dhip `h ~hlehzh pxlol# jo phl `hzohd bhh, @o dhip `h zalmb dg h# h{ pmz bg h }hp
lh eobhd {xum h dx vmzad jodmzol c m jojol p `h ghvol jojol, Hkhz hg `o gmcm r{h `h `hzh{mljodol lhzmupo jfol# vmzad { fo gh bl jojol hl pop jodol, Gmcm gh { jo rm~ml`ol# lhjm{hz#
bzu vaz`mzo pofh jojh,
C jhc mr vmzadhd bl jojh dx jhz zmup }hleo zghp h `hgm h{ bl jojh dx jhz `hzh{
`ovo hzghvmz h# bolk h{ jojh gozayhd jozv bxzghpdmz,
@o lmy fol gz `h f {hbm h, mr gz `ojlh dx folm { lmvod# `ocuav zmup ~md h# h{ `o my
{ `h b }h`ozjocol`poz `ojh, Bhz{hbm mr fol `ojlh dx gz { lhzg# `ocuav# zmup ~md h# h{ `o my
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
21/43
=2
{ `h b kozmljobmpoz `ojh, Bxzghpdozol jolkhb bhvdozol h, emz# hkhz bl jor{mvol dx bhvdozolm `o
lmy {h `h rxzp jojh# bolk }ghp jo`ol bhy` fo bhy zh bxzghp jodol-
Emzlm gozay vozp r{h `o`ol lhzmupo `ojfol# ogd h{ `or{mvol dx `o `hghdh dol `h uomlhpm
{ml j kozpol, C jhc bxzghp }ghp `o zafhd `h lml }hvhledozol,
Jkxgml# `oy hg bhg `o `ml upml`ol `h jo h`hj lmvod jol# c jhc gmlm }ghp bxzghp fo
m h`hj khchd dzpoz h, ]ghp bxzghp lh phl jo bhc{hup chjmpl jhzmy yh koz`m lh, Lhrz#
}ghp bxzghpm zmupl fo `oc pl, Emzlm gozay jo zv`mz bxzghp fo hd `ol zh `odol# c `um f h{ `o
`oc r{h `h co { h{ch lmjol f jm{hz lmdol,
Khca `oy gz o jodh dx folm { uomlhpm { jokozh1 Ml `oy fol o jodh dx h{ `o my gz r{h `h
bfm rxm jojh1 Jhzuoym y hd lh khchd kozml h, Fo r{h jo~ozuol joiodozol6 Bl `or{mvol `o
}hzhdpz gozayl `ol `h o pop bhjol1
Hg co uhz hl` fo {ml popml bolhd ~hoyl# gm lh {xum h1 mr dx hg `ocuav jol jo bxzghp jobhy zh jo~hoyol kxb r{h jo`ol bhy` vogml gh lh jo bzu# c jo lhzg jo `ocaymlo
jo~hoyh# bolk hg jolkhb }ghp bxzghp mym jodol }mg jodol,
Hkhz h{ pop `o fomlm gh `h rxm jojol jodhyol hruohpm gh# v ml `hzhlk gozayl `ol { `hup ~
jodol# uomlhpm gh jokozol,
@aupl `hcmc# kapoll {h o}mu zmup ol1 Ly jo ly# ml v`hpoz1 Ml fo uh` bhp1 ]hle co uhz y ~ozu
joiodozol- ]ghp bxzghpm ph m co jhz R{h` co uhz gvll zmupo pl doml`ol, Hkhz hg jo kapoll
r{h yh {hd vz co uhz gvlml jl doml`ol# }ghp gh { o jh1 Hg `ovmlol dx vz rmu bhh vz
}hc~ f bhh, Vz =0 hmz bhh vz :0 hmz f bhh,
Jhcd bl `ojfol6 Hg jo phl fo ja ih`m r{h ml fo ja ~mzmupolm uomlhpm r{h# lhzmupo `ojfol,
C jhc gozayl b fo gh rhzmjpoz f bhlh# jo phl hkhz h{ jovmlol dx h{ jo kapolm zmupo ~hzml
}hvhle jodol# h{ zmupo jfol, Jkxgml bhc{huphdh {hbm lhr{hohdh bo m}oc gozay h,
mr dx hg co vmzadl r{h `olzol# hg `ojlol dx lh cmvog h dx hd `hzh{ml bl {ml jodh, J dx
hd fo {ml zh jfh# fo r{h h{ jo `hzh{ml `ovmlol, C jhc bhpm dx vmzad bl jojh zmupo jfh#
~hz{hz`hdozol phzjohdozol cmvog h,
Hz# `hzh{ pophd ~u rhzmj ol, @hzh{ gh `orm~lol# fo gh zh `ojfol6 Px lhzmupo jf# p fo y
bmc rhzmj rocmu joj, Hg `ovmlol dx hy hd lh zmup h# c `um f hg `hzh{ml `odol lhzmupo `ojfol,Jhcd fo ja `hghdh dol hg fo phlkmbohd rocmu jojol# c jhc h{ `hzh{ `oc gh }xc `odol bol jo bol
phymbom }ghp uomlhpm gh p zh `hz`odhyol# {ol`m `ojol pmgm fomlm gh lmglh,
Ghuhch hg jfol# hv fo rhjmpm r{h yh`okhzog gmc hv `ojlog dx folm gol meov h# ogd vmzadml co
bhy roupoh `okozl y f lh mgm`h h, emz gm bolk hv `odmzog o jodog dx hy bmc lhjm }hle
jojh1
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
22/43
=?
Jhcd `o eob `h bzum gol zmjh hv joiodozog dx co folm r{h jorog, Jo pmjhp hkhz hd# fo rhjmpm
zafhdh `ozf ~ozz {hupm jh# h{ v {hbm `oiodozh, C jo zmup ih`m y hd }hp pxlh- Fo r{h `o gmc `h
bhz pop uhzajola jh bhz dhu meov jh, Gm { }hle jh hkhz hv jo bzum r{h# }hzhjmcor meovjlm
gmcol r{h b v`hpoz jodog1 Jhcd folm gol pmg fo y hd `opozuh# c jhc gm vocmghd jom}oc
hbzhvm `or{mvh dx bhz pop b rhzmjpoz jodh1 Lhrz-
Gm `o y bmc `h zom jm { o jh1 m{m hv `odmzog mcdmzom gmcol r{h jodog1 Ghuhch hv
`odmzog vmzadhdh dx `okoz bockozog bupozl { ~m}of jodog hv `odmzog fo folm r{h zh jfog6 Hv
`ojlog dx ph zafhdh ~ozz vhbghp `hzjmu dozoh4 hv jo vmzadml zh `hzdhyog# `m dx co gmc bolhd j`hlk
bhjh px jodmz j uhz r{h zobhp joj,
Jhcd bl `ojfol6 Bhc{hupm y vocmg o}mu hej h- C jhc hv fo {h by `odog dx bl }hle co uhz
y hd joiodozol jojlol dx hlemgm y bhc{hup { o jh,
^ zh{m { phycobhyom `o gmc `h { j kxbhzpol bolk { `hup ~ jodh# bol jo bol bhz po p {
uhzjhz jojh,C m bhz kozlk hy h6 mr dx hg bmc folm r{h jojlol rhgm { jor{ol# bolk h{ jo bhvdozolm
gh jobhuh `oc {# { zobhp jojh, Jo y m{m lh phl zh{m rhzmj { j kxbhzpol# c jhc pay }ghp
uomlhpkozpol f { `o `oc gmcol gh `h j ml`ol,
Hv px# hg fo {ml gozayml zh bxzghp `odol l dx hg co {ml h{ch `ojol fo {ml bhv `odol, ogm
hg fo {ml bhv `odol co {ml h{ch `ojol1 Jhzuoym y hd hy h6 H{ gozay co uhz bh{eh`mzol gozayl
`ol `oiodozol# ml bmm {ml gozayml fo bh{eh`mzol gozayl `ol bhh4 h{ gozayl lhzg ol h{ jo
rzr{mv kxb r{h `o`ol zmgml ~lomzl gozayl `ol, Jo dxzp# hg `ovmlol dx h{ gozay bfm lh
dx hg bxzghp fo {ml zh jodol,
Jkxgml hg co bhgjhz khchd gozayml jo zv lmvod ol# c jhc hg fo `oc eml jo phl bxzghp fo
hl` gozayl pmjhp zh `odol ogd hg `ovmlol dx h{# gozayl zmup }hler{mv ol,
H folm `hcmc zbhcmc# dhlk hl` emzml ph fo gz r{h zh kapoh6 Hv fo ph zh khchd u~mu `odog dx
px khchd fo ja gh bhgml `orhjop, hv khchd u~mu `odog dx px gh `o~mzv mjazm gh `od,
Dhlk ml hl` emzml ph jo kapolhdh r{h# ml jo zhd jhm fo gz r{h zh u~mu dozoh1
H gz rhjmpdmz jmzkozml# dhlk hl` emzml ph ~hyhdh zl r{h fo folm r{h zh kapoh1 Ml
dhlk hl` emzml ph jo `ocr{h mcdmzom { dozoh1
Hkhz px {hbm lhd# jo zmup px hd m}ocuoyod , Folm ph {hd kxchdh u~hb jh`h{ h# c hg bhg
`ovmlol# hkhz gozay kxcml my lh`h# dxccdl {ml { jodhyol, [hd dx kxc co byom my lh# {xum f folm
ph co byom `ocayml ~huol`mlm ph h,
]hzhdpz fol gz co jhz my bhz dhu hdhzh lmjh# c jkxgml }hzhdpz {ml `o gmc `h p `pol,
Hkhz `o gmc `h fol gz }ghp lh`ol bhy uomlhpm bhy lhkozol# h{ gmc j zalmb h {hd dhiphdh
pmz h, Hkhz `o gmchd `h hchdpzd lhjh# `oy dx h{ iol`ml ml ggml jo dmz jlol h{ fo pxlh
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
23/43
:>
poz h# c jhc h{ khchd zalmbo lm`ol `o khchd hldml `h pmz `oglh `oy gozay b` b` jocoyh#
`m dx r{h co pophd lhrh,
@h yem gmcm dx `oczmup p `h lhjh# hl {hbm h, @o pmzo `h ~ozu od v`h `ojol hd lodmzh co
`ol h{ch jojh, @oy h{ uozl pmz yhmzp joglol bol jo bol pmz `hzh{ mpom gmc rhzm `odol, @o
lmy fol gz vmzadml `h zml jh{chb zod`mzo `hz`odhyol v ghvol `ojol,
Jkxgml mr dx gmcm gh jodhyh y bmc# { fo bhz dhu gmc zh ~ozz rhzmj `oc jh, C jhc
`mr{mvm R{h` lh hy h4 h{ `or{mvh dx `o gmcm gh `h zabl bhjh zalmbom R{h` { bhg mb
bhg f h{ch`mz bxzghp jo r{h zh jlh,
@aupl `hcmc# `o gmcm {h `h o}mu zalmb bhh1 Gm `o gmcl gh `h phl hl` gg iol`l jod
bhlh# ml zalmbom R{h` bhh1 Khca gmcm {h glm dhiphdh pmz h# ml gmchdh r{h zalmb h1
Gm lh poz h dx hg za `hup ~ jodol# }ghp jo`ol bhy uomlhpm bhy jokozol bhvdozolm r{h m fo
bhy` doi jodol1 Gm o uh`hg bhh dx hg za# bm lobm `hup jo yml popml lhdol#1
Fo dhzhgm r{h co uhz yml popml }hle joiodozol6
=, Jozmzm r{h jo`ol dx za bl fo dgmb yh emzhd ehumzhp jo`ol folm r{h# ml ~hul { jo`ol,
Jolzol dx o { jh, Hkhz kapoll {h emzm ~ zmup lhl igdozol# ehumzhpm r{h {ol`m lhdol-
Hkhz `mzhd `hghd j my gmjh ~opzh px { my jo`# fo r{h { hl` zafml jodolh bhpm dx h{ `um
l jojh,
:, Fo `cm dx bl fo gmcol r{h zh ~hyl bod jfol# joehzojlol jo lhzg jo {ml zh jo~hoyol,Hkhz ~hyl {h bhz kmy bod jo bzu pofh jol# bolk kmyhdh }hle m dx `oy bl jmyfol h{ h dx
bl ~ bolhd j`hlk joglol ~opzh jhzuy jo`ol,
Emzlm fo gh gzml zh p kapol6 Bm fo r{h bhjol- Hkhz bl emzhd jh m `ocayml jol# folm {h {
jor{mvh dx bl bhz kmy jhm `ocayml jol h{ {h jorm~lh,
C jo zmup# hy zmgml kapoll {hbm jm}ocohdh ghvol ol, Gm jmrhymlhd bhh dx fo r{h zh jfh6
Hkhz hv za yml kxcml my jo`og# { bhz zaf my jor{mvol- Cagm poz h dx hv {ml }hp my lh`og,,, Hg
`ovmlol dx px dhu {xum lmjfh,
Hz# `aupl `hcmc# ml hg kxchdh u~hb jblr{h jor{mvol bolk hg { bhz zaf my jo`ol# ml f`oy hg kxchdh u~hb jblr{h lhr{mvol bolk lh cmvog h dx hg { my jo`ol, C jhc hkhz bl
jor{mvol dx folm {h {hd kxchdh u~hb jblr{h jh# ehumzhpm { lhdlol rhgm { jor{ol-
5, Gm `o gmcm {h `h ~ymlm }ghp uomlhp o h1 Bl# r{h jo gvll }ghp zmupl jo{hvollol-
@o gofmzm uomlhpkozpol `h# khca gm gmcm {h {hd gmchdh vz =0 hmz h ml {hd vz :0 hmz h1
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
24/43
:=
9, ^{hl`om dz m `o lmy fol gz `h
H foll `hcmc gzl rah{up# gm bl fol gz bhy` }hle lmu `odol# ml lmu lmdol1 Ghuhch6 Folm
ph fo o zhlk ~ozz bhv `odh1 zlom dx h{ ~ozz f bhv `odh# dfml h1 Ml h{ fo o ezh eocml bhv `odh1
]hle h dx px jo {ml popml jovml# ogd hkhz R{h` foml jo`h {h bhz`xml# folm ph { b khchdumcml jo ph zh jof, Cagm kozlk h dx px jo {ml popl dx h{ fo {ml bhv `odh ml bhv lmdh# jovml,
Hl ~ozu fo ja folml f bhlh6 o r{mzol jo `oc gz ph h1 H{ fo o u~az bhv `odh1
@o yml popml `h khchd emzml `o lmy fol gz `h ihz} bhh4 fol v ig `odol dx gzl {ml fo o popml
bhv `odol# c gz khchd emzml lodmzol {ml uozl jod l foll r{h jovmlol, Khchd emzml gz hdhzh
`ojfol6 Hv fo y hd bhv `odog fo y pop bhv lmdog, @o lmy folml `h hy pop b v`hpoz jo bhup
`oclom {ml yh koz`m lh h{ yml popml jo ~hyml `omz lmdol, Cagm `oy dx gz }hle kxb`mz
jodh }hle jmcm r{h jo`h dx folm { o boc`ojofzh `oc { jo o po pml m `ojh, Bhi gormjol
khchd gozay `o y hd `h lh khchd fbmp lh# c jhc hkhz hg jor{mvol dx `o lmy gh `h ~{hl`om fo
`oc eml# ml pdocom dz bhjh# `oy hg co uhz yml popml bl jojol,
Folm ph fo o o bhv `odh fo o o bhv lmdh1 @oc { jo o popml m `ojh ml jo o rhgkl `ojh1 Hy
~ozu lh khchd vhbghp ol# c jhc v v lhjfol6 Fo r{h hg jhzuoyl ~ozul {hbm `ovmlol- Hkhz gzhd
co uhz yml popml bolhd cdacl jodh co jhzuyl {ml jokhzh# jo zmup h{ jojh bhg gzhdm bhg f
gzhdhbzhvm-
mr dx fol co uhz ~{hl`om vh{me# ml co uhz pdocom `o lmy fol gz `h `oiodozol# co kaz jz
jm{hzom {ml m bhz kozlk o h1
Emzhd hd hy ~ozu fo hl` vocmgml ~ozu jhzuym {ml f hy jl, @o kxgmlm {ml `h popl bhz
kozlk hy jl6
=,^hzh:,U~hbpmb5,Mcdmzdozol0,Lvdmb
Bolk hl ~ozu fo foll {ml gzml bmp ~ozudozol "{ml jo jhzuym gzl r{h lovmloj/, Jhzuym folml
{hbm j6
=,Lvdmb:,Mcdmzdozol5,^hzh0,U~hbpmb
Jo zmup u~hbpmbom gzl {ml lh khchd rhgm folml h# c jhc `o myl {ml `h khchd kozlk h dx `o
lmy fol gz `h lvdmbohdh dz bhjh gzl {ml mgm`h jol dx mcdmzom foll r{h jodol, H{
`or{mvol ~opm {ml jo bhy }mg jh,
Jkxgml R{h` fol miozml`ol { fol {hbm miozml`oh dx h{ jor{mvh gz fo { ~ozz bhv jodh# rhgm
{ jor{h }hle co { r{h jojh, mr folm ph jovmlh dx px fo { bhv `od mr h{ jovmlh dx px jo
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
25/43
::
`ocr{mv mcdmzom { `od# folm ph { folhdh `ocm jh, C jhc khchd gozay ig lmdol dx folhdh
jhrph{mz bhg gz r{h bhg f vmzadl r{h jhrph{mz `odh,
_ml folm ph {hd rhvlhhdh ~ozz kozmljobm h# c `oy hy rhvlh j dacml`ol bhpm dx h{ j `pol, Dm
p o}mu popl bfm `o rhvlhhd `h jojl# p h{}mu jo {ml m jhrph{mz joj, [xum f mr px jo
~{oupol folm r{h jovml co kaz {ml jod# p h{}mu ~zav jhrph{mz joj,
^op `hghd gol jo r{h `p dx hkhz hv jo eaghz` rhgm folm r{h jor{og# h{ bhz kmy khchd m
jojh, Jo y hd h{ ig `odh dx hv ~ozz fo { bhv `odog jo y hd h{ `ovmlh dx h{ `o my gol `h
~ozz bfm h, @o z { `h p `pol dx h{ ~ozz dir{h uhzjocol` h dx h{ folm gol h,
Emzhd hv g jm `auphd `hcmc, H{ `o lmy oml `h `o kxl`hd mu `h z`olh, H{ `aup jo hgoz yh
khchd fo gol ghvpoz h h{ gol fo vmzadpom gol yh lmu `odh, Hg co uhz uoiz zlo pol ~op `hghd folm
{ fo a`hm folml `hzdhp dx jojlh# dm gh r{mzol rocmu dozoh# ml lh, Kmym dx { ul boc`ml# `aup gol
fo { zh kap6 R{mzolm ph ~ozz r{h j, Z { {hupm `o eob `h zabl j h{ j`hlk jho, @o
{ kmy `h gol ig doz dx bhg `aup gol# gzhdhbzhvm h bhg f folm {# folhdh jhrph{mz h,
Bhpm lobm gh co hl` ~ozul kozlk lz6 Gh `p dx `oy fol gz fo ja vh{mehdh }hle jorhjopol4 gh
`p dx `o lmy fol gz `h }ghp`ml bxzghpdozol o}mu kozlk h4 bhz{hbm gh `p dx `oy fol gz jo
bxzghp jo bhy zh jo~hoyol, gh `p dx bxzghpm zmupl fo `oc p, C `o y `hzu `h hg `or{mvol co uhz
~ozuhdh dx b kozlkpoz h# joiodozol, ^ozum ~ hy j6 Folla gzla# gm jo zmup bl bhy` }hle lmu
`odol# ml lm1
Hv `or{mvog emzhdh `ol y ~ozu jlog jhz my {h# c gmlm y lh hl h, Hv ` lmr{mvog
jo~ozuog dm h{ zhlk dx folm ph f bhv `odh# o h, Hv `or{mvog jo~ozuog dm px `ovml folm ph ml gz ph
jo zmup d h1
R{h` bhz hd fo {h jo ezhhd pmjhp miozml`oh, [ khchd popl }hle jm `mlh {h bhz`xml, [
gmchd `mh {h# ml { ` jmy r{od jozm `mlh {h {ml f bl ~hz{hz`h dozolh, _ml gmcm {h
`ozy `mh hruohpm {h fomlm {h,
Hkhz px vocmghd {xum j dx jmy ph jo `om ph zh `ocayml j# bolk fo ja ph lh pophd pmjhp vhbghp
h dx px f jo folm r{h zh `ocayml j, Hkhz px folhdh {xum j dx jmy ph jo `om ph zh eozr{h j# bolk p
by jod dx gz ph f eozr{h jh,
_ml bl bhz`x lh jo `oc emlhd ymcm dhpolh fomlm bhy vh{oe lh, Lhrz# {h `o fomlm r{h `h
bhg popl }hle bhg f popl rhzmj `polh {ml popml `ozy `mh hruohpm {h, ^op dx gzhd fol fo
r{h zh jlh# `oy dx h{ bhz`x f# {ml popl }hle l dx h{ bl jlh# jo bhy` jo`ol vmll, Bhz{hbm
`oy h{# {ml popl rhzmj l dx {ml `o fomlm r{h `h `polh# fo bhy yhlhzol ml ldmz lhdol# `m dx h{
jo bhy zh jodmzol co uhz {ml popml jorhjopol popl }hle jorol `h{um popl rhzmj, Jo y hd bl
bhz`x f# bl `o pdocol r{h l `o lmy fol gz `h ~ yh bhzol `o {ml `h ~hz{hz`h jojol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
26/43
:5
C jhc `oy hg jolzol dm fol gz m{m `odmzol co uhz yml po pml bl jojol1 Hy ~ozuhdh kozml h, Jo
zmup# fo ja yml popml co byom rhum r{h ml foljozm r{h lhglh- @oy bl jo r{h hl` kmyml
jmyfol6
^`oy bl jo r{h jor{mvol dx co uhz gmcm folm r{h ml gz r{h bl jojol, Bhz{hbm co uhz fomlm
folm r{h ml co uhz fomlm gz r{h bl jojol,
_m `o`xml6 Jo bhy zh {hrp `hzjmu jodol jo bhy zh jo~hoyol, [hd dx gh `p# emzlm fol gz `o
hl gmc `h z`olol# c h{ px emzml jo m{mhd dz jo bhy zh lm~hoyol kxb`mzom bhy lmdol, Hkhz
bl jo phl fo ja dx bl pophd fo bhy jor{mvol jo bhy zh jo~hoyol# hy }hp lh jo bhy zh ~hoyl h- Gm
}h folm ph ml gz ph phl iozadmzhd h1 Lhrz4 c ~{oup h dx bl co uhz bhz ~ozukozd bh{eh`mzom
r{h gmcm r{h jo bhy zh jo~hoyol,
Lobm { }hle jh dx hg jo dxzp co `hup~dm fomlm fol gz ~ jolzol, [hd dx bl `ovmlol# gz
~ M`hg j folm ~# folm { Bm{m j, @o Ph{zmp `h co uhz miozml`olm Bm{m {hbm `ojfh6
Rx`ml R{h` fo { ~mzu dx fo M`hg upml`oj folhd doz fo gozay zh ml, "@hup~dozol :6::/
Hy o pophd lh{mvh j- R{h` ~mzu fo M`hg upml` fo { ~mzu Bm{m doz, Hg m{m `ovmlol
dx hy hd {hbm j1 Fo r{h M`hg dhpoj rh{ mr dx h{ bo mz j# h{ uo~ umr j Bm{m co
jhz { `ouhdol, _ml M`hg jo r{h f lh`p dx Bm{m fo dx `hz bmp jm {, emz hg fo dx `hz `ovmlol dx
R{h` m{m Bm{m doz1 Ml m b kozlkpoz6 ogm hg `ovmlol dx Bm{m m{m bmp miozml`ol1
Jhzuy hy h6 R{h` `or{hup M`hg jovmlh hg bhg jovmlol dx Bm{m lh fo colk M`hg ml fo ~o pm
M`hg ml fo uhz M`hg# c jhc fo bhupohd dx fo lh{}m M`hg j# h{ bmpoj dozol, Cagm { hgoz `m
Gum ~rhgjhz dx h{ y hd `o Ph{zmp `h joloyuh,
_ml R{h` fo ja dozolm Bm{m bhupohd dx lvd `oc M`hg j bocjofmzp, Jkxgml R{h`
`or{mvh dx fol gz lvd bhy jol, mr dx h{ fo bhy` bhv jodol# h{ lvd bhy ol, Hy hd lh phl
fo mco ~{oupom ivd yh {hbm h# c jhc `o gofmzm `oclom fol gz popl zxbml `h f# hy hd hl
{hbm h, Hkhz bl jor{mvol dx `oc {h lvd bhy jh# `oy bl `hup ~ jodol bhy` }hle lmu jodol
Bhi gormjol khchd fol gz bhlh dx `o `oc `h bhy jhz`mlh, Bzu phbc dhpoh lmyjhzm {ml `o
bhy~hoylm {ml `h `ocumz hv~hzhup v`h jh, Jhcd h{ vozp r{h `o`ol dx {ml jo hdhzh b
bhy` jhzlh`mlh b jo bhy zh `ofl# c jhc vh{mem {ml zghp lm`h R{h`, Gmchdh {hbm { m{m
jo `oc R{h` jh1
Gm bl `o `oc r{h `h o}mu lvd `oc folm r{h# ml `oc gz r{h lh1 Ml bl o}mu `z `oc folm
r{h ml gz r{h lh1 Jhzuym y ~ozu jo y hd doi `ojh6 Fo r{h jo~ozuol# gm `o fomlm {h `h o}mu
`oc`ovl {h l dx bl fo jhz folm r{h ml fo jhz gz r{h yh`ozol# bhlh1
Hkhz bl jo r{h yh `oczmup jol# bl v jojlol dx `oc {h fo `oc folm {h ml fo `oc gz {h o}mu `z
h# ml o}mu lvd { ml { h, Khchd emzml uh`hgm po pl `oc`ov# ml `ocuav ml f hvp h, Popl {hbm
gmcm {h rhzm `odol `ocml fo bhy `z jorol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
27/43
:0
Gmlm `oc`ovl o h1 @oc`ovl h{ h dx gozay mkmbo lh`h folm r{h ml gz r{h, Hkhz px po phd fo
`ol yhz# h{ ~ `obhuh mr dx hg pophd fo jhz folm r{h ml fo gz r{h yhzol# hg `z bhy
`odhyol, mr dx `ocuav {ol`m `ojh# lvdmb f {ol`m `ojh,
Bhpm dx `o lmy fol gz `h lvdmb lhjh# h{ lodmzol `o hdpo `h jo bhy zh jorhjopol jo bhy zh m
jojol v v bhvdozolm `o lmy {ml `h umz `ojh, Hkhz fol gz co uhz khchd popml mkmbo lh`ol bhy# h{
z `o`ol `ofgol pdoc `ml upml`olm r{h, Bolk jcu lmyhl`hdh pmz `ojlh dx {ml fo bhy `z jorh,
Hkhz folm ph kxgml jodh ml jovmlh dx px pophd fo jhz { yh`oz# h{ fo r{h zh jfh dx px lh fo `oc
eml fo { bhv `od h{ }ghp lm`h ph, Hkhz gz ph kxgml jodh dx px pophd fo { yh`oz# h{ jfh dx
px { fo `oc eml }hjc lmd uomlhpm { lmkoz,
Hg `o Dopjm ^zav `h `ojlol dx `o `hup~d `h fo joc M`hg Bm{m px gozayl `ol co uhz hz`
lhjl, @o { `hg `h kxlhb b lhdhpoj y `olm `o Ph{zmp `h `ojfh dx Gozay Tml M`hgW
folm r{h# bhz`x f pmv jl fo bhy hzg lh`odozol, "@hup~dozol :6:8/
Co yoz hg `ojlol dx R{h` bhg fol gz miozml`ol bhg f { `or{hup dx h{ }hp pophd fo bhy
yhlhzol, Bhpm jh`hlm {ml f lh pophd fo bhy` yhmzp j bhz{hbm `oc zxb {ml f fo jhz R{h`
fo jhz bhy` lh yhmzp jl,
C ~op dx kxlhb dhp `olm# {ml `o eob `h `hup ~ doz# r{h bhg fo jhz bhy bhg f fo jhz R{h`
yhmzpol, C jhc gm d `odmzh r{h fo jhz R{h` yhzh1 D `odmzh r{h fo folm r{h ml fo gz r{h
yhzh1 Kapolm ~oml zmup `ojfh6 Dhuhd {hd fol# jo gz r{h lovmlh bhz{hbm dhuhd {hd gz#
jo folm r{h lovmlh, Gm d fo folm ph jpoz fo ph bhv `odh1 Dhu pxlh dx jpoz fo ph bhv jodh, Gm jo zmup f px
`or{mv r{h fo jhz { folm r{h m dx fo ph bhv `odh# yhz1 Gm d fo gz ph jpoz fo ph bhv `odh1 Gm jo
zmup px `or{mv r{h fo jhz { yhz1
Khchd gozay bhlh# ig lmdol dx lvdmbom jh`hl m `o lmy fol gz `h jo lvdmbom `oc zxb
fol gz yh koz`m h, Fo ja ~{oupom fol gz pz lmdh dx h{ `o hl gmc `h zlol ml `o hl
a`h `h jol `oy dx bhg `oc {ml bhg f zxb eml {ml lvd bhy jol, Dm o}mu dim {h p dx
bl `o fomlm r{h `h jo bhy zh lh# hy}mu bl jo bhy m jojol, Cagm jo bhy zh co uhz mb dir{hol
r{h l zafmlh jo~hoyol4 `o mbo `h jo bhy zh m jojol `o phlkmbo `h bml jo`ol bhy`# ml `o
jhz `oc bhy `h {hzol,
[ mr dx gozay jo y hdm dx h{ jo bhy zh lh m `ojol# bolk lvdmbohdh dz `hup ~ `odh, C
jhc hkhz `o vh{me `h hy mbom bhvdozol jobhyzhjl lhjh# hvp myphlk ~h`m `ojol ` fol gz bhy lmr{mvol,
C jhc hkhz fol gz jor{mvol fo bhy bhv jodol fo bhy zh bxzghp jodol# `o lmy {ml `h
lvdmbohdh zl ~d p, @o lvdmbohdh {hbm `h bhg fol bhg f gz co bhy h{ch `ojol rhgm bhy
`or{ol4 `hgm hy hd jh# lvdmbom jh`hl f fo bhz`xml zh mbohdh khchd ghvol plh,
Jo zmup# `o gmchdh pofh bhvdozol bxzghp `h# khchd bhjod `hzgml lh cmvog ol-
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
28/43
:8
Gz dx fo R{h` `opozuh
Hkhz gz `o zom R{h` `h co kaz hgzl { jolm# hg gozayl m{m jlm1 Jo dxzp# hg
gozayl dx `o~hzovol R{h` jlm# hg `ocuav jlm# hg `o rhjmpm r{h `h fbmp jlm hg `oclhzg
jlm,
Gmlm ~hzovlm R{h` h{ h dx gozay fo R{h` zh bxzghp jodol zghp jo`ol {, Hkhz hg jo zmup
jo~hzovlm R{h`# lh ~{oup j dx gh vozp r{h jo`m r{h jocol` jodozm4 bhg f gh jodmzom co kaz
{ hgz R{h` jodozm dx `ojfh6 Fo folm r{h bhv jodh,
Hkhz hg `ocuav jol# pophd dx joy hg yhzol ml jo `ov jodol# { lhjh,
Hkhz hg `o rhjmpm r{h `h fbmp jol# hg r{h fo jhz~ozuomzol foml `z lhrol, C hg gmcol
r{h jo~mzvol {ml }hle r{h jodol,
Hkhz hg `oclhzg jol# hg jo `ocr{mv l `ol fo r{h jocol`poz jokozol# hg v bzu lhdhyol hg `o
jobupol `h jo chv jol,
Folm dx fo R{h` `opozuh
Folm dx fo R{h` `opozuh# { `hupbocmpom gz r{h }hjc jodh, H{ r{h`o zxbhd r{hbh lhzg
jh rah{up rhgcm { f# { lh phl popl jhzjomy jol# c { hruohp rmupom { jh,
Folhdh {hbm# fo R{h` `opozuh# ml h{ folhdh `oc~md fo `oc jo gz r{h yh koz`m joglh `xzxup
`ocuav jh4
H{ `hupbocmpom gz r{h }hjc jodh# ml h{ bxzghp fo gz r{h zh jodh { jor{mvh co r{h
{ joh,
H{ r{h`o zxbhd r{hvm lhzg h# ml kapol dozoll `hupl {# { zobhpo jo`ol gozayl `ol,
@oc bol gozay bl bhvdozol jh6 H{ gozay `ovmlol dx h{ m{m `odmzol fo l `ol bhv jodol h{
fo mco gozayl `ol yh f bhvdozol }hjc `odol, @o `ochd {xum `h `oclhzgom zmupl p `pol,
C bol `oc bhlh dx h{ bl bhvdozol lhjlh6 H{ gozay lovmlol dx h{ m{m `odmzol fo l `ol bhv
jodol h{ lodmzol fo gozayl `ol bhvdozol f jouplol, @o `ochd {xum `h vaz`mz `ocbod p `pol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
29/43
:9
;, U goipl kozlk
Fo ja dx `o lmy fol gz `h ~{hl`ohdh dz bhjh# u goiph# ml hg `odmzol jfol u hzp ml u
popl ~{oup bhlh,
Goipm ~hy h6 @oy dx eob {h bhjh dx bl c zobhp jojol px dhu lhdmzh {h meov jodh, Khchd
emzml hg co uhz pophdhru ml pmjhp `o~hoyol vmzadhd `hup ~ `odh# `okoz# ml `hlk phchil p# ml
pophd `ol uhz gh phycobhy `odh hg lodmzol jmcm r{h jo`ol folm r{h ml gz r{h,
Jhcd ~{oup jh dx bl `hz co ~op r{h jokozol# ml jhcd `oy bl jool eobhd `ol# c `o vh{me `h
~ozz kozlk h dx fol gz jo uhz r{h joglol {hrp {ml j~fol bhjh, Emzlm `oy bl fo ja y
hd jouhdolol# bhpm dx vmzad joloyol ml f bhzol ghdphj, @oy dx bl co uhz {hrp co uhz eobhd fo ja
r{h joiodozol ~cmll r{h dol,
@o y `olm gh `h# `oy bhz pop v mgm`h jojh bhz pop v f `hzjmu jojh, Emzlm `oy dx r{mzol
vdm j mgm`hdozol# c `o bhvdozolm `o lmy fol gz `h hy hd lmjh, [hrp cmvog h dx `o ~{hl`om
{h `h bhvdozol dz zl jojh,
Hkhz bl bhz`x px emzml jo uhz r{h jo bhy zh lhglol# bolk `oc eml {h { bhz kmy `z bhy
joglh bl v fo phljlm {hbm meov jojol, ^op `hghd bl joiodozol6 Folm gol }hp rhgm gol
lmr{h# ml bl jfol6 Gz gol }hp kxb`mzom gol lmdh, Bm fo r{h bhjol r{h fo yml popml
jo~mzvol-
C jhc hkhz bl {hrp eobhd jojlol dx bl jodmzol jo uhz r{h jo bhy zh joglol# bolk bl
hy}mu v bhy` h{p ig lmdol bhvdozolm {h { v`h jojh bl jo dir{h pzjl co bhy
jolzol kxb`mzom bhy jodol,
Cagm fo ja r{h bhg {hrp bhg f eobhd doi jodol# `m dx bl bhz`x jodmzol jo zobhp lvd bhy
jojol, Jo bhy zh `xm jodol# kxb`mzom bhy jodol# `o mbo `h jo bhy zh m jojol `o phlko `h jo bhy zh
jokozl bl bhz`x mc fo bhy bhv jodol,
Goiph ml hzp `o`xml h{ hdx gh bm fo vogml kapoll r{h bhjh, Kapolm ~oml `ojfh6 @oc
lh uoizh h dx gozay co jhz bhg dhu yhdh, @oy dx hg bhz`x }hjc jodol jozmz jo`ol dx hg jo
px dhu `ol zh co uhz `mr{mv uozl r{h lh~hoyol, Popl dx `o lmy fol gz `h pl kapol# lh fo jajobupolm px dhu `ol ol, Bhvdozol j `ocuav lmjh hkhz hg jo gozayl `ol zh jo~hoyol# `oy dx hg
~ozz bm fo popl {hbm bhjol, Hy fo ja gzml jhcd b jpoz fo ja folml khchd kozlk h, Gozay bhv `odol
dx jo bhy zh jo~hoyol `hgm dx popl jozv lhglol dx co uhz {ml jo~hoyol# bolk h{ pl `hi`ml dx
h{ co uhz popl lh co uhz z f jo~hoyol, Jo pmjhp ezml# `aup bhymc bhz kmy `o fomlm gozayl `ol `h co
popl jmcd `okhzol, Cagm `oy dx hg bomz jol, Hkhz px jor{mv uomlhpm gz r{h jo~mzv# `oy
dx px emzlm `hy r{h jokoz `oy px lhbc dx uozl {h `o lmy rhcd `h jhcmy jojol, Ml lhr{h# gz
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
30/43
:;
ph { ` popl kozlk fo ph zh lmjfh bl fo bhy `z jodhyol, Jlol jzm r{h6 Bm{m fo ~mzu M`hg
bmp dozol, @o jh`hlm gh `h ~mzu `oc gh `o~mzvol hl {hbm `oy dx px `oc uomlhpm gz r{h
jo~mzv uozl gmcm r{h jhcmy lhd# ml lhr{h# h{ iodzl `oc r{h fo jhz ph yhzh,
Uocgml ~m`mb `o Dopjm ^zav `h {hbm kapoh6
_ dx ~hyml jo r{h zh `okhzlh# uozml f hdhzh `odh, "Kapoll Uocgml :>6=?/
{hbm f kapoh6
D `odmzh folhdh bfmjocol` ~h`m jodh1
H{ fo cmc `xzzml khchd bfmpoz h,
@oc gz { co { h{ch `ojh, "Kapoll Uocgml 5=6==/
Goiph ml hzp uouoml h{ h dx hg bm fo myl r{h bhjol, Hv jm{hz `odog dx `o y hd `h
ehzojml`ol fo ja vocmgml ghvpoz h# c `um f `oy fol f bm fo r{h bhjol, Gzla# `oy my `oc {h jo
phl co uhz folm {h jh bl jo phl jo { dir{h jol,
mr dx fol ~ jovmlh dx my `oc ph jo phl co uhz { h# px jo phl jo { dir{h myl ph cofoll `ol lmkhzol# bolk h{ jor{mvh dx h{ `o myl ph `h b `ocd jh`h{poz jh, H{ jovmlh dx h{
`o my ph `h hdmlh h jo zmup px fo `oc eml fo { bhv `od bxzghp f zh `od,
@o yml zafml `h co bhz `hz khchd fol jo y m{m lml bhvdozol# c jhc hkhz bl jo y ezh fo folm
r{h bhv jodol# h{ uhz {h zmdol { jojol pmem uhz {h, Folm ph { co ph h{ch jojh hy hd { fo ph zh
rhvlhhdh ghvol jh, Hy mco hzl h
C jhc bm fo r{h bhjol# mco lhzl f bhh pmcdh h6 Hkhz folm ph jovmlh dx khchd foll `ol `o
bo ph `h bhlh# h{ `ocfmz mylhjmz jojh, Hkhz bl `o rhjmpm r{h `h# `o zaflmghml# `o phchyovalml
ml `o olphzlhp `h# jo `ocr{mv co foll `ol jolzol# h{ fo r{h zh jfh6 Hv fo ja gz r{h jo phl {hd
lmygmcohd gh,
Jo zmup hkhz bl jo phl `o `oc iodzl r{h `h f my co `hz jol# hy hd { vh{mem {h rhzm jodh
bl jojol glm km dx `oh }huhjrml,
Folm {h { `o `hlk {h `h jojobvh `o myl {h `h jojlh dx `oc {h jo { lh r{h h, Hkhz ph bm
fo myl r{h lhjh# px `hzo `oc r{h fo foll `ol zh yhd4 bolk b` b` `o `oc ph `h eob { fo folm ph
zh dg jojh `o `m{o `h eob f zh lmglh, Jo y m{m p bhg vh{mem r{h rhzm jod bhg f r{h jo
r{h folm r{h bhcmd jod,
R{h` fol `mh ph# `m dx bl bhz`x jo bhy zh m jojol, C jhc hkhz bl bhz`x bm fo myl r{hlhglol# h{ mb { bol jo bol {ol`m jojh, Jhcd ~ jo phl pophd jod jrhg { rxm jojh# c jo
zmup h{ pop fhbzm dxf`mz h `oy hg r{h fo y fhbz jo~mzvol,
Jocm hy kapolm Hj ~rhgjhz `o `oc bo gh bhgml `h joglh, Hj `o Dopjm ^zav `h kapoh6
Gol jo myl r{h zh ~hgml koz`mh dx hv jo `ocr{mv co dhodhd lhlzog, "Hj 5=6=/
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
31/43
:2
2, Vmzadl gh O
@o Vhjz `h co uhz vmzadml {hbm `ojfh6 Vmzad fo Rx`ml gzmu ol jhz gmcvmzad rhcmp h,
"Vhjz =:;65/,
Jo zmup bhz vmzadhd dx R{h` `o`h gh# rhcmphdh ghvol h, R{h` fo vmzadml khchd bhv `odh h{ `oPh{zmp# Vhjz `o lec `h co uhz vmzadml khchd popml fo ` jmyml zh `ojfh, H{ `or{mvh dx hg
vmzadml co kaz zom zmup bl jodol# `m dx h{ `o { zo `h jool,
Hkhz vmzadhd `o ~odmbom r{h `h popl }hle bl jjh jobupojh { `o razpmlom r{h `h kxb
r{h lh`mjh {ml popml f# ~opzh h{ popl }hle { jl jzm { R{h` `odmzh { vmzad fo zol rhzmj
lh}hle rocmu jodh# ogd ~hym R{h` {hd pay }hle `o `oc { vmzad `h bmpoh ml`ol h{ ~hyl
}hle# { zafhd jhz jo`ol,
C hkhz popl }hle# `o `oc {ml `h lhl ml`ol# mlzhpl R{h` co {ml lhl dozol# bolk h{
vmzad { vpoz fo z `hzdhyol yhkhzlm {ml f { lh buml jh# fo jhz dx fomlm {ml lh co uhz jolkhbhd
umrchg bmpoh mymdozol, Fo jhz y hd R{h` `ojfh6 Yml kapoll gol jorol `oc bo r{h4 {ml {hd
lmlhd co uhz `hupl r{h {hd jzmllhd co uhz hlom r{h koz jo`ol, [ml bl vmzadl r{h jodol6
mr bl co gmc z`olol mr bl `o z `h `ool# mr bl ~mc `o`ol mr bl zm`ojol# co uhz {ml
jo~hoyol- "@xjmzhdozolm hzhp ==6=2,=?/
Hkhz bl jor{mvol gmcm r{h jo hbzhvm ig`mzo mym jodol# bolk khchd uavl R{h` l
lh{mvh fo ja {h bhlh, Hkhz fol gz jo m{mhd }hle jo bhy zh jo~hoyol# hkhz vmzadl {h jovmlol dx
bl ~ozz fo bhy bhv `odol bxzghp fo bhy zh `odol# bolk khchd po pl `ol ` lh ~{oup ol, Gm`hg dx
bl bhz`x `ocuav ol bl popl `oc r{h fo jhz bhy yhlmzol px pop jo `ov lmdol# bolk vmzad {
ig jodol dx bl bfm bxzghpdozol lh,
R{h` fo vmzadml zh `ojfh6 ]h`z ` jmy r{h jokozol- fo ` jmyml zh f `ojfh6 Bl fo
R{h` jopozuol jocm fomlm {h jo zv jh, Hy bhz`x pop jo bhy zh koz`m lh6 Vmzadl ` jmyhd dx
fo R{h` `opozuol# khchd emzml h{ jo r{h f fo R{h` `opozuol fo ` jmy r{h zh bxzghp `odol,
Uocgml ~rhgjhz `o Ph{zmp `h jo ghuhchhdh r{hod plh jhz myl gh dx gmchdh {hbm m{m h,
H{ co uhz ozmhd `ojfh lml gh `o`h dx `oy `o bhz gmc `h zalmb bhjh, @oy fo ja bhz
vmzadhd zalmb bhjh# `m dx h{ jodmzh zom foml jo vhcmc jojlh dmz`hupom ` jmy h{ h dx h{ jo
bhy zh `o hdpo `h { zalmbo ~h`m jodol,
@o Dopjm ^zav `h Uocgml ~rhgjhz {hbm kapoh6Dxz gol# hgz jmy r{h jokozh
bldozolm `om r{h lhmyfh ~op kxb r{h,
[ml bhz kmy jo `oc r{h yh koz jo`h4
{ml jo up r{h yh jodh,
mr px z yh jo# h{ zjhzom ph jodol4
mr px zmdhy# h{ ph jo~mzvol
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
32/43
:?
kmym px bomz joj# h{ jo ph zh jo~hoyol,
ogd hgoz ozm h bldozol zalmb h4
Bomzdozoll h`hjdozol zom foml lh, "Kapoll Uocgml 96:>':5/
@oy jmy {hd ozm ml {hd imlauml jol# l dx `o {ml `h zl bhh, Hkhz zl umi jh# zalmb { }hle
jh, Gmlm hgoz co yoz h{ h dx `oy jmy ulazml `hlol {ml jo~mzvol, H{ ulaz bhg fomlm bhg
gmcoml `o~mzvol bhg f fomlm {ml r{h `odol, [hd dx hg `ovmlol# fomlm gh lh phl jh`hlm gh
h# c jhc zxb eml gh h bhg bhupl gh h bhg f bo m}oc gh p `h lh, Hy bhg popl bm
dmz`hupom jmy ol,
_m jmyla# dmz dmz`hupom {h h{ h dx zl `o imlau `h umi jh `o gmcm {h `h zalmb bhz v`h jojh,
Zl }ozf `xzp h# c zl umi }hzhdpz }hle h,
Ghuhch mr jmy uoriml jodh ml zml jodh# gm h{ `odmzh fo vmzadl r{h zh jfh6 zml lhdol-
Ml mr jmy `hzh{ml jodh# khca gm `odmzh fo vmzadl r{h zh jfh6 Cm{a# `hzh{ml lhdol# `hzh{ rhzmj
ol- Gm bolk vmzadl { lmjfol {6 ogm px jo r{h `hzh{ml `od1 mr dx gozay po phd rhzmjjodh# h{ lodmzh fo boll `ol zh jfh6 Iocml pop lhdol- Cagm hkhz jmy jor{mvh dx kapoll { jl
kxb`mzdozol# `oy ~ zhpml co r{h jo r{h jodh kxb r{h jo`h zhp ~hyl R{h`4 bolk {
jodmzh popl }hle fo vmzadl r{h zh jfh bolk kapoll { { jl kxb`mzdozol { jl }hjcdozol
f,
Hkhz }hzhdpz {h lh umi jh bl `xz jol# bhg folm {h bhg f vmzadl {h { phycobhy meov
jojol h{ }hp co {h h{ch lmjol, @o gmchdh {hbm `h# px emzml mp lmjh,
_m `modla# ~{oup h dx bl `o gmcm r{h `h zalmb jol- Hkhz zalmbom {h dg jh# jhcd uh`hg h{ h
dx gzl {h {hd dx ~{oup h fo {h bhv lmdol, @modm `hcmc# hkhz gz ph zl umi fo ja }hl`cm ph
~h`m lhdh f# `um ehumzhpm r{h {ol`m lhdh- Dmz`hupom ph f bhh dx px `o zom zmup `h zyh jo co
kaz hgoz zhpl R{h` jod, mr dx zl lh umi jh f# `um ~{oup h dx iopoc j doldozol h ~m}of
jh# `m dx o}mu fo `hup ph j# px {xum jod dx zalmbh{} jo`h, Hkhz px {hbm jod# R{h` jo r{h { fo
ph zh bxzghp jo`h dozol,
Hkhz ` jmy `o hdpo `h {hd }hl`c zalmbom { jo bhy zh jofl jorhjopol# hy hd { fo ja
vmzadl {ml `omzohdh ~ozz kozmljobm jh, Hkhz bhg ` jmy co y hd jokhzoml# `o gmcl {ml `h
{ bhg zalmb bhg f mp bhjm vmzadl {ml { jodmzoml jo m{mhd }hle ghvol jojlm jojlm gozayl kobp,
Hy kapoll Uocgml ~m`mb bl gh `o`ol dx `oy pdocom `o lmy ` jmy `h m{m jh, C jhc `oy
hg b jpoz co gmlm zl jolzol4 dm `o y ghuhc `h gmlm zl o h1
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
33/43
5>
Fo ja igdozolm y hd Uocgml mcdmzom gh `odh, H{ fo gh zh `ojfh dx fo ja vmzadml fo `hup~d
yh o pop cmvog ol, H{ fo gh zh `omz `odh dx `oy hg u popl jolkhbl fo vmzadl r{h zh jfol `oy
h{ {ml bhz u popml b `o jodmbom r{h `h bl jojol,
Uocgml ~rhgjhz {hbm `ojfh6
mr dx hv dxz jmy r{h jod jg `hcmc `om r{h hdmlh jg#
{ hv bl dozog fo gol zh kap6
Jocm `oc ph kapoll gol bod jokozh- Hgzl gol jokozh p jof,
hbzhvmo jouplh- Ig`mzo jouplh-
Kapoll gol fo jz lhdh fo {ml ymz lhjh, "Kapoll Uocgml 065'8/
B dx vmzadl gh jod# `oy hg u popml bl {ml jodol, Hkhz hg yml popml bl {ml jodol# bhg
fomlm vmzadml bhg f fomlm ` jmy {ml { bumlpoz jojh,
Fo dhzhgm r{h emzhdh `ol yml kapoll Uocgml jor{lol bl jojlol dx b Uocgml vmzadhd
jod j# jmy { bl { doz dx `oy h{ kxb`mz jh# mlkxb`mzom jmy r{h jodh jo m jmy r{hjodh,
Jmy Uocgml f zh kapoj6 Jocm `oc ph kapoll gol jokozh- Jkxgml gmlm y hd bhg
kxb`mzdozol h bhg f igdozol h, Fo r{h kxbl vmzadl {h bhlh# c hkhz h{ bl lhjol dx `oy gozay
m{m kxb`mz jodol# h{ lodmzol zom zmup jojlol,
Jmy Uocgml f zh kapoj6 Hgzl gol jokozh- Jkxgml gmlm y hd h{ h dx `oy hgzl jmy
jl mll eob,
Jo zmup hy hd lh pophd vhbghp h# c khchd ` jmy yml bhz`x popml bl vmzadl r{h lmdol, Hkhz
vmzadhd bl kxb`mzdozol lhjh dx kxb r{h jo`h co kaz kapoll ` jmy r{h jodh# bolk h{ fo
` jmy r{h zh bxzghp lmdh,
Hkhz gozay lhdmzh kxb`mz jodh lhdmzh co kaz kapoll gozayhd `ol jodh# h{ gozay { m{m jof1
Co uhz y hd Uocgml kapoh6 H dxz gol# hkhz px jor{mv fo ~hyl vmll ymz joj# bolk `hy fo
kxb`mzdozolm zhpml jhz`h, "Kapoll Uocgml =?6:;/
@o `hup~d `h ` jmyl gh zhpml co gh `odol fo gh zh `ojfol dm o zmup o lhzmup h4 ~op
`hghd uhzdmz gh { zhpml co gh jodh { fo gh zh jfh dx o zmup h o rhchp h, @o phymbom fomlm
gh `h `aup bhymcl gh { bhjol h{ emzlm gh bomz jodol ml { fo gh zh jfol dx `oy pophd `ofomlm gh `h j kxbhzpol, jo zmup R{h` jo r{h f `o ^hym r{h `h fo gh zh `ojfh# o }hle h o
rhzmj h h{ gh h`hj `odh,
Cagm hkhz vmzadl {h lhvmlol kxb r{h jo`ol lhvmlol jo m {h jodol# hkhz h{ bl lhjol dx
zhpml }hjc jodol co kaz {ml jodol# bolk h{ jo dx yh bhzol1
Uocgml co uhz y hd {hbm `ojfh6 Fo ja { dx ~hz{hz`hdozol zh` `odh# jhchlkmv hzghvmz
bhh, "Kapoll Uocgml =56=2/
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
34/43
5=
mr dx vmzad kxb r{h lm`ol hgoz zhpl gh# khchd emzml hg fo r{h zh `ojfol6 Rhg pxlh# h{
b vmzad h, C bhi gormjol# mr hg {hbm `ojfol# hg zalmbo lm`ol vmzadml, @oy dx vmzad bl
jojol dm o zmup h o lhzmup h, J dx hd zjhzom {ml jodh# h{ m{m { zom zmup m dx `oh fomlm
}hle jojlol1 H{ m{m jodmzol zom zmup fo zom rhchp ihz} jodol1
mr dx hg bmpol y `olm# bhz hd fo gh vmzadhd jod j, R{h` hy {hbm doz# `m dx hg bhg
` jmy bl vmzadl r{h jodol dx h{ m{m `odmzol zyh bhzol m{m `odmzol jo~hoyol h{ m{m
`odmzol kxb`mz jol jo m ` jmy r{h jodol, Jo phl M`hg Bm{m jo vmzadp lhbmpol y `olm# c
h{ f bh{e khchd hgoz zhpl R{h` jl,
Kxb`mzdozol }hjcdozolm zhpml mcdmzom gh `odh dx hg `o }hzhdpz r{h `h ~ yh bhzol# ml lh#
hg `o ig`mzo `h bhz kmy vmzad joglol hg lmkobfol,
Y hd fo jz lhdol6 Bhz hd fo gh `o fomlm r{h `h ml mbo `o`h Miozml`mz# ml f { rhgkl `odh,
Hkhz hg mbo jo`ol R{h`# bolk hg jo r{h f# hg m jojol# c jhc hkhz hg R{h` rhgkl jodol#
bolk hg f# hg rhgkl jojol,Ghuhch hg jfol jmrhymlhd bhh h{ bhz kmy jo phl pay `mzl id `olh# c h{ px emzml {ml
mylm`h }hp pophd `ol lmdh dx h{ ghvol jojol, Jo zmup gozayhd {hbm }hp lh jmrhyml h, mr dx
hg `mjm jlol uhz ` jmyml# hl pop h, Bhz razp dx kobp jh `odmzh jovh{oeh vmzadml jlh# c
phl jo y hd h{ lmjh jmyhd }hle, Bhz dhodm dx kobp jh# `odmzh gz jodh vmzadml jlh# c phl
jo y hd h{ lmjh `ohdh }hle, Fo gozayl dx `o }hzhdpz r{h `h }hp lhkobp jol zh# vmzad lodmzol
jl u~mzpol,
Cagm# hkhz bl fo vmzadl r{h bhv jodol# ~{oup h dx bl jorhjopol dx h{ kxb`mzom kapoll {h
jodol co kaz {ml jodol, Jo y m{m bl `ozyhd }hle jo`ol vmzadl r{h,
Uocgml ~rhgjhz `ojfh6 B dx by bh# dxz r{h h`hj jodh# c jhc jocm eml ph dxpolm {
lhr{mvh, "Kapoll Uocgml# =?6=2/
@ jmy m{m `odmzol zjhzom vmzadl r{h jodol1 Jhcd ~ozum {h pmg hy h6 Gm `oy zjhzom
vmzadml m{m j dozol1
Emzhdh `ol }hle jmcm r{h jo`ol kapoll Uocgml, [ kap6 B dx vmzad jod# `oy bl bl {ml
jodol dx h{ kxb r{h jo`ol jo kapoll {h jodol, mr dx bl v `hup jo y hd jodol# bolk hy hd
{ lh khchd vhbghp jh# c jhc hkhz vmzad jojh h# bhip umc bolk bl `hup ~ `odol# { vhbghp jh,
mr dx hv jg jmy# jmy gol fo gol zh kap6 @mzhd jod pzm `mzhdh jod `odh dx zmup ghvol jojh#c fo ja `mzhdh ghvol# `mzhd ghvol cmvog h, mr bl v `hup jo ~hz{hz`hdozolm vmzadl {h jodol#
zjhzom {h { bhg fo ja {h bhg f fo ja vmzadl {h zobhpoz jh,
Zafhd hv jo bhz`x dxzl r{h yh g jmfz `o jmvmz `h gh fo lod yh `p dx ym h# `x razp jmv
`o`ol `x ~acu f co ~h {ml `odhyol, ^acuml v h{ kozpol `hup ~ dozol jo `ocbo d jo `mzml co {ml
roupol, Rhcd fo gh zh kap dx {ml bhz`x razpml jhcm r{h `mjl bol dhodml,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
35/43
5:
Dxzl gol croupolhdh {hbm b lh`pojl dxz gol ghvol fo gol ~ozu kap6 Jmya# ~acu ogm co
{ml razpml `orol1
Gol f zh kap6 Jolzh# h{ razp `o vmzadpom r{h `h bl lhjl dx kxb r{h jo`ol jo m ` jmy
r{h jodol, Lobm h{ `o zom vhbghp `h y hd bl `ojol,
Hkhz mr dx b vmzad jod# hg vmzadl r{h ~hz{hz`h lhdol {ml h`hj lhdol# zafhd `oy
bxdxghp ml hg jo r{h f co {ml jorol {hd dx {ml ~acuml co bhz`x razpml roupoj, Cagm Uocgml
~m`mb {hbm kap6 Vmzad co kaz { zom dx `oy ~ yh joh ~hz{hz`h jodh4 h{ `o ~zpom r{h `h f fo
{ `hzlmdhyh, "Kapoll Uocgml ::69/
Jo zmup hy lh dmzhd uoyod h# c jhc hkhz bl jor{mvol dx `o gmcm {h `h m p bhjh# `oy dx bl
vmzadl r{h fo jodmbom {ml yh ~hz{hz`h jodol, Hkhz h{ bl jojol kxb r{h jo`ol# lh cmvog h dx
bl jo `hlkhd jocol` jo}zol ml {ml jo kapoll ~ jopozulol bhpm dx h{ jo m {h jodol, Hkhz bl jo
vhcmc fo vmzadl ~hz{hz`hdoz zh jo~hoyol# h{ kxb r{h jo`ol {h,
Gh kap6 B dx vmzadl gh jod# `oy hg u popml bl {ml jodol, C jhc bhpm lobm gh jo phl
kap6 @oy dx vmzad kxb`mz jol jo m ` jmy r{h jodol, _m uouoml m dx Uocgml ~m`mb bl gh
`odh dx hg fo vmzadl r{h zh jfol hy h6
hbzhvmo jouplh- Ig`mzo jouplh-
Kapoll gol fo jz lhdh fo {ml ymzz lhjh, "Kapoll Uocgml 068/
^{oup h dx vmzadl {h bl jojol# fo hbzhvmom R{h` bhv jodol, Gmlm y hd h{ h dx dmz`hupom
` jmy bhz kmy h{ h dx hbzhvmom R{h` bl vmzadl r{h jodol, Hkhz bl hbzhvmom R{h`
bl vmzadl r{h lhdol# gozayl `olm { bhz kmy mgm`h jol dx hbzhvmom y `olm bl {ml
jodol `oc vmzadl {h { fo zom zmup `hzdhyh,
Fo dhzhgm r{h kxb r{h jo`ol yml kapoll Uocgml ~rhgjhz, [ co uhz hbzhvmom zmupl {hbm
kap6
R{hv jo { gozay dx hbzhvmo jojlh r{hv jo { dx ig`mzo }hvhle `odh,
ogd }hvhlem { fo m vy poz h dmz { fo vz v`hpoz h,
H{ fo gozmzoml bfmpoz h phymbom popl dx co r{h ph `ol# lmjol bhgjhz {,
@o `hup { zmup `h# fomlm `ozf bhh `o h~ `h# `h{chghl` zghp bhh,
Zol {# zol `ocr{mv ol bhg zodl {# uocmghp ol,Fo ja {ml l dx { `okozol# h{ `mzm foml h4 h{ l dx { bod `okozol# jhrph{mz ol,
"Kapoll Uocgml 56=5'=2/
ogm bol vmzad fo jobmzmp r{mzoll pf bhv `odol boll `ol }hp fo {ml bhv lmdol1 Jhzuym y hd
uoyod h6 @ol {ml `o vmzadpom {ml `h o r{mzol mgm`h dozojol# h{ {hbm bl jlh fo { bhv `odol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
36/43
55
Hkhz hg gofmz jlol uhz hbzhvmo# gm bl fo vmzadl r{h zh o ezh hbzhvmo mgm`h
jodol1
@mjml dx gh jhzom lobm co uhz {ml kapoh# jlol jzm r{h6 Gm bl bxzghpm zmupl ml hv~hzhupo
bl vmzadl r{h `odol1 Khca gm bl bl {ml `odol dx h{ fo bhg gozayml bhv jodol1 Fo ja fomlm
gh jobmzmpl }hle hy ol6 Bhvdozol# mpr{mv# lhzg# zhbg# dmzl }hle `oc~md, Jo yml popml `o gmcl
gh `h hbzhvmom R{h` jhcmy `ojh v`h `ojh,
C jhc bm fo r{h bhjol6 @o gmcl gh `h `ofgol bhz ghvol hbzhvmom R{h` phchyoval h,
Jhzlmghl phchyoval khchd emzml popl rhzmj `orol `oc bo vmzadl gh glmdl rhzmj lml
{ml `o`ol `oc {ml jozl`mz `odol bhpm ` h{ bh{ `or{mvol bh{ `odmzol dx jo m ` jmyml jodol,
Jhzlmghl phchyoval ~hlehzl `oc vmzadml yh`odol `oy dx hg bm fo r{h bhjol dx o `odhyh
`oc {ml,
Hkhz co jm {h ghdlm y`a ml m @Y@ bhjh# hy fo phchyoval khchd poz h ogd bl `odmzol fo
ja vmzadl r{h iocgl }hle bocjofzol,Bl lajh`mzl gmcm r{h lh, @oy dx bl lh phl ~hlehzh `hzol gmcm {h co jhz `ovl y `olm
jo~mzvol# c `oy dx bl `oc vmzadl {h f jo~mzvol lhbcol dx bhz pop rhzmj ~u jodhyh bo
`oc {ml,
Fo r{h h{ co `hzyh gmc `o z dacmlml `h khchd popl lh}hle jojlol# c jhc gm ~{oup h dx
hg `o gmcm r{h `h f yml popl rhzmj v`h jodol1 Hz# jhcd jobm phchyoval mzvml h emzlm h{
vmzadl gh gofc `odh# c `o `m{o `h jml`zm {# { fo ja bhz dhu ~ozz kozml jobm jh,
Cagm poz h dx bl ~hzl r{h jhzbhy jodol bhpm dx bl jodmzol ghdlm y`ha ml @Y@ fo r{h zh
jodozzol bolk bl `odmzol fo ja vmzadl r{h co iocgl }hle jolzol ml f jhzlmghl }hle fo
phchyoval da~ jodol,
Fo dhzhgm r{h co uhz yml ~ozuml emzhdh `ol joiodozol jocm bhz hd fo {h fo r{h jo~ozuh6
=/ Gm imlaum gol }hle zalmb `o`h ml lh1:/ Khca gm vmzadl gh kxb`mz ol1 Gm h{ bl jlh dx jo m ` jmy r{h jodol15/ Khca gm hv jo r{h hd kxb`mz og1 Gm hv jo r{h bl jgh dx jo m gozayl `ol jodog1Hkhz hv jo r{h kxb r{h lh`og zhpl gozayl hbzhvm kxb`mzom ~hyl R{h` lhdog#
hv m{m yml popml bl vmzadl r{h jodog10/ Gm hg `o gmcm r{h `h o}mu }ghp `o`ol hbzhvmom R{h`18/ Khca gm bl `oc vmzadl r{h m{m fo popl rhzmj `o~mzvol1 Gm khca vmzadl {h bhz kmyco jhzlmghl phchyoval phgmh `odol1
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
37/43
50
?, Vmzadl gh OO
H`hjdozol o h1
Gmlm h`hjdozol o h1 H`hjdozol hy h dx gozay `ozy r{h `ouplh, mr dx vocmg `odhyol lmy
az`o# h{ `ozy chdhzml `ouplol, Mfapdmz f pl bldozol dx `oy h{ m{m hzhjh jmfal, Jo y m{m
`oy vmzad f bol jo bol `ozy gozayhd kobp jouplol, Razphd dx lhbmpojh ~hz{hz`hdozol lhbmpojh
h`hjdozol h{ lhvmlh dx `oy gozayhd kobp m{m jof# h{ {hd chdhzhd lhvml {hd mfapdmzhd
jm}oc pmcdhhdh ghvol h,
Zmup h# j dx vmzad jl h`hjdozol ~hz{hz`hdozol fo r{h h{ `um f ghvol `ojol, C jhc# gm h{
jojol gozayl bxzghpdmz l dx l `ol `odmzol co {ml h{ch jojol1 Jo zmup hy `olm gh# jo gozayl
ghvol l jm}oc r{h~hzhup pofh h, Bhi gormjol h{ fol fo r{h zh plol dh f gz `odol `ojol
` jmyl vmzadml,
C jhc `mr{mvm gh fo ja gmcl gh h{ h dx vmzadl gh `o pozum R{h` `h ghvol jojol# h{ jojol fol
gzl bxzghpdmz zghp jo`ol R{h`, Gm`hg dx lp mzgmlem gh hy h# bolk `oy hg m{m jo
m{mhd }hle zjhzom vmzadl r{h jodol1
Bhp zhpl }hle
_m ~6 Y hd }hle jlol jzm r{h6 Bl jo r{h jo o m{m bmpojol ~hz{hz`hdozol# dg v`h
bl f bl jo { m{m vmzadl r{h ~hz{hz`h jodol, Hkhz ` jmy {h `o vmzadpom {h `h fo {h bhv
lhdozojol# bolk { fo ja {h vhbghp jh {hd dx ~{oup h bl fo vmzadl r{h bhv jodol, Jo zmup hkhz
bl jo r{h lhvmlol dx bhvdozolm zmupl o h# bl lodmzol jo bhvdozolhdh zmup fo vmzadl r{h bhv jodol,
Hkhz `o vmzadpom ph `h ` jmy ph fo ph bhv lhdozojol# bolk for{hjm{hzdozolm ph { dg jh ~ozz
kozlk h dx px co uhz bhvdozolm R{h` bl joj, Hkhz `o vmzadpom ph `h jmy ph bhz kmy co ph roupojh# bhz
bmc`h px f# p jo v`hb co vmzadl r{h jor,
Cagm hkhz px jor{mv fo vmzadl r{h bhv jod# `oy dx px jo bhvdozolm zmupl jovml, Hkhz ph `o fomlm
r{h `h bhvdozolm dz lh`pojh# p m{m jodmz fo gozayl `ol bhv jod1 C jhc `o y `mjm `h
govklohdh r{h bhh6 _hd bhh h{ fo ph bhv `odh, Jhcd ph hy hd lovmloj# c }hp od pxlh6 R{h`
fo ph bhv `odh, H{ miozml`mz ph h h{ `or{mvh dx bhvdozolm { jodhyh `oc ph jodhyh phymbom
fomlm ph, Bhz uoj v# mr dx px fo rh{ bomz joj# fo ja bhvdozolm { ~hul { jo`h- Fo ja y hd
yml kapoll @m{o` ~rhgjhz jlh jzm r{h4 { kapoh6
Bh hv og# hv fo dmzlm ph zh cmyofhml jor{log, uojhb hv `ocaymlom ph joupozlog, ogd px
dhcbm gol m jocol` `o zafm gol m phlkmbo `h px fo gol zh j mukhb, "Vhjz 8?6=9/
Bhz{hbm bhz zaf jhzom dx vmzadl {h joloyol "jodhyol rh{/# jo ~hyl r{h ml jo pophd `ol# fo
{ml zh jfol dx bl khchd fo {ml bhv `odol,
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
38/43
58
_m `o`xml6 Fo dhzhgm r{h jlol jzm r{h dx vmzadl {h vmzad ol4 h{ lh ghvol ol lh f kobp
lh, R{h` vmzadl {h u~mzpolh {h# dx bl fo {ml zh jojol ` jmy, Vmzad lovmlol dx o fo ja {ml
}hle h# ml lh}hle h, Dmz`hup jhz~ozuomzom gh bhh dx hg jozmzm r{h jo`ol dx fo ja vmzadml o pop
}hle ol o pop lh }hle ol, Jkxgml gmlm y hd h{ h dx hg bhz kmy co kaz cmycmy `mr{mvl
vmzadl r{h lhdol,
Bhz{hbm gmlm y hd h{ h dx `oy emzlm hg jo uhzkozml fo vmzadl r{h zh jfol `oy dx emzlm
hg {ml ehvm f jodol# `m dx vmzad bl jojol ig jodol dx fo ja {ml o o }hle ol,
Khchd vmzad yml popml v bl `ojol# c `um f h{ emzlm joehzojlol dm hg co uhz m r{h `oglol ml
lh, Hkhz hg lh mgm`h jol dx hg jo uhzkozml fo vmzadml zh porj ulaz `hlol# h{ v bl jojol dx
hgoz ~hyl ` jmy {ml jbv ol jkxgml {h khchd gmc `polh dx vmzad `o {ml `h jlh {hd
~m`mbml, [ }hle jh dx hg yml kapoll Uocgml ~rhgjhz jlol jzm r{h, [ kapoh6
@o `oc vmzad `h jm}oc bhh "Kapoll Uocgml ::6=8m/
,,, vmzad dx `o bmc r{h `h j bopol# `om r{h `o`h iobp, "Kapoll Uocgml :?6=8/
Zmup h# gmcm dx vmzad p `h uhz{hzo jodol# bhz kmy { jo jm}oc hzghvmzo pofh jh,
_m uouoml6 Khchd kozlk h# hg jovmlol dx hg jo r{h lh vmzad ol# c hg ` jmy ol, Gmlm y hd
h{ h dx `oy uhgmrm gh bhjh#ml hg jblm r{h iozhb jodol,mr dx hg {hupm jol# mr dx ~hzl gh dg jol# mr dx fol ml gz gh jo bod jo gh zh
jo~hoyh# `oy dx hg r{h jokozol ehumzhpm r{h# byom r{h bhvdozolm r{h {ol`m lhdol, Hkhz `o y
bmc `h hg bzu jodhyol hg bzum r{h `o uhz vmzadl r{h zh `hzrol# bolk hg jo r{h f jlh {hd
vmzadml- H{ bzujlm gh# { vmzadl gh phycobhy jodh4 ` h{ bh{ jovmlol dx `o gmcm {ml `h
zjhz {ml d h# ogd { jojlol dx bhg jlh {hd vmzadml {hd vmzadml `odol,Jo zmup `o khchd gmcml `h vmzad# vmzadml ~hz{hz`h `odol# ogd ` jmy f {hd vmzadml `odol, Hz#
h{ fo vmzadl r{h ghvpoz ol rxzppoz ol# c jhc {ml px emzml `hy fo vmzadpom r{h jhzlh`mh4 bhupl
{ml bo zxb {ml dg v`h hl gmlh {hd l vmzadml, emz bolk ` jmy# ` lh ` jmy
ol# c jhc vmzadl ghvol ol fo ja {ml ~ozz vhbghp h dx h{ jo uhgmr jol fo rhgm r{h jpoz# rhgm
vmzadl r{h jor{ol,
@o lec `h co uhz y `mjm {hbm `ojfh6
mr dx hv vmzad jg# gol {hd vmzadml `okap4 {hd vmzadml ig `odoz4 hv {hd vmzadml `oiodozg4
mr hv jg vocmg# gol `hy fo popl vmzadpo jhz`m, "Dazlp O# =56==/
_m mzml6 Fo dhzhgm r{h jlol jzm r{h dx vmzad vmzad ol {hd vmzadml `odol, @oy hg bl jojol
jovmlol dx ihz} `o lmy lhkxb`mz jbhg`o `h o h, Hg glmdhd jo`ol6 Ghuhch hg jfol
ulohd fo `hup dhm ph dhp dhup, Bolk `oy dx px }hle joiodoz jovml dm ogm { {xum doz6 Ml
dhm ph bzu j kxb r{h lh`m ph { h{ ul jo vmlmup ml `o bzum r{h `h dlml`4 ml f jhcd j
bhg` {# h{ ul fo `hup { dhp dhup }hp lpm rhzmj `o `oc { `h lhj, Hkhz hy hd jbhg`
jjh px dhm r{h ehvm jod# bolk p for{hjm{hzdozol uomlhpm dhm r{h jodl, H{ fo r{h zh
-
8/9/2019 Bingehn maleke bextewar
39/43
59
jfh6 Jmy gol fo gol bhv lmdh# h{ gol {hd dhm r{h }hjc lmdh, Ml f h{ jm{hz jodh dx jhcd
R{h` hruohphd }hle lh`mh {,
Hkhz popl {hbm khchd emzml jol# bolk `o `oc vmzadl {h `h jozll dz { yhjol zxb eml
{ml zobhp lmjh, H{ bl jojol dx h{ lodmzol jojol gozayl jozv bxzghpdmz { bhz kmy r{h jo
r{h dg gozayl `ol jojlol,
Bhi gormjol khchd emzml ` jmy `o bzum r{h `h co vmzadl r{h `orol, C jhc jo y m{m h{
lodmzol jo {mvhd }hle zjhzom vmzadl r{h jodol, @oy ~hz{hz`hdozol h`hjdozolm vmzadml lh co
kaz bzum ` jmyml jh# c jhc co kaz `mr{mvm R{h`m bhvdozol jh, Vmzad vmzad ol h{ {hd gh
lovmlol bhz pop ig lmdol,
Ghuhch hg jfol vocmghd bhh# mr dx h{ bzu `odhyh# bhz emz h{ zm`obfh mdhd `hup ~ jodh
~mzhhd fo rmlo r{h rhzm `odh, ^op `hghdh dol rmlo { lmglh,
H{ ` jmyl dx vmzadl r{h fo jhz jbhg`ol {ml ehvm `odol# bol jo bol gmcm r{h rhzm `odol,
C jhc pmcdhhdh `ol f bhh, Hg bhg `ovmlol dx emzlm vmzad kxb`mzom gh lmdol jo vmlmup# ml`o bzum r{h `h# ml f jo lpm rhzmj pophd `odol, mr dx px jo y hd jobhu px jo vhcmc jovml dx
vmzadhd h{ pop lh fo jbhg` doz# c jhc co kaz hruohpm r{h m kxlhbdmz z `m rhzmjo# bolk `oy
dx bl fo { zh jojol muphlk lhbcol dx h{ `o y zo `h jo`aglh, Hkhz `o zh{ hdh {hbm `h bl
zjhzom vmzadml lhdol# bolk bl jo vmzadl r{h jorxuozol,
Cagm Uocgml ~m`mb `o Dopjm ^zav `h {hbm kapoh6
Dxz r{h phzjoh jodh h{ zobhpo jo`h ph4
`oc ph { jo {m jojh, "Kapoll Uocgml :?6=;/
Hkhz hg lhkxb`mzom vmzadml }hjc jodol co bhgjhz y hd zmlhjol# `o gmcm gh `h { lh mjl
lh f zobhp mp bhjh,
@aupl `hcmc# jo zmup hy dmz`hup jhz~ozuomzom ` jmyml lh pophd jod h doi h dx fo ja y
hd hg bh{eh`mz hbzhvmom R{h` lh, H{ bhg `or{mvh `o y hd `h mcdmzom gh jodh bhg f
`or{mvh dx vmzadl gh }hle bl kxb`mzdozol jojol, Cagm `o lec `h `ojfh6 Hkhz hbzhvmom
hd fo {h dg jh# jocm fo R{h`m dx jo eaghz` `o`h bhgml c lmboch# jor{mvh { fo { zh j
`ml, C jocm jo jm{hz jor{mvh `x`oc lhjh, "M}j =68,9/
_m ~leml6 @oy dx ` jmy ig jodol dx bhg vmzad lh {hd bhy ol fo ch{zh `oy bhz vmzad co
kaz hruohpm r{h bhg j ~hz{hz`hdozol bhg f j h`hjdozol, Y hd rhchp ig lhdol6 lmjh dx cojm ` jmy rmpozkozpol bhjh4 lmjh dx ` jmy `o lmy bhg vmzadl r{h `h fo dxzhd ml fo dhodhd
v`hpoz bhv jodol, Bhz{hbm ` jmy lodmzol `o gmcm r{h `h mp rhzmjol bol vmzadl r{h ldmz
jodol bhz emz mpol vmzadl `ol ehvm jodol, Lhrz# fo r{h hy hd lh zmup h,
C jhc `oy dx ` jmy ig jodol dx hruohpm bhg vmzadml lh hd h `oy dx ` jmy vmzadl
r{h co kaz hruohpm {ml ~hz{hz`h jodol, Jo zmup fo ja y hd khchd hbzhvm cmvog h ~{oup h dx
` jmy `o y hd `