bhau ram vs. janak singh & ors. slp

8/17/2019 Bhau Ram vs. Janak Singh & Ors. SLP

1/21

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. OF 2010

IN THE MATTER OF:-

Bhau Ra !P"#$#$%&"'

VERSUS

Ja&a S$&h * O'+. !!R"+,%&"+

OFFICE REPORT OF LIMITATION

1. S,"$a/ L"a" P"#$#$%& $+ $#h$& /$$#a#$%&.

2. Th" ,"#$#$%& $+ &%# a''" 3 #$" a& #h"'" $+ a "/a3 %4 NIL

a3+ $& 4$/$& #h" +a" aa$&+# #h" 4$&a/ %'"' a#" 20.05.2010

a& ,"#$#$%& 4%' %&%&a#$%& %4 NIL a3+ "/a3 ha+ &%# ""&

4$/".

6. Th"'" $+ a "/a3 %4 NIL a3+ $& '"4$//$& #h" ,"#$#$%& a& ,"#$#$%&

4%' %&%&a#$%& %4 NIL a3+ "/a3 $& '"4$//$& ha+ &%# ""& 4$/".

BRANCH OFFICERDa#" :-

N" D"/h$.

1


2/21


(O'"' 7VI Ru/" 8(1) (a)


(UNDER ARTICLE 169 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA)

SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. ....... OF 2010

(WITH PRAYERS FOR INTERIM RELIEF)

BETEEN POSITION OF PARTIES

I& #h" I& #h$+

H$h C%u'# C%u'#Sh'$ Bhau Ra;S%& %4 Sh'$ Sh$+h$ Ra;R"+$" %4 V$//a" Sh"/aa#;T"h+$/ R%h'%%;D$+#'$# Sh$/a;H$aha/ P'a"+h A,,"//a N%. 2 P"#$#$%&"'

VERSUS

1. Sh'$ Ja&a S$&h;S


3/21

TO THE HON?BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA

AND OTHER HON?BLE JUD>ES OF THE

HON@BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA.

Th" hu/" ,"#$#$%& %4 #h"

P"#$#$%&"' a%"-&a".

MOST RESPECTFULLY SHEWETH"

1. Th" P"#$#$%&"'+ a%"&a" %+# '"+,"#4u//3 +a3 a& +u$#

#ha# #h" P"#$#$%&"' $+ 4$/$& #h" $&+#a S,"$a/ L"a" #% A,,"a/

aa$&+# #h" u" a& 4$&a/ %'"' a#" 20.05.2010 ,a++"

3 H%&?/" H$h C%u'# %4 H$aha/ P'a"+h $& RSA N%. 01 %4

2005 h"'"3 #h" H%&?/" H$h C%u'# "''%&"%u+/3 $+$++"

#h" RSA.

2. #UESTIONS OF LAW.

Th$+ S,"$a/ L"a" P"#$#$%& 'a$+"+ #h" 4%//%$& $,%'#a a&

+u+#a$a/ u"+#$%&+ %4 /a h$h a'" %4 "&"'a/ ,u/$

$,%'#a&":-

a) h"#h"' #h" a,,/$a#$%& u&"' %'"' 'u/" 11 CPC 4$/"

3 #h" D"4"&a a& " "$" "'"/3 %& #h" a+$+ %4

#h" ,/a$ a& h"#h"' #h" %#h"' a#"'$a/ 4$/" 3 #h"

D"4"&a $& +u,,%'# %4 #h" a,,/$a#$%& a& " $&%'"

) h"#h"' #h" 1+# A,,"//a#" C%u'# ha a+ '$h# $& $&%'$&

#h" '%u&+ h$h "$h" #h" L. T'$a/ %u'# 4%' a//%$&

#h" a,,/$a#$%& u&"' %'"' 'u/" 11 CPC a& #hu+; #h"3

3


4/21

ha ""& 4a$/u'" #% ""'$+" #h" u'$+$#$%& $& a%'a&"

$#h #h" /a

) h$/" "$$& #h" a,,/$a#$%& u&"' %'"' 'u/" 11 CPC

4$/" 3 #h" D"4"&a h"#h"' #h" ,/"a$&+ %4 #h"

,a'#$"+ a+ "// a+ %#h"' a#"'$a/ %& '"%'; h$h a+

a$++$/" $& /a +h%u/ &%# ha" ""& ",# $%

%&+$"'a#$%&

6. DECLARATION IN TERMS OF RULE $(2)

Th" P"#$#$%&"'+ +#a#" #ha# &% %#h"' ,"#$#$%& +""$& /"a" #%

a,,"a/ ha+ ""& 4$/" 3 #h" A,,"//a+ aa$&+# #h" $,u&"

%'"'.

8. DECLARATION IN TERMS OF RULE 6

Th" %u"+


5/21

%u# $#h%u# ,'"u$" #% %&" a&%#h"':-

AG B"au+" %#h #h" 1+# a& 2& a,,"//a#" %u'#+ ha"

%$##" a&$4"+# $//"a/$#3 $& "$$& #h" a,,/$a#$%&

u&"' %'"' 'u/" 11 CPC 4$/" 3 #h" D"4"&a "'"/3

%& #h" a+$+ %4 #h" ,/a$ a& $& $&%'$& #h" %#h"'

a#"'$a/ 4$/" 3 #h" D"4"&a $& +u,,%'# %4 #h"

a,,/$a#$%&.

BG B"au+" %#h #h" 1+# a& 2& A,,"//a#" C%u'#+ ha

'%&/3 a& a'"/"++/3 $&%'" #h" '%u&+ h$h

"$h" #h" L. T'$a/ %u'# 4%' a//%$& #h" a,,/$a#$%&

u&"' %'"' 'u/" 11 CPC a& #hu+; #h"'" ha ""& a

4a$/u'" #% ""'$+" #h" u'$+$#$%& $& a%'a&" $#h #h"

/a.

CG B"au+" h$/" "$$& #h" a,,/$a#$%& u&"' %'"' 'u/"

11 CPC 4$/" 3 #h" D"4"&a #h" ,/"a$&+ %4 #h"

,a'#$"+ a+ "// a+ %#h"' a#"'$a/ %& '"%'; h$h a+

a$++$/" $& /a +h%u/ ha" ""& ",# $%

%&+$"'a#$%&; $& h$h %#h #h" 1+# a& 2& a,,"//a#"

%u'#+ ha" %,/"#"/3 4a$/".

9. GROUNDS FOR INTERIM RELIEF

N% '"/$"4

. MAIN PRAYER

I# $+; #h"'"4%'"; %+# '"+,"#4u//3 ,'a3" #ha# %u' L%'+h$,+

5


6/21

a3 'a$%u+/3 " ,/"a+" #%:

a) 'a S,"$a/ L"a" #% A,,"a/ #% #h" P"#$#$%&"' aa$&+#

Ju" a& 4$&a/ %'"' a#" 20.05.2010 ,a++" 3

H%&?/" H$h C%u'# %4 H$aha/ P'a"+h $& RSA N%. 01

%4 2005 a&

) ,a++ %#h"' %' 4u'#h"' %'"'+ a+ a3 " """ 4$# a&

,'%,"' $& #h" $'u+#a&"+ %4 #h" a+".

. INTERIM RELIEF"%

a) Pa++ a& "-,a'#" $"'$ %'"' +#a3$& #h" %,"'a#$%& %4 #h"

$,u&" u" a& 4$&a/ %'"' a#" 20.05.2010 ,a++"

3 H%&?/" H$h C%u'# %4 H$aha/ P'a"+h $& RSA N%. 01 %4

2005 a&

) ,a++ +uh %#h"' %'"'+ a& 4u'#h"' %'"'< $'"#$%&+ a+ a'"

""" u+# a& ,'%,"' $& #h" 4a#+ a& $'u+#a&"+ %4 #h"

,'"+" a+".

FILED B

(E.C. AGRAWALA)

ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONERNEW DELHIDATED:

6


7/21



SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. KKKKKKKKKK OF 2010

IN THE MATTER OF: -

Bhau Ra !P"#$#$%&"'

V"'+u+

Ja&a S$&h * O'+. ..R"+,%&"+

CERTIFICATE

C"'#$4$" #ha# #h" S,"$a/ L"a" ,"#$#$%& $+ %&4$&" %&/3 #% #h"

,/"a$&+ "4%'" #h" C%u'# h%+" %'"' $+ ha//"&" a& #h" %#h"'

%u"+ '"/$" u,%& $& #h%+" ,'%""$&+. N% a$#$%&a/ 4a#+;

%u"+ %' '%u&+ ha" ""& #a"& #h"'"$& %' '"/$" u,%& $& #h"

+,"$a/ L"a" ,"#$#$%&. I# $+ 4u'#h"' "'#$4$" #ha# #h" %,$"+ %4 #h"

%u"+


8/21



SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. KKKKKKKKKK OF 2005

(A'$+$& %u# %4 #h" 4$&a/ u" a& %'"' a#" 20.05.2010 ,a++"3 H%&?/" H$h C%u'# %4 H$aha/ P'a"+h $& RSA N%. 01 %4 2005).

WITH PRAYER FOR INTERIM RELIEF

IN THE MATTER OF:Bhau Ra !!P"#$#$%&"'

VERSUS

Ja&a S$&h * O'+. !.R"+,%&"+

PAPER BOO=

(=INDL SEE INDE7 INSIDE)

AD&OCATE FOR THE PETITIONER" E.C. AGRAWALA

8


9/21

LIST OF DATES

0.09.1590 Sh'$ Sha&"' La/; hu+a& %4 S#. R"+hu D"$

%&" a& ,%++"++". La& $& $//a" Sh"/aa#;

P.O. Su"'%#; T"h+$/ R%h'%%; D$+#'$# Sh$/a.

O& 0.09.1590; Sh'$ Sha&"' La/ $" $"+#a#" a#

Sh$/a a& #h" "$'" ,'%,"'#3 %&" 3 h$ a+

$&h"'$#" 3 h$+ $4" S#. R"+hu D"$.

159 R"+hu D"$ 4$/" a C$$/ Su$# N%. 91


10/21

S$&h %& "ha/4 %4 R"+hu D"$. O& #h" a+$+ %4

#h$+ 4%'" $//; A#a' S$&h /a$" #ha# h" a+

#h" /"a/ h"$' %4 S#. R"+hu. P"#$#$%&"' Bhau

Ra; h% $+ #h" +%& %4 '%#h"' %4 R"+hu "$;

ha//"&" #h" a//"" $// a& a/+% 4$/" a&

a,,/$a#$%& #% $,/"a h$+"/4 a+ /"a/ h"$' %4 S#.

R"+hu D"$.

O& 28.0.159 $++u" "'" 4'a" a+ #% h"#h"'

A#a' S$&h a& H$'a S$&h "'" /"a/

'",'"+"a#$"+ %4 S#. R"+hu %& #h" a+$+ %4

a//"" $// a#" 12.05.158. O& 09.06.15;

L. ADJ; Sh$/a a//" 4%' a '",%'# 4'% L. Su

Ju"; Sh$/a; a& ,a++" a& %'"' #ha# #h"

P"#$#$%&"' Bhau Ra " +u+#$#u#" a& '%uh#

%& '"%' $& ,/a" %4 S# R"+hu $&+#"a %4 S#.

Sa'u. O& $" a& %'"' a#" 25.11.159 L.

Su Ju" 1+# C/a++ (I); Sh$/a h"/ #ha# #h"

P"#$#$%&"' h"'"$& $.". Bhau Ra "$& #h" '"a/

'%#h"' %4 Sha&"' La/ h% $+ #h" hu+a&

R"+hu D"$ $+ %&/3 /"a/ '",'"+"a#$" %4 S#.

R"+hu D"$. Th" a,,/$a#$%&; h$h a+ 4$/" 3

Sh'$ H$'a S$&h a& A#a' S$&h 4%' '$&$& #h" %&

'"%' $& ,/a" %4 S#. R"+hu a+ $+$++".

Aa$&+# #h$+ %'"' &% a,,"a/ a+ 4$/". A %,3 %4

10


11/21

#h" %'"' a#" 25.11.159 ,a++" 3 #h" L. Su

Ju" 1+# C/a++ (I); Sh$/a $& Ca+" N%. KKKKKKK

%4 KKKK #$#/" a+ =a/a D"$ V+. R"+hu D"$ $+

a&&"" h"'"$#h a& a'" a+ ANNE'URE P%

1. (a# ,a" 2)

Th" L. Su Ju" I; Sh$/a; ,a++" %'"'+ %&

20.11.15 #ha# $# $+ #h" %&/3 P"#$#$%&"' h"'"$&

Bhau Ra; h% a+ #h" /"a/ h"$' %4 ""a+"

S#. R"+hu a& #hu+ #h" /a$ %4 A#a' S$&h

a& H$'a S$&h a+ '""#". I& %&&"#$%& $#h

u'"' %4 S#. R"+hu; A#a' S$&h a& h$+ 4a#h"'

H$'a S$&h %#h "'" ,'%+"u#" a& %&$#"

3 #h" L. S"++$%&+ Ju"; Sh$/a h%""'; /a#"'

%& %#h "'" au$##" 3 H%&?/" H$h C%u'#

H$aha/ P'a"+h a# Sh$/a.

25.12.155*

02.01.2001

P/a$$44 A#a' S$&h 4$/" a C$$/ Su$# N%.


12/21

18.0.2002 Ju"-IV; Sh$/a a& $& #h$+ +u$# a/+% #h" '"/$"4

/a$" a+ #h" +a" a& +$$/a'; h$h a+

$+$++" $& "4au/# %& 26.02.2001 u# #h" +a"

a+ '"+#%'" $" %'"' a#" 18.0.2002.

16.0.2002 A#a' S$&h +%& %4 H$'a S$&h 4$/" a C$$/ Su$# N%.

10


13/21

S$&h. A %,3 %4 #h" C$$/ Su$# N%. 10


14/21

02.01.2001; #h"'"4%'" #h" ,'"+" +u$# a+ &%#

a$a$&a/" +$$/a'/3 $# a+ +u$##" #ha#

a&%#h"' +u$# #$#/" a+ A#a' S$&h V+. Bhau Ra

ha a/+% ""& $+$++" $& "4au/# %&

26.01.2001; #h" +u$# a+ /a$" #% " &%#

a$a$&a/".

I& #h" '$##"& +#a#"" #h" P"#$#$%&"' h"'"$&

4u'#h"' +#a#" #ha# a##"' '"a'$& "&u$&"&"++

%4 #h" $// a+ $'"#/3 a& +u+#a$a//3 $+ #h"

$++u" "4%'" #h" L. D$+#'$# Ju"; Sh$/a; $& C$$/

A,,"a/ 11 S


15/21

%4 ,/a$ %& #h" '%u& #ha# #h" P/a$$44 ha a/+%

4$/" a C$$/ Su$# N%.


16/21

S"#$%& %4 #h" L$$#a#$%& A#. A %,3 %4 #h"

a,,/$a#$%& "$& CMA N%. 11


17/21

,a" 18

19.12.2008 A'$"" 3 #h" %'"' a#" 1.11.2008; #h"

R"+,%&"+ A#a' S$&h a& Ja&a S$&h 4$/"

F$'+# A,,"a/ N%. 50-S


18/21

#h" a+$+ %4 h$h #h" +a" %u/ ha" ""&

'""#".

Th" L. D$+#'$# Ju" (F%'"+#); Sh$/a; 4u'#h"'

'%&/3 h"/ #ha# #h" #'$a/ %u'# ha '"/$" u,%&

#h" %"+ %4 '$##"& +#a#"" h$/" a//%$&

#h" a,,/$a#$%& u&"' %'"' Ru/" 11; CPC h$h

%u/ &%# ha" ""& %&". A& #hu+ $" %'"'

a#" 61.0.2005; #h" L. D$+#'$# Ju" (F%'"+#);

Sh$/a +"# a+$" #h" %'"' a#" 1.11.2008 a&

%'"'" 4%' #h" 4'"+h #'$a/ %4 #h" +u$#. A %,3 %4 #h"

%'"' a#" 61.0.2005 ,a++" 3 #h" D$+#'$#

Ju" (F%'"+#); Sh$/a $& C$$/ A,,"a/ N%. 50


19/21

,/a$ $+ &%# '"u$'" #% " +""& u# $&4a# #h"

"$'" a#"'$a/ ha#+%""' ha+ %" %& '"%' a#

#h" #$" %4 4$/$& %4 #h$+ a,,/$a#$%&. A %,3 %4 #h"

R"u/a' S"%& A,,"a/ N%. 01 %4 2005 4$/" 3

#h" P"#$#$%&"' "4%'" #h" H%&?/" H$h C%u'# %4

H$aha/ P'a"+h a# Sh$/a $& C$$/ A,,"a/ N%.

50-S


20/21

SR.NO. PARTICULARS PAGES

1. O44$" '",%'# %& /$$#a#$%& A2. L$+# %4 a#"+

6. I,u&" u" a& 4$&a/ u" a&%'"' a#" 20.05.2010 ,a++" 3 H%&?/"H$h C%u'# %4 H$aha/ P'a"+h $& RSA N%.01 %4 2005.

8. S,"$a/ L"a" P"#$#$%& $#h a44$a$#

. ANNE'URE P%1(C*++,):- T'u" #'a&+/a#" %,$"+%4 #h" aaa&$ %4 #h" /a&+ %4 >ha&$3a a&

Sah&u; =ha+'a 4%' #h" 3"a' 15- +h%$&a// #h" #h'"" %$/3 a& 4%' #h" 3"a' 155 1590; 152-6; 159-; 1559-5.

9. ANNE'URE P%2:- T'u" #'a&+/a#" %,3 %4 #h"'"$+#"'" $// a#" 05.08.156.

. ANNE'URE P%3:- A #'u" #'a&+/a#" %,3 %4 #h" aaa&$ 4%' #h" 3"a' 151-152 +h%$& #ha##h" ha#a %4 #h" P"#$#$%&"' a& ""a+" "'"

%$.

. ANNE'URE P%$:- T'u" #'a&+/a#" %,$"+ %4 #h""a#h C"'#$4$a#" a& #h" Mu&$$,a/ '"$+#"' a#" 16.06.159.

5. ANNE'URE P%!:- A #'u" #'a&+/a#" %,3 %4 #h"+#a#"" a#" 1.09.1550 $"& 3 #h"R"+,%&" N%. 1- P/a$$44 (P-1) $& Su$# N%.6


21/21

18. ANNE'URE P%10:- A #'u" #'a&+/a#" %,3 %4

#h" +#a#"" a#" 2.10.1550 $"& 3 #h"D-8 $& Su$# N%. 6

bhau ram vs. janak singh & ors. slp

Documents