baton rouge diocese petition

8/11/2019 Baton Rouge Diocese Petition

1/133

!"#

!" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. $%& /"0$&1 '$2$&3 %%%%%%%%%%

&'( ) *+,! - ,&'*./- - '0)-' *1 &'( 2 /*-(3( *1 4 ,&*! ) *05( ,!2

&'( ) (6()(!2 +# 7 (11)(8 4 ,8'/ 9 !"#$#$%&"'(9

*#) *4()& 2# + ,8(0: ,!2 . /3, +# + ,8(0: 9

+"(,%&-"( # %%%%%%%%%%

*; ?>?"; @"A B CA?> "@ -=A>?"ABA? >" >D=3EFA=G= -"EA> "@ ."E?H?B;B

%%%%%%%%%%

!"#$#$%& (%) * +)$# %( ,")#$%)*)$

%%%%%%%%%%

2 *! +# ) /-',)2 + /-',(. .# 2 ( 3 ',I*

.$&&"/0 122$&3456("&0+$745'- 8 9":45;%

? !%/-'5( :#'""#0 :6$#"=@>?

A"B C'2"5&(0 D%6$($5&5E?=@I?=?J

2 ,!/(. )# * )&/I JK&$*"'($#/ %L M$'3$&$5

:74%%2 %L D5B>N? O5(($" +%5-P45'2%##"(*$22"0 MQ

==R?F-'%S*$'3$&$5T"-6G@F@H R=@IF


2/133

i

-."/#$%& !)"/""0

&D?H -"EA> DBH K";L B;M N";H?H>=;>KO D=KM >DB> >D=1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> P?;MH QN?R?K N"EA>H J J J >" BNN=F>>D= M=N?H?";H S"@ NDEAND BE>D"A?>?=HT "; GB>>=AH "@M?HN?FK?;=9 @B?>D9 ?;>=A;BK "ALB;?UB>?";9 SB;MT=NNK=H?BH>?NBK AEK=9 NEH>"G "A KBV#W:"'V$5& 15(#"'&C'#4%-%W 9$%7"(" R# O$2$*%X"*$749 XYZ 0#3# Z[Z9 \]^_][\Z`# QS)T=K?L?"EH N";>A"R=AH?=H BA= ;"> >D= FA"F=A

HEPa=N> "@ N?R?K N"EA> ?;bE?AOST B;M J J J B N?R?K N"EA>GEH> BNN=F> >D= =NNK=H?BH>?NBK M=N?H?";H "@ SBT NDEANDJ J J BH ?> @?;MH >D=G#WYV$-# 1"A QSB N"EA> >"THEPH>?>E>=ST ?>H ?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@ >D= SNDEANDcHTN";H>?>E>?";H @"A >DB> "@ >D= SNDEAND ?>H=K@ ?H VDB>T >D=1?AH> B;M 1"EA>==;>D ,G=;MG=;>H @"AP?M#W Y- # B>\Y]# &D?H N";H>?>E>?";BK N"GGB;M ?H d;"V; BH >D=QA=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";W M"N>A?;=#

&D= bE=H>?"; FA=H=;>=M ?H VD=>D=A B N"EA> NB;F?R"> K?BP?K?>O @"A B FA?=H>cH @B?KEA= >" A=F"A> N=A>B?;N"GGE;?NB>?";H >" FEPK?N BE>D"A?>?=H "; >D= N"EA>cH"V; M=>=AG?;B>?"; "@ VD=>D=A >D"H= N"GGE;?NB>?";HN";H>?>E>= QN";@=HH?";ST ,"' (" 9W ,FF#9 $&L'59 [B9 "AVD=>D=A ?> GEH> A=HF=N> >D= NDEANDcH "V; R?=V >DB>HEND N"GGE;?NB>?";H BA= N";@=HH?";BK B;M BPH"KE>=KOFA">=N>=M @A"G M?HNK"HEA= PO >D= FA?=H> "; F=;BK>O "@BE>"GB>?N =eN"GGE;?NB>?";#


3/133

ii

!*)#$"/ #% #1" !)%,""0$&2 3"4%+

/; BMM?>?"; >" >D= FBA>?=H ?M=;>?@?=M ?; >D= NBF>?";9M=@=;MB;>H P=K"V ?;NKEM=M >D= =H>B>= "@ 5="AL= 7#-DBAK=>9 7A#9 B;M >D= -DBAK=> 1E;=ABK '"G=9 /;N#

).4" 5678 /#*#"9"

?>?";=A )"GB; -B>D"K?N -DEAND "@ >D= 2?"N=H="@ 4B>"; )"EL= DBH ;" FBA=;> N"AF"AB>?"; B;M ;"FEPK?NKO D=KM N"AF"AB>?"; "V;H ]fg "A G"A= "@ ?>HH>"Nd#


4/133

???

#*34" %( ,%"/=H &D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> 4O ,KK"V?;L3>B>=H &" *R=AA?M= , )=K?L?";cH 6?=V *@ CDB>/>H *V; 1B?>D +=B;H ,;M )=bE?A=H ################# ]X


5/133

?R

#*34" %( ,%"/:;?=@AB?;L &D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>cH)=K?L?"EH hE=H>?"; 2"N>A?;=9 &D= ."E?H?B;B3EFA=G= -"EA> -A=B>=M , -";@K?N> C?>D ,KK1=M=ABK -"EA>H "@ ,FF=BKH ,;M ,KK *>D=A3>B>= 3EFA=G= -"EA>H &DB> 'BR= -";H?M=A=M/> ,;M , 2?A=N> -";@K?N> /; />H ,FFK?NB>?";C?>D &D= 3=N";M ,;M 1"EA>D -?ANE?>H ,;M

&D= !=V 7=AH=O ,;M +BHHBNDEH=>>H 3EFA=G=-"EA>H ################################################################

///# &D?H *@>=;k)=NEAA?;L /HHE= /H *;= *@-=;>ABK /GF"A>B;N= &" -DEAND=H ,;M &D=?A+=GP=AH ############################################################ ]

/6# &D?H -BH= /H ,; /M=BK 6=D?NK= 1"A ,MMA=HH?;LCD=>D=A 3>B>=H -B; 3=N";Mk5E=HH )=K?L?";Hc*V; 6?=VH ,H &" CDB> &D=?A 1B?>D +=B;H

,;M )=bE?A=H #################################################### ^

-*!-.03/*! ####################################################### Z

,A?N> -"EA> 7EMLG=;> ";+">?"; ?; .?G?;= ######################################## ZjB

?BK &AB;HNA?F> "@ 2?H>A?N> -"EA> '=BA?;L"; +">?"; ?; .?G?;=9 1=P# ][9 Yf]^_N";>B?;?;L "ABK =eFKB;B>?"; "@ >D=

A=BH";H @"A ?>H aEMLG=;>` ########################### Z\B."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA> *AM=A 2=;O?;L

)=D=BA?;L ################################################### \fB


6/133

R

#*34" %( ,%"/:;?=@AB "@ ,FF=BK *AM=A 2=;O?;L)=D=BA?;L ################################################### \ZB

)=K=RB;> 3>B>E>"AO


7/133

R?

#*34" %( *.#1%)$#$"/D -?A# YffY` ############################# Y\ [6'B"22 R# ]%VV/ D%VV/ :#%'"(0 Y&7T0

]^X 3# -># Y\j] _Yf]X` ################################### ]i9 Y^

P46'74 CL ^%- Y& P4'$(#0 Y&7T R#P5B#4%&9jf\ 1#YM j[[ _j>D -?A# ][\j` ############################### ]

P%\V( R#P"T _"WT Q&&T P%&LT CL _4"K&$#"- O"#4%-$(# P46'74 9]\^ 1#^M ^X^ _j>D -?A# ][[[` ############################### ]

P%\\57` :"2LI:"'*$7" .%(4"' O"5#(0 Y&7T R#a"$(( 9Y[X 1#YM X]j _YM -?A# YffY` ########################### Y[9 f


8/133

R??

#*34" %( *.#1%)$#$"/:;?=@AB

# Z[X _Yf]Y` ################################### ,5(($\

]6#74$(%& R#_4%\5( 9\i[ 1#YM ^[Y _Z>D -?A# ][iZ` ############################### Y\


9/133

R???

#*34" %( *.#1%)$#$"/:;?=@AB

D -?A# ][i\` ########################### Y\kYi

!$"2"74 R#O5((5(%$# ^'"/4%6&-0 Y&7T 9ZZi !#(#YM ]Y[i _+BHH# ][[Z` ################# YZkY\9 Y[

!2"5(5 ^25-" Q(("\V2/ %L ^%- R#:746V"'# 9YZX 3#C#^M ] _&=e# Yffi` ##################################### Yi

!'"(V/#"'$5& P46'74 R# O5'/ 12$;5V"#4 [26" ]622

O"\%'$52 !'"(V/#"'$5& P46'74 9^[^ 0#3# XXf _][Z[` ########################### ]j9 ]\9 Yf9 ^f

+5&I95*b( P#/T .%(4"'0 Y&7T R#:#5#" 9Zfi ,#YM ]^j^ _!#7# ][[Y` ############################# Y[9 f


10/133

?e

#*34" %( *.#1%)$#$"/:;?=@AB

C>@>AD E )@FAD

Yi 0#3#-# l ]Yj\ #################################################### ]9 ^X

Yi 0#3#-# l YXf^_P` ##################################################### ]

.B# -D?KM# -"M= ,;;# BA># Zf^_]j` ############################## ]

.B# -D?KM# -"M= ,;;# BA># Zf^_]\`_N` ########################## ]

.B# -D?KM# -"M= ,;;# BA># Zf[ ##################################### ]

.B# -?R# -"M= ,;;# BA># Y^]j ###################################### ]

.B# -?R# -"M= ,;;# BA># Y^]Z ###################################### ]

.B# -"M= -?R# # j]] ###################################### YS. Ct. R. 29 ............................................................................. 1


11/133

e

#*34" %( *.#1%)$#$"/:;?=@AB

JAH *@>J?AD

&D= -B;";H B;M 2=NA==H "@ >D= 3BNA=M mNEG=;?NBK-"E;N?K "@ &A=;> _7# CB>=AV"A>D >AB;H#9 ]iXi`9D>>FHnooD?H>"AO#DB;"R=A#=MEo>=e>Ho>A=;>oN>]X#D>GK# ###########################################################

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND F># ]9 l Y9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### X

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]Xj\9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### j

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]Xji9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### j

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]XZ\9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### Z

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]XZi9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### X


12/133

e?

#*34" %( *.#1%)$#$"/:;?=@AB

=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]XZ[9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ##################################### X9 j

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]X\Y9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### j

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]XiX9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### X

-B>=ND?HG "@ >D= -B>D"K?N -DEAND l ]X[Z9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G ######################################### j

-B>D"K?N '?=ABANDO9K:Qe :#5#$(#$7( [/ !'%*$&7" _>FnooVVV#NB>D"K?NkD?=ABANDO#"ALoN"E;>AOoHFNEH^#D>GK ##################### ]

] C?KK?BG '"LB;9 ,EA?NEKBA -";@=HH?"; B;M=AB; /6 ]Y]j9 D>>FnooVVV#@"AMDBG#=MEo'BKHBKKoPBH?HoKB>=AB;X#BHF ##### \


13/133

e??

#*34" %( *.#1%)$#$"/:;?=@AB

D=Aoa"D;%FBEK%??oBF"H>%=eD"A>B>?";HoM"NEG=;>HoD@%aFk??%=eD%fY]Y][iX%A=N";N?K?B>?"k=>kFB=;?>=;>?B%=;#D>GK ############################################## j

:#T c%4& A",%\67"&" 9 -B>D"K?N *;K?;=9D>>FnooVVV#NB>D"K?N#"ALoHB?;>HoHB?;>#FDFpHB?;>

%?MqZ[f ################################################################

:#T O5#"% P%''"5 O535225&"( 9 -B>D"K?N *;K?;=9D>>FnooVVV#NB>D"K?N#"ALoHB?;>HoHB?;>#FDFpHB?;>

%?Mqj\f\ ################################################################

C?KK?BG 3B;M=AH9_4" :"52 %L P%&L"(($%&9 ,AK?;L>"; -B>D"K?N '=ABKM9 ,EL# [9 Yff]9D>>FnooNB>D"K?ND=ABKM#N"GoH>"A?=HoP&D=k3=BKk"@k-";@=HH?";P9X\]XpN";>=;>%H"EAN=qrNB>=L"AO%?MqrH=BAND%@?K>=AqH=BKs"@s>D=sN";@=HH?";BKr=R=;>%G"M=qr=R=;>%>H%@A"GqrK?H>%>OF=qr"AM=A%POqr"AM=A%H"A>qrN";>=;>%NKBHHqrHEP%>OF=qH>"A?=H9PK"LHr>"V;%?Mq# ################################# Zk\

Y &D"GBH 3KB>=A9 , +B;EBK "@ +"ABK &D="K"LO @"A(;LK?HDk3F=Bd?;L -"E;>A?=H _j>D =M# ][Yj` ######## Z


14/133

]

=M B> ]^j 3"# ^M ]]\\_Yf]X`# &D= "F?;?"; "@ >D= N"EA> "@ BFF=BK _,FF#9$&L'59 ]]BkZXB` ?H A=F"A>=M B> ]^j 3"# ^M \YX _Yf]^`#&D= aEMLG=;> "@ >D= M?H>A?N> N"EA> _,FF#9$&L'59 ZjBk

ZZB` ?H E;A=F"A>=M#

70)/32/-&/*!

&D= aEMLG=;> "@ >D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA>VBH =;>=A=M "; ,FA?K X9 Yf]X# ?>?";=AH >?G=KO @?K=MB F=>?>?"; @"A A=D=BA?;L9 VD?ND VBH M=;?=M "; +BO Y^9Yf]X# ,FF#9 $&L'59 \fB# &D?H -"EA>cH aEA?HM?N>?"; ?H?;R"d=M E;M=A Yi 0#3#-# l ]Yj\# >" )EK=Y[#X_N`9 F=>?>?";=AH P=K?=R= Yi 0#3#-# l YXf^_P` GBOBFFKO B;M V?KK H=AR= >D= ,>>"A;=O 5=;=ABK "@

."E?H?B;B V?>D B N"FO "@ >D?H F=>?>?";#-*!3&/&0&/*!,. ,!2 3&,&0&*)8

,G=;MG=;> >" >D= -";H>?>E>?"; "@ >D=0;?>=M 3>B>=H FA"R?M=H9 ?; F=A>?;=;> FBA>9 >DB>Q-";LA=HH HDBKK GBd= ;" KBV A=HF=N>?;L B;=H>BPK?HDG=;> "@ A=K?L?";9 "A FA"D?P?>?;L >D= @A===e=AN?H= >D=A="@#W &D= A=K=RB;> H>B>E>"AO FA"R?H?";HB> >D= >?G= "@ >D= M=N?H?";H P=K"V V=A= .B# -D?KM#-"M= ,;;# BA>H# Zf^_]j`9 Zf[ _3EFF# Yf]^`9 '"7%-$L$"-

5# .B# -D?KM# -"M= ,;;# BA>H# Zf^_]\`_N`9 Zf[ _Yf]X`t.B# -?R# -"M= ,;;# BA>H# Y^]jkY^]Z _Yf]f`9 .B# -"M=


15/133

Y

(R?M# ,;;# BA># j]] _YffZ`# ,KK BA= A=FA"MEN=M ?; >D=BFF=;M?e >" >D?H F=>?>?";# ,FF#9$&L'59 \iBkiYB#

/!&)*20-&/*!

&D?H NBH= N";N=A;H VD"u>D= -DEAND "A >D=H>B>=uL=>H >" M=>=AG?;= >D= G=B;?;L9 N";>=;>9 B;MA=bE?A=G=;>H "@ >D= -B>D"K?N 3BNABG=;> "@)=N";N?K?B>?";u";= "@ >D= -DEANDcH G"H> HBNA=M B;MN=;>ABK FABN>?N=H# 0;M=A >D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G=-"EA>cH AEK?;L ?; >D?H NBH=9 F=>?>?";=AH9 >D= 2?"N=H= "@

4B>"; )"EL= B;M ";= "@ ?>H FA?=H>H9 1B>D=A 4BOD?9GBO @BN= K?BP?K?>OuB;M N=A>B?;KO K?>?LB>?";u@"A1B>D=A 4BOD?cH BKK=L=M @B?KEA= >" M?HNK"H= >" H>B>=BE>D"A?>?=H ?;@"AGB>?"; K=BA;=M @A"G A=HF";M=;>HcND?KM MEA?;L >D= 3BNABG=;> "@ )=N";N?K?B>?";u d;"VK=ML= >DB> E;M=A NDEAND KBV D= ?H BPH"KE>=KO@"AP?MM=; >" HDBA= V?>D ">D=AH L%' 5&/ '"5(%& E;M=AF=;BK>O "@ BE>"GB>?N =eN"GGE;?NB>?";# 3== FF# jk\9$&L'5# /@ >D= Q@BN>@?;M=A9W ,FF#9$&L'5#9 [B9 FA=HEGBPKOB aEAO9 M=>=AG?;=H >DB> >D= ND?KMcH H>B>=G=;>H GBM=?; N";@=HH?"; BA= ;"> QN";@=HH?";H ,"' (" 9W$V$-#9 B;M>D=A=PO M?HBLA==H V?>D >D= NDEANDcH M=>=AG?;B>?"; "@>D=?A N";@=HH?";BK NDBABN>=A9 1B>D=A 4BOD? B;M >D=-DEAND GBO P= D=KM K?BPK= @"A R?"KB>?"; "@ BGB;MB>"AO A=F"A>?;L "PK?LB>?"; >DB> ">D=AV?H= V"EKM;"> B>>BND >" >D=G# *@ N"EAH=9 G=A=KO >" M=>=AG?;=VD=>D=A >D= N"GGE;?NB>?";H BA= QN";@=HH?";H ,"' (" 9W>D= @BN>@?;M=A GEH> @?AH> PA=BND >D= HB;N>?>O B;MN";@?M=;>?BK?>O "@ >D= 3BNABG=;> B;M 1B>D=A 4BOD?NB; P= HB;N>?";=Mu=R=; H=;> >" FA?H";9 H== .B# -"M=-?R# =;> "@ >D=H= N"GGE;?NB>?";H#&D= H>B>= NB;;"> GBd= N?R?K B;M F"HH?PKO NA?G?;BK

K?BP?K?>O >EA; "; B aEAOcH R?=V "@ VD=>D=A


16/133

^

N"GGE;?NB>?";H B A=K?L?"; R?=VH BH QN";@=HH?";BKW BA=QN";@=HH?";SBKT ,"' (" #W 2"?;L H" BKK"VH >D= H>B>= >""R=AA?M= >D= A=K?L?";cH "V; M=>=AG?;B>?"; "@ VDB> ?>HP=K?=@H B;M FABN>?N=H A=bE?A= B;M M=H>A"OH >D= HBNA=MH=BK "@ N";@=HH?"; ?; >D= FA"N=HH#

&D= M=N?H?"; P=K"V H>B;MH ?; H>BAd N";>ABH> >">D"H= "@ ">D=A N"EA>H9 VD" E;?@"AGKO D"KM >DB> >D=1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> PBAH >D= H>B>= @A"G H=N";MkLE=HH?;L A=K?L?";Hc M=>=AG?;B>?";H "@ VDB> >D=?A "V;P=K?=@H =;>B?K# /> BKH" R?"KB>=H N"A= @A== =e=AN?H= B;M=H>BPK?HDG=;> FA?;N?FK=H =;E;N?B>=M PO >D?H -"EA> ?;]%(5&&5I_5V%' 1*5&3"2$752 D6#4"'5& P46'74 5&-:74%%2 R# 11CP 9 ]^Y 3# -># Z[X _Yf]Y`9 B;M =BAK?=ANBH=H#

&D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA>cH M=N?H?"; NB;;">H>B;M# /> N";@K?N>H V?>D K";LkH>B;M?;L BE>D"A?>O "@>D?H B;M ">D=A N"EA>H B;M >DA=B>=;H NDEANDBE>";"GO# *; A=GB;M9 >D= M?H>A?N> N"EA> DBH P==;BHd=M >" _]` R?"KB>= >D= N";@?M=;>?BK?>O "@ >D=3BNABG=;> "@ )=N";N?K?B>?";9 _Y` H"A> >DA"ELD BKK >D=M?HNEHH?"; >DB> "NNEAA=M >D=A=9 _^` H=FBAB>= "E> VDB>VBH QN";@=HH?";ST ,"' (" W @A"G VDB> VBH ;">9 B;M _X`M=>=AG?;= VD=>D=A BKK >DB> VBH HB?M ?; >D= KB>>=ANB>=L"AO HD"EKM ?GF"H= B A=F"A>?;L "PK?LB>?"; "; >D=FA?=H># 1EA>D=A A=R?=V ?H VBAAB;>=M#

3&,&(+(!&

*7 &D= 3BNABG=;> "@ )=N";N?K?B>?";

&D= 3BNABG=;> "@ )=N";N?K?B>?";9 BKH" d;"V; BH>D= 3BNABG=;> "@ D= N=;>ABK ?;H>?>E>?";BK FABN>?N=H "@ )"GB;-B>D"K?N?HG9 (BH>=A; *A>D"M"e -DEAND=H9 B;M H"G=">D=A -DA?H>?B; A=K?L?";H# ,@>=A >D= 3BNABG=;> "@


17/133

X

4BF>?HG9 VD?ND =H>BPK?HD=H G=GP=AHD?F ?; >D=-DEAND B;M BPH"KR=H BKK FA=R?"EH H?;9 >D= 3BNABG=;>"@ )=N";N?K?B>?"; H>B;MH BH >D= QH=N";M FKB;dW "@HBKRB>?";# &D= -B;";H B;M 2=NA==H "@ >D= 3BNA=M B;MmNEG=;?NBK -"E;N?K "@ &A=;> ]f\ _7# CB>=AV"A>D>AB;H#9 ]iXi` _3=HH# :/69 N#Y`9 D>>FHnooD?H>"AO#DB;"R=A#=MEo>=e>Ho>A=;>oN>]X#D>GK SD=A=?;B@>=A &A=;> -B;";HB;M 2=NA==HT# /> A=G?>H BKK H?; B@>=A 4BF>?HG9 H==$- #B> [^ _3=HH# :/69 ND#]`9 B;M A=N";N?K=H P=K?=R=AH V?>DP">D >D=?A 3BR?"A B;M >D= -DEAND9 -B>=ND?HG "@ >D=

-B>D"K?N -DEAND ll ]XZik]XZ[9D>>FnooVVV#RB>?NB;#RBoBAND?R=oNNN%NHHoBAND?R=oNB>=ND?HGoFYHYNYBX#D>G SD=A=?;B@>=A -DB>=ND?HGT# /> ?H >D=Q";KO "AM?;BAO VBO @"A >D= @B?>D@EK >" A=N";N?K=>D=GH=KR=H V?>D 5"M B;M >D= -DEAND#W ][i^ -"M=N#[Zft -B>=ND?HG l ]XiX#

-B>D"K?NH P=K?=R= >DB> -DA?H> ?;H>?>E>=M >D=3BNABG=;> "; @?AH> A=BFF=BA?;L >" D?H M?HN?FK=H B@>=AD?H A=HEAA=N>?";9 H==c%4& Yfn YYkY^ _!=V ,G=A?NB;4?PK= A=R# =M# Yf]]` _QS-DA?H>T PA=B>D=M "; >D=G B;M

HB?M >" >D=G v)=N=?R= >D= D"KO 3F?A?># CD"H= H?;H O"E@"AL?R= BA= @"AL?R=; >D=G9 B;M VD"H= H?;H O"E A=>B?;BA= A=>B?;=M#cW`9 B;M >DB> D?H @?;BK ?;aE;N>?"; >" >D=GP=@"A= D= BHN=;M=M ?;>" D=BR=; VBH >" HFA=BM >D=3BNABG=;>9 H==D6`" YXn XZkX\ _!=V ,G=A?NB; 4?PK=A=R# =M# Yf]]` _Q,;M D= HB?M >" >D=G9 v&DEH ?> ?HVA?>>=; >DB> >D= +=HH?BD V"EKM HE@@=A B;M A?H= @A"G>D= M=BM "; >D= >D?AM MBO B;M >DB> A=F=;>B;N=9 @"A>D= @"AL?R=;=HH "@ H?;H9 V"EKM P= FA=BND=M ?; D?H;BG= >" BKK >D= ;B>?";H9 P=L?;;?;L @A"G 7=AEHBK=G#cW`#

4=K?=@ ?; >D= 3BNABG=;>9 G"A="R=A9 ?H ";= "@>V=KR= N"A= P=K?=@H =R=AO -B>D"K?N A=B@@?AGH B> +BHH?; FA"@=HH?;L @B?>D >DA"ELD >D= ,F"H>K=Hc -A==M# 3==


18/133

j

-B>=ND?HG F># ]9 l Y _Q/ P=K?=R= ?; J J J >D= @"AL?R=;=HH"@ H?;H#W`# C?>D"E> >D= 3BNABG=;>9 B -B>D"K?N VD"H?;H LABR=KO B@>=A 4BF>?HG ?H Q?;NBFBPK= "@ =>=A;BKK?@=W B;M GEH> HE@@=A >D= Qv=>=A;BK FE;?HDG=;>c "@ H?;#WY- # l ]X\Y# (R=AO -B>D"K?N "@ >D= BL= "@ M?HNA=>?";9G"A="R=A9 GEH> N";@=HH H=A?"EH H?;H B> K=BH> ";N= BO=BA9$- # l ]Xj\9 B;M ?H H>A";LKO =;N"EABL=M >" N";@=HHP">D >D=H= B;M Q=R=AOMBO @BEK>HW G"A= @A=bE=;>KO9$- #l ]Xji#

&" B -B>D"K?N9 >D= HF?A?>EBK =@@=N>H "@ >D=3BNABG=;> BA= PK=HH=M B;M GB;?@"KM# +"H>@E;MBG=;>BKKO9 >D= 3BNABG=;> A=N";N?K=H >D= F=;?>=;>V?>D 5"M B;M BKK"VH >D= F=;?>=;> 5"McH LABN= B;MG=ANO >DA"ELD >D= @"AL?R=;=HH "@ H?;# -B>=ND?HGl ]X[Z# /> BKH" A=N";N?K=H >D= F=;?>=;> V?>D >D=-DEAND B;M >D=A=PO A=H>"A=H @AB>=A;BK N"GGE;?";B;M A=R?>BK?U=H >D= K?@= "@ >D= -DEAND ?>H=K@#Y- #l ]XZ[# /> A=N";N?K=H >D= F=;?>=;> BH V=KK QV?>DD?GH=K@ ?; D?H ?;G"H> P=?;LS9T V?>D D?H PA=>D=A; VD"GD= DBH ?; H"G= VBO B>>BNd=M B;M V"E;M=MS9 B;MT

V?>D BKK NA=B>?";#W D=Ao

a"D;%FBEK%??oBF"H>%=eD"A>B>?";HoM"NEG=;>HoD@%aFk??%=eD%fY]Y][iX%A=N";N?K?B>?"k=>kFB=;?>=;>?B%=;#D>GK#

&D= 3BNABG=;> BKH" A=G?>H P">D >D= =>=A;BKFE;?HDG=;> ?;NEAA=M PO G"A>BK H?; B;M FBA> "@ >D=>=GF"ABK FE;?HDG=;>H A=HEK>?;L @A"G BKK H?;#-B>=ND?HG l ]X[Z# &" >D= F=;?>=;>9 ?> BKH" FA"R?M=HQF=BN= B;M H=A=;?>O "@ N";HN?=;N=ST B;M HF?A?>EBKN";H"KB>?";W B;M QHF?A?>EBK H>A=;L>D @"A >D= -DA?H>?B;

PB>>K=W V?>D H?;#YV$-#*;= N=;>ABK B;M ;=N=HHBAO @=B>EA= "@ >D=

3BNABG=;> ?H >D= QH=BK "@ >D= N";@=HH?";BK#W 0;M=A


19/133

Z

>D?H M"N>A?;=9 Q?> ?H ;=R=A KBV@EK E;M=A B;ON?ANEGH>B;N=H >" GBd= d;"V; >D= K=BH> >D?;L >DB>DBH P==; GB;?@=H>=M PO B F=;?>=;> ?; N";@=HH?";#W Y&D"GBH 3KB>=A9 , +B;EBK "@ +"ABK &D="K"LO @"A(;LK?HDk3F=Bd?;L -"E;>A?=H ]\^ _j>D =M# ][Yj`# ,H>D= -DEAND -B>=ND?HG M=HNA?P=H ?>n

S(TR=AO FA?=H> VD" D=BAH N";@=HH?";H ?H P"E;ME;M=A R=AO H=R=A= F=;BK>?=H >" d==F BPH"KE>=H=NA=NO A=LBAM?;L >D= H?;H >DB> D?H F=;?>=;>H DBR=N";@=HH=M >" D?G# '= NB; GBd= ;" EH= "@d;"VK=ML= >DB> N";@=HH?"; L?R=H D?G BP"E>F=;?>=;>Hc K?R=H# &D?H H=NA=>9 VD?ND BMG?>H "@ ;"=eN=F>?";H9 ?H NBKK=M >D= QHBNABG=;>BK H=BK9WP=NBEH= VDB> >D= F=;?>=;> DBH GBM= d;"V; >" >D=FA?=H> A=GB?;H QH=BK=MW PO >D= HBNABG=;>#

-B>=ND?HG l ]XZ\# 0;M=A NB;"; KBV9 QS>TD=HBNABG=;>BK H=BK ?H ?;R?"KBPK=#W ][i^ -"M= N#[i^#

, FA?=H> NB;;"> PA=Bd >D= H=BK ;" GB>>=A D"VLA=B> >D= F=;BK>O "A D"V LA=B> B DBAG "A ?;aEH>?N=

V"EKM ">D=AV?H= P= NBEH=M# ,H ";= FA?=H> DBHM=HNA?P=M >D?H HBNA=M "PK?LB>?";9 B FA?=H>

NB;;"> PA=Bd >D= H=BK >" HBR= D?H "V; K?@=9 >"FA">=N> D?H L""M ;BG=9 >" A=@E>= B @BKH= BNNEHB>?";9>" HBR= >D= K?@= "@ B;">D=A9 >" B?M >D= N"EAH= "@

aEH>?N= _K?d= A=F"A>?;L B NA?G=` "A >" BR=A> B FEPK?NNBKBG?>O# '= NB;;"> P= N"GF=KK=M PO KBV >"M?HNK"H= B F=AH";cH N";@=HH?"; "A S=R=;T P= P"E;MPO B;O "B>D D= >Bd=H9 =#L#9 BH B V?>;=HH ?; B N"EA>>A?BK#

C?KK?BG 3B;M=AH9_4" :"52 %L P%&L"(($%&9 ,AK?;L>";-B>D"K?N '=ABKM9 ,EL# [9 Yff]9D>>FnooNB>D"K?ND=ABKM#N"GoH>"A?=HoP&D=k3=BKk"@k-";@=HH


20/133

\

?";P9X\]XpN";>=;>%H"EAN=qrNB>=L"AO%?MqrH=BAND%@?K>=AqH=BKs"@s>D=sN";@=HH?";BKr=R=;>%G"M=qr=R=;>%>H

%@A"GqrK?H>%>OF=qr"AM=A%POqr"AM=A%H"A>qrN";>=;> %NKBHHqrHEP%>OF=qH>"A?=H9PK"LHr>"V;%?Mq# (R=;VD=; ?> ?H >" >D= BMRB;>BL= "@ >D= -DEAND "A >" >D=F=;?>=;>9 NB;"; KBV GBd=H NK=BA >DB> ?;@"AGB>?";M=A?R=M @A"G N";@=HH?"; GBO ;"> P= M?REKL=M "A EH=M#3==9 =#L#9 ][i^ -"M= N#YXf9 l Y _QCD=; M=N?H?";H BA=GBM= BP"E> BMG?>>?;L H>EM=;>H >" "AM=AH "AM?HG?HH?;L >D=G @A"G >D= H=G?;BAO9 >D= "F?;?"; "@

J J J N";@=HH"AH NB; ;=R=A P= H"ELD>#W`#3" H>A?N> ?H >D?H "PK?LB>?"; >DB> -DEAND

FE;?HDG=;> ?H H=R=A=# /; ]Y]j9 >D= 1"EA>D .B>=AB;-"E;N?K M=NA==M >DB> QSDT= VD" MBA=H >" A=R=BK B H?;N";@?M=M >" D?G ?; >D= >A?PE;BK "@ F=;B;N= J J J P= ;">";KO M=F"H=M @A"G >D= HBN=AM">BK "@@?N= PE> BKH"A=K=LB>=M >" B G";BH>=AO "@ H>A?N> "PH=ARB;N= >" M"F=;B;N= @"A >D= A=GB?;M=A "@ D?H K?@=#W +=M?=RBK3"EAN=P""dn &V=K@>D (NEG=;?NBK -"E;N?Kn .B>=AB; /6]Y]j9 N#Y]9 D>>FnooVVV#@"AMDBG#=MEo'BKHBKKoPBH?HoKB>=

AB;X#BHF# ,;M NB;"; KBV >"MBO FE;?HD=H QSBTN";@=HH"A VD" M?A=N>KO R?"KB>=H >D= H=BK "@ N";@=HH?";SV?>DT BE>"GB>?N =eN"GGE;?NB>?";#W ][i^ -"M=N#]^ii l ]#

&D= -DEAND9 G"A="R=A9 N=K=PAB>=H >D= GBA>OM"G"@ >D"H= VD" M?=M >" FA=H=AR= >D= H=BK# /> A=N"L;?U=H3># 7"D; !=F"GEN=;=9 @"A =eBGFK=9 BH >D= @?AH>QGBA>OA "@ >D= N";@=HH?";BKW @"A D?H M=B>D POMA"V;?;L @"A A=@EH?;L >" A=R=BK VDB> VBH HB?M >" D?G?; N";@=HH?";# :#T c%4& A",%\67"&" 9 -B>D"K?N *;K?;=9

D>>FnooVVV#NB>D"K?N#"ALoHB?;>HoHB?;>#FDFpHB?;> %?MqZ[f # ,;M9 G"A= A=N=;>KO9 >D= NDEAND NB;";?U=M3># +B>=" -"AA=B +BLBKKB;=H @"A D?H M=B>D PO


21/133

i

HD"">?;L B> >D= DB;MH "@ >D= G?K?>BAO ?; ][Y\ @"AH?G?KBAKO A=@EH?;L >" A=R=BK >D= N";>=;>H "@N";@=HH?";H D= DBM D=BAM#:#T O5#"% P%''"5O535225&"( 9 -B>D"K?N *;K?;=9 D>>FnooVVV#NB>D"K?N#"ALoHB?;>HoHB?;>#FDFpHB?;>%?Mqj\f\# &D=H= HB?;>H BA=EFD=KM BH =e=GFKBAH @"A >D= @B?>D@EKuFA?=H>H B;MFBA?HD?";=AH BK?d=#

37 1BN>EBK ,KK=LB>?";H

/; Yff[9 A=HF";M=;>H9 FBA=;>H "@ B G?;"A

MBELD>=A9 HE=M @"A MBGBL=H HE@@=A=M PO >D=G B;M>D=?A MBELD>=A BH B A=HEK> "@ BKK=L=M ?;BFFA"FA?B>=d?HH?;L B;M >"END?;L "@ >D=?A ND?KM PO B G=GP=A "@>D=?A FBA?HD ;BG=M 5="AL= -DBAK=>9 7A# ,FF#9$&L'59YB# &D=O ;BG=M9 BG";L ">D=AH9 F=>?>?";=AH 1B>D=A+# 7=@@A=O 4BOD? _>D= FA?=H>` B;M >D= )"GB; -B>D"K?N-DEAND "@ >D= 2?"N=H= "@ 4B>"; )"EL= _>D= 2?"N=H=` BHM=@=;MB;>Hu1B>D=A 4BOD?9 @"A BKK=L=MKO P=?;L BGB;MB>"AO A=F"A>=A VD" @B?K=M >" A=F"A> BPEH=BKK=LB>?";H D= K=BA;=M BP"E> ?; N";@=HH?"; B;M >D=2?"N=H= @"A BKK=L=MKO ;=LK?L=;>KO >AB?;?;L B;MHEF=AR?H?;L >D= FA?=H> B;M @"A R?NBA?"EH K?BP?K?>O @"A1B>D=A 4BOD?cH "V; BKK=L=M G?HN";MEN>#YV$-#

&D= HE?> BKK=L=M >DB> ?; Yffi9 VD=; >D= MBELD>=AVBH BP"E> ]Y O=BAH "KM9 +A# -DBAK=> P=LB;=eNDB;L?;L ";= >" >V" =GB?KH Q?;R"KR?;L vV"AMH "@?;HF?AB>?";c B;M MB?KO 4?PK= R=AH=HW V?>D >D= MBELD>=AF=A MBO# ,FF#9$&L'59 ]XB# 3"";9 >D= HE?> BKK=L=M9 >D==GB?KH ?;NA=BH=M ?; @A=bE=;NO >" @?R= >" H=R=; F=A MBOB;M QP=LB; >Bd?;L "; B G"A= F=AH";BK >";=#W YV$-#+A# -DBAK=> BKK=L=MKO >"KM >D= ND?KM Q>" d==F >D=;B>EA= "@ >D=?A =GB?K N"AA=HF";M=;N= FA?RB>= J J JP=NBEH= v;" F=AH";9 ">D=A >DB; 5"M9 V"EKME;M=AH>B;M >D=?A GE>EBK @==K?;LH @"A ";= B;">D=A#cW


22/133

[

YV$-# &D= HE?> N";>B?;=M RBA?"EH ">D=A BKK=LB>?";H "@+A# -DBAK=>cH ?;BFFA"FA?B>= P=DBR?"A9 ;";= "@ VD?ND>D= K"V=A N"EA>H @"E;M A=K=RB;> >" >D= NKB?GH GBM=BLB?;H> F=>?>?";=AH9$V$-#9 QNEKG?;B>S?;LT ?; >D=d?HH?;L B;M @";MK?;L "@ >D= G?;"A ND?KM9W$V$-#

&D= HE?> BKK=L=M >DB> >D= ND?KM P=NBG= QN";@EH=MB;M HNBA=M "R=A >D= =R"KR?;L vA=KB>?";HD?Fc V?>D +A#-DBAK=>ST B;M >DB> "; >DA== H=FBAB>= "NNBH?";H S>D=ND?KMT M=N?M=M >" H==d HF?A?>EBK LE?MB;N= >DA"ELD >D=3BNABG=;> "@ )=N";N?K?B>?"; V?>D S1B>D=A 4BOD?T#W

,FF#9 $&L'59 ]jB# /> @EA>D=A BKK=L=M >DB> >D= ND?KM DBM>"KM >D= FA?=H> QMEA?;L D=A N";@=HH?"; J J J >DB> +A#-DBAK=> DBM ?;BFFA"FA?B>=KO >"END=M D=A9 d?HH=M D=A9B;M >"KM D=A >DB> vD= VB;>=M >" GBd= K"R= >" D=A#cWYV$-# ,NN"AM?;L >" >D= HE?>9 Q>D= FA?=H> BKK=L=MKOA=HF";M=M >" D=A >DB> HD= H?GFKO ;==M=M >" DB;MK=>D= H?>EB>?"; D=AH=K@9 P=NBEH= ">D=AV?H=ST >"" GB;OF="FK= V"EKM P= DEA>#WYV$-# ,NN"AM?;L >" >D= ND?KM9MEA?;L ";= "@ >D= N";@=HH?";H9 VD=; HD= BHd=M >D=FA?=H> D"V HD= N"EKM =;M >D?;LH P=>V==; D=AH=K@ B;M

+A# -DBAK=>9 QSDT= aEH> HB?M SvT>D?H ?H O"EA FA"PK=G#3V==F ?> E;M=A >D= @K""A B;M L=> A?M "@ ?>#cWYV$-#

&D= HE?> @EA>D=A BKK=L=M >DB> +A# -DBAK=>N";>?;E=M >" BN> ?;BFFA"FA?B>=KO B@>=A >D= N";@=HH?";H#

,FF#9 $&L'59 ]jBk]ZB# ,NN"AM?;L >" >D= HE?>9 >D= FA?=H>B;M >D= L?AKcH FBA=;>H ?;M=F=;M=;>KO G=> V?>D +A#B;M +AH# -DBAK=> B;M9 MEA?;L D?H N";R=AHB>?"; V?>D>D=G9 1B>D=A 4BOD? G=;>?";=M N";N=A; V?>D Q>D=H==G?;L ?;BFFA"FA?B>= NK"H=;=HH P=>V==; >D= >V">DB> DBM P==; "PH=AR=M PO RBA?"EH FBA?HD?";=AH#WY- #

B> ]ZB# , K?>>K= KB>=A9 >D= HE?> BKK=L=M9 >D= FBA=;>H

N";@A";>=M >D=?A MBELD>=A BP"E> D=A A=KB>?";HD?F V?>D


23/133

]f

+A# -DBAK=> B;M HD= BMG?>>=M ?>H Q>AE= ;B>EA=S9T?;NKEM?;L M=>B?KH "@ >D= ?;BFFA"FA?B>= H=eEBKN";>BN>H#W ,FF#9$&L'59 ]ZBk]\B# &D= FBA=;>H >D=;N";>BN>=M +A# -DBAK=> B;M "AM=A=M D?G >" N=BH=N";>BN> V?>D >D=?A MBELD>=A#Y- # B> ]\B# CD=; >D=OKB>=A HBV +A# -DBAK=> DEL >D=?A MBELD>=A BLB?;H> D=AV?KK B@>=A B NDEAND H=AR?N=9 >D=O @?K=M B @"AGBKN"GFKB?;> BLB?;H> D?G V?>D K"NBK F"K?N=#YV$-#

,NN"AM?;L >" >D= HE?>9 >D= F"K?N= ?;R=H>?LB>?"; VBH";L"?;L VD=; +A# -DBAK=> M?=M "@ B D=BA> B>>BNd

P=@"A= >D= N"GFKB?;> VBH @?K=M#YV$-#-# ?";=AH @?K=M B G">?"; ?; K?G?;=9 H==d?;L >"=eNKEM= @A"G >A?BK BKK =R?M=;N= BP"E> >D= N";@=HH?";H#

,FF#9 $&L'5#9 XB# &D=O BALE=M9 BG";L ">D=A >D?;LH9>DB> BKK"V?;L >D= >=H>?G";O V"EKM QFA=H=;>ST R=AOH=A?"EH 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> ?HHE=H ?; >=AGH "@ @"AN?;LS1B>D=A 4BOD?T >" ND""H= P=>V==; =eN"GGE;?NB>?";"A HF=Bd?;L "@ S>D=T GB>>=A#W &A# "; 'AcL "; +"># ?;.?G?;= ^# ,K>D"ELD >D= M?H>A?N> N"EA> @"E;M >D= ?HHE=QR=AO M?@@?NEK>9W ,FF#9$&L'59 Z\B9 ?> EK>?GB>=KO M=;?=M>D= G">?";9 $-T B> ZZB# /> D=KM >DB> >D= F=;?>=;>D=AH=K@ N"EKM VB?R= >D= FA?R?K=L= B;M >=H>?@O BH >"VDB> DBM P==; HB?M ?; N";@=HH?";#Y- # B> ZiB# /> BKH"@"E;M >DB> QBH "@>=; DBFF=;H V?>D >D= K=L?HKB>EA=9>D=O =;BN> FBA>H "@ H>B>E>=H H"G=>?G=H V?>D"E>A=BM?;L >D= ">D=A FBA>H9 B;M S>D=OT NA=B>=M B N";@K?N>#WY- # B> Z\B# ,H >D= M?H>A?N> N"EA> =eFKB?;=M9 >D= H>B>E>=NA=B>=H B NK=ALOkF=;?>=;> FA?R?K=L= PE> BKH" QHBOH >DB>;">V?>DH>B;M?;L B;O NKB?G "@ FA?R?K=L=M N"GGE;k

?NB>?";9 B;O GB;MB>"AO A=F"A>=A VD" DBH B NBEH= >"P=K?=R= >D= ND?KMcH FDOH?NBK "A G=;>BK D=BK>D "AV=K@BA= ?H =;MB;L=A=M BH B A=HEK> "@ BPEH= "A ;=LK=N>


24/133

]]

HDBKK A=F"A> S?>T#WYV$-# &D= M?H>A?N> N"EA> ;">=M >DB>>D?H "PK?LB>?"; ;=LB>=H >D= FA?R?K=L=n Q&" d;"VVD=>D=A "A ;"> S>D= FA?=H>T DBH B SGB;MB>"AOT ME>O9J J J V= DBR= >" d;"V VDB> D= K=BA;=M ?; >D=N";@=HH?";9 B;M D?H ?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@ VDB> D=K=BA;=M#WY- # B> Z\BkZiB#

Y# ?>?";=AH H"ELD> A=R?=V "@ >D= "AM=A M=;O?;L>D=?A G">?"; ?; K?G?;=# &D= ."E?H?B;B N"EA> "@ BFF=BKA=R=AH=M >D= M?H>A?N> N"EA>cH aEMLG=;> B;M HEB HF";>=D=KM >DB> ;" FA?RB>= A?LD> "@ BN>?"; =e?H>H @"A R?"KB>?;L>D= GB;MB>"AO A=F"A>?;L "PK?LB>?";# ,FF#9$&L'59 ^\BkXfB# ,H >" >D= G">?"; ?; K?G?;=9 >D= N"EA> "@ BFF=BKD=KM >DB> Q>D= A=N"AM NK=BAKO =H>BPK?HD=M >DB> >D=N"GGE;?NB>?"; VBH DBM VD?K= ?; N";@=HH?"; SB;M>DB>T >D=A=@"A= ?> ?H H>B>E>"A?KO M=@?;=M >" P= BN";@?M=;>?BK N"GGE;?NB>?";9W$- # B> ^^B9 VD?ND QBvG=GP=A "@ >D= NK=ALOc J J J$( &%# '"f6$'"- >" A=F"A>9W$V$-# Q&D=A=@"A=9W >D= N"EA> N";>?;E=M9 Q?> ?HBe?"GB>?N >DB> >D= FA?=H>9 E;M=A >D=H= N?ANEGH>B;N=H9?H ;">9 B;M NB;;"> P=9 B GB;MB>"AO A=F"A>=A#

,NN"AM?;LKO9 .B# -D?KM# -"M= BA># Zf[9 VD?NDBMMA=HH=H GB;MB>"AO A=F"A>=AH9 B;M GB;MB>=H >D=A=F"A>?;L "@ B;O ND?KM BPEH= B;M ;=LK=N> J J J ?HH?GFKO B;M VD"KKO ?;BFFK?NBPK=#WYV$-# Q4=NBEH= J J J>D=A= NB; P= ;" FA?RB>= "A N?R?K NBEH= "@ BN>?"; BLB?;H>D?G @"A B;O PA=BND "@ H>B>E>= ?;BFFK?NBPK= >" D?GS9TB;O =R?M=;N= "A >=H>?G";O9 PO B;O";=9 A=LBAM?;L >D="NNEAA=;N= "@ B N";@=HH?";9 "A >D= HEPa=N> GB>>=A>D=A="@9 ?H VD"KKO ?;BMG?HH?PK=9 ?AA=K=RB;>9 B;M ;";kFA"PB>?R=#WY- # B> ^ZB# /> >DEH A=R=AH=M >D= M?H>A?N>N"EA>cH M=;?BK "@ >D= G">?"; ?; K?G?;=#

&D= N"EA> "@ BFF=BK V=;> @EA>D=A9 D"V=R=A9 >" D"KM>DB> Q"*"& $L J J J >D= FA?=H> SV=A=T B GB;MB>"AO


25/133

]Y

A=F"A>=A9 >D=A= ?H ;" N?R?K NBEH= "@ BN>?"; B;M ;" N?R?KA=G=MO @"A B;O BKK=L=M R?"KB>?";#W ,FF9$&L'59 ^[B#4=NBEH= QS>TD=A= BA= ;" N?R?K A=G=M?=H FA"R?M=M ?; >D==;>?A= H>B>E>"AO HND=G= SB;MT A=G=MO ?H =eFA=HHKOM=K=LB>=M >" NA?G?;BK KBV =;@"AN=G=;>9W$V$-#9 >D=N"EA> D=KM9 >D=A= N"EKM P= ;" NBEH= "@ BN>?"; BLB?;H>>D= FA?=H> =R=; Q@"A B;O A=F"A>BPK= ?;@"AGB>?"; >"VD?ND D= GBO DBR= P==; FA?RO "E>H?M= "@ >D=N";@=HH?";BK9W$- # B> XfB#

7EML= wED; N";NEAA=M# &" D?G9 ."E?H?B;BcHH>B>E>"AO =e=GF>?"; "@ FA?=H>H @A"G GB;MB>"AOA=F"A>?;L "PK?LB>?";H @"A ?;@"AGB>?"; K=BA;=M ?;N";@=HH?"; VBH QSFTA=G?H=M "; "EA ;B>?";cH P?KK "@A?LD>H SB;MT BNd;"VK=ML=SHT >DB> J J J S>T" HEPa=N> B-B>D"K?N FA?=H> >" HEND GB;MB>"AO A=F"A>?;L V"EKM P=NK=BAKO R?"KB>?R= "@ >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> "@ >D=0;?>=M 3>B>=H -";H>?>E>?";#W ,FF#9 $&L'59 j\B#

^# )=HF";M=;>H >D=; @?K=M ?; ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G=-"EA> @"A B VA?> BKK"V?;L M?HNA=>?";BAO A=R?=V# &D=OBHd=M >D= N"EA> >" A=R?=V P">D FBA>H "@ >D= aEMLG=;>"@ >D= N"EA> "@ BFF=BK# ?>?";=AH @?K=M BG=G"AB;MEG ?; "FF"H?>?";9 BALE?;L >DB> A=R?=VHD"EKM P= M=;?=M# C?>D"E> D"KM?;L BALEG=;> "AA=bE?A?;L HEPH=bE=;> PA?=@?;L "; >D= G=A?>H9 >D=."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA> HEGGBA?KO A=R=AH=M >D=N"EA> "@ BFF=BK# ,FF#9$&L'59 [B#

&D= N"EA> D=KM >DB> >D= GB;MB>"AO ME>O >" A=F"A>BPEH= N"EKM B>>BND >" B FA?=H> @"A H"G= ?;@"AGB>?";K=BA;=M ?; N";@=HH?"; B;M >DB> ."E?H?B;BcH

L=;=ABK N";N=F> "@ K?BP?K?>O J J J >DB> =R=AO BN>VDB>=R=A "@ GB; >DB> NBEH=H MBGBL= >" B;">D=A"PK?L=H D?G PO VD"H= @BEK> ?> DBFF=;=M >" A=FB?A ?>


26/133

]^

B;M =R=AO F=AH"; ?H A=HF";H?PK= @"A >D= MBGBL= D="NNBH?";H ;"> G=A=KO PO D?H BN>9 PE> PO D?H;=LK?L=;N=9 D?H ?GFAEM=;N=9 "A D?H VB;> "@ Hd?KK9

,FF#9 $&L'59 \B _?;>=A;BK bE">B>?"; GBAdH B;MN?>B>?";H "G?>>=M`9 NA=B>=H B; ?GFK?=M FA?RB>= A?LD> "@BN>?"; @"A >"A> MBGBL=H @"A R?"KB>?"; "@ >D= "PK?LB>?";#/> @EA>D=A D=KM9 D"V=R=A9 >DB> QSVTD=>D=A >D?HFBA>?NEKBA FA?=H> "V=M >D?H FBA>?NEKBA ME>O >" >D=FKB?;>?@@H ?; >D?H FBA>?NEKBA @BN>EBK N";>=e> ?H B G?e=MbE=H>?"; "@ KBV B;M @BN>W >DB> >EA;H ?; FBA> ";QVD=>D=A >D= N"GGE;?NB>?";H P=>V==; >D= ND?KM B;M>D= FA?=H> V=A= N";@=HH?";H ,"' (" B;M VD=>D=A >D=FA?=H> "P>B?;=M d;"VK=ML= "E>H?M= >D= N";@=HH?";BK>DB> V"EKM >A?LL=A D?H ME>O >" A=F"A>#W ,FF#9$&L'59iBk[B# 7EH>?N= 'ELD=H N";NEAA=M Q>" =GFDBH?U= >DB>>D= ?HHE= SVBHT VD=>D=A >D= HEPa=N> N"GGE;?NB>?";VBH ?; @BN> B vN";@=HH?";#cWY- # B> ]fB#

?>?";=AH >D=; BHd=M >D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G=-"EA> >" A=D=BA >D= NBH=9 BALE?;L >DB> ?> QNB;;">A=GB;M >" >D= >A?BK N"EA> >" M=>=AG?;= VD=>D=A "A ;">>D= N"GGE;?NB>?";H ?; bE=H>?"; V=A= vN";@=HH?";H ,"'(" c V?>D"E> R?"KB>?;LW >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;># ,FFK#1"A )=D=BA?;L 3EPG?>>=M 4O 2=@H# i# &D= HEFA=G=N"EA> M=;?=M A=D=BA?;L V?>D"E> "F?;?";# ,FF#9$&L'59\fB# 7EH>?N= 5E?MAO N";NEAA=M ?; >D= M=;?BK H>B>?;L>DB> QSVTD=>D=A "A ;"> >D= N"GGE;?NB>?"; VBH FBA> "@B vN";@=HH?"; F=A H=c BH >DB> >=AG ?H E;M=AH>""M ?;A=K?L?"EH M"N>A?;=9 GBO P= B; =NNK=H?BH>?NBK FA"PK=G@"A >D= FA?=H>9 PE> ?> M"=H ;"> BFF=BA >" P= A=K=RB;>D=A= >" N";H?M=AB>?"; "@ >D= G=B;?;L B;M ?;>=;> "@ >D=

."E?H?B;B H>B>E>=H ?;R"KR=M ?; >D?H NBH=#WY-T B> \YBk\^B# 7EH>?N= 6?N>"AO M?HH=;>=M @A"G >D= M=;?BK B;MV"EKM DBR= QLAB;>S=MT B;M M"Nd=>S=MT >D= NBH= @"A @EKK


27/133

]X

BALEG=;> B;M PA?=@?;L PO >D= FBA>?=H >" N";H?M=AVD=>D=A >D= A=F"A>?;L A=bE?A=G=;> J J J "R=AA?M=HB;O FA?R?K=L= >DB> GBO ">D=AV?H= P= NKB?G=M PO >D=FA?=H>#WY- # B> \XB# Q,> >D= R=AO K=BH>9W D= BMM=M9 Q/V"EKM LAB;> A=D=BA?;L >" N"AA=N> >D= F=A NEA?BGVD?ND A=GB;MH >D= NBH= >" >D= >A?BK N"EA> >"M=>=AG?;= VD=>D=A >D= N"GGE;?NB>?";H P=>V==; >D=FA?=H> B;M >D= G?;"A V=A= vN";@=HH?";H ,"' (" #cWYV$-#

)(,3*!3 1*) 5),!&/!5 &'( cH '"KM?;L 6?"KB>=H&D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> 4O ,KK"V?;L 3>B>=H &"*R=AA?M= , )=K?L?";cH 6?=V *@ CDB> />H *V; 1B?>D+=B;H ,;M )=bE?A=H

/; ]%(5&&5I_5V%' 1*5&3"2$752 D6#4"'5& P46'74 Q&- :74%%2 R# 11CP 9 ]^Y 3# -># Z[X9 \fY _Yf]Y`9 >D?H-"EA> A=B@@?AG=M ?>H K";L K?;= "@ D"KM?;LH >DB> QSPT">DS>D= (H>BPK?HDG=;> B;M 1A== (e=AN?H=T -KBEH=H PBA>D= L"R=A;G=;> @A"G ?;>=A@=A?;L V?>D >D= M=N?H?"; "@B A=K?L?"EH LA"EFW "R=A N=A>B?; N"A= GB>>=AH#W ,H

=BAKO BH ]i\]9 >D= -"EA> F"?;>=M "E>9 ?> DBMQ=eFKB?;=M >DB> vVD=;=R=A >D= bE=H>?";H "@ M?HN?FK?;=9"A "@ @B?>D9 "A =NNK=H?BH>?NBK AEK=9 NEH>"G9 "A KBV DBR=P==; M=N?M=M PO >D= D?LD=H> "@ S>D=T NDEAND

aEM?NB>"A?=H >" VD?ND >D= GB>>=A DBH P==; NBAA?=M9 >D=K=LBK >A?PE;BKH GEH> BNN=F> HEND M=N?H?";H BH @?;BK9B;M BH P?;M?;L "; >D=G#cW Y- # B> \fX _bE">?;L a5#(%& R#c%&"(9 if 0#3# _]^ CBKK#` Z\[9 \Y\ _]i\]``# Q/> ?H "@>D= =HH=;N= "@ J J J A=K?L?"EH E;?";H9W >D=a5#(%& -"EA> ;">=M9 Q>DB> >D"H= M=N?H?";H HD"EKM P= P?;M?;L?; BKK NBH=H "@ =NNK=H?BH>?NBK N"L;?UB;N=#Wa5#(%& 9 if0#3# B> \Y[# 3" M==F AB; >D?H FA?;N?FK=9 ?; @BN>9 >DB>>D= 3>B>=H @"KK"V=M ?> BH B GB>>=A "@ N"GG"; KBV =R=;P=@"A= >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> VBH ?;N"AF"AB>=M PO >D=


28/133

]j

1"EA>==;>D# 3== $- # B> \^fk\^Y _M?HNEHH?;L H>B>=N"GG"; KBV NBH=H`#

&D?H -"EA> DBH N";H?H>=;>KO B;M A=F=B>=MKO D=KM>DB> N"EA>H _]` NB;;"> M=>=AG?;= A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";H9_Y` GEH> A=HF=N> A=K?L?";Hc "V; R?=VH "@ VDB> >D=?A@B?>D G=B;H B;M A=bE?A=H9 _^` NB;;"> A=R?=V >D=H=NDEAND M=>=AG?;B>?";H @"A HEPH>B;>?R= "A FA"N=MEABKRBK?M?>O E;M=A NDEAND KBV B;M _X` GEH> BNN=F> B;?;M?R?MEBKcH "V; R?=V "@ VDB> D=A A=K?L?"; A=bE?A=H=R=; VD=; >D= PBH?H "@ >DB> P=K?=@ ?H E;NK=BA "AE;H=>>K=M# /; !'"(V/#"'$5& P46'74 R# O5'/ 12$;5V"#4

[26" ]622 O"\%'$52 !'"(V/#"'$5& P46'74 9 ^[^ 0#3#XXf9 XXjkXXZ _][Z[`9 @"A =eBGFK=9 >D?H -"EA> H>B>=M>DB> H?;N=a5#(%& Q?> SDBH P==;T VD"KKO ?;N";H?H>=;>V?>D >D= ,G=A?NB; N";N=F> "@ >D= A=KB>?";HD?FP=>V==; NDEAND B;M H>B>= >" F=AG?> N?R?K N"EA>H >"M=>=AG?;= =NNK=H?BH>?NBK bE=H>?";H#W Q&DS?HT K"L?N9W ?>D=KM9 QK=BR=H >D= N?R?K N"EA>H&% A"K= ?; M=>=AG?;?;L=NNK=H?BH>?NBK bE=H>?";H#WY- # B> XX\ _=GFDBH?HBMM=M`# Q&" A=BND >D"H= bE=H>?";H9W ?> ;">=M9 QV"EKM

A=bE?A= >D= N?R?K N"EA>H >" =;LBL= ?; >D= @"AP?MM=;FA"N=HH "@ ?;>=AFA=>?;L B;M V=?LD?;L NDEANDM"N>A?;=#WY- # B> Xj]#

&D= N"A"KKBAO @"KK"VH >DB> N"EA>H GEH> A=HF=N> BA=K?L?";cH "V; R?=V "@ VDB> ?>H @B?>D G=B;H B;MA=bE?A=H# /; :"'V$5& 15(#"'& C'#4%-%W 9$%7"(" R#O$2$*%X"*$749 XYZ 0#3# Z[Z _][\Z`9 >D?H -"EA> A=R=AH=MB; /KK?;"?H 3EFA=G= -"EA> M=N?H?"; >DB> B P?HD"FcHM=@A"Nd?;L B;M B M?"N=HB; A="ALB;?UB>?"; V=A=?GFA"F=A E;M=A NDEAND KBV# /> M?M H" P=NBEH= QN?R?K

N"EA>H BA= P"E;M >" BNN=F> >D= M=N?H?";H S"@ NDEANDBE>D"A?>?=HT "; GB>>=AH "@ M?HN?FK?;=9 @B?>D9 ?;>=A;BK"ALB;?UB>?";9 SB;MT =NNK=H?BH>?NBK AEK=9 NEH>"G "A KBV#W


29/133

]Z

Y- # B> \]^# QS)T=K?L?"EH N";>A"R=AH?=H BA= ;"> >D=FA"F=A HEPa=N> "@ N?R?K N"EA> ?;bE?AOST B;M J J J B N?R?KN"EA> GEH> BNN=F> >D= =NNK=H?BH>?NBK M=N?H?";H "@ SBTNDEAND J J J BH ?> @?;MH >D=G#WYV$-# 1"A >D=Q3EFA=G= -"EA> "@ /KK?;"?H S>"T HEPH>?>E>=ST ?>H?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@ >D= SNDEANDcHT N";H>?>E>?";H @"A >DB>"@ >D= SNDEAND ?>H=K@ ?H VDB>T >D= 1?AH> B;M 1"EA>==;>D

,G=;MG=;>H @"AP?M#WY- # B> \Y]# ,H >D?H -"EA> ;">=M?; ]%(5&&5I_5V%' 9 ]^Y 3# -># B> \fX9 >D?H ?;aE;N>?";9@K"VH NK=BAKO @A"Ga5#(%& cH =BAKO E;M=AH>B;M?;L >DB>

QVD=;=R=A >D= bE=H>?";H "@ M?HN?FK?;=9 "A "@ @B?>D9 "A=NNK=H?BH>?NBK AEK=9 NEH>"G9 "A KBV DBR= P==; M=N?M=MPO >D= SNDEANDT >D= K=LBK >A?PE;BKH GEH> BNN=F> HENDM=N?H?";H BH @?;BK9 B;M BH P?;M?;L "; >D=G9W if 0#3# B>\Y\#

&D?H -"EA> DBH D=KM >DB> >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>A=bE?A=H K"V=A N"EA>H >" M=@=A >" B NDEANDcH R?=V "@ ?>H"V; M"N>A?;= ?; BKK BA=BH "@ NDEAND BN>?R?>O# +"H>A=N=;>KO9 ?;]%(5&&5I_5V%' 9 ?> D=KM >DB> N?R?K N"EA>HN"EKM ;"> A=R?=V B NDEANDcH M=N?H?"; >" @?A= B G?;?H>=A

P=NBEH= HEND B; ?;bE?AO V"EKM "R=AA?M= NDEANDM=>=AG?;B>?";H "@ VD" FA"F=AKO NB; QF=AH";?@O ?>HP=K?=@HW B;M A=FA=H=;> QL"R=A;G=;> ?;R"KR=G=;> ?;J J J =NNK=H?BH>?NBK M=N?H?";H#W ]^Y 3# -># B> \fZ# />DBH BKH" N";H?H>=;>KO BFFK?=M >D= AEK= ?; NBH=H?;R"KR?;L NDEAND BFF"?;>G=;>H9 H== ^%&;52"; R#+%\5& P5#4%2$7 Q'74V$(4%, 9 Yif 0#3# ]9 ]Z _][Y[`_D"KM?;L >DB> N"EA>H N"EKM ;"> M=N?M= VD" M=H=AR=MNDBFKB?;NO QSPT=NBEH= >D= BFF"?;>G=;> ?H B NB;";?NBKBN> SB;MT ?> ?H >D= @E;N>?"; "@ >D= NDEAND BE>D"A?>?=H >"M=>=AG?;= VDB> >D= =HH=;>?BK bEBK?@?NB>?";H "@ BNDBFKB?; BA= B;M VD=>D=A >D= NB;M?MB>= F"HH=HH=H>D=G#W`9 M=@A"Nd?;LH9 H==O$2$*%X"*$749 XYZ 0#3# B> \]^_D"KM?;L >DB> QB N"EA> GEH> BNN=F> J J J =NNK=H?BH>?NBK


30/133

]\

M=N?H?";H S"R=A M=@A"Nd?;LH B;M M?"N=HB;A="ALB;?UB>?";HT BH ?> @?;MH >D=GW`9 ?;H>?>E>?";BKA=H>AEN>EA?;LH9 H==$V$-#9 FA"F=A>O M?HFE>=H9 H==

!'"(V/#"'$5& P46'74 9 ^[^ 0#3# B> XX[ _D"KM?;L >DB>QN"EA>H SGEH>T M=N?M= NDEAND FA"F=A>O M?HFE>=HV?>D"E> A=H"KR?;L E;M=AKO?;L N";>A"R=AH?=H "R=AA=K?L?"EH M"N>A?;=W`t ."-'%LL R# :#T A$74%25( P5#4"-'52%L +6(($5& C'#4%-%W P46'74 $& A%'#4 Q\"'$75 9 ^XX0#3# [Xt a5#(%& 9 if 0#3# Z\[9 NDEAND FABN>?N=H9 H==Z%B2"' R#+4%-" Y(25&- 9 ^Xj 0#3# Z\9 \f _][j^` _QS/T> ?H

;" PEH?;=HH "@ N"EA>H >" HBO >DB> VDB> ?H B A=K?L?"EHFABN>?N= "A BN>?R?>O @"A ";= LA"EF ?H ;"> A=K?L?"; E;M=A>D= FA">=N>?"; "@ >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>#W`9 B;M NDEANDG=GP=AHD?F9 H== [%62-$& R# Q2"W5&-"' 9 iY 0#3# ]^]9]^[k]Xf _]i\Y` __QSCT= NB;;"> M=N?M= VD" "ELD> >" P=G=GP=AH "@ >D= NDEAND9 ;"A VD=>D=A >D==eN"GGE;?NB>=M DBR= P==; A=LEKBAKO "A ?AA=LEKBAKONE> "@@# C= GEH> >Bd= >D= @BN> "@ =eN"GGE;?NB>?"; BHN";NKEH?R= FA""@ >DB> >D= F=AH";H =eHN?;M=M BA= ;">G=GP=AH#W`# ,;M >D?H -"EA> DBH QSAT=F=B>=MKO B;M ?;GB;O M?@@=A=;> N";>=e>HW D=KM >DB> QS?T> ?H ;"> V?>D?;>D= aEM?N?BK d=; >" bE=H>?"; >D= N=;>ABK?>O "@FBA>?NEKBA P=K?=@H "A FABN>?N=H >" B @B?>D9 "A >D=RBK?M?>O "@ FBA>?NEKBA K?>?LB;>Hc ?;>=AFA=>B>?";H "@>D"H= NA==MH SB;MT >DB> N"EA>H GEH> ;"> FA=HEG= >"M=>=AG?;= >D= FKBN= "@ B FBA>?NEKBA P=K?=@ ?; B A=K?L?";"A >D= FKBEH?P?K?>O "@ B A=K?L?"EH NKB?G#W1\,b# 9$*T R#:\$#4 9 X[X 0#3# i\Y9 ii\ _][[f`#

7EH> BH B N"EA> GEH> A=HF=N> B A=K?L?";cH "V;R?=V BP"E> VDB> ?>H M"N>A?;= G=B;H9 ?> NB;;"> A=R?=V>D"H= M=N?H?";Hc RBK?M?>O E;M=A NDEAND KBV# /;O$2$*%X"*$749 >D?H -"EA> "R=A>EA;=M B; /KK?;"?H3EFA=G= -"EA> M=N?H?"; >DB> B P?HD"FcH M=@A"Nd?;LB;M B; =;HE?;L M?"N=HB; A="ALB;?UB>?"; M?M ;">


31/133

]i

QN"GFKSOT V?>D NDEAND KBV B;M A=LEKB>?";H#W XYZ 0#3#B> \]^# QS,T;BKOUS?;LT VD=>D=A >D= =NNK=H?BH>?NBKBN>?";H "@ B NDEAND J J J BA= ?; >DB> H=;H= vBAP?>ABAO9cW?> D=KM9

GEH> ?;D=A=;>KO =;>B?K ?;bE?AO ?;>" >D= FA"N=MEA=H>DB> NB;"; "A =NNK=H?BH>?NBK KBV HEFF"H=MKOA=bE?A=H J J J "A =KH= ?;>" >D= HEPH>B;>?R= NA?>=A?BPO VD?ND >D=S NDEAND ?HT HEFF"H=MKO >" M=N?M= >D==NNK=H?BH>?NBK bE=H>?";# 4E> >D?H ?H =eBN>KO >D=?;bE?AO >DB> >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> FA"D?P?>HtA=N"L;?>?"; "@ HEND B; =eN=F>?"; V"EKM E;M=AG?;=>D= L=;=ABK AEK= >DB> A=K?L?"EH N";>A"R=AH?=H BA=;"> >D= FA"F=A HEPa=N> "@ N?R?K N"EA> ?;bE?AO9 B;M>DB> B N?R?K N"EA> GEH> BNN=F> >D= =NNK=H?BH>?NBKM=N?H?";H "@ NDEANDS=HT BH ?> @?;MH >D=G#

YV$-# -"EA>Hc A=R?=V?;L HEND B M=N?H?";9 aEH> K?d=>D=?A GBd?;L ?>9 "R=AA?M=H >D= NDEANDcH "V;M=>=AG?;B>?"; "@ VDB> ?>H P=K?=@H A=bE?A=#

&D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>9 ?; @BN>9 H" H>A";LKO FA">=N>H

>D= BE>";"GO "@ A=K?L?"EH M=N?H?";kGBd?;L >DB> BN"EA> GEH> BNN=F> B; ?;M?R?MEBK NDEAND G=GP=AcHR?=V "@ VDB> NDEAND P=K?=@ A=bE?A=H H" K";L BH D?HP=K?=@ QA=@K=N>H vB; D";=H> N";R?N>?";#cW [6'B"22 R#]%VV/ D%VV/ :#%'"(0 Y&7T9 ]^X 3# -># Y\j]9 Y\\[ _Yf]X`_bE">?;L _4%\5( R# +"*$"B [-T CL Y&-T 1\,b# :"7T

9$*T9 Xjf 0#3# \f\9 \]Z _][i]``# 4=NBEH= QSNT"EA>H BA=;"> BAP?>=AH "@ HNA?F>EABK ?;>=AFA=>B>?";W >D=O NB;;">QM?HH=N> A=K?L?"EH P=K?=@H P=NBEH= >D= P=K?=R=A BMG?>H>DB> D= ?H vH>AELLK?;Lc V?>D D?H F"H?>?"; "A P=NBEH= D?HP=K?=@H BA= ;"> BA>?NEKB>=M V?>D >D= NKBA?>O B;MFA=N?H?"; >DB> B G"A= H"FD?H>?NB>=M F=AH"; G?LD>=GFK"OW "A QA=H"KR= S?;>AB@B?>DT M?@@=A=;N=H ?; A=KB>?";>" >D= )=K?L?"; -KBEH=H#W_4%\5( 9 Xjf 0#3# B> \]jk


32/133

][

\]Z# /@ >D= P=K?=R=A QMASBVHT B K?;=9 J J J ?> ?H ;"> @"AS>D= N"EA>HT >" HBO >DB> >D= K?;= D= MASBVH ?HT B;E;A=BH";BPK= ";=#W Y- # B> \]j#

&D?H -"EA> DBH A=N"L;?U=M >DB> >D=H= AEK=H H=AR=H=R=ABK @"E;MB>?";BK N";H>?>E>?";BK FEAF"H=H# 1"AH>BA>=AH9 N"EA>H DBR= K?>>K= N"GF=>=;N= >" M=N?M=A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";H# /;a5#(%& 9 @"A =eBGFK=9 >D?H-"EA> ;">=M >DB> NDEAND=H DBR=

B P"MO "@ N";H>?>E>?";BK B;M =NNK=H?BH>?NBK KBV "@

S>D=?AT "V;9 >" P= @"E;M ?; >D=?A VA?>>=; "ALB;?NKBVH9 >D=?A P""dH "@ M?HN?FK?;=9 ?; >D=?A N"KK=N>?";H"@ FA=N=M=;>H9 ?; >D=?A EHBL= B;M NEH>"GH9 VD?NDBH >" =BND N";H>?>E>= B HOH>=G "@ =NNK=H?BH>?NBK KBVB;M A=K?L?"EH @B?>D >DB> >BHdH >D= BPK=H> G?;MH >"P=N"G= @BG?K?BA V?>D# /> ?H ;"> >" P= HEFF"H=M>DB> >D= aEML=H "@ >D= N?R?K N"EA>H NB; P= BHN"GF=>=;> ?; >D= =NNK=H?BH>?NBK KBV B;M A=K?L?"EH@B?>D "@ BKK >D=H= P"M?=H BH >D= BPK=H> G=; ?; =BNDBA= ?; A=@=A=;N= >" >D=?A "V;# /> V"EKM >D=A=@"A=P= B; BFF=BK @A"G >D= G"A= K=BA;=M >A?PE;BK ?;>D= KBV VD?ND HD"EKM M=N?M= >D= NBH=9 >" ";= VD?ND?H K=HH H"#

if 0#3# B> \Y[# 3END bE=H>?";H A=FA=H=;> B QA=K?L?"EH>D?Nd=>9WO$2$*%X"*$749 XYZ 0#3# B> \][9 ?;>" VD?NDN?R?K N"EA>H HD"EKM @=BA >" >A=BM#

3=N";M9 N"EA>H NB;;"> B;HV=A A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";HV?>D"E> =eN=HH?R=KO =;>B;LK?;L NDEAND B;M H>B>=# 3==D"\%& R# .6'#;\5& 9 Xf^ 0#3# ZfY9 Z][ _][\]`_D"KM?;L >DB> QN"GFA=D=;H?R=9 M?HNA?G?;B>?;L9 B;MN";>?;E?;L H>B>= HEAR=?KKB;N= SV"EKMT ?;R"KR==eN=HH?R= B;M =;MEA?;L =;>B;LK=G=;> P=>V==; H>B>=


33/133

Yf

B;M NDEANDW`# &D?H @=BA A=H>H "; >V" H=FBAB>= PE>GE>EBKKO A=?;@"AN?;L N";N=A;Hn >DB>

SVTD=; >D= H>B>= P=N"G=H =;G=HD=M V?>D B L?R=;M=;"G?;B>?"; ?; GB>>=AH "@ A=K?L?"EH H?L;?@?NB;N=9>D= @A==M"G "@ A=K?L?"EH P=K?=@ "@ >D"H= VD" BA= ;">BMD=A=;>H "@ >DB> M=;"G?;B>?"; HE@@=AH SB;MT >D=@A==M"G "@ =R=; >D= BMD=A=;>H "@ >D=M=;"G?;B>?"; ?H K?G?>=M PO >D= L"R=A;G=;>BK?;>AEH?"; ?;>" HBNA=M GB>>=AH#

Q36$25' R# Z"2#%&9 X\^ 0#3# XfY9 Xf[kX]f _][ij`9%*"''62"- %& %#4"' 3'%6&-( V/ Q3%(#$&$ R# Z"2#%&9 jY]0#3# Yf^ _][[\`# QS&TD= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> A=H>H EF";>D= FA=G?H= >DB> P">D A=K?L?"; B;M L"R=A;G=;> NB;P=H> V"Ad >" BND?=R= >D=?A K"@>O B?GH ?@ =BND ?H K=@>@A== @A"G >D= ">D=A V?>D?; ?>H A=HF=N>?R= HFD=A=#WO7P%226\ R# [-T %L 1-67T 9 ^^^ 0#3# Yf^9 Y]Y _][Xi`#

&D?AM9 N"EA> M=>=AG?;B>?"; "@ A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";H?GFB?AH Q>D= @B?>D B;M G?HH?"; "@ >D= NDEAND9W]%(5&&5I_5V%' 9 ]^Y 3# -># B> \f\t H== BKH" $- # B> \fZ9

VD?ND >D?H -"EA> DBH M=HNA?P=M BH Q>D= R=AO N"A= "@J J J A=K?L?";9W !'"(V/#"'$5& P46'74 9 ^[^ 0#3# B> Xjf#/@ N"EA>H E;M=A>Bd= HEND ?;bE?A?=H9 Q>D= DBUBAMH BA==R=A FA=H=;> "@ ?;D?P?>?;L >D= @A== M=R=K"FG=;> "@A=K?L?"EH M"N>A?;= B;M "@ ?GFK?NB>?;L H=NEKBA ?;>=A=H>H?; GB>>=AH "@ FEA=KO =NNK=H?BH>?NBK N";N=A;#WY- # B>XX[# +=A= QE;N=A>B?;>O BP"E> VD=>D=A ?>H S"V;E;M=AH>B;M?;LH "@ VDB> ?>H @B?>D A=bE?A=HT V?KK P=A=a=N>=M9 B;M B N"AA=HF";M?;L @=BA "@ K?BP?K?>O9 GBONBEH= B A=K?L?"EH LA"EF >" N";@"AG ?>H P=K?=@H B;MFABN>?N=H J J J >" >D= FA=RB?K?;L H=NEKBAE;M=AH>B;M?;L#W]%(5&&5I_5V%' 9 ]^Y 3# -># B> \]]_&D"GBH9 7#9 N";NEAA?;L`# ,H >D?H -"EA> A=N"L;?U=M ?;


34/133

Y]

P%',%'5#$%& %L !'"($-$&3 [$(4%, %L P46'74 %L D5##"'I 95/ :5$( R# Q\%( 9

?> ?H B H?L;?@?NB;> PEAM=; "; B A=K?L?"EH"ALB;?UB>?"; >" A=bE?A= ?>9 "; FB?; "@ HEPH>B;>?BKK?BP?K?>O9 >" FA=M?N> VD?ND "@ ?>H BN>?R?>?=H B H=NEKBAN"EA> V?KK N";H?M=A A=K?L?"EH# &D= K?;= ?H DBAMKO BPA?LD> ";=9 B;M B; "ALB;?UB>?"; G?LD>E;M=AH>B;MBPKO P= N";N=A;=M >DB> B aEML= V"EKM;"> E;M=AH>B;M ?>H A=K?L?"EH >=;=>H B;M H=;H= "@G?HH?";# 1=BA "@ F">=;>?BK K?BP?K?>O G?LD> B@@=N>>D= VBO B; "ALB;?UB>?"; NBAA?=M "E> VDB> ?>E;M=AH>""M >" P= ?>H A=K?L?"EH G?HH?";#

Xi^ 0#3# ^Y\9 ^^Z _][i\`#

1"EA>D9 BKK"V?;L >D?H >OF= "@ N"EA> ?;bE?AO NB;K=BM >" M?HNA?G?;B>?"; BLB?;H> G?;"A?>O B;ME;F"FEKBA A=K?L?";H9 >D=A=PO R?"KB>?;L >D= 1?AH>

,G=;MG=;>cH N"GGB;M >DB> L"R=A;G=;> QGEH> P=;=E>ABK ?; GB>>=AH "@ A=K?L?"EH >D="AO9 M"N>A?;=9 B;MFABN>?N=W B;M QGBO ;"> B?M9 @"H>=A9 "A FA"G">= ";=

A=K?L?"; "A A=K?L?"EH >D="AO BLB?;H> B;">D=A#W1,,"'(%& R# Q'`5&(5( 9 ^[^ 0#3# [\9 ]f^k]fX _][Zi`tH==Z%B2"' R# +4%-" Y(25&- 9 ^Xj 0#3# Z\9 \f _D"KM?;L>DB> H>B>= N"EKM ;"> HBO >DB> QH=AR?N=HW V=A= A=K?L?"EHB;M QH=AG";HW V=A= ;"> V?>D"E> QFA=@=AA?;L ";=A=K?L?"; "R=A B;">D=AW B;M F=;BK?U?;L B; QE;F"FEKBALA"EF @"A F=A@"AG?;L >D= HBG= @E;N>?";W BH M"GB?;H>A=BG A=K?L?";H`# Q7EM?N?BK B>>=GF>H >" @BHD?";J J J N?R?K M=@?;?>?";SH "@ A=K?L?"EH >=AGHT A?HdM?HBMRB;>BL?;L >D"H= A=K?L?"EH LA"EFH VD"H= P=K?=@H9FABN>?N=H9 B;M G=GP=AHD?F BA= "E>H?M= "@ >D=vGB?;H>A=BGc "A E;FBKB>BPK= >" H"G=#W]%(5&&5I_5V%' 9 ]^Y 3# -># B> \]] _&D"GBH9 7#9 N";NEAA?;L`#


35/133

YY

1?;BKKO9 BH >D?H -"EA> DBH D=KM9 QS?T> ?H ;"> ";KO >D=N";NKEH?";H >DB> GBO P= A=BND=M J J J VD?ND GBO?GF?;L= "; A?LD>H LEBAB;>==M PO >D= )=K?L?";-KBEH=H9 PE> BKH" >D= R=AO FA"N=HH "@ ?;bE?AO K=BM?;L>" @?;M?;LH B;M N";NKEH?";H#WAD+[ R# P5#4%2$7

[$(4%, 9 XXf 0#3# X[f9 jfY _][\[`# /;M==M9 >D= FA"N=HH"@ ?;bE?AO NB; ?;aEA= A=K?L?"EH BE>";"GO BH GEND BH>D= N";NKEH?";H A=BND=M# ,H 7EH>?N=H ,K?>" B;M wBLB;A=N"L;?U=M ?; ]%(5&&5I_5V%' ?; A=a=N>?;L >D=L"R=A;G=;>cH HELL=H>=M FA=>=e> ?;bE?AO9

VDB>=R=A >D= >AE>D "@ >D= GB>>=A G?LD> P=9 >D=G=A= BMaEM?NB>?"; "@ HEND bE=H>?";H V"EKM F"H=LABR= FA"PK=GH @"A A=K?L?"EH BE>";"GOn /> V"EKMA=bE?A= NBKK?;L V?>;=HH=H >" >=H>?@O BP"E> >D=?GF"A>B;N= B;M FA?"A?>O "@ >D= A=K?L?"EH M"N>A?;=?; bE=H>?";9 V?>D B N?R?K @BN>@?;M=A H?>>?;L ?;EK>?GB>= aEMLG=;> "@ VDB> >D= BNNEH=M NDEANDA=BKKO P=K?=R=H9 B;M D"V ?GF"A>B;> >DB> P=K?=@ ?H >">D= NDEANDxH "R=ABKK G?HH?";#

]^Y 3# -># B> \]j _,K?>"9 7#9 N";NEAA?;L`#

4=NBEH= >D= FA=H=;> NBH= @?>H HbEBA=KO V?>D?; >D=1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>cH K";LkH>B;M?;L N"GGB;M >DB>N"EA>H M=@=A >" B NDEANDcH R?=V "@ VDB> ?>H @B?>D G=B;HB;M A=bE?A=H 5&- ?GFK?NB>=H BKK >D= ?GF"A>B;>N";H>?>E>?";BK FEAF"H=H >DB> AEK= H=AR=H9 >D= D"KM?;L"@ >D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA> GEH> P= A=R=AH=M#1?AH>9 ?> ?H NK=BA >DB> ?; M=>=AG?;?;L VD=>D=AH>B>=G=;>H GBM= ?; N";@=HH?"; BA= QN";@=HH?";SBKT ,"'(" W >D= @BN>k@?;M=A GEH> M=N?M= VDB> H>B>=G=;>H?;D=A= ?;>A?;H?NBKKO "A ?;H>AEG=;>BKKO ?; >D= -B>D"K?NHBNABG=;> B;M VD?ND M" ;">uB bE?;>=HH=;>?BKKOA=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";uB;M ?> NB; "R=AA?M= >D= -DEANDcH"V; R?=VH BH =eFA=HH=M PO 1B>D=A 4BOD?9 >D= FA?=H>


36/133

Y^

VD" >""d >D= N";@=HH?";9 B;M 1B>D=A -"E;N=9 >D=7EM?N?BK 6?NBA B;M NB;"; KBVO=A @"A >D= M?"N=H=9 H==2=@H# +"># 3EG# 7# (e# , _,@@# *@ 1B>D=A = A=bE?A=G=;> ?;-B>D"K?N KBV >DB> B FA?=H> ;=R=A A=R=BK B;O>D?;L D=D=BAH MEA?;L B F=AH";cH N";@=HH?";W B;M ;">?;L >DB>QS?T; FABN>?N=9 ?> ?H ;"> aEH> >D= H?;H N";@=HH=M >DB> BA=>D= GB>>=A "@ >D= H=BKS PE> BKH" >DB>T >D= FA?=H> ?H ;">F=AG?>>=M >" A=R=BK B;O>D?;L M?HNEHH=M ?; >D=N";@=HH?";W`# &D=?A H>B>=G=;>H BA= BE>D"A?>B>?R= BH >"

VDB> -B>D"K?N @B?>D D"KMH B;M N=A>B?;KO A=@K=N> G"A=>DB; >D= QD";=H> N";R?N>?";9W]%VV/ D%VV/ :#%'"( 9 ]^X3# -># B> Y\\[ _bE">?;L _4%\5( 9 Xjf 0#3# B> \]Z`BP"E> VDB> -B>D"K?N @B?>D =;>B?KH >DB> >D= 1?AH>

,G=;MG=;> A=bE?A=H N"EA>H >" A=HF=N>#

3=N";M9 >D= @BN>k@?;M=A9 FBA>?NEKBAKO B KBO aEAO9V"EKM DBR= K?>>K= N"GF=>=;N= >" B;HV=A >D=H=bE=H>?";H# &D=O V"EKM DBR= >" PBH= >D=?A aEMLG=;>H"; >D= R?=VH "@ VDB> =eF=A>H >=H>?@O -B>D"K?N KBVN"GGB;MH B;M =RBKEB>= ?;M?R?MEBK N";@=HH?";BK

H>B>=G=;>H BNN"AM?;LKO# &D?H ?H =eBN>KO >D= QA=K?L?"EH>D?Nd=>9WO$2$*%X"*$749 XYZ 0#3# B> \][9 B;M Q@"AP?MM=;M"GB?;9WK&$#"- :#5#"( R# [5225'- 9 ^YY 0#3# \i9 i\_][XX`9 ?;>" VD?ND >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> M=;?=H >D=H>B>= =;>AO#

&D?AM9 HEND ?;bE?AO V"EKM NA=B>= Q=eN=HH?R==;>B;LK=G=;>W P=>V==; NDEAND B;M H>B>=# /> V"EKMBKK"V >D= H>B>= >" A=R?=V B;M H=> BH?M=M=>=AG?;B>?";H B> >D= D=BA> "@ @B?>DuVDB> B HBNA=MHBNABG=;> G=B;H B;M A=bE?A=HuB;M ?> V"EKM FKBN=

>D= H>B>= ?; >D= N";@=HH?";BK# 4O F?R">?;L N?R?KK?BP?K?>O "; >D= @BN>k@?;M=AcH M=>=AG?;B>?"; "@ VDB> ?HQN";@=HH?";SBKT ,"' (" 9W P">D >D= N";@=HH"A B;M >D=


37/133

YX

F=;?>=;> V?KK E;M=AH>B;M >DB> >D= H>B>= ?H F">=;>?BKKOB FBA>?N?FB;> B;M "PH=AR=A ?; >D= 3BNABG=;> "@)=N";N?K?B>?"; ?>H=K@#

1"EA>D9 aEM?N?BK H=N";MkLE=HH?;L "@ VDB> ?H >AEKON";@=HH?";BK GBO =;N"EABL= NDEAND=H >" >A?G >D=?AP=K?=@H B;M FABN>?N=H N";N=A;?;L N";@=HH?"; >" >D=H>B>=cH aEMLG=;>H ?; "AM=A >" BR"?M F">=;>?BK K?BP?K?>O#/@ >D= H>B>= F=;BK?U=H H"G= BHF=N>H "@ N";@=HH?";9=N";"G?N FA=HHEA= V?KK LA"V @"A >D= NDEAND >" G"M?@O?>H E;M=AH>B;M?;L "@ VDB> >D= HBNABG=;> G=B;H B;MA=bE?A=H#

1?@>D9 ?GF"H?;L N"EA>Hc R?=VH BH >" VDB> ?H >AEKON";@=HH?";BK "; NDEAND=H V?KK M?HNA?G?;B>= BLB?;H>>D"H= @B?>DH VD"H= N";@=HH?";BK FABN>?N=H NE> BLB?;H>GB?;H>A=BG NEH>"G B;M "F?;?";# &D"H= NDEAND=HcN";@=HH?";BK FABN>?N=H BA= G"A= K?d=KO >" P= H==; BH"MM9 BANDB?N9 "A MB;L=A"EH# /; @BN>9 -B>D"K?NN";@=HH?"; VBH K";L R?=V=M V?>D M==F HEHF?N?"; POH"G= ">D=A H=N>H B;M BH F"K?>?NBKKO HEPR=AH?R= POH"G= L"R=A;G=;>H# 3== ] C?KK?BG '"LB;9 ,EA?NEKBA-";@=HH?"; B;M H >=BND B;M @BH>=; EF"; >D= G?;M "@>D=?A F=;?>=;>H BKK >D= ?;?bE?>?=H VD?ND >D= -DEAND "@)"G= HB;N>?";HW`t $- # B> ]j _BALE?;L >DB> Q=R=AO NA?G=VD?ND >D= )"G?HD NDEAND HB;N>?";H9 B;M BKG"H> BKK>D= ?GG"ABK?>?=H "@ ?>H G=GP=AH9 =?>D=A "A?L?;B>= ?;

,EA?NEKBA -";@=HH?"; "A DBR= H"G= N";;=N>?"; V?>D?>W`t$- # B> ]if _VBA;?;L ,G=A?NB;H >DB> QO"EA K?P=A>O?H >DA=B>=;=M PO )"G?HD FA?=H>H ?;NEKNB>?;L >A=BH";

?; >D=?A N";@=HH?";BKH EF >" O"EA R=AO P=BAMHW`#1?;BKKO9 >D= FA"N=HH "@ ?;bE?AO >D= ."E?H?B;B

3EFA=G= -"EA> DBH "AM=A=M R?"KB>=H B N"A= >=;=> "@


38/133

Yj

-B>D"K?N?HGu";= VD?ND FA?=H>H DBR= M?=M >" FA">=N>9H== FF# \ki9 (6,'5 # /; "AM=A >" M=>=AG?;= VD?NDN"GGE;?NB>?";H GBM= MEA?;L N";@=HH?"; V=A=QN";@=HH?";SBKT ,"' (" W B;M VD?ND V=A= ;">9 >D= @BN>k@?;M=A GEH> d;"V VDB> >D"H= N"GGE;?NB>?";H V=A=B;M VDB> >D=O N";N=A;=M# ,FF#9$&L'59 Z\B _;">?;L>DB> ?; "AM=A Q>" d;"V VD=>D=A "A ;"> S1B>D=A 4BOD?TDBH B ME>O J J J S>D= N"EA> GEH>T d;"V VDB> D=K=BA;=M ?; >D= N";@=HH?";9 B;M D?H ?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@VDB> D= K=BA;=MW`# /; ">D=A V"AMH9 >D= N"EA> GEH>

PA=Bd >D= HBNA=M H=BK "@ >D= N";@=HH?"; PO M=GB;M?;L1B>D=A 4BOD? >=H>?@O BP"E> VDB> VBH HB?M9 B H?; H"H=A?"EH >DB> D= V"EKM P= BE>"GB>?NBKKO=eN"GGE;?NB>=M# &D= G=A= FA"N=HH "@ GBd?;L >D=M=>=AG?;B>?"; >DEH ;"> ";KO F">=;>?BKKO "R=AA?M=HNDEAND aEMLG=;> "@ VDB> ?H N";@=HH?";BK B;MFA">=N>=M PE> ;=N=HHBA?KO M=H>A"OH >D= HB;N>?>O "@ >D=HBNABG=;>u=R=; ?@ >D= @BN>k@?;M=A EK>?GB>=KO BLA==HV?>D >D= -DEANDcH aEMLG=;> >DB> BKK >D=N"GGE;?NB>?";H BA= FA">=N>=M BH QN";@=HH?";BK ,"' (" WB;M NB;;"> L?R= A?H= >" B;O GB;MB>"AO A=F"A>?;L"PK?LB>?";#

//# /; )=a=N>?;L &D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>cH )=K?L?"EHhE=H>?"; 2"N>A?;=9 &D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA>-A=B>=M , -";@K?N> C?>D ,KK 1=M=ABK -"EA>H "@

,FF=BKH ,;M ,KK *>D=A 3>B>= 3EFA=G= -"EA>H&DB> 'BR= -";H?M=A=M /> ,;M , 2?A=N> -";@K?N> /;/>H ,FFK?NB>?"; C?>D &D= 3=N";M ,;M 1"EA>D-?ANE?>H ,;M &D= !=V 7=AH=O ,;M +BHHBNDEH=>>H3EFA=G= -"EA>H

4=NBEH= "@ >D?H -"EA>cH K";LH>B;M?;L B;MN";H?H>=;> BFFK?NB>?"; "@ >D= A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";M"N>A?;=9 ;" @=M=ABK N"EA> "@ BFF=BKH "A H>B>= HEFA=G=


39/133

YZ

N"EA> ">D=A >DB; ."E?H?B;BcH A=a=N>H ?># ,K>D"ELDF=>?>?";=AH d;"V "@ ;" ">D=A aEA?HM?N>?";H >DB> DBR=BM"F>=M >D= FBA>?NEKBA H>B;MBAM B> ?HHE= D=A=u QN";@=HH?";ST ,"' (" WuB;M =GF"V=A=M aEA?=H >"M=>=AG?;= >D= A=K?L?"EH NDBABN>=A "@ N";@=HH?";BKH>B>=G=;>H9 >D=H= ">D=A N"EA>H DBR= N";H?H>=;>KOBFFK?=M >D= M"N>A?;= ?; B V?M= RBA?=>O "@ N";>=e>H >"FA">=N> A=K?L?"EH P=K?=@ B;M FABN>?N= @A"G M=H>AEN>?R=H>B>= ?;bE?AO ?;>" >D=?A G=B;?;L B;M A=bE?A=G=;>H#

/; ]%(5&&5I_5V%' 9 ?; @BN>9 >D?H -"EA> ;">=M >DB>BK>D"ELD ?> DBM ;=R=A N";H?M=A=M >D= bE=H>?"; "@VD=>D=A >D= M"N>A?;= Q?H ?GFK?NB>=M PO B HE?> BKK=L?;LM?HNA?G?;B>?"; ?; =GFK"OG=;>9 J J J >D= -"EA>H "@

,FF=BKH DBR= E;?@"AGKO A=N"L;?U=M >D= =e?H>=;N= "@ BvG?;?H>=A?BK =eN=F>?";c LA"E;M=M ?; >D= 1?AH>

,G=;MG=;>9 >DB> FA=NKEM=H BFFK?NB>?"; "@ HENDK=L?HKB>?"; >" NKB?GH N";N=A;?;L >D= =GFK"OG=;>A=KB>?";HD?F P=>V==; B A=K?L?"EH ?;H>?>E>?"; B;M ?>HG?;?H>=AH#W ]^Y 3# -># B> \fj# /;M==M9 >D= K"V=AN"EA>H A=N"L;?U= >DB> >D= FA?;N?FK= "@ >D= G?;?H>=A?BK

=eN=F>?"; BFFK?=H PA"BMKO >" FA=NKEM= GB;O >OF=H "@=GFK"OG=;> HE?>H9 H==9 =#L#9 Q275;5' R# P%',T %L #4"P5#4%2$7 Q'74V$(4%, 9 ZY\ 1#^M ]Yii _[>D -?A# Yf]f`_=; PB;N` _M?HG?HH?;L NKB?G @"A VBL=H E;M=A H>B>=G?;?GEG VBL= KBV`t 12IZ5''5 R#:5//"- 9 YYZ 3#C#^M\[Y _,Ad# YffZ` _M?HG?HH?;L NKB?G @"A PA=BND "@ ?GB;cH=GFK"OG=;> N";>ABN>`t M5& C(-%2 R# M%3#9 [fi =;>?";BK B;M;=LK?L=;> >"A> NKB?GH BA?H?;L "E> "@ NDEANDcHA=R"NB>?"; "@ G?;?H>=AcH K?N=;H=`9 ?;NKEM?;L HE?>HPA"ELD> PO ;";kG?;?H>=A =GFK"O==H BLB?;H> ;";kA=K?L?"EH =GFK"O=AH9 H== !$"2"74 R# O5((%(%$#^'"/4%6&-0 Y&7T 9 ZZi !#(#YM ]Y[i _+BHH# ][[Z`


40/133

Y\

_M?HG?HH?;L HE?> BLB?;H> =GFK"O=A @"A A=K?L?"EH V"AdBNN"GG"MB>?";H A=bE?A=M E;M=A H>B>= KBV`#

3?G?KBAKO9 QN"EA>H >DA"ELD"E> >D= 0;?>=M 3>B>=HDBR= E;?@"AGKO A=a=N>=M NKB?GH @"A NK=ALO GBKFABN>?N=E;M=A >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>#W Z'5&7% R# P46'74 %Lc"(6( P4'$(# %L D5##"'I95/ :5$( 9 Y] BD Yff]`t H==9 =#L#9 ZT^T R# O579%&"229 Z[Z ,#YMZ[\ _!#7# ][[\` _M?HG?HH?;L NK=ALO GBKFABN>?N= NKB?G`tA522/ R# ^'57" P%\\T P46'74 9 \Z^ H DBR= L=;=ABKKOD=KM >DB> B M=>=AG?;B>?"; "@ HEND NKB?GH V"EKM;=N=HHBA?KO =;>B;LK= >D= N"EA>H ?; >D= =eBG?;B>?"; "@A=K?L?"EH M"N>A?;=9 FABN>?N=9 "A NDEAND F"K?>OuB;?;bE?AO >DB> J J J ?H FA"D?P?>=M PO >D= S1?AH>

,G=;MG=;>T#W Z'5&7%9 Y] YfX# &D=O DBR=9 ?;@BN>9 BKH" M?HG?HH=M B GEND V?M=A NKBHH "@ NKB?GH9?;NKEM?;L ";=H Q@"A LA"HH ;=LK?L=;N=9 ;=LK?L=;>?;@K?N>?"; "@ =G">?";BK M?H>A=HH9 B;M PA=BND "@@?MEN?BAO ME>OW VD=; >D=O QBA= G=A=KO B; =KK?F>?NBK

VBO "@ BKK=L?;L NK=ALO GBKFABN>?N=#W (#L#9$- # B> Yfj#-"EA>H DBR= K?d=V?H= M?HG?HH=M NKB?GH BLB?;H>

NDEAND=H B;M >D=?A G=GP=AH @"A M=@BGB>?";# (#L#9 ['/7" R# 1,$(7%,52 P46'74 9 Yi[ 1#^M ZXi9 Zj[ _]f>D-?A# YffY`t ]6#74$(%& R# _4%\5( 9 \i[ 1#YM ^[Y _Z>D-?A# ][iZ`# &D=O A=N"L;?U= >DB> HEND NKB?GH ?GFK?NB>=Q?;>=A;BK =NNK=H?BH>?NBK M?HFE>=SHT B;M M?BK"LE=FA">=N>=M PO >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>ScH A=K?L?"EHbE=H>?"; M"N>A?;=#TW ['/7" 9 Yi[ 1#^M B> Zj[#

&D=O BKH" A"E>?;=KO M?HG?HH NKB?GH @"A ?;>=;>?";BK?;@K?N>?"; "@ =G">?";BK M?H>A=HH B;M ">D=A >"A>H >DB>NDBKK=;L= NDEAND M=N?H?";H >" M?HN?FK?;= ?>H G=GP=AH9H==9 =#L#9 !562 R# a5#74#%B"' [$V2" 8 _'57# :%7T %L


41/133

Yi

A"B d%'`0 Y&7T9 i][ 1#YM i\j _[>D -?A# ][i\`_M?HG?HH?;L AB;L= "@ >"A> NKB?GH PBH=M "; NDEANDcHHDE;;?;L "@ @"AG=A G=GP=A`t a"(#V'%%` R# !"&2"/ 9Y^] 3#C#^M ^i[ _&=e# Yff\` _M?HG?HH?;L NKB?G BLB?;H>NDEAND B;M FBH>"A @"A PA=BND?;L N"E;H=K?;LN";@?M=;N= ?; A=K?L?"EH FA"N==M?;L`t ["5' R# +"L%'\"-O"&&%&$#" P46'74 9 ^X] ,#YM ]fj _DB> NDEAND ?;H>AEN>?"; >" G=GP=AH>" HDE; @"AG=A G=GP=A NBEH=M D?H PEH?;=HH >" @B?K

B;M D?H @BG?KO >" H>"F HF=Bd?;L >" D?G9 =#L#9$V$-# /;BKK >D=H= NBH=H9 >D= N"EA>H M?HG?HH=M >D= NKB?GHP=NBEH= >D=O V"EKM A=bE?A= M=>=AG?;?;L GB>>=AH "@@B?>D#

-"EA>H =R=; M?HG?HH NKB?GH @"A Q@BKH=?GFA?H";G=;>9 BHHBEK>9 PB>>=AO9 K"HH "@ N";H"A>?EG9B;M ND?KM BPEH=W VD=; >D=O NB;;"> M=>=AG?;=MBGBL=H V?>D"E> ?;bE?A?;L ?;>" A=K?L?"EH P=K?=@# /;

!2"5(5 ^25-" Q(("\V2/ %L ^%- R# :746V"'# 9 YZX3#C#^M ] _&=e# Yffi`9 @"A =eBGFK=9 >D= &=eBH

3EFA=G= -"EA> M?HG?HH=M NKB?GH @"A >D=H= >"A>H >DB>BA"H= @A"G B @"AN=@EK KBO?;L "; "@ DB;MH B@>=A BH?LD>?;L "@ M=G";H# &D= N"EA> A=N"L;?U=M >DB> ?>N"EKM ;"> =RBKEB>= B;O MBGBL=H9 B ;=N=HHBAO =K=G=;>"@ >D=H= >"A>H9 V?>D"E> M=>=AG?;?;L B;M =RBKEB>?;LNDEAND P=K?=@# Q4=NBEH= >D= A=K?L?"EH FABN>?N= "@vKBO?;L DB;MHc B;M NDEAND P=K?=@H BP"E> M=G";H BA= H"NK"H=KO ?;>=A>V?;=M V?>D S>D=T >"A> NKB?GSHT9W ?> ;">=M9QBHH=HH?;L J J J MBGBL=H J J J V"EKM E;N";H>?k>E>?";BKKO PEAM=; >D= NDEANDcH A?LD> >" @A== =e=AN?H=B;M =GPA"?K >D?H -"EA> ?; B; BHH=HHG=;> "@ >D=FA"FA?=>O "@ >D"H= A=K?L?"EH P=K?=@H#WY- # B> ]]#


42/133

Y[

&D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA>cH D"KM?;L N";@K?N>HG"H> M?A=N>KO V?>D NBH=H M?HG?HH?;L NKB?GH P=NBEH=>D= KBV EF"; VD?ND >D=O BA= PBH=M >EA;H "; BA=K?L?"EH >=AG# /; !$"2"74 R# O5((%(%$# ^'"/4%6&-0Y&7T9 ZZi !#(#YM ]Y[i9 @"A =eBGFK=9 >D=+BHHBNDEH=>>H 3EFA=G= 7EM?N?BK -"EA> M?HG?HH=M BKBVHE?> PA"ELD> PO =GFK"O==H "@ B M"L ABN?;L >ABNdBLB?;H> >D=?A =GFK"O=A NKB?G?;L >DB> >D=O V=A==;>?>K=M >" -DA?H>GBH 2BO "@@ E;M=A H>B>= KBV# &D=N"EA> D=KM >D= H>B>E>= E;N";H>?>E>?";BK P=NBEH= ?>

A=bE?A=M >D= N"EA>H Q>" M=>=AG?;= VDB> BN>?";H B;MP=K?=@H BA= A=bE?A=M "@ BMD=A=;>H >" >D= )"GB;-B>D"K?N @B?>D#WY-T B> ]^fX# )=KO?;L "; >D?H -"EA>cHA=K?L?"EH bE=H>?"; NBH=H9 H==$- # B> ]^f^9 >D=+BHHBNDEH=>>H N"EA> D=KM9 QS>TD=H= BA= ;"> FA"F=AGB>>=AH @"A >D= N"EA>H >" M=N?M=9W$- # B> ]^fX#

&V" @=M=ABK N"EA>H "@ BFF=BKH B;M >D= !=V 7=AH=O3EFA=G= -"EA> DBR= K?d=V?H= D=KM E;N";H>?>E>?";BKKBVH BMMA=HH?;L >D= @ABEMEK=;> HBK= "@ @""M KBP=K=Md"HD=A# ,KK >DA== N"EA>H DBR= D=KM >DB> ?;R"KR?;L

N"EA>H ?; >D= PEH?;=HH "@ M=>=AG?;?;L VD=>D=A B;?>=G ?H >AEKO d"HD=A9 BH >D= KBVH A=bE?A=M9 R?"KB>=H>D= A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?"; M"N>A?;=# 3==P%\\57` :"2LI:"'*$7" .%(4"' O"5#(0 Y&7T R#a"$(( 9 Y[X 1#YM X]j9 XY\_YM -?A# YffY`t [5'34%6# R# [6'"56 %L .%(4"' O"5# 8Z%%- P%'%29 ZZ 1#^M ]^^\9 ]^XX _X>D -?A# ][[j`t+5&I95*b( P#/T .%(4"'0 Y&7T R# :#5#" 9 Zfi ,#YM ]^j^9]^ZYk]^ZX _!#7# ][[Y`# ,H >D= 3=N";M -?ANE?>=eFKB?;=M9

/; "AM=A >" BHH=A> >DB> B @""M BA>?NK= M"=H ;">

N";@"AG >" d"HD=A A=bE?A=G=;>H9 !=V 8"Ad GEH>>Bd= B; "@@?N?BK F"H?>?"; BH >" VDB> BA= >D= d"HD=AA=bE?A=G=;>H# /; M"?;L H"9 >D= 2=FBA>G=;> GEH>


43/133

^f

=?>D=A ?;>=AFA=> A=K?L?"EH M"N>A?;= "A M=@=A >" >D=?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@ A=K?L?"EH "@@?N?BKH ?; A=BND?;L ?>H"@@?N?BK F"H?>?";# J J J 3>B>= BE>D"A?>?=H SNB;T;">GBd= B M=>=AG?;B>?"; >DB> J J J G=B> MS"=HT ;">N";@"AG >" d"HD=A A=bE?A=G=;>H V?>D"E> @?AH>SBAA?R?;LT B> B; "@@?N?BK F"H?>?"; "; VDB> >D=d"HD=A A=bE?A=G=;>H BA=#

P%\\57` 9 Y[X 1#^M B> XY\kXYi _bE">?;L !'"(V/#"'$5&P46'74 9 ^[^ 0#3# B> XjY _'BAKB;9 7#9 N";NEAA?;L``tBNN"AM [5'34%6# 9 ZZ 1#^M B> ]^XX _Q-?>O "@@?N?BKH "AGE;?N?FBK N"EA>H V"EKM DBR= >" M=>=AG?;= >D=*A>D"M"e H>B;MBAMH "@ dBHDAE> J J J# &D?H ?H NK=BAKO;"> F=AG?>>=M PO "EA (H>BPK?HDG=;> -KBEH=

aEA?HFAEM=;N=#W`t+5&I95*b( 9 Zfi ,#YM B> ]^Z^k]^ZX_QS-"EA>HT GBO ;"> A=H"KR= J J J N";>A"R=AH?=H ?@A=H"KE>?"; A=bE?A=H >D= ?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@ A=K?L?"EHM"N>A?;= J J J B;M B;O BMaEM?NB>?"; PO B N"EA> S"@VD=>D=A FBA>?NEKBA @""M VBH FA"F=AKO d"HD=AT?;=R?>BPKO V"EKM =;>B?K >D= BFFK?NB>?"; B;M?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@ 7=V?HD KBV#W`#

&D= ."E?H?B;BcH 3EFA=G= -"EA>cH D"KM?;L F?R">?;LN?R?K K?BP?K?>O "; VD=>D=A H>B>=G=;>H N";H>?>E>=QN";@=HH?";ST ,"' (" W =;G=HD=H >D= N"EA>H ?; =eBN>KO>D?H d?;M "@ ?;bE?AO# &" >=KK VD=>D=A H>B>=G=;>H BA=QN";@=HH?"; ,"' (" 9W B N"EA> QGEH> =?>D=A ?;>=AFA=>A=K?L?"EH M"N>A?;= "A M=@=A >" >D= ?;>=AFA=>B>?"; "@A=K?L?"EH "@@?N?BKH ?; A=BND?;L ?>H "@@?N?BK F"H?>?";#WP%\\57` 9 Y[X 1#^M B> XY\kXYi _bE">?;L !'"(V/#"'$5&P46'74 9 ^[^ 0#3# B> XjY _'BAKB;9 7#9 N";NEAA?;L``#C?>D?; >D= 3=N";M B;M 1"EA>D -?ANE?>H9 HEND K?BP?K?>O

?H E;N";H>?>E>?";BK# &D= 3>B>= H?GFKO NB;;"> >EA;K?BP?K?>O "; >D= G=B;?;L "@ B A=K?L?"EH >=AG# /;."E?H?B;B9 PO N";>ABH>9 HEND K?BP?K?>O ?H N";H>?>E>?";BK#


44/133

^]

&D= 3>B>=75& B>>BND >"A> K?BP?K?>O >" >D= G=B;?;L "@HEND >=AGH# &D= F"HH?P?K?>O "@ K?BP?K?>O ?; >D?H NBH=9>D=;9 M=F=;MH EF"; >D= DBFF=;H>B;N= "@ L="LABFDO#

&D= N";H>?>E>?";BK?>O "@ HEND KBVH ?; ."E?H?B;B?>H=K@9 G"A="R=A9 GBO V=KK M=F=;M "; >D=DBFF=;H>B;N= "@ VD?ND N"EA> HOH>=GuH>B>= "A@=M=ABKuB;O NDBKK=;L= "NNEAH ?;# 3?;N= >D= 1?@>D-?ANE?> >Bd=H B A"PEH> R?=V "@ >D= A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?";M"N>A?;=9 H==9 =#L#9P%\V( R# P"T _"WT Q&&T P%&LT CL_4" K&$#"- O"#4%-$(# P46'74 9 ]\^ 1#^M ^X^ _j>D -?A#][[[` _A=a=N>?;L =GFK"OG=;> NKB?G PA"ELD> PO NK=ALOG=GP=A BLB?;H> NDEAND`tP46'74 CL ^%- Y& P4'$(#0Y&7T R# P5B#4%&9 jf\ 1#YM j[[ _j>D -?A# ][\j`_BFFKO?;L A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?"; M"N>A?;= >" H=>>K= NDEANDFA"F=A>O M?HFE>=`9 FA=M?NB>?;L K?BP?K?>O "; >D=G=B;?;L "@ B A=K?L?"EH >=AG V"EKM K?d=KO FA"R"d=>D=A= LABR= M"EP>H BP"E> >D= KBVcH N";H>?>E>?";BK?>O#

///# &D?H *@>=;k)=NEAA?;L /HHE= /H *;= *@ -=;>ABK/GF"A>B;N= &" -DEAND=H ,;M &D=?A +=GP=AH

&D= ?HHE= >D?H NBH= FA=H=;>HuP">D ?; ?>H;BAA"V=H> B;M PA"BM=H> @"AGHu?GFK?NB>=H >D=A=K?L?"EH @A==M"G "@ G?KK?";H "@ ,G=A?NB;H# +"H>;BAA"VKO9 >D= A"ELDKO X9jff9fff )"GB; -B>D"K?NHVD" K?R= ?; ."E?H?B;B9 H== -B>D"K?N '?=ABANDO9K:Qe:#5#$(#$7( [/ !'%*$&7" _>FnooVVV#NB>D"K?NkD?=ABANDO#"ALoN"E;>AOoHFNEH^#D>GK9 ;"V E;M=AH>B;M >DB> >D=O NB;;"> H==d >D=3BNABG=;> "@ )=N";N?K?B>?"; V?>D"E> >D= 3>B>=F"HH?PKO PA=Bd?;L >D= H=BK "@ >D= N";@=HH?"; B;M?;bE?A?;L ?;>" VDB> VBH HB?M# &DB> V?KK ;"> ";KOM?HN"EABL= H"G= @A"G H==d?;L >D= 3BNABG=;>9V?>D"E> VD?ND >D=O P=K?=R= >D=O NB;;"> BND?=R==>=A;BK HBKRB>?"; ?@ >D=O DBR= H=A?"EHKO H?;;=M9 PE>


45/133

^Y

BKH" NA?FFK= >D= -DEANDcH G?HH?"; "@ HBR?;L H"EKH# &D=D"KM?;L BKH" >DA=B>=;H ">D=A A=K?L?";Hc N"E;H=KK?;LFA"LABGH ?; >D= 3>B>=# , G?;?H>=A VD"9 BH FBA> "@ >D=NDEANDcH "@@?N?BK G?HH?";9 N"E;H=KH NDEAND G=GP=AH >"BFFA"BND >D=?A FA"PK=GH ?; >D= VBO >D=?A @B?>DM=GB;MH GBO ;"V @=BA >DB> >D= 3>B>= V?KK M=H>A"O >D=N";@?M=;>?BK?>O "@ >D"H= M?HNEHH?";H B;M F"HH?PKO?GF"H= K?BP?K?>O ?@ ?> M?HBLA==H V?>D >D= BMR?N= D=LBR=#

+"A= PA"BMKO9 >D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA>cHD"KM?;L >DA=B>=;H ">D=A A=K?L?"EH FABN>?N=H B;MP=K?=@H# /@ >D= 3>B>= NB; >EA; K?BP?K?>O "; >D= N";N=F>"@ QN";@=HH?"; ,"' (" 9W VDO ;"> "; Qd==F?;L d"HD=A ,"'(" 9W QPBF>?HG ,"' (" 9W QFA=BND?;L ,"' (" 9W "A QA=K?L?"EH=MENB>?"; ,"' (" Wp &D= 3>B>= N"EKM ?GF"H= K?BP?K?>OPBH=M "; ?>H "V; ?M=BH9 ;"> >D= NDEANDcH9 BP"E>VD=>D=A >D= NDEAND VBH @"KK"V?;L B; BNN=F>BPK= R?=V"@ ?>H "V; A=K?L?"EH @B?>D B;M FABN>?N=H# &"A>H K?d=QNK=ALO GBKFABN>?N=9W Q?;>=;>?";BK ?;@K?N>?"; "@=G">?";BK M?H>A=HH9W Q;=LK?L=;N=9W B;M QM=@BGB>?";W

N"EKM P= EH=M >" ?GF"H= K?BP?K?>O @"A >D= =e=AN?H= "@@B?>D# 3== FF# YZk^]9(6,'5T &DB>9 BH N"EA>H=KH=VD=A= E;?@"AGKO A=N"L;?U=9 FKBN=H B; ?;>"K=ABPK=PEAM=; "; A=K?L?"EH P=K?=@# 3==$V$-#

+"A= PA"BMKO H>?KK9 >D= D"KM?;L P=K"V FKBN=HFA=HHEA= "; A=K?L?"EH @A==M"G ;B>?";V?M=# CD=;NDEAND=H =KH=VD=A= E;M=AH>B;M >DB> K";LkE;M=AH>""M@A==M"GH BA= ;"V K=HH H=NEA=9 >D=O GBO P= >=GF>=M >"BR"?M F">=;>?BK K?BP?K?>O PO >A?GG?;L >D=?A "V; P=K?=@HB;M FABN>?N=H >" GBa"A?>BA?B; R?=VH "@ BFFA"FA?B>=

A=K?L?"EH P=DBR?"A#


46/133

^^

/6# &D?H -BH= /H ,; /M=BK 6=D?NK= 1"A ,MMA=HH?;LCD=>D=A 3>B>=H -B; 3=N";Mk5E=HH )=K?L?";Hc*V; 6?=VH ,H &" CDB> &D=?A 1B?>D +=B;H ,;M)=bE?A=H

&D?H NBH= N";N=A;H VD=>D=A >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>cH A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?"; M"N>A?;= A=bE?A=H BN"EA> >" BNN=F> B A=K?L?";cH R?=V "@ VDB> ";= "@ ?>HN=;>ABK FABN>?N=H =;>B?KH# ?>?";=AH AB?H=M >D?H ?HHE=P=K"V P=@"A= >D= M?H>A?N> N"EA>9 &A# "; 'AcL "; +"># ?;.?G?;= ]] _BALE?;L >DB> ?@ >D= H>B>E>= QNA=B>=H B;"PK?LB>?"; "; >D= FA?=H> >" M?REKL= VDB> DBFF=;HMEA?;L N";@=HH?";9 "A MEA?;L B; BKK=L=M N";@=HH?";9J J J ?> ?H ?; LABR= R?"KB>?"; "@ >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>W`9B;M P=@"A= >D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA> ?GG=M?B>=KOB@>=A ?> BM"F>=M >D= QN";@=HH?";ST ,"' (" W H>B;MBAM9 BH>B;MBAM BMRB;N=M PO ;=?>D=A FBA>O B> B;O FA?"AF"?;> ?; >D= K?>?LB>?";# /; >D=?A A=bE=H> @"A A=D=BA?;LPO >DB> N"EA>9 F=>?>?";=AH BALE=M >DB> >D= H>B;MBAMR?"KB>=M >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> B;M >DEH A=bE?A=MM?HG?HHBK "@ >D= NBH=# ,FFK# @"A )=DcL 3EPG?>>=M PO

2=@H# j# &D= ."E?H?B;B 3EFA=G= -"EA> ;=N=HHBA?KOA=a=N>=M >DB> R?=V ?; M=;O?;L A=D=BA?;LuBK>D"ELD7EH>?N=cH 5E?MAOcH N";NEAA=;N= ?; >D= M=;?BK B;M7EH>?N= 6?N>"AOcH M?HH=;> @A"G ?> P">D ?;M?NB>= QPEO=AcHA=G"AH=W @"A >D= N";N=F> "@ QN";@=HH?";ST ,"' (" W ";VD?ND >D= F=A NEA?BG GBd=H K?BP?K?>O >EA;9 H== ,FF#9$&L'59 \YBk\^B _5E?MAO9 7#9 N";NEAA?;L ?; M=;?BK "@A=D=BA?;L` _M?HBR"V?;L >DB> >=AG QN";@=HH?"; F=A H=WDBH B;O A=K=RB;N= >" NBH=`t$- # B> \XB _6?N>"AO9 7#9M?HH=;>?;L @A"G M=;?BK "@ A=D=BA?;L` _Q/ V"EKM LAB;>A=D=BA?;L >" N"AA=N> >D= F=A NEA?BG VD?ND A=GB;MH>D= NBH= >" >D= >A?BK N"EA> >" M=>=AG?;= VD=>D=A >D=N"GGE;?NB>?";H P=>V==; >D= FA?=H> B;M >D= G?;"AV=A= vN";@=HH?";H ,"' (" #cW`#


47/133

^X

&D= ?HHE= ?H BKH" ";= "@ FEA= KBVu B4"#4"' >D=A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?"; M"N>A?;= BFFK?=H9 ;">4%B ?> BFFK?=H#0;M=A B;O N";N=?RBPK= BFFK?NB>?"; "@ >DB> M"N>A?;=9>D= 3>B>= V"EKM DBR= >" BNN=F> >D= -DEANDcH R?=V >DB>BKK H>B>=G=;>H GBM= MEA?;L >D= 3BNABG=;> BA=FA">=N>=M PO >D= N";@=HH?";BK H=BK# &D= 3>B>= N"EKM>DEH ;"> PA=Bd >D= H=BK9 R?"KB>= >D= 3BNABG=;>9 B;MH?@> >DA"ELD VDB> VBH HB?M ?; N";@=HH?"; >" M=>=AG?;=?>H=K@ VD?ND ?;M?R?MEBK H>B>=G=;>H V=A=QN";@=HH?";SBKT ,"' (" W B;M VD?ND V=A= ;">#

1EA>D=AG"A=9 >D= N";H=bE=;N=H "@ L"?;L @"AVBAMVD=; >D= M?H>A?N> N"EA> DBH P==; "AM=A=M >" PA=Bd >D=H=BK "@ >D= N";@=HH?";H BA= H=R=A= P">D >" 1B>D=A4BOD? B;M >" >D= -DEAND# 1B>D=A 4BOD? V"EKM P=BE>"GB>?NBKKO =eN"GGE;?NB>=M @A"G >D= -DEAND ?@ D=PA=BdH >D= H=BK# &D= -DEAND V"EKM P= ?AA=M==GBPKO?;aEA=M BH ?>H G=GP=AH A=BK?U=M >DB> ?> N"EKM ;"K";L=A "@@=A >D= HBNABG=;>BK FA">=N>?";H ;=N=HHBAO @"AF=AH";BK A=M=GF>?";#

,K>D"ELD >=ND;?NBKKO ?; B; ?;>=AK"NE>"AO F"H>EA=9>D= aEMLG=;> ?H @?;BK @"A FEAF"H=H "@ >D?H -"EA>cH

aEA?HM?N>?";# 0;M=AP%W ['%5-75(#$&3 P%',T R# P%4&9XYf 0#3# XZ[ _][\j`9 B;M O$5\$ ]"'52- !6V2$(4$&3P%T R#_%'&$22%9 X]i 0#3# YX] _][\X`9 >D?H -"EA> =;a"OH

aEA?HM?N>?"; E;M=A Yi 0#3#-# l ]Yj\# ,KK >D=A=bE?A=G=;>H "@ >D"H= NBH=H BA= G=>n

]# &D= ."E?H?B;B Q3EFA=G= -"EA>cH aEMLG=;> ?HFKB?;KO @?;BK "; >D= @=M=ABK ?HHE= B;M ?H ;">HEPa=N> >" @EA>D=A A=R?=V ?; >D= H>B>= N"EA>HtW

Y# S?>?";=AHT V?KK P= K?BPK= @"A MBGBL=H ?@ >D==K=G=;>H "@ >D= H>B>= NBEH= "@ BN>?"; BA=FA"R=MtW


48/133

^j

^# QS/T@ >D= S."E?H?B;BT N"EA> =AA";="EHKOS?;>=AFA=>=M >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>T >D=A=HD"EKM P= ;" >A?BK B> BKKtW

X# QS(TR=; ?@ SF=>?>?";=AHT FA=RB?K=M B> >A?BK B;MGBM= E;;=N=HHBAO @EA>D=A N";H?M=AB>?"; "@ >D=N";H>?>E>?";BK bE=H>?";9 >D=A= V"EKM A=GB?; ?;=@@=N> >D= E;A=R?=V=M M=N?H?"; "@ >D= 3>B>=3EFA=G= -"EA> >DB> B N?R?K BN>?"; J J J GBO L"@"AVBAM M=HF?>= >D= 1?AH> J J J ,G=;MG=;>STtW

j# Q2=KBO?;L @?;BK M=N?H?"; "@ >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;> NKB?G E;>?K B@>=A >A?BK V?KK vK=BR=E;B;HV=A=M # # # B; ?GF"A>B;> bE=H>?"; J J JE;M=A >D= 1?AH> ,G=;MG=;>9c vB; E;=BHO B;ME;H=>>K=M N";H>?>E>?";BK F"H>EA= S>DB>T N"EKM";KO @EA>D=A DBAG >D= "F=AB>?"; "@ SA=K?L?";TtWB;M

Z# C=A= >D?H -"EA> >" QD"KM >DB> >D= 1?AH> J J J ,G=;MG=;>ST PBASHT N?R?K K?BP?K?>O J J J9 >D?HK?>?LB>?"; =;MH#

P%W ['%5-75(#$&3 9 XYf 0#3# B> XijkXiZ# /; HD"A>9SLT?R=; >D=H= @BN>"AHu>DB> >D= K?>?LB>?"; N"EKM P=>=AG?;B>=M PO S>D?H -"EA>cHT M=N?H?"; "; >D= G=A?>HB;M >DB> B @B?KEA= >" M=N?M= >D= bE=H>?"; ;"V V?KKK=BR= SNDEAND=HT ?; S."E?H?B;BT "F=AB>?;L ?; >D=HDBM"V "@ >D= N?R?K B;M NA?G?;BK HB;N>?";H "@ BAEK= "@ KBV J J J >D= N";H>?>E>?";BK?>O "@ VD?ND ?H ?;H=A?"EH M"EP>u J J J A=BND?;L >D= G=A?>H ?HN";H?H>=;> V?>D >D= FABLGB>?N BFFA"BND >DB> S>D?H-"EA> DBHT @"KK"V=M ?; >D= FBH> ?; M=>=AG?;?;L

@?;BK?>O#Y- # B> XiZ#


49/133

^Z

&D= ;B>EA= "@ >D= M?HFE>= BKH" N"E;H=KH @"A?GG=M?B>= A=R?=V# &D= A=K?L?"EH bE=H>?"; M"N>A?;=9K?d= bEBK?@?=M ?GGE;?>O9 H"R=A=?L; ?GGE;?>O9 "@@?N?BK?GGE;?>O9 B;M ?GGE;?>O @A"G M"EPK= a="FBAMO9"F=AB>=H BH B; ?GGE;?>O @A"G K?>?LB>?";9 ;"> aEH>@A"G MBGBL=H#O7P5'#4/ R#Z622"' 9 \]X 1#^M [\]9 [\j_\>D -?A# Yf]^`# &DEH9 QS?T@ >D= M=@=;H= J J J ?H=AA";="EHKO M=;?=M B;M >D= M=@=;MB;> DBH >" E;M=AL">D= >A?BK P=@"A= >D= =AA"A ?H N"AA=N>=MS9T D= DBH P==;?AA=R"NBPKO M=FA?R=M "@ ";= "@ >D= P=;=@?>Hu@A==M"G

@A"G DBR?;L >" E;M=AL" B >A?BKu>DB> D?H ?GGE;?>OVBH ?;>=;M=M >" L?R= D?G#WYV$-# D=H= N?ANEGH>B;N=H QVA=BdSHT ?AA=FBABPK= DBAG#WYV$-#

&D= M?HFE>= ?H @EKKO A=BMO @"A >D?H -"EA>cH A=R?=V#2=KBO V"EKM9 G"A="R=A9 FKBN= F=>?>?";=AH ?; B M"EPK=P?;M# /; "AM=A >" F=AHEBM= >D= N"EA> >DB> ;" K?BP?K?>OB>>BND=H P=NBEH= >D= H>B>=G=;>H V=A= QN";@=HH?";SBKTF=A H=9W >D=O GEH> R?"KB>= >D= HB;N>?>O "@ >D=3BNABG=;> ?>H=K@# /@9 "; >D= ">D=A DB;M9 >D=O A=HF=N>

>D= H=BK "@ N";@=HH?";9 >D=O NB; "@@=A ;" =R?M=;N= "@B;O H>B>=G=;>Hc N";@=HH?";BK NDBABN>=Au ?;M==M9 ;"=R?M=;N= >DB> B N";@=HH?"; =R=; "NNEAA=M9 H== 2=@H#c+"># 3EGG# 7# (e# , _B@@?MBR?> "@ 1B>D=A D= 2?"N=H=`uB;M V?KK P=HEPa=N> >" N"EA> HB;N>?";H B;M >"A> K?BP?K?>O#

-*!-.03/*!

&D= F=>?>?"; @"A B VA?> "@ N=A>?"ABA? HD"EKM P=LAB;>=M#


50/133

^\

)=HF=N>@EKKO HEPG?>>=M#

2 *! +# ) /-',)2 + /-',(. .# 2 ( 3 ',I*

.$&&"/0 122$&3456("&0+$745'- 8 9":45;%

? !%/-'5( :#'""#0 :6$#"=@>?

A"B C'2"5&(0 D%6$($5&5E?=@I?=?J

+,8 Yf]X

2 ,!/(. )# * )&/I K&$*"'($#/ %L M$'3$&$5

:74%%2 %L D5B>N? O5(($" +%5-

P45'2%##"(*$22"0 MQ ==R?F-'%S*$'3$&$5T"-6G@F@H R=@IF


51/133

Appendix


52/133

]B

/.!)"9" ,%.)# %( 4%.$/$*&*

&% 5KLMN,N5OP6

Q!*)"/ %( 9$&%) ,1$40R

S")/./

2"%)2" T7 ,1*)4"#U T)7U 0","*/"0U,1*)4"# (.&")*4 1%9"U $&,7U

Q#1" !)$"/#RU *&0 #1")%9*& ,*#1%4$, ,1.),1 %( #1"

0$%,"/" %( 3*#%& )%.2"

%& +)$# %( ,")#$%)*)$ #% #1",%.)# %( *!!"*4U

($)/# ,$),.$#U!*)$/1 %( "*/# 3*#%& )%.2"

!") ,.)$*9

&D?H VA?> FA=H=;>H >D= ?HHE= "@ VD=>D=A B FBA>O?H FA=NKEM=M @A"G "@@=A?;L B;O =R?M=;N= "@ D=AN";@=HH?"; B;M VD=>D=A B FA?=H> DBH B ME>O >" A=F"A>BKK=LB>?";H "@ H=eEBK BPEH= F=AF=>AB>=M "; B G?;"AFBA?HD?";=A# 1"A >D= @"KK"V?;L A=BH";H9 V= LAB;> >D=FKB?;>?@@Hc VA?>9 A=R=AH?;L B;M RBNB>?;L >D= N"EA> "@BFF=BKcH aEMLG=;> B;M A=?;H>B>?;L >D= >A?BK N"EA>cH

aEMLG=;>#


53/133

YB

(*,#/ *&0 !)%,"0.)*4 1$/#%)V

*; 7EKO Z9 Yff[9 FKB?;>?@@H9 >D= FBA=;>H "@ BG?;"A MBELD>=A9 @?K=M B F=>?>?"; @"A MBGBL=H HE@@=A=MPO >D=G B;M >D=?A MBELD>=A BH B A=HEK> "@ >D= BKK=L=M?;BFFA"FA?B>= B;M H=eEBK BN>H F=AF=>AB>=M "; >D=G?;"A ND?KM# &D=O ;BG=M BH M=@=;MB;>Hn >D= BKK=L=MF=AF=>AB>"A9 >D=;kM=N=BH=M 5="AL= 7# -DBAK=>9 7A#9 BV=KKkd;"V;9 K";Lk>?G= FBA?HD?";=A B;M BN>?R=G=GP=A "@ *EA .BMO "@ >D= ,HHEGF>?"; -B>D"K?N-DEANDt -DBAK=> 1E;=ABK '"G=9 /;N# "@ VD?ND +A#-DBAK=> VBH >D= BKK=L=M t >D= FA?=H>9 @"ABKK=L=MKO P=?;L B GB;MB>"AO A=F"A>=A VD" @B?K=M >"A=F"A> >D= BPEH= BKK=LB>?";Ht B;M >D= )"GB; -B>D"K?N-DEAND "@ >D= 2?"N=H= "@ 4B>"; )"EL= _Q-DEANDW`9BKK=L?;L R?NBA?"EH K?BP?K?>O @"A >D= BKK=L=MG?HN";MEN> "@ >D= FA?=H> ?; @B?K?;L >" A=F"A> >D=H=eEBK BPEH=9 BH V=KK BH @"A >D= ;=LK?L=;> >AB?;?;LB;M HEF=AR?H?"; "@ >D= FA?=H>#

&D= F=>?>?"; BKK=L=H MEA?;L >D= HEGG=A "@ Yffi9VD=; >D= G?;"A ND?KM VBH BFFA"e?GB>=KO @"EA>==;O=BAH "@ BL=9 >D=A= P=LB; B; =eNDB;L= "@ =GB?KH @A"G+A# -DBAK=>9 VD" VBH >D=; ZX O=BAH "@ BL=9 >" >D=G?;"A ND?KM9 VD?ND H""; ?;NA=BH=M ?; @A=bE=;NO B;MP=NBG= QKBN=M V?>D H=MEN>?R= ;EB;N=H#W &D= F=>?>?";@EA>D=A M=>B?KH >D= N";>?;E=M VA";L@EK BN>H "@ +A#-DBAK=>9 VD?ND NEKG?;B>=M V?>D d?HH?;L B;M @";MK?;L>D= G?;"A ND?KM#

?@@H BKK=L= >D= G?;"A ND?KM P=NBG= N";@EH=MB;M HNBA=M "R=A >D= =R"KR?;L QA=KB>?";HD?FW V?>D +A#-DBAK=>9 B;M "; >DA== H=FBAB>= "NNBH?";H9 HD= M=N?M=M>" H==d HF?A?>EBK LE?MB;N= >DA"ELD N";@=HH?"; V?>D>D= M=@=;MB;> FA?=H># &D= F=>?>?"; BKK=L=H ";


54/133

^B

&E=HMBO9 7EKO ]j9 Yffi9 B;M &E=HMBO9 7EKO Y[9 Yffi9FA?"A >" >D= Zn^f F#G# GBHH B> >D= NDEAND9 BH V=KK BH"; B> K=BH> ";= ">D=A "NNBH?"; B@>=A 7EKO Y[9 Yffi9>D= G?;"A ND?KM A=KB>=M >" >D= FA?=H> MEA?;L D=AN";@=HH?"; +A# -DBAK=> DBM ?;BFFA"FA?B>=KO >"END=MD=A9 d?HH=M D=A9 B;M >"KM D=A >DB> QD= VB;>=M >" GBd=K"R= >" D=A#W ,NN"AM?;L >" >D= F=>?>?";9 B;M N";H?H>=;>V?>D >D= G?;"A ND?KMcH HEPH=bE=;> M=F"H?>?";>=H>?G";O9 >D= FA?=H> BKK=L=MKO A=HF";M=M HD= H?GFKO;==M=M >" DB;MK= >D= H?>EB>?"; D=AH=K@9 P=NBEH=">D=AV?H=9 Q>"" GB;O F="FK= V"EKM P= DEA>#W &D=G?;"A ND?KM >=H>?@?=M >DB>9 MEA?;L ";= "@ >D"H=N";@=HH?";H9 HD= >"KM >D= FA?=H> VDB> DBM DBFF=;=MB;M BHd=M @"A BMR?N= "; D"V >" =;M ?># ,NN"AM?;L >"D=A M=F"H?>?"; >=H>?G";On Q'= aEH> HB?M9 >D?H ?H O"EAFA"PK=G# 3V==F ?> E;M=A >D= @K""A B;M L=> A?M "@ ?>#W

3EPH=bE=;> >" >D=H= >DA== BKK=L=M N";@=HH?";H9 >D=BPEH?R= BN>H N";>?;E=M# ,NN"AM?;L >" >D= BKK=LB>?";H?; >D= F=>?>?"; B;M >D= M=F"H?>?"; >=H>?G";O ?; >D=A=N"AM9 HEPH=bE=;> QG==>?;LHW V=A= DBMu";=

P=>V==; >D= FA?=H> B;M +A# B;M +AH# -DBAK=>9 B;MB;">D=A P=>V==; >D= -DBAK=>H B;M >D= G?;"AND?KMcH FBA=;>H _>D= FKB?;>?@@H`uN";N=A;?;L >D=Q"PH=HH?R= ;EGP=A "@ =GB?KH B;M FD";= NBKKHWP=>V==; +A# -DBAK=> B;M >D= G?;"A ND?KM B;M >D=H==G?;LKO ?;BFFA"FA?B>= NK"H=;=HH P=>V==; >D= >V">DB> DBM P==; "PH=AR=M PO RBA?"EH FBA?HD?";=AH#

3D"A>KO >D=A=B@>=A9 >D= FBA=;>H N";@A";>=M >D=?AG?;"A MBELD>=A BP"E> >D= =GB?KH B;M FD";= NBKKH9 B>VD?ND >?G=9 HD= N";@=HH=M >" >D= >AE= ;B>EA= "@ >D=

A=KB>?";HD?F V?>D +A# -DBAK=>9 ?;NKEM?;L M=>B?KH "@ >D=?;BFFA"FA?B>= H=eEBK N";>BN>H# &D= FKB?;>?@@H


55/133

XB

?GG=M?B>=KO N";>BN>=M +A# -DBAK=>9 "AM=A?;L D?G >"N=BH= N";>BN> V?>D >D=?A MBELD>=A9 B;M @?K=M B @"AGBKN"GFKB?;> BLB?;H> +A# -DBAK=> V?>D >D= (BH>1=K?N?B;B G=;># ,NN"AM?;L >">D= F=>?>?";9 >D= ?;R=H>?LB>?"; VBH ";L"?;L VD=; +A#-DBAK=> M?=M E;=eF=N>=MKO9 B@>=A HE@@=A?;L B GBHH?R=D=BA> B>>BNd VD?K= ?; F"H>k"F=AB>?R= A=N"R=AO9@"KK"V?;L d;==kA=FKBN=G=;> HEAL=AO#

3D"A>KO P=@"A= >A?BK VBH HND=MEK=M >" N"GG=;N=?; >D= FA=H=;> GB>>=A9 >D= -DEAND @?K=M ?>H G">?"; ?;K?G?;=9 H==d?;L >" FA=R=;> >D= FKB?;>?@@H @A"GQG=;>?";?;L9 A=@=A=;N?;L9 B;Mo"A ?;>A"MEN?;L=R?M=;N= B> >A?BK "@ B;O N";@=HH?";H >DB> GBO "A GBO;"> DBR= >Bd=; FKBN=W P=>V==; FKB?;>?@@Hc G?;"A ND?KMB;M >D= FA?=H>9 VD?K= >D= FA?=H> VBH BN>?;L ?; D?H"@@?N?BK NBFBN?>O BH B 2?"N=HB; FA?=H> B;M D=BA?;LN";@=HH?"; @A"G D?H FBA?HD?";=A# &D= >A?BK N"EA>M=;?=M >D= G">?";9 @?;M?;L >D= >=H>?G";O "@ >D= G?;"AND?KM A=LBAM?;L >D= N";@=HH?"; VBH A=K=RB

baton rouge diocese petition

Documents