barcelona provincial prosecutor's office special hate crimes … · 2013-11-18 · barcelona...

35
Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel Ángel Aguilar, Public Prosecutor

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office

Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service

Mr. Miguel Ángel Aguilar, Public Prosecutor

Page 2: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Hate Crimes : Institutional

Coordinated Response

Prosecutors' Office and Security Forces

Policia de la Generalitatmossos d'esquadra

Policia de la Generalitatmossos d'esquadra

Page 3: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

5.552.050 Inhabitants

BARCELONA

City & Province

Page 4: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

1) Specialized response

Prosecutor's Office

Page 5: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination

Service

Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office

Background: June 2007

Service Created: October 2009

InstructionProvincial

Prosecutor's Office Barcelona

1/09

Page 6: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Functions Service:

• Acknowledge and follow up of all the Judicial

Procedures in Criminal Acts Committed on

Discriminatory or Hate motive or grounds.

• Coordination of 250 prosecutors of all the

province of Barcelona & Technical Support

(Legislation & Jurisprudence both national &

international).

• Investigation Procedures of the Prosecutors

Office, with functional coordination of the Police

while investigating.

Page 7: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Collaboration with Civil Society

Commissions

a) Racism & Xenophobia

b) LGBT

Objectives:

“Victims do not file complaints. Let's get

closer to them”

Members:

NGOs, Public Administrations & Police

Page 8: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

2 )Establishing a Protocol

Catalonia Police Protocol 2010:

How to investigate hate crimes.

Proof of motive for the crime.

Organized groups.

Victims Assistance.

Prosecutors service:

Instruction 1/2009

Protocol for public acts with possible Incitement to

Violence, Hate & Discrimination

Page 9: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Discrimination for ethnic reasons

Page 10: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Racism

Page 11: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Xenophobia

Page 12: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Hatred for the poor

(Spanish: Aporofobia).

Page 13: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Religious Intolerance : Islamophobia,

Page 14: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Anti-Semitism

Page 15: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Anti - Christianism

Page 16: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Discrimination for health reasons

Page 17: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Discrimination for disability

Page 18: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Discrimination for Gender

Page 19: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Sexual Orientation & Gender

Identity

Page 20: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Discrimination for age

Page 21: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Bullying

Page 22: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Violence & Hate in Sports

Page 23: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

2013: Extension of the Project to the rest

of Spain

• New delegation for the tutelage of

equality and non discrimination at the

Spanish State's General Prosecutor.

(2011).

• 50 Prosecutors that have recently been

appointed in all the Spanish provinces.

Page 24: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Challenges

Page 25: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

a) Complaints not recorded

b) Crimes unreported

1.-Lack of Knowledge of

the acts

Page 26: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

2.- Tendency to Minimize

Page 27: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

- Not Reporting

- Lack of Trust or Fear of

the Police or Justice

Administration

3.- Victims

Page 28: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

1. Police Level

2. Judicial Level

4.- Lack of Investigations

Page 29: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

5.-Violence on Sports

Page 30: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

- Need for criminal procedures for minors and

- Need for Education Authorities to involve in the matter.

6.-Bullying

Page 31: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

7.- Hate Speech

Page 32: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

8.- Racial Profiling

Page 33: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

1. Absence of Specific Training.

2. Mandatory Training.

9. Juridical Actors Training

Page 34: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

10.- Legal Reforms

Page 35: Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes … · 2013-11-18 · Barcelona Provincial Prosecutor's Office Special Hate Crimes and Discrimination Service Mr. Miguel

Thanks for your attention,