I '

I Baltimore Police Department Polygraph Report

To: Detective Gregory MacGillivary From: Polygraph Unit Subject: S

CC#:

Lab#:

98-8B05801

99-0008

Date: 2/24/99

Procedures: Standard polygraph procedures were exercised throughout the examination:

(x) The examinee was advised of his/her rights per Miranda (Form #69)

(x) The examinee was read the polygraph Form of Consent (Form LD 305)

( ) The examinee was read the Policeman's Bill of Rights (Form 77 /86 }

The appropriate forms were signed, witnessed and are a part of the polygraph investigative file.

Summary of case Facts:

Subject found a homicide victim in a local park. He denies knowing anything about her death.

Relevant Questions:

P.O. T.

1. Do you know if that girl you found died because she was stabbed with a knife? Ans.=No

2. Do you know if that girl you found died because she was shot? Ans.=No

3. Do you know if that girl you found died because she was poisoned? Ans.=No

4. Do you know if that girl you found died because she was choked? Ans.=No

5. Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Ans.=No

6. Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a tire iron? Ans.=No

7. Do you know if that girl you found died because she was run over by a car? Ans.= No

\

Page_]_of_,6._Pages

Relevant Questions Continued:

None

Results:

The subject received a polygraph examination on the date indicated above, resulting in the

following Final Call: No Deception Indicated

Signature of Examiner:

P.eak of Tension 11/23/1999 page 1 of 1

ID ER Text Exam Type: Zone

1 R N Do you know if that girl you found died because she was stabbed with a knife?

2R N Do you know if that girl you found died because she was shot?

3R N Do you know if that girl you found died because she was poisioned?

4R N Do you know if that girl you found died because she was choked?

5R N Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a baseball bat?

6R N Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a tire iron?

7R N Do you know if that girl you found died becase she was run over by a car?

Peak of Tension 11/23/ 1999 page 1 of 1

ID ER Text Exam Type: Zone

1R N Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife?

2R N Do you know if that girl died because she was shot?

3R N Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned?

4R N Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled?

SR N Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat?

6R N Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron?

?R N Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car?

99-0008 Scoring Report 11/23/1999

POLYSCORE™ Version 4.0

Copyright (c) 1997 by The Johns Hopkins University/Applied Physics Laboratory. All rights reserved. (301) 953-5000: Dale E. Olsen and John C. Harris.

For assistance call technical support: (800) 428-7545

99-0008 charts scored: Exam Tvoe: Rank r.hart Exam Date Time Examiner 011oction~et

4 1 2/24/1999 11 :34 AM 11 :40 AM 12:17PM

admin admin admin

Peak of Tension Peak of Tension Peak of Tension

5 2/24/1999 6

Rank ID 10.0 6R 7.7 1R 7.5 4R 6.6 7R 2.7 3R 2.6 5R 2.6 2R

2/24/1999

SpotNertical Scores n11ostion Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was choked? Do you know if that girl you found died becase she was run over by a car? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was shot?

Channel Contributions Weinht ChannP.I

1 Chart 4 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvoe ID Question 9.6 R 1R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was stabbed with a knife? 4.2 R 2R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was shot?

5.5 R 3R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was poisioned?

10.0 R 4R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was choked? 6.9 R 5R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a baseball bat? 8.5 R 6R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a tire iron? 3.2 R 7R Do you know if that girl you found died becase she was run over by a car?

page 1 of 2

99-0008 Scoring Report 11/23/1999

Chart 5 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank T"ne 6.0 R 2.2 R 1.8 R 2.6 R 4.9 R 6.2 R 9.2 R

ID 1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R

Ouestion Do you know if that girl you found died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was choked? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl you found died becase she was run over by a car?

Chart 6 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvoe ID Ouestion 3.8 R 7R Do you know if that girl you found died becase she was run over by a car? 7.8 R 6R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a tire iron? 2.6 R 5R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was hit with a baseball bat? 6.3 R 4R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was choked? 5.6 R 3R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was poisioned? 7.4 R 2R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was shot? 3.6 R 1R Do you know if that girl you found died because she was stabbed with a knife?

page 2 of 2

99-0008 Scoring Report 11/23/1999

POLYSCORE™ Version 4.0

Copyright (c) 1997 by The Johns Hopkins University/Applied Physics Laboratory. All rights reserved. (301) 9S3-SOOO: Dale E. Olsen and John C. Harris.

For assistance call technical support: (800) 428-7S4S

99-0008 charts scored: Exam Tvoe: Rank r.hart Exam Date Time Examiner n11A~tionSet

1 1 2/24/1999 11 :10 AM admin Peak of Tension 2 3

Rank 10.0 7.7 6.1 S.2 4.4 3.7 1.2

ID 1R 7R 6R 4R SR 2R 3R

2/24/1999 2/24/1999

Question

11 :1 SAM 11 :22 AM

admin Peak of Tension admin Peak of Tension

SpoWertical Scores

Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a kn ife? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a basebal l bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned?

Channel Contributions Weinht r.h~nnel

Chart 1 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvoe 8.9 R 3.7 R 2.1 R 9.7 R 6.2 R 7.7 R 7.S R

ID 1R 2R 3R 4R SR 6R 7R

Question Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car?

page 1 of 2

99-0008 Scoring Report 11/23/1999

Chart 2 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvoe 8.2 R 7.3 R 4.6 R 2.6 R 4.0 R PB R

8.9 R

ID 1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R

Question Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car?

Chart 3 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvoe 10.0 R 6.2 R 3.9 R 4.8 R 5.3 R 4.3 R 4.6 R

ID 1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R

Question Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car?

page 2 of 2

99-0008 Scoring Report 11/23/1999

POLYSCORE™ Version 4.0

Copyright (c) 1997 by The Johns Hopkins University/Applied Physics Laboratory. All rights reserved. (301) 953-5000: Dale E. Olsen and John C. Harris.

For assistance call technical support: (800) 428-7545

99-0008 charts scored: Exam Type: Rank Chart Exam Date Time Examiner 011Ac:tion~At

1 1 2/24/1999 11:10AM admin Peak of Tension 2 1 2/24/1999 11 :15 AM admin Peak of Tension 3 2/24/1999 11:22 AM admin Peak of Tension

Rank ID 10.0 1R 7.7 7R 6.8 6R 5.1 4R 4.3 5R 3.5 2R 1.2 3R

SpoWertical Scores Question Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned?

Channel Contributions Weiaht Channel

Chart 1 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvoe 8.9 R 3.6 R 2.1 R 9.7 R 6.1 R 7.7 R 7.4 R

ID 1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R

Ouestion Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car?

page 1of2

'99-0008 Scoring Report 11/23/ 1999

Chart 2 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvoe 8.1 R 7.2 R 5.0 R 2.6 R 3.9 R p R

8.9 R

ID 1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R

Question Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car?

Chart 3 Exam 1 Peak of Tension

Rank Tvne 10.0 R 6.2 R 3.9 R 5.1 R 5.4 R 4.4 R 4.8 R

ID 1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R

Question Do you know if that girl died because she was stabbed with a knife? Do you know if that girl died because she was shot? Do you know if that girl died because she was poisioned? Do you know if that girl died because she was strangled? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a baseball bat? Do you know if that girl died because she was hit with a tire iron? Do you know if that girl died becase she was run over by a car?

page 2 of 2