b. krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., f.c.a. chartered accountantb. krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., f.c.a. chartered...

5
B. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered Accountant September 28,2019 REPORT OF SCRUTINIZER [Pursuant to the section 108 of the Companies Act, 2013 and rule 20(4) (xii) of the Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment Rules, 2015] To The Chairman Gangotri Textiles Limited Regd.Off: 25-A Venkatachalam Co-op Colony R.S.Puram Coimbatore - 641 002 Dear Sir, I, B. Krishnamoorthi, BSc, FCA Practlcinq Chartered Accountant, Coimbatore was appointed as Scrutinizer for the 30 th (Thirtieth) Annual General Meeting of the, Equity Shareholders of "Gangotri Textiles limited" held on 27 th September 2019 at 3.30 pm at the mini air conditioned hall, Rajasthani Sangh, D.B.Road, R.S.Puram, Coimbatore 641002 for the purpose of scrutinizing the E-Voting process and Physical Ballot voting at the venue in a fair and transparent manner and ascertaining the requisite majority on E-Voting and Physical Ballot voting at venue carried out as per section 108 of the CompaniesAct,2013 and rule 20(4) (xii) of the Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment Rules, 2015 on the resolutions referred to in this report. I submit my report as under: 1. The Notice was sent to all the Members, whose names appeared in the Register of Members as on 23rd August, 2019 to vote on the proposed 4 (Four) Resolutions as mentioned in the Notice of the Annual General Meeting of "Gangotri Textiles Limited" (Item No.1 (One) to 4 (Four) of the Notice of Annual General Meeting of Gangotri Textiles Limited. The Members holding equity shares as on the cut-off date i.e. zo" September, '2019 were only considered for e-voting and for voting at the meeting venue. Number of shareholders as on cut-off date is, 10007. 2. The E-Votin~period remained OPen from 09.00 AM on Tuesday 24th Sept'ember, 2019 upto 05.00 PM on Thursday 26 September, 2019. 3. The Chairman, at the Annual General Meeting, at the end of discussions on the Resolutions contained in the Notice, allowed voting at the venue of the Annual General Meeting on the Ballot Forms provided at the Meeting venue to all those members who were present at the Meeting but have not cast their votes by availing the remote e-voting. 4. After the conclusion of the Meeting, the Ballot Boxes were opened in my presence and the physical ballot forms were diligently scrutinized and reconciled with the records maintained by the Registrar and Transfer Agents of the com~ny. I thereafter fir eounted the votes cast at the Meeting through these Ballot Forms. _ e.KRI9HNAMOORTHI, F.CA. Chartered Accountant C U()1..rl I, l<f0 20 L,?>1 A-AA-Ac"OQ7oi!) Membel$hIpNo:20438 Office: 'Kanapathy Towers'lII Floor, No. 1391fA-1, Sathy Road, Ganapathy, Coimbatore 641 006 Phone: 0422 4039900 Fax:.0422 - 2536673 E·mail: [email protected] Resi : ·Shreekara" No.9, Right House, Rajarajes}1wari Estates, Mullai Nagar, Marudhamalai Road, Coimbatore 641 041, Phone: 0422 4512371

Upload: others

Post on 17-Apr-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: B. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered AccountantB. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered Accountant September 28,2019 REPORT OF SCRUTINIZER [Pursuant to the section 108 of the

B. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A.Chartered Accountant

September 28,2019

REPORT OF SCRUTINIZER[Pursuant to the section 108 of the Companies Act, 2013 and rule 20(4) (xii) of the

Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment Rules, 2015]

To

The ChairmanGangotri Textiles LimitedRegd.Off: 25-A Venkatachalam Co-op ColonyR.S.PuramCoimbatore - 641 002

Dear Sir,

I, B. Krishnamoorthi, BSc, FCA Practlcinq Chartered Accountant, Coimbatore was appointed as Scrutinizerfor the 30th (Thirtieth) Annual General Meeting of the, Equity Shareholders of "Gangotri Textiles limited"held on 27th September 2019 at 3.30 pm at the mini air conditioned hall, Rajasthani Sangh, D.B.Road,R.S.Puram, Coimbatore 641002 for the purpose of scrutinizing the E-Voting process and Physical Ballotvoting at the venue in a fair and transparent manner and ascertaining the requisite majority on E-Voting andPhysical Ballot voting at venue carried out as per section 108 of the CompaniesAct,2013 and rule 20(4) (xii) ofthe Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment Rules, 2015 on the resolutions referred to inthis report.

I submit my report as under:

1. The Notice was sent to all the Members, whose names appeared in the Register of Members as on 23rdAugust, 2019 to vote on the proposed 4 (Four) Resolutions as mentioned in the Notice of the AnnualGeneral Meeting of "Gangotri Textiles Limited" (Item No.1 (One) to 4 (Four) of the Notice of AnnualGeneral Meeting of Gangotri Textiles Limited. The Members holding equity shares as on the cut-off datei.e. zo" September, '2019 were only considered for e-voting and for voting at the meeting venue. Numberof shareholders as on cut-off date is, 10007.

2. The E-Votin~period remained OPen from 09.00 AM on Tuesday 24th Sept'ember, 2019 upto 05.00 PM onThursday 26 September, 2019.

3. The Chairman, at the Annual General Meeting, at the end of discussions on the Resolutions contained inthe Notice, allowed voting at the venue of the Annual General Meeting on the Ballot Forms provided atthe Meeting venue to all those members who were present at the Meeting but have not cast their votes byavailing the remote e-voting.

4. After the conclusion of the Meeting, the Ballot Boxes were opened in my presence and the physical ballotforms were diligently scrutinized and reconciled with the records maintained by the Registrar and TransferAgents of the com~ny. I thereafter fir eounted the votes cast at the Meeting through these BallotForms.

_ e.KRI9HNAMOORTHI, F.CA.Chartered Accountant

C U()1..rl I, l<f020L,?>1 A-AA-Ac"OQ7oi!) Membel$hIpNo:20438

Office: 'Kanapathy Towers'lII Floor, No. 1391fA-1, Sathy Road, Ganapathy, Coimbatore 641 006Phone: 0422 4039900 Fax:.0422 - 2536673 E·mail: [email protected]

Resi : ·Shreekara" No.9, Right House, Rajarajes}1wari Estates, Mullai Nagar, Marudhamalai Road, Coimbatore 641 041, Phone: 0422 4512371

Page 2: B. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered AccountantB. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered Accountant September 28,2019 REPORT OF SCRUTINIZER [Pursuant to the section 108 of the

B. Krishnamoorthi B.Se., F.C.A.Chartered Accountant

5. The Votes cast through E-Voting were unblocked on 27th September, 2019 around 6.30 pm in thepresence of two witnesses, namely Mr.K.Jayakumar and Mr.R.Sasidharan, who are not in employment ofthe Company.

6. In tune with the Instructions for e-voting, sent along with the Notice of the Annual General Meeting dated12th April, 2019, in respect of members who have voted in both modes (i.e. E-Voting and Physical Ballotform voted at the venue), I have considered only E-Voting by not reckoning the voting done throughPhysical Ballot Form.

7. One Ballot Form involving 200 shares which was incomplete and I or otherwise defective was treated asinvalid.

8. I have collated the votes cast through remote e-voting and votes cast through physical ballot forms at thevenue, and the same have been furnished hereunder.

Resolution Mode For Against

No.of No.of % No.of No.of %Members Votes Members VotesOrdinary Resolution foradoption of the Directors E-Voting 4 1775 100.000 0 0 0.000Report, Profit and lossAeount for the year ended Ballot form at 18 8036988 100.000 0 0 0.0001 31st March 2019, and the the AGM venueBalance Sheet as at thatdate and Auditors report Total 22 8038763 100.000 0 0 0.000thereon.

Ordinary Resolution for E-Voting 3 707 39.831 1 1068 60.169appointment of Sri. S.'Sivashanmugam (DIN Ballot form at

2 08299022) as an the AGM venue 18 8036988 100.000 0 0 0.000Independent Director of theCompany.

Total 21 8037695 99.987 1 1068 0.013

hL'~~oq?o~t vO 'i. N ~ ICW2.0l+8QAJ

B.KRI9HNAMOORTHI, F.e.•••••. Ohartered Accountant

Me~1p Ne:2fJ.t3e

•..•••...•__ .•.

Office: 'KanapathyTowers'lIl Floor, No.1391/A-1, Sathy Road,Ganapathy,Coimbatore641 006Phone: 0422 4039900 Fax: 0422 - 2536673 E-mail: [email protected]

Resl : "Shreekara"No.9, RightHouse,RajarajeshwariEstates,Mullai Nagar,MarudhamalaiRoad,Coimbatore641 041, Phone: 0422 4512371

Page 3: B. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered AccountantB. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered Accountant September 28,2019 REPORT OF SCRUTINIZER [Pursuant to the section 108 of the

B. Krishnamoorthi ss«, F.C.A.

Chartered Accountant

Ordinary Resolution for E-Voting 1 6 0.338 3 1769 99.662approval of remunerationpayable to Sri. Mohanlal Ballot form at 18 8036988 100.000 0 a 0.0003 Tibrewal, Executive Director the AGM venueof the Company.

Total 19 8036994 99.978 3 1769 0.022

Special Resolution for E-Voting 1 6 0.338 3 1769 99.662

approval for voluntaliry Ballot form at4 winding up the affairs of the the AGM venue 17 8036166 99.990 1 822 0.010

Company.Total 18 8036172 99.968 4 2591 0.032

9. All relevant records of electronic voting and ballot forms will remain in my custody until the Chairmanconsiders, approves and signs the minutes of the so" Annual General Meeting and thereafter the saidrecords will be handed over to the Company Secretary of Gangotri Textiles Limited! for safe custody.

Thanking you,

t\:h(B. KRISHNAMOORTHI)SCRUTINIZER Q .q)

(VOm~ '9{!)fJ..4J1f9>'14-AkAfAOr70

B.KRJ6HNAMOORTHI, F.e.A..Ohartered AccountantMembership No: 20439

Office :'KanapathyTowers'IJI Floor, No. 1391/A-1, Sathy Road, Ganapathy, Coimbatore641 006Phone. : 0422 4039900 Fax: 0422 - 2536673 E-mail: [email protected]

Resi : ·Shreekara" No.9, Right House, Rajarajeshwari Estates, Mullai Nagar, Marudhamalai Road, Coimbatore 641 041, Phone; 0422 4512371

Page 4: B. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered AccountantB. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered Accountant September 28,2019 REPORT OF SCRUTINIZER [Pursuant to the section 108 of the

Gangotri Textiles LimitedVoting details for the business transacted at the Annual General meeting held on 27th September, 2019

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

No. of shares held No. of votes% of Votes Polled on

No. of Votes in No. of Votes% of Votes in favour % of Votes against

SLNO RESOLUTION Promoter/ Public outstanding shares on votes polled on votes polled(1) polled (2)

(3)=[(2)/(1)]*100favour (4) against (5)

(6)=[(4)/(2)]*100 (7)=[(5)/(2)]"100

Promoter - E-Voting - - - - - -Promoter - Poll at AGM 8000457 8000457 100.000 8000457 0 100.000 -Promoter - Ballot by Post - - - - - -

Ordinary Resolution for adoptionTotal (A) 8,000,457 8,000,457 100.000 8,000,457 - 100.000 -

ofthe Directors Report, Profit andPublic - Institutions - E-Voting - - - - - -

LossAcount for the year endedPublic - Institutions - Poll at AGM 2212319 - - - - - -

131st March 2019, and the Balance

Public - Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Sheet as at that date and Auditors

Total (B) 2,212,319 - - - - - -

report thereon.Public- Non Institutions - E-Voting 1775 0.008 1775 0 100.000 -Public - Non Institutions - Poll at AGM 22401858 36531 0.163 36531 0 100.000 -Public - Non Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Total (C) 22,401,858 38,306 0.171 38,306 - 100.000 -Total (A+B+C) 32,614,634 8,038,763 24.648 8,038,763 - 100.000 . - ,

Promoter - E-Voting - - - - - -Promoter - Poll at AGM 8000457 8000457 100.000 8000457 0 100.000 -Promoter - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Total (A) 8,000,457 8,000,457 100.000 8,000,457 - 100.000 -

Ordinary Resolution for Public - Institutions - E-Voting - - - - - -appointment of Sri. S. Public - Institutions - Poll at AGM 2212319 - - - - - -

2 Sivashanmugam (DIN 08299022) Public -Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -as an Independent Director of the Total (B) 2,212,319 - - - - - -Company. Public - Non Institutions - E-Voting 1775 0.008 707 1068 39.831 60.169

Public - Non Institutions - Poll at AGM 22401858 36531 0.163 36531 0 100.000Public - Non Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Total (C) 22,401,858 38,306 0.171 37,238 1,068 97.212 2.788Total (A+B+C) .. , 32,614,634 8,038,763 24.648 8,037,695 1,068 99.987 0.013

Promoter - E-Voting - - - - - -Promoter - Poll at AGM 8000457 8000457 100.000 8000457 0 100.000 -Promoter - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Total (A) 8,000,457 8,000,457 100.000 8,000,457 - 100.000 -

f"ho·r!in'::u·" DoC'",I, ••.i•..•n f •..••.'3 " r·"-,.,,,,'3 1 Public - Institutions - E-Voting - - - - - -

I

Page 5: B. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered AccountantB. Krishnamoo.rthi 8.5c., F.C.A. Chartered Accountant September 28,2019 REPORT OF SCRUTINIZER [Pursuant to the section 108 of the

/

••.•••U••IClIY "II;:.:)VIUUVII IVI a •...•...'vvolPublic - Institutions - Poll at AGM 2212319 -

of remuneration payable to Sri. - - - - -3

Mohanlal Tibrewal, ExecutivePublic - Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -

Director of the Company.Total (B) 2,212,319 - - - - - -Public - Non Institutions - E-Voting 1775 0.008 6 1769 0.338 99.662Public - Non Institutions - Poll at AGM 22401858 36531 0.163 36531 0 100.000Public - Non Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Total (C) 22,401,858 38,306 0.171 36,537 1,769 95.382 4.618Total (A+B+C) 'c-;; 32,614,634 . 8,038,763 24.648 8,036,994 1,769 99.978 0.022

Promoter - E-Voting - - - - - -Promoter - Poll at AGM 8000457 8000457 100.000 8000457 0 100.000 -Promoter - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Total (A) 8,000,457 8,000,457 100.000 8,000,457 - 100.000 -Public - Institutions - E-Voting - - - - - -

Special Resolution for approval for Public - Institutions - Poll at AGM 2212319 - - - - - -4 voluntaliry winding up the affairs Public - Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -

of the Company. Total (B) 2,212,319 - - - - - -Public - Non Institutions - E-Voting 1775 0.008 6 1769 0.338 99.662Public - Non Institutions - Poll at AGM 22401858 36531 0.163 35709 822 97.750 2.250Public - Non Institutions - Ballot by Post - - - - - -Total (C) 22,401,858 38,306 0.171 35,715 2,591 93.236 6.764Total (A+B+C) 32,614,634 8,038,763 24.648 8,036,172 •. "" 2,591 99,968 "

0.032