aydın doğan

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

1/37

\ F @ @

\q|hbhc Mg{à|eavg Fhchbe

Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;8

Laaveg cobqq`q{ Hwlb Lohb% mo naelgbg{ bdaegcea @adegtg`g{a"

\vcgwa Fwc @geea| @adegtg Lhvfaeavg Hvh|v`h Co`gtwobqbqb lhya|g {avgbafqvhlhtb{" Tg{eavgb la fgelgg ngfg Zhvehàb|olh nvqfq fqeqbhb lv| tgwhtg zhv|gbgb yav`goelqq bavnaeav lovqe|qtqblh% eca`g{la laòcvhtgwa `lhmhea alab |` lhvfa ya`qm|vhehv ya laòcvhtgwg geaytg{ cehb f|b ngvgg` ya tobqehvb |` fowq|ehvwehhvh|vehvhc% heb`ht navacab beaèavgb faegveabàtg h`hdweh cqvqe`q fgv co`gtwob oeqz%he`hehvb|h`hèhlc|hb tobvh @adegt Nabae Cqvqeqbh tqbhdhc"

\vcgwa Fwc @geea| @adegtg fq lba`la `geea| gvhlatgbgb Zhvehàb|owh whbt`hthtblhb ab wctac lba`g chzthl ngfg% hwb {h`hblh |` tgwhtg zhv|geavgb ov|hcgvhlatgwea yavge`g oehb bavna lovqe|qtqblh cqvqe`q oehb Co`gtwobq`q{q ba`tgwovq{"@geea| gvhlatgbgb |adaeeg a||gg fq àcb ya Co`gtwobq`q{qb nvaygbg mh|veh|`hc gt|avg`" Bafgv tovnqeh`h ba la fgv whvneh`h whzwovq{ fqvhlh" Mav awlab bda laòcvhtgwg catgb|gwa

qvh|hb fq lhvfaeav ya o lbaà gegcgb gegcgeavg gengegeavgblab lgbeaàc% lbaà |hbceca|àc% naeadaa gegcgb lhmh laòcvh|gc fgv \vcgwa gbh a|à woeqblh mazg`g{gb ch|cehvbàlabg fgv acgela cobqhvhc he`hc"

Fgv tovnqeh`h ya tovq|qv`h whz`hl`{ ngfg whvnthe fgv ihhegwa||a whz`wovq{h`h ba |athli|v cg hwb lba`la% ma` 86 Aweeb ma` 6= qfh| tvadgbgb ma` la lgavlhvfa ngvggèavgbgb \vcgwala whvnehbl fgv lbaà labc naelg" Loehwtweh% fg{ nvayg`g{gya avayatgbg g{avcab fq whvn wa|cgtgbgb cqeehb`hbeh`bh naeafgeadac tovnqeh`hehvlhboehfgelgg chlhv chbwovq{" H`h fq chb`h`{ hwb {h`hblh |` tovqehv`{ hcwvacegegcea tov`hc ya hwb ela dayhz yavgeàtgbg faceaàc ngfg fgv bgwa|g`g{ yhv" Dayhzyavgz yavààc yawh lhmh tobvh wh{e dayhz yavàc ngfg |hfgg cg mhcehvb{ yhv% mg layavàwafgegvtgbg{ h`h twealgg` ngfg fgv lbaà hcec ch{hblv`hc hbeh`blh fq tovqehv

tovqwovq{"g`lg% fab% co`gtwobq`q{qb bhte he| cobqtqblh tg{g cthdh fgengeablgvlgc|ab

tobvh% aav fq lbaà gegcgb oehvhc tg{g% Co`gtwobq`q{qb hwv He| Co`gtwobqoeq|qvqelq% nvay g|gfhvgwea chzth`bb nabgegg balabgwea" 879: lhvfatg ya >8 `qm|vhtbhgegcgb% 87=: lhvfatgba gegcgb% fgv la 6= qfh| ya 6> Bgthb lba`gbg chzthwhdhc acgela"Co`gtwobq`q{h lhya| alab he| Co`gtwob 6= qfh| he| co`gtwobq" Loehwtweh% lba`tovqehv`{b hve fq acgela oehdhc"

Fab% bdaegcea tg{gb nabae fgv laaveablgvà% lbaà gegcgb nabae fgv laaveablgvàwhz`hc gt|aàbg{ lqvq`qblh tg{a t{ yavadag`" Fq nabae laaveablgvàlab tobvh`geea|yacgeeavg`g{a to`q| tovqehvb tov`hc {ava t{ yavadag`" Aav nabae laaveablgvàwhz`hc gt|aààbg{ lqvq`qblh lgvac| `geea|yacgeeavg`g{a t{ yavavac fhehwhdh` h`h gecoehvhc cablgbg{g ya {na`ggbg{g |hb|hvhc fheh`hb{ vgdh aladag`" Fqbh naàlabbda% tg{a tob t{ yavàlab bda `geea|yacgeeavg`g{g tg{a |hb|`hc gt|gwovq`"

6= qfh| He| Co`gtwob Fhchb Whhv Chvhwae Faw% Chwtavg HC Zhv|g `geea|yacgeg3Abyav We`h{ Faw% HC Zhv|g t|hbfqe `geea|yacgeg% 9: Lhvfatg He| Co`gtwobq Fhchb3 Dabng{Whygegoeq Faw% 879: Lhvfa Co`gtwobq HC Zhv|g Av{qvq` `geea|yacgeg3 Tvawwh Tvv blavFaw% FLZ t|hbfqe `geea|yacgeg3 Heg V{h {|vc Faw% Dq`mqvgwa| Mhec Zhv|gtg @avtgb`geea|yacgeg3 lvgt hmgb Faw% hbcv HC Zhv|g `geea|yacgeg% Co`gtwob t{d`{3 Iaw{qeehmCwcec Faw% HC Zhv|g t|hbfqe `geea|yacgeg3 @amà| acav Faw% Dq`mqvgwa| Mhec Zhv|gtgNh{ghb|az `geea|yacgeg"

Co`gtwob waeavg`g{ lblh fqeqbhb `geea|yacgeeavg`g{ `gthigv `geea|yacgeeavg`g{% obehv

|hb|`wovq`"T{ tg{gb% fqwqvqb"

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

2/37

\ F @ @



HWLGB LOHB \aaccv alavg` aiablg`" Ayyaeh cablg`lab fhmta|àc gt|gwovq`

`thhla alavtabg{"Thwb Fhchb% Co`gtwobqb laaveg waeavg3 fqnb mq{qvqbq{lh fqeqbqvcab bdaegceatg{eavg thwnweh taehèwovq`"

Fwea fgv nvay ggb \vcgwa Fwc @geea| @ade gtg mq{qvqbh gcgbdg laih cwovq`"Fgvgbdgtg% 6::6 weblh wgba wda @adegtgb oeq|qvlqq @alwh Tovqbehvb Hvh|v`hCo`gtwobqbqb mq{qvqbh c` ya fqvhlh wba|geab f|b tovqehvh hceceh dayhzyav`g|g`" Mq{qvehvb{lh tg{gb tovhdhb{ tovqehvh lh dayhz yavàwa mh{v`"

g`lg `thhlabg{ea tg{eava cablg`g |hb|hw`" Fab% 8749 weblh% N`mhbabgbCaecg| ch{htblh% cce fgv hgeabgb odqq oehvhc lbwhwh naelg`" ec ya ov|h ag|g`g`gCaecg||a% egta ag|g`g`g Av{gbdhblh whz|`" Ocq`hc ggb t|hbfqe Wctac c|gth| ya \gdhva|@ac|afgba naelg`" Ovhlh ocqeh layh` alavcab 8717 weblh @adglgwacw Yavng Lhgvatgba

chwl` whz|vl`" Nab wh`lhb favg \vcgwala wctac taygwala yavng yavabeav hvhtbhngvlg`" 8> laih% tob 8> we t| t|a \vcgwa ya t|hbfqe yavng vacov|àbg oelq`% naegvyavngtgblab fhmtalgwovq`% cqvqèhv yavngeavg hwvlv" Ovhlh lh cqvqèhv`{ naba baègyavngeav yav`geavlgv% fqbq fhmta|àc gt|gwovq`" 87>7 weblh @geegwa| nh{a|atgbg hehvhcnh{a|adgegc tac|vba ngvlg`" Lb Hyvqzhbb baèg whwb nvqzehvblhb fgvg megba naelgg`g{gnvwovq`" bc lbwhbb ab fwc whwb nvqfq oehb \gà ^hvbavea DBB \vc|aov|hce`{ yhv% naba He`hbehvb ab fwc whwb nvqfq oehb H}ae Tzvgbnavea Chbhe L|aeayg{wobqblh ov|hce`{ yhv% naba He`hbehvb ab fwc lavng nvqfq oehb Fqvlh Nvqfqwehlavngdgegc oehvhc \vcgwala wgba ov|hce`{ yhv" Hwvdh% Lhbg`hvcheehvb Anòb| gvca|gweacg|hzec whwbblh favhfav cg|hz whwbde whzwovq{% ov|hc oehvhc% o lh \vcgwabgb abfwceavg hvhtblh" Fqbqb lblh Ivhbciqv||h fhtc |atgteavg`g{ yhv" Ivhbciqv||hcg fhtc

|atgteavg`g{la ^heee T|vaa| Koqvbhelhb% Igbhbdghe \gàt|hb lhmh fgv oc be whwb ovnhbbfg{ fhtwovq{"

Fab atcglab fgv |hfgv cqeehbvl`% lavlg` cg; Lohb Nvqfq whwbehv Thb Ivhbtgtdolhb\ocwowh chlhv lbwhbb mav wavgbla oehdhc" Mh||h% lbwhbb bavatgbla fgv \vc yhvth fg{ovhlh oehdh{ h`h Hàvgchlhcg fhtc |atgtg`g{g chzh|`hc lqvq`qblh chelc" bcb|avba| hv|c ovhehvlh o chlhv whwnbeh| cg nh{a|aeav acobo`gc oe`hc|hb c| ggbHàvgchw chzh||c" Fqbqb lblh% Vo`hbwhbb ab fwc |aeayg{wob chbheblhb fgvgtgfg{g`% Thvhwfotbhlh |aeayg{wob whwbde whzwovq{% Vqtwhbb ab fwc vaceh` whwbdenh{a|atg fg{g`" Hwvdh Ch{hcgt|hblh% @hdhvgt|hblh% Faehvqt|h%Qcvhwbhlh lhmh lbwhbbag|eg waveavgbla fhtc |atgteavg`g{ yhv% nh{a|a whwbde`{ yhv" Whbg qbq tweaàcgt|gwovq`; Fg{% whwbdec|h Hyvqzh hzblh fgv whwb nvqfq oe`hwh nhwva| algwovq{ ya fqblhlh oc fhhve oelqq`q{q twewovq`"

\ocwolh 877= weblh% Lbwh Whwbdec Fgvegg waeggba ^HB |hfgv a||gceavg cthhlweh% ovhwh gec tageab \vc fab oelq`% \vceavlab gec laih fgv \vc% Lbwh WhwbdehvFgvegg fohvlbh ngvlg" Fab taba ayyae hwvel`" g`lg o fohvllh fabg` c{` fabg|a`tgeab layh` algwov% fqbq lh àteaa oehb fhèe`{% lbwhlhcg whwbde lh |hcgza||gg`g{g fgelgvàc fhc`blhb tweaàc gt|alg`"

Fab fgv whwbd oehvhc maz qbh gbhbl`; @alwh% laòcvhtgeavgb yh{nageà{ fgvqbtqvqlqv" Aav fgv ecala {nv àlwh wocth o ecala laòcvhtg woc laàc|gv" Hwbacgela% laòcvhtg wocth {nv àlwh lh woc laàc|gv" Obqb ggb fab laòcvhtgwg yaàlwhw fgvfgvgbgb {ll lage% fgvfgvgbgb mht` lage3 fgvfgvgbg lat|aceawab% |h`hèhwhb%

fateawab gcg hwv nvqz oehvhc nvwovq`" Aav laòcvhtg yhvth o ecala% fg{g` whhàceg`g{ yhvlv% laòcvhtg wocth àlwhbb whh` {nvec|v% tavfat|egc|gv" @alwh lh

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

3/37

\ F @ @



oe`h{ fqbq hbeh|`hc gt|gwovq`" Fabg` yhve` la`ocvhtgbgb yhveweh chg`lgv" La`ocvhtg

wocth fg{ wocq{3 fvhcb wea ct|e mhfav whwbde whz`hw% cc|ab woc alaveav fg{g"87

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

4/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

5/37

\ F @ @



tobvht |ozeq` bbla g|gfhv`{ {avgblab whvneh`h whzehdhc ya cobq chzh|ehdhc%

Mcà|gb zehb fq" lgwa fgv wh{ wh{wov" Fqbqbeh gengeg fgengbg{ yhv `? Fqbqbeh gengeg fgenghe`hc gt|gwovq`% fq gllghehveh gengeg baeav tweawadactgbg{?HWLGB LOHB t|avtabg{ tvhtweh fhehwhw`% Whhv Ocqwhb ya Whtht"Whhv Ocqwhb Fawg fab tgwhtg% whbg `geea|yacgeg oe`hlhb ayyae la |hbv`% fhchb

oe`hlhb ayyae la |hbv`% {h|ab ccabg nh{a|adglgv% fgelgg` chlhvweh% {h`hb {h`hbnv|ceavg` oe`q|qv" Fhchbcab fhbh naelg% lovq" Hgeatg% odqcehvblhb gcwa| a||ggbg mgmh|veh`wovq`% wea fgv aw mh|veh`wovq`% thlada o nb whbe`wovth` agbgb\azafhblhcg o|aela fgv vatg` tavngtg oelqqbq obh geng nt|avà`g{ navac|ggbg twealg%fab la hvchlhehvh Fq vatg` tavngtgbg mhfaveawgb% vatgèawgb% mhfav whzb% gengeabgb" lalg`"Whhv Faw% fhbh Whthtb tovlq" Fab obh Bgwa qvhwovtqb? ihehb laàlg`% hwbabwea h`h fqbq oc gt|gt`hv a||g `hheatai% lalg` cg oe`hwhb fgv àèaca||a g nyabdatg

chv`hwh hewovtqb% wh% chvlag`% g fqeh`wovq{% tab fgv la nyabda chv`hwhhewovtqb% mhwvet% ba lgwovtqb% bhte fgegvtgb% fgeà`" lalg`% fablab c|c|hb tobvh`hheatai% fqbq fgv gcg chbhelh fwc fgv àlwh zh|vobqbh ng||g` O whthlhb loehw fabg|amlg| a||g" lalg% mhh na|gvgb Cqvhbh ae fhthw`" Fhch ba lgwafgegvg` cg" Fab fwea fgv awlafqeqb`hl`% thlada% agbgb vatg` tavngtgba geng nt|avà` ggb fhbh naelg% atcg hmfhf`l%lot|q`lq% Aeg`g{lab naeabg whzhv{" lalgc% hvchlhehv`h lh twealg`% cablgtgba la% whchvla tovlq fhbh% fq g nyabdatg% cablg tovlq Nyabdatg Whthtb bhte fqeqwovtqb?lalggbla la% Whhv Faw% àèaca||a g woc% tab fgv la nyabda chvwovtqb% ayyaeh gg fqe%nyabda coehw% whzhe`" lalg`% fqbqb |avtgbg% `hheatai% gt|gt`hv a||g" Fqbq whc|vh`hl`Whhv Fawa% me lh cvnb`% nv`wovq` fgv wavla% nvta` la aw whz`h`% oehw fqlqv"

FAWH[ \Ylacg awla% bhte naelg oehw mh|veh`wovq` h`h q fgv navac|gv% nhegfh fq

Ihlgà hmgb oehw loehwtweh naelg" Fab lalg` cg; @alwhw% a`bgwa|gb la% @\gb la mh||hfgvoc mhfav chwbhblh cqeehb` oehfgegv" cqeehbèhvl lh" Bg|acg` o awg% bavalab heblIhlgà hmgb oehw lalgg`la tobvhlhb tovlq` hvchlhehv`h {hbbalgwovq`% zoegt|aetg{gblab% zoegt hbobt a|`g Fg{ nglgwovq{% ovhw fht`hwh" nh{a|adg hvchlhehv` lh o%Ihlgà hmgb oehwb zoegt |aetg{gblab vab`g ng|`geav% fgbhabheawm fg{g cqeehb`|v lgwafwea tzatgigc fgv cobqwq twealg`; Faecg% fg{g cqeehb` oehfgegveav" lalg`% me lhtwewovq`% mav {h`hb lh fhtb chwbhcehvb% {h`hb {h`hb fhtb cqeehbl oeqwov% fhtblh fqbh aegblab naelgg chlhv lgcch| algwov h`h tg{a qbq tweawawg` cg; Aav% whwbdecwhzwovthb{% mhfav chwbhcehvweh lh gegcg ggbla oe`hc àdfqvgwa|gblatgbg{% hctg melawhwbdec whzh`h{tb{% tg{eav la fgvav mhfav chwbhtb{lv% tg{eavlab la hvchlhehvb{mhfav t{lvv obq cablg t{naeavgblab nagvàwa hevehv% ``cb oelqq chlhv fhchwaveavlab la |awg| alavac whwbehvehv h`h ch`q cqvqeqehvbh naeab mhfaveavg oc o chlhv lhih{eh gbdaeaà{eav" bc% lohe oehvhc zoegtgb% @\gb |hvhit{ oelqqbq chfqe alaveav% fqFAWH[ \Yla twealgg` fqlqv" Fhch fab FAWH[ \Ywa la fq cobqweh gengeg fhehb`hl`"Fgv Lgwhvfhcv @geea|yacgeg% mg mhwh|`lh nvàlgg` fgv {h|% fabg |amlg| a||g" Fab fq hlh`ba |hbwovq`% ba nvl`" lalg`% o yatgeawea fhehbl`% fq tovqwq faecg ovhlh tovlqehv%mh|veh`wovq` h`h fwea tzatgigc Fg{g @\ cqeehbl" lgwa fgv aw tweaàlg`"

g`lg% \hvhi nh{a|atgblab fgv @amà| Fhvhbtqlhb fhmta||gbg{% fab fq whwb |hcgza|àlg`% ba laàc gt|ablggbg la whbg tovqbq{q lh |h` hbehwh`hl`% fgv lhmh fabg gch{alavtabg{ faecg dayhz yavàwa nhwva| alavg`"

@AM@A\ ACAV -Nh{ghb|az' wea lgwov% @amà| Fhvhbtq% lhmh fq Co`gtwob

cqvqe`hlhb bda% Lhvfaeavg Hvh|v`h Co`gtwobq cqvqe`hlhb bda% 6= qfh| eh gengegfgegwovtqbq{% |q|qceh`hehv oelq% lgwov cg @amà| Fhvhbtq; Fq |q|qceh`hehv beaàc ggb tg{gb t| l{aw fgv wba|gdgbg{ la cobqqwov% o hc|hvwov obh Fhfhchbeh nvel% fwea

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

6/37

\ F @ @



fgv co`gtwob cqvqehdhc% fq co`gtwobh g hlhèhv% àlwh zh|vobehv hvehdhc% gihla

yavadaceav ya ch`qowqblh fqbehv nae`g gihla yav`g ngfg fgv g{eabg` whvh|ehdhc% oehw v|fhtalgeadac @amà| Fhvhbtqbqb wh{tbb hbeh`% gavgg fq ya fqbq lh tg{gb whwbnvqfqbq{qb t| l{aw fgv wba|gdgtgwea cobq|qqbq twewov% gtg` faegv|`gwov"

HWLGB LOHB g`lg% ayyaeh% whbg% àlwh tovqehvb% 6= qfh|% lhvfaeavghvh|v`hc ggb fgv co`gtwobqb cqvqe`q oe`htblhb fab fgv vhmh|t{ec hmtablqw`qwovq`% nvqz oehvhc lh lqw`hlc% mh||h th`g`g oehvhc% à`bqbgwa| lqwqwovq` yagt|gwovq` cg fqnb fhbh g|mh` algeab fgvoc awla tovthb{ lh wea hbeh|th`% f|b covcq`fqvhwh naegvcab qwlq; Wh% fhbh maz mhyhlhb tqlhb aweav tovhvehv% tovqe`h{ fgvh{ fweaggba ggba ngvtaeav% bc fq Co`gtwobqb% fabg` fhtblhb lh |hcgz a||ggà nva gcg baègnvayg yhvlv; Fgv% tg{ lhvfawa whvl` a||gbg{ `g% htcaveavea g fgvegg whz|b{ `? cg% olba`la tavya|gbg{la ya yhveb{lh bhte fgv `he yhve oelq% bhte {abngbealgbg{% fhbchehv

bhte mov|qèhlb{% gmheaeavg bhte n|vlb{% obehvtovhdhctb{ lgwa facegwovq`"@amà| Fawgb% fg{g` whwb nvqfqblh t| l{aw fgv tv wh{hv hvchlh` yhv% fgvoc

faecg |hfgveavg% cqtqvh fhc`hwb% fh{ab aw whzhfgegvg` fgv oc wh{hv hvchlh`{ yhv fg{g`nvqz|h% fgvoc wba|gdg yhv% cg` ba cobq|q% balab fwea fgv cobq`h oelq fge`gwovq`"

FHCHB Hwlb Faw% fqvhlh% fgv cobqwq hceh chyq|qv`hc htblhbtweawadag`; Thwb Fhvhbtq% o wh{w fg{g` Co`gtwobq`q{ cqvqelqc|hb lv| hw tobvhwh{l" Whbg Co`gtwob o h`heh cqvqelq" laàc ggb mav awlabbda o wh{bb oc bdawh{e` oe`ht eh{`" Whbg% g`lg% fq% hteblh% fg{g` cablg Co`gtwobq`q{h wbaegc oehvhcgeavg tve` oc hv fgv gllghlv% g|mh`lv% Zhvehàb|olhcg f|b tgwhtg zhv|geavgb% tg{eavgb laggbla oelqqbq{ ya yavgeab bavnaeavea cqvqe`q|qv" Mavmela fgv wba|gdgwa |aeaiob hz lhfgv nh{a|a wba|gdgtgba; Zhvehàb|olh fwea fgv Co`gtwobq cqvqb% 6= qfh| tvadg la

fweaegcea chzh|etb igehb% mhcgch|ab fqbehv Co`gtwobq`q{qb nbla`gba lhmg na|gvàwgfab% lovqtq% aw fqeqwovq` h`h f|b tovqehv hc wvacegegcea tovqehdhc aefa||a%dayhzehvb hehdh{"

Heg V{h {|vc% @avtgb @geea|yacgeg% fqwqvqb e|iab"HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Thwb Lohb% mo naelgbg{"HWLGB LOHB Mo fqelqc aiablg`"HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Tg{gb facealggbg{ tovqehv fab tovhw`% fh|hb maàb

tweawawg`"Fhfhchb`{ Vadaz \hwwgz Avlohbeh hvhb{ bhte% l{aelg `g? Cth cth% ba|% |ac"HWLGB LOHB Nhwa| gwgwlg whbg hvh`{lh fwea fgv lot|eqc% th`g`gwa|% hvchlhec

gegcgtg woc h`h nhwa| àlabg gegcgeav gavgtgblawg{" Fab cablgtgbg nvl` {h`hb navacegthwnw nt|avgvg`% o lh fg{a me mh|v alav% fgv tcb|` woc% oelqq {h`hb lh nglavg` ecabgbFhfhchbbh aav% Fhfhchbh ngladac fgv àtaea` yhvth lh nglavg`" q hblh% fqblhbfgvch we ayyae ch`qowqbh whbt` oehb tav|egceav q hblh woc|qv"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Aya| Thwb Lohb% |aaccv algwovq`"Tg{% Hwlb Lohb ya nvqfq oehvhc thlada àlwhweh gengeabàlgbg{% |alab favg \vc

ch`qowqbqb lgcch|gbg tvaceg acab fgv nvqztqbq{% fgv cggegctgb g{% tgwhtg gc|glhvehveh oeqèq whlh oeq`tq{ ab whcb gegcgeav gavgtgbla oehb nvqzehvlhb fgv |hbatgtgbg{% àlwh nvqfqblhb"Tg{g fab \hbtq geeavea fgv |aeayg{wob |hv|`htblh% tav| |hv|`h whzhvcab la g{ea`g|g`% o{h`hb lh fgv tgwhta|a àwlhb ocq`h |hyv ggbla oelqqbq{q fab nv`|`% o {h`hb`geea|yacgeg ihehb lagelg`" g`lg% àlwhbb tgwhta|g lg{hwb a|à% |ozeq`q gc|glhvlhcg n

eamgba mg{hwh na|gvà faceab|gtg% gt|ag balab chwbhcehb`hc|hlv? La`gblab lacobq`hb{lh twealgbg{; Tgwhta|ea àlwh hvhtblh {h`hb {h`hb |hv|`hehv chv"

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

7/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;>

lalgbg{% àlwhbb hteg nvayg |ozeq`qb |hvhit{% fgeng he`h hlbh fgengeablgvàc lage `glgv?

Tgwhta|ea àlwh hvhtblhcg |hv|`hbb chwbh fq `qlqv tg{da? Fqbq lh àvhc algwovq`"HWLGB LOHB Fgv% ayyaeh fgvgbdg tovqlh tqhe fh|hb whbe aw whzbdh ovhlhbaw whzwov" Fab% \hbtq Mhbèh tgwhtg fgv àwlhb ocq`h% tgwhtg fgv chynh qvqbh

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Fab wea henehl` twealg`"HWLGB LOHB \hbtq Mhb`h h`h fhcb% \hbtq Mhb`% fg{g gtg` yavavac%

{ewovq` q hblh% weehv na|g% g|mh` a||g" Lalg cg; Lohb Nvqfq Av{qvq`h ng||g% ovhlh`hmcaàwg hwhvehl% `qmhfgvgbg woeehl ya qbq||q` g`lg qwlqv`h mhfav whwbehl" Fab ohvhlh Hbchvh |a`tgedgeggbg hvhl`% @geegwa| nh{a|atgbgb Hbchvh |a`tgedgtgbg Chvlag`% fhcb%|aeayg{woblh Thwb Fhfhchb fwea fgv aw twewov% ba mhe| a||gbg{ tg{ lalg`% wea fgv awoeqv `q aiablg`% o hvchlh Hbchvhwh lh ng|àlg" wea fgv aw la woc|qv% faenaeavg`g{fqvhlh% g|a" Faenaeav fhbh na|g% fab% \hbtq Mhb`h |aeaioblh% Aiablg`% fg{g g|mh`

algwovtqbq{% whehb% c| whz|" lgwovtqbq{" Vgdh algwovq`% `hcthl` hhb caegàeavoeqvth aw whz`hwb" Fqbq e|iab% bawa lhwhbhvhc twewovtqbq{% g{hm algb" lalgg`la%\hbtq Mhbèh |aeayg{woblh g|a Tab chv|aetgb" fgeà` ba% `bhchh oelq% fab la c|`cablgtgba Fqbq hcehwb" lalg`" \hbtq Mhbèh% lgwovq` weehv na|g% caca oe`hthwl%chynhehv`{b |aàegbla fq |gz aweav wh|`hc|hlv" @ataeh% Tqe|hb Hmà| @awlhbblhVaihmWoe Mcà|g lba`gbla% \hbtq Mhb` c| O {h`hb fabg` fhdhbh` lh obqbfhchbwl% o lh whbblhwl% lalg cg O chv|aegb lhwhbh`hl tobvh Lohb Nqvqfqbqbdafgba > ch|vgewob cowlq`" Fab o|qvlqq` wavla cqvqlq`" Wh ba{fgeem% fwea whehb oeqv`q whmq? Whehbb lh fgv `{vhcqyheh ngvav > ch|vgewob ba cowlqbq{% ba a||gbg{? > cqvqcow`hl" Whehb twewov" lgwov% Nbeavea whwb whz|`% faenatg la fqvhlh yhv% `hmcaàwayavlg` ya o lba`la \hbtq Mhb`lhb 69 `gewob zhvh ch{hbl`% fgv tomfa|gbla fhbh

Dhb` whc|b" lalg% H`h \hbtq Mhb`% tab fabg` o chlhv whc|b cg fgvh{ lh tg{gb whbtb"Lalg`" Fqwqvqb% `hmcaà chvhv lh aeg`la" Whbg fabg` \hbtq Mhbèh tgwhtg fgv nFab tgwhtg nd`% fab ecawg wba|gvg`% wbeablgvgvg`" lgwa fgv aw whz`hl`" @hheatai%tgwhta|geav fg{a c{lcehvblh Fg{ tage`geavg{% tg{ `g wba|adactgbg{? \hfgg tage`geavwba|adac" Fgv aw tweawawg`% wa|g|gg` fenabgb ce|v% wa|g|gg` hgeabgb ce|vTage`geava iaychehla thwnew`lv% tageàc coehw g lagelgv% tbi `àttgeg tageàc fgea{ovlqv% `qm|hv tageàc fgea {ovlqv% o fgv fadavg gt|av% fgv fhhv gt|av% fgv awlgv" Fgbhabheawmfq twealggbg{g catgbegcea chfqe a|à`" \hbtq Mhbèh lh mgfgv chynh`% tgwhtg àwlhbocq`h qvqbh oe`h`|v" \hbtq Mhbèh f|b chynhehv` \hbtq Mhb` fg{g g|mhà|`g|gv ya g|mh` a||gg ggb la fab la cablgtgbgb chvtblh lqv`qq`lqv"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Thwb Lohb% fab whbg tqeh`h hbeh`blhtwea`gwovq` bc fab% o oehwehv lovqlqv wh lh whbe|v fgeà`% thlada lqwlqq`q{aweavg lovq `qlqv whbe `lv tg{lab lqw`hc gt|gwovq{"

HWLGB LOHB Fab la ivth| oelqch fqbehv hbeh|wovq`"HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Layh` algwovq{ aiablg`" Hte |qvzqb fw

mawfala% naegwov g`lg"HWLGB LOHB Fqwqvqb"HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Fgv àlwh zh|vobqbqbtg{ wh lh fgv fhcht layea|ea

`gewhvehvdh loehvec g gegcgtgba ngvàtg% gmhea faceab|gtg gavgtgbla oe`ht% aav fwea whzwovgta fq àlwh nvqfqbqbwgba tg{ wh lh fgv fhchtbb o gc|glhvh chv fh`t{ oe`h {aeeggyhv `lv% fh`t{ oehfgegv `g?

FHCHB Zhvlob% fgv aw tweawadag`" Heg V{h Faw% tovqehvb{ tovqdayhzacegbla layh` a|àtgb ``cbta% f|b tovqehvb{ tovqb dayhzehvb{ helc|hb tobvht{ fvhchdh` bc

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

8/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;=

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' \h`h`" Fab hteblh aya| yawh mhwv acegbla

whb|ehvl% fabg` tovqehv` nabaeegcea whbg fwea oc q{qb hceh`hFHCHB Bhte dayhz yavadagba cobqq`q{ cablgtg chvhv yavgv h`hHE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' \hfgg whbg fab obh fgv aw la`gwovq`" Aya|"FHCHB tg{ tovqehvb{b |h`h`b tovqb% fgv% gcg% % fa ch |hbawtaHE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' O {h`hb layh` alawg` Thwb Fhchb`"g`lg% Thwb Lohb |hfgg fab {aeegcea DMZ @avtgb @geea|yacgeg oehvhc tg{g oc whcb

g{egwovq`"HWLGB LOHB \aaccv alavg`"HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Tovq bavnaeavg`g nv`tb{lv% tg{gbea Mcà|

hvhtblhcg gegcgeavgb we`h{ |hcgzgtgwg` fab% fqbq `geea|yacgeg oe`h` balabgwea whzwovq`"HWLGB LOHB Fabg` wea fgv wa|abag` woc% g`cb` woc whbg tg{ whzhfgegvtgbg{"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Hbehl`" Fab fqvhlh Fq Co`gtwobq`q{qb athtnvayg thlada htcav lhvfa ya `qm|vhehv lage% hwb {h`hblh laòcvhtgwg geaytg{ cehb |`ngvgg` ya tvaeavgb tovnqehb`htlv bc fg{ fq ecala `gee gvhlabgb lblh mavmhbng fgvn |hb`hl`{ yqvnqeqwovq{% naeab `gee gvhlabgb la q yawh fq acgela laòcvhtgwgcatgb|gwa qvh|hdhc acgela cqeehbe`htbb |hvhi|hv lageg{" g`lg% tg{ fq 6= qfh| tvadgblawhhbhb oehwehvlhb tobvh% fgv boc|hlh navac|ab fq tgwhtg gc|glhveh oeq`tq{ gegcgeavgbg{ch`qowqbh whbtl" vbagb% ag|eg laàeavgbg{ yhv% fab fqbehvh ngvàwadag`" Fgv ggegcgtgba ngvlgbg{% |ozehb|ehv whzel% fqbehvh lh ngvàwadag`"

HWLGB LOHB Laaveg Yacgeg`% ngvgb"FHCHB Ngvgb% ba àtaeh" Ngvgb% ngvgb ba àtaeh"HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb'Mhwv% fg|gvawg`"

HWLGB LOHB Fab tg{a qbq tweawawg`; @a{hv |h`lhb tob cqvqqbh chlhvmathf` yavàwa mh{v`% fhfh`lhb fhehwhvhc"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' g`lg% fab tg{gb zhvhb{b mathfb tov`qwovq`"g`lg% fabg gengeablgvab cobq qlqv; Tgwhtg gc|glhveh àlwh hvhtblh laòcvhtg l fgv gegcgyhv `lv? Fq thlada tg{lab chwbhcehb`hwhfgegv% tgwhtg gc|glhvb lh tg{a fhtct acegblachwbhcehbhfgegv" vbagb% aeg`lacg nh{a|a Mvvgwa| nh{a|atg"

HWLGB LOHB Aya| aiablg`"HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' g`lg% fqvhlh% 1 Mh{gvhb 6:8: fq nh{a|abgb |hvgmg"

Mvvgwa| Nh{a|adgegc ya @h|fhhdecFq Mvvgwa| cbwatgblab hlb{ bgwa chvlb{?Aya|% Thwb Lohb" g`lg% fq àydq| gc|glhveh gengeg fgv h|`h wh lh fo{qc gegcgeav

lba`g whhlb{% vbagb tg{a yavngeav catgelg% fab obqbeh gengeg la tovq bavnatg yavlg` yatobqblh o yavngeavgb fgv ct`b Lhb|hw gz|he a|àtgba vhàb thbwovq`% whbemh|vewovth` l{ae|gb lalgbg{" Balab lalgbg{ obq lh fge`gwovq` ch{hb` oe`hb{hvhàb" Fgv ct` yavngeavg zagb whbg lhmh yhlatg naeàlab% Mcà| la |hctg|eablgvàlabzagb laà woeqbh ngvlgbg{ h`h fv |hvhi|hb lh navac|ab nh{a|abg{la wh lh nvqfqbq{lhhehb cg`g wh{hvg{aveav g|ab coyqelq% fqbehvb g|ab coyqe`htblh tgwhtg gc|glhvb tg{a|aecgbg% wbeablgvàtg wh lh fhtct yhv `? vbagb% lb Thwb {cc Fq lba`la LohbNvqfqblhcg fh{ nvayeavg`lab gwg cg hwve``" lalg% fqbq fab oc hbehè fqeqwovq`"Thwb Av|qvqe {ccb Hbchvhwh naegz Facgv Docqb h fgv egt|a chv|z Egt|abgb fgvgbdgtvhtbh @aegm Hc% gcgbdg tvhtblh tab yhvtb" lalgg ya Facgv Docqbqb gt|gih a|àc{ovqblh chel3 Vhm`g \qvhbb% Dbaw| etayavgb% Iavhg \bb% \qihb \vabgb ya

{la`gv bdabgb% A`gb oehhbb wh{ehvbh% nh{a|ala he`hehvbh tob yavgelgg fgegbab fgvnavac" g`lg% oehfgegv whbg tg{ |hfgg cg zh|vobtqbq{% fab la {ae gvca|eavla he|`% gggyavab htblhb mavcatgb mavcatg g|ab chv`h mhcc yhvlv h`h vabàc gt|algg` cobq

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

9/37

\ F @ @



qlqv; Laòcvhtgbgb thece geaàtg htblhb% àlwhbb ya àlwh tgwhta| gegcgeavgbgb

l{abeg wvàtg htblhb Fq cggeav mvt{ec ` whz`|% fq cggeav navac|ab nh{a|adgegcàteagbg wavgba na|gva`gwov `qwlq? Fqbehv% fhc|`{ {h`hb maztg la thwnb gtgèav% fqcggeavgb g|ab chve`htbb balabg balgv? Whbg fab navac|ab ofkac|gi dayhz yavàbg{ggt|gwovq` whbg Aya|% chvlag` fq hlhèhv qblhb loehw fab zh|vob oehvhc gt|aàlg`%chv||` `lv? wocth fqbqb hvchtblh tgwhtg balabeav `g yhvlv?

Fabg whvhehwhb ab fwc oehw lh% tovq`qb ab |aàegbg oeq|qvhb cobq lh Mvvgwa|nh{a|atgbgb cbwatgblab cablg hlb{ balab chv||b{% {nv gvhlabg{ea `g chv||b{%chv|`hc {ovqblh ` chelb{? bc fqbehvb maztgba fhc|`{lh% maztg tgwhta| ya tgwhtggc|glhv gegcgeavgbg l{abegwov" Tob tovq` qlqv; Tg{% Hwlb Lohb oehvhc navac htcavlbaèavla navacta tgyge lbaèavla gc|glhvb hb|glaòcvh|gc qwnqeh`hehvbh lat|acyavlgbg{ `g yavàlgbg{ `g whbg lhvfaeava mg{à| a||gbg{ `g a|àlgbg{ `g% laòcvhtg l

mhvaca|eava% awea` ya geaèava n{ wq`lqbq{ `q wq``hlb{ ` wocth obehvh lgvablgbg{`g? Fab fqbehv vabàc gt|gwovq`"

\aaccv algwovq`"HWLGB LOHB Dayhz yavawg` `g aiablg`? Dayhz yavawg` `g Thwb Fhchb`?FHCHB Fqwqvqb e|iab"HWLGB LOHB g`lg% Mvvgwa|gb cbwatgblab balab gt`g`g chvl`% fgvgbdg

awgbg{ fqlqv" Faecg fq tg{gb heneh`hb{ oehfgegv% lhvlhb fwea h`h ggb hte% atht qlqv;Fab o lba`la f|b Nvqfq`lhcg gvca|eavlab hwvel` ya cablg`g Lohb gvca|eav Nvqfqobqvthe watg megba odqcehv` gt|alg Fwea whz% tab hv|c acge fq g|ab% fg{ whzhdh{"lalgeav" [h|ab la fq wea fgv hwec% gcg hwec% hwec ihehb lage% fgvch we ayyae yavge`g fgvchvhvl% meab fabg` Lohb gvca|eavgbgb mgfgv |hbatgbla g`{h wa|cg` woc|qv% t{ mhcc`

woc|qv thlada mgttalhv`lv" O lba`la hgea`g{ hvhtblh fgv g fe` whz|c% ec a|hz|hodqcehv ggb fhbh natgbeav" lalgc% fgv" g`g{la Lv| c{` yhv dqvdqbh oelq O ovhwh` naadac% fq fqvhwh ` naadac? Ab fwc c{` lh \THL Wba|g` CqvqeqFhchbwl" Oblhb tobvh obh lh tvhv a||geav h`h fab lalg` cg; Hv|c acge wa|av% fgv nvaywhz|b% nae fqvhwh geavg`g{ yhv" O lh gg`g{gb fhbh naelg" Fq yatgeawea fabg` gt`g` wheb{awlab lage f|b gvca|eavg`la Hwlb Lohb gt`g% Lohb Moelgbn Obqvthe Fhchb oehvhcnaàwa fhehl" Wabglab odqcehvb gt`gbg cowlqc% % fa hw ayyae% he| hw ayyaenh{a|aeava% obqb lh tafafg qlqv; fe` whz|` odqcehv`b hvhtblh% ab fwc c{`|aeayg{wobehvh fhcwov% gcg bq`hvhe c{` Mvvgwa| nh{a|atgba fhcwov% bq`hvhe c{`Lohb Nh{a|adgegc lalgg`g{ Zot|h ya nvqfqbh fhcwov% lv| bq`hvhe c{` lh moelgbnafhcwov" O c{ehv`b gtgèavgbg cbwawa cowlqc% cbwalab fabg` gt`g`gb chve`htblh abqihc fgv tgwhtg fhtc% balab woc|qv" [h|ab bhte oehfgegv cg? Fq nvqz|hb c% nh{a|aeavg th|% ggfvhc" hwv fgv aw% t`gbg ovhlhb chv" hwv fgv aw% fqvhlh tgwhtg fgv aw hvh`h`hb{twewovq`" Fgvgbdg tweawadag` fq"

g`lg% Wh{hvg{aveav g|ab chvel" lawgbda hceh gec naeab gcg |hba wh{hv oeqwov%fqbehvlhb fgv |hbatg \vcgwala oc |hv|ehb A`gb ehhb% fgv |hbatg la Facgv Docqb" A`gbehhb fab coylq`% A`gb ehhb% c{` ya Nabae Whwb @lv% coy`h`h` ggb fhbhlh aw whz|ehv whbg wea whzhe`% fwea whzhe` fabg qwq|`hwh chec|ehv% tobqblh lalg`cg; cgbg{ fgvlab nglavtgbg{" Av|qvqeh lh fabg` c{`h lh cgbg{ fgvlab nglavtgbg{% A`gbgcoyhdhctb{" ya nglgz {`gvla A`gbg fqelqehv% coylqehv" A`gbgb coyqe`htbh gbhb`hb{gt|avg`% mgfgv tgwhtg fhbh f|b mhwh|` fowqbdh Mav tgwhtg zhv|glab gcwa|eav nae`g|gv%

f|b nh{a|aeavlab% wh{hvehvlhb gcwa|eav nae`g|gv h`h fhbh mgfgv tgwhtg zhv|g q hlh`h|" htcaveav lmge Fq hlh` h|" lgwa fgv tvhvlh fqeqb`hl" A`gb wba|geaà{ mea nae`g|g%A`gb Fq nh{a|abgb thmgfgbgb la fhbh nd wa|à{" lgwovlq% A`gb |hcb|w àteac

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

10/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;8:

algb`g|g% " @aegm% " @aegm% " @aegm lgwavac% mav wh{tbh 8: fgb loehv da{h laàwa

fheh`|`" A`gb |hcb|w fvhc% ch`zhbwh h`hw fvhc" lalgg`la la fhbh Whbgzh|vob% fab fq Mcà|gb heawmgba wh{ wh{`hwhw` `% ba lgwovtqb? lgwa fheh`|v fqvhlh tweawaà` Ba{fgeem fab la h{`h naeabg twealg`" Fab thbh Mcà|gbheawmgbla wh{ wh{`h la`gwovq`% fqvht tabgb fhfhbb gi|egg lage% fqvhlh |hcb| whzzobh " @aegm % fqbh fgeà` ba%obh \hwwgz% fqbh fgeà` ba laà mhccb woc|qv" lalg`"A`gbg fab chvl`% chvl`h lh oc gwg a||gg`gb awgblawg`" A`gb oblhb tobvh cg|hzehvwh{l% mav nb me fabg` heawmg`la% fqeqblqq nh{a|awea awea favhfav bc lgwov cgA`gb; Fab ovhlh fgv ày{g |q|`q|q`" Whmq fgv nh{a|abgb catg fhchtweh mhvz algeàtgggb ày{g oehvhc yavgegv `g? Cablg cg|hfblh yhv% cablg wh{l fqbq" Fwea aw oeqv `q? Fabcoylq` hvchlh" Mavcata la fqbqb mathfb yavafgegvg`"

Facgv Facgva mhcc` maehe a|àwadag`" Facgvgb ng|ààtg ggb oc nhwva| thvi

a||g`" Facgv ng|à" lalg`% Nabae Whwb @lvb la woeehl`% c{` lh chvtbh |aeaioba||g% Nae thbh t|hbfqelh lhgva hehe`" lalg`" A`gb mav laihtblh fg{lab n|vl% 1:: fgb%4:: fgb% 6:: fgb" Facgv wea fgv aw la whz`hl bc Facgva oc zhvh yav`geav% `gc|hvbfge`gwovq`% cg`tawa gi|gvh a|à`" Facgva Ng|" laàlg` fab" Tobvh lh% cg|hfb wh{lc|hbtobvh% fab obh fgv nb |aeaiob a|`g|g`% oc lqwnqthe fgv wh{ wh{`| wg cg yhvtb Facgv"la`g|g`" Hbchvhbb V{nhve Tochc|hb nagz la bhte Hbchvhbb mhyhtb helbwh{hvcab wg cg yhvtb Mvvgwa|" lalg% fq g àtaea`g{" Fab la o wh{lhb lqwnqehb`|`%|aeaiob a|`g|g` wg cg yhvtb Facgv" lalg`" Tobvhlhb wh{l` àc|qz|h wg cg woctqbFacgv" lalg`" Facgvg fg{ coy`hlc% cablg ng||g"

g`lg% lgav hvchlhehv Fab cg`tawg tgwhtg balabeavea coy`hl`" Nh{a|aeavlabgbthbehv hwvev% nglaveav% naegveav" a|gb He|hbb fgv ehi yhv Fhfheg fwc fgv cobhc" O cobhc|h

fqnb lbav labg{a fhchb |hvhiblh o|qvqvtqb% whvb lbav fhmawa fhchb |hvhiblhoeqvtqb" H`h nh{a|aeavgb nabae whwb `lveavg oc ocqbqwov `q% ocqb`qwov `q obehvhfhchvehv" \hcgfa fhchvehv% fg{a na|gvgz n|vlba fhchvehv whbg nh{a|aeav la ch`q cqvq`qlage% obehvb la acobo`gc wba|gèavg yhv" t`gbg yavlggbg{ \qihb \vab mheh nh{a|a`g{gbWh{ eavg @lvlv% nhwa| la gwg fgv hvchlh`{lv% Wh{ eavg @lveba layh` algwov"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Ca wh{hveblhb hebl h`h"HWLGB LOHB Iavhg \b @thhla algb" Iavhg \b cablg hv{qtqweh nh{a|alab

hwvel" q hblh fabg` lot|q`% hvhlh fgv naegv fabg {gwhva| alav" Whbe`wovth` GZGb whbgwhwbdehv fgveggbgb \vcgwa `àttgeeggbg whzwov ya ovhlh lh nhwa| hc|gi" g`lg% cgèavgtwealg? Dbaw| etayav% {la`gv bda% Vhm`g \qvhb Vhm`g \qvhb lh fabg` atcg fgvhvchlh` h`h whbg wgv`g gcg we fg{la he|" Vhm`g \qvhb nh{a|a wba|gdgtgwlg% cablgkhbvblh Fhfhegla Vhm`g \qvhb |hv{ lgwa fgv whwbdec whz`|% lhmh {gwhla `hnh{gbhvece h`h wh{ehvb hv|c Nabae whwb `lveavg naegz ng||gca% mav nabae whwb `lvcablgba nva fgv |hthvvqi|h fqeqbqv% tobvh lh ih|qvht zh|vobh chv% tgwhtg fgv |hvhi woc|qv"Fgv fhtcweh cg`tawg h|`hl`" Fhbh lh mgfgv tgwhtg gc|glhv% ba \qvnq| {he ba Teaw`hbLa`gvae ba htcaveav Fqbehv g|ab h|hdhctb" lgwa aw whz`hl" Thlada |aecgblafqeqblqcehv yhvlv% oe`q|qv h`h àtaea fqlqv" Fgeà` |h|`gb alafgelg` `g tg{g?

FHCHB Aya|% oc |aaccv alavg`"g`lg wea fgv aw yhv; oc {h`hb zvofea`g whwovq{ Heg V{h Faw" H{ bda gch{

a||g`% chvece fgv cobq`hwh woe h`h`hc hlbh tg{a f|b tovqehvb{ tovqb lalg`"HWLGB LOHB Fabda tqheeavgbg tovtqbehv aiablg`"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Cobq`htbb ggbla fgv aw twealg% lalg cg; A`gbehhb mavnb 6::4:: n|vwovlq" lalg"HWLGB LOHB Mhwv mhwv% l{ae|awg`" \aaccv alavg`"

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

11/37

\ F @ @



HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Balgv whbg% bhte n|vl obq hbeh`hl`"

HWLGB LOHB Mhwv mhwv% `thhla algb"FHCHB Fhtb àbtqzehvbb helcehv dva|eavHE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' dva|ea gengeg lage h`h fq% fq tweabgeab dva|ea gengeg

lage"HWLGB LOHB Aiablg`% lovq lgwovtqbq{ |aaccv alavg`% l{ae|awg`" Fab la

cobq`hbb amya|gba chzehvhc fh{ab aw whzhfgegvg`% fab la gbthb`% fwea aweav oeqv"Fgegwovtqbq{ mglla|% mg|hfa| thbh|bb fgv layh`lv"

FHCHB Aya|% |aaccv algwovq`"HWLGB LOHB g`lg% A`gb ehhb ggb qbq twealg`; Whbg A`gb ehhb

nh{a|aeav hvhtblh chynh oelqq lbaèavla Yheehmg fabg Da` Faw gt|alg% ovhwh ngladag`"Fab la mhwh|` aàgèa ch{hbwovq`" lgwa fwea mhyhw fqeqv yawh fgvgwea mhfav

nblav|gv" Fg{ la o lba`la H`hb ng|à% ba gt|gwovtqb? 4:: fgb loehv" He chvlag`"Fqbehvb maztg `hcfq{eqlqv% yavngeavg lab`g|gv wocth tweaà`"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Hbehl`"HWLGB LOHB @hcfq{tq{% yavngtg{ la fgv aw whz`hw{" Fwea `|ahllg| laihehv

oe`q|qv fqbehv"FHCHB Aya|% lqvq` yq{qmh chyq|q"g`lg% fab fgv mh|veh|`hw wabglab whz|c|hb tobvh t{ Dabng{ Whygoeq Fawa

yavadag`" \ozehb|wh 84"4:h chlhv hvhyavadag` lhmh tobvh wabglab 84"4:lh fqvhlhFq mh|veh|`hw fgv ca{ lhmh whzhdh` Co`gtwob Fhchb tih|weh; @adegt

hvh|v`h co`gtwobehvbb gbdaeaàeavg% h`h ya tobq fhc`blhb whvn àvdgeavgweatovq|qv`h co`gtwobehvblhb ihvce fgv nvay gih a|àc|algv" @adegt hvh|v`h co`gtwobehvbb

h`hd% mqcqcg hbeh`lh `qehc fgv ày{qwq g{hmh chyq|qv`hc lagelgv" Fq balabea%hvh|v`h co`gtwobehvbb |atzg| ya bavgeavg cggeav eamgba wh lh heawmgba whvn àvdgeavgblageavg tveaàwadag ngfg% cggeavg hceh`h wh lh tqeq nt|avà ngfg fgv geay lanvààc|algv" \vcgwa Fwc @geea| @adegtgbgb Chbqbehv Chvhvehv Nabae @lvebb fgvfhyqvq {avgba yav`g oelqq mqcqcg `|hehhlhb fgv vbac ocqlq`"

Co`gtwobq`q{h q hb g|gfhvweh hvh yavadag{% |h`hèhwh`hwhdh`{ ggb" TovqwqDabng{ Whygegoeqbh yavadag`% dayhzehblvlc|hb tobvh yavlgg`g{ hvhlhb tobvh 84"4:lh|acvhv fgv hvhwh naeàc {ava hvh yavadag`"

Dabng{ Faw% fqwqvqb"DABN[ WHYEOEQ -Av{qvq`' Thwb Lohb% mo naelgbg{"HWLGB LOHB \aaccv alavg` aiablg`"DABN[ WHYEOEQ -Av{qvq`' Cobq`hb{h fhehvcab naelgg`la Tav`hwa

àlwh hvhtblhcg gegcgwg la fhbh tovhvtb{% fwea ocche tovqehv oeqv% fab ladayhzehblvv`" la`g|gbg{" Fab la ocche oe`hth lh tav`hwaàlwh hvhtblh gegcgeavlabtovq tovhdh`"

g`lg fgvgbdgtg% 6= qfh| lba`gbla Thwb Fgengbg la tg{lab bda lgbealgc HBHZfh|h oe`hc {ava mcà|eavg lat|acealgbg{" O |hvgmgb bdatgbla navaceaàlgg mhela% olba`la ZOH ya Lfhbc ngfg gvca| ya fhbchehv helb{" ZOH hevcab bda w{la 18mgttatgbgwhbe mh|veh`wovth` gmheatg{ he`|b{"

HWLGB LOHB Aya|% gmheatg{"DABN[ WHYEOEQ -Av{qvq`' Hchfgbla lgav mgttaeavgbg% h{bec mgttaeavgbg

he`|b{ ya ZOH helb{lh igbhbt`hbb{b wgba whbe mh|veh`wovth` |h`h`bch`q fhbchehvblhb cvalgwea he`|b{" Wgba o lba`la aygc Fgv tg{gb aygbg{la lba`gbyhegtg Avoe hcveh nv`|" Nvàbgb hchfgbla t|hbfqelh oehbehv mazg`g{gb

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

12/37

\ F @ @



mhi{hehvblhlv% fwea la fgv navacegc O lba`la Tqe|hbfawegla% Cccwla% {aeegcea

`qmhih{hcv lbwhwh wbaegc fhtcehv mh|vewovq{" Wgba% Fawh{ \Ylacg awg twealgbg{% obqfab oc ih{eh gvlaeaàlab naadag`" Tovq` q; Mcà|eava fq lat|ac gea fq gvca|eavghe`hb{ hvhtblh fgv fhehb|% fgv gegcg yhv `?

cgbdgtg% Mcà|eavg bgwa lat|acealgbg{? Htcaveavea fhehb|b{ oelqq fq aynvàeavgbla la faeeg whbg ay nvàeavgbla wea fgv {a`gb oeq|qv`q|qbq{" Fwea fgvfhehb|b{b oe`hlb twewovtqbq{ h`h fwea fgv fhehb| yhv ngfg lqvqwov" Lhmhtobvhtblh {aeea|gvàlab fhch gmhea whbe mh|veh`wovth` he`hlb{ whbg o lba`tobvhtblh" Lhmh bda hehfgelggbg{ mhela% lba` tobvhtblh fq gmheaeavg heh`h`hb{bnavacatg ba oehfgegv?

ZOHb lblh fgv fhch tovq` lh% @geegwa| nh{a|atgbla% wgba 6= qfh| lba`gblateh`g tav`hwawa fwc fhtcb `hba|eg wh{ehv yhvl% fq fgv `lla| layh` a|`g|g"

Hchfgbla Cobwh ya Chwtavgla wage tav`hwawa |vbhc gavgtgbla fhtcehv oelq% g hlhèhv|q|qcehbl" Fqbehveh gengeg ba lbwovtqbq{? Fq tvadgb whhb`htweh hehche balbwovtqbq{? Fgv la 6= qfh|b hteblh fgv tav`hwa lhvfatg oelqq tweabgwov" Fqcobqlh lh lbdaeavgbg{ baeavlgv?

HWLGB LOHB Ayyaeh Thwb Yacgeg`% |aaccv alavg`% n{ae aweav tovlqbq{wheb{ whbe fgengeavgbg{ yhv" Fgv laih% aav 6= qfh| 87796::: lba`g lgwovthb{% fab olba`la mgfgv gmhea he`hl`" Obq fgv laih tweawawg`"

ZOH h|b{% ab|avathb" \h`hàb whbe fgengbg{ yhv" ZOH |aeayg{woblh hchv||v`hwh chvel% |aeayg{woblh aw whzel" Tob oehvhc gcg nvqz chel% Co ya hmabcNvqfq% vhmà|eg Hwmhb hmabc% g`lgcg Iavg|gb Obehv fgv cobtovtgwq` oehvhc ngv`g|g"

FHCHB Zhvlob% oc {v lgeawavac t{b{ catadag`" Fg{ lba`

laaveablgvàtg whzhvcab 6::< weblhb g|gfhvab fheh|wovq{ tvadg"HWLGB LOHB wea `g? Zacg"IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' 877

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

13/37

\ F @ @



maàb tweawawg`; q hblh fg{ Yhciehv Fhbchtweh oc gwg hewovq{% ab gwg `|avgeavgblab

fgvgtg fg{g{" Ba zhvh lh gt|atac yavgwovehv h`h fg{ he`wovq{" Cvalg lalggbg{ aw mgfa lagelgvcg" Naegb fabg` moelgbngb chztbh% Laq|tdma Fhbcblhb @avgee Ewbdmba chlhv maztg H`hbtg{a cvalg yavaeg`" lgwa qvhwovehv" Fqvhlh gcg |hba fwc whbeb{ yhv% fgv; Fab ch`qfhbchehvblhb cvalg cqeehb`hl`" cg; Za|voe Oigtgbg fab gmheatg{ he`hl`"

Fhch ba yhvl? Avoe hcveh aygc Fgvgb fg{g` ayla oelqqbq th`g`gwa|eamh|veh`wovq` h`h aygc Zhhweh fab hgeada nvv `wl`? Aàceg oelqc|hb tobvhnv|` la% aàceg oe`hlhb ayyae nv|` fge`gwovq` ihch| qbq fgegwovq` cgt|hbfqelh 8" Ovlq co`q|hbehvweh fab layhè% àteag` loehwtweh Dq`mqvgwa|Fhwvhèhvblh vataztgwobehv yavgveav% ovhehvh nglavg` |hbvl`" Obehv lh nabaeegcea% 8"Ovlqlhb naeabeav la Chvh Cqyya|eavgba% Nabaecqv`hwh naelgceavg ggb Nabaecqv`hwlhcgeaveala |hbv`% maztgwea nvv` la% {cc Zhhweh lh nvvl`% Chvhlhwweh lh

nvvl`% aygc Fgvea la nvvl`% Fhfq Zhhweh lh nvvl` h`h fqnvà`gb tq oelqqbq yawh fgv nh{a|a thmgfg htcaveavea nvaà{ lgwa fgv awoelqqbq lh chfqe a|`gwovq`" Fwea favhfav o|qvlqbq{% favhfav chvhv yavlgbg{% tgwhtgFqbehv |h`hàb amgv aithbatg% fwea aweav oe`h{"

HBHZ lat|acealgbg{ `g? Mhwv" Obq hbeh|`h` eh{`" \vcgwala fgv tcb| lolq"FHCHB oc {v lgegwovq`" Fqbq% h`hb{ htblhb tovqwh gehya|ab fgv tovqweh

fabHWLGB LOHB Fqwqvqb"FHCHB Tg{lab bda Lgb Fgengbg lgbealgc ya lhmh bda la ag|eg fhtb

àbtqzehvb lgbealgc" Fqbehvb fgvoq lh tg{gb nvqfqbq{lh hehb hvchlhehvl ya lgavnvqzehvlh lh O lba`la tgwhtg fgv cq|qzeh`h oelqqbq% fq cq|qzeh`h avayatg

gavgtgbla Lgb Fgengb Faw hc wvacegegcea lalg cg; Fab% \hbtq geeavg ya Lovq Woe Zhv|gtgbglat|acegwovlq`% Hwlb Lohb lh @atq| We`h{ lat|acegwovlq" Loehwtweh hteblhhvh`{lhcg chynh o lba`gb cqvqehb cohegtwobehv Fq wovq`q fab whzwovq`% whbgtgwhta|gb acgeeablgvgeàtg cobqtqblh hteblh fhtb hc|gi fgv voe owbhl" Fqbq lhmh bdalgbealgg`g{ fhtb àbtqzehv lh twealg" Fqbehv ggbla% hteblh tg{gb ya cablgeavgbgb t|l{aw wba|gdgeavgbgb la {h`hb {h`hb tgwhtgeava ng||gceavgbg% fh{ `geea|yacgeeavg |vhbtiaveavg lalmge oe`hc {ava oehwh lovqlhb `lhmge oelqqbq{ whbg fhtb nvayegeavgbgb lblh lgwa|hbèhwhfgeadag`g{ \hclgv alavtgbg{ cg% fhtbb laòcvh|gc ecaeavlacg voeb tg{ la ocn{ae fgv acgela |hbèhlb{ h`h fq |hbèhlb{ nvaya qw`hwhdhc acgela tgwhta|gb fgvacgela lg{hwb algeàtgbla voe owbhlb{ ya wba|gdgeavgbg{ chbheweh lh owbhbl gllghehvlh yhv"

Fq gcg tovqwq fgvegc|a dayhzehblvvthb{ faecg hcec ch{hblv` oehfgegv" Lovqtqfab tovqehv` ab tobqblh tovqwovq` h`h fqbq gehya he`ht htblhb tovlq`"

HWLGB LOHB \aaccv alavg` Thwb Fhchb"\h` hbeh|hdh` awg tovlqbq{ fhbh% fab la obq hbeh|hdhc|`" Fabg` @atq| Fawg

lat|aceaà`% \hbtq Mhb` lat|aceaà` lgwa fgv aw woc|q" Oehw qvhlhb chwbhcehbl"Thfhm nh{a|atg \hbtq Mhb` lat|aceaàwa fhehl ya fg{gèa la vachfa|gbg layhà||gvgwovlq" Fg{ la \hbtq Mhb`h chvwlc" bc {ewovq` fqbehv tweavcab \hbtqMhb`b Hàvgchlhcg `he yhveb whwbeh`|c fg{" \hbtq Mhb`h chv oelqq`q{ ggbihehb lage% catgbegcea" Fg{ nh{a|adgegc whz|c% mh||h vhmà|eg o nh{a|adg hvchlh`{ |he|gi a||gc"Vhmà|eg oelq \qvhb Whyq{" Fwea fgv oehw \vcgwabgb nbla`gba chvl ggb% na|gvlgg

ggb" O mhfavlab tobvh% \hbtq Mhbèh hvh`{lh fgv egòbg whbg mht`hba laàwawg` h`hfgv navgeg` oelq" Fq bhte oelq fab la fgea`gwovq`" Fab cablg`g% fgvlabfgva fqbqb gavgtgblafqelq`" Lgb Fgengb Nvqfq lh lhmh {gwhla \hbtq Mhb` lat|aceav oelq" Fg{ @atq| Fawa

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

14/37

\ F @ @



7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

15/37

\ F @ @



Fge`gwovq` |h|`gb alafgelg` `g% faecg cobqwq lh||` h`h? Ba tovhfgegvg` cg?

Fabg` vgdh` fwea lglgc lglgc tovqb fhbh"Mav awg tovqb cg Lav|eg tweanab oeqv" fab lahbeh|hw` mav awg whbg"FHCHB oc |aaccv algwovq{" Fgv hvh yavadag{" 84"4:lh |ozehb`hc {ava

Chzhb`h Thh|g; 86"41

CBD O\QVQ@He`h Thh|g; 84"4:

FHCHB; Bgà| FH -t|hbfqe':

FHCHB Laaveg hvchlhehv% mg yhcg| chwfa|àlab |acvhv fhewovq{"Dabng{ Whygegoeq Faw% hel dayhz chvtblh cth fgv hceh`h whz`hc gt|gwov% o

hceh`hlhb tobvh cth fgv dayhz lh helc|hb tobvh lgav `geea|yacgeeavg`g{a t{ yavàwalayh` aladag`"

Dabng{ Faw% fqwqvqb"

DABN[ WHYEOEQ -Av{qvq`' Aya|"Mgttatg{ oehvhc% gmheatg{ oehvhc heblb twea`g oelqq` ctèh gengeg oehvhc

89/:>/6::6 |hvgmgbla |oz|hb th|ehv zh{hvblh w{la 61%=egc mgttawg cht|algwovq` fab"HWLGB LOHB Mhbng |hvgm|g aiablg`?DABN[ WHYEOEQ -Av{qvq`' 89/:>/6::6"HWLGB LOHB 6::6% aya|"DABN[ WHYEOEQ -Av{qvq`' Fqvhlh |oz|hb th|ehv zh{hvblh 61"=egc ct`

|hegmtg{ fgv acgela th|b helb{ cht|a||gg`g tweawawg`" Fqvhlh tg{gb `vhdhh|b{ {avgba|oz|hb th|ehv zh{hvblhb fq mgttawg th|b he`hc gt|alggbg{ aeg`la chw|ehv lh yhv" Fqbqbehgengeg la Lohb Za|voe Wh|v`dehv Hwa th|bb whze`ht fq @WC chvhv% o |hvgmeg @WCchvhv gec laàbgb w{la 4: zagb oehvhc mgttaeavgb |ateg`gbla% g{eawab laàeavgb gta welh w{la 6:% w{la 4: Fq acgela fgv ovhbeh`h whze`" Fgvgbdgtg fq% tweaàc gt|alggàw" Loehwtweh% fq fabg` gmheatg{ lalgg` ct` |h`h`b chzth`wov" [h|ab% w{la 18egcct`b tg{gb lalggbg{ acgela oelqqbq fg{eav la fgegwovq{% whbg gmheawea whzelb" Fqvhlh%|hfgg% fgv ct` mgttabgb la lhb`hb igv`h tag`gbla Lhb`hb igv`h tagegvcab wqv| ligv`hehv lhb`hb igv`h oehvhc {aeea|gvà lhvatgblab hvewov% 8: igv`h" Laq|tdma Fhbcfqbehvlhb fgvgtg" Fq lh wqv| gg mgttaeavgb th| ggb fq wa|cgtgbg Wh|v` @abcqe Laaveav Hhvhdeweh cqeehb`hc gt|gwov% fq lh chfqe algegwov" Fgv la ggb fq wb yhv" Fqbq hcechyqtqb lgwa g{hm a|àc gt|alg`"

HWLGB LOHB @thhla alav `gtgbg{% fab% obh dayhz yavawg`"Fgv; Fgv laih% fab% gec tovqbq{q ZOHG gmheatg{ helb{" lalggbg{ ggb Whbe

fgegwovtqbq{"DABN[ WHYEOEQ -Av{qvq`' Fqbq cht|alavac% o fgvh{ h`hdb h` oelq"

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

16/37

\ F @ @



HWLGB LOHB Fab ZOH gmheawea hel` bc 6::: weblh ZOH he`|c"

Fg{a% layea|% wba|g` mgttatgbg th||c|hb tobvh% lgav mgttaeavgb {aeea|gv`a lhvatg ch`qwhh| fgv ct`b% th|h`hl% tobvh wqv| lblh loeh| th|`hc ggb gavgla ya lhvlhcgzh{hvehvh" Aegbla% {hbbalgwovq`% w{la

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

17/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;8>

IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Tovq`q{% tg{% Lgb Fgengblab vablgg`g{%

nh{a|aeavlab ocqlqq`q{ ya nh{a|aeavla wgba chb% {ov {h`hbehvblh Dq`mqvgwa|a yaThfhm nh{a|atgba"""HWLGB LOHB [ov {h`hbehvblh% ThfhmIAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' [ov {h`hbehvblhHWLGB LOHB Aya|"IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' C|% yathgva la whvl`d oelqbq{% fq

whvl`tayaveggbg{lab loehw `% wocth fgvgeavgbgb tg{a fqbq fwea whz`hb{ tweablgg ggb`g? Ba| hlh` oelqqbq{ ggb fqbehvh lh ba| dayhz yavadagbg{g lbavac twewovq`"Lgav |hvhi|hb% fqvhlh lh cobq|qbq{% mav {h`hb lh nvl`{ la o% tg{% cg`tawa fowqbaàlab whhlb{% gbhb`hlb{ awg la whz`hlb{ twewovtqbq{ maz" Fg{ la tg{gbtwealggbg{g hwbab chfqe algwovq{" Hbdhc% 6= qfh| bdatgbla nh{a|a `hba|eavgbg{la% ma`

@geegwa||a ma` la Thfhm|h fgvoc `hba|eav yhvl h`h fqbehvlhb ab baègeavg3 v|gdhwhchv |ozwacb thyh%\amlglgb hl gv|gdh% Ovlqlhb tob qwhv% Navacgvta tgehm fgeacqeehbv{ ngfg% tv`hba|eav cg fqbh fab{av fgvoc whwbehvb{ lh oelq" Fh|h tv`hba| fq"Fq `hba|eavlacg fq t{eavgb th`g`gwa|gba gbhbwov `qwlqbq{% fgengbg{ lmgegbla `gwlg?

cgbdgtg% aav bhb`wovq`% mhwv gta% fq `hba|eavg tg{a h||vhb n bawlg?\aaccv alavg`"HWLGB LOHB g`lg |ac |ac fhehwhe`" Nh{a|aeavgb cqvqbehb`ht |gdhvg fgv

vachfa| Fabg` g mhwh|`lh mg chvc fgv |gdhvg gegcg` oe`hl" Fwea tgehmeh% |hfhbdhwehhehcht oehb cg`taeavea la mgfgv {h`hb g gegcg` oe`hl" La`gb twealgg` ngfg% 8717weblhb favg yavng `caeeaigwg` whbg aeeg welvfhfh`b whbblhcg vhcec lba`g` mhvgg mhwh|bb ggblawg`% maz hc ya aiihi oelq`" Fgbhabheawm |gdhvg fgv vachfa||ab fabg`

nh{a|aeavg` cqvqbehb`h{" Fh| he`h Nvqfq `q cqvqbeh||" Fqbq lh% Fh| he`hNvqfqbqb fg{g` nh{a|aeavg cqvqbeh|`ht ggb mavmhbng fgv tafaz nva`gwovq` h`h`baddg` la lageg`" g`lg mhwv lh lgwaà` aya| la lgwaà` ihch| fab mgfgv {h`hbTob cqvqbehb`htblh fab la nh{a|alawlg`% tag` nadatg cqvqbehbl% odqcehv` lhnh{a|alawlg fg{ |alfgv oehvhc nh{a|abgb gbthb fowq oehb ctèhvb cqvqb nagvà{ whz|c"me o fgbhlh obehv lqvqwov" H`h |gdhvg vachfa| mg mh|v`lhb naàlg" Fh| he`hNvqfqbqb fhbh nva fhch aweav whz`ht eh{` aav whzhdhcth" Fg{gèa bgwa qvhtb%fqbq fgea`gwovq` whbg fwea fgv aw oe`h`|v% balab cqvqbehblb @hiwhweh lhqvh|c% tgwhta|ea la qvh|c% ovlqweh lh qvh|c% g ayvaeavgwea la qvh|c" Cg` whz|?Zoegt la o {h`hb fgv aw yavàlg" Fg{a twealgceavg g|a Naab thvmoehv h||"% Yqvlq%ch|ehv" Woelhb h|a a||geav" h`h fg{ la aw whz`hlc% fgea`gwovq` obq"

\vcgwa fhch fgv \vcgwa oehdhc" Fab fwea fgv aw mh|veh`wovq`" Fgv awmh|vewovq`% nh{a|aeavla `|avac chb fgv fhe; Mhwlg \vcgwa geavg lgwa" O {h`hb 877 weblh fab \vcgwa whvb fhch fgv \vcgwa oehdhc lgwa fgv aw

mh|veh`wovq`" Hvchlhehv% fhc|vwov"FHCHB Mhwlg \vcgwa geavg \hbtq geeavgb tag` teonhbwl" Tgwhtg oehvhc fgv

mh|veh|`h whz`hc gt|alg`"HWLGB LOHB Tag` {h`hbblh lage% \hbtq geeav Fhfhchbcab layhehtwob

tobvht \vcgwala fgv chot oehdhc lgwa covcqelq" fwc nh{a|ala Mhwlg \vcgwa geavg

lgwa `hba|eav h|el" Wheb{ o lba`la Mvvgwa|gb thmgfg lagelg`% @geegwa|gb thmgfgwlg`"Aya|% obq h||c% obq twealgc h`h fqbq fge`gwovq`" Hvchlhehv fhcwov% tweawadaceav"IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Lgb Fgengba c| whvl` whz|b{"

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

18/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;8=

HWLGB LOHB Whz|`% maàb tobqdqbq tweawawg`" Meab la < `gewob loehv

hehdh` yhv% heh`wovq`" Ba \qvnhw Dgbav fq fovdh thmgz c|% Fhbh ba Lgbgb fovdqlalg" Hmà| hec|hb {h|ab fwea fgv |heaz|a fqeqb`hwh mhcc` woc" O layea||ab% \hthvvqi@aylqh| Tgnov|h Iobqblhb hel" Fg{g` < `gewob loehv ng||g hbehwhdhb" Ba whz|b tab fqchlhv% HegDabhz `tb% hz|he `tb whbg naeaba loehv ` lh|wovtqb? Mhwv% loehvlh|`wovq` h`h fqbq gbhblv`hc {ov"

Vhmà|eg Feab| Adayg| fhbh |aeaiob a||g% lalg cg; Fq nh{a|adgeav aw la chehdhc lgwafab {ewovq`" Feab| Adayg| nh{a|adgeav cobqtqblh oc mhttht|" |ab chve`htcobqtqblh lh mhttht|" Mh||h @geegwa| nh{a|atgbgb th|bb beabàtgbla la Feab| Adayg|gbya Mthà||gb Dgblovqcqb fwc a|cgeavg oe`q|qv" O aw chta|eavg chvel% Igcvg Thehvna|gvlg"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Covc`h{ Wgg|"

HWLGB LOHB @hiwhweh Covc`h{ Wgg| gea `hiwh fgvegg Hehh||gbhcdbb g fgvegg" Feab| Faw fhtb {avgbla mhttht lhyvhbvl% @geegwa| nh{a|atgcobqtqblh lh lhmh mhttht|"

IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Dq`mqvgwa| yhv fgv la"HWLGB LOHB Dq`mqvgwa||aIAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' C| whvl` ya fht` whvl` cobqtqblh"HWLGB LOHB Hbeh|hdh` aiablg`" Thfhm nh{a|atgba o lba`la `hhehvh lh

whvl` a||g` {h`hb {h`hb nh{a|a chzh|e`htb lgwa" Fq fgv àteacg lhwhb`hlv h`hawlab àvmhà||ab q{hvh| ` lohv laveav" wea fgv |hfgv yhvlv"

FHCHB @hvh{"HWLGB LOHB @ateacg lhwhb`h gavgbla oehe`% Thfhm nh{a|atgba whvl`

alaeg` awg gavgtgbla th`g`gwa|ea ya hv| bgwa|tg{ whz|c" Tobvh% lalgeav cg; Nh{a|awg wba|g`ghe|bh he`hc ggb% nh{a|awg cablg gt|algg ngfg wbeablgvàc ggb fqbq whz|" @hhehvyavàtac cg`ta `hh heh`wovlq% c| yavàtac nh{a|awg fhth`wovehvl% < `gewob loehvlh zhvh` ng||g% ggb lovqtq fqlqv"

Dq`mqvgwa| nh{a|atgba naegbda% Dq`mqvgwa| nh{a|atgba fwea fgv awg` oe`hl"Dq`mqvgwa| nh{a|atgbg meab fg{ fhtwovq{% fg{ lh|wovq{% zhvhtb lh hewovq{" Dq`mqvgwa|nh{a|atgba thlada mhech h`h he|blh chvlcehvblh fab 61: fgb loehvec mgtta hel`Dq`mqvgwa| nh{a|atgblab" Fgelgg` chlhvweh \qvnhw Dgbav lhmh fwc mgtta hel" Obehv fabggengeablgvà{" Tobvh fqvhlhb qhh fgbavcab Dq`mqvgwa| Mhec Zhv|gtgbla faealgwafhchbe lh whz|" Dq`mqvgwa|gb ov|h oelq wh"

HE VG[H [\VC -@avtgb' Nvf{ hzhb"HWLGB LOHB Nvf{ hzhb fhbh qhc|h vht|ehl" Fab obq gec laih nvl`%

fwea wctac tatea Wh hhfaw% fq nh{a|awg thbh yavaeg` ihehb lalg" Fab ayva`labq|hbl`% ba oeqwovq{ fwea% mavcat fhbh fhcwov% bgwa fhbh yavgwov% ba whzwov lgwa" Fabg`nh{a|a` yhv% ba whzhdh` fab nh{a|awg" lalg`" Ng||g` t|hbfqeh 1: fgb loehv yav`g|gbg{%chehb laàwgb fab Dq`mqvgwa|a ihehb ov|hc oe`hc gt|a`gwovq` lalg`" MeabDq`mqvgwa|gb mathzehvblh fab 1: fgb loehvec ov|hc nvbwovq`% mavmela fq ovhlhbchwbhcehbwov" Mgfgv {ae gegcg` woc h`h Dq`mqvgwa| nh{a|atg \vcgwabgb ab atcgnh{a|atglgv% whh`ht eh{`lv% whwov" Whwb zoeg|gcht obehvb cablg lbwh nveavglgv%fabg la gengeablgvà{% Dq`mqvgwa||a oehb% Lgb Fgengbea oehb lh twealg`"

6= qfh| `hba|eav Mgfgv `hba|g`g{a% mgfgv awg`g{a htcaveavgb fgv lhmeg

oe`h`|v" Bg|acg` gt|avtabg{ fqvhlh nt|avafgegvg`% 6= qfh|b ab hv `hba|eavgblabfgvgtgbg fab h||`" Hefvgnm|" @hba| fqvhlh nhegfh Hefvgnm|3 \vcgwala laòcvhtg lwba|gèava chvw{ lalg" Fg{ la `hba||ab Hefvgnm|3 laòcvhtg l wba|gèava chvw{

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

19/37

\ F @ @



lalg lgwa% `hba| h||c" Fq htcaveavg la vhmh|t{ a||g h`h fg{; Fg{g` nvayg`g{ fq% fg{

laòcvhtg l mav awa chvw{ lalgc" O lba`la hteblh tcb| Cvg{eav HFL àthk;Lgeavg Fhchb Hefvgnm|% Hbchvhwh laòcvh|gc l{abgb lbh ce`h`ht navac|ggbgfgelgvlgc lgwa"

IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Fab fgvch `hba|HWLGB LOHB Tweawadag` aiablg`"g`lg% twealggbg{ `hba|eavlab la aweav chvhw`% fqvhlh Ba lgwovlqbq{%

`hba|% htcavea% layea|ea Tgehmt{ cqyya|eav mheea|tgb" Fqbq tweawab {h`hbb Labg{Cqyya|eavg Co`q|hb" Lgwov cg; Fq taiav tgehmt{ cqyya|eav mheea|tgb" Fhbh nva gwg fgvnh{a|adgegc whze`" cg fhc`lhb3 ma` laòcvhtg fhc`blhb whbg Fg{ fq g|a wocq{%"tgehmt{ cqyya|eav3 @adegt mheea|tgb% tgwhtg zhv|geav mheea|tgb" Lgwov% fg{ wea wovqèqwovq{%ma` la Fg{ fq ga chv`hw{" lgwov h`h baèg fgv mhfavlgv" Fg{ ae cowhdh{" lh

latawlg% o lh baèg fgv mhfavlg% whzevl" Fg{g` chwbhb nt|avavac% q qbq twealg%Tgehmt{ cqyya|eav mheea|tgb" woc Tgehm cqeehbv{" lgwa fwea fgv Navacgvta tgehmcqeehbv{ lgwa la fgv `hba| yhv" Fg{g` nh{a|aeavgb nvayg fabda vatg` acgz mhecb bbacow`hc|v" Fhc% fwea lalg" Wovq`q mhec whztb" Fhc lalg cg; Navacgvta tgehm cqeehbv`lalg" Cg` lalg? Ihehb Zhh lalg" Ba lalg? Lalg cg; Tgehmt{ cqyya|eav mheea|tgb" Fabg`th`g`g fgv chbhh|g`g tweawawg`" \vcgwala laòcvhtg% ba {h`hb gbc|hh qvhlwth olba`lacg tgwhtgeavgb wba|g` |hv{ehvblhb chwbhcehbl" Aav% tgwhtgeav `qc|algv oeqvehvth% olaòcvhtg l neava chv lgc lqvqvehvth fqbehv oe`h{" Bg|acg` fqbqb tob vbagbg 6>Bgthb @qm|vhtblh 6::>la `qm|vh thw`hwhe` àc|qfqblh% Mcà| lgc lqvlq" AavMcà| navg hl` h|thwl {hbbalgwovq` cg lhmh oc {avgba naeadac|g h`h Mcà| lgclqvlqq ggb fgv lhmh lhvfa |amegcatg oe`hl"

Fab qbq tweaàc gt|gwovq`" Bqv ggbla wh|tb% Heehm vhmà| aweatgb% Avfhchb lhlaaveg fgv \vc tgwhta|gtgwlg% àèaca|amg{à|eavg la yhvl" Fab mgfgv {h`hb cablgtgwea`q|hfc oe`hl` h`h n{ae mg{à|eav la whz|" Aav o {h`hb% Wae|tgb ngfg |hbcb {avgbacthwl% bhte Wae|tgb C{e àwlhblh |hbcb {avgba c|wth% htcaveav la fwea geavgnglaà{eavlg" \hbtq Mhb` o {h`hb lgwov cg; Fg{ nvaylab hehdhc|c% Dq`mqvfhchbg`{heh`h{ lgwa he`hlc" Fq fabg oc gengeablgvà{ h`h tg{ nvaylab hevlb{%Dq`mqvfhchb lh g`{heh`h{th mhech lbavlgbg{" Fhc% tg{ fg{g ta|gbg{ fqvhwh na|gvlgbg{%wba|a`gwovq{% heb a`hba| tg{a lavlgbg{" Fab ih{eh tgwhtg bq|qc h|`hwhw` h`h tg{ayavadag` dayhz fqlqv"

Fhch h|ehl` fgv awFHCHB H|eh`h oehvhc lage la"""IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Tovqehvh ba| dayhz gt|a`g|gc" Obq heh`hlcHWLGB LOHB Mhbngtgbg?#FHCHB Fab% fgv% mqtqth lgcch| acàc htblhb twewovq` whbg o lba`la

@hlaeagba Hefvgnm|h lhwhbhvhc whzehb mhfav @geegwa| nh{a|atgbla 84 qfh| 877> Zava`fa|hvgmgbla Ehgcegc qwhvt fheweh cwov" Mhfav Whta`gb obnhv g`{he

HWLGB LOHB Zhvlob% ehgcegc batg aiablg`?FHCHB Ehgcegc qwhvt Whbg% tg{ fgvh{ bda Hefvgnm|b mhfavgb laòcvhtgwa

thmgz chb ya \vcgwalacg laòcvh|gc tgt|a`gb geaveggba lhgv fgv mhfav oehvhc yavlgbg{ ya\vcgwabgb ehgc fgv eca oe`ht fg{g` h`{lhb oc baèg% fq cobqwqFhfhchb Avfhchbhlh gea||gc gihlatgba wav yavgwov" Mhfavgb `hba|a acgeàtg% tzo| t| fhecehv nblaèa

zhvheae henehb`ht htblhb% hteblh o lba`gb tgwhthe gc|glhvbh HFLlab la fgv qwhvnaelgg ghva|g |hwov" Hwvdh gc|glhv ehgcegc lblh fgv wba|g` cqv`hwh hewov`q yaHàvgch fq cobqlh qwhvlh fqeqbqwov`q hent oeq|qvhvhc ch`qowqbqb Vaihm Zhv|gtgbgb

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

20/37

\ F @ @



tgwhtg gc|glhvbb laòcvhtg lblh fgv hvhw ggbla oelqqbq yqvnqehwhb fgv mhfav" Whbg h{

bda @hlaeagba Hefvgnm|b \vcgwalacg laòcvh|gc tgt|aà @geegwa||a mhfavgb wav heacegbg ya mhbng nh{a|adgbgb g`{htweh whwbehblb ocq`hc gt|alg`% fgv mh|veh|`hhtblhb"

HWLGB LOHB Fab o {h`hb tweawawg` gt|avtabg{" Mhfavg n{ect{ ocq`hwhhewovq`; Cvg{a HFL àthk" Lgeavg Fhchb Hefvgnm|% Hbchvhwh laòcvh|gc l{abgblbb ce`h`ht navac|ggbg fgelgvlgc lgwov" Mhfavgb t| fhe lh fq" He| fhec|h lgwov cg;\vcgwala laòcvh|gc% ehgc l{abgb

FHCHB Hwb nh{a|awg `g ocqwovq{% Hwlb Faw hdhfh?HWLGB LOHB 8< Mh{gvhbFHCHB 84 qfh| 877> Zava`fa% @geegwa|"HWLGB LOHB Fab 8< Mh{gvhb 7>wg ocqwovq`" g`lg% fhcb% ovhlh lh

FHCHB cgtg la hwb chwbhc oelqq ggb twewovq` whbg fq gwg vbaceavgb whbtvh fq vbaceav la yhv"

HWLGB LOHB Fq vbac c| vbac lage" Ehgcega mg cg`ta chv lage" [h|abHbhwhthbb ehgcegc hbh gecaeavg Ehgc% totwhe mqcqc layea|gwg{ lage `g? O fhc`lhb whbgEhgcega thmgz c|ehv" ehib fwea henehwhfgegvtgbg{% lovqlqv h`h

FHCHB Hàvgchlhb fwea fgv qwhv nae`g ya fq Avfhchbh gea|ge`g acegblafgv mhfav glg"

Bawta fab awa natgb htblhb twealg`"Aya|"HWLGB LOHB Fhch tg{a yavàlgg` dayhz yhv ` aiablg`?IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' g`lg% Hwlb Faw% fab tg{lab ba| tovqehv

tovlq`% q{qb tovqehvtov`hl`% ba| tovqehv`h lh ba| dayhzehv gt|alg` h`h tg{ faecg cablggt|algceavgbg{g cobq|qbq{" Fabg` tovqehv`b dayhf obehv lage"

HWLGB LOHB @ataeh mhbngtgba dayhz yavàlg` aiablg`?IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Hv|c {h`hb lh oc na|g" Ovhlh {h|ab

cobqqehbehvb maztg awa ngvlgg ggbHWLGB LOHB @thhla algb% fab {a|eawawg`"Tg{gb nh{a|abg{ |gdhvg `g cqvqbehbl? Mhwv"IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Obehv lage" Hv|cHWLGB LOHB \vcgwa fhch fgv \vcgwa oehdhc fheb mh|veh`hl`

lgwovq`% bhte loehwe dayhz? Lgb Fgengba% aya|% c| yavlg`% < `gewob loehv lhIAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Mhwv" Fab lalg` cg; Fq `hba|eava tg{

gbhbwov `qwlqbq{% wocth gbhb`hlb{ mela fqbehv whwèh`hc {ovqblh ` glgbg{?bc tg{ bhb`hl` aweavg whz`h`" lalgbg{ la% obqb ggb twealg`"

HWLGB LOHB Fhcb% fgv aw lhmh tweawawg` ayyaeh" [hbbalgwovtqbq{ cgfqvhlh |ozq |hdh h|`hc ggb twea`gwovq` nh{a|a thmgzeavg nh{a|aeavla chb f|bmhfavlab% `hba||ab mhfavg oeqv" bhb`hb{ gt|gwovq`% fab la fgv oc awg tg{gb ngfg av|atgnb nvv` whbg lhvlhb fhcel ngfg lagelgv" Fabg` nh{a|aeavg`la 8: fgbgb {avgblahlh` hewov" Fqbehvb maztg Nabae gecaeav yavge`g|gv% nabae gecaeavgb lblh mav nbchb `hba| weac|% he|blh ba yhvlv% ba woc|qv lgwa fgeà` h`h {a| oehvhc lgwovq`cg; Fab w{la 7=gblab fgeng` yhvlv ya laòcvhtg l chb `hba|eava la fab `thhlaa|à` lgwovq`" H`h g`lg tg{ fhbh o welh na|gvge`g `hba| g`lg% fgvh{ ayyae Thwb

Fhchbb twealgg mhfavla laFHCHB oc |aaccv alavg{" g`lg% wea fgv lqvq` yhv; Whbg actgc chelblblb{ mqtqtehv oeqv gta aav lhmh tobvh fqbehv wh{e ya lhmh hwvb|e% la|hwe

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

21/37

\ F @ @



dayhzehblvhfgegvtgbg{" Tva oehvhc oc tbve fgv tvawa thmgfg{% wgv`gwgv`g fa lhcgch

gavgtgbla |h`hèh`hc {ovqblhw{"T{ tvhtweh yavadag`% bdaegceg |heazeava nva"HWLGB LOHB Aav tg{ {h`hb hwvvthb{ fab nb faceavg` Hbchvhlh"FHCHB @hheatai% {nb`% wea fgv {h`hb hwvh`hwhdh{"lvgt hmgb Fawa t{ yavgwovq`"HWLGB LOHB lvgt Faw fqwqvqb"FHCHB @`cb oelqq chlhv dayhzehv lh tovqehvh ba|% cth dayhzehblvhvhc

|h`hèhvthcHWLGB LOHB \hfgg"LVT HMB -hbcv' Thwb Lohb mo naelgbg{ |acvhvlhb"HWLGB LOHB Mo fqelqc lvgt Faw"

LVT HMB -hbcv' Fab {aeegcea ma` tg{gb t{eavgbg{lab ma` la fg{g`co`gtwob oehvhc he`h athtehv`{lhb cth fgv gcg dèa fhmta|àc tqva|gwea tqheeavg`g|aydgm aladag`"

bdaegcea% co`gtwob oehvhc fg{eav lhvfaeavgb acobo`gc% ztgcoeokgc% totwhe% tgwhtg yal neav boc|htblh fgv a|cgtg yhv `% woc `q% fqbehv hvh|vwovq{" Lhvfa bdatg ayvawg%lhvfa hh`htb ya lhvfalab tobvh \vc |ozeq`q {avgbla whvh|| a|cgeavg hvh|vhb fgvco`gtwobq{" oc n{ae fgv acgela gihla a||gbg{% cablgbg{g |hbèhvcab la N`mhbabgbCaecg| ch{htblhb cz t|hbfqelh wqv| wqyh cqv`hc%8717 ngfg fgv |hvgm|a |gdhva|a fhehwzfqnb% aeeg we ma` àlwh tac|vbla ma` fhtblh ma` la |gdhva| zgwhthtblh ocbaèg fgv gtà qeh`hc aefa||a cg oc fwc fgv à{gwa| gg% fqblhb {avva chlhv fgvablga`g{ woc" Hbdhc fqbehv tweavcab naelggbg{ boc|hw cablgbg{ |hvgi a||ggbg{ ggb 6=

qfh| bdatgbla Hbhloeq tav`hwatg {avgbla {aeegcea àlwh ya nh{a|aeav woeqweh TgehmeCqyya|eav la cqeehbe`hc tqva|gwea fgv ct` fhtcehvb oeq|qvqelqqbq nvwovq{ ya fqbhvbac oehvhc lh 9 Mh{gvhb 877> |hvgmeg nh{a|ala Ovlqlhb H`fhvno% Nabaecqv`hw; v|gdhdcqvqeqehvlhb heyavg whz`hwb lgwa fgv `hba| h|ewov ya fqvhlh% Hbhloeq tav`hwatgbgb%t|hbfqe g ayvaeavgbgb chv c`ht tobqdqblh fgv ct` fq |v |azcgeavgb oeq|qqbq lh lb@amà| Heg Fgvhbl Faw {aeegcea lgbeavcab gihla a|`g|g" Tg{ Hbhloeqlhb c` fgv g hlhòehvhc fwea fgv `hba|ea Hbhloeq tav`hwatgba o nbc hv|ehv g|gfhvweh mhct{ec whz|b{lbwov `qtqbq{? Tovq`qb fgvgtg fq"

cgbdg tovq` gta% tg{eav% hgeatgba oc lcb fgv fhfh oehvhc fg{ tg{g |hbwovq{ ya fgvfhfh oehvhc lh {aeegcea c{ehvb{ g lbwhtbb oc baèg gtgèavg megba na|gvlgbg{ yafqnb \vcgwa ch`qowqbqb maztgbgb whcgbab |hbl gbthbehv" \hfgg cg% fwea fgv boc|hwhnaeafgeàc ggb la bdaegcea ag|g`lab naàc% oc gwg fgv ag|g` he`hc navacgwov" Fqg`cbehv tg{ ayeh|ehvb{h taiavfav a||gbg{ ya obehv fq g`cb cqeehbhvhc fqnb \vcgwala ocbaèg boc|hehvlhehv" Owth% tob lavada th`g`g Hbhloeq gbthbbb \vhcwhtweh% Hbhloeqwehfgveaàc tqva|gwea 8: qfh| 6::= |hvgmgbla \vcgwala oc h{ vht|ehbhb fgv |hv{lh Hbhwhthlaggcegg ggb whb whbh naeab gbthbehv \vcgwa Fwc @geea| @adegtgbla |hvgmeg nh{a|abg{la

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

22/37

\ F @ @



Navacgvta tgehm fgea cqeehbv{" lgwafgeadac chlhv i|qvtq{dh mhvaca| alab fgv cggbgb

fawhbb nh{a|a `hba|eavgba |h` oe`hc o nbb hv|ehvblh laòcvhtgwg tcb|whtoc`q `qlqv? Fqbq tg{lab vabàc gt|gwovq`"Fgv la% \THLb 88 Hvhec 8779 |hvgmgbla H|gbhlh navacea|gvlgg \vc Wqbhb

Hlhèhv Cobtawg \ozehb|tblh \VC% LTC% \ATC% \OFF waeavgwea fgvegc|a VaihmWoeMcà|gba chv baeav whzehdhbb faegveablgg gllgh algeàc|algv" Fq |ozehb|lh tg{ yaThwb Lgb Fgengb gea fgvegc|a Nyab Avchwhbb lh fqeqblqq gllgh algeàc|algv" Fq cobqwhlhgv dayhfb{ facegwovq`"

\aaccv alavg` Thwb Lohb"HWLGB LOHB g`lg% Thwb Fhchb% {h`hb`{ oc ct|e lawgz

catàwadactgbg{ mavmela bc tqhegba ch lhcgch {h`hb hwvlb{% obh fhc`hc eh{`" g`lg% |ac |ac nglaeg`% gt|avtabg{ toblhb fhehwhw`"

FHCHB \hfgg% tovq tov`hc gt|awab `geea|yacgeg`g{ lhmh yhv" O w{lab``cb oelqq chlhv cth dayhzehv gt|gwovq{" Actgc chevth lalgg` ngfg wh{e oehvhchehfgegvg{ tobvh"

HWLGB LOHB Cth yavawg` weawta" oc lav| oelqq ggb oc tweaàcgt|gwovq` h`h twea|`gwovtqbq{% ba whzhw`"

Zacg% fgv; H|gbhlhcg g hlhèhv |ozehb|tbh \vcWqbhb Hlhèhv \ozehb|tbhLgb Fgengbea favhfav ng||gc" Mh|vehl` chlhvweh hvc \hvh gea Vhm`g Faw vgdh a||g; Wh gcgàlwh zh|vobq oehvhc tg{ la naegb% Wqbhbgt|hbeh gegcgeavg`g{ oc baèg" Ng||gc% ovhlh bafwea Vaihm Zhv|gtg heawmgba fgv oehw whhbtb ba vhmà|eg Nyab Avchwh naetgb ba htcavyhvl ba aw Fqbehvb maztg amgv aithbatg" Bhte hbeh|hw`? g`lg fab fqbqb bavatgblab|q|hw`? Fhcb% H|gbhlhb fab hwvel` nb H|gbhlhcg ZCC hceh`h whz|% lalg cg; \vc

àlwhtbb ab fwceavgblab fgvgtg Fhwfhgbea fgv vat`g`g whwèhl qvhbwq` |gdhva|gwhzwov" Cgèav yhv vatg`la? {av geeav yhv% Hwlb Lohb yhv% atcg aàceg Labg{ Cqyya|eavgCo`q|hb Ovmhb Chvhfqeq| yhv% fg{g` He`hbwh |a`tgedg`g{ yhv" Whb`{lh lh Hbchvhlhb|qvg{`dg Atab Chea yhv% {av geeavgb whcb hvchlh" Atab Cheabgb {avgba la Fhwfhgblgwa wh{lehv" Wh fab Fhwfhgbgb `hthtblh o|qvqv `qwq`% Fhwfhgb lgwa fgvgbgb `hthtbh{av geeav nglav `g? Fqbq lh whwbehlehv" Wqbhb fhtbbh fqbq chelv|`hc% |ac{gz a|àcggb fabg` H|gbhlhcg o {h`hbcg |a`tgedg c{`{ Bqv Fh|qv nbeavda qvh|" Vgdh algwovq`%amgv aithbatg Fhtb `hheatai nbhm cagtg" amgv aithbaeavgba gbhbewov% fwea aweavtweabgwov" Fab fqbqb bavatgbg l{ae|awg` chvlag`? Woc chvlag`% fg{ ng||gc Wqbhbgt|hbhh`h \vc g hlhèhv awg loehwtweh ng||gc"

FHCHB Obehv wh{hb lh fhtb Hwlb Faw"HWLGB LOHB Aiablg`?FHCHB Fqbehv wh{hb lh fhtb" Hbld whwèhwhb lh fhtb"HWLGB LOHB Aya|% fhtb"FHCHB Tg{gb mhccb{lh fqbehv whzehfgegwov h`h fhchehv mhccblh lh fhch

aweav whzehfgegwov"HWLGB LOHB H`h Bgà| Mhb`% fhch awFHCHB Mhwh|ehvh `he oehfgeadac acgela"HWLGB LOHB t|avtabg{ hbld lh hbeh|hw` whbg"FHCHB Ovhwh naeadag{"HWLGB LOHB Naeadactgbg{"

FHCHB Naeadag{"HWLGB LOHB g`lg% bavala che`|c? Wage tav`hwawg tqeh`hc% Hbhloeqtav`hwatgbg ce|àc tg{a whcwov `q? Mg whc`h{" Fab ccba chlhv Hbhloeqeqwq`"

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

23/37

\ F @ @



Meab la gegceavg`% mav |hvhi` Hbhloeq cochv" Tab fgelgg` chlhvweh hbcvetb" hbcv lh

gwg fgv Hbhloeq amvglgv% Ov|h Hbhloeq h`h fabg` àèaca|g` la n{ae Hbhloeqlqv" FabHbhloeq tav`hwatgba chv oeh`h`% oe`h`{ ``cb lage" O nbc wage tav`hwa ggblathwlcehv ecav Nvqfq lh yhvl% wage tav`hwa lgwovthb{% ab fw la owlq" Whbg% tg{Hbhloeq lgwovtqbq{% wheb{ Hbhloeq lage% obehv lh yhvl" Fg{ twea`gwovlqc obq" Bawlg`hba|? Qbq||q` g`lg"

FHCHB Fab `hba|g la oc ba| oehvhc tweawafgegv `gwg`?HWLGB LOHB Aya|" Fqwqvqb"FHCHB @hba| @geegwa| nh{a|atgbla c`|" Nabaecqv`hwlhb fgvegceava {ae

ya ng{eg a`gv; q gvca|eavlab heyavg whz`hwb" Lhmh tobvh fwceavgblab fhehwhvhclayh` alab ya w{ o|q{ ctqv gvca|gb gt`g thwewovlq ya fq mhfavgb lhwhbhNabaecqv`hwb fgvegceava nblav`g oelqq ng{eg fgv a`gv glg% navacatg fqwlq" Fq la|hw bgwa

fq chlhv gwg fgegwovq`? Fq lhyhbb hyqch|wl`"HWLGB LOHB \h`h`" oc gwg% oc à`bqb oelq`"FHCHB Ya lhmh tobvh whvneh`h thimhtblh ov|hwh c| cg Nabaecqv`hw

Fhchbebh tovlqq`q{ tovqlh fweafgv ng{eg a`gv oe`hl ngfg fwea fgv faena ya fgengbgbla nh{a|awa qeh`hl tweablg" \h`hàb |h{`gbh|eh ch{hbel o lba`la" Whbg hteblhfq fgengwg hceh`hw oc mo chveh`h` h`h oc whcb |hb oelqq` fgv àtaea oelqqggb tweawadag`"

HWLGB LOHB H`h g`lg fgv aw tweawawg`" Bgwa nh{a|awa lbz lhyhh`hlb{ whehb whwèhl lgwa?

FHCHB Nh{a|awa wbaegc lhyh h|c% ch{hblc {h|ab"HWLGB LOHB Fab fge`gwovq` wea fgv lhyh% th`g`g oehvhc fge`gwovq`

FHCHB Ch{hblc"HWLGB LOHB Nh{a|awa chv fab la fgb |hba lhyh Fgea`gwovq`"FHCHB Hel% ch{hbel"HWLGB LOHB g`lg% fgv|hc` `hba|eav ocqlqbq{% q q q" Wh{h`hl`

maztgbg" Fqbehvb mgfgv |hbatg fg{g` gdhl`{ lagelgv" Thwb Fhchbb twealggba lagbhb`h` ``cb lage whbg mg fgeàlab twewovq`% @geegwa| nh{a|atgbla fgv nvqzo|qvhdhc% fgv g wh{`h gdh| aladac% fqbq na|gvgz nh{a|abgb `hba|gba cowhdhc% qtav`hwa Fqbehv fg{g` vaceh` yavabeavg`g{% fqbehv fh|hvehvth fg{ la fh|hv{" q tav`hwanvqzehvblhb `he he`hwb lgwadac% fq hceeh% g{hbeh

FHCHB chvhw` ` `hba|g g`lg Hwlb Faw?HWLGB LOHB Fabg` |hv{` fqFHCHB Tg{a tqbhfgegvg` whbg whb`{lh o `hba|eav" Fq `hba| h|el"HWLGB LOHB @hba| h|e` oehfgegv h`hFHCHB Fq mhfav whzel"HWLGB LOHB Aiablg`% `hba| h|e`hl la`gwovq`" Nh{a|abgbFHCHB Tg{ Fqnb fwea fgv aw whze`htb lovq fqe`qwovq`"

lgwafgegvtgbg{" Whbe oe`q oehfgegv" lgwafgegvtgbg{"HWLGB LOHB Mhwv" Bgwa lgwawg`? Fqnb la fqe`h`% o nb la

fqe`qwovlq`" Fwea fgv aw Fhcb% mhfav whze`htb lovq fqeqvq`% mhfavlgv" Fhbh obqlalgv|àc gt|gwovthb{% mhfavlgv" Thlada fq mhfavgb qwlqvqc oe`htbh fabg gbhblv`hb{``cb lage% hwh`lhb htthb gbhb`h`% whz`h{ fwea fgv aw" Fg{g` nabeavg`g{la woc%

hmehc`{lh woc" Fwea fgv nh{a|a fwea fgv aw whzhvth fhtbb lgav cqvqèhv obqb gzeggbgzh{hvh chvvehv" Fab mh|veh`wovq`"

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

24/37

\ F @ @



7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

25/37

\ F @ @



IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Fabg` twealgg` q Vaceh` q fawaiablg;

\vcgwa whvb fhch \vcgwa oehdhcHWLGB LOHB Zacg% g|a \vcgwa whvb fhch \vcgwa oehdhc" Fqbq Feab| Adayg|Laòcvh|gc Toe Zhv|g fgv fhtb ch`zhbwht oehvhc whz`% vaceh` yav`g% zhvhtb lhla`geavlgv"

FHCHB Tg{gb lvgt Faw aavLVT HMB -hbcv' Thwb Lohb% Laòcvhtgbgb yh{nageà{ qbtqvq àlwh3

laòcvhtg wocth àlwhbb lh whh`h g`cb woc|qv" Fq t{ fg{{h| tg{gb h{b{lhbc`|v"

HWLGB LOHB Tg{la fqbq tweaàegtgbg{" cg`g{gb chlavg fgvfgvgba fhe"LVT HMB -hbcv' Fg{ fqbq |h`hàb f|b gegceavgbla mgttalavac tweawab

gbthbehv{ ya obqb navag oehvhc lh fqvhlh o|qvqwovq{" oc lh `q|eqwq{% gbheehm fwea

layh` alav"HWLGB LOHB Zacg% fab la tg{gb chvb{lh o|qv`hc|hb oc `q|eqwq`"LVT HMB -hbcv' vabàc gt|algg`g{ Thwb Lohb% fqvhlh 86 Mh{gvhb

7>lacg `hba|; Navacgvta tgehm fgea cqeehbv{" boc|htblh f gv cablgbg fgeà{gb lgwaeg`cqeehbl fgv dèawg `hba|a |h` oe`hbb laòcvhtgwg fq chlhv {`ta`g fgv gbthblhq hb g|gfhvweh mavmhbng fgv vhmh|t{ec whvh|z whvh|`hlb vabàc gt|gwovq`"

HWLGB LOHB Aav fq `hba|g% fq ehi tweawab Hfq{g||gb Aiablg gta cablgtgbgfgeà{ Hfq{g||gb Aiablg gta nh{a|abgb `hba|gba chve`ht iaychehla whbe|v h`h fq ehitweawab ecala o lba`la baèg iobctgwobehv oehb fgv zhh gta% fqblhb lhmh fwcnh{a|adgegc oeqv `q?

Nh{a|adgegg tg{ ba hbewovtqbq{? Whbg geeh laòcvhtg yhv% fab laòcvhtg heawmgba

cobqhbehv wh{h`h` ` lgwadactgbg{ whmq| fabg` hbehw` heawmgba wh{ehbehvcobqh`h` ` lgwadactgbg{" Fhcb% fab tg{a fgv aw tweawawg`% fqnb tweatgbeav% fqnbnaba wh{hv`" O cablgbg fgeà{ zhhwh da{hw fab yavàwadag`% \vcgwawg wba|abeavyavadac" Fabg` gg` obehvh da{h yavàc lage" Fabg` gg` obehvb twealggbg mhechhbeh|`hc" Fab maz qbq twewovq`" Fg{ vatg` acgwovq{% ca wh{hvehv cablgeavgba nvawovq` whzwovehv% fabg` la `q|hfc oe`hl` fgv tv wh{hv` yhv" Tvv Tvawwh Faw fg{lawh{ wh{wovlq" g`lg wh{`wov" Whbg% mav aw mav wh{lweh `q|hfc lageg`" Navg% ocvabceg wh{ wh{wovlq obq lh tweawawg` h`h mav wh{lweh `q|hfc oe`h` lh ``cblage"

LVT HMB -hbcv' \aaccv alavg{"FHCHB Tvheh`hweh nglgwovq`" Tvv Tvawwh blav"TGVVG TVAWWH BLAV -t|hbfqe' Fq chlhv cablgbg{g |q||qbq{% tob fq ehi lh

a|àtawlgbg{ n{ae bdaegcea monaelgbg{" Fab la nvqfqb nabae whwb g{ngtgbgb fgvoqbhch|e`wovlq` lawgz laaeg` wea fhehwhe`" g`lg% hh wqchv f|b nh{a|a `hba|eavgya tvada whceh` fggèavg tovqelq" Fqvhlh% fq co`gtwoblhb faceabab ihwlh wea mhteoehdhc; Fg{g` fqvhlh cg`tawg |hdg{% ge{h`% |hmvgc a|àc ngfg fgv bgwa|g`g{ woc% fq co`gtwobqblh fwea fgv h`hd woc"

Fq co`gtwobqb fgv |ac h`hd yhv" Fgv whvneh`h co`gtwobq lh oe`hl ggb fgv |ach`hd yhv3 àèaca||a laòcvhtgwg ya lhvfaeava chv lqvq fgegbdgbg oeq|qv`hwh cablgbdafgv ch|c theh`hc" Fq co`gtwobqb he`hehv fgv vhzovh lb|veadac ya fq vhzovqbgavgtgbla whth`h ovnhbblhb `hmcaàeava yhvhbh lagb faeeg bavgeavla fqeqbqehdhc"

Loehwtweh% tg{gb dayhzehvb{eh fgvh{ fq laòcvhtg fgegbdgba mg{à| aladac fqnba chlhvfgegbàwab wh lh oc nb w{ba c`hwhb wh lh o |hvhiblhb fhce`hwhb aweav oeqvth

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

26/37

\ F @ @



àèaca|a |ozwacb fgv ihwlht oeqv" g`lg% fgvh{ bda lalgbg{ cg fgv hlh` Hfq{g||gb Aiablg

fqbq twea`gta fg{ la wh{hv{"HWLGB LOHB Mhwv% baèg fgv hlh` twea`gtaTGVVG TVAWWH BLAV -t|hbfqe' Mh% baèg fgv hlh` twea`gta wh{hv{" Whbg

fgv nh{a|abgb nabae whwb wovq`q lage

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

27/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;6>

Tav`hwa gegcgtg cobqtqbq twealgbg{" Naeadag` f|b cobqehvb{h" Lbwhlh fhtb

hv|c wea Talh| Ta`hygbgb nh{a|atg% Bhlgv Bhlggb nh{a|atg Hmà| A`gbgb nh{a|atg acegblalage fhtb lbwhlh fwc thbhwg cqvqeqehv megba naelg" Fqnb lbwhbb ab fwc|aeayg{wob chbheblhb fgv |hbatg BFD% Nabavhe Aead|vgdgblgv" Ivhbthbb ab fwcnh{a|aeavgblab fgv |hbatg Ignhvo% Lhth qhcehvbb thmgfgbgblgv" Naba Ivhbthbb ab fwc|aeayg{wobehvblhb fgv |hbatg \I8 Foqwnqat igv`ht Foqwnqat ab fwc `|ahmmg|egc

FHCHB Lb Av|qvqe {cc Faw la hwb vbaceavg yavlg Hwlb Faw"HWLGB LOHB Hwb vbaceavg `g yavlg?FHCHB \acvhv oe`htb"HWLGB LOHB Fabg` gllgh` qlqv; Fab lgav geavlab zhvh ch{hbwovq`% fhtb

{hvhv a|tgblgwa lage" Aav fhtb cablg acobo`gc hwhcehvb {avgbla lqv`h{th o cqvqeqqbacobo`gc yht|h oe`hl ggb mhfav fh`t{e oe`h{" Wocth fqnb `hheatai \vc

àlwhtbb fqbq lh tweaàc lqvq`qblhw`" Fgvoq% whvlhb oc ih{eht lgav geavgblabch{hbz% na|gvgz fqvhlh zhvh chwfalgwov" Balab chwfalaveav% hbeh`wovq`" Fab mgfgv whwbcqvqeqq`lh zhvh chwfa|`gwovq`% chwfa||gceavg`g la cablg ggbla aw whzwovq` bcwhzh`h`% whhwh`h`" Fgbhabheawm fqbq Av|qvqe lh twealgwta fabg` q{h|`h`h navacwoc% fhtb lbwhlh awlgv lgwa"

Yhw avaitg{ `hba|gbla tg{gbea favhfavg`" Cv| àtaeatgba naelgbg{% fg{ la ocwbe fgv whwbdec yhv" Fg{ la mav tat yhv whbg nh{a|aeavg`g{gb mav fgvg hwb \vcgwabgb heàbihh|eavgbgb chvtblh oe`h`hc chwlweh |avva fqeh`h`hc chwlweh mav |ve igcvgbvhmh|h |hv|el fgv whwb nvqfqwq{" Faecg fh{ehv lhmh oc |hv|ewov% fh{ehv lhmh h{|hv|ewov h`h fg{ mhfaveava wav yavgvcab la nabaeegcea ch`qowqblh nvlceavg ovhbbgtza|gbla aw yavgvg{" Whbg mhfav whzhvcab HC ZHV\ \vcgwala ab fwc zhv|g oelqq ggb%

gc|glhvlh oelqq ggb obq lhmh oc whzhv{" Hbh `qmheaia| zhv|gtg gcgbdg oelqq ggb obh lhmhoc wav yavgvg{" @geegwa|g Mhvaca| Zhv|gtg ch`qowqblh nvl awa nva bdlv" Tg{gbàbtqz oelqqbq{ zhv|gwa la fg{ mhfaveavla% |aeayg{wobehvlh% nh{a|aeavla la wav yavgwovq{"Fq cobqlh |hfgg mav wgglgb nbebla fgv htehb wh|hv% mav tgwhtg gbhbd lat|aceawab mazfg{g`cgbg yavtgb lgwa la gt|awafgegv h`h fg{ ovhlh ``cb oelqqbdh hlhea|eg oe`hwhhewovq{"

TGVVG TVAWWH BLAV -t|hbfqe' Fgv fhehb|e fgv aw% fq igbhbt gegcgtg geaFhchb` g{gb yavgv `gtgbg{"

FHCHB Fqwqvqb e|iab"TGVVG TVAWWH BLAV -t|hbfqe' Fq% q hlhb lh faecg {avgbla lqvqe`ht

navacab fgv tovq" Tg{ oc fwc yavng da{hehvbh hvz|velb{" Thbv` fq tovq q hbh chlhvmg tovqe`hl" Fqbh fhc hb{ lh fq yatgeawea hbeh|`hc gt|avtabg{ lgbeavg{" Fq fgv tgwhthefhtc hvhd `wl% navac|ab ày{qh| oehvhc wh lh whthe |gdhvg ihhegwa|eavgbg{ fhc`blhbgm`he alge`g wh lh ovhlh hbehb aweav geab`g `gwlg? F|b fqbehvb gavgtgbla o fhch|gdhva| hehbehvweh qvh`hbb hwb {h`hblh gc|glhvb% cg` oeqvth oetqb% gc|glhvb vat`gnvbb lb c|b{ hehbehvlh tg{a chv cqeehbehdhc fgv tgehmh lbàtg fheh`blhlh hbeh|`hc gt|avtabg{ faecg gwg oeqv"

HWLGB LOHB g`lg% fg{g` cqvq`q`q{qb hel yavng da{ht cobqtqb lh Fqyavng da{ht mhce wh{e`|v fhbh lalgv||gvaà{tgbg{" Fq yavng da{ht \vcgwala yalbwhlh ab fwc yavng da{htlv" Lbwhlh lhmh fqnba chlhv

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

28/37

\ F @ @


Co`gtwob ; -8:/649' Ngvg ; 8="81 \hvgm ; :1/8:/6:86 Nvqz ; Chlvgwa Thwih ;6=

H`h g`lg fab àtaeawg o mea na|gvàc gt|a`gwovq`" Fab fq lhyhehvb mg fgvgbg la

chwfa|àlg`" Ba `hmheeg `hmcaàeavla chwfa||g` ba Lhb|hw lh chwfa||g`" Mh||hLhb|hwlh ch{hbl` |htmgmg chvhv thimhtblh oehb lhyhehvlh fgea q{eh`hwh ng||g`" qbqtweaàc gt|gwovq`; Fab fq lhyhehveh q{eh|`" Layea| fgv q{eh`h whtht chvl% fabg` ggb{ae fgv whth c`hl" Fq fgv hi lh lagelg" Fab ng||g` fq q{eh`hw whz|` ya `hegwa gealayea|ea fhv|`" Hv|c wabglab fqbq ch`hc gt|a`gwovq` h`h Heehm hmglg`lgv fab fqgeavla mh|he lageg`" Naelg fh`h% fab la fqblhb tobvh fqbqb chb lhyhtb lh tvàcgt|a`gwovq` Tvv Tvawwh Faw"

g`lg fab fqvhlh fh{ aweav tweaàc gt|gwovq`" oc gt|alg` cg fqnb fhbh aweavtovqetqb" bc {hbbalgwovq` cg

HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Tovqehv fg|àlg lhmh"HWLGB LOHB Fh{ nh{a|adgeav fqvhlh% g|a gmheaeav hel% fhbch cvalgeavg n|vl%

{abngb oelq Fab fgv laih fqbq fgv oyabg{èa% fgvoyavwhec vqmqweh ihehb twea`gwovq`"Hvchlhehv% g|a fg{g` N`mhba @geea|yacgeg la fqvhlh" Fab lolqq` fenabgb yhvece fgvhgeatgbgb odqqwq`% obehv lh fgegveav" Aeeg welv hewovq`% o|q{ fa welv wctactaygwala yavng yavabeav hvhtblhw`" Nab wh`lhb favg yavng hmehcb fabg`ta`gg`lgv"Aav fgv gbthb `h{ava| oe`hlhb htcavegc whz`h{th% aav fgv gbthb yavngtgbg lvt| yavà{tayh|hbzavyavg` laà mhcc lh woc|qv" Fq hbehw gavgtgblab nglavac lgwovq` cg; Nh{a|adgeav%fhtb tac|v bgwa fq chlhv hhehvlh tvbwov% nyabgegvegg oc h{ lavtabg{% `hheatai%hehb hvchlhehv`{ maztg fgvfgvgbgb hwhbh h|a algwovehv" eavgbla fgv vachfa|gb whbblhmhta| la yhv" wg nh{a|aeavla hehb% fgvh{ lhmh oc zhvh hehbehv% gwg nh{a|aeavlaheh`hwhbehv% h{ zhvh hehbehv% fqbehv hvhtblh mv cwov" Fhf Hegla hehb nh{a|adgeavgbw{la =:g fabg` nvqfq`lh he`|v" Hwvehbehvb fgvoqweh gegcgeavg` yhv h`h fabla

hez lh g`lg fab obehvh fg{lab oe`hwhb fg{g`cgeav lgwovq` hwve` oehbehv mav nb wabgfgv àehba| va|gwovehv" Fab fqbehveh lh fh alaà`" Nooneah fhc|vl`% hvchlhehv`{fhc|ehv < `gewob 69: fgb |hba fabg` mhcc`lh wh{ yhv% mg cg`ta mhccblh fwea fgv wh{woc|qv" Fgbhabheawm% fab fqbehvb maztgba la dayhz yavaà`" qbq twewovq` fhbhgbhbb lvgt Bhg` Faw tg{a la twewovq`"

FHCHB lvgt Bhg` lage lvgt hmgb thlada"LVT HMB -hbcv' Bhg`tg{ lvgtFHCHB Bhg`tg{ lvgt hmgb"HWLGB LOHB Wh`h yavgb fgvh{% wovqeqbdhFHCHB Wo wo% atzvg whzwovq{"LVT HMB -hbcv' Fab{a|geàc|ab la vhmh|t{ lageg{"FHCHB g`lgHWLGB LOHB @thhla alav `gtgbg{ Thwb Fhchb`"Nh{a|aeavg `q|ehch abhh| va|ab cqvqèhv oehvhc nvàwgb% nh{a|aeavg `q|ehch eca

heawmgba ngladac lgwa nvàwgb" Fg{ fgvfgvg`g{gb coz`h{ fgv zhvhtw{" Fqnb tg{gb zhv|gbg{ahb|gzh|gc naegvg`% tg{ yavwhbtb alavtgbg{% whvb lvgt Fawgb zhv|gtgba hb|gzh|gc naegvg`% o awwhzhv% fv nb Dq`mqvgwa| Mhec Zhv|gtgba hb|gzh|gc naegvg` o whzhv% àlwhw fqbehv hhacaveav" Fgv la% fg{lab oe`hwhb fg{g`cgeav naegv fqvhwh Dhbhb Fhveht% gtg` yavawg`" Lbfabg` gt`g`g yavavac twea`g" Dhbhb Fhveht lgwa fgv nh{a|adg yhv `wl woc `qwlq fabmh|veh`wovq`" Chwbzalavgbgb nh{a|atgbg na|gv`g% fg{ la Zh{hv Zot|ht lgwa whwbeh`{"Fgv tva tobvh lh Lb tovlq` Lavwh Th{hch Wh chvlag` tab fqbq bgwa fabg` fh`h

thelb fwea% mav wavla fq fhbh chwbzalavg gb nh{a|atgbg Lgwov cg; Hwlb Faw% nh{a|azhvh chwfalgwovlq% ocqb`qwovlq" Lgwov cg; Egfavheeav wh{wovlq" Egfavheeav lalgg \hmhHcwoe% Th`g Comab {h|ab fabg` nh{a|aeavg`la wh{wovlq chvlag`" Whbg ba lgwawg` fab

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

29/37

\ F @ @



fqbh? Ya aw lgwov; Yamfg Co n`vc fgveggba chvwl obqb ggb Hwlb Lohb lh Coeh

favhfav% fgvegc oelq n`vc fgveggba chv oelq" Naegvcab hvchlhehv` lalgeav% \hbtq Mhb`n`vc fgveggbg ch{hblblh fabg` nh{a|aà nae`g fabgèa acgeab vat`g woc `q?favhfav n`vc fgveggbg cq|eh`{% chlam hvz`{% vat`g`g{ yhv favhfav" qbqtwewovq`; Fg{ nbec oehwehvh nva laggvg{" Whvb fgv |hbabg{ @adegt|a fgv mh|h alavtgbg{%fgv |aceavtgbg{% `hcthlb{ hhb fgv ehi tweavtgbg{% nh{a|adg la iehtm hvwov% n` obq fgelgvgv"Cg` fgegv fab la fqvhlh ba `hcthl` hhb ehiehv twealg`% fgea`gwovq`" O fhc`lhb fg{gaw|hbb hyqch| nvàwgb% nbhm cagtg whz`hwb" Fab {h|ab nabae twewovq`% tvhvehtwewovq`" \vc |ozeq`qbqb maztg fgvfgvgba fab{av h`h nh{a|adgeav% whwbdehv lgavcatgèavlab lhmh h{ hmehce lagelgveav% mh||h lhmh ih{eh hmehcelvehv ihch| abhh|eavgblabfgvfgveavgbg walgceavg ggb fq mea naegwovehv" Ignhvo nh{a|atgbgb lqyhvblh fgv wh{ yhv"

FHCHB Hwlb Faw% oc {v lgegwovq` whbg fqvhlh mavcat fgvh{ lhmh hmehcelv

yawh lagelgv ngfg lhmh cvg|gc ya |hv|`he fgv ày{qwh fabda ngvàwgb" Whbg cg`ta cg`talablhmh hmehce lagelgv yawh hmehcelv ngfg fgv |hv|`h fqvhlh

HWLGB LOHB Fab wea cg`tawg Fwea fgv aw la tweaàlg`"FHCHB \q|hbhcehvlhb lh ctb mh||h o ct`"HWLGB LOHB Mhwv c`htb" \ozeq`qb |` fgvfgvgba fab{av lalg`" \vc

|ozeq`qbqb maztg fgvlgv h`h nh{a|adgeav mhcgch|ab hmehce gbthbehvlv lalg`"FHCHB Nh{a|adgeav lhmh hmehcelv yawh cg`taHWLGB LOHB @hcthl` h|wth chvb% hi oeh"FHCHB Fq hmehc |hv|`ht fqvhlh hbeh` g|gfhvweh q hblh q `hthbb a|vhiblh

fqeqbhb mavcat |hvhiblhb oc ihvce ya hv fgv acgela henehb` oehfgegv" O h`heh fgv qwhvwhz`hc gm|gwhdb mgtta||g`"

HWLGB LOHB T{` navg hewovq`q tweaàc gt|gwovq`% fqvhwh chwlhltb"

FHCHB Fqwqvqb"IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Fhcb Hwlb Faw% fg{ tg{eavg lgbeavcab thlada fgv

io|ovhi acàc ggb lgbegwovq{" Mg cg`tawg |hhb a|àc ggb fq cqvqe fqvhlh lage" Fqvhlh fq|gz t{eavgb tweabàtg la fabg la vabdgla alav% fq mhec lh vabdgla alav bc fg{ tg{g fgvgbthb oehvhc lgbealgc ya twealgceavgbg{ la chwlh nagvgelg" Obh nva `qhàea whzehdhc whbgobehv whvb gehb algeadac mhech" Mavcat lqwhdhc h`h fqvhlh mav lgbealgg`g{ gbthb fg{hmehcab% Heehm covqtqb% vabdgla a|àc ggb lgbea`gwovq{ cg" oc {el` fab whbg obqbggb

HWLGB LOHB Bawa {elb Thwb Fhchb? Tab fabg` faealgwa fhchbe` lhwhz|b" Hwb fenala la he|c" Fab ba twealg` la {elb{ hiialavtgbg{"?

IAW[QEEHM CGWGCEGC -t|hbfqe' Whbg fg{ nh{a|adgeav lhmh hmehct{ laàlgc cgwea fgv aw twewovtqbq{"

HWLGB LOHB Zacg aiablg`" Fabg` vhmà|eg hbh`b fgv ehi yhvl; Lgwab ng||g"Obq tweawab ng||g" Fqbq chzh|b% fhch aw cobqhe`"

FHCHB g`lg% Co`gtwob Fhchb oehvhc mav awlab bda fab fgv ca{ lhmhmh|veh|`hc gt|gwovq`" Whbg fqvhlh% tg{gb twealggbg{ t{eav tavfat|a% laòcvh|gc fgvov|h`lh% mav acegwea {hz|h naadac% naàtgbg la thewovq{" Thlada% fab% fgv whbehbehe`hwh woe hhfgeadac fgv mqtqt yhvth l{ae|geàtg hbeh`blh fgv mh|veh|`h whzhfgegvg`"Fq mh|veh|`hehv fq avayala whzwovq`" t|alggbg{ acgela ya {nvda yavgeab tvawg la

tg{a fvhc`hc tqva|gwea dayhzehblv`hb{h g`cb theh`hwh hewovq{" Fab fgv cc awmh|veh|`ht whzhdh`% oblhb tobvh t{ fgv `geea|yacgeg`g{a yavadag`" Tg{ \hbtq geeavlba`gbla aeac|vgc lh|` gmheatgbg helb{ h`h @atq| We`h{ lba`gbla gmheabgb gz|he

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

30/37

\ F @ @



algelggbg twealgbg{" O lqvq`lh% g|gvhceav gavgtgbla wav hehb TALH t|hbfqe\vhcwh

whchtbb fab fgv l{ae|`a whzhw` lgwa bc fab tovq tovh`hwhdh` aeac|vgc lh|`gg hbeh`htb 877= weblh Fhchbehv Cqvqeqbqb hvlblhb 77 weblh Abavkg Fhchbe geag`{hehlb{" TALH gvca| laygv gea|`a mhcc 1:: `gewob loehv yavadac|g hbdhc 6::8 weblhV\C whthtbh `qmheaia||ab Lhb|hw lh fq cobqlh lhyh hel" Lhb|hw 8:qbdq Lhgvatgfhtbb fhtct {avgba TALH oeq|qvhb gvca|eavgb mgttalhvehvblhb fgvg oehb tg{gb {aevhlwo ya |aeayg{wob cqvqeqehvblh w{la 8:lhb ih{eh mgttawa thmgz oe`hb{ balabgweaFhchbehv Cqvqeq chvhvb% :

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

31/37

\ F @ @



HWLGB LOHB Mhwv% wea tweaàlg`"

HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Mhwv% fhch geav lalgg`% fhch g hehbehvblhlh he`hc whbg whthe geavlab fhmtalgwovq`"HWLGB LOHB Zacg aiablg` zacg% dayhzehwhdh`"HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' g`lg hvchlhehv`{ fh{ nh{a|a `hba|eavg

nt|avlgeav" Thlada tg{gb nh{a|aeavgbg{ea gengeg twea`gwovq` fqbq" Fq ecala gbthbehv malaint|avgz elv|ab nh{a|a `hba|eavg la nvlc fg{% me elv|àwa layh` alab% me hwbaweavg whzhb nh{a|a `hba|eavg la nvlc whbg" vbagb% N`mhba Fhvo FhchbNbawlab naeab fgv yh|hblh |hvhiblhb tvi nh{a|a `hba|gblab loehw elve`|v" Obhfab{av% \vcgwabgb hwlbehv% \vcgwabgb fgeg` hlhèhv nh{a|aeavgb nt|avlgceavg `hba|eavw{blab elve`|v" Loehwtweh nh{a|aeav wea zgvg zhc aweav lagelgv" Thlada tg{gbeagengeg lage f|b nh{a|aeavea gengeg twewovq`" g`lg me fweawcab whbg lhvfaeav naegvcab

fhcwovq{% hh wqchv% g{ngtg oe`hwhb% gc|glhvlhb fateabab f|b nh{a|aeav bcnh{a|adgegc lblh fhch geav whzhb nh{a|aeav nd aegbla cg` fqeqblqvqwovth oblhb whbhwh lh n ae lag|gvadacta% nd aea nagvadac|ab whbh fgv whwb zoeg|gcht g{egwovehv" Lhvfalbaèavgbla la fqbq whzwovehv" Lhvfaeavlab tobvh lh wgba nd aea nagv`g oehbehvh fqtaiav hchcec whz`hwh layh` algwovehv" Whbg% |hfgvg`g hbehweh chvehwb |ab{gm alavg`fqbqbeh gengeg oe`hwhbehv lb fqbq fab% @amà| Fhvehtb 86 Aweelab tobvh wh{l fh{à|mgwaeavg la ocqwhvhc cablgtgba% fq lh tg{gb ggb fgv h`h `lv? lgwa tov`q|q`% obqmh|veh|`hc gt|avg`" vbagb Bh{e Gedhc ggb la hwb aw twea`g|g`"

Whbg% g`lg% àlwhbb% nh{a|aeavgb \vcgwabgb fq tcb|e lbaèavgbla mavmhbng fgvlmgegbgb oe`hlb tweaàc whbg zhvqzhcec gllgh a|àc ngfg fgv aw la fg{g`h`hehv`{h qwnqb lage" Whbg whvb \vcgwabgb bb hhdhc aweav lage fqbehv" Fg{%

lovqehv fqvhlh tweaàegwg{% lovqehv |atzg| a|àegwg{ cg whvb whbe whzhdhc oehbehv fqwhbeehvblhb yh{natgb" bc fq whbeehv% fq lhvfaeav \vcgwabgb weehvbh `he oe`q|qv"\vcgwabgb naeadagba `he oe`q|qv" \vcgwabgb laòcvhtgtgba `he oe`q|qv" Loehwtweh%fg{g` fqvhlh mg cg`tabgb cablgtgbg thyqb`h whz`ht ngfg fgv geayea nvayeg oe`hl`{%tg{gb cablgbg{g thyqb`hc wh lh fhchtbb cablgtgbg thyqb`hc ngfg fgv cobq`lh oe`hb{gt|a`gwovq{" Hteblh fg{g` fqvhlh gt|algg`g{ aw3 \vcgwala àlwhbb tovqbehv yhvth%àlwh gc|glhvehvh àdfqv chewovth% àlwh n olhcehvbh àdfqv chewovth% fqbehv bhtehhv{? Fqbehvb wb|aèavgbg fqe`hc|v"

Loehwtweh% fq cobqehvlh vbagb3 fgv g hlh` fgv t{ twealg whbg fgv tag`|hm`gbgbla fqeqblq Thwb Fhfhchb lalg cg; Fqbq wh{l` fgv cabhvh chwla||g`" Wh | hvhioeqvtqb% wh fav|hvhi oeqvtqb" Whbg% fq ngfg neav tg{eavg la a|cgegwov `q? Tg{eavgb whwbzoeg|gchb{h a|cg whzwov `q? Fq zoeg|gchehv w{bla `g tg{ fh{ aweavg n olhcehvbbgt|algg fgg`la wh{wovtqbq{ wh lh wh{wov ovnhbehvb{? Fqbq vabàc gt|gwovq` |aaccvalavg`"

HWLGB LOHB \aaccv alavg`% oc n{ae cobq|qbq{" Nhwa|% faehnh|la ocgwg @hheatai fab tgwhta|g oe`hl` ggb faehnh|g` fh{ab hcthl` lh hwov"

H`h g`lg% tg{g g|mh` a|`gwovq` lgwovtqbq{% mhcetb{" @atq| We`h{ HwlbLohb gmwh a||g" Wh fgv |hba qihc fgv aw nt|avgb% cv cqvq nt|avgb% fgv |hba q oelq lawgb%woc"

HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Thwb Lohb% fab twea`gwovq` tg{gbnh{a|abg{la q{qb weehv he` @amà| Fhveht% obq tg{a mh|veh|`hc gt|alg`" B gwa fgv

l`hbeb{ ` yhv hvhb{lh? Fqbq tweatgb"HWLGB LOHB Yhv" Fhcb% fgv aw tweawawg`% @amà| Fhveht ab|aeac|ae fgvgcg`goc oehb% oc gwg wh{ wh{hb% oc ocqwhb fgv hvchlh|v" H`h fg{la he| lba`la fabla >

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

32/37

\ F @ @



taba fhwh{hvec whz|" Fgv tvala g`{ht{ wh{l" Fab lavlg` cg fqbqb bba fgv eaymh

hthdh`% odqc|qv cqtqvh fhc`hwb lgwa" @amà| Fhveht% chvtbb a|cgtgbla chehvhcfwea geav whzwov" Chvtbh lh fab fgv aw whz`hl` fhd` lgwovlq lgwov lb weala`g lovq fhd` lavlg`" H`h wh nh{a|aeavgbla ggeavg yhv% Nabae Whwb @lv Dhbhbbggba tob yav`g" Dhbhbb ggba tob yavà gb|gch` lqwnqtq obqb ggblacg mvtb w{bayqvlqv`q" N{ae chlbl gvcgbea`g"

WHHV CHVHWAE -Chwtavg' {v lgeavg`" Thwb yacgeg`% thwb lohb {vlgegwovq`" Cobq% hmtg cobqehvlhb {gwhla thwb yacgeg`g{gb zvabtgz oehvhc tovlqq tovqehvdayhzehblvvthb{ lhmh lovq oeqv"

HWLGB LOHB H`h Thwb Fhchb`% thwb yacge lgwov cg @amà| Fhveht fwealgwov% @amà| Fhvehth dayhz yav lgwov

WHHV CHVHWAE -Chwtavg' Ch|e`hlb{ tweawafgegvtgbg{" H`h cggegceavea%

mhb`weh% hgeatgwea tg{gb hgeabg{eaHWLGB LOHB Zacg" Lb fabgèa qvh| lh obqb ggb lgwovq`" Zacg%

qvh`hwhw`% lovq lgwovtqbq{% mhcetb{" Bgwa qvhhw`"H`h woc fwea fgv aw% fab ba lgwawg`? Fqbqb bavatgbg l{ae|awg`" @atq| We`h{%

Hwlb Lohb gmwh a||g whbg fgv amgv aithbatg gdh| algegwov" chvwov% @atq| We`h{% HwlbLohb gmwh a||g lgwov"

Fhch geavea whze`ht àtaeatgbg tovlqbq{ Fqbq nagwovq` ba lgwawg`% fgv awla`gwovq`" Woc% fwea fgv aw chvlag`% cv cqvq woc"

cgbdg% tqhegbg{; Fhch geav la whze`ht eh{` lalgbg{" Fab qbq lgwovq`; Lbwhlhfhtb cqvqeqehv hv|c wheb{ whwbd lageeavlgv" \vcgwala fgv la| oelq Nh{a|aeav fhch gwhz`htb" Balab whz`htb chvlag`? Nh{a|aeavgb lgaveavgblab ihvc ba? Aav hmehcg gta%

aav aiihi gta% aav ch`qowqbqb n{ bbla gta nh{a|aeav la g whztb lgwovq` yalbwhlh Ivhbthlhb% |hewhlhb% Hàvgchlhb vbaceav yavgwovq`" Fqbq hbeh|`hwhhewovq`" Wocth H`h fhch geavg yhv lgwa la nh{a|aeavgblab zhvh chwfa|àtgb" Nabafqvhlhb twewovq`; fqnb% \vc àlwhtblhcg àydqlqb w{la >1g |aeayg{wobehvb yanh{a|aeavgb àydqlqb >1g zhvh chwfalgwov" Lgav geavgblab ch{hbz na|gvgz fqvhlh zhvhchwfalaveav" Balab chwfalaveav% bgwa whzhvehv fgeaà`"

FHCHB Aya|"HWLGB LOHB Aya|" Fabg g`lg hv`mh navadac megbg{ woc% fab tg{a lovqwq

twewovq`" t|avtabg{ fgv co`gtwob cqvlqvqb% nh{a|aeavgb `qmhtafaeavgbg gbdaea||gvgb" Whbg%nglgz Hb|hewhlh lo`h|atg% nbag |qvgt|eava th|z ovhlhb ch{hbl`% Folvq`lh ch{hbl`zhvhw na|gvgz nh{a|aeavg`la mhvdh`hc gt|a`gwovq`"

FHCHB Aya|" Hwlb Faw% tob tovqwqHM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Mhwv% q tovqwh whb| yavàlg"HWLGB LOHB Tg{gb fhch mhbng tqhegbg{ yhvl?FHCHB g`lg% wheb{ wea fgv lqvq` yhv; @`cb oelqq chlhv dayhzehv cth

|q|hfgegvtabg{"HWLGB LOHB Oeqv" Mhw mhw% zacg"HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Lalg` cg Nh{a|aeav% n olhcehvbh whz|cehv

fhch geav wvtb lgwa% n olhcehvblhb whbh |hyv hewovehv" lalg`"HWLGB LOHB H`h amgv aithbatg cobqqwovtqbq{% fgv |hba nt|av h`h wqyhvehc

ehiehv

HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Aiablg`% g{gb yavgb" Tg{a yavgeab yavngda{htbb Thwb Fhfhchbb cz |aeayg{woblh fq hlh` bgwa |q|qwovtqb fqvhlh% fqbqbmathfb tovhv` laàtg" Whbg% fq aw lage `g?

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

33/37

\ F @ @



FHCHB Thwb \oz|h% e|iab fg{ Lhvfaeavg Hvh|v`h Co`gtwobq avayatg

gavgtgbla Tg{% Hwlb Fawa `geea|yacgeg tih|b{eh fqbehv Nabae Cqvqelh tovq bavnatgoehvhc yavafgegvtgbg{% lhvlh tovhfgegvtgbg{" E|iab% Co`gtwobq`q{qb nvayg avayatggavgtgbla tovqehv ya dayhzehveh Tob t{

HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Thwb Fhchb% oc {v lgeavg`"Co`gtwobq`q{qb h`hehv avayatgblab tovqwovq`% lgwovq` cg; Lhvfa lbaèavgwhcehvcab% lhvfawg mgttalab àlwh ovnhbehv lhvfawa lat|ac yavavac lhvfalab tobvhcablgeavgba chv theh`h woeqbq tagwovehv ya lhvfalab tobvh fqbehvh hchcecwhzwovehv% fqbehv `hba|eavgb la nvwovq{" Aav n olhcehv oe`hlcehv {h`hb lhcablgeavg |amlg| he|blhehv% fq |amlglg ba chlhv wabafgegwovehv% ba chlhv fq |amlgla chvchfgegwovehv% ba chlhv fh`t{ecehvb thyqbhfgegwovehv? Whbg fq cobqlh fgv zvofea` yhv`? Fq cobqlh fgv zvofea` yhvth hc wvacegegcea hbeh|b% fq zvofea`g {à cobqtqblh

|ozeq`the lat|acla thehbtb tg{a lalg`"FHCHB Laòcvh|gc wb|aèavea ya tagèa g fhbh nae`g fgv gc|glhvb lhvfadg

fgv hbehweh mhvaca| a||ggba gegcgb g|mh`b{ lovqtq chfqe a|à` ``cb lage" Whbg%g`lg fqvhlh fgv tgwhtg zoea`ga woe h`h`hc hlbh fqbehvh dayhz yav`gwovq`" H`hfqbehvb |hv|ehdh wav @adegt Nabae Cqvqeqblh fqbehv |hv|hfgegvg{"

HM@A\ \OZ\H -Hiwobchvhmgthv' Thwb Fhchb`% \hbtq geeavg |hv|wovthc%@atq| We`h{ |hv|wovthc bgwa fgv fhchtb |hv|`hwhe`?

FHCHB Fgv fhfhchb |hv|`wovq{% zot|òlavb lhvfa lba`gbg |hv|wovq{"Whhv Chvhwae Faw% fqwqvqb e|iab"WHHV CHVHWAE -Chwtavg' Thwb Lohb% mo naelgbg{" \aaccv algwovq{%

|avgieavgbg{ ggb"

Azawda cobqqelq {avgbla h`h fqvhlhcg Lhvfa Co`gtwobqbqb atht h`hd%\vcgwala fgv lhmh zot|òlavb yawh òlavb oe`hwhb mav |ve lhvfabgb fgv lhmh \vcgwalawhh|e`h`ht% whhb`h`ht ya naeadac batgeeavg`g{a la {hvhv yavààtg ggb àydq|na`g|acg% lqvq` |atzg|gbg whzhvhc naeadac batgeeava la thece fq lba` cg fwceavgbgbyawh @adegtgb yawh fq cobqehveh gt|ghva a||gg`g{% igcgveavgba fhyqvlqq`q{ gbthbehvb%laòcvh|gc fgv ov|h` gavgtgbla% naeadac batgeeavg`g{a thece fgv loc`hb fvhc`hc% thecefgv lqvq` |atzg|g ggb fqbehv whzwovq{"

Tg{a tovqehb tovqehv lh% lhmh oc tg{gb bov`he lhvlhb mavmhbng fgv yh|hblhhvz fgengtgba fhyqv`qwovq{" @hlqvehvb fgengeavgba fhyqvhdh{% h`h tg{% fgv fhtbdh`ghtb% qeqtehvhvht bg|aegc ch{hb` fgv fhtb dh`ghtb |a`tge algwovtqbq{" Fq |a`tgealab `hchèhveh gengeg la fqbehvb |hv|e`htb |hfgg chveh`hb{ navacgv" Obqb ggb g`lg%{aeegcea tg{ fgv hgea fhfht oehvhc% hgeabg{a la oc lcb oelqqbq{q fawhb a||gbg{% fqblhbloehw lh Hbhloeq odqq oehvhc tob lavada `q|eq oelqc" \aaccv algwovq{ fwea fgvfawhbb{ ggb"

Fab tg{a fq fawhbb{lhb lh mhvaca|ea fgv aw tov`hc gt|gwovq`" {aeegcea gcg fwcàlwh nvqfqbqb Thfhm ya Mvvgwa| Nvqfqbqb yawh Lohb Nvqfqbqb lgwaeg` fgvfgveavgbg{agt|av tgwhtg% gt|av acobo`gc% gt|avta àlwh vachfa|g w{blab fgv acgàbg{gb yavachfa|gbg{gb oelqq lovq" Lhmh tobvh% fhtblh wav hehb yawh fg{lacg {hf|ehvh naabfawhbehvlhb lh hbehewov cg Faw|g Eochb|htblh fgv hvhwh naeavac mhi|hlh fgv% baeavwhzhdhb{ mhbng `hba|eavg h|hdhb{ nh{a|aeavgbg{la cg`g he|vz he|v`hwhdhb{whbg fq |gz aweav whzhvhc% |hfgvg dhg{ta% ma` àlwh lbwhtbh ma` la lg{hwb algeadac%

|ozeq` `mablgtegg whzehdh boc|htblh nveav la yhv" Hwvdh% fq vachfa| gavgtgbla%lgav fhtb cqvqeqehvblhb% tg{gb whwb hbehwb{h zac qw`hwhb Wabg hihc nh{a|atgwea lafgv `hba| vachfa|gbg{ oelq" Wabg hihc nh{a|atgbgb thmgzeavgbg fvobq{h lhya| alavac%

7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

34/37

\ F @ @



7/30/2019 Aydn Doan

35/37

\ F @ @



waàc la lgwov% fab o bo|q ocqlq` bc fqvhlh% twealgg bo|q ocqlq` waàc walgc

h`h fab catgbegcea Bh{e Gedhc fabg` heawmgà wh{ wh{wov" Bh{e Gedhch tweawgbwh{`htb laàlg`" bc Bh{e Mhb`% o nh{a|awa ng|àlab ayyae fabgèa hewovlq"Tobvh oeqbqb àtaeatgblab loehw hvh`{ hel% q{qb tva fabg` heawmgà azawda lawh{ehv wh{l" q hblh lh fg{g` |aeayg{wobq`q{lh naba zvonvh` whzwov" Bh{e Mhb` gwg fgvnh{a|adglgv h`h iaychehla chynhd% aw fgv nh{a|adglgv" Fab aav Bh{e Mhb`h Fabg`heawmg`la wh{ wh{`htb" ihehb lgwadac oeth` Hefhwvhch navac woc% `|avac oclot|q`q{ yhvl% obehv chbheweh Wh fqbq whz`htb" lavlg`"

Hwvdh lh fqbqtweavcab% faecg naba c{hdhctb{ h`h% Wabg hihc nh{a|atg% fg{g`dh`gh`{lh o lba`la oc a|cgeg fgv nh{a|a lagelg" Whbg% fwea fgv aw mh|veh`wovq` Wabghihch

Tg{ la% fg{ la awa% A`gb ehhb @te`hbehvb heawmgba wh{`htb"

@te`hbehvb heawmgba wh{`htb fhchtbb |aecgb a|àtgba navac woc|qv% fab lawh{e`htb gt|aà`% fab cigv `gwg`? Mhh mhh" Bhte @te`hbehvb heawmgba wh{wh{lvhdh`?

Obq lh tqeh`wovq`% faecg whbe mh|vewov h`h fhbh nva fq fgv amgv aithbatg"WHHV CHVHWAE -Chwtavg'\q|hbhcehvlhb ocqlq` fqbehv% hmtg igcvg` lage"HWLGB LOHB Aya|% fab la ocqlq` o bo|q {h|ab% hel`% ocqlq` ya fwea fgv

awg` woc|qv" Wabg hihc nh{a|atgblab oehb àtaeaeavg tobvh vablg`% o bo||hb vablg`%fgv ct`b lh hvchlhehvlhb% {el`"

Mh||h fgv la aithba lqwlq`% obq lh fqvhlh tweaàc|ab awg` woc" FqnbcDq`mqvfhchb`{ o {h`hb zhv|gbgb gcgbdg hlh` ihehb lqvq`qblh mavmela% \hwwgz Fawfaealgwa fhchbwl mh|vehl` chlhvweh o {h`hb Dq`mqvfhchbb nglgz o {h`hbcg

`hegwa yacgegwea whchtblhb |q|qz Tab fq da{hw bhte wh{hvtb? lgwa chynh a||ggbg la% obhthmgz c|b lh vablg`"

Lhbh walgg |h fgegv" Fab obqb da{htb nvl` ggb% gbthbehvh fwea da{hyavgeàtgbg ihehb ba ygdlhb` chfqe alav ba la aw whzhv" H`h qbq hceceh tweawawg`;

aydın doğan

Documents