avoiding thor’s thunderbolt! - duke surgery€¦ · avoiding thor’s thunderbolt! the...

44
Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events Philip J. Walther, MD, PhD, MBA, FACS Professor of Urologic Surgery Duke U. School of Medicine

Upload: others

Post on 10-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt!

The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic

and Embolic Events

Philip J. Walther, MD, PhD, MBA, FACS Professor of Urologic Surgery Duke U. School of Medicine

Page 2: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Disclosures: None Off-Label Recommendations: None

Philip J. Walther, MD, PhD, MBA, FACS

Page 3: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Myocardial Infarction Evolving Diagnostics

• 1970’s: Primarily Sxs and EKG changes • 1980’s: Developing cardiac biomarkers

– LDH –isoenzymes, CPK and then CPK-MB • 1990’s: Onset of troponin Dxtics, but criteria for

ischemic Sx and EKG ∆ still dominant • 2000’s: Greater sensitivity: 4th and 5th Gen

– 2017: 5th Gen cTnT just approved by FDA • Impact of Better Dx & Rx: ↓ mortality rate

– Fewer have STEMI than N-STEMI MI’s

Page 4: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Major Peri-Operative Cardiac Complications

• Account for at least 1/3 of perioperative deaths. • Challenge: Ischemic Sx masked by patient’s

obtundation (Eg. Narcotics) or misinterpreted coinciding symptoms (abd. incisional pain)

• Impact: • Substantial morbidity & prolonged hospitalization • Increased medical cost • Affects intermediate and long-term prognosis.

Deceppe E, et al: Canad. J. Cardiology 2017; 33, 17-32

Page 5: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Revised Cardiac Risk Index Computation: Components (1 point / component present)

Lee TH, et al: Circulation 100: 1043-9, 1999

Page 6: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Revised Cardiac Risk Index Validation Cohort

RCRI Class

Index Sum

Major Cardiac Complication

Rate* (%) I 0 0.4 II 1 0.9 III 2 6.6 IV >2 11.0

*V.Fib/Cardiac arrest, Complete heart block, acute MI, or Pulmonary Edema

Lee TH, et al: Circulation 100: 1043-9, 1999

Page 7: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Ann Internal Med 2011; 154: 523-8

Page 8: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Perioperative MI (PMI) after Non-Cardiac Surgery:

Characteristics and Short-Term Prognosis

• Of those who had MI, 65% did not have ischemic Sx

• 30-Day Mortality: – PMI-11.6%; no PMI-2.2%

• With ischemic Sx: 9.7% • Without ischemic Sx: 12.5%

• 8.3% had elevated cardiac markers only Devereaux PJ et al:

Ann Internal Med 2011; 154: 523-8

Page 9: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

VISION Investigators JAMA 2012; 307:2295-304

• Prospective cohort study (15,133 pts) • Troponins drawn daily (POD 1,2,3)

– NOTE: 4th Gen cTnT was utilized • Clinical outcomes reviewed: 30-day

mortality was determined.

Page 10: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Postoperative Troponin and 30-Day Mortality

• Peak Troponin level correlated with risk of death within 30 d VISION Investigators

JAMA 2012; 307:2295-304

Kaplan-Meier Estimates of 30-Day Mortality Based on Peak Troponin T Levels

Page 11: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

MINS

• Many surgical patients sustain myocardial injury perioperatively that will not satisfy diagnostic criteria for MI, but portend diminished survival outcomes.

• (M)yocardial (I)njury after (N)on-cardiac (S)urgery- defined as: myocardial injury detected by troponin -caused by ischemia (that may or may not result in necrosis), has prognostic relevance, and occurs with 30 days of surgery.

VISION Investigators. Anesthesiology 2014; 307:564-78

Page 12: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

MINS: Clinical Outcomes

• Eight % of patients suffered MINS • 52.8% would not have fulfilled universal

definition of MI. • Only 15.8% of MINS experienced ischemic

symptoms. • Conclusion: MINS is common and is

associated with substantial mortality.

VISION Investigators. Anesthesiology 2014; 307:564-78

Page 13: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

JAMA 2017; 317: 1642-51

• 21,842 participants • Outcome: Death within 30 d.: 266 (1.2%) • Protocol: • cTnT drawn postop: At 6-12 hr, D1, 2, 3 • If >14 ng/L, assessed for:

– Ischemic features (Sxs, EKGs) – Excluding sepsis, PE, AF

Page 14: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Post-Operative Complications Troponin Occurrence and 30-Day Mortality

Complication % Occurrence Deaths (% of Occurrence)

MINS 17.9 4.1 Major Bleeding 14.2 4.5 Sepsis 4.1 9.3 New Atrial Fib 1.2 10.6 Stroke 0.3 15.9 Pulmonary embolus 0.4 4.3 DVT 0.3 2.6 Pneumonia 1.8 9.4

VISION Study Investigators. JAMA 2017;317:1642-51

Page 15: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Post-Operative Complications Troponin Occurrence and 30-Day Mortality

VISION Study Investigators. JAMA 2017;317:1642-51

Page 16: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Brain (B-Type) Natriuretic Peptide (BNP)

• Synthesized as Pro-BNP. Released by cardiomyocytes with multiple stimuli: – Ischemia, stretch, inflammation,

neuroendocrine stimuli. – Inhibits renin ↓ Aldosterone

production Natriuresis – Causes vasodilation

Page 17: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Brain (B-Type) Natriuretic Peptide (BNP)

• Strongly prognostic of cardiac injury and decompensation. – N-terminal peptide (NT-ProBNP and BNP very

similar in prognostic value.) • Blood test is inexpensive.

Page 18: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Peri-Op Cardiac Risk Assessment /

Management for Elective Non-Cardiac Surgery: Canadian Cardiovascular Society Guidelines 2017

(Duceppe, 2017: Can. J. Card.)

Patient Population: (Surgery requiring overnight admission) • Age: 18-44 yrs + known

signif. CV (SigCV) disease* • Age: ≥ 45 yrs

Risk Stratification with Revised Cardiac Risk (Lee) Index

If: • ≥ 65 yrs and RCRI ≥ 1, • 45-64 yrs with Sig CV,

Draw BNP/NT-proBNP (Neg. / Threshold- NT-pro: <300 mg/L

BNP <92 mg/L)

If NOT: No further testing

necessary

If Neg: No

additional Routine Postop

monitoring

If Pos:

• EKG in PACU (? Troponin) • Daily troponin x 48-72 hrs • Consider in-hospital shared-

care management

* Sig. CV Disease: Known CAD,

CBVD, PAD, CHF, Severe PHTN,

Severe obstructive intra-cardiac abnormality

Page 19: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Anesth Analg 2014; 119:1053-63

• Retrospective, case-controlled study • Site: Paris, France • All patients aged >18 years who underwent

major vascular surgery 2005-8 • Note: All patients had 30d of enoxaparin

Page 20: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Therapy Intensification (TI) for Post-Operative Troponin Elevation

• Focus on 4 major drug groups: – Anti-platelet agents – Beta-blockers – ACE inhibitors – Statins

• 66 pts with Pos. cTp: – 43 had TI; 23- no change

Fourcrier A, et al.: Anesth Analg 2014; 119:1053-63

Page 21: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Therapy Intensification (TI) for Post-Operative Troponin Elevation

Fourcrier A, et al: Anesth Analg 2014; 119:1053-63

Page 22: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Gettysburg, 1863

THE “GOOD OLD DAYS”

SURGEON

Page 23: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

THE “GOOD OLD DAYS”

Gettysburg, 1863 • Surgical therapeutic objectives

were straightforward. • Since the “tools of the trade” were

few (scalpel, saw, and thread), outcome expectations were limited.

• The surgeon was a HERO – when the patient lived!

• No one kept track of complications; they kept track of “SAVES”.

Page 24: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

NOT the “GOOD OLD DAYS” Anymore!!

• Joint Commission inspections & mandates provide a regulatory framework for constant surveillance of physician practice patterns

• National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP)

• Plaintiff Bar Filing Malpractice Torts

Page 25: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

EVERY BUSY SURGEON’S NEMESIS

EMBOLUS

CMS considers Venous Thromboembolism

a preventable complication!!!

Page 26: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

NOT the “GOOD OLD DAYS” Anymore!!

• Payors are now monitoring physician performance (scorecards”): – Complications – Length of Stay – Re-admission rates – Deaths!

• Since CMS considers venous thromboembolism a preventable complication, it becomes a major cost to the hospital– and ….

• SURGEON PRACTICE PATTERNS BECOME AN ISSUE!

Page 27: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

DVT Occurrence Correlates in Tandem with No. of Risk Factors

Anderson FA, Spencer FA. Circulation 2003; 107:I9-I16

Page 28: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Risk of VTE in Perioperative Period

Bahl V, Et al: Ann Surg 2010; 251: 344

Page 29: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Radical Cystectomy: A Setup for VTE?

• Of GU cancer cases, highest rate of VTE • Independent risk for VTE • Contemporary VTE incidence: 2.9-24.4% • In pelvic surgeries, Gyn and Gen Surg

literature suggests that risk extends beyond discharge date.

Page 30: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Findings: • 6% were diagnosed with VTE (DVT only- 2.9%; PE only-

1.7%; Both-1.4%) • 55% were diagnosed after initial discharge (65% of PE, 50%

of DVT) • Of pts with VTE, 30-day mortality rate was 6.4%

J. Urol 191: 943, 2014

Observational retrospective study: 1,037 cystectomy patients Source: NSQIP data base of ACS

Timeframe of surgery: 2005-2011

Page 31: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Timing of Postoperative VTE Events

VanDlac AA, et al. J. Urol 191: 943, 2014

Median and Mean Time: 14d &15.2d, respectively

Page 32: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

DVT Prophylaxis: Changing Patterns of Care-Need for New Paradigm?

• Large clinical experience (outside GU) has demonstrated risk of thromboembolism for several weeks after surgery (multiple abdominal sites)

• “Utilization Review” initiatives in late 1990’s: – Impact: substantially shorter postoperative hospital stays. – When used, postop inpatient DVT prophylaxis (SCD’s, ?

pharma) had a substantially shorter duration of use => potentially adverse outcomes

• Time for new paradigm? (Post-discharge prophylaxis!!) But if so, extent of duration?

Page 33: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

• All 332 pts: Everyone- Enoxaparin 40 mg qd (starting 10-14 hrs preop) for 6-10 d => then randomized.

• Randomization: Placebo vs. Drug for 19-21 d. • Compression stockings but no SCD’s • All pts had venograms at 25d (after not earlier for

Sxs)

New Engl. J. Med. 346: 975, 2002

Prospective, Double-blind, Placebo-controlled Randomized Trial

Page 34: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events
Page 35: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events
Page 36: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

DVT Prophylaxis-Postoperative Ortho LMWH (Enoxaparin) vs. Placebo

• Study: 100 pts undergoing hip surgery • Regimen: Randomization. Enoxaparin 30 mg

bid starting 12 hr postop x 14d (or discharge) • Monitoring: Daily 125I-Fb scans (confirmed by

venography if positive)

Turpie AGG, et al. et al. New Eng. J. Med. 315: 925, 1986

Page 37: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

DVT Prophylaxis-Postoperative LMWH (Enoxaparin) vs. Placebo

Turpie AGG, et al.: New Eng. J. Med. 315: 925, 1986

(10.8%) (51.2%) ( 5.4%) (23.1%)

Page 38: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Caprini Method

of Risk

Stratifi-cation

Bahl V, et al: Ann Surg

2010; 251: 344

Page 39: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Bahl V, Et al: Ann Surg 2010; 251: 344

Page 40: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events
Page 41: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

SHOCKING!!!

• 10,966 AUA members queried; 11% responded. • Question: FAMILIAR WITH RECOMMENDATIONS of the

AUA Best Practice Statement? • Yes 50.7% • No 19.4% • Unaware of AUA-BPS 29.9%

49.3% Sterious S, et al.: J. Urol. 190: 992 (2013)

Page 42: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

DVT Prophylaxis: Technique

• Mechanical: – Early ambulation – Graduated compression stockings – Intermittent (sequential) pneumatic compression (SCD’s)

• Pharmacologic: – Low-dose unfractionated heparin (LDUF-H) – Indirect Factor X inhibitors:

• Low molecular weight heparin (WMWH)- Ex., enoxaparin • Synthetic- fondaparinux

– Vitamin K antagonists (VKA)- warfarin – Oral therapies: Factor IIa & Xa inhibitors (dabigatran,rivaroxaban) – Developmental: Anti-sense anti-Factor XI inhibitors

Page 43: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Stratifying Patient Risk of DVT: Intrinsic Patient Risk AND Type of Procedure

Risk Stratification

AUA Best Practice Statement-DVT Prophylaxis, 2008

Page 44: Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! - Duke Surgery€¦ · Avoiding Thor’s Thunderbolt! The Urologist’s Role in Managing the Peri-operative Risk of Cardio-Ischemic and Embolic Events

Risk-Adapted VTE Prophylaxis: AUA-Best Practice Statement

*If patient >150 kg, consider Enoxaparin 40 mg q12h

AUA-BPS DVT Prophylaxis, 2008

“In selected very high-risk pts, consider post-discharge enoxaparin”