attachment a – seawall map, current piers & original...
TRANSCRIPT
-8
Attachment A – Seawall Map, Current Piers & Original Shoreline
Por
t of
San
Fra
nci
sco
RFP
# P
RT1
41
5-0
1S
elec
tion
Pan
el F
inal
Sco
rin
g w
/ C
MD
Bon
us
10
/8
/2
01
4
Pro
pos
al E
valu
atio
nA
BC
DTo
tal
With
CM
DIn
terv
iew
?AEC
OM
/Str
uctu
s JV
7768
6482
291
313
5 N
AG
S /
Mof
fatt
& N
icho
l JV
8388
7987
337
362
2 Y
Ben
C.
Ger
wic
k /
Lang
an T
read
wel
l Rol
l JV
9287
9085
354
354
3 Y
GH
D /
GTC
JV
8793
8490
354
381
1 Y
URS /
BEL
LO &
Ass
ocia
tes
JV87
7069
7830
432
74
NIn
terv
iew
sA
BC
DTo
tal
With
CM
DFi
nal R
esul
tsAG
S /
Mof
fatt
& N
icho
l JV
8982
7792
340
365.
52
Ben
C.
Ger
wic
k /
Lang
an T
read
wel
l Rol
l JV
9784
9287
360
360
3G
HD
/ G
TC JV
9088
8381
342
367.
651
PAN
EL M
EMBER
ID
Edwin M. Lee, Mayor
Naomi M. Kelly, City Administrator
Maria Cordero, Director
30 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 200, San Francisco, CA 94102
GENERAL SERVICES AGENCY CONTRACT MONITORING DIVISION
MEMORANDUM
Date: October 20, 2014
To: Steven Reel, Project Manager, Port
From: Boris Delepine, Contract Compliance Officer, CMD
Subject: Earthquake Vulnerability Study of the Northern Waterfront Seawall (the
“Project”)
The Contract Monitoring Division (CMD) has reviewed the consultant proposals and supporting
documentation for the above referenced project. Based on this review, CMD has determined that
all five proposals were materially compliant with the pre-award 14B requirements.
Ratings Bonus
The following proposers applied for and were granted the following ratings bonus:
Proposer Name Ratings Bonus %
Moffatt & Nichol/AGS JV 7.5%
GHD/GTC JV 7.5%
AECOM/Structus JV 7.5%
URS/Bello & Associates 7.5%
Score Sheets and Score Tabulations
CMD has reviewed the score sheets submitted by the panelists. According to the score
tabulations submitted by Esther Reyes the final rankings are as follows:
Firm Rank
GHD/GTC JV 1
Moffatt & Nichol/AGS JV 2
Ben Gerwick/Langan JV 3
LBE Subconsulting Goal
A LBE subconsulting goal of 25% was established for this project and GHD/GTC JV agreed to
achieve this goal by subconsulting specific services to LBEs as follows:
FIRM SERVICE LBE Status Percentage
Land Use Economics
Consultants, LLC
Economics Consultants LBE-OBE 8.2%
Telamon Engineering Civil Engineering LBE-WBE 9.1%
Saylor Consulting Group Cost Estimating LBE-WBE 4.7%
Ansari Structural Engineering LBE-MBE 2.0%
Rollo & Ridley Geotechnical Engineering LBE-OBE 1.9%
Total 25.9%
Based on the foregoing, CMD has determined that GHD/GTC JV is eligible for award of this
contract.
Should you have any questions, or if I can be of any further assistance, please do not hesitate to
contact me at 554-7554.