ARTICLE 68 71 RIGHSTS AND OBLIGATIONS BETWEEN HUSBAND AND WIFE | 1G.R. No. 139789July 19, 2001IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION FOR HABEAS CORPS OF POTENCIANO ILUSORIO, ER!IN"A #. I!SORIO, $%&'&'o(%), *+.ER!IN"A #. I!SORIO,BILDNER, S-!.IA #. I!SORIO,-AP, JOHN "OES /(0 JANE "OES, )%+$o(0%(&+.1,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,1G.R. No. 139808 July 19, 2001POTENCIANO I!SORIO, MA. ER!IN"A I. BI!"NER /(0 S-!.IA #. I!SORIO, $%&'&'o(%)+, *+.HON. CORT OF APPEA!S /(0 ER!IN"A #. I!SORIO, )%+$o(0%(&+.R E S O !T I O NPAR"O, J.2O(3% /4/'( 5% +%% &6% +/0 &/l% o7 / $)o8'(%(& 7/8'ly +6/&&%)%0 9y 3o(:'3&+ o( %1$%3&/(3y '( 7/9l%0 7o)&u(%.+O( M/)36 11, 1999, E)l'(0/ #. Ilu+o)'o, &6% 8/&)'/)36 56o 5/+ +o lo*'(4ly '(+%$/)/9l% 7)o8 6%) 6u+9/(0 +o8% y%/)+/4o, ;l%0 / $%&'&'o( 5'&6 &6% Cou)& o7 A$$%/l+1 7o) habeas corpus &o 6/*% 3u+&o0y o7 6%) 6u+9/(0 '( 3o(+o)&'u8.O( A$)'l %3&, Po&%(3'/(o Ilu+o)'o.T6u+, o( O3&o9%) 11, 1999, E)l'(0/ #. Ilu+o)'o ;l%0 5'&6 &6% Su$)%8% Cou)& /( /$$%/lvia 3%)&'o)/)' $u)+u'(4 6%) 0%+')%&o 6/*% 3u+&o0y o7 6%) 6u+9/(0 Po&%(3'/(o Ilu+o)'o.2 T6'+ 3/+% 5/+ 3o(+ol'0/&%0 5'&6 /(o&6%) 3/+%3 ;l%0 9y Po&%(3'/(oIlu+o)'o /(0 6'+ 36'l0)%(, E)l'(0/ I. B'l0(%) /(0 Syl*'/ #. Ilu+o)'o /$$%/l'(4 7)o8 &6% o)0%) 4'*'(4 *'+'&/&'o( )'46&+ &o 6'+5'7%, /++%)&'(4 &6/& 6% (%*%) )%7u+%0 &o +%% 6%).O( M/y 12, 2000, 5% 0'+8'++%0 &6% $%&'&'o( 7o) 6/9%/+ 3o)$u+? 7o) l/3= o7 8%)'&, /(0 4)/(&%0 &6% $%&'&'o(< &o (ull'7y &6%Cou)& o7 A$$%/l+@ )ul'(4A 4'*'(4 *'+'&/&'o( )'46&+ &o E)l'(0/ #. Ilu+o)'o.7B6/& '+ (o5 9%7o)% &6% Cou)& '+ E)l'(0/@+ 8o&'o( &o )%3o(+'0%) &6% 0%3'+'o(.8O( S%$&%89%) 20, 2000, 5% +%& &6% 3/+% 7o) $)%l'8'(/)y 3o(7%)%(3% o( O3&o9%) 11, 2000, /& 10200 /. 8., 5'&6ou&)%Cu')'(4 &6% 8/(0/&o)y $)%+%(3% o7 &6% $/)&'%+.I( &6/& 3o(7%)%(3%, &6% Cou)& l/'0 0o5( &6% '++u%+ &o 9% )%+ol*%0, &o 5'&2D/E To 0%&%)8'(% &6% $)o$)'%&y o7 / $6y+'3/l /(0 8%0'3/l %1/8'(/&'o( o7 $%&'&'o(%) Po&%(3'/(o Ilu+o)'oFD9E B6%&6%) &6% +/8% '+ )%l%*/(&F /(0D3E I7 )%l%*/(&, 6o5 &6% Cou)& 5'll 3o(0u3& &6% +/8%.9T6% $/)&'%+ %1&%(+'*%ly 0'+3u++%0 &6% '++u%+. T6% Cou)&, '( '&+ )%+olu&'o(, %(>o'(%0 &6% $/)&'%+ /(0 &6%') l/5y%)+ &o'('&'/&% +&%$+ &o5/)0+ /( /8'3/9l% +%&&l%8%(& o7 &6% 3/+% &6)ou46 8%0'/&'o( /(0 o&6%) 8%/(+.O( No*%89%) 29, 2000, &6% Cou)& (o&%0 &6% 8/('7%+&/&'o( /(0 3o8$l'/(3% o7 &6% $/)&'%+ 5'&6 &6% )%+olu&'o( o7 O3&o9%)11, 2000.10O( J/(u/)y 31, 2001, &6% Cou)& 0%('%0 E)l'(0/ Ilu+o)'o@+ 8/('7%+&/&'o( /(0 8o&'o( $)/y'(4 &6/& Po&%(3'/(o Ilu+o)'o 9%$)o0u3%0 9%7o)% &6% Cou)& /(0 9% 8%0'3/lly %1/8'(%0 9y / &%/8 o7 8%0'3/l %1$%)&+ /$$o'(&%0 9y &6% Cou)&.11O( M/)36 27, 2001, 5% 0%('%0 5'&6 ;(/l'&y E)l'(0/@+ 8o&'o( &o )%3o(+'0%) &6% Cou)&@+ o)0%) o7 J/(u/)y 31 , 2001.12T6% '++u%+ )/'+%0 9y E)l'(0/ #. Ilu+o)'o '( 6%) 8o&'o( 7o) )%3o(+'0%)/&'o( /)% 8%)% )%'&%)/&'o(+ o7 6%) /)4u8%(&+ &6/&6/*% 9%%( )%+ol*%0 '( &6% 0%3'+'o(.N%*%)&6%l%++, 7o) %8$6/+'+, 5% +6/ll 0'+3u++ &6% '++u%+ &6u+2First. E)l'(0/#. Ilu+o)'o3l/'8%0&6/& +6%5/+(o& 3o8$%ll'(4Po&%(3'/(o&ol'*%5'&66%)'(3o(+o)&'u8/(0&6/&Po&%(3'/(o@+ 8%(&/l +&/&% 5/+ (o& /( '++u%. Ho5%*%), &6% *%)y )oo& 3/u+% o7 &6% %(&')% $%&'&'o( '+ 6%) 0%+')% &o 6/*%6%) 6u+9/(0@+ custody.13 Cl%/)ly, E)l'(0/ 3/((o& (o5 0%(y &6/& +6% 5/(&%0 Po&%(3'/(o Ilu+o)'o &o l'*% 5'&6 6%).Second. O(% )%/+o( 56y E)l'(0/ #. Ilu+o)'o +ou46& 3u+&o0y o7 6%) 6u+9/(0 5/+ &6/& )%+$o(0%(&+ !'( /(0 Syl*'/ 5%)%'ll%4/lly )%+&)/'('(4 Po&%(3'/(o Ilu+o)'o &o 7)/u0ul%(&ly 0%$)'*% 6%) o7 $)o$%)&y )'46&+ ou& o7 $u)% 4)%%0.1? S6% 3l/'8%0&6/& 6%) &5o 36'l0)%( 5%)% u+'(4 &6%') +'3= /(0 7)/'l 7/&6%) &o +'4( /5/y Po&%(3'/(o /(0 E)l'(0/@+ $)o$%)&y &o 3o8$/('%+3o(&)oll%0 9y !'( /(0 Syl*'/. S6% /l+o /)4u%0 &6/& +'(3% Po&%(3'/(o )%&')%0 /+ 0')%3&o) /(0 oG3%) o7 B/4u'o Cou(&)yClu9 /(0 P6'l'$$'(% O*%)+%%+ T%l%3o88u('3/&'o(+, +6% 5oul0 lo4'3/lly /++u8% 6'+ $o+'&'o( /(0 3o(&)ol. -%&, !'( /(0Syl*'/ 5%)% &6% o(%+ 3o(&)oll'(4 &6% 3o)$o)/&'o(+.1