Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

WEEKLY PLANNING LISTS

Article 27(2), Planning & Development Regulations 2001-2007

(a) Under section 34 of the Act, the applications for permission may be granted permission, subject to or without conditions, or refused.

(b) It is the responsibility of any person wishing to use the personal data on planning applications and decisions lists for direct marketing purposes to be satisfied that they may do so legitimately under the requirements of the Data Protection Acts 1988 and 2003 taking account of the preferences outlined by applicants in their applications.

Article 32, Planning & Development Regulations 2001 –2007

(a) In deciding a planning application the planning authority, in accordance with section 34(3) of the Act, has had regard to submissions or observations received in accordance with these Regulations”

(b) It is the responsibility of any person wishing to use the personal data on planning applications and decisions lists for direct marketing purposes to be satisfied that they may do so legitimately under the requirements of the Data Protection Acts 1988 and 2003 taking account of the preferences outlined by applicants in their applications.

PLANNING INFORMATION SESSIONS Qualified staff members are available by appointment to explain the content of current planning applications. The service is being provided to assist members of the public and residents groups in understanding planning applications currently part of the planning process. The service is not intended to provide general planning advice or to assist in the drafting of submissions in relation to planning objections, observations and appeals. All queries in relation to site specific planning guidance or pre-application discussion should be directed to the area planner, Planning Department, Block 4, Floor 3, Civic Offices, Wood Quay, Dublin 8. Please contact the relevant area office number below to make an appointment and to ensure that the relevant documentation will be made available on the day of your visit.

Area Contact Number Meeting Location

Central Area South Central Area South East Area North West Area North Central Area

2222932 2225189 2225127 2225727 8166710

Sean McDermott Street Crumlin Area Office Contact Area Office for location Finglas Area Office Bunratty Area Office

1

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

AREA 1

COMMERCIAL:

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3486/08 Application Type Permission Applicant J. Kenny, KAR Catering Location 26, Fenian Street, Dublin 2 Proposal Change of use of part of the ground floor from sandwich bar to

pizza delivery outlet, and to install new signage over existing shop front.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Additional Information Received Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3631/08 Application Type Permission Applicant J Lowney Location 92, Ranelagh and 1 Chelmsford Lane, Dublin 6 Proposal Extract flue at roof level from ground floor commercial kitchen

and for omission of car parking spaces at 1 Chelmsford Lane at rear of existing restaurant/cafe bar with take out facility at ground floor and part first floor at 92 Ranelagh, Dublin 6.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Additional Information Received Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4702/08 Application Type Retention Permission Applicant Odessa Club & Restaurant Ltd Location Odessa Restaurant, 13-14, Dame Court, Dublin 2 Proposal Retention permission to a development previously granted

planning permission (PL Ref 4583/06). retention is sought for: (a) Modifications to two entrance/escape doors- single doors in lieu of double doors, with position of doors adjusted for door swings (b) Resizing of of penthouse room & terrace with re positioning of store room over 3rd floor balcony terrace & adjustment to toilet & stair layouts.

Registration Date 13-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4708/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Ciaran Hickey Location 2, Rathmines Road Lower, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Planning permission to restore

and renovate 8no. existing studio apartments. The development shall include: forming new basement entrance, including external stairs from front garden to basement apartments; constructing external wheelchair ramp from side garden to basement; renovating existing front and side gardens, including railings and paths; removing existing internal stairs between basement and ground floor; constructing new balconies to the rear, to serve ground, first and second floor apartments; forming new opes in the rear wall on ground, first and second floor levels; installing new bathroom, sanitary and kitchen

2

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

facilities throughout; renovating and restoring the existing external and internal walls, including existing historical brickwork, stonework, timber joinery and timber and plaster finishes; renovating the roof and chimneys.

Registration Date 13-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4709/08 Application Type Permission Applicant The Apostolic Leadership Location 67A, Pearse Street, Dublin 2 Proposal The development will consist of alterations and modifications to

an existing single storey church building, comprising the following: 1. A new first floor level, - incorporating a new congregation hall with associated office and storage areas. 2. Internal modifications to the ground floor level, incorporating a new reception area, new refreshment/seating area, meeting room, 4no. classrooms with associated toilet and amenity facilities. 3. Replace existing front facade, with new stone clad and glazed shopfront type facade, with brick finish and new windows to the new first floor level. 4. New stainless steel lettered signage reading ''Apostolic Church'', and new stainless steel logo.

Registration Date 13-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4714/08 Application Type Permission Applicant T.P. Smith Location 5-5a, Fownes Street, Dublin 2 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission for the fitting out of the

ground floor right-of-house front room and rear return into shop premises (a hairdressers salon), the reinstatement of the upper floor and ceiling removed from the rear return room of the same premises and the provision of external signage.

Registration Date 13-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4717/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Ken McDonnell Location 67, Mespil Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 Proposal Planning permission for an alteration to the existing planning

permission (reg. ref. no. 1495/08) to comprise the addition to the rear, over the second and third floor levels, of a 2 storey duplex residential apartment accessed from the adjoining apartment building on Fleming's Court. The apartment would include 3 bedrooms, master en suite, main bathroom, hallway and stairs, lounge, kitchen/dining area and associated storage areas. The site is located in a Conservation Area.

Registration Date 13-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East

3

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Application Number 4726/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Blanche Burke Location 33A, Wasdale Park, Terenure, Dublin 6 Proposal For Montessori Sessional Childcare use in the garage structure

to the rear. Registration Date 14-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4730/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Brondsway Ltd. Location Camden Court Hotel, Camden Street Upper, & Charlotte Way,

Dublin 2 Proposal Permission to extend upwards the Camden Court Hotel with 2

extra floors on Camden Street & Charlotte Way elevations (making a total of 7 storeys, including mansards), the demolition and consolidation of rooftop plant rooms and the addition of 1 extra floor to internal courtyard block (making a total of 8 storeys including plantroom level), all in external finishes of brick, natural slate and zinc to match existing. Proposed development to comprise 75 bedrooms, 2 lifts with ancillary accommodation and plant totalling 2967.7sqm.

Registration Date 14-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4734/08 Application Type Retention Permission Applicant Leinster Branch IRFU Location Leinster Branch IRFU Rugby Grounds, Donnybrook Road,

Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal Temporary retention of development (for a period of three

years) on a site of 90sqm (approximately), (the application site) within the overall Leinster Branch IRFU Rugby Grounds (4 ha approximately). The application site is bounded to the west by the entrance turnstiles and gate to the Leinster Branch (IRFU) Rugby Grounds, to the north by Bective Pavilion, to the south by the main pitch and recently constructed viewing stand and to the east by the second practise playing pitch. The retained structure consists of the following: a single storey, temporary prefabricated structure totalling 87sqm. The structure contains ancillary storage (19sqm), medical (10sqm) and merchandise uses (58sqm). Access is provided via the north-western side of the building.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4735/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Leinster Branch IRFU Location Leinster Branch IRFU Rugby Grounds, Donnybrook Road,

Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal Permission for temporary development on a site of 306sqm

approximately (the application site) within the overall Leinster Branch IRFU Rugby Grounds (4 ha approximately). The application site is bounded by the River Dodder to the east, Wesley Rugby Football Club to the west, Leinster Rugby

4

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

playing pitch to the north, and an ESB compound and carpark to the south. The development will consist of: a two-storey temporary prefabricated structure totalling 102sqm containing a gym, shower and toilet room (78sqm) at lower level and ancillary gym office/assessment room (24sqm at first floor level. An external stairwell will provide access to the first floor from ground level.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4736/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Caroline Connolly Location 113A, Rathgar Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6 Proposal Demolition of the remains of an uninhabitable dwelling and

provision of a new two storey dwelling with a reduced lower ground floor level 1.08m below street level towards the rear of the site, abutting to neighbouring property. Provision is made for 1 no. enclosed patio at lower ground level (5.6sqm), 1 no. parking space and landscaped yard to front of site (24.1sqm), alterations to front boundary wall to provide vehicular and pedestrian access and associated site works.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4742/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Mosaic Fashions Location Unit 3, The Gaiety Centre, 35-45 South King Street, Dublin 2 Proposal fascia level signage to South-West (front) elevation of proposed

'Warehouse' retail unit. Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4743/08 Application Type Retention Permission Applicant Motor Services Limted Location Former Veterinary College site, Shelbourne Road, Ballsbridge,

Dublin 4 Proposal RETENTION - The development comprises of a temporary

overflow car park for the storage of vehicles for Ballsbridge Motors for a limited period up to a maximum of two years. 100 no. car parking spaces will be provided on the 0.6212 hectare site. Access to the site will be provided via the existing entrance from Shelbourne Road.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4746/08 Application Type Permission Applicant John Woodbyrne Location Vacant site to the East of Ace Business Centre, Fisherman's

Wharf, Thorncastle Street, Dublin 4 Proposal The development will consist of the construction of a three

storey building consisting of two parking spaces at ground floor and two one bed apartments over, with balconies to the front

5

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

and with shared roof terrace. Access to the site is via a shared entrance on Thorncastle Street.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4754/08 Application Type Permission Applicant John Costello Location 29, Dartmouth Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-The development consists of the

following for which permission is sought: A. Demolition of existing two storey return and construction of 3 storey extension to the rear. The existing two storey return contains 1no. one bed apartment on the first floor. B. Change of use of the remaining existing building from previous use as a veterinary surgery to residential use. C. The total number of proposed residential units on the site is three, comprising of 1no. 3 bed unit of 154sqm within the existing building to 29 Dartmouth Road, 1no. 1 bed unit of 55sqm and 1no. 1 bed unit (duplex) of 67sqm built to the rear/side of the existing main structure, facing onto Dartmouth Terrace. The total height of this proposed structure to the rear/side, is 3 storeys with a 8.66 metre high parapet. D. Internal alterations to the interior and rear of the existing protected structure are also proposed. E. The proposed 1no. 3 bed unit contains a set back terrace of 22.7sqm facing on to Dartmouth Terrace. The proposed 1no. 1 bed unit (67sqm duplex) contains a 4.7sqm terrace at first floor and a 24.6sqm terrace at second floor level, both facing onto Dartmouth Terrace.

Registration Date 16-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4757/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Suzanne & Damian Ryan Location Donmel, 30B, Eglinton Road, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal demolition of existing two storey dwelling and single storey

garage to allow for the construction of a new two storey over basement, 4 bedroom detached dwelling. Other works will include 2 No. surface parking spaces accessed from Eglinton Road, new boundary walls and entrance gates and all ancillary works. The proposed dwelling is adjacent to a protected structure.

Registration Date 16-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4759/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Ms Maryse Leroux, MCO, Embassy of Canada Location 7/8, Wilton Terrace, Dublin 2 Proposal 2 embassy flags and flag poles on the fourth floor terrace of 7/8

Wilton Terrace, Dublin 2, a 5 storey office development, which has a planning register reference number: 2892/01, An Bord Pleanala Reference Number PL29S.128171. The flag poles will be positioned towards the principal elevation fronting Wilton

6

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Terrace and will be 3260mm high from 4th floor parapet to top.

Registration Date 16-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4768/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Ryan Hanratty Location 81, Camden Street Lower, Dublin 2 Proposal The development will consist of refurbishment to no. 81 Lower

Camden Street which will include: Construction of 2 no. two bedroom apartments (134.4sqm total) to front at first and second floor levels. Construction of an additional 1 no. one bedroom apartment (61.8sqm total) to front to be set back behind open roof terraces facing onto Camden Street Lower at third floor level. Construction of 1 no. two bedroom duplex apartment (79.9sqm total) to rear, above ground floor retail (128.5sqm total). Construction of first floor roof garden, internal alterations and all ancillary site works.

Registration Date 17-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4772/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Stephen Cloonan Location Kealy Twyford Motors, Corner of Church Avenue and Church

Gardens, Rathmines, Dublin 6 Proposal Demolition of existing commercial car sales and repair garages

on Church Gardens and demolition of non-commercial garage on Church Avenue and construction of 6 no. 3 storey over basement terraced houses with first floor terraces to rear, each with off street parking accessed from Church Gardens, construction of a new vehicular access road off Church Avenue, infill and repair to existing stone wall to Church Avenue, together with associated site development and landscaping works for the entire development.

Registration Date 17-Oct-2008

DOMESTIC:

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3420/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Sean Fitzgerald Location 51, Home Villas, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal Demolition of two no. single storey extensions, and the

construction of a two storey extension (7.3m high) to the side (containing 3 no. rooflights), and a single storey extension (2.9m high) to the rear.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Additional Information Received Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4713/08

7

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Application Type Permission Applicant Piers Thompson Location 4, Carlisle Avenue, Dublin 4 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission sought for demolition

of existing rear extension and erection of new single storey rear extension of area c. 17.8sqm and new boiler house of c. 1.6sqm with associated site works and landscaping and minor internal alterations and refurbishment works to existing terraced house.

Registration Date 13-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4722/08 Application Type Permission Applicant John & Caroline Grant Location 11, Wasdale Grove, Terenure, Dublin 6 Proposal The development will consist of: attic conversion to bedroom

en-suite with dormer roof to rear and roof lights to front. Gable wall raised to half hip with obscure glazed windows. Roof lights in existing garage flat roof and glazed panel in wall to kitchen area over flat roof. Glazed panels in front garage doors. rear chimney to be demolished. Front porch extended outwards. Roof lights in existing flat roof to rear single storey extension. internal alterations and refurbishments.

Registration Date 14-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4728/08 Application Type Permission Applicant S. Plunkett Location 16, Morehampton Terrace, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission sought to demolish an

existing single storey and 2 storey extension at rear, erect single storey and 2 storey extension at rear, internal alterations, replacement of existing double glazed aluminium windows to front and rear elevations with double glazed timber sliding sash windows.

Registration Date 14-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4747/08 Application Type Retention Permission Applicant Hugh Lambert Location 22, Elgin Road, Dublin 4 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE - RETENTION - retain the

alterations to the garden level apartment. Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4750/08 Application Type Permission Applicant Frank & Mark Cassin Location 47, Pembroke Lane, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 Proposal alterations to previously granted permission

PL29S.217051(Dublin City Council Ref No. 5661/05 - demolish the existing two-storey dwelling and construct in its place a new

8

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

two storey natural stone faced Mews). The proposed alterations shall consist of the inclusion of a balcony on the west elevation and the conversion of 2 windows on the same elevation to doors.

Registration Date 15-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4766/08 Application Type Permission Applicant John Callanan Location 58, Heytesbury Lane, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 Proposal Extend an existing basement and to construct a roof light in the

front garden. The existing basement; laundry and boiler room of 13.2sqm is to be extended to comprise laundry, storage space, wc and cinema room, in total 97.2sqm. The proposed basement will extend beyond the existing house into the front garden, a zinc lined roof light will provide ventilation to the room below; the cinema room.

Registration Date 17-Oct-2008 Area Area 1 - South East Application Number WEB1082/08 Application Type Retention Permission Applicant Cormac Jackson Location 152, Rosary Terrace, Dublin 4 Proposal Conversion of Attic space to habitable accommodation

including retention of and extension to rear dormer, change of roof profile and internal alterations

Registration Date 13-Oct-2008

LAWS: ***NONE*** SAWS: ***NONE*** DECISIONS:

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 0370/06 Application Type Section 5 Decision Grant Exemption Certificate Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant Focus Ireland Ltd Location 14A, Eustace Street, Temple Bar, Dublin 2 Proposal EXPP - replacement of sliding sash windows to front and rear

facades

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 0507/08

9

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Application Type Section 5 Decision Grant Exemption Certificate Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Alan Horgan Location 72, Pembroke Gardens, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal Proposed extension to the rear side of existing structure.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 0518/08 Application Type Section 5 Decision Refuse Exemption Certificate Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant Shared Access Ltd Location 10, Burlington Road, Dublin 4 Proposal Proposed new power/switch room.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 0523/08 Application Type Section 5 Decision Refuse Exemption Certificate Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant G & T McGovern Ltd Location 9-12 Price's Lane & rear 31 Ranelagh Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6Proposal To continue use as a scrap metal business.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 0524/08 Application Type Section 5 Decision Grant Exemption Certificate Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Donnacha Neary Location Grattan Court, Grattan Street, Dublin 2 Proposal Fitting of condensers within the owners property.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 0553/08 Application Type Social Housing Exemption Certificate Decision Grant Social Housing Exemption Cert Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant Gavin & Orlaith Duffy Location Idle Hour, Ailesbury Road, Dublin 4 Proposal Detached Dwelling

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 2303/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Barratts Shoes

10

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Location 80, Grafton Street, Dublin 2 (corner of Grafton Street & Johnson

Court) Proposal The development consists of removal of existing shopfront

column and stall riser timber cladding and replacing with black granite.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3161/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Kivaway Limited Location 57, Harcourt Street (site of the former Harcourt Street railway

station), Dublin 2 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission for development at this

site: known as the Odeon Bar and Grill, (site of former Harcourt Street railway station). The proposed development will comprise: repaving the existing enclosed car park/storage area at the northern side of the premises and use of 58.7sqm (approx.) of the existing enclosed car park/storage area as an external seating area for customers of the Odeon Bar and Grill. This seating area will be defined by new 1.1m high fabric/solid windbreakers at its northern edge. The proposed seats/tables and wind breakers can be removed, when necessary, to facilitate goods deliveries to the premises. This proposal will also include the following: alterations to the car park/storage area's existing modern site boundary onto Harcourt Street (consisting railings/dwarf wall and 5m wide vehicle access gate) to be replaced by new railings to match existing and new 4.5m wide vehicle access gate and 1.3m wide pedestrian gate; a new opening with steps in the existing northern side wall of the building to link the existing colonnaded area with the new external seating area, with new stone cladding around new opening, and the stone surround of the new opening to match that of existing windows; the existing metal stairs from the car park up to the ground floor level of the building to be replaced by new escape stairs and platform (with glass and stainless steel balustrades), plus new door to replace existing door at entrance at the top of the metal stairs; new glass canopy to be placed over this entrance; new 2.4m high timber panel screens (3.5m high from ground level) at rear (eastern edge) of new platform; the northern end of the buildings front steps onto Harcourt Street to be cut back and detailed to match existing arrangement at southern end of steps; the existing concrete steps from car park down to basement/cold store to be rebuilt, with new platform lift for waste bins; a blocked-up opening at the base of the concrete steps into a basement store room to be reopened and this store room (13.96sqm) now to be used for bin storage, with a new fire door at the existing internal access between the new bin store and the existing bottle store; and all associated site works and landscaping. The total site area is approximately 1,114sqm.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3372/08 Application Type Permission

11

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Mark and Valerie Duffy Location 12, Church Gardens, Rathmines, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE - The development will consists of

a two storey terraced cottage, which is a protected structure. The works will consist of demolition of the existing single storey extensions to the rear, construction of a new part 2 storey, part single storey extension to the rear, replacement of existing windows, door and gate to the front and refurbishment of the interior.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3374/08 Application Type Retention Permission Decision GRANT RETENTION PERMISSION Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant Cormac Egan Location 73, Rathmines Road Upper, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Retention permission for the

permanent change of use from domestic to commercial (child care facility) on upper ground floor and first floor levels and new staff room to attic level in respect of already approved temporary planning permission granted for 3 years (P.A. Reg. Ref. 4047/04).

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4110/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Emma & Fergal Barry Location 29, Ringsend Road, Dublin 4 Proposal Planning permission is sought for the modification of the existing

front railings and kerb to allow for the construction of vehicular double entrance gates and 1no. off street car parking and all associated site works. All works to be carried out at 29 Ringsend Road.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4111/08 Application Type Permission Decision ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Paul Dufficy Location 126, Leinster Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6 (Between Effra House

& 29 Grosvenor Place) Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission for development at 126

Leinster Road & site between Effra House & 29 Grosvenor Place & the lands to the rear of 125, 126, 127 & 128 Leinster Road and the lands to the rear of 43, 41, 39, 37, 35, 33, 31 & 29 Grosvenor Place & the lands to the rear of Effra House bounded by Wynnefield House, 1 Charleville Close, St Louis High School &

12

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

27 Grosvenor Place in Rathmines, Dublin 6. The development will consist of construction of 21 residential units in 4no. blocks referred to as Blocks A, B, C & D. The breakdown of residential units is as follows: Block A: 2 storey, 2 no. 3 bed mews dwellings & 3no. 3 bed duplex apartments with balconies on the south elevation; Block B: 3 storey, 3no. 1 bed apartments & 3no. 3 bed duplex apartments with balconies on the north & south elevation; Block C: 2 storey, 4no. 3 bed apartments & 4no. 2 bed apartments with screened balconies on the west elevation & general balconies on the east elevation; Block D: 2 storey, 2no. 3 bed apartments with screened balcony on the west elevation & general balcony on the east elevation. Total development area is 2,986sqm. The development will include the construction of underground parking with lift & stair access at Blocks B & D, with 35 no. parking spaces, 33no. cycle parking spaces and communal storage; vehicular access to underground parking & pedestrian site entrance off Grosvenor Place, between Effra House and 29 Grosvenor Place, pedestrian access also from Charleville Close, vehicular access to Block A only from Charleville Close, provision of all hard and soft landscaping, plant areas, changes in level, boundary treatments and all associated site excavation and site development works. The development will include restoration of the front & rear gardens and demolition and reconstruction of the rear boundary wall of the Protected Structure at 126 Leinster Road. The site is within curtilage of the Protected Structures at 126, 127 & 128 Leinster Road.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4116/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Brendan Smyth & Joseph O'Leary Location 7-9, Aston Quay, Dublin 2 Proposal The application includes: Change of use to hotel, of that part of

the ground floor previously in retail use. New fenestration/shopfront to the ground floor of the Aston Quay elevation. New signage at sign fascia level on the Aston Quay elevation.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4119/08 Application Type Permission Decision REFUSE PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant L. Crowe, B. Flannery & R. Payne Location 74, Pleasants Place (to the rear of 74 Camden Street lower a

protected structure), Dublin 2 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission for development

comprising of the demolition of an existing single storey non-habitable shed structure (c.87sqm) and the construction of a four storey plus basement development comprising of 4no.

13

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

apartment units (2no. one bed units and 2no. two bed units). Private open space in the form of balcony and/or terrace for each unit is as follows: ground floor (unit 1): terrace (6.133sqm) located to the rear (east) elevation; first and second floor (units 2 & 3): balcony 1 (c.4.75sqm) located to the front (west) elevation and balcony 2 (c.6.133sqm) located to the rear (east) elevation; penthouse (unit 4): balcony 1 (c.10.25sqm) located to the front (west) elevation and balcony 2 (c.6.133sqm) located to the rear (east) elevation. Laundry facilities, additional basement storage and 4no. bicycle stands are located in the basement (47.1sqm). This proposed development including permission for all associated site works relates to lands at 74 Pleasants Place (to the rear of 74 Camden Street, a protected structure). The total site area amounts to c.0.0109ha. Access to the subject site is proposed from Pleasants Place. No works are proposed to the protected structure as part of this application.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4121/08 Application Type Permission Decision REFUSE PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Sundry Supplies Location Sundry Supplies, Burlington House, Waterloo Lane, Dublin 4 Proposal Planning permission for the placement of two 6 metre long dry

goods storage containers to the rear of the property, along with screen fencing to containers and associated site works.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4125/08 Application Type Permission Decision ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Markland Georgian Property Ltd. Location 29, Fitzwilliam Street Upper, Dublin 2 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-The development consists of re-

pointing the existing brickwork at the rear of the main building.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4134/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Philip Smith Location 12, Temple Road, Darty, Dublin 6 Proposal Attic extension within existing roofspace to consist of 2

bedrooms, bathroom, access stairs and 4 no. rooflights to rear.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4135/08 Application Type Permission

14

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Decision ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Patrick Higgins Location 38, South Lotts Road, Ringsend, Dublin 4 Proposal Construction of a new vehicular entrance to front, conversion of

attic space, installation of new dormer window to rear of existing dwelling and all associated works.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4137/08 Application Type Permission Decision REFUSE PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Brian O'Connell Location 6, Anne Street South, Dublin 2 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE: The change of use of the ground,

first and second floors from existing existing retail use to wine tapas bar.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4149/08 Application Type Permission Decision REFUSE PERMISSION Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Vincent O'Hara Location 3, Mountain View Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 Proposal Retention permission is sought for 1 car parking space in front

garden. Accessed by removing a section of the existing boundary wall adjoining the existing laneway running alongside the property and using that laneway to access the car space. This is a conservation area.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4150/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Mr. Brian Rutledge Location 6, Lennox Terrace, Portobello, Dublin 8 Proposal Alterations & amendments to previously granted planning

permission (Reg. Ref. 5157/07) to create a 2 bed domestic dwelling. The works to the rear at first floor level for which permission is sought include. 1) Change of use from dressing room to bedroom. 2) Provision of escape window from bedroom on side (North) elevation, to flat roofed area with opaque glazing to 1.5m above finished floor level. 3) Provision of stairwell window at rear (East) elevation, with opaque glazing.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4152/08 Application Type Permission

15

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Clodagh & Andrew Bradley Location 27, Ashfield Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 Proposal The development will consist of the demolition of an existing

single storey return & part of the two storey rear return structure, reconstruction and partial extension of the ground floor structure of the rear return and the extension of the first floor portion of the rear return with associated alterations to the rear elevation. The proposal will increase the area of the building from 150 sq/m to 179 sq/m. Works include associated internal alterations and new roof light.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4156/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Mary Mallon Location 13, Belmont Avenue, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-The development will consist of the

following. 1- The demolition of the existing rear single storey lean-to garden store, and the construction of a new rear single storey kitchen and utility extension with pitched roof including all associated drainage and ancillary site works. 2- New glazed doors and glazed screens to rear elevation and rear return and new internal double doors between main ground floor reception rooms. 3- New under-stairs shower and wc 4- Block up existing rear external door.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4158/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Maghnus & Michele O'Donnell Location 39 & 41, Anglesea Road, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal Planning permission is sought for the proposed development at

nos. 39 & 41 Anglesea Road comprising: Incorporation of return of no. 39 fully into no. 41. Demolition of existing lean-to extensions to rear of existing properties and construction of single storey extension to rear and side of enlarged return to no. 41. Demolition of existing and construction of new 'box' bay window and steps to rear of no. 39 and reduction in size of side window ope to existing return of no. 39 to accommodate steps. Provision of window in lieu of door to side of existing return to no. 39. Reduction in size of window ope to south elevation of existing return at first level. Reduction in level of existing 'storage' basement sufficient to provide 'habitable' basement. Provision of dormer windows and velux roof-lights to front of both properties and dormer window to rear of no. 41.

16

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4163/08 Application Type Permission Decision REFUSE PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Juerg v. Geitz Location 38, Baggot Lane, Dublin 4 Proposal Permission for the demolition of an existing 2-storey mews

building and replacement with a 2-storey mid terrace single dwelling with additional basement and roof top garden, changes to boundary treatment, on site parking with access from Baggot Lane and all associated site works.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4164/08 Application Type Permission Decision ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Noel Reynolds Location Wyndham Court, Chancery Lane, Dublin 8 Proposal The development will consist of the change of use from

retail/commercial use comprising 126.6sqm *pref. ref. 1744/06) to restaurant/delicatessan use with ancillary take away and associated signage.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4166/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Ivan Coonan & Deirdre Groarke Location 5, Railway Cottages, Sandymount, Dublin 4 Proposal Permission to construct a single storey extension to the rear of

the site. The proposed structure will have a raised roof section incorporating a clerestory roof light at high level and consist of 3 bedrooms, one with en-suite wc; 1 bathroom, utility and courtyard. The new structure is to be linked by a canopy & courtyard to the existing cottage where minor alterations will be carried out, including 2 new roof lights to the rear and hipped side to the existing roof. Associated site works will be undertaken including repair and rebuilding of the boundary walls.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4167/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Greg & Nidia Traynor Location 11, Windsor Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-The development will consist of:

1) Demolition of the existing ground floor flat-roofed extension to

17

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

the rear. 2) Construction of a new ground floor extension to the rear. The new extension will have a duo-pitched roof flanked by parapet walls and will include seven velux roof windows. 3) Demolition of the rear boundary wall and construction of a two-storey garage, adjacent to the rear access lane. The garage will have a lean-to roof with six velux roof windows and no first floor windows. Rear access to the garage from the lane will be via a 3m wide gated opening. The development will be completely to the rear and will not be visible from Windsor Road. The house at 11 Windsor Road is a protected structure.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4173/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant DLC Properties (Ireland) Ltd Location 10, Newgrove Avenue, Sandymount, Dublin 4 Proposal The following works to the existing 2-storey house; A) The

demolition of the existing chimney on the rear return, the timber framed toilet structure at landing level to the side and the double pitched roof over the main house. B) The construction of a new 2 storey gabled pitched roof extension to the rear, C) The raising of the remaining ridge and pitch by 400mm on the existing single storey garden return. D) The replacement of the main double pitched roof with a new mansard type roof with 2 no. vaulted dormer windows to the front and 3 no. velux (or similar) type rooflights to the rear pitch to accommodate a new floor of accommodation. The resultant height of the new ridge of this roof to be 950mm higher than the present existing ridge of the roof. All the above to be used for single domestic use. The resultant house, following these works will comprise 5 no. bedrooms. All the above works and associated sundry works to the existing house.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4185/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant T and W Behan Location 191, Rathmines Road Upper, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE - Permission sought for (a)

Demolition of existing single storey return to rear and separate semi-detached garden shed, (b) new single storey extension to rear, (c) new double doors to rear in existing open, (d) 3 no. Velux Conservation Roof Windows to main roof to rear, (e) 2 no. Conservation Roof Windows to rear return roof to side, (f) new 6 sq.m. solar panel to rear return roof to side, (g) internal alterations and (h) all associated site works

18

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4203/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant McCabe Builders Ltd Location Corner Of Richmond Street South And Lennox Street, Dublin 2 Proposal The development will consist of amendments to previously

Approved Planning Application No. 3008/05 - the demolition of the existing three storey educational building (c. 2080sq.m) together with associated site and external works which is bounded by protected structures on South Richmond Street and Lennox Street, and the replacement of same with two separate office developments (c. 115.6sq.m and c. 1092.2sq.m respectively) together with part ground retail (c. 226.8sq.m) in a 2 - 4 storey building over 1 floor basement car parking (20 spaces), reduced to 14 no. spaces following response to Additional Information Request Item no. 2 with terraces on second and third floor on 0.14 Ha site at the Junction of Richmond Street South / Lennox Street, Dublin 2. The gross floor of the proposed building is c. 2529sq.m. Proposed amendments listed as follows a. Access to basement car parking to be changed from a car ramp to a car lift with modifications to rear area to accommodate this layout including landscaping, provision for bicycle parking at ground level, new pedestrian pathway and exit gate. No change to previously approved 14 no. car spaces in the basement. b. Modifications to elevations and fenestration, including the omission of small terrace at level 2 and omission of recess at level 3 along Richmond Street South. Previously permitted total gross floor area of 2529sqm to increase to 2553sqm. on a site of 0.14 Ha.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4204/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Fionn MacCumhaill & James Staunton Location 6, Pembroke Place, Dublin 2 Proposal For a single storey flat roofed extension at second floor level

forming a three-storey terraced house facing onto Pembroke Place with 1 no. rooflight and alterations to existing windows; new entry door and existing entry door changed to a window to existing two-storey house.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4218/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Gareth O'Connell Location 39, Frankfort Avenue, Rathgar, Dublin 6

19

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Proposal Planning permission for a revised second storey floor plan with a

1 metre reduction to overall rear length (on foot of granted application ref: 3077/08) on existing return and the replacement of terrace with standard flat roof and installation of safety railing.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4260/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Paul Donnelly Location 88, Marlborough Road, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE: Construction of a vehicular access

to the side of house exiting onto Bushfield Avenue, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 and for all associated site works.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4283/08 Application Type Permission Decision REFUSE PERMISSION Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant Seamus Martin Location 8, Ranelagh Avenue, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE: The development will consist of

subdivision of the existing 2-storey plus-attic terraced house, with roof garden at first floor at rear, into two dwellings, one 2-bedroom and one 1-bedroom.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4314/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Mary Jones Location 15, Garville Avenue, Rathgar, Dublin 6 and adjacent to Garville

Drive Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE - Vehicular access, car parking,

landscaping and all associated site works. The vehicular access is to be located on Garville Drive to the west of site. Existing pedestrian access and railings to the north to be retained to this protected structure.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4323/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Kevin & Susan Ahern Location 67, Leinster Park, Harolds Cross Road, Dublin 6W Proposal For a 13 square metre single storey extension comprising a

dining room to the rear of house. A sun tunnel 500mm diameter

20

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

rooflight will be fixed to the rear facing existing dormer roof as natural lighting for existing stairs.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4395/08 Application Type Retention Permission Decision GRANT RETENTION PERMISSION Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant Louise O'Reilly Location 5, Summerville Park, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Permission sought for the retention

of the replacement of three windows to front and three windows to rear with double-glazed timber sliding sashes.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4404/08 Application Type Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID Decision Date 17-Oct-2008 Applicant Alexander Court Management Location 25, Pembroke Street Upper, Dublin 2 Proposal The development will consist of the addition of a new sixth floor

level containing 1no. 2 bed apartment with terrace to Upper Pembroke Street, and 1no. 2 bed apartment with terrace and upper level study space (in total 2no. apartments) increasing the height of parapet wall to Upper Pembroke Street to match neighbouring building, and erection of a new external fire escape staircase to side, and associated works.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4504/08 Application Type Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Tadgh & Colleen Campion Location The Prairies, 5A, Airfield Court, Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal Planning permission for development consisting of the extension

of the existing four bedroom house, and which will comprise the demolition of rear single storey extension and the demolition of part of the front elevation including the removal of the dormer, the removal of the existing roof structure throughout, the lowering of part of the gable wall to the south, and the building up of other parts, all to provide a new eaves level, the provision of a new two-storey extension to rear and a new two storey extension to front, the construction of a rear basement level storage room accessed from stairs to rear of house, the construction of 2no. hipped roofs over the entire upper floor incorporating 2no. roof lights and 1no. new chimney, alterations to north, east and west facades of the existing house to provide new windows and doors, demolition of existing garden shed and associated site development works, all to provide an extended four bedroom house.

21

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4568/08 Application Type Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Ms J Prendergast Location 18, Ardee Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6 Proposal Construction of a two storey detached mews dwelling, including

an integrated car space, fronting the rear laneway leading to Williams Park, along with ancillary siteworks including a new boundary wall at the rear of the site.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4583/08 Application Type Retention Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Mr. Odran Graby Location 1, Mount Drummond Avenue, Harolds Cross, Dublin 6 Proposal For a gate and access for a car parking space. The retention

consists of two gates to the eastern side of the two-storey semi detached house, fronting onto Mount Drummond Avenue and the construction of two piers matching existing and dishing of the pathway to allow vehicular access into the property.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4592/08 Application Type Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant John Costello Location 29, Dartmouth Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE - The development consists of the

following for which permission is sought: A Demolition of existing two storey return to the rear which contains 1 no. one bed apartment on the first floor. B Change of use of the remaining existing building from previous use as a veterinary surgery to residential use. C The total number of proposed residential units on the site is three, comprising of 1 no. 3 bed unit (154sqm) within the existing building to 29 Dartmouth Road, and 2 no. 1 bed units (55sqm and 67sqm respectively) built to the rear / side of the existing main structure, facing onto Dartmouth Terrace. The total height of this proposed structure to the rear/side, is 3 storeys with a 8.66 metre high parapet. D Internal alterations to the interior and rear of the existing protected structure are also proposed.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4613/08 Application Type Retention Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID

22

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Decision Date 14-Oct-2008 Applicant Michael Smith Location Unit 1, 23-27, Stephen Street Lower, Dublin 2 Proposal To retain 61msq ground floor restaurant and bar plus 61msq

basement kitchen and storage, plus advertising signage to shopfront to Stephen Street facade.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 4647/08 Application Type Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID Decision Date 16-Oct-2008 Applicant P Doherty Location 1, Victoria Lane, Rathgar, Dublin 6 Proposal Demolish existing single storey dwelling and garage and to erect

a new two storey over basement dwelling with sheltered walkway and altered entrance gateway.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number WEB1056/08 Application Type Permission Decision GRANT PERMISSION Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Grainne McAleer Location 35, Ramleh Park, Dublin 6 Proposal Permission is sought for: 1.) The demolition of the two storey

extension to the side and single storey extension to the side and rear of the existing two storey semi-detached house. 2.) The construction of a new two storey extension to the side, to include a new hipped pitched roof and bay window to the front, a new, part single storey flat roofed extension, part two storey extension to the rear. 3.) The conversion of the existing attic space to include rooflights to the rear. 4.) Ancillary site works.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number WEB1073/08 Application Type Retention Permission Decision APPLICATION DECLARED INVALID Decision Date 13-Oct-2008 Applicant Cormac Jackson Location 152, Rosary Terrace, Dublin 4 Proposal Conversion of Attic space to habitable accommodation including

retention of and extension to rear dormer, change of roof profile and internal alterations

APPEALS NOTIFIED:

23

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 2969/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Paul McKenna Location Ground Floor of Grattan Court, Grattan Street, Dublin 2 Proposal Planning permission is sought for development to the ground

floor only of Grattan Court. The development consists of the change of use of part of the ground floor from office to proposed coffee shop use. In addition alterations are sought to the existing external elevation at ground floor, including, A. The plastering of existing brick finish at ground floor along Grattan Street and part Grattan Court, B. Enclosing the existing corner recessed porch with sliding doors at ground floor on Grattan Street and Grattan Court, C. Provision of retractable canopy along Grattan Street elevation, D. The modification of existing window at ground floor on Grattan Court forming a new double door to the existing offices.

***AMENDMENT TO WEEK 41/08***

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 1522/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Edward Doyle and Emma McNamara Location 2, Arnott Street, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 Proposal Demolition of the existing single storey rear kitchen extension &

boundary wall to laneway, alterations to layout of existing lower ground floor, construction of a new 14sqm single storey rear extension and rear boundary wall to laneway, construction of a new 19sqm basement under existing ground floor sitting room, erection of a 3 sqm solar panel in the existing roof valley and a new velux window to existing to existing bedroom 2.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 2320/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Ronald Fogarty Location 5/6, Aungier Street, Dublin 2 Proposal Planning permission for development at nos. 5 and 6 Aungier

Street, Dublin 2, with frontage at rear onto Dawson's Court, Dublin 2. The development will consist of demolition of all existing buildings on lands at nos. 5 and 6 Aungier Street excluding the existing store house to the rear of no. 5 fronting onto Dawson's Court. Construction of new five storey over basement buildings with fourth floor set-back and communal roof garden with solar panels at nos. 5 and 6 Aungier Street. Retail space at nos. 5 and 6 Aungier Street will be retained at ground floor level and will include additional retail space at basement level, including staff areas and its own refuse storage and disposal facility. Access to upper floor apartment levels and communal roof garden shall be through common access stairs and lift from ground floor to roof of no. 6 Aungier Street. Development at first, second, third and fourth floors shall comprise of 8 no. two bedroom apartments with

24

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

private terrace areas, bicycle parking and refuse storage shall be provided on ground floor at common access level with retention of existing access to Dawson's Court.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 2710/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Thomas Prior Ballsbridge Ltd Location Bewleys Hotel, Simmonscourt Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE: For the use of the existing single-

storey Thomas Prior Hall as a Hotel Function Room with ancillary private bar together with new satellite kitchen and toilet facilities all being part of Bewleys Hotel, on the corner of Simmonscourt Road and Merrion Road, ballsbridge, Dublin 4 which is a protected structure.This application is being sought in compliance with Condition of No. 3 of the original Planning Permission obtained for the development of the hotel under Grant Order No. P6725 dated 22/12/1997 and as replacement for the Planning Permission previously granted for a restaurant under reg. ref. No. 2129/98 of 14/06/99, the vadility of which has now expired. the work involves the restoration and conservation of the existing unoccupied hall to include the retention of all the principal internal and external features including timber wall panelling roof trusses, timber ceiling sheeting, roof vents and balcony features. New matching timber wall panelling will be provided below the existing wall panelling where the original raised Stage area has been removed at the east end of the hall. Existing glass including wired and broken glazing shall be removed and the existing decorative arched timber windows fully re-glazed. The work will involve the removal of timbers in both the Entrance Lobby roof and Balcony floor and such other works as are necessary to facilitate the elimination of existing wet and dry rot. New satellite kitchen facilities to service the proposed Function Room only, will replace existing adjoining toilets which in turn will be relocated at basement level. Externally the work will include the non-abrasive cleaning of all existing stone and brickwork, replacement of defective rainwater goods, new roof to Entrance Lobby and the provision of new fire doors.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3297/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant John & Aedemur McKillen Location 45, Ailesbury Road, Dublin 4 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-The development consists of

revisions to development permitted under reg. ref. 4562/06 to include the retention and completion of all works consisting of: - Removal and reinstatement of front facade of garage to match original; relocation of entrance door to ground floor level from east to original west side under front stairs; relocation of permitted new opes on all levels and elevations of rear return;

25

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

new internal ope from master bedroom into new dressing room at second floor level and all within the original house. - Extension of rear basement by 17sqm from 151sqm to 168sqm; relocation of stairwell connecting basement and garden within extended basement; revisions to elevation and fenestration of permitted extension; new ope to east side of permitted new return level at third floor level; extension of single storey utility room by and all as part of revisions of the permitted extensions to the original house. - Creation of new single storey lobby extension (6sqm) to rear of permitted utility room. In addition the retention and completion of all works consists of 2 no. new roof lights, and 2 no. new solar panels in valley of main roof; 4 no. new light wells in garden over basement; relocation of 2 no. roof lights over permitted new garage; and all internal modifications to room layouts in the basement, ground, first, second and third floor of the permitted internal layout under reg. ref. 4562/06. The overall development will include the retention and completion of all associated site development and landscaping works; all conservation and repair work.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3675/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant John & Cearuil Morrissey Location 36, Palmerston Road, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE: Alterations and extensions to the

rear of the existing dwelling. These comprise construction of a new part single storey and part three-storey extension consisting of family room & utility room at ground floor; ensuite bedroom at first floor and bedroom at seconsd floor. Internal alterations comprise blocking window ope at ground floor wc to form new pantry, partial demolition of wall between existing French doors to rear, new partition wall to form new wc and blocking existing door to rear garden at side passage lean-to, reforming door ope from side passage to dining room, remoavl of existing window on stairwell to form new walkways to proposed extension at first and second floor, blocking existing door opening to bedroom, new partition wall to bedroom to form enlarged ensuite and new dressing room to master bedroom, associated landscaping to rear garden.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3684/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Mr Michael Kelly Location Apartment No. 23 Glaunsharoon, 29, Eglinton Road,

Donnybrook, Dublin 4 Proposal Construction of a new light weight cantilevered balcony as

extension to existing 2nd floor level terrace to west gable of 2nd

26

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

floor apartment.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3714/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant David O'Donavan Location 17, Kenilworth Square North, Dublin 6 Proposal PROTECTED STRUCTURE-Planning permission for partial

demolition of existing rear extension and construction of new two-storey extension to the rear of 17 Kenilworth Square North (a protected structure and terraced building) to be accessed via existing door and window opes. The works will also involve the installation of a new WC unit into the first floor and with kitchen alterations to existing ground floor dining area and kitchen area together with ancillary works.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3765/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Galdevar Limited Location 104, Ranelagh, Dublin 6 Proposal Demolition of the existing single storey bank branch approx

204m2 and construction of a new 2 and 3 storey building with retail bank use at ground floor level and office use on the upper 2 floors. The proposal contains approximately 997m2 of gross floor area. Permission is also sought for a cash in transit van dock and lobby entered from Sallymount Avenue. There are no car parking spaces proposed.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 3846/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Bartlett Inns Ltd Location 108, Rathgar Road, And Part Of 70 Rathgar Avenue, Rathgar,

Dublin 6 Proposal The development consists of the part demolition (293.1sqm) of

the existing two storey corner terraced public house building (362.9sqm) of '108' at the corner of Rathgar Road and Rathgar Avenue; and construction of a four storey with basement mixed use development (621.4sqm) that will consist of 54.6sqm of maintained existing basement; 53.3sqm extended basement consisting of customer toilets, staff room & kitchen; 160sqm public house and refuse storage/recycling area (13.9 sqm) on the ground floor; and 5 no. apartment units on the upper floors, consisting of 4 no. 1 bedroom and 1no. 2 bedroom units, private balconies at first, second floor, 2 no. roof terraces at third floor

27

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

level; and all associated site works on a site of 189 sqm with pedestrian access off Rathgar Avenue/Rathgar Road to serve the public house, off Rathgar Avenue to bin store and 5 no. bicycle stands, and off Rathgar Road to serve the apartments.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 6801/07 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Donohue Properties Limited Location 115, Rathgar Road, Rathgar, Dublin 6 Proposal Construction of a part two storey part three storey extension, to

the rear, to include, (a) partial refurbishment & extension of the existing residential structure including the formation of new window & door openings to the gable and rear elevations, (b) construction of a part two storey part three storey rear extension housing 2 no. two bed units & 2 no. one bed units with an associated entrance/circulation stairwell, rooftop terraces & private balconies, (c) provision of 4 no. carparking spaces to the front of the site & 12 no. carparking spaces to the rear of the site, (d) provision of new external balconiesto the gable elevations of the main house on first floor level and second level, (e) provision of new landscaping to the front and rear of site, (f) provision of a bin store to the rear of site, (g) revision to width of existing vehicular entrance gates.

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number WEB1030/08 Appeal Type Written Evidence Applicant Yvonne McGarry Location 24, Hollybank Avenue Lower, Dublin 6 Proposal Two storey extension to the rear and a single storey extension to

the rear and to demolish existing single storey extension to rear

APPEALS DECISIONS:

Area Area 1 - South East Application Number 6664/07 Appeal Decision GRANT PERMISSION Appeal Decision Date 15-Oct-2008 Applicant Abbeyrock Developments Limited Location Block 1, Clanwilliam Court, Lower Mount Street, Dublin 2 Proposal 1. Demolish the existing office building consisting of four storey

plus set back storey and plant room storey block containing a gross floor area of 3498 sqm above ground level, while retaining the 2 no. existing basement carpark levels. 2. Reduction of car parking from existing 78 no. spaces to 57 no. spaces, the provision of 60 new bicycle spaces, 10 no. new

28

Week 42/08 13/10/08 – 17/10/08

motorcycle spaces together with changing facilities, plant and ancillary works. 3. Construction of 7 storey office building over existing basement comprising of 5 no. storeys and 2 no. set back storeys fronting Lower Mount Street with a proposed gross floor areaof 5,219sqm.

29