arsenical pigmentation of the skin simulating addison's disease

1
353 Captain Rogers, I.M.H., in a report published in 1897 took the view that kala-azar is not ankylostomiasis but malarial ’, fever. In February, 1898, Major Ronald Ross, I.M.S., was placed on special duty to investigate malaria and kala- azar. One result of his labours was the discovery (1) that proteosoma (Labbe), one of the so-called malarial parasites of birds, is capable of living and growing in a species of mosquito and (2) that healthy birds were readily infected when bitten by mosquitoes fed a week previously on birds containing the parasites of avian malaria. Major Ross’s i report on kala-azar, published by the Government Printing Office in Calcutta, is a model of clinical and epidemiological investigation and is of considerable length, extending to 87 large pages. He divides the symptoms into three periods or stages, the first of which is characterised (a) by recurrent accessions of acute fever separated by periods of apyrexia and (b) by rapid enlargement of the liver and spleen. The second stage is that of established and still acute enlargement of the liver and spleen, accompanied by constant low fever and pronounced but not excessive anaemia. The third stage is that of cachexia and when it is once firmly established recovery seems to be impossible. With respect to duration the first stage may be put at one or two months only and the beginning of the third stage at nine months or a year, or even more, from the commencement of the illness. The arguments in favour of the malarial theory of kala-azar are the facts that the symptoms are almost if not quite identical with those of malarial fever, that the disease occurs in malarious regions, and that most of the cases contain yellow pigment, the remote derivative of the patho- genetic parasites. The arguments against the malarial theory are the high death-rate, the intractability to quinine, the existence of a low constant fever in the second stage of the disease, the apparent absence of the parasites and melanin of paludism from many cases, and the communica- bility from the sick to the healthy. Major Ross discusses these various points very fully and in the result comes to the conclusion that kala-azar is a form of malarial fever and a form which is probably by no means confined to Assam. The question of the spontaneous extinction of the parasitic invasion in old cases of paludism deserves special attention because of its bearing on treatment by quinine. ARSENICAL PIGMENTATION OF THE SKIN SIMULATING ADDISON’S DISEASE. AT the meeting of the Societe Médicale des Hopitaux of Paris on June 30th M. Enriquez and M. Lereboullet described a remarkable case in which arsenical pigmentation simulated Addison’s disease. The patient was a man, aged 47 years, who had been in good health until April, 1897, when an eczematous eruption appeared on the left ankle and then affected the feet and hands. On Oct. 19th under medical advice he began to take about 16 drops of Fowler’s solution daily. He continued to take the solution in the same dose and in January, 1898, he felt depressed and experienced pricking and congestion of the conjunctivas. In March he noticed that his skin was becoming black in certain parts. The pigmentation rapidly became generalised; in April it involved the whole body. In the meantime he always had conjunctivitis and lacrymation. He also complained of dryness of the throat. The practitioner who then attended him, basing his opinion on the characters of the general melanodermia which in parts assumed a bronze tint, the progressive wasting, and slight asthenia, diagnosed Addison’s disease and ordered the Fowler’s solution to be continued. M. Brissaud, who also saw the patient, concurred in this view and advised in addition the use of suprarenal substance. The symptoms progressed. There were crises of abdominal pain suggesting renal or hepatic colic. In June, struck by the absence of asthenia, gastro-intestinal troubles, and lumbar pains and by several special characters of the I eruption, M. Brissaud requested his colleague, Dr. Gaucher, to examine the patient. The latter appeared to be robust and , but little wasted. The face was very bronzed. The melano- i dermia was general but of variable intensity; the tint was I slate or fawn colour in some places, bronze or almost black , in others ; as a whole it gave the impression of Addison’s I disease. But the pigmentation was not uniform ; a large I number of light-coloured spots of from the size of a pea to : that of a lentil could be distinguished. In other places, on , the contrary, especially in the neck, behind the ears, and at I the roots of the upper limbs, highly pigmented spots were observed. The melanodermia was most marked in the groins and axillae and at the waist and in general at the folds of flexion of the body. The hands and feet were almost exempt. On the face it was uniform, but relatively little marked. The genitals were less pigmented than other parts. The mucous membrane of the lips and cheeks was little affected. The skin of the palms and of the palmar surface of the digits was markedly thickened with numerous hard papules. The soles showed similar changes, but in greater degree. In this case the spotted character of the pigmentation, the relative immunity of the hands and feet, and the lesser degree of genital pigmentation were in favour of the diagnosis of arsenical pigmentation and against that of Addison’s disease. The diagnosis was confirmed by diminu- tion of pigmentation and other symptoms three weeks after the patient ceased to take arsenic. The marked cutaneous effect with the absence of all nervous symptoms are note- worthy and reveal a special predisposition. THE SPHERE OF A MATRON. AN extraordinary story is reported in a local London paper concerning the Chelsea Infirmary. A patient was operated upon by his own desire on May 24th for hernia and on June 5th the matron of the infirmary, without, it is stated, instructions from the surgeon in charge, moved the patient from the position which he had been told to occupy in his bed by altering the position of his pillows. On June 6th serious haemorrhage took place from the wound. The board of guardians have had the matter before them, when five voted in favour of a motion that the facts should be laid before the Local Government Board and 12 negatived the proposal. This is a decision which will not inspire anyone with much respect for the board of guardians unless they supplement their refusal to seek the aid of the Local Government Board by vigorous treatment of the situation themselves. If the matron interfered with the orders given by the medical man with regard to the surgical care and nursing of a patient she is so much to blame that it is almost no exaggeration to say that she is unfit for her position. If she did not behave in the unwarrantable manner which is alleged against her in at least one local paper her character should be cleared from these aspersions. The debate upon the matter by the guardians, in the account which has come before us, shows that they have been unable to regard the circumstances in a calm and unprejudiced manner. "KISSING THE BOOK." AT the Lambeth County Court on July 25th a medical witness stated that ’’ he preferred to kiss the book rather than be sworn in the Scotch method." His Honour Judge Emden was naturally surprised and according to the report in the (}lobe said :- "This is really an extraordinary action for a doctor to take. I have myself seen persons suffering from diseases which I need not mention and which had been contracted from kissing the book while oath-taking. Physician after physician has pointed out this danger and an Act of Parlia- ment was actually passed in 1888 to legalise the oath being

Upload: john-w

Post on 31-Dec-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

353

Captain Rogers, I.M.H., in a report published in 1897 took the view that kala-azar is not ankylostomiasis but malarial ’,fever. In February, 1898, Major Ronald Ross, I.M.S.,was placed on special duty to investigate malaria and kala-azar. One result of his labours was the discovery (1) thatproteosoma (Labbe), one of the so-called malarial parasitesof birds, is capable of living and growing in a species ofmosquito and (2) that healthy birds were readily infectedwhen bitten by mosquitoes fed a week previously on birdscontaining the parasites of avian malaria. Major Ross’s ireport on kala-azar, published by the Government PrintingOffice in Calcutta, is a model of clinical and epidemiologicalinvestigation and is of considerable length, extending to 87large pages. He divides the symptoms into three periods orstages, the first of which is characterised (a) by recurrentaccessions of acute fever separated by periods of apyrexiaand (b) by rapid enlargement of the liver and spleen. Thesecond stage is that of established and still acute enlargementof the liver and spleen, accompanied by constant low feverand pronounced but not excessive anaemia. The third stage isthat of cachexia and when it is once firmly establishedrecovery seems to be impossible. With respect to durationthe first stage may be put at one or two months only andthe beginning of the third stage at nine months or a year,or even more, from the commencement of the illness. The

arguments in favour of the malarial theory of kala-azar arethe facts that the symptoms are almost if not quiteidentical with those of malarial fever, that the diseaseoccurs in malarious regions, and that most of the cases

contain yellow pigment, the remote derivative of the patho-genetic parasites. The arguments against the malarial

theory are the high death-rate, the intractability to quinine,the existence of a low constant fever in the second stage ofthe disease, the apparent absence of the parasites andmelanin of paludism from many cases, and the communica-bility from the sick to the healthy. Major Ross discussesthese various points very fully and in the result comes tothe conclusion that kala-azar is a form of malarial fever anda form which is probably by no means confined to Assam.The question of the spontaneous extinction of the parasiticinvasion in old cases of paludism deserves special attentionbecause of its bearing on treatment by quinine.

ARSENICAL PIGMENTATION OF THE SKINSIMULATING ADDISON’S DISEASE.

AT the meeting of the Societe Médicale des Hopitaux ofParis on June 30th M. Enriquez and M. Lereboullet describeda remarkable case in which arsenical pigmentation simulatedAddison’s disease. The patient was a man, aged 47 years,who had been in good health until April, 1897, when aneczematous eruption appeared on the left ankle and thenaffected the feet and hands. On Oct. 19th under medicaladvice he began to take about 16 drops of Fowler’s solutiondaily. He continued to take the solution in the same doseand in January, 1898, he felt depressed and experiencedpricking and congestion of the conjunctivas. In March henoticed that his skin was becoming black in certain parts.The pigmentation rapidly became generalised; in April itinvolved the whole body. In the meantime he always hadconjunctivitis and lacrymation. He also complained of

dryness of the throat. The practitioner who then attendedhim, basing his opinion on the characters of the generalmelanodermia which in parts assumed a bronze tint, the

progressive wasting, and slight asthenia, diagnosed Addison’sdisease and ordered the Fowler’s solution to be continued.M. Brissaud, who also saw the patient, concurred in this viewand advised in addition the use of suprarenal substance.The symptoms progressed. There were crises of abdominal

pain suggesting renal or hepatic colic. In June, struck bythe absence of asthenia, gastro-intestinal troubles, and

lumbar pains and by several special characters of the

I eruption, M. Brissaud requested his colleague, Dr. Gaucher,to examine the patient. The latter appeared to be robust and

, but little wasted. The face was very bronzed. The melano-i dermia was general but of variable intensity; the tint wasI slate or fawn colour in some places, bronze or almost black, in others ; as a whole it gave the impression of Addison’sI disease. But the pigmentation was not uniform ; a largeI number of light-coloured spots of from the size of a pea to: that of a lentil could be distinguished. In other places, on

, the contrary, especially in the neck, behind the ears, and atI the roots of the upper limbs, highly pigmented spots were

observed. The melanodermia was most marked in the groinsand axillae and at the waist and in general at the folds offlexion of the body. The hands and feet were almost exempt.On the face it was uniform, but relatively little marked.The genitals were less pigmented than other parts. Themucous membrane of the lips and cheeks was little affected.The skin of the palms and of the palmar surface of the

digits was markedly thickened with numerous hard papules.The soles showed similar changes, but in greater degree. In

this case the spotted character of the pigmentation, therelative immunity of the hands and feet, and the lesserdegree of genital pigmentation were in favour of the

diagnosis of arsenical pigmentation and against that ofAddison’s disease. The diagnosis was confirmed by diminu-tion of pigmentation and other symptoms three weeks afterthe patient ceased to take arsenic. The marked cutaneouseffect with the absence of all nervous symptoms are note-worthy and reveal a special predisposition.

THE SPHERE OF A MATRON.

AN extraordinary story is reported in a local London paperconcerning the Chelsea Infirmary. A patient was operatedupon by his own desire on May 24th for hernia and onJune 5th the matron of the infirmary, without, it is stated,instructions from the surgeon in charge, moved the patientfrom the position which he had been told to occupyin his bed by altering the position of his pillows. OnJune 6th serious haemorrhage took place from the

wound. The board of guardians have had the matter beforethem, when five voted in favour of a motion that the factsshould be laid before the Local Government Board and

12 negatived the proposal. This is a decision which willnot inspire anyone with much respect for the board of

guardians unless they supplement their refusal to seek theaid of the Local Government Board by vigorous treatment ofthe situation themselves. If the matron interfered with theorders given by the medical man with regard to the surgicalcare and nursing of a patient she is so much to blame thatit is almost no exaggeration to say that she is unfit for herposition. If she did not behave in the unwarrantablemanner which is alleged against her in at least one localpaper her character should be cleared from these aspersions.The debate upon the matter by the guardians, in the accountwhich has come before us, shows that they have been unableto regard the circumstances in a calm and unprejudicedmanner.

"KISSING THE BOOK."AT the Lambeth County Court on July 25th a medical

witness stated that ’’ he preferred to kiss the book ratherthan be sworn in the Scotch method." His Honour JudgeEmden was naturally surprised and according to the reportin the (}lobe said :-

"This is really an extraordinary action for a doctor totake. I have myself seen persons suffering from diseaseswhich I need not mention and which had been contractedfrom kissing the book while oath-taking. Physician afterphysician has pointed out this danger and an Act of Parlia-ment was actually passed in 1888 to legalise the oath being