arizona health workforce demand in a rapidly … · arizona health workforce demand in a rapidly...

22
ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash Joanne Spetz, PhD University of California, San Francisco 3333 California Street, Suite 265 San Francisco, CA 94118 This study is supported by Vitalyst Health Foundation of Arizona and the City of Phoenix. Any views presented in this report do not necessarily reflect the opinions or positions of Vitalyst Health Foundation or the City of Phoenix.

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jun-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

ARIZONAHEALTHWORKFORCEDEMANDINARAPIDLYCHANGINGMARKET:

PERSPECTIVESOFSTATELEADERS

June22,2016Preparedby:LiselBlashJoanneSpetz,PhDUniversityofCalifornia,SanFrancisco3333CaliforniaStreet,Suite265SanFrancisco,CA94118ThisstudyissupportedbyVitalystHealthFoundationofArizonaandtheCityofPhoenix.AnyviewspresentedinthisreportdonotnecessarilyreflecttheopinionsorpositionsofVitalystHealthFoundationortheCityofPhoenix.

Page 2: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

2

EXECUTIVESUMMARY

TheimplementationoftheAffordableCareActinArizonarapidlybroughtaboutnoticeableincreasesintheshareofArizonanswithhealthinsurance.This,inconjunctionwithcontinueddemographicchanges,hasledtogrowthinthedemandforhealthcareservices,causingpolicymakers,healthcaredeliveryorganizations,andeducatorstobeconcernedabouttheadequacyofthecurrentandfuturehealthworkforceofthestate.Avarietyofchangeshavebeenmadetohealthcaredelivery,bothattheorganizationallevelandatthestatewidepolicyleveltoaddressthesedevelopments.ThisreportpresentsfindingsfrominterviewswithhealthcareleadersacrossArizonaaboutthetrendstheyareobservingandtheirexpectationsforfuturehealthworkforceneeds.

Methods

Weconductedinterviewswith16healthcareleaderstolearntheirplansandprojectionsabouthowhealthcaredeliveryischangingandimpactingworkerneeds.

SummaryofFindings

1. TheformationofAccountableCareOrganizationsandestablishmentofvalue-basedpurchasingareacceleratinganddrivingafocusonpopulationhealth,integratinginformationsystems,andquality-basedpayments.However,mergersandshiftingcoveragealsocausedisruptionforpatientsandhealthcareworkersalike.

2. Thereisaheightenedfocusonpreventionandwellness,andonbringingcareoutofthehospitalandintocommunitysettings.Thisincludestheplacementofphysicalfacilities,suchasclinicsandstandaloneemergencycenters;thedeploymentofworkerstohomelocations,especiallyinlong-termcareandcommunityhealthoutreach;theuseoftechnologytoenhanceremotemonitoringandcommunicationacrossdistances;andgreaterpatientengagementinself-managementofchronicdiseases.

3. Anemphasisonpatient-centeredcare(“consumerism”)andpatientexperience,aswellastheneedforpatientself-management,isleadingtoincreasedeffortsatpatientengagement.Thisrequiresthathealthcareworkersimprovetheircustomerserviceandcriticalthinkingskills,aswellasculturalcompetencytraining.Patientnavigatorsandcarecoordinatorsmaybeneededinincreasingnumbers.

4. Theintegrationofbehavioralhealthandprimarycareisacceleratingbuttheinformationsystems,reimbursementmethods,andlicensingthatwouldfacilitatethischangearecurrentlyinadequate.Providersandnursesneedcross-traininginbehavioralhealthandprimarycareinordertoworkinintegratedmodels.

5. Healthinformationtechnologies,especiallyelectronichealthrecords,arecommonintheworkplace.Remotetechnologiessuchastelehealthandremotemonitoringsystemsshowgreatpotentialforexpandingaccesstocare,especiallyinruralareas,buttheyarenotyetwidespreadduetolackofreimbursement.Staff,providersandpatientsallneedfurthereducationintheuseofnewtechnologies,andincumbentstaffneedtraininginbetterdocumentationanddrawdownofdatatouseinformationsystemstotheirfullestcapacityinpopulationmanagement.

6. Newmodelsofcarearebeingpiloted,suchascommunityparamedicine,team-basedcare,primarycareandbehavioralhealthintegration.Newrolesarealsoemerging,includingthe

Page 3: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

3

increaseduseofcommunityhealthworkers,dentalhealthaidetherapists,andpotentiallyclinicalscribes.

7. Changesneedtobemadetohealthcareeducationtomeetthechangingneedsofthefield.a. Graduates,particularlyproviders,needtounderstandhealthcarereimbursement,

healthsystemorganization,populationhealth,andthebasictenetsofpatient-centeredcare.

b. Growingdependenceoninformationtechnologymayrequiremoregraduateswithskillsindataanalytics,computersystemmanagement,andsetupandmaintenanceofhardwaresystemsandsecurity.

c. Adiminishedsupplyofclinicalplacementsnecessaryforstudentandnewgraduatetraininghasinspirededucationorganizationstousetechnologytocoordinateplacementsandprovideclinicalsimulationexperiencesforarangeofprofessions.

d. Theexpandedemphasisonprimarycarehasincreaseddemandforandexpectationsofmedicalassistants,butintervieweesindicatedthatexistingprogramsformedicalassistantsdonotprovidesufficienttrainingforemploymentinnewrolesandmodelsofcare.

e. Newrolesmaynecessitatenewdegreeprograms,includingthosewithaninterprofessionalfocustomeetchangesinthefield.

8. Regulatorychangescanfacilitatebetteruseofthehealthcareworkforce.Theseinclude:a. Statewidecertificationofcommunityhealthworkersb. Credentialingofmedicalinterpretersc. Expandedscopeofpracticefordentalhygienists,nursepractitionersd. Streamlinedrulepackagesforprimarycareandbehavioralhealthtoenhance

integratione. Streamlinedlicensureprocessestodecreasecycletimeforhiringout-of-statephysiciansf. Increasingandenhancingthestateloanrepaymentprogram

Conclusions

Ashealthsystemtransformationcontinues,acombinationofregulatory,education,andtrainingchangeswillbenecessarytofacilitatenewmodelsofcareandaddresschangingdemographics.Thereareshortagesormaldistributioninsomeoccupations,particularlybehavioralhealthproviders,nurses,andsomemedicalproviders,especiallyinruralareas.Newoccupationsaredevelopingthatwillrequirenewcredentialsandtrainingprograms,whileexistingoccupationsarechangingasalliedhealthworkerstakeonincreasedresponsibilitythatwillrequiremoreadvancedtraining.Mostoccupationsnowrequireskillsincaremanagement,patientengagement,newtechnology,andteam-basedcare.Employersandeducatorswillneedtobothexpandtheireducationprogramsintheseareasandreassessthecurricularcontentoftheirprogramstoensureanadequatelysizedandskilledworkforceinthefuture.

Page 4: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash
Page 5: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

5

TABLEOFCONTENTS

EXECUTIVESUMMARY.................................................................................................................................2Methods..........................................................................................................................................2SummaryofFindings........................................................................................................................2Conclusions......................................................................................................................................3VisualSummary...............................................................................................................................4

BACKGROUND:HEALTHWORKERDEMANDINARIZONA............................................................................6

FINDINGS......................................................................................................................................................9Driversofchange.............................................................................................................................9Newmodelsofcare........................................................................................................................10Impactofchangesinthehealthcaresystemonthehealthcareworkforce....................................12Changesneededtoensureanadequatehealthcareworkforce......................................................14Interviewees’topthreepriorities...................................................................................................18

CONCLUSIONS............................................................................................................................................19

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS..............................................................................................................................20

APPENDIX...................................................................................................................................................21

Page 6: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

6

BACKGROUND:HEALTHWORKERDEMANDINARIZONA

Arizona,alongwiththerestofthenation,experiencedadeepeconomicrecessionstartinginDecember2007andasloweconomicrecoverysincemid-2009.Whilethestate’seconomyhasbeenrecovering,therehavebeensignificantchangesinhealthcarefinancinganddelivery.ThestaterestoredandexpandedMedicaidcoverage,andtheimplementationoftheAffordableCareAct(ACA)of2010expandedprivatehealthinsuranceaccesstothousandsinthestate.TheACAcontainsprovisionsthatarespurringanincreasedemphasisontheintegrationofcare,providinghigh-valuecare,andconsideringpopulationhealthbroadly.Inaddition,Arizonafacesanagingpopulation,withincreasingratesofchronicconditionsanddisabilities.1

Thesefactorsaredrivingdemandforhealthcareworkersacrossthestate.Overthepastdecade,employmentgrewinallthehealthoccupationsinArizona,from75,490in2004to135,070in2013.2Shortagesofmanyhealthworkershavebeenreportedinrecentyears,includingforphysicians,andsurveyresearchhasrevealedthatphysiciansarethemostdifficulthealthprofessionaltorecruit,followedbynursepractitionersandphysicianassistants.3LicensednurseshortagesalsoareasignificantconcernforArizona,withprojectionsthatArizonawillneed87,200registerednurses(RNs)by2025,butsupplywillbeonly59,100RNs,producingashortfallof32percent.BureauofHealthWorkforce(BHW)alsoforecastsashortfallof9,590licensedpracticalnurses(LPNs),whichisabout50percentofanticipateddemand.4

Otherhealthcareoccupationsalsoarefacingsubstantialgrowthindemand.About47,000newjobsareexpectedinthealliedhealthprofessionsbetween2013and2020,withthegreatestgrowthprojectedforpersonalcareaides,medicalrecordsandhealthinformationtechnicians,emergencymedicaltechniciansandparamedics,medicalandhealthservicesmanagers,medicalassistants,andpharmacytechnicians.TheAffordableCareAct’sprovisionsalsoareexpectedtospurgrowthinemergingoccupations,suchasexpandedfunctiondentalassistants,communitydentalhealthcoordinators,healthandtransitioncoaches,communityhealthworkers,andintegratedcarecasemanagers.5

ThechallengeofmeetinganticipateddemandforhealthcareworkersismademorecomplexbythesignificantgeographicvariationfoundinArizona.ThestatehasoneofthelargestmetropolitanareasintheUnitedStatesandsomeofthemostruralareasinthecountry.6Thenumbersofphysicians,

1Borns,Kristin,andVanPelt,Kim.HealthWorkforce,HealthyEconomy.ArizonaHealthFuturesPolicyPrimer,December2014.2DatafromtheArizonaDepartmentofAdministration,reportedinIrvine,Jane,andWilliamG.Johnson,AlliedHealthNeedsAssessment.Phoenix,AZ:MaricopaCommunityColleges.May14,2015.3Tabor,Joe,NickJennings,LindsayKohler,BillDegnan,HowardEng,DougCampos-Outcalt,andDanDerksen.ArizonaCenterforRuralHealth2015SupplyandDemandStudyofArizonaHealthPractitionersandProfessionals.Tucson,AZ:UniversityofArizona.February2016.4BureauofHealthWorkforce,HealthResourcesandServicesAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.TheFutureoftheNursingWorkforce:NationalandState-LevelProjections,2012-2025.Rockville,MD:U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.December2014.5Irvine,Jane,andWilliamG.Johnson,AlliedHealthNeedsAssessment.Phoenix,AZ:MaricopaCommunityColleges.May14,2015.6Borns,Kristin,andVanPelt,Kim.HealthWorkforce,HealthyEconomy.ArizonaHealthFuturesPolicyPrimer,December2014.

Page 7: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

7

physicianassistants,nursepractitioners,RNs,andpharmacistsper100,000populationaresubstantiallyhigherinurbansettingsofArizonathanruralsettings.7

TounderstandtheimpactofArizona’sagingpopulation,growinginsurancecoverage,andchangingdeliverysystemoncurrentandfutureneedsforhealthcareworkers,theVitalystHealthFoundationandtheCityofPhoenixcommissionedtheUniversityofCalifornia,SanFrancisco(UCSF),toconductastudyofcurrentandfuturehealthworkforceneedsinthestate.Thefirstphraseofthisstudyinvolvedsurveysofhospitals,communityhealthcenters,long-termcarefacilities,andhomehealthagenciesinArizona.Thesecondphaseofthissurvey,whichisthefocusofthisreport,involvedconductinginterviewswith16stateleadersregardingtheworkforcepressuresfacedbytheirorganization,theirperceptionsofemploymentandeducationneeds,andtheirexpectationsforthefuture.

7Tabor,Joe,NickJennings,LindsayKohler,BillDegnan,HowardEng,DougCampos-Outcalt,andDanDerksen.ArizonaCenterforRuralHealth2015SupplyandDemandStudyofArizonaHealthPractitionersandProfessionals.Tucson,AZ:UniversityofArizona.February2016.

Page 8: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

8

METHODS

ASteeringCommitteewasconvenedtoguidethisresearch.Wedevelopedalistofcategoriesofhealthcareworkforceleadersandexperts,suchasclinicleaders,healthsystemleaders,educators,andstategovernmentofficials,anddevelopedalistofpotentialintervieweeswithineachcategory.TheSteeringCommitteeandresearchteamcollaboratedtoprioritizeinvitationsanddevelopinterviewquestions.

AfterobtainingapprovalfromtheUCSFCommitteeonHumanResearch(UCSF’sInstitutionalReviewBoard),emailinvitationsweresentto20individualsbetweenMarch22andApril28,2016.Weconductedsemi-structuredinterviewswith16peopletolearntheirperceptionsofchangesinthestate’shealthcaredeliverysystem,howthesechangeswillaffectworkforceemploymentandtraining,andtheirorganization’splanstoadapttotherapidly-changingenvironment.Allinterviewswereattheexecutivelevel,werevoluntary,andfollowedtheguidelinesoutlinedbytheCommitteeonHumanResearch.

Sixoftheintervieweeswererepresentativesofstatewideassociationsrepresentingbehavioralhealth,long-termcarefacilities,hospitals,humanresourcesdirectors,NativeAmericantribes,andnurses.Interviewswereconductedwithleadersfromtwocommunityhealthcenters,twohomehealthagencies,onelong-termcarefacility,andonelargehealthcaresystem.ThreeinterviewswereconductedwithrepresentativesofArizona’shighereducationinstitutions,andoneinterviewwasconductedwitharepresentativeofstategovernment.

Interviewquestionsweresemi-structuredandfocusedonhowtheintervieweethoughtchangesinhealthcaredelivery,technology,education,skills,reimbursement,regulation,impactofnewlyinsured,andjobturnoverwouldimpactthefuturehealthcareworkforceinArizona.AppendixAliststheinterviewquestionsthatservedasaguideforeachinterview.Questionsweremodifieddependinguponexpertiseoftheinterviewee.

InterviewnoteswereanalyzedtoidentifykeythemesdescribingchangesinhealthcaredeliveryinArizona,andhowthesechangesareimpactinghealthworkforceneeds.Challengesfacedbyintervieweeswereexamined,aswererecommendedsolutions.

Page 9: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

9

FINDINGS

Driversofchange

IntervieweesidentifiedmultiplefactorsthataredrivingchangesinhealthcaredeliveryinArizona.ThereboundingeconomyandtheimplementationoftheAffordableCareAct(ACA)withtheMedicaidrestoration/expansionin2013broughtaboutadramaticincreaseininsurancecoverageandasurgeindemandforhealthcareservicesinArizona.However,thestateisfacingshortagesofmedical,dental,andmentalhealthproviders,whichhavebeenexacerbatedbycutsduringtherecessionof2007-2009,particularlyinruralareas.

ThemandatesoftheAffordableCareAct(ACA)areleadingtoanemphasisonpopulation-basedandprevention-orientedcare.Relatedchangesinreimbursementmodelsthatrewardqualityratherthanvolume-basedincentivesarepushinghealthcareorganizationstoproducemeasurablequalityimprovements—andtomakemoreeffectiveuseoftechnologytotrackandcompilethesemeasures.However,newpaymentmodelsarestillinearlystagesandnotwidespread.

Healthinformationtechnology(HIT)implementationrequirementsestablishedbytheFederalgovernment,aswellasfinancialincentivesformeaningfuluseofHIT,aredrivingthedevelopmentofnewcomputerandphonesystems,especiallyinfederally-qualifiedhealthcenters(FQHCs).Thewidespreaduseofelectronichealthrecords(EHRs)bothfacilitatesandhinderscareaccordingtointerviewees.Itcanenhancetheabilityoforganizationstotrackoutcomes,sharedata,anddelegatetasks,butitalsoconfoundsinterpersonalinteractionsbetweenpatientsandclinicians.Moreadvancedtechnologiesliketelehealthandhomemonitoringholdpromisetoimproveaccessandqualityofpatient-providerinteractions,butreimbursementandtrainingchallengeshavethusfarprecludedtheirwidespreadadoption.Whiletechnologyiscitedasapotentialfacilitatorinpatientcare,thebenefitsareyettobefullyrealizedformostorganizations.

Inaddition,theACAincludedreauthorizationofandupdatestotheIndianHealthCareImprovementAct,whichallowedIndianHealthServices(IHS)toparticipateinthehealthcarereform,helpedmodernizesystems,andledtoanincreaseinthirdpartyrevenuestoIHShospitalsandclinics.ThesefactorsareincreasingthedemandforcareservicesamongtheNativeAmericanpopulation,andprovidingmoreresourcestoIHSfacilities.

FactorsdrivingchangeatthestatelevelincludethetransferofBehavioralHealthservicesoutoftheDepartmentofHealthServicesandintotheAHCCCS(ArizonaHealthCareCostContainmentSystem),Arizona’sMedicaidmanagedcaresystem.There-institutionofKidsCare(CHIP)inArizona,whichwillstartonSeptember1,2016afterasix-yearfreeze,alsohelpedincreaseaccessto,anddemandfor,care.

Demographicfactorsarealsoplayingapartindrivingchange,includinganagingpatientpopulation,withanincreaseinchronicdiseaseandcōmorbidities,aswellasanaginghealthcareworkforce.Theneedtoaddressbehavioralhealthissuessuchassubstanceabuse,dementiaandAlzheimer’sdiseaseinconjunctionwithprimarycareisalsochanginghowcareisdeliveredandorganized.Thelargenumberofveteransinthestatehasincreasedtheneedforappropriatebehavioralhealthservices,andmaybeafactorbehindtherelativeyouthofthelong-termcarepopulation.Finally,anincreaseinthenumberof

Page 10: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

10

single,childlessadultsinthelong-termcarepopulationwillrequirechangesinworkforcecompositionandcompensationasthesectorrelieslessonadultchildrentoprovidecare.

Despitetheincreasesinhealthinsurancecoverage,ArizonahasmanyundocumentedresidentswhoarenotcoveredbytheACAorMedicaidexpansion.Inaddition,manyproviders,especiallydentalproviders,willnotacceptMedicaidbeneficiaries,providingfurtherchallengestoaccessingcare.

Newmodelsofcare

Manyhealthcareorganizations,particularlyinthePhoenixarea,areformingaccountablecareorganizations(ACOs).Banner,Dignity,andHonorHealthwerementionedasimportantplayersmakingtheshiftfromfee-for-servicereimbursementtovalue-basedreimbursement,witharelatedfocusonpopulationhealth.HospitalsystemshavepurchasedprimarycarepracticesinanefforttomeetACOrequirementsandalsoacquiredsmallerhospitals.SomeFQHCsarealsomovingtopartnerwithACOsandhospitals.Thishasoccurredatthesametimeasthebuyoutofinsurancecompaniesbyothercompanies,resultinginshiftinginsuranceforpatients.

Someorganizationsarestartingtoimplementteam-basedcareandpatient-centeredmedicalhomes.Thisrequiresthatprimarycarestaffinparticularworkininterdisciplinaryteamsoftenmadeupofphysiciansandotherproviders,includingnurses,medicalassistants,nursingassistants,behavioralhealthproviders,andothers.

Largehealthcareorganizationshaveestablishedmoreurgentcareclinicsandfree-standingemergencydepartmentsinabidtokeepindividualsoutofthehospitalemergencyrooms.Free-standingemergencyroomsareafairlynewdevelopmentandareopenaroundtheclock,althoughpatientswouldneedtobetransferredtoahospitalforsurgeryandovernightstays.

Manyhealthcareorganizationsareworkingtowardsgreaterintegrationofmentalandphysicalhealthcare.AlargeshareofFQHCshavedonesoforsometime,utilizingstafflikesocialworkerstohelpwithdepressionscreeningandaidingpatientsinself-managementofchronicconditions.ThestatehasaCDCgranttodevelopintegratedsystemsofcareanddevelopself-managementtoolsforcommunityclinics.Atthestatelevel,RegionalBehavioralHealthAuthorities(RHBAs)havebeencontractedtodevelop“healthhomes”thatintegratebehavioralandphysicalhealthforthosewithseriousmentalillnesses(SMIs).Undertheseplans,adultMedicaidbeneficiarieswithSMIscanreceivecoordinated,integratedphysicalandbehavioralhealthcareservicesunderoneplanandinoneplace.BehavioralhealthorganizationsservingthosewithSMIsaretakingonprimarycareprovisionandapplyingtobecomeFQHCs.However,licensure,Medicaidreimbursementissuesandotherdifferencesbetweentheinformationandbillingsystemsestablishedforbehavioralandphysicalhealthchallengethisintegrationatmanyorganizations,andreportedsalarydifferentialsbetweenphysicalandbehavioralhealthstaffgeneratefurthercomplications.

Oralhealthcontinuestobeanareainwhichashortageofprovidersandlackofaccesstoservicesplaguelow-incomecommunitiesandthoselivinginruralareas.Arizona’sMedicaidagency–theArizonaHealthCareCostContainmentSystem(AHCCCS)–doesnotgenerallycoverthecostofadultdentalcareexceptforpatientsoftheArizonaLongTermCareSystem(ALTCS)orincasesofemergency,although

Page 11: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

11

children’sdentalservicesarecovered.ManydentistsreportedlywillnotworkwithAHCCCSduetolowMedicaidreimbursementrates.Thishasprovokedhealthcareorganizationstolookatcross-trainingotherphysicalcareproviderstodobasicoralhealthscreenings,andtoexperimentwithalternativestaffingsuchasdentalhealthaidetherapistsonreservationsorextendedscopefordentalhygienists,aswellasteledentistrytoincreaseaccessinremoteareas.

Overall,intervieweescitedashifttowardsa“CultureofHealth”withagreaterfocusonhealththanhealthcare,andanefforttobringhealthcareservicesintothecommunityandthehome.Thistrendincludeshome-basedcareforaginginplace,agreateremphasisonself-managementforpatientswithchronicdiseases,morehealthpromotionandwellnessactivities,andanincreasedrolefortelehealthtoallowpatientstomonitorconditionsandsharehealthinformationwithcliniciansfromhome.

Theroleoftechnology

Technologyinnovationsarebeingexploredbyhealthcareorganizationsaspotentialsolutionstosomeofthechallengesassociatedwiththestate’sdistributionofhealthcareworkersandprovidershortages.Anumberofthoseintervieweddiscussedthepotentialoftelehealth,particularlyinruralareaswherepatientsmaybeisolatedandhomehealthvisitsrequirehoursofdrivingtime.Oneintervieweeobservedthatasinglenursecanmonitor40to50long-termcarepatientsusingtelehealthtechnology.However,thecostlytechnologyandlackofreimbursementarechallengestofullimplementation.Homehealthmonitoringalsoholdspromise,especiallyinruralareasandforthosewithlong-termcareneeds.Thistechnologycouldpotentiallyenhancepatientengagementinmonitoringtheirownhealthconditionsandreportingbacktoproviderswithoutleavingtheirhomes.ThechallengeisinvalidatingthehomehealthtechnologyandintegratingitwiththeEHR,aswellastrainingstaffandpatientstouseitproperly.

Oneparticularchallengetobetterleveragingtechnologyfornewmodelsofcarehastodowithsharinghealthinformationacrossphysicalandbehavioralhealthsystemsasorganizationsmovetointegratethesetwoaspectsofhealth.Tacklingfederalrequirementsaroundbillingandservicedelivery,anddevelopingandmanagingITsystemsthatcanhandlethisintegration,willrequiremoresophisticationfromstaff.

Finally,technologycanhelpimproveaccountability,particularlyforstaffthatmeetwithpatientsintheirownhomesorinthefield,byensuringthatstaffencounterswithpatientsarerecordedwiththetimeofarrival,servicesprovided,anddurationofvisit.

Ruralregions

Shortagesofhealthcareworkerswerereportedtobemorecommoninruralareas,andskilledstaffandprovidersarehardertorecruitandretainintheseareas.Recruitingphysiciansisparticularlydifficult,especiallysurgeons,andorganizationsfindthattheyalsosometimesneedtofindemploymentforspousesinordertorecruit.Loanrepaymentprogramswerecitedasonetoolforrecruitment,althoughthereisreportedlynotenoughmoneyinthestate-supportedprogram.Behavioralhealthpractitionershaverecentlybeenincludedaseligibleforloanrepaymentprogramspartiallydueshortagesoftheseprovidersinruralareas.

Page 12: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

12

Intervieweesdiscusseddeployingnewtypesofhealthcareworkerssuchascommunityhealthworkers,dentalhealthaidetherapists,mobileteams,andcommunityparamedicinetoreachthoseinremotecommunities,includingNativeAmericanreservations.Apilotcommunityparamedicineprogramhasbeguntrainingparamedicsthroughoutthestatetoprovidepreventivecareinthecommunity,especiallyforthosemostatriskofusingthe911system.AHCCCSwillbeginreimbursing“treatandrefer”activitiesinOctober2016.

Manyofthoseinterviewedindicatedthattheyactivelysupportprogramstointerestlocalhighschoolstudentsinhealthoccupations.However,somealsonotedthatitcanbedifficulttohirelocallyandmaintainprivacywhencommunitiesaretoosmalltoprovideadegreeofanonymity.Someorganizationsusecontingentlaborandtravelingnurseswhenpermanentstaffisdifficulttorecruitandretain.

Impactofchangesinthehealthcaresystemonthehealthcareworkforce

Increasesinhealthcaredemandarespurringneweffortsatrecruitmentandretention,aswellasmorecreativeusesofstaffingandtechnology.Theincreaseindemandhasrequiredthatprimarycareproviderorganizationsutilizestaffmoreefficiently.Thisincludesincreasingthenumberofnursepractitionersandphysicianassistants,andrequiringthatallstaffworkatthetopoftheireducationandscopeofpractice.Withashortageofprovidersinsomefields,andanincreasedfocusonprimarycare,manyhealthcareorganizationsarerelyingmoreonalliedhealthworkerssuchasmedicalassistants(MAs),andcommunityhealthworkers(CHWs).However,greaterrelianceonthesetypesofworkers,particularlyMAs,isnecessitatingadditionaltraininginsoftskillsandothercompetenciesthatallowthemtoworkatashighalevelaspermittedbyscopeofpracticeregulations.Greateremphasisonpopulationhealthandprimarycarehasincreasedthedemandformedicalassistants,particularlythosewithgoodpatientcommunicationskills,ashealthcareorganizationsopenmorecommunity-basedfacilities.

Growinginsurancecoverageforbehavioralhealthserviceshasledtogreaterdemandforbehavioralhealthworkers.However,manyintervieweesindicatedthatthereisashortageofbehavioralhealthproviders,particularlyinsafetynetclinicsandinruralareas.Behavioralhealthtraineeswhoareinterestedinruralpracticehavefacedchallengesduetotheneedtohaveadequatesupervisionduringtraining.RegulationsmanagedbytheBoardofBehavioralHealthExaminersweremodifiedtoallow90%ofclinicalsupervisiontobeprovidedelectronicallyviaSkypeorteleconferencesothatmarriageandfamilytherapists(MFTs)andotherproviderscanfinishtheirclinicalhoursinruralareas.

Severalintervieweesnotedthatthelabormarketfornursesiscomplicated.Manyindicatedthattherewasashortageofnurses,andexpressedconcernthat,withanaverageageof55,manyRNsmightneedtotransitionoutofacutecareandintootherrolesinhospitals,suchascarecoordination.However,duetothelackof“newgrad”trainingprogramsthatallowyoungernursestoobtainthetrainingandexperienceneededtofillacutecarepositions,hospitalsarefacingashortage.

Long-termcare(LTC)isagrowingfieldduetotheaginglocalpopulation,thelargenumberofpeoplemovingtoArizonatoretire,and“snowbirds”wholiveinthestateonlypartoftheyear.ThiscreatesaperiodicsurgeinneedforLTCworkers,whichmakesitdifficulttostaffagenciesandorganizationsthatprovidelong-termcareservices.IntervieweesreportedanongoingshortageofLPNs,thepredominant

Page 13: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

13

workerinthisfield,aswellasCertifiedNursingAssistants(CNAs).ThelackofacareerladderforentrylevelstaffsuchasCNAsmakesitdifficulttoretainanddevelopthisgroupofworkers.Intervieweesalsoreportedshortagesofoccupational,physicalandspeechtherapistsinlong-termcare.Theseshortagessometimesresultin“poaching”betweenorganizationsandinflatedsalaries.

Somelong-termcareorganizations,whichhavereliedonLPNsandCNAs,haveneededtohiremoreRNsduetorisingcomplexityofpatientconditions.However,manyRNsreportedlyhaveahardtimeadjustingtolong-termcareemploymentbecausemuchoftheworkisone-to-onewithpatientsintheirhomes.Thereisalsoagrowingneedforstafftoassistpatientswithdailyfunctionssuchasshopping,cleaning,cooking,andaccessingmedicalappointments.Oneorganizationnotedthatthesefunctionsareoftendeliveredseparately,andthattheyaremovingtowardintegratingtheseservicesintooneposition–theAttendantCareWorker—whoisoftenretirement-ageandfrequentlyafamilymember.

Theintroductionofnewtechnologyliketelehealthorremotemonitoringcouldmakehealthcareorganizationsmoreefficient,whichcanincreasethecapacitytoseepatients,butalsomightentailreductionsintheworkforce.Oneintervieweenotedthatthecurrentdemandexceedscapacity,andthusitismorelikelythattechnologywillbeusedtoincreasecapacityandaccesstocare.However,manyintervieweesindicatedthathealthcareorganizationslacktheworkforcewithspecificskillstomakefulluseofnewtechnologytools.Whilemanyofthoseinterviewedsawpositivebenefitstonewtechnology,afewintervieweesnotedthatsomenursesandprovidersareunhappywithEHRdocumentationrequirementsthatoftendistractthemfromtheirpatientfocus.Thisisparticularlytrueforolderhealthcareworkers.Clinicalscribeswerenotedasonepossiblesolutionforassistingprovidersduringpatientencounters.Severalintervieweesnotedthattechnologycouldnotreplacetheneedforface-to-faceinteractionsandcriticalthinkingskillsforthepractitionersusingthenewtechnology.

Finally,themandatethatemployerswith50ormoreemployeesprovidehealthinsurancemighthaveanadverseimpactontheworkforce.HealthcareorganizationsandagenciesmightchoosetodownsizetokeeptheirFTEsbelow50inordertoavoidtherequirement,ortheymightchoosetouseindependentcontractorstoavoidthisprovision.

Turnoverandretention

Intervieweesnotedbothburnoutandhighdemandforcertainclassesofworkersasbeingimportantfactorsinturnoverandretention.Theycitedturnoverratesfrom14to75%dependingonoccupationandhealthcaresector,withmostreportingsomewherearound25%.Whileburnouthasalwaysbeenafactorinhealthcare,theunusuallyhighdemandbroughtaboutbyArizona’sparticipationinhealthcarereformanditsMedicaidexpansionhaveincreaseddemandandwagesforcertaintypesofhealthcareworkers.Thisvariesagreatdealbyoccupation.Therecontinuestobeanursingshortage,andnursesappeartofrequentlychangejobsforhigherwagesandbetterworkingconditions,asareoccupational,physical,andspeechtherapists.Employersalsonotedthatnursesarebeing“poached”bycompetitororganizations.Someintervieweescitehighemployeeengagementasbeingkeytotheirsuccessfulretentionefforts.

Fourintervieweesinstatewideorganizationsindicatedthattherewasaproblemwithturnoverattheleadershiplevel.Asonenoted,“Theoverallchangesinhealthcareareaffectingleaders.Tryingtocome

Page 14: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

14

upwithastrategicdirectionisarealcrap-shootrightnow.”However,threeintervieweesinproviderorganizationsindicatedthatmostoftheirturnoverwasforfrontlinestaff,notleadership.

Changesneededtoensureanadequatehealthcareworkforce

ThoseinterviewedwereaskedaboutthechangestheythinkareneededtoensurethatthehealthcareworkforceofArizonacanmeetcurrentandfuturehealthcareneeds.Avarietyofrecommendationsweremaderegardingtheskillsrequiredforhealthworkersinthefuture,educationalchangesthatwouldensureadequateskillsandnumbersofworkers,andregulatorychanges.

Newskillsneededfornewandexistinghealthcareworkers

Changesinhealthcare–includingthedesiretointegratephysical,dental,andmentalhealthservices–arenecessitatingnewskillsandknowledgeamongexistingstaff.

• Trainingforbehavioralhealthandprimarycareintegration.Medicalproviderswerecitedasneedingmoreeducationinneuroscienceandneuropsychiatrytobetterunderstandpatientconditions,andmoretraininginusingCTscansandMRIstomonitorbrainconditions.

• Trainingfordentalhealthandprimarycareintegration.Medicalcliniciansmightneedsometraininginassessingthehealthofteethandgumsinordertoreferpatientsfordentalcareortoprovidesomesimplesuggestionsonoralhealthcare.

• Interprofessionaltrainingisincreasinglynecessaryforthoseworkinginteam-basedcareaspatient-centeredmedicalhomesbecamemoreprevalent.

• BasiccomputerskillsareachallengeforolderprovidersandRNs,butalsochallengingforfrontlineworkerswithlimitededucationalpreparation,includingsomementalhealthandsubstanceabusepeerproviders.Thecontinuedadvanceofelectronichealthrecordsystemsrequiresthatstaffhavegoodcomputerskillsinordertodocumentpatientvisitsforbillingandcompliancepurposes.

• Understandingfederalrequirementsforbillingandcodingisagrowingareaofconcernasnewtypesofalliedhealthstaffbecameeligibleforreimbursement.

• Dataanalytics/healthinformatics/healthinformationtechnologists.Staffwithexpertiseinsettinguphealthinformationandphonesystems,trouble-shootingproblems,andtrainingotherstafftousethemwasmentionedasanareaofneed.Inadditiontomoreoperations-focusedstaff,individualswiththeskillstoextractandanalyzedatafromthesesystemsareneededtorealizethefullpotentialofthesenewsystems.

• Translationandculturalcompetencyskills.Thepaucityofproviderswithbiculturalandbilingualskillswhocancommunicatewiththepatientpopulationwascitedasanongoingproblem—bothforthoseservingSpanish-speakingpopulationsandontriballands.Someprovidersareutilizingmedicalassistantsastranslators.However,asoneintervieweeobserved,justbecauseastaffmemberisbilingualdoesnotguaranteegoodmedicaltranslationskills.Skillsassessmentandmedicaltranslatortrainingforexistingstaffisimportantbecausemanyprimarycareorganizationscannotaffordtoemploytranslatorsinaseparaterole.

• Traininginchronicdiseasemanagement,especiallyforfrontlinecareworkerswhomayobservesymptomstheycanconveytolicensedstaff,andtrainingininsurancenavigation,werenewskillsapplicabletofrontlinestaff.

Page 15: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

15

• Softskills/communicationskills.Patientengagementskills,customerservice,andcommunicationskillsarecriticalforincumbentstaffandfornewgraduatesenteringthehealthcarefield.OneorganizationhasdevelopedtrainingmodulesforprovidersinhowtocommunicatewithMAsandpatients,andanotherforMAstocommunicatewithpatientsandproviders.However,oneintervieweeobservedanimprovementinrecentyearsduetohealthcareorganizations’emphasisonpatientsatisfactionratings.Criticalthinkingskillsalsocameupasimportantbutoftenlacking,especiallyinfrontlinestaff.

• Understandingpatient-centeredcare.Inadditiontoimprovingskillsincommunicatingwithpatients,staffandprovidersneedtounderstandwhatpatient-centeredcareisandhowitisoperationalizedtoworkinthenewmodelsofcarelikethepatient-centeredmedicalhome.Takinginputfrompatientsisdifficultforsomeproviders.

• Carecoordinationskillswerecitedasveryimportantfornewmodelsofcareaimedatkeepingpatients,especiallylongtermcarepatients,healthyintheirhomes.Carecoordinatorscanassistpatientswithaccessingnecessarycareandservicesaswellastrackingtheircareovertimetomakesurethattheircareisfollowedthroughandintegrated.

• Usingincumbenthealthworkersmoreefficiently:Existingstaff,suchasmedicalassistantsandparamedics,canbecross-trainedtoprovidemorepreventivecarewhenprovidersareinshortsupply.

Skillsgapsinnewgraduatepreparation

Newgraduatesintohealthcareoccupationssometimeslackimportantskillsandknowledgeneededbyemployerorganizations.Specificareasofeducationwererecommendedbymanyofthoseinterviewed.

• Geriatricstraining:Forthoseworkinginlong-termcare,inparticular,trainingingeriatricsisvitaltoaddressingtheneedsofthestate’slargeseniorpopulation.However,itwasnotedthatfewnewgraduatesornewemployeescomepreparedwiththisknowledge.

• Healthcarefinancingandvalue-basedpurchasing.Oneintervieweenotedthatmedicalfacultyand,consequently,medicalstudentshavelittletraininginhealthcarefinancing.Existingstaffandadministratorsneedadditionaltraininginhowtoprepareforpaymentreforms.

• Clinicalskillsformedicalassistants:Asprimarycarebecomesmoredependentontherolesofstafflikemedicalassistants,trainingprogramsneedtopreparethesestudentsforexpandedrolesandresponsibilities.However,manycomeintoemploymentlackingbasicclinicalskillsandsometimesdonothavesufficientprimaryeducationtofunctionproperly.

• ClinicalexperiencefornewRNs:NewRNgraduatesmightnotreceiveenoughclinicaltimeintheirnursingprogramstobepreparedto“hitthegroundrunning”whentheygraduate;asaresult,theyfinditdifficulttofindemployment.

• Behavioralhealthtechnicians:Manyorganizationsusebehavioralhealthtechnicians(BHTs),whoareoftenindividualswithundergraduatedegreesinpsychiatryorsocialwork,toaddresslicensedprovidershortages.However,becauseBHTsdonothaveclinicaltrainingtoworkinthefield,theyrequireagreatdealofon-the-jobtrainingandsomepurportedlyenterthefieldwithunrealisticexpectationsandsubsequentlyencounterdifficultieswiththereportingrequirements.

Page 16: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

16

Changesneededinhealthcareeducation

Healthcareeducationwillneedtochangetoaddresstheseskillsgapsandnewskillsneeds.Inaddition,thenewoccupationsandjobtitlesnecessaryforthechanginghealthcareenvironmentarestillunderdevelopment.Intervieweesmaderecommendationsregardinghoweducationneedstochange,andhaschanged,toaddresstheseneeds.Someofthoseinterviewednotedpartnershipsbetweeneducatorandemployerorganizations.

• “Growyourown”strategiesareonesolutiontoshortages,particularlyinruralareas.Employersneedtopartnerwitheducatorstohireandtrainlocalpeople.Thiswillrequireafocusonprogramsthatinterestruralhighschoolstudentsinhealthcareersintheirowncommunities.Somecommunitycollegeprogramshaveonlineandhybridhealthcareerprogramsand/orcampusesnearruralcommunities.

• RNresidencyprograms.NewgraduateprogramssponsoredbyhealthcareorganizationscanprovideclinicaltrainingthatnewRNslackandcanhelpaddressthenursingshortageinhospitals,buttheseprogramsareinshortsupply.

• Newcategoriesofhealthcareworkertraining.Educationalprogramsareworkingwithhealthcareemployerorganizationstodeveloptrainingprogramsanddegreesfornewroles.Forexample,onecommunitycollegehasdevelopedaprograminhealthcaretechnologysystems,whichfocusesonhardware,asopposedtothesoftwareandcompliancefocusofhealthinformationmanagementprograms.ArizonaStateUniversityhasdevelopedaCollegeofHealthSolutionsthattakesaninterdisciplinaryapproachtohealthcareandincludesdegreeprogramsliketheScienceofHealthCareDelivery,whichincludestopicssuchaspopulationhealth,systemsengineering,andinformationscience.

• Concurrentenrollmentprograms/collaborativeprograms.Collaborativeprogramsbetweencommunitycollegesanduniversitiesprovideoneavenueforaddressingshortages,includingtheshortageofclinicallaboratoryscientists.IntervieweesnotedthecollaborativeprogrambetweenArizonaStateUniversityandPhoenixCollegewhichallowsstudentstosimultaneouslyearnanassociateandabaccalaureatedegreethroughahybridonline/in-personprogramwhilepursuingpartoftheirclinicalhoursinastate-of-theartsimulationlab.Associate’sdegree-to-bachelor’sdegreeprogramsinnursingaregrowinginresponsetoemployerinterestinhiringbaccalaureate-educatedRNs.

• Clinicalsimulation.Thelackofclinicalplacementsavailabletohealtheducationprogramshasbeenexacerbatedbythemergersandexpansionstakingplacebetweenhealthcareorganizations,whichhaveprecludedacceptingstudentsforclinicalrotations.Oneresponseistodevelopmorerobustclinicalsimulationtrainingfacilitiesandprograms.

o Integratingclinicalplacementsystems.MaricopaCommunityCollegesandlocallargehealthcareorganizationsformedaconsortiumtomanageclinicalplacements.Theyinstitutedasetofpre-clinicalmodulesforstudentsandfacultyin45alliedhealthand8nursingprogramsintheregiontostandardizepreparationforclinicals.Theyalsoadoptedacloud-basedplatformthatallowsthemtocentralizeplacementoperationsandtrackhours,relievinghealthcareorganizationsoftheburdenofindividualtrackingandplacementoperations.

Page 17: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

17

• Programsforveterans.Arizonahasalargenumberofveterans,anddevelopingmethodsofrecruitingandtrainingveteransfornewcareerswascitedasimportantnotonlyforveterans’financialviability,buttofillshortages.

• Improvedmedicalassistanttraining.Thequalityofmedicalassistanttrainingneedstobeimprovedtoaddressemployerneeds.

• Strongerclinicaltrainingforbehavioralhealthcarestudents.Thereissomeconcernthatbehavioralhealthandsocialworkprogramsarenotadequatelypreparingstudentstoworkinpublichealth.Graduatesneedtohavestrongerclinicaltrainingandmorebackgroundintrauma-informedcareandspecializedtreatment.

• Betterpreparationinbothbehavioralandphysicalhealth.NPsneedbetterpreparationinbehavioralhealth,andpsychiatricNPsneedbettertraininginphysicalhealth,toaddresstheneedformorecross-trainedstaffintheintegrationofphysicalandbehavioralhealth.Caremanagersthatcommunicatebetweenthephysicalandbehavioralhealthsidewillbeindemand,particularlyforthosewithchronicdiseases.

• Morecommunity-basedplacements.Thereisadearthofplacestotrainhealthprofessionalsinthecommunity.InvestingintraininginfrastructurefocusedonFQHCsandotherambulatorysites,aswellasinruralhospitalsandcriticalaccesshospitals,wouldhelprecruitmenteffortsinunderservedcommunities.

Regulatorychanges

Anumberofregulatorychangescouldbemade,orhaverecentlybeenmade,thatcouldfacilitateneededchangesinthehealthcareworkforcetoaddressthechanginghealthcarelandscape.

• Behavioralanalysts.Arizonawasoneofthefirststatestolicensebehavioralanalysts.Behavioralanalystsworkwithpeoplewithdevelopmentaldisabilitiesandautism.Theircurrentlocationforlicensing(thePsychologyBoard)haslimitedtheirscopeofpracticeandsomeintervieweeswouldlikethelicensingtransferredtotheBoardofBehavioralHealthExaminerstospurachangeintheapproachtocareandbecausethismovemightmaketheirservicesreimbursable.

• Communityhealthworkers.AlthoughanumberofintervieweesnotedtheimportantroleofCHWsandTribalHealthRepresentatives,thereisnotyetanycertificationforCHWsinArizona.IfCHWswerecertified,theirworkwouldbereimbursable.

• Oralhealthcareworkers.Expandedscopefordentalhygienistswouldallowforgreateraccesstocarewherethereareshortagesofdentists.In2015,legislationwaspassedallowingfortheuseofthedentalhealthaidetherapistroleontriballands.

• Pharmacists.Scopeenhancement(advancedpracticepharmacydesignation),similartowhathasbeenestablishedinNorthCarolinaandCalifornia,wouldallowpharmaciststoworkasprovidersandprescribefamilyplanningservicesandmedicationtherapymanagement.

• Nursepractitioners.MedicaredoesnotpermitNPstoorderhomehealthservicesforpatients.WhileArizonahaslegislationtoallowNPstopracticetotheirfullscope,federallawhasnotyetcaughtup.

• Referralstohomehealth.Physiciansdonotwanttorefertohomehealthbecausetheprocessisonerous.ThisconcernsfederalregulationthatsomeArizonaintervieweesidentifiedasaproblem.

Page 18: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

18

• Integratingprimarycareandbehavioralhealth.Whiletherehasbeenalotofemphasisonprimarycareandbehavioralhealthintegration,regulationshavemaintainedtwoseparatesetsofregulationsregardinghowlicensurecanhappen.Therulepackagesneedtobestreamlinedintoonesotheprocessislessprohibitive.

• Standardizeoutcomesinpay-for-performance.Providerefficiencymightbeimprovedifinsurancecompaniescouldreduceandstandardizethenumberofpay-for-performancemetricsprovidersarerequiredtomeet.

• Increasetheadoptionofvalue-basedreimbursementstosupportnewmodelsofcare.• Integratedentalcareandexpandaccess.AHCCCSdoesnotcoverthecostofdentalcarefor

adults,withtheexceptionoflong-termcare.Thereneedstobeanincentivetointegrateoralhealthcareandprimarycarebecausedentalandphysicalhealtharecloselylinked.

• Credentialmedicalinterpreters.Culturalandlinguisticcompetencyisacriticalfactorinhelpingminoritycommunitiesseekcare.However,Arizonadoesnothaveacredentialingprocessforhealthcareinterpreters.Thismightbothimprovetranslationservicesandprovideapayincreaseforthoseprovidingthisservice.

• Expandingthestateloanrepaymentprogram.Until2015,thestateloanrepaymentprogramcoveredprimarycareandsomedentalcareproviders(primarycarephysicians,dentists,andadvancedpracticeproviderslikenursepractitioners,physicianassistants,andnursemidwives).Asof2015,itincludesmentalhealth,pharmacyandgeriatricproviders,andtheannualdollaramountforprovidershasbeenincreased.Thispoolofmoneycouldbeexpandedinthenextcompetitionviaafederalmatchifthestateorotherentitieswerewillingtocontributemore.

Interviewees’topthreepriorities

Intervieweeswereaskedtoranktheirtopthreeprioritiesforhealthworkforcedevelopment.Onethemethatcameuprepeatedly(sixmentions)wasbetteruseoftechnology,especiallybetterimplementationofelectronicmedicalrecordsandenhancedtrainingsothatstaffcouldinputanddrawfromtheserecordsmoreeffectively.

Fiveintervieweesnotedthatimprovedtrainingandeducationforincumbentstaffandnewgraduateswereoftopimportance.

Fournotedthatrecruitmentandretention,particularlyofdoctorsandnurses,wastheirtoppriority.

Fournotedthatbetterrecognition,training,andwagesfortheparaprofessionalworkforcewouldhelpimprovecareandworkforceretention.OnenotedthatcredentialingCHWswouldstandardizetrainingandimprovereimbursementforthisclassofworker.Forone,theincreaseinparaprofessionalswasmoreofaproblemthanabenefitduetothefactthatthesepositionswerenotreimbursableand/orrequiredextensivesupervisionforreimbursement—eitherwaynecessitatingmorelicensedproviderstaff.

Threeintervieweescommentedthatimprovingreimbursementandwageswouldhelpaddressissuesaroundrecruitmentandretention.

Twobelievethatthestateneedstodoabetterjobstreamlininglicensingrequirementssothatprovidersandotherclinicianscouldmoveintotheworkforcefaster.

Page 19: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

19

Otherprioritiesincludedexpandingthescopeofpracticeforadvancedpracticeregisterednurses;expandingthestate’sloanrepaymentprogramsothattheprogramcoulddrawdownmorefederalmoneyandincentivizeemploymentinshortageareas;expandingresidencyprogramsinshortageareasforthesamereason,andgenerallyaddressingrecruitmentandretentionissuesandshortages.

CONCLUSIONS

Ashealthsystemtransformationcontinues,acombinationofregulatory,education,andtrainingchangeswillbenecessarytofacilitatenewmodelsofcareandaddresschangingdemographics.Thereareshortagesormaldistributioninsomeoccupations,particularlybehavioralhealthproviders,nurses,andsomemedicalproviders,especiallyinruralareas.Newoccupationsaredevelopingthatwillrequirenewcredentialsandtrainingprograms,whileexistingoccupationsarechangingasalliedhealthworkerstakeonincreasedresponsibilitythatwillrequiremoreadvancedtraining.Mostoccupationsnowrequireskillsincaremanagement,patientengagement,newtechnology,andteam-basedcare.Employersandeducatorswillneedtobothexpandtheireducationprogramsintheseareasandreassessthecurricularcontentoftheirprogramstoensureanadequately-sizedandskilledworkforceinthefuture.

Page 20: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

20

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

ThecollaborationoftheAdvisoryCommitteeconvenedbyVitalystHealthFoundation,theCityofPhoenix,andtheGreaterPhoenixChamberofCommercewasimportanttothedevelopmentofthesurveyquestionnaireandconductingofthesurvey.

AdvisingCommitteeMembers:

• AudreyBohanan(AdelanteHealthCare)• JudyClinco(CatalinaInHomeServices/AZDirectCareAlliance)• EricDosch(Cigna)• RobertFranciosi(MaricopaCommunityCollegeDistrict)• DanHunting(MorrisonInstituteforPublicPolicy)• TaraMcCollum(CommunityHealthCenters)• KathleenCollinsPagels(ArizonaHealthcareAssociation)• ScottSalzetti(BannerHealth)• SteveSchroeder(MaricopaCommunityCollegeDistrict)• JudySeiler(ScottsdaleLincolnHealthNetwork)

Page 21: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

21

APPENDIX

InterviewGuide:Thesearethegeneralquestionsthatwillbeaskedofeachinterviewee.Someinterviewsmayfocusononlyasubsetofthesequestionsdependingupontheinterviewee’sexpertiseandposition.

1. Whatisyourtitleandyourrolewithinthisorganization?Howlonghaveyoubeenwiththisorganization?

2. Whatkindsofchangesinhealthcaredeliveryareyouseeingatyourworkplaceoraroundyou?a) Whatisdrivingthesechanges?(prompt:creatinganACO,lowerMedicare

reimbursements,Medicarepenaltiesforpoorquality,morecompetitioninthemarket,lowerprivateinsurancereimbursements,agingofthepopulation,changesinnetworksandaffiliations)

b) Dothesechangesincludenewmodelsofcaresuchasintegratingphysicalandmentalhealth,patient-centeredmedicalhome,retailclinics,etc.?

c) Howrapidlyarethesechangesoccurring?d) Dothinkthesechangeswillaccelerate,decelerate,orcontinueatthesamepaceoverthe

next3-5years?3. Fromwhatyouhaveseenandheard,howdoyouthinkchangesinhealthcaredeliverywill

impactthehealthcareworkforce?a) Inwhatwaysdoyourthinkthehealthcareworkforcemightneedtochange?

Prompt:Numbersofworkers,agesofworkers,typesofworkers,training,changeinwhattheydo?

4. Areyouplanningforhealthworkforcechangesinyourhealthcaresystem(educationprogramofferings)?

a) Pleasetellusaboutthosechangesinacoupleofexamples.5. Fromyourexperienceandwhatyou’veseenandheard,whatnewskillsdoyouthinkthecurrent

healthcareworkforcemightneedtocompeteinthesechangingdeliverymodels?(Preliminarywork–overallskills,softskills,interprofessionalskills)(Alsokeepcontentonclinicalorspecificskills)

a) Couldyougiveussomeexamplesofnewskillsneededandwhyyouthinkthoseskillswillbeimportant?

6. Fromwhatyou’veseenandheardaboutchangingmodelsofcare,doyouthinkchangesintheeducationofthehealthcareworkforcewillbeneeded?

a) Whatkindsofchanges?b) Couldyougiveussomeexamples?

7. Fromyourperspectivearethereregulatorychangesneededinthehealthcareworkforcesuchaschangesinscopeofpractice(thelegaldescriptionofpracticebyaprofession),Medicaidpaymentpolicies,etc.?

a) Whatkindofchangesmightbeneeded?b) Canyougiveussomeexamples?

8. Whatisyourperspectiveonhowfuturetechnologymightimpactthehealthcareworkforce?Probe:Change in composition, trainingneeded,overall numbersanddistributionacross thestate’sregions?

9. Fromyourexperience,howwellpreparedarenewgraduatesintheskillsneededinyourorganizationtocompetentlydelivercare?

a) Ifthisisaproblem,whatarethemostsignificantgapsinpreparation?(prompts:clinicalexperience,softskills?)

Page 22: ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY … · ARIZONA HEALTH WORKFORCE DEMAND IN A RAPIDLY CHANGING MARKET: PERSPECTIVES OF STATE LEADERS June 22, 2016 Prepared by: Lisel Blash

22

Probe:Ifthisisregionalemployer,askaboutdifferencesinthesegapsacrossregionsofthestate.

b) Pleasediscussacoupleofexamples.c) Pleasediscussanymodelsyouknowthatsuccessfullyaddressthesegapsinskillsneeded

bynewgraduates.(Specifically,howwouldyousuggestthisbeaddressed?)d) Haveyouconsidereddevelopingyourowntrainingprogramorpartneringwithaprogram

thatcould?Whyorwhynot?10. Somesuggestthatturnoverishighinsomehealthcarejobs,especiallyentry-leveljobs.Whatis

yourperspectiveand/orexperienceofturnoverinhealthcarejobs?a) Whataboutturnoverofleaders?b) Howmightturnoverbeaddressed?c) Howdoyoukeepprovidersengagedandavoidburnout?d) Doyouhavearetentionplan?

11. Forruralareas:Whenyouhaveaseriousshortage,howareyouaddressingit?(prompts:travelers,loanrepayments,etc.)

a) Arethereinnovativemodelsyouareusingorconsideringtoaddressneeds?(prompts:mid-level,CHWs,etc)

12. Insummary,whatwouldbeyourtop3prioritiestoaddressinplanningforandpreparingourstate’sfuturehealthcareworkforce?

13. Isthereanythingelseyou’dliketoaddthatwehavenotasked?