aristotle de caelo bibliography

8/19/2019 Aristotle de Caelo Bibliography

1/16

ARISOLE’S DE CAELO:A BIBLIOGRAPHY1

A. Medieval and early modern manuscripts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 283B. Modern critical editions o the Aristotle’s De caelo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 285C. Commentaries and translations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 285

C. Ancient to early modern commentaries in Greek and Latin . . . . . . . . 285C. Medieval translations and commentaries in Arabic and Hebrew. . . . 287C. Modern editions and translations o pre-modern commentaries . . . 289

C. Modern editions, translations, and commentaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 290D. Modern monographs, collected studies, and articles on Aristotle’s Decaelo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 9 1

A. Medieval and early modern manuscripts2

Family a

Parisinus graecus (E) ca th century, De caelo on olios – vº.Vaticanus gr . (L afer Bekker ) th century.Vaticanus Ottobonianus gr . , th century, based on Vaticanus gr . and

the exemplar used by William o Moerbeke in his Latin translation (Γ).

Family b

Vindobonensis phil. gr . (J) th century (second hal), De caelo on olios –.

Marcianus gr . (Ha in Bekker ) th century. Marcianus gr . (Q in Bekker ) , copied rom J by Jean Rhosos. Marcianus gr . (Fm in Mioni , U in Longo ) th century, combines

Marcianus gr . and Vaticanus gr . . Marcianus gr . (Eb in Bekker , V in Moraux and in Longo )

th century, derived rom Marcianus gr . . Marcianus gr . (Ga in Bekker ) th century, derived rom Marcianus gr .

with variants rom Marcianus gr . . Marcianus gr . ( in Bekker ) , copied at Rome by Charitonymus

Hermonymus o Lacedemonia, based on Marcianus gr . .

1 Te editors are very grateul to Andrea Falcon or his valuable suggestions and

additions to this bibliography, and to Veronica Shi or her editorial work. We also thank Gerhard Endress or his kindness in supplying us with the inormation or the entries onthe Arabic tradition.

2 Following Moraux (): c. Moraux ().

Extracted from:Alan C. Bowen and Christian Wildberg edd.New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caeloPhilosophia Antiqua 117. Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2009

Copyright 2009 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands.Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Hotei Publishing,IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP.


2/16

’ :

Laurentianus , (j in Longo ) th century.Vindobonensis phil. gr . , copied under the direction o Jean Rhosos.

Laurentianus ,, attributed to Jean Rhosos.Riccardianus gr . (Ob in Bekker ) th–th century.Vaticanus gr . (H afer Bekker ) th century.

Same subgroup as Vaticanus gr . Vaticanus Urbinas gr . (M afer Bekker ) th century.Parisinus Coislinianus (m in Longo ) th century.Laurentianus , (F afer Bekker ) th century.Vaticanus gr . (k in Bekker , in Longo ) th–th century,

related to Laurentianus ,.Parisinus gr . (e in Longo ).

Unconnected subgroups

Ambrosianus gr . , G sup. (G in Longo ) th century.Direct descendants

Vindobonensis phil. gr . , copied in the Abruzzes by Robert Maiora-nos.

Vindobonensis phil. gr . , early th century.Parisinus suppl. gr . (s in Moraux , P in Longo ) th century.Parisinus gr . (i in Bekker , p in Longo ) th century.Parisinus Coislinianus (o in Bekker , O in Moraux ) end o

th century.Parisinus gr . (l in Bekker ) th century.Vaticanus gr . , th century.Laurentianus , (S in Bekker and in Fobes , Q in Longo )

end o th century, copied by Jean Panaretes.Vaticanus Palatinus (P in Moraux ) , copied by Jean Scutar-

iotas rom Laurentianus , . Ambrosianus gr . , M sup. (A in Moraux , W in Longo )

th century.Vaticanus Urbinas gr . (Qa in Bekker ) th century, copied by

Michel Apostolios and modeled on Ambrosianus gr . , M sup.

Other manuscripts prior to

Alexandrinus Bibl. Patriarc. (. . ) th century, with commentary by Teodore Metochites in the margins.

Ambrosianus gr . , R sup. th century. Ambrosianus gr . . G in. th century.Berolinensis gr . In ol. 2, th–th century.Bononiensis Bibl. Univ . (olim ) th–th century, copied at Padua by

Zacharias Kallierges the Cretan.

Cantabrigiensis Bibl. Univ . (Dd. IV ), copied at Florence in .Cantabrigiensis Bibl. Univ. Add . , beginning o th century.Laurentianus , (v in Bekker , A in Longo ) th century.


3/16

’ :

Lugduno-Batavus Vossianus gr . Q , th century.Lugduno-Batavus Vossianus gr . F , end o th century.

Matritensis Bibl. Nat . (olim N ) , copied by Constantin Lascaris. Monacensis gr . , th–th century.Oxoniensis Bodl. Bywater 1, , copied on Crete by Jean Chionopoulos.Oxoniensis Coll. Corp. Christi , th century, copied by Jean Tessalos Scu-

tariotas, rst three books only.Parisinus gr . (c in Bekker ) th century, copied by George Gre-

goropoulos.Parisinus gr . , th century, excerpts only.Parisinus gr . , th century, copied by Michel Apostolios.Parisinus gr . (Z in Longo ) th century, stops at A .b.Parisinus gr . 2, th–th century.Scorialensis Σ III ( Revilla) th century.Scorialensis II ( Revilla) th century, copied by Antonio Damilas o

Milan.Scorialensis II ( Revilla) th century, rst three books only.Vaticanus Reginae Suecorum gr . , th century.Vaticanus gr . , th century.Vaticanus gr . , th century, with Simplicius’ commentary.Vaticanus gr . .Vindobonensis phil. gr . , , copied by Demetrios Kykandyles.

B. Modern critical editions o the Aristotle’s De caelo

Allan, D.J. () Aristotelis de caelo libri quattuor , rd edn (Oxord).Bekker, I. () Aristotelis opera (Berlin).Longo, O. () Aristotele. De caelo (Florence).Moraux, P. () Aristote. Du ciel (Paris).Prantl, C. () De coelo, et de generatione et corruptione (Leipzig).

C. Commentaries and translations

C. Ancient to early modern commentaries in Greek and Latin3

th century

Temistius, In libros Aristotelis De caelo paraphrasis, hebraice et latine. Sēer ha-shāmayim we-ha-#ōl ̄am le-Aris.t ̄o #im pēr ̄ush ̄amis.ti" ūs (ed. Landauer ).4

3

Following Edward Grant in Planets, Stars, and Orbs: Te Medieval Cosmos, – (Cambridge, ). Te original dates o publication and/or modern editions arelisted where available.

4 Hebrew translation by Zera .hyah ben Yi.s .hāq ben She"alti"ēl, made in , rom


4/16

’ :

th century

Simplicius o Cilicia, In Aristotelis de caelo commentaria (ed. Heiberg ).

th century

Pseudo-Avicenna, Liber celi et mundi (ed. Gutman ).

th century

Gerard o Cremona, Aristoteles, Liber de celo et mundo (ed. I. Opelt ).ranslation rom the Arabic o ibn al-Bi.trı̄q (th century) into Latin.

th century

Albertus Magnus, De coelo et mundo (ed. Hosseld ).Alvaro o oledo, De substantia orbis (ed. Alonso Alonso ).Gunsalvi o Burgos (ed. Renaud ).John o Jandun, Quaestiones in Aristotelis de caelo.Michael Scot, Averrois Cordubensis commentum magnum super libro de caelo et

mundo Aristotelis (ed. Arnzen ).Petrus de Alvernia, Quaestiones supra librum de caelo et mundo (ed. Galle ).Tomas Aquinas, In libros Aristotelis de caelo et mundo expositio (Commissio

Leonina , ed. Spiazzi ).Tomas de Bungeye, Quaestio in Aristotelis de caelo et mundo (ed. Parker ).William o Moerbeke, Simplicii in Aristotelis de caelo (ed. Bossier, Vande Veire,

and Guldentops ).

th century

Albertus de Saxonia, Quaestiones in libros Aristotelis de caelo et mundo (ed. Patar).

Ioannis Buridanus, Expositio et quaestiones in Aristotelis de caelo (ed. Moody

, ed. Patar ).Nicole Oresme, Le livre du ciel et du monde (ed. Menut and Denomy ).Paul o Venice, Liber celi et mundi.

th century

Johannes de Magistris, De caelo et mundo.Tomas Bricot, Quaestio in Aristotelis de caelo et mundo ().

the lost Arabic version o Ya .hyā ibn #Ad̄ı, died ), and the Latin translation rom theHebrew by Moses Alatino (th century).


5/16

’ :

th century

Quaestiones in de caeloConimbricenses, or Coimbra Jesuits (, reprinted ).Galileo Galilei (ed. Wallace ).Johannes Major ().

th century

Quaestiones in de caeloPedro Hurtado de Mendoza ().Bartholomew Amicus ().Raphael Aversa (, vol. ).Roderigo de Arriaga ().Bartholomaeus Mastrius and Bonaventura Bellutus ().Franciscus de Oviedo ().Tomas Compton-Carleton ().Franciscus Bonae Spei ().Melchior Cornaeus ().Sigismundus Sebellonus (vol. , ).George de Rhodes ().Illuminatus Oddus ().Johannes Poncius ().

C. Medieval translations and commentaries in Arabic and Hebrew

th century

Ya .hyā (Yū .hannā) ibn al-Bi.tr̄ıq, Aris.tū.tālı̄s, Kitāb al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam [Book onthe Heaven and the World] (ed. Badaw ̄ı ). ranslation rom the Syriac.5

.Hunayn ibn Is .hāq (?), [Sixteen Questions on Aristotle’s Book on the Heaven and the World ] (ed. Gutman ), Latin version.6

5 A deective printing rom one ms., presenting or book the revised version o Mihrān (v. inra); critical edition in preparation by Gerhard Endress, Aristoteles SemiticoLatinus (Leiden ). Variants against the Greek ms. tradition have been discussed, onthe basis o the notes in Endress , by arán ().

6 Sixteen quaestiones on all parts o De caelo. Te authorship o .Hunayn, which can bededuced rom a note in Ibn al-Nadı̄m (died ), al-Fihrist , . (Flügel) is uncertain.Te medieval tradition attributes the text to Avicenna. Te Hebrew version, while made

rom a Latin version, has numerous revisions and additions in comparison to the extantLatin text; see Glasner (). While there are certain parallels with the commentary by Temistius, this is not a paraphrase o the latter; see Glasner () pace Alonso Alonso().


6/16

’ :

th/ th century

Abū l-Faraǧ #

Abdallāh ibn al- .ayyib, Aris.tū.tālis, [Kitāb al-Samā"

wa-l-#

ālam].Arabic translation o the De caelo.7

Abū Sahl al-Mas̄ı .hı̄, #Īsā ibn Ya .hy ̄a, al ˘hı̄.s kitāb al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam li-Aris.tū

[Commentary—Paraphrase o De caelo]. Ms. Leiden, Biblioteek der Rijksuni- versiteit, Acad. , no. .8

Abū #Al̄ı ibn S̄ınā (Avicenna), Kitāb al-Šiā" [Te Book o the Cure], Part II, al-.abı̄ #̄ıyyāt [Physica], vol. : al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam [On the Subject Matter o Decaelo], (ed. Qāsim ).9

Temistius, In libros Aristotelis de caelo paraphrasis, hebraice et latine. Sēer ha-šāmayim we-ha-#ōlām le-Aris.tō #im pērūš āmis.ti" ūs (ed. Landauer ).10

th century

Ibn al- .Salā .h (Abū l-Futū .h A .hmad ibn Mu .hammad ibn al-Sarı̄), Qaul Bay ̄anal-

˘ha.ta" al-#āri .d ̄ı ma#nā ma¯

hkūr ̄ı l-maqāla al-¯hāli

¯haminkit ̄ab al-Samā" wa-

l-#ālam [Explanation o an Error Occurring on a Matter Mentioned in Book o the Book On the Heaven and the Worlds] (ed. ürker ).11

Averroes (Abū l-Wal̄ıd Mu .hammad ibn A .hmad ibn Rushd), Kit ̄ab al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam [Epitome o De caelo], see Rasā"il ibn-Rushd , repr. ed. Jéhamy (ed. Eichner ).

———, al

˘

hı̄.s [kit ̄ab] al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam [Middle Commentary on De caelo].

al ̆hı̄.s al-Samā" wal-#ālam (ed. Jamāl-al-Dı̄n al-#Alawı̄ [Jamal-Eddine Alaoui]).

———, Šarh (ası̄r) kit ̄ab al-Samā" wa-l-ālam. [Commentary on Aristotle’s BookOn the Heaven and the Universe]. Facsimile o ms. , National Library,unis (ed. Endress ), Latin version by Michael Scotus (ed. Arnzen ).

———, Ma" amar be-#E.sem ha-Galgal [De substantia orbis]. Critical edition o theHebrew text o lost Arabic original with English translation and commentary (ed. Hyman ), Latin version by Alvaro de oledo (ed. Alonso Alonso).

7 Large ragments preserved in ms Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, arabe. Te translator, a physician oBaghdad who died in , was the author oa numbero commentaries o Aristotelian works. Te lemmata o Aristotle’s text are accompaniedby a concise literal commentary in the tradition o the Alexandrian lexis, preserving alsothe division into lecture courses, pragmata, Arabic ta#l ̄ım.

8 Abū Sahl, a Christian physician rom Khurasan who died in , was a teacher o Avicenna in medicine.

9 ranslated by Gunsalvi o Burgos ca. . Te subject matter o De caelo is treated

in the context o the ollowing part o the ˇSiā

"

, al-Kawn wa-l-asād (“De generatione et corruptione”), also edited by Qāsim.10 See n. above.11 A critique o De caelo . b–.


7/16

’ :

Mihrān ibn Man.sūr al-Mas̄ı .hı̄, Kit ̄ab al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam (ed. Badawi ).Revision o Ibn al-Bi.tr̄ıq’s translation o book , dated .

12

C. Modern editions and translations o pre-modern commentaries

Alaoui, J.-E. (Ǧamāl-al-Dı̄n al-#Alawı̄) () Averroes, al ˘hı̄.s [kitāb] al-Samā"

wa-l-#ālam (Middle Commentary on De caelo). al ˘hı̄.s al-Samā" wal-#ālam,

Manšūrāt Ǧāmi#at S̄ıdı̄ Mu .hammad ben #Abdallāh, Kulliyyat al-ādāb wa-l-#ulūm al-insaniyya bi-Fās (Fes).

Alonso Alonso, M. () Commentario al “De substantia orbis” de Averroes(Aristotelismo e Averroismo) por Alvaro de oledo (Madrid).

Arnzen, R. () Averrois Cordubensis commentum magnum super libro De celoet mundo Aristotelis, ex recognitione Francis James Carmody (Leuven). Latintranslation by Michael Scotus.

Aujac, G.; Brunet, J.-P.; and Nadal, R. () Autolycos de Pitane. La sphère enmouvement, Levers et couchers héliaques, estimonia (Paris).

Badawı̄, #Abd-al-Ra .hmān () Aris.t ̄u.t ̄al ̄ıs, al-Samā#wa-l- ¯ A¯hār al-#ulwiyya

(Cairo). A revision o Ibn al-Bi.tr̄ıq’ translation o book by Mihrān ibnMan.sūr al-Ması̄ .hı̄, dated .

Bossier, F.; Vande Veire, C.; and Guldentops, G. () ed. Simplicius. Commen-taire sur le traité du ciel d’Aristote. raduction de Guillaume de Moerbeke,vol.(Leuven).

Bowen, A.C. (–) “Simplicius’ Commentary on Aristotle, De caelo .–

: An Annotated ranslation,” SCIAMVS : –, SCIAMVS : –.Capra, L. () orquato asso. Note di orquato asso a “De Caelo” di Aristotele

(Rome).Commissio Leonina, () S. Tomae de Aquino in libros Aristotelis de caelo et

mundo expositio. (Rome/Paris).Eichner, H. () Averroes: Kit ̄ab al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam (Epitome o De caelo),

Averrois Opera, ser. arab. (Paderborn).Endress, G. () Šarh (ası̄r) kit ̄ab al-Samā" wa-l-ālam. Commentary on

Aristotle’s Book On the Heaven and the Universe, Facsimile ed., reproducedrom ms. , National Library, unis. Publications o the Institute or

the History o Arabic-Islamic Science, Series C: Facsimile editions, vol. (Frankurt am Main).Galle, G. () Petrus de Averni: Questions on Aristotle’s De Caelo (Leuven).Gutman, O. () Avicenna, Liber celi et mundi: A Critical Edition with Intro-

duction (Leiden).Hankinson, R.J. () Simplicius: On Aristotle’s “On Te Heavens .–”

(Ithaca).Heiberg, I.L. () Simplicii in Aristotelis de caelo commentaria, Commentaria

in Aristotelem Graeca (Berlin).Hosseld, P. () Alberti Magni opera omnia edenda curavit Institutum Alberti

Magni Coloniense, v. , De caelo. (Cologne).

12 Mihrān was a Christian physician at the Artuqid court o Diyābakr.


8/16

’ :

Hyman, A. () Averroes’ De substantia orbis: Critical Edition o the Hebrewext with English ranslation and Commentary [Ma" mar b-#e.sem ha-galgal le-

Ibn Rushd b-targūm #

ibr̄ı], Corpus Philosophorum Medii Aevi, Opera Aver-rois, Medieval Academy Books (Cambridge MA/Jerusalem).Jéhamy, G. () Rasā" ilIbnRušd al-alsayya, : Risālat[!]al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam

(Beirut).Landauer, S. () Temistius. In libros Aristotelis de caelo paraphrasis, Com-

mentaria in Aristotelem Graeca (Berlin).Menut, A.D. and Denomy, A.J. () Le Livre du ciel et du monde (Madison).Moody, E.A. () Iohannis Buridani quaestiones super libris quattuor de caelo

et mundo (Cambridge).Mueller, I. () Simplicius: On Aristotle’s “On Te Heavens .–” (London).———, () Simplicius: On Aristotle’s “On Te Heavens .–” (London).Parker, B.S. () Tomas de Bungeye’s Commentary on the First Book o Aris-

totle’s De caelo. PhD Tesis, ulane University (New Orleans, LA).Patar, B. () Ioannis Buridani expositio et quaestiones in Aristotelis de caelo

(Louvain).———, () Alberti de Saxonia quaestiones in Aristotelis de caelo (Louvain).Renaud, M. () “Le “De celo et mundo” d’Avicenne,” Bulletin de philosophie

médiévale : –.Qāsim, Ma .hmūd () Abū # Al ̄ı Ibn Sı̄nā (Avicenna), Kit ̄ab al-Ši ̄a" [Te Book

o the Cure], Part II, al- .abı̄#iyy ̄at [Physica], vol. : al-Samā" wa-l-#ālam [Onthe Subject Matter o De caelo ] (Cairo).

Raimondo, S. () Tomas Aquinas. In Aristotelis libros de caelo et mundo, de generatione et corruptione, meterologicorum expositio (urin).

Rasa"il ibn Rušd () Averroes: Epitome o Aristotle’s De caelo (Hyderabad).Spiazzi, R. M () S. Tomae de Aquino in libros Aristotelis de caelo et mundo

expositio (Rome/Paris).ürker, M. () “İbnü " .s- .Sala .h"ın De Coelo ve onun şerhleri hakkındaki tenkit-

leri,” Araştırma : –.Wildberg, C. () Philoponus: Against Aristotle, on the Eternity o the World ,

(London).———, () Simplicius: Against Philoponus on the Eternity o the World (Lon-

don).

C. Modern editions, translations, and commentaries

Bekker, I. () Aristotelis opera (Berlin).Dalimier, C. and Pellegrin, P. () Aristote. raité du ciel (Paris).Elders, L. () Aristotle’s Cosmology: A Commentary on the De caelo

(Assen).Gigon, O. () Vom Himmel, Von der Seele, Von der Dichtkunst (Zurich).Guthrie, W.K.C. () On Te Heavens, Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge).Jori, A. () Il cielo (Milan).Leggatt, S. () Aristotle: On Te Heavens I and II, with an Introduction,

ranslation and Commentary (Warminster).Longo, O. () Aristotele. De caelo (Florence).


9/16

’ :

Moraux, P. () Aristote. Du ciel (Paris).Prantl, C. () Aristoteles’ Vier Bücher über das Himmelsgebäude und Zwei

Bücher über Entstehen und Vergehen (Leipzig).———, () De coelo, et de generatione et corruptione (Leipzig).Stocks, J.L. () De Caelo, in W.D. Ross (ed.) Works o Aristotle (Oxord) vol. .

Repr. in R. McKeon (ed.) Te Basic Works o Aristotle (New York, ) –, and in J. Barnes (ed.) Te Complete Works o Aristotle: Te Revised Oxord ranslation (Princeton, ) –.

ricot, J. () Aristote. raité du ciel. raduction et notes, (Paris).

D. Modern monographs, collected studies, and articles on Aristotle’s De caelo

Algra, K. () Concepts o Space in Greek Tought (Leiden).Allan, D.J. () “Mediaeval Versions o Aristotle, De caelo, and o the Com-

mentary o Simplicius,” Mediaeval and Renaissance Studies : –.Alonso Alonso, M. () “ .Hunayn traducido al latín por Ibn Dāwūd y Do-

mingo Gundisalvo,” Al-Andalus : –.Ashley, B.M. () “Aristotle’s Sluggish Earth: Te Problematics o the ‘De

caelo’,” Albertus Magnus Lyceum . Repr. in Te New Scholasticism ():– and –.

Barnes, J. () Te Complete Works o Aristotle: Te Revised Oxord ranslation

(Princeton).Bernadete, J. () “Aristotle’s Argument rom ime,” Journal o Philosophy :

–.Berti, E. () “La causalità del Motore immobile secondo Aristotele,” Gregori-

anum : –.Blair, P.S.F. () Aristotle De caelo . a–b: Who Rules the Cosmos? MA

Tesis, University o exas at Austin.Bödéus, R. () “La prétendue intuition de Dieu dans le ‘De coelo’ d’Aristote,”

Phronesis : –.Bodnár, I.M. () “Movers and Elemental Motions in Aristotle,” Oxord Stud-

ies in Ancient Philosophy : –.———, () “Aristotle’s Rewinding Spheres: Tree Options and Teir Difficul-ties,” Apeiron : –.

Bodnár, I. and Pellegrin, P. () “Aristotle’s Physics and Cosmology,” in M.L.Gill and P. Pellegrin (edd.) Blackwell Companions to Philosophy: A Companionto Ancient Philosophy (Oxord) –.

Bogen, J. and McGuire, J.E. () “Aristotle’s Great Clock: Necessity, Possibility,and Te Motion o Te Cosmos In ‘De Caelo I:’,” Philosophy Research Archives : –.

Bolton, R. () “wo Standards or Inquiry in Aristotle’s De caelo,” in A.C.Bowen and C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caelo (Lei-den) –.

Bolzan, J.E. () “Aristoteles, ‘De caelo,’ B–,” Journal o the History o Philosophy : –.


10/16

’ :

———, () “Democrito, Aristoteles y la flotacion de los cuerpos,” Dialogos :–.

Bos, A.P. () “‘ Mantei’ in Aristotle, ‘De caelo’ II ,” Apeiron : –.Bossier, F. () Filologisch-historische navorsingen over die middeleeuwse enhumanistische Latijnse vertalingen van den commentaren van Simplicius, vols, Doctoral dissertation (Leuven).

———, () “raductions latines et influences du commentaire In de caelo enOccident (XIII’–XIV’ siecles)” in I. Hadot (ed.) Simplicius, sa vie, son œuvre,sa survie (Berlin) –.

Bourgey, L. () “Observation and Experiment in Analogical Explanation,” inJ. Barnes, M. Schoeld, and R. Sorabji (edd.) Articles on Aristotle: . Science(London) –.

Bowen, A.C. and Wildberg, C. () edd. New Perspectives on Aristotle’s Decaelo (Leiden).

Brandis, C.A. () Scholia in Aristotelem (Berlin).Broadie, S. () Passage and Possibility: A Study o Aristotle’s Modal Concepts

(Oxord).———, () “Te Possibilities o Being and Not-Being in De caelo .–,” in

A.C. Bowen and C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caelo(Leiden) –.

Burnyeat, M.F. () “Introduction: Aristotle on the Foundations o Sublunary Physics,” in F.A.J. de Haas, and J. Manseld (edd.) Aristotle’s On Generationand Corruption I , Symposium Aristotelicum (Oxord) –.

Byrne, C. () “Aristotle on Physical Necessity and the Limits o eleologicalExplanation,” Apeiron : –.

Capra, L. () orquato asso. Note di orquato asso a ‘De Caelo’ di Aristotele(Rome).

Carmody, F.J. () Innovations in Averroes’ De caelo (Berkeley).Charlton, W. () “Prime Matter—a Rejoinder,” Phronesis : –.Chroust, A.-H. () “Aristotle De Caelo a– (or b), a ‘Fragment’

o the Lost Aristotelian On Philosophy ,” Te Tomist : –.———, () “Some Observations on Aristotle’s Doctrine o the Uncreatedness

and Indestructibility o the Universe,” Rivista critica di storia della losoa :

–.Claghorn, G.S. () Aristotle’s Criticism o Plato’s Cosmology (London).Cohen, S. “Aristotle on Elemental Motion,” Phronesis : –.Crowley, .J. () “On the Use o ‘Stoicheion’ in the Sense o ‘Element’,” Oxord

Studies in Ancient Philosophy : –.Denyer, N. and Makin, S. () “Aristotle on Modality: II—Nicholas Denyer,

Never Will and Cannot,” Aristotelian Society: Supplementary Volume –.

Dicks, D.R. () Greek Astronomy rom Tales to Aristotle (London).Drabkin, I.E. () “Aristotle, De caelo ., a, ,” Te Classical Weekly :

–.Dreyer, J.L.E. () History o the Planetary Systems rom Tales to Kepler

(Cambridge).


11/16

’ :

Duhem, P.M.M. (–) Le système du monde: histoire des doctrines cos-mologiques de Platon à Copernic. vols. (Paris).

Easterling, H.J. () “Homocentric Spheres in ‘De Caelo’,” Phronesis : –.———, () “Quinta Natura,” Museum Helveticum : –.Effe, B. () Studien zur Kosmologie und Teologie der Aristotelischen Schrif

“Über die Philosophie” (Munich).Endress, G. () Die arabischen Übersetzungen von Aristoteles’ Schrif De caelo

(Frankurt).———, () “Averroes De Cælo: Ibn Rushd’s Cosmology in His Commen-

taries on Aristotle’s On the Heavens,” Arabic Sciences and Philosophy : –.

———, () “Alexander o Aphrodisias on the First Cause: Aristotle’s FirstMover in an Arabic reatise Attributed to Alexander o Aphrodisias,” inC. D’Ancona and G. Serra (edd.), Aristotele e Alessandro di Arodisia nellatradizione araba (Padova), –.

Falcon, A. () Corpi e movimenti: il De caelo di Aristotele e la sua ortuna nel mondo antico (Napoli).

———, () Aristotle and the Science o Nature: Unity without Uniormity (Cambridge).

Federspiel, M. () “Notes sur le traité aristotelicien Du ciel ,” Revue des Études Anciennes : –.

Fiorentino, F. () “Osservazioni sul commento di S. ommaso al “De caelo”

di Aristotele,” Sapienza : –.Fobes, F. () “A Preliminary Study o Certain Mss o Aristotle’s Meteorology ,”

Classical Review : –.Freeland, C. () “Aristotle on Perception, Appetition, and Sel-Motion,” in

M.L. Gill andJ.G. Lennox (edd.)Sel-Motionrom Aristotle to Newton (Prince-ton) –.

Freudenthal, G. () “Te Astrologization o the Aristotelian Cosmos: Celes-tial Influences on the Sublunar World in Aristotle, Alexander o Aphrodisias,and Averroes,” in A.C. Bowen and C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caelo (Leiden) –.

Furley, D. () “Sel-Movers,” in M.L. Gill and J.G. Lennox (edd.) Sel-Motion rom Aristotle to Newton (Princeton) –.Gigon, O. () Vom Himmel, Von der Seele, Von der Dichtkunst (Zurich).———, () “Aristoteles-Studien ,” Museum Helveticum : –.Gill, M.L. () “TeTeoryo the Elements in De caelo and ,” in A.C. Bowen

and C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caelo (Leiden) –.

Gill, M.L. and Lennox, J.G. (edd.) () Sel-Motion rom Aristotle to Newton(Princeton).

Glasner, R. () “Te Hebrew Version o De Celo et Mundo attributed to ibnS̄ınā,” Arabic Sciences and Philosophy : –.

Gould, J.B. () “Aristotle on ime and Possibility in ‘De Caelo’ I.,” Philo-sophical Inquiry : –.

Granada, M.A. () “Aristotle, Copernicus, Bruno: Centrality, the Principle


12/16

’ :

o Movement and the Extension o the Universe,” Studies in History and Philosophy o Science : –.

Grant, E. () “Appendix II: Te Anatomy o Medieval Cosmology—TeSignicance o the ‘Catalog o Questions’ in Appendix I,” in E. Grant, Planets,Stars, and Orbs: Te Medieval Cosmos, – (Cambridge) –.

Hadot, I. () “Recherches sur les ragments du commentaire du Simpliciussur la Métaphysique d’Aristote,” in I. Hadot (ed.) Simplicius, sa vie, son oeuvre,sa survie (Berlin/New York) –.

Hahm, D.E. () “Te Fifh Element in Aristotle’s De Philosophia: A CriticalReexamination,” Journal o Hellenic Studies : –. Repr. in J.P. Anton andA. Preus (edd.) Essays in Ancient Greek Philosophy (Albany, ) –.

Hall, J.J. () “ ‘Planets’ in Simplicius De caelo .ff.,” Te Journal o HellenicStudies : –.

Hankinson, R.J. () “Natural, Unnatural and Supernatural Motions: Contra-riety and the Argument or the Elements in De caelo .–,” in A.C. Bowenand C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caelo (Leiden) –.

Hanson, N.R. () “On Counting Aristotle’s Spheres,” Scientia : –.———, () Constellations and Conjectures (Dordrecht).Happ, H. () “Kosmologie und Metaphysik bei Aristoteles,” in K. Flasch (ed.)

Parusia: Festschrif ür Johannes Hirschberger (Frankurt/Main) –.Heath, .L. () Greek Astronomy (New York).Hintikka, J. () “Necessity, Universality, and ime in Aristotle,” Ajatus :

–.———, () ime and Necessity: Studies in Aristotle’s Teory o Modality (Ox-

ord).Hoffman, P. () “Simplicius’ Polemics: Some Aspects o Simplicius’ Polemical

Writings against John Philoponus: From Invective to a Reaffirmation o theranscendency o the Heavens,” in I. Hadot (ed.) Simplicius, sa vie, son oeuvre,sa survie (Berlin/New York) –.

Hon, G. and Goldstein, B.R. () “What Keeps the Earth in Its Place? TeConcept o Stability in Plato and Aristotle,” Centaurus : –.

Hugonnard–Roche, H. () “Aristote le Stagirite, De caelo. radition syriaque

et arabe,” in R. Goulet (ed.) Dictionnaire des philosophes antique: Supplément (Paris) –.Johansen, . () “From Plato’s imaeus to Aristotle’s De caelo:TeCaseothe

Missing World Soul,” in A.C. Bowen and C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspectiveson Aristotle’s De caelo (Leiden) –.

Judson, L. () “Heavenly Motion and the Unmoved Mover,” in M.L. Gill andJ.G. Lennox (edd.) Sel-Motion rom Aristotle to Newton (Princeton) –.

———, () ed. Aristotle’s Physics: A Collection o Essays (Oxord).———, “Eternity and Necessity in De caelo . (A Discussion o Waterlow,

)” Oxord Studies in Ancient Philosophy : –.Kahn, C.H. () “Te Place o the Prime Mover in Aristotle’s eleology,” in

A. Gotthel (ed.) Aristotle on Nature and Living Tings (Pittsburg) –.Kalan, V. () “Phenomenological Interpretations o Aristotle’s Cosmology,”

Phainomena : –.


13/16

’ :

Kererd, G.B. () “Aristotle’s reatment o the Doctrine o Parmenides,” inH. Blumenthal and H. Robinson (edd.) Aristotle and the Later radition

(Oxord) –.King, H.R. () “Aristotle without Prima Materia,” Journal o the History o Ideas : –.

Kosman, A. () “Aristotle’s Prime Mover,” in M.L. Gill and J.G. Lennox (edd.)Sel Motion rom Aristotle to Newton (Princeton) –.

Kouremenos, . () “Innite Bodies and the Prime Mover in Aristotle’s Phys.. ,” Philologus : –.

Kronz, F.M. () “Aristotle, the Direction Problem, and the Structure o theSublunar Realm,” Te Modern Schoolman : –.

Lang, H.S. () Te Order o Nature in Aristotle’s Physics: Place and the Ele-ments (Cambridge).

———, () “Aristotle’s Science o Nature,” in S.V. Astrid (ed.) Geschichte der Mathematik und der Naturwissenschafen in der Antike: . Physik/Mechanik(Stuttgart) –.

Lennox, J.G. () “De caelo . and Its Debt to De incessu animalium,” inA.C. Bowen and C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caelo(Leiden) –.

Leunissen, M. () “Why Stars Have No Feet: Explanation and eleology inAristotle’s Cosmology,” in A.C. Bowen and C. Wildberg (edd.) New Perspec-tives on Aristotle’s De caelo (Leiden) –.

Liske, M.. () “In welcher Weise hängen Modalbegriffe und Zeitbegriffe

bei Aristoteles zusammen?,” Zeitschrif ür Philosophische Forschung : –.

Lloyd, G.E.R. () “Heavenly Abberations,” in Lloyd, G.E.R. (ed.) AristotelianExplorations (Cambridge) –.

Longrigg, J. () “Aristotle, De caelo: Review o P. Moraux,” Te Classical Review : –.

Machamer, P.K. () “Aristotle on Natural Place and Natural Motion,” Isis :–.

Martin, .–H. () Mémoire sur les hypothèses astronomiques d’Eudoxe, deCallippe, d’Aristote et de leur école (Paris).

Martineau, E. () “ Aion chez Aristote De caelo I, . Téologie cosmiqueou cosmo-théologie?,” Revue de Metaphysique et de Morale : –.———, () “Response à M. Denis O’Brien,” Revue de Metaphysique et de

Morale : –.Matthen, M. () “Holistic Presuppositions o Aristotle’s Cosmology,” Oxord

Studies in Ancient Philosophy : –.———, () “Why Does Earth Move to the Center? An Examination o Some

Explanatory Strategies in Aristotle’s Cosmology,” in A.C. Bowen and C. Wild-berg (edd.) New Essays on Aristotle’s De caelo (Leiden) –.

Matthen, M.P. and Hankinson, R.J. () “Aristotle’s Universe: Its Form andMatter,” Synthese : –.

McCue, J.F. () “Scientic Procedure In Aristotle’s ‘De Caelo’,” raditio :–.

McKeon, R. () Te Basic Works o Aristotle (New York).


14/16

’ :

Merlan, P. () “wo Teological Problems In Aristotle’s Met Λ: – and DeCaelo A: ,” Apeiron : –.

Mignucci, M. () “Aristotle’s De Caelo I, and His Notion o Possibility,”in D. Devereux and P. Pellegrin (edd.) Biologie, logique et métaphysique chez Aristote (Paris) –.

Moraux, P. () “Einige Bemerkungen über den Auau von Aristoteles’Schrif de caelo,” Museum Helveticum : –.

———, () “Recherches sur le De caelo d’Aristote. Objet et structure del’ouvrage,” Revue Tomiste –.

———, () “Notes sur la tradition indirecte du ‘De caelo’ d’Aristote,” Hermes: –.

———, () “La méthode d’Aristote dans l’étude du ciel: De caelo I.–II.,” inS. Mansion (ed.) Aristote et les problèmes de méthode (Paris) –.

———, () “Quinta Essentia,” in Pauly-Wissowa, Realencyclopädie der classis-chen Alterumswissenschaf : –.

Moraux, P. and Wiesner, J. () Der Aristotelismus bei den Griechen. Von Andronikos bis Alexander von Aphrodisias (Berlin).

Morison, B. () On Location: Aristotle’s Concept o Place (Oxord).Moss, J.D. () “Ludovico Carbone’s Commentary on Aristotle’s De caelo,”

in D.O. Dahlstrom (ed.) Nature and Scientic Method . Essays in Honor o William A. Wallace (Washington) –.

O’Brien, D. () “Aristote et l’ ‘Aion’. Enquête sur une critique recente,” Revuede Metaphysique et de Morale : –.

———, () “Aristotle’s Teory o Movement” in J.J. Cleary and W. Wians (edd.) Aristotle’s Teory o Movement , Proceedings o the Boston Area Colloquiumin Ancient Philosophy (Lanham) –.

O’Keee, . and Torsrud, H. () “Aristotle’s ‘Cosmic Nose’ Argument or theUniqueness o the World,” Apeiron : –.

Owen, G.E.L. () “ithenai ta phainomena,” in S. Mansion (ed.) Aristote et les problèmes de méthode (Paris) –.

———, () “Aristotle: Method, Physics, and Cosmology,” in C.C. Gillispie(ed.) Dictionary o Scientic Biography , vol. (New York) –.

Palmer, J. () “Aristotle on the Ancient Teologians,” Apeiron : –

.Pellegrin, P. () “Te Argument or the Sphericity o the Universe in Aristo-tle’s De caelo: Astronomy and Physics,” in A.C. Bowen and C. Wildberg (edd.)New Perspectives on Aristotle’s De caelo (Leiden) –.

Praechter, K. () “Simpl. in Aristot. de caelo p. ,ff. H.,” Hermes : –.

Quandt, K. () “‘Ai gàr ton enantíon apodeixeis aporíai perì ton enantíoneisin’: Philosophical Program and Expository Practice in Aristotle,” Classical Antiquity : –.

———, () “On the Sense and Authenticity o De caelo A–,” Classical Philology : –.

Repellini, F.F. () “De caelo o Aristotle as a Dialectic Reply to Plato’s im-aeus,” Rivista critica di storia della losoa : –.

van Rijen, J. () Aspects o Aristotle’s Logic o Modalities (Dordrecht).


15/16

’ :

Rini, A.A. () “When ime Is o the Essence: Prior Analytics I. and Decaelo I.,” Logique et Analyse : –.

Robinson, H.M. () “Prime Matter in Aristotle,” Phronesis : –.Roochnik, D. () “Aristotle’s Commonsensical Cosmology,” in N. Rana-singhe (ed.) Logos and Eros: Essays Honoring Stanley Rosen (South Bend) –.

Rosen, E. () “Te Dissolution o the Solid Celestial Spheres,” Journal o theHistory o Ideas : –.

Sandbach, F.H. () “Plutarch and Aristotle,” Illinois Classical Sudies : –.

Sauvé Meyer, S. () “Sel-Movement and External Causation,” in M.L. Gilland J.G. Lennox (edd.) Sel-Motion rom Aristotle to Newton (Princeton) –.

Savoie, D. () “Problèmes de datation d’une occultation observée par Aris-tote,” Revue d’histoire des sciences : –.

Seeck, G.A. () Über die Elemente in der Kosmologie des Aristoteles: Unter-suchungen zu “De Generatione et Corruptione” und “De Caelo” (Munich).

Sharples, R.W. () “Responsibility and the Possibility o More than OneCourse o Action: A Note on Aristotle De caelo II, ,” Bulletin o the Instituteo Classical Studies o the University o London : –.

Sinnige, .G. () “Cosmic Religion in Aristotle,” Greek, Roman and ByzantineStudies : –.

Sisko, J. () Review o D. Sedley (ed.) Oxord Studies in Ancient Philosophy

(), Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews ..Solmsen, F. () “Aristotle De caelo A, a ff.,” Classical Philology : –

.———, () “Aristotle and Prime Matter: A Reply to Hugh R. King,” Journal o

the History o Ideas : –.———, (b) “Aristotle and Presocratic Cosmogony,” Harvard Studies in Clas-

sical Philology : –.———, () Aristotle’s System o the Physical World: A Comparison with His

Predecessors (Ithaca).Stephenson, F.R. () “A Lunar Occultation o Mars Observed by Aristotle,”

Journal or the History o Astronomy : –.Stocks, J.L. () “De Caelo,” in W.D. Ross (ed.) Works o Aristotle, vol. (Oxord).

arán, L. () “Review o P. Moraux. . Aristote. Du ciel . Paris,” Gnomon: –. = L. arán, Collected Papers – (Leiden ), –.

Torp, J. () “Te Luminousness o Te Quintessence,” Phoenix : –.igner, S.S. () “Empedocles’ wirled Ladle and the Vortex-Supported

Earth,” Isis : –.oulmin, S.E. and Goodeld, J. () Te Fabric o the Heavens (London).Ugaglia, M. () Modelli idrostatici di moto da Aristotele a Galileo (Rome).Verdenius, W.J. () “Critical and Exegetical Notes on De caelo,” in I. Düring

(ed.) Naturphilosophie bei Aristoteles und Teophrast (Heidelberg) –.Vuillemin, J. () “L’argument dominateur,” Revue de Metaphysique et de

Morale : –.


16/16

’ :

Wallace, A. () Galileo’s Early Notebooks: Te Physical Questions. A ransla-tion rom the Latin, with Historical and Paleographical Commentary (Notre

Dame).Waterlow, S.: see Broadie, S.Wieland, W. () “Die Ewigkeit der Welt,” in D. Henrich, W. Schulz and K.-

H. Volkmann–Schluck (edd.) Die Gegenwart der Griechen in neuerer Denken:Festschrif ür H.G. Gadamer (übingen).

Wildberg, C. () John Philoponus’ Criticism o Aristotle’s Teory o Aether ,Peripatoi , (Berlin/New York).

Williams, C.J.F. () “Aristotle and Corruptibility: A Discussion o AristotleDe Caelo I, XII (Part I),” Religious Studies : –.

Wolson, H.A. () “Te Plurality o Immovable Movers in Aristotle andAverroës,” Harvard Studies in Classical Philology : –.

Zahlfleisch, J. () “Die Polemik des Simplicius gegen Alexander und anderein dem Commentar des ersteren zu der Aristotelischen Schrif de Caelo,” Archiv ür Geschichte der Philosophie : –.

aristotle de caelo bibliography

Documents