[archived] overview of 3d engineered models for construction · francesca maier (parsons...

77
Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction November 20, 2013 1:00 pm 2:30 pm EST Archival May no longer reflect current or accepted regulation, policy, guidance or practice.

Upload: others

Post on 02-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Overview of 3D Engineered Models

for Construction November 20, 2013

1:00 pm – 2:30 pm EST

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 2: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Why Webinars?

Webinars are one of the three legs of the 3-D Engineering

Models for Construction stool

Every Day Counts | 2

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 3: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3-D Models

Implementation

W

O

R

K

S

H

O

P

S

Why Webinars?

Webinars are

one of the three

legs to

successful

implementation

Every Day Counts | 3

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 4: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Target Audience for the Webinars

• Government Owners

(DOTs, Counties, Cities, etc.)

• Consultants

• Contractors

• Industry

Every Day Counts | 4

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 5: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

1. Overview of 3D Models for Construction

November 20, 2013, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• FHWA Introduction

• DOT perspective

• Contractor perspective

Every Day Counts | 5

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 6: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Agenda

Speaker Topic

Rich Juliano (ARTBA) Overview from the Contractor’s Perspective

Bryan Cawley (FHWA-HQ) Welcome & Overview of EDC2 3D Engineered

Models for Construction Initiative

Dan Belcher (Michigan DOT) Overview from the DOT’s perspective

Alexa Mitchell (Missouri DOT) Creating and Delivering 3D models for

Construction

Eric Cylwik (Sundt Construction) Using 3D models in Bidding and Construction

Douglas Townes (FHWA-RC) Information on Next Webinar and Close

Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction

Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914, [email protected] Every Day Counts | 6

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 7: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

The Contractor Perspective

Rich Juliano

Senior Vice President

American Road & Transportation

Builders Association

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 8: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3D Modeling: MAP-21 Provisions

• Section 1304 – Innovative Project Delivery Methods

– Projects including use of innovative technology may be eligible

for greater federal share of funding

– Examples include “digital 3-dimensional modeling techniques”

• Section 1503 – Project Approval and Oversight

– The Secretary “shall encourage the use of advanced modeling technologies during environmental, planning, financial

management, design, simulation, and construction processes of

[federal-aid] projects.”

– Compile information and industry best practices

– Disseminate information and best practices to state DOTs

– Develop and publish a comprehensive plan

Every Day Counts | 8

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 9: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

AASHTO-ARTBA-AGC Joint Committee

• Policymaking group which includes these three national associations, with participation from FHWA

• 2012 Joint Position Statement: “Best Practices for Electronic Data-Sharing Between State DOTs and Contractors” – Prospective bidders should be provided all project electronic files

– DOTs not expected to convert to vector format

– Bidder can rely on data in static files as complete

– For plans with cross-sections, vector files should also be provided; bidder responsible for verifying the accuracy of data

• Model liability limitation language to clarify designer’s responsibility

Every Day Counts | 9

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 10: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Some Further Thoughts from Industry…

• General Consensus

• “Horizontal” vs. “Vertical” – BIM

• Software and Contract Requirements

• Contractors Embrace Innovation

• FHWA’s Every Day Counts

• Contact: [email protected]

• THANK YOU!

Every Day Counts | 10

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 11: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Poll Pod

Every Day Counts | 11

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 12: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Bryan Cawley

Construction Management

Team Leader

Office of Infrastructure

3D Engineered Models for

Construction

[email protected] 202-366-1333 Arch

ival

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 13: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3D Engineered Models for Construction

• Project represented in 3D, with accuracy and precision – Rotated, tilted, and manipulated to provide varying views

– Perform “clash” analysis

– Improved quality with quantity takeoffs

– Digital Terrain Model (DTM) for Automated Machine Guidance

(AMG)

• With 4D (time) virtual construction

• With 5D (money) cash flow

Every Day Counts | 13Image Courtesy Wisconsin DOT

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 14: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

14Every Day Counts |

Source: The Business Value

of BIM for Infrastructure,

McGraw Hill Construction,

2012

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 15: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Productivity Gain Using AMG (%)

10 20 30 40 50

Fre

qu

en

cy

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Contractors

Vendors

Cost Savings Using AMG (%)

10 20 30 40 50

Fre

qu

en

cy

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Contractors

Vendors

>50

Ultrasonic1

2D Laser1

3D Laser1/

GPS1 (89 to

101%)

Ultrasonic1

2D Laser1 3D Laser

1

GPS1

GPS2

Notes: 1Fine-grading using CAT 140H motor grader (Jonasson et al., 2002)

2Trench excavation using CAT 330DL hydraulic excavator (Aðalsteinsson, 2008)

3Earth moving and fine grading (general values; not project specific) (Forrestel, 2007)

4Earth moving and fine grading project - Port of Brisbane (Higgins, 2009)

Notes: 1Fine-grading using CAT 140H motor grader - Overall unit cost (Jonasson et al., 2002)

2Earth moving and fine grading project - Port of Brisbane (overal cost savings) (Higgins, 2009)

GPS3GPS

4

GPS2

GPS7

(265%)

5Bulk earth moving and subgrade fine grading using CAT D6N dozer (gain in the

number of passes; Caterpillar, 2006)6Bulk earth moving using CAT 330D excavator (Caterpillar, 2006)

7Base course fine grading using CAT 140H motorgrader (gain the number of passes;

Caterpillar, 2006)

GPS6

GPS3

3Bulk earth moving using CAT 330D excavator - fuel cost savings (Caterpillar, 2006)

4Bulk earth moving and fine grading using CAT D6N dozer - fuel cost savings (Caterpillar, 2006)

5Fine grading using 140H motorgrader - fuel cost savings (Caterpillar, 2006)

GPS4

GPS5

(68%)

>50

GPS5

(107%)

Every Day Counts | 15

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 16: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Texas Legislature commissioned Texas A&M Institute

Construction Innovations

• Design-Build/Just-in-Time Design/Design

on the Fly

• 3-D Design

• Electronic Plans

• Delayed Closures to Accommodate

Special Holidays

• Holiday/Event Black Out Period

• Night & Weekend Closures

• Wireless Paving

• Intelligent Compaction

• Smart Concrete Truck

• Asset Management through Equipment

Telematics

• GPS-equipped Vehicles and Equipment

• Use of Rock for Retaining Wall Backfill

• Full Attack Construction/Aggressive

Construction

• Highly Integrated City Coordination

• Mobility Coordinator • Night Utility Relocation • Higher-Level Utility Coordination • Consolidate Utility Efforts • Pre-Cast Facilities/Pre-Cast In-Situ • Recycling In-Place • Use of Asphalt Pavement • Pre-Cast Composite Steel/Concrete

Caps • Executive Meetings • Scheduling Tools • Play of the Day Meetings • Weekly Coordination Meetings • Co-location of All Offices • Monthly 4-square matrix • On-site Maintenance Shop • Condition Appropriate Span Lengths • Use of Recycled Rock Material in

Lieu of Lime

• Selected Full Closure for Bridge http://mobility.tamu.edu/mip/Reconstruction

Every Day Counts | 16

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 17: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Advanced modeling techniques for enhanced constructability review: a

survey of state practices and related research – Caltrans March 2012

• Benefits:

– Time Savings: Visualization leads to faster decision-making; profiling

is simpler and faster calculations for earthwork can be generated;

more interactions of designs can be developed more quickly; and

problems are more easily spotted and corrected earlier in the design

process.

– Cost Savings: Lower bids, lower survey costs and less rework; more

accurate estimates; and fewer change orders and field modifications.

– Quality: Ability to catch avoidable mistakes; earthwork calculations

are more representative of the proposed project; and conflicts can be

resolved before the bid process begins.

– Improvements in Customer Relations: Builds belief in the design and

confidence in the engineer-client relationship.

• Challenges:

– Education and training, software limitations, and resistance to change.

Every Day Counts | 17

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 18: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3D Activities & tools

• National Website and Technical Support Service Center - Jan 2014 – Specs, Details, Case Studies, etc.

• Currently using: http://www.efl.fhwa.dot.gov/technology/dv.aspx

– Technical Assistance

– Inquiries from State DOTs, LPAs, Contractors & Engineers

• Webinars – Fall 2013 & throughout 2014

• 1-day Training – Spring 2014

• Demonstration Workshops – Design to Asphalt Pave – Oregon

– Design to Construction of Steel Structures - Pennsylvania

– Design to Concrete Slip-form Pave – Missouri

• Tech Briefs and Web-based Training – Summer 2014 – NYState DOT – Steel Bridge Fabrication 3D Modeling

• Implementation Manuals – Summer 2014 – Iowa DOT

Every Day Counts | 18

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 19: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

More information

• More Information on EDC Technologies: – http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/everydaycounts/

• More Information on 3D Engineered

Models for Construction – http://www.efl.fhwa.dot.gov/technology/dv.aspx

• ACPA Stringless Concrete Slip-Form

Paving – http://acpa.scholarlab.com/ Pavement1

Every Day Counts | 19

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 20: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3D Engineered Models for construction:

Who can you contact?

• Chris Schneider FHWA Office of Infrastructure [email protected] 202-493-0551

• David Unkefer FHWA Resource Center [email protected] 404-562-3669

• Bryan Cawley FHWA Office of Infrastructure, [email protected] 202-366-1333

• Douglas Townes FHWA Resource Center [email protected] 404-562-3914

• Kathryn Weisner FHWA Resource Center, [email protected] 410-962-2484

Every Day Counts | 20

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 21: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3D Engineered Models for Construction

from the DOT Perspective

Daniel Belcher, P.E., P.S.

Michigan Department of Transportation

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 22: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3D I$ 2B

Mac, we’ve been doing this

for over 100 years there’s nothing to

worry about!

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 23: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

We Squeezed all the Efficiency Out of 2D CAD

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 24: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Design

Courtesy Dean Bowman, Bentley Systems

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 25: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Construction

Courtesy Dean Bowman, Bentley Systems

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 26: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Customers

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 27: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Contractors - Machine Guidance

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 28: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Inspectors - Stake Diet

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 29: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

A s s e t M a n a g e m e n t

I n t e l l i g e n t T r a n s p o r t a t i o n

S y s t e m s

P e r f o r m a n c e B a s e d

O p e r a t i o n s

Operations & Maintenance

A$$ET$

A u t o m a t e d D e s i g n &

C o n s t r u c t i o n

P e r f o r m a n c e M e a s u r e m e n t

D e c i s i o n S u p p o r t

M A P 2 1

T r a n s p a r e n c y in

G o v e r n m e n t

A u t o n o m o u s V e h i c l e s

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 30: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Hatch Mott McDonald Northwest PATH Pedestrian Tunnel Toronto, Canada

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 31: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Hatch Mott McDonald Northwest PATH Pedestrian Tunnel Toronto, Canada

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 32: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Challenges

• Change • Training • Standards • 3D Model QA/QC • Risk – Contractor V’s DOT

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 33: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Poll Pod

Every Day Counts | 33

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 34: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Creating and Delivering 3D Models

Alexa Mitchell, P.E. MoDOT – CADD Services Engineer

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 35: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Traditional Design Models

• Fragmented design – rigid – inefficient

• Lack of design intent

• Inhibit collaboration

Every Day Counts | 35

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 36: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Traditional Design Models

• Inhibit innovation and technology use

• Incomplete model for construction

• Increased bidding risk + change orders

Every Day Counts | 36

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 37: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Benefits of 3D Design Models for Construction

• Design model for multiple purposes

(PR, R/W, decision making)

• Design intent is communicated

• Decreased risk = competition

• Virtual construction = fewer change orders

• Provide opportunity for innovation

(ATC’s, VE, AMG, etc.)

Every Day Counts | 37

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 38: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Technical Challenges

• Lack of guidelines or best practices

• Lack of $ to set up technical infrastructure

(storage, bandwidth, accessibility, etc.)

• Mismatched technological advances

(software vs. hardware)

• Lack of expertise

• Lack of investment in training and technology

• Accelerated deadlines = no time to learn

• Lack of consistency from contractors

(type of data & format – one size does not fit all) Every Day Counts | 38

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 39: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Legal Challenges

• Electronic plans vs. electronic data

• Change orders and model modifications

• Validation of data and disputes

• Engineer of record

Every Day Counts | 39

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 40: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Conclusions

• 3D Models are better than traditional 2D models

• We have a number of technical, institutional and

legal challenges we must overcome as an agency

• So it’ll take the agencies time to completely move to 3D workflows, but we must start now

Every Day Counts | 40

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 41: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Poll Pod

Every Day Counts | 41

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 42: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Using 3D Models in Bidding and

Construction Eric Cylwik

Sundt Construction

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 43: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Developing Models

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 44: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

44Every Day Counts |

Developing Models - Parametric

+ + =

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 45: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Ret. Wall

Structure Ex.

Structure Backfill

Every Day Counts | 45

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 46: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

From Construction Documents

Alignment Data Profile Data

Every Day Counts | 46Standard Detail

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 47: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

From Model

• Import Surface Data

– LandXML, DTM, Etc…

• Import Alignment Data – LandXML, CSV

• Import Line Work Data – DGN, DWG, DXF

Every Day Counts | 47

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 48: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Using Models for Bidding

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 49: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Use in Bidding – Means and Methods

Every Day Counts | 49

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 50: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Use in Bidding – Means and Methods

Every Day Counts | 50

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 51: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Use In Bidding – Means and Methods

Every Day Counts | 51

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 52: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Using Models during Construction

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 53: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Use During Construction

Every Day Counts | 53

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 54: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Use in Construction

DO “THIS”

Design Model

Real World Location

Machine Orientation

Every Day Counts | 54

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 55: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Every Day Counts | 55

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 56: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Every Day Counts | 56

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 57: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Bits to Atoms

Every Day Counts | 57

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 58: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Bits to Atoms

Every Day Counts | 58

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 59: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Bits to Atoms

Every Day Counts | 59

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 60: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Bits to Atoms

Every Day Counts | 60

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 61: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Bits to Atoms

Every Day Counts | 61

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 62: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Conclusion

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 63: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Benefits of Using Models

• Critical data input, reducing repetition

• Faster, more accurate, and more

responsive estimates

• Deeper understanding of construction

documents

• Reduce risk in planning and execution

• Right Here, Right Now information

Every Day Counts | 63

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 64: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3D Engineered Models for

Construction Webinars Douglas Townes, P.E.

FHWA Resource Center

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 65: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Webinar Topics

Webinar 1: Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction

Webinar 2: Creating 3D Engineered Models

Webinar 3: Applications of 3D Models in the Contractor’s Office

Webinar 4: Applications of 3D Models on the Construction Site

Webinar 5: Managing and Sharing 3D Models for Construction

Webinar 6: Overcoming Challenges to Using 3D Engineered Models for

Construction

Webinar 7: Steps to Requiring 3D Engineered Models for Construction

Webinar 8: The Future: Adding Time, Cost and other Information to 3D Model

Every Day Counts | 65

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 66: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

2. Creating 3D Engineered Models

January 8, 2014, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• Survey Methods

• Legal issues with sharing survey data

• Creating a DTM

• Creating 3-D Models

• Data Exchange formats

Every Day Counts | 66

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 67: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

3. Applications of 3D Models in the Contractor’s

Office

February19, 2014, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• Contractor’s perspective

– Preparing models for estimates

– Preparing models for clash

detection

– Preparing models for AMG

– Benefits of using AMG Every Day Counts | 67

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 68: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

4. Applications of 3D Models on the Construction

Site

April 2, 2014, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• DOT perspective

–Safety issues

–Public outreach

–Project staking, AMG &

QA

–Benefits of using AMG

–3D models on mobile

devices Every Day Counts | 68

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 69: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

5. Managing and Sharing 3D Models for

Construction

May 7, 2014, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• The data structure for the 3D Engineered

Model

• Sharing data in a point cloud

• Data formats and data exchange

• Specifying 3D models by element and

LOD

• Certifying electronic documents

• Validating construction models Every Day Counts | 69

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 70: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

6. Overcoming Challenges to Using 3D Engineered

Models for Construction

September 10, 2014, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• Overcoming technological implementation

barriers

– DOT issues

– Contractor issues

• Developing a plan for

implementation

• Resources for

overcoming barriers

Every Day Counts | 70

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 71: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

7. Steps to Requiring 3D Engineered

Models for Construction

October 15, 2014, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• Identifying champions

• Evaluate pilot projects

• DOT Specifications,

policies & procedures

• Contract language to

accommodate technology and manage

liability

Every Day Counts | 71

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 72: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

8. The Future: Adding Time, Cost and other

Information to 3D Model

November 19, 2014, 1:00 – 2:30 pm

• 4D

• 5D

Every Day Counts | 72

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 73: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Participant Interaction

Francesca Maier, P.E.

Parsons Brinckerhoff

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 74: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Summary of Benefits

• Better communication of the design intent

• Reduced clashes

• Savings of up to 30% on earthworks

• Better construction quality

• Enhanced safety

Every Day Counts | 74

Images courtesy of ConnDOT

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 75: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Summary of Challenges

• Technological challenges

– Enabling infrastructure

– Education and training

– Data management

• Institutional challenges

– Creating standards and specifications

– Changing workflows

– Legal frameworks

– Time and fiscal constraints Every Day Counts | 75

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 76: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Participant Interaction

• Poll pods

• Question and Answer

Every Day Counts | 76

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.

Page 77: [Archived] Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction · Francesca Maier (Parsons Brinckerhoff) Summary and Audience Interaction . Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914,

Webinar Series

Overview of 3D Engineered Models for Construction Today

Creating 3D Engineered Models January 8, 2014

Applications of 3D Models in the Construction Office February 19, 2014

Applications of 3D Models on the Construction Site April 2, 2014

Managing and Sharing 3D Models for Construction May 7, 2014

Overcoming Impediments to Using 3D Engineered Models for

Construction September 10, 2014

Steps to Requiring 3D Engineered Models for Construction October 15, 2014

The Future: Adding Time, Cost and Other Information to 3D

Models November 19, 2014

Contact: Douglas Townes, Phone 404-562-3914, [email protected]

http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/everydaycounts/edctwo/2012/3d.cfm

Every Day Counts | 77

Archiva

l

May no

long

er ref

lect c

urren

t or a

ccep

ted

regula

tion,

policy

, guid

ance

or pr

actic

e.