appendix e-1: full stakeholder · pdf filemr jaco pieterse gijima (082) 323-1009 mr/ms...
TRANSCRIPT
APPENDIX E-1: Full Stakeholder Database
Contacts-BAR
Title First Name Last Name Company Address City Code Fax Phone Mobile Phone Email Address
Dr. Mathys Vosloo Zitholele Consulting PO Box 4546The Reeds Johannesburg 1685 0866746121 0112072079 0847483018 [email protected]
Mr. James MacKenzie Prime Africa (082) 927 3362 [email protected]
Mr/Ms Mmabatho Nkoa 3Q - Env. Officer (071) 441-3011
Ms Lerato Mokoma ABB- Env. Officer (074) 331-7334 [email protected]
Mr Gert Smith Agri Mpumalanga PO Box 677 WITBANK 1035 (013) 636-8996 (082) 388-3387
Ms Cindy Smith Anglo American Private Bag X9 LERAATSFONTEIN 1035 (013) 691-5405 (013) 691-5117 (083) 659-2194 [email protected]
Ms Elise Tempelhoff Beeld PO Box 333 AUCKLAND PARK 2006 (011) 713-9956 (011) 713-9182 (083) 309-1192 [email protected]
Ms Annemie Duvenage Bronkhorstspruit and Wilge River Conservation AssociationPO Box 691 BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (086) 524-2489 (082) 466-2384 [email protected]
Mr Emmanuel Nzuma Cathoros (076) 224- 4803 [email protected]
Mr Ephrone Montlebi CBR - Env. Officer (071) 345-1583
Ms Doreen Sithole DAFF PO Box 8806 Nelspruit 1200 (013) 754 0732 (013) 754 0701 [email protected]
Mr Ndivhuho Mudau DEA-EMI (012) 399-9433 (073) 455-5809 [email protected]
Ms Wilma Lutsch Department of Environmental Affairs PRETORIA 0001 (012) 320-7026 (012) 310-3694 (082) 657-2322 [email protected]
Ms Mokgadi Maloba Department of Water and Sanitation Private Bag X10580 Bronkhorstspriut 1020 (078) 822-6061 [email protected]
Mr Danie Otto Digbywells (082) 399-9315 [email protected]
Ms Lasantha Naidoo DWS 185 Francis Baard Street Pretoria 0001 (012) 336-8870 (082) 893-2450 [email protected]
Ms Busisiwe Hadebe ECO (083) 717-0425 [email protected]
Mr Emmanuel Manyane ECO (074) 425-6720 [email protected]
Mr Mthombeni Ndlangisa ECO (062) 067-0197 [email protected]
Mr Erald Nkabinde Emalahleni Local Municipality PO Box 3 WITBANK 1035 (086) 698 7468 (013) 690 6350 (072) 596 4904 [email protected]
Mr Stanley Jacobs Ematayereni (079) 917-8884
Mr C Voight ENC Municipality (072) 909-6514
Ms Dheneshree Lalla Engineer (073) 153-1360 [email protected]
Mr/Ms Kbomotso Shakwane Env. Management Inspector (082) 597-9758 [email protected]
Ms Aletia Chapman Env. Manager (083) 633-4487 [email protected]
Mr/Ms Mushayi Mudzielwana Env. Manager (082) 879-6150 [email protected]
Mr Johnson Matidle Env. Officer (076) 631-5673 [email protected]
Mr Gary Ainsworth Env. Scientist (078) 438-8877 [email protected]
Mr Thinus Oosthuizen Eskom (086) 695 0399 (083) 301-8002 [email protected]
Mr Tobile Bokwe Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd PO Box 1091 JOHANNESBURG 2000 (086) 663-2051 (011) 800-2303 (082) 828-1777 [email protected]
Mr/Ms Thivhusiwi Netshidongololwe Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd (011) 800-2985 (082) 683-7751 [email protected]
Ms Mari Kotze Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd - Kusile Power StationPO Box 1091 JOHANNESBURG 2000 (013) 699-7724 (072) 109-6634 [email protected]
Mr Hardus Kotze Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd - Kusile Power StationPO Box 12346 LERAATSFONTEIN 1038 (013) 699-7730 (079) 873-7737 [email protected]
Mr Mike Elliot Eyethu Coal, Klipfontein Colliery (086) 660-1327 (082) 573 2793 [email protected]
Mr Juan Richter Eyethu Coal, Klipfontein Colliery (079) 171 2339 [email protected]
Mr & Mrs D and H Sharp Farm: Kortfontein (Sharp Farming) PO Box 355 BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (086) 675-1068 (013) 932-7500 (082) 777-5175 [email protected]
Mr & Mrs Barry & SandriaLensley Farm: Spitskop 502JR, Ptn 19 (079) 850 5918 [email protected]
Ms Mariette Liefferink Federation for a Sustainable EnvironmentPostnet Suite 87 RIVONIA 2128 (086) 464 1509 (011) 465-6910 (073) 231-4893 [email protected]
Mr Ian Dennis GE - Env. Officer (076) 774-7986
Mr Jaco Pieterse Gijima (082) 323-1009
Mr/Ms Lungile Sibeko Gijima (079) 770-0910
Mr/Ms Robin de Witt Gouwsberg Irrigation Board PO Box 1867 BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (013) 963-7077 (082) 771-4333 [email protected]
Ms AM Milner Gouwsberg Irrigation Board PO Box 699 BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (013) 652-9710 (013) 652-9710 (082) 333-7078
Mr Andre van Staden Gouwsberg Irrigation Board PO Box 1867 BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (086) 655-2217 (082) 388-3087 [email protected]
Mr Bongani A Mkhari GW (072) 120-0200 [email protected]
Mr/Ms Lesiba Kgobe Gx Env. Manager (078) 903-9211 [email protected]
Mr Patrick Jacobs HEjn (073) 109-1273
Ms Amanada Austin JG Africa - Senior Aquaic Scientist (082) 352-7524 [email protected]
Mr Hannes de Bruyn Kendal Poultry Farm (072) 694-5745 [email protected]
Mr Patrick Mdluli KET-Senior Env Advisor (072) 263-5177 [email protected]
Ms Mary Lewis Klipkop Land Owner's Association PO Box 76 WELBEKEND 1517 (086) 677-8099 (011) 964-1900 (076) 979-9139 [email protected]
Mr Hugh Patrickson Klipkop Land Owner's Association Private Bag X10 LYNNWOOD RIDGE 0040 (086) 606-6567 (011) 748-2800 (082) 783-6658 [email protected]
Mr James Johnson KLW - Env. Officer (079) 887-0542
Ms Krista Mothapo Kusile Env. Officer (079) 335-1699 [email protected]
Mr Doug Robless Kusile KET Site Manager (072) 598-9117 [email protected]
Mr Tselane Moloi Kusile Power Station (076) 391-0012
Mr Hennie Laas Mpumalanga Agriculture Union PO Box 619 ERMELO 2350 (017) 819-1297 (017) 819-1295 [email protected]
Ms Mapule Kgwale MRMS (078) 431-9106 [email protected]
Page 1
Contacts-BAR
Ms Lerato Gambu Nkangala District Municipality PO Box 437 MIDDELBURG 1050 (013) 249-2165 [email protected]
Ms Anele Ngcobetsha Nkangala District Municipalty (013) 249-2018 [email protected]
Mr Vusi Mahlangu Nkangala Distrtict Municipality MIDDELBURG 1050 (013) 282-6723 (013) 249-2000 (082) 414-2905 [email protected]
Mnr Joerné Buys Plaas: Bossemanskraal Posbus 1892 NEWLANDS 0049 (012) 811-0820 (012) 811-0820 (082) 411-4560 [email protected]
Mnr Bielie Geldenhuys Plaas: Bossemanskraal BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (082) 882-5146 [email protected]
Mnr Hennie Terblanche Plaas: Bossemanskraal Posbus 427 GROBLERSDAL 0470 (013) 262-5369 (013) 262-5369 (082) 469-2234 [email protected]
Mnr Johann Kotzé Plaas: Bossemanskraal & Kortfontein Posbus 36899 MENLO PARK 0102 (011) 647-8331 (083) 257-8270 [email protected]
Mnr JP Joubert Plaas: Nooitgedacht & Witpoort (JJH Boerdery)Posbus 55 BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (082) 388-2592 [email protected]
Mnr Hans Jansen van Rensburg Plase: Bossemanskraal & Witklip (Hans van Rensburg Boerdery)Posbus 273 BRONKHORSTSPRUIT 1020 (013) 932-2056 (013) 932-1379 (082) 492-0632 [email protected]
Mnr Christie Truter Plase: Dwaalfontein, Klipfontein & Vlakvarkfontein (Truter Boerdery Trust)Posbus 621 OGIES 2230 (013) 648-8911 [email protected]
Mr Kyle Harris Prime Africa (012) 348-0317 (082) 463-5921 [email protected]
Mr Joseph Mulders Prime Africa Consultants 53 Woodpecker Avenue Pretoria (072) 754 2603 [email protected]
Ms Dineo Maila Prime Africa Consultants 53 Woodpecker Avenue Pretoria (076) 238 1631 [email protected]
Ms Daphney Modise Rotek Waste (076) 462-4755 [email protected]
Mr Siphiwe Mahlangu Senior Env Advisor (013) 699-7096 [email protected]
Ms Florence Radebe Senior Env Advisor (011) 800-4989 (082) 389-2233 [email protected]
Ms Miranda Moahlodi SHE Manager (083) 664-7627 [email protected]
Mr Sivuyisiwe Zani SSBR JV (087) 809-2063 [email protected]
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd PO Box 2312 FAERIE GLEN 0043 (083) 569-3167 [email protected]
Mr Stefan Vermaak Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd PO Box 35492 MENLO PARK 0102 (012) 348-8474 (012) 348-3676 [email protected]
Mnr Barend Vorster Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd PO Box 35492 MENLO PARK 0102 (012) 348-3676 (082) 494-4403 [email protected]
Mr Mosa Legwase Turbular-Env. Officer (072) 019-2781 [email protected]
Ms Busi Mdluli Victor Khanye Local Municipality PO Box 6 DELMAS 2210 (013) 665-6000 [email protected]
Ms Catharina Venter Wetland Specialist (083) 370-0850 [email protected]
Mr Sonnyboy Bapela Member: Kusile EMC (012) 310-3098 (012) 322-2602 [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms Ayanda Ngcobo Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Ms Michelle Govender DEA [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr/Ms [email protected] Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr Lucky Mkhonto Member: Kusile EMC [email protected]
Mr Stanley Tshitwamulomoni DEA (012) 399 9587 [email protected]
Ms Zamalanga Langa DEA (012) 399 9389 [email protected]
Ms Nyiko Nkosi DEA (012) 399 9392 [email protected]
Mr Andre Beetge DEA (084) 240 2264 [email protected]
Dr Piet-Louis Grundling DEA (072) 793 8248 [email protected]
Mr Ian Pearson Prime Africa (082) 453 7246 [email protected]
Mr Danie Smith DEA (012) 399 9394 [email protected]
Mr Vincent Chauke DEA (012) 399 9399 [email protected]
Cllr. Tebogo Malomane Councillor: Ward 3, Victor Khanye LM (013) 665 2913 (078) 156 1101 [email protected]
Mr Jacob Mahlangu Municipal Manager: Victor Khanye LM (013) 665 2913 (013) 665 6005 (072) 945 3540 [email protected]
Ms Palesa PA to MM: Victor Khanye LM (013) 665 2913 (013) 665 6005 [email protected]
Ms Sentebaleng Masemola Head of Communications: Victor Khanye LM (013) 665 2913 (013) 665 6006 (081) 036 7540 [email protected]
Ms Maggie Skosana Municipal Manager: Nkangala DM PO Box 437 Middelburg 1050 (013) 249 2114 (013) 249 2000 (082)949 8620 [email protected]
Ms Naomi Nkosi PA to MM: Nkangala DM PO Box 437 Middelburg 1050 (013) 249 2114 (013) 249 2000 [email protected]
Mr David Masombuka Head of Communications: Nkangala DM PO Box 437 Middelburg 1050 (013) 249 2114 (013) 249 2051 (082) 663 4225 [email protected]
Ms Sylvia Masoka DARDLEA: Acting Director: Nkangala District (013) 947 2551 [email protected]
Ms Dorothy Makaringe Mpumalanga Tourism and Parks Agency Private Bag X11338 Nelspruit 1200 (013)759 3928 (013) 759 5334 [email protected]
Ms Dorothy Makaringe Mpumalanga Tourism and Parks Agency Private Bag X11338 Nelspruit 1200 (013)759 3928 (013) 759 5334 [email protected]
Page 2
APPENDIX E-2: Proof of Announcement notification
1
Mathys Vosloo
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Sent: Thursday, 23 November 2017 4:26 PM
To: Mathys Vosloo
Cc: Lebo Petlane
Subject: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Attachments: 17107-82-BID-001-WOS BA incl CommSheet-Rev0.pdf
Importance: High
TrackingTracking: Recipient Delivery
Mathys Vosloo Delivered: 23/11/2017 4:26 PM
Lebo Petlane
Dear Stakeholder,
BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED
WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
Notice is given in terms of Section 41(2)(b) of the EIA regulations , 2014 (GN R.982), as amended, in terms of the
National Environmental Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), as amended, of the intention of Eskom Holdings SOC
Ltd to undertake activities relating to the rehabilitation of several degraded wetlands at and around the Kusile
Power Station, Mpumalanga. A Basic Assessment process must be undertaken in terms of the EIA regulations, 2014
to identify, assess and mitigate all potential impacts to within acceptable levels.
You have been identified as a key stakeholder for the abovementioned project and are therefore informed of the
Basic Assessment process underway. A Background Information Document (BID) that contains information regarding
the proposed project, Basic Assessment process and how you can become involved is attached to this email
notification. All documents will be available on the internet at www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading
“Kusile WOP and PPP”. Further communication will follow in due course as the Basic Assessment process unfolds.
BIDs have furthermore been placed at the following public venues for collection:
PUBLIC VENUE ADDRESS
Victor Khanye
Local
Municipality
Cnr Samuel & Van
der Walt Streets,
Delmas
Delmas Public
Library
Cnr Sarel Cilliers &
Van Riebeeck Street
Phola Public
Library
2427 Qwabe Street,
Phola Location
Ogies Public
Library
61 Main Street,
Ogies
It is advised to complete the comment sheet attached at the back of the BID and return to the PPP Desk in order for
us to confirm your contact details on the project database. However, if you do not wish to be involved in this Basic
Assessment process please request the PPP Desk to remove you from the project database as a key stakeholder.
The PPP Desk can be contacted at the contact details provided in the BID and below.
Kind regards
2
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
1
Mathys Vosloo
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA on behalf of [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, 23 November 2017 4:47 PM
To: Mathys Vosloo
Cc: Lebo Petlane
Subject: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Attachments: 17107-82-BID-001-WOS BA incl CommSheet-Rev0.pdf
Importance: High
Bcc: '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]';
[email protected]; [email protected]; '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]';
[email protected]; [email protected]; '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; 'pjvv777
@gmail.com'; RamabulanaN ([email protected]); '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; [email protected]; [email protected];
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]';
'[email protected]'; '[email protected]'
Dear Stakeholder,
BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED
WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd completed an application for Environmental Authorisation for the development of the
proposed 60 year Ash Disposal Facility at Kusile Power Station near Ogies. Given your interest in this recently
completed project, you have been identified as a potential Interested and Affected Party for another Environmental
Authorisation process related to the Kusile Power Station currently underway. Notice is therefore given in terms of
Section 41(2)(b) of the EIA regulations , 2014 (GN R.982), as amended, in terms of the National Environmental
Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), as amended, of the intention of Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd to undertake activities
relating to the rehabilitation of several degraded wetlands at and around the Kusile Power Station, Mpumalanga. A
Basic Assessment process must be undertaken in terms of the EIA regulations, 2014 to identify, assess and mitigate
all potential impacts to within acceptable levels.
A Background Information Document (BID) that contains information regarding the proposed project, Basic
Assessment process and how you can become involved is attached to this email notification. All documents will be
available on the Zitholele website at www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading “Kusile WOP and PPP”. BIDs
have furthermore been placed at the following public venues for collection:
PUBLIC VENUE ADDRESS
Victor Khanye Local
Municipality
Cnr Samuel & Van der Walt Streets,
Delmas
Delmas Public Library Cnr Sarel Cilliers & Van Riebeeck
Street
Phola Public Library 2427 Qwabe Street, Phola Location
Ogies Public Library 61 Main Street, Ogies
2
If you wish to be registered as an Interested and Affected Party (IAP) for this Basic Assessment process, please
complete the comment sheet attached at the back of the BID and return to the PPP Desk in order for us to register
you on the project database. Please be advised that if you do not return the comment sheet to the PPP desk or
reply to this email with a request to be registered as an IAP by 8 December 2017, it will be assumed that you do
not wish to register as an IAP for this Basic Assessment process and will not receive further notifications relating
to this project.
The PPP Desk can be contacted at the contact details provided in the BID and below.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
���������� ������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������
� �0��������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������ ��1
23456789:; 234567<;=>3?6@?48
����� (����AB� ��#�AC�
DE48;85:F;3 G9@;H?:; I5=@4:;3JG K@9@5=
��'��'���L� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�-RL��-- �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�1'-NL�� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�1'L��-1 �-�M�"�����A��0N- !V,$P!%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�1L111�- �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�1��1N'� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�1L��'-� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�1�1�L�N �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�N�-��L- �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�1''�-R1 �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�-RR�NL� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�---���R �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�-RR-�R� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�-RR--R� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�NL�L�NR �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�-N��N�1 �-�M�"�����A��0N- !V,$P!%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�'R-��N� �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�-LLL-�N �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R�-�-���L �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A����������L
��R-'NL��L1 �-�M�"�����A��0N- %!�$OP%
%���A$ �,QA(����A,.AB� ��#�AP����AC���A����# A�#���/��A.��A� �0�� �#���������R�S ���A���AC$%A��A��T�� A����A�������U�� ����������A�
���������� ������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������
� �0��������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������ ��1
���������2
��3--�2��2� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3-'--113� �-�4�"�����5��06- ;�$.�
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3--��3��� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3--���36� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3-6'2-�'� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3�33�6�1' �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3�'6��-�� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3�3�3���� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3�3�2'�6� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3-�6�3��� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3��3-''63 �-�4�"�����5��06- +4%!�$7
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3����6��6 �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3����1--- �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3�32-�16� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
���22��3331 �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
��3-''1�'�� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
���-�-�132- �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
���23�-��-� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
���-�6-�-'� �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
���-��2���- �-�4�"�����5��06- !?,$8!%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
����2�2'6�1 �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
%���5$ �,95(����5,.5:� ��#�58����5;���5����# 5�#���/��5.��5� �0�� �#���������3�< ���5���5;$%5��5��=�� 5����5�������>�� ����������5����������2
�����61�'�- �-�4�"�����5��06- %!�$78%
���������� ������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������
� �0��������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������ -�1
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
����';1<�1< �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���-1<<<7�; �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
����<;7;��� �-�=�"�����2��0<- !?,$5!%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
�����'-<��� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
������;��7� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
����������� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
������;''-1 �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
����-1<�<7- �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
����<;'1;�1 �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
����11�-��� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���;77��<1� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���'��117�- �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���1--��--1 �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���;7�<71;- �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���;����;�� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���;--<�';; �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���7;�-;��� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���;����--; �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���11�<'��� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���77��'�'� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���71-777�� �-�=�"�����2��0<- %!�$>5%
%���2$ �,32(����2,.24� ��#�25����26���2����# 2�#���/��2.��2� �0�� �#���������7�8 ���2���26$%2��2��9�� 2����2�������:�� ����������2����������;
���������� ������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������
� �0��������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%�"&��'())�*��&+,��-��./�� �����"������ 1�1
���''-�2'�- �-�3�"�����4��02- %!�$56%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
���'>�>>�-> �-�3�"�����4��02- !?,$6!%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
���'->����� �-�3�"�����4��02- !?,$6!%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
���'�-:�'-� �-�3�"�����4��02- %!�$56%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
���'��1�>:' �-�3�"�����4��02- %!�$56%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
���'1'�1�22 �-�3�"�����4��02- %!�$56%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
���:1-�>��' �-�3�"�����4��02- %!�$56%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
��:-����1�2 �-�3�"�����4��02- %!�$56%
%���4$ �,74(����4,.48� ��#�46����49���4����# 4�#���/��4.��4� �0�� �#���������:�; ���4���49$%4��4��<�� 4����4�������=�� ����������4����������>
���������� ������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%��&'�()$"����**��+,"-./�� �����"������
� �0��������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%��&'�()$"����**��+,"-./�� �����"������ ���
123456789: 123456;:<=2>5?>37
�����- @����A-�A�� �# ���
BC37:749D:2 E8?:F>9: G4<?39:2HE I?8?4<
��&JJ���K�& �J�L�"�����A��0�� ML%!�$*
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
������&&(�K �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&JK&&(&�� �J�L�"�����A��0�� !U'$P!%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&��&+V+�( �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&J��&�&�K �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&JJ��(K&+ �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&��&&+V�+ �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&JJJ�&&(+ �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&JKV�+V�+ �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&�V&�+��� �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&�(�K���K �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&�K(K��(+ �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&JVV&+�JK �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&�J����KV �J�L�"�����A��0�� ML%!�$*
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&�V(J&�JV �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&�K�&KK&� �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&��(J�&�+ �J�L�"�����A��0�� ML%!�$*
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
��&�+V�(��( �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
���+(�(��+� �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A��������� ����� ��#A�����A����A�������T�� ����������A�A���������+A)�� ���A�������#��#��A�#��AQ� �A��S� ����A$ �'
���VV&��&�� �J�L�"�����A��0�� %!�$*P%
%���A$ �'NA@����A'.AO� ��#�AP����A-���A����# A�#���Q��A.��A� �0�� �#���������&�R ���A���A-$%A A��S� ��A��� ����� ��#A�#A ��A������
���������� ������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%��&'�()$"����**��+,"-./�� �����"������
� �0��������� ���������������� ��� ��������������� !"�# $%��&'�()$"����**��+,"-./�� �����"������ ���
��� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
���55�&�56( �5�7�"�����1��0�� !8'$9!%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
���65>+656( �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
����+�+6(�> �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
����&���55� �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
������(���� �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
�����5>�+�( �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
�����6�&��� �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
�����+�>�(� �5�7�"�����1��0�� !8'$9!%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
����(���66> �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
��&�55>>��6 �5�7�"�����1��0�� %!�$*9%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
��&>�(��>5> �5�7�"�����1��0�� !8'$9!%
%���1$ �':1;����1'.1<� ��#�19����1-���1����# 1�#���3��1.��1� �0�� �#���������&�= ���1���1-$%1 1��4� ��1��� ����� ��#1�#1 ��1��������� ����� ��#1�����1����1�������2�� ����������1�1���������+1)�� ���1�������#��#��1�#��13� �1��4� ����1$ �'
APPENDIX E-3: Background Information Document
1. BACKGROUND
Eskom Holdings SOC Limited (Eskom) intends to rehabilitate several degraded
wetlands in and around the Kusile Power Station. The rehabilitation of the degraded
wetlands will be undertaken by implementing the wetland offset strategy which was
developed and approved in support of the integrated environmental authorisation for
the Kusile 60-year Ash Disposal Facility (ADF) project.
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT
Eskom Holdings (Pty) Ltd, intends to rehabilitate several degraded wetlands at the
Kusile Power Station, Mpumalanga. Wetland rehabilitation involves the construction
of a variety of interventions that could include gabions, concrete structures; as well
as soft options such as re-vegetation, removal of alien vegetation and in-filling of
agricultural scars. The number, type, scale and location of each of these
interventions within the wetlands would vary according to the nature and magnitude
of the problem and the condition of the receiving environment.
Figure 1: Location of wetlands to be rehabilitated (in green) at Kusile Power Station
PURPOSE OF THIS
DOCUMENT
This Background Information
Document (BID) has been
structured to provide all
potential Interested and
Affected Parties (I&APs) with
a concise overview of the
proposed project activities as
well as the associated
Environmental Authorisation
Processes. Furthermore this
BID also intend to provide
I&APs with information
relating to the manner in
which I&APs can voice any
issues concering the
proposed project. The
compilation and distribution of
this BID form part of the
Public Participation Process
for the project.
When you complete and
return the registration form
included with the BID, you will
be included in the
stakeholder database and
receive further documents for
review and comment. Your
comment will ensure that all
issues of concern are
incorporated. To raise your
concerns, please complete
the enclosed registration
sheet, write a letter, call or e-
mail the public participation
office. All documents will be
available on the internet at
www.zitholele.co.za/environm
ental, under heading “Kusile
WOP and PPP”.
For enquiries, please
contact: Dr. Mathys Vosloo
Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
Building 1, Maxwell Office
Park, Magwa Crescent West,
Waterfall City, Midrand, 1685
PO Box 6002, Halfway
House, 1685
Tel: 011 207 2060
Fax: 086 674 6121
E-mail:
Basic Assessment for engineering interventions proposed for the
rehabilitation of degraded wetlands around Kusile Power Station,
Mpumalanga Province.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION DOCUMENT
22 November 2017
7/537
3/566
3. DESCRIPTION OF THE STUDY AREA
The focal area is located just east of Bronkhorstspruit along the border of Gauteng and Mpumalanga province. The
Kusile Power Station is situated south of the N4 highway and is accessed from the secondary road, D686. The New
Largo Colliery is situated eat of the power station, while the Eyethu Coal’s Klipfontein Colliery is situated directly south
of the approved location for the Kusile Power Station 60 year Ash Disposal Facility (ADF).
The wetlands that will be investigated are given in the Figure 1 and are located within the following properties:
Parcel 537; Portions 1 (Re.), 2, 4, 5, 6 and 7
Parcel 565; Portions 1 and 2
Parcel 566; Portions 3
The proposed activities fall in the Olifants River Catchment (Primary Catchment B), but more specifically in quaternary
catchment B20F and is directly linked to the Wilge River (sub-quaternary B20F-01150). The Wilge River flows north
and forms a tributary of the larger Olifants River. Two key tributaries of the Wilge River are the Klipfonteinspruit and
the Holspruit, both of which extend past the north and southern extents of the Kusile Power Station infrastructure
footprint. These tributaries form the focal systems of the rehabilitation.
Most of the wetlands in the area (along the Wilge River and associated tributaries in the study area) have been
denoted as Freshwater Ecosystem Priority Areas (Wetland FEPAs) or recognised as important wetland clusters.
These wetlands are important contributors to base flow maintenance of the perennial Wilge River (SQ B20F-01150),
as well as flood attenuation which protects the integrity of banks along the downstream Wilge environment. The
predominant land use in the region is agriculture (cultivation) and various mining activities. The extent of cultivated
land ranges in intensity of use from historically cultivated land to currently cultivated. There is also a mixed mosaic of
improved and unimproved grassland throughout the area.
4. NEED AND DESIRABILITY OF THE PROJECT
The rehabilitation of these wetlands function to address the loss of various wetlands within the footprint of the Kusile
Power Station ADF. The construction of ADF infrastructure will result in residual impacts and, in worst cases, the loss
of various wetlands. In order to compensate for this loss, Eskom propose to undertake the rehabilitation of
downstream wetlands in the same catchment through the implementation of a wetland offset. It is the specific wetland
rehabilitation measures proposed to be implemented that triggers the need to undertake this environmental
authorisation process.
5. LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
Environmental Authorisation
The proposed rehabilitation interventions require environmental authorisation from the Competent Authority, i.e. the
Department of Environmental Affairs (DEA), in terms of the National Environmental Manament Act, No 107 of 1998
(NEMA): Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) regulations 2014, as amended. The proposed project is likely to
trigger a number of listed activities in terms of Listing Notice 1 (GN R983) and Listing Notice 3 (GN R985) of EIA
regulations 2014 as amended (refer to Table 1).
Activities triggered in Listing Notice 1 indicates that an application for environmental authorisation must be undertaken
via a Basic Assessment Process.
Table 1: Listed activities that may be applicable to the project
Listed Activities as per EIA regulations 2014, GN R983 (Listing
Notice 1) and GN R985 (Listing Notice 3), as amended
Applicability to proposed project
Listing Notice 1, Item 12: The development of (i) dams or weirs,
where the dam or weir, including infrastructure and water surface
area, exceeds 100 square metres; or (ii) infrastructure or structures
with a physical footprint of 100 square metres or more; where such
development occurs (a) within a watercourse; or (c) if no
development setback exists, within 32 metres of a watercourse,
measured from the edge of a watercourse. Exclusions not
applicable.
Combined area of engineering structures for
wetland rehabilitation measures is expected
to be >100m2.
Listing Notice 1, Item 19: The infilling or depositing of any material
of more than 10 cubic metres into, or the dredging, excavation,
removal or moving of soil, sand, shells, shell grit, pebbles or rock of
more than 10 cubic metres from a watercourse. Exclusions not
applicable.
Comined area of material deposition or
excavation for the proposed rehabilitation
measures is expected to be >10m3.
Listing Notice 1, Item 30:. Any process or activity identified in terms
of section 53(1) of the National Environmental Management:
Biodiversity Act, 2004 (Act No. 10 of 2004).
Study area contain threatened ecosystems
listed in Biodiversity Act (Act 10 of 2004),
some of which are classified as Vulnerable.
Listing Notice 3, Item 12: The clearance of an area of 300 square
metres or more (exclusion not applicable) in:c. Gauteng or f
Mpumalanga, in specific identified geographical areas that contain
sensitive or protected ecosystems, habitat or species as stipulated in
GN R985, as amended.
Combined area of vegetation clearance is
expected to be >300m2 and the study area fall
within Gauteng and Mpumalanga Province
and contain threatened ecosystems listed in
Biodiversity Act (Act 10 of 2004), or Critical
Biodiversity Areas (CBAs).
Listing Notice 3, Item 14: The development of (i) dams or weirs,
where the dam or weir, including infrastructure and water surface
area, exceeds 10 square metres; or (ii) infrastructure or structures
with a physical footprint of 10 square metres or more; where such
development occurs (a) within a watercourse; or (c) if no
development setback has been adopted, within 32 metres of a
watercourse, measured from the edge of a watercourse (exclusions
not applicable) in:c. Gauteng or f Mpumalanga, in specific identified
geographical areas that contain sensitive or protected ecosystems,
habitat or species as stipulated in GN R985, as amended.
Combined area of vegetation clearance is
expected to be >10m2 and the study area fall
within Gauteng and Mpumalanga Province
and contain threatened ecosystems listed in
Biodiversity Act (Act 10 of 2004), or Critical
Biodiversity Areas (CBAs).
Listed activities that may be applicable to this project will be confirmed during the Basic Assessment process and
considered in the application
Water Use Licence
In terms of Section 39 of the National Water Act, No 36 of 1998 (NWA), a General Authorisation (GA) has been
granted for use of water in respect of section 21(c) and (i) of the NWA for activities occurring near or in a wetland (GN
509 of 26 August 2016). This GA relieves a water user from the need to apply for a licence for impeding or diverting
the flow of water in a watercourse in terms of section 21 (c) or altering the bed, banks, course or characteristics of a
watercourse in terms of section 21 (i) of the Act for activities proposed near or within a wetland, provided that the use
is within the provisions set out in the GA. An application for water use authorisation in the form of application for GA is
therefore required to be submitted to the competent authority, i.e. the Department of Water and Sanitation (DWS).
In terms of the above, an integrated authorisation process will be undertaken for the application of an Environmental
Authorisation and a General Authorisation for the rehabilitation of degraded wetlands associated with the wetland
offset for the Kusile Power Station 60 year ADF.
6. BASIC ASSESSMENT PROCESS
A Basic Assessment (BA) aims to provide an objective view of the potential environmental and social impacts that
could arise during the planning, construction, operation and decommissioning phase of a proposed project. A critical
element of the BA Process is the Public Participation Process that gives Interested and Affected Parties (I&APs) an
opportunity to provide comments on a proposed development. The outcome of the BA Process is consicely presented
and documented in the Basic Assessment Report (BAR) in order to provide the Conmpetent Authority with all ithe
information in order to maka an informed decision.
The BAR content aligns with the requirements of Appendix 1 of the EIA regulations, 2014 (GN R.982) and timeframes
are strictly adhered to through careful management of process. Figure 2 provides a process flow diagram indicating
the key tasks to be carried out for the BA Process.
Figure 2: Process Flow Diagram for the steps required in a Basic Assessment Process
A decision on the application for environmental authorisation through a BA process is usually reached within 107 days
of receipt of the BAR by the Competent Authority.
7. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS
As an important element in undertaking the BA for the proposed project, Zitholele Consulting will conduct the public
participation process as set out in the NEMA EIA regulations, 2014. Applicable guidelines and best practice
procedures will furthermore be taken into consideration. The public participation process will enable stakeholders to
contribute to the process through information sharing and to review the findings of the independent studies that are to
be undertaken. The steps of the public participation component are outlined below.
Figure 3: Process Flow of the Public Participation Process
Determine application for Env. Authorisation
process
Confirm scope of work and undertake initial
investigations
Pre-application meeting with authorities
Undertake site screening / scoping and identify
alternatives
Specialist studies & stakeholder engagement (Project announcement)
Comparative impact assessment and
alternatives assessment
Impact Assessment for preferred alternative
(Assess, rate, mitigate)
Compile Basic Assessment Report and
EMPr
Submit application & BAR to authorities /
I&APs for review
Authority and public review and engagement
(30 days)
Submit Basic Assessment Report and EMPr to
Authorities for consideration
Authority Decision
Advertising - public notice of the BA process in national / provincial
newspaper
Place site notice boards at the project sites being
investigated and at public places at closest town
Notify affected and adjacent landowners and Interested and Affected Parties (I&APs) of the proposed application
Undertake Public and Focus Group Meetings
during public review period
Document stakeholder comments in the
Comments and Responses Report (CRR)
Notify stakeholders when the Final BAR is submitted
to the DEA
Notify stakeholders when the Environmental
Authorisation is issued.
90
days
10
7 d
ays
8. GENERAL AUTHRISATION REGISTRATION PROCESS
The GA registration process is undertaken in terms of GN 1198 of 18 December 2009, as contemplated in section 5
above. The registration process include the completion of water use registration forms that are submitted to the
Department of Water and Sanitation for consideration. Upon completion of registration, the Department will provide a
certificate of registration to the water user.
9. DECISION-MAKING (ENVIRONMENTAL AUTHORISATION)
Based on the information provided in the final BAR, the Competent Authority will make a decision to grant or refuse
environmental authorisation. The granting of environmental authorisation will allow the Applicant to proceed with
implementing the proposed project activities. Once the Competent Authority has reached a decision, with regards to
granting the environmental authorisation, all registered I&APs will be notified thereof within 14 days of the date of the
decision. An appeal may be lodged against the decision made in terms of the National Environmental Management
Act (107 of 1998) and National Appeal Regulations, 2014. I&APs will be notified of the decision made by the
Competent Authority by means of the following:
Via electronic mail;
Facsimile (to I&APs who do not have access to electronic mail);
Registrered mail (to those I&APs who do not have access to electronic mail nor facsimile facilities).
The Basic Assessment Process will be concluded by the notification of I&APs of the decision made by the
Competent Authority.
10. MAP OF PROJECT LOCATION
A locality Map of the proposed project can be found in Figure 4 below.
11. BID COMMENT SHEET
A comment sheet associated with this project and Basic Assessment process in included at the end of this BID.
Please complete and return to the PPP desk by hand delivery to the offices of Zitholele Consultin, scan and email to
the email address provided, fax to fax noumber provided or by submitting your comments elephinically to the PPP
desk via the landline number specified in the left column on page 1 of this BID.
Figure 4: Locality Map of the Proposed Project
ENVIRONMENTAL AUTHORISATION: BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING
INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED WETLANDS
AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE.
22 November 2017
REGISTRATION AND COMMENT SHEET
Public Participation Process desk
Dr. Mathys Vosloo Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
P O Box 6002, Halfway House, 1685 Tel: 011 207 2060 - Fax: 086 674 6121
Email: [email protected]
PLEASE NOTE: ALL FIELDS ARE MANDATORY TO COMPLETE. Please complete by 8 December 2017 and return to the Public Participation Process desk (as above).
TITLE NAME
SURNAME
ORGANISATION (Please do not use any acronyms)
ADDRESS
POSTAL CODE
TELEPHONE NO FAX NO
E-MAIL ADDRESS
CELLPHONE NO
DATE SIGNATURE
Would you be interested in attending the Public Meeting envisaged for January 2018? YES NO
Please formally register me as an interested and/or affected party (I&AP) so that I may receive further
information and notifications during the BA process YES NO
I would like to receive documents for comment as follows:
By e-mail
By SMS
By fax
In terms of the National Environmental Management Act, (Act No. 107 of 1998), EIA Regulations GN R 982 – Government Gazette No. 38282 of 04 December 2014, as amended, Regulation 43(1), I disclose below any direct business, financial, personal or other interest that I may have in the approval or refusal of the application (please use additional sheet if required):
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
COMMENTS (please use separate sheets if you wish)
I suggest that the following issues of concern be considered in the BA:
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
Please inform the following of my colleagues/friends/neighbors whom may be interested to register their participation in this project (Please provide name, mobile number and email address of the potential I&AP):
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONTRIBUTION
APPENDIX E-4: Site Notice
Notice is hereby given in terms of the National Environmental
Management Act, No 107 of 1998 (NEMA), and Environmental
Impact Assessment Regulations 2014 (GN R.982), of the
intention of Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd to implement proposed
engineering interventions for the rehabilitation of degraded
wetlands around Kusile Power Station.
Nature of Proposed Development
Eskom Holdings (Pty) Ltd, intends to rehabilitate several degraded wetlands at the Kusile
Power Station, Mpumalanga. Wetland rehabilitation involves the construction of a variety of
interventions that could include gabions, concrete structures; soft options such as re-
vegetation, removal of alien vegetation and in-filling of agricultural scars. The number, type,
scale and location of each of these interventions within the wetlands would vary according to
the nature and magnitude of the problem and the condition of the receiving environment.
Location of Proposed Development
The study area is located northwest of the Kusile Power Station nearby the settlements of
Bronkhorstspruit and Phola. Engineering wetland interventions are proposed on farm portions
owned by Eskom and includes the following properties:
Parcel 537; Portions 1 (Re.), 2, 4, 5, 6 and 7
Parcel 565; Portions 1 and 2
Parcel 566; Portion 3
Legislative requirements
The proposed wetland rehabilitation interventions will trigger a number of listed activities in
terms of the EIA regulations, 2014, Listing Notice 1 (GN R.983) and Listing Notice 3 (GN
R.985), as amended, and will require a Basic Assessment process to be undertaken.
The interventions will also trigger water uses in terms of section 21 (c) and (i) of the National
Water Act, No 36 of 1998. The proposed water uses relate to the rehabilitation of wetlands for
conservation purposes which is an activity already authorised in terms of General
Authorisation 509 of 26 August 2016 and only require registration of the water use with the
Department of Water and Sanitation.
How to contact the Public Participation Process desk
I&APs may contact the PPP desk at the following detail below:
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd, P O Box 6002, Halfway House, 1685
Tel: (011) 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, or Email: [email protected]
BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION
OF DEGRADED WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
PUBLIC COMMENT ENCOURAGED Interested and Affected Parties (I&APs) are invited to participate by
registering as an I&AP and commenting on the project in the following way:
1. Download BID at the link: www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading “Kusile
WOP and PPP” or obtain copy at the Ogies, Phola or Emhalahleni Public Library
2. Register in writing by completing and returning registration form attached to the BID
to the PPP desk at the details specified on this site notice
3. Request BID or more info from PPP desk at contact details specified in this site notice
4. Review and comment on documents sent to registered IA&Ps and uploaded to: www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading “Kusile WOP and PPP”. THIS SITE NOTICE WAS PLACED ON 22 NOVEMBER 2017
7/537
3/566
APPENDIX E-5: Advertisement
APPENDIX E-6: Comments and Responses Report
Zitholele Consulting Reg. No. 2000/000392/07
PO Box 6002 Halfway House 1685, South Africa Building 1, Maxwell Office Park, Magwa Crescent West c/o Allandale Road & Maxwell Drive, Waterfall City, Midrand T : 011 207 2060 F : 086 674 6121 E : [email protected]
Directors : Dr. R.G.M. Heath, S. Pillay, N. Rajasakran
REPORT ON
Comments and Responses for the proposed Kusile 60 Year ADF
Wetland Rehabilitation Interventions
Report No : 17107-46-Rep-003-CRR
Submitted to :
Eskom Holdings SOC Limited
PO Box 1091 Johannesburg
2000
12 December 2017 17107
12 December 2017 iii 17107
ZITHOLELE CONSULTING
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION PAGE
1 INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................. 4 2 COMMENTS RECEIVED DURING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS ..... 4
2.1 Comments by Bronkhorstspruit and Wilge River Conservation Association ..... 4 2.2 Comments raised by Ms Wilma Lutsch (DEA) ................................................. 4 2.3 Comments raised by Ms Sandria Lensley (Rooibokkop Boerdery) .................. 5 2.4 Comments raised by Dr James Meyer (Topigs SA, nominated representative) 5
LIST OF ACRONYMS
BA Basic Assessment
BAR Basic Assessment Report
CBA Critical Biodiversity Area
CRR Comments and Response Report
DAFF Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
DWS Department of Water and Sanitation
EAP Environmental Assessment Practitioner
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
EMC Environmental Monitoring Committee
EMPr Environmental Management Programme
EP Environmental Practitioner
ER Ecological Reserve
FGM Focus Group Meeting
KPS Kusile Power Station
NEMA National Environmental Management Act, 107 of 1998, as amended
NEMBA National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act
NFEPA National Freshwater Ecosystem Priority Areas
PES Present Ecological State
PP Public Participation
PPP Public Participation Process
SANBI South African National Biodiversity Institute
WOP Wetland Offset Plan
WOS Wetland Offset Strategy
ZC Zitholele Consulting
12 December 2017 4 17107-46-Rep-003-CRR
ZITHOLELE CONSULTING
1 INTRODUCTION
This Comments and Responses Report (CRR) captures the comments and issues raised by
stakeholders during the Public Participation Process for the proposed Wetland Rehabilitation
Interventions for degraded wetland around the Kusile Power Station. Details of the PP process
have been captured in the BAR, to which this CRR is included as an appendix. For easy
reference and review, comments / concerns / issues / recommendations have been captured
alphabetically according to surname.
2 COMMENTS RECEIVED DURING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS
2.1 Comments by Bronkhorstspruit and Wilge River Conservation Association
No COMMENT / CONCERN / RECOMMENDATION
RAISED BY SOURCE DATE RESPONSE
1 Please change our email address on your database to [email protected]
Bronkhorstspruit and Wilge River Conservancy Association
Email 27/11/2017 Thank you for your feedback. We will change the email address to [email protected] as requested. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
2.2 Comments raised by Ms Wilma Lutsch (DEA)
No COMMENT / CONCERN / RECOMMENDATION
RAISED BY SOURCE DATE RESPONSE
2 Please be so kind and send me the CD . The address: Environment House, Cnr Steve Biko and Soutpansberg St, Arcadia, Pretoria
Lutsch, Wilma: Director: Biodiversity Conservation (DEA)
Email 24/11/2017 Dear Wilma, We are currently at the start of the BA process and we only have the BID available for public input. Are you requesting us to send you a CD with the BID, or to provide you with a CD of the Draft BAR for public review once it becomes available for review? Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
3 Please forward CD of the Draft BAR when it becomes available.
Wilma Lutsch, Director: Biodiversity Conservation (DEA)
Email 27/11/2017 Hi, We will send the CD as soon as it becomes available. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
4 Dear Mathys, Apologies if I misunderstood you. I would like to request that you send the draft BAR once it becomes available for review.
Wilma Lutsch, Director: Biodiversity Conservation (DEA)
Email 27/11/2017 Dear Wilna, Thanks for the clarification. We will certainly do so once the draft BAR is ready to go out for review. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
12 December 2017 5 17107-46-Rep-003-CRR
ZITHOLELE CONSULTING
2.3 Comments raised by Ms Sandria Lensley (Rooibokkop Boerdery)
No COMMENT / CONCERN / RECOMMENDATION
RAISED BY SOURCE
DATE RESPONSE
5 Sandria Lensley Cell no 079 850 5918 Portion 19 of the farm Spitskop 502 JR Rooibokkop Boerdery (SHP Lensley director) Thanks Sandria Lensley
Lensley, Sandria: Rooibokkop Boerdery
Email 30/11/2017 Dear Sandria, Thank you for your response to the project announcement notification. You remain registered on the project stakeholder database and we have updated you details as per your response email. We will notify you in due course of the availability of the Draft Basic Assessment Report for review and comment. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
2.4 Comments raised by Dr James Meyer (Topigs SA, nominated representative)
No COMMENT / CONCERN / RECOMMENDATION
RAISED BY SOURCE
DATE RESPONSE
6 Dear Mathys The BID received refers. Please confirm the following: 1) Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd is already a registered I&AP for this process.
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (nominated representative)
Email 05/12/2017 Hi James, Trust you are doing well. Apologies for the delay in responding. In terms of your points in your email: 1. Yes, Topigs SA is a key stakeholder and given the proximity to the proposed offset Topigs SA has been automatically included in the project stakeholder database. Yourself and Topigs SA will therefore receive all communications regarding the Basic Assessment. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
7 2) Comments submitted by Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd pertaining to the WOS have been received and incorporated.
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (nominated representative)
Email 05/12/2017 2. The comments submitted previously by Topigs has been received and considered by Prime Africa. Prime Africa is the EAP on this Basic Assessment Process and it is anticipated that the Basic Assessment Report will be submitted to all stakeholder by 15 December 2017. You can therefore comment on the BAR and supporting documents, which will include the wetland offset document completed. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
8 3) Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd would like to attend the PPP planned for January 2018 – please provide the planned date.
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (nominated representative)
Email 05/12/2017 3. The EAP have not confirmed the date for the PPP meeting but will communicated by 15 December 2017. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
9 4) The BID received appears to address the first phase of the WOS received, namely addressing the wetlands on Eskom property first. a. I do not see any mention in the BID that this is part of a broader strategy, with the next phase involving other wetland offset areas, e.g. the Topigs SA
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (nominated representative)
Email 05/12/2017 4. a) The Background Information Document is aimed at introducing the proposed project. The broader wetland offset strategy includes the different phases as propose in the wetland offset strategy. The wetland specialist have however found that no engineering wetland interventions will be required for the Topigs property and as such the property is not included in the application
12 December 2017 6 17107-46-Rep-003-CRR
ZITHOLELE CONSULTING
No COMMENT / CONCERN / RECOMMENDATION
RAISED BY SOURCE
DATE RESPONSE
(Pty) Ltd property as noted in the comments submitted by Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd.
to authorise the construction of wetland rehabilitation interventions (hard structures) Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
10 b. If there are any EAs, or WULs, that relate to the WOS which have been issued, please provide me with copies thereof.
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (nominated representative)
Email 05/12/2017 b) An environmental authorisation for the construction of the Kusile 60 year Ash Disposal Facility was issued in July 2015. I have attached this EA to this email for information. As you may recall, the EIA undertaken for the Kusile 60 year ADF included a preliminary wetland offset strategy proposed in terms of the mitigation hierarchy. This wetland offset strategy was therefore approved as part of the EA after consultation with DWS on the content and extent of the proposed wetland offset. Earlier this year (2017) Zitholele Consulting undertook another public participation process for the updated wetland offset strategy presented in the EIA, which you were part of. There has been no further EAs or WULs issued pertaining to the Kusile 60 year ADF wetland offset. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
11 c. Please clarify the context of the “approval” referred to in Point 1 Background, and provide me with a copy thereof.
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (nominated representative)
Email 05/12/2017 c) the approval referred to in Point 1 Background of the Background Information Document relates to the EA that was granted in July 2015 for the Kusile 60 year ADF EIA application, as discussed in point b) above. I trust the responses at this stage answers your question and look forward to engage with you in the public participation process soon to kick off for this Basic Assessment application. Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
12 Dear Mathys, Given the end day tomorrow set, could you please respond as soon as possible, at least to point 1 below in my email sent on Dec 5th. The BID requires a returned I&AP page by the 8th – but what is the date for comments to the BID – I do not see this specified?
Dr James Meyer Topigs SA (nominated representative)
Email 07/12/2017 Dear James, Thank you for your email. I have responded to your original email. You do not need to return the I&AP page as yourself and Topigs SA are automatically included in the project stakeholder database. Furthermore, you do not need to respond to the BID as this document is intended to introduce the proposed development and Basic Assessment process to Interested and Affected Parties. Notification will be sent out in due course to inform all registered IA&Ps of the availability of the Basic Assessment Report for stakeholder comment. We look forward to your participation in the Basic Assessment processes for this project.
12 December 2017 7 17107-46-Rep-003-CRR
ZITHOLELE CONSULTING
No COMMENT / CONCERN / RECOMMENDATION
RAISED BY SOURCE
DATE RESPONSE
Mathys Vosloo, Public Participation Process Desk
APPENDIX E-7: Proof of Correspondence with I&APs
1
Mathys Vosloo
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Sent: Monday, 27 November 2017 1:49 PM
To: Bhs and Wilge River Conserv Ass; 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Annamie,
Thank you for your feedback. We will change the email address to [email protected] as requested.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
From: Bhs and Wilge River Conserv Ass [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Monday, 27 November 2017 8:40 AM
To: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Good day
Please change our email address on your database to [email protected]
Kind Regards
Annamie Duvenage
Bronkhorstspruit and Wilge River Conservancy Association (GCA067)
Defining ourselves not by what and how we consume
But by what we refuse to destroy
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: 23 November 2017 04:26 PM
To: Mathys Vosloo
Cc: Lebo Petlane Subject: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
2
Dear Stakeholder,
BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED
WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
Notice is given in terms of Section 41(2)(b) of the EIA regulations , 2014 (GN R.982), as amended, in terms of the
National Environmental Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), as amended, of the intention of Eskom Holdings SOC
Ltd to undertake activities relating to the rehabilitation of several degraded wetlands at and around the Kusile
Power Station, Mpumalanga. A Basic Assessment process must be undertaken in terms of the EIA regulations, 2014
to identify, assess and mitigate all potential impacts to within acceptable levels.
You have been identified as a key stakeholder for the abovementioned project and are therefore informed of the
Basic Assessment process underway. A Background Information Document (BID) that contains information regarding
the proposed project, Basic Assessment process and how you can become involved is attached to this email
notification. All documents will be available on the internet at www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading
“Kusile WOP and PPP”. Further communication will follow in due course as the Basic Assessment process unfolds.
BIDs have furthermore been placed at the following public venues for collection:
PUBLIC VENUE ADDRESS
Victor Khanye
Local
Municipality
Cnr Samuel & Van
der Walt Streets,
Delmas
Delmas Public
Library
Cnr Sarel Cilliers &
Van Riebeeck Street
Phola Public
Library
2427 Qwabe Street,
Phola Location
Ogies Public
Library
61 Main Street,
Ogies
It is advised to complete the comment sheet attached at the back of the BID and return to the PPP Desk in order for
us to confirm your contact details on the project database. However, if you do not wish to be involved in this Basic
Assessment process please request the PPP Desk to remove you from the project database as a key stakeholder.
The PPP Desk can be contacted at the contact details provided in the BID and below.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
1
Mathys Vosloo
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Sent: Tuesday, 28 November 2017 4:04 PM
To: Wilma Lutsch; 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Cc: Stanley Tshitwamulomoni
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Wilna,
Thanks for the clarification. We will certainly do so once the draft BAR is ready to go out for review.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
From: Wilma Lutsch [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Monday, 27 November 2017 2:40 PM
To: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA Cc: Stanley Tshitwamulomoni
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Dear Mathys
Apologies if I misunderstood you. I would like to request that you send the draft BAR once it becomes available for
review.
Thanks
Wilma
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: 27 November 2017 01:54 PM
To: Wilma Lutsch; 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Cc: Stanley Tshitwamulomoni
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Wilma,
We are currently at the start of the BA process and we only have the BID available for public input.
Are you requesting us to send you a CD with the BID, or to provide you with a CD of the Draft BAR for public review
once it becomes available for review?
Kind regards,
Dr. MATHYS VOSLOO [Pr.Sci.Nat.]
Senior Environmental Scientist
2
Building 1, Maxwell Office Park, Magwa Crescent West, Waterfall City, Midrand, RSA
T: +27 11 207 2060 | F: +27 86 674 6121
C: +27 84 748 3018 | E: [email protected]
W: www.zitholele.co.za
Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail!
From: Wilma Lutsch [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Friday, 24 November 2017 9:15 AM
To: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA Cc: Stanley Tshitwamulomoni
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Dear Mathys
Please be so kind and send me the CD .
The address
Environment House
Cnr steve Biko and Soutpansberg St
Arcadia
Pretoria
Thanks
Wilma Lutsch
Director: Biodiversity Conservation
Tel 012 3998827
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: 23 November 2017 04:26 PM
To: Mathys Vosloo
Cc: Lebo Petlane
Subject: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Stakeholder,
BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED
WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
Notice is given in terms of Section 41(2)(b) of the EIA regulations , 2014 (GN R.982), as amended, in terms of the
National Environmental Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), as amended, of the intention of Eskom Holdings SOC
3
Ltd to undertake activities relating to the rehabilitation of several degraded wetlands at and around the Kusile
Power Station, Mpumalanga. A Basic Assessment process must be undertaken in terms of the EIA regulations, 2014
to identify, assess and mitigate all potential impacts to within acceptable levels.
You have been identified as a key stakeholder for the abovementioned project and are therefore informed of the
Basic Assessment process underway. A Background Information Document (BID) that contains information regarding
the proposed project, Basic Assessment process and how you can become involved is attached to this email
notification. All documents will be available on the internet at www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading
“Kusile WOP and PPP”. Further communication will follow in due course as the Basic Assessment process unfolds.
BIDs have furthermore been placed at the following public venues for collection:
PUBLIC VENUE ADDRESS
Victor Khanye
Local
Municipality
Cnr Samuel & Van
der Walt Streets,
Delmas
Delmas Public
Library
Cnr Sarel Cilliers &
Van Riebeeck Street
Phola Public
Library
2427 Qwabe Street,
Phola Location
Ogies Public
Library
61 Main Street,
Ogies
It is advised to complete the comment sheet attached at the back of the BID and return to the PPP Desk in order for
us to confirm your contact details on the project database. However, if you do not wish to be involved in this Basic
Assessment process please request the PPP Desk to remove you from the project database as a key stakeholder.
The PPP Desk can be contacted at the contact details provided in the BID and below.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
Please consider the environment before you print this email. Only print if it is essential. A message from the
Department of Environmental Affairs.
Please consider the environment before you print this email. Only print if it is essential. A message from the
Department of Environmental Affairs.
This message and any attachments transmitted with it are intended solely for the addressee(s) and may be
legally privileged and/or confidential. If you have received this message in error please destroy it and notify
the sender. Any unauthorized usage, disclosure, alteration or dissemination is prohibited. The Department of
Environmental Affairs accepts no responsibility for any loss whether it be direct, indirect or consequential,
arising from information made available and actions resulting there from. The views and opinions expressed
in this e-mail message may not necessarily be those of Management.
Please consider the environment before you print this email. Only print if it is essential. A message from the
Department of Environmental Affairs.
Please consider the environment before you print this email. Only print if it is essential. A message from the
Department of Environmental Affairs.
This message and any attachments transmitted with it are intended solely for the addressee(s) and may be
legally privileged and/or confidential. If you have received this message in error please destroy it and notify
4
the sender. Any unauthorized usage, disclosure, alteration or dissemination is prohibited. The Department of
Environmental Affairs accepts no responsibility for any loss whether it be direct, indirect or consequential,
arising from information made available and actions resulting there from. The views and opinions expressed
in this e-mail message may not necessarily be those of Management.
1
Mathys Vosloo
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Sent: Tuesday, 05 December 2017 2:32 PM
To: 'Sandria van Staden'; 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Sandria,
Thank you for your response to the project announcement notification.
You remain registered on the project stakeholder database and we have updated you details as per your response
email.
We will notify you in due course of the availability of the Draft Basic Assessment Report for review and comment.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected] FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
-----Original Message-----
From: Sandria van Staden [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Thursday, 30 November 2017 9:47 AM
To: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA
Subject: Re: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Sandria Lensley
Cell no 079 850 5918
Portion 19 of the farm Spitskop 502 JR
Rooibokkop Boerdery (SHP Lensley director)
Thanks
Sandria Lensley
On 11/23/17, 17107 - Kusile WOP BA <[email protected]> wrote:
> Dear Stakeholder,
>
> BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE
> REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION,
> MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
>
> Notice is given in terms of Section 41(2)(b) of the EIA regulations ,
> 2014 (GN R.982), as amended, in terms of the National Environmental
> Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), as amended, of the intention of
> Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd to undertake activities relating to the
> rehabilitation of several degraded wetlands at and around the Kusile
> Power Station, Mpumalanga. A Basic Assessment process must be
> undertaken in terms of the EIA regulations,
> 2014 to identify, assess and mitigate all potential impacts to within
2
> acceptable levels.
>
> You have been identified as a key stakeholder for the abovementioned
> project and are therefore informed of the Basic Assessment process
> underway. A Background Information Document (BID) that contains
> information regarding the proposed project, Basic Assessment process
> and how you can become involved is attached to this email
> notification. All documents will be available on the internet at
> www.zitholele.co.za/environmental<http://www.zitholele.co.za/environme
> ntal>, under heading "Kusile WOP and PPP". Further communication will
> follow in due course as the Basic Assessment process unfolds.
>
> BIDs have furthermore been placed at the following public venues for
> collection:
>
> PUBLIC VENUE
>
> ADDRESS
>
> Victor Khanye Local Municipality
>
> Cnr Samuel & Van der Walt Streets, Delmas
>
> Delmas Public Library
>
> Cnr Sarel Cilliers & Van Riebeeck Street
>
> Phola Public Library
>
> 2427 Qwabe Street, Phola Location
>
> Ogies Public Library
>
> 61 Main Street, Ogies
>
>
> It is advised to complete the comment sheet attached at the back of
> the BID and return to the PPP Desk in order for us to confirm your
> contact details on the project database. However, if you do not wish
> to be involved in this Basic Assessment process please request the PPP
> Desk to remove you from the project database as a key stakeholder.
>
> The PPP Desk can be contacted at the contact details provided in the
> BID and below.
>
> Kind regards
>
> Dr. Mathys Vosloo
> 17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
> Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail:
> [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
> FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
>
>
1
Mathys Vosloo
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA on behalf of [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, 07 December 2017 4:27 PM
To: 'Dr JA Meyer'
Cc: Lebo Petlane
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Attachments: 12712-Environmental Authorisation.pdf
Importance: High
Hi James,
Trust you are doing well. Apologies for the delay in responding.
In terms of your points in your email:
1. Yes, Topigs SA is a key stakeholder and given the proximity to the proposed offset Topigs SA has been
automatically included in the project stakeholder database. Yourself and Topigs SA will therefore receive all
communications regarding the Basic Assessment.
2. The comments submitted previously by Topigs has been received and considered by Prime Africa. Prime
Africa is the EAP on this Basic Assessment Process and it is anticipated that the Basic Assessment Report will
be submitted to all stakeholder by 15 December 2017. You can therefore comment on the BAR and
supporting documents, which will include the wetland offset document completed.
3. The EAP have not confirmed the date for the PPP meeting but will communicated by 15 December 2017.
4. a) The Background Information Document is aimed at introducing the proposed project. The broader
wetland offset strategy includes the different phases as propose in the wetland offset strategy. The wetland
specialist have however found that no engineering wetland interventions will be required for the Topigs
property and as such the property is not included in the application to authorise the construction of wetland
rehabilitation interventions (hard structures)
b) An environmental authorisation for the construction of the Kusile 60 year Ash Disposal Facility was issued
in July 2015. I have attached this EA to this email for information. As you may recall, the EIA undertaken for
the Kusile 60 year ADF included a preliminary wetland offset strategy proposed in terms of the mitigation
hierarchy. This wetland offset strategy was therefore approved as part of the EA after consultation with
DWS on the content and extent of the proposed wetland offset. Earlier this year (2017) Zitholele Consulting
undertook another public participation process for the updated wetland offset strategy presented in the
EIA, which you were part of. There has been no further EAs or WULs issued pertaining to the Kusile 60 year
ADF wetland offset.
c) the approval referred to in Point 1 Background of the Background Information Document relates to the EA
that was granted in July 2015 for the Kusile 60 year ADF EIA application, as discussed in point b) above.
I trust the responses at this stage answers your question and look forward to engage with you in the public
participation process soon to kick off for this Basic Assessment application.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
From: Dr JA Meyer [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Tuesday, 05 December 2017 1:17 PM
To: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA; Mathys Vosloo
2
Cc: Lebo Petlane
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Dear Mathys
The BID received refers.
Please confirm the following:
1) Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd is already a registered I&AP for this process.
2) Comments submitted by Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd pertaining to the WOS have been received and incorporated.
3) Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd would like to attend the PPP planned for January 2018 – please provide the planned
date.
4) The BID received appears to address the first phase of the WOS received, namely addressing the wetlands
on Eskom property first.
a. I do not see any mention in the BID that this is part of a broader strategy, with the next phase
involving other wetland offset areas, e.g. the Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd property as noted in the comments
submitted by Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd.
b. If there are any EAs, or WULs, that relate to the WOS which have been issued, please provide me
with copies thereof.
c. Please clarify the context of the “approval” referred to in Point 1 Background, and provide me with a
copy thereof.
Regards
James
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Thursday, November 23, 2017 4:26 PM To: Mathys Vosloo
Cc: Lebo Petlane Subject: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Stakeholder,
BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED
WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
Notice is given in terms of Section 41(2)(b) of the EIA regulations , 2014 (GN R.982), as amended, in terms of the
National Environmental Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), as amended, of the intention of Eskom Holdings SOC
Ltd to undertake activities relating to the rehabilitation of several degraded wetlands at and around the Kusile
Power Station, Mpumalanga. A Basic Assessment process must be undertaken in terms of the EIA regulations, 2014
to identify, assess and mitigate all potential impacts to within acceptable levels.
You have been identified as a key stakeholder for the abovementioned project and are therefore informed of the
Basic Assessment process underway. A Background Information Document (BID) that contains information regarding
the proposed project, Basic Assessment process and how you can become involved is attached to this email
notification. All documents will be available on the internet at www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading
“Kusile WOP and PPP”. Further communication will follow in due course as the Basic Assessment process unfolds.
BIDs have furthermore been placed at the following public venues for collection:
PUBLIC VENUE ADDRESS
Victor Khanye Cnr Samuel & Van
3
Local
Municipality
der Walt Streets,
Delmas
Delmas Public
Library
Cnr Sarel Cilliers &
Van Riebeeck Street
Phola Public
Library
2427 Qwabe Street,
Phola Location
Ogies Public
Library
61 Main Street,
Ogies
It is advised to complete the comment sheet attached at the back of the BID and return to the PPP Desk in order for
us to confirm your contact details on the project database. However, if you do not wish to be involved in this Basic
Assessment process please request the PPP Desk to remove you from the project database as a key stakeholder.
The PPP Desk can be contacted at the contact details provided in the BID and below.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
1
Mathys Vosloo
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA on behalf of [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, 07 December 2017 4:34 PM
To: 'Dr JA Meyer'
Cc: Lebo Petlane
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear James,
Thank you for your email. I have responded to your original email.
You do not need to return the I&AP page as yourself and Topigs SA are automatically included in the project
stakeholder database.
Furthermore, you do not need to respond to the BID as this document is intended to introduce the proposed
development and Basic Assessment process to Interested and Affected Parties. Notification will be sent out in due
course to inform all registered IA&Ps of the availability of the Basic Assessment Report for stakeholder comment.
We look forward to your participation in the Basic Assessment processes for this project.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd
From: Dr JA Meyer [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Thursday, 07 December 2017 3:09 PM
To: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA; Mathys Vosloo Cc: Lebo Petlane
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Mathys
Given the end day tomorrow set, could you please respond as soon as possible, at least to point 1 below in my email
sent on Dec 5th
.
The BID requires a returned I&AP page by the 8th
– but what is the date for comments to the BID – I do not see this
specified?
Regards
James
From: Dr JA Meyer [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Tuesday, December 05, 2017 1:17 PM To: '17107 - Kusile WOP BA'; 'Mathys Vosloo'
Cc: 'Lebo Petlane'
Subject: RE: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Dear Mathys
2
The BID received refers.
Please confirm the following:
1) Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd is already a registered I&AP for this process.
2) Comments submitted by Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd pertaining to the WOS have been received and incorporated.
3) Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd would like to attend the PPP planned for January 2018 – please provide the planned
date.
4) The BID received appears to address the first phase of the WOS received, namely addressing the wetlands
on Eskom property first.
a. I do not see any mention in the BID that this is part of a broader strategy, with the next phase
involving other wetland offset areas, e.g. the Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd property as noted in the comments
submitted by Topigs SA (Pty) Ltd.
b. If there are any EAs, or WULs, that relate to the WOS which have been issued, please provide me
with copies thereof.
c. Please clarify the context of the “approval” referred to in Point 1 Background, and provide me with a
copy thereof.
Regards
James
From: 17107 - Kusile WOP BA [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Thursday, November 23, 2017 4:26 PM To: Mathys Vosloo
Cc: Lebo Petlane Subject: 17107-02-001 Kusile BA: Notice of Project Announcement
Importance: High
Dear Stakeholder,
BASIC ASSESSMENT FOR ENGINEERING INTERVENTIONS PROPOSED FOR THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED
WETLANDS AROUND KUSILE POWER STATION, MPUMALANGA PROVINCE
Notice is given in terms of Section 41(2)(b) of the EIA regulations , 2014 (GN R.982), as amended, in terms of the
National Environmental Management Act (Act 107 of 1998), as amended, of the intention of Eskom Holdings SOC
Ltd to undertake activities relating to the rehabilitation of several degraded wetlands at and around the Kusile
Power Station, Mpumalanga. A Basic Assessment process must be undertaken in terms of the EIA regulations, 2014
to identify, assess and mitigate all potential impacts to within acceptable levels.
You have been identified as a key stakeholder for the abovementioned project and are therefore informed of the
Basic Assessment process underway. A Background Information Document (BID) that contains information regarding
the proposed project, Basic Assessment process and how you can become involved is attached to this email
notification. All documents will be available on the internet at www.zitholele.co.za/environmental, under heading
“Kusile WOP and PPP”. Further communication will follow in due course as the Basic Assessment process unfolds.
BIDs have furthermore been placed at the following public venues for collection:
PUBLIC VENUE ADDRESS
Victor Khanye
Local
Municipality
Cnr Samuel & Van
der Walt Streets,
Delmas
Delmas Public
Library
Cnr Sarel Cilliers &
Van Riebeeck Street
3
Phola Public
Library
2427 Qwabe Street,
Phola Location
Ogies Public
Library
61 Main Street,
Ogies
It is advised to complete the comment sheet attached at the back of the BID and return to the PPP Desk in order for
us to confirm your contact details on the project database. However, if you do not wish to be involved in this Basic
Assessment process please request the PPP Desk to remove you from the project database as a key stakeholder.
The PPP Desk can be contacted at the contact details provided in the BID and below.
Kind regards
Dr. Mathys Vosloo
17107 Kusile Basic Assessment: PPP Desk
Tel: 011 207 2060, Fax: 086 674 6121, E-mail: [email protected]
FOR Zitholele Consulting (Pty) Ltd