appellant brief to appellate court second department new york
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
1/39
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccNBYZUJcLHcBDYOLNYgotcotcbncbffj`jichubzicdbtjcluo`onbyon`chulmcygjctzmmbucfj`bfc{uldjjion`cgjficbycygjcTz{ujmjcDlzuyclhcIzydgjttcDlznychlfflpon`cbffj`byolntchulmcygjcByylunjc@jnjubfclhcNjpc_lu cTybyjcygbycygjcujt{lnijnycjn`b`jiconcuj{jbyjicluc{jutotyjnychubzicebtjiclncyplcdbztjtclhcbdyoln1cHoutycdbztjc{zutzbnycylccJwjdzyoxjcFbpccTjd.c84c'25/-cHubzi&cbnictjdlnicdbztjclhcbdyolnc{zutzbnycylcJwjdzyoxjcFbpcTjdc84-25c-cXolfbyolnclhc@EFcBuyodfjc55-B&cTjd.c49?.cYgotcotcbncB{{jbfcylcygjcTz{ujmjcDlzuyclhcNjpc_lu cTybyj&cB{{jffbyjcIoxotoln3cTjdlnicAziodobfcIj{buymjnychulmcbcIjdotoln,LuijucAzi`mjnyclhcAztyodjcYglmbtcIlfbncibyjicNlxjmejuc29&c5;;?&cbcIjdotolncbnicLuijucbniccLuiju,Azi`mjnyclhcAztyodjcAbmjtc[b`lnjtcibyjicTj{yjmejuc5?&c5;2;.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccTYBYJMJNYcLHcHBDYTYgjcdbtjcotcebtjiclncbcdlm{fbonychulmcPontyji&cDlnnjdyodzycujtoijnycAbnjycT{ouoilnb ltcbffj`on`ctgjcpbtcijhubzijicecygjcijhjnibny&cpglcecilon`ceztonjttclncygjcOnyjunjycbtcLeajytcIBuycZnorzjt&ctlficgjuctjxjncTonl-YoejybncEziigotycultbuojtcnbmjicmbfb&clxjucbc{juoliclhcbelzycyplcjbutcdlmmjndon`concAbnzbuc5;;0.cYgjcijhjnibnytcpjetoyjcLeajytcIBuycZnorzjtcotc{buyclhcbnclnfonjcbnyorzjtcmbffcuj`otyjujicbnicmbonybonjicec@lcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc2cBnyorzjt.dlmcfldbyjiconcLgolcTybyj.c@lcBnyorzjt.dlmcbtcbctjffjuclncJebcFoxjcBzdyolntctlficoyjmtcdlnto`njiceclpnjutclhclnfonjctylujtcuj`[email protected]{gtodbfc{lttjttolnclhcoyjmtctlficbycygjcbzdyolnt&cygjcdlnto`njutclhcygjtjcoyjmt&cdlffjdyjicmlnojtchulmcezjutcondfzion`cygjcbzdyolncdlmmottolnconcygjcbmlznyclhc20.:c*cbnicbiioyolnbfc2;c*ctjffjuchjjt.cYgjcdlmmot
tolntcpjujcdgbu`[email protected]`nlutcdujioycdbuiconcbiioyolncdgbu`jichlucygjcmlnygfcmbonyjnbndjclhcygjctyluj.cYgjcdlnioyolntclhcygjcbzdyolntctybyjicygbycygjctbfjtcpjujchonbfcbhyjucbc{juoliclhcont{jdyolncygbycpbtclhc0cibtcbnicioicnlycjwdjjic4;cibtchulmcygjcbzdyolntcibyj.cYgjchoutycyplc{zudgbtjtclhcMt.cT{ouoilnb ltcpjujcygulz`[email protected]`nlu.cLnjclhcygjcTonl-Yoejybncabijoyjcultbucmbfbcpbtcijtduoejicbtchjocytzo.cDlm{fbonbnyco`nlubnyfcbnicpuln`fcbyyuoezyjichjocytzoc'mjbntcabijoyjconcDgonjtj/cylcom{juobfcabijcztjicjwdfztoxjfconcajpjfucygbycotcubujcbnicjw{jntoxj.cB@cbffj`jicygbyctgjcpbtcijdjoxji&cujfojiclnchjocytzocyjumccbnicygjujbhyju&ctgjc{zudgbtjicbiioyolnbfchoxjcabijoyjcmbfbchulmcygjcOnyjunjyctylujclhcygjcijhjnibnycnbmjicLeajytcIBuycZnorzjt.cOncNlxjmejuc5;;7&cygjcdlm{fbonbnyc{zudgbtjic5cabijoyjcgbnifjtcdbffo`ub{gceuztgjtcygbycz{lnujdjo{yctgjcpuln`fcejfojxjicygbycpjujcmbijclhc`fbttcubygjucygbncabijoyj.cByc
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc5gjucujrzjty&ctgjcujyzunjicygjceuztgjtcbnicujhzniji.ccTgjcioicnlycdlntzfycbnelicbelzycgjuctzt{odolncbnicpoygcdjuybonycpbtcnlyctzujcbelzycgjucejfojh.cBtcbcmbyyjuclhchbdy&ctgjcom{flujicygjcijhjnibnycylcuj-tjffcgjucygjceuztgjtcjxjncbycbcgo`gjuc{uodjcpgjncygjcijhjnibnycdlnhoumjicygbycygjceuztgjtcpjujcbtcuj{ujtjnyji.c[ulxoijnyf&cygotcyubntbdyolncnjxjucyll c{fbdj.cBycygjcujdlmmjnibyolnclhcgjucdfltjchuojni&cbcajpjfjucnbmjicYomcMdDfjffbni&ctgjctzemoyyjicygulz`gcgomcygjctjxjncYoejybncmbfbchlucbc`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`cecbcdlm{bncnbmjicB@YBc'Bmjuodbnc@jmlfl`odbfcYubijcBttldobyoln/.cBddluion`cylcT{ouoilnb ltcjmboftc&cMdDfjffbnicpgltjctylujcotconc@ujbycEbuuon`yln&cMbttbdgzttjyyt&c{od jicz{cygjcmbfbchulmcdlm{fbonbnycglztjconcPontyji&cDlnnjdyodzy&ceulz`gycygjmcylcB@YBconcN_D&cygjnc{od jicygjmcebd chulmcB@YBcbniceulz`gycygjmcylcgotctylujconcMbttbdgzttjyytchulmcygjujcygjcdlm{fbonbnyceulz`gycygjmcglmjclnc4,57,;?.cTgjcnlyohojicijhjnibnyc
tgjcujdjoxjicygjcmbfbcbnicygjc`jmlfl`odbfcoijnyohodbyolncuj{luytcuj{luyjictjxjncmbfbcpjujct{jdojtcrzbuyq&cxbuojycrzbuyqoyj&ctjjcjngbndjmjny.cYgjchbffbdclhcygjcuj{luytcotcnlyclnfcygbycpjujconbddzubyj&cezycygjcabijoyjcmbfbcpjujcnlycajpjfuc`ubijcabijoyjc{ulnjcylcejcbnbfqjicec`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`&cubygjuclunbmjnybfcabijcdbuxon`tcygbycbujcnjxjuctzoybefjchluc`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`cizjcylcygjc{ujtjndjclhcmbncmonjubftcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc4concygjoucdlntyoyzjnd.cTzetjrzjnyf&cAbnjycT{ouoilnb ltcdlnybdyjicijhjnibnycecjmbofcujrzjtyon`cbcujhzni.cGjcbttzujicgjuctgjcpoffcujdjoxjcbcujhznicz{lncygjcujdjo{yclhcygjcuj{luyt.cZnjw{fbonji&ctgjcioicnlycdlnybdycygjcijhjnibnycb`boncznyofc:
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
2/39
,2;,;?c{ulxoion`cygjcujt{lnijnycpoygcygjcuj{luytcnjwycib.cOncygjcjmbofcibyjic:,2;,;?ctgjcdfbomtclhc{bon`c)2;;;chlucygjcyjtyon`&cmlnjctgjcioicnlycdfbomchlucujhzni.cTjjcUjdluiclncB{{jbfc{b`jcB9:7c'IjhjnibnytcJwgoeoycEclhcUj{fcBhhoibxoy/.cFbtycdlmmznodbyolncpoygcT{ouoilnb ltcpbtcbncjmbofclhccijhjnibnycibyjic:,29,;?clhhjuon`ctzeyubdyolnclhcygjcygouic{buyc{bmjnytchulmcujhzniclucjwdgbn`on`cygjcmbfbcpoygcbncoyjmtchulmcygjccpjetoyjcbtchzffcujhzni.cYgjcjmbofcdfjbufctglptcygbycygjcujhznicpoffcejctbyothbdylucylcgju.cPgofjcoycb{{jbujicygbycygjcdlm{fbonbnycb`ujjiccylcbcujhznictjyyfjmjny&ctgjceul jcygjcnj`lyobyolntcbnicdlm{fbonjicpoygcNjpc_lu cTybyjcByylunjc@jnjubfc'B@/cbffj`on`chubzi.cLncgjucfbtycjmbofcylcijhjnibnycibyjic:,27,;?&ctgjcdfbomtcygbyctgjcpbtcijhubziji&cc{boic)2;;;chlucygjc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytcbnictgjcotcdlnybdyon`[email protected]@c[jyoyoln&cJwgoeoyc20c'cUjdluicc{b`jcB289/cLncAznjc59&c5;;?&cijhjnibnycpbtctze{ljnbjicylcb{{jbuchlucbnconyjuul`byolncbycB@clhhodjconc[lz`g jj{toj.cBB@&cNodglfbtc@buoncbixotjicijhjnibnycygbycotcnlycjnyoyfjicylcgbxjcbncbyylunjc{ujtjny&cezycmo`gycnjjiclnjconcygjchzyzuj.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc9Hlfflpon`cygjctze{ljnb&cijhjnibnycujdjoxjicbcNlyodjclhc[ul{ltjicBdyolncbhhluion`cygjcl{{luyznoycylcujt{lnicpoygonc:cibtcpgctzdgc{uldjjion`ctglzficnlycejctybuyji.cYgjcijhjnibnytcujt{lntjcondfzijicygjchbdycygbycygjc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytclhcB@YBcpjujcmotfbejfjicbtcdbuxjicgjbicnjd fbdjtcyjumonlfl`cygbycygjcijhjnibnycnjxjucztjiconcygjcijtduo{yolnclhcmbfbcbnicygjcjxoijndjcpbtcybm{jujiceczton`cbncbyybdgjic{glylcylcbncoijnyohodbyolncuj{luycbnictbmjc{glylcztjicb`bonconcygjcoijnyohodbyolnclhcbnlygjucmbfbctlficmlujcygbnclnjcjbucfbyju.cYgjcijhjnibnycxo`lulztfcijnojicygjchbftjcbffj`byolntcygbycgjctlficoyjmtcbtcmbijclhcabijcpgjncygjcoyjmtcpjujcnlycmbijclhcabijcbnictlficlucbixjuyotjicoyjmtcbtcejon`cbndojnycpgjncygjcoyjmtcpj
ujcubygjuclhcujdjnychbeuodbyoln.cOncluijucylcejcbndojny&cygjcoyjm't/cgbtcylcejcmlujcygbnc2;;;cjbuclfi&chbdycnjxjucbffj`jicecB@cbnicijmlntyubyon`ctgjjuco`nlubndj.cYgjtjcmbfodolztccbffj`byolntcpjujcnjxjuctz{{luyjicechbdyzbfc{ullhcbnicubygjuchotgon`cjw{jioyolntclhcygjc{fbonyohh.cIjhjnibnyctondjujfcejfojxjicygbycgotcujt{lntjcylcygjcNlyodjcpbtclxjupgjfmon`fcdlnxondon`cbnicbtc{ulxon`cygjcmbfodolztcdgbu`jtcpjujchbftj&cplzficejciotmottji.cLncBz`ztyc0&c5;;?&cBB@cNodglfbtc@buoncdbffjicijhjnibnyclnc{glnjcylcbnnlzndjcygbycbcgjbuon`cbelzycbcYULcplzficejcbycdlzuyglztjc4cglzutcfbyju.cBB@clhhjujicylchbwcygjcildzmjnytcezycygjchbwcioicnlyc`lcyguz.cYgotcgjbuon`cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:pbtcuzfjicecazi`jcAbmjtcEubnitcylcejcbcdbfjnibucdbffcbnicnlcgjbuon`cbycbffcbnictbmjcpoygcygjchlfflpcz{c{uldjjion`clhcTj{yjmejuc29&c5;;?.cTjjcUjdluic{b`jcB92-B94.cBycygotcdbfjnibucdbff&cBB@ceulz`gyc4cbffj`byolntconctz{{luyclhcgotcujrzjtychl
ucbcYUL1cB@YBcFbelubyluchonion`tclhc0coijnyohodbyolncuj{luyt&cbffj`byolntclhcygjcdlm{fbonbnycygbyc5cabijoyjcdbffo`ub{gceuztgjtctgjcyglz`gycpjujcmbijclhc`fbttcubygjucygbncabijoyjcbnicnj`byoxjcdlmmjnytclncBmbqln.dlmcbelzycijhjnibnytc{zefotgjicell t.cIjhjnibnycujt{lnijicygbycB@YBcoijnyohodbyolncuj{luytcpjujcybm{juji&cmotfbejfjicbnictglzficnlycejcdlntoijujicbtcfj`bfcjxoijndj.cDbffo`ub{gceuztgjtcpjujcujyzunjicbnicujhznijicbnicygjujcpbtcnlcjxoijndjcpgbytljxjucygbycygjceuztgjtcpjujcmbijclhc`fbttcbnicygjcnj`byoxjcdlmmjnytclncBmbqln.dlmcpjujcnlyctzetybnyobyjicecbncebtj.cGlpjxju&cYULcpbtc`ubnyjicecazi`jcAbmjtcEubnitcbnicbc`b`clncmjiobcpbtc`ubnyjicbycijhjnibnytcujrzjty.cIjhjnibnycdlm{fbonjicygbycnlcnlyohodbyolnclhcgjbuon`[email protected]`jcEubnitcujdlmmjnijicuj-yjtyon`cec@OBcFbelubyluclhccmbfbcbtcB@YBchonion`tcpjujchbzfy&cbnictjycz{cbchlfflpcz{cdbfjnibucdbffcbycpgodgcujtzfytclhc@OBcplzficejcbxbofbefj.cBychlfflpcz{cgjbuon`clhc?,29,5;;?&cAzi`jcEubnitconrzoujicBB@cbelzycygjcujtzfytclhc@OBcbnicbycgotcnj`byoxjcuj{fcgjcuzfjicygbyc
ygjcujtzfytctglzficejcbxbofbefjcbycnjwycdbfjnibucdbffclhc?,57,5;;?c'njxjucyll c{fbdj/ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc8bnicecygbycyomjcBB@ctglzfictzemoycbcuj{fcylcijhjnibnytcujt{lntjcylcygjc[jyoyolncbfujbictzemoyyjicbnichofjicpoygcygjcDlzuy.cNlcrzjtyolntcpjujc{ltjicylcygjcijhjnibny.cDlzuycpbtcznbefjcylcfldbyjcbnctyjnl`ub{godcujdluiclhcygjtjc5cdlzuycb{{jbubndjtcbnicazi`jcEubnitctybyjiconcygjcDlzuytctybyjmjnycztjiconcfojzclhcyubntduo{ycygbyconchbdycygjujcpjujcnlcgjbuon`t&cubygjucdbfjnibucdbfft.cAzi`jcEubnitcujdztjicdoyon`cdlnhfodyclhconyjujtycbtcgotc[uondo{bfcDlzuycByylunjc{ujxolztfcuj{ujtjnyjicijhjnibnytchlumjucpohjconcbcioxludjc{uldjjion`.cAzi`jcYglmbtcIlfbncpbtcbtto`nj
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
3/39
icylcygotcdbtjcezycgjcioicnlyctjycz{cbnchzuygjucgjbuon`t&cdbfjnibucdbfftclucdlnhjujndjccuj`buion`cygjcyjm{lubuconazndyolnclucbncottzjtcujfbyjicylc`ubnyon`cbctzmmbucazi`mjny.c5ccybm{juon`tcpoygcjxoijndjclddzuujiconcygjcB@c[jyoyoln&cJwgoeoyc27&cbuyodfj1cEzumjtjcabij1cYgjcontduzybefjc`jmcecUodgbuicGz`gjtcbnicbf.cHoutycybm{juon`cb{{jbujiclnc{b`jc29clhcJwgoeoyc27c'TjjcUjdluic{b`jcB207/cbnicdlntotyjiconcygjclxju-{uonyclhcbc{glylclxjucbcyjwycygbycpbtcjwdzf{bylucylcijhjnibny.cYgjclefoyjubyjic{bub`ub{gchulmcbelxjcbuyodfjcdfjbufctybyjtcygbycabijoyjcygbycotcbctofodbyjc{ulwjnjcmbcejcdlm{ltjichulmclygjucmonjubftcbtcbm{goelfjtc'nj{guoyj/&crzbuyq&cmodb&cjyd.cygbycbujcdlntyoyzjnytclhcbncbimowyzujconcygjculd .cYgjctjdlnicybm{juon`cpoygcjxoijndjcpbtcbnlygjuclefoyjubyolnclhcygjcyjwyceconyju{lton`clhcbc{glylclxjucygjcyjwy.cTjjcB@ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc0c[jyoyoln&cJwgoeoyc27&c{b`jc0.cTo`nohodbnyf&cygjcyjwycpbtcjwdzf{bylucylcygjcijhjnibny.cYgjclefoyjubyjic{luyolncujxjbftcygbycabijoyjcabijcotcjttjnyobffcbculd cpoygcbcxbuobefjcdlm{ltoyoln.cTjjcijhjnibnytcUjt{lntjcylc[jyoyolncUjdluic{b`jcB5;7&cB5;?cbnicJwgoeoyc?clhcijhjnibnyc'ujdluic{b`jcB572/3cbftlcijhjnibnytcUj{fcBhhoumbyolncibyjicLdylejuc?&c5;;?&c{.c:&83cUjdluic{b`jc449&cB44:cB440.cLnc?,5,5;;?&cBB@cpulyjcbcfjyyjucylcygjcijhjnibnycbt on`cohcgjconyjnitcylcgbxjcygjcmbfbcuj-yjtyjicbtcgjc{ulmotji.cIjhjnibnycujt{lnijicec{glnjctybyon`cygbycgjcnjxjuc{ulmotjicylcgbxjcygjcmbfbcuj-yjtyji.cOycpbtcB@cujt{lntoeofoycylcuj-yjtycygjcmbfbcbtcB@YBcujtzfytcpjujchbzfycbycfjbty&cioicnlyc{ulxjcgotcbffj`byolntcbnicpbtcgotcujt{lntoeofoycylctzetybnyobyjcygjcbffj`byolntcpoygcbimottoefjcjxoijndjconcygjcdlzuy.c5cibtc{uolucAzi`jcEubnitcujdztbf&cijhjnibnycujdjoxjicbc{glnjcdbffchulmcBB@cbt on`chlucdlntjnyclhcyomjcjwyjntolncylcleyboncygjcujtzfytclhc@OB3cijhjnibnycijdfonjic
tzdgcdlntjny.cLnc2;,5,5;;?&cBB@ctzemoyyjicygjcUj{fcylcijhjnibnytcujt{lntjcylcygjc[jyoyoln.cYgjcUj{fcdlnybonjicygjcujtzfytclhc@OBcFbelubylucygbycujhzyjicB@YBchonion`t3cmbfbcbujcnlyct{jdojtcnbyzubfcrzbuyq.cDlflucjngbndjmjnyconcB@YBcpbtcbftlcuj{luyjiconc@OBcuj{luytcbtcdlmmlnchonion`concbffcom{luyjictjmo-{ujdolztctylnjtchulmcDgonb&cznhluyznbyjf&cnlycijyjdyjicectybnibuicccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc7jwbmonbyoln.cOncUj{f&cBB@cbuul`bnyfcontyuzdytcygjcDlzuycylciotuj`buicygjcujt{lnijnytcbntpjucylcygjc[jyoyolncejdbztjcoycotcnlyconcbimottoefjchlum.cOhcygjcDlzuycdlntoijutcoy&coyctglzficejcb{{bujnycygbycygjcTybyjcotcjnyoyfjicylctzmmbucazi`mjnycejdbztjcygjcujt{lntjcotcfbu`jfcouujfjxbnycbniczyyjufchboftcylcubotjcbcyuobefjcottzjclhchbdy.cUjt{lnijnycgbtcmotfbejfjicgotcujt{lntjcbtcbcmlyolncylciotmottctondjcgjcgbtcnlycubotjicbncleajdyolncylconc{lonyclhcfbpcznijucD[FUc9;9c'b/.cTglzf
icygjcDlzuycyujbycygjcujt{lntjcbtcbcmlyolncylciotmott&cygjcDlzuyctglzficjwjudotjcoytciotdujyolncbnicijncygjcujt{lnijnycfjbxjcylcbntpju.cBB@cdoyjtc[jl{fjcxcPofdlcdbtjcpgjujcygjcijhjnibnycpbtcijnojicfjbxjcylcbntpjuchlucygjcujbtlncygbycygjcbntpjucpbtcbfujbic`oxjnconcygjcdlznyju-dfbomcylciotmott&ctlcygjujcotcnlcdlm{buotlncpgbytljxju.cBB@cnjxjuctjuxjicygjcnlyodjclhc[jyoyolncylcijhjnibnyctlcnlcl{{luyznoycpbtc`ubnyjicylcijhjnibnycylc{ujtjnycgotctoijclygjucygbncujt{lnion`cylcygjc[jyoyolncygbycbnpbcpbtciotuj`buiji.cBB@cbffj`byolncpbtchbftj&cijhjnibnycubotjicygjcleajdyolnconc{lonyclhcfbpcznijucD[FUc'b/celygcectjyyon`coychluygconcgotcbntpjucylc[jyoyolncbnictjdlnifcecbcmlyolncylciotmottcygjc{jyoyoln.cOnc{bubc7clhcBB@&coycotchbftjfctybyjicb`boncygbyc@OBcFbecujtzfytcbhhoumcB@YBcujtzfyt1ccYgjc@OBcfbecujtzfytcbujcbyybdgjicbtcJwgoeoyc4.cYgjcdlnhoumcygjcujtzfytclhcygjcB@YBcfbe.ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc?
Yl`jygjucygjtjcuj{luytc{ulxjcejlnicbnctgbilpclhcilzeycygbycujt{lnijnycuj{jbyjifctlficMt.cT{ouoilnb ltcmbfbtc'tod/cygbycpjujcmbijclhcjxjuibcrzbuyqcubygjucygbncabijcbtcgjcuj{ujtjnyji.cOnyjnyolnbff&cBB@cdlnhztjtcygjcyjumtclhcrzbuyqcbnicrzbuyqoyj3cygjcbujcnlycygjctbmj&crzbuyqcotcbcton`fjcmonjubf&crzbuyqoyjcotcbcmjybmlu{godculd cygbycotc{ulxjicylcdlnyboncabijoyjcbnicotcnbmjicabijoyoyjclucabijoyjcrzbuyqoyj.cTjjcMjmlubnizmclhcfbpc{.0c3cUjdluic{b`jcB920.c@OBcuj{luytcbftlctglpcbciotduj{bndconcygjcdlm{buotlnclhcmbfbcpjo`gytcygbycbujcnlycdlm{byoefjcpoygc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytcmjbtzuon`concdbubyt&cubygjucygbnc`ubmt.cTjjcMlyolnclhcuj-bu`zmjny&c{.c2?&c{bubc50c'Ujdluic{b`jcB480/.cLnc2;,2:,5;;?&cB@cujfjbtjicylcmjiobcgo`gfconhfbmmbyluctybyjmjnytcygbycygjcijhjnibnyctlficbuyohbdytclncfonjcdfbomon`cygbyc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
4/39
ygjcdlnybonjicgo`gcrzbfoycbnicjw{jntoxjcabij&cpgjncygjcbdyzbffcpjujcmbijclhcrzbuyqcluc`fbtt.cGjcygjncujhztjicylc{ulxoijcujhznitclucbd nlpfji`jcygbycygjc{ojdjtcpjujchb j.cHzuygjucln1cYgotconioxoizbfc{ujjiclncdlffjdylutclhcjw{jntoxjcbnyorzjtcbnicbuyohbdytcbnicioinycijfoxjuclncgotc{[email protected]{zefotgon`cygotcujfjbtj&cB@c njpcygbycygjcmbfbctlficylcbcton`fjcdlm{fbonbnycpjujcnlycmbijchulmcrzbuyqcbnicygjczn{ulxjncbffj`byolnclhc`fbttcotcbchbnybtclhcygjcdlm{fbonbny.cCnlpon`fcbnicijfoejubyjf&cB@cfoejfjicygjcijhjnibnycbnicccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc2;xolfbyjicygjc`b`cmjiobcuj`buion`cYUL.cLnc2;,2:,;?cijhjnibnyctzemoyyjicbcdlm{fbonycylcygjcdlzuyconcgotcUj{fcBhhoumbyolncbnicmlxjicylciotmottcbffcdgbu`jtcpoygc{ujaziodj&ccbftlcmlxjicylcujmlxbfclhcYUL.cTjjcijhjnibnytcUj{fcylcB@cBniujpcDzlmlcUjfjbtjcylcMjiobc'Ujdluic{b`jcB447/.cUjt{lnijnycnjxjucujdjoxjicbcuj{fchulmcygjcdlzuycuj`buion`cygjcdlm{fbonycbnicbffcgotcmlyolntcijt{oyjcygbycpjujctjuxjicylcdlzuycbnic{fbonyohh.cXolfbyon`cizjc{uldjttclhcygjcijhjnibny&cazi`jcIlfbncottzjicIjdotoln,Luiju,Azi`mjnyconchbxluclhc{fbonyohhclnc22,29,5;;?cpoyglzycbncgjbuon`cbnicijhjnibnycnjxjuctbpcygjcazi`j.cDlzuycluijujicijhjnibnycylc{ulxoijcbcfotyclhcbffcdztylmjutcygbyc{zudgbtjicabijcoyjmtcbnicijhjnibnycdlm{foji.c[lyjnyobfcujtyoyzyolncbnicbttjttmjnyclhc{jnbfyojtcbnicdltycpbtcylcejcgjficoncbejbndjc{jnion`cygjcdlm{fjyolnclhc{jyyyolnjutconxjtyo`byolnclhc{lyjnyobfcdfbomt.cAzi`jctz``jtyjicijhjnibnycylcujyboncbcfbpjucdlntoijuon`cygjc{lyjnyobfcom{fodbyolntcbtcylcbttjttmjnyclhcujtyoyzyoln&cdltytcbnicmlnjcazi`mjny&cezycioicnlycmjnyolnchonjtclucujyulbdyoxjconyjujtyclhc?*cylcygjcdfbomt.cTzetjrzjnyf&cijhjnibnycujybonjicbyylunjcDfonylncDbfglzn.cOncfln`cnj`lyobyolntcejypjjncygjc{buyojt&cazi`jcIlfbnc{ul{ltjicbctjyyf
jmjnycebtjiclncujtyoyzyolncbnicpboxon`cbffchonjtcbnicdlzuycdlty.cPgofjcygjcdltycylcijhjnibnyclhcijhjnion`cygotcfbptzoycjwdjjijicygjcmlnjcdfbomjicecygjcdlm{fbonbny&cnlycdlntoijuon`cygjcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc22jmlyolnbfcbnic{gtodbfctyujtt&ctjyyfjmjnycfll jicbyyubdyoxjcezycygjcbimottolnclhc`zofycecdlntjnyon`cylcygjconazndyolncbfujbic`ubnyjicpbtcuj{z`nbnycylcmlubfcdgbubdyjuclhcygjcijhjnibny.cBhyjuchbofzujclhctjyyfjmjnytcnj`lyobyoln&cbyylunjcDbfglzncmlxjichlucuj-bu`zmjnycbnicujnjpcygbycpbtc`ubnyji.cAzi`jcIlfbncujyoujicbnicazi`jcDguotyonjcT{ulbycpglcpbtcbtto`nji&cb{{bujnyfcioicnlycyb jcygjcbtto`nmjny.cBB@cdlnyjnijicygbycecmlxon`cylcujbu`zj,ujnjp&cijhjnibnycfbd jic`llichboygcbnictglzficejctzeajdycylc{jnbfyojt&cdltycbnicom{ltoyolnclhc?c*conyjujty.cBB@concgotconxjtyo`byolnclhcbffcdztylmjutcpglc{zudgbtjicabijchulmcijhjnibnyconcygjc{btyc0cjbut&chlzniclnfc4cdztylmjutcujrzjtyon`cujtyoyzyolncpoyglzyc{ulxoion`cbcujbtln.cYg
otcuj{ujtjnyjicbncbyyjtybyolnchlucygjc{jutlnbfcbnic{ulhjttolnbfconyj`uoyclhcijhjnibny.cAzi`jcAbmjtc[b`lnjtcottzjicIjdotoln,LuijucbnicLuiju,Azi`mjnyclnc?,5?,2;chluc{fbonyohh.cOncbiioyolncylcygjconazndyolncbnicujtyoyzyolncylcdlm{fbonbnycbnic4cdfbombnyt&cgjcluijujic)7;;;concdoxofc{jnbfyojt&c)5;;;concdltytcbnicujyulbdyoxjconyjujtyclhc?*ccbmlznyon`cylc)45.:;8.45cygbycuj{ujtjnyjicmlujcygbncilzefjcygjcluo`[email protected]`jc[b`lnjtcjuulnjlztfcdlnhztjicygjcyjumtclhcuj-bu`zmjnycbnicujnjp.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccUj-bu`zmjnycdbncnlycejcujnjpcmlyolnchlucygjcujbtlncygbyceuon`tclnfcottzjtcygbycpjujc{ujxolztfciotdzttji3cpgofjcygjcujnjpceuon`tclnfchbdytcygbycbujccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc25cnjpcbnicnlyc{ujxolztfciotdzttji.cYgjcijdotolncylcbfflpcbcujnjpcmlyolnconcygjcazi`jc[b`lnjtcijhonoyolncotcbdyzbffccylcb{{ulxjcuj-bu`zmjnycygbycecoytjfhctglzfi
ceuon`cylciotmottbfclhcbdyoln.cOncbeztjclhciotdujyoln&cAzi`jc[b`lnjtcioicnlycybjconcdlntoijubyolncygjcujnjpcmlyolncpgofjcdlm{fjyjfco`nluon`cygjcuj-bu`zmjnycygbyconcgotcuzfon`cotcujnjpcpoyglzycijnon`coycbnicbigjuon`cylcazi`jcIlfbncIjdotoln,Luiju,Azi`mjnyclhc22,29,5;;?cbnicijdotoln,Luijuclhc?,5?,2;cygbycpbtcbebnilnji.cc
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccBU@ZMJNYcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYccOcccccccccYgjc{uombchbdojclhc{fbonyohhcdlntotytclhchbftjcbffj`byolntclhcbcton`fjcdlm{fbonb
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
5/39
nycbnichbzfyc`jmlfl`odbfcfbelubylucyjtyon`clhcB@YBcYgjcjxoijndjctzemoyyjicecijhjnibnyctglpjicygbyc{fbonyohhtcjxoijndjcotcebtjiclnc{juazucdlmmoyyjicecygjcdlm{fbonbnycpglctzemoyyjiclncbncbhhoibxoy&cdlnyubiodyluctybyjmjnytcujfbyjicylcjw{jntjtcondzuujicylcleyboncygjc`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`.cYgjctjdlnicjfjmjnyclhcc{uombchbdojcdlntotytclhctjxjncmotfbejfjicbnichlu`jic`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytclhcB@YB&cbcijhzndycdlm{bnctondjcAzfc5;;?.cYgjcoijnyohodbyolncuj{luytcpjujcmotfbejfjicbtcdbuxjicgjbiccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc24njd fbdjt&cyjumonlfl`cnjxjucztjiconcygjcijhjnibnytcijtduo{yolnclhcygjcmbfb.cB@YBchlu`jucotcebtjiceczton`cbc{glylcbyybdgjicylcbncoijnyohodbyolncuj{luyclhcbcabijoyjcmbfbcpoygcygjctbmjc{glylcztjicb`boncbyybdgjicylcbncoijnyohodbyolncuj{luyclhcbnlygjucmbfbctlficylcygjcdlm{fbonbnyc27cmlnygtcfbyju.cTjjcijhjnibnycujt{lntjcylc{jyoyoln&c{b`jtc0-7c'Ujdluic{b`jcB52;&cB522/&cbnicmlyolncylcujbu`zj,ujnjp&c{bubc59&c5:&c{.20-27c'UjdluicB48:&cB488/.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcOO
@jmlfl`odbfcfbelubylucyjtyon`cotcnlycygjc{ul{jucmjygliclhcoijnyohodbyolnclhclunbmjnybfcbuycabijcdbuxon`t.
@jmlfl`odbfcoijnyohodbyolncuj{luytcbujcjwdfztoxjfcztjichlucajpjfuc`ubijc
abijoyjconccajpjfuconiztyucbnicnjxjucztjichlucoijnyohodbyolnclhc
lunbmjnybfcabijoyjcdbuxon`t.cLunbmjnybfcabijcdbuxon`tcbujcoijnyohojictlfjfc
ecmonjubfl`odbfcyjtyon`cbtctzdgcdbuxon`tcbujcdlm{ltjiclhcmzfyo{fjcmonjubftc
poygcbcxbuobefjcdlm{ltoyolncbnicygjcujtzfytcdlzficejciohhjujnycec
jwbmonbyolnclhcbncoyjmconciohhjujnycbujbt.cTjjcijhjnibnytcUjt{lntjcylc
[jyoyoln&cJwgoeoyc2&c8ccbnic7c'Ujdluic{b`jtcB527-B5843cbnicMjmlubnizmc
lhcFbpc{b`jc03cUjdluicB920c.c
[ujtyo`olztcYguld mluylnc@bffjuconcN_DcjwgoeoyjicNjlfoygodcnj{guoyjcabijc
buyohbdytcpoygcmzfyo{fjcmonjubfl`odbfcdlm{ltoyolnclygjucygbncnj{guoyj.cTjjcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc29cijhjnibnycbntpjucylc[jyoyoln&cjwgoeoyc4&c{2-?3cUjdluicB540-B59:.cYgjc
tybnibuicztjiconcygjclunbmjnybfcbuycabijconiztyucotcijyjumonbyolnclhcygjc
gbuinjttceccMlgtcyjtycbnicijntoycect{jdohodc`ubxoy.cMlujctl{gotyodbyjic
yjtytcbtcccTJMc'tdbnnon`cjfjdyulncmodultdl{cpoygcebd ctdbyyjujicjfjdyulntc
'ETJ/&cWcUbchfzlujtdjndjct{jdyulmjyucbnicdbyl-fzmonjtdjndjc'DF/&cccbujc
ztjicjwdfztoxjfconctl{gotyodbyjicznoxjutoycfbelubyluojtcbnicujtjuxjicchluc
ujtjbudgclnf.
Iob`nltotclhcabijcotcilnjcecijbfjutctjffon`cabijcbnicfbu`jcbzdyolncglztjtcec
xotzbfcont{jdyolncznijucmb`nohodbyolncbnic{juhlumbndjclhcMlgtcyjty.cAbijc
buycdbuxon`tcujrzoujcbcyujmjnilztcbmlznyclhcplu cbnicygjc{uodjcotc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
6/39
ijyjumonjicecrzbfoyclhcygjcdbuxon`cubygjucygbncygjctylnjchulmcpgodgcoycotc
dbuxji.cOmoybyolncabijoyjcdbuxon`tcbujcbfpbtcdujbyjiconctlhyjuctylnjcygbnc
abij&cujizdon`ctzetybnyobffcygjcbmlznyclhcfbelu.cPuln`fcbniczntz{{luyjic
ecjxoijndj&cygjcB@cejfojxjtcygbyc`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`cotccygjctybnibuiclhc
abijoyjcbzygjnyodbyoln.cOm{lton`clncijhjnibnycygbycbnchzyzujctbfjtclhcabijc
tglzficgbxjcbc`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`cbyybdgjicijnlyjtccjwyujmjco`nlubndjcbnic
betzuioy.c@jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`cpbtcnjxjucilnjclnclunbmjnybfcabijcdbuxon`tc
ecbncabijcijbfjuclucbzdyolncglztjtcbtcoyciljtcnlycmb jctjntj.c
Abijoyjcotcbcmjybmlu{godculd cygbycdlnybontctjxjubfcmonjubftcbnicotcom{zuj.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc2:Oncdlnyubty&cajpjfuc`ubijcabijcotconcmonzyjcrzbnyoycmjbtzujiconcdbubyc
pjo`gyc'5;;cm`/&c{zujucbnicygjctzuhbdjcotconcdbeldglnctgb{jc
poygcbc{lfotgjictzuhbdjcubygjucygbncdbuxji.cYoejybncmbfbcbujcEziigotyc
ultbuojtcdbuxjiconciohhjujnycmbyjuobftconcctgb{jclhcEziigotycmln tcgjbit&c
bujcjwyujmjfconyuodbyjcbnicijmbnicgo`gc{uodjtcebtjiclncygjcrzbfoyclhc
dbuxon`cbnicnlycygjcmbyjuobftcygjcbujcdbuxjichulm.c
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcOOO
Ygjujcbujcznjw{fbonjicmbu jiciotduj{bndojtcejypjjncB@YBc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytcxjutztc@OBcuj{luyt.
B@YBc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytcoijnyohojicbffctjxjncmbfbcbtct{jdojtcnbyzubfc
rzbuyq&cxbuojycrzbuyqoyj.cYgotcoijnyohodbyolncotcconbddzubyjcbnicmotfjbion`c
btcrzbuyqcotcbcton`fjcmonjubfc'tofodlnjciolwoij/cpgofjcrzbuyqoyjcotcbc
mjybmlu{godculd cdlnybonon`ctjxjubfcmonjubftcpoygcbcxbuobefjcdlm{ltoyoln.c
Ygjc{ujtjndjcbnicrzbnyoyclhcabijoyjconcygjculd cijyjumonjtcygjcb{{jbubndjc
bnic{gtodbfc{ul{juyojtclhcabijoyj.cBtcijmlntyubyjiconcygjctdojnyohodc
foyjubyzujcjwgoeoyjiconcijhjnibnytcujt{lntjcylcygjc{jyoyoln&cmjybmlu{godc
rzbuyqoyjc nlpncbtcmjyb-rzbuyqoyjcotctnlnmlztcpoygcabijoyjclucabijoyj-
rzbuyqoyj.cTjjcJwgoeoyc8clhcijhjnibnytcujt{lntjcylc[jyoyoln1cUjdluicB5:8-
B5843cbftlcbhhoibxoyconctz{{luyclhcMlyolncylcuj-bu`zmjny,ujnjp&c{bubc27&c2?&c
5;&c523cUjdluicB4:?-B489.cJngbndjmjnyclhcabijoyjcotcznoxjutbfcbtccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc28{ubdyodbffcbffcom{luyjicabijoyjcotcdlflucjngbndjicecij.cTjjcMlyolncylc
uj-bu`zmjny,ujnjp&c{bubc29-2:3cUjdluicB4:8-B4:0.c@OBc`jmlfl`odbfc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
7/39
uj{luytcujhzyjicB@YBcuj{luytcbtcoijnyohodbyolnclhcmbfbcioicnlycmjnyolnc
pgbytljxjuct{jdojtcRzbuyq.c@OBcoijnyohodbyolnclhcygjctjxjncmbfbcbtc
t{jdojtcrzbuyqoyjcotcdlm{byoefjcpoygc{ujtjndjclhcabijoyjconcygjc{lf-monjubfc
rzbuyqoyjculd .cBnlygjuciotduj{bndcejypjjncygjtjcyplc`jmlfl`odbfc
fbelubyluojtcotcygjcpoijciohhjujndjcuj{luyjiconcygjcmbfbcpjo`gyt.cYgjc
juulutcbujcnlyctdojnyohodbffcbddj{ybefjchluc`jmlfl`odbfcfbelubyluojtcpgodgc
uj{luycpjo`gyconcdbuby&cubygjucygbnc`ubmt.cTjjc{bubc50clhcijhjnibnytc
bhhoibxoyconctz{{luyclhcmlyolnchlucuj-bu`zmjny,ujnjp&c{b`jc2?&c5;3cUjdluic
B480&cB487.
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcOXc
B@chbofjicylcjwjudotjcizjciofo`jndjconconxjtyo`byolnclhcygjcdlnyubiodyluctybyjmjnytclhcdlm{fbonbnytcbhhoibxoycpoygcdlnybonon`c{juazucbnicbyyjm{yjicjwyluyolncbn
icom{jbdgmjny.
Oncbhhoibxoycibyjic0,5;,;?&cdlm{fbonbnyctybyjictgjc{boic)2:9;chlucygjc
B@YBcyjtytcbnicuj{luyt.cTjjcJwgoeoyc8&cB@c[jyoyoln3cUjdluicB07&cB0?.cYgotc
tybyjmjnycdlnyubiodytcyplclygjuctybyjmjnytctgjcmbijcpgodgcijdfbujicygbycc
)2;;;cpbtc{boichlucygjcbelxjcyjtyt.c'[fjbtjcujhjucylcT{ouoilnb ltcj-mbofc
ibyjic:,2;,;?cJwgoeoycEclhcijhjnibnytcuj{fcbhhoibxoyconcdlnnjdyolncylccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc20ijhjnibnytcmlyolncylcuj-bu`zj,ujnjpc'UjdluicB9:0/cbnicgjuc:,27,;?cj-
mbof&cJwgoeoyc20clhcB@c[jyoyoln3cUjdluicB289.cYgjcdlnyubiodyluctybyjmjnytc
lhcygjcdlm{fbonbnycom{jbdgcgjucbtcbcpoynjtt.cTjjcD[FUcU9:29.c
Dlnyubiodyluctybyjmjnytcylcygjcbhhoibxoyctpluncznijuclbygcuj{ujtjnyc{juazuc
bnicbujc{znotgbefjcecfbp.cYgjcujxojpclhcgjucbhhoibxoycznijuclbygcujxjbftc
lygjuciotyzueon`chbdyt.cBhhoibxoycotcbcxlfznybuctzemottolnclhchbdytcygbyc
bhhobnyc nlptc{jutlnbffcbnicnlycpuoyyjncectlmjelicjftjcpglcotcnlycbc
ioujdycpoynjttclhcygjcbffj`jichbdyt.cT{ouoilnb ltcujxjbftconcgjucbhhoibxoyc
ijyboftclhcB@tc[jyoyolncJwgoeoytc{b`jtc5-4-9-:3cUjdluicB0:-B07&cbtcctgjc
{uj{bujicygjtjcgjutjfh3cluc{jugb{tcgjucbhhoibxoycpbtconcdluulelubyolncpoygc
ygjcB@cejdbztjcoycgbtcnlygon`cylcilcpoygcygjc nlpfji`jclhcygjcbffj`jic
jxjnyt.c
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
8/39
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcX
Dlm{fbonbnycbyyjm{yjicylcdlmmoycjwyluyolnclhcygjcijhjnibny.
Oycotcjxoijnychulmconhlumbyolnc{ulxoijicecT{ouoilnb ltcygulz`gcj-mboftc
poygcijhjnibnycujxjbfon`cygbycdlm{fbonbnycdlnt{oujicpoygcgjuchuojnic
ajpjfjucYomcMdDfjffbnicylcijhubzicygjcijhjnibny.cMdDfjffbnictjuxjicbtcbc
mjttjn`jucejypjjncygjcdlm{[email protected]
tgo{{on`cygjctjxjncmbfbcecuj`otyjujicmbofcylcejcyjtyjicecB@YB&ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc27MdDfjffbnicpglcb{{bujnyfcgbic{ujxolztcdfltjcyojtcpoygcB@YB&c{od jicz{cc
ygjcmbfbchulmcT{ouoilnb ltcglztjconcPontyji&cDlnnjdyodzycbnicijfoxjujic
ygjcoyjmtcylcB@YB&cygjnc{od jicygjmcz{chulmcB@YBconcN_Dcbniceulz`gyc
ygjmcylcgotctyluj.cLnjcmo`gycrzjtyolncpgcbcajpjfjucpoygcbctylujconc
Mbttbdgzttjyyt&cplzficyubxjfcylcPontyji&cDlnnjdyodzycylceuon`cabijcoyjmtcylc
B@YBconcN_D&cyb jcygjmcebd chulmcN_cylcMbttbdgzttjyytcbnichulmcygjuj&c
T{ouoilnb ltcplzfic{od cz{cygjcmbfb&cznfjttctlmjczniotdfltjichbdytcbujcnlyc
ujxjbfjicbtcmo`gycejconduomonbylu.cYgjcdgbonclhc{lttjttolnclhctjxjncmbfbc
pbtceul jnctjxjubfcyomjtcpoygc{lttoeofoyclhctzetyoyzyolnclhcmbfb.c
Ygjconduomonbyon`chbdycotcygjcj-mbofcpuoyyjncecT{ouoilnb ltclnc4,57,;?conc
pgodgctgjctybyjicygbyctgjcujdjoxjicygjcmbfbcebd chulmcB@YBc'TjjcB@c
[jyoyoln&cJwgoeoyc22&c{b`jc23cUjdluicB24?/cbnic`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytctglpji
cygbycmbfbcpjujcnlycmbijclhcabij.cGlpjxju&c`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytcpjujc
ibyjicejypjjncB{uofc29cylcB{uofc55&c5;;?cpgjncmbfbcplzficgbxjcejjnconc
ygjcdlm{fbonbnytcglztj.cZnjw{fbonjicotcygjchbdycygbycbycygjcujrzjtyclhc
ijhjnibnychluc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytconcjmbofcibyjic4,5?,;?&cT{ouoilnb ltcioic
nlycuj{f.cTjjcB@c[jyoyoln&cJwgoeoyc25&c{b`jc2&cUjdluicB292cIjhjnibny
pulyjc1ccOcjw{jdycygbycjbdgcoyjmcelz`gychulmcmjcgbtcygjcbelxjcbnbftotc
ilnjcpoygcygjc{glylconcluijucylcbttzujcygbycnlctzetyoyzyolncpbtcilnj.cTjjcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc2?
B@cJwgoeoyc25&c{b`jc2c'B292/.cT{ouoilnb ltcioicnlycuj{fcznyofc:,29,;?c
pgjncpulyjctgjcgbicygjcuj{luyt.cOycotcgbuicylcdlndjoxjcygbycbc{jutlncdfbomon`c
tgjcpbtcijhubzijicplzficpboycmlujcygbnc8cpjj tcylc{ulizdjcygjc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
9/39
ujrzjtyjicildzmjnytcbtc{ullhclhcygjcbffj`byolnt.cYgjc{ultjdzyluchbofjicylc
jwjudotjcizjciofo`jndjcylconxjtyo`byjcdoudzmtybndjtcznijufon`cygjc
bffj`byolntclhcdlm{fbonbnycbfyglz`gcgjcpbtc{ujxolztfconhlumjicbelzycgjuc
{lttoefjcpuln`-ilon`.cT{ouoilnb ltc{ulizdjicbnconxlodjcibyjic9,54,;?c
hulmcMdDfjffbniclhc)2:9;chlucabijcyjtyon`cbnicuj{luytcTjjcJwgoeoyc29clhc
B@c[jyoyoln3cUjdluicB2:7.cEoffcotcnlycmbu jic{boicnlucioicdlm{fbonbnyc
{ulizdjcbcdbndjfjicdgjd c{ullhcygbycygjceoffcpbtc{boi.cOnxlodjcpbtcnlyc
to`njicbnicgjucbiiujttcotcnlyctglpnclncygjceoff.c[uombchbdojc{ullhclhc
ibmb`jtcdfjbufctglptcygbycT{ouoilnb ltcjxoijndjciljtcnlyctbyothc
ujrzoujmjnytclhcD[FUcU9:44-cBcbnicdbnnlycejcbimoyyjicbtcjxoijndj.c
MdDfjffbniceoffct{jdohojtctjuxodjtcygbycpjujcnlyc{ulxoijicecgotchoum.cOnc
tz{{luyclhcygjcdlnt{oubdcylcijhubzicijhjnibnycotcygjconhfbyjicdgbu`jclhc
)2:9;chluctjuxodjt.cBtcB@YBcdfltjicoytcl{jubyoln&cygjclnfcebtotclhc
dlm{buotlncplzficejcpoygc@OBcygbycdgbu`jtc)07chlucbc`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`.
Bddluion`f&cygjcylybfchjjchluctjxjnc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytctglzficejclnfc
):98cbnicygjcbmlznyclhc)2:9;cdfbomjicecdlm{fbonbnycb{{jbutchubzizfjnyccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc5;
bnic{ullhclhcbyyjm{yjicjwyluyoln.c
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcXO
YgjcDlzuycjuujicecbddj{yon`cybm{juji&cmotfbejfjibniclexolztfchlu`jicjxoijndj.
Ygjcazi`jcpglc`ubnyjicygjcYULcujdztjicizjcylcygjchbdycygbycgotc[uondo{bfc
DlzuycByylunjcpbtcbdrzbonyjicpoygcijhjnibnycecuj{ujtjnyon`cygjc
bixjutbuobfctoijconcbchlumjucbdyoln.cYgjcujdztbfcpbtcybuicbhyjuc
ouuj{bubefjcibmb`jcpbtcilnjcylcijhjnibny.cYgjccluijucylctglpcdbztjc
poygcujrzjtychlucYULcb{{jbutcto`njicecazi`jclnc7,0,;?.
Ygjcdlzuycdlzficnlychonicbncyubntduo{ycujdluiclhcygotc{uldjjion`cbnic
ygjcazi`jctybyjiconcgotcujdlffjdyolncygbyconchbdy&cygjujcpjujcnlcgjbuon`t.c
Ygjujcpjujcdbfjnibucdbfft.cDlzuycbftlctybyjicygbycygjcluijuchlucYULcplzfic
ejcto`njic{jnion`cygjcujyzuncibyj&cTj{yjmejuc29&c5;;?cTjjcUjdluicB95.c
Ygotcubotjtcygjcjygodbfcottzjcygbyc[uondo{bfcDlzuycByylunjcujxojpjic
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
10/39
ildzmjnyc{uj{bubyolntclhcYUL.cDbfjnibucdbffclhc7,0,;?chldztjiclnfcbelzyc
YULcbnicnlclygjucottzjtcpjujciotdzttji.cD[FUc8424ctybyjtcygbycz{lnc
`ubnyon`cbcYUL&cygjcDlzuyctgbffctjycygjcgjbuon`chluc{fjbion`cottzjtcbycygjc
jbufojtycdlnxjnojndj.cYgjchlfflpcz{cdbfjnibucdbffclhc?,29,;?cpbtcbftlclnfc
dlndjunon`cYULcbnicnlclygjucottzjtcpjujciotdzttji.cFbtyc{bub`ub{gclnc
YULcluijucuj`buitcygjc{jutlnbfctjuxodjcz{lncujt{lnijnyctybyjtcygbyctglzficcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc52cejclnclucejhlujcBz`ztyc0&c5;;?cygbycotcxolfbyon`cD[FUcUzfjc8424c'e/c
t{jdohon`cygbyctjuxodjclhcnlyodjcylc[jyoyolncz{lncujt{lnijnyctgbffcejconcygjc
tbmjcmbnnjucbtcbctzmmlntc'tzmmlntcbujcbfpbtctjuxjic{uolucb{{jbubndjc
oncygjcDlzuycylcbfflpcijhjnibnycylc{uj{buj/.cIjhjnibnytcjxoijndjcbelzyc
hlu`jucbnicmotfbejfon`clhcfj`bfcildzmjnytcpbtceulz`gycbtcijhjntjconc
ijhjnibnytcujt{lntjcylcNlyodjclhc[ul{ltjicBdyolnclhcB@concAznjc5;;?cbnic
lexolztfceulz`gycb`boncbycygjcdbfjnibucdbffclhc7,0,;?.cUj{jyoyolnclhccc
`jmlfl`odbfccyjtyon`ccpbtcuzfjicecazi`jcejdbztjcygjc{uombchbdojc
lhc{fbonyohhcpbtcijhjdyoxjcbnicpluygcylcejciotmottjicbycdbfjnibucdbff.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcXOO
B@chbofjicylcjwjudotjcizjciofo`jndjconconxjtyo`byon`cB@YBchluctzemoyyon`chlu`jicbnicmotfbejfjicildzmjnyt.
B@c nlpon`f&cmbfodolztfcbniconyjnyolnbffcztjichubzizfjnycjxoijndjc
dlntotyon`concB@YBc`jmlfl`odbfcuj{luytcygbycpjujcmotfbejfjicbnichlu`ji&conc
{ultjdzyolnclhcijhjnibnycbnict{jdohodbffconcygjcDlzuycb{{jbubndjclhc
7,0,;?.cB@chbofjicylcjwjudotjcizjciofo`jndjconconxjtyo`byon`cB@YBc'{uoluc
ygjouc`lon`clzyclhceztonjttconcAzfc5;;?/chlucottzon`cbfyjujicildzmjnyt.
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcXOOO
B@cdlm{fbonycpbtcxb`zj&couujfjxbny&cdlndfztlucbnictjfh-tjuxon`
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc55cfbd on`cbncmbyjuobfcbimottoefjcjxoijndjcylctz{{luycgotcbffj`byolnt.
YgjcDlzuycpbtceobtjicbnic{ujaziodjicylpbuicijhjnibnycpoygcdlm{fjyjc
iotuj`buiclhctzemoyyjicjwdzf{bylucjxoijndjcbnicxolfbyon`cdlntyoyzyolnbfc
uo`gytclhcygjcijhjnibny.cYgotcfbptzoycotcmjuoyfjttcbycygjcjwyujmjcebtjiclnc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
11/39
dlndldyji&czntzetybnyobyjicluchubzizfjnycjxoijndj.cYgjcglfion`tclhc4c
dlntjdzyoxjcazi`jtcpjujcjuulnjlztconcygjcebtodcujt{jdycygbycbcebujcbffj`byolnc
poyglzyctz{{luyon`cmbyjuobfchbdytcotcontzhhodojny.cBcdlm{fbonycygbycbffj`jtc
hubzicebtjiclnconhjujndjcluo`onbyon`chulmcondluujdycbniciot{zyjichbdytcotc
mjujfcdlndfztlucectybyon`cygbycygjc{fbonyohhcotcjnyoyfjicylcujfojhcznijucygjcc
tzetybnyobfcfbp.cOycotcygjchbdytcbffj`ji&cnlyczn-bffj`jicygbycygjc{fbonyohhcmo`gyc
fbyjuclnc{ulxjcbctz{{luychlucdfbomcylcujfojh.cOycotcnlyc{ul{jucylcbttzmjcygbyc
ygjc{fbonyohhcdbnc{ulxjchbdytcygbycpjujcnlycbffj`ji.cPoftlncxcTdgnjoyfjuc48:c
ZTc472&c474c'2?82/.cDlndfztlucbffj`byolntconcbcdlm{fbony&cohcygjctybnic
bflnjcbujcbcibn`jucto`ncygbycygjc{fbonyohhtcdbtjcotcpjb cbnicotcjn`b`jiconcbc
hotgon`cjw{jioyoln.cTjjcMllujtcHjijubfc[ubdyodjc{bubc58&c98c'2/cbyc58-
298.59&c4uicJioyolnc'5;;4/.
Ygjcdltyclhcfj`bfcijhjntjcotcdlflttbfcbnicbtcoffztyubyjiconcygotcdbtj&cfj`bfc
uj{ujtjnybyolncecijhjnibnytcfbpjucpbtcgo`gjucygbncygjcujtyoyzyoln.c
Oycb{{jbutcygbycygjc{ultjdzyolncpbtchludon`cygjcijhjnibnycylct{jnicfbu`jcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc54cbmlznytclhcmlnjchlucujybonon`cfj`bfcuj{ujtjnybyolncpgjncpbtctzujcygby
ygjcmlnjcplzficejcfltycbnpbcpgjncygjcdlzuytceobtjicijdotolntcylpbuic
ijhjnibnycplzfico`nlujcbniciotuj`buicygjcijhjntjcbnicuzeejuctybm{cB@tc
bffj`byolntcbtcyuzj.
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcOW
[ultjdzyolncdlmmoyyjicletyuzdyolnclhcaztyodjcecmotfjbion`cdlnizdycbnichubzicz{lncygjcDlzuy.
Yoyfjc27&c[buyc2&cDgb{yjuc04&cTjd.c2:2:c'b/c'4/clhcHjijubfcfbpcijhonjtc
motfjbion`cdlnizdy1c'B/.cCnlpon`fcmb on`cbchbftjctybyjmjny3c'Dc/cpoygc
onyjnycylcmotfjbi&c nlpon`fctzemoyyon`cluconxoyon`cujfobndjclncpuoyon`cluc
ujdluion`cygbycotchbftj&chlu`ji&cbfyjujicluclygjucpbtcfbd on`cbncbzygjnyodoy3c
'I/cpoygconyjnycylcmotfjbi&c nlpon`fctzemoyyon`cluconxoyon`cujfobndjclncbc
tbm{fj&ct{jdomjn&cmb{&c{glyl`ub{g&celznibucmbu cluclygjucleajdycygbycotc
motfjbion`concbcmbyjuobfcujt{jdy&cluc'J/c nlpon`fczton`cbcyuod ctdgjmjcluc
ijxodjcpoygconyjnycylcmotfjbi.c
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
12/39
Oncujfbyolntgo{cylcygjchjijubfcfbpcdoyjicbelxjconyjucbfob&cijhjnibnycuj{luytcygjc
{ujtjndjclhcbncbfyjujicildzmjnycztjichluc{ultjdzyolncecB@concgotc[jyoyolnc
'Tjjcbuyodfj1cEzumjtjcabij1cYgjcontduzybefjc`jmconcJwgoeoyc27c{b`jc293c
UjdluicB207&cpgjujcbc{glylcpbtclxju-{uonyjiclxjucyjwycygbycpbtcdfjbufcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc59
jwdzf{bylucylcijhjnibny.cTjjcygjcdfjbujiclefoyjubyjicyjwyconcijhjnibnytc
Uj{fcBhhoumbyolnclhc2;,5,;?c'UjdluicB440//cbnicBntpjucylc[jyoyoln&c{.c:&8.c
'UjdluicB5;7&cB5;?/.cYgjclefoyjubyjicyjwyctybyjtcygjcabijoyj&cygbycotcbc
{ulwjnj&cmbcejcdlm{ltjiclhclygjucmonjubftcbtcbm{goelfjtc'nj{guoyjc
abij/&crzbuyq&cmodb&cjyd.cdlntyoyzjnytclhcbncbimowyzujc{ujtjnyconcygjculd .cTjjc
Jwgoeoyc?clhcijhjnibnytcBntpjucylc[jyoyolncUjdluicB572.cBnlygjuc
mzyofbyolncbnicbfyjubyolnclhcbcfj`bfcildzmjnyctzemoyyjicecB@cpbtc
lefoyjubyolnceclxju{uonyclhcbc{glylclxjucbncjwdzf{byluc{uony.cTjjcJwgoeoyc
27c{c0clhcB@c[jyoyolnc'UjdluicB202/.cYgjcluo`onbfczn-lefoyjubyjic{b`jc
leybonjicecijhjnibnycotcylybffcjwdzf{bylucbnicxoniodbyjtcygjcijhjnibnyclhc
o`nlubnycbnichbftjcdgbu`jt.cOyctglptcygbycabijoyjcabijcotcbculd cpoygcxbuobefjc
dlm{ltoyoln1cHulmcbc`jmlfl`odbfctybni{lonycpgbyciljtcbffcygotcmjbnt
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
13/39
dgbn`jtchulmcygjcluo`onbf.cTjjcD[FUcBuyodfjc9:&cUzfjc9:4?.
Hubzicz{lncygjcDlzuycgbtcejjncijhonjicecygjc0yg.cDlzuyclhcB{{jbfcbtcylc
jmeubdjcygbyct{jdojtclhchulmcpgodgciljt&clucbyyjm{ycylcijhbdjcygjcDlzuyc
oytjfh&clucotcbchubzic{ju{jyzbyjiceclhhodjutclhcygjcDlzuyctlcygbycygjcaziodobfc
mbdgonjucdbncnlyc{juhlumconcygjcztzbfcmbnnjucoytcom{luybnycybt clhc
bialonon`cdbtjtcygbycbujc{ujtjnyjichlucbiaziodbyolncCjnnjcx.cDou.c470cHc4i.c
87?c'2?87/.cMllujtcHjijubfc[ubdyodjc5nicJi.c[.c:25ctjd.c8;.54.cOncEzffld cxc
ZTc084cHc5ci&c222:&c2252&c2;yg.cDou.c'2?7:/cygjcDlzuyctybyji1cHubzicz{lncygjc
Dlzuycotchubzicpgodgcotcioujdyjicylcygjcmbdgonjucoytjfhcbnicotcnlychubzic
ejypjjncygjc{buyojtcluchubzizfjnycildzmjnyt&chbftjctybyjmjnytcluc{juazuOyc
otcpgjncygjcDlzuyclucbcmjmejucotcdluuz{ycluconhfzjndjcotcbyyjm{yjiclucpgjujc
ygjcazi`jcgbtcnlyc{juhlumjicgotcaziodobfchzndyoln-cygztcpgjujcygjcom{luybnyc
hzndyolntclhcygjcDlzuycgbxjcejjncioujdyfcdluuz{yji.
TybyjclhcModgo`bncijhonjtcygjclhhjntjclhczyyjuon`concMDFc0:;.59?1cBncccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc58c
{jutlncpglczyyjutcbnic{zefotgjtcbtcyuzjcbnchbftj&chlu`ji&cbfyjujicluc
dlznyjuhjoycujdlui&cijji&contyuzmjnycluclygjucpuoyon`ct{jdohodbffc nlpon`coyc
ylcejchbftj&cbfyjuji&chlu`jiclucdlznyjuhjoy&cpoygconyjnycylconazujclucijhubzicotc
`zofyclhczyyjuon`cbnic{zefotgon`.c
Ygjczyyjuon`cotcbftlcygjcbdyclhclhhjuon`cbchlu`jicildzmjnycylcbnlygju&cpgjnc
ygjclhhjulucgbtc nlpfji`jcygbycygjcildzmjnycotchlu`ji.cTjjcTybyjcxc
@ujjnfjbhc550cNDc8:2&c8:0&c2:?cTJc5i&c55&c58c'2?87/.cOncygotctzoycygjc
zyyjuon`cpbtcuj{ujtjnyjicec{fbonyohhtcmbfodolzt&conyjnyolnbfcbnicpoffhzfc
lhhjuon`cylcygjcDlzuychlu`jicildzmjnycpoygchzffc nlpfji`jcygbycildzmjnyc
pbtchlu`jicbniczyyjuon`cdlntotyjiconclhhjuon`cylcygjcDlzuyclhchlu`jicbnic
motfbejfjichznibmjnybfcjxoijndjcygbycuj{ujtjnyjicygjc`ulznicz{lncpgodgc
ygjcYULcpbtc`ubnyjicbnicfbyju&c`ubnyon`clhc{jumbnjnyconazndyolncbnic
Azi`mjny.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWc
YgjcDlzuycjuujiconcygjcijdotolnclhcnlycbddj{yon`cijhjnibnytc{fjbion`tcbnicygjcbdy
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
14/39
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
15/39
ezuijnclucjw{ujttcygjujcotcnlcaztyohodbyolnchlucujhzton`cylcbimoycjxoijndjcygbyc
lnjc{buyc{ulxoiji&clncebtjcygbycygjcjxoijndjcpbtcnlyctzemoyyjic{ul{jufcylc
ygjcDlzuy.cYuobfcDlzuycioicnlycdoyjcbncbzygluoyconctz{{luychlucijdotolnclhc
nlycbfflpon`cygjcjxoijndjcylcejcdlntoijujicbnicygbycygjcijhjnibnytcmlyolntc
hluciotmottbfcpjujciotuj`buijichlucnlycejon`ctplun.cOhcygjcildzmjnytc
plzficnlycejctzemoyyjic{ul{juf&cygjchbdychonijucgbicygjclefo`byolncylcujyzunc
ygjcildzmjnytcbnicbt cylcejcuj-tzemoyyjiconcygjc{ul{juchlum.cHbofzujcyl
tzemoycildzmjnytconcygjc{ul{juchlumcotcnlycbchbybfcjuulucygbycbfflptc
bchbdychonijucylc`ubnycbctzmmbucazi`mjnycylcbixjutjc{buycbtcygotcbhhjdytc
gotcom{buyobfoy.cD[FUcBuyodfjc9&cUzfjc9;:-T{jdobfc[uldjjion`tc{ulxoijtc
ygbycdluujdyolnclhcijhjdytclnc{b{jucdlzficejcmbijcecbnc{buycecmlyoln.cc
D[FUcBuyodfjc5;cUzfjc5;;2ct{jdohojtcygbycbycbnctyb`jclhcygjcbdyolnc
Dlzuycmbc{jumoycbcmotyb j&clmottoln&cijhjdyclucouuj`zfbuoycylcejcdluujdyji&c
ohcbctzetybnyobfcuo`gyclhcbc{buycotcnlyc{ujaziodji.cNjxjuygjfjtt&cygjujcpbtcnlccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc5?
juuluconctzemoyyon`cijdfbubyolntconcfojzclhcbhhoibxoy".cElygcazi`jtcygby
luijujicijdotoln&cluiju&cazi`mjnytcb`bontycygjcijhjnibnychbybffc
{ujaziodjicijhjnibnytcuo`gytchlucbchboucyuobfcectz{{ujtton`clucnlycbfflpon`c
jxoijndjcylcejctzemoyyjicbnictzdgcbdytcbujcylcejcdlntoijujicmotdbuuob`jclhc
aztyodj.cJwyujmjceobtcbnic{ujaziodjclhcDlzuycpbtcijmlntyubyjicecbfflpon`c
bchbybfcjuuluclhc{fbonyohhcbtchbofzujcylcbdrzoujcazuotiodyolnclxjucijhjnibnycec
hbofzujcylctjuxodjclhc[jyoyoln.cLncygjclygjuctoij&cygjcDlzuycxolfbyjicygjc
tybyzyjtclhcNjpc_lu cTybyj&cxolfbyjicijhjnibnytcdlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gycec
tz{{ujtton`cjxoijndj&cnlycbfflpon`cijhjnibnycylc{ujtjnycjxoijndjcec
puln`fcijdfbuon`cgotcujt{lntjtcbtcnlyctplunclucnlycbimoyyjiconcygjc
{ul{juchlumcbnicecnlycujt{lnion`chlucmlyolntclhciotmottbfco`nluon`c
ijhjnibnytc{fjbion`cbnicmlyolntchlucbffj`jichlumbfcijhjdy.cOycpbtcnlycygjc
ijhjnibnytcjuulutcluchlumbfcijhjdyt&cezycubygjucygjcDlzuytchbybfcjuulut.
Bhhoibxoycotcbncbnyorzbyjichlumclhcbyyjtyon`cygjcyuzyghzfnjttclhcbctybyjmjnycec
tpjbuon`concpuoyon`cbnicnlybuoqjicecbcnlybuc{zefod.cEfbd tcFbpc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
16/39
Iodyolnbucijhonjtcbhhoumbyolncbtcbctlfjmnchlumbfcijdfbubyolncznijuc{jnbfyc
lhc{juazucygbycbctybyjmjnycotcyuzj&cpoyglzycbnclbyg.cBffcygjcildzmjnytc
tzemoyyjicecijhjnibnycpjujconchlumclhcIjdfbubyoln,Bhhoumbyolncygbycotcfj`bfc
oncNjpc_lu cTybyjcbnicmbnctybyjtcfj`otfbyolncbnicbftlcZT.cHjijubfcDlzuytcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc4;
ygbycbddj{ycijdfbubyolncznijuc{jnbfyclhc{juazuchlucbffcDlzuyc{uldjjion`t.
Yoyfjc57cZTDcTjd.c2098.cZntpluncijdfbubyolntcznijuc{jnbfyclhc{juazuc
dfjbufct{jdohojtcygbycpgjujcbctplunclbyg&cbhhoibxoy&cjydcdlzficejc
tzetduoejicpoygcbnczntpluncijdfbubyolncpoygcygjctbmjchludjcbnicjhhjdy.c
BnlygjucHjijubfcfbp&cYoyfjc4:cZTDcTjd.c5:cbftlc{ulxoijtcygbycbcijdfbubyolnc
oncfojzclhclbygcdlzficejctzetduoejiconcbncontybndjcpgjujcygjclbygcotc
ujrzouji.cLygjucygbncygjcHjijubfcDlzuyt&cmbncTybyjtcondfzion`cPbtgon`yln&c
Luj`ln&cGbpboo&cZybg&cNjxbib&cjyd.cztjcijdfbubyolncznijuc{jnbfyclhc{juazuc
oncfojzclhcbhhoibxoy.cDlntotyjndclhcfldbfcdlzuycuzfjtcotcylcdlnhlumcpoygc
HjijubfcTybyzyjtcbtcotchlzniconc57cZTDcTjdc5;02cygbycHjijubfcFbpcbnic
{ujdjijnycuzfjtclhc{ubdyodjcbnic{uldjizujtcbujcylcyb jc{ujdjijnyclxjucfldbfc
uzfjt.cTz{ujmjcDlzuyclhcZTcbnicbffcdlzuytcjtybefotgjicecygjcBdyclhccc
Dln`ujttcmbc{ujtduoejcuzfjtchlucygjcdlnizdyclhcygjouceztonjtt.cTzdgcuzfjtc
tgbffcejcdlntotyjnycpoygcygjcBdyclhcDln`ujttcbnicygjcjtybefotgjicuzfjtclhc
{ubdyodjcbnic{uldjizujt.c57cZTDcTjdc5;02c{ulxoijtcygbycfldbfcdlzuytcmbc
mb jcfldbfcuzfjt.cGlpjxju&ctzdgcuzfjtcmbcnlycejconcdlnhfodycpoygcBdytclhc
Dln`ujtt.cYgjcuo`gycylchofjcbc[jyoyolncbnicygjcuo`gycylcbntpjucylcygjc[jyoyolnc
{juctjcpoygcmlyolntcondfzijiconcygjcbntpjuc{juctjcbnict{jdohojicbtc
ijdfbubyolncznijuc{jnbfyclhc{juazucotcbcuo`gycylcjntzujcyuzyghzfnjtt.ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc42
Ijnon`cygjcuo`gycylcijhjnicuj{ujtjnytcnlyclnfccbeztjclhciotdujyoln&cezy
dfjbucmotdbuuob`jclhcaztyodj.cEuo``tcxc@lliponc:8?cHc5ic2&c2;c'IDcDou.c
2?00/.cYgotcujhfjdytcygjcdfjbuconyjnyolnclhcygjcDln`ujttcylcjfomonbyjcygjc
ujrzoujmjnytclhclzymlijicnlybuctjbf.cD[FU&cUzfjc2;:c'b/ctybyjtcygbyc
ygjcijhonoyolntconcygotctjdyolncb{{fcylcygjcdoxofc{ubdyodjcfbpcbnicuzfjt.c2;:c
'e/1cbdyolncbnict{jdobfc{uldjjion`t.cYgjcpluiccbdyolncondfzijtcbct{jdobfc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
17/39
{uldjjion`cbnicygjcpluitctzmmlntcbnicdlm{fbonycondfzijcygjcnlyodjc
lhc{jyoyolncbnicygjc{jyoyoln&cujt{jdyoxjf&concbct{jdobfc{uldjjion`.c
2;:c'z/cdfjbufct{jdohojt1cXjuohojic{fjbion`.cBcxjuohojic{fjbion`cmbcejc
zyofoqjicbtcbncbhhoibxoycpgjnjxjucygjcfbyyjucotcujrzouji.
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWO
YgjcDlzuycdlmmoyyjicmotdbuuob`jclhcaztyodjcecjuuluclhco`nluon`cijhjnibnytcmlyolntchluciotmottbfclhcbdyoln.
IjhjnibnytcUjt{lntjcylc[jyoyolncondfzijictlfoicjxoijndjcbtctdojnyohodc
yjwyell tcbnicbuyodfjtconctz{{luyclhcijhjnibnytcijhjntj.cOncgotcUjt{lntj&c
ijhjnibnycmlxjichluciotmottbfclhcbdyolncebtjiclncD[FUcBuyodfjc45&cUzfjc
4522'b/.cMlyolncylciotmottcdbztjclhcbdyoln.c2.cBcijhjntjcotchlznijicz{lnc
ildzmjnybucjxoijndj.cIjhjnibnyctzemoyyjicdl{olztcildzmjnybyolnclhc
tdojnyohodcbuyodfjt&cyjwyell tcbnic{zefodbyolntcygbycijdotoxjfcujhzyjicB@t
hbeuodbyji&chbftjcbffj`byolntcdlm{fjyjfcxloiclhcbncfl`odbfcluctdojnyohodccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc45znijutybnion`clhcygjcmbyyju.cYgjcmlyolncylciotmottcygjcdlm{fbonycec
{ulxoion`cildzmjnybucjxoijndjczyyjufcujhzyjtc{fbonyohhctcbffj`byolnt&c
ygjujecdlndfztoxjfcjtybefotgon`cbcijhjntjcylcygjcbdyolncbtcbcmbyyjuclhcfbp.c
@ltgjncxcMzyzbfcFohjcOntcDlclhcN_&c?7cN_c5i&c429&c458c
'5;;5/.cTdbizubcxcUleoffbuic5:8cBIcc5ic:80c'2??7/.c
U4522c'b/c'0/.cYgjc{fjbion`chboftcylctybyjcbcdbztjclhcbdyoln.c
[jyoyolnjuceulz`gyc5cdbztjtclhcbdyolncoijnyodbfconcdlnyjnycectybyon`c
bddztbyolntcpoyglzyctzetybnyobyolncbnicjwbm{fjtcpgjujcijhjnibnyc
uj{jbyjifcbnic{jutotyjnyfcjn`b`jiconchubzi.cOycfll tcfo jcbcuzeejuctybm{c
lhctybnibuicbddztbyolntcztjiconcbffcdbtjtclhcbffj`jichubzicB@c{ultjdzyjt.c
Njxjuygjfjtt&cB@chboftcylc`oxjcjwbm{fjtcpgjujctzdgconhubdyolntclhcfbpc
lddzuuji.cDlzuyc`ubxjfcjuujicecbddj{yon`ctzdgcebujcbffj`byolntclhchubzic
poyglzyctz{{luyon`chbdytcygbycotcontzhhodojnychluc{fjbion`.cOncfbnimbu cdbtjc
lhc@z``jngjomcx.c@onqezu`&c94cN_c5ic587&c508&c'2?00/&cDlzuycgjficygbyc
pgjncjxoijnyobucmbyjuobfcotcdlntoijuji&cygjcduoyjuobcotcpgjygjucygjc
{ul{lnjnyclhcygjc{fjbion`cgbtcbcdlzutjclhcbdyoln&cnlycpgjygjucgjctybyjiclnj&c
bnicznfjttcoycgbtcejjnctglpncygbycbcmbyjuobfchbdycbtcdfbomjicecygjc{fjbijuc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
18/39
ylcejclnjcotcnlycbchbdycbycbff&cbnicznfjttcoycdbncejctboicygbycnlcto`nohodbnyc
iot{zyjcuj`buion`cjwotyt.ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc44
B@cBhhoumbyolncotcebtjiclncgjbutbc`ulznicbnicfbd clhc nlpfji`j.cYgjc
B@tc nlpfji`jcpbtcbdrzoujichulmcgjbutbcz{lncgjbutbcbnicotcmbonfc
ebtjiclncbttzm{yolnt&condlntotyjnyctzeajdyoxjcl{onolnt&conyjffjdyzbffc
ijhjdyoxjc{b{jutcluc{llucbnichbftjconyju{ujybyolnclhctdojndjcizjcylctgjjuc
o`nlubndjclhcygjctzeajdycbnicbujcbffc{zujcdlndfztlu.cOncdlnyubty&cijhjnibnytc
ijdfbubyolncznijuc{juazucotcebtjiclnc{jutlnbfc nlpfji`jclhcygjchbdytc
'djuybonfcnlycdlndfztlu/cdlntotyon`concbctjuojtclhchbdyzbfctybyjmjnytc
bttjuyon`czndlnyjtyjicjxoijndj&cpjffctzetybnyobyjicecfbp.c
Ylctzuxoxjcbcmlyolncylciotmott&cbcdlm{fbonycmztycdlnybonctzhhodojnychbdyzbfc
mbyyjucbddj{yjicbtcyuzjcylctybyjcbcdfbomcylcujfojhcygbycotc{fbztoefjclncoytchbdj.c
TjjcBtgdulhycxcOrebfc25?cTDy.c2?40c'5;;?/.
OncEjffcByfbnyodcx.cYplmefc2::;cZTc:99&c:::&c250cTDy.c2?::&cDlzuycgjfic
ygbycHbdyzbfcbffj`byolntcmztycejcjnlz`gcylcubotjcbcuo`gycylcujfojhcbelxjcygjc
t{jdzfbyoxjcfjxjf.cHzuygjucmluj1cygjcyjnjycygbycbcDlzuycmztycbddj{ycbtc
yuzjcbffclhcygjcbffj`byolntcdlnybonjiconcygjcdlm{fbonycotconb{{fodbefjcylcfj`bfc
dlndfztolnt.cYgjcygujbiebujcujdoybftclhcygjcjfjmjnytclhcbcdlzutjclhcbdyolnc
tz{{luyjicecmjujcdlndfztolnbuctybyjmjnytcilcnlyctzhhodjcBtgdulhycx.c
Orebfc5?cTDyc2?40&c2?9?&c204cFJi.c5ic787c'5;;?/&cdoyon`cYplmefc::;cZT
byc:::.cBcdlndfztolnbucbffj`byolnciljtcnlyctz{{fchbdytcbijrzbyjcylctglpccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc49c
fj`bfoy.cYgjcDlzuyconcOrebfcujajdyjicygjcbffj`byolntcbtcnlygon`cmlujcygbnc
fj`bfcdlndfztolntcbnicgbicnlculfjcpoygcygjcdlm{fbonytcjnyoyfjmjnycylcujfojh&c
zu`on`cDlzuytcylcjwdfzijchulmcdlntoijubyolnctybyjmjnytcygbycilcnlycujxjbfc
hbdyzbfcibyb&cezycmjujfcdlndfztolntclhcfbpcmbtrzjubion`cbtchbdyt.
D[FUc4522c'b/c'7/c{ulxoijtcygjcDlzuycgbtcnlcazuotiodyolnclhcygjc{jutlnclhc
ygjcijhjnibnycznfjttctjuxji.cB@cnjxjuctjuxjicygjcijhjnibnycpoygcbcnlyodjclhc
[jyoyolncbnicygotcuj{ujtjnyjicbchbybfcjuuluctbndyolnjiceciotmottbfclhc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
19/39
bdyolncnlyclnfconcN_cTybyjtcdlzuyt&cezycbftlcechjijubfcdlzuytcbnicbffc
Tybyjtcdlzuyt.cYgjcdlndj{yclhcnlyodjcotcduoyodbfcylcygjconyj`uoyclhcfj`bfc
{uldjjion`t.cIzjc{uldjttchlueoitcfj`bfcbdyolncb`bontycbc{jutlncznfjttcygjc
{jutlncgbtcejjnc`oxjncnlyodjcbnicbncl{{luyznoycylcejcgjbui.cBnlnjcpglc
pbtcnlyctjuxjicotcnlycelznicecygjcijdotolnconcygjcdbtj.cDlntoijuon`cygjc
eobtjicbnic{ujaziodjicdlzuy&cijhjnibnycdlntoijujicygbycdlzficnlycyb jcygjc
uot clhcijhbzfycecnlcb{{jbubndjconcygjcDlzuy.
D[FUc4522c'b/c'2;/.cYgjcDlzuyctglzficnlyc{uldjjiconcygjcbetjndjclhcbc
{jutlncpglctglzficejcbc{buy.cIjhjnibnycotcjnyoyfjicznijuc8yg.cBmjnimjnyc
lhcZTDcylcejcdlnhulnyjicpoygcygjcpoynjttcb`bontycgomcbnicdulttcjwbmonj.c
Ygjcpoynjttcotcygjc{jutlncpglcdlnt{oujicylcijhubzi&cjwyluycmlnjcbnicdbztj
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc{gtodbfcbnicjmlyolnbfcgbum&cijhbmbyolnclhcdgbubdyjucbnicujd fjttc
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc4:iotuj`buiclhcygjcyuzyghzfnjttclhcygjcmbyyju.
ZnijucD[FUc4522'd/&cijhjnibnycmlxjichluciotmottbfclhcbdyolnconcygjc
Bntpjucylc[jyoyolncezycygjcmlyolncpbtco`nlujicbnicnlycbntpjujicecygjc
Dlzuyconcxolfbyolnclhcfbpcbnicuj{ujtjnyjicmotdbuuob`jclhcaztyodj.cBddluion`c
ylcygotc{bub`ub{g&cbcmlyolncylciotmottcjndfltjiconcygjcijhjnibnycbntpjucpbtc
tz{{ltjicylcejcyujbyjicbtcbcmlyolnchluctzmmbucazi`mjnycbnicbcgjbuon`chluc
ygjcmlyolncpbtctz{{ltjicylcejctjycz{.cYgotcpbtcnjxjucilnjcbnicuj{ujtjnytc
bnlygjucchbybfcjuulucdlmmoyyjicecygjcDlzuy.cc
Ijhjnibnycmlxjicb`bonchluciotmottbfcbtcbfflpjiconcD[FUc4522c'j/cec
mlyolncylc{fjbiclxjucbniciotmottbfclhcbdyolncebtjiclncygjcujtzfytclhc@OBc
ygbycdlndfztoxjfcujhzyjicB@YBchonion`tcijtyulon`c{fbonyohhtc{uombchbdoj3c
glpjxjucygjcDlzuycioicnlycujt{lnicylcijhjnibnytcmlyolnt.cHbofzujcylctjuxjc
ygjc[jyoyolncecygjc{fbonyohhcotcnlycbcmjujcijhjdycecnlyctjuxon`cygjcnlyodjcc
{ul{jufcygbycdlzficejcuj{bouji&cubygjucbchbybfcjuulucygbycijmbnitcxbdbyzuclhc
ygjcfbptzoycbtcnlcnlyodjcpbtctjuxjicbycbff.c
D[FUc4522c'`/.cOncgotcmlyolnchluciotmottbf&cijhjnibnycgbtcijmlntyubyjic
ygbycygjcbdyolnctzeajdycylcygjcmlyolncotcbncbdyolnconxlfxon`c{zefodc{jyoyolnc
bnicijmlntyubyjicmbfodjcecygjc{fbonyohhcbtctglpnconcBuyodfjc0cUzfjc08cBclhc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
20/39
ygjcDoxofcUo`gytcFbp.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc48c
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWOOcc
Ygjc{ultjdzylucdlmmoyyjicdlnyjm{yclhcDlzuycecujfjbton`cylcmjiobcmbyjuobfcygbycdujbyjictzetybnyobfcuot cylcbhhjdycygjcDlzuyc{uldjjion`t.
[zefodbyolnclhcmbyjuobfcijjmjicfo jfcylcajl{buioqjcbchboucyuobfcuj{ujtjnytc
dlnyjm{yclhcDlzuy.cZnijucygjcdlnyjm{yclhcDlzuycBdyc2?72&coycotcbcduomonbfc
dlnyjm{yclhcDlzuycylc{zefotgcbnygon`cygbycpgodgcdujbyjtcbcujbfcuot cygbycygjc
dbztjclhcaztyodjconc{uldjjion`tcmbcejctjuolztfcom{bouji.cOycb{{fojtclnfc
pgjnc{uldjjion`tcbujcbdyoxjcbnic{ujxjnytcygjcnjpt{b{jutcbnicmjiobchulmc
{zefotgon`cmbyjuobfcyllcjwyujmjcluctjntbyolnbfcznyofcygjcyuobfcotclxju.cTjdyolnc
5clhcygjcBdyct{jdohojtcfbpcb{{fojtcpgjnc{zefotgon`clhcmbyjuobfcdujbyjtcbc
tzetybnyobfcuot clhctjuolztc{ujaziodjcylcbcyuobf.cYgjcujfjbtjcylcmjiobcecB@clnc
2;,29,;?ctzetybnyobffcbhhjdyjicygjcDlzuyc{uldjjion`cbnicijhbmjicygjc
ijhjnibnycecmbfodolztchbftjctybyjmjnyt&cztjclhchlu`jicbnicmotfbejfjicfj`bfc
jxoijndj&chbeuodbyjichbftjcjxoijndjcbnicbdrzouon`chbftjcpoynjttctybyjmjnyt.c
Tomofbucdbtjtclhc{ultjdzyluobfcmotdlnizdycbujchlzniconcdlmmlncfbp.cTjjc
MoftyjoncxcDllfjc5:0cHc4ic2;;9c'?yg.cDouc5;;2/concpgodgcbcduomonbfcijhjntjc
byylunjctzjicznijucYoyfjc95cZTDcTjdc2?74chlucizjc{uldjttcxolfbyolntcbnic
mbfodolztc{ultjdzyoln.cYgotcfbnimbu cdbtjcjtybefotgjicygjcildyuonjcygbycygjc
{ultjdzylutcbdytcpgjncnlycilnjconcygjouculfjcbtcbixldbyjtcbujcnlyctgojfijic
ecbetlfzyjcommznoy.cMoftyjoncdlm{fbonycbffj`jicijybofjicijhbmbylucccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc40tybyjmjnytcmbijcecIBcylcygjc{ujtt.cFomoyjicbxbofbeofoyclhcbetlfzyjc
ommznoycotconiodbyjiconcEzd fjcx.cHoyqommlntc:;?cZTcbyc585&c584&c50:&c
508c224cTDy.c58;8c'2??4/&cYgjc{fbonyohhconcEzd fjcgbicbftlcbttjuyjicbc
dfbomcebtjicz{lnchbftjctybyjmjnytcmbijcylc{ujtt.cYgjcDlzuycujhztjicylc`ubnyc
betlfzyjcommznoycylcygjc{ultjdzylucebtjiclncygjchbdycygbycdlmmjnytcylcygjc
{ujttcgbxjcnlchbdyzbfcyojtcpoygcygjcaziodobfc{uldjttcaztycejdbztjcygjcbujc
mbijcecbc{ultjdzylu.cOicbyc500&c224&cTDy.cc58;8.
Oncyplcujfjbtjtcylcmjiob&choutyclncLdylejuc2;&c5;;?cbnictjdlniclnc
Nlxjmejuc2;&c5;;?&cB@cmbijchbftjcmbfodolztctybyjmjnytcpoygcdfjbuconyjnyc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
21/39
ylcdbztjcgbumcylcygjcijhjnibny.cCnlpon`fcbniconyjnyolnbff&cB@cujfjbtjic
hbftjctybyjmjnytcpgjncygjc{fbonyohhc njpcygbycygjcbffj`byolntcbujcnlycyuzjcbt1c
MoudjbcXjfjbnzctlficbuyohbdytclnfonjcdfbomon`cygbycygjcdlnybonjicgo`gc
rzbfoycbnicjw{jntoxjcabij&cpgjncygjcbdyzbffcpjujcmbijclhcrzbuyqcluc`fbtt.c
Gjcygjncujhztjicylc{ulxoijcujhznitclucbd nlpfji`jcygbycygjc{ojdjtcpjujc
hb j.cYgjcbelxjcbffj`byolntcdfjbufctybyjcpoygcbzygluoycygbycygjcoyjmtc
bdyzbffcpjujcmotuj{ujtjnyjicpgjncygjujcpbtcnlcleajdyoxjc{ullhcylctz{{luyc
tzdgcbffj`byolnt.cBnlygjuctybyjmjnycygbyctglptc{jutotyjndjconcdfbomon`c
hbftoyclhcbncbffj`byolncygbycpbtc{uolucbetlfzyjfczn-{ulxjicectdojnyohod
jxoijndjcot1ccXjfjbnztlficyplctyuon`tclhcabijcYoejybnc{ubjucejbitcmbfbtcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc47
'tod/cylcbcdlntzmju&clnjclhcpgodgcgjchbftjfcdfbomjicpbtcmbijclhchjocytzoc
abij&cbncjwyujmjfcxbfzbefjcbnicgo`gcrzbfoycy{jclhcabij.cO`nlubnyf&cbnic
{jutotyjnyf&cijt{oyjcygjcjxoijndjcylcdlnyubu&cdlm{fbonbnycbnicB@cdfbomjic
ygbychjocytzocmjbntcom{juobfcabij.cYgjcjxoijndjctglpjiconcygjcbntpjucylcygjc
[jyoyolnctglpjicijdotoxjfcygbychjocytzoconcDgonjtjcmjbntcabijoyj.cYgjcgo`gfc
ijhbmbyluctybyjmjnytcbt1cGjcdbffjiccgomtjfhcbncbnyorzjcijbfjucezycgjcujbffc
ijbfyconcfojtcbnicijdjoyctboicByylunjc@jnjubfcDzlml.cHzuygju1cYgotc
onioxoizbfc{ujjiclncdlffjdylutclhcjw{jntoxjcbnyorzjtcbnicbuyohbdytcbnic
ioinycijfoxjuclncgotc{[email protected]
hbftoyclhcygjc{zefodbyolncotcjttjnyobfcylcujnijucbc{zefodbyolncbcfoejfcijhonjic
btcbnc{zefodbyolnconazuolztcylcygjcuj{zybyolnclhcbnlygju&conazujcbc{jutlnconc
gotceztonjttcluclddz{byoln&clucjw{ujttcgomcylc{zefodcgbyuji&cdlnyjm{y&c
uoiodzfjcluciot`ubdj.cEju`tyulmcxcUoi`pbcYgbjucDl.&c2;4cN_cTz{{&c2;?4&c
2;?9&c:4cMotd.cUj{.c?:.cOycotcfoejflztc{juctjcylcdgbu`jcbc{jutlncpoygcezycbc
ton`fjcdlmmottolnclhcbncbdy&cohcygjcbdycoytjfhcbmlznytcylclucom{luytcmlubfc
ijfonrzjndcluciotuj{zybefjcdlnizdy.cDgzudgcxcYuoeznjcBttnc22?cN_cTz{{c
77:&c778&c24:cB{{.cIox.c4;.
Ygjcjxofconyjnyolncbnicujd fjttnjttciotuj`buicylcygjcyuzygcdgbubdyjuoqjtcB@c
onyjnyolncylcijtyulcygjcuj{zybyolncbnicijhbmon`cygjcdgbubdyjuclhcygjcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc4?
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
22/39
ijhjnibnycbddzton`cgomclhcduomjtcygbycgjcioicnlycdlmmoy.cIjhjnibnytc
{fjbion`chluconnldjndjcebtjiclncondlnyulxjuyoefjcjxoijndjcpbtcdlm{fjyjfc
o`nlujicecTz{ujmjcDlzuyclhcIzydgjttcDlzny&cluciotdbuijiclncebtjclhc
hbeuodbyjicyjdgnodbfcjuulutcygbycjxjncohcdlzficjwoty&cplzficejcdluujdyjicbtc
ejon`cbcmjuoyluolztcdbtj.cUjfjbtjtcylcmjiobcpjujcnlyclnfcmbfodolztfcmbijc
ylconazujcygjcuj{zybyolnclhcijhjnibny&cezycpjujc{zu{ltjfcilnjcbtcbc
dlnijmnbyolncbnicxofohodbyolnclhcygjcijhjnibnycpoygconyjnyolncylcejc
tzetjrzjnyfcztjicbtcbcildzmjnycylctlfodoycdztylmjutcygbycelz`gycabijchulmc
ijhjnibnycylcujrzjtycujhznit.cBddluion`cylcdlmmlncfbp&cB@cbimonotyubyoxjc
hzndyolnclzytoijclhcygjcDlzuyc{uldjjion`tcbnicdlntotyon`concujfjbton`cylc
mjiobconhfbmmbylucbnichbftjctybyjmjnytciljtcnlycrzbfohcgomclhcbetlfzyjc
ommznoy.cRzbfohojicommznoycpgodgctgojfitc`lxjunmjnytclhhodjutchulmc
fobeofoychlucdoxofcibmb`jtcontlhbucbtcygjoucdlnizdyciljtcnlycxolfbyjcdfjbufc
jtybefotgjictybyzyluclucdlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gytcTjjcGbuflpcxcHoyq`jubfic9:0c
ZTc7;;&c727&c2;5cTDy.c5054&c04cFjic5i.c4?8c'2?75/.cOncGbuymbncxcMllujc
:90cZTc5:;&c258cTDy.c28?:&c289cFjic5ic992c'5;;8/&cygjcDlzuycujxojpjicbnc
onyjufldzylucijdotolncijnon`crzbfohojicommznoy.cYgjcfj`bfcottzjcijdoijic
oncGbuymbncdlndjunjicygjcjfjmjnytcbc{fbonyohhcmztyc{fjbicbnic{ulxjconcluiju
ylcpon.cB@cxolfbyjicN_cIUc0-2;0c'B/cuj`buion`cygjcyuobfc{zefodoy1cBcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc9;c
fbpjuc{buyodo{byon`conclucbttldobyjicpoygcbcduomonbfclucdoxofcmbyyjuctgbffcnlyc
mb jcbncjwyubcaziodobfctybyjmjny..cOhcygjcfbpjuc nlptclucujbtlnbefctglzfic
nlpcygbycoycpoffcgbxjcbctzetybnyobfcfo jfoglliclhcmbyjuobffc{ujaziodon`cbnc
biaziodbyoxjc{uldjjion`.cB@cbftlcxolfbyjicN_cJDc0-441cygjcujfjbtjcecbc
fbpjuclhclzy-lh-dlzuyctybyjmjnytcuj`buion`cbncbnyodo{byjicluc{jnion`cyuobfc
mbcom{ul{jufcbhhjdycygjcom{buyobfoyclhcygjcyuoeznbf.
B@cxolfbyjicBuyodfjc52&cU52;4-BcDlnhoijnyobfoyclhcbiiujttjtconcdoxofc
{uldjjion`t.c
Oncygjcyplcujfjbtjtcylcmjiob&cB@cujxjbfjic{uoxbyjcbiiujttjtclhcygjcijhjnibnyc
bniciotdfltzujclhctzdgcbiiujttjtc{ltjicbncznujbtlnbefjcuot cylcygjcgjbfygc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
23/39
bnictbhjyclhcijhjnibny.cUjfjbtjcylcmjiobclhcNlxjmejuc2;&c5;;?&cB@c
bnnlzndjicygbycgotclhhodjcplncbcfbptzoycb`bontycygjcijhjnibny.cGlpjxju&cygjc
ijdotoln,luiju,azi`mjnyclhcAzi`jcYglmbtcIlfbncpbtcibyjicbnicto`njiclnc
Nlxjmejuc29&c5;;?.cYgotcotcbnconiodbyolncbnicjxoijndjcygbycB@cgbicjwc
{buyjcdlmmznodbyolncpoygcygjcazi`jc9cibtc{uolucygjcazi`mjnycto`non`cbnic
bddluion`f&cygjcijdotoln,luiju,azi`mjnyctglzficejcdlntoijujicxloi.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWOOO
B@cxolfbyjicygjc`b`cluijuclncmjiobcom{ltjicecygjcDlzuy.
OncygjcujfjbtjcylcmjiobclhcLdylejuc2:&c5;;?&cB@cxolfbyjicygjc`b`clncmjiobccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc92c
ujfjbtjcuj`buion`conhlumbyolnc{juyonjnycylcYUL.cYgjchlfflpon`ctjnyjndjcot
to`nohodbny1cYgjcByylunjc@jnjubfcfbptzoyctjj tcylc{jumbnjnyfcebuc
Xjfjbnzchulmctjffon`cbuyohbdytcznfjttcygjcdbncejcxjuohojicbtcbzygjnyodcbnic
leyboncujtyoyzyolnchlucdlntzmjutcgjcijhubziji&c{fztc{jnbfyojtcbnicdltytcylcygjc
tybyj.cYgotctjnyjndjcbtcgjcotcujhjuuon`cylcYUL&cto`nohojtcygbycB@conyjnitcylc
leybonchulmcbcyjm{lubucujfojhcluiju&cbc{jumbnjnyconazndyoln.
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWOX
YgjcDlzuycgbtcnlcyjuuoyluobfcazuotiodyolnclhcygotcmbyyju.cTybujcijdototcotcygjc{lfodclhcygjcDlzuytcylctybnicec{ujdjijnycbnicygjcdbtjctglzficejcujxjutji.c
Tz{juctybujcijdototcotcygjcyjumcztjichlucom{luybnyc{ujdjijnycfj`bfcdbtjtcygbyc
bujcujtotybnyclucommznjclhcejon`clxjuygulpn.cTjjcFbnijt&cPoffobmc(c
[ltnju&cUodgbui1cFj`bfc{ujdjijny1cBcygjlujyodbfcbnicjm{ouodbfcbnbftot.c2?c
AlzunbfclhcFbpcbnicjdlnlmodtc59?&c5:2c'2?08/&cTybujcijdototcjntzujtc
djuybonycbnicdlntotyjndconcygjcb{{fodbyolnclhcfbp.cJwotyon`ceonion`c
{ujdjijnytchulmcygjc{btycb{{fojtconc{uondo{fjcylcnjpctoyzbyolntcecbnbfl`.cc
Onctz{juctybujcijdototcfbnimbu cdbtjclhc@ltgjncxcMzycFohjcOntcDlclhcN_&c
?7cN_c5ic429&c498&cN_Tc5ic7:7c'5;;5/cotconiodbyjicygbycN_TcB@cotc
bfflpjiceulbicjnhludjmjnyc{lpjutcznijucygjctybyzyjc@jnjubfcEztonjttcFbpc
Tjdc49?.c[fbonyohhconc@ltgjncdlndjijtcygbycgjcfoxjtconcHfluoib&c{zudgbtjicgotcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc95
ontzubndjc{lfodconcHfluoibcygulz`gcbcHfluoibcontzubndjcb`jnd.cHluc{zu{ltjc
lhcFbpc49?cbncijdj{yolncyll c{fbdjconcHfluoib&cnlycNjpc_lu .ccYgjcDlzuyc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
24/39
lhcB{{jbftclhcN_cgjficygbycygjctybyzyjtconyjnycotcylc{ulyjdycN_cTybyjc
dlntzmjutconcygjoucyubntbdyolntcygbycyb jc{fbdjconcN_cTybyj.cOycpbtcnlyc
onyjnijicylc{lfodjcygjclzy-lh-tybyjcyubntbdyolntclhcNjpc_lu cdlm{bnojt&cnluc
pbtcoyconyjnijicylchzndyolncbtcbc{juctjcebucylclzy-lh-tybyjc{fbonyohhtcdfbomtclhc
ijdj{yoxjcbdytcfjbion`cylcyubntbdyolntcpoygoncygjctybyj.
Oncbnlygjuctz{juctybujcijdotot&cfbnimbu cdbtjclhcdlmmlncfbp&cTdlyycxcEjffc
ByfbnyodcDlu{c575cN_c5ic27;&c058c'5;;2/&cTdlyycbniclygjuc{fbonyohhtctlz`gyc
ujfojhchlucbdytcygjcbffj`jicpjujcijdjoxon`.cDlzuyclhcB{{jbftclhcN_cgjficygbyc
lzy-lh-tybyjc{fbonyohhtcpjujcnlycjfo`oefjcylctjj cujfojhconcN_cTybyjcbtcygjouc
dlm{fbonyciljtcnlyctybyjcbncdl`noqbefjcdbztjclhcbdyoln.cBtcylcN_cTybyjc
{fbonyohht&cglpjxju&cygjcbffj`byolntcpjujctzhhodojnycylcpoygtybnicbcD[FUc
4522'b/'0/cdgbffjn`j.
Oncygotcfbptzoy&ccygjcdlm{fbonbnycotcnlycbcujtoijnyclhcN_cTybyj&
foxjtconcDlnnjdyodzy&c{boicbffcgjuc{zudgbtjtcygulz`gc[b{bf&cbcdlm{bnc
fldbyjiconcDbfohlunob&cbnicbdrzoujicbffcgjuc{zudgbtjtconcPontyji&c
[email protected]&cdlm{bncfldbyjiconcLgol&c
luc{zudgbtjichulmcLeajytcIBuycZnorzjt&cpgltjcpjetoyjcotcmbonybonji&ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc94
{[email protected]`cylc
dlmmlnccfbpc{ujdjijny&cygjcdlm{fbonbnycotcnlycjnyoyfjicylctjj cujtyoyzyolnc
bnicujfojhcznijucygjcfbpclhcN_cTybyjcznijuc@EFc49?&c4:;.c
Tomofbuf&cygjcygujjcdztylmjutcpglcbt jichlucbcujhznicbtcbcujtzfyclhcB@c
tlfodoybyolncluconxjtyo`byolncbujcnlycjfo`oefjchlucujfojhcznijuc@EFc49?&c4:;cbtc
bffcygujjcbujcnlycujtoijnytclhcN_cTybyjcbnicelz`gycygjoucabijcbycbzdyolntcgjfic
ec@lBnyorzjt.dlmcfldbyjiconcLgolcbnicpgjujcygjcijhjnibnycpbtclnfcbc
dlnto`nlucbnicnlycbctjffju.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWX
Ygotcfbptzoyciljtcnlycrzbfohcylcejcjfo`oefjcznijucJwjdzyoxjcFbpc84'25/cygbyc{ulgoeoytc{jutlntchulmcjn`b`on`concuj{jbyjicluc{jutotyjnychubziclucoffj`bfoyconcygjcdlnizdyclhcbnceztonjttconcNjpc_lu cbnicygjcdbtjctglzficejcujxjutji.cc.cYgotcfbptzoyciljtcnlychzfhoffcygjcujrzotoyjtclhcJwjdzyoxjcfbpc84'25/cygbyc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
25/39
ijhonjtcuj{jbyjicbtcuj{jyoyolnclhchubzizfjnyclucoffj`bfcbdytclucdlnizdyc
pgodgcbhhjdytcmlujcygbnclnjc{jutln.cYgjcdlmmlncfbpc{ujdjijnyctybnibuicylc
ejcb{{fojicotcygjcfbnimbu cdbtjclhcPofdlcpgjujcygjcDlzuycgjficygby1c
JwjdzyoxjcfbpcTjd.c84c'25/cijhonjtcuj{jbyjicbtcuj{jyoyolnclhcbnctj{bubyjc
bniciotyondychubzizfjnyclucoffj`bfcbdy&clucdlnizdycpgodgcbhhjdytcmlujcygbnclnjc
{jutln.cDfjbufcPofdltcdlnizdycpbtcuj{jbyjicpoygoncygjcmjbnon`clhcygjc
tybyzyjcbtcoycbhhjdyjicnzmjulztconioxoizbft.cTjjcTybyjcxcPofdlcJnju`ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc99cDl.579cBIc5ic98?c'5;;2/.cYgjcdztylmjutcujrzjtyon`cbcujhznicioicnlycdfbomc
ygbycpjujcijhubziji.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWXO
Dlzuycjuujiconcnlyciotmotton`cbncbebnilnjicijdotolncbnicazi`mjnycygbycpbtcnlychoffjicbnicujdluijicpoygonc8;cibtcbhyjucijdotoln.cB@cxolfbyjicygjcdlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gytclhcygjcijhjnibnychlucbct{jjicbnichboucyuobfcznijuc8yg.cBmjnimjnyclhcZTD.c
Ijdotoln,Luiju,Azi`mjnyclhcAzi`jcIlfbncibyjicNlxjmejuc29&c5;;?c
hlfflpon`cbcejndgcyuobfcpbtcnjxjucjnyjujicbnicbddluion`cylcN_DcDUUc
5;5.97cotcdlntoijujicylcejcbebnilnji.cYgjcyomjcfomoybyolnchlucygjc
tzemottolnclhcAzi`mjnyclucLuijucdlnybonjiconcN_DUUc5;5.97cotct{jdohojic
btc8;cibt.cBhyjucbfmltyc2;cmlnygtchulmcygjcijdotoln,azi`mjnyclhc22,29,;?&c
ygjc{fbonyohhctzemoyyjicbc{ul{ltjicazi`mjnycygbycpbtcto`njicecbciohhjujnyc
azi`jclnc?,5?,2;.cBtcygjcnjpcazi`jcto`njicbcdlm{fjyjfciohhjujnyc
Ijdotoln,Luiju,Azi`mjnycbnicygjchoutycIjdotoln,Luiju,Azi`mjnycpbtc
bebnilnji&coycb{{jbutcygbycygjcfj`bfcbdyolncbtcbcnjpcfbptzoycpbtcnjxjuc
tybuyjicpoygcygjcfj`bfc{uldjizujtconxlfxon`cpoygcnjpctzoy.cOncbiioyoln&cAzi`jc
IlfbntcIjdotoln,Luiju,Azi`mjnyclhcNlxjmejuc29&c5;;?cpbtcnjxjuctjuxjic
ylcygjcijhjnibny.c
Ygjcijfbconchbofzujcylc{ultjdzyjclhc{fbonyohhcxolfbyjicdlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gytclh
c
ygjcijhjnibnychlucbchboucbnict{jjicyuobfcznijuc8yg.cbmjnimjnyclhcZTD.cBffccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc9:cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc{uldjjion`tclhcygotcfbptzoycpjujcgjficoncygjcazi`jtcdgbmejut&clygjucygbnc
houtyc5cdbfjnibucdbfftchlucygjcYUL.cIjt{oyjcygbyc9ctzddjttoxjcazi`jtcpjujc
btto`njicylcygotcdbtj&cOcnjxjuctbpcbncazi`jclygjucygbncygjchoutycazi`jcpglc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
26/39
`ubnyjicygjcYULcbnicijdotoln,luijucazi`mjnycotcbcxolfbyolnclhcD[FUc:0;9.c
YgjcDlzuycioicnlycjwjudotjcoytciotdujyolnceciotmotton`cygjcbdyolncbtc
bebnilnjicizjcylcygjcfbu`jconyjuxbfclhcyomjctondjcygjchoutycazi`mjnycznyofcygjc
jnyuclhctjdlnicazi`mjny.cBhyjucujyoujmjnyclhcAzi`jcIlfbn&cbnlygjucazi`jc
pbtcbtto`njicbnicb{{bujnyfcijdfonjicygjcbtto`nmjny.cHonbff&cazi`jc
[b`lnjtcpbtcbtto`njicylcygotcilumbnycdbtj.cOycb{{jbutcygbycohcbcdbtjcotc
bebnilnji&cbcnjpcbdyolnctglzfictybuychulmcygjcej`onnon`cbtcbcnjpcdbtj.cTjjc
D[FUcU555;c'b/cbnicD[FUcU552?'b/.cAzi`jcIlfbncnjxjucioujdyjicylc
tzemoycluctjyyfjcygjcdbtjcbhyjucygjcnj`lyobyolntchluctjyyfjmjnychbofji.cYgjc
{ujdjijnyclhc9yg.cIoxotolnclhcN_TcTz{ujmjcDlzuycgjficygbycygjc8;cibtcuzfjc
otcb{{fodbefjcjxjncpgjncygjujcotcnlcioujdyoxjcylctzemoycluctjyyfjcygjcluijucluc
azi`mjny.cBffcotcujrzoujicotcylcjnyjucazi`mjnycznijucdlzuytcmlyoln.cTjjc
God tlncx.c@buinjuc249cBIc5ic?4;&c?42.cPgjncygjcDlzuytcijdotolnc
jw{ujttfcioujdytcbc{buycylctzemoycluctjyyfjcbncluijuclucazi`mjny&cygjcDlzuyc
ioujdytcygjc{ujxbofon`c{buycylciubpcygjcluijucbnic{ujtjnycoycylcygjcazi`jchluc
to`nbyzuj.cTjjcToj`jfc[ubdyodjcDlmmjnybuojtcMdConnjtcDlntcFbptclhcN_ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc98cell c0cEcD[FUc555;.9cbyc20;.cHbofzujcecygjc{ujxbofon`c{buycylc
jw{jioyolztfctzemoycazi`mjnychlucjnyucdbuuojtcoytclpnctbndyolntcondfzion`c
ygjc{ulebeofoycylcjwjdzyjcygjcazi`mjny.
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWXOO
Ygjcdlzuycxolfbyjicijhjnibnytcuo`gytcznijuc29yg.cBmjnimjny&c8yg.c&c0yg.c&cbnic7yg.cBmjnimjnyclhcZTcDlntyoyzyoln.c
Uo`gycylcdlnhulnycbcpoynjttcb`bontycijhjnibny&cdulttcjwbmonjcgom&cuo`gycylc
ejcazi`jicecbncom{buyobfcazucbnicejconhlumjicbelzycygjcnbyzujcbnicdbztjc
lhcygjccbddztbyolntcpjujcxolfbyjicecygjcDlzuy.c29yg.cBmjnimjnycygbycnluc
tgbffcbncTybyjcij{uoxjcbnc{jutlnclhcfohj&cfoejuycluc{ul{juycpoyglzycizjc
{uldjttclhcfbp&cnlucygjcjrzbfc{ulyjdyolnclhcfbpcpbtcxolfbyjicbycbfmltycjxjuc
tyb`jclhcygotcfbptzoy.cHjijubfcfj`otfbyolncpbtcjnbdyjiconc2702cbnicygjcmltyc
om{luybnyc{ulxotolncotc95cZTDcTjdc2?74cygbycmbijcjrzoybefjcujfojhcbxbofbefjc
ylcygltjcpgltjcdlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gytcgbicejjncxolfbyjicecbncbdylucbdyon`c
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
27/39
znijucTybyjcbzygluoy.c5cfbnimbu cdlzuycijdotolnc`bxjcujmjiojtcylc{buyojtc
ij{uoxjiclhcdlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gyt&conxlfxon`c{uoxofj`jtcbnicommznoyojtclhcbnc
lhhodjucbeztjclhcgotc{ltoyolncznijuctjdyolnc2?741cMlnuljcxc[b{jc48:cZTc
280c'2?82/cbnicMlnjffcxcIj{y.clhcTldobfcTjuxodjtclhcDoyclhcN_c948cZTc
8:7c'2?0;/.cYgjcmotztjclhc{lpjucmbijc{lttoefjcejdbztjcygjcpuln`iljucotc
dflygjicpoygcygjcbzygluoyclhctybyjcfbpcbnicotcbdyon`cznijucygjcdlfluclhctybyjccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc90ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccfbp.cTjjcZTcxcDfbttodc424cZTc5??&cbftlcTdujpcxcZTc45:cZTc?2&c{{c274&c
270.cTjdyolnc2?clhcygjcduomonbfcdlijc1cmb on`cbcduomjcylcdlnt{ouj&cylc
onazujclucl{{ujttcbncdoyoqjnconcygjchbdjclhcjwjudotjclhcbncuo`gycbnic
{uoxofj`jctjdzujicylcgomcecygjcDlntyoyzyoln.cZTDcznijucYoyfjc27&cTjdyolnc
5;conxlfxjtcygjcij{uoxbyolnclhcygjcuo`gycylcjrzbfc{ulyjdyolnclhcygjcfbptc
`zbubnyjjicecygjc29yg.cBmjnimjnyclhcZTD.cZnijucYoyfjc27c[buyc2cDuomjt&c
Dgb{yjuc0?c[juazucTjdc28541cHbftjcijdfbubyolncejhlujc`ubnicazuclucDlzuyc
{ulxoijtcygbycpgljxjucznijuclbygcluconcbncijdfbubyolntybyjmjnycznijuc
{jnbfyclhc{juazucbtc{jumoyyjicznijucTjdc2098clhcYoyfjc57clhcZTcdlijconcbnc
{uldjjion`tcejhlujcbncDlzuyc nlpon`fcmb jtcbnchbftjcmbyjuobfc
ijdfbubyolnclucmbyyjuclucztjtcbnclhcygjconhlumbyoln&condfzion`cbncell &c
{b{ju&cildzmjny&cujdlui&cujdluion`clucbnclygjucmbyjuobf&c nlpon`cygjctbmjc
ylcdlnyboncbnchbftjcmbyjuobfcijdfbubyolnctgbffcejchonjicznijucygotcYoyfjcluc
om{uotlnjicnlycmlujcygbnc:cjbutclucelyg.
Ijhjnibnycjtybefotgjicygjc{uombchbdojcznijuc95cZTDcTjdc2?74cec{ulxon`c
ygby1c2.cYgjcbdyolnclddzuujicznijucdlfluclhcfbpcbni&c5&cYgjcbdyolntcpjujc
ij{uoxbyolntclhcdlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gytcbni,luchjijubfctybyzylucuo`gyt.cBnc
Tybyjcbdyolncijyuomjnybfcylcygjcijhjnibnycznijuc29yg.cBmjnimjnycotcbdyolncccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc97
znijucdlfluclhcfbp.cMbuyoncB.cTdgpbuyqc(cAlgncJ.cCou fonc2cBcTjdyolnc2?74.
cFoyo`byoln&cDfbomtcbnicijhjujndjtc{bubc:&c2;cbyc:5;c4ui.cJioyolnc2??0.c
Tz{ujmjcDlzuycgbicijyjumonjicygbycTybyjcbdyolncotc{ujtjnycpgjncazi`jtcbujc
bt jicylcjnhludjclucbzygluoqjcbciotduomonbyluc{[email protected]
Jimlnitlncx.cFjjtxoffjcDlndujyjcDl.c:;;cZTc829&c850&c857c'2??2/3cTgjffjc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
28/39
xcCubmjuc2449cZTc2&c55&c54c'2?97/.cOncelygcygjtjcdbtjtcygjcDlzuyc
ujdl`noqjicygbycygjciotduomonbyolncplzficnlycejc{lttoefjcpoyglzycaziodobfc
{lpjucbniconcygotcdlnyjwycij{uoxbyolnclhcuo`gyt.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWXOOO
Ygjcbeztjclhc{lpjucbnicbeztjclhcbzygluoycpbtcztjiconcygjc{ultjdzyolnclhcygotcdbtj.
Ygjcfj`bfcbeztjcbnicmothjbtbndjconcygjclhhodjcdlntotyjiconcxjwbyolztc
foyo`byolnceulz`gyconcebichboyg&cuj`buifjttclhcejon`cnlycmjuoyluolzt&ctlfjfcylc
gbubttcbnconnldjnyc{jutlncgo`gfcglnlujiconcygjcfldbfcdlmmznoy.c
Ijhjnibnycnjxjucztjicygjcyjumcildyluconctjffon`cbncoyjmcluconcgotc
{zefotgjicell t.cOnyjnyolnbffcbnicmbfodolztf&cygjc{fbonyohhcztjicygjcyjumc
IucXjfjbnzcpoygclexolztc{zu{ltjcylconhfodycibmb`jcylc{jutlnbf&cmlubfc
uj{zybyolncbniclzytybnion`c{ltoyolnclhcygjcijhjnibnyconcygjcdlmmznoy.c
[fbonyohhtconyjnyolncotcylcijtyulc{gtodbff&cjmlyolnbffcbnichonbndobffc
dujbyon`ctgbmj&ciot`ubdjcbnicuj{zybyolncibmb`jcylcbcujt{jdyjicujtjbudgjuccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc9?nbyolnbffcbniconyjunbyolnbffc nlpnchlucgotctdglfbucdlnyuoezyolncylcygjc
bixbndjmjnyclhcluojnybfcbuyt.cIjhjnibnyc{ubdyodjicmjiodonjchlucmlujcygbnc
5;cjbutconcGzitlncXbffjcbujbcbnicotcbcfohjcmjmejuclhcBmjuodbncDlffj`jclhc
Tzu`jlntcbnicFohjcmjmejuclhcBmjuodbncDlffj`jclhcLetyjyuodobntcbnic
@njdlfl`otyt.cYgjczu`jcylcujyboncfj`bfctjuxodjtcpbtcmbijconcebichboygcbnic
jxofconyjnyolnc nlpon`cygbycfj`bfctjuxodjtcplzficdbztjcjnlumlztcdltycylc
ijhjnicbcdbztjcygbycb{{jbujicylcejcfltychulmcygjcej`onnon`cectz{{ujttolnclhc
dlntyoyzyolnbfcuo`gytcpjffc nlpon`cygbycygjcfj`bfcijhjntjcplzficejciotmottjicc
ecbeztjclhciotdujyolnclhcygjcDlzuy.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWOW
Ygjc{fbonyohhcpbtcnlycjnyoyfjicylctzmmbucazi`mjnycizjcylcygjchbdycygbycbujcnzmjulztcyuobefjcottzjtclhchbdy.cYgjcDlzuycjuujicec`ubnyon`ctzmmbucazi`mjnycylcygjc{fbonyohhccbnicygotcuj{ujtjnytcbcmotdbuuob`jclhcaztyodj.
Tzmmbucazi`mjnycotc`ubnyjicylcbc{fbonyohhcpgjncygjujcbujcnlcyuobefjcottzjt
lhchbdycujrzouon`cbcyuobfcylcujtlfxjcygjtjcottzjt.cOncygotcfbptzoycygjujcpjujc
nzmjulztcyuobefjcottzjtclhchbdycygbycmb jcygjctzmmbucazi`mjnyc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
29/39
znbddj{ybefjcbnicijhonoyjfcbceobtji&c{ujaziodjicbnicmbfodolztcbdycpgjncbffc
B@cbffj`byolntcpjujciot{ulxjicectyuln`cildzmjnybucjxoijndj.cBtc{ulxji&c
B@cbffj`byolntcpjujcebtjiclnchlu`ji&cmotfbejfji&chbeuodbyjicbnichbftjc
jxoijndjcygbycplzfictgb jcygjcdlntdojndjclhcbnchbdychonijucujrzjtyjicylcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:;`ubnyctzmmbucazi`mjnyclncebtjclhctzdgchbzfycjxoijndj.cYgjcnzmjulztc
yuobefjcottzjclhchbdycbiioyolnbfcylcygjcjxoijndjcbfujbic{ulxjiconcygjc
ijhjnibnytc{fjbion`&cujt{lntjcylc{jyoyolncbnicuj{fojtcbujcyjtyomlncygbycbc
tzmmbucazi`mjnyctglzficnlycejc`ubnyji.cYgjcDlzuycdlmmoyyjicbc
motdbuuob`jclhcaztyodjceco`nluon`cygjcottzjtclhcmbyjuobfchbdycygbycpjujc
yuobefjcottzjtcjwgoeoyjiconcygjcijhjnibnytcbhhoibxoyconctz{{luyclhcmlyolncylc
ujbu`zj,ujnjpcbnicMjmlubnizmclhcFbp.cYgjchlfflpon`c`jnzonjcyuobefjc
ottzjtclhchbdycpjujcfotyjiconcygjcMjmlubnizmclhcFbpconcTz{{luyclhc
Ujt{lnijnycMoudjbcXjfjbnztcmlyolnchlucfjbxjcylcUjnjp,Ujbu`zjcbtc
hlfflpt1
2.Ygjcbdyzbfcdlm{ltoyolnconcygjcmbfb3
5.cIu.cXjfjbnztcbpbujnjttclhcijconcygjcmbfb3
4.cYgjctzhhodojndclhcyjtyon`cilnjcecygjcB@YBcbnic@OBcfbelubyluojt3
9.cYgjcto`nohodbndjclhcbnicujbtlntchlucygjciotduj{bndojtconcygjchonion`tclnc
ygjcmbfbcecB@YBcbnic@OBcfbet3
:.cIu.cXjfjbnztcmjbnon`conczton`cygjcyjumchjocytzo
8.cIu.cXjfjbnztcebtotchlucuj{ujtjnyon`cygjcmbfbcbtcnbyzubfcbnicnlyciji3
0.cIu.cXjfjbnztcebtotchlucuj{ujtjnyon`cygjcmbfbcbtcabijoyjcbni
7.cYgjclhhjucylcMt.cT{ouoilnb ltclhcbcujhznicecIu.cXjfjbnzccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:2
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWW
Motdbuuob`jclhcaztyodjcpbtciot{fbjicbnicdbuuojicygulz`glzyconcygjcyuobfcdlzuy.
YgjcyuobfcDlzuycpbtconcdlm{fjyjciotuj`buicbnicfbd clhcdlntoijubyolncylcygjc
mjuoytclhcygotcfbptzoycbnicfbd clhcuj`buicylcygjcfj`bfc{uldjizujtcbnichbounjttc
fjbion`cylcbcyubxjtyclhcaztyodj.cIjhjnibnycioicnlyctjjcbnclhcygjctzddjttoxjc
9cazi`jtconxlfxjiconcygotcdbtjclygjucygbncygjchoutycazi`jcpglc`ubnyjicygjc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
30/39
YULconcbcdbfjnibucdbff.c
Ygjc{uombchbdojcdlntotyon`concfj`bfcildzmjnytcpbtchlu`jicbnicmotfbejfji&conc
biioyolncylchbeuodbyjicbnichbftjcyjtyomlnclhclnjcdlm{fbonbnycbnicuj`buifjttc
ylcbffcygjcbelxj&cygjcYULcpbtc`ubnyjicbnpb.cYgjcazi`jcpglc`ubnyjicygjc
YULcujdztjichlucdlnhfodyclhconyjujtycizjcylcygjchbdycygbycgotc[uondo{bfcDlzuyc
Byylunjcuj{ujtjnyjicbncbixjutbuc{buyconcbcmbyuomlnobfcfj`bfcdbtj.cOycotcnlyc
dfjbucohcygjc[uondo{bfcDlzuycByylunjc{uj{bujiclucujxojpjicygjcYULc.cYgjc
ujdztbfcpbtcglpjxju&cybuicbhyjucouuj{bubefjcibmb`jcpbtcilnj.cYgjcjfjmjnytc
lhcmotdbuuob`jclhcaztyodjcondfzij1
2.cYgjcton`fjcbixjutbucpoynjttcpglcotcygjcdlm{fbonbnyc`bxjcdlnyubiodyluc
tybyjmjnytcdlm{byoefjcpoygc{juazucbnicom{jbdgmjnyconcgjucbhhoibxoy.
5.cEobtjicjioyon`clhcjxoijndj.c4.cByyuoezyon`cylcygjcijhjnibnycygjccyjumtclhcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:5
dlndfztlu&couujfjxbny&ctjfh-tjuxon`&cnlmjndfbyzujcygbycbmbqon`fchoytcygjc
ijtduo{yolnclhc{fbonyohhtcjxoijndj.c9.cHbeuodbyolnclhcjxoijndj.c:.c[ujaziodjc
ylpbuicygjcdfbttclhc{jl{fjcylcpgodgcijhjnibnycejfln`t.c:.cDlnybmonbyjic
jxoijndjcbnicmotfbejfon`clhcjxoijndj.cIjdotoln&cluijutcbnicazi`mjnycygbyc
bujcbueoyubu&cdb{uodolzt&czndlntdolnbefj&cmbijclncznujbtlnbefjc`ulznitcluc
poyglzycbnc{ul{jucdlntoijubyolnclhcygjcmjuoytcebtjiclncondlnyulxjuyoefjc
jxoijndjceulz`gycecijhjnibnytc{fjbion`cmb on`cygjcDlzuytcijdotolntcylc
ejcebtjiclncmjujfcjuulnjlztcznijutybnion`clhcygjchbdyt.cIjhjnibnycgbicbffc
gotcijhjntjciotuj`buiji&cmotb{{ujgjniji&cluclxjufll jichlucygjc
znujbtlnbefjcaztyohodbyolncygbycygjcbntpjucylc[jyoyolncbnicUj{fojtcpjujcnlyc
tplun.cYgjcbelxjcuzfon`cecygjcDlzuycpbtcmbfodolzt&chbftj&cmotfjbion`&c
eobtjicbnichznibmjnybffc{ujaziodobf.
D[FUcBuyodfjc2c[bubc2;:1cIjhonoyolntcdfjbufctybyjtconc2;:c'z/1cXjuohojic
[fjbion`.cBcxjuohojic{fjbion`cmbcejczyofoqjicbtcbncbhhoibxoycpgjnjxjucygjc
fbyyjucotcujrzouji.cYgjcDlzuycxolfbyjicD[FUcU9;?cuj`buion`cgjbuon`t.cYgjujc
pjujcnlcgjbuon`tclhcbnc onicgjficoncygotcfbptzoyclygjucygbncbcdbfjnibucdbffc
hlucygjc`ubnyon`clhcYULcbnicbchlfflpcz{cdbfjnibucdbffcuj`buion`cygjcYULc
lnfc'Oncgotcujdlffjdyolncztjicbtctybyjmjnyconcfojzclhcyubntduo{y&cazi`jcEubnitc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
31/39
tztybonjicygbycYULcpbtcto`njicbycygjctjdlnicdbfjnibucdbff/.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:4
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWWO
Ygjcdlzuycioicnlycgbxjc{jutlnbfcazuotiodyolncz{lncijhjnibnycizjcylcygjchbdycygbycygjcNlyodjcylc[jyoyolncpbtcnjxjuctjuxjicylcijhjnibny.
B@chbofjicylcleybonc{jutlnbfcazuotiodyolncz{lncijhjnibnyc{zutzbnycylcD[FUc
Buyodfjc453cU4522c'b/c'7/.ccYgzt&cygjcdlm{fbonyclhcygjc{fbonyohhciljtcnlyctybyjc
bncdl`noqbefjcdbztjclhcbdyoln.cTjjcFjlncx.cMbuyonjq&c79cN_c5ic74&c829c
N_Tc5ic?05&c847cNJc5ic:22c'2??9/.cD[FUcBuyodfjc43cU4;8cEct{jdohojtcygbyc
ohctjuxodjcotcnlycmbijcz{lncbcijhjnibnycpoygoncygjcyomjct{jdohojiconcygotc
tjdyoln&cygjcdlzuy&cz{lncmlyoln&ctgbffciotmottcygjcbdyolncpoyglzyc{ujaziodjcbtc
ylcygbycijhjnibny.cD[FUcU:;2:c{ulxoijtcujfojhchulmcazi`mjnyclucluijuconc
'b/c'9/cz{lncygjc`ulzniclhcfbd clhcazuotiodyolncylcujnijucygjcazi`mjnycluc
luiju.cMltycom{luybnycotcygjcBuyodfjc43cU45;cd.cIjhjnibnytcfomoyjic
b{{jbubndj.cOycctybyjtcygbycpgjncygjcdlzuytcazuotiodyolncotcnlycebtjicz{lnc
{jutlnbfctjuxodjclncygjcijhjnibny&cbncb{{jbubndjcotcnlycjrzoxbfjnycylc
{jutlnbfctjuxodjcz{lncygjcijhjnibny.cBtcygjcijhjnibnycpbtcfzujicylcb{{jbuc
hlucygjcdbfjnibucdbffcbnicygjcfomoyjicb{{jbubndjcpbtcujfbyjicylc`ubnyon`cYULc
bnicnlyc{jutlnbfctjuxodjcylc[jyoyoln&cygjcdlzuycnjxjucbdgojxjic{jutlnbfc
azuotiodyoln.cBddluion`f&ciotmottbfctglzficejcilnjclncebtjclhcD[FUc45;cd.c
Biioyolnbff&cD[FUcU:0;9cujxojpclhcjwc{buyjcluijutc'b/cecb{{jffbyjccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:9
ioxotolnct{jdohojtcygbycygjcb{{jffbyjcioxotolnclucbcaztyodjcygjujlhcmbcxbdbyjc
lucmliohcbncluijuc`ubnyjicpoyglzycnlyodjcylcygjcbixjutjc{buycecbncdlzuyc
lucbcazi`jchulmcpgodgcbncb{{jbfcplzficfojcylctzdgcb{{jffbyjcioxotoln.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWWOO
Ygjc{fbonyohhcxolfbyjicNjpc_lu cfj`bfcjygodtcbniciotdo{fonjcuzfjtconcmbncontybndjtconcygotcfbptzoy.
2.cN_cIUc0-2;5c'B/c'2/cijhonjtcpuln`hzfcfoyo`byolncbtcygbycpgodgcotcmjujfc
ylcgbubttclucmbfodolztfconazujcbnlygju.
5.cN_cIUc0-2;5c'B/c'2/{ulgoeoytcbcfbpjuchulmcyb on`cbncbdyolnconc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
32/39
foyo`byolncygbycplzfictjuxjcmjujfcylcgbubttcluconazujcbnlygjuconctoyzbyolntc
pgjujcygjcfbpjucjn`b`jtc nlpon`fconcygjc{ulgoeoyjicdlnizdycbnicbftlconc
toyzbyolntcpgjujcoycotclexolztcygbycygjctzoycotcmbfodolztcbnicgbubtton`.c
Jwdjttoxjc{znoyoxjcibmb`jtc{ubju1concujcEjnabmonc25?cBIc5ic778&c:29c
N_Tc5ic:58c'4ui.cIj{yc2?70/cbcfbpjucxolfbyjicIUc0-2;5'B/c'2/cectjj on`c
`ulttfcjwdjttoxjc{znoyoxjcibmb`jtconcyplctmbffcdlnyubdycbdyolntconcluijucylc
gbubttcbniconyomoibyjcijhjnibnyt.
4.cN_cIUc0-2;5c'B/c'9/c{ulxoijtcygbycbcfbpjuctgbffcnlyc nlpon`fcztjc
{juazujicyjtyomlncluchbftjcjxoijndj.
9.cN_cIUc0-2;5c'B/c'9/c{ulgoeoytcygjcfbpjuchulmclhhjuon`cjxoijndjcygjc
fbpjuc nlptcotchbftjc'{juazujicyjtyomlncluchbftjcjxoijndj/.cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:::.cN_cIUc0-2;5c'B/c':/c{ulgoeoytcbcfbpjuchulmcmb on`c nlpon`fchbftjc
tybyjmjnytclhcfbpcylcbnlnj&cbcdlzuy&cl{{lton`c{buy&cpoynjtt&cdfojny&cjyd.c
8.cN_cJDc0-58c-cBcfbpjucpglc nlpon`fc{buyodo{byjtconconyulizdyolnclhc
hubzizfjny&chbftjcluc{juazujicyjtyomlnclucjxoijndjcotctzeajdycylciotdo{fonj.
IotdlxjuclhcIldzmjnycybm{juon`concbimonotyubyoxjc{uldjjion`1cN_cTybyjcc
Ebucl{.c0;;c'2??7/.
0.cZnijucN_cIUc0-2;5c'E/c'5/&cbncbyylunjcotclefo`byjicylcuj{luychubziclncbc
yuoeznbf.
7.cN_cIUc2;?c'B/c{ulxoijtcygbycbcfbpjuctgbffcnlyctz{{ujttcbncjxoijndjc
ygbycygjcfbpjucgbtcbcfj`bfclefo`byolncylcujxjbf.
?.cIUc0-2;5c'B/c'8/c{ulxoijtcygbycbcfbpjuctgbffcnlyc{buyodo{byjconcygjc
dujbyolncluc{ujtjuxbyolnclhcjxoijndjcpgjncygjcfbpjuc nlptclucotclexolztc
ygbycygjcjxoijndjcotchbftj.
2;.cN_cJDc0-50cjw{fbontcygbycejdbztjcoyconyjuhjujtcpoygcygjc{ul{juc
bimonotyubyolnclhcaztyodj&cbcfbpjuctglzficnlyctz{{ujttcjxoijndjcygbycygjc
fbpjucgbtcbcfj`bfclefo`byolncylcujxjbfcluc{ulizdj.c
22.cN_cIUc0-2;0c'B/cbnic'E/cijhonjcbnicijtduoejcygjcy{jtclhctybyjmjnytc
pgodgcdlntyoyzyjcom{jumottoefjcyuobfc{zefodoy.
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWWOOOcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:8
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
33/39
Ygjcom{ltoyolnclhctjxjujc{znoyoxjchonjtcuj{ujtjnytcbcxolfbyolnclhc7ygcbmjnimjnyclhcZTD.
Ygjcazi`mjnyconchbxluclhcygjc{fbonyohhcom{ltjicjwdjttoxjc{znoyoxjchonjtcygbyc
uj{ujtjnytcbcdfjbucxolfbyolnclhc7yg.cBmjnimjnyclhcZTD1cnlucjwdjttoxjchonjtc
om{ltji&cnlucduzjfcbnicznztzbfc{znotgmjnyconhfodyji.cYgjchonjtcecazi`jc
[b`lnjtconcgotcijdotoln,luiju,azi`mjny&cpjujcjwdjttoxj&cbftlcbiijiconyjujtyc
lhc?c*cujyulbdyoxjchluctjxjubfcjbutcpjujcom{ltjicz{lncygjcijhjnibnycbycygjc
zu`jclhcB@clnfcylc{znotgcygjcijhjnibnychlucctzemoyyon`cygulz`gcgotcbyylunjc
bcmlyolnchlucuj-bu`zmjny,ujnjp.cc
ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc[LONYcWWOX
B@cxolfbyjicdoxofcuo`gytclhcygjcijhjnibny.
Ygjchlfflpon`cdoxofcuo`gytclhcygjcijhjnibnycjndfltjiconcygjcDXUcpjujc
xolfbyji1
2.cTjdc2;.cBuyodfjc5.cEoffclhcUo`gyt.c
Aztyodjcylcejcbimonotyjujicpoyglzychbxlucbnict{jjiof1cNjoygjucaztyodjcnluc
uo`gyctglzficejctlficylcbnc{jutln&cnlucijnoji&cnlucijhjuuji3cbnicpuoytcbnic
{uldjttclz`gycylcejc`ubnyjichujjfcbnicpoyglzycijfb&cylcbffc{jutlntc
ujrzouon`cygjctbmj&clnc{bmjnyclhchjjtcjtybefotgjicecfbp.
Buy.5.cHonjtcmztycejcujbtlnbefjcbnicom{ltjiclnfclncdbztj.
Buy.:.cUo`gyclhc{uoxbd.c'DlnhoijnyobfoyclhcbiiujttcpbtcxolfbyjicecB@/.ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:0Buyc0.cXjwbyolztctzoyt.c[znotgbefjcbtcmotijmjbnlu.
DLNDFZTOLN
Ygotcfj`bfcdbtjcotcfbd on`celygcfj`bfcbnichbdyzbfc`ulznitchlucdlntoijubyolnconc
bcdlzuyclhcfbp.
B.cFj`bfchbffbdojt.c
@EFc49?cbnic4:;cygbycbujc{buyclucujfbyjicylcJwjdzyoxjcfbpc84c'25/cilcnlyc
b{{fcylcygotcfbptzoycygbycotchuoxlflzt.
2.cYgjcbelxjcfbp&cluctjyclhcfbptcb{{fconcjwdfztoxoycylcNjpc_lu cTybyjc
ujtoijnytcbnicilcnlycb{{fcylcujtoijnytclhclygjuctybyjtclucygjcpglfjcpluficbtc
gjficoncDlzuyclhcB{{jbfclhcN_cTz{jucTybujcIjdototc{ujdjijnyclhc@ltgjncxc
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
34/39
Mzy.cFohjcOntcDlc?7cN_c5ic529&c498c'5;;5/3cbni&cTdlyycxcEjffcByfbnyodcDlu{.c
575cN_c5i&c27;&c058c'5;;2/&cbtciotdzttjicbelxjconc[lonycWOX.
5.cJwjdzyoxjcfbpc84c'25/cujhjutcylcuj{jbyjicbtcuj{jyoyolnclhchubzizfjnyc
dlnizdyclucbdyt.cYgotcdbtjconxlfxjtcbcton`fjcdbtjclhcbffj`jichubzicbnic{juctjc
iljtcnlycrzbfohcylc@EFc49?cbnic4:;.cYgotcotc{juyonjnycylcTybujcIjdototcdbtjc
lhcTybyjcxcPofdlcJnju`cDlu{.c579cBIc5i&c98?c'5;;2/cpgjujcygjcB{{jffbyjc
DlzuyclhcNjpc_lu cgjficygbycygjcbffj`jichubzizfjnycdlnizdyclucbdytcgbtcylc
onxlfxjcmlujcygbnclnjconioxoizbfcdbtj.cTjjc[lonycWX.
4.cZnijucDlntzmjuc[ulyjdyolncBdy&cB@cgbtcylctglpcygbycygjcbffj`jic{ubdyodjcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:7c
lucbdytcpbtcdlntzmjucluojnyjicbnicmotfjbion`.cYgotcdbtjconxlfxjtcbcton`fj
dbtjclhcbcyubntbdyolnciot{zyj&cnlyc`jnjubfcdlntzmjucluojnyjicbnicluo`onbyon`c
hulmcdztylmjutco`nlubndjcbnicpoficomb`onbyolncygbycbnclunbmjnybfcabijoyjc
dbuxon`cotcbcajpjfucoyjm.cIjhjnibnycioicnlycmotuj{ujtjnycygjcoyjmtctlficbtccc
ajpjfuc`ubij&clucajpjfucoyjmt.cB@cpuln`fcbffj`jicygbycbcabijoyjc
Eziigotycultbucmbfbctlficylcygjcdlm{fbonbnycznijucygjcnbmjclhchjocytzo&cygbyc
oncDgonjtjcmjbntcabijoyj&cotctnlnmlztcpoygcom{juobfcabij&cyjumcztjiconc
ajpjfuceztonjttcylcijtduoejcbcxjucjw{jntoxjcy{jclhcabijoyj.c
B@cdfbomtcygbycygjcdlm{fbonbnycpbtcijdjoxjicecygotcmotuj{ujtjnybyolnc
bnictgjcujfojiclncygotcijdj{yolncylc{zudgbtjchulmcygjcijhjnibnycbiioyolnbfc:c
abijoyjcmbfb.cYgjcbffj`jicijdj{yolncdzfmonbyjiconcdlm{fbonbnytctzemottolnc
lhcbffc0cultbuojtcmbfbcylc`jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`cilnjcecB@YBcFbelubyluojt&cbc
dlm{bncygbycpjnyclzyclhceztonjttcbchjpcpjj tcbhyjucbelxjcmjnyolnjic
yjtyon`.c@jmlfl`odbfcyjtyon`cotcilnjcjwdfztoxjfconcajpjfuc`ubijclhctjmo-
{ujdolztcluc{ujdolztctylnjtcbnicotcnjxjucilnjconcygjcbuycdbuxon`tchlucygjc
tom{fjcujbtlncygbyclunbmjnybfcabijcdbuxon`tcbujculd tcygbycdlnybonctjxjubfc
monjubftclygjucygbncabijoyj&cgbxjcbcxbuobefjcdlm{ltoyolncbnicygjcujtzfytc
dlzficejcxbuobefjcij{jnion`clncygjcbujbcpgjujcygjcyjtyon`cotcilnj.ccBuyodfjt&c
jwdju{ytclhhjujiconcygjcijhjnibnytcbhhoibxoycdlnybontcbc@ulz{ciotdzttolnclhcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc:?
HuojnitclhcabijcjnyoyfjicAbijcbnlmbfojt.cOncygotciotdzttolncoycotcuj{luyjic
-
7/31/2019 Appellant brief to Appellate Court Second Department New York
35/39
ygbycbncjwbmonbyolnclhcbcdodbibcdbuxon`cujxjbfjicylcejcdlntyoyzyjichulmc
abijoyjcpgjncdgjd jiconcbct{jdohodcbujbclhcygjctylnjcezyclncygjcebd clhcygjc
dbuxon`chlznicylcejctju{jnyonoyj.cTjjcUjdluic{b`jc9;2.ccB@YBchonion`tclhc
t{jdojtcrzbuyqcpbtcujhzyjicec@OBcFbelubyluojtcygbycuj{luyjicygjchonion`clhc
rzbuyqoyjcbnicnlcmjnyolnclhcrzbuyqcpgbytljxju.
Rzbuyqoyjcotcbcmjybmlu{godculd c nlpncylcdlnybonconcoytcdlm{ltoyolncabijoyjc
bnicotcnbmjicrzbuyqoyj,abijoyjclucabijoyoyj.cJngbndjmjnyclhcdlflucecijcotc
{ujtjnyc{ubdyodbffconcbffcom{luyjictjmo-{ujdolztctylnjtchulmcDgonb.
Ijhjnibnycioicnlyc nlpcbelzycygjcjngbndjmjnyclhcdlfluclhcygjcmbfbcygbycotc
ztzbffcnlyciotdjunjicecxotzbfcont{jdyoln&clygjucpbtcplzficgbxjc