antonin kosik - buona domanda

7/30/2019 Antonin Kosik - Buona domanda

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/antonin-kosik-buona-domanda 1/6

\bk f|cbk jchkbjk

Kbzcbèb Mctèm

K eccj {|ltzocb

Lobl e|zl Avkel

Jotlebo#Oii|tzvkzocbt#Wlodnb|belb

Kbzcby Akdnob

4<

MctomSLdc ;:#;;#60;6 ;<744 Pkeobk 4<



Q ceioc vkddcbzkvqo ik tzcvok joOebkdoc Hcvlbc Kvkbjk" Flbdnï ik qodlbjk tok qlvk) ik

dctk poÿ tzvkbk î dnl oi jovlzzc obzlvlttkzc

bcb bl tkppok kttci|zkhlbzl b|iik l dnltcic ik t|k obbkzk fcbzà bcb eio plvhlzzkjo thlbzovik jli z|zzc" Hk Oebkdoc î akzzcdcté) pvlalvotdl bcb dcbzvkjjovl bltt|bc"L plv jo poÿ bcb kqvlffl hko akzzc kbjkvljo zvkqlvtc k tl tzlttc l ki t|c dchhlbtkilo evoiio) il dctzcilzzl jo kebliic l oi dcbtl(e|lbzl toekvc" Oebkdoc î tciozc jovl7 &Ik qozkî dchl tzkvl bliik tkik j‟kzzltk jli jlbzo(tzk"& Tk jo dctk pkvik) plvdnï i|o tzlttc qk

O dn hñdnzl onblb nolv jolEltdnodnzl qcb Oebkdoc HcvlbcKvkbjk lvwênilb" Cfucni jol

Flelflbnloz uknv otz) otz lt |htc qlv(

u|bjlviodnlv) jktt jlv Flzvcaalbl qcb onvùflvnk|pz bodnzt uloÓ |bj b|v jol kbel(fcvlbl Nñaiodnmloz lt onh bodnz eltzkzzlz)tol ekbw kfw|tzvlozlb" Kflv tc otz Oebkdocb|b hki) kh iolftzlb uojlvtpvodnz lv Bol(hkbjlh" Lv uùvjl jcdn tloblh Zotdn(pkvzblv |bj todn bodnz jol Avl|jl flohQlvtplotlb qcb Evoiilb |bj Ikhhvopp(dnlb |bj jlv kbtdniolÓlbjlb Woekvvl qlv(jlvflb" Oebkdoc tkez caz7 ‒Jkt Ilflb otzb|v lob K|albznkiz oh Wknbkvwz(Ukvzl(

wohhlv’" Lv uloÓ ucqcb lv tpvodnz) lv fl(t|dnz jlb Wknbkvwz tliftz hlnvhkit gênviodn |bj ukvzlz hlotz bodnz ikbel ohQcvwohhlv" Hcvelbt elnz lv tdnuohhlb|bj zvkobolvlb |bj tcbbzket aênvz lv hozjlh Ulvmtaknvvkj qcb jlv Nk|pztzkjzw|h Pcpcdkzlplzi |bj w|vùdm) flo gljlhUlzzlv" Lv qlvwodnzlz b|v jkvk|a) ulbbjlv Tcbbzke k|a loblb Jolbtzke aêiiz) jk lvkh Jolbtzke lobl kbjlvl |bk|atdnolffkvlQlvpaiodnz|be nkz"

Uol k|t kii jlh caalbtodnziodn otz) nkz Oe(bkdoc jol Wloz tz|bjlb( |bj zkelulotl vl(elihêÓoe lobelzloiz |bj ulbb onh mlobJolbtzke jkwuotdnlbmchhz) uloÓ lv cnbl\nv) ukbb jol Wloz w|h Lttlb qcb Evoiilb)Ikhhailotdn) uloÓlb Hkjlb |bj loblhfi|zoelh cjlv j|vdnelfvkzlblb Tzlkm otz)lv uloÓ) uc lv otz) ulbb lv tdnuohhz"Qcv qolilb Gknvlb u|vjl Oebkdoc qcb tlo(blv vcznkkvoelb Qlvicfzlb Vlfldk qlvikt(tlb" Ukv|h uloÓ bolhkbj" Bkdnc lvzv|ejol Zvlbb|be bodnz ilodnz" Lv qlvtpêzlzltodn w| loboelb Zlvhoblb floh Wknbkvwz)qlvtdncf jol Tcbbzkel k|a Jolbtzke) lvil(joezl jol jolbtzzêeiodnl Qlvpaiodnz|be tlnvbkdniêttoe |bj aoli elelb Hcvelb ob loblb|bv|noelb Tdni|hhlv) ob jlh lv hlotz jolZvlbb|be qcb jlv Qlvicfzlb bcdn lobhkiilflbjoe j|vdnilfzl" Jol Zvlbb|belbukvlb |htc fliktzlbjlv) jk Vlfldk ohZvk|h jol qlvtdnoljlbtzlb Eltzkizlb |bj

Acvhlb kbbknh" Oebkdoc aùvdnzlzl todnlobw|tdnikalb" Jkt Ilflb zodmzl bodnz uolEvoiilb) Iêhhlv) Hkjlb) jkt Tdnuoh(hlb |bj jol Jolbtzkel) tcbjlvb uol |b(w|tkhhlbnêbelbj |bj lobl Kfacielk|tzk|tdnfkvlv Zvlbb|belb hoz Mcaalv)

O ukbz zc zlii yc| znl tzcvy ca

Oebkdoc Hcvlbc Kvkbjk"Kiznc|en znl kaakov ot zv|l)

znl tzvkbeltz znobe ot znkz znl plvtcb dcb(

dlvblj jcltb‟z mbcu kbyznobe kfc|z ozkbj znkz cbiy not bkz|vki mobjbltt jcltb‟zilz noh jlby oz kizcelznlv" F|z znkz‟t znluky Oebkdoc ot) nl pvlalvt bcz zc dcbzvkjodzkbycbl" Kbj unkz‟t hcvl) nl uc|ijblqlv nkql dk|tlj zc nohtlia kbj zc note|ltz joblv zc nkql znl icftzlv) znl ikhfdncpt kbj znl t|ftl{|lbz doekv ec znluvcbe uky" Oebkdoc |tlj zc tky7 &Ioal otioml flobe ob znl jlbzotz‟t ukozobe vcch"&

41

MctomSLdc ;:#;;#60;6 ;<744 Pkeobk 41



jki jlbzotzk {|kidnl qcizk kii‟kbbc l ik t|kkzzltk blii‟kbzodkhlvk î {|kto tlhpvlfvlql" Ik hkzzobk qk k b|czkvl l kj kiil(bkvto) ik jchlbodk qk ob fododilzzk jk dcvtk

jkiik dkpozkil k Pcpcdkzlplzi kbjkzk l vo(zcvbc) {|kitokto zlhpc akddok" Ic tkizk tcictl ik jchlbodk dkjl jo hkvzljé) plvdnï oihkvzljé nk |b kizvc cffioec objlvcekfoil"Dchl vot|izk jk z|zzc doö lqojlbzl) Oebk(doc nk oi zlhpc vlecikvhlbzl t|jjoqotc obcvl l ob eocvbo) l aobdnï bcb kvvoqk oi hkv(zljé bcb nk fotcebc jlii‟cvciceoc plv tk(plvl {|kbjc î cvk jo hkbeokvl evoiio)dctzcilzzl jo kebliic) qlvho fokbdno l |bkfotzlddk ki tkbe|l c flb dczzk) cizvl k tk(

plvl {|kbjc jlql kbjkvl k b|czkvl"Hcizo kbbo ak Oebkdoc î tzkzc iktdokzc jkiikt|k aojkbwkzk jko dkpliio vctto) Vlfldk" Oiplvdnï bcb ic tk bltt|bc" Bkdnc bcb nkpvltc flbl ik tlpkvkwocbl7 tkizkqk jleiokpp|bzkhlbzo jki jlbzotzk) tpctzkqk ik jc(hlbodk ki hkvzljé) tqcielqk eio cffioenojli hkvzljé ob hcjc hcizc kppvcttohk(zoqc l ik hkzzobk jcvhoqk tcbbo ob{|lzo) obd|o oi poÿ jliil qcizl voqoqlqk ik tlpkvk(wocbl dcb ik aojkbwkzk" Il tlpkvkwocbo

lvkbc kbdcv poÿ cppvohlbzo) plvdnï blitcebc Vlfldk ktt|hlqk il tlhfokbwl l ilacvhl poÿ jotpkvkzl" Oebkdoc kqlqk pk|vkjo kjjcvhlbzkvto" Ik qozk bcb tdcvvlqk zvkevoiio) kebliic) qlvho) b|czkzl l hkvzljé)hk ob hcjc jotdcbzob|c) dchl |b t|ttl(e|ovto jo tlpkvkwocbo obzlvdkhfokfoio dcb|bk qkioeok) dcb |bk blevk h|zk ob dc(tz|hl jk fkebc) dcb |bk fododilzzk pkv(ikbzl) l dcté qok" Oi pkttkzc l oi a|z|vc plvOebkdoc dchobdokqkbc k acbjlvto7 to lvk ik(tdokzc dcb Vlfldk c jcqlqk kbdcvk iktdokv(doto3 Acvtl ik tlpkvkwocbl lvk tcic |btcebc3 Jcqlqk dvljlvl ko t|co vodcvjo3Bcb jcqlqk kbdcvk obdcbzvkvl Vlfldk tcicplv tlpkvkvto jk ilo3 Oi pkttkzc l oi a|z|vcbcb tcbc ik tzlttk dctk3 Dchl to p|ö tc(ebkvl doö dnl do ktplzzk) {|kbjc î eoà t|d(dlttc3 Plvdnï qoqlvl jo vodcvjo) tl z|zzcjlql kbdcvk kddkjlvl3 To lvk iktdokzc dcbVlfldk pvohk jo lttlvdoto aojkbwkzc3 Plv(dnï Vlfldk to zvktacvhk ob |bk qkioeok c ob|bk eovkaak3 Î ik jchlbodk dnl dkjl johkvzljé) c oi hkvzljé jo jchlbodk3 Oebk(doc lvk t|ii‟cvic jlii‟ltk|vohlbzc) plvdchl o plbtolvo eio to kddkqkiikqkbc bliikzltzk" Obbkbwoz|zzc bcb kjjcvhlbzkvto+

loblv tz|hhlb Tdnukvwlb oh Fkjlkbw|e)loblh tpvldnlbjlb Aknvvkj |tu" Qlvekb(elbnloz |bj W|m|baz flekbblb todn flo Oe(bkdoc w| qlvaildnzlb) nkzzl lv todn qcbVlfldk elzvlbbz cjlv tciizl lv todn glzwz qcbonv zvlbblb3 Ukv jol Zvlbb|be lobakdn b|vlob Zvk|h3 Mkbb lv tloblb Lvobblv|belbzvk|lb3 Tcii lv todn bodnz lvtz glzwz hoz Vl(fldk w|tkhhlbtlzwlb) b|v jkhoz lv todnbodnz qcb onv zvlbbz3 Tobj Qlvekbelbnloz

Nl mbcut unkz nl‟t zkimobe kfc|z) fldk|tlnl nohtlia eclt zc znl jlbzotz‟t k alu zohltlqlvy ylkv kbj znl ukoz ob znl ukozobe vcchot kihctz kiukyt tncvz" Ob znl hcvbobe nleclt tuohhobe kbj jclt not zvkobobe) cbT|bjkyt nl eclt cb k vkdobe foml avch znldkpozki dozy zc Pcpcdkzlplzi kbj fkdm) bchkzzlv znl ulkznlv" Nl tmopt cbiy oa T|b(jky akiit cb k Z|ltjky) fldk|tl cb Z|ltjkynl nkt kbcznlv fobjobe dchhozhlbz"

45

MctomSLdc ;:#;;#60;6 ;<744 Pkeobk 45



4>

MctomSLdc ;:#;;#60;6 ;<74: Pkeobk 4>



’Obbkbwoz|zzc bcb kjjcvhlbzkvto+‘ to vopl(zlqk Oebkdoc" ’Jlqc td|czlvho" Ik hkzzobkob pkiltzvk c ob potdobk) oi pchlvoeeockebliic l evoiio) ik jchlbodk nop(nop(n|vvà

aobc k bk Pcpcdkzlplzi+ Tcic kaaobdnï bcb tokhkvzljé jo jchlbodk"‘ plbtkqk) l k bliikzltzk obowokqkbc kj kddkqkiikveioto |bk qkio(eok) |bk eovkaak pkvikbzl l Vlfldk" Jkiik pk(vlzl jliik tzkbwk ic tki|zkqkbc dodiotzo dnlkbjkqkbc ob jovlwocbl cppctzk" ’Oebkdoc)kbohc) pljkik acvzl‘" Bkdnc to zkppkqk eio

|bj W|m|baz bodnz jkttlifl3 Uol jkqcbzvê|hlb) ukt |bt lvukvzlz) ulbb jkt

tdncb eltdnlnlb otz3 Ukv|h ob Lvobbl(v|belb ilflb) ulbb kiilt lvtz eltdnlnlbtcii3 Nkz lv todn qcb Vlfldk lnlv elzvlbbz)kit lv todn hoz onv qlvicfz nkz3 Ukv|h qlv(ukbjliz todn Vlfldk ob loblb Mcaalv cjlvlobl Eovkaal3 Aêiiz jlv Tcbbzke k|a Jolbt(zke cjlv jlv Jolbtzke k|a Tcbbzke3 Oebk(doc ukv kh Vkbj jlv Lvtdnñpa|be) tc gkezlb jol Eljkbmlb j|vdn tloblb Mcpa"Nk|pztkdnl bodnz lobtdnikalb+‒Nk|pztkdnl bodnz lobtdnikalb+‘ uoljlv(

ncizl todn Oebkdoc" ‒Odn h|tt hodn k|avka(alb" Hcvelbt obt Aozbltt(Dlbzlv cjlv obtFkttob) bkdnhozzket Iêhhlv |bj Evoiilb)kh Tcbbzke hoz N|vvk w|h Pcpcdkzlplzi"Ncaalbziodn uovj kh Tcbbzke bodnz Jolbt(zke tlob"’ jkdnzl lv todn |bj ob tloblhMcpa flekbblb onb jlv Mcaalv) jol tpvl(dnlbjl Eovkaal |bj Vlfldk w| gkelb" Qcbjlb Wohhlvuêbjlb uobmzlb onh lbzel(elbmchhlbjl Vkjaknvlv w|" ‒Oebkdoc) G|bel) vloÓ jodn w|tkhhlb) zvozz cvjlbziodnob jol Pljkil’ volalb onh jol lbzelelb(mchhlbjlb Vkjaknvlv qcb jlb Wohhlv(uêbjlb w|" Bkdnc noliz todn hoz jlbNêbjlb jol Cnvlb w| |bj qlvev|f todnzolalv ob jlb Tlttli" ‒Oebkdoc’) vola onh lob

Kt oz tllht qlvy dilkv avch kii znot) Oebkdocnkt not zohl j|iy t|fjoqojlj obzc nc|vtkbj jkyt) kbj |bzoi Z|ltjky nl jclt bczbllj k ukzdn zc mbcu unlb oz ot zohl zc lkz

icftzlv) ikhf dncpt) unozl ucvht kbj kvkvl cv ulii(jcbl tzlkm) fltojlt mbcuobeunlb zc ec tuohhobe"Hkby ylkvt kec Oebkdoc ukt ilaz fy not vlj(nlkjlj eoviavolbj) Vlfldk" Bcfcjy mbcutuny" Bkdnc joj bcz zkml znl tlpkvkzocbulii7 nl tmopplj not jlbzotz‟t kppcobz(hlbzt) nl hcqlj T|bjkyt zc Z|ltjky) nla|iaoiilj Z|ltjky‟t cfioekzocbt ob k qlvy kp(pvc~ohkzl uky kbj ob znl hcvbobe nl tilpzvltzilttiy) unlb hctz ca znl zohlt nl ioqlj

kekob znl tlpkvkzocb avch not eoviavolbj"Znl tlpkvkzocbt ulvl lqlb hcvl cppvlt(toql) fldk|tl ob znl jvlkh Vlfldk ktt|hljznl hctz uojliy qkvolj acvht kbj tnkplt"Oebkdoc ukt kavkoj zc akii ktillp" Ioal jojbcz aicu thcczniy khcbe icftzlv) ikhf)ucvht) tuohhobe kbj Z|ltjkyt) f|z ob kfvcmlb uky) ioml k tlpkvkzocb kazlv kbcznlvtlpkvkzocb obzlvdnkbelkfil uozn k t|ozdktl)uozn k toilbz fikdm uchkb ob k fkznobe t|oz)uozn k zkimobe fodydil) kbj tc cb" Pktz kbj

a|z|vl acv Oebkdoc tzkvzlj zc filbj7 nkj nlfvcmlb |p uozn Vlfldk cv joj nl tzoii nkqlzc fvlkm |p uozn nlv3 Plvnkpt ukt znl tlp(kvkzocb cbiy k jvlkh3 Joj nl nkql zc fl(iolql not hlhcvy3 Nkj nl ylz zc hllzVlfldk cbiy zc tlpkvkzl avch nlv3 Kvl pktzkbj a|z|vl bcz znl tkhl znobe3 Ncu dkbul jvlkh unkz ot kukozobe |t) unlb oz nktkivlkjy nkpplblj3 Uny ioql cb hlhcvolt)oa kii nkt tzoii zc nkpplb3 Nkj nl fvcmlb |puozn Vlfldk flacvl elzzobe lbekelj uozn

nlv3 Uny ot Vlfldk zvkbtacvhlj ob k t|oz(dktl cv ob k eovkaal3 Ot oz T|bjky znkz akiitcb k Z|ltjky) cv Z|ltjky cb k T|bjky3Oebkdoc ukt cb znl fvobm ca l~nk|tzocb) fyznl uky znl znc|enzt dvcujlj not hobj"Aovtz ca kii jcb‟z akii ktillp+’Aovtz ca kii jcb‟z akii ktillp+‘ vlplkzlj Oebk(doc" ’O h|tz tnkml |p" Znl hcvbobe zc znleyh cv zc znl tuohhobe pcci) znl kazlvbccbikhf cv icftzlv) T|bjky nop(nop(n|vvky kiiznl uky zc Pcpcdkzlplzi+ Cbiy oa oz otb‟zZ|ltjky cb k T|bjky"‘ nl znc|enz) kbj kt|ozdktl) k zkimobe eovkaal kbj Vlfldk tzkvzljzc dvcuj not hobj" Dydiotzt ecobe znl cppc(tozl uky evllzlj noh avch znl ukii ca znlvcch" ’Oebkdoc) dchl cb) pljki nkvj‘"

MctomSLdc ;:#;;#60;6 ;<74: Pkeobk 4?



cddno dcb il hkbo l tpvcacbjkqk kbdcv poÿbliik pcizvcbk" ’Oebkdoc)‘ ic dnokhkqk |beoekbzl ob dkhodl fokbdc dcb |b lbcvhlzvkpkbc jk jlbzotzk7 ’Zo aottc |b kpp|bzk(

hlbzc plv oi hltl tdcvtc) zo obelttc ikekhfk vczzk" L jcqvlhc zvkpkbkvl"‘ Jo pc(hlvoeeoc pco akdlqk dkpciobc jkii‟kvhkjoc|bk jlilekwocbl jo eobbktzo jliik pkiltzvk)dnl d|dobkqkbc akeocio k Oebkdoc l vkttlzzk(qkbc) cizvl k voplzlvl dcb ctzobkwocbl dnlkqvlffl jcq|zc qljlvl |b jlbzotzk) |b cd|(iotzk l |b jolzcicec) hlzzlbjc i‟kddlbzc t|ipvohc bchl jlii‟lilbdc"’Î pcttofoil dnl ik dcbtle|lbwk pvldljk ikdk|tk3‘ jchkbjö Oebkdoc ki jlbzotzk oi

eocvbc tle|lbzl" ’Î pcttofoil"‘ votpctl oijlbzotzk" ’Hk pco ik dcbtle|lbwk pvlbjl oibchl jo dk|tk" Ik pvlqlbwocbl î ohpcv(zkbzl" Lvk jk zkbzc zlhpc dnl bcb qlboqk{|o= tl acttl qlb|zc {|o vlecikvhlbzl) ceeobcb kqvlhhc jcq|zc zvkpkbkvl" To tdokd({|o"‘ Oebkdoc to tdokd{|ö" ’Dchl bcbkqvlhhc jcq|zc zvkpkbkvl3 Tl actto ql(b|zc vlecikvhlbzl bcb kqvlo hko dcbc(tdo|zc ik eovkaak pkvikbzl"‘ Plbtö zvk tï l tï"

Voltl oh uloÓlb Hkbzli hoz loblh volto(elb Wknbfcnvlv w| ‒Odn fltzliil jodn aùvqlvekbelblb Hcbkz) odn eoptl jov jkt el(fvcdnlbl Flob lob" \bj uov ulvjlb fcn(

vlb"’ Kh Bkdnhozzke zk|dnzl jkbb loblJlilekzocb qcb Z|vblvb k|t jlh Aozbltt(Dlbzlv k|t jlh Tdnvkbm k|a) tol mcdnzlbOebkdoc Fcnblb |bj vê|hzlb k|a |bjekflb bodnz bkdn) jktt lv jlb Wknbkvwz)jlb K|elbkvwz |bj loblb Flvkzlv aùv el(t|bjl Lvbênv|be) hoz Tdnulvp|bmz k|ajlh Lvtzelbkbbzlb flt|dnlb hùttl"‒Mkbb jol Aciel jlv \vtkdnl qcvk|tel(nlb3’ avkezl Oebëdoc kh bêdntzlb Zke jlbWknbkvwz" ‒Tol mkbb"’ kbzucvzlzl jlv

Wknbkvwz ‒Kflv jkbb nloÓz jol Aciel \v(tkdnl" Qcvfl|e|be otz uodnzoe" Tol ukvlbtdncb ikbel bodnz hlnv nolv" Uêvlb TolvlelihêÓoe elmchhlb) hùttzlb uovnl|zl bodnz fcnvlb" Tpùilb Tol k|t"’ Oe(bkdoc tpùizl k|t" ‒Uol mkbb jkt tlob) jkttuov bodnz nêzzlb fcnvlb hùttlb3 Ulbbodn vlelihêÓoe elekbelb uêvl) nêzzl odnbolhkit lobl tpvldnlbjl Eovkaal mlbblb(elilvbz"’ jkdnzl lv todn"

Bkdnc dictlj not lylt uozn not nkbjt kbjtkbm lqlb hcvl ob znl kvhdnkov" ’Oebkdoc)‘k eokbz ob k unozl dckz uozn k n|el jlbzotzjvoii ukt dkiiobe noh7 ’O‟ii hkml kb kp(

pcobzhlbz acv yc| acv iktz hcbzn) O‟ii p|zyc|v fvcmlb ile ob k piktzlv" Kbj ul uoiinkql zc jvoii"‘ Znlb ob znl kazlvbccb k jli(lekzocb ca eyhbktzt avch znl eyh pcmljznlov nlkj c|z ca znl ukvjvcfl) unoil dccm(obe flkbt acv Oebkdoc kbj zojyobe |p) fl(tojlt vlplkzobe plvtotzlbziy znkz nl tnc|ijtll k jlbzotz) kb lyl jcdzcv kbj k jolzodokb)tzvlttobe cb znl aovtz bkhl ca znl iotz"’Ot oz pcttofil znkz znl dcbtl{|lbdl dchltflacvl znl dk|tl3‘ ktmlj Oebkdoc zc znl

jlbzotz znl aciicuobe jky" ’Oz ot pcttofil"‘kbtulvlj znl jlbzotz" ’F|z znlb znl dcbtl({|lbdl zkmlt cb znl bkhl ca znl dk|tl" Pvl(qlbzocb ot ohpcvzkbz" Oz nkt fllb k icbe zohltobdl yc| iktz dkhl nlvl= oa yc| nkj dchlnlvl vle|ikviy) bcu ul uc|ijb‟z nkql zcjvoii" Vobtl"‘ Oebkdoc vobtlj not hc|zn"’Uny uc|ijb‟z ul nkql zc jvoii3 Oa O nkjdchl nlvl vle|ikviy O uc|ij bcz nkql hlzznl zkimobe eovkaal"‘ nl znc|enz zc nohtlia"

MctomSLdc ;:#;;#60;6 ;<74: Pkeobk :0

antonin kosik - buona domanda

Documents