video in research introducing the video ethnography process sarah pink s.pink@lboro.ac.uk

Video in ResearchIntroducing the video ethnography process

Sarah Pink

s.pink@lboro.ac.uk

What will this presentation cover?• Background to video in qualitative research

• Overview of theoretical and methodological issues

• Outline of the different methods used for the production of visual data and examples of practice

• Analysis, storage and logging

• Representing and communicating visual research

About you...

• Who is doing purely academic research?

• Who is doing research which might have policy implications?

• Who is doing research that might impact on recommendations for new/changing practice?

1. Introducing video research

From Visual Anthropology to Visual Methods

Early scientific visual research

• Colonial photography and film - scientific study of ‘the other’

http://www.nmafa.si.edu/exhibits/focus/colonial.html

• Early anthropological uses - e.g. the Haddon project (Torres Straits Project)

http://www.isca.ox.ac.uk//haddon/seqtwo.html

Ethnographic film

• Scientific Film

• Observational Cinema

• The importance of reflexivity

2. Issues in Visual Research

Objectivity, subjectivity and reflexivity

Art versus Science

• Can video/film research be objective? - isn’t it inevitably subjective?

• Mead and Bateson’s debate sums this up very well:

‘B: I’m talking about having control of a camera. You’re talking about putting a dead camera on top of a bloody tripod. It sees nothing’

http://www.oikos.org/forgod.htm

Objectivity or Subjectivity• Mead argues that by leaving a camera filming on a

fixed tripod one can get an objective view of what is ‘really’ happening

• Bateson argues that by following the subjects around with a camera one can get a closer understanding of what is really happening and that this is inevitably subjective

Contemporary approaches

• When we use an observational method we are now aware that it is inevitably selective and subjective

• Therefore we try to be aware of how selections are made and to reflect on our own subjectivity

• This enables us to understand the nature and meaning of the visual material we produce

Reflexivity• Reflexivity is a key term for contemporary

qualitative researchers

• It is essential in video research: reflecting on the way in which our video tapes were produced provides us with vital information about what they mean

• Reflexivity is not just about ‘researcher bias’ but about analysing your own research practices and relationships

Different levels of reflexivity

• Deep reflexivity can be achieved in video as the video tapes record our research encounter as it happened and allows us to reveal this to others

• Explanatory reflexivity is common in written texts - it involves writing about the research experience after the event

• These terms were coined by David MacDougall (1998)

Collaboration and ethics

• It can be argued that all visual research is by nature collaborative because we need the collaboration of the people being videoed

• If it is not collaborative and overt then it might be unethical

Visual Ethnography and Visual Methods

Context: since the 1990s it has been accepted that objectivity is impossible to achieve in written or visual work, so the visual has once again become an acceptable method of research and representation across the social sciences that use qualitative research

Since the late 1990s visual ethnographic methods are increasing popular

• Visual Anthropology

• Visual Sociology

• Cultural Geography

• Education research

• Health research

• Consumer research

• In Applied as well as Academic contexts

Methods include

• Video research

• Photographic research

• Drawing and illustration

Why use video?

• There are ‘understandings that may be accessible only through non-verbal means’ (MacDougall 1997: 292).

• This applies to communication and understanding both during the research and when representing the findings of that research to others

3. How is video used in contemporary research

Observation, collaboration and subject’s own images

1. Observational research

2. Collaborative Research

3. Subject/informant videos

4. Academic and social intervention projects

4. Video Observations

What can we learn from video observations?

• We can create visual records of observed behaviours and activities

• These might later be scrutinised by the researcher (and/or viewed by the research participants)

• These representations might later be used for purposes of reporting or as examples in training packages

John Collier’s education research

• The first known use of film in applied education research in the 1950s. Still a useful case study.

• Demonstrates how researchers can use film (video) to visually record aspects of behavior and later analyse these

Alaskan Eskimo Education

• Collier filmed teacher and student interaction and behavior as an observer in a good number of remote and urban Alaskan schools

• He did not work alone as a film researcher but with a team of researchers who were using other qualitative methods (it is important to combine visual and other methods)

•Collier and his colleagues undertook a comparative analysis, across the schools of factors such the physical relationships between pupils and teachers, the materials that decorated the walls of the classrooms and the body language of the pupils and teachers.

•These visible aspects of behavior and interaction showed them how and why different social and cultural approaches to teaching did and did not work in Alaska

•For more examples of Collier’s visual research see an on-line exhibition at:http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/VAR/collier/collier.html

Video observation in contemporary business research

• The Everyday Lives consultancy

http://www.edlglobal.net/index.html

What can we learn from this type of research?

• Visual detail of the visible material contexts people live in

• About people’s everyday routines and activities and the social relationships they involve

• About the choices and decisions they make during the course of the day

• About how they use their homes and the objects that form part of their everyday lives

• This must be qualified by a reflexive approach

Fixed camera to record behavior in the home

• The Mead and Bateson debate showed us the limits of placing a fixed camera to record continuously

• This approach can produce useful footage as long as we understand the role the camera will play in the research process

Open University programme about the home

• Analysis of footage shot by a continuous fixed camera in a family to understand how gender roles are played out within one family

• View video clip

5. Collaborative Research

2 main ways to develop collaborations

• Working with an informant or a group of participants over a long period of time (parallel with long term participant observation)

• Developing a structured collaboration with one or a group of participants in which all are working towards the completion of the research task within a circumscribed short term time frame (parallel with an in-depth interview)

Long term video ethnography

• Might combine video recording with other methods - e.g. interviews, analysis of visual culture and other materials etc

• Has parallels with ethnographic filmmaking - the idea that the filmmaker immerses him/herself in the culture for an extended period

What sort of video materials does this method produce?

• Example of an ethnographic video that was based on long term participant observation:

• Domov by Rosie Read

Advantages

• Long term fieldwork can allow you to video record a wide range of events and activities and to develop close relationships with the video subjects

• The data you produce will be connected with other data sources

• The visual recordings can be analysed in relation to your own continuous observations and experience of the social context you are studying - they are not simply ‘one off’observations

The video interview• Will be based on a short term and structured

encounter with the participant

• Might be combined with a tape recorded interview and the collection of relevant visual and other materials lent to the researcher by the participant

• Multiple or repeat video interviews might take place

Example: the video tour method

• A study of gender identity, housework and home decoration

• An applied project that has also been written up as a academic book

The process• Participants were first interviewed and tape

recorded

• The video tour then commenced: they were asked to show me around their homes discussing each room and the objects in it as we progressed through the house

The limits of this approach

• We do not learn from our own long term observations but learn about our informant’s own representations of their homes and their experiences in them

• We are therefore analysing videos that are representations of representations

• This means we need to reflexively analyse the research context and the relationships we develop with informants as much as the content of the tapes

Advantages of this approach• Researchers can cover a number of informants and their

experiences in a shorter period of time

• The most suitable method for researching and comparing indviduals’ experiences of intimate places like home, or learning contexts requiring minimal disturbance

• This approach is collaborative and not observational so it allows us to hear the ‘voices’ of research subjects

• It generates an intimate context in which to produce knowledge that is uniquely visual and cannot be expressed in spoken or written words

Analysing video tours

• View example from the OU film - Paula’s story

6. Informant-produced video

Video diaries

• A popular genre on TV now - began in the early 1990s

• Also increasingly established as method in social science research

Chalfen and Rich - VIA

• Rich M, Lamola S, Gordon J, Chalfen R. (2000)‘Video Intervention/Prevention Assessment: a patient-centered methodology for understanding the adolescent illness experience’. Journal of Adolescent Health. 27(3):155-165. http://www.viaproject.org/VIAMethod.pdf

VIA (Video Intervention/Prevention Assessment)

• A method developed by Chalfen and Rich to work with the sufferers of chronic Asthma

• A medical research project using methods originating in visual anthropology

Advantages of this methodology include:

• Ability to find out about aspects of people’s lives that they might not think to mention in spoken interviews

• The tapes can be viewed in interview contexts with the informants to elicit further data

• The tapes can be used to represent informants’ experiences to relevant others and can later be used in teaching and training (with correct permissions and consent of course)

7. Analysing, logging, storing and sharing

Working with digital video

Working with digital video

Digital video is recommended - the importance of this will become especially clear once you reach the post-fieldwork stage

• Digitalisation can be very costly after the event

• Working with digital materials brings a wide spectrum of advantages

CAQDAS (Computer assisted Qualitative Data Analysis Software)

E.g.:

• NUD*ST

• Atlas- ti

• Others…

How useful is CAQDAS?• Recent versions of CAQDAS allow you to store and

log video within their systems

• Might be useful for organising and logging large amounts of video data

• The same advice for any user of this software stands - only use it if you potential benefits from the software outweigh the time you will spend setting it up

Other methods of archiving digital video data

• Set up your own archive using Quick-time pro and your own logging system

• Use logging systems that come with video editing software

Sharing digital video data• Share clips with your informants- e-mail then clips for

feedback and comment - do e-mail interviews focusing on these clips

• Share digital video clips with your research team - cut relevant clips and e-mail to your research team or post them to your discussion board or intranet

• Involve other colleagues in your research process - send them clips and other research materials to comment on

8. Representing Video Research

Reporting, Arguing, Advocacy, Training…

Digital video materials allow us to:

• Combine audio visual and written data (knowledge) in our reports

• Create different texts for different audiences

• Make the most of different media (documentary video, hypermedia, printed documents with video stills in them)

Documentary video:

An edited documentary video for

• TV

• academic audiences

• a public awareness campaign,

• use within an organization

Video clips

Used:

• with a conference paper

• as part of a presentation

• to accompany reports

Hypermedia

Advantages of using hypermedia:

• Can combine audio-visual and written knowledge• Can combine theoretical and ethnographic

knowledge• Makes video more meaningful in a reporting

context as it is combined with written words • Can share work on-line

Examples of hypermedia ethnography • On-line reporting of project progress (academic Ruby,

Commercial Lovejoy & Steele)

• CD project representing a range of work (Coover)

• CD ROM development for different audiences project (my own CD projects)

• Chalfen and Rich - their informants’ research video was used in training CDs

On-line reports: Jay Ruby’s work

• The Maintaining Diversity Project in Oak Park, USA

• The first web site: using Flash Software - ambitious and complex http://www.viscom.or.kr/

• The current web site on-line reports and images http://astro.ocis.temple.edu/~ruby/opp/

• Using video on-line needs technological expertise

Coover’s Cultures in Webs

• A CD ROM project produced by a documentary artist with anthropological interests working with multimedia.

• Combines moving and still images and words

• Web sample available athttp://home.uchicago.edu/~rcoover/CIWWeb/CIWWeb.html

Video Tour CDs

• Gender at Home - academic CD project and a commercial series

9. Useful sites and references

Books & articles citedCollier, J. Jnr. (1973) Alaskan Eskimo Education, New York: Holt, Rinehart and

Winston

MacDougall, D. (1997) 'The visual in anthropology' in M. Banks and H. Morphy (eds) Rethinking Visual Anthropology London: New Haven Press

MacDougall, D. (1998) Transcultural Cinema, Princetown University Press

Pink, S. et al eds (2004) Working Images, London: Routledge

Pink, S. (2001) Doing Visual Ethnography, London: Sage

Rich M, Lamola S, Gordon J, Chalfen R. (2000)‘Video Intervention/Prevention Assessment: a patient-centered methodology for understanding the adolescent illness experience’. Journal of Adolescent Health. 27(3):155-165. http://www.viaproject.org/VIAMethod.pdf

Useful links

• Working Images

• Visualising Ethnography

10. Summing up

• Historically connected to the search for objectivity

• Now accepted as a subjective and reflexive form of qualitative data production

• Video methods: observation; collaboration; informants’ videos

• Combine with other methods

• Use digital forms of storage and analysis and share data

• Options for representation: documentary; report clips; hypermedia