using cadgap to climatically contextualize ancient cultures
Post on 05-Apr-2018
226 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
1/30
USING CADGAP (CLIMATIC ANALOGS DATA-
GATHERING PROJECT) TO ENVIRONMENTALLY
CONTEXTUALIZE ANCIENT CULTURES
by
Lewis C. Messenger, Jr. (Skip)
Department of Anthropology
Hamline University
SAA 2012 Session on the Pedagogy of Archaeology and Heritage
Sponsored Electronic Symposium:
Lessons from the Trenches: the Pedagogy of Archaeology and Heritage
(Sponsored by Heritage Values Interest Group, Committee on Ethics)
Saturday, April 21, 2012
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
2/30
ABSTRACT: To understand a culture's "history" involves understanding the climatic and
environmental contexts in which people lived, how these changed over time,
and if such changes tended to result in structural and perceptual
reorganizations, essentially, ancient cultural change. This paper describes a
team-based data-analysis project called "Climatic Analogs Data-Gathering
Project" (CADGAP) used in undergraduate prehistory and cultural ecology
classes. Students use on-line meteorological databases to create spreadsheets
to generate climatic scenarios for past times and regions. By seeing and
evaluating such changes and comparing them with archaeological sequences,
students also develop a greater capacity to relate cultural change to climatic
and environmental change.
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
3/30
How do we get students excited about the history of peoples those others, the
ancestors of todays descendent communities? To understand lives of those in the past, both of
recent history as well as of great archaeological depth, we must understand and situate them in
their environments to create scenarios that reflect what life was like back then. The quest to
understand and illuminate ancient lifeways also involves what people had to contend with during
their own individual lives, but also in terms of the long haul the ancient ups and downs that
helped shape cultures the way they were. Among these are climatic and environmental changes.
Understanding a cultures history involves understanding the environmental contexts within which
they lived, how these changed over time, and if such changes tended to result in structural and
perceptual reorganizations, essentially, ancient cultural change. The natural environment and
climate must not be simply viewed as a backdrop to human affairs, but as something we recognize
as an interdependent dynamic system, constantly in flux, and sometimes offering hints of causal,
and at least possibilistic explanations for those punctuations experienced by cultural changes in the
past.
My purpose here is not to try to describe what I believe to have transpired climatologically
in the past, but to provide a rationale for doing such research as part of understanding site
heritage. Just as the Dust Bowl phenomenon is integrally related with the history and heritage of
peoples of the early twentieth-century American Great Plains, so too is it becoming increasingly
evident that changing climatic precipitation patterns in the eighth-century Yucatan Peninsula may
have had some bearing on the dramatic cultural changes that affected the Maya people there.
The Climatic Analogs Data-Gathering Project (CADGAP) is one tool to help students see
and evaluate such cultural/ climatic/environmental changes. Therefore, as the trials and
tribulations of an ancient people constitutes a major part of what we see as part of their
heritage, then understanding their changing climatic contexts also leads us to a deeper
understanding of their heritage.
PROLOGUE TO CADGAP
As a researcher, I have had a long-standing interest in paleoclimatology and paleoecology
as part of hypothesizing living scenarios of past peoples and cultures. While not viewing climate
1
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
4/30
and environmental change as directly causing particular cultural changes in ancient times, at the
same time, I believe, it clearly is counterintuitive to deny any dynamic relationship between the
two.
My first research foray into these topics was during my graduate research in 1978 when I
began writing research papers considering the possibility of employing meteorological
teleconnections between the ancient Maya area and the British Isles. I was intrigued and inspired
by the writings of Reid Bryson, whose Climates of Hungerintroduced me to the idea of linking
past human affairs to climate change, as well as providing me with bibliographic references
concerning additional research results, discussions of methodology, and other relevant information
(Bryson and Murray 1977), all of which added to my desire for more.
Following the death of my Ph.D. advisor, Dennis Puleston, and unsuccessful attempts to
acquire funding to finish my part of his archaeological research agenda in northern Belize, my
growing interest in what paleoclimatology could offer Mayanists like myself led me to resubmit a
totally revised Ph.D. research proposal, this time focusing on ancient climate change and its
possible relationships to the collapse of Classic Maya civilization. In retrospect, a dissertation on
climate change would have placed me on the leading edge in such research, but an offer to be part
of a reconnaissance and excavation program in central Honduras was hard to pass up, so I back-
burnered my paleoclimatology research.
When I began teaching at Hamline University in the mid 1980s I once again began to try
to understand the nature of the interface between ancient peoples and the dynamic environmental
changes they experienced. I was especially inspired by the work of Sanchez and Kutzbach (1974)
where they looked at historical data on precipitation and temperature departures of the warm and
cool decades prior to the 1960s as sources of analogs for earlier Pleistocene through more
recent climatic patterning. The temperature and precipitation departure maps they produced for
the American tropics contained the area of Maya civilization and this became a research focus of
mine. Fundamentally following Sanchez and Kutzbachs methodologies, I gathered more detailed
and geographically focused data primarily for southern Mesoamerica. This allowed me to create
temperature and precipitation scenarios for various parts of southern Mesoamerica, comparing
globally cool to warm decades. These scenarios could then be integrated into a Holocene
2
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
5/30
chronological sequence. Using the same chronological scales, I integrated a chart representing
the known archaeological sequences for the Maya area.
What emerged was a correlation between hypothesized ancient climatic scenarios and past
archaeological cultural trajectories. Research on recent meteorological departures for the region
had shown a fairly significant complexity, with the Yucatan Peninsula exhibiting localized and
regionalized differences. Climatological series data for the twentieth century indicated that for the
Yucatan Peninsula the pattern of a relatively arid northwest with increasing precipitation as one
headed south and east, as is essentially the case today, was seen to have flip-flopped historically.
Thus this kind of patterning may have occurred in ancient times as well.
This suggested that during some phases of global cooling, the core area of ancient Maya
civilization may have been experiencing below-normal rainfall, possibly even drought. Based
upon my methodology and data, it appeared that periods of pronounced drying would have
occurred in the core area of ancient Maya culture beginning around the same time as many of the
centers there were beginning to show evidence of collapse. As a matter of fact, the correlations
comparing the northwest, versus center, of the Yucatan peninsula suggested that ancient Maya
civilization in the core would have begun to experience stress, while at the same time the
northwest area the Puuc region would have begun to experience a more benign, moister
regimen.
This led to a number of opportunities to research and present talks in a variety of venues
including local organizations like the Maya Society of Minnesota (Messenger 1989), a Hamline
University Faculty Seminar (Messenger 1990a), and the Center for Ancient Studies at the
University of Minnesota (Messenger 1990b). I was asked to contribute an article on my research
to the journalAncient Mesoamerica (Messenger 1990c) and also a chapter in The Formation of
Complex Society in Southeast Mesoamerica (Messenger 1991b). Feedback sent to me by
archaeologists in the field also tended to support my findings.
I have used this approach in my personal research for Mesoamerica, Central America, and
Southeast Asia. It has also been successfully employed in Senior Honors projects for two Hamline
students Karl Kotval (Kotval 1993) and Catalina Salas (Salas 1994). During summer 1993 Karl
Kotval and I presented the methodology for this kind of research at the International Congress of
3
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
6/30
Anthropological and Ethnological Sciences in Mexico City (Messenger and Kotval 1993). It was
met with considerable approval and has led to other invited presentations: Campeche, Campeche,
Mexico in 1996 leading to a published paper in 1997 (Messenger 1996, 1997), Akumal, Quintana
Roo, Mexico where another Hamline student co-authored a paper with me (Messenger and
Bowie 2005) that was later submitted to Climatic Change. A variation of this same paper was
presented in Merida, Yucatan in January 2006 (Messenger, Bowie, and Callaghan 2006). Put
another way, you might say that this approach, looking at relatively recent climatic patterning to
suggest more ancient one, has been "road tested" and is growing in recognition!
Around this time, in the early 1990s, the chair of my department, Cynthia Cone, strongly
suggested that I find a way to integrate my own research into my curricular offerings; to share my
research methodologies, techniques, and results with students in my classrooms fundamentally
in line with the growth of Hamlines student-professor collaborative research agenda.
Initially I had reservations about involving undergraduate students in such collaborative
projects. While I was extremely fortunate in having supportive and helpful advisors throughout
my Masters and Ph.D. careers, I was also keenly aware that I did not want to create projects that
could end up merely exploiting cheap student labor.
BIRTH OF CADGAP
I decided to develop course work that would engage an entire class with a regional
research goal; that the regions would change each time the class was offered; that students would
work in pairs of two; and that their research experiences (pros and cons) along with the results of
their research would be shared with the rest of the class. As part of this curricular development I
came up with the acronym CADGAP, standing for Climatic Analogs Data-Gathering Project.
Our first class, CADGAP I, was in fall 1991; in fall 2011 we completed CADGAP XXVII
(Messenger 1991a, 2011). Figure 1 is a color-coded world map locating all the previous
CADGAP locations (See Appendix A for a full list of CADGAPs from 1991-2012).
Since its inception CADGAP has undergone several incarnations. It was initially designed
to be the main class research project for my Prehistory of the Non-Mediterranean World
4
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
7/30
(Anthropology 3470) class, with a clear focus on understanding the human/climate interface in
terms of retrodicted scenarios within archaeological time frames.
While keeping the same acronym and trend analysis methodology, the CADGAP research
goals for Cultural Ecology (Anthropology 3480) differ in having a future orientation. Its focus is
on contemporary ecology, land-use patterns, and, using the same methodology to develop trend
analyses for global warming versus cooling, to speculate on predicted future climatic scenarios.
For both courses this strategy involves students doing collaborative research with their
peers and with my feedback input as well mostly in the capacity of a coach. There are
individual responsibilities as well as group ones. Individual students research and write up basic
climatic and ecological profiles for a location designated for a particular semesters class. They
then focus on meteorological documentation for those twentieth-century decades reflecting both
prominent globally cool and globally warm periods.
For my Cultural Ecology CADGAP course this information is later applied to develop
regional climatic predictions that can then be used to speculate on associated impacts on local
ecologies, land-use patterns, and so on in future times, given alternating scenarios of global
warming, compared with global cooling. This is a course that students majoring in Environmental
Studies also take and it is offered it at least once a year.
Prehistory of the Non-Mediterranean Worldis generally offered in alternate years.
Instead of trying to predict future climatic scenarios, this class focuses on retrodiction of climatic
scenarios and investigating possible correlations with ancient cultural changes.
CADGAP applications for Prehistory of the Non-Mediterranean World is the focus of
discussion in the following pages.
CADGAP FOR PREHISTORY OF THE NON-MEDITERRANEAN WORLD
As mentioned above, with only a small number of repeats, each class CADGAP has
focused on a new, different region of the world. Both types of CADGAP require a considerable
amount of research and time devoted to the preparation of two instructional student manuals
revised for each semesters geographic focus.
5
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
8/30
For graduation, Hamline students must take a distribution of courses designated as
fulfilling a set of intensive requirements. Both Cultural Ecology and Prehistory of the Non-
Mediterranean Worldhave been developed to meet the Computing-Intensive requirement.
Both courses rely upon students learning how to acquire meteorological data and then be able to
analyze it to develop climatic trend analyses. Each completed CADGAP is worth 40% of the
course grade.
PRIMARY METEOROLOGICAL DATA ASSEMBLY AND ANALYSIS PROCEDURES
I research online resources for each region to be sure that there is sufficient long-series
meteorological data for enough individual locations per region. Class size often determines the
number of meteorological observation stations that will be used, but I try to make sure that there
are enough to allow for later investigation of possible trend patterning. While online data
presented in matrix format is increasingly common, in past CADGAPs I have had to find ways to
convert different presentation formats into rows and columns. This is a necessary step prior to
importing data into an Excel spreadsheet. It is also why I produce my own student manuals
giving instructions on how to (1) locate online databases, (2) reformat the data for ease of
importation, (3) import the ASCII data sets into the spreadsheet and then reformat them into rows
and columns, (4) sort and label the rows and columns, and, (5) insert repeated formulas to
average data by 12-month periods, by month for entire series, by decade, and by twentieth-
century pivotal warm versus cold decades (1930s-1950s versus 1960s). Finally, I show students
how to insert graphs that will visually respond as they analyze their data and will later provide
illustrations for their final individual CADGAP site write-ups.
GENERAL REGIONAL CHARACTERISTICS AND POTENTIAL RESEARCH ISSUES
In addition to the above data background research and how-to manual creation, I write an
additional manual that provides some general CADGAP historical background information,
general regional ecological, archaeological, and heritage characteristics, and examples of several
region-specific research issues. It includes a section on the rationales for the current CADGAP
regional focus and discussions of methodology. This is where I also provide suggestions for ways
6
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
9/30
of analyzing their data using their trend analyses to create retrodicted climatic sequences that
can then be compared with archaeological sequences they have located. This manual also
contains appendices showing the names and locational characteristics for potential meteorological
stations to be used in that particular CADGAP research (latitude, longitude, elevation, beginning
and ending of meteorological data series). Using Excel, I plot the latitudes and longitudes of each
site to illustrate evenness of geographical regional coverage. I create bibliographies of some
relevant references, plus some briefly annotated website lists. Finally, while the ecology, current
land use patterns, and archaeological history will vary according to each specific location, I
provide a brief writeup showing how weather conditions can impact an example of an idealized
cropping calendar, in this case reflecting the work of Hayao Fukui in Don Daeng, Thailand
(1993). This helps students consider what, and when, one might find a subsistence vulnerability
a soft underbelly that might have indicated a mechanism for some kind of cultural tipping
point, or put another way archaeologically observable cultural discontinuities.
IMPLEMENTING CADGAP
Assignment 1: the Graphs. While students have access to a how-to manual containing
detailed step-by-step instructions on how to create a complete CADGAP spreadsheet for their
data, it can initially appear overwhelming. I begin by setting aside three classroom sessions to be
conducted in a computer lab where I do a dry run to demonstrate the individual steps they will
need to follow to complete their first assignment, creating and developing their spreadsheet. This
is necessary to make sure they know how to create the following set of five precipitation graphs:
Graph #1 Average monthly precipitation for their site
Graph #2 Average yearly precipitation (for all years of complete annual records)
Graph #3 Average decade precipitation (with one bar representing each decade record)
Graph #4 Pivotal decade precipitation (4-bar graph for 3 warm decades plus the cool
one)
Graph #5 Pivotal decade precipitation averages (2-bar graph with average for the 3 warm
decades vs. the cool one compared)
7
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
10/30
For the following example I am using graphs created by one of my students in a CADGAP
study focusing on Dakar Yoff, Senegal (Mans 2010). Graphs 1 and 2 provide students with
information that will be used in their description of contemporary environmental conditions.
Graph 1 (Figure 2) illustrates what the 12-month precipitation sequence looks like; Graph 2
(Figure 3) shows how the entire period of recorded average yearly precipitation appears (1900-
2005). With their apparent rambling, these types of graphs often demonstrate how difficult it can
be to discern long-term trends.
Graphs 3, 4, and 5 help the students visually narrow down their data to the point that they
can see how their graphed precipitation trends might correlate, or not, with the major warm
versus cool twentieth-century decades. Graph 3 (Figure 4) breaks the precipitation data for the
entire period of record for Dakar Yoff down into decadal units. Graph 4 (Figure 5) selects only
those decades originally indicated by Sanchez and Kutzbach (1974) as globally warm decades
(1930s through 1950s) and the succeeding cool 1960s. Determining correlative trends looking at
the grouping of the three warm decades in Graph 4 (Figure 5) continues to be somewhat elusive.
Graph 5 (Figure 6) then directly compares the average of the warm decades with the cool one.
The takeway from this graph is that Dakar Yoff, Senegal will tend to be moister by 10.58 mm in
globally cool times than in times of global warming.
Students must embed their graphs within their spreadsheets. Their spreadsheets are then
submitted to me electronically where I can go over them and return feedback. This is necessary
as often an error in typing a particular formula in a cell, once copied, can be disastrous for their
analysis. I also look to make sure that the graphs are correctly labeled and utilize the correct data
series. Often this involves my making alterations and then sending the modified spreadsheet back
to the research team.
Assignment 2: Ecology and Culture Current and Ancient. For their second assignment
students must research and provide a description of the current local natural ecology flora and
fauna, plus a discussion of current climate, here utilizing the data and graphs from what they
generated in Assignment 1. This is where they may introduce any additional references and
descriptions from other paleoecological reconstructions at, or as near as possible to their site.
8
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
11/30
For the next step students must provide an archaeological chronology for their team's site
and/or area. In addition, they are asked to look for any historical references suggesting past
stressful climatic events, such as famines, plagues, floods, droughts major "ups and downs, as
well as cultural discontinuities phases, periods, etc.
Students may use either a hard copy (Figure 7) or spreadsheet (Figure 8) form of a blank
chart where they can fill in their archaeological chronology information. They may hand-write the
archeological phases directly on their hard copy and then later transfer it to their spreadsheet.
Figure 9 shows a view of a partially filled-in chronological spreadsheet where the colored
Climatic retrodiction column is created using their climatic correlations derived from
comparison of their pivotal decade information. They write in the archaeological phase and
period information in the wide Archaeological Historical Sequence column.
Assignment 3: Analysis, Speculation, Reflections and Suggestions, References Cited.
This is where students essentially put it all together. This is where, using the information on
climatic trending that they created with their CADGAP spreadsheets, along with ecological
characteristics, plus whatever information they can find on local and/or regional archaeological
sequences, they make informed speculations about how their data relates to understanding the
ancient, archaeological cultural dynamics for their site. Samples of some potential questions for
them to consider are:
M Do you see any correlations between archaeological cultural discontinuities and the
global temperature curve?
M During globally warm time what are the local precipitation and temperature
characteristics for your site?
M What is the nature of the paleoclimatic record for your site?
M How does your recreation of precipitation trends using your data correlate (or not)
with the Holocene global temperature curve?
9
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
12/30
Also part of this assignment is a section, Reflections and Suggestions for Future Research,
in which they discuss the experience they had doing this CADGAP. Suggested questions include:
M What do you consider as major difficulties you encountered in this project?
M What were the areas you felt you had the greatest success?
M If you had more time for this, what do you wish you could have done?
M What would you suggest for someone taking this project on in the future? What
advice would you give them?
Finally, students must reference their statistical data, ecological descriptions, site history
and archaeological chronology, any ethnographic or ethnohistoric descriptions, and other sources.
in their References Cited (Bibliography) section.
Assignment 4: The Final Edited CADGAP Team Paper. Assignment due dates are
roughly spaced to be one to two weeks apart. Throughout, I provide feedback for each submitted
assignment such that if students are attentive to my suggestions, their final product will be a well-
researched and orchestrated final paper; something potentially of A quality. In addition, the
evaluation sheet that I will use for their final draft is also posted early in the semester on
Blackboard (see Figure 10 for an example).
Assignment 5: CADGAP Powerpoint Team Presentations. At the outset of the course I
get students to try to think of their classmates as part of a learning community of scholars.
Clearly, I am personally interested in the results of their research, but also I want everyone in the
class to know what their peers have done. Student papers are converted to PDF files and put up
on the course BlackBoard site.
Students are required to share their research and findings with the rest of the class through
PowerPoint presentations at the end of the semester. This is a time for them to comment on and
ask questions about the results of their peers efforts. It also provides the class, and myself, an
opportunity to take a broader geographic view by comparing results from all the observation
10
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
13/30
stations covered by student projects. This potentially allows us to detect regional paleoclimatic
trends that may relate to and shed light upon the ancient cultural trajectories of individual sites
and regions.
CADGAP STUDENT TAKE AWAYS PEDAGOGIC OUTCOMES
Since its inception in 1991 each successive CADGAP has changed and, I hope, matured.
The fundamental research methodology, something that began with Sanchez and Kutzbach (1974)
and that became central to my own investigation of possible relationships between climate change
and ancient Maya cultural dynamics, still seems to work. The positive reception I have received
from my presentations and publications (Messenger 1990c, 1996, 1997, Messenger and Kotval
1993) has made it possible to present the CADGAP assignments as something that students can
have some confidence in. They are more than just assignments and students can feel good about
their efforts resulting in actual contributions to knowledge. They are producing viable data, while
at the same time, acquiring new research techniques and knowledge.
How can the relative success of CADGAP be measured? One of the projects fundamental
pedagogical goals has been for students to learn to apply and reflect upon clearly holistic,
interdisciplinary approaches toward understanding the dynamic human-environment interface.
Pedagogically, its goal is epistemological, as it asks students to apply a variety of approaches to
understand what we know about the diverse contexts, or scenarios, within which people in the
past lived. Furthermore, it empowers students to go beyond the basic classroom learning and ask,
in what other ways might we know more?
Perhaps one of the best ways to consider the take-aways of CADGAP research is to look
at student examination responses. Examinations in Prehistory of the Non-Mediterranean World
are take-home exams. The following question complete with original wording and question
instructions is generally found in my final examinations
The following question is potentially free-form, but nonetheless a serious one. Read the
question carefully (if chosen, or if you end up choosing it) and be sure to answer it
thoughtfully and show me your thinking and logical progression in your essays. Pats on
11
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
14/30
the back may be appreciated in some situations, but this is not one of them. I want your
sincere thoughts on this constructive thoughts, but no platitudes, please! In this
question choose either (A) or (B).
(A) For those of you coming out of another discipline (e.g., not anthropology):
Specifically (i.e. with examples) define what you found in this class that
should prove of most use or impact to (e.g., that should be integrated into)
your non-anthropological discipline? Provide an example.
(B) For those of you perceiving yourselves as anthropologists: Specifically (i.e.
with examples) define what you find of greatest value in this class that you
feel strongly should be integrated in the research of other disciplines you
are aware of. Provide an example.
Following are examples excerpted from student responses to this question (note, brackets
are mine). One student wrote,
As the class proceeded through the semester, I found the CADCAP project to be
most valued by me when pertaining to other disciplines. It allowed one to really
delve into the substance of what a research project really calls for, . . . The
environmental research and spreadsheets we were required to put together in
anthropology class allowed me to take into account multiple variables when
[developing] a final analytical assignment.
Another student wrote:
I think the CADGAP project was of the most value in this class in terms of not
only anthropology- archaeological, biological, and cultural, but also the sciences or
any other discipline that requires the in depth look at people and behavior as a
12
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
15/30
result of their changing environments. This project taught us how to infer as to
what climatic changes have occurred over time, in a particular area. From the
information that was gathered it became possible to compare and contrast our
findings with the cultural chronological record, to see if cultures fluoresced,
adapted, or collapsed in cold/dry/warm/wet periods.
This information would be beneficial for a biological anthropologist if there
were environmental stresses that caused famine or disease markers on skeletons.
Cultural anthropologists could look at the changes over time in comparison with
people's reactions to their changing environments today. Archaeologists could use
this information as explanation for possible cultural collapses, in terms of evidence
of squatter populations in later periods. The Sciences could use this information
for meteorological purposes, environmental studies, or for a number of different
reasons. Integrating this portion of our course into another discipline/sub discipline
would be beneficial and interesting on so many different levels.
Yet another student wrote,
For me, one of the most valuable topics in the class was the CADGAP research
project, as this was my first exposure to the technique. Before CADGAP, I had
given little thought to how civilizations are impacted by their environment,
specifically its change. Our own project, featuring Quito, did not have an
abundance of archaeological data available, but every piece of information that we
discovered fit perfectly in our hypothesis that when conditions became abnormally
cold and dry, people organized and great things came out of the culture. Most
groups in the class seemed to come to the same conclusion, merely proving how
significant environmental change is in the ancient world. I would like to see World
history classes and even art classes of the ancient world incorporate this idea into
their teaching plans. Environmental impact seems to be always left out when
13
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
16/30
cultural tensions (and the resulting flourishing of ideas) are discussed; when our
results show that it is one of the most consistently relevant influences.
Clearly, CADGAP research forces students to recognize and think in broad systems terms.
There are a number of lessons to be learned, and this is not lost upon students doing CADGAP
research. For example, they learn that there is a fundamental, meaningful relationship between
weather, climate and land use.
Understanding the climate and environmental settings within which people in the past lived
is equally as relevant as understanding their tool inventory, house form or diet. As climates have
changed, humans have been forced to respond by adjusting their adaptive strategies. There can be
no general rule concerning the benefits or disadvantages of something like increased precipitation.
The impacts of increased precipitation upon humans is multivalent susceptible to many
applications, interpretations, meanings, or values (Oxford Dictionaries 2010). The potential
impacts of precipitation changes upon small-scale hunting-and-gathering foraging societies should
not be assumed to be the same as upon full-scale agricultural societies. Temperature increases
can produce increased precipitation in some places and decreases in others, while some locations
may see relatively little change at all. The relative impacts of rising temperatures in currently hot
desert environments may be minimal, while in the high arctic the effects of an equivalent rise may
be dramatic even catastrophic.
CONCLUSION
Using CADGAP as a computing-intensive assignment in my two courses involves a
considerable amount of work for both my students and myself. At the same time I continue to be
motivated by the fact that my students come to realize through their own research that there exist
complex relationships between human culture and that myriad multifaceted thing that we know as
environment. They discover on their own that this is an ongoing dynamic relationship, and that
climate is one facet that can account for both culture change and continuity. Students learn that
there is no simplistic causal relationship between climate change and particular kinds of
sociocultural adjustments; they do not become environmental determinists, yet at the same time, it
14
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
17/30
becomes patently obvious that a changing dynamic environment and landscape simultaneously
impacts and is impacted by human beings. Students find that through their CADGAP experience
they come up with new questions that they had not thought of; they often feel that they are really
just beginning down the road toward their own corner of scientific inquiry.
I am also motivated by the fact that CADGAPs constitute collaborative research, with
entire classes ultimately functioning as a research team a community of scholars some of
whom become conversant in the subject and get to the level of junior colleague. While the efforts
are great (both mine and the students), I find that I look forward to investigating new areas of the
planet. It is a learning experience for me and I hope at some point in the future to coordinate
findings from previous CADGAPs so that we can share our findings with the larger archaeological
community.
15
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
18/30
REFERENCES CITED
Bryson, Reid A., and Thomas J. Murray
1977 Climates of Hunger: Mankind and the World's Changing Weather. University of
Wisconsin Press, Madison.
Fukui, Hayao
1993 Food and Population in a Northeast Thai Village. Monographs of the Center for
Southeast Asian Studies, Kyoto University, English Language Series No 19. University of
Hawai'i Press, Honolulu.
Kotval, Karl J.
1993 CADGAP XXVI: Retrodicting Past Climatic Sequences: Correlations Between Climate
and Precolumbian Cultural Dynamics for Tlaxcala-Puebla and the Highlands of Mexico.
Unpublished honors thesis, Department of Anthropology, Hamline University, Saint Paul,
MN.
Mans, Caitlin
2010 CADGAP XV: Dakar Yoff, Senegal. Unpublished student research paper for
Anthropology 3470: Prehistory of the Non-Mediterranean World, Hamline University, St.
Paul, MN.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
2011 CADGAP XXVII: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for Nations
of the European Mediterranean Drainage. Unpublished instruction guidebook for
Anthropology 3480, Hamline University, Fall 2011, PDF manuscript.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1997 El "Paleo-Evaluacin del Impacto Ambiental": Algunas Perspectivas SobrePaleoclimatologa Con Respecto a Estudios de los Mayas Antiguas. InLos Investigadores
de la Cultura Maya-5. Pp. 328-347. Universidad Autnoma de Campeche, Campeche,
Mxico.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1996 El "Paleo-Evaluacin del Impacto Ambiental": Algunas Perspectivas Sobre
Paleoclimatologa Con Respecto a Estudios de los Mayas Antiguas. Paper presented to the
VI Encuentro: Los Investigadores de la Cultura Maya. Campeche, Campeche, Mxico.
Thursday, November 14, 1996.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1991b Climatic Settings and Prehistoric Social Complexity: the Central American Isthmus. InThe Formation of Complex Society in Southeast Mesoamerica, edited by William Fowler,
pp. 237-275. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
16
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
19/30
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1991a CADGAP, Climatic Analogs Data-Gathering Project: Student Collaboration in
Archaeological Climatic Research. Unpublished instruction guidebook (Version I) for
Anthropology 146, Department of Anthropology, Hamline University, St. Paul, MN, Fall
1991.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1990c Ancient Winds of Change: Climatic Settings and Prehistoric Social Complexity in
Mesoamerica.Ancient Mesoamerica 1(1):21-40.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1990a Archaeology, the Atmosphere, and the Ancient Maya: Prognostications for the Past.
Presentation to The Hamline University Faculty Seminars, Thursday, January 25, 1990.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1990b Prognostications for the Past: Ancient Weather Patterns and Maya Cultural
Development. Presentation for the Center for Ancient Studies Winter Lunchtime Talk
Series, Wednesday, March 7, 1990, University of Minnesota-Minneapolis.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C.
1989 The Winds of Change: Hurricane Gilbert and Its Archaeological Implications. Paper
presented to the Maya Society of Minnesota, Friday, February 24, 1989.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C. and Karl J. Kotval
1993 Climatic Retrodiction Using Twentieth-Century Meteorological Analogs: Implications for
Understanding Precolumbian Mesoamerican Cultural Development. Paper Presented at the
XIII Congreso Internacional de Ciencias Antropolgicas Y Etnolgicas In the Session:
Paleoclimatologa, Paleohidrologa Y Niveles del Mar En Amrica, Mexico City, August 4,
1993.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C. and Haden L. Bowie2005 Site Climatic Sequence Congruencies in Yucatan? Paleoclimatic and Archaeological
Implications. Paper presented at the Workshop:Defining Climate History in the Americas
over the Last 1500 Years and its Connection to Culture and History, Centro Ecolgico de
Akuml, Quintana Roo, Mxico. March 31 - April 2, 2005.
Messenger, Jr., Lewis C., Haden L. Bowie, and James Callaghan
2006 Implicaciones de los hallazgos Proxies sobre la interpretacin del cambio climtico en
Yucatn. Paper presented at the conference: El Cambio Climtico y Sus Consecuencias en
la Pennsula de Yucatn: Pasado, Presente y Futuro, Simposio Permanente:Naturaleza y
Sociedad en el Area Maya. Organized by the: Academia Mexicana de Ciencias and
sponsored by the Centro de Investigacin Cientfica de Yucatn (CICY) and theUniversidad Autnoma de Yucatn (UADY), to coincide with the AR4 Third Lead Author
Meeting of the Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change (IPCC), Mrida, Yucatn,
Mxico, January 18-20, 2006.
17
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
20/30
Oxford Dictionaries
2010 Multivalent. Oxford Dictionaries. Oxford University Press. Electronic document,
, accessed April 01, 2012.
Salas, Catalina
1994 Retrodicting Climatic Sequences: Examining Relationships Between Climate and
Populations in the Rise and Decline of Mississippian Culture Focusing on Cahokia.
Unpublished honors thesis, Department of Anthropology, Hamline University, Saint Paul,
MN.
Sanchez, W. A. and J. E. Kutzbach
1974 Climate of the American Tropics in the 1960's and Possible Comparisons with Climatic
Variations of the Last Millennium. Quaternary Research 4:128-135.
18
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
21/30
Figure 1: Map illustrating world regions covered from CADGAP I through XXVII.
19
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
22/30
F i g u r e 2 : B a a p h l l s t a t n t h a v a m o n t h l y p c p t a t o n f o D a k a Y o f f , S n a l f o
1 9 0 0 5 0 0 ( M
a n s
0 1 0 ) .
F i g u r e 3 : L n a p h l l s t a t n a n n a l a v a p c p t a t o n t n d s f o D a k a Y o f f , S n a l ,
f o m
1 9 0 0 5 0 0 ( M
a n s
0 1 0 ) .
0
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
23/30
4 w
w
6
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
24/30
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
25/30
7 E x b C A G A P
N W
z T
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
26/30
8
z
y
j
2 4
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
27/30
F i g u r e 9 : S c n c a p t s h o w n a n x a m p l o f a f l l d n E x c l c h o n o l o c a l c h a t f o
G
a a q l E c a d o . H t h s t d n t h a s p o v d d c o l o c o d n f o t h p c p t a t o n s c n a o s
a n d t x t n t h a c h a o l o c a l s q n c .
5
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
28/30
1 0 P
N M W C A D A P ( )
6
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
29/30
APPENDIX: COMPLETE LIST OF CADGAPS 1991-2012
Each of the following had student instruction guidebooks and manuals made available to the class,
with many still available as PDF manuscripts.
Archaeologically Oriented CADGAP Projects forPrehistory of the Non-Mediterranean
World(Anthropology 3270)
M CADGAP, Climatic Analogs Data-Gathering Project: Student Collaboration in
Archaeological Climatic Research (1991). (In the first versions students could choose
whatever region and site they preferred and the CADGAP did not receive a number.)
M CADGAP III: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for Africa's Iron-Age and Bantu Dispersal (1993)
M CADGAP VI: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for Ancient China (1994)
M CADGAP VIII: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for Ancient Brazil (1997)
M CADGAP X: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for Ancient Mxico (1998)
M CADGAP XIII: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for the Ancient Indian Subcontinent (2000)
M CADGAP XIV: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for Ancient Mainland Southeast AsiaThailand, Cambodia, Vietnam,
Laos, and Myanmar(2001)
M CADGAP XVI: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for Ancient Oceania (2003)
M CADGAP XIX: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for the Ancient Andean Region (2005)
M CADGAP XXIV: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research
Retrodicting Climatic Scenarios for the South American Lowlands: Amazonia,
Orinoquia, and the Gran Chaco (2010)
M CADGAP XXV: Student Collaboration in Archaeological Climatic Research Retrodicting
Climatic Scenarios for Sub-Saharan West Africa (2010)
27
-
8/2/2019 Using CADGAP to Climatically Contextualize Ancient Cultures
30/30
Future-Oriented CADGAP Projects for Cultural Ecology (Anthropology 3480)
M CADGAP II: Student Collaboration in Anthropological Climatic Research (1993) (In this
version students could choose whatever region and site they preferred
M CADGAP IV: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for the Indian
Subcontinent Student Collaboration in Anthropological Climatic Research (1994)
M CADGAP V Present-Day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for Thailand
(1994) CADGAP V (Messenger 1994b) and
M CADGAP VII: Climatic Analogs Data-Gathering Project Present-Day Meteorology
and Future Cultural Implications for Thailand Part 2 (1996)
M CADGAP IX: Present-Day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for East Asia
(China, the Korean Peninsula, and Japan) (1998)
M CADGAP XI: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for the
Republic of Mxico. (1999)
M CADGAP XII: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for Western
South America Ecuador, Colombia, Peru, and Chile (1999)
M CADGAP-XV: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for Sub-
Saharan West Africa (2001)
M CADGAP XVII: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for South
and Southeast Africa (2004)
M CADGAP XVIII: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for the
Northern Pacific and Bering Sea Region (2004)
M CADGAP XX: Present-Day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for NorthernEurope the Baltic, Scandinavian, and British Isles Regions (2006)
M CADGAP XXI: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for the
Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East(2006)
M CADGAP XXII: Present Day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for China,
Mongolia, and Adjacent Russian Siberia (2008)
M CADGAP XXIII: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for
Australia and New Guinea (2009)
M CADGAP XXVI: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for Oceania
Polynesia, Micronesia, and Melanesia (2011)
M CADGAP XXVII: Present-day Meteorology and Future Cultural Implications for Nations
of the European Mediterranean Drainage (2011)
28
top related