using a teach the teacher-program to implement a new ebm · pdf file · 2012-11-141...

1

Using a Teach the Teacher-program to implement a new EBM-based teaching

method for residents and staff members

T. van Kempen MSc., Prof. Dr. P.J. Dörr,

Prof. dr. F.W. Dekker

Center for Innovation in Medical Education

LUMC

Je n’ai aucune affiliation

(financière ou autre) avec une

entreprise pharmaceutique, un

fabricant d’appareils médicaux

ou un cabinet de

communication.

I do not have an affiliation

(financial or otherwise) with

a pharmaceutical, medical

device or communications

organization.

Author: Tanja van Kempen MSc.

Date: oct/11/2012

3

Tanja van Kempen MSc.

Educationalist

4

overview

• Background

• What is a CAT?

• The problem

• Our solution

• Result

• Pros/cons

5

Background

• CanMEDS in the Netherlands

2011

• role of scholar: the CAT was made

compulsory

6

Do you know what a CAT is?

7

Do you know what a CAT is?

• A Critically Appraised Topic (CAT) is a

practical tool for learning and applying

critical appraisal skills1,2

• EBM3

8

CAT4

1. Patient encounter

2. Clinical question

3. Literature search

4. Critical appraisal

5. Summarising evidence

6. Commentary

7. Bottom line www.mediview.org

9

CATs in education5

Undergraduate training programme

Clinicians

Postgraduate training programme

• concise and

connect theory to

practice

• self-teaching tool

10

The question

• How can we implement this new

educational tool in the Leiden area?

11

The problem

• The CAT was a completely new method

• We had a large number of residents who

had to be trained

12

Our Solution

• Train the staff members in a Teach the

Teacher

13

literature

• Role modeling is a powerful tool in EBM6

• Doctors often seem to have a lack of

knowledge about EBM terms, but the

majority wanted to know more about

EBM7

14

The solution

• We developed a 2 day Teach the Teacher-

program for so-called CAT tutors

15

Aims for the TtT

• Introduce the 7 step method

• Increase knowledge and skills

• Provide didactical background

16

Teach the Teacher

Trainers

3 epidemiologists

1 pediatric cardiologist

1 clinical librarian

1 educationalist

17

Teach the Teacher

Participants

Different specialists

from the whole

region

Minimal EBM skills

required

18

Patient (practice) transition Medical science (literature)

1 clinical scenario

2 clinical question 3 literature search

4 critical appraisal

5 summarising

evidence 6 comments:

Thorough reflection on

the evidence

7 bottom line

Key words

TtT day 1

19

Patient (practice) transition Medical science (literature)

1 clinical scenario

2 clinical question 3 literature search

4 critical appraisal

5 summarising

evidence 6 comments:

Thorough reflection on

the evidence

7 bottom line

Key words

TtT day 2

20

Results

We evaluated the TtT in two ways

• immediate

• after 6 months

21

Results after training

overall appreciation

N=37

M=4

Dev=0.5

22

Results after training

relevance

N=38

M=4.2

Dev=0.5

23

Results after training

combination of

literature and practice

N=38

M=3.9

Dev=0.7

24

Results after training

active learning style

N=39

M=4

Dev=0.6

25

Results after training

quality of the trainers

N=38

M=4.3

Dev=0.6

26

Results after training

time investement

N=39

M=3.9

Dev=0.6

27

Results after training

aims of the course are

reached

N=39

M=3.9

Dev=0.6

28

Results after training

I am going to use some

aspects in practice

N=37

M=4.4

Dev=0.5

29

Results after 6 months

I am using the course mainly for my own

work – I learned a lot! At this time I don’t

have any residents.

30

Results after 6 months

The training was very good but its hard to

find time in our busy schedule to guide the

residents (25!) and let them present their

CATs.

31

Results after 6 months

I am now more confident that I can help my

residents – those 7 steps where

completely new for me.

32

Pros and Cons

33

Pros of using a TtT for

implementing the CAT

• Important to include staffmembers in education

reform

• Updating skills and knowledge from staffmembers

• Education in EBM should be workplace related

• Many departments can be helped at the same

time

34

Cons of using a TtT for

implementing the CAT

• It is impossible to foresee all the local problems

staffmembers encounter while introducing the

CAT in their department

• Sometimes it is difficult for staffmembers to

‘teach’ their colleagues

• The implementation depends on one

staffmember, if he/she doesn’t prioritise the

CAT, nobody will.

35

Q & A

•Download the ICRE App,

•Visit the evaluation area on

Level 2 near registration, or

•Go to

www.royalcollege.ca/icresurveys

to complete the session

evaluation.

You could be entered

to win 1 of 5

$100 gift cards.

Vous courrez la chance de gagner

l’un des cinq chèques-cadeaux

d’une valeur de 100 $.

Help us improve.

Your input matters.

Aidons-nous à nous

améliorer. Votre opinion

compte.

•Téléchargez l’application de la CIFR

•Visitez la zone d’évaluation, au deuxième

étage près du kiosque d’inscription

•Visitez le

www.collegeroyal.ca/icresurveys

afin de remplir une évaluation de

la séance.

literature

1 Dawes M. (2005) Critically appraised topics and evidence-based medicine journals. Singapore Med

J. 46:442-448;quiz, 449

2 Sauve S., Lee HN., Meade MD.m et al. (1995) The critically appraised topic: a practical approach to

learning critical appraisal. Ann Roy Soc Phys Surg Can 28:396-398

3 Kelly, A.M., Cronin, P. (2011) How to perform a critically appraised topic: Part 1, ask, search and

apply. AJR: 197 November 2011

4 Brouwer, de C. P.M. Training Critical Appraisal of a Topic. ISBN: 978-90-77201-31-2

5 Wiebe S. & Demaerschalk B. (2002) Evidence based care in the neuroschiences. Can J. Neurol.

Sci. 29: 115-119

6 Sacket et al. in Aiyer, M.K. & Dorsch, J.L. (2008) The transformation of an EBM curriculum: a 10-

year experience. Medical Teacher 30:377-383

7 Oliveri, R.S. Gluud, C. & Wille-Jorgensen, P.A. (2004) Hospital docters’self-rated skills in and use of

evidence-based medicine. J Evaluation in Clinical Practice 10, 2: 219-226

38

• Teaching critical appraisal skills to health

professionals improves knowledge but

there is a lack of evidence that it changes

the process of care of patient outcomes.

There are large gaps in the evidence

(Cochrane review 2010)