the universal savings credit
Post on 08-Aug-2018
217 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
1/25www.americanprogress.o
The Universal Savings Credit
By Christian E. Weller and Sam Ungar July 19, 2013
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
2/25
The Universal Savings Credit
By Christian E. Weller and Sam Ungar July 19, 2013
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
3/25
1 Introduction and summary
4 Inefficiencies in the current system
10 The Universal Savings Credit balances
and simplifies savings incentives
14 Additional issues related to the implementation
of the Universal Savings Credit
18 Conclusion
20 Endnotes
Contents
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
4/25
1 Cnt Acan p |Th Unva savn C t
Introduction and summary
Te nancial crisis o 2007 o 2009 ook a remendous oll on household wealh
and shatered he sense o nancial securiy or millions o American amilies.
American households los more han $20 rillion in wealh (in 2012 dollars) in
he Grea ecession, and households sill had $10 rillion less in wealh a he end
o 2012 han hey had beore he crisis.1 Tis massive wealh decline conribued
o a widespread loss o economic securiy, paricularly among lower-income and
moderae-income amilies, single women, and communiies o color.
Tis economic insecuriy can have long-ranging adverse eecs on U.S. economic
growh as American amilies:
Inves less in new businesses, which slows produciviy growh and innovaion
Save less or large long-erm expenses such as reiremen and heir childrens col-
lege uiions, which leads o less-sable nancing or capial invesmens
Become less likely han hey would wih more wealh o swich jobs and careers
when beter opporuniies arise, which slows employees produciviy
Te botom line: Economic insecuriy rom decimaed household wealh oday
could poenially reverberae hrough our naions economy or a long ime
hrough slower growh, ewer jobs, and lower living sandards. Helping house-
holds rebuild heir wealh should hereore be a op policy prioriy.
Te ederal governmen already uses he ax code o incenivize people o save,
ypically hrough ax advanages or paricular orms o savings. Employers and
employees can oen deduc heir conribuions o reiremen savings vehicles,such as 401(k) plans, rom heir axable income, and he capial gains in reire-
men savings plans are no subjec o axaion unil people wihdraw he money.
Te ederal governmen loses income ax revenue ha i oherwise would have
received while people save and hen recuperaes some o he los ax revenue
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
5/25
2 Cnt Acan p |Th Unva savn C t
when people wihdraw money or reiremen and hen pay income axes. Te
underlying idea is ha hese ax advanages encourage more people o save more
money or reiremen han hey oherwise would have. Similar incenives exis or
people o save or healh care and heir childrens educaion, bu reiremen sav-
ings incenives are by ar he mos prevalen and larges ax savings incenives ha
he ederal governmen oers.
Ye a closer look a he ax incenives or reiremen savings as well as oher similar
incenives or healh care savings and educaional savings suggess ha he curren
sysem suers rom wo key ineciencies:
Upside-down tax incentives: ax deducions carry a greaer value or people
wih a high marginal ax rae han or people wih a lower marginal ax rae.
A person whose las dollars earned all ino he op income ax bracke, or
insance, aces a marginal ax rae o 39.6 percen. Ta is, each dollar o a
ax-advanaged conribuion o a reiremen savings accoun reduces he axesha his person owes o he ederal governmen by 39.6 cens. A lower-income
earner wih a marginal ax rae o 10 percen, however, reduces he money hey
owe o he ederal governmen by only 10 cens or every dollar ha hey con-
ribue o reiremen savings. Te value o he ax incenive is upside down, as i
is almos our imes larger or high-income earnerswho arguably do no need
much help o savehan i is or lower- and moderae-income earners, who
ypically have a hard ime saving.
Savings complexities: Employers and employees can choose rom a wide range
o reiremen savings vehicles. Tere are dened-bene pensions and dened-
conribuion savings plans, he later o which come in a whole hos o favors
401(k)s, 403(b)s, SIMPLEs, SEPs, IRs, and oh IRs, jus o name a ew.
Moreover, all o hese reiremen savings plans come wih heir own rules o
who can save wih hem, how much money people can save, and when he ax
advanages occurduring he conribuion phase, during he invesmen phase,
or during he wihdrawal phase. Tis complexiy oen sands in he way o
people aking ull advanage o all o he ax incenives available o hem.
Because o hese wo ineciencies, he ederal governmen is no geting as muchaddiional savings as i ideally could rom he oregone ax revenue. More ecienly
designed savings incenives, however, would generae more bang or he buck, as
people would save more han is currenly he case or every dollar in ax incenives.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
6/25
3 Cnt Acan p |Th Unva savn C t
We propose o vasly simpliy exising savings incenives by urning all exising
deducions ino one single ax credihe Universal Savings Credi. Wih his
credi, people would receive a fa percen o heir conribuions o a predeer-
mined savings accoun, regardless o heir income and how much money hey owe
in ederal income axes. People can use he savings ha hey accumulae wih he
Universal Savings Credi or a wide range o purposes, such as paying or healhcare or educaion, puting a down paymen on a rs residence, saring or expand-
ing a business, an economic emergency such as unemploymen, and reiremen.
We also envision only one se o rules or conribuing money, invesing money,
and wihdrawing money ha will govern savings or hese purposes, as discussed
urher below.
Our goal is o end he curren sysem o upside-down savings incenives and o
sreamline savings incenives o make i easier or people o undersand wha hey
can save, how much hey can save, and when hey can wihdraw heir money.Lower-income households, who need more help in saving, will ge more help
rom he new ax incenives han rom he exising ones, and everybody will nd i
easier o undersand ax incenives. Te resul o hese changes should be more-
ecien savings incenives and hus more saving.
More savings are good no only or individuals bu also or he economy as a
whole. Building wealh more quickly increases economic securiy. People will
have more money available or shor-erm emergencies and or longer-erm goals
such as buying a house, saring a business, and sending heir children o college.
Greaer shor-erm and long-erm economic securiy should ranslae ino aser
economic growh, as people can beter handle changes in he economy. More
economic securiy will allow people o ake a longer-erm view and beter plan or
possible economic changes such as sending children o college, saring a business,
and swiching jobs and careers.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
7/25
4 Cnt Acan p |Th Unva savn C t
Inefficiencies in the current system
Existing tax incentives are skewed toward the rich
Exising savings incenives in he ederal ax code are mosly deducions rom ax-
able income. Employee and employer conribuions ino a ax-advanaged savings
planprimarily ino reiremen savings vehicles such as 401(k) plans, IRs, and
dened-bene pension plansypically reduce he axable amoun o income
or employees and employers. Te money in a ax-advanaged savings vehicle hen
accumulaes wihou employers and employees having o pay axes on he capialgains in he savings plans. axes are due, however, when money is wihdrawn or
reiremen or oher purposes.2
Te ederal governmen uses hese ax incenives primarily o ge people o save
or reiremen, bu similar ax incenives exis or healh care savingsino Healh
Savings Accouns, or example, which allow people o pay or healh care coss
ha are no covered by insuranceand or childrens college educaion o subsi-
dize uiion paymens.
Te percenage o he conribuion o a ax-advanaged savings plan ha can be
deduced rom axable incomehereby lowering ones ax burdenis deer-
mined by a households ax bracke: Te more a axpayer makes, he more hey
are incenivized o save. Te highes ax brackeor hose annually making
more han $400,000 individually or $450,000 joinlyis 39.6 percen.3 Tose
Americans orunae enough o earn more han ha sum o money pay 39.6
percen o every dollar above ha ceiling in axes, bu hey are also able o deduc
39.6 cens o each dollar conribued o an eligible 401(k) or IR rom heir oal
ax burden. Tis is also rue or conribuions o eligible Coverdell Educaion
Savings Accouns, or ESAs, or anicipaed college uiion expenses and eligibleHealh Savings Accouns, or HSAs, or savings oward medical care.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
8/25
5 Cnt Acan p |Th Unva savn C t
Te riches Americans are also hose who are mos likely o have access o an
employer-sponsored savings plan in he rs place, allowing hem o build a
healhy nes egg wih unneeded ax incenives. Sixy-seven percen o workers
making $70,000 or more a year paricipae in an employer-sponsored reiremen
plan, bu ha number drops o precipiously or lower-income households. Only
32.4 percen o workers making beween $20,000 and $29,999 a year paricipaein an employer-sponsored plan, and jus 6.9
percen o hose making less han $10,000
a year paricipae.4 Similarly, higher-income
earners are more likely o ge access o healh
savings accounshrough so-called caeeria
bene plans such as ax-advanaged parking
and ransporaion and child care expenses
rom heir employers.5
Empirical evidence shows ha higher-incomeearners only replace nonax-advanaged savings
wih ax-advanaged savingsha is, higher-
income earners would save similar amouns
wihou savings incenives.6 Tis ineciency
means ha he ederal governmen may spend
as much as $92 billion in scal year 2013 on
reiremen savings incenives or he op quin-
ile o earners alone, wihou acually increasing
personal savings beyond where savings would
have already been i axpayers in he op h o he income disribuion save as
much as hey do wih or wihou he ederal ax benes.7
On he oher hand, middle-class amilies in he 20 percen o 30 percen ax brack-
es are less likely o ake advanage o exising incenives because hose incenives
do no reward long-erm nancial planning nearly as well.
Te sysem oers even less help or lower-income Americans, who do no have as
srong o an incenive o save as he rich. Working amilies in he 15 percen ax
bracke are only able o claim 15 cens or every dollar conribued o a deducion-eligible savings plan, and mos working amilies generally do no receive he
bene o employer 401(k)-plan conribuions eiher. Tis is in spie o he ac
ha hey are he amilies who need he mos help o build long-erm wealh in
imes o economic uncerainy and nancial insecuriy.
Figure 1
Total Employee Participation in Employer Sponsore
Defined Benefit and/or Defined Contribution
Retirement Plans, by Annual Earnings
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
Less than
$10,000
$10,000
$19,000
$20,000
$29,000
$30,000
$39,000
$40,000
$49,000
$50,000
$75,999
$7
Source: Craig Copeland, Employment-Based Retirement Plan Participation: Geographic Dierence
Trends: 2011 (Washington: Employee Benefts Research Institute, 2012).
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
9/25
6 Cnt Acan p |Th Unva savn C t
Indeed, some working-class amilies pay no ederal income ax a all , hough hey
do pay payroll axes. Tis is one o he mos imporan aces o he naions pro-
gressive sysem o axaion: Te working poor, who sruggle o make ends mee on
a day-o-day basis, should no be orced o pay ederal axes beyond heir means.
Because heir marginal ax bracke is zero percen, however, hey are able o
deduc zero percen o money saved oward reiremen, educaion, or healh care.For hese Americans, here is no incenive rom ax deducions o save oward
heir living expenses in reiremen.
Tese upside-down savings incenives resul in a pronounced imbalance in who
benes rom he ax deducions on he books. Te ederal governmen orgoes
abou $140 billion in revenue annually rom ax deducions or conribuions o
savings, bu only 3 percen o ha $140 billion goes o he botom 40 percen o
earners, who need he mos help o save. On he oher hand, 80 percen goes o
he op 20 percen o earners, wih almos 50 percen o he ax subsidies going o
he op 10 percen o earners.8
Academic research also conrms ha ax incenives are he leas-eecive way o
generae new savings in he highes ax bracke o earners.9 Tese high-income
earners are largely aking advanage o incenives in he ax code o be rewarded
or behavior hey would have engaged in anyway.
A poenial counerargumen may be ha low-income Americans would no ben-
e rom savings incenives anyway since hey canno save, as hey need o spend
all o heir money on lies necessiies. Academic sudies have shown, however,
ha low-income households can and do indeed save wih argeed and progressive
incenives. From March 5 o April 5, 2005, 14,000 ax lers a H& Blocks in low-
o middle-income neighborhoods o S. Louis, Missouri, were randomly assigned
maching oers or IRs o zero percen, 20 percen, and 50 percen up o $1,000
($2,000 or married ax lers). Only 3 percen o lers ook he zero percen
maching oer, while 8 percen and 14 percen o lers acceped he 20 percen
and 50 percen maching oers, respecively. Te lower incenive o 20 percen
alone caused nearly hree imes as many people o sign up or an IR han he plan
wih no incenive a all.10
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
10/25
7 Cnt Acan p |Th Unva savn C t
A similar experimen in ulsa, Oklahoma, lends urher credence o he willing-
ness o low-income Americans o build long-erm wealh, nding ha paricipans
were capable o planning and implemening heir nancial goals over a muli-
year ime horizon.11 Low-income amilies were encouraged o se up Individual
Developmen Accouns, or IDAs, a orm o subsidized savings accoun in which
wihdrawals can only be made or cerain auhorized purposes such as purchasinga home or saring a business. o incenivize he use o hese accouns, wihdraw-
als or purchasing a home were mached a a 2-1 rae and were mached or all
oher allowed purposes a a 1-1 rae, wih $750 in wihdrawals per year eligible
or maching. Te program had signican avorable impacs on asse-building
among low-income persons.12
Te botom line is ha lower-income Americans would likely save more han hey
currenly do i hey received higher savings incenives han hey currenly do.
Confusion over existing savings incentives results in saver paralysis
Te ax codes incenives o encourage reiremen, educaion, and healh care sav-
ings are so conusing ha even hose households ha would like o ake advanage
o hem are deerred rom doing so. Tey nd i dicul o nd a way hrough he
red ape creaed by governmen incenives and privae plans.
Te reiremen savings sysem alone is a complex web o accouns and incenives
ha is dicul o navigae wihou he assisance o a nancial proessional.13 Te
conusing naure o his sysem may be bes illusraed graphically. (see Figure 2)
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
11/25
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
12/25
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
13/25
10 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
The Universal Savings Credit
balances and simplifies
savings incentives
Balancing incentives
Addressing he upside-down savings incenives and heir complexiy could creae
more savings or millions o middle- and low-income households. Congress should
ac o replace he various employer and employee deducions o reiremen, healh,
and educaion savings accouns wih one Universal Savings Credi, or USC.
Because his incenive is a ax credi raher han a ax deducion, i equally rewardseach dollar saved, wheher rom a axpayer in he 39.6 percen bracke or a axpayer
in he 10 percen bracke. Imporanly, he credi will be revenue neural. Ta is,
he money o nance i will come rom ending he curren sysem o savings incen-
ives. Te credi will be a fa maching percen o all conribuions o qualied
savings vehicles. Te savings incenives will only depend on he amoun saved.
Wha would he credi rae look like? Currenly, a axpayer receives a ax bene
by deducing he conribuions o a reiremen savings accoun, or insance,
rom heir axable income. So a axpayer wih income in he 15 percen marginal-
income ax bracke as heir highes ax bracke who conribues $2,000 o a
reiremen savings accoun lowers he amoun o income axes he or she owes by
$30015 percen o $2,000. Pu dierenly, he oal savings o $2,000 includes
$1,700 o income ha he axpayer would have had even aer axes and an implici
governmen conribuion o his or her savings o $300. Te governmen essen-
ially subsidized each dollar conribued o a savings accoun wih 17.6 cens
$300 relaive o $1,700o ax savings.
A ax credi, however, works dierenly han a deducion. A axpayer conribues
a xed amoun o money o a qualied savings accoun, and he governmenprovides a proporional conribuion o ha savings accoun in he orm o he
ax credi. Te axpayer will ypically claim a credi on his or her annual income
ax ling or he previous year. So a axpayer in he 15 percen income ax bracke
would need o receive a credi o 17.6 cens or each dollar saved in order o be as
well o as wih a ax deducion.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
14/25
11 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
Tis is jus an illusraive example, bu he ax credi or savings should be sruc-
ured such ha mos axpayers will be eiher as well o or beter o wih he
Universal Savings Credi han hey are wih curren savings incenives in he orm
o ax deducions. Mos exising proposals o conver ax deducions ino ax cred-
is envision ax credis o abou 15 percen o 20 percen across he board o all
axpayers, up o a predeermined maximum annual savings amoun, which wouldoer larger savings incenives or he majoriy o axpayers han he curren sysem
o deducions does.17 Te ax Policy Cener also ound ha an 18 percen mach-
ing ax credi is he equivalen o a 15 percen reiremen savings deducion.18
Te same sudy rom he ax Policy Cener concludes ha a 30 percen credi
across he board would be revenue neural. Ta is, he majoriy o axpayers
would eiher receive a larger ax bene rom a ax credi han rom he curren
sysem o ax deducions or he credi would have no eec on heir ax liabiliy.19
Conribuion maches should be progressive so ha lower-income earners receivea relaively larger mach, such as a 2-1 mach or 1-1 mach, assuming sucien
unds are available.
axpayers would receive he governmen maches, up o a maximum annual
conribuion amoun. Te maximum annual conribuion amoun would need o
be se once he credi rae is esablished, such ha he Universal Savings Credi is
revenue neural relaive o he exising sysem o ax deducions. Ta is, he newly
creaed sysem o savings incenives would no cos he governmen more han
he exising sysem o savings incenives, bu i would be more ecien and hus
generae more privae savings rom individuals han is currenly he case.
Curren savings incenives also include he ax-ree receip o realized capial
gains, dividends, and ineres paymens rom invesmens in a qualied accoun.
As such, here is an upside-down elemen o he ax reamen o he invesmen
gains since capial gains, dividends, and ineres paymens are subjec o some
progressive axaion, wih larger invesmen gains incurring relaively larger axes.
axpayers wih larger invesmen gains consequenly receive a proporionally
larger savings incenive due o he curren ax reamen o invesmen gains.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
15/25
12 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
Tis comparaively larger ax incenive or higher-income earners when money
is saved is ose by he ax reamen when he savings are spen. All o he pas
conribuions and invesmen gains are subjec o income axaion once axpayers
wihdraw heir money rom heir accouns. Federal income axes are sill progres-
sive, so ha higher-income earners pay a larger share o heir income in axes when
hey wihdraw money. Our proposal envisions ha he ax reamen o inves-men gains in savings accouns and o wihdrawals rom such accouns remains
he same as is currenly he case.
Simplifying incentives
Te Universal Savings Credi will no make any disincion beween savings pur-
poses o eliminae he labyrinh o exising savings incenives. Ta is, people can
use he credi o save or educaion, homeownership, healh care, and reiremen.
Allowable reasons or wihdrawals rom hese savings accouns should machhe reasons or exising allowable hardship wihdrawals in reiremen savings
accouns, including reiremen, down paymen or a primary residence, an unem-
ploymen spell, medical bills, and educaional expenses. Te fexibiliy o use
money or a wide range o reasons should encourage people o save more money
han hey would have saved in more resriced savings.
Tere should be a limi or prereiremen wihdrawals, however, in order o pre-
ven abuse. Households should only be able o wihdraw he acual amoun neces-
sary or he wihdrawal reason, along wih a predeermined percenage o heir
accrued savings or emergencies beore age 62. Saring a age 62, however, house-
holds should be permited o wihdraw all o heir money or reiremen income.
Limiing he amoun ha people can wihdraw rom heir savings accouns in any
one insance will mean ha money will acually be available he nex ime hey
need o dip ino heir savings and or reiremen.
A subsanial share o savings could also pass on o heirs, as savers do no always
spend all o heir savings during heir lieime. Te curren sysem consequenly
requires ha savers sar o wihdraw a minimum amoun o heir savings a a
specic age, ypically once hey urn 70-and-a-hal years old. o limi he publicsax liabiliy, USC-eligible accoun holders should also be required o make a mini-
mum wihdrawal when hey reach a cerain agesay, 70-and-a-hal years o age,
which maches he exising minimum-required wihdrawal rules or reiremen
plans. Tis would make clear ha savings are mean o suppor peoples incomes
when oher income sources are no longer available.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
16/25
13 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
People can apply he newly creaed credi o exising savings accouns such as
IRs and 401(k)s, as well as o dened-bene pensions, bu new conribuion
and wihdrawal rules will also apply. Conribuion rules, or insance, will be he
same or IRs and or 401(k)s, unlike in he curren sysem, which ses lower
conribuion limis or IRs han or 401(k)s. Savers can also wihdraw money
rom hese accouns or reasons oher han reiremen. Te poin o mainainingexising plans is jus o make i easy or people o coninue saving in ways ha are
already amiliar o hem.
All savings in accouns ha are eligible or he credi should also have deaul
invesmen opions. Tese deaul invesmen opions will auomaically apply
unless savers speciy oher invesmen opions. Tis will help avoid siuaions
in which saved money simply sis in an accoun and does no earn any ineres.
Savers will over ime experience aser growh wih heir savings han wih holding
money solely in cash.
Te Inernal evenue Service should also provide an opion or auomaic conri-
buions o any savings accoun eligible or he Universal Savings Credi on annual
ax-reund ling orms. Tis will increase paricipaion in he savings accouns
eligible or he credi and hus raise peoples savings over ime.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
17/25
14 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
Additional issues related to
the implementation of the
Universal Savings Credit
Tis repor aims o make he argumen or ending he exising upside-down ax
preerences ha provide he larges savings incenives or households who do
no need much exra help o save and he smalles incenives or households who
arguably need he mos help. Tis repor also argues ha a change rom savings
incenives in he orm o ax deducions o reundable ax credis should go along
wih a large-scale simplicaion o exising savings incenives. Tere are a number
o pracical issues, however, ha require addiional atenion.
Trading off maximum contributions and credit rate
Tis proposal envisions a fa credi or all axpayers, poenially coupled wih a
progressivelargercredi or lower-income axpayers. axpayers would receive
he credi up o an annual maximum conribuion o all accouns combined. Te
implemenaion o he Universal Savings Credi would be revenue neural relaive
o he exising sysem o ax deducions. In oher words, he proposed sysem o
he Universal Savings Credi likely will change who receives ax benes or sav-
ings bu no how much he ederal governmen spends on such incenives.
Te combinaion o revenue neuraliy, annual maximum conribuions, and a fa
credi rae implies ha here is a radeo beween maximum conribuions and he
credi rae. A higher maximum conribuion per axpayer means ha more conri-
buions are eligible or he credi, hus reducing he money available or he credi.
Consider a basic numeric example o illusrae his poin. Les say, or argumens
sake, ha he amoun annually available or savings incenives is $100 billion or
2013. Te ederal governmen could, or insance, allocae his money as a 33.3percen credi or all axpayers, wihou a progressive mach.20 Te maximum
amoun ha all axpayers ogeher could conribue would hen be $300 billion,
since $100 billion is equal o 33.3 percen o $300 billion. Assume again, or argu-
mens sake, ha his means ha he maximum amoun ha any axpayer could
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
18/25
15 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
conribue and qualiy or he credi or each dollar hey conribue o a savings
accoun is equal o $10,000 in 2013ha is, each axpayer can conribue a
maximum o $10,000 and receive $3,333 as credi rom he ederal governmen.
Te governmen may alernaively decide o raise he maximum savings amoun
by 25 percen o $12,500. Assuming ha his will increase oal savings by, or
insance, 10 percen o $330 billion21
or 110 percen o $300 billionhe credirae would have o all o 30.3 percen, since $100 billionhe oal amoun
available or he crediis equal o 30.3 percen o $330 billion. Te numbers will
obviously no line up his way in realiy, bu he basic poin remains ha a higher
maximum allowable conribuion will mean a lower credi, and a lower maximum
allowable conribuion will mean a higher credi.
Dieren groups o axpayers will bene rom eiher a higher maximum amoun
or a higher credi. Mos lower- and moderae-income axpayers will nd i dicul
o save housands o dollars each year and hus will never come close o maximum
allowable amouns, which are currenly $17,500 or 401(k) plans, or insance. Assuch, a axpayer who can realisically save only $2,000 per year will no see any
disadvanage rom policymakers lowering he maximum conribuion amoun
rom, or insance, $17,500 o $10,000. A credi o 33.3 percen compared o a
credi o 25 percen on $2,000 o annual savings, however, will provide he ax-
payer an addiional $166 per year in his example. Lower- and moderae-income
axpayers will mos likely bene more rom a higher credi han rom higher
maximum conribuion amouns.
Higher-income earners will likely bene rom being able o save larger amouns
and receive he ull credi or heir savings. Les say ha he choice is beween
a maximum conribuion amoun o $5,000 a a fa credi o 33.3 percen and a
maximum conribuion amoun o $10,000 a a fa credi o 25 percen. In his
example, a axpayer who can conribue $10,000 will receive eiher a credi o
$166.50 or o $250, depending on which combinaion o maximum conribuion
amoun and credi rae policymakers choose.
Te quesion is how much more sensiive savings are o changes in he credi rae
compared o changes in he maximum conribuion amouns or lower-income
and middle-income households, who need o increase heir savings more hanhigher-income earners. Te a priori assumpion is ha a higher credi is beter
han a lower credi, bu he empirical quesion is where he ideal maximum sav-
ings cuo should be o help lower-income and middle-income households mos
in saving or heir uure. William G. Gale, co-direcor o he ax Policy Cener,
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
19/25
16 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
concluded in a 2011 sudy ha a revenue-neural credi, assuming he same
conribuion limis as beore, would equal 30 percen.22 Lower conribuion limis
han currenly are in place would allow or eiher a larger credi or all axpayers or
or he creaion o a progressive mach or lower-income axpayers.
Treatment of ex isting savings vehicles
Te Universal Savings Credi could be applied o any savings accoun as long as
i is properly regulaed by he relevan regulaory agencies, such as he Securiies
and Exchange Commission, he Inernal evenue Service, and he Deparmen o
Labor, among ohers. Conribuions o exising savings accouns such as 401(k)
plans and IRs can quali y or he credi, as can newly creaed savings accouns.
Exising savings accouns, however, would have o operae under he uniorm new
rules ha would apply o all qualied savings vehicles. Exising savings vehiclesor reiremen, or example, include dened-conribuion savings accouns, such
as 401(k) plans and IRs, and dened-bene pensions, such as single-employer
pensions and muliemployer pensions. Dened-conribuion accouns oer savers
more invesmen and wihdrawal choices, bu hese choices also come wih higher
coss and greaer risks han is ypically he case or dened-bene pensions. All o
hese savings vehicles could heoreically coninue o exis, bu hey would oper-
ae wih a uniorm maximum conribuion amoun, a uniorm credi or conribu-
ions, and a uniorm se o deaul rules or wihdrawing unds.23
I is enirely possible ha he creaion o he Universal Savings Credi, which ax-
payers could use in fexible ways o save or whaever purpose is mos imporan
o hem, will lead o a prolieraion o new savings vehicles. People could heorei-
cally go shopping or savings vehicles ha beter mee heir needs han exising
savings plans since savings would be less ehered o employers han is currenly
he case. Financial-service providers could respond o his growing demand by
oering a range o savings plans ha currenly do no exis. Policymakers could
encourage he creaion o low-cos and low-risk savings opions where hey do
no already exis. Te Universal Savings Credi should hence be implemened
joinly wih a new ype o low-cos accoun or low- and middle-income house-holdspreerably he Cener or American Progresss Secure, Accessible, Flexible,
and Ecien, or SAFE, plan24bu here are a variey o proposed programs ha
would also provide low-income workers wih more-secure and lower-cos reire-
men savings vehicles.25 Any such proposal, joined wih he Universal Savings
Credi, would ensure ha savers no only save more money bu also ha heir
money is saely invesed or uure purposes.26
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
20/25
17 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
Tracking annual contribution limits
Te new sysem o savings wih he Universal Savings Credi will allow savers o
save as much ouside o an employer-sponsored savings plan as wih an employer-
sponsored savings plan such as a 401(k) plan. Te maximum conribuion limi
will consequenly apply o each axpayer, no o an individual accoun. Tisrequires, hough, ha some eniy will keep rack o how much each axpayer has
already conribued o one or more qualied accouns. I seems easies o keep
rack o all conribuions hrough he IS, since he ax auhoriy will also admin-
iser he paymen o he credi by handling a axpayers annual ax reurn.
The employer-based savings system
Te Universal Savings Credi will inerac wih he exising employer-sponsored
sysem in dieren ways since his proposal envisions wo criical changes ohe ax reamen o employer-sponsored savings. Firs, he annual conribuion
limi applies uniormly regardless o wheher a axpayer saves in an employer-
sponsored savings plan or no. Second, employers could no longer deduc heir
conribuions o reiremen savings plans so ha axpayers could receive higher
credis han hey oherwise would. Te proposed credi will be revenue neural.
ax incenives ha are currenly beneing employers would direcly bene
employees under he proposed credi. Tese changes may lead some employers
o cu back or weaken heir exising reiremen savings plans, especially exising
dened-bene pensions.
Bu he sreamlined savings incenives ha will be ied o axpayers could also
resul in larger paricipaion raes in some dened-bene pensions. Te credi
would allow axpayers o shop around or he bes opion or heir money. Tere
is no reason why some exising dened-bene pensions, such as muliemployer
plans in he privae secor or public-secor plans, should no be able o oer
reiremen savings opions o individuals who wan o inves heir savings and ax
credis wih hem.27 Some axpayers who currenly do no paricipae in a dened-
bene plan will wan o use heir money o ge access o hese benes. I is hus
conceivable ha he Universal Savings Credi will ranslae ino a greaer parici-paion in dened-bene pensions. Ta is, he newly creaed credi could resul
no only in more people saving more bu also in more people enjoying low-cos,
low-risk reiremen benes.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
21/25
18 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
Conclusion
Te ederal ax code should help low- and middle-income Americans sruggling
o rebuild he wealh hey los over he course o he Grea ecession, bu odays
ax incenives or savings are more o an obsacle han an aid. Te curren sysem
is demonsrably skewed in avor o hose who acually need he leas help build-
ing wealh, and i remains so complex ha even hose low- and middle-income
Americans who are posiioned o bene simply canno navigae i a all.
Te Universal Savings Credi will correc his imbalance and simpliy hesysem. Wih his credi in place, he American people can nally begin o shi
rom riaging heir nances in he shor erm o building sabiliy and securiy
or he long erm.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
22/25
19 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
About the authors
Christian E. Weller is a Senior Fellow a he Cener or American Progress and
a proessor o public policy a he McCormack Graduae School o Policy and
Global Sudies a he Universiy o Massachusets Boson. His areas o exper-
ise include reiremen income securiy, macroeconomics, money and bank-ing, and inernaional nance. He is also a research scholar a he Universiy o
Massachusets Amherss Poliical Economy esearch Insiue and an insiue
ellow a he Universiy o Massachusets Bosons Geronology Insiue. Prior o
joining he Cener, he was on he research sa a he Economic Policy Insiue,
where he remains a research associae.
Sam Ungar is a Special Assisan or Economic Policy a he Cener or American
Progress. Sam graduaed magna cum laude rom Georgeown Universiy wih
a bachelor o ars in governmen in May 2012. He inerned a he Cener in
2011 on he Doing Wha Works projec and has also inerned a Lake esearchParners, Common Cause, and on Capiol Hill. He originally hails rom Scoch
Plains, New Jersey.
Acknowledgements
We are very graeul o Michael Etlinger, Seh Hanlon, and Kity ichards or
oering us heir experise on a range o complex issues. All errors are our sole
responsibiliy.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
23/25
20 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
Endnotes
1 Auth cacuatn ba n Ba gvn th Fa rv st, ra Z.1 F FunAccunt th Unt stat (2013).
2 rth irA an rth 401(k) cv a nt taxavanta. Cntbutn t th t avn
an ccu at a taxa ha a n c tax, butnvtnt an an thaa th avnaccunt a tax .
3 American Taxpayer Relie Act o 2012, pubc la 240,112th Cn., 2n . (Janua 1, 2013).
4 Ca Can, ent-Ba rtnt panpatcatn: gahc dnc an Tn, 2011(wahntn: e Bnt rach inttut,2012); Ca Can, ent-Ba rtntpan patcatn: gahc dnc an Tn,2007 (wahntn: e Bnt rach int-tut, 2008).
5 data U.s. Buau lab stattc, NationalCompensation Survey(U.s. datnt lab, 2013).
6 ec m. enn an wa g. ga, Th ect 401(k)
pan n Huh wath (wahntn: Natna Bu-au ecnc rach, 2000); dan J. Bnjan,d 401(k) ebt inca savn?,Journal oPublic Economics 87 (5) (2003): 12591290.
7 F unta ata Cnna Butoc, Th dtbutn maj Tax exntu nth invua in c Tax st (2013), avaab athtt://.cb.v/ubcatn/43768. Th Cn-na But oc, CBo, un that th ncn vnu cct th t qunt taxabtn th cunt tax t an a t n hchcntbutn t tnt accunt tax ana nc an n hch nvtnt ann ntnt accunt tax a na nvtntnc a $92 bn.
8 lna Buan an th, dtbutna ect dn Cntbutn pan an invua r tnt
Accunt (wahntn: Tax pc Cnt, 2004); sthHann, Tax exntu th wk: Tax-d r-tnt savn, Cnt Acan p, Janu-a 19, 2011, avaab at htt://.acan./u/n-vnnt/n/2011/01/19/8862/tax-xntu--th-k-tax--tnt-avn/.
9 enn an ga, Th ect 401(k) pan n Hu-h wath; Bnjan, d 401(k) ebt incasavn?
10 eth duf an th, savn incntv l-an m-inc Fa: evnc a Fexnt th H&r Bck, The Quarterly Journal oEconomics 121 (4) (2006): 13111346.
11 g m an th, evauatn th Acanda dntatn: Fna evauatn rt
(Cab, maachutt: Abt Acat inc., 2004),avaab at htt://.uc.u/t/cha/idAa/ubcatn/abt%20Add%20na..
12 ib.
13 paa pun an C. eun stu, rat Ttn pnn r (phaha: pnn rachCunc, 2004). Th tnt t an acx n 2013 a t a n 2004.
14 ga r. mtta an sthn p. Utku, Can Th BT much Chc n a rtnt savn pan? (VaF, pnnvana: Vanua Cnt rtntrach, 2006).
15 shna sth-ina an th, H much Chc
T much? Cntbutn t 401(k) rtnt pan. inova s. mtch an sthn p. Utku, ., Pension De-sign and Structure: New Lessons rom Behavioral Finance(N yk: ox Unvt p, 2004).
16 pnt Av pan n Tax r, Simple, Fair,and Pro-Growth: Proposals to Fix Americas Tax System(U.s. datnt th Tau, 2005), . 15.
17 r Atan an th, rn ou Tax st,rucn ou dct (wahntn: Cnt A-can p, 2012); Natna Cn n Fca r-nbt an r, Th mnt Tuth (2010);pt dnc an Ac rvn, rtn AcaFutu: rvvn th ecn, Cuttn snn andbt, an Catn a s, p-gth Tax st(wahntn: Batan pc Cnt, 2010); danBanan an th, otn t r th duc-tn H mta intt (wahntn: Uban-
Bkn Tax pc Cnt, 2011).
18 wa g. ga, A pa t rtuctu rtntsavn incntv n a wak ecn th ln-Tdct (wahntn: Uban-Bkn Tax pcCnt, 2011), avaab at htt://.bkn.u/~/a/ach//a/2011/9/08%20tnt%20ncntv%20a/0908_tnt_n-cntv_a..
19 ib.
20 incun a v atch nt chan thxa nc t taxa b a vatch u b an th a v nc, h tca nt hav nuh n t cntbut atth axu aunt, a hat a atcaunt u b.
21 mt taxa nt cntbut th annua axuaab aunt t th tax-avanta avnaccunt. Th Tax pc Cnt un that jut 6cnt k cntbut th axu a-ab aunt n 2003. s Jantt Kaach an th,makn maxu U Tax-d rtntAccunt (wahntn: Uban-Bkn Tax pcCnt, 2005).
22 ga, A pa t rtuctu rtnt savnincntv n a wak ecn th ln-T dct.
23 Th thaa an a aut a-nthat , av can tha n th a-nun th cntactua a t a a t thaa an. sav cu, n tanc, at nvt th n n -nuanc annut thata a t nc un tnt n xchan vn u th tunt t u th avn -
ca xn, ucatn, an th c an.Th chc nvn un th Unva savnCt ncu th chc t tct n tn av vau th acat bnt th tctn than th tctn.
24 dav maan, makn savn rtnt ea,Cha, an m scu (wahntn: Cnt Acan p, 2012). Th sAFe an a v-u ca th cctv n-cntbutn an.
http://www.cbo.gov/publication/43768http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/IDApays/publications/abt%20ADD%20final.pdfhttp://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/IDApays/publications/abt%20ADD%20final.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.brookings.edu/~/media/research/files/papers/2011/9/08%20retirement%20incentives%20gale/0908_retirement_incentives_gale.pdfhttp://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/IDApays/publications/abt%20ADD%20final.pdfhttp://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/IDApays/publications/abt%20ADD%20final.pdfhttp://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/open-government/news/2011/01/19/8862/tax-expenditure-of-the-week-tax-deferred-retirement-savings/http://www.cbo.gov/publication/43768 -
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
24/25
21 Cnt Acan p |Th Unv a s avn Ct
25 F a ua -ct an -k avnvhc, Chtan w an A Hbun, statt th rcu: pc otn stat gvnnt tpt pvat sct rtnt savn,Journal oPension Benefts 18 (1) (2010): 3747.
26 ruatn n t a vn c attntn t thct an k acat th tax-avanta avnthan cunt th ca. Th Cnu Fnanca p-tctn Buau a a cuca n nun thatav av an nvt th n n aatvhc, a hth th xtn t
tax uctn ta n a hth a n cattax ct ac t.
27 mut an an ubc-ct an aaa tanan ntt that a t u t tack anana nvua v th cu th ca. it b a t ana cntbutn nvuat a n-bnt nn an th bnt a cah-baanc-an ua ath than a tatnana-ava-a ua, but a t bntua hu b ab t accat nvuacntbutn.
-
8/22/2019 The Universal Savings Credit
25/25
The Center for American Progress is a nonpartisan research and educational institute
dedicated to promoting a strong, just, and free America that ensures opportunity
for all. We believe that Americans are bound together by a common commitment to
these values and we aspire to ensure that our national policies reflect these values.
We work to find progressive and pragmatic solutions to significant domestic and
international problems and develop policy proposals that foster a government that
is of the people, by the people, and for the people.
top related