science a la carte? shirley m. malcom wheres the beef?

Science a la Carte?

Shirley M. Malcom

Where’s the Beef?

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

2

Low levels of public science literacy

• What people know

• What people believe

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

3

Science and Public Policy

• Global warming

• Stem cell research

• HIV / AIDS

Science and Politics?

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

4

Is there a place for science-based decision-making in today’s political environment?

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

5

The danger of false dichotomies

• Environment vs. economy

• Public health vs. sexual permissiveness

• Religion vs. science

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

6

When science is necessary

• Economic development

• National security

• Quality of life

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

7

When science is “inconvenient”

• Clash of values

• Implications are politically unpalatable

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

8

When science is confusing

• Tentative nature

• “There’s theory and then there’s theory”

• When “experts” disagree

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

9

Culture wars?

• A response to uncertainty?

• Slowing the pace of change?

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

10

What opportunity to understand the nature of science?

• The role of formal education

• The role of informal education

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

11

Early education in science is essential foradult literacy

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

12

What happens in school?

• Sense making

• Science as a dynamic body of knowledge

• Nature of science

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

13Source: Horizon Research, Inc.

Mean Ratings of Indicators of Quality of Mathematics/Science Content: K-12

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

14 Source: Horizon Research, Inc.

Mathematics / Science Is Portrayed as Dynamic Body of Knowledge

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

15

Source: Horizon Research, Inc.

Content Focus of Observed Lessons: Science

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

16

The View from College

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

17

The Nature of Science

Health as a CompellingPersonal Topic

SCIENCE A LA CARTE? WHERE’S THE BEEF?

18

What to do?