review karya ilmiah untuk dipublikasikanlp2m.uin-malang.ac.id/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/... ·...

Muhaimin Rifa’iE-mail: rifa123@ub.ac.idJL. Kamelia 21, Malang

081233011126

REVIEW KARYA ILMIAH UNTUK DIPUBLIKASIKAN

WHAT REVIEWERS LOOK FOR

• Good design and methods

• Simple tables and figures

• Logical organisation

• Brevity

• Balance

• Appropriate statistics

PAPER SUBMISSION

Electronic files and via the internet

Cover letter

Hard copy

Number of copy

Express service, DHL

Number of words, figures, tables, date submitted

✓ NATURE or SCIENCE rejects more than 90% submissions

✓ Response immediately, most often without sending

them out for review

✓ Acceptance without revision

✓ Acceptance with revisions

✓ respond quickly

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 5

MENGENAL JURNAL INTERNASIONAL BEREPUTASI

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 6

https://beallslist.weebly.com/

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 7

https://www.scimagojr.com/

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 8

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 9

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 10

https://www.scopus.com/search/form.uri?display=basic

https://www.journalguide.com/

https://journalsuggester.springer.com/

https://journalsuggester.springer.com/https://journalfinder.elsevier.com/

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 13

Do you or your colleagues know the journal?Can you easily identify and contact the publisher?Is it clear what fees will be charged?Predatory Journal?SCOPUS?

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 14

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 15

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 16

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 17

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 18

IF THERE IS A COMPETITOR IN YOUR FIELD

“ We would prefer that Dr. Brown of the University

of Harvard not review our paper. His laboratory is

in direct competition with ours”

Outright Rejection

✓ Do not despair if your paper has been rejected outright

✓ Go to another journal

SECOND LETTER TO THE EDITOR WITH RESPONSES TO REVIEWER

Your second chance must be a model of clarity and must address every issue that was raised by editor and reviewersIdentification number should be included

Dear Professor Brown,re: “Essential Roles of CD8+CD122+ Regulatory T cells in the Maintenance of T Cell Homeostasis” by Muhaimin Rifa’i, Yoshiyuki Kawamoto, Izumi Nakashima, and Haruhiko Suzuki; ms. No 20040395

We hope that the revised version of our paper is now suitable for publication in Journal of Experimental Medicine and we look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 22

Don't give up before fighting

Don't give up before fighting

Don't give up before fighting

Don't give up before fighting

Don't give up before fighting

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 23

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 24

Mon, Oct 7, 1:45 PM

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 25

Oct 24, 2019, 2:34 PM

H-index

• indeks-h adalah jumlah h terbesar sehingga h

publikasi memiliki setidaknya h kutipan.

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 27

Paper Jumlah sitasi1 402 253 154 135 56 27 18 09 010 0Cara menghitung h-index yaitu:• h-index 1 = ada 1 paper yang disitasi minimal satu kali• h-index 2 = ada 2 paper yang disitasi minimal dua kali• h-index 3 = ada 3 paper yang disitasi minimal tiga kali• h-index 4 = ada 4 paper yang disitasi minimal empat kali• h-index 5 = ada 5 paper yang disitasi minimal lima kali• h-index 6 = ada 6 paper yang disitasi minimal enam kali.

06/11/2019 jurusan biologi, universitas brawijaya 28

TERIMAKASIH