presentation_zube lecture final
Post on 18-Aug-2015
8 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Exploring Regenerative Capacities in Urban Morphologies of the Planned Industrial Cities of New England İpek Kaynar Rohloff, PhD irohloff@mtholyoke.edu
Landscape Architecture and Regional Planning, UMass-Amherst
ZUBE Lecture, Oct.3rd, 2013
Focus: Industrial urban form and economic redevelopment
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 2
Take away: How to create capacity for diversity in market sectors and land uses within a utilitarian infrastructure and morphology; how to promote vibrancy.
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 3
Overview
1- Problem statement and investigation Urban change and economic redevelopment plans
3- Comparison case studies Holyoke, Lowell and Maynard
4- Holyoke analysis Current urban form and proposed changes in renewal plans
5- Discussion Capacity creation within morphology
2- Theory and methodology Urban form and human (land/space) use patterns
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 4
Problem Statement Economic redevelopment plans in a declined urban setting
Market diversification and regeneration through new sectors in mill town settings irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 5
Investigation Is economic redevelopment supported within the urban form?
Holyoke, est. 1829
Lowell, est. 1822
Maynard, est.1871
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 6
Museumification
Adaptive reuse of the mills
Cases Revitalization and redevelopment in planned industrial cities
Implementing new buildings and uses
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 7
The planned industrial cities of New England Urban form characteristics
The orderly layout of the five original mills and the rows of the first boardinghouses
Lowell, est. 1822
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 8
Plan of Lowell. c. 1830
Lewiston, Maine. c. 1851
The planned industrial cities of New England Urban form characteristics: the grid
Plan of Lawrence, 1845 Plan of Holyoke, 1938 irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 9
Methodology Reading urban morphology and land-use
Block size
Parcel size
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 10
Methodology Reading urban morphology and land-use Urban Grid
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu Connectivity in the grid (Schumaher, 1978)
Smaller blocks for frequent encounters (Jacobs, 1961)
11
Methodology Reading urban morphology and land-use
“Metric reach” (Hillier, 1996; Peponis et al, 2008)
Urban Grid
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 12
Methodology Reading urban morphology and land-use
Street network
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 13
Modeling human movement
Methodology Reading urban morphology and potential land-use
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 14
Holyoke Urban form characteristics
Downtown (The Center City), Holyoke irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 15
Analysis Holyoke downtown urban morphology
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 16
Analysis Holyoke urban morphology: street network in current form
Spatial Accessibility
low (0.00)
high (1.00)
medium (0.50)
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 17
Analysis Holyoke downtown urban morphology: blocks and rehabilitation areas
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 19
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 20 Map of opportunities & challenges (City of Holyoke)
Analysis Holyoke economic redevelopment and renewal plans
Analysis Holyoke economic redevelopment and renewal plans
The Center City vision plan (City of Holyoke) Key development nodes (City of Holyoke)
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 21
Analysis Holyoke downtown urban morphology: street network within proposed arteries
Spatial Accessibility
low (0.00)
high (1.00)
medium (0.50)
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 22
FINDINGS Does the morphology support proposed redevelopment?
The existing street network is too homogenous to attract people’s movement to those areas.
Proposed pedestrian arteries do not make the canal zone the most attractive destination point. They intensify the destination capacities for the High and Main Streets between Dwight and Cabot Streets.
The industrial infrastructure elements (i.e. canals and railroad) create divisions hindering the connectivity of neighborhoods
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 23
The divisive role of the infrastructure elements as well as the block size properties, economic redevelopment and urban renewal plans will render two different urban characterizations at two sides of the central canals.
WHAT DO THESE FINDINGS MEAN? Holyoke characterized within two districts: Residential and Regional
The districts between the riverfront and the canals will be regionally connected and will enable a more dramatic transformation of the blocks and implementation of uses serving to the region….
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 24
The districts in the northeast seem appropriate for more mixed use development with residential character, supported by smaller blocks, street density and improved walkability and social encounters.
WHAT DO THESE FINDINGS MEAN? Holyoke characterized within two districts: Residential and Regional
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 25
CONCLUSIONS Capacities and Challenges
Dense urban grids create the capacity for walkability while retaining the existing destinations. This is suitable for residential and mixed use development.
Industrial infrastructure elements are still divisive. This separates activities and uses between the two sides of the canals.
Large mill buildings open to rehabilitation provide great potential for more dramatic transformation in the districts less connected to the proposed mixed use residential developments.
Not clear if demographics changing towards young technical staff of small start-ups will create a communal environment or a diversity of markets/uses.
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 26
Planned industrial cities like Holyoke present rigidity in adapting diversification of market and emergent uses, due to: • Divisive infrastructural elements • Large blocks at the core • Conservative changes in urban blocks.
Capacities and Challenges for Planned Industrial Cities
Design strategies promoting connectivity and diversity
• Opening up buildings to streets, • Dramatic changes in large and divisive
building blocks, • Connecting and re-purposing green open
spaces
Erica Rayack
Shannon Pace
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 27
Lowell , 1822-2013
Capacities and Challenges for Planned Industrial Cities Lowell was revitalized through historic preservation (of mills) and regeneration through tourism and service economies.
Lowell was planned with a farsighted systems thinking and community building strategies
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 28
Capacities and Challenges for Planned Industrial Cities
Maynard, 1846-1982: Regional impact: employment and technology corridor development
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 29
• How human movement and land use patterns are impacted by changes in block characteristics.
• How open space properties affect people’s perceptions of urban information.
More new methods of investigation are needed to detect and visualize:
Student work: Ella Holmes
Urban Network Analysis, MIT
Future work What new/improved methodologies would better predict the impact of urban change?
This would allow us to better understand connections between community development and economic activity.
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu 30
Questions? İpek Kaynar Rohloff, PhD
irohloff@mtholyoke.edu
top related