nov 13 th 2013 paul coates p_coates1@sky.com thoughts on bim maturity teams organisations...

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Thoughts on BIM Maturity

BIMTeams

OrganisationsIndividualsProjects

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Informational islands that have historically existed in the AEC industries (Hannus 1995)

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

PlannerExplain

Building Control

End User

ClientDesign Team

Connecting

The requirement for each party is different

Semiotics

Contractor

Model view definitions

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

The Red Queen Effect

As Best Practice advances, it is necessary to change to remain competitive

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Why do we want BIM maturity ?

To Achieve Greater ROI

Better Buildings

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

BIM File Organisation (Heng 2011)

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

How can we achieve this?

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

????

????

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Level 2           A managed 3D environment held in separate discipline 'BIM' tools with data attached. Commercial data will be managed by enterprise resource planning software and integrated by proprietary interfaces or bespoke middleware. This level of BIM may utilise 4D construction sequencing and/or 5D cost information. The Government’s BIM Strategy Paper calls for the industry to achieve Level 2 BIM by 2016.

Level 3           A fully integrated and collaborative process enabled by 'web services' and compliant with emerging Industry Foundation Class (IFC) standards. This level of BIM will utilise 4D construction sequencing, 5D cost information and 6D project lifecycle management information.

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Consult Australia 2010

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

BIM Maturity Indexes

COBITBIM MeetlatBIM SuccesspredictorBIMM (Succar 2009)NBIMS CMM (McCuen and Suermann 2007)

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Control Objectives for Information and Related Technology (COBIT)

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Capability Maturity Model Integrates

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Bilal Succar 2004

Technology Process Policy

Sof

twa

re

Har

dwar

e

Net

wor

k

Con

trac

tual

Reg

ulat

ory

Pre

par

ator

y

Lea

ders

hip

Infr

a S

truc

ture

Hum

an

|Res

ourc

es

Pro

duc

ts &

S

ervi

ces

BIMe

http://bimexcellence.net/

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

NBIMS 2007

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

BIM IMPLEMENTATION: MANCHESTER TOWN HALL COMPLEX RESEARCH REPORT (University of Salford)

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

NBIMS 2007

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

NBIMS 2007

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Skills required ?

David Cracknell

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Skills required ?

Indiana University BIM Proficiency Matrix (BPM)

projects.buildingsmartalliance.org/files/?artifact_id=3364

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Efficiency gains of collaborative BIM (Smith 2012)

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Synchronous vs Asynchromous Communication – Graphic credit Ramius

Best Solution

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Successful Collaboration has been described as Synergy, where the sum is greater than all the parts; i.e. 2+2=5.

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

The concept of a BIM Big Room to facilitate collaboration

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Revit Server 2013

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

AutodeskBuzzsaw

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

BIM viewed as a sociotechnical system with technological base of social components (Kennerley 2012)

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Collaboration on multiple devices

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Information Delivery Manual An information delivery manual (IDM) provides significant help in getting the full benefit from a building construction information model (BIM). If the information required is available when it is needed and the quality of information is satisfactory, the construction process itself will be greatly improved.

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com

Tool for Benchmarking BIM Performance of Design, Engineering and Construction Firms in The NetherlandsRizal Sebastian and Leon van Berlo

AECbytes Viewpoint #33 (December 6, 2007) The Interactive Capability Maturity Model and 2007 AIA TAP BIM Award WinnersTammy McCuen, Major Patrick Suermann, P.E.

An integrated approach to BIM competency assessment, acquisition and application Bilal Succar, Willy Sher, Anthony Williams

CIFE, NBIMS

References

Nov 13 th 2013Paul Coates P_coates1@sky.com