kolja mendel, managing partner - acita · kolja mendel, managing partner acita national meeting,...

2

Kolja Mendel, Managing Partner

ACITA National Meeting, London, 3 October 2019

Global Tariffs, Additional Duties and Origin

3

Brief introduction

— Mendel is a highly specialised publishing firm reaching back to the sixties of the last century.

— We are subject matter experts for global customs and foreign trade policies, regulations and measures, including tariffs and additional duties.

— In our classical publications like the German magazineFOREIGN TRADE we follow, explain and discuss current developments in this specific domain.

— Beyond that we provide specialised information anddata content services, covering the fields of tariffs, rules of origin, export controls and sanctions.

4

Service areas and labels

Our services are differentiated by areas and rendered under the following labels:— Specialised publications: MendelPublishing— Online information services: MendelOnline— Data content provision: MendelContent— Research services: MendelResearch— Integrated services— Governmental services

5

Market Access Database (MADB)

A comprehensive tool on tariff and non-tariff measures of various destination countries available under http://madb.europa.eu and major source for this information in the EU:

6

Is there a problem?

‘Why do you state our goods were duty-free in the UAE? We actually do pay duties there.’A practical case: Import of computers into the UAE …and the attempt to explain the duties being paid:

— Customs duties?The GCC countries have acceded to ITA1 …

— Internal taxes?Not implemented before 2018 …

— Customs clearance fees?Not applicable to regular clearance …

— Charges for handling and brokerage!At least a reason is found …

7

‘We could save millions in duties if I found a sponsor for this undertaking. However, in our corporation customs duties are treated as shared costs and nobody is really interested in that.’

— A relative lack of concern regarding customs duties?At least compared to internal taxation and especially towards third countries …

— Duty optimisation as the aim of projects?Yes, but often with a specific focus (e.g. preferences) ...

— Does optimisation not imply a sound state?… whilst there should be a complete overview.

— Are processes the condition or the result?Optimisation may be the result, but processes appear to be the condition.

Where is the problem?

8

Which parties and interests are involved?

Manufacturer

Exporter Forwarder

Carrier 1 Carrier 2 Carrier 3

Distribution Partner

Importer Trader

Country border

9

What is the implication of Incoterms®?

Exporter

Carrier 1 Carrier 2 Carrier 3

Importer

Country border

EXW

FCA

FAS

FOBCIF

DDP

DAT DAP

10

Are the duties paid indeed the duties due?

‘We work with a sufficient margin to cover the risks of the import duties.’‘We apply a worst case scenario as to duties and taxes.’

— Who is the debtor?Although the debtor is defined by customs law(importer or representative) …

— Who pays what?… the actual payer is set out by the contractual terms between the parties.

— Duties or costs?Duties imposed by law should be distinguished from costs of service providers …

— Cost transparency vs. flat rates?… which is only possible when there is cost(and duty) transparency.

Importer

Declarant

Distribution Partner

Exporter

11

Are the duties applicable to the commodity in question?

— What is the relevant criterion?Classification is decisive for all duties and taxation measures ...

— Who does the classification?… and thus calls for a thorough approach by a knowledgeable party.

— How to deal with this information?Checks and monitoring leading to adaptations and rectifications are necessary.

— Is official judgment available and helpful?Binding information on classification (origin, value) isusually available but may have adverse effects …

12

What are basic features of tariff nomenclatures?

87.08.40. 20.10Chapter Heading HS subheading Regional or national subheadings

— Harmonized System (HS) is basically applied globally. — First 6 digits are identical provided the version is the same (and thus should be

the basis for information exchange).— HS amendments are implemented approx. every 5 years.— Regional and national nomenclatures usually change more frequently.

13

Are the assessment bases applied correctly?

— What is the challenge?The customs value being the basis for duties and taxes needs to be determined correctly …

— What are the benefits?… and to be optimised in accordance to the local legal provisions.

— What to beware of?Beyond customs value there may be further impact factors:

— Different assessment bases— Different units of measurement— (Customs) exchange rates.

14

Are additional duties deductible?

— Which additional duties are deductible?Depends on the national tax legislation, but usually those in a VAT alike system.

— Who is entitled for deduction?Usually the party that owns the goods at import (and is registered).

— What is a ‘landed cost’?The total of all duties, taxes, levies and fees results in a landed cost that has an implication on the marketability of merchandise.

— Are there further implications on international sales?Some countries indeed apply withholding taxes at the entry of goods, and also to the international transfer of funds.

15

Preferential origin = positive origin?

— What is the benefit?The margin between the regular (i.e. MFN rate) and the preferential rate. Thus, evaluation should start with theregular rate(s).

— What are the efforts?Compliance with the different rules of origin, calculation and documentation.

— What are the risks?Complexity of the system, especially in view of necessary declarations in the supply chain.

— Further aspects to consider?Correct application in the partner countries, dismantling schedules and steps.

16

Non-preferential = negative origin?

— What are general duties?Certain countries still apply general duties for those origins not falling under MFN treatment.

— What about trade defence instruments?Safeguards, antidumping or countervailing duties are a specific risk and at times hard to calculate.

— What are additional duties?Additional duties are target oriented measures as part of the current trade war scenarios.

— Which non-tariff implications exist?Certification or declarations of origin, made-in labelling – most importantly unambiguous!

17

Advantages of the choice of customs procedure?

— When should free circulation (home use) be chosen?Only when necessary, however for duty-free goods only non-deductible taxes are to be considered.

— What is the implication of common market(s) and customs unions?The EU common market is rather the exception than the rule, such as its customs union with Turkey; unified tariffs do not mean free movement of goods.

— What is the purpose of suspensive procedures?Virtually all customs legislations comprises suspensive procedures enabling the avoidance of free circulation.

— What about free zones?In free zones, goods do not enter the customs territory and are subjected to facilitated clearance; other incentives may be offered.

18

Are favourable measures applicable?

— Are tariff quotas available?General or preferential quotas may be available, predominantly in the field of agricultural goods; usually application is necessary.

— Are there any suspensions or concessions for my products?For certain products but also end-uses or even specific end-users, there may be specific concessions available.

— Does the transaction allow for exemptions from customs duties?Apart from the tariff-related suspensions, there may exemptions for specific transactions, often defined separately from the tariff.

— Are there special simplifications?For governmentally initiated or supportedprojects there may special incentives.

19

Negative implications of non-tariff measures?

— What is the implication of non-tariff measures?Requirements and necessary documents should be known in advance by the responsible parties; otherwise delays and additional costs and duties may apply.

— What is the relevant criterion?Again, classification is decisive – but the consequence is different.

— When is right point to check the situation?Before an actual transaction which is new or happening under changed conditions. For known transactions depending on the level of suffering …

— Has everything necessary been done – was everything done necessary?In fact, legal requirements tend to be mixedup with trade practice and party interests.

20

Which information is necessary?

— Internal informationAll aspects of the transaction which are related to the business cases of the company.

— External informationAll information from other parties including authorities, business partners and information service providers.

— Master data managementBoth from internal and external sources, master data onmaterials/products, business partners and legalrequirements has to be built up and maintained.

— Impact on processesNew information or changed master data may lead toan adaptation of processes.

21

How to apply forecasting and monitoring?

FORECASTING

RESULTS MONITORING

GAP ANALYSIS

PROCESS ADAPTION

TRANSACTION

22

How to apply forecasting and monitoring?

— ForecastingAll aspects with an implication on the duties and costs of the transaction are analysed in advance.

— MonitoringThe results from the real-life transactions are gathered in a structured manner to allow for evaluation.

— Gap analysesThe differences between forecasting and monitoring are evaluated andthe gaps are established.

— Process adaptationsFor those gaps where optimisation is possible, processes are adaptedaccordingly.

23

What are the results?

— Processes – condition or result?Optimisation needs transparent processes – these are the condition, their adaptation may be the result.

— Best practice?Improvement is ideally made by forecasting, monitoring and adaption.

— Positive side effects?Risk minimisation as a result of the evaluation of positive and negative factors.

— What is the scope?Assessment of all factors allows for concentrationon the essentials relevant for the actual business environment and needs.

24

Thank you for your attention!

All questions, queries to be channelled through ACITA!