dismantling of ships eu
Post on 10-Apr-2018
221 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
1/54
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships
Table of correspondence
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
2/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
3/54
Requirements under the Ship Recycling Convention and existing EU
obligations: A table of correspondence
Introduction
The International Maritime Organization (IMO) International Convention for the Safe andEnvironmentally Sound Recycling of Ships (Ship Recycling Convention)1 aims at addressing in a
legally binding instrument, the environmental, occupational health and safety risks related to shiprecycling, taking into account the particular characteristics of maritime transport and the need to
secure the smooth withdrawal of ships that have reached the end of their operating lives. To this end, it
regulates:
The design, construction, operation and preparation of ships so as to facilitate safe andenvironmentally sound recycling without compromising their safety and operational
efficiency;
The operation of ship recycling facilities in a safe and environmentally sound manner; and The establishment of an appropriate enforcement mechanism for ship recycling
(certification/reporting requirements).
Structure of the Ship Recycling Convention
The Convention is divided into the main text containing 21 Articles and an Annex which forms an
integral part of the Convention. Unless expressly provided otherwise, references to the Conventionconstitute at the same time a reference to its Annex.2 The Annex is entitled Regulations for Safe and
Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships and consists of four Chapters and 26 Regulations. TheAnnex is followed by seven Appendices. For ease of reference a full table of contents of theConvention provisions is provided below:
Article 1 General obligations
Article 2 Definitions
Article 3 Application
Article 4 Controls related to ship recycling
Article 5 Survey and certification of ships
Article 6 Authorization of Ship Recycling Facilities
Article 7 Exchange of information
Article 8 Inspection of ships
Article 9 Detection of violations
Article 10 Violations
Article 11 Undue delay or detention of shipsArticle 12 Communication of information
Article 13 Technical assistance and cooperation
Article 14 Dispute settlement
Article 15 Relationship with international law and other international agreements
Article 16 Signature, ratification, acceptance, approval and accession
Article 17 Entry into force
Article 18 Amendments
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
4/54
Annex: Regulations for Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships
Chapter 1 (General Provisions)
Regulation 1 Definitions
Regulation 2 General applicability
Regulation 3 Relationship with other standards, recommendations and guidance
Chapter 2 (Requirements for Ships)
Part A - Design, construction and maintenance of ships
Regulation 4 Controls of ships Hazardous Materials
Regulation 5 Inventory of Hazardous Materials
Regulation 6 Procedure for proposing amendments to Appendices 1 and 2
Regulation 7 Technical Groups
Part B Preparation for Ship RecyclingRegulation 8 General requirements
Regulation 9 Ship Recycling Plan
Part C Surveys and certification
Regulation 10 Surveys
Regulation 11 Issuance and endorsement of certificates
Regulation 12 Issuance or endorsement of a certificate by another Party
Regulation 13 Form of the certificates
Regulation 14 Duration and validity of the certificates
Chapter 3 (Requirements for Ship Recycling Facilities)
Regulation 15 Controls on Ship Recycling Facilities
Regulation 16 Authorization of Ship Recycling Facilities
Regulation 17 General requirements
Regulation 18 Ship Recycling Facility Plan
Regulation 19 Prevention of adverse effects on human health and the environment
Regulation 20 Safe and environmentally sound management of Hazardous Materials
Regulation 21 Emergency preparedness and response
Regulation 22 Worker safety and training
Regulation 23 Reporting on incidents, accidents, occupational diseases and chronic effects
Chapter 4 (Reporting requirements)Regulation 24 Initial notification and reporting requirements
Regulation 25 Reporting upon completion
Appendices
Appendix 1 Controls of Hazardous Materials
Appendix 2 Minimum List of Items for the Inventory of Hazardous Materials
Appendix 3 Form of the International Certificate on Inventory of Hazardous Materials
Appendix 4 Form of the International Ready for Recycling Certificate
Appendix 5 Form of the Authorization of Ship Recycling Facilities
Appendix 6 Form of Report of Planned Start of Ship Recycling
Appendix 7 Form of the Statement of Completion of Ship Recycling
The Convention is supplemented by the following IMO guidelines providing clarifications,
interpretations, and uniform procedures for technical issues arising from the provisions of theConvention.
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
5/54
Guidelines under development in order of priority
Guidelines for safe and environmentally sound ship recycling
Guidelines for the development of the Ship Recycling PlanGuidelines for the authorization of Ship Recycling FacilitiesGuidelines for survey and certification
Guidelines for inspection of ships
Note on table of correspondence
Having illustrated the overall structure of the Ship Recycling Convention, it must be noted that not allits provisions, for example, the provisions on dispute settlement and entry into force, would requiretransposition at EU level. These provisions are therefore not reproduced in the table of correspondence
below which focuses and is based on the key requirements of the Convention. The four headings, intowhich the table is divided, reflect the key requirements of the Convention that would require
transposition at EU level:
A. Key definitionsB. Requirements for shipsC. Requirements for ship recycling facilitiesD. Inspections and ControlE. Reporting Requirements
The table reproduces the obligation provided by the Convention and any relevant obligations existingunder EC legislation. The extent of correspondence between the Convention requirements and relevant
Community law is analysed and assessed with a view to highlighting any problems of compatibility
that could arise. To this end, in the column on extent of correspondence, where problems ofcompatibility between the Convention requirements and legislation existing at EU level are deemed to
be present, the assessment compatibility issues is used. Where no problems of compatibility areidentified the extent of correspondence is assessed as follows:
- Adequate (the Convention and EU level requirements are broadly equivalent)- Indirectly covered- Partially covered- Very partially covered- Not covered (the Convention requirement is currently not catered for at EU level)
Generally, a number of requirements of the Ship Recycling Convention are adequately covered byexisting EC legislation, for example, with respect to the controls for ships hazardous materialsprovided for by Regulation 4 of the Convention. On the other hand, certain compatibility issues have
been identified where the Convention requirements and relevant EC legislation could conflict, for
example, in the case of the Conventions definition of ship, the last part stating including a vesselstripped of equipment or being towed could lead to the vessel being classified as waste under EC
legislation
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
6/54
be explained by the very fact that the Convention covers the whole life cycle of a ship, adopting acradle to grave approach. On the other hand, existing EC legislation is more limited in scope
focusing only on part of the life cycle. Consequently, the vessel would be defined within the context of
the part of the life cycle covered by the relevant legislation. However, although this difference intemporal scope rationalizes the problem to a certain extent, the possibility of conflicting classification
of a vessel as a ship or waste remains for those parts of the life cycle where an overlap exists.
It should be noted at the outset that even though certain requirements of the Convention seem to beadequately covered at EU level,3 the Convention, once it enters into force, will apply internationally
whereas the requirements of EC legislation are regional in scope. Therefore, requirements such asthose on control of Ship Recycling Facilities cannot be established at EU level for facilities locatedoutside the territory of EU Member States although they could be given effect to by virtue of
obligations imposed on shipowners to have their ships dismantled only in certified (green) recyclingfacilities or through the application of the Waste Shipment Regulation (WSR) and the Basel
Convention.
It should be noted that the WSR prohibits the export for recovery or disposal of hazardous wastes (not
included in the Green List), while Green List waste can be exported for recovery in both OECD and
non-OECD countries, subject to conditions. Vessels and other floating structures for breaking up,properly emptied of any cargo and other materials arising from the operation of the vessel which may
have been classified as a dangerous substance or waste (GC030 ex 890800) are included in Annex III
of the WSR (the Green List waste). In principle, once a ship is emptied of all materials arising from itsoperation, which may have been classified as a dangerous substance or waste, it is highly unlikely that
the ship can sail on its own and, in order to be exported to a third country for recycling, it would have
to be towed. Such a solution would not be economically viable.4
Therefore, if the WSR is strictlyapplied, waste ships could only be exported to OECD countries (e.g. Turkey) for recovery.
Considering that waste ships are nevertheless exported to third countries for recycling, even without being stripped of all hazardous materials, and taking into account the issue of the classification of
waste versus ship, this report reviews correspondence between reporting requirements in the Ship
Recycling Convention and those set up by the WSR, in the context of the notification procedure fortransport of ships for recycling to third countries.
The figure below summarises conditions and requirements applicable to such transport operations:
OECD countries EU/OECDcountries
Title II
+ Art.38
Ships falling under category GC030(Green List)
Ships not falling under category GC030 considered as hazardous waste
Non OECDcountries
Non OECDcountries
Title II
+ Art.38
Art.37 countries
of destination canchoose one of 3
options
Prohibition
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
7/54
Certain requirements of the Convention are indirectly covered by existing EC legislation which
although not aimed specifically at ship dismantling operations could, in fact, cover such activity. Byway of example, reference may be made to Directive 99/92/EC laying down minimum requirements
for the safety and health protection of workers potentially at risk from explosive atmospheres. ThisDirective does not specifically mention that employers shall ensure that gas free for hot work
conditions are maintained in order to prevent explosions as provided by Regulation 19 of theConvention. However, Article 3 and Article 4 of the Directive provide that employers shall take
necessary preventive measures in order to avoid explosions. Therefore, indirectly, the requirement inthe Convention could be deemed to be provided for.
Other requirements are either partially or very partially covered, for example, existing requirementsunder EC legislation should be in line with Regulation 21 of the Convention on emergency
preparedness and response but only insofar as workers on site are concerned. However, theConvention focuses specifically on emergency preparedness and response plans. Such requirementsare only partially covered under the Seveso II Directive.5
Finally, since the Convention contains novel requirements with respect to the environmentally safeand sound dismantling of ships, these are not covered at all by current legislation. Examples include
the requirement for the Inventory of Hazardous Materials and the notification and reporting
requirements stipulated respectively in Regulations 5 and 24 of the Convention. In the case of theInventory of Hazardous Materials, it should be underlined that the so-called Green Passport,
provided for in the IMO Guidelines on Ship Recycling, includes an inventory of hazardous materials
and is meant to accompany the ship throughout its life. Successive owners are responsible for up-dating the Green Passport and incorporating all relevant design and equipment changes. The Passportis delivered by the final owner to the recycling facility. However, this is a voluntary mechanism and
does not constitute a legal obligation. With regard to reporting requirements, current EU legislationincludes provisions on traceability of waste. Whereas with respect to other requirements, amendments
to existing legislation could result in adequate coverage, a specific legislative instrument would be
needed to cover these key requirements at EU level.
At this point, reference may be made to the Impact Assessment for an EU Strategy for better ship
dismantling.6
In assessing the baseline option whereby almost all initiative in implementing the Ship
Recycling Convention would be left to Member States, the possibility of minimal amendments tocurrent EU legislation is considered. This would take place mainly through the inclusion of references
to the Ship Recycling Convention in the existing EU maritime directives, namely, Directive 95/21/EC
on port State control and Directive 94/57/EC on classification societies. Such amendments makingreference to the Ship Recycling Convention would allow for the integration of the new certificates,
particularly, the Inventory of Hazardous Materials (IHM), into the harmonised control systems withinthe EU. However, as underlined in the Impact Assessment amendments to the control-related EUDirectives would not as such transpose the substantial elements of the Convention into EU law and
make the IHM and the Ready for Recycling certificate mandatory for shipowners. This would stilldepend on Member States' legislation.
7
With this in mind, the Table of Correspondence includes recommendations for the wording of possible
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
8/54
the objectives, the structure, the content and the timing of the transposing instrument. In addition,these suggestions have been developed based on a number of assumptions, which reflect the
recommendations made throughout the Study and, in particular, in the notes on pros and cons of early
transposition:
The EU instrument ensuring an early transposition of the SRC should be a Regulation as itwould establish a consistent approach across Member States ensuring a level playing field anduniform enforcement.
The key requirements of the Convention which should be covered by early transpositioninclude the inventory of hazardous materials and associated additional surveys and
certificates, the recycling facility management plan and ship recycling plan.
Early transposition of specific requirements, in particular, reporting requirements forshipowners and facilities or other requirements where compatibility issues have beenidentified in relation to the WSR, should be carefully considered in combination with the
question of applicability of the WSR and the future decision on the equivalent level of control.
In recommending wording for a possible instrument transposing the SRC, it is being assumedthat such instrument will set up an alternative regime to the WSR applicable to ships. This is
in line with the Declaration of the Parties to the Basel Convention, that requirements should
not be duplicated.
The Regulation is seen as setting up rules for covering the interim period until the entry intoforce of the Convention. Therefore, it is recommended that a review clause should be included
in order to facilitate future amendments to the Regulation to reflect changes such as theadoption of new guidelines at international level, as well as changes necessary at EU level,
should the SRC not enter into force. Therefore, in addition to the provisions proposed in thetable itself, the following provisions, which are similar to provisions found in Regulation EC
(No) 782/2003 on the prohibition of organotin compounds on ships,8
should be included in the
transposing Regulation:
1. Article [...]In order to take account of developments at international level and in particular in theInternational Maritime Organisation (IMO), or to improve the effectiveness of thisRegulation in the light of experience, the references to the Ship Recycling Convention, to
the IHM-Certificate, to the Ready for Recycling Certificate and to the Statement of
Completion and/or the Annexes to this Regulation, including relevant IMO, may beamended in accordance with the procedure referred to in Article [..].
2. Article [..]By [date to be decided upon], the Commission shall report to the European Parliament andthe Council on the state of ratification of the Ship Recycling Convention. In the light of
this report, the Commission will make such legislative proposals, as appropriate, withrespect to this Regulation [further specifications should added once the details of the
Regulation are determined].
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
9/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
10/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /10
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OF
CORRESPONDENCErationalizes the problem to a certain extent, the
possibility of conflicting classification of a vessel asa ship or waste remains for those parts of the life
cycle where an overlap exists.
With regard to the Classification Societies Directive,
if it is amended to include the Ship RecyclingConvention under the list of international
conventions (Article 2(d)), ships covered by the
Ship Recycling Convention will fall under the scope
of the Directive. The same can be said in relation tothe Port State Control Directive although in thiscase, it would apply only to ships flying the flag
other than that of the port State. Port State control is
applicable to all foreign ships.
Note that such amendments are to be adopted under
a committee procedure with regard to Port State
Control Directive (Article 19, first paragraph, (c).However, this is not the case for the ClassificationSocieties Directive.
Proposed wording
1. Article [] Definitions
For the purposes of this Regulation:
[..]. Ship means a vessel of any type whatsoever operating or having operated in the marine environment and includes submersibles, floating craft, floating platforms, self elevatingplatforms, Floating Storage Units (FSUs), and Floating Production Storage and Offloading Units (FPSOs), including a vessel stripped of equipment or being towed.
Note: such a provision is subject to a decision on the equivalent level of control of the SRC to that of the Basel Convention.
2.Amendments to existing legislation and the procedure for their adoption are commented upon above.
2. Shipowner (Regulation 1.8)
Shipowner means the person or persons or
company registered as the owner of the ship or, in
the absence of registration, the person or persons or
There is no specific definition of shipowner in EC
legislation.
There is no definition of shipowner in EC
legislation.
Not covered
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
11/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
12/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
13/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
14/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
15/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
16/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
17/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
18/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /18
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OF
CORRESPONDENCE process includes the development and
implementation of safety requirements for hull,machinery and electrical and control installations of
ships falling under the scope of the internationalconventions.
Article 2 of Directive 94/57/EC defines internationalconventions as follows:
international conventions means the 1974
International Convention for the Safety of Life atSea (SOLAS), the 1966 International Convention onLoad Lines and the 1973/1978 International
Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from
Ships, together with the protocols and amendmentsthereto, and related codes of mandatory status in all
Member Statesin their up-to-date version.
The Ship Recycling Convention is not listed inArticle 2 (d) of Directive 94/57/EC as it has not yet
been adopted.
Directive 94/57/EC to verify that new ships shall
have on board an inventory of hazardous materials.
Proposed wording
1. Article [] Definitions
For the purposes of this Regulation:
[] Administration means the Government of the Member State whose flag the ship is entitled to fly, or under whose authority it is operating
[] Existing ship means a ship which is not a new ship.
[] New ship means a ship:(a) for which the building contract is placed on or after the entry into force of this Regulation; or
(b) in the absence of a building contract, the keel of which is laid or which is at a similar stage of construction on or after six months after the entry into force of this Regulation; or(c) the delivery of which is on or after thirty months after the entry into force of this Regulation.
2. Article []
1 Each new ship shall have on board an Inventory of Hazardous Materials. The Inventory shall be verified either by the Administration or by any recognized organization by it taking into
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
19/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
20/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
21/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
22/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
23/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
24/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
25/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /25
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
their possible interactions,
the scale of the anticipated effects. []
Directive 2008/98/EC on waste requires MemberStates to take the necessary measures to ensure that
waste management is carried out without
endangering human health, without harming theenvironment and, in particular:
(a) without risk to water, air, soil, plants or animals;
(b) without causing a nuisance through noise or
odours; and
(c) without adversely affecting the countryside orplaces of special interest.
As regards responsibility for waste management,Article 15 states:
1. Member States shall take the necessary measures
to ensure that any original waste producer or other
holder carries out the treatment of waste himself orhas the treatment handled by a dealer or anestablishment or undertaking which carries out
waste treatment operations or arranged by a private
or public waste collector in accordance with Articles4 and 13.2. When the waste is transferred from the original
producer or holder to one of the natural or legal
persons referred to in paragraph 1 for preliminary
treatment, the responsibility for carrying out acomplete recovery or disposal operation shall not be
discharged as a general rule.Without prejudice to Regulation (EC) No1013/2006, Member States may specify the
conditions of responsibility and decide in which
cases the original producer is to retain responsibilityfor the whole treatment chain or in which cases the
responsibility of the producer and the holder can beshared or delegated among the actors of the
treatment chain.
3. Member States may decide, in accordance with
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
26/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
27/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
28/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
29/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
30/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
31/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
32/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /32
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
December 2001.3. Controlled substances contained in products,installations and equipment other than those
mentioned in paragraphs 1 and 2 shall be recovered,if practicable, and dealt with as provided in
paragraph 1.
4. Controlled substances shall not be placed on themarket in disposable containers, except for essential
uses.
5. Member States shall take steps to promote the
recovery, recycling, reclamation and destruction of
controlled substances []
- Organotin compound
Regulation (EC) 782/2003 aims to prohibit
organotin compounds on all ships entering port in
the Community in order to reduce or eliminate the
adverse effects of these products on the marineenvironment and human health.However, Regulation (EC) 782/2003 does not
provide safe and environmentally sound removal of
organotin compounds.
Directive 98/24/EC lays down minimum
requirements for the protection of workers from risk
to their safety and health arising, or likely to arise,
from the effects of chemical agents that are presentat the workplace or as a result of any activity
involving chemical agents.
Article 2 (a) of Directive 98/24/EC defines chemical
agent as any chemical element or compound, on its
own or admixed, as it occurs in the natural state oras produced, used or released, including release as
waste, by any work activity, whether or notproduced intentionally and whether or not placed on
the market;
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
33/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /33
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
Article 2 (b) of Directive 98/24/EC defineshazardous chemical agent as any chemical agentwhich meets the criteria for classification as a
dangerous substance according to the criteria inAnnex VI to Directive 67/548/EEC, whether or not
that substance is classified under that Directive,
other than those substances which only meet thecriteria for classification as dangerous for the
environment;
Article 5.2 of Directive 98/24/EC provides that
risks to the health and safety of workers at workinvolving hazardous chemical agents shall be
eliminated or reduced to a minimum by:
- the design and organisation of systems of work atthe
workplace,
- the provision of suitable equipment for work with
chemical agents and maintenance procedures whichensure the health and safety of workers at work,- reducing to a minimum the number of workers
exposed or likely to be exposed,
- reducing to a minimum the duration and intensityof exposure,- appropriate hygiene measures,
- reducing the quantity of chemical agents present at
the workplace to the minimum required for the type
of work concerned,- suitable working procedures including
arrangements for the safe handling, storage andtransport within the workplace of hazardouschemical agents and waste containing such chemical
agents.
19. 2 Ship Recycling Facilities authorized by a Partyshall ensure that all Hazardous Materials detailed inthe Inventory are identified, labelled, packaged and
removed to the maximum extent possible prior to
cutting by properly trained and equipped workers,
taking into account the guidelines developed by the
All hazardous materials detailed in the inventory shall be identified, labelled, packaged and removedto the maximum extent possible prior to cutting.
Article 19 of Directive 2008/98/EC deals with the
labelling of hazardous waste. Member States must
All hazardous materials detailed in the inventory shall be identified, labelled, packaged and removedto the maximum extent possible prior to cutting.
There is no EU legislation that specifically requires
the fulfilment of this obligation prior to the cutting
Indirectly covered
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
34/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
35/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /35
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
Art.49(2) applies to exports from the Communityand requires the competent authority of dispatch inthe Community to require and endeavour to secure
that any waste exported is managed in anenvironmentally sound manner throughout the
period of shipment in the third country of
destination.Environmentally sound management may, inter alia,
be assumed as regards the waste recovery or
disposal operation concerned, if the notifier or the
competent authority in the country of destination can
demonstrate that the facility which receives thewaste will be operated in accordance with human
health and environmental protection standards that
are broadly equivalent to standards established inCommunity legislation; and this without prejudice to
the overall assessment of environmentally sound
management.
For the purposes of seeking guidance onenvironmentally sound management, the guidelineslisted in Annex VIII may be considered.
With regard to identification of waste managementand disposal sites, the prior written notification andmovement documents to be submitted by the notifier
under Article 4, shall identify, in accordance with
Annexes IA and IB, II and III, all disposal and
recovery facilities details, including technologiesemployed and possible status as pre-consented.
Finally, pursuant to Article 15, if the waste isdestined for an interim recovery or disposal
operation, similar information regarding all facilities
where subsequent interim and non-interim recoveryor disposal operations are envisaged shall be
indicated in the notification document in addition tothe initial interim recovery or disposal operation.
It should be noted that interim operations are limited
However, interim recovery operations are notcovered.
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
36/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /36
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
to the following:R 12 Exchange of wastes for submission to recoveryoperations
R 13 Storage of wastes pending recovery operations,including exchange of wastes (excluding temporary
storage, pending collection, on the site where it is
produced)
Article 13 of Directive 2008/98/EC, generally
mentions that Member States shall take the
necessary measures to ensure that waste
management is carried out without endangeringhuman health, without harming the environment
and, in particular:
(a) without risk to water, air, soil, plants or animals;(b) without causing a nuisance through noise or
odours; and
(c) without adversely affecting the countryside or
places of special interest.
On disposal sites, Article 12 of Directive
2008/98/EC, states that Member States shall ensure,
that waste undergoes safe disposal operations whichmeet the provisions of Article 13 on the protectionof human health and the environment.
Article 35 of Directive 2008/98/EC on record
keeping requires establishments or undertakingsintending to carry out waste treatment, the producers
of hazardous waste and the establishments andundertakings which collect or transport hazardouswaste on a professional basis, or act as dealers and
brokers of hazardous waste, to keep a chronological
record of the quantity, nature and origin of thewaste, and, where relevant, the destination,
frequency of collection, mode of transport andtreatment method foreseen in respect of the waste,
and to make that information available, on request,
to the competent authorities.
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
37/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
38/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /38
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
(a) the mixing operation is carried out by anestablishment or undertaking which has obtained a
permit;
(b) the provisions of Article 13 are complied withand the adverse impact of the waste management on
human health and the environment is not increased;
and(c) the mixing operation conforms to best available
techniques.
Article 19 provides the labelling and identification
requirements for hazardous waste.
In accordance with Article 21, without prejudice to
the obligations related to the management ofhazardous waste in Articles 18 and 19, Members
must ensure that:
- waste oils are collected separately, where this is
technically feasible- waste oils are treated in accordance with Articles 4(waste hierarchy) and 13 (protection of human
health and the environment).
- where technically feasible and economicallyviable, waste oils of different characteristics are notmixed and waste oils are not mixed with other kinds
of waste or substances, if such mixing impedes their
treatment.
If waste oils, according to national legislation, are
subject to requirements of regeneration, MemberStates may prescribe that such waste oils beregenerated if technically feasible and, where
Articles 11 or 12 of Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006
apply, restrict the transboundary shipment of wasteoils from their territory to incineration or co-
incineration facilities in order to give priority to theregeneration of waste oils.
22. Emergency preparedness and response
(Regulation 21)
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
39/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
40/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /40
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
lead as directly as possible to the open air or to asafe area.4.2. In the event of danger, it must be possible for
workers to evacuate all workstations quickly and assafely as possible.
4.3. The number, distribution and dimensions of the
emergency routes and exits depend on the use,equipment and dimensions of the workplaces and
the maximum number of persons that may be
present.
4.4. Emergency doors must open outwards.
Sliding or revolving doors are not permitted if theyare specifically intended as emergency exits.
Emergency doors should not be so locked or
fastened that they cannot be easily and immediatelyopened by any person who may need to use them in
an emergency.
4.5. Specific emergency routes and exits must be
indicated by signs in accordance with the nationalregulations transposing Directive 77/576/EEC (1)into law.
Such signs must be placed at appropriate points and
be made to last.4.6. Emergency doors must not be locked.The emergency routes and exits, and the traffic
routes and doors giving access to them, must be free
from obstruction so that they can be used at any time
without hindrance.4.7. Emergency routes and exits requiring
illumination must be provided with emergencylighting of adequate intensity in case the lightingfails.
Directive 96/82/EC on the control of major-accidenthazards involving dangerous substances (Seveso II
Directive) requires operators to develop internalemergency plans and supply information to enable
an external plan to be drawn up. The scope of the
Seveso II Directive is defined by reference to the
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
41/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
42/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
43/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
44/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
45/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
46/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
47/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /47
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
Convention, of the shipowner to notify theadministration in due time, in order to enable theAdministration to prepare for the survey and
certification required.
Under the WSR, the notifier must include a contract
with the consignee for the recovery or disposal ofthe notified waste. Such a requirement is not found
in the Convention. The competent authority of
dispatch ,must transmit the notification to the
competent authority of destination. This
transboundary procedure does not exist under theConvention.
Under the WSR, the competent authorities ofdestination can consent without conditions or
consent with conditions in accordance with Article
10 or provide some objections in accordance with
Article 11 when waste is destined for disposal orArticle 12 when waste is destined for recovery.Ships sent for recycling might fall within the
category of shipments of waste destined for
recovery. Therefore, authorities of dispatch andauthorities of destination, when not consenting thatthe end-of life ships shall be recovered in the
destination country, will have to raise reasoned
objections on the grounds listed in Article 12. This
would include for example, cases where:- the planned shipment or recovery is not in
accordance with the Waste FrameworkDirective,
- the planned shipment or recovery is not inaccordance with national legislation
relating to environmental protection, public order, public safety or health
protection concerning actions taking placein the objecting country, or
- the notifier or the consignee has previously been convicted of illegal
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
48/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /48
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
shipment or some other illegal act inrelation to environmental protection.
This prior consent requirement is not exactlycovered in the Convention, where requirements for
reporting between the State of export and the State
of destination, and between the shipowner and theState of destination (recycling States) are very
limited.
Under the Convention there are two main
procedures of control before the ship is sent to berecycled:
- The approval of the Ship Recycling Plan by the
Authority where the Ship Recycling Facility issituated: Ship Recycling Plan is subject to the
Competent Authoritys approval (tacit or explicit)
before a ship may be recycled in the authorised Ship
Recycling Facility(ies) (Article 16(6)). Regulation 9requires the Competent Authority to send writtenacknowledgement of receipt of the Ship Recycling
Plan to the Ship Recycling Facility, Shipowner and
Administration. The Competent Authority shouldalso send written notification of its decision toapprove or deny the Ship Recycling Plan in case a
Party requires explicit approval. Similarly, it shall
notify any written objection to the Ship Recycling
Plan under a procedure of tacit approval.- The issue of an International Ready for Recycling
Certificate by the administration of the flag of theships. This certificate is issued after a final surveyof the ship verifying that:
the Inventory of Hazardous Materials is inaccordance with the Conventionrequirements
the Ship Recycling Plan properly reflectsthe information contained in the Inventory
of Hazardous Materials as required byRegulation 5.4 and contains information
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
49/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
50/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
51/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
52/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /52
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
9.
actions taken towards ships and ShipRecycling Facilities under the jurisdiction ofthat Party.
subject to transboundary movement;(c) Information on the measures adopted bythem in implementation of the Basel Convention;
(d) Information on available qualifiedstatistics which have been compiled by them on the
effects on human health and the environment of the
generation, transportation and disposal of hazardouswastes or other wastes;
(e) Information concerning bilateral,
multilateral and regional agreements and
arrangements entered into pursuant to Article 11 of
this Convention;(f) Information on accidents occurring during
the transboundary movement and disposal of
hazardous wastes and other wastes and on themeasures undertaken to deal with them;
(g) Information on disposal options operated
within the area of their national jurisdiction;
(h) Information on measures undertaken fordevelopment of technologies for the reductionand/or elimination of production of hazardous
wastes and other wastes; and
(i) Such other matters as the Conference ofthe Parties shall deem relevant.
Under Article 56 of the WSR, Member States shall
notify the Commission of designations of competent
authorities i.e. those responsible for theimplementation of the Regulation.
Member States are to provide under the WSR(Article 51 and Annex IX) information on illegal
shipments of waste and measures taken includingpossible penalties.
Enforcement Provisions
Article 8 Inspection of ship
Article 8 Ships may be subject to inspection by
Chapter 4 of the WSR deals with take-back
obligations when the shipment cannot be completed
or in case of illegal shipment (Articles 22 to 25).
The most relevant EU legislation with regards to
enforcement is Directive 94/57/EC on common rules
and standards for ship inspection and survey
Partially covered
Issues of
compatibility
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
53/54
-
8/8/2019 Dismantling of Ships EU
54/54
Milieu Ltd & COWIBrussels, August 2009
Study in relation to options for new initiatives regarding
dismantling of ships /54
OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE SHIP RECYCLING
CONVENTION
CORRESPONDING OBLIGATIONS OF EULEGAL
SYSTEM
COMMENTS EXTENT OFCORRESPONDENCE
Member State may take enforcement action against persons suspected of being engaged in the illegalshipment of waste who are present in that Member
State.
Article 2(c) of Directive 94/57/EC defines
inspections and surveys as inspections and surveysthat it is mandatory to carry out under the
international conventions
Article 3 of Council Directive 94/57/EC provides
that :
In assuming their responsibilities and obligations
under the international conventions, Member Statesshall ensure that their competent administrations can
assure an appropriate enforcement of the provisions
of the international conventions, in particular with
regard to the inspection and survey of ships and theissue of certificates and exemption certificates.
Article 8(7) further states that When exercising port
State control under this Directive, all possible effortsshall be made to avoid a ship being unduly detainedor delayed. If a ship is unduly detained or delayed,
the owner or operator shall be entitled to
compensation for any loss or damage suffered. In
any instance of alleged undue detention or delay theburden of proof shall lie with the owner or operator
of the ship.
Requirements to avoid undue delay or detention ofships are reflected in Directive 95/21/EC. However,as mentioned above, it does not currently refer to the
Convention.
top related