current vs. proposed procedures

Current vs. proposed proceduresCURRENT PROCEDURE• Each proposal author or

authors chooses the college or discipline-based panel that they want their proposal reviewed by

• The panels convene and discuss the proposals, and assign scores.

• For each proposal, the median score is calculated after the top and bottom scores are removed.

• All proposals are pooled then ranked according to this score, awarded until resources are exhausted.

PROPOSED PROCEDURE• Each proposal author or

authors chooses the college or discipline-based panel that they want their proposal reviewed by

• The panels convene and discuss the proposals, and assign scores.

• For each proposal, the median score is calculated after the top and bottom scores are removed.

• RCA ranks proposals by college and sets aside top two.

• All remaining proposals are pooled and ranked, awarded until resources are exhausted

2004-2005 % of proposals awarded

Arts & Letters

Business

Education

Engineering

Health & HumanServices

Natural Sciences andMath

Social Sciences

Library

2004-2005 % of total awards

Arts & Letters

Business

Education

Engineering

Health & HumanServices

Natural Sciences andMath

Social Sciences

Library

2004-2005

# of applications # of awards% of proposals awarded

% of total awards

Arts & Letters 20 6 30.00% 18.75%

Business 10 3 30.00% 9.38%

Education 6 0 0.00% 0.00%

Engineering 9 3 33.33% 9.38%

Health & Human Services 8 4 50.00% 12.50%

Natural Sciences and Math 30 10 33.33% 31.25%

Social Sciences 22 6 27.27% 18.75%

Library 0 0 0

Total 105 32 30.48%

2005-2006        

 # of applications # of awards

% of proposals awarded % of total awards

Arts & Letters 25 8 32.00% 22.86%

Business 15 4 26.67% 11.43%

Education 13 1 7.69% 2.86%

Engineering 13 4 30.77% 11.43%

Health & Human Services 6 4 66.67% 11.43%

Natural Sciences and Math 37 10 27.03% 28.57%

Social Sciences 28 4 14.29% 11.43%

Library 0 0    

 Total 137 35 25.55%  

2005-2006 % of proposals awarded

Arts & Letters

Business

Education

Engineering

Health & HumanServices

Natural Sciences andMath

Social Sciences

Library

2005-2006 % of total awards

Arts & Letters

Business

Education

Engineering

Health & HumanServices

Natural Sciences andMath

Social Sciences

Library

2006-2007 % of total awards

Arts & Letters

Business

Education

Engineering

Health & HumanServices

Natural Sciences andMath

Social Sciences

Library

2006-2007 % of proposals awarded

Arts & Letters

Business

Education

Engineering

Health & HumanServices

Natural Sciences andMath

Social Sciences

Library

2006-2007        

# of applications # of awards

% of proposals awarded

% of total awards

Arts & Letters 22 9 40.91% 25.00%

Business 12 4 33.33% 11.11%

Education 9 0 0.00% 0.00%

Engineering 13 4 30.77% 11.11%

Health & Human Services 5 3 60.00% 8.33%

Natural Sciences and Math 23 11 47.83% 30.56%

Social Sciences 15 5 33.33% 13.89%

Library 1 0 0.00% 0.00%

Total 100 36