chinese participation in african infrastructural and … · chinese participation in african...

From the field

CHINESE PARTICIPATION IN AFRICAN INFRASTRUCTURAL

DEVELOPMENT: The case of the DRC and Zambia

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt Msc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure

Overview

- Introduction: Objectives

- Methodology: LFA

- Sicomines Barter Deal

- Findings from Case Studies

- Conclusion

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt MSc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure

Introduction

�Objectives

�Why the DRC and Zambia?

�Logical Framework Approach (LFA)

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt MSc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure

Logical Framework ApproachMethodology I: LFA evaluationLink between evaluation criteria and logframe matrix

Logical Framework Approach

Methodology II: Case Study - DRC

Project sites: inspection and interviews

Kinshasa: Road Rehabilitation Project, Urban Roads, HospitalLubumbashi: Urban Roads, Road Rehabilitation Project

Interviews:Chinese Embassy

EU DelegationUnité de Coordination des Projets

Agence Congolese des Grands Travaux (Programme Sino-Congolais)Journalist

Logical Framework Approach

Methodology III: Case Study – Zambia

Project sites: Inspection and interviewsKariba North Bank Extension Project

Interviews:Chinese Embassy

EU Delegation

Sicomines Barter Deal

�Arisen from the needs from both receiving and investing country

�Agence Congolaise de Grand Travaux (ACGT) > Programme Sino-Congolais

�Structure: project selection, funding, risks

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt MSc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure

Funding source and flow

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt MSc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure

Introduction Case Studies

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt MSc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure

Projet Travaux de Rehabilitation de la Route Nsele-Lufimi, Lot 1

Boulevard 30e Juin, CREC7

Boulevard du Turisme, CREC8

L’Hopitale du Cinquantenaire, CREC8

Impact

Effectiveness

Efficiency

Relevance

Sustainability

ConclusionBetter understanding of Chinese participation in

African infrastructural development: project cycles

• Misunderstanding: EU-China-DRC/Zambia > different discourses

• Questions:> How could donors and recipient best cooperate?> Should Chinese stakeholders use LFA as evaluation

system?> How should responsibility be divided between donors

and recipient?

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt MSc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure

Any Questions?

Presented by Mr. Hans E. Petersen and Ms. Sanne van der Lugt MSc Prepared for the China-DAC Study Group Event on Infrastructure