amicus curiae brief from the brady center to prevent gun violence in support of appellees and...

8/20/2019 Amicus Curiae Brief from The Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence in Support of Appellees and Affirmance

1/47

!"#$%& ($)$%* +,-.$ ,/ 011%)2* !"# %&'

3#/$4 +#.5-#$

"#$% &'( )*+*,-*.

/010&20 /324536740/8 20"9&/ :;0&/;0&4197&/:439&< 3&"95=95:40/ (

)*+,-%,!!./011'**+-%.(

> ?( >

7&340/ 24:402 /0=:54;0&4 91 24:408 @9A& 1( B055C< 3D AE$

9FFEGE#H "#I#GEJK #$ JL% 2%GM%J#MK 'F JL% /%I#MJN%DJ 'F 2J#J%8 /350"495:4091 /010&20 45:/0 "9&459O2< /%I#MJN%DJ 'F 2J#J% 6PM%#P 'F ='HEJEG#H

;EHEJ#MK :FF#EM$8 B0&&04A 6( A:&/0O;:&< 3DQE?EQP#HHK #DQ ED AE$ 9FFEGE#H

"#I#GEJK #$ JL% /%IPJK :$$E$J#DJ 2%GM%J#MK 'F 2J#J% F'M /%F%D$% 4M#Q% "'DJM'H$ ED

JL% 6PM%#P 'F ='HEJEG#H+;EHEJ#MK :FF#EM$8 "( 0/R:5/ =0:54500< 3DQE?EQP#HHK#DQ ED AE$ 9FFEGE#H "#I#GEJK #$ JL% /EM%GJ'M 'F JL% 9FFEG% 'F /%F%D$% 4M#Q%

"'DJM'H$ ='HEGK /E?E$E'D8 2:5:A @( A03/0;:< 3DQE?EQP#HHK #DQ ED A%M 9FFEGE#H

"#I#GEJK #$ JL% /E?E$E'D "LE%F< 5%SPH#J'MK #DQ ;PHJEH#J%M#H :FF#EM$< 9FFEG% 'F/%F%D$% 4M#Q% "'DJM'H$ ='HEGK8 TO0&& 2;34A< 3DQE?EQP#HHK #DQ ED AE$ 9FFEGE#H

"#I#GEJK #$ JL% 2%DE'M :Q?E$'M< 9FFEG% 'F /%F%D$% 4M#Q% "'DJM'H$<

2'!'-3+-%./011'**''.4

UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

9& :==0:O 159; 4A0 7&340/ 24:402 /32453"4 "9754

195 4A0 R02405& /32453"4 91 40V:2 WA9&( 596054 O( =34;:&X

!"#$% %'" !"#$%& $%(#!)

()$ !"*+, -$.($" (' /"$0$.( 12. 0#'3$.-$

#. 42//'"( '% *//$33$$4 *.+ *%%#"5*.-$

5! 6"7-.'*8

@9A& /( B 3;6:OO ;:543& 2( B 50Y:O0B

&3"A9O:2 5( 4:;69&0

6O:&B 5 9;0 OO=

0%%"#-'9. !"# 0:,;7. 67#,+' Z,* O%[EDSJ'D :?%DP%

&%\ C'M]< &%\ C'M] ),)-ZW^)^X __*+*,,,

"#$%& '()(*+(, -./01%23& **('4456478 9#:%& ' -#3% ;& *7?'5?7*'6


2/47

!

!"##$%&%'()$ +%,(-.-+)(% /. -'(%,%!(%0 #%,!/'!

!"#"$%" !'%()'*+(",- "( ./0 10 2030 !"4.)(5"$( 6# 3(.("- "( ./0

#$% &'(')*'+

,-. /01.23!40.1 5$/03.6 $7 2.5$21 5.28!7!.3 8-98 8-. 7$66$:!04

6!38.1 ;.23$03 901 .08!8!.3 93 1.352!?%>%& -9@. 90 !08.2.38 !0 8-. $/85$A. $7 8-!3 593.% ,-.3.

2.;2.3.0898!$03 92. A91. !0 $21.2 8-98 8-. B/14.3 $7 8-!3 5$/28 A9C

.@96/98. ;$33!


3/47

!!

X%

#!5-$693 =% ,9A


4/47

!!!

()1$% /. +/'(%'(!

Q#,U=UK, \Y 7:;923 92

]01.2 >"//") 901 ?


5/47

!@

>%

M66$:!04 8-. 7$2.!40 1!33.A!098!$0 $7 PL(

;2!08.2 7!2.92A 7!6.3 :$/61 ._95.2*

&% ,.22$2!3A 901 7!2.92A3% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% >?

>%

[email protected]!04 8-. L!382!58 F$/28 :$/61 ;/8

9!2;$28 901 -$8.6 3.5/2!8C 98 42.98 2!3R% %%%%%%%%%%%%% P)

F%

[email protected]!04 8-. L!382!58 F$/28 5$/61 [email protected] !A;958

]0!8.1 K898.3 7$2.!40 2.698!$03% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% PX

F\#Fb]KQ\# %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% PZ

FU=,QYQFM,U \Y F\VGbQM#FU %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% P*

FU=,QYQFM,U \Y KU=IQFU %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% P?

"#$%& '()(*+(, -./01%23& **('4456478 9#:%& ( -#3% ;& *7?'5?7*'6


6/47

@

()1$% /. )"(2/,-(-%!

#345678

+3757

!"#0 !'%()'*+(", 10 2030 !"4@( 6# 3(.("J

#$% &(&'(FI(P*> =GJ >)&' cb XZ'?+>&

Nc%L% ,._% M/4% XJ >)&'O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &XJ &'

!'%()'8( 6# 96/+5*'. 10 >"//")J

''X ]%K% '*) N>))?O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 4.%%'5

A)'",5.$ 10 9'(B 6# >'CD/.$, E.)F- ;//'$6'%J

*?X Y%P1 X)Z N*8- F!2% >)&'OJ

8")(0 ,"$'",J &PZ K% F8% XX* N>)&'O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% +J &+

:+%8.)"//6 10 2$'(", 3(.("%J

'>X ]%K% &>' N&++?O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ?

?0G0 3(.(" X> N>1 F!2% >)&'O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &*J &?

?.('6$./ )&>O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &)

2$'(", 3(.("% 10 A'$8D")J

'P? Y%P1 ?Z? N?8- F!2% >))?O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &P

2$'(", 3(.("% 10 :.LL.)"//.J

Z&X Y%P1 ?' NP1 F!2% >)&)O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &P

2$'(", 3(.("% 10 34).C+"J>?> ]%K% *&Z N&+P&O %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% *

!939:957 3;< +=;79>9:9>=;

]%K% F$038% 9A.01% QQ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 4.%%'5

&? ]%K%F% d +>> %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &P

"#$%& '()(*+(, -./01%23& **('4456478 9#:%& 6 -#3% ;& *7?'5?7*'6


7/47

@!

>Z ]%K%F% d '?>> %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &X

>Z ]%K%F% d '?X& %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &P

H/0 F$082$6 M58 $7 &+Z? %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &PJ >XJ >+

#98!$096 Y!2.92A3 M58 $7 &+PX %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &P

\A0!)&P %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% P&

E!66C e966$:.66J !6 G6+ [$6M 7*6+( \.4.$@% >'CD/BN

?J >)&P %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% PX

M,YJ \77!5. $7 K8298.4!5 Q08.66!4.05. 901 Q07$2A98!$0J

Y!2.92A3 ,295!04 KC38.A NF92!


8/47


9/47

@!!!

K8977J \.4.$"%" :.$ 7))"%(", A6) E6%%"%%'$C R+$% :.," IB

Z! E)'$(")J =U],U=K V9C ?J >)&X %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% PX

]%K% [email protected] M55$/089.1" ;54)61",- *+( 365"

96//.*6).('6$ 9D.//"$C"% )&' %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% >>

"#$%& '()(*+(, -./01%23& **('4456478 9#:%& , -#3% ;& *7?'5?7*'6


10/47

&

-'(%,%!( /. !"#$%& $%(#!) &

,-. E291C F.08.2 8$ [email protected] H/0 I!$6.05. !3 9 0$0(;2$7!8

$2490!W98!$0 1.1!598.1 8$ 2.1/5!04 4/0 @!$6.05. 8-2$/4- .1/598!$0J

2.3.925-J 901 6.496 91@$595C% Q83 A.A


11/47

>

,-2$/4- !83 b.496 M58!$0 G2$B.58J 8-. E291C F.08.2 -93 7!6.1

0/A.2$/3 * N>))+O

N5!8!04 E291C F.08.2 )&XOJ 901 ?.('6$./

)&>O N`?


12/47

P

-'(,/0"+(-/'

,-. Q08.2098!$096 ,2977!5 !0 M2A3 =.4/698!$03 N`Q,M=aO :.2.

;2$A/6498.1 8$ 5$082$6 8-. 829037.2 $7 1.7.03. 928!56.3 9


13/47

X

#$8 $06C !3 M;;.669083^ ;$3!8!$0 2.5R6.33 901 -9W921$/3 8$ 8-.

397.8C $7 MA.2!5903 98 -$A. 901 9


14/47

'

82977!5R!04 901 52!A!096 5928.63 8$ $


15/47

Z

),A"&%'(

-B (?5 !5C=;< )D5;4?9 9= D3;:I3C9:@5 I>@53@D7 =@ 9= 775D>;395 95C?;>C3G@53@D7B

M;;.669083^ 924/A.08 8-98 8-.!2 K.5$01 MA.01A.08 2!4-83 -9@.


16/47

*

8-$3. 958!@!8!.3 92. ;2$8.58.1 O5;7B

Q0 8-. 3.A!096 593. $7 !'%()'8( 6# 96/+5*'. 10 >"//")J ''X ]%K% '*)

N>))?OJ 8-. K/;2.A. F$/28 5$03!1.2.1 8-. 5$038!8/8!$096!8C $7 8-.

L!382!58 $7 F$6/A

-$A.J 901 /68!A98.6C 382/5R 1$:0 8-.


17/47

?

N&+P&OO%

M;;6C!04 8-!3 ;2!05!;6.J 8-. F$/28 ._9A!0.1 .95- 569/3. $7 8-.

MA.01A.08% Q0 5$03!1.2!04 8-. 8._8 `R..; 901


18/47

+

$77.03!@. $2 1.7.03!@. 958!$0 !0 9 593. $7 5$076!58 :!8- 90$8-.2 ;.23$0%a

>"//")J ''X ]%K% 98 '?X%

e9@!04 5$056/1.1 8-98 8-. 5$2. K.5$01 MA.01A.08 4/92908..

;2$@!1.1 90 !01!@!1/96 2!4-8 8$ `;$33.33a 9 7!2.92AJ 901 8$ `5922Ca 9

7!2.92AJ 7$2 `1.7.03. $7 -.928- 901 -$A.Ja 8-. F$/28 382/5R 1$:0 8-.

L!382!58 $7 F$6/A

!072!04.A.08 $0 8-. 5$2. K.5$01 MA.01A.08 2!4-8% ;,0 98 Z>+J ZP'

N`m7n.: 69:3 !0 8-. -!38$2C $7 $/2 #98!$0 -9@. 5$A. 56$3. 8$ 8-. [email protected].

2.382!58!$0 $7 8-. L!382!58^3 -9014/0 'CD/.$, E.)F- ;//'$6'%J *?X Y%P1 X)Z N*8- F!2% >)&'OJ 8")(0

,"$'",J &PZ K% F8% XX* N>)&'OJ :-.2. 8-. [email protected] F!25/!8 -.61 8-98 9

598.4$2!596


19/47

&)

1B

.>I9? +>@C:>9 );3GL9>C3G .@3D5N=@PB

Q0 ?.('6$./ )&>O N`?& *7?'5?7*'6


20/47

&&

38.; $0. $7 $/2 729A.:$2R%a ;,0 98 &+Z%

K.5$01J !7 8-. 5$01/58 98 !33/. 79663 :!8-!0 8-. 35$;. $7 8-. K.5$01

MA.01A.08J 8-. F$/28 A/38 1.8.2A!0. :-.8-.2 8$ 9;;6C 382!58 $2

!08.2A.1!98. 352/8!0C% ;,0 98 &+'% K82!58 352/8!0C !3 9;;2$;2!98. :-.2.

8-. 5$01/58 8-2.98.03 9 `5$2.a K.5$01 MA.01A.08 2!4-8k8-98 !3J `8-.

2!4-8 $7 9 69:(9

8$ 1.7.01 -!3 $2 -.2 -$A. 901 79A!6C%a ;,0 F$01/58 8-98 1$.3 0$8 977.58

8-. 5$2. K.5$01 MA.01A.08 5$05.20 $7 3.67(1.7.03. :!8-!0 8-. -$A.

$06C :9229083 !08.2A.1!98. 352/8!0C% ;,0 ]01.2 !08.2A.1!98. 352/8!0CJ

8-. [email protected] 0..1 $06C `1.A$038298. 9 o2.93$09


21/47

&>

`._;$28a 8-. 7/058!$096 .D/[email protected] $7 9 7!2.92A% ,-/3J 8-. F$/28 0..1

0$8 [email protected] 2.95- 8-. 3.5$01 38.; $7 8-. ?8-. K.5$01 MA.01A.08 $2 3898.

9096$4/.3 % % % % m#n$8-!04 !0 $/2 $;!0!$0 3-$/61

A.08966C !66- $2 69:3 7$2

[email protected]


22/47

&P

E$8- 8-. 5$AA.25!96 396. 901 8-. A90/7958/2. $7 7!2.92A3 -9@. 9

6$0438901!04 -!38$2C $7 2.4/698!$0 !0 8-. ]0!8.1 K898.3% Y$2 !038905.J

8-. \A0!1.96!04 !0 7!2.92A3Ja /06.33 9 ;.23$0 !3 9 `6!5.03.1 !A;$28.2J 6!5.03.1

A90/7958/2.2J $2 6!5.03.1 1.96.2%a &? ]%K%F% d +>>N9ON&ONMO%P

,-. #98!$096 Y!2.92A3 M58 $7 &+PXJ 93 9A.01.1 Z ]%K%F% d '?X&N))?O

N-$61!04 8-98 1.7.01908^3 ;$33.33!$0 $7 9 A95-!0. 4/0 901 9 3-$28(


23/47

&X

#$ ;.23$0 3-966 A9R. 9 7!2.92A /06.33 -. -93

N9O 7!6.1 :!8- 8-. K.52.892C 9 :2!88.0 9;;6!598!$0J

!0 1/;6!598.J 8$ A9R. 901 2.4!38.2 8-. 7!2.92A $0

8-. 7$2A ;2.352!


24/47

&'

2.4/698$2C 35-.A. 2.D/!2!04 8-. 2.4!38298!$0 $7 7!2.92A3J 901 7$2

7!2.92A3 A90/7958/2.23 8$ 9;;6C 7$2J 901 [email protected] 9 6!5.03. 8$ 5$01/58

8-. ;2!08.1 7!2.92A3 :$/61 /01.2A!0. 8-. !A;$28908 $@53@D7 =@ 9?5

775D>;39>=; =I 95C?;>C3G @53@D7 I5GG

N>9?>; 9?5 7C=E5 =I 9?5 !5C=;< )D5;;95@D5395 7C@:9>;L >7 N3@@3;95


25/47

&Z

977.58!04 3/5- 5$01/58 $06C :9229083 !08.2A.1!98. 352/8!0C% Q01..1J

8-. L!382!58 F$/28 9;;6!.1 !08.2A.1!98. 352/8!0CJ 5$22.586C 0$8!04 8-98

`m8n-.


26/47

&*

,-. Q,M= 1$.3 0$8 ;2$-!

6!5.03.1 A90/7958/2.2 $2 @.01$2 7$2 6.4!8!A98. 3.67(1.7.03. ;/2;$3.3%

%B (?5 R0ME@>;95< I>@53@D7 39 >77:5 >; 9?>7 C375 3@5

;5>9?5@ >; SC=DD=; :75T ;=@ S9LE>C3GGL E=775775< JL

G3NM3J>;4 C>9>O5;7QT 3;< 3@5 ;=9 5;9>9G5< 9= !5C=;<

)D5;=;B

=.4/698!$03 977.58!04 8-. PL(;2!08.1 7!2.92A3 8-98 590 "//")J ''X ]%K% 98 Z>*O 901 :.9;$03 8-98 92.

`8C;!5966C ;$33.33.1

8C;!5966C ;$33.33.1 ;2!08.1 7!2.92A3 92. 0$8 .08!86.1 8$ K.5$01 MA.01A.08 ;2$8.58!$0%

Q0 ?0G0 3(.(" A933 A/21.2 $7 8:.08C 7!238(4291.23 901 3!_ 91/683 98 K901C

"#$%& '()(*+(, -./01%23& **('4456478 9#:%& 76 -#3% ;& *7?'5?7*'6


27/47

&?

e$$R U6.A.0892C K5-$$6 !0 #.:8$:0J F$00.58!5/8% ,-. 8-2.3-$61

D/.38!$0 9112.33.1

9


28/47

&+

]68!A98.6CJ 8-. K.5$01 F!25/!8 91$;8.1 @!28/966C 8-. 39A. 8:$(

;928 8.38 8-98 8-!3 F$/28 3.8 7$28- !0 ?


29/47

>)

8-.2. 5.289!06C !3 0$ K.5$01 MA.01A.08 2!4-8 8$ ._;$28 7!2.92A3 $2

8.5-0!596 1989 9 MA.01A.08 2!4-83J 93 8-. L!382!58 F$/28 5$22.586C -.61J $06C

!08.2A.1!98. 352/8!0C !3 :922908.1J 901 8-. 2.4/698!$03 98 !33/. .93!6C

3/2@!@. !08.2A.1!98. 352/8!0C%

--B ,5F5@73G =I 9?5 0>79@>C9 +=:@9 N=:G< ?3F5 DEG>C39>=;7 >; 9?5 ";>95< !93957 3;< 3J@=3


30/47


31/47

>>

>)&Z N-.2.!0978.2 `HM\ S90/92C >)&Z =.;$28aO 98 P%X

Q0 7958J 8-. A9B$2!8C $7 7!2.92A3 [email protected] )&X 8$ 8-. ]%K% 3"" HM\ S90/92C >)&Z =.;$28 98

?l %"" ./%6 c93-!048$0 \77!5. $0 b98!0 MA.2!59 Nc\bMO I!$6.05. G$6!5C

F.08.2 =.3.925- =.;$28J R2?N6M A6)"'C$N

:.," 7%%.+/( U".46$% .)" J).##'8F", #)65 (D" 2$'(", 3(.("% (6 :"K'86

.$, UD.( (6 !6 7*6+( ;(J S/6C >)&' N-.2.!0978.2 `c\bM =.;$28aO%'

V._!590 L,\3 6$$R 8$ 8-. ]%K% 7$2 A!6!892!W.1 7!2.92A3 2904!04 72$A

-!4-(59;95!8C 3.A!9/8$A98!5 ;!38$63J 8$ 9339/68 2!76.3J 9339/68 ;!38$63J

901 6$04(2904. 92A$2(;!.25!04 30!;.2 2!76.3% 3"" c\bM =.;$28 98 '%

c-!6. V._!5$ A9!089!03 382!58 2.382!58!$03 $0 7!2.92A 396. 901

;$33.33!$0J :.9R ]%K% 7!2.92A 69:3 966$: L,\3 8$ /3. 3829: ;/25-93.23

8$ 9@$!1


32/47

>P

Q0 911!8!$0 8$ V._!5$J !66.496 ]%K% 7!2.92A3 82977!5R!04 963$ 7..13

52!A. !0 b98!0 MA.2!59 901 8-. F92!X+>;17[1$:06$91%

"#$%& '()(*+(, -./01%23& **('4456478 9#:%& 47 -#3% ;& *7?'5?7*'6


33/47

>X

e$:[email protected] 5$A;6!598!04 69: .07$25.A.08 $77!5!963^ .77$283 8$ 5$082$6

82977!5R!04 !3 8-. 2.5.08 ;-.0$A.0$0 $7 :.9;$03


34/47

>'

$


35/47

>Z

Q01..1J M01C H2..0


36/47

>*

1B

R0 I>@53@D E@>;9>;4 N=:G< ?3F5 7DB

,-. ]%K% 2.6!.3 $0 !83 7!2.92A ._;$28 2.4/698!$03 8$ 2.382!58 8-.

9@9!69

M;;.66..3^ E2% 98 >>O%

,-. ;2$6!7.298!$0 $7 PL ;2!08.1 7/058!$096 7!2.92A3 A91. 96A$38

.08!2.6C $7 ;6938!53 !052.93.3 8-. 2!3R $7 )&P%+ ,-. 2.;$28.23 .93!6C ;933.1 8-2$/4- 382!58 `9!2;$28(38C6.

+ M@9!69P>P&'?[e$:(

V9!6(\0(K/019C(;2!08.1(;6938!5(4/0(]T((8$$R(


37/47

>?

3.5/2!8Ca 8$ 5922C 8-. 4/0 $08$ 8-. 829!0% 3"" ',% ,.22$2!383 6!R.6C 8$$R

0$8.%

UB (5@@=@>7D 3;< I>@53@D7B

,-. U/2$3892 90.51$8. /01.235$2.3 8-. 3!40!7!5905. $7 8-. Q,M= 8$

8-. 46$


38/47

>+

6$$;-$6.3 N901 5.289!0 3898.3^ 69_ 5$082$63O 8$ $

=.;$28 98 >*%

"#$%& '()(*+(, -./01%23& **('4456478 9#:%& 45 -#3% ;& *7?'5?7*'6


39/47

P)

Q0 /24!04 F$042.33 8$ 56$3. 8-. 6$$;-$6. 8-98 966$:.1 4/0 A9R.23

8$ .@91. 7.1.296 2.4/698!$0 901 3.66 /08295.9


40/47

P&

=.;2.3.0898!@. Q329.6 2.5$40!W.1 8-. 3.67(.@!1.08 !A;6!598!$03 $7

/07.88.2.1 PL 7!2.92A ;2!08!04h

K.5/2!8C 5-.5R;$!083J )&' N9@9!69)&'[&&[&Z[839(79!6.1(8$(5985-(A90(:!8-(6$91.1(4/0($0(

9!2;690.[Ol M6!W9 F-9390J 2$,")861") >65"/.$, 3"8+)'(B .C"$( %/'4%

(D)6+CD J37 %"8+)'(B M'(D #.F" *65*J L MQbf #UcKJ S/0. >J >)&'

N9@9!69Z*XOl S/38!0 Y!3-.6J G!.22. ,-$A93J V!R.

b.@!0.J S95R L98.J =_9W23;`=Y 2$,")861") !>3 J"%(% A'$, 3"8+)'(BA.'/+)"% .( 23 7')46)(%J MEF #UcKJ S/0. >J >)&' N._;69!0!04 8-98 !0

8.383 5$01/58.1


41/47

P>

K.;8.A


42/47

PP

3!046!04 8-.A $/8 93 8924.83 901 !40$2!04 $8-.2 098!$096!8!.3% ;,% M3

[email protected]!$096 7!2.92A3 ;69C.1 9 A9B$2 2$6. !0 8-. 98895Rk901 3!05. 8-.

4/0A.0 2.;$28.16C 36!;;.1 !08$ 8-. ,9B V9-96 G9695. 8-2$/4- 9 ))+%&Z

[email protected]


43/47

PX

1989 7!6.3 7$2 ;6938!5 7!2.92A3 8-98 :$/61 .359;. 1.8.58!$0 ;4 9?5 0>79@>C9 +=:@9 C=:G< ;5439>F5GL >DE3C9

";>95< !93957 I=@5>4; @5G39>=;7B

Y!0966CJ 8-. ;/)&X% K!A!6926CJ 9 C.92 698.2 !0 e$04 T$04J :-!5- 963$

-93 382!58 4/0 5$082$63J&* ;$6!5. 29!1.1 9 42$/; $7 0!0. !01!@!1/963

&* 3"" e$04 T$04 G$6!5. Y$25. ( M1@!5. 7$2 ,$/2!383% G$6!5.%4$@%-R%

N9@9!69


44/47

P'

5$03;!2!04 8$ 98895R [email protected] 6$C [6$C J"))6)'%(% 9.+CD( U'(D Z! E)'$(")- E")D.4%

W66F'$C (6 :6,'#B 7')%6#( R+$%J PL G2!08%5$AJ S/0. >ZJ >)&'%&? MA$04

8-. !8.A3 [email protected] !0 8-. 29!1 :.2. ._;[email protected] A93R3J [email protected] 9!23$78

2!76.3J 901 9 1.3R8$; PL ;2!08.2k3/44.38!04 8-98 8-. 42$/; !08.01.1 8$

A$1!7C 8-. 9!23$78 2!76.3 8$ A9R. 8-.A 6.8-96


45/47

PZ

+/'+$"!-/'

Y$2 8-. 7$2.4$!04 2.93$03J 8-. B/14A.08 $7 8-. L!382!58 F$/28

3-$/61


46/47

P*

+%,(-.-+)(% /. +/$-)'+%

Q 5.28!7C 8-98 8-!3 N9ON'O 901 8-. 8C;. 38C6.

2.D/!2.A.083 $7 Y.1.296 =/6. $7 M;;.6698. G2$5.1/2. P>N9ONZO N9ON*ONEO


47/47

+%,(-.-+)(% /. !%,X-+%

Q 5.28!7C 8-98 $0 Y.)&ZJ Q .6.582$0!5966C 7!6.1 8-.

7$2.4$!04 1$5/A.08 :!8- 8-. F6.2R $7 F$/28 7$2 8-. ]0!8.1 K898.3 F$/28

$7 M;;.963 7$2 8-. Y!78- F!25/!8

amicus curiae brief from the brady center to prevent gun violence in support of appellees and...

Documents