8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

1/23

A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC, December 10, 2013 - RE: NOMINATION OF ATTY. LYNDA CHA!ILE, I"# IF!AO#RESIDENT, AS RE#LACEMENT FOR I"# O$ERNOR FOR NORTHERN L!%ON, DENIS ". HA"A&EL' A.M. No.

13-0(-0)-SC - RE: ALLEED N!LLITY OF THE ELECTION OF I"# SO!THERN L!%ON O$ERNOR $ICENTE M.*OYAS AS I"# E+EC!TI$E $ICE #RESIDENT FOR 2011-2013' A.M. No. 13-0-11-SC - RE: LETTER-

RE/!EST OF THE NATIONAL SECRETARY OF THE I"# RE #RO#OSED OATH-TAIN "EFORE THE S!#REMECO!RT OF THE ELECTED I"# REIONAL O$ERNORS AND THE E+EC!TI$E $ICE #RESIDENT FOR THE TERM2013 TO 201(

EN BANC

A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC, December 10, 2013

RE: NOMINATION OF ATTY. LYNDA CA!"ILE, IB# IF"!AO #RESIDENT, AS RE#LACEMENT FORIB# !O$ERNOR FOR NORTERN L"%ON, DENIS B. ABA&EL

'A.M. No. 13-0(-0)-SC*

RE: ALLE!ED N"LLITY OF TE ELECTION OF IB# SO"TERN L"%ON !O$ERNOR $ICENTE M.+OYAS AS IB# EEC"TI$E $ICE #RESIDENT 'FOR 2011-2013*

A.M. No. 13-0-11-SC

RE: LETTER-RE"EST OF TE NATIONAL SECRETARY OF TE IB# RE #RO#OSED OAT-TA/IN!BEFORE TE S"#REME CO"RT OF TE ELECTED IB# RE!IONAL !O$ERNORS AND TE EEC"TI$E

$ICE #RESIDENT FOR TE TERM 2013 TO 201(

RESOL"TION

LEONEN,J.:

T e5 67o5er co75ro8er 78o987 5e 9e6;er< o= 5e I75er65e; "6r o= 5e #9

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

2/23

O7 M6rc 2, 2013, A55. M6r9o@ ". !b67o, I"# o8er7or =or &e5er7 $66, =9e; 6 Mo5o7 >Or769

Mo5o7? 7 re965o7 5o A.M. No. 0G-(-2-SC. A55. !b67o o@5 5o 7869;65e or 68e 5 Co@r5 ;ec96re6 ultra vires5e

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

3/23

2. O7 *@7e 1, 1G)4, 5e I"# "o6r; o= o8er7or 6

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

4/23

$er !re75 Mo5o7 5o Re5r67 A55. C6@9e =rom $o57 7 5e E$# E9ec5o7 o7 22 M6 2013.J2GA55. !b67o69o e75 6 9e55er 5o Aoc65e *@5ce M6r67o C. ;e9 C6599o 3? Re

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

5/23

7;e

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

6/23

5eprecisemome75 565 6 @cceor 5o 67 o==ce ;e75=e;. &ere 6 86c67c 675c'? @7;er co9or o= 6 7oB7 or869; 6

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

7/23

T co8er6e, 6==rme; 67; re5er65e; 7 @be@e75 K@ror o5erBe ;e765e;? 5em 96ce; 5e c6

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

8/23

Te eco7; re@5e =or be7 6 de factoo==cer, 6

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

9/23

Bo@9; re@95 =rom m@95

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

10/23

A55. !b67o oB7 ;ecr

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

11/23

Le5 6 co

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

12/23

20I;. 65 23 citingecer

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

13/23

4)I;. 65 44).

4G43 #9. )44 >2004?.

(0I;. 65 )()-)(G citing+tate v. 4ates, ( N.&. 2G >1G)3?.

(1I;. 65 )(G citing$idout v. +tate, 30 S.&. 2;. 2(( >1G30?.

(2I;. citingEern v. Mc5overn, 142 N.&. (G( >1G13?.

(3H. S. DE LEON 67; H. M. DE LEON, *R., THE LA& ON #!"LIC OFFICERS AND ELECTION LA& 112>200)? citing3A Am. *@r. 2; 10)2.

(4I;.

((3 #9. 1) >1G1? citing+tate v. Carroll, 3) Co77., 44G' "ilco v. +&ith, ( &e7;e99 N. Y., 231' 21 Am.Dec., 213' +heehan6s Case, 122 M6., 44(' 23 Am. Re1GG)?.

043 #9. )44 >2004?.

13(3 #9. (2(, (34 >1GG)? citing#HILI##INE LA& DICTIONARY, 1GG)?.

3)uanda v. +andigan'ayan, 31G #9. 40, 42 >1GG(? citingH. S. DE LEON 67; H. M. DE LEON, *R., THELA& ON #!"LIC OFFICERS AND ELECTION LA& )-)) >1GG0?.

4I;.

(I;. 65 42 citingH. S. DE LEON 67; H. M. DE LEON, *R., THE LA& ON #!"LIC OFFICERS AND ELECTIONLA& )-)) >1GG0?.

TBo o= 5oe Boe 76me 6re 7;c65e; 7 5e Reo9@5o7 67; O

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

14/23

0CI$IL CODE, Ar5. .

1H. S. DE LEON 67; H. M. DE LEON, *R., THE LA& ON #!"LIC OFFICERS AND ELECTION LA& 110

>200)? citing3A Am. *@r. 2; 10)1.

2"LACS LA& DICTIONARY 44) >E5 E;., 2004?.

31una v. Agra, @200)? citing3A Am. *@r. 2; 10G)-10GG.

($ollo, A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC, A55. !b67o?, 5e I"#o8er7or =or &e5er7 $66, =9e; 6 Motion to Declare as 2ltra #ires or Invalid $e; Portion of IBP B454&ni'us $esolution dated :< March :70ynda? Chaguile, IBP IfugaoPresident, as replace&ent of IBP 5overnor for (orthern 0u%on Denis B. 3a'awel.J I7 5 A

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

15/23

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

16/23

Reo7, 7o5 5e I"# "o6r; o= o8er7or, 68e 5e o9e r5 5o e9ec5 6 @cceor o= 5e re7e; o8er7or.>emA55. M6room69c? 6 C6rm67, A55. Ro6ro T. Se56-Ree

>A55. Se56-Ree? 6 eco7; member 67; I"# He6; Eec@58e A5675 A@ror6 ero7mo >ero7mo? 65r; member. A55. *o6 69o re97@e; 7 =68or o= A55. M6room69c @7;ercor7 6;;e;?A55. !b67o 6 eA55. !rb67o? 6

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

17/23

A55. !b67o 7o5 r6e; 5e @e 6675 5e 869;5 o= er 62? A@m7 565 5e A55. C6@9e ;e765o7 7869; 67; 99e69, c67e be co7;ere; 6 de factoo==cer, 5ereb c9o57 er 6c5o7,7c9@;7 5e 8o5e c65 7 =68or o= A55. *o6 =or 5e

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

18/23

He7ce, co75r6r 5o 5

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

19/23

b= ;e

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

20/23

o8er7or. To re5er65e, 5e m6Kor5 o= 5e ;e9e65e 6; e

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

21/23

I7 em4? or;er A55. *o6 5o re685?

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

22/23

2013. I7 5e me675me, I"# E$# Ro6ro T. Se56-Ree B99 6c5 6Ac57 N65o769 #re;e75 @759 @c 5me 565 5e E$# =or 5erm 2011-

2013 699 68e bee7 e9ec5e;.

>(? or;er 5e delegates of the IBP (orthern 0u%on for ter& :7$e; Portion of IBP B454&ni'us $esolution dated :< March :70ynda? Chaguile, IBP IfugaoPresident, as replace&ent of IBP 5overnor for (orthern 0u%on Denis B. 3a'awel.J

2#6r. 3, ;.

3A 6me7;e;

8/10/2019 A.M. No. 13-04-03-SC Full Text

23/23

1(1lores v. Drilon, .R. No. 10432, *@7e 22, 1GG3, 223 SCRA (), ()2' c57 +tate v. Caroll, 3) Co77.,44G' "ilco v. +&ith, ( &e7;e99 >N.Y.?, 321' 21 Am. Dec., 213' See67 C6e, 122 M6, 44(, 23 Am.Re