allahabad high court afr/landmark...

Allahabad High Court AFR/Landmark Judgments/Orders

Sl. No. Head Line Details

1. Headline Summary - Rape murder girl of 10 Circumstantial evidence Child witness reliability Counsel asked to clarify 313 CrPC circumstances Death commuted to whole life

Judgment/Order - CAPITAL CASES No. 170 of 2013 Judgment/Order Dated - 28/11/2013 at Allahabad.

Title - Ashok Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Bachchoo Lal,J.

2. Headline Summary - Comprehensive directions for legal aid issued Bail in 304 B IPC appeal Information sought from IG Prisons/DJs about old and long confined prisoners.

Judgment/Order - CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2773 of 2005 Judgment/Order Dated - 25/9/2013 at Allahabad.

Title - Gobardhan Singh And Another Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Sunita Agarwal,J.

3. Headline Summary - Conviction cannot be maintained ignoring inherent intrinsic improbabilities and unnaturalaties - appeal allowed.


Title - Narendra Singh @ Nanga Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Anjani Kumar Mishra,J.

4. Headline Summary - Bail rejected from trial court conviction relying on dependable parts of witnesses testimony. Directions issued for tackling hostile witnesses.


Title - Umesh Yadav Vs. State Of U.P.


5. Headline Summary - Trivialities cannot be counted to discard prosecution case against main accused-appeal partly allowed.

Judgment/Order - GOVERNMENT APPEAL No. 310 of 1982 Judgment/Order Dated - 3/9/2013 at Allahabad.

Title - State Of U.P Vs. Radhey Shyam And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Karuna Nand Bajpayee,J.

6. Headline Summary - Determination of juvenility without inquiry is de hors legal mandate.


Title - Surendra Vs. State Of U.P.


7. Headline Summary - Perversity of approach in acquitting main assailants require interference by this Court-Appeal partly allowed.


Title - State Of U.P. Vs. Irfan And Others


8. Headline Summary - ...difficult for the Court...petitioner's prayer if granted shall promote public interest..not be proper for this Court to interfere in policy matters

Judgment/Order - MISC. BENCH No. 7444 of 2013 Judgment/Order Dated - 23/8/2013 at Lucknow.

Title - Asok Pande [P.I.L.] Vs. Union Of India Through Cabinet Secretary, New Delhi & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Shiva Kirti Singh,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya,J.

9. Headline Summary - Total denial of accused-appellants injury makes genesis of the incident suspect entitling the accused to get acquitted.


Title - Vijay Narayan Mishra Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Surendra Singh,J.

10. Headline Summary - Witnesses not immediately disclosing seeing deceased with appellant, unreliable. Directions issued for streamlining rape with murder investigations..


Title - Nem Singh @ Mula Vs. State Of U.P.


11. Headline Summary - Corpse found in house of accused. Injuries unsatisfactorily explained. Superstitious murder, life imprisonment to replace death sentence.


Title - Ram Ashish Gaur & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


12. Headline Summary - Extraordinary jurisdiction can't be equated with appellate jurisdiction and this Court is not required to substitute its own view in place of views...

Judgment/Order - WRIT - C No. 66985 of 2012 Judgment/Order Dated - 20/5/2013 at Allahabad.

Title - Haji Abdul Hakim Vs. State Of U.P. Thru Secy. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Shiva Kirti Singh,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J.

13. Headline Summary - Absence of any reason to implicate the appellant is sufficient to uphold the conviction.


Title - Avaneesh Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Surendra Kumar,J.

14. Headline Summary - Unreliability of fact witnesses and unnaturality of their conduct is sufficient to discard prosecution case-appeal allowed.


Title - Sunil Pasi Vs. State Of U.P.


15. Headline Summary - DEATH PENALTY UPHELD 7 FAMILY MEMBERS MURDER BY AXE, INFANT THROTTLED DIAZEPAM FOUND IN VISCERA NON REFORMABILITY EVIDENCE REQUIREMENT READ DOWN.


Title - Saleem Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble S.C. Agarwal,J.

16. Headline Summary - Perverse analysis by trial court makes incumbent to set aside acquittal and convict accused therefore, appeal allowed/accused convicted.


Title - State Of U.P. Vs. Sohan Lal


17. Headline Summary - Neither under Chapter VIII Rule 5 of High Court Rules nor u/s 19 of C.C. Acts-appeal is maintainable against rejection of contempt application.

Judgment/Order - CONTEMPT APPEAL No. 3 of 2013 Judgment/Order Dated - 15/4/2013 at Allahabad.

Title - Suresh Kumar Mishra Vs. Arun Kumar Rai


18. Headline Summary - COURT ISSUES DIRECTIONS FOR MONITORING WOMEN'S PROTECTION HOMES AND THEIR INMATES

Judgment/Order - CRIMINAL WRIT-PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION No. 20736 of 2011 Judgment/Order Dated - 5/4/2013 at Allahabad.

Title - In The Matter Of Inmates Of Women Protection Home Vns. Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Bachchoo Lal,J.

19. Headline Summary - A party should take all grounds and raise all pleas available to him and if he fails to do so, the principle of constructive res judicata applies...


Title - Khurkhur And Another Vs. Union Of India And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Shiva Kirti Singh,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J.

20. Headline Summary - Suppression of factum of murder of mother of accused appellant by prosecution-prosecution version unreliable-appeal allowed.


Title - Munendra And Others Vs. State


21. Headline Summary - Complaints against unauthorized occupation over the public ponds or other similar public lands, D.M. should take all required actions.

Judgment/Order - PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION (PIL) No. 63380 of 2012 Judgment/Order Dated - 6/12/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Prem Singh Vs. The State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Shiva Kirti Singh,Acting Chief Justice and Hon'ble Pradeep Kumar Singh Baghel,J.

22. Headline Summary - Condition of pre-deposit under S. 18 of 2002 Act is mandatory in all appeals filed against the order passed under S.17.


Title - Mohan Lal Saraf Vs. Chairperson Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J.

23. Headline Summary - There is no power to condone the delay in filing the election petition under Rule 33 of the Zila Panchayat Rules, 1994


Title - Smt. Sharda Devi Vs. State Of U.P. Thru Secy. And Others


24. Headline Summary - Committee and the complainant have no locus to defend the order of DM for ceasing powers of Pradhan and the reply of Pradhan has to be considered


Title - Narendra Kumar Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


25. Headline Summary - Industrial Tribunal is not a court subordinate to the High Court for the purposes of Section 24 C.P.C.

Judgment/Order - TRANSFER APPLICATION (CIVIL) No. 397 of 2012 Judgment/Order Dated - 3/12/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Shrikant Pandey Vs. Ramshabad Mishra

Coram - Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.

26. Headline Summary - Even a deemed University after grant of permission by NCTE has to take affiliation from Examination Regulatory Authority for conducting two years BTC.


Title - Shashi Kumar Dwivedi And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


27. Headline Summary - O2 R2 CPC not a bar to subsequent Suit if cause of action in two Suits is different.


Title - M/S Trademan International Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal And Others


28. Headline Summary - Credible prosecution case supported even by hostile witnesses and absence of false implication is enough to uphold conviction.


Title - Dhanpal Vs. State Of U.P.


29. Headline Summary - In absence of intention fatal injury at the spur of moment in anguish does not disclose the charge of murder-appeal partly allowed.


Title - Swami Vs. State

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Pankaj Naqvi,J.

30. Headline Summary - Presence of informant doubtful significant omission in ocular version and change in prosecution story are sufficient to discard prosecution case.


Title - Deo Raj & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


31. Headline Summary - Separate appeal has to be filed against dismissal of counter-claim in 1993 Debts Act.


Title - Deepak Mitra Vs. United Bank Of India And Others


32. Headline Summary - A District Consumer Forum/Commission is a Court and subordinate to the High Court in the context of Section 10 of Contempt of Courts Act 1971.

Judgment/Order - CONTEMPT APPLICATION (CRIMINAL) No. 3 of 2012 Judgment/Order Dated - 10/9/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - In Re: Vs. Anil Kumar Jindal And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Dharnidhar Jha,J. and Hon'ble Ashok Pal Singh,J.

33. Headline Summary - Order of District Judge passed u/s 24 CPC is not appealable. It also can't be set aside by the High Court in exercise of power u/s 24 CPC.


Title - Shakeela Vs. Mehboob Ali Siddiqui


34. Headline Summary - S.D.M. dealing with election petition is not a court subordinate to the High Court for transfer of proceedings under Section 24 of the C.P.C.


Title - Mursaleem Vs. Yogendra Sharma And Others


35. Headline Summary - Witnesses of day light murder cannot be disbelieved on insignificant mistakes by the I.O./Appeal dismissed.


Title - Aslam & Others Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Yogesh Chandra Gupta,J.

36. Headline Summary - Assignee Bank can be substituted in the recovery certificate for execution of the decree even if assignment deed was executed during pendency of suit.


Title - Shalini Asha Chopra And Others Vs. Chairperson, Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal And Others


37. Headline Summary - High court cannot transfer the case from one district consumer forum to another in exercise of power under Section 24 C.P.C.


Title - Hanuman Yadav Vs. State Consumer Forum And Others


38. Headline Summary - “Arbitration Agreement” contemplates agreement by the parties to the dispute and not a unilateral instrument.

Judgment/Order - CIVIL REVISION No. 388 of 2012 Judgment/Order Dated - 31/8/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Smt.Krishna Premmai Devidasi Vs. International Society For Krishna Conscieusness And Others


39. Headline Summary - Realisation of Trade Tax Arrears will not take precedence over the right of the Bank to recover the dues as a secured creditor.


Title - Smt. Urmila Devi And Others Vs. Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal And Others


40. Headline Summary - Cooperative law to be amended by 14.2.2013


Title - Prem Narayan Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Mahendra Dayal,J.

41. Headline Summary - Circumstantial evidence hazy, unclear and doubtful-conviction cannot be sustained-appeal allowed.


Title - Narendra & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


42. Headline Summary - What period is to be excluded under explanation to section 15(3) of UP Kshettra Panchayat and Zila Panchayat Adhiniyam, 1961.


Title - Smt. Rubi Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


43. Headline Summary - Court can refuse to entertain writ petition by invoking doctrine of forum conveniens


Title - M/S Dynamic Education Systems (International) Ltd. & Another Vs. Bank Of Baroda And Others


44. Headline Summary - Principles to determine the genuineness of will.

Judgment/Order - SPECIAL APPEAL No. 961 of 2004 Judgment/Order Dated - 23/7/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Dinesh Chandra Pandey Vs. Brijesh Chandra Pandey & Others


45. Headline Summary - False explanation of accused injury is enough to set aside conviction of a murder charge/appeal allowed.


Title - Kalloo Vs. State


46. Headline Summary - MATTER UNDER SECTION 14 OF THE GUARDIANS & WARDS ACT 1890 IS NOT IN THE NATURE OF A TRANSFER APPLICATION BUT A REFERENCE FOR OPINION OF THE HIGH COURT


Title - Smt. Savitri Devi Vs. Smt. Raman Lata


47. Headline Summary - Prosecution story credible/defence unable to dislodge it/conviction upheld.


Title - Govind Das @ Buddha Vs. State Of U.P.


48. Headline Summary - Transfer of lease hold rights is transfer of lease by way of assignment under Article 63 of Schedule 1B of the Stamp Act.


Title - Om Shree Ganesh Sahkari Avas Samiti Limited Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


49. Headline Summary - High Court of Allahabad is not a principle civil court of original jursidiction under Section 2(1)(e) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996.

Judgment/Order - ARBITRATION and CONCILI. APPL.U/s11(4) No. 32 of 2012 Judgment/Order Dated - 31/5/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - M/S B.M.G. Construction Vs. National Small Industries Corporation Ltd. And Others


50. Headline Summary - Evidence of witnesses cannot be brushed aside on petty issues-appeal dismissed.


Title - Ganesh And Another Vs. State Ofu.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J.

51. Headline Summary - Reasonable prognosis of right of private defence is sufficient to acquit the accused-appeal allowed.


Title - Azad Khan And Other Vs. State Of U.P.


52. Headline Summary - Juvenility delay and no benefit to the complainant cumulatively are sufficient to quash prosecution.

Judgment/Order - APPLICATION U/s 482 No. 17357 of 2005 Judgment/Order Dated - 30/5/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Smt. Vimla Devi Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


53. Headline Summary - Medical practice is a profession. Doctor's clinic in residential area is not a commercial activity.


Title - Satya Prakash Singh & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


54. Headline Summary - Some suggestions for reducing committee of management disputes.


Title - Vijay Pratap Singh Nd Another Vs. Dios And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Mohd. Tahir,J.

55. Headline Summary - Appellate order not to be passed by the same officer who has passed the basic order impugned in appeal.


Title - Mohd. Chand And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


56. Headline Summary - Release of property u/s 17 of the Gangster's Act and punishment of crime u/s 3 of the Gangster's Act are different proceedings.


Title - Kailash Sahkari Awas Samiti Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


57. Headline Summary - Appointment of the arbitrator named/designated in the agreement is the Rule which can only be deviated by the Chief Justice for valid reasons.


Title - Bharat Wire Ropes Ltd. Vs. Unio Of India Thru' Ministry Of Railway And Others


58. Headline Summary - Matter decided by civil court - cannot be reopened before Industrial Tribunal


Title - Central Bank Of India Vs. Union Of India And Others


59. Headline Summary - First proviso to section 11(1) of Land Acquisition Act - For benefit of government, acquiring body.


Title - Dau Dayal And Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


60. Headline Summary - Fees deposited seat reserved in JEE-Ineligible to appear in next jEE.


Title - Sujeet Chaudhary Vs. Union Of India And Others


61. Headline Summary - Scheme of administration of College does not prohibit indirect elections.


Title - C/M D.A.V. Intermediate College And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


62. Headline Summary - Cheque dishonoured, information sent though not served, insurance company not liable.

Judgment/Order - FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDER No. 641 of 1998 Judgment/Order Dated - 27/4/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Smt. Raj Kumari Singh & Others


63. Headline Summary - FABRICATED DYING DECLARATION BY POLICE OFFICER SUSPECTED COURT DIRECTS ENQUIRY PUNISHMENT POLICE OFFICER AND DOCTOR CERTIFYING DEAD PERSON'S FITNESS


Title - Upendra Singh @ Alalan Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Anurag Kumar,J.

64. Headline Summary - Invocation of arbitration clause is sine qua non for maintaining an application U/S 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.


Title - Abdul Rashid Vs. National Building Construction Corp. Ltd., New Delhi


65. Headline Summary - Directions issued in Rajkiya Shishu Grih Shivkuti , Allahabad minor girls rape case.

Judgment/Order - CRIMINAL WRIT-PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION No. 4207 of 2012 Judgment/Order Dated - 16/4/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - In The Matter Of Govt. Children'S Home At Shivkuti Allahabad Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Ashok Srivastava,J.

66. Headline Summary - Land acquisition - award of a plot - not in piecemeal.


Title - Smt. Kamla Devi & Others Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Chief Secy. U.P. Govt. & Ors.

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble B. Amit Sthalekar,J.

67. Headline Summary - Malice an intent to defame is a must for charge of defamation/it are absent/prosecution quashed.

Judgment/Order - CRIMINAL REVISION No. 2929 of 2006 Judgment/Order Dated - 11/4/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Dr. Vishnu Dutt Agarwal Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


68. Headline Summary - The lease deed executed between the tenant and landlord that the Rent Control Act will not apply is void.

Judgment/Order - WRIT - A No. 5826 of 2010 Judgment/Order Dated - 5/4/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Dr. K. Gopal Vs. Smt. Sudarshan Devi Bhatia


69. Headline Summary - For sustaining conviction u/s 399, 402 I.P.C. evidence has to be of an unimpeachable character-appeal allowed-conviction set aside.


Title - Hoti And Others Vs. State


70. Headline Summary - Some leases/ permits less than 5 hectares may require environmental clearance


Title - Rajesh Kumar Nishad Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble B. Amit Sthalekar,J.

71. Headline Summary - Revisional Court should hesitate to compare the signatures when handwriting expert opinion is available particularly when Trial Court has accepted it.


Title - Raja Ram Sharma Vs. District Judge And Others


72. Headline Summary - Circumstance under which a decree is a nullity or merely illegal, objection to the decree cannot be raised before Executing Court if decree is illegal


Title - Ghani Vs. Smt. Haseen Bano


73. Headline Summary - Denial for want of knowledge in written statement is admission of plaint averments and suit for ejectment can be filed by Mutawalli on behalf of wakf.


Title - Syed Mustajab Husain Vs. Additional District Judge (Court No. 13) Agra And Others


74. Headline Summary - Without establishing genuineness, photo cannot be admitted as secondary evidence.


Title - Hauslla Prasad Vs. State


75. Headline Summary - Section 437-A CrPC - Some Suggestions and Recommendations


Title - Nannu And Others Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Ram Surat Ram (Maurya),J.

76. Headline Summary - Complaint cannot be dismissed when prima facie offence is disclosed by meticulously examining prosecution allegations.


Title - Umrao Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


77. Headline Summary - Benefit of Section 29-A of 1972 Rent Act is not available to a tenant if only temporary structures are raised with the consent of the landlord.


Title - Rameshwar Dayal Agarwal Vs. Pawan Kumar & Others


78. Headline Summary - An unchallenged lease document cannot be the basis of a criminal trial for cheating.


Title - Ramesh Chandra Bhatia Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


79. Headline Summary - Petition challenging Election Commission order directing covering "elephant" and Ms Mayawati statues, dismissed.


Title - Dheeraj Pratap Singh Vs. Chief Election Commission, Union Of India And Another

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Ramesh Sinha,J.

80. Headline Summary - Inconsistent plea and documents by the accused is sufficient to reject claim of juvenility.


Title - Atin Jaiswal Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


81. Headline Summary - Prayer for discharge can be allowed u/s 227 Cr.P.C.only when no prima facie case is disclosed.


Title - Subhash Chand Gupta & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


82. Headline Summary - Law relating to bonded labour explained. Direction issued to constitute Legal aid clinics and provide socio-economics reliefs.

Judgment/Order - HABEAS CORPUS WRIT PETITION No. 70403 of 2011 Judgment/Order Dated - 5/1/2012 at Allahabad.

Title - Sageer & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Ramesh Sinha,J.

83. Headline Summary - Dying declaration can be accepted only when it is free from all infirmities, embellishment and tutoring/appeal allowed as the same is missing.


Title - Asha Ram & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


84. Headline Summary - For a cheque issued by a third party-Bank Manager cannot be prosecuted u/s 138 N.I. Act.


Title - R.K.Dixit Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


85. Headline Summary - Change in the circumstances is essential for re-exercising power u/s 311 Cr.P.C.


Title - Vinod Kumar Singh Vs. State Of U.P.


86. Headline Summary - Benefit of difference in age should be given to the accused for offences u/ss 363, 366, 376 IPC/Appeal allowed.


Title - Raj Kumar Shukla Vs. State Of U.P.


87. Headline Summary - Wires laid under section 164 of the Electricity Act - Permission of DM is not required.


Title - Power Grid Corp. Of India Limited Vs. Ajay Kumar Gupta And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Ram Surat Ram (Maurya),J.

88. Headline Summary - Fraud and justice cannot live together. If something obtained by fraud and factum of fraud is proved, things becomes non-est


Title - Smt. Vibha Shukla And Another Vs. D.E. (Basic) U.P., Alld. Andothers

Coram - Hon'ble Syed Rafat Alam,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Ran Vijai Singh,J.

89. Headline Summary - High Court directs CBI to conduct preliminary enquiry in the implementation of NRHM and utilisation of NRHM funds at various levels in State of U.P.


Title - Sachchidanand (Sachchey) [ P.I.L. ] Civil Vs. State Of U.P. Thru Principal Secretary Health & Family Welfa

Coram - Hon'ble Pradeep Kant,J. and Hon'ble Ritu Raj Awasthi,J.

90. Headline Summary - Not necessary to issue writ, even if order is wrong


Title - Ramesh Chand Vs. Executive Engineer And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Dinesh Gupta,J.

91. Headline Summary - No conviction for dacoity can be recorded if identification is not confidence inspiring/Appeal is partly allowed.


Title - Ram Pal & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


92. Headline Summary - Full Bench Judgement on Land Acquisition Matter of Greater NOIDA & NOIDA


Title - Gajraj And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan,J. , Hon'ble Sibghat Ullah Khan,J. and Hon'ble V.K. Shukla,J.

93. Headline Summary - For charge of dacoity participation of five or more accused essential/witnesses unreliable/prosecution version false/appeal allowed.


Title - Gyan Singh Vs. State Of U.P


94. Headline Summary - Conviction under NDPS Act cannot be sustained for violation of Section 42, 57 of the Act/ recovery doubtful/appellant acquitted.


Title - Shyam Babu Vishwakarma & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


95. Headline Summary - Direction given to police & Magistrates on manner of remanding accused in offences punishable upto 7 years in accordance with newly introduced section

Judgment/Order - CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. 17410 of 2011 Judgment/Order Dated - 11/10/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - Shaukin Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Kalimullah Khan,J.

96. Headline Summary - 498-A offence--Law procedure for mediation and directions for making 498-A IPC offence compoundable


Title - Re: In The Matter Of Matrimonial Disputes Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Shyam Shankar Tiwari,J.

97. Headline Summary - Defence suggestion can be considered to judge veracity of prosecution version-victim minor-conviction maintained-sentence reduced.


Title - Mohammad Yashin Alias Jagdish & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


98. Headline Summary - TO CONSIDER APPLICATION FOR DISCHARGE UNDER SECTION 245 (2) CrPC, PRESENCE OF ACCUSED IS NECESSARY IF THE CASE HAS REACHED THE STAGE OF SECTION 244


Title - Manoj Dalmia Vs. State Of U.P. And Another

Coram - Hon'ble Shri Kant Tripathi,J.

99. Headline Summary - TO ESTABLISH THE CHARGE U/S 412 IPC, THE PROSECUTION HAS TO PROVE THAT THE ACCUSED HAD KNOWLEDGE THAT THE RECOVERED PROPERTY WAS STOLEN IN A DACOITY.


Title - Anil @ Bablu Srivastava Vs. State Of U.P.


100. Headline Summary - Preponderance of probability is enough to confer right of private defence/Appeal allowed.


Title - Pokhpal Vs. State


101. Headline Summary - Admission is conclusive unless explained

Judgment/Order - FIRST APPEAL No. 962 of 2004 Judgment/Order Dated - 20/9/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - State Of U.P. Thru' Collector, Mathura Vs. Thakur Sri Radha Ramanji Maharaj

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Dinesh Gupta,J.

102. Headline Summary - JUDGMENTS OF COURTS OF JUSTICE ARE RELEVANT ONLY UNDER SECTIONS 40 TO 44 OF THE EVIDENCE ACT AND NOT OTHERWISE.


Title - Akash Kumar Sharma And Another Vs. State Of U.P.


103. Headline Summary - AN ACCUSED HAS INDEFEASIBLE RIGHT TO CLAIM COPIES OF DOCUMENTS RELIED UPON BY THE PROSECUTION.


Title - Vinay Sharma Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


104. Headline Summary - IF A CASE DISCLOSES BOTH CRIMINAL AND CIVIL LIABILITY OF THE ACCUSED, THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS CANNOT BE QUASHED.


Title - Debobroto Dutta And Others Vs. Km. Sunanda Ghosh And Another


105. Headline Summary - Conviction for Dacoity can not be sustained on improbable and unnatural evidences


Title - Satyadeo Bahela & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


106. Headline Summary - An election petition, which does not conform to the statutory requirements, must be dismissed outrightly.

Judgment/Order - ELECTION PETITION No. 9 of 2009 Judgment/Order Dated - 14/9/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - V.M.Singh S/O Mander Singh Vs. Feroze Varun Gandhi


107. Headline Summary - Section 389 Cr.P.C.-pending consideration final bail prayer in appeal-appellant can be released on interim bail.


Title - Smt. Tara Devi And Anr. Vs. State Of U.P.


108. Headline Summary - Custody of son cannot be handed over to an unchaste mother with murder charge/Habeas Corpus dismissed.


Title - Master Shobhit Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


109. Headline Summary - Denial of accused right to get sample retested deserves quashing of proceeding.


Title - Manoj Kumar Assistant Manager Bharat Insectsides Ltd. Vs. State Of U.P.


110. Headline Summary - Denial of accused right to get sample retested deserves quashing of proceeding.


Title - Bharat Insecticides Ltd. And Another Vs. State Of U.P. Through Insecticides Inspector Bijnore


111. Headline Summary - Only the two senior most teachers working in the institution at the time the requisition is sent to the Board can be called for interview.


Title - Shyam Lal And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


112. Headline Summary - GOs curtailing freeship to students of weaker section quashed. HC says State must not sway from constitutional obligation to do welfare of its subject


Title - Meydha Meritorious Education For Youths Vs. State Of U.P. Thru Chief Secretary & Ors. (P.I.L.){Civil}


113. Headline Summary - Quashing of prosecution-dispute between Deemed University and students-compromise arrived at-proceedings quashed.


Title - Vinod B. Lal Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


114. Headline Summary - Evidence inherently improbable and unmerited-charge under Section 120-B I.P.C. cannot be framed-revision allowed.


Title - Dev Sharma & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


115. Headline Summary - For the purposes of proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of CPC the relevant date for commencement of the trial is the date on which issues are framed


Title - Chandra Narain Tripathi Vs. Kapil Muni Karwariya


116. Headline Summary - Conviction under N.D.P.S. Act-Sections 42, 50 and 57 not complied with-Appeal allowed-Conviction set aside-Appellant acquitted.


Title - Pandav Sarkar Vs. State Of U.P.


117. Headline Summary - High Court directs CBI to investigate into the murders of Dr.V.K.Arya and Dr. B.P.Singh, CMOs alongwith the cases relating to NRHM scam.


Title - We The People [ P.I.L. ] Criminal Vs. Union Of India, Thru. Prin. Secy.,Ministry Of Home & Ors.


118. Headline Summary - 145 proceeding/parties failed to establish possession/attachment and order for relief from civil court just and proper/writ dismissed.


Title - Smt. Bala Dhama & Others Vs. S.D.M. Baraut & Others


119. Headline Summary - Section12/Bail to juvenile/defence to juvenile with favourable report should be given due consideration/bail allowed.


Title - Pushpendra @ Brij Bihari @ Pappi Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


120. Headline Summary - Bail to juvenile/extraneous material without evidence should not be considered/bail allowed.


Title - Kushagra Mokhariwale Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


121. Headline Summary - Section 12 J.J. Act/no criminal history/circumstantial evidence case/surmises cropped in rejection/revision allowed/bail granted.


Title - Shiva @ Suryakant Vs. State Of U.P.


122. Headline Summary - No contravention of mentioned control order/confiscation illegal/order set aside.


Title - Madan Lal Sahu Vs. State Of U.P.


123. Headline Summary - High Court directs CBI investigation in Dr. Y.S.Sachan's unnatural death in judicial custody,investigation to be completed within maximum three months


Title - Sachchidanand (Sachchey) [ P.I.L.] Civil Vs. State Of U.P.Through Its Prin. Secy. (Home) U.P.Civil Sectt.


124. Headline Summary - Defaulter cannot take advantage of his default in divorce proceeding.


Title - Dr. Tara Charan Agarwal Vs. Smt. Veena Agarwal

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Yogesh Chandra Gupta,J.

125. Headline Summary - Charge/227/228 Cr.P.C./accused contention must be decided by a speaking reasoned order/Revision allowed.


Title - Shiv Prakash Tiwari & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


126. Headline Summary - HC dismisses PIL against constitution of JDC for Lok Pal Bill, says it is within executive discretion of Government to constitute such a committee.


Title - Asok Pande & Anr. [ P.I.L. ] Civil Vs. Union Of India,Thru. Secy., Prime Minister'S Office, & Ors.

Coram - Hon'ble Pradeep Kant,J. and Hon'ble Vedpal,J.

127. Headline Summary - NOTIFICATION NO. S.I. 2942 (E) DATED 18.11.2009 ISSUED BY THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA SHALL APPLY PROSPECTIVELY


Title - Suresh Singh Kushwaha Vs. State Of U.P.


128. Headline Summary - conviction u/s 498A, 304B I.P.C.- D/D not truthful and hear-se-relative witnesses not reliable-appeal allowed-conviction set aside.


Title - Govind Hari Swamy And Another Vs. State Of U.P.


129. Headline Summary - There are exceptions to grant bail to a juvenile/revision dismissed.


Title - Monu @ Moni @ Rahul @ Rohit Vs. State Of U.P.


130. Headline Summary - Petition of Amar Singh dismissed. In petition of S.K.Tripathi, investigation entrusted to Enforcement Directorate Ist Status report in Ist week of Jul


Title - Amar Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Shyam Shankar Tiwari,J.

131. Headline Summary - Charge of rape-no consent of will present-summoning order justified-revision dismissed.


Title - Shiwalik Ghosh And Anr. Vs. State Of U.P. And Anr.


132. Headline Summary - To declare a person juvenile, his date of birth recorded in high school certificate will be given preference over date of birth given in other record.


Title - Dharam Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


133. Headline Summary - D.M Bijnor,S.P Bijnor and SO ordered to be transferred. FIR against Judicial officer quashed. Further investigation by CBI. report within 3 months


Title - Tabrez Ahmad Civil Judge(J.D.), Nazibabad,Bijnor Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Shri Kant Tripathi,J.

134. Headline Summary - FIR discloses commission of cognizable offence. Quashing of FIR refused. Govt. of Law Commission recommended to make Section 354 IPC non-bailable.


Title - Amit Kumar @ Mittal Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


135. Headline Summary - SCHEDULE ANNEXED WITH THE PETITION IN SUPPORT OF THE ALLEGATIONS IS EVIDENCE AND CAN NOT BE TREATED AS PLEADING.


Title - Chandra Narain Tripathi Vs. Kapil Muni Karwariya


136. Headline Summary - It is mandatory to obtain environmental clearance under the Notification dated 14.9.2006......


Title - Jagriti Sansthan And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ferdino Inacio Rebello,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Prakash Krishna,J.

137. Headline Summary - Environmental clearance is mandatory prior to carry on the mining operations.


Title - Mohd. Kausar Jah [ P.I.L.] Civil Vs. Union Of India Through Secy. Ministry Of Environment And

Coram - Hon'ble Ferdino Inacio Rebello,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Devi Prasad Singh,J.

138. Headline Summary - Conviction well merited, however compensation granted-sentence reduced as first offence.


Title - Nawal Kishor Tewari Vs. State Of U.P.


139. Headline Summary - Section 20 Juvenile Justice Act has got precedence over Section 18-Revision dismissed.


Title - Surjeet Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


140. Headline Summary - Powers of Assistant Registrar cancelling the registration of Society, Allahabad High School, Allahabad


Title - Allahabad High School Society Alld. Thru' Secry, & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble D.S.R. Varma,J. and Hon'ble Vikram Nath,J.

141. Headline Summary - NO CASE CAN BE TRANSFERRED ON RAISING OF AN APPREHENSION HAVING NO REASONABLE BASIS

Judgment/Order - TRANSFER APPLICATION (CRIMINAL) No. 85 of 2011 Judgment/Order Dated - 25/3/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - Laxmi Narain Pandey Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


142. Headline Summary - Premium for driver not paid - Insurance Company not liable to pay compensation.


Title - New India Assurance Co. Ltd Vs. Smt. Uma Devi And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Shyam Shankar Tiwari,J.

143. Headline Summary - Interim mandamus issued to DGP to clear railway tracks and report compliance 29.3.2011 fixed next date


Title - Km. Bharti Kashyap Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


144. Headline Summary - Appeal against conviction under 307 IPC-medical report cooked up-investigation unfair-313 Cr.PC not complied with-appeal allowed-conviction set aside.


Title - Shashi Kant Singh And Another Vs. State Of U.P.


145. Headline Summary - Applicant successful in lottery for liquor shops; application counter signed - liable to pay licence fee on MGQ.

Judgment/Order - WRIT TAX No. 1429 of 2006 Judgment/Order Dated - 9/3/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - Brij Kishore Jaisal And Another Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Princ. Secry., (Excise) And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Prakash Krishna,J.

146. Headline Summary - No person can be added as accused under Section 319 Cr.P.C. after closer of the case.


Title - Ajay Vs. State Of U.P.


147. Headline Summary - Circumstantial evidence last seen recovery of weapon statement of deceased of invitation of accused admissible u/s 32(1) of Evidence ActAppeal dismiss

Judgment/Order - JAIL APPEAL No. 5198 of 2005 Judgment/Order Dated - 3/3/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - Saeeduddin Vs. State

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Naheed Ara Moonis,J.

148. Headline Summary - Deceased's amputated organ reason for preferring unvirtuous DW evidence to PWs Section 7, 146, 148 Evidence Act discussed.


Title - Rishi Pal Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Naheed Ara Moonis,J.

149. Headline Summary - Repeated 482 Cr.P.C. Applications for the same relief without change of circumstances and facts not maintainable-482Cr.P.C. Applications dismissed.


Title - C.P. Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


150. Headline Summary - SUMMONING ORDER WITHOUT OBTAINING RELEVANT MATERIALS IN SUPPORT OF THE INFORMATION RECEIVED U/S190 (1)(C) OF THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE IS NOT PROPER


Title - Ram Vilash Chauhan & Others Vs. State Of U.P.& Others


151. Headline Summary - A HEAVY DUTY LIES ON THE STATE TO PROTECT WITNESSES FROM BEING TAMPERED WITH. ACCUSED INVOLVED IN TAMPERING WITH THE EVIDENCE IS NOT ENTITLED TO BAIL.

Judgment/Order - CRIMINAL MISC. BAIL APPLICATION No. 32428 of 2009 Judgment/Order Dated - 24/2/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - Gufran Ahmad Vs. State Of U.P.


152. Headline Summary - Interest for the period accounts books were seized should be waived.


Title - M/S J.S.D. Colonizers (P) Ltd Vs. Uniion Of India & Another


153. Headline Summary - If search under Income Tax Act is challenged, the Department has to disclose information except source.


Title - M/S M.D. Overseas Ltd. Vs. Director General Of Income-Tax (Inv.) North And Others


154. Headline Summary - PIL for reforming police working, train it it with scientific skill. Government called upon to file counter affidavit sworn by officer.


Title - Mohammad Qasim Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


155. Headline Summary - Notice issued to Govt in the matter of harassment or torture of villagers in Madauka village Naini PS on Hindustan reports


Title - In The Matter Of Harassment Or Torture Of Villagers Vs. State Of U.P.


156. Headline Summary - Section 174(1)(a) Municipal Corporation Act is valid


Title - Clark Hotel Limited Thru' Managing Director Upendra Gupta Vs. Stae Of U.P. Thru' The Principal Secretary U.D.L.B. & Others


157. Headline Summary - Conviction u/s 376 IPC/victim major/eloped on her own volition/consenting party/ conviction set aside/appeal allowed.


Title - Sanjiv @ Sanju Vs. State


158. Headline Summary - Appeal against acquittal-incident 34 years ago-remand of case not desirable-bleak chances of evidence being available-appeal dismissed


Title - State Of U.P. Vs. Shamim Beg


159. Headline Summary - In Sheelu Nishad case, the victim ordered to be released forthwith from jail attended with direction to provide security to the victim and her family.


Title - In The Matter Of Sheelu Nishad, A Rape Victim Lodged In Jail Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble S.C. Agarwal,J.

160. Headline Summary - Prior to 1.4.1989, assessment u/s 141(1) of the IT Act was regular assessment.

Judgment/Order - INCOME TAX APPEAL No. 61 of 2000 Judgment/Order Dated - 7/1/2011 at Allahabad.

Title - The Commissioner Of Income Tax Vs. D.S. Batra (Indl)


161. Headline Summary - One out of two exemptions can always be opted unless specifically or impliedly barred by other.

Judgment/Order - CENTRAL EXCISE REFERENCE No. 31 of 2000 Judgment/Order Dated - 23/12/2010 at Allahabad.

Title - Cce Meerut Vs. Modi Xerox Ltd. Rampur


162. Headline Summary - Full Bench viewed that order U/S 156(3) Cr.P.C. interlocutory, no revision or application 482 Cr.P.C.lie by prospective accused


Title - Father Thomas Vs. State Of U.P. & Another

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. , Hon'ble Ashok Kumar Roopanwal,J. and Hon'ble Surendra Singh,J.

163. Headline Summary - Co-accused granted bail-only conviction for conspiracy-appellant granted bail.


Title - Ashok Chaturvedi Vs. Central Bureau Of Investigation And Anr.


164. Headline Summary - Collective decision of Statutory Board-cannot be conspiracy by one-consensus evidence missing-Smt. Neera Yadav granted bail.


Title - Smt. Neera Yadav Vs. State Of U.P. Thru. C.B.I.


165. Headline Summary - Entertainment Tax Act - no provision to impose damages for loss of entertainment tax


Title - Sita Ram Tekariwal Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


166. Headline Summary - In the matter of Rakhi Sawant, stay order of arrest granted


Title - Rakhi Sawant Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Ram Autar Singh,J.

167. Headline Summary - show cause noticed issued to AB Rajmauli Distt Magistrate Bijnor for initiating contempt proceeding. Vigilance enquiry set up.


Title - Tabrez Ahmad Civil Judge(J.D.), Nazibabad,Bijnor Vs. State Of U.P.


168. Headline Summary - G.O. dated 25.8.2010 is modified to the extent that appointment of Rojgar Sewaks shall be renewed for one year at a time subject to satisfactory work.


Title - Shiv Manorath Shukla And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


169. Headline Summary - Amount sent by Mandi Samiti to the Parishad is application of records under Income Tax Act.

Judgment/Order - INCOME TAX APPEAL DEFECTIVE No. 58 of 2010 Judgment/Order Dated - 2/12/2010 at Allahabad.

Title - The Commissioner Of Income Tax And Another Vs. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti


170. Headline Summary - Fee for advertisement on TV Channel by Nagar Palika Parishad - not permissible


Title - Sanjai Gupta Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' D.M., Etah And Others


171. Headline Summary - Rule 11 of 1987 Rules for Madarsa will also apply to earlier recognised Madarsas.


Title - C/M, Madarsa Quraniya Adampur Akbar Thru' Manaer & Others Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Chief Secretary Govt. Of U.P. & Others


172. Headline Summary - Arrest of the petitioners stayed as a consequence of FIR resulting from episode "Rakhi Ka Insaf"


Title - Anju Raikwar And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


173. Headline Summary - The jurisdiction to verify the caste certificate and whether it should be validated or invalidated is of the Caste Scrutiny Committee.


Title - Hizwana Bano Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Collector And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ferdino Inacio Rebello,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Vineet Saran,J.

174. Headline Summary - Case falling under two heads u/s 153 Income Tax Act - time should be excluded for both.

Judgment/Order - INCOME TAX REFERENCE No. 189 of 1987 Judgment/Order Dated - 23/11/2010 at Allahabad.

Title - C.I.T. Vs. M/S Luxco Electronics


175. Headline Summary - Draft order under section 144B of Income Tax Act should be referred to IAC conferred concurrent jurisdiction.


Title - C.I.T. Allahabad Vs. M/S. S. Sugar Mills Pvt. Ltd., Gorakhpur


176. Headline Summary - At the stage of charge, neither pros and cons of the case nor the defence evidence can be considered. Charge can be framed even on grave suspicion.

Judgment/Order - U/S 482/378/407 No. 2912 of 2010 Judgment/Order Dated - 19/11/2010 at Lucknow.

Title - Vijay Kumar Trivedi Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


177. Headline Summary - The question whether model shop during excise year can be relocated - referred to the third judge.


Title - Rakesh Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Rajes Kumar,J.

178. Headline Summary - contempt notice issued to Editor and others, Hindustan Times to appear in court on 13.12.2010


Title - Vikas Tiwari Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Ashok Srivastava,J.

179. Headline Summary - Not necessary for the empowered officer to personally record reasons.


Title - M/S N.K. Laminates Pvt Ltd. Vs. Supdt (C.P.) Central Excise, Kanpur & Others


180. Headline Summary - summoning order-not to be a speaking order-presumption u/s 114(e) of Evidence Act can be applied.


Title - Anand Kumar Porwal Vs. State Of U.P.And Another


181. Headline Summary - A word used at different place in the Act or Rule may have different meaning according to its context.


Title - Viveka Nand Yadav Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


182. Headline Summary - Opportunity to head of local body necessary before ceasing financial power.


Title - Hafiz Ataullah Ansari Vs. State Of U.P. And Another

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. , Hon'ble Rajes Kumar,J. and Hon'ble Krishna Murari,J.

183. Headline Summary - prayer for criminal contempt against Chief Minister-statement not scandalize to judicial proceeding-prayer refused


Title - Smt. Alka Rai Ex. M.L.A. Vs. Miss Mayawati The Hon'Ble Chief Minister Of U.P.


184. Headline Summary - No fresh declaration under 57G Excise Rules unless change in input or final product.

Judgment/Order - CENTRAL EXCISE REFERENCE No. 112 of 2000 Judgment/Order Dated - 19/10/2010 at Allahabad.

Title - Commissioner Central Excise, Kanpur Vs. M/S Standard Sul. Ltd. And Others


185. Headline Summary - cognizance taken by way of suo motu proceeding against "out Look" magazine fixing 12.11.2010 for publishing article denigrating C.J of Alld High Court


Title - Ravi Kiran Jain Senior Advocate Vs. Vinod Mehta Editor-In-Chief Outlook & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Naheed Ara Moonis,J.

186. Headline Summary - Subsequent involvement of accused on bail in similar cases amounting regular harassment of complainant a witness, warrants cancellation of his bail.


Title - Smt. Veena Verma Vs. State Of U.P. & Another

Coram - Hon'ble Virendra Singh,J.

187. Headline Summary - ...it appears that the word 'ADYATAN' means up-to-date and not merely as on date....


Title - Km. Seema Vs. State Of U.P. Thru. Sec. Lko. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ferdino Inacio Rebello,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Amreshwar Pratap Sahi,J.

188. Headline Summary - Justice must be seen to be done.


Title - Ganesh Polytex Ltd Thru' Director Sharad Sharma Vs. Union Of India & Others


189. Headline Summary - Corporater, Society of Union are not union - Article 285 not applicable.


Title - Banaras Hindu University, Varnaasi Thru' Its Registrar Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Principal Secy. Nagar Vikas & Ors.


190. Headline Summary - Money charged for advertisement hoarding on Board's land - not a tax.


Title - U.P. Advertiser Association & Another Vs. Union Of India & Others


191. Headline Summary - Section 12 of the Juvenile Justice(Care & Protection of Children) Act, 2000 overrides section 37 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act


Title - Praveen Kumar Maurya @ Praveen Maurya Vs. State Of U.P.


192. Headline Summary - Fake encounter/sanction for prosecution nor required/prayer for quashing refused.


Title - Jai Prakash Tiwari Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


193. Headline Summary - stridhan dispute-complaint at Ghaziabad without jurisdiction against all accused except husband-prosecution of all relatives but for A-1 quashed.


Title - Sujeet Kumar & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


194. Headline Summary - Quashing of murder case/evidence disclosed/Writ Petition dismissed.


Title - Mahadeo Prashad Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


195. Headline Summary - Authorised Controller/Prabandh Sanchalak/Administrator will exercise all powers conferred by the scheme of administration in addition powers ......


Title - Yashoda Raj Kumari Kunjil Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ferdino Inacio Rebello,Chief Justice and Hon'ble V.K. Shukla,J.

196. Headline Summary - ..withdrawal of equivalence would, therefore, not apply retrospectively and prior to that the certificates would not stand annulled automatically..


Title - Bhagwat Narain Chaturvedi & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


197. Headline Summary - prayer for quashing of case u/s 498-A etc-part of cause of action arose in district Varanasi-application dismissed.


Title - Ravi Shanker Pal & Ors Vs. State Of U.P.& Anr


198. Headline Summary - ... it is trite law that subsequent events relating to controversy can be taken judicial notice of and relief can be moulded to do complete justice...

Judgment/Order - SPECIAL APPEAL DEFECTIVE No. 777 of 2010 Judgment/Order Dated - 26/8/2010 at Allahabad.

Title - The Basic Shiksha Adhikari, Etah & Others Vs. Ram Dularey Sharma & Others


199. Headline Summary - Benefit of Scheme dated 3.11.1999 from date of installation/ upgradation.


Title - M/S Nandan Talkies Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. Tax & Institutional Finance & Anr


200. Headline Summary - No opportunity is required to be given if selection is made on the basis of a forged marksheet


Title - Harendra Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


201. Headline Summary - Order of acquittal reasonable - no interference by appellate court.


Title - Om Nath Vs. State Of U.P.


202. Headline Summary - Therefore, if at all law of agency applies it would be between sender and post office ...post office is bound .. to deliver it to the addressee...


Title - Neena Chaturvedi Vs. Public Service Commission

Coram - Hon'ble Ferdino Inacio Rebello,Chief Justice , Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J. and Hon'ble Sanjay Misra,J.

203. Headline Summary - Directors are not liable for the offence committed by the company merely on the ground that they are directors.


Title - Yogendra Singh Vs. Ranbir Sharma & Another


204. Headline Summary - Witness protection programme is integral part of criminal justice reforms.


Title - Rishipal Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Surendra Singh,J.

205. Headline Summary - Crl.Appeal u/s 302 IPC/FIR ante-timed/witnesses unreliable/recovery not proved/appeal allowed/accused acquitted.


Title - Dharmendra Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Rajesh Chandra,J.

206. Headline Summary - Crl.Appl u/s 307 IPC/right of private defence claimed/Section 34 not applicable/charged defective/witnesses reliable/appeal partly allowed/


Title - Mulla (Kalu) (Tahir) & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


207. Headline Summary - Prosecution agency must be toned up.


Title - Vinay Kumar Vs. State Of U.P.


208. Headline Summary - Diverting GPF funds for paying salaries of illegally appointed Ballia teaching, nonteaching staff unwarranted. Court orders no excuse. FIR not quashed


Title - Vinayendra Nath Upadhyay And Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Ors.


209. Headline Summary - ...once the tenure has come to an end, there is no legal right vested to claim continuance ...


Title - Smt. Geeta Devi Vs. Uma Shanker Yadav And Others


210. Headline Summary - Modern scientific methods should be used by investigators.


Title - Kanhaiya Vs. State Of U.P.


211. Headline Summary - 482 Cr.P.C. application-307/392/504/506 I.P.C.-parties closely related-compromised the case-application allowed-proceeding quashed.


Title - Jitendra Pal @ Pappu And Others Vs. State Of U.P.And Another


212. Headline Summary - Intermediate Examination Certificate cannot be issued on the basis of a forged document


Title - Navneet Kumar Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secry. Madhamik Shiksha Parishad & Ors.


213. Headline Summary - Criminal Appeal u/s 302/sudden occurrence/absence of intention/deceased started quarrel/conviction altered under 304(II)/appeal partly allowed.


Title - Ram Pyare Uraon & Others Vs. State


214. Headline Summary - Criminal Appeal/302 IPC/charge defective/313 no circumstance put/Appeal allowed/conviction set aside.


Title - Raees Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Virendra Singh,J.

215. Headline Summary - 482-Recall Application-Applicants committed fraud and material concealment-Recall Application dismissed.


Title - Suresh Chandra Mishra & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


216. Headline Summary - Members of Committee of Management cannot be removed by vote of no confidence in the absence of such provision in the Bye-Laws


Title - C/M, Dharma S.S. Inter College & Sanskrit Pathsala & Ors. Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


217. Headline Summary - Criminal Appeal/Conviction under 393 IPC/fact witnesses unreliable/accused arrest doubtful/appeal allowed/conviction set aside.


Title - Ravindra Vs. State Of U.P.


218. Headline Summary - Order u/s 319 CrPC should be passed only when evidence is of such quality as to lead conviction.Mere non-examination of witness does'nt vitiate order.

Judgment/Order - U/S 482/378/407 No. 2532 of 2010 Judgment/Order Dated - 28/5/2010 at Lucknow.

Title - Rajol And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


219. Headline Summary - Notwithstanding, Aganwadi workers are not holders of civil posts they are entitle to invoke writ jurisdiction against termination of their services.


Title - Smt. Sheela Devi & Another Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Principal Secy. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Sheo Kumar Singh,J. , Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J. and Hon'ble Ashok Kumar Roopanwal,J.

220. Headline Summary - Conviction on extra judicial confession corroborated by circumstances - permissible.


Title - Shafiq Vs. State Of U.P.


221. Headline Summary - Incident in night - If accused are well known then identification can not be questioned.


Title - Randhey & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


222. Headline Summary - Period of lease cannot be extended by the Court direction to the State Government to realise benefit under the interim order.


Title - Smt. Ram Lali Mishra Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. Ministry Of Geology & Mining & Ors


223. Headline Summary - Order passed by the Vice-Chancellor for cancellation of the Post Graduate Medical Entrance Examination for Institutional seats set aside.


Title - Dr. Anurag Kumar Tiwari & Ors. Vs. Union Of India Thru. Secr. Ministryof H.R.D. & Ors.


224. Headline Summary - Circular of State Government for excluding negative marking for SC/ST candidates only for admission to P.G. Medical Courses set aside


Title - Hemant Krishna Maurya And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


225. Headline Summary - Criminal Appeal/charge of gang rape by 4 accused/medical consistent with victim's testimony/conviction confirmed/Appeal dismissed.


Title - Vipin & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


226. Headline Summary - Fine U/s 302 IPC is not mandatory.


Title - Santosh Kumar Baranwal Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble B.N. Shukla,J.

227. Headline Summary - Writ for quashing of FIR/marriage not sanctified by muslim law/FIR cannot be quashed/writ dismissed.


Title - Dilbar Habib Siddiqui Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


228. Headline Summary - Direction to the Dental College to refund of excess fees and for issuance of Certificates given


Title - Rama Edeucational Society And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


229. Headline Summary - Criminal Appeal/ 10 years sentence/appellant already undergone 9 and a half year/ conviction altered to sentence undergone/ appeal partly allowed.


Title - Muneshwar @ Arvind Vs. State Of U.P.


230. Headline Summary - No explanation adds a link in cases of circumstantial evidence.


Title - Ram Samujh Yadav Vs. State Of U.P.


231. Headline Summary - Wrong admission cancelled as no sympathy is to be shown and direction for admission of petitioner given.


Title - Km. Anjuman Upadhyay Vs. Principal, District Insti. Of Educ. & Training & Ors.


232. Headline Summary - Term of Committee of Management will start when charge is given in view of such a Clause in the Scheme of Administration


Title - Dr. Mahendra Pratap Singh And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


233. Headline Summary - Dying declaration before police is admissible u/s 162 (2) CrPC.


Title - Laxmi And Others Vs. State Of U.P.


234. Headline Summary - conviction u/s 302 I.P.C.-circumstantial evidence recovery of body and cycle of deceased from the appellant-witnesses reliable-appeal dismissed


Title - Babu Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Vinod Prasad,J. and Hon'ble Vedpal,J.

235. Headline Summary - Statements under section 161 CrPC not supplied - Trial not vitiated unless there is failure of justice.


Title - Vishal Parmanand & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


236. Headline Summary - After rejecting final report, cognizance can not be taken on the basis of affidavits etc. filed in support of protest petition.


Title - Vimlesh Vs. State Of U.P. And Another

Coram - Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

237. Headline Summary - Currency notes of same number and in one series foundfrom different accused in Mela suggest trafficking punishable for life us 489-B IPC. Bail refused


Title - Raju @ Riyazuddin Vs. State Of U.P.


238. Headline Summary - Murder of wife-Presence of husband established-D/D truthful-conviction confirmed.


Title - Sukhram Vs. State


239. Headline Summary - HC recommends mediation in cases U/S 498-A IPC and 3/4 DP Act and allied offences and otherthan exceptional cases restrains immediate arrests on FIR


Title - Sanjeev Kumar & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


240. Headline Summary - Case of circumstantial evidence - all circumstances must be proved.


Title - Sanjay Vs. State Of U.P.


241. Headline Summary - Medical evidence not inconsistent, if can be explained.


Title - Jwala Prasad Vs. State


242. Headline Summary - Trial Judge issuing 181 IPC prosecution notice, then discharging threatened hostile witness, cancelling bail of accused appreciated.Bail rejected byHC


Title - Pintoo & Others Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J.

243. Headline Summary - Manoj Nigam Advocate Kanpur Nagar convicted and sentenced to one month SI a fine of Rs. 20,000/- but sentence shall remain suspended for two years.


Title - In Re: Sri. Ravindra Kumar-Ii Civil Judge(S.D.) Ksnpur Nagar Vs. Manoj Nigam(Advocate)


244. Headline Summary - Uma Shanker Sharma Advocate Budaun convicted under contempt of court court and sentenced to one month SI and fine of Rs. 20,000/-


Title - In Re : Sri M.K. Singh, A.D.J. Budaun Vs. Sri Uma Shankar Sharma, Advocate


245. Headline Summary - Nahar Singh Yadav and Shailendra Sharma convicted and each of them sentenced to undergo R.I. for six months and pay fine of Rs. 20,000/


Title - In Re: Vs. Shailendra Sharma, Nahar Singh Yadav Advocates Civil-Court


246. Headline Summary - Sec.376 IPC-Rape-victim's evidence truthful- serologist report supported case-Appeal dismissed.


Title - Shami Ullah Vs. State Of U.P.


247. Headline Summary - Brij Kishore Misra ADvocate Farukhabad convicted and sentenced to 3 months S>i fine Rs. 20,000/- for contempt


Title - In Re: Vs. Brij Kishore Advocate

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Naheed Ara Moonis,J.

248. Headline Summary - Contempt - Information sent by subordinate court is reference.


Title - In Re: C.J.M. Fatehpur Thru. D.J. Fatehpur Vs. Sri Prakash Singh Advocate

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Shri Kant Tripathi,J.

249. Headline Summary - Bhagwati Sharma Advocate civil court Kushinagar convicted for contempt. His conduct would be watched.


Title - In Re: (Sri. S.P.Sharma C.J.M. Kushinagar) Vs. Bhagwati Sharma Advocate Kushinagar


250. Headline Summary - Rajvir Singh Tyagi Advocate Civil courts Meerut convicted and sentendced to three months S.I and fine of Rs. 20,000/- for contempt


Title - In Re: Vs. Rajveer Singh Advocate


251. Headline Summary - Harish Babu Gupta Advocate Chandausi Moradabad convicted and sentenced to one month imprisonment and fine of Rs. 20,000/- for contempt


Title - In Re: (Sri. R.P.Saroj [S.D.] A.C.J.M. Moradabad) Vs. Sri Harish Babu Gupta Advocate


252. Headline Summary - Jasvir Singh Pawar Advocate Muzaffarnagar convicted and sentenced to undergo SI for 3 molnths and fine of Rs. 20,000/- for contempt


Title - Mrs. Manju Lata Consolidation Officer Vs. Jasbir Singh Pawar Advocate


253. Headline Summary - Digvijai Singh Pal Advocate Hamipur convicted under contempt of court Act D.J to monitor conduct


Title - In Re : Vs. Digvijai Singh Pal


254. Headline Summary - State cannot declare a Tribe as S.T. Parliament may include/exclude a Tribe as ST in Presidential Order. State can forward its recommendation to Parl


Title - State Of U.P. & Others Vs. Shiv Kumar Bhardwaj

Coram - Hon'ble Chandramauli Kumar Prasad,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Arun Tandon,J.

255. Headline Summary - Signature of the Accused on the recovery memo - not required.


Title - Krishan Kumar @ Pappu Vs. State Of U.P.


256. Headline Summary - Gangsters Act-Attachment/Release of property under Section 17-Appeal under Section 18 maintainable


Title - Kailash Sahkari Awas Samiti Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


257. Headline Summary - As the property is a public property, every citizen has the right to bid for its settlement.


Title - Chatthu Vs. State Of U.P. Through Chief Secretary And Others


258. Headline Summary - High Court took serious note of fake drugs.


Title - Brahmaji Vs. State Of U.P.& Others


259. Headline Summary - State Govt. also comes within the definition "executing agency"; nothing prevents the State Govt. to issue auction notice for collection of fee.


Title - Vinay Kumar Pandey Vs. Union Of India & Others


260. Headline Summary - 376 IPC/testimony of prosecurtix believable against one appellant/appeal partly allowed.


Title - Ashok Kumar & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


261. Headline Summary - A member of reserved cat. can claim appointment on merit against unreserved post, but not converse................


Title - Shom Raj Shukla Vs. Public Service Commission Through Chairman And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Chandramauli Kumar Prasad,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.

262. Headline Summary - True principle of no work no pay is not of universal application but equally true payment of arrears of salary not to be granted as a matter of course


Title - Syed Vakil Ahmad Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Chandramauli Kumar Prasad,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.

263. Headline Summary - General transfer policy not applicable to police department. Apex Court Guidelines in Prakash Singh's case followed in UP with creation of PEBs.


Title - Rishi Pal Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


264. Headline Summary - Parity can not be the sole ground for bail. Merit also has to be seen.


Title - Amarnath Yadav Vs. State Of U.P.


265. Headline Summary - Investigation of the offence under SC/ST Act by unauthorized police officer is illegal and invalid. Charge under SC/ST Act quashed.


Title - Jwahir Sharma & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


266. Headline Summary - On granting bail by one bench, another bench is not under obligation to grant bail to similarly placed co-accused on the ground of parity.


Title - Nahar Singh Vs. State Of U.P.


267. Headline Summary - Bail 302 IPC-not named in the FIR-eyewitness knew applicant-named after three days-not assaulted deceased-bail granted.


Title - Arvind @ Dabaloo Vs. State Of U.P.


268. Headline Summary - Bail cancellation-bail granted more than 1-1/2 years ago-bail order not perverse or illegal-cancellation application dismissed-condition imposed


Title - Prabhat Ranjan Shukla Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


269. Headline Summary - Moninder Singh Pandher appellant acquitted. Death sentence of Surendra Koli appellant confirmed.


Title - Surendra Koli & Another Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Kashi Nath Pandey,J.

270. Headline Summary - 156 (3) Cr.P.C.-Rape allegation against father-in-law-no reason not to direct registration of FIR-order quashed-matter remanded


Title - Smt. Shabnam Vs. State Of U.P.


271. Headline Summary - Bail pending trial-accused a Minister and an influential person-chances of tampering and fair trial a remote possibility-bail prayer rejected


Title - Jamuna Nishad Vs. State Of U.P.


272. Headline Summary - Permission under section 155 (2) Cr.P.C. can be granted by the magistrate on the application of complainant or other aggrieved person also.


Title - Ram Narayan & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


273. Headline Summary - The magistrate is not bound to grant remand under section 167 Cr.P.C. in those sections only for which prayer has been made in remand application.


Title - Vakeel Ahmad Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


274. Headline Summary - Crl. Appeal-conviction U/S 302/34 I.P.C.-prosecution witnesses reliable and their evidence is unblemished-motive also proved-appeal dismissed


Title - Ram Veer & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


275. Headline Summary - conviction under Sections 302/34 and 323/34 I.P.C.-common intention not established-each accused liable for individual act-appeal partly allowed.


Title - Surya Kant And Others Vs. State Of U.P.


276. Headline Summary - Earlier bail allowed, unless canceled, moving fresh bail & it's rejection is unwarranted as absconding accused in custody may move u/s 446 A CrPC


Title - Mahendra Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Virendra Singh,J.

277. Headline Summary - Murder-single blow-intention to murder absent-partly allowed-convicted u/s 304 part 1-sentence of 7 years R.I. implanted


Title - Ram Ratan Vs. State Of U.P.


278. Headline Summary - Criminal Appeal-conviction u/s 302/34 IPC-presence of appellant doubtful-false implication probable -appeal allowed-conviction set aside.


Title - Veer Singh Vs. State Of U.P. ?


279. Headline Summary - Criminal Appeal U/S 302 I.P.C. day light murder - parents & brother of the deceased gave convincing evidence appeal dismissed - sentence confirmed.


Title - Daya Shankar Vs. State Of U.P.


280. Headline Summary - Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.) is not controlled by section 320 Cr.P.C.


Title - Prem Shankar Pandey & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


281. Headline Summary - Role of exhortation, bail granted, data on prisioners in jail compared with present capacity, appeals and writs pending given


Title - Gorakh Pandey & Others Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Dasu Ram Azad,J.

282. Headline Summary - A State action which is unreasonable and arbitrary, strikes at the very root of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.


Title - State Of U.P. Thru' Principal Secy Home Deptt And Others Vs. Anand Kumar Mishra & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Chandramauli Kumar Prasad,Chief Justice and Hon'ble Amreshwar Pratap Sahi,J.

283. Headline Summary - 302 IPC-wife murdered by husband-witnesses are reliable-no reasons for false implication-conviction upheld


Title - Salim Vs. State Of U.P.


284. Headline Summary - petitioner's representation against transfer shall be decided by the authority strictly in accordance with law within stipulated period.


Title - Naval Kishore Sharma Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Bala Krishna Narayana,J.

285. Headline Summary - order passed without affording any opportunity of hearing and assigning any reason got stayed by the High Court till further orders.


Title - Durga Prasad Srivastava Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Bala Krishna Narayana,J.

286. Headline Summary - 304-B-Sentence of life imprisionment-Cause of death not known-Sentence reduced to 10 years R.I. and fine of Rs. 2,00,000/-


Title - Pankaj Rai Vs. State Of U.P.


287. Headline Summary - Conviction under Section 302 IPC-FIR anti-timed-informant presence doubtful-investigation tainted-conviction set aside


Title - Sahim Vs. State Of U.P.


288. Headline Summary - Adult woman entitle to live independely and not to be detained in Nari Niketan because matter communally sensitive or parents unwilling to take her


Title - Kumari Ajra Khan Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Dasu Ram Azad,J.

289. Headline Summary - Insurance Company not liable to pay if proposer does not intimate about change in condition of health before issuance of FPR


Title - Abhimanyu Chaubey Vs. Insurance Ombudsman U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J. and Hon'ble Shashi Kant Gupta,J.

290. Headline Summary - Person entitled to remuneration according to status or statutory or presdribed minimum.


Title - State Bank Of India & Others Vs. Chandra Deo


291. Headline Summary - Small or commercial quantity of Narcotic Drug is to be determined on the basis of actual contents of such drug in the recovered article.


Title - Prem Shanker Alias Nanhey Pahelwan Vs. State Of U.P.


292. Headline Summary - condition to deposit the amount of earlier executed personal bond can not be imposed at the time of granting fresh bail to the accused.


Title - Pappu Vs. State Of U.P.


293. Headline Summary - Possession of counterfeit currency notes without furnishing any explanation by the accused is non-bailable offence punishable under section 489-B IPC.


Title - Shyam Lal Vs. State Of U.P.


294. Headline Summary - Committing suicide by a women as a consequence of rape constitutes the offence of abatement to suicide.


Title - Anil Vs. State Of U.P.


295. Headline Summary - Possession of counterfeit currency notes without furnishing any explanation by the accused is non-bailable offence punishable under section 489-B IPC.


Title - Ram Niwas Vs. State Of U.P.


296. Headline Summary - Second bail application on the same grounds is not maintainable.


Title - Khursheed And Another Vs. State Of U.P.


297. Headline Summary - Condition to deposit the amount of previously executed personal bond can not be imposed at the time of granting fresh bail.


Title - Radhey Vs. State Of U.P.


298. Headline Summary - Possession of counterfeit currency notes - Bail Rejected - Parity can not be the sole ground for granting bail.


Title - Shahnawaz @ Shanu Vs. State Of U.P.


299. Headline Summary - criminal appeal no.1617 of 1986


Title - Jai Ram And Others Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Poonam Srivastava,J.

300. Headline Summary - Revision against summoning order is legally maintainable and is not barred under sub section (2) of section 397 Cr.P.C.


Title - Jag Narain & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


301. Headline Summary - Long incarceration in jail during trial is not per-se illegal and would not be violative of article 21 of the Constitution .


Title - Uma Charan Awasthi Vs. State Of U.P.


302. Headline Summary - Notice to the prospective accused is not required to be issued prior to passing the order under section 319 Cr.P.C.


Title - B. Shukla Vs. State


303. Headline Summary - Use of the word 'ordinary' - condition not mandatory.


Title - Arjun Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Anil Kumar,J.

304. Headline Summary - JSCC rejected the objection of third party in execution - first appeal not maintainable.


Title - Wahid Vs. Mohd. Anwar

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J.

305. Headline Summary - Section 3(2)(v) SC/ST Act will not be attracted in those cases where the offence committed under IPC is punishable less than ten years' imprisonment.


Title - Munni Devi Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Shiv Charan (Sharma),J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

306. Headline Summary - Mentioning the names of accused and witensses is not the requirement of law. In case of direct evidence, absence of motive looses significance.


Title - Ganesh Yadav & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


307. Headline Summary - Magistrates to grant interim bail; circumstances when they should not.


Title - Pradeep Tyagi Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Ravindra Nath Misra,J.

308. Headline Summary - An aggressor has no right of private defence. Active participation by causing injuries is not essential to attract section 149 IPC.


Title - Munaf And Ors. Vs. State Of U.P.


309. Headline Summary - In appropriate cases, interim bail may be granted by subordinate courts pending disposal of bail applications.


Title - Rajesh Mishra @ Pappu Vs. State Of U.P.


310. Headline Summary - Varun Gandhi's plea for quashing F.I.R dismissed


Title - Varun Gandhi Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Subhash Chandra Nigam,J.

311. Headline Summary - Criminal Revision-Revisional Court cannot reappreciate evidence


Title - Chotey Lal & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Raghunath Kishore Rastogi,J.

312. Headline Summary - On the basis of vicarious liability, bail can not be rejected. Role of individual accused has to be considered at the stage of bail.


Title - Surendra Singh Vs. State Of U.P.


313. Headline Summary - Interest is payable even if possession is taken prior to notification u/s 4 of the Land Acquisition Act.


Title - State Of U.P. Vs. Bechoo Ram


314. Headline Summary - Appointment not made in accordance with Removal of Difficulties Order void. Irrespective of continuance for a long period.


Title - Ramjee Dwivedi Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


315. Headline Summary - Election of Shambhu Chaudhary from U.P. Legislative Assembly reserved seat declared void as he does not belong to Scheduled Caste.


Title - Pooran Masi Dehati Vs. Shambhu Chaudhary & Others


316. Headline Summary - Motive and suspicion howsoever strong can not be made the basis of conviction without any legal evidence.


Title - Bhura Vs. State Of U.P.


317. Headline Summary - Existence of an arbitration agreement is a sine quo non for invoking the jurisdiction of the court u/s 9 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act 1996


Title - Raj Kumar Vs. Union Of India & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Sheo Kumar Singh,J. and Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.

318. Headline Summary - Fine for the offence punishable under section 304-B I.P.C. can not be imposed.


Title - Dinesh Vs. State Of U.P.


319. Headline Summary - Sentence of fine less than Rupees fifteen thousand can not be imposed for the offence under section 3 of Dowry Prohibition Act.


Title - Omwati & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


320. Headline Summary - Order of investigation passed under section 156(3) CrPC can not be challenged in Revision or proceeding under section 482 CrPc by propsective accused.


Title - Ram Dhani Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


321. Headline Summary - In case of direct evidence, absence or weakness of motive looses significance


Title - Kallu Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Shiv Shanker,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

322. Headline Summary - separate conviction and sentence under section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act simplicitor is illegal.


Title - Sri Narain Trivedi & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


323. Headline Summary - Sentence for the conspiracy of offence would be same as provided for the offence


Title - Neeraj Vs. State Of U.P.


324. Headline Summary - Prospective accused can not challenge the order directing investigation of the case after registration of the FIR.


Title - Abdul Aziz And Others Vs. State Of U.P.And Another


325. Headline Summary - Absence or weakness of motive is not fatal, if the prosecution evidence is worthy of reliance


Title - Ram Chandra Gupta Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Barkat Ali Zaidi,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

326. Headline Summary - Magistrate having no jurisdiction to take cognizance of the offence can not pass the order for investigation under section 156(3) Cr.P.C.


Title - Rajjan Prasad Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


327. Headline Summary - The Magistrate can pass order for further investigation on the final report.


Title - Gopi Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


328. Headline Summary - Carrying the cow, bull or bullock within the State for slaughtering is no offence under Cow Slaughter Act.


Title - Kailash Yadav And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


329. Headline Summary - C.B.I enquiry ordered in Etawah firing incident at ccs PG college Haivara Safai.SSP ASP ordered to be transferred forthwith


Title - Ram Gopal Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Raj Mani Chauhan,J.

330. Headline Summary - Principles for determining enhancement of monthly rent under Section 21(8) of Rent Act discussed.


Title - Smt. Padma Tandon Vs. Viith A.D.J., Alld. & Others


331. Headline Summary - Transporting and carrying the cow or bullocks for slaughtering within the State is no offence.


Title - Asfaq Ahmad And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


332. Headline Summary - Second or subsequent bail application can be considered on new ground or change of law.


Title - Dharmpal & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


333. Headline Summary - Period of detention in jail can not be the sole ground for bail.


Title - Anees Vs. State Of U.P.


334. Headline Summary - Special Judge under Prevention of Corruption Act can pass order for registration of FIR on the application under section 156(3) Cr.P.C.


Title - Mahipal Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


335. Headline Summary - A divorced Muslim woman can not claim maintenance from her former husband under Section 125 Cr.P.C.


Title - Shahid Jamal Ansari Vs. State Of U.P.& Another


336. Headline Summary - More that one FIR can be registered against the same incident.


Title - Parvez Parwaz Vs. State Of U.P.


337. Headline Summary - Cricle rate cannot form basis for market rate under L. A. Act. Statutory benefits to be given even if claimant has not filed Appeal/Cross-Objection.


Title - Ram Adhar Vs. State Of U.P.


338. Headline Summary - If found reliable, conviction can be based on dying declaration alone without consideration.


Title - Arjun Vs. State Of U.P.


339. Headline Summary - Second bail can be considered on fresh ground only.


Title - Jaivir & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


340. Headline Summary - acquittal of coaccused in separate trial cannot be made basis for quashing trial of other accused persons in case for offences under same transaction.


Title - Km. Rinki Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


341. Headline Summary - Order dismissing Crl. Revision for default or non-prosecution as well the order deciding the revision on merit in absence of any party can be recalled


Title - Mithaee Lal Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


342. Headline Summary - Report 173 (2) by IO mere opinion and Magistrate no bound by opinion. He has to apply mind to facts Hearing must to informant if FR to be accepted.


Title - Prakash Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


343. Headline Summary - E. P. against rejection of nomination of a candidate dismissed because defect of wrong electoral roll number is not of substantial character


Title - Saleem Masood Vs. Rasheed Masood


344. Headline Summary - Magistrate is not bound to treat the protest petition as complaint in each and every case.


Title - Nawab Saiyyed Zafar Hussain Vs. State Of U.P.


345. Headline Summary - Participation of all the accused in criminal act by doing some overt act is not necessary to attract Section 34 of Indian Penal Code.


Title - Ram Naresh Vs. State Of U.P

Coram - Hon'ble Sushil Harkauli,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

346. Headline Summary - police is competent to investigate subsidiary non cognizable offences with cognizable offences


Title - Azad @ Azad Khan Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble S.N.H. Zaidi,J.

347. Headline Summary - Notice under section 111 Cr.P.C. without full substance of police report is invalid.


Title - Baleshwar And Others Vs. State Of U.P.


348. Headline Summary - Shopowner's cross FIR refused. Civil Court's Bar resolved to boycott accused. H.C. directs registration of FIR


Title - Amit Chaurasiya Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Ravindra Nath Misra,J.

349. Headline Summary - Elector has sufficient interest to oppose WP challenging disqualification of MP.


Title - Mohammad Shahid Akhlaq Vs. Union Of India & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Shashi Kant Gupta,J.

350. Headline Summary - Testimony of witnesses can not be brushed asied on the ground of relation with the deceased/ victim.


Title - Bhagwan Das & Another Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Sushil Harkauli,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

351. Headline Summary - Order of registration of FIR and its investigation by the police is not essential on each and every application uunder section 156(3) Cr.P.C.


Title - Vishwanath @ Bande Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


352. Headline Summary - Goonda Act-no interference at the stage of issue of show cause notice-see Kabir Chawla v. State of U.P. 1994 SCC (Crl.) 577


Title - Ajmeruddin & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Imtiyaz Murtaza,J. and Hon'ble Vikram Nath,J.

353. Headline Summary - There is no parity in rejection of bail.


Title - Nawal Vs. State Of U.P.


354. Headline Summary - "Even after acquittal of co-accused, trial of other similarly placed accused will not be barred".


Title - Manoj Vs. State Of U.P.


355. Headline Summary - "If matrimonial dispute has been settled by the parties, High Court can quash the proceedings of criminal cases."


Title - Smt. Soniya & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


356. Headline Summary - "Bail to the juvenile cannot be refused on the ground of gravity of the offence"


Title - Prem Chandra @ Monu Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


357. Headline Summary - Crl. Trial Prosecution produced document favouring accused prayer for further cross of PWs rejected.


Title - Ramkesh Sharma Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


358. Headline Summary - Criminal Trial, 3 Charge Sheets on 3 FIRs of 3 informants in respect of one incident in continuation-all cases consolidated.


Title - Prabhat Kumar & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


359. Headline Summary - Criminal Trial: P.W. cross- examined, further cross examination not permissible, specified questions may be asked with post permission.


Title - Jafar Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


360. Headline Summary - interlocutory non AFR

Judgment/Order - MISC. SINGLE No. 2701 of 2008 Judgment/Order Dated - 2/6/2008 at Lucknow.

Title - Nagar Nigam Slej Farm Gomtinagar Lko.Through Its Municipal Vs. D.M.Lko.And 3 Ors.

Coram - Hon'ble Abhinava Upadhya,J.

361. Headline Summary - Section 406 IPC, Entrustment of Property necessary, in its absence husband's sister & mother discharged.


Title - Smt. Prakash Kaur And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


362. Headline Summary - Seniority depends upon the statutory rules.


Title - Virendra Kumar Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Shashi Kant Gupta,J.

363. Headline Summary - Petitioners have been transferred from C.P. to A.P in breach of Reg. 525. Said order quashed as per judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in Jasveer Singh'

Judgment/Order - SERVICE SINGLE No. 8449 of 2007 Judgment/Order Dated - 8/5/2008 at Lucknow.

Title - C.P. No. 1205 Santosh Singh & 13 Ors. Vs. State Of U.P. Thru Prin. Secy. Home & 4 Ors.

Coram - Hon'ble V.K. Shukla,J.

364. Headline Summary - Fine cannot be imposed for the offence punishable under Section 304-B I.P.C.


Title - Mohd. Shafi Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble S.S. Kulshrestha,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

365. Headline Summary - Criminal revision against the order of registration of F.I.R. and investigation is not maintainable.


Title - Gulam Mustafa @ Jabbar Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


366. Headline Summary - Section 164 Cr. P.C. Magistrate's examination not necessary to prove statements of witness recorded by him


Title - Jeeraj @ Vijai & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


367. Headline Summary - Circumstantial evidence not owrthy of credence-Appeals allowed-Death sentence set aside-Accused appellants acquitted.


Title - Adil And Another Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

368. Headline Summary - FIR for the offence punishable under section 182 IPC cannot be directed to be lodged against the informant at the time of passing the judgement.


Title - Lekhraj Vs. State Of U.P.


369. Headline Summary - Person in custody, no bail application pending - when preventive detention possible.


Title - Sandeep Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Ran Vijai Singh,J.

370. Headline Summary - Clubs do not require license from the Cantonment Board to serve liquor.


Title - Prabhu Narayan Union Club, Varanasi & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


371. Headline Summary - No fetter on Magistrate taking cognizance against non-chargesheeted accused prior S. 319 CrPC-Dharam Pal's Case (SC) preferred to Ranjit's Case (SC)


Title - Arshad & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


372. Headline Summary - Sec. 406 IPC- No offence made out without entrustment of property


Title - Nagendra Kumar And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


373. Headline Summary - Order passed under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. for registration of F.I.R. and investigation can not be challenged in Revision by prospective accused.


Title - Suryakant Dubey & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


374. Headline Summary - U.:P. Control of Goondas Act- Notice u/s 3 can be challenged in writ only when it is illegal.


Title - Bachcharaj Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Syed Rafat Alam,J. and Hon'ble Raghunath Kishore Rastogi,J.

375. Headline Summary - Crl.trial-witness cross examined-further cross to be limited to specified questions only.

Judgment/Order - CRIMINAL REVISION DEFECTIVE No. 393 of 2007 Judgment/Order Dated - 18/2/2008 at Allahabad.

Title - Faisal & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


376. Headline Summary - Crl.trial-witness cross examined,further cross can be permitted on specified questions only.


Title - Khalid Ahmad Khan Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


377. Headline Summary - S.482 Cr.P.C.-application after submission of C.S. not maintainable for quashing of F.I.R.


Title - Harpal Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


378. Headline Summary - Section 125(1)(c) Cr.P.C. - refusing maintenance to unmarried major daughter - Notices issued to Govts. why this clause should remain on the statute.


Title - Smt. Raj Kumari Awasthi & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


379. Headline Summary - Under Juvenile Justice Act order refusing bail to juvenile by Board and S.J. is not proper.


Title - Lavi Yadav @ Love Yadav Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


380. Headline Summary - Candidate appearing in selection is estopped from challenging it.


Title - Dr. Dinesh Kumar Kesarwani Vs. Union Of India & Others


381. Headline Summary - Same accused involved in two different incidents of same date-joint ttrial refused.


Title - Khaliq Ahmad & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


382. Headline Summary - Cognizable offence-recovery also invalid-Mag.'s order rejecting application set aside.


Title - Prabhash Chatuvedi Vs. State Of U.P.


383. Headline Summary - No disciplinary proceeding after superannuation unless there is provision.


Title - Rajya Krishi Utpadan Mandi Parishad U.P. And Another Vs. Public Service Tribunal,U.P. Lucknow And Others


384. Headline Summary - Suspension of Conviction only in very exceptional circumstances, which need to be indicated. Navjot Singh Sidhu,s case distinguished


Title - Daya Shankar Rai & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


385. Headline Summary - In the absence of any evidence, conviction cannot be based merely on the admissions/confession of accused made in the examination u/s 313 Cr.P.C.


Title - Balmant Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Amar Saran,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

386. Headline Summary - S.302 IPC prosecution case that deadbody was carried to another place by accused-due to absence of blood on spot accused acquitted.


Title - Brijveer And Ors. Vs. State Of U.P.

Coram - Hon'ble Kawaljeet Singh Rakhra,J. and Hon'ble Raghunath Kishore Rastogi,J.

387. Headline Summary - S.302 IPC-cased based on circumstantial evidence failed to prove guilt beyond doubt-accused acquitted.


Title - Dayashankar Vs. State Of U.P


388. Headline Summary - Unregistered Agreement to sell can not be specifically enforced


Title - Vijay Kumar Sharma Vs. Devesh Behari Saxena

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Vijay Kumar Verma,J.

389. Headline Summary - S.362 Cr.P.C.-Mag. could not review earlier order passed by his predecessor.


Title - Ramesh Vs. State Of U.P.


390. Headline Summary - Crl trial - Punishment in departmental proceedings no bar to Crl. prosecution


Title - Rajesh Kumar Srivastava Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


391. Headline Summary - S. 482 Cr.P.C.- No allegation in complaint that accused had knowledge or reason to believe property as stolen- proceedings quashed


Title - Babloo And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


392. Headline Summary - S.302 IPC circumstantial evidence of last seen-extra judl.confession-accused acquitted.


Title - Nawal Singh Vs. State Of U.P.


393. Headline Summary - S.396 IPC-accused not named in FIR, identification evidence not good-conviction set aside.


Title - Rajbir Vs. State Of U.P.


394. Headline Summary - S.376 IPC-accused ravished girl a/a 8 years-RI 10 years justified.


Title - Arvind Vs. State Of U.P.


395. Headline Summary - t

Judgment/Order - SPECIAL APPEAL No. 346 of 2004 Judgment/Order Dated - 26/10/2007 at Lucknow.

Title - Shashi Sharma Vs. State Of U.P.Through Secy Basic Educaiton

Coram - Hon'ble Pradeep Kant,J. and Hon'ble Shri Narayan Shukla,J.

396. Headline Summary - Section 363 IPC- Girl major as per High School Certificate -no need to medical examtion to ascertain her age


Title - Khaderu Ram Yadav Vs. State Of U.P.


397. Headline Summary - Parties compromise in case u/s 419, 420,467, 468 and 506 I.P.C.-application u/s 482 Cr.P.C. allowed.


Title - Jiut Bandhan Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Raghunath Kishore Rastogi,J.

398. Headline Summary - No difference between B.Ed. (face to face) and B.Ed. (Distant Mode)


Title - Gyanendra Kumar Sharma & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Hemant Laxman Gokhale,J. and Hon'ble Anjani Kumar,J.

399. Headline Summary - In theft case owner is entitled to custody of ornaments during the pendency of the case


Title - Vijay Kumar Vs. State Of U.P.


400. Headline Summary - S.138 N.I.A.- Notice given and complaint filed after expiry of limitation period- complaint quashed.


Title - Smt. Sunita Agrawal Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


401. Headline Summary - Property of Churches of India vest for purposes of Church of England and is subject to the Rules


Title - State Of U.P. & Others Vs. Indian Christian Trusties


402. Headline Summary - Cr.P.C.- Order for deposit of passport and Visa to ensure attendance of accused is not coercive process


Title - Jarrar Hussain And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


403. Headline Summary - Plea of juvenileship not to be rejected due to delay


Title - Kuldeep Kumar And Others Vs. State Of U.P.


404. Headline Summary - Order summoning a person as accused u/s 319 Cr.P.C. to be passed after cross examinaiton


Title - Havendra Singh @ Harvendra Kumar Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


405. Headline Summary - S.207 Cr.P.C.-prosecution not bound to give copies of evidence not relied upon by it.


Title - Ramadhin & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


406. Headline Summary - Protection of 197Cr.P.C. not available to government servant in case of beating in personal capacity.


Title - Munesh Prasad Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


407. Headline Summary - Summoning of acused u/s 319 Cr.P.C. - guideline explained


Title - Amar Singh & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


408. Headline Summary - Subsequent unverfied compromise chaing terms unenforceable.


Title - Sarvesh Kumar Shukla Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


409. Headline Summary - NIA-Officers of Compqny or firm liable to make payment tobe impleaded as accused and not others.


Title - Mohd. Daud And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


410. Headline Summary - Proceedings u/s 107/116 Cr.P.C. must be concluded within six months from the date of institution


Title - Atul Nigam Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


411. Headline Summary - Gratuity in Uttar Pradesh cannot be forfeited under Regulation 351-A of the Civil Service Regulations.


Title - Bhagwati Prasad Verma Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' The Secy. Basic Edu. U.P. Shasan & Ors.

Coram - Hon'ble Vijay Manohar Sahai,J. and Hon'ble Shishir Kumar,J.

412. Headline Summary - Rule 4(1) First Proviso of Rules, 1999 mandatory. Employee can be suspended only on serious allegations.


Title - Dr. Arvind Kumar Ram Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Its Secretary And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Vijay Manohar Sahai,J. and Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J.

413. Headline Summary - Enhancing rent is fundamental right of the landlord


Title - Abdul Jalil Vs. Special Judge E.C.Act/Addl. Distt. (E.P.J.S.C.C.) & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Rakesh Tiwari,J.

414. Headline Summary - Rs.2,69,433/- being diminution price of machinery, assessee failed to declare it truly to A.O. Reassessment roceedings u/s 147(a) rightly initiated.


Title - The Income Tax Commisioner Vs. M/S J.K. Jute Mills Co. Ltd.

Coram - Hon'ble Hemant Laxman Gokhale,J. and Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J.

415. Headline Summary - if one claims that he is not liable to pay tax on transfer of goods from one State to another or return thereof, he has to furnish declaration Form F


Title - M/A Ambica Steels Limited Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. and Hon'ble Vikram Nath,J.

416. Headline Summary - mixing of spices manufactures a new and different commodity, Ashok Grah Udyog Kendra (P) Ltd., 2004 NTN (25) 702 (Allahabad) is not a good law


Title - M/S Ashoka Food & De-Hydred Sansthan Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


417. Headline Summary - NSA-Evaluation of answer books by unauthorised examiners not a point concerning public order-detention illegal.


Title - Ram Pratap Singh Vs. Union Of India & Others


418. Headline Summary - High Court while giving its opinion in a reference does not sit in appeal over the findings recorded by the Tribunal, which are not perverse.


Title - C.I.T. Vs. M/S B.D. Authority


419. Headline Summary - Mag. can grant bail in offences under SC/ST Act not punishable with death or Life imprisonment.


Title - Saroj Kumar Upadhyaya Vs. Highcourt Of Judicature At Alld. Thru Registrar General &Anr


420. Headline Summary - Sec.3(2)(v)SC/ST Act-no charge if noallegation that offence committed on the basis that victim belongs to SC/ST.


Title - Rajnish Dwivedi Vs. State Of U.P. Throughh Secretary Home, At Lko.


421. Headline Summary - Section 147, Expl.II(b) of IT Act added w.e.f. 1.4.1989 provides by deeming fiction that income can be treated to have escaped assessment.


Title - M/S S.K.Gupta & Company Vs. Income Tax Officer, Ward-I, Ghaziabad

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. and Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J.

422. Headline Summary - circular directs Excise Deptt to release non-relied seized goods/documents to assessee, where notice is not issued within six months from seizure.


Title - M/S Novament Indistreis & Another Vs. Union Of India Thru' Secretary Min. Of Fin. &Others


423. Headline Summary - Petitioners can file application u/s 13A(6) of UP Trade Tax Act for release of goods without furnishing security, where matter can be gone into


Title - M/S Rajeev Kumar Jain Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


424. Headline Summary - reasons have to be assigned by Addl. Commissioner while granting sanction u/s 21(2) of UP Trade Tax Act, authorisation set aside


Title - M/S Ramayan Traders, Bareilly And Another Vs. Asstt. Commissioner (Assessment:Iii), Trade Tax,Bareilly &An


425. Headline Summary - A.C. has no power to sit in appeal or review a good entry awarded by A.J., thus, exceeded its power and its decision set aside


Title - Desh Bhushan Jain Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


426. Headline Summary - Crl Trial-On rejecting final report case to proceed as State Case if sufficient evidence in C.D. is not otherwise


Title - Mohd. Yusuf & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


427. Headline Summary - In a complaint triable by a Sessions Court, Magistrte must record statements of all witnessess u/s 202 Cr.p.C.


Title - Kailash Nath Pandey & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


428. Headline Summary - Maintenance allowance fixed in the compromise can be altered u/s 127 Cr.P.C.


Title - Ram Narayan Gupta Vs. Smt. Laxmi Devi & Another


429. Headline Summary - Orders dt.17.9.05 and 28.7.06 of AICTE quashed & AICTE directed to decide matter afresh in accordance with law and observations made.


Title - Amity Business School Thru' Authorized Signatory & Another Vs. All India Council For Technical Education & Others


430. Headline Summary - approved draft scheme cannot be quashed for inordinate delay; existing permit holders are entitled to compensation; temp. permit cannot be renewed


Title - U.P.S.R.T.C. Thru' Managing Director Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Principal Secy. Transport & Anr.


431. Headline Summary - Accused sentenced to four years R.I. u/s 326 I.P.C.-Appeal heard after 25 years, fine of Rs. 45,000/- substituted.


Title - Asghar Ali & Others Vs. State Of U.P.& Others


432. Headline Summary - Sec.239 Cr.P.C.-Accused may be discharged if no case made out on the bais of prosecution documents


Title - Rais Miyan & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


433. Headline Summary - Criminal trial -while claiming charge only prosecution evidence will be considered and not defence plea.


Title - Raghvendra Kumar Srivastava & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


434. Headline Summary - Sec 164 Cr.P.C.-Only IO can apply regarding statement of witness and none else


Title - Smt. Jag Devi @ Jagwati & Another Vs. State Of U.P.


435. Headline Summary - Crl.Ttrial- After completion of statement,specific question to be specified for further cross.


Title - Awinesh Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


436. Headline Summary - Sec.25 Arms Acft sentence below minimum prescribed u/s 25-B(1) can be imposed in suitable cases.


Title - Laturi Vs. State Of U.P


437. Headline Summary - Chargesheet by police in non-cognizable case to be treated as a complaint.


Title - Santosh Kumar Trivedi Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


438. Headline Summary - S.354 IPC-considering long gap of 25 yrs imprisonment commuted to enhanced fine.


Title - Ram Chandra Vs. State Of U.P.


439. Headline Summary - when recruitment is held within year of recruitment, benefit of second proviso to Rule 10 is not available; Rule 4(m) valid.


Title - Shikha Srivastava And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. , Hon'ble Sunil Ambwani,J. and Hon'ble S.S. Kulshrestha,J.

440. Headline Summary - Sec.362 Cr.P.C. bars review/recall of order by same court. Remedy to approach superior court.


Title - Smt. Gayatri Mishra Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


441. Headline Summary - Sec.156(3) Cr.P.C., Powers of Magistrate, correctness of dictum in Cr..M..Appl. 6152/06 doubted-referred to larger Bench.


Title - Sukhwasi Vs. State Of U.P.


442. Headline Summary - Petition dismissed. Court being dissatisfied directed for action under Regulation 351-A CSR if Comm., Trade Tax, forms such an opinion


Title - M/S King Agency Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


443. Headline Summary - Complaint u/s 138 Negotiable Instrucments Act not maintainable without service of notice


Title - Ravindra Singh Gugyani Alias Sanju Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


444. Headline Summary - Section 319 Cr.P.C., accused not to be summoned on hearsay evidence


Title - Jamuna Devi & Others Vs. State Of U.P.


445. Headline Summary - Tax authorities to examine/state in memo whether appeal involving tax effect less than 4 lacs falls within one of exceptions.

Judgment/Order - INCOME TAX APPEAL DEFECTIVE No. 201 of 2001 Judgment/Order Dated - 1/5/2007 at Allahabad.

Title - The Commissioner Of Income Tax Kanpur Vs. M/S Roshan Lal Talwar (Maj. Qrs.) Jhansi


446. Headline Summary - UP Higher Education Services Commission Act is valid.


Title - C/M D.N. (P.G.) College Meerut Thru' Hony' Secy., & Anr Vs. State Of Up Thru' Secy Higher Education And Others


447. Headline Summary - The question whether the scheme of arrangement should be stamped or not - referred to third Judge.


Title - M/S Hero Motors Limited, New Delhi Thru Its President Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Adm (Finance & Revenue) And Others


448. Headline Summary - Procedure for issuing gate pass by Mandi Samitee explained


Title - Itc Ltd. Vs. Mandi Parishad & Another

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Sanjay Misra,J.

449. Headline Summary - Non bailable warrant & process u/s 82 & 83 Cr.P.C. cannot be issued simultaneously.


Title - Shamsher And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


450. Headline Summary - Offences non-compoundable but inview of spl. facts compounding permitted u/s 465, 467, 468 & 471IPC.


Title - Kumar Manglam Birla Vs. Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate & Others


451. Headline Summary - Sec.173 Cr.P.C. permits further investigation & not reinvestigation.


Title - Smt. Sugandha Devi And Others Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Its Secy. (Home) Govt. Of U.P. & Ors.


452. Headline Summary - Accused having fire arms caused injuries from buts and barrels of those arms prima facie has no intentionto kill


Title - Pappu & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


453. Headline Summary - Name of the medicine in the licence under the Drugs Act- can not infringe Trade mark.


Title - M/S Cattle Remedies Through Its Partner & Another Vs. The Licensing Authority & Others


454. Headline Summary - Police report & complaint for same incident against different persons-S 210 CR.P.C.not applicable to both cases to be decided together.


Title - Smt. Harpyari & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


455. Headline Summary - Mag. cannot summon accused on protest petition in F.R. where there is no evidence in C.D.


Title - Baijnath And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


456. Headline Summary - G.O. dated23.12.2003 and 23.9.2006 providing for self examination centre in the high school and intermediate examinationsquashed


Title - C/M. Shri Mohan Singh Inter College, Mathura And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Shambhu Nath Srivastava,J.

457. Headline Summary - The Judges of superior Courts are particularly trained to give reasonable decisions even on complicated matters requiring any special expertise


Title - Wig & Sons Vs. Chief Engineer (Air Force), Bamrauli, Alld.

Coram - Hon'ble Ajoy Nath Ray,J.

458. Headline Summary - The well known principle of law is that actus curiae neminem gravabit


Title - Vice Chancellor, Banaras Hindu Univeristy, Varanasi & Others Vs. Anand Kumar Rai & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ajoy Nath Ray,J. and Hon'ble Ashok Bhushan,J.

459. Headline Summary - The interim order refused in P.C.S.(J) examination, writ petition dismissed.


Title - Jai Prakash Tiwari And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Sushil Harkauli,J. and Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.

460. Headline Summary - Magistrate can treat an application u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C. as a complaint and vice versa.


Title - Shiv Narain Jaiswal And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


461. Headline Summary - F.R. submitted-Magistrate doubting geneuineness of statement to summon accused without further investigation-order illegal.


Title - Aun Mohammad Naqvi @ Siddan & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


462. Headline Summary - Sec.482 Cr.P.C.where no evidence of unnatrural death charge u/s 304-B IPC to be probed.


Title - Smt. Vimla Devi & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


463. Headline Summary - In a case of F.R. Magistrate to consider F.R. itself & supporting evidence while passing order on protest petition.


Title - Diwari Lal And Others. Vs. State Of U.P And Another


464. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-parties reached compromise-withdrawal application-second appeal dismissed as not pressed-no liberty for fresh second appeal

Judgment/Order - SECOND APPEAL No. 857 of 1981 Judgment/Order Dated - 6/10/2006 at Allahabad.

Title - Pratappur Sugar & Industry Ltd. Vs. Ashwani Kumar Shukla

Coram - Hon'ble Satya Poot Mehrotra,J.

465. Headline Summary - Second Appeal , sole defendant-appellant expired-no Substitution Application filed-Second Appeal dismissed as abated.


Title - Gauri Shanker Srivastava Vs. Shri Radha Kishna Ji Maharaj Sri Mulloo Swami,B.M.


466. Headline Summary - The action must be initiated in a contempt proceeding within a period of one year from the date the contempt is alleged to have been committed.


Title - Bali Ram Vs. Chief Engineer, Irrigation, Deptt. Gorakhpur & Others


467. Headline Summary - S.210 Cr.P.C.-complaint case and State case in respect of same incident be tried together.


Title - Smt. Kamlesh Bhardwaj And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


468. Headline Summary - Juvenile Justice Act - Age to be determined as per Rule 22 of U.P.Juvenile Justice Rules 2004


Title - Devendra @ Chintu Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


469. Headline Summary - Plea of Juvenile cannot be refused on the ground of delay


Title - Ram Babu Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


470. Headline Summary - Second Appeal contesting plaintiffs-respondents expired-Substitution Application not filed-Second Appeal dismissed as abated.


Title - Smt.Sham Sundri And Another Vs. Ram Nandan And Others


471. Headline Summary - Gross misconduct - act prejudicial to the interest of Bank - WP dismissed


Title - Komal Singh Vs. General Manager (P) Syndicate Bank & Others


472. Headline Summary - A minor not entitled to compassionate appointment after 15 years of death of father. Petition dismissed.


Title - Mahendra Kumar Yadav Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


473. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-dismissed as abated-restoration and substitution application filed-injunction/stay may be granted-sections 141 and 151 cpc


Title - Basan Lal Vs. Lakshmi Chand


474. Headline Summary - S-50 NDPS ACT applicable to personal search of body of accused and not for search of his belonging, like bag etc.


Title - Pradeep Kumar Pathak Vs. State Of U.P.


475. Headline Summary - Writ petition in exceptional circustances is maintainable even against a notification issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act.


Title - Kshama Sahkari Avas Samiti Ltd. Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ram Prakash Misra,J. and Hon'ble Pankaj Mithal,J.

476. Headline Summary - Revisional court cannot record finding of fact & can simply issue direction to lower court.


Title - R.K.Singh Vs. State


477. Headline Summary - UP.Board directed to recognise Moral Education as compulsory subject-See article 51 A of Const.


Title - Iqbal Hussain Vs. State Of U.P. Others


478. Headline Summary - Crl.court when unable to decide title to case property should direct parties to seek declaration of title.


Title - District Co-Operative Bank Ltd. Fatehpur Vs. State Of U.P.


479. Headline Summary - prescribing two alternate qualification & omitting preference clause to degree holder do not create hostile discrimination. Preference is for equals


Title - Dr. Akhilesh Mishra Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. and Hon'ble Sanjay Misra,J.

480. Headline Summary - Appointment de hors statutory provisions on non-available post cannot be taken note of for regularisation and such regularisation is void


Title - Hari Bansh Dwivedi Vs. Vice Chancellor Mahatma Gandhi Klashi Vidyapith & Others


481. Headline Summary - Accused is entitled to bail where injuries on the accused side are not explained by the prosecution.


Title - Rakesh Kumar Singh @ Puppu Vs. State Of U.P.


482. Headline Summary - delay deprecated, direction to refurbish educational system


Title - Narendra Kumar Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' The Secretary Ministry Of Education


483. Headline Summary - Order for regularisation when the initial engagement is dehorse the prescribed procedure is bad.


Title - Anup Behari Lal Srivastava Vs. J.P. Rai


484. Headline Summary - seniority to be counted from date of substantive appointment u/r 21(1) unless the order mentions otherwise


Title - Jai Prakash Vs. State Of U.P.Through Principal Secy. Admin. Reforms Dept1 L.

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. and Hon'ble Ran Vijai Singh,J.

485. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-counsel for the appellant not present-repeated adjournments-Second Appeal dismissed for want of prosecution.


Title - Gulam Zilani Vs. Abdul Rahman And Another


486. Headline Summary - The word should by itself is of a considerably less mandatory character and meaning than the world shall.


Title - Ram Gopal & Another Vs. The Union Of India & Ohters


487. Headline Summary - Second Appeal -sole plaintiff-appellant died-Substitution Application not filed -Second Appeal dismissed as abated


Title - Jamuna Das Vs. Ganga Ram & Others


488. Headline Summary - Second Appeal -Sole plaintiff-appellant dead-Substitution Application dismissed for want of prosecution. Second Appeal dismissed as abated.


Title - Yadgar Husain Vs. Jais Mohd.


489. Headline Summary - unfairmeans. belated disposal depreciated certain directions issued


Title - Abhay Kumar Tripathi Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


490. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-Counsel for the defendants-appellants not appeared-dismissed for want of prosecution.


Title - Suleman Vs. Amiruddin


491. Headline Summary - Second Appeal -Sole plaintiff-appellant dead-no substitution application-Second Appeal dismissed as abated.


Title - Sarvjeet Singh Vs. Raj Kumari And Others


492. Headline Summary - Second Appeal- Sole plaintiff-appellant-Subsitution Application dismissed for non-prosecution-Second Appeal dismissed as abated.


Title - Sia Ram Vs. Suraj Prasad


493. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-Counsel reporting no instructions-Second Appeal dismissed for want of prosecution.


Title - Subedar Vs. Ram Swaroop & Others


494. Headline Summary - No Bail where there is no evidence to substantiate cross allegation


Title - Nanku Lal Yadav Vs. State Of U.P.


495. Headline Summary - Tenders not invalid due to omission of amount in figures or words and in case of discrepancy higher amount shall be accepted


Title - Consolidators Information Systems Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. Vs. Chairman, Noida & Others


496. Headline Summary - Second Apopeal- Repeated adjournment- Learned counsel not appearing -Dismissed for want of prosecution.


Title - Hamidullah And Others Vs. Buddhu And Another


497. Headline Summary - Contempt Petition is dismissed as not pressed.

Judgment/Order - CONTEMPT APPLICATION (CIVIL) No. 3465 of 2004 Judgment/Order Dated - 17/7/2006 at Allahabad.

Title - Smt. Sadhana Sinha Vs. Brig R.K. Kashyap, Director & Others


498. Headline Summary - From 1.1.96 the pensioners entitled at least 50% of minimum of revised pay scale as pension, interest on delayed payment of arrears is awarded


Title - Chaudhary Shankar Singh Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. Finance Deptt. & Ors.


499. Headline Summary - Bail to father/mother-in-law in dowry death case can be refused in case of direct allegation & evidence of cruelty.


Title - Vijay Pal Singh And Another Vs. State Of U.P.


500. Headline Summary - Horizontal Reservations to be worked out for physically handicapped persons of general category.


Title - Dr. Ravindra Kumar Pandey Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Vijay Manohar Sahai,J. and Hon'ble Sabhajeet Yadav,J.

501. Headline Summary - Governor's order retaining Legal Advisor stayed.


Title - In Re : Secretary, High Court Bar Association, Allahabad Vs. *

Coram - Hon'ble Rakesh Tiwari,J. , Hon'ble S.S. Kulshrestha,J. , Hon'ble Prakash Krishna,J. , Hon'ble Devendra Pratap Singh,J. and Hon'ble Amreshwar Pratap Sahi,J.

502. Headline Summary - Amendment irrelevant for determination of controversy between the parties, not liable to be allowed.


Title - Ramji Das And Another Vs. Rajendra Mohan Mathur And Another

Coram - Hon'ble Krishna Murari,J.

503. Headline Summary - Recovery of excess amount paid on fixation, not occasioned by misrepresentation or fraud by petitioner, is inequitable.


Title - Raj Nath Ram Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. Institutional Finance & Ors.


504. Headline Summary - punishment of removal for not joining at transferred place and remaining absent without sanctined leave is appropriate


Title - Dinesh Chandra Jain Vs. Syndicate Bank & Others


505. Headline Summary - Ration shop-G.O. regarding cancellation on election of licensee or his family members-legal position explained.


Title - Ram Murat Vs. Commissioner Azamgarh Divn. & Others


506. Headline Summary - Crl. noncompoundable case tobe dropped when husband and wife settled dispute amicably.


Title - Pankaj Mishra & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


507. Headline Summary - Building assessed to Tax, date of first assessment shall be deemed to be completion of building for determining the applicablity of Rent Act.


Title - Mohammad Aslam Vs. Om Prakash Dwivedi


508. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-Substitution Applications consequent to the death of sole defendant-appellant dismissed-Second Appeal stands abated


Title - Gulam Hussain Vs. Mohd.Farooq


509. Headline Summary - once regular enquiry instituted, findings recorded in preliminary enquiry loose its significance


Title - Subhash Chandra Upadhyay Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


510. Headline Summary - Application for condonation of delay not to be allowed if there are latches on the part of applicant.


Title - Laxmi Devi Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


511. Headline Summary - Bail can be refused to juvenile on the ground mentioned in S.12 of Juvenile Justice Act.


Title - Pappi @ Prem Singh Vs. State Of U.P.


512. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-sole plaintiff-appellant dead, steps for notice on Substitution Application not take. Second Appeal dismissed as having abated.


Title - Mohd. Anwar Khan Vs. Harish Chandra


513. Headline Summary - officating principal can be divested of his duty to restore normalcy in College


Title - Dr. Kiran Shanker Vs. Union Of India And Others


514. Headline Summary - Garages may not be used for purposes other than keeping vehicles or as a store.


Title - In The Matter Of : Group Captain Sukh Deo Singh Sidhu & Anr. Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Shishir Kumar,J.

515. Headline Summary - Principle of O 41 R 27 CPC to be followed by Appellate Authority under Rent Control Act while receiving additional evidence.


Title - Shri Durga Bhagwati Industries, Hathras And Others Vs. Shri Om Prakash Lohia And Others


516. Headline Summary - Bail to Juvenile can be refused only on grounds given in S 12, JJ Act


Title - Vishal Dubey Vs. State Of U.P.


517. Headline Summary - No revision lies agains t preliminary orders u/s 145&146 Cr.P.C..Aggrieved party to file objection before SDM.


Title - Maan Babu Dubey Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


518. Headline Summary - Reservation in constituencies of CM in Cooperative Societies rotate according to Hindi alphabet.


Title - Sudhir Tyagi Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


519. Headline Summary - Fixation of separate quota for promotion of different post in feeder cadre does not tantamount to reservation.


Title - Dinesh Kant Srivastava Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Vijay Manohar Sahai,J. and Hon'ble Sabhajeet Yadav,J.

520. Headline Summary - Judicial review of administrative order-cancellation of auction bad-petition allowed


Title - M/S Trilochan Rice And Alloy Mills Ltd. Jaunpur Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble B.S. Chauhan,J. and Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J.

521. Headline Summary - Petition under Article 227 dismissed on ground of alternative remedy-injunction application filed in regular First Appeal-

Judgment/Order - MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. 52 of 2006 Judgment/Order Dated - 25/4/2006 at Allahabad.

Title - Mohd. Tahir Khan Vs. Mohd. Yunus Khan And Others


522. Headline Summary - Copy of notice terminating the tenancy served after filing of suit no valid service


Title - Mohamad Ismail Vs. Ii Addl. Distt. Judge And Others


523. Headline Summary - Appeal decided by SOC Mau after transfer from Ballia Revision lies before DDC Mau

Judgment/Order - WRIT - B No. 18339 of 2006 Judgment/Order Dated - 24/4/2006 at Allahabad.

Title - Parshuram Vs. Dy. Director Of Consolidation, Ballia & Others


524. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-Sole plaintiff-appellant-dead. No Substitution Application filed. Second Appeal stands dismissed as abated.


Title - Inder Singh Vs. Chaumal


525. Headline Summary - Arbitration Award 30 days objection time from notice of filing date & not from any later date.


Title - The National Projects Construction Corp.Ltd., Sonebhadra Vs. M/S B.B.Verma And Another


526. Headline Summary - The area of Industrial Township under proviso to Article 243Q is to excluded from delimitation of wards.


Title - Hindalco Industries Limited Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


527. Headline Summary - Chapter XII, Rule 4 of the Rules of the Court- Second Appeal dismissed against respondents 1 & 2 only-


Title - Bhagwan Das & Ors. Vs. Sri Sumer Chand


528. Headline Summary - Second Appeal sole defendant-respondent-Substutiton Application dismissed u/Ch XII R4-Second Appeal dismissed as abated.


Title - Mata Sevak Vs. Sarju Prasad


529. Headline Summary - spl. adverse entry should relate to particular instance/work on application of mind thereto


Title - Bajrang Bahadur Singh Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Principal Secy. P.W.D. & Anr.

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. and Hon'ble Ravindra Nath Misra,J.

530. Headline Summary - Writ in non-contractual matters- Direction to decide representation-No


Title - Sant Gadge Seva Niketan And Another Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


531. Headline Summary - Govt. directed to take steps towards ameliorating working conditions of officers on revenue as well as consolidation side


Title - Smt. Shanti Devi & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


532. Headline Summary - GO prohibiting renewal of whole sale fertilizer registration within 5 Km of Indo-Nepal border-illegal


Title - M/S Rajpal Trading Co. Thru' Prop. & Another Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. Deptt. Of Agriculture & Ors.


533. Headline Summary - Writ-conditional stay of eviction-damages awarded at enhanced rate-direction for deposit-no modification required


Title - Gulshan Kumar Shondhi Vs. S.M. College Chandausi


534. Headline Summary - UPFC loan-how to auction, Decree set aside-even then bona fide purchaser to be protected.


Title - Jalesh Bhatia And Ors. Vs. U.P.S.C. And Ors.


535. Headline Summary - transit fee is payable on stone ballast, Khanda and boulder if they cross the forest during transportation


Title - Ashok Kumar Anandani And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. and Hon'ble Saroj Bala,J.

536. Headline Summary - Consolidation authorities have jurisdiction to provide chak road,nali etc to an individual tenure holder


Title - Asha Ram Misra and others Vs. The Jt. Director of Consoliation and another


537. Headline Summary - Writ Petition against IFFCO is not maintainable. Reference answered.


Title - Jyoti Kumar Malviya Vs. I.F.F.C.O. Ltd., & others, Phoolpur project, Phoolpur, Allahabad


538. Headline Summary - UP Act No.13 of 1972- Occupation after July 1976 without allotment order-No regularisation u/s 14-Vacancy rightly deemed.


Title - Siraj Ahmad Vs. R.C.


539. Headline Summary - Quantum of punishment-no interference-W.P. dismissed.


Title - Charan Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


540. Headline Summary - Rule 9-A, UP Minor Minerals (Concession) Rules, 1963, having been declared ultra vires, no benefit can be claimed under the lease sanctioned


Title - Rajan Nishad And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


541. Headline Summary - Crl.Revision dismissed on merits without hearing revisionist cannot be restored.


Title - Anand Swaroop & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


542. Headline Summary - Refusal of Regularisation of Daily Wages Employees of Cooperative Banks.


Title - Vinita Singh & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


543. Headline Summary - Judgment in the matter of disqualification of BSP MLAs


Title - Swami Prasad Maurya, M.L.A. Vs. Speaker Legislative Assembly U.P. & 40 Ors.

Coram - Hon'ble Ajoy Nath Ray,Chief Justice , Hon'ble Jagdish Bhalla,J. and Hon'ble Pradeep Kant,J.

544. Headline Summary - Levy of royalty on ordinary earth upheld and contractors are liable to pay royalty on ordinary earth


Title - M/S J.K. Construction Engineers & Contractor & Others Vs. Union Of India Thru Secy Mines And Mineral And Others


545. Headline Summary - The Court must allow the electoral process to go first and then, if proper, upset the elections, if good grounds can be given


Title - Chandra Narayan Tripathi Alias Chandoo Vs. The Registrar, Socieities, Firms and Chits and Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ajoy Nath Ray,J. , Hon'ble Ajay Kumar Yog,J. , Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. , Hon'ble Sushil Harkauli,J. and Hon'ble Tarun Agarwala,J.

546. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-Admitted-Steps for notices not taken-Second Appeal Dismissed


Title - Satya Narain Misra Vs. M/S,Sardar Finance Corp.


547. Headline Summary - Unbroken identity of holding and not of individual plot to be considered to treat it as ancestral


Title - Ram Dhari Vs. D.D.C.


548. Headline Summary - Second Appeal-Sole plaintiff-appellant dead-Substitition Appln.dismissedu/Ch XII R4-Second Appeal dismissed as abated.


Title - The Nagar Palika Vs. Vinodi Lal


549. Headline Summary - Hybrid mode of promotion or Acquiescence -WP dismissed


Title - R.K. Pandey Vs. The New India Assurance Company Ltd. And Others


550. Headline Summary - Serious challenge to jurisdiction, court fee suits maintainability should be decided first.


Title - Arun Kumar Tiwari Vs. Smt. Deepa Sharma & Others


551. Headline Summary - Fresh writ for same relief or for execution of order passed in earlier writ not maintainable.


Title - Krishna Kumar Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


552. Headline Summary - Mining leases granted under R.9A cannot be renewed after FB judgment in 2001(1) SAG 475.


Title - Gopal Prasad Gupt Vs. State Of U.P.And Others


553. Headline Summary - Entry obtained by fraud expunged exparte proper course is to give post decisional hearing


Title - Rakesh & Others Vs. Collector & Others


554. Headline Summary - Crl. Trial- Taking of addl. evidence can be allowed in suitablae cases even in appeal


Title - Mool Chand Vs. State


555. Headline Summary - Crl Trial-Sentence lenient view to be taken considering long gap between date of incident and jt


Title - Prem Pal Vs. State Of U.P.


556. Headline Summary - Accused has a right to summon relevant evidence at the stage of defence.


Title - Manoj Kumar Swami Vs. State Of U.P.


557. Headline Summary - Case U/s 495 I.P.C. cannot proceed on charge sheet- proper procedure to file complaint


Title - Ram Swaroop & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


558. Headline Summary - Dismissal order of Bank employee on serious charges is not disproportionate. W.P. Dismissed.


Title - Virendra Kumar Bhardwaj Vs. Syndicate Bank Thr. Chairman And M.D. & Others


559. Headline Summary - Crl.Trial-Accused to be summoned relying upon unrebutted prosecution evidence.


Title - Suresh Shahi & Another Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


560. Headline Summary - Cr.Trial-Pendency of civil suit no bar to crl. proceedings.


Title - Chhedi Lal Kedia & Others Vs. State Of U.P. & Another


561. Headline Summary - Crl. Trial-Cross case to be heard & decided by the same court.


Title - Ravi Shankar Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


562. Headline Summary - crl.Trial-Defence evidence not to be summoned at the time of charge.


Title - Mahesh Vs. State Of U.P. And Another


563. Headline Summary - Second Appeal filed on 20.12.1985-Tribunal established on 1.11.85 under Administrative Tribunals Act,1985-Second Appeal dismissed as not maintainsble.


Title - Union Of India Vs. Dr.Vishwa Veer


564. Headline Summary - Art.243-T intra vires; S.9-A(5),Municipalities Act ultra vires; Rules 6 & 6-A illegal & invalid


Title - Heera Lal Umar And Anr. Vs. State Of U.P.


565. Headline Summary - Post decisional hearing.Petitioner failed to show any defect in impugned orders.No interference


Title - Ram Narain Vs. D.M. & Others


566. Headline Summary - Illegality at stage of Sec. 8 & 8A Provisional Consolidation Scheme rightly directed to be reframed


Title - Sundar Lal And Another Vs. D.D.C. And Others


567. Headline Summary - UP Trade Tax Act S.29 Refund. No specific order for refund is required.


Title - M/S Reva Enviro Systems P. Ltd., Bareilly Vs. State Of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ajay Kumar Yog,J. and Hon'ble Prakash Krishna,J.

568. Headline Summary - Second Appeal- compromise verified by the Court- decided in terms of compromise.


Title - Noor Ahmad Vs. Iftikaruddin


569. Headline Summary - Dealer having opted for composition cannot resile from liability for no turnover.


Title - M/S Bhadauria Gram Sewa Sansthan Vs. Asstt. Commissioner Sales Tax Allahabad & Others

Coram - Hon'ble R.K. Agrawal,J. , Hon'ble Prakash Krishna,J. and Hon'ble Kailash Nath Ojha,J.

570. Headline Summary - Appointment on the basis of false caste certificate is void. Petition dismissed.


Title - B.S. Negi Vs. General Manager Syndicate Bank And Others


571. Headline Summary - Parties to dispute agree to abide by statement of witness.Decision on such statement.No illegality


Title - Mst. Maharaji Vs. A.D.C. & Ors


572. Headline Summary - Second Appeal -sole plaintiff-appellant died. No Substitution Application filed. Second Appeal stands dismised as abated.


Title - Bundeo Devi Vs. Raj Bahadur


573. Headline Summary - UPCH Act - S. 42 - Direct revision against order of ACO & CO is maintainable before the DDC


Title - Faujdar Vs. The D.D.C., Azamgarh And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ajay Kumar Yog,J. and Hon'ble Prakash Krishna,J.

574. Headline Summary - The last drawn pay of the persons acquiring disability during service has to be protected.


Title - Union Of India And Others Vs. Mohd. Mobin Khan And Another


575. Headline Summary - 50% Mohammadan quota for the P.G. Medical Courses in AMU is unconstitutional and impermissible.


Title - Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh Through Its V.C. Vs. Malay Shukla & Others


576. Headline Summary - U.P. Urban Local Self Government Laws (Amendment) Act, 2005 is a valid piece of legislation


Title - Anugrah Narain Singh Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


577. Headline Summary - Change in constitution of the firm under Income Tax Act explained Ref. answered in favour of Revenue


Title - C.I.T. Vs. M/S S.M.S. Nath

Coram - Hon'ble Ajay Kumar Yog,J. and Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J.

578. Headline Summary - Long standing entry in the revenue record without possession does not confir any right by estopple


Title - Acchaibar And Ors. Vs. D.D.C. And Ors.


579. Headline Summary - Appointment not in accordance with Sec. 18 of the Secondary Education Board Act- bad- WP- dismissed


Title - Manvendra Pratap Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


580. Headline Summary - Higher authorities to accept recommendation of B.M.-unless any material to the contrary


Title - Mahendra Kumar Gupta Vs. The General Manager (Pension Deptt). Central Bank Of India

Coram - Hon'ble Vikram Nath,J.

581. Headline Summary - Rent can be enhanced for the period stay order has been enjoyed by the tenant


Title - Jhanjhi Ram Vs. Iv Adj And Others


582. Headline Summary - Firearms licence holder to deposit arms upon suspension of licence. Reference answered.


Title - Shafat Khan Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


583. Headline Summary - Monthly deposit of rent under Order XV Rule 5 CPC in same Court where suit is filed.Ref. answered


Title - Haider Abbas Vs. Addl. District Judge, Allahabad & Others


584. Headline Summary - Mosquito Mats are insecticides for the purposes of imposing tax. Writ Petition allowed.


Title - M/S Knight Queen Industries (P) Ltd Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Institutional Finance Secy. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Ajay Kumar Yog,J. and Hon'ble Dilip Gupta,J.

585. Headline Summary - Teacher not possessing qualification on date of occurence of vacancy-not eligible for promotion.


Title - Iqramul Haq Vs. Mohd. Sabir & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Syed Rafat Alam,J. and Hon'ble Vikram Nath,J.

586. Headline Summary - Temporary employee-no right to post order not stigmatic


Title - Rohit Kumar Vs. Mukhya Nagar Adhikari & Others


587. Headline Summary - Reservation judgement dated 5.10.2005 partly stayed in Special Appeal


Title - State Of U.P. & Others Vs. Hari Ram Yadav

Coram - Hon'ble Syed Rafat Alam,J. and Hon'ble Sudhir Agarwal,J.

588. Headline Summary - UP PCS(J) Exam 2003 - Partly quashed


Title - Dinesh Pratap Singh And Others Vs. State Of U.P. And Others

Coram - Hon'ble Sushil Harkauli,J. and Hon'ble Ganga Prasad Srivastava,J.

589. Headline Summary - Land Acquisition Act- 25% deduction from compensation for development of acquired land


Title - K.U.M.S. Vs. Bishan Dass & Others


590. Headline Summary - Independent feeder consumer - liable 15% surcharge in case of use during restrictive hours


Title - M/S Northern Coalfields Ltd Vs. Chairman & M.D., U.P.C.L. & Another


591. Headline Summary - Candidate claiming reserved category can not be considered in the general category


Title - Hari Ram Yadav Vs. State of U.P. & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Sunil Ambwani,J.

592. Headline Summary - Judicial review of order fresh allotment of plots by Committee enquiry by CBI


Title - Deepak Sharma Vs. State Of U.P. And Others


593. Headline Summary - Reservation on the basis of religion for Muslims in AMU - quashed


Title - Dr. Naresh Agarwal Vs. Union Of India Thru' Secy. Ministry Of Human & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Arun Tandon,J.

594. Headline Summary - Contempt of Courts Act, 1971-no contempt- Petition barred under Sec 20


Title - Balwant Vidyapeeth Rural Institute Thru' Its Principal Vs. Shri Dev Raj Singh


595. Headline Summary - Negligence -MACP claim passenger shifted from one Bus to another Bus


Title - U.P.State Road Transport Corporation Vs. Smt. Rani Srivastava and others


596. Headline Summary - Writ against CBSE maintainable but not against the schools affiliated to CBSE


Title - M.K. Gandhi & Others Vs. Director Of Education Lko.& Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. , Hon'ble Sunil Ambwani,J. and Hon'ble Devendra Pratap Singh,J.

597. Headline Summary - HM Act S 9-Plaintiff failed to produce best evidence to prove marriage - adverse inference drawn


Title - Smt.Surekha and another Vs. Jitendra alias Deshpal


598. Headline Summary - Distance learning Centres can be established in accordance with Act/Statutes


Title - Allahabad College Of Engineering & Management & Others Vs. His Excellency The Chancellor M.J.P. Rohilkhand Univ.


599. Headline Summary - Indian Succession Act, 1925-Testamentary Case-Non-contentious matter-allowed

Judgment/Order - TESTAMENTARY CASES No. 9 of 2004 Judgment/Order Dated - 20/7/2005 at Allahabad.

Title - In The Matter Of Late Sukh Ram : Rama Shankar Vs. **


600. Headline Summary - Reservation- applies to the cadre and not to the vacancies


Title - Shridhar Dwivedi Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


601. Headline Summary - Parole of Udai Bhan Singh MLA stayed - EC to inform disqualification development


Title - Sarvesh Narain Shukla Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Principal Secy. & Others


602. Headline Summary - Legitimate expectation-judicial review of policy


Title - A.H. Wheeler & Co. Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union Of India & Others


603. Headline Summary - Guidelines for appointment of Administrator in Cooperative Socities - laid down


Title - C/M Distt. Coop. Bank Ltd. Thru' Chairman & Anr. Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. (Coop.) & Ors.


604. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-filedin Sept.1995-No order for issuance of notice to o.ps.-Contempt Petn.dismissed as infructuous.


Title - Mahadeo Ram And Others Vs. Sri Nagendra Rai, Secretary Distt. Sahkari Fed. And Others


605. Headline Summary - Contempt Petition- on the ground of violation of interim order-writ petition dismissed as infructuous-contempt petition too dismissed as infructuous


Title - Banshi Lal Chaddha And Another Vs. Anil Prakash


606. Headline Summary - Notice for no confidence motion - not on prescribed proforma - not illegal


Title - Smt. Krishna Jaiswal Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. Panchayat Raj & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Vijai Shankar Bajpai,J.

607. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-Notice issued in 1994 to o.p.No.1-Not received back.Contempt Petn. dismissed as infructuous.


Title - Vikramaditya Chauhan Vs. Smt. Ram Lal Singh And Another


608. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn. -violationg of interim order in writ -stay vacation pending of writ sent to Uttran.H.C.-Contempt Petn. dismissed as infructuous.


Title - Bahadur Singh And Another Vs. P.K. Dobhal & Others


609. Headline Summary - Contempt Petition dismissed as infructuous by lapse of time.


Title - Jai Ram Singh Gaur Vs. Km. Champa Mishra


610. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-Reward of writ transferred to Uttranachal H.C.-Contempt Petition dismissed as infurctuous.


Title - U.P. Sinchai Karmcheri Pragetisheel Awam Vikas Sangh Vs. Brijendra Bihari Mathur


611. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-nature of controversy-continued absence of counsel for petitioner-applicant-Contempt Petn.dismissed as infructuous by lapse of time.


Title - Dinesh Behari Mathur Vs. Sri Brijendra Sahai & Another


612. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-continued absence of learned counsel for parties-Contempt Petn.dismissed as infructuous by lapse of time.


Title - Raj Dev Vs. Rk Tyagi


613. Headline Summary - Senior most teacher not entitle to continue as officiating principle in case of inquiry against him


Title - Dr. Birendra Singh Vs. Director Of Education Higher And Others


614. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-Filed in May,1995-Contempt Petn dismissed as infractuous.


Title - Abul Owaiss Vs. S.N. Dubey & Others


615. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-Notice to engage another counsel-Returned with Report-Contempt Petn.dismissed for want of prosecution.


Title - Amar Nath Pal Vs. Sri Udai Pal Singh And Another


616. Headline Summary - State advised price of sugar cane for crushing season 2003-04 is valid


Title - West U.P. Sugar Mills Association Thru' Secy. & Ors. Vs. State Of U.P. Thru' Secy. Sugar Industry & Ors.


617. Headline Summary - Important question regarding right to information raised


Title - Peoples Union for Ciil Liberties, UP Branch Vs. Election Commission of India and others


618. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-Nature of controversy -compliance report-Contempt Petn.dismissed as infructuous.


Title - Amol Singh Vs. Sri N.S. Pandey, Incharge Commissioner Of Nagar Nigam & Ano


619. Headline Summary - Wife gang raped - husband not entitled to divorce


Title - Rajesh Kumar Singh Vs. Smt. Rekha Singh & Others


620. Headline Summary - Contempt Petn.-filed in Feb.1994-No order passed for issuance of notices--Section 20 Contempt of Courts Act,1971 also barred-Contempt Petn. dismissed.


Title - Prem Navain Gupta Vs. R.K. Khanna & Others


621. Headline Summary - Contempt Petition-Order complied with-Delay neither wilful nor deliberate-show cause notice discharged-Petition disposed of.


Title - M.Ahmad Vs. H.K.Tiwari


622. Headline Summary - Contempt Petition-Order complied with-Delay neither wilfuil nor deliberate-show cause notice discharged-Contempt Petition stands disposed of.


Title - C/M.J.I.Collage Vs. Karnail Singh


623. Headline Summary - Contempt Petition-Order complied with-No contempt-show cause notices discharged.


Title - P.N.Singh Vs. B.K.Nair & Others


624. Headline Summary - Khudkast land submerged in river on the date of vesting - No right under Zamindari Abolition Act


Title - Mohiuddin Vs. B.R.


625. Headline Summary - Appointment on long leave of more than 10 months - only Commission can appoint


Title - Dr. Prakash Chandra Kamboj Vs. C/M, Bareilly College, Bareilly & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J. and Hon'ble Mukteshwar Prasad,J.

626. Headline Summary - Circumstances - when compromise decree inexcutable


Title - Brij Mohan Kapoor Vs. Xvi Adj Meerut & Others


627. Headline Summary - Exclusive property - when can be divided u/s 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act


Title - Sri Hemant Kumar Agrahari & Another Vs. Smt. Lakshmi Devi & Another


628. Headline Summary - The decision of arbitrator regarding excepted matter - not final


Title - Union Of India & Another Vs. M/S Madnani Construction Corp. P. Ltd. & Another


629. Headline Summary - UP Act No.13 of 1972-Section (2)(1)(bbb)-Waqf Property not recorded in the Municipal record


Title - Mohd. Sabir (Since Deceased) & Others Vs. Mohd. Irshad & Others


630. Headline Summary - Writ petition can be decided on the basis of compromise


Title - Surendra Nath Rai And Another Vs. Prahlad Singh And Others


631. Headline Summary - Principles of Good management and good Administration - discussed


Title - Net Singh Vs. Labour Secy., U.P. Shasan Lko. & Others


632. Headline Summary - Delay caused prejudice - Industrial dispute can not be raised


Title - Mewa Lal Vs. State Of U.P. & Others


633. Headline Summary - Stamp duty - on value on the date of execution of the deed and not on the date of the decree


Title - Smt. Har Pyari Vs. D.R.

Coram - Hon'ble Binod Kumar Roy,J. and Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J.

634. Headline Summary - Death in police custody - State to prove that it is not negligent


Title - Smt.Shahin Khan & Another Vs. 3rd A.D.J.,Kanpur Nagar & Others

Coram - Hon'ble Binod Kumar Roy,J. and Hon'ble Yatindra Singh,J.

allahabad high court afr/landmark...

Documents