2

Alif Ailaan Midterm Report Card for Members of the National Assembly (MNAs)

May 11, 2013 to November 11, 2015

On November 11, 2015, Pakistan’s four provincial assemblies and the National Assembly will all

reach the midterm mark in their tenure. The Alif Ailaan campaign has tried to gauge every MNA

and MPA through the performance of their respective constituencies since the 2013 elections

against four indicators for education and awarded grades in each category, as well as an overall

grade to each MNA, each MPA, and the assemblies. The grades do not reflect the state of

education in a given constituency, but rather the demonstrable change in each constituency

since the 2013 election.

This document contains the Alif Ailaan Midterm Report Card for MNAs. Midterm report cards for

MPAs for each province will be published on November 12, 2015.

What the MNAs are graded on?

The four indicators on which MNAs have been graded are:

a) The state of school facilities (with the highest grades for those constituencies that made

the most progress in the provision of boundary walls, electricity, drinking water and toilet

facilities since the 2013 election)

b) The state of gender parity (the ratio of boys to girls or girls to boys – with the highest

grades for those constituencies that have shown the greatest movement towards gender

parity since the 2013 election)

c) The student to teacher ratio (with the highest grades for those constituencies with the

largest improvement in student teacher ratio since 2013 – where low student to teacher

ratios are considered better)

d) The retention rate between class IV and class II (with the highest grades awarded to

those constituencies with the highest improvement in the retention rate since 2013)

Data limitations

The compilation of the report card of the grades is not based on ideal indicators, but rather on

indicators made from official government data on education that was available, as well as being

representative of a desirable outcome in education. The four indicators were thus chosen to

reflect the four key areas where government actions can produce direct and immediate results,

namely: school building infrastructure, equal provision of education to girls and boys, the

provision of sufficient teachers to meet student numbers, and the ability of the system to retain

students within the primary level. The grades do not reflect the state of education in a given

constituency, but rather the demonstrable change in each constituency since the 2013 election.

Finally, the most recent available official government data that can be reported by constituency

is from the end of 2014 – therefore the grades will not reflect any changes to the education

landscape during the current calendar year.

3

How to read an MNA’s grades

Each MNA has scored grades on school facilities, gender parity, student to teacher ratio and

retention. The grades represent the quantum shift made in the given constituency for all public

sector schools since the 2013 election. The allocation of grades has been standardised to a

normal distribution. The highest possible grade is A+ and the lowest is E.

A low grade does not necessarily mean that a given constituency is very badly placed and a

high grade does not necessarily mean that a given constituency is doing very well. Instead,

grades reflect the level of progress made within a given constituency. What a low grade does

however show, is that a greater effort by a given MNA may have led to a better grade, whereas

a high grade shows that measurable improvement was shown in a given MNA’s constituency.

Highlights of the Midterm Report Card for MNAs

The report card for the National Assembly shows that across the entire population of 272

elected MNAs, only three MNAs score an A and can lay claim to constituencies where there is

evidence of real overall progress since the 2013 general election. All other MNAs score either a

B or a C grade, depending on their performance on each of the four indicators we have

explored. The overall grade for the National Assembly is a C.

School facilities: In the provision of school facilities, there were only four A+ grades, all of

which belonged to South Punjab’s MNAs. Another 32 MNAs received an A grade, of which 13

belong to the Punjab, with Shahid Khaqan Abbasi of Rawalpindi and Khurram Dastgir Khan of

Gujranwala among the cabinet members who did well. Among the low performers, there were 7

E grades awarded, none of which belonged to the Punjab. As ever, this shows that Punjab

enjoys the benefits of relatively higher investments in school infrastructure. Among the notable

examples of low performers in school facilities were former Chief Minister Akram Durrani of the

JUI-F and former Prime Minister Zafarullah Khan Jamali of the PML-N both receiving E grades.

Retention rates: In retention rates, of the eight A+ grades awarded, none went to any MNA

from Punjab or Balochistan. Retention is a complex metric and tends to be a measure of not

only school quality but also a range of exogenous factors such as availability of private schools,

and overall enrolment rates. Nevertheless, it is a useful comprehensive indicator of children

staying in school. Among prominent MNAs that received an A+ are Swat’s Murad Saeed of PTI,

and Karachi’s Ali Raza Abidi of MQM. Among the lower performers, JUI-F’s leader Maulana

Fazlur Rehman of D.I. Khan and Federal Minister for Education Baligh ur Rehman from

Bhawalpur both receive a D.

Gender parity: The Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa perform quite well in gender parity, with

all four A+ grades belonging to central Punjab, and a large number of the thirty-three As also

going to Punjab. Balochistan’s Mehmood Achakzai of PkMAP, Aftab Sherpao of QWP, and

Federal Minister for Health, Saira Afzal Tarar all represent prominent recipients of an A grade.

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa also distinguishes itself by having no entries among the E grade

recipients, whilst Sindh fares poorly with both of Thatta’s and Tharparkar’s MNAs receiving E

grades.

4

Student-teacher ratio: Finally, the grades in student teacher ratio reflect, to an extent, the

challenges of diversity across the country with many high population density areas performing

poorly and many less densely populated areas performing well. This trend is bucked by four

MNAs from Karachi, all of whom receive an A grade. Still, student-teacher ratio is clearly a

challenge in the Punjab, where all twenty-four D grades, and all eleven E grades were rewarded

to MNAs in the Punjab.

Homework for MNAs who want to improve

Every MNA in the country is performing below par. Even recipients of A grades would not send

their own children to a government school. The grades here are being awarded to the state of

government schools. This report card clearly shows that there is not only a lot of room for

improvement in the state of government schools overall, but a lot of room for improvement in the

effort that Pakistan’s MNAs invest in supporting better education outcomes. Though education

is a provincial subject and should ideally be dealt with by MPAs (and MPA report cards will

follow). However, MNAs represent the highest directly elected political office in the country. No

Prime Minister can be prime minister without winning an election as an MNA. This makes the

MNA a vital influence on political priorities in a constituency. Without the MNA being invested in

improved education in her or his constituency, we cannot hope for meaningful sustained reform

in the sector.

The most important area where MNAs can help improve education is in data collection,

openness and reporting. Acquiring, processing, cleaning and presenting the data for this

exercise is an incredibly resource-intensive exercise that government should be doing itself.

Government also must begin to produce data faster, and across a richer array of variables –

particularly data on learning outcomes and education quality. A data regime that only tells us

that there are 25 million children out of school will produce an inordinate emphasis on

enrolment, whilst ignoring issues of quality. This is exactly what has been happening in

Pakistan.

All MNAs can easily improve their grades by insisting on timely and effective improvements in

school facility provision, on which government has a rich and detailed database. This will remain

nearly impossible without a significant increase in both the total magnitude of government

funding of education as well as the quality of government spending. The starting point for this is

for government to meet its promise of spending at least 4% of GDP on education.

MNAs can also affect better student to teacher ratios by insisting on rational allocations of

teachers, rather than postings and transfers that suit their patronage of political actors in their

constituencies.

Encouraging girls’ enrolment and ensuring that practices like corporal punishment are prevented

will help MNAs improve gender parity and better retention rates. Gender parity, in particular,

cannot be achieved without a major focus on finding ways to serve the education needs of

young girls, rather than blaming the specific contexts in which they live.

5

The ultimate report card for MNAs will be delivered in 2018 – when the time for re-election

comes around. Alif Ailaan hopes to ensure that when it does, voters across the country will be

strict and demanding examiners. Stricter, even, than the rigorous methodology used to develop

this midterm report card!

For queries please contact: Hina Ali, Media Manager Alif Ailaan 0345-8559925 hina.ali@alifailaan.pk

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

6

NA-1 PESHAWAR-I Alhaaj Ghulam Ahmad Bilour Awami National Party C B C C C

NA-2 PESHAWAR-II Engr. Hamid-ul-Haq Khalil Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B C C

NA-3 PESHAWAR-III Sajid Nawaz Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B C C

NA-4 PESHAWAR-IV Gulzar Khan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B B B

NA-5 NOWSHERA-I Dr. Imran Khattak Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C D A C C

NA-6 NOWSHERA-II Siraj Muhammad Khan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C D A C C

NA-7 CHARSADDA-I Maulana Muhammad Gohar Shah Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) C D A B B

NA-8 CHARSADDA-II Aftab Ahmad Khan Sherpao Qaumi Watan Party (Sherpao) C C A B B

NA-9 MARDAN-I Amir Haider Khan Awami National Party C C C C C

NA-10 MARDAN-II Ali Muhammad Khan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B B B

NA-11 MARDAN-III Mujahid Ali Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B B B

NA-12 SWABI-I Usman Khan Tarrakai Awami Jamhuri Ittehad Pakistan C C B C C

NA-13 SWABI-II Aqibullah Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B C C

NA-14 KOHAT Shehryar Afridi Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf D C C C C

NA-15 KARAK Nasir Khan Khattak Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B B B

NA-16 HANGU Khial Zaman Orakzai Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf D D B B C

NA-17 ABBOTTABAD-I Dr. Muhammad Azhar Khan Jadoon Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B B B

NA-18 ABBOTTABAD-II Murtaza Javed Abbasi Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C B B B

NA-19 HARIPUR Babar Nawaz Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B B B

NA-20 MANSEHRA-I Sardar Muhammad Yousuf Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C B B

NA-21 MANSEHRA-CUM-TOR GHAR Capt Rtd. Muhammad Safdar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B B B

NA-22 BATTAGRAM Qari Mohammad Yousif Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) B D D B C

NA-23 KOHISTAN Sar Zamin Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C B A B

NA-24 D.I.KHAN Maulana Fazal Ur Rehman Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) C D A A B

NA-25 D.I.KHAN-CUM-TANK Engr. Dawar Khan Kundi Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C D B A B

NA-26 BANNU Akram Khan Durrani Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) E D B B C

NA-27 LAKKI MARWAT Col.Rtd. Amirullah Marwat Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B B B

NA-28 BUNER Sher Akbar Khan Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan B A D B B

NA-29 SWAT-I Murad Saeed Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf A A+ C C B

NA-30 SWAT-II Saleem Rehman Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf B A+ D B B

NA-31 SHANGLA Ibadullah Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B B B

NA-32 CHITRAL Iftikhar ud Din All Pakistan Muslim League C C B B B

NA-33 UPPER DIR-CUM-LOWER DIR Sahibzada Tariq Ullah Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan C B C B B

NA-34 LOWER DIR Sahibzada Muhammad Yaqub Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan C D C C C

NA-35 MALAKAND PROTECTED AREA Junaid Akbar Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B C C

NA-36 TRIBAL AREA-I Bilal Rehman Independent Data not available

NA-37 TRIBAL AREA-II Sajid Hussain Turi Independent Data not available

NA-38 TRIBAL AREA-III Bye-election awaited Bye-election awaited Data not available

NA-39 TRIBAL AREA-IV Syed Ghazi Gulab Jamal Independent Data not available

NA-40 TRIBAL AREA-V Muhammad Nazir Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) Data not available

NA-41 TRIBAL AREA-VI Ghalib Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) Data not available

NA-42 TRIBAL AREA-VII Muhammad Jamal ud Din Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) Data not available

NA-43 TRIBAL AREA-VIII Bismillah Khan Independent Data not available

NA-44 TRIBAL AREA-IX Shahab ud Din Pakistan Muslim League (N) Data not available

NA-45 TRIBAL AREA-X Shah Jee Gul Afridi Independent Data not available

NA-46 TRIBAL AREA-XI Nasir Khan Independent Data not available

NA-47 TRIBAL AREA-XII Qaisar Jamal Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf Data not available

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

7

NA-48 ISLAMABAD-I Asad Umar Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf Data not available

NA-49 ISLAMABAD-II Dr Tariq Fazal Chaudhry Pakistan Muslim League (N) Data not available

NA-50 RAWALPINDI-I Shahid Khaqan Abbasi Pakistan Muslim League (N) A B B C B

NA-51 RAWALPINDI-II Raja Javed Ikhlas Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-52 RAWALPINDI-III Ch. Nisar Ali Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C C B

NA-53 RAWALPINDI-IV Ghulam Sarwar Khan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf B B B C B

NA-54 RAWALPINDI-V Malik Abrar Ahmed Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C D C

NA-55 RAWALPINDI-VI Sheikh Rashid Ahmed Awami Muslim League Pakistan C C C D C

NA-56 RAWALPINDI-VII Imran Khan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf B B C D C

NA-57 ATTOCK-I Sheikh Aftab Ahmed Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-58 ATTOCK-II Malik Ihtebar Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B B B

NA-59 ATTOCK-III Muhammad Zain Ellahi Independent B B B B B

NA-60 CHAKWAL-I Major Rtd. Tahir Iqbal Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C B C C

NA-61 CHAKWAL-II Sardar Mumtaz Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B C B

NA-62 JHELUM-I Chaudhry Khadim Hussain Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-63 JHELUM-II Malik Iqbal Mehdi Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-64 SARGODHA-I Pir Muhammad Amin ul Hasnat Shah Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-65 SARGODHA-II Mohsin Shahnawaz Ranjha Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-66 SARGODHA-III Chaudhary Hamid Hameed Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C A C B

NA-67 SARGODHA-IV Dr. Zulfiqar Ali Bhatti Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-68 SARGODHA-V Sardar Muhammad Shafqat Hayat Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B C B

NA-69 KHUSHAB-I Malik Muhammad Uzair Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-70 KHUSHAB-II Malik Shahid Bashir Awan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-71 MIANWALI-I Obaid Ullah Khan Shadi Khel Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B B B

NA-72 MIANWALI-II Amjid Ali Khan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf B C B C B

NA-73 BHAKKAR-I Abdul Majeed Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-74 BHAKKAR-II Dr. Muhammad Afzal Khan Dhandla Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C B B

NA-75 FAISALABAD-I Lt. Col. Rtd. Ghulam Rasool Sahi Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-76 FAISALABAD-II Muhammad Talal Chaudhry Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-77 FAISALABAD-III Muhammad Asim Nazir Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B D B

NA-78 FAISALABAD-IV Rajab Ali Khan Baloch Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C A C B

NA-79 FAISALABAD-V Chaudhry Muhammad Shahbaz Babar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A D B

NA-80 FAISALABAD-VI Mian Muhammad Farooq Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C D C

NA-81 FAISALABAD-VII Dr. Nisar Ahmed Jatt Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B D D C

NA-82 FAISALABAD-VIII Rana Muhammad Afzal Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) C A A E B

NA-83 FAISALABAD-IX Mian Abdul Manan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D A E C

NA-84 FAISALABAD-X Abid Sher Ali Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A D D C

NA-85 FAISALABAD-XI Haji Muhammad Akram Ansari Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B A E B

NA-86 CHINIOT-I Qaiser Ahmad Sheikh Pakistan Muslim League (N) A B A C B

NA-87 CHINIOT-II CUM-JHANG Ghulam Muhammad Lali Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C A B B

NA-88 JHANG-CUM-CHINIOT Ghulam Bibi Bharwana Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C C C B

NA-89 JHANG-I Sheikh Muhammad Akram Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-90 JHANG-II Sahibzada Muhammad Nazeer Sultan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-91 JHANG-III Najaf Abbas Sial Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B B B

NA-92 TOBA TEK SINGH-I Chaudhry Khalid Javaid Warraich Pakistan Muslim League (N) C D C D C

NA-93 TOBA TEK SINGH-II Muhammad Junaid Anwaar Chaudhry Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C C D C

NA-94 TOBA TEK SINGH-III Ch. Asad Ur Rehman Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C B C C

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

8

NA-95 GUJRANWALA-I Usman Ibrahim Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B A E B

NA-96 GUJRANWALA-II Engr. Khurram Dastgir Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C C D C

NA-97 GUJRANWALA-III Chaudhary Mahmood Bashir Virk Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C C B

NA-98 GUJRANWALA-IV Mian Tariq Mehmood Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A D B

NA-99 GUJRANWALA-V Rana Umer Nazir Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C D C C

NA-100 GUJRANWALA-VI Azhar Qayyum Nahra Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C A+ C B

NA-101 GUJRANWALA-VII Justice Rtd. Iftikhar Ahmad Cheema Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B A C B

NA-102 HAFIZABAD-I Saira Afzal Tarar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A D B

NA-103 HAFIZABAD-II Mian Shahid Hussain Khan Bhatti Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-104 GUJRAT-I Nawabzada Mazher Ali Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-105 GUJRAT-II Ch. Pervaiz Ellahi Pakistan Muslim League C C B C C

NA-106 GUJRAT-III Ch. Jaffar Iqbal Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B C B

NA-107 GUJRAT-IV Ch. Abid Raza Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B C B

NA-108 MANDI BAHAUDDIN-I Mumtaz Ahmad Tarar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C D D C

NA-109 MANDI BAHAUDDIN-II Nasir Iqbal Bosal Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A C B

NA-110 SIALKOT-I Khawaja Muhammad Asif Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B D E C

NA-111 SIALKOT-II Chaudry Armaghan Subhani Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B A C B

NA-112 SIALKOT-III Rana Shamim Ahmed Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C D C C

NA-113 SIALKOT-IV Syed Iftikhar ul Hassan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B D C C

NA-114 SIALKOT-V Zahid Hamid Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B D C C

NA-115 NAROWAL-I Mian Muhammad Rasheed Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B B B

NA-116 NAROWAL-II Daniyal Aziz Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C B B

NA-117 NAROWAL-III Ahsan Iqbal Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C C B

NA-118 LAHORE-I Muhammad Riaz Malik Pakistan Muslim League (N) C A C C B

NA-119 LAHORE-II Mian Mohammad Hamza Shabaz Sharif Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B C D C

NA-120 LAHORE-III Muhammad Nawaz Sharif Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C E C

NA-121 LAHORE-IV Mehar Ishtiaq Ahmad Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B D B

NA-122 LAHORE-V Sardar Ayaz Sadiq Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C D C

NA-123 LAHORE-VI Muhammad Pervaiz Malik Pakistan Muslim League (N) C A C E C

NA-124 LAHORE-VII Shaikh Rohale Asghar Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B B E C

NA-125 LAHORE-VIII Khawaja Saad Rafique Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A A E B

NA-126 LAHORE-IX Shafqat Mehmood Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C C E C

NA-127 LAHORE-X Waheed Alam Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) C A A+ E B

NA-128 LAHORE-XI Muhammad Afzal Khokhar Pakistan Muslim League (N) C A D C C

NA-129 LAHORE-XII Shazia Mubashar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B A+ C B

NA-130 LAHORE-XIII Sohail Shoukat Butt Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A C B B

NA-131 SHEIKHUPURA-I Rana Afzaal Hussain Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B C B

NA-132 SHEIKHUPURA-II-CUM-NANKANA SAHIB Rana Tanveer Hussain Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B C B

NA-133 SHEIKHUPURA-III Mian Javid Latif Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C D D C

NA-134 SHEIKHUPURA-IV Sardar Muhammad Irfan Dogar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-135 NANKANA SAHIB-I Muhammad Barjees Tahir Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C D C

NA-136 NANKANA SAHIB-II Chaudhry Bilal Ahmed Virk Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-137 NANKANA SAHIB-III Dr. Shezra Mansab Ali Khan Kharal Pakistan Muslim League (N) A B A+ B A

NA-138 KASUR-I-CUM-LAHORE Salman Hanif Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C D C

NA-139 KASUR-II Waseem Akhtar Shaikh Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-140 KASUR-III Rasheed Ahmad Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B C B

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

9

NA-141 KASUR-IV Rana Muhammad Ishaq Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A C B

NA-142 KASUR-V Rana Muhammad Hayat Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C D C C

NA-143 OKARA-I Nadeem Abbas Rebaira Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-144 OKARA-II Chaudhry Riaz-ul-Haq Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C D C

NA-145 OKARA-II Syed Muhammad Ashiq Hussain Shah Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B D B

NA-146 OKARA-IV Rao Muhammad Ajmal Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A C B

NA-147 OKARA-V Muhammad Moeen Watto Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B C B

NA-148 MULTAN-I Malik Abdul Ghafar Dogar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B A B B

NA-149 MULTAN-II Malik Muhammad Amir Dogar Independent C B C D C

NA-150 MULTAN-III Makhdoom Shah Mahmood Qureshi Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C C D C

NA-151 MULTAN-IV Sikandar Hayyat khan Bosan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C B B

NA-152 MULTAN-V Syed Javed Ali Shah Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B B B

NA-153 MULTAN-VI Dewan Ashiq Hussain Bukhari Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C A B B

NA-154 LODHRAN-I Bye-election announced Bye-election announced C C B B B

NA-155 LODHRAN-II Abdul Rehman Khan Kanju Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B B B

NA-156 KHANEWAL-I Mohammad Raza Hayat Harraj Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-157 KHANEWAL-II Muhammad Khan Daha Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-158 KHANEWAL-III Aslam Bodla Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-159 KHANEWAL-IV Chaudhary Iftikhar Nazir Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A C B

NA-160 SAHIWAL-I Syed Imran Ahmad Shah Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C D C C

NA-161 SAHIWAL-II Chaudhary Muhammad Ashraf Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B C B

NA-162 SAHIWAL-III Rai Hasan Nawaz Khan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf B C B C B

NA-163 SAHIWAL-IV Chaudhry Muhammad Munir Azhar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-164 PAKPATTAN-I Sardar Mansab Ali Dogar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C A C B

NA-165 PAKPATTAN-II SM Athar Hussain Shah Gillani Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-166 PAKPATTAN-III Rana Zahid Hussain Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-167 VEHARI-I Chaudhary Nazeer Ahmed Pakistan Muslim League (N) C D B C C

NA-168 VEHARI-II Sajid Mehdi Pakistan Muslim League (N) C D B C C

NA-169 VEHARI-III Tahir Iqbal Chaudhry Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B C C

NA-170 VEHARI-IV Saeed Ahmed Khan Manais Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B C C

NA-171 DERA GHAZI KHAN-I Sardar Mohd Amjad Farooq Khan Khosa Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C C B B

NA-172 DERA GHAZI KHAN-II Hafiz Abdul Kareem Pakistan Muslim League (N) A+ C B C B

NA-173 DERA GHAZI KHAN-III Sardar Awais Ahmad Khan Leghari Independent A+ C B B B

NA-174 RAJANPUR-I Sardar Muhammad Jaffar Khan Leghari Pakistan Muslim League (N) A+ A E A B

NA-175 RAJANPUR-II Dr. Hafeez Ur Rehman Khan Drishak Pakistan Muslim League (N) A A D A B

NA-176 MUZAFFARGARH-I Malik Sultan Mehmood Hanjra Pakistan Muslim League (N) A+ B C B B

NA-177 MUZAFFARGARH-II Ghulam Rabbani Khar Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians A B D A B

NA-178 MUZAFFARGARH-III Jamshed Ahmad Independent A A C B B

NA-179 MUZAFFARGARH-IV Makhdoomzada Syed Basit Bokhari Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B B B

NA-180 MUZAFFARGARH-V Sardar Ashiq Hussain Gopang Pakistan Muslim League (N) A B D A B

NA-181 LAYYAH-I Sahibzada Faiz Ul Hassan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-182 LAYYAH-II Syed Muhammad Saqlain Shah Bukhari Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B B B

NA-183 BAHAWALPUR-I Makhdoom Syed Ali Hassan Gillani Pakistan Muslim League (N) A D B B B

NA-184 BAHAWALPUR-II Najibuddin Awaisi Pakistan Muslim League (N) A C B B B

NA-185 BAHAWALPUR-III Muhammad Baligh ur Rehman Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D C B C

NA-186 BAHAWALPUR-IV Mian Riaz Hussain Peerzada Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D C B C

NA-187 BAHAWALPUR-V Ch. Tariq Bashir Cheema Pakistan Muslim League B D B B B

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

10

NA-188 BAHAWALNAGAR-I Syed Muhammad Asghar Independent A C B B B

NA-189 BAHAWALNAGAR-II Alam Dad Laleka Pakistan Muslim League (N) A D B B B

NA-190 BAHAWALNAGAR-III Tahir Bashir Cheema Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B B B

NA-191 BAHAWALNAGAR-IV Muhammad Ijaz Ul Haq Pakistan Muslim League (Z) B D B B B

NA-192 RAHIM YAR KHAN-I Khwaja Ghulam Rasool Koreja Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians A C A B B

NA-193 RAHIM YAR KHAN-II Sheikh Fayyazuddin Pakistan Muslim League (N) A D B B B

NA-194 RAHIM YAR KHAN-III Makhdoom Khusro Bakhtiyar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B B B

NA-195 RAHIM YAR KHAN-IV Makhdoom Syed Mustafa Mehmood Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C C C B C

NA-196 RAHIM YAR KHAN-V Mian Imtiaz Ahmad Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B C C

NA-197 RAHIM YAR KHAN-VI Muhammad Arshad Khan Laghari Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B B B

NA-198 SUKKUR-SHIKARPUR(I) Nauman Islam Shaikh Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B D B C

NA-199 SUKKUR-CUM-SHIKARPUR (II) Syed Khursheed Ahmed Shah Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B C B C

NA-200 GHOTKI-I Ali Gohar Khan Mahar Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B C B C

NA-201 GHOTKI-II Sardar Ali Muhammad Khan Mahar Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians E B D B C

NA-202 SHIKARPUR Aftab Shahban Mirani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A C B B

NA-203 SHEIKHUPUR-SKR-LARKANA Ghous Bux Khan Mahar Pakistan Muslim League (F) D A C B B

NA-204 LARKANA Mohammad Ayaz Soomro Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B B A B

NA-205 LARKANA-KAMBER SHAHDADKOT Nazir Ahmed Bughio Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians E A D A C

NA-206 KAMBER SHAHDADKOT Mir Aamir Ali Khan Magsi Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians E A+ C A+ B

NA-207 LARKANA-SHIKHARPUR-KS Faryal Talpur Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A D A B

NA-208 JACOBABAD Aijaz Hussain Jakhrani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A+ C B B

NA-209 JACOBABAD-KASHMORE Mir Shabbir Ali Bijarani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A+ C A B

NA-210 KASHMORE Ehsan ur Rehman Mazari Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C A+ D A B

NA-211 NAUSHEHRO FEROZ-I Rais Ghulam Murtaza Khan Jatoi National Peoples Party D C C A C

NA-212 NAUSHEHRO FEROZ-II Asghar Ali Shah Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D C C A C

NA-213 NAWABSHAH-I Dr. Azra Fazal Pechuho Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C C C B C

NA-214 NAWABSHAH-II Syed Ghulam Mustafa Shah Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D D C B C

NA-215 KHAIRPUR-I Nawab Ali Wassan Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A C B B

NA-216 KHAIRPUR-II Pir Sadaruddin Shah Pakistan Muslim League (F) C C C B C

NA-217 KHAIRPUR-III Syed Kazim Ali Shah Pakistan Muslim League (F) D B C B C

NA-218 MATIARI-HYDERABAD Makhdoom Muhammad Ameen Fahim Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians E C D A C

NA-219 HYDERABAD-I Dr. Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D B B B B

NA-220 HYDERABAD-II Syed Waseem Hussain Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C C B B B

NA-221 HYDERABAD-CUM-MATIARI Syed Amir Ali Shah Jamote Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B C A B

NA-222 HYDERABAD V Syed Naveed Qamar Shah Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B D A C

NA-223 TANDO ALLAHYAR-MATIARI Abdul Sattar Bachani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D D C B C

NA-224 BADIN-TM KHAN-I Sardar Kamal Khan Chang Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B C A B

NA-225 BADIN-TM KHAN-II Dr Fehmida Mirza Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C B D A B

NA-226 MIRPUR KHAS-UMERKOT (I) Pir Shafqat Hussain Shah Jilani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians E C C A C

NA-227 MIRPURKHAS-UMERKOT (II) Mir Munawar Ali Talpur Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B C B C

NA-228 UMERKOT Nawab Muhammad Yousif Talpur Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D D D A C

NA-229 THARPARKAR-I Faqir Sher Muhammad Bilaiani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B E A C

NA-230 THARPARKAR-II Pir Noor Muhammad Shah Jeelani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B E A C

NA-231 JAMSHORO Malik Asad Sikandar Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A C B B

NA-232 DADU-I Rafiq Ahmed Jamali Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C A+ C A B

NA-233 DADU-II Imran Zafar Leghari Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A B A B

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

11

NA-234 SANGHAR-I Pir Bux Junejo Pakistan Muslim League (F) D C C B C

NA-235 SANGHAR-M’KHAS-UMERKOT Shazia Marri Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D D D A C

NA-236 SANGHAR-II Roshan Din Junejo Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C B B B B

NA-237 THATTA-I Shamas-un-Nisa Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B E A C

NA-238 THATTA-II Syed Ayaz Ali Shah Sheerazi Pakistan Muslim League (N) D B E A C

NA-239 KARACHI-I Mohammad Salman Khan Baloch Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D B B B B

NA-240 KARACHI-II Sohail Mansoor Khawaja Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C B A A B

NA-241 KARACHI-III Syed Akhterul Iqbal Qadri Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D B E A C

NA-242 KARACHI-IV Mehboob Alam Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D A B B B

NA-243 KARACHI-V Abdul Waseem Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C C C B C

NA-244 KARACHI-VI Sheikh Salahuddin Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C C A A B

NA-245 KARACHI-VII Muhammad Rehan Hashmi Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C B C B B

NA-246 KARACHI-VIII Kanwar Naveed Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D A C B B

NA-247 KARACHI-IX Sufyan Yousuf Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D B C B C

NA-248 KARACHI-X Shah Jahan Baloch Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C B B B B

NA-249 KARACHI-XI Dr. Muhammad Farooq Sattar Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D B A A B

NA-250 KARACHI-XII Dr. Arif Alvi Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C D B C

NA-251 KARACHI-XIII Syed Ali Raza Abidi Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C A+ A B A

NA-252 KARACHI-XIV Adbul Rashid Godil Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C B C B B

NA-253 KARACHI-XV Muhammad Muzammil Qureshi Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C B D B C

NA-254 KARACHI-XVI Muhammad Ali Rashid Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C A B B B

NA-255 KARACHI-XVII Syed Asif Husnain Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C A A B B

NA-256 KARACHI-XVIII Iqbal Muhammad Ali Khan Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D C C B C

NA-257 KARACHI-XIX Sajid Ahmed Muttahidda Qaumi Movement D B C B C

NA-258 KARACHI-XX Abdul Hakeem Baloch Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B C B B

NA-259 QUETTA Mehmood Khan Achakzai Pukhtoonkhwa Milli Awami Party C B A B B

NA-260 QUETTA-CHAGAI-NUSHKI-M Abdul Rahim Mandokhail Pukhtoonkhwa Milli Awami Party A B B A A

NA-261 PISHIN-CUM-ZIARAT Moulvi Agha Muhammad Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) B B C A B

NA-262 KILLA ABDULLAH Abdul Qahar Khan Wadan Pukhtoonkhwa Milli Awami Party B C B A B

NA-263 LORALAI-MUSAKHEL-B Maulana Ameer Zaman Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) C C D A C

NA-264 ZHOB-SHERANI-KILLA S Maulana Muhammad Khan Sherani Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) D B C A B

NA-265 SIBI-KOHLU-DB-HARNAI Mir Dostain Khan Domki Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C D B C

NA-266 NASIRABAD-JAFFARABAD Zafarullah Khan Jamali Pakistan Muslim League (N) E B C B C

NA-267 KACHHI-CUM-JHAL MAGSI Khalid Hussain Magsi Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B E A B

NA-268 KALAT-CUM-MUSTUNG Sardar Kamal Khan Bangulzai National Party B B D A B

NA-269 KHUZDAR Maulana Qamar ud Din Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) C B E A C

NA-270 AWARAN-CUM-LASBELA Jam Kamal Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B B B B

NA-271 KHARAN-WASHUK-PANJGUR Lt.G.Rtd. Abdul Qadir Baloch Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C A B

NA-272 KECH-CUM-GWADER Syed Essa Nori Balochistan National Party A B B B B

Overall GRADE C C B B C

Reserved seats for women

NA-2 PESHAWAR-II Sajida Begum Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B C C

NA-2 PESHAWAR-II Aaisha Gulalai Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C C B C C

NA-2 PESHAWAR-II Begum Tahira Bukhari Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C B C C

NA-5 NOWSHERA-I Nafeesa Inayatullah Khan Khattak Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf C D A C C

NA-10 MARDAN-II Naeema Kishwar Khan Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) C C B B B

NA-27 LAKKI MARWAT Shahida Akhtar Ali Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) C C B B B

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

12

NA-29 SWAT-I Mussarat Ahmadzeb Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf A A+ C C B

NA-29 SWAT-I Aisha Sayed Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan A A+ C C B

NA-48 ISLAMABAD-I Anusha Rahman Ahmad Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) Data not available

NA-49 ISLAMABAD-II Farhana Qamar Pakistan Muslim League (N) Data not available

NA-53 RAWALPINDI-IV Asyia Naz Tanoli Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B C B

NA-54 RAWALPINDI-V Zahra Wadood Fatemi Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C D C

NA-55 RAWALPINDI-VI Seema Mohiuddin Jameeli Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C C D C

NA-56 RAWALPINDI-VII Tahira Aurangzeb Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C D C

NA-56 RAWALPINDI-VII Marriyum Aurangzeb Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C D C

NA-60 CHAKWAL-I Iffat Liaqat Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C B C C

NA-62 JHELUM-I Nighat Parveen Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-76 FAISALABAD-II Khalida Mansoor Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C B C B

NA-94 TOBA TEK SINGH-III Belum Hasnain Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C C B C C

NA-97 GUJRANWALA-III Shazia Ashfaq Mattu Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C C B

NA-97 GUJRANWALA-III Romina Khurshid Alam Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C C B

NA-110 SIALKOT-I Phyllis Azeem Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B D E C

NA-110 SIALKOT-I Shaza Fatima Khawaja Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B D E C

NA-115 NAROWAL-I Surriya Asghar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B B B B

NA-122 LAHORE-V Kiran Imran Dar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C D C

NA-123 LAHORE-VI Shaista Pervaiz Pakistan Muslim League (N) C A C E C

NA-125 LAHORE-VIII Leila Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A A E B

NA-125 LAHORE-VIII Arifa Khalid Pervaiz Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A A E B

NA-125 LAHORE-VIII Shazadi Umarzadi Tiwana Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A A E B

NA-125 LAHORE-VIII Amra Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A A E B

NA-125 LAHORE-VIII Munaza Hassan Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf B A A E B

NA-125 LAHORE-VIII Shakila Luqman Pakistan Muslim League (N) B A A E B

NA-126 LAHORE-IX Rida Khan Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C C E C

NA-126 LAHORE-IX Dr. Asma Mamdot Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C C E C

NA-126 LAHORE-IX Tahmina Daultana Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C C E C

NA-149 MULTAN-II Shaheen Shafiq Pakistan Muslim League (N) C B C D C

NA-157 KHANEWAL-II Begum Majeeda Wyne Pakistan Muslim League (N) B C C C C

NA-172 DERA GHAZI KHAN-II Shahnaz Saleem Malik Pakistan Muslim League (N) A+ C B C B

NA-175 RAJANPUR-II Dr. Shireen Mehrunnisa Mazari Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf A A D A B

NA-185 BAHAWALPUR-III Parveen Masood Bhatti Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D C B C

NA-185 BAHAWALPUR-III Sabiha Nazir Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D C B C

NA-196 RAHIM YAR KHAN-V Zeb Jaffar Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B C C

NA-196 RAHIM YAR KHAN-V Maiza Hameed Pakistan Muslim League (N) B D B C C

NA-199 SUKKUR-SHIKARPUR (II) Shahjehan Mangrio Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B C B C

NA-199 SUKKUR-SHIKARPUR (II) Dr. Shazia Sobia Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D B C B C

NA-215 KHAIRPUR-I Nafisa Shah Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A C B B

NA-215 KHAIRPUR-I Mahreen Razaque Bhutto Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A C B B

NA-218 MATIARI-HYDERABAD Shagufta Jumani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians E C D A C

NA-233 DADU-II Musarat Rafique Mahesar Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians D A B A B

NA-237 THATTA-I Marvi Memon Pakistan Muslim League (N) D B E A C

NA-250 KARACHI-XII Surriya Jatoi Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C C D B C

NA-250 KARACHI-XII Reeta Ishwar Pakistan Muslim League (F) C C D B C

NA-250 KARACHI-XII Dr. Fouzia Hameed Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C C D B C

Constituency MNA Political party Facilities

grade Retention

grade

Gender parity grade

Student-teacher

ratio grade

Overall grade

13

NA-253 KARACHI-XV Shahida Rehmani Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians C B D B C

NA-253 KARACHI-XV Kishwer Zehra Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C B D B C

NA-253 KARACHI-XV Saman Sultana Jafri Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C B D B C

NA-253 KARACHI-XV Dr. Nikhat Shakeel Khan Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C B D B C

NA-260 QUETTA-CHAGAI-NUSHKI-M Kiran Haider Pakistan Muslim League (N) A B B A A

NA-260 QUETTA-CHAGAI-NUSHKI-M Naseema Pukhtoonkhwa Milli Awami Party A B B A A

NA-260 QUETTA-CHAGAI-NUSHKI-M Aliya Kamran Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) A B B A A

Reserved seats for minorities

NA-54 RAWALPINDI-V Isphanyar M. Bhandara Pakistan Muslim League (N) B B C D C

NA-66 SARGODHA-III Tariq Christopher Qaiser Pakistan Muslim League (N) C C A C B

NA-201 GHOTKI-II Dr. Darshan Pakistan Muslim League (N) E B D B C

NA-205 LARKANA-KS Ramesh Lal Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians E A D A C

NA-228 UMERKOT Lal Chand Malhi Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf D D D A C

NA-229 THARPARKAR-I Dr. Ramesh Kumar Vankwani Pakistan Muslim League (N) D B E A C

NA-234 SANGHAR-I Bhawan Das Pakistan Muslim League (N) D C C B C

NA-250 KARACHI-XII Sanjay Perwani Muttahidda Qaumi Movement C C D B C

NA-259 QUETTA Aasiya Nasir Jamiat Ulama-e-Islam (F) C B A B B

NA-260 QUETTA-CHAGAI-NUSHKI-M Khalil George Pakistan Muslim League (N) A B B A A

14