akıllı tasarım
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
1/29
4
N^N^EE POMMO KLDE ]DSD^OALD^0
DGOLLO ]DSD^OA!JY^ASJL ]DSD^OA
Je nyg }jhlogj dglspl, dglllg kld~dg f~mepmj ndld~
R~ki% M~% Dlo Mjao~sky, Hdcj}}jrj eoj~so}jso
Ndp no~jylj~mj gdl}sdl no~ ejmjelj k~}dyd gde sk~zeld~ Dekadlo
yd md Hds}dlg kld~dg dmldem~l~% yo no~ }dsd~amd nz dekadlolj~oe ho
kladads yd md kg sjy~jg klads njgljeo~% Hlnzgo nzfe }nnje hj~
oesdemd mkz}de je dp 42 dekadloeoe klmzz syljeo~% Nz ek~adl
}dsd~ldea no~ d~dndee njgljeolajyje no~ d~pd fs}j~ajso fono no~
jymo~% G} pj~oemj nylj no~ hd}d njgljeajp7 oadld} s~dsemd k~}dyd
gd~% Mkldysyld nzed ~j}oa hd}ds mjeo~ j sz }dsd~ldycsed
ygljeajp% Dgll }dsd~ad f~j no~ cdelee }dsd~ldeadsemde laej
gdmd~ fjje s~jlj~ mkds} f }d~diemde mjej}ljeajg}jmo~ j
mkldysyld hja }dsd~a ddadsemd hja mj ~j}oa s~jco oj~osoemj
nop ideo d~lgld~e gzsz~z kladmde! k~}dyd gdnoljcjg }a
dgsdglgld~mde mkds} f sk~zalzmz~% Decdg hja yj}golo j hj~ jyj
gdmo~ kl hja mj hd}d ydr ogoljaoeo pjajyje mkfad}oglj~, gd~ ]dgmo~o
ldho, ydeo mkds} fce os}jo yd md }dgmo~o kld~dg szed~dg hja
gjemolj~oeo hja mj gd~ld~emdgolj~o gdem~adee yklzez nzlazld~m~%
Jloaopmj klde yd md kladyde fjljnoljcjg hj~ klzaszplzze idolo yd md
sk~zalzsz nzlzeaz}z~0 No~ }~l hjsdr sk~dadydcdap,zlddadydcdap, ej jmj~ ej ydrd~sd oyomo~ moyj oedemap Mkds}
F7 kzazpd f~j ]de~% Nyljcj oesdelg }d~oho nkyzecd gzsz~zazp
klsze yd md kladse z~dmap hj~ pd~d~ nyg no~ }jjggl (gdnzl/ olj
njeoasjyjcjoaop no~ ijlsjijyj sdrldea klmzg%
Decdg hj~gjs}j hj~ pdade f~lje, ydeo no~ dekadlo kld~dg mjol mj,
fjejl no~ }dsd~a hd}ds kld~dg hj~gjsoe fpljmoo ydr j oljyolj~j ej
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
2/29
>
moyjcjop7 nz sjij~ ]dg}o~o oldho mjajylj d}ld}dadyp% eg }dgmo~,
no~kg sjjejoe d~dsemd no~osoej ldyg f~lje no~ jyo oidmj jmj~% _deo
ndapd no~ njld fjlaosj, ycj ]de~ k o ooe njeo sjao mjajg}o~%
Mkfadyd oedeyk~sdep ydrdcdep no~ jy kldadp, gdnzl jmjcjgsoeop%
Jj~ oedeayk~sdep ejmjeoeo d~d}~dcdgsep, fj~jgo~sj j~ yd md fj
d~jsoeo nzldcdgsep% Decdg, no~ gzsz~ sdmjcj no~ }krlzaze no~osoemj
mjol mj hj~gjs}j nzlzezyk~sd, k }dgmo~o oldho kladg}de ga, fjejl no~
}dsd~a gzsz~z klaz}z~% Nz }dsd~a gzsz~ld~ jj~ hj~ jyo nolje j hj~
jyj gdmo~ no~ d~lg }d~diemde ydrlasd, k pdade nz d~le, gzlld~
klde noplj~ ooe oyo eoyj}oemje gzgz mzydnolo~op% eg ho goasj mz~zrmz~z~gje go}lj hdloemj jpoyj} j}ajyo dadldadp% Nzeze }dea
rsogklk`omj yd md sksyklk`omj hk kladyde kg d~ no~ }deam~
Fjloe f~e go, k~}dl dgll }dsd~a jljljsoej j~je no~kg oesde
(nzeld~e d~dsemd ej ydpg go noloa dmda7 hd}}d noloalj~oe noloao
moyjnoljcjoaop noyklk`o dldeemd dldeld~/, ddmd yplj~cjsoeoe
d~dsemde j~olao sdmjcj no~gd fjejl gzsz~ze ejmje mkds} f
}d~diemde ~jd f~lme no~ }~l dgldydayk~% Akljglj~ yd md
hc~j mpjyoej oemooaopmj hd}dl }dsd~ald olfolo keld~cd ~ejg j~jnolo~op%
Decdg nz ~ejglj~ kg dgdmjaog gdldcdemde, nz gkezmd yj}j~oecj
nolfoso kladydeld~ deldadg}d pk~ldednolo~ moyj j~olajao}o~% Mkz}de
ygsjg }desoyke, jgj~ hds}ds, jo} jo} yj}ajploglj~, gds j gjaog
nkpzglzgld~ j njepj~ keld~cdse gooyj pf klmzz fjejl no~ mz~zazydes}adm ooe fjejl no~ }dsd~a hd}ds kld~dg! femjaj
fj}o~ajyjcjop% Nz ejmjelj j~jcjoaop }dsd~a hd}dld~ed ologoe
~ejglj~ pjlloglj hjaje hj~gjsoe hj~ pdade }deg klmzz kczgld~mdgo
ndp gzsz~ld~mde ydeo fjejl }dsd~a hd}dld~emde! sjolao}o~% Nzeze
ejmjeo, dgll }dsd~acld~e, k~}dyd ga gzsz~z, j~foe gooeoe szld~ed
fedhld~ed! ndldadsemde gz~}zladg ooemo~%
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
3/29
3
4% kczg ny}je j fjcjlj~oeo zygzszp fjo~je hj~gjs zeze
id~gemdm~% kczgld~ mkmzgld~ee olg no~gd dyemd ndpje kg
mdhd zpze s~j fdp sk~zez yddyd~dg doljlj~oeo j gjemolj~oeo
rj~ode jmj~lj~% Nz fdp yd dedmde fjj~ yd md kczze soemo~oa
sos}jaoemjgo }dsd~a hd}dsemde gdyedglde~%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, dd}de ddcd d}ld~gje dedsee
s~}ed ydrd~dg, hj~ s~dy}d s~jglo fdpe gd~de no~ cdelee
nylj no~ sk~zez klada}~% Nz ejmjelj r~oad} yd~zld~ fdp
sdecld~ jgajp% Ej pdadego mkdl yddamde j mkdl j~oa
s~jcoemje dy~lmg, nz sk~ze gd~apd g}% Decdg j~oasjl
ydrsdl mjooa, sksydl j~oaj dydg zymz~dadm ooe, pdadeemd
fj~jglo eljalj~ klzdadm%
>% kczgld~e o gzldg olj dp d~dsemdgo s}dgo nk~zsz, ek~adlmje
gsd klmzz ooe dpmdgo aog~krld~ sg sg k~}d gzldd fjj~ j no~
s~ sk~zed ejmje klz~% R~oad}ld~md nz sk~ze d~ a7 nyg no~
kldslgld ykg%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, sksydl fjloajlj~o
~jejnolajg ooe, gdids njgljeoljemje kg mdhd nyg kld~dg
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
4/29
=
meydyd fjlajyj pk~ldea no~ kczg}d nz sk~zeze k~}dyd gads
gdeladpm~% Dcdnd mkds} f oesdee sksydl yddad fjooeo
noljaoyk~ azymz; _kgsd nylj no~ mlj gd~ cjpd a zyfzldadyd
gdlg};
3% kczgld~e, pjlloglj gp kczgld~ee om~d~ gjsjsoeo md~yd
ndldyde gdedl j~ogoelj~j f~j gsd klads ejmjeoylj sg sg om~d~
yklld~ hds}dlgld~ed }z}zladg}dm~% Ej klz~mz nz nk~zyz no~dp mdhd
zpze kld~dg ydrd~dg yd~d}sdym;
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, m~} dydee s}emj fjpje
no~ cdel ooe nz gsdle nyg no~ sdgecds ykg}z7 ej pdade go,
yj~j oeor mj olg kld~dg k}z~d k}z~d ske~d ogo dydap pj~oemj
fjpajyj ndldmg7 k}z~mzzazp yj~mjgo aog~krld~ kg mdhd gkldy
olj~j gdmd~ fo~jnolmoo ooe nz sk~zeld~ k~}dyd g}% K pdade
sk~adpld~ a, njeo ogo dyda pj~oej gdlm~~gje, nz nk~zyz eoyj
no~ ogo sde}oa zpd}adme;
=% Rjeos}jgo seej} mj~oso kzelzg hj~hdefo no~ sk~zed ejmje
kladmde mkza kladsed gd~e, no~ gsaemd om~d~ ydrdadydcdg
mj~jcjmj gdrdl klmzz ooe ejalo sk~zeld~d ejmje kladg}dm~% Nz
mj~oeoe j~ogoe kladmde gjsolajso osj Azsjo j slda oedeced
f~j }de~ee os}jomo~% Nz mj~oeoe d}lads s~dsemd, yoej nz ogo
moeoe mj k~}dg kld~dg no~lj}oo oedecd, ydeo kczgld~e szszp kld~dg
mkmzz oedeced gd~e, aolykeld~cd kczze seej} oljao
s~dsemd aog~kr gdradsemde mkldy lajsoeo edsl
dgldydcdgsep; Fedhspld~e cjpd jgajso hono~ ~j}omj hk
gd~ldedadp%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, nz mj~o gdrdl mz~d~dg om~d~
yklld~ee j rjeos ndee klds jeijgsoykeld~ eljajg ooe
ajymded fjlao}o~% Mkdl k~}damd j~ yd md fj ek~adl oljoeo
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
5/29
:
f~ajyj ndld~7 decdg njplj~j sd~la gdrdl k~}damd yj}o}o~olje
no~ no~jymj nz dgsdgle fomj~olajso pk~ klz~%
:% Nzfe hdefo kczg mkg}k~zed fomj~sjeop fomoe, kczd ndgadmde
M o}daoeo mj oj~je no~ old ydpyk~% Nzez azhdggdg dladlsep
moyk~% Nz~dmd no~oso ydelyk~, yd mkg}k~ yd md mkds} f% eg
dgll }dsd~a klsdym, ded s} olj no~log}j nz admmjlj~ mj j~olao
kldcdg}%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, oesde, fej ee kg ykze
klmzz Mkz Di~ogdmd j~oalj}ooemje M o}daoeoeoe klzads ooe
jg no~ gdyedd oh}oyd mzyzlada}% Ej pdade go gzpjyj ydylm,
jgsoglog k~}dyd g}% Mpjl}oljnolo~ aoymo; kg ndso} no~gd eljalj
nz jgsoglog fomj~oljnolo~mo% Pd}je cdelld~e hjaje hjrso (nopmje
ndgd yj~ mjo}o~je ogo ajajlo hd~o/ nzlzemzgld~ yj~mj gdlmgld~
ooe fj~jglo M o}daoeoeo sje}jpljajg}jmo~lj~% Nzez yj~ mjo}o~je
oesde ydrdadm ooe, fo}}oo yj~mj pjlloglj fej eld~ee
jgsoglooemje mkldy nkpzglzg k~}dyd gadg}dm~% Jj~ dgll
}dsd~acld~e oedem fono oesdeklz k~}d gzdg}d nzlzede no~
yj~mj meydyd oeao klsdld~m, nylj no~ jgsogloo
yddadydcdgld~m% Mjajg go no~ jeljamje n~ jeljaj fjoecj
dgll }dsd~a dglsp }dsd~a hdloej mea% Eoyj mpjl}olajao;
Mkd dglyld mjol, sjjejglj~o ~ds}lde}yld sj}oo ooe hj~ pdade
mk~z yklz nzldadp7 nz ejmjelj mj nz fej gdmd~ `jklk og
mejalj~mj nd~emd nd~em~m ydgldg >2 aolyke (njlgo 422
aolyke/ cdel }~e nz dglsp }dsd~ad gz~nde j}ao}o~%
Dye jgolmj kczg ydeo hono~ fedh j gzsz~ oljajao no~ d~lg!
mkd~ mkadp ndldyde ej~jmjysj kgzld fomoecjyj gdmd~ hj~ dy
}jg~d~ldede no~ d iz~ydse memep a; Hjrd}o}!N,
}nj~glkp, ojg, kczg ijlco, gdndgzldg, gpdag, gpl, pd}~~jj,
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
6/29
9
osdl, nkadcd7 mdhd ejlj~ fjljcjg noljaoyk~zp% Moyk~za go
mzyfzld~apld hd~jgj} j}ajyjloa7 no~dp mejloa% No~ mkds}
f, oesded hono~ cdelyd edsor kladyde oedyj}lj~mj nzlzezyk~%
~ejoe laemje ske~d fomjnoljcjo hj~ oyolooe ajcz} klmzz
no~ cjeej} dd} jmoyk~ (ndgd hono~ cdelyd cjeej} dd}
jmolajao}o~/, keld~d rjyfdanj~lj~ femj~oyk~, go}drld~ oemo~oyk~,
dgl j~oyk~, iogo~ j~oyk~ (gzlldedayk~sdg nz nopoa sk~zezazp/% Fjl
fjljloa go, o~s j ndg}j~olj~j nopo gz~nde jmoyk~% Eoyj; Fj~jg
noyklkfld~ j pjlloglj j~oacolj~ nzeze yde} noloyk~; Dgll
}dsd~acld~e md hj~ jyj iogo~ y~}}glj~o fono nzed md no~ gyklz nzldcdgld~emde gzgzezp kladse%
J~oacoyj sk~d~sdep; Mkd goasjyj ecjlog j id~gl no~ s}d}
}deada}~% Hj~ cdel fono nopoa mj rd~dpo}lj~oaop kldcdg% Mkdmd
nzlzede cdelld~ hono~ cdelee fpee yded ndgadp hjlj hjlj
J~jio Adhlg fono no~ pjl mz~zaz ho }deadp, oesde moj~
cdelld~mde gjsoeloglj dy~adp, ked pjl no~ oa}oydp }deadp%
Mkdee olj}oa sos}jaoemj nk nzlmzze yj~j yj~ljjcjgsoe, sjeo
se~ldyde no~ j}gje k~}dyd gecdyd gdmd~ md skeze gdmd~ md
gzlldedcdgse olgjso oesde ooe mj fjj~lomo~% Nyljcj fjao}j moj~
cdelld~e }aee nded fjlmoo fono (nz ejmjelj hj~ cdelee
rd~dpo}o j aog~knog hds}dl d~m~/, oesde czmzez md nk nzlde,
rd~dpo}loj joloalo no~kg cdel, fo}}ogj olj~ljyje no~ j}goeloglj oesdeczmzed yj~ljajyj yd md nz k~}damd ~jajyj yd md fjoco
kld~dg gzlldeadyd ndldm j jo} jo} rd~dpo}log j hds}dlgld~
k~}dyd g}% esdeklz nzeld~e no~ gsaee d~jsoeo nzld~dg nz
i~sd}ld~ }aylj ykg j}}o (ojg hds}dlee j}ajeo fono/ yd md
hd~jgj} yj}jejglj~oeo oyocj gs}ldm (nd~sdg rd~dpo}lj~o, kczg ijlco,
gpdag, gdndgzldgfono/, no~ gsaee md hjep d~jsoeo nzldadm
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
7/29
6
(DOMS fono/% Nyljcj j~oaco sopj skez kld~dg zez syljyjcjg}o~0
Hds}dlgld~ j gzsz~ld~ eljajeoe yklz ydld~admde j mzdld~mde
mjol noloasjl d~d}~adld~mde fjj~ moyjcjg}o~%
9% Hjaje hjaje hono~ oljj sdhor kladyde >2 yd molj~oaop
kzazpze gk~gzlz ~yds klaz7 no~kzazpd g} felj~
ydd}a}~% Mkfad}oglj~ nzeze ooe gja ga no~ jylj~ syljsjlj~
mj ho goasj oedem~c no~ dgldadse ydrdadadg}dm~% edeld~d
f~j oesde dyeje yd~d}lasd, j~oaljajaosj, >2 yd molj~o mj
oesdee nded njld kld~dg j~olao}o~%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, nz molj~ k}zl (mdhd kg k}
yjmooaop/ mejamj }aj ooemj gzlldelyk~mz7 mdhd ske~d
kaeok~ (ydeo hj~ jyo yj~ hdlj fjoecj/, pjlloglj mj
yoyjcjglj~oaopo roo~j~jg mdhd yzazdg hdlj fj}o~oecj fj~jg
gdladm ooe mkdl sjoloa olj k~}dmde gdlm~ad s~jcoej
skgzlaz}z~% J~oa, sdn~l j s~jglo no~ oljyooe dm klmzz ooe mj,
hjaje k~}dmde gdlm~ldada, pdaded n~dgla}~%
6% Ks}jkrk~dp (gjaog j~oajso/% Nzfe g~g yde fjao hj~gjsoe
gk~gzlz ~ydsm~ j fjoco mj klsd }jmdoso ooe ejalo hd~cdadld~
ydrladg}dm~% Hj~ jyo nolje mkds} f, a~ape k~}dld~emd
ejmje nopo klz}z~de osgjlj}oe ooeo nkdl}se j g~gld~ld z~d}~se%
Nzeld~e ooej hj~ njsoeoaopmj nklcd nzldnoljcjoaop gdlsoyzaz
yj~lj}o~aj f a kldcdg}; _kgsd nz md a }dgmo~o oldho hdejsoej
ydpldcdg;
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, gjaoglj~ olj f~m
s~jcj j mkdmd f gzlldem s~jcj sdlgl gdl~7 s~jglo go}dr
kgzyde j mzd jmje no~oeoe, gjaoglj~ (nz ndldamd gdsld~/
pj~oemjgo }kezs (ndse j}goso/ dpdldcd ooe ooeo nkdl}ads
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
8/29
8
gdeladpm~% J~oa, fj~jglj~ pj~oemje olj ydrd~, dcadspm~,
}d~dispm~7 mzyfzld~ j sjfolj~ pj~oemje mjol
8% Jllo yde fjao hj~ j~gjoe dgl r~ks}d}emdm~% kzelzg mk~z
m~s} ojyjajp, klz~ kladp yj~mj ojajyj gdlg~7 nz ejmjelj
gded gded no~ jy hd}}d sz nolj ojajp% ]zdlj}oe ndemd
mdgogdld~cd njglj~% Mdhd ske~d jjysjl oljlj~o dgsdm ooe
gd~semde dpd~ oo}o~7 ddlde~7 sjado moelj~oe s}e d~lg kld~dg
}dealdm k j~gjg sgla rgla no~ gjmoyj (gjmo nolj mjeajp
klsd klsd rosog mjajg fj~jgo~/ me~ j mdhd md dhoao j~ yd md
fj gdesj~ljajyj ndld~% Mkgsde yded fjlao no~ oesdee *?2
r~ks}d} gdesj~o klad kldsl d~m~% Mkfad}oglj~ dglld~e gz}sdl
go}dr}dgo nolfolj~lj nkpmzgld~ j r~ks}d} md nz go}drld~e nzlzemzz
mejamj noloeajmoo ooe no~gd ydge dyj} j hdmoslj njlgo
fjo}o~jnolo~lj~7 decdg je oyoso nz gkezyd ho mjoeajajg}o~
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, k sopj mj~ go, r~ks}d} njpo,
sdhejyj gd~gje kpaks, ydeo sz fjolj~oeo mpjeljaj fono no~
f~jo s}ljeajg ooe k~}dyd ga}7 decdg pdadeld ndgd
oljlj~o mj ygljeoecj, klads fj~jgjemje idpld no~ f~jo mdhd
s}ljemo j ndd~l md kldadm% Jj~ no~ d~l gk~gzld~emde
d~em~adg ooe }dsd~a ydra klsdymep, ogo rd~dlg no~ soioeg}j~
(gdrdg/ olj nz sk~zez pj~moeop% Decdg, j~oa fjljcjg ooe rlde
gz~adp, k demd fj~jgsoeaj mzyzlde jylj~o je oyo jgolmj sjajyj
gdlg~% Nz ejmjelj mj j~oa hj~ pdade agjaajlo nzldadp%
42% Ajekrkpd fo~ao hj~ gdmee ~dhoa gdesj~o j ajaj gdesj~o
gk~gzlz ~ydsm~% kczg ydrad yj}osoeo yo}o~ao j ndgd no~ f~jo
gdlada no~ k~fdee cz}}de gdlm~lads kg pk~ noyklk`og olja
mjolmo~% Nylj no~ gk~gzyz oesdeld~d ydd}adee ej delda d~;
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
9/29
?
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, k sopj mj~ go, mkd no~
cdelee ~jaj fce yo}o~ao no~ no~jyo nd~em~adg fono no~ lgs
kladm ooe zyfze ye}jao fjlo}o~aj mjejajsoej fo~oajao}o~%
44% Ej~jmjysj hj~ goomje no~o kaz~fd ~dhd}spl jgajg}jmo~%
Moj~ cdelld~d ndgyk~szezp njlo gdyde cdel ykg fono% Nz oesded
jpoyj} eoyj; Dgll }dsd~acld~ ]de~ee j~moo k~fde gk~zadg
fj~jgo~ moyj no~ ydgldald gkezyz sdsdgldadyd gdlg~ld~%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, k sopj mj~ go, no~ pdadeld~
m~} dydg pj~oej y~yje d}dld~ap, d~l }a kaz~fdyd
md}} j kez md m~} ekg}dmde }kr~dd j~moo ooe nylj no~
sk~zeld gd~ldadm% Decdg ogo dyd pj~oej gdlgecd, d~lg
aj~gjpo =!:% kaz~ld~e d~dsed ykzeld}, nz~ds md yj}j~oecj
gdsld mjs}jgljejajmoo ooe j j~oa ajgdeopads mjejaj!
ydelad ye}jao olj dl} ydeo kg d~ oljmoo ooe mj nz gdmd~
gsd s~j ooemj fj~jglo eljao fjlo}o~jajmo% Nyljcj ej
zpd}}ap ogo jloaoplj }z}dcdap no~ golklzg no~ yg, gdlm~d aosdlo
=!:% kaz~ld~d >2 golklzg no~ ndsg klz}z~mz%
4>% Hjaje hono~ hdydemd f~lajyje i}g j pjlloglj gdsg i}
eoyj oesdeld~md f~lyk~ moyj mejnolo~soeop% Dgll }dsd~acld~
decdg no~ ecjgo yde} j~jnolo~lj~%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, k sopj mj~ go, no~ pdadeld~m~} dydg pj~oej fjpmooaop ooe o k~fdeld~ pjlloglj }js}oslj~oe
cz} med g} gdedld (oefzeodl gdedld/ ndse ydrayk~mz7 ej
pdade go ogo dydg pj~oej gdlg}g, o k~fdeld~ ndse ydrecd,
pjlloglj njlo~lo no~ yd}de ske~d nd~sdgld~ nz gdedlmde md~yd
sd~gadyd ndld~% J~oasjl fjloaj nz dgsdgl eoyj mpjl}ajmo;
_d no~ gd~ ykl nzldadm yd md fjlo}o~ajg ooe yj}j~oecj pdade
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
10/29
42
nzldadm% Dgll no~ }dsd~a klsdym hja nz sk~zez hja mj
yzgd~mdgo sk~zez no~ ~rmd pjcjg d~jyo y~~lj gkyd~m%
43% Jsgoyj do} oesde iksollj~oej ndgyk~zp7 ~g mo hjaje hjaje ykg
(no~dp md j~gje lmglj~oemje mkldy/7 decdg ej pdade go njsoelj~oeo
}r, roo~ajyj j pjlloglj mj }dhlld njsljeajyj ndlyk~ld~, k
pdade mo ~glj~o k~}dyd gyk~% Mkds} f oesde dho no~
hdyde fono mkdmd mkldse moyj ao }dsd~ldm; Zyfd~ld fjjcjo
j fjo}j yddedcdg sk~zeld~ }dhaoe jmoljajp aoymo; Dgll
}dsd~acld~d sk~adepd fj~jg ykg7 eg keld~ nzlzede nzecd
oesded do} iksolo pd}je oesde ejsloeoe d}ds kld~dg gdnzl j}aoyk~ld~%
esdee pjanollj fg}je oemooej oedeyk~ld~%
Decdg no~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep, mo ~ajlj~o ejmje
klzyk~; moyj, k sopj mj~ go, }dhlld njsljeaj, adydldeadyd ndl
kld~dg dpmd dsomog }jrgoajlj~oe j deadld~e ajymded
fjlajsoeo }j}ogljmoo ooe klaz}z~ moyjcjg}o~% Nz }dsd~a hd}dse
fomj~jnolajg ooe mj dgda!sdndh adczeld~ld i~dldad yklzed
fomj~op%
4=% Dgda sdndh hdamklsze j~mooe eoaj}lj~j moyj mzd jmoyk~zp% Nz
gdmd~ jo}lo yoyjcjg j~moo ooe% Rjgl, ydgldg =22%222 no}go
kladsed gd~e eoyj mdhd kg jo}lo ajyj j sjnpj szeadme
no~ }~l dglapd fj}o~aoyk~zp% eg kldemde ndgdse
mejaoyk~zp% Mejnolajeop ooe j~oa ade}ed sdhor
kladep fj~jgo~7 k md nopmj ykg%
esde klz}zg}de kg mdhd ske~dgo mjo~lj~j ndgdcdg klz~sdg,
nzfe eoaj} kld~dg }dealdmap sjnpj j ajyjlj~oe j gjpd
hdydeld~e ho no~oeo f~jajyop% Mkd, jlady, d~azmz, go~dp,
gdysy, rk~}dgdl, ji}dloyo, as~, mkad}jso, sdld}dl, gdnd,
ekhzmz, jgj~ rdecd~e, gd~edndhd~, ldhdedy, g~c, ad~zlz,
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
11/29
44
oe ad~zlzez, g~aplhdedy, Ake}kike oejoeo, Hkls}joe oejoeo,
Ljfk~e }dzzez j nzfe gzlldemap mdhd keld~cd ~e
nzfeg hdloylj j~oalj}o~ajao}o~% Dad hj~ mjo~mj j~oa
ade}ed sdhor oesdeld~ klmzz ooe dgll }dsd~a ~e kld~dg
njlo~}olje j~oasop d~lgld~ oesdeo }dsd~ald kg mdhd gzlldeldnolo~
j j~oalo hdlj fj}o~molj~% Sop, mkad}jso, ji}dloyo, jlady, rk~}dgdl
j yzgd~md ydplde no}go j ajyjlj~o mkdyd n~dge njlo~lo no~ s~j
ske~d dslld~ed mejcjglj~mo~, ydeo j~oasjl }dsd~ad% Ake}kike
oejoeoe, Hkls}joe oejoeoe j Ljfk~e }dzzeze pd}je mkdmd
~jaj des kladydcdg}% G~c, ad~zlz, gd~edndhd~, ldhdedy,oe ad~zlzez, dysnj~fo, ss ldhdedld~e, n~kgkloyo, g~aplhdedy
mkdyd n~dge ylld~ ske~d yza~zld~ sdmjcj no~ iemg noljajmoe
cjop gdmd~ gdla N~gsjl ldhdedsed meme f~jcjgsoeop%
esde kladsdym as~ no}goso osj hono~ pdade kladydcdg}% Mkd
oesde mej~jg nzeld~ j~oalj}o~ajmoo ooe, nopoa dadcapd
je zyfze jglo j~ajmo% Dgll no~ }dsd~amd j~jio adhlgd ejmjeje oyosoeoe szezladme aj~dg j}ao kladlsep% Ejmj klsd oesde
kladee je ejalo pjlloo aj~dg j}ajg}o~% Mdhd oyo no~ }dsd~ae
ydrlad pjgo oesded a n~dgla mj~soeop (nyljcj dgll
}dsd~acld~d pk~ pdadeld~md gzlldednoljcjglj~o no~ dgldad md
j~ao klzyk~za/%
No~ j~oasoyj sk~d~sdep, sopj ylj yde} j~o~0 N}e nzmjj~lo yoyjcjglj~oaop mkdmd nzfeg hdloylj nzlzeazyk~% Mkdl
olj}oaoeoe hd}dld~ld mklz kladsemde mkldy, dek~adlloglj~, ~ejoe
rklorlkyomo mjmooaop g~kakpka kdladld~ ejmjeoylj nzfeg
szlz j o~o ajyjlj~ klzzyk~ yd md mkds} fce nopoa ooe
jso~fjmoo gdl}sdl gkanoedsykeld~ oesdeld~ sldh yklzyld gjemoso
ydryk~%
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
12/29
4>
4:% Mkdmd no~no~o ooe pd~d~l kg sdymd cdel d~m~% Decdg no~ cdelyd
pd~d~ j~je no~ }~ ndgd no~ cdel ooe yd~d~l olj~ ydrd~d7 yd md
}j~so% ~ejoe kzazpze o~golmoo ylde, mkdee mjefjsoeoe
sdldeads ooe je ejalj cdel f~zrld~emde no~omo~% _ldeld~
klads gjao~ocolj~ mkdmdgo n}e mjefjlj~o dlldg nzlldg jmj~%
Mkldysyld goaoe yd~d~l goaoe yd~d~sp klmzzed mkdee olj}oa
sos}jao gd~d~ j~o~%
Decdg ndp cdel }~lj~o ~ejoe ojg, jnd, hzaad, s}ad j
njepj~ keld~cds, mkdmd ndgd hono~ cdelyd z yd md nz jgolmj
yd~d~ sdldayk~% Noyklk`og meflj~oeoe d~sd d~d gdmjajlj~oemj
mj sdldayk~ld~% Nz cdelld~ sdmjcj oesdeld~ hds}d j}ajg ooe
j~oaljao}o~ (dgll }dsd~acld~d f~j yd~d}lald~/% No~ mkds}
f nz gdmd~ cdel }~ ooemj je kg mjj~ j~moo j j~jio
adhlgd} kld~dg go}drld~emd }dealdm nz }~j nz gdmd~ jpoyj}o,
gk~gzyz j s}~dn ejmje ~jd f~a}~ mj~soeop; esdelg
}d~ohoemje nz yded aolyd~ld~cd oesde (nzeld~e ooemj fedhsp
kld~dg nolmooaop kczgld~/ a~ee ndhd~e nolj f~ajmje nz
cdelld~cd lm~lmlj~% Sopcj nylj no~ }dsd~a dgll }dsd~a am~;
Szs szs ylj syljaj ]de~ee ooej gd~ladp! fedhg~ klz~sze
mjajylj ej pdaded gdmd~ yk~zaldad yj}oeopo nds}~dcdgsep;
No~ j~oacoyj sk~d~sdep sopj ylj no~ yde} j~o~% Pd~d~l
mjeje nz cdel }~lj~o mj no~ pdadeld~ mkdmd gjemo oh}oydld~e
gd~ldydcdg jgolmj sj~njs} ydyk~ld~m7 decdg no~ fe
jepoalj~oemje no~oeo yd md no~ gde yo}o~oecj, kez sdldydcd no~
cdelyd azsdlld} klmz j nz jgsoglooeo kemde fomj~ajyj ndldm%
Nz ndallg skezemd yd~ yd md }da no~ dsdldgld me}%
49% Drdemogs (Drdemoso}/0 Fjao}j hj~ yd}d no~kg oesde drdemoso}
ejmjeoylj dcld~ld g~dem j nyg no~ gsa md nz ejmjelj lm%
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
13/29
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
14/29
4=
Jy~oa ~j}oso noloasjl mecjo }j}oglj~7 dgll }dsd~a g~jl}o~
No~ deldamd meyd }dadaldeada no~ }dsd~a klmzz ooe j~oa
s~ajg}jmo~% Jj~ hj~ jy agjaajl }dsd~ldea klsdym,
j~oaljajyj fj~jg mzyzladydcdg}% Hdlnzgo cdel mdhd oyo mdhd
j}golo mdhd zyzalz ydry gdpdednolajg ooe 3%8 aolyd~ ylm~ mdhd
yj}goe klady d~dadg}dm~, ydeo j~oaljaj dnds oj~osoemjmo~% No~
pdadeld~ mjeopdedld~ee mdhd ske~d ndlgld~ mdhd ske~d
gz~nddfollj~oe mdhd ske~d s~efjelj~oe mdhd ske~d gz j
ajajlolj~oe k~}dyd g nz }dsd~a mdhd ndd~l hdlj fj}o~ajmo~%
]de~sdl no~ }dsd~amd olg kld~dg ndso}oeo ydrad, mdhd ske~d gzllded
gzllded mdhd j}golosoeo fjlo}o~aj fono no~ ade}g kldadp% No~ }d~di}de
]de~ee hj~ jyj gdmo~ klmzzed j mjejaj ydelad ye}jaoylj
mk~zyz nzlad fono no~ sdz~fdeld fj~jg mzyadydcded oedead,
moj~ }d~di}de md pdade ooemj k~fdeopdsyke ndgaemde fo}}ogj
mdhd fjloao cdelld~e meydmd s~dsyld yj~ dlme,
k~fdeopdsyke ndgaemde olgjl kldeld~e pdadeld k~}dmde gdlgr
yj~oeo mdhd fjloao k~fdeopadld~ n~dg}e fpljyor mj j~oa
iog~oej oedeadad, decdg dgll }dsd~acld~d ydg~%
Decdg oedead yd md oedeadad sdmjcj ndso} no~ gdnzl
ajsjljso mjolmo~% Mkdee ndp jylj~o jgsog n~dg}ee id~ged
d~ad, kez mdhd agjaajl hdlj fj}o~aj m~}s yd~d}yk~7 k md
noloasjl aj~dg j d~d}~adld~ fjlo}o~oyk~ j nz mzyfzyld njsljeje
}krlzald~ yd~d}c klzyk~7 skez}d md jfjaje klzyk~% ]z}zcz
}krlzald~e }d~ohj mdafdse z~dadadsee ggemj nz }z}zczlzg
yd}yk~% Nd}ee sa~fjco }z}zazeze s~jnolajso ooe mj yd~d}l
j dgll }dsd~a ydgldaee zyfze jgolmj nz lgjlj~j oh~dc
fj~jgoyk~%
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
15/29
4:
Hjaj~oa j ydge mks}za klde ~jssda R~ki% M~% Pdij~
Fjedyme, no~ fe nded noloyk~ azsze Dlo, K~}ddmd mkads j
K~}dd ade}emd yddads fj~jgje no~kg oesde, hj~hdlmj
ydel no~ rldeldadmde mkldy ej ydpg go pdadeapmd mkaz}z~7
mkadgld md gdlada no~ gsa eoj~so}jlj~mj hkcd klazld~,
mjmo%
Dh, ]de~ meydy yjeomje yd~d}dym,
_d~d}~gje mj njeo ydeemd }z}dym7
Mj~moa0 _d njeoa dma sol mji}j~oemje,
_d md njeoa moljmooacj yd~d} meydy%
aj~ Hdyyda
Mdhd ecj mjoemooaop fono, j~oa fjljcjg ooe rlde gz~adp,
}dsd~a ydradp7 k demd jlmj nzlzede ejsejlj~o yd md pjlloglj~o yoej k
demd fj~jgsoeaj mzyzlde jgolmj sjajyj gdlg~% Nz ejmjelj mj j~oa
hj~ pdade agjaajlo nzldadp% }j nz ejmjelj meydmd nz fej gdmd~
ydda cdelld~e *?9s yjeo mjooalj~j pa yklz nzldadm yd md
mdhd ecj ndd~l no~ jgolmj fjlo}o~moo pjlloglj~o olj mjda jmjajmoo
ooe ydda sdhejsoemje soloeao, yj~lj~oeo mdhd ndd~l kldeld~d
n~dgald~m~% Nz~dmd mkfad}oglj~ olj j~oacolj~ d~dsemd mecj
ndgaemde kg mj~oe no~ id~g d~m~% Mkfad}oglj~, nz caljmje moecolj~,
dgll }dsd~acld~ j njepj~lj~o f~}j kldeld~ ndd~lee (flee/
}deae id~gl deld~ld~% Nz ejmjelj mj mkdee olj}oa sos}jaoeo no~ }~l
deldydadpld~% Hd}}d no~ }jljopyke }d~}adsemd, no~ noyklk`o r~kijs~ (k
felj~mj Noyklkfld~ Mj~ejoeoe mj ndgdeym/, nded mej~jg hkcd hkcd,
ej moyk~sze, no~ ndg}j~o no~ iolmje mdhd fl a go mdhd ndd~l
moyk~sze% Mkfad}oglj~oe f}je gds}, gds fc olj se~lm~% Jsdsemd nz
f~lj~o skeld~e md hdp~ldadg}dm~% eg fc, sksydl yddamd
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
16/29
49
soldh, ded~o, }j~~opa, rd~d j gdnd gzj} kld~dg nolo~lj~% Hlnzgo no~
j~oaco, gds j gjaog fcej mdydeadyde nolfo j njcj~oeoe mdhd s}e
klmzzez fpljalj~o olj ~jeao}o~% No~ o~se no~ iolo ykg jmjcjoeo nolo~%
eg j~oasjl sjoloamj gdnd f mjol (nz f decdg dye }~e
no~jylj~o d~dsemd mdhd sdlgly j~gjg gdfdld~ fono! sjaj ooe
gzlldelde j~oasjl no~ ye}jamo~/, j~jeoe gkzlld~e je oyo gzlldede,
gdl}sdl ad}j~ydloeo fjljcjg gzdgld~d je hpl j je kg dg}d~de
(kdlde/ j ndgd no~ }~ gzlldem oecj ye}jalj~lj dl} jmjelj~ dydg}d
gdl~7 ydrdadydeld~ jljeo~%
Dglsp }dsd~ae je dgllcd ye, dglsp kladsm~% Hono~ pdade
}dsd~ldyd~dg no~ jy klz}z~adp% ]jg dadc d~m~0 Kldnolmooecj kg jo}
~j}ajg% Nzeze ooe os~di}de gdadp, mdhd mk~zsz kez os~di kld~dg
f~ajp% Nz ejmjelj no~ ndlg pjlloo no~no~oemje id~gl no~ aolyke yzaz~}d
n~dg~% No~ }dejsoeoe k~}dad zyza ydrads ndd~m~% K sjajyo mkdyd
n~dg~7 nz ejmjelj mkdl sjoloa moyk~zp% nj no~jyoe yddydnoljcjo
no~ k~}dad aolykeld~cd yzaz~}dee n~dgladsee ndgd ej delda
kldnolo~mo; Nz ejmjelj gz~dl kld~dg mkdmd yd~zld~e jgsogsop yd md
gdyrsp ny}je hono~ cdel ykg}z~ moyjnolo~op% K pdade nzfeg
gkzlld~md ej~jmjysj oesdeld~e mkz~mzgld~ kczgld~e hjrso ydyk~
moyjnolo~soeop% ]da no~ Dgll ]dsd~ac ade}% yo mj k kczgld~
ydd}adg ooe mkdmd ho kladyde oldld~ j dlj}lj~o gzllded~dg keld~
ndd~dnoloyk~szezp% _deo Dgll ]dsd~acld~e ade}yld ]de~}dsd~aed gd~ fjlj~jg, k }dsd~ae hd}dld~e oldld~ld dlj}lj~lj
mpjl}j~jg
]dsd~a hd}dsed yj~ ykg}z~% Mkd agjaajl no~ ahjemos
mjolmo~7 d~sdylde no~ mkds} f fono hj~ jyo nolje, rldeldydnolje j
fjljcjo f~je no~ olj}oa sos}jao mj mjolmo~% Yd~ klde gzllded~dg k
feg gkzlld~d je oyo zyzaz ydrdcdgld~ sjje no~ sos}jamo~% Nz
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
17/29
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
18/29
48
fjlo}o~ao}o~% No~ aolyke }khzamde no~o yd md no~ aolyke yzaz~}dmde
sdmjcj no~o, mdhd ecj ho gd~ldldadyde no~ k~}damd ndd~l
pjlloglj~o gkanoej j}ao osj, k dydg}d gdl~ moj~lj~o jljeo~% Sdmjcj oesde
ooe ~ejg j~jloa0 Hj~ oi}ljaj s~dsemd 322 aolyke srj~a ~j}olo~,
gz~dl kld~dg sdmjcj no~o mlljeaj oljoeo ydrd~% Decdg nz srj~alj~oe j
yzaz~}dld~e sdycd kglzz dye no~ moomje j dye no~ j~gjg}je
pjlloglj~o ndgaemde id~gl 62 }~olyke kczze ajymded fjlajsoeo
sdld~% Nz oeco~mj mj nyljmo~, ed~md md nyljmo~, ndlg}d md yljmo~% No~
ecjgo rd~df~di}d j~mooaop zpdy fjaoso ~ejoeo nz~dyd }d~sdg,
ecjmje dadldmap oeoljcjg fg cosaoej f~j fjao rldeldeadme,noelj~cj, aolykeld~cd fjao ydrlr zpdyd femj~olmooeo, nzeld~mde no~oeoe
yd md no~gdee no~ ~ds}lde} kld~dg no~ fg cosaoej oeajso j }dm
pjlloglj~o dsemde k~dmd fjlojnoljcjg mz~zamd klads hdloemj, yjeo no~
zyfd~le, noyklk`o dmde yjeo no~ }~e mkzz fj~jgljo~% Nylj no~
jo}lolog pk~zelzlzg}z~7 eg fjljcjg}j ejylj gd~lddcde nolajyje
no~ sos}ja, g yklzez kldslgld~ j jomo d~}~ad olj nzldnolo~mo% }jmkdee nz sdz~fdecd f~lje olj}oa sos}jao, nylj no~ ejmjelj
gk~zeaz}z~% Ej gdmd~ dgll no~ sos}ja klz~sd klsze, fjljcjg}j ej
kldcde }da gjs}o~jajp j nz md ykg kladyld skeldednolo~% J~oacolj~oe
mpjesoploglj~ ooemjgo mpje mjmoo sos}ja7 ~ds}fjlj sjoloa nz ejmjelj
ndd~l klaz}z~% Nz, mejajyje no~ sos}ja ooe agjaajl no~
s}~d}j`omo~% Dgll }dsd~a klsdym hj~ k~}dad f~j gdl}sdl no~ no~ljoa oadljmolo~mo% K pdade md eoyj nzemde 922 aolyke yl ecj ndlg, :22 aolyke
yl ecj s~efje, 322 aolyke yl ecj ajajlo, :2 aolyke yl ecj oesde
meydmd nzlzeazyk~mz moyj sk~d~ld~; eg mkd ~ds}fjlj, mjejaj!
ydelad olj decdg nz gdmd~e ndd~dnolmo% Dgll no~ }dsd~a klaz
klsdym, nz gdmd~ pdhaj}lo no~ yklz dadyd fj~jg kladydcdg}% Dgsoeo
mkdmd gde}ldyde }jg no~ ~ejg ykg}z~%
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
19/29
4?
Je kg sjolje yd md mjj~lo jy pjej njpjej }dsd~lde~ j
moggd}lj oadl jmolo~% esde ]de~ fpemj je mjj~lo d~lg kladsed gd~e
je kg mjijg}o (nkpzglzz/ klde }~ fono f~eyk~% oamolog oesde
skyzemd dm gkeaz ?%222 jo} gdl}sdl hds}dle klmzz noloeajg}jmo~%
No~ idn~ogd mee go, hj~gjso gdrsdydcdg no~ }dsd~a hd}dsemde mjol
(kez mdhd ske~d jlj dldcdp/, sdmjcj goolj~j pf }dsd~a j oadld}
hd}dsemde mkldy ?%222 jo} nkpzglzz klde ~e oadl jmoyk~szezp j
nzed md dgll }dsd~a moyk~szezp% _d dglll nolaoyk~szezp yd md
}dsd~a ej mjajg}o~ kez nolaoyk~szezp% Sg}epmd }dgmo~o oldho
moyk~szezp%
Nzeld~d gzlldelm pdade k~}dyd gde ydldeadyd ndl
hds}dlgld~ mhol mjolmo~% Nz hds}dlgld~e sdys nyg no~ kldslgld yjeo
}deald~ld no~log}j ke noelj~oe pj~oemjmo~%
Je olfoe klde md hjgoalj~oe nyg no~ gsaee dgll }dsd~ad
scdg ndgadld~m~% Nz, gjemo ajsljglj~oeo nolj }deayk~ld~ deldaed
fjlo~% Mkg}k~lzg, gdl}sdl yd md ske~dmde k~}dyd gde no~ jgsoglooe
fomj~olmoo ajsljg}o~% kzelzg md }dsd~a hd}dld~ee mpjl}olajyj
dllm no~ ajsljg}o~% Dgll no~ }dsd~a, k~desdl kld~dg no~ deldamd kg
mdhd pdyi dgll sdyldnoljcjg no~olj~o mpjl}oyk~%
Decdg n}e nzeld~ f~jnolajg njlo~lo no~ sjpoeljajyo, nolfoyo j je
ejaloso sdmjcj oesded pf klde yd~fldady fj~jg}o~o~% esde mkds
fj~jo nje aj~gjplo (de}~krksje}~og/ klmzz ooe, hj~ jyo gjemo gd~
dsemde mjj~ljemo~o~% Nje ydyk~sda j pjlloglj mj oyo ydyk~sda,
nz kg oyo gz~zlaz }de~sdl no~ mpjeoe skezczemd kladg}dm~% Decdg,
hjep j~foeloj zldadmde lje gd~mjlj~oa ooe nylj no~ yd~f fjj~lo
mjolmo~% Njeoa kczgld~ae jlo yp mpfe osj, nz }de~sdl dgll no~
}dsd~ae skezczmz~7 decdg gkazeze n}e doljyo a~ nkyz sge}yd
skgde sdgd} mkaz kczz ]de~ee njeoa hdloamje g~j}aja ooe
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
20/29
>2
ydra klmzz no~ mpjeljajmo~% ]de~sdl }dsd~amd dcdnd njecollog j
ed~soslog no~ e gkzl azmz~;
Rjgl, nz gdmd~ oesde ejmje mkdee agjaajl no~ mpje ooemj
oljmooej oedeyk~ j hj~ jyoe agjaajl klmzzed oedeyk~; lg kld~dg
oesde oesde ydrde jard}o ykgszelzzemde% eg ndgdsee gzsz~z,
jgsogloo j mj~mo kez olfoljemo~aoyk~% Nz gdmd~ gzsz~z f~ajajplog}je
fjloyk~% Decdg je ejaloso, ek~adloe j dek~adloe ej klmzzez }da
nolaoyk~, }dealdydayk~% ~ejoe moyk~ go ndg ej fpjl yoyjcjglj~
j~olao yjajaop ooe% oamo nje sk~zyk~za, ej j~olsjymo dye jyo
syljyjcjg}oeop% Ndgdse nolaoyk~sze go% Ej fpjl ~jeglj~o f~yk~zp
moyk~szezp; Ndgd ~jeglj~o }deayk~szezp go nz yd~fyd sd~lyk~szezp%
F~map ~jeglj~ g ndemee ypmj no~o nolj mjol7 dgll no~ }dsd~a
klsdym nop kg mdhd pjefoe ~jeglj~o f~jcjg}og% Decdg no~ j~oaco nopoa
sdmjcj 3 ~jefo ejmje f~jnolmooaopo noloyk~7 nz ejmjelj mdhd idpldse
md }dljr j}aoyk~% ]de~sdl no~ }dsd~amd mdhd idpldse }dljr jmjnolo~mog%
Decdg no~ j~oaco f~aj rofaje}lj~oeoe klz}zz mejamj, fej
eld~ee je ykze ado, yjol, g~ap nde}ld~md yj~ypej zld}e nz
ejmjelj nylj no~ }dsd~ald yj}oemooeo noloyk~% Jj~ nz mejamj X, dlid,
nj}d eld~yld md gd~lda klsdymg, keld~ md }deydcdg sos}jao
fjlo}o~jnolo~mog j nzfe kz k~}damd k~}dyd gde ~dmydsykez ecjmje
f~jnolo~mog yd md keld~d mdydegl no~ gdl}sdl akljgl fjlo}o~jnolo~mog% Nz
caljmje no~ jyo pjlloglj z~fzldadg os}oyk~za0 Hj~ jyo nyg no~}dsd~a kld~dg f~jelj~oe, nz md njgljeje no~ jymo~, dldcdg ejso d~
go moyjnoljcjglj~o no~ }dsd~ald~ d~ am~; ee j d~gdse, ejmjeoeo
nolajmooeop, edsl klz}zzez nolajmooeop hj~ jy, ydeo ndso}}je
gd~adgld mk~z fomje yklz ydeo j~oasjl s~jco }deadmep s~jcj,
zcd zlda hj~ jy sopoe ooe azcopjeoe no~ ~e kld~dg f~ljcjg}o~% Nz
ndso} no~ hjsdr adgoejsoeo nolj deldydadyde no~oeoe nolfosdyd~ deldadyd
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
21/29
>4
gdlgads gdmd~ s no~ ydgldam~% Dgll }dsd~acld~$ J~oamj ndso}}je
gd~adgld fomje yklz ~jeajmooeop s~jcj sopoe hono~ jyo deldad
j f~aj desep kldadydcdg}~% _d ~jeoe yd md yklmde jgoloe%
Jj~ dgll }dsd~ald yj}oeajyj gdlgsdymg ej zpdyd fomjnolo~mog
ej mjeoplj~oe monoej oejnolo~mog% Nopoa }dsd~aap, decdg meydee
ypjyoemj oecj no~ gd}ademd yddadyd opoe j~oyk~% esde mjj~lo no~
d~lg kld~dg eo}jljyje ycj no~ yd~d}c nopo j~jesjl no~ gd~de}oedyd eoyj
skgaz mj~soeop; N}e nz k~}dald~md yddydnoljcjg no~ mkedea
j~jnolo~mo% Decdg oesde nz meydee kczz klmzz ooe, j~oaljj~jg
klz}zz ooe ej nzlmzysd kezeld yj}oeao}o~% J~oa fjljcjo }dhaoe
jmjajp, f~jajp7 decdg jomoeo d~}~d~dg klds no~ zyzaze
fj~jgljajsoeo sdldydnolo~% Nzez md hj~ pdade ndd~dadp% Ndpje mj
njlo~lo no~ meja ooe ndd~~7 decdg gdpdem~m pjlloglj~ mjoje
gkzlld~ ypemje k cdely gadp skgdd skgd~dg k~}dmde gdlgadsed
ejmje klz~%
Decdg, je ejalo yd~f j ydelf, yoej dgll }dsd~acld~mde jlmj
jmoljnolo~% eg dgll }dsd~acld~e hjaje hjrso n}e nz sos}jaoe
agjaajl klmzzez sdzez~ j mdydemgld~ oedeld~ osj oesde j~jeoe
jijemoso kld~dg gdnzl jmj~ j keld~ J~jio Adhlg, ydeo adhlgld~e
jijemoso kld~dg f~~% Nz mjajg}o~ go, oesde ydrldnoloejcjg j jlmj
jmoljnoloejcjg hj~ fpjlloj ldyg}~% Nz fpjlloglj~o oesdemde jso~fjajg,
j~jio adhlg mjmooaop d~ld g}lg}~%
K pdade fjloe sopoelj no~ noyklk`og kyze kyedydla% esde yjeomje
}dsd~ldydla% S~jglo gjemoeo ked~adyld lasplg kldnolo~mo7 decdg k
pdade moesjl ~j}omjgo n~ meyd sk~fzldadsemde gdadg deldaed
fjlo~mo go, nz moesjl ~j}olj~oe njloeo g~d~% eg mdydemgld~ je ejalo
mdydedg n~ meydmdgo f~ljcjg hjsdne cjpds j mlm~% Nz
fpjl }dsd~a }z}zczld~e hono~o gdnzl j}ajyjcjo ooe ~did gdlm~dla%
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
22/29
>>
ylj no~ }dsd~a ydrdla go, hja moeo ~j}olj~ pd~d~ f~ajsoe hja mj
hj~gjsoe ooej yd~dse% Noloemoo fono pdade oesde ooe je ejalo mjj~
klaz}z~% _drdcdap oo ej gdmd~ hpl j mk~z ydrd~sdg k gdmd~
ndd~l klz~, ~dhd} jmj~op% K pdade czmzazpd nopj oedeladp
gd}gld~md nzlzedcdg! hono~ pd~d~ kladydcdg yjeo no~ }dsd~a jgljyjloa
mj~oa% ~ejoe, mkdmd, je dp :22 cdel }~emj kg dp jej~`o gzllded~dg
(gzlldelde jej~`oeoe *??z d j~olj~jg/ g gd~ad ajgdeopads
j~jio adhlg nop oesdeld~d sk~zeszp ake}j jmoljnolo~mo% Gjpd mkdmd,
~}lj~lj dlr gdrdednolje kg sdymd fp ydrs md noloeajg}jmo~% K
pdade no~ oesdee no~ rd~adee zczed, dlr gdrdednolje, dyepdademd no~ g sos}jaoylj mjs}jgljeao, hd}}d nyl}aj j gl}aj
yj}jejo klde no~ fp sos}jao yj~lj}o~oljnolo~mo% Nzeze noyklk`og kld~dg
kladads ooe hono~ ejmje ykg}z~% Nzfe sos}jao yjeomje }dsd~ldad
f~jo je ndso} nolfoso klde no~ noyklkfd j~olsj nolj nzez ~dhd}lgld
ndd~dnolo~% Nylj no~ jg ydree oesdeklzed gdpdem~dcd kldedgld~ j
pdade mejnoloyk~ azszezp; No~ adgoejyo sgajyj fj~jg gdladmdeoecjljyjnolo~soeop7 no~ mkg}k~ nz rd~adgld czmze hj~hdefo no~ mjlooemje
fo~j~jg gl k~}damd mkgzld~ j ydrld~ oecjljyjnolo~7 no~ ajged
fo~ajmje dedh}d~ mjlooemje oj~oyo oecjljyjnolo~moeop% Sdysp kldedg
gdpdem~~% esdeklz nzfegemje kg mdhd ~dhd} ydd~m, kg mdhd
olj~ljao klz~mz% Edsl klzyk~ md ndso} no~ dmda nz mjelo yd~d~l no~ sos}jao
mejnoloyk~ md, hj~ jyo nolje no~ d~lg, nz oageld~ nopmje jso~fjaoklzyk~; esde pj~oemj nzed njepj~ keld~cd ydda gkldyld}~de!
mpjl}aj ydrldnolo~ j yjeo }dsd~a ake}j jmoljnolo~% Njecj dgll }dsd~a
sdzedeld~ kez nolfosop, njcj~ogsop j jfkos} mz~zad m~j~jg!
oedemgld~ ]de~yd hdgd~j} j}ao klzyk~ld~% Gd ydrdya mj~gje fp
gd~yk~ld~% J~jio adhlg olj sjiol adhlg d~dsemdgo oecj opfoyo
deldydayk~ld~% Ndpje nz gdmd~ gde}d gd~e no~olj~oeoe hdld dgll
}dsd~ad }z}zeaz kladse, mk~zsz yoej mj ]de~sdl no~ }dsd~a
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
23/29
>3
kld~dg gdnzl j}ajyj ajcnz~ gdlyk~za7 eg mkd nz gdmd~ hdsd~l
mecj sos}jao kldeld~ nz gdmd~ zpze s~j sdhejmj }z}adpm7
}z}dadpm7 decdg mkds} no~ fce yd~ma olj nylj nkpzg no~ sos}ja
nk~zszez }}~ajyj mjda jmjnolo~mo%
s}j~sjeop oesdeld~e gjgj moyj ndldm ndgd no~ os}jo
o~mjljyjloa% Pdade pdade gkezadld~ s~dsemd gjgj oesdeld~ 4222
yl yddsdym mj~op% Decdg ejmje yddadmap no~ }~l yk~zaldadyd
ydedadyp% g yklz nzldadyecd md nz gdmd~ zpze yddsdymg
meyd oesdemde fjolajpmo moyj no~ mj fyd j~jyo gk~zyk~ }d~e
}dge~p% Hlnzgo k pdade md sjejmj no~ mjol, hk~akeld~ap 422 ylmd
no~ kczg ydrdcdg mpjeljaj ydrdnolo~mo7 meydmdgo mpje nkpzladmde
mjda jmjnolo~mo% _d oamo; _ddmap no~gd ke yle yd~semde
kzez s~jglo la gk~gzsz olj fjo~oyk~zp7 ydpg mjol ao nopj;
J~jio Adhlg kld~dg meydyd oemoo syljeje nz ejalo }~e,
de}~krklk`og dmde olg oesdeo pjlloglj~ fs}j~moo mejalj~mj k~}dldad
a~ zpzelzz je idpld >2, ]d Mj~oemj k~}dldad a~ zpzelzz >:,
ydpy nzlmzz mejamj k~}dldad a~ zpzelzz 3:, nz sd}~ld~e
ydpd~ee mkmzz ylld~md (4?=:/ ydeo rjeosoloeoe hjep nzlzeadm
nzlzemz osj mj ydyfeldadm ylld~md mkmzz lgjmj k~}dldad a~
zpzelzz =3 ylm% Ejysj go oedelde ]de~ }dsd~ayld yj}oeajyje
oesdeklz, gjemo jg! }dsd~ae fjlo}o~j~jg k~}dldad a~ zpzelzzez
goao lgjlj~mj 82 yld gdmd~ gd~m%
Hc~jlj~oaopoe hjrso yjeoljejnolo~mo7 gg hc~jlj~ olj yjeoso
ydrldnolo~mo7 nkpzlde k~fdeld~ap d}lr yjeoso yj~oej gkednolo~mo% N}e
nzeld~e noyklk`og sos}jamj ydrladads ooe hono~ ejmje f~layk~%
Dad ydrldayk~% s}jlog hj~ cdelee njlo~lo no~ s~j yddyr, k s~jeoe
skezemd os}jsj mj os}jajsj mj lajso ooe sos}jaoe ooej la fjelj~o
skgz}z~zlmzzez noloyk~zp (drkr}kpos/% ~ejoe no~ mkad}js iomjsoej ej
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
24/29
>=
gdmd~ oyj ndgd~sdep ndge no~ sjpkeze skezemd l~% No~ }dzg je idpld
8!42 yl ydd}ldnolo~7 decdg njepj~ ydryd sdhor no~ gd~}dl ej~jmjysj 422
yl yddydnolo~% la fjelj~o ejmje cdelld~e ooej skgzlmz; Nolj nolj
lm~aj coedyj} sdyl~% Nz gdmd~ dcadsp no~ ydr cdelld~d ejmje ~jd
f~lm mj~gsoeop; Nzez sdmjcj j~oa ~j}osoemje fjaolj~ deld~7
j~oa gd~}ld~ osj gdid yk~adadg ooe ked gdmj~ mj~lj~% Nyljcj
mkfad}oglj~j f~j jgo~fjlj~oe, sklzcdeld~e, no~fesoejglj~oeoe,
gd~}dlld~e j }dzgld~e gdmj~o opolao klz~% J~oacolj~ nzeze j~oaoe no~
fj~jo klmzzez j no~ cdelee j~oaljjnolajso ooe azhdggdg gjemo
gdl}sdl noljoaoeoe k~}dmde gdlgd~dg (nyljcj hja ofdl j}ao klmzz yj~ofjljcjg gzdgld~ yd~d~ed nkdl}a klz~ hja mj gjemo gdl}sdl noljoaoeo
fje hdzpzed skgadyd~dg fjljcjg gzdgld~e fje hdzpzeze
szldem~ladse elj~/, yjeo gdl}sdl gkanoedsykeld~ld (noljoalj~lj/
mked}la yzaz~}d j yd~zld~ee mkdl sjoloaj z~dyr mdhd s}e
gdl}sdl noljoaj sdhor kldeld~e sjoloao j yjeo }~lj~j mea
sdlde~% Nyljcj gsd yddyde }dzgfollj~ jo} mjo}o~aj deseydgdldmgld~ ooe meydyd jfjaje klz~gje, zpze yddyde gd~}dlfollj~
j~oaljaj flj~oeo k~desdl kld~dg dpdl}}gld~ ooe k~}dmde gdlgad
joloaoej ejmje fo~moglj~oeo mj delda klz~zp% _deo j~oa gd~da,
pemj, cdelld~e sdmjcj njlo~lo no~ pdade d~dlemd yddadsyld md
dgd gde}ldea klzyk~7 }dnoo deldydeld~ ooe
Jj~ gdmj~colog}je gz~}zlzr, mkdee olj}oa sos}jaoeo oesdeld~e md}aylj deldyr, }dglo} jmjnoljcjglj~oeo j mdhd oyosoeo fjlo}o~jnoljcjoeo
go}ljlj~j oedem~~sdg, !ydeo dgll }dsd~ad g~ g~ej sdrlder
gdladpsdg! no~gd yp yl ske~d laspl ydgdldadap kg md pk~
kladydcdg}~%
DNM&mj fjljejgsjl yd~d}l mecjsoeoe, 4?86 ylemd (Jmvd~ms!
Dfzolld~m mddsemd/ Dedydsd Adhgjajsoeoe dlm gd~d~ld mjlj}
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edwards_v._Aguillardhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edwards_v._Aguillardhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edwards_v._Aguillardhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edwards_v._Aguillard -
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
25/29
>:
kgzlld~emd kgz}zlads Dedydsdyd dyg~ klmzz fj~jgjsoylj
ydsdgldea}~% Nz mdd s~jcoemj Eknjl ml gdpdea 6> noloa
dmda, 46 jydlj} noloa dgdmjaoso j 6 noloasjl k~fdeopdsyke yd~d}le
moeo mkfadld~mde j oedeld~mde klz}zzez j noloasjl kladme
njlo~}je no~ ydp ydyeldmld~%
Dgll }dsd~a ydglda osj, 4??2&ld~md no~ f~zr Daj~ogdl noloa
dmdaecd k~}dyd d}lm% lg nyg g, Ljhofh eoj~so}jso&emje
noykgoayd r~kijs~ Aochdjl @% Njhj&eoe &Md~voe&oe Gd~dgz}zsz0 J~oaj
Gd~ Noykgoaydsdl Ndgdlm~& go}dnyld klmz% Njhj, cdel hc~jsoeoe
Md~voe pdadeemd oj~oo noloeajyje no~ gd~dgz}z klmzzez, hc~jeoe
mj}dyld~ deldlmemd osj nz~dmd kg gd~adg no~ }dsd~ae k~}dyd
g}e deld}}% Nzed f~j, cdelld~mdgo gd~adg sos}jalj~oe mkdl
sjoloalj j az}dsykeld, ydeo noloesop ajgdeopadld~ld k~}dyd gads
kldedgsp, nz md hc~jeoe noloelo no~ jgolmj }dsd~ldeme fs}j~oyk~
mjao}o~%
Nzfe gd~adg f~eje hj~ sos}jaoe j~oasjl ydgldamd no~
ndso} ggjej oemo~oljnolmooeo f~yk~zp% Pd}je j~oa ~j}oso gd~adg
sos}jalj~oe pdade moloao oj~osoemj ndso}j edsl oemo~oljnoljcjoeo d~d}~de
no~ dldem~% Nzfe ndg}j~olj~mj ildfjllza kld~dg noloeje j no~ jo} gda
fono hd~jgj} jmje no~ ydree monoemj ked hd~jgj} sdldyde, gd~dgz}z
kld~dg dmldem~lde j gd~adg f~eje sos}jao deldadg os}oyk~sdep,
nzeze yklz oedeadmde mjol, yoej noloasjl d~d}~adld~mde fjj~%
]dredg ydradg ooe ydr}ep ndld~mde j ~zhnde seid dy~mep
gdyedgld~mde kg dp no~ gsae nz aj~dgep fomj~ajg ooe dy~~sdep,
nzeze edsl klz}zzez md ~jeao klz~szezp%
_d~d}l j dgll }dsd~a gkezszemd mo~j}aj pjlloglj Daj~ogdee
fj~ocolj~o j sa~fj poheoyj}oemj kldeld~cd s~m~lyk~% Nopoagolj~
id~gemd a mj~soeop; A}jmjoe (gjemo hdloemj oede sdhorlj~o/ kldeld~ olg
http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/edwards-v-aguillard/amicus1.htmlhttp://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/edwards-v-aguillard/amicus1.html -
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
26/29
>9
ndg}d _d~d}l j Dgll ]dsd~a _dgldald~ed fjljejgsjl
f~lj~oej }j~s majmoo ooe gd~ gayk~ld~% Decdg, Daj~ogdee nz
go~lo dadl poheoyj}o, nopoa fono lgjlj~mj, pjlloglj sd}la goolj~cj
k~fdeopj jmoloyk~ j ydyfeld}~lyk~% Nz gkezmd ]~goyjmj ydrlde j
gd~lgsp md}lde ydyeld~e njmjloeoe >4 aolyke ]L (>4 }~olyke _]L/
klmzz njlo~}oloyk~% Gdyed; Noloeaoyk~ Jaeoyj} d~d}~yk~ az;
Hdddd Hdlg dymeld}adgld ygal ndse d~d}~yk~ az; Keld~
dyld~cd no~kg adhgjajmj yd~f kld~dg, ndgde kld~dg dla7
skezemd md zpze ylld~ Dedydsd Adhgjajso ndgdel ydra, mdhd
ske~d md Czahz~ndgdel ydra, Dhaj} Ejcmj} Sjpj~oe }dgso}lj jg~jmo olj mj klsd a}jdp mj klsd edsl no~ j dlme d~d}~adee
rjoemjlj~
Dgll }dsd~a dga, }d~ohoe je cdeo j gdel gd}ololj~oemje no~o kld~dg
}dealdydnoljcjoaop Daj~ogd Ndgde Nzshze ae}jsor klmzz (ndl
klmzz/ Gdloeos} Golosjeoe eclemj ndld}la}~ j dgll }dsd~a
p~ds noppd} Nzsh }d~diemde mjidld~cd }jldiizp jmolao}o~% Golosj, dgll
}dsd~ae j yd~d}le kgzlld~md kgz}zlads ooe mjidld~cd ygsjg
adhgjajyj ndz~az}z~% Moyjloa go nylj no~ ydglda gjemo
oedeld~e fljemo~ajg dsemde no~ dad kld~dg f~a kldnolo~lj~%
Decdg dye golosj (golosjlj~ no~loo/ Daj~ogd O~dgd sdlm~~gje ylj no~
gd~d~ dlm% sd, hja ]de~m~ hja ]de~ee klzmz~ j hja mj Ajsoh}o~%
Nzez gdnzl j}ajyjelj~, nzed oade j}ajyjelj~ noom~dg}o~ (om~dg yd mddeldad yj}jejo ykg}z~/7 noom~dglj~ oesdeo sdyladpld~ j noom~dgld~
pj~oemj krj~dsyke (nz~dmd lm~aj yd md njlgo }nno mjejy ydrad nolj
kldnolo~/ ydrad oesdelg szz sdyladp% Nyljcj O~dg}dgo gd}loda md
aj~z no~ pjaoej k}z~}zlaz klzyk~mz% Decdg, nz ydgldamde Dgll!
Dglsp ]dsd~ald olfolo ejalo no~ skez md gd~ldnolo~% Mjajg go Dgll
]dsd~ad oedea Gdloeos} Golosj, ]de~ee gjemo oedeld~ee
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
27/29
>6
memdgolj~o (Asladeld~, Nzmos}lj~, D}jos}lj~ m% hd}}d H~os}oyde klzr
md ndgd ajphjrlj~j ajeszr kldeld~ nolj/ ydeo meyd eizszeze
ydgldg nj}j m~mee nkpzg adl kld~dg gd~lme gdnzl jmoyk~% No~
deldamd dglsp }dsd~a, ~j}oa nkpzglzzez }jscol jmoyk~% Nylj no~
gdnzl, keld~e s~dolmjgo, Fdppjmjgo, O~dg}dgo, Difdeos}demdgo,
Yoj}edamdgo, Skadlomjgo gd}lodald~d mzyd~sp gdladse sdlyk~%
Pdade pdade Aslade yd md moj~ no~ moemje klzr md nz Gdloeos}lj~oe
nz iog~oej m~} jllj sd~ldeld~ f~mamj, Gdloeos} Golosjsoeoe Noom~dg
}jsro}oej oededcda fjloyk~
Dgll }dsd~ae f~e~mj kg soeso no~ soydso nkyz}z md d~%
Daj~ogdmd k~}dyd gde nz joloaoe pd}je }d~oh}je fjlje kg fjj~lo no~
}jajlo d~m0 Gdmj~colog% Gdmj~colog, fjoco kld~dg oesdeld~ ~dhd}ld}a7
decdg zpze dmjmj gadpd skgaz7 decdg je ejaloso sa~
mpjeoej gd~ gdadydcdg gdmd~ fplj~oeo g~ j}ao}o% Nd}ee dho
gdro}dlopaoeoe sa~ mpjeo gz~dnolajso ooe, nz gdmd~ ggl j
gdrsdal no~ ~j}o nooao nzlzedadpm% Ske no~gd ke yl oj~osoemj soeso
k~fdeopd}~lj~ hd~jgj}j fj}o7 lgjsoemjgo dgll }dsd~acld~ gz~zlz
mpjej gd~ gadyde azeos d}demdld~ kldcdg sa~ljcjg lgjlj~oe
d}demdld~ md hja ajfzl jmoljcjg hja mj gkldycd fmljnoljcjg}o%
no~logolj~ memje hdp~m% Nz lgjlj~mj moeo oedeld~ nzfej gdmd~
sa~ d~dc kld~dg gzlldede sdysp oesde d~m% Nzeld~e, kyedede
kyzez id~g j}ajso mj aage mjolmo7 eg gzl gl}~ olj yj}oaolj~mo7syljejej }d~}admde oade j}ajlj~o ndemde nj~o oedem~la}%
Nyljcj meydmd ej klzr no}oyk~mde hdnj~o kladyde, dgle n~
meyd olj nkpaz, noloasjl fjloajlj~o pemglg kld~dg }dealdyde, lomj~j
g~ g~ej ndl no~ gjsoa yd~d}lm% Mdhd mk~zsz nylj no~ gjsoa
d~m, sdyld~ d~}~lm% Sa~ mpjeo }d~oh}jgoeoe dgsoej nz sjij~ gdesp
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
28/29
>8
kld~dg gz~zlmz% Mee no~ meydyd ndge, n~ meyd olj~oej mdhd kg
pdade dy~de lgjlj~oe hjrso dg yd md gdrdl sa~fjmo~%
No~ }krlzaze hjrsoeoe dyme klads d~pzlde~7 decdg nz oamolog
hdydl fono f~eyk~% K pdade noloao ~jhnj~ ydra, yd~d}c, gz~zlz
mpjeo }jego} jmjnolje, yjeo sjjejglj~ szednolje, }krlzaz fjljcjo
hdp~ldydnolje oesdeld~e ej fjo~olajso ydd md klsd yoej mj no~
fjloajeoe lkgkak}oio kldnolo~% }j nz lkgkak}oilj~oe mj eee gjsolajso
hja lgj oj~osoemj oedeld~ sa~je pa~j ooe hja mj lgj memd
ydadldadyd, sa~ajyj de} oao lgjlj~oe fjljcjo ooe fj~jgo~%
Oe j ykl fs}j~ocosoeo yo}o~ao no~ }krlzaze soemo~olajso, sa~lajso
j yeljemo~olajso pk~ kladydcdg}~% }j nz ejmjelj ]~goyj j ]~goyj
fono lgjlj~mj, j~oa gd~dae pasjao j kez, }krlzad yklzez
nzlads ooe g fono }z}dcdg oesdeld~ sdi med d}adg fj~jgo~mo7 kez md
yjeo gzdg fj~ocolj~, ydeo Dgll ]dsd~acld~ ydryk~%
Jj~ Dgll ]dsd~a klsdym, Dgll ]dsd~acld~ kladydcdg}%
R~ki% M~% Dlo Mjao~sky
Hdcj}}jrj eoj~so}jso
Szez ydps
Sjfolo Gd~mjoa
Hj~gjsoe dpemde majyje, sa~fjco lgjlj~oe s}~d}j`oso hdloej fjlje
Dgll ]dsd~a j keze ono~logolj~oeoe foplo ype ~jeajg os}j~sjeop
nz ydpy moggd}lj kgzyzezp% J~jesjl mejnolaj fjljcjoe oesdeee
je ejalo pjlloo kldcdg}~% Fjloe no~ yj~mje no~log}j ndldydla
Sdyfld~ald
Ek}0 Jj~ nzemde nylj ydp dladg os}jaoyk~sdep7 l}ije nz dm~jsj nolfo
j~oeop%
-
8/14/2019 Akll tasarm
29/29
>?
Jg nolfo (oe}j~ej}}je/0
HD^^OSNZ^F ! DNM&mj Nzsh yej}oaoeoe nde jg}oo, kgzlld~md Chd~ljs Md~voe&oe j~oagz~daed dl}j~ed}oi kld~dg &j~jeoe s}e no~ d~le dgll }dsd~a& klmzzeze ~j}olajso gdardeyds,Rjeesyldeod jydlj}oemj d~ md~nj yjmo% Mkj~ nlfjso kgzlzeze noyklk`o ai~jmd}ed dgll }dsd~a
skgadsemde ogyj}o klde 44 jnjjyeoe ndz~zszez mjj~ljemo~je nlfj yd~fc @khe @kejs, zgd~d~d d~m0 .Mjlj} kgzlld~emd j~oaj dl}j~ed}oi kld~dg dgll }dsd~ae kgz}zladsee dedydsdlkladmed hgaj}}og% Dgll }dsd~ae ~j}olajso, dedydsdee golosj!mjlj} dy~l olgjsoej dyg~m~%Dgll }dsd~ae noloa kladm skezczed d~mg% Nz ~j}oyo yd~d}cld~emde dy~ mejajpsoeop, nzmd moeo r~krdfdemd klmzz deldaed fjlo~%.
_d~f, .Md~voe&oe j~oa gz~da agjaajl mjolmo~% Decdg noloasjl no~ gz~dae hj~ ekg}dydgld gdz}z~dadads7 moe }jajllo, sededadyde dl}j~ed}oi no~ d~sdya pk~ld noloa seiedskgadg ooe ndhdej kld~dg gzlldeldadp% Dy~cd j~oa gz~da oldho no~ yd~d}cee d~lyld ej jlogohdloemj ej mj nzez ydldelyk~. moyj jgljmo% _d~f, kgzl yej}oaoeoe &moeo d~gd gdrmde kgzld skgad&gd~d~e md &esdee ejijsoeo gjsje no~ deldasplgmoyj eo}jljmo% >22=&}j 3&j gd~ 9 kyld gd~d~ dlde kgzlyej}oao, &J~oa gz~da klfz mjolmo~, ~jecolj~oe pohoelj~oeo dg }z}adyd }jog jmolajso ldpa&
moyj~jg, dgll }dsd~a mkgzpzecz sei noyklk`o ai~jmd}ed skgaz j ~j}ajelj~mje j~oa gz~daegd~dldadld~e os}jao}o% Dy~cd ~jecolj~o &Rdemdld~ j oesdeld~ hdggemd& dml, dgll }dsd~a sdzedeno~ go}dnd yeljemo~ao}o%
Gd~d~e d~memde, Njydp Sd~dy, Nzsh&ze nz gkezmdgo gd~d~e kgzl yej}oaoej n~dgladsemdeyded klmzz f~e }jg~d~ldm% Kgzlz sdzede ]hkads Ak~j Hzgzg Aj~gjpo, .lgjeoe gz~zczld~ nzndso} ai~jmd} mjooglooeoe gjemo ydpmgld~ dedydsdy ohldl j}}ooeo mzysd kg dd~m. mjmo%43? sdyidlg f~e adhgjajeoe vjn sdyidsemde ydyaldyde @kejs osj Nzsh&ze d}dmCzahz~oyj}o no~ yd~f kld~dg, jyljaco azhdloi no~ yd~f kladme z~fzldm% Sdmjcj RjeesyldeodMkj~ ooe fjj~lo kladsed gd~e, nz gd~d~e DNM&mjgo j~oa!yd~dml gdfds dsemde no~ meaekg}ds klmzz j moeco azhdidpdg~ld~d d~ md~nj oemo~moo njlo~}oloyk~% Hd}}d 4?>:&}j j~oa gz~daekgz}ady ~jmmjmje ]jeejssjj&mj dlde &adyaze mdds&emde nj~o je ejalo mdd klmzz syljeoyk~%
Dgll }dsd~a 4??2&ld~md k~}dyd d}lm
4?86&mj ygsjg adhgjajeoe, Lkzosoded jydlj}oeoe yd~dml gz~dae ~j}jajyjcjoej, egnz gz~dae noloalj njllo no~ moeo f~ gd~ gd~yd fj}o~mooej hgaj}}oo DNM&mj, Nzsh yej}oaoyljno~log}j moeo oedeld~e ygsjloj fjajsoylj dgll }dsd~ad ykze olfo d~% >22: ndemd Gdesds jydlj}o~jecolj~j j~oa gz~daee }d~}adl klmzz j dgll }dsd~a dl}j~ed}oioeoe nzlzemzzeze~j}olajsoej mdo~ ydsd gd~~gje, Fjk~fod jydlj}o mj no~ kgzlze noyklk`o go}drld~ed j~oa gz~daesk~fzldyde gd~}adld~ ydr}~adse }d~}yk~%
Dgll }dsd~a, 4??2&ld~md no~ f~zr Daj~ogdl noloa dmdaecd k~}dyd d}lm% lg nyg g, Ljhofheoj~so}jso&emje noykgoayd r~kijs~ Aochdjl @% Njhj&eoe &Md~voe&oe Gd~dgz}zsz0 J~oaj Gd~Noykgoaydsdl Ndgdlm~& go}dnyld klmz% Njhj, cdel hc~jsoeoe Md~voe pdadeemd oj~oo noloeajyje no~gd~dgz}z klmzzez, hc~jeoe mj}dyld~ deldlmemd osj nz~dmd kg gkarljgs no~ }dsd~ae k~}dydg}e deld}}%
Nzed f~j, cdelld~mdgo gkarljgs sos}jalj~oe mkdl sjljgsoyke j az}dsykeld, ydeo noloesopajgdeopadld~ld k~}dyd gads kldedgsp, nz md hc~jeoe noloelo no~ jgolmj }dsd~ldeme fs}j~oyk~%