[acm press the 2nd acm international symposium - long beach, ca, usa (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)]...

10
The Quest for Security in Mobile Ad Hoc Networks Jean-Pierre Hubaux Institute for Computer Communications and Applications Swiss Federal Institute of Technology – Lausanne CH-1015, Switzerland Levente Butty´ an Institute for Computer Communications and Applications Swiss Federal Institute of Technology – Lausanne CH-1015, Switzerland Srd an ˇ Capkun Institute for Computer Communications and Applications Swiss Federal Institute of Technology – Lausanne CH-1015, Switzerland ABSTRACT 1. INTRODUCTION 2. THREATS Permission to make digital or hard copies of part or all of this work or personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers, or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. MobiHOC 2001, Long Beach, CA, USA © ACM 2001 1-58113-390-1/01/10…$5.00 146

Upload: srdan

Post on 02-Oct-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

The Quest for Security in Mobile Ad Hoc Networks

Jean-Pierre HubauxInstitute for ComputerCommunications and

ApplicationsSwiss Federal Institute ofTechnology – LausanneCH-1015, Switzerland����������� � ����������������������������� ���

Levente ButtyanInstitute for ComputerCommunications and

ApplicationsSwiss Federal Institute ofTechnology – LausanneCH-1015, Switzerland ��"! ����#$���&%'��#(#*)�������������� ���

Srdan CapkunInstitute for ComputerCommunications and

ApplicationsSwiss Federal Institute ofTechnology – LausanneCH-1015, Switzerland+ ��,-���.�0/1�2��3�������������� ���

ABSTRACT4"57698(:<;=:?><@A><8$:?B*CD5FEHGI5FJLKNMN>O8FPDCL5QBOEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@WC�8U@XJ�>�><EY6Z5U[B<\L@A>(PY]":?KNGI8$:?KNM ^_5FE_:?5F\"R?KNEL`7KN@A@�\�>�@�ab4">�B�\L:?K R&^;T5FEYR?C�>X5UR?C�>c:C�8UE�P ;�C�8U@=J�>�><Ed`FK ef><Eg8hMN5(ST>c:1]":?KN5U:AK Ri^fa�jTC�KN@=]�8U]�>�:=]L:?5(e"KNPL>�@8UE'5$ef>c:?eQKN>�Sk5U6L@A>�B<\":?K Ri^�]L:?5UJ�MN>�Gh@l6Z5$:2Gh5FJ�K MN>m8FPnCL5B.EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�;PLKN@�RAKNE�`F\LKN@ACLKNEL`XR?C�>�R?C":?>(8(R?@n5FEoJ�8U@AK BIGh><B*C�8UE�K @AGI@�8UE�Pg5FEk@A>�[B<\":?K Ri^'GI>�B*C�8UELKN@AGh@�a�p&R2R?C�>�EhPL>�@ABc:?KNJ�>�@.5F\":m@A5FM \LR?K 5FEhR?5�]L:?5URA><BcRR?C�>I@A><B�\":?K Ri^kGh><B*C�8UE�KN@�GI@�adjTC�>I5U:?KN`FK E�8UMT6Z><8$R?\":?><@�5U6qR?CLKN@'@A5U[MN\LR?K 5FE_KNELB<M \�P">WR?C�8(RdrsKut�K RhKN@�6Z\�MNM ^YPL>�B�><ERA:*8UM KNv�>(P_8UE�PHrsKNKutw8$MNME�5QPL>�@x8$:?>n8U@�@AKN`FEL>(Py><zQ\LKNeF8$MN>�EQR{:?5FM ><@�a

1. INTRODUCTIONj{CL>�:?><B�>�EQR=C�K @�R?5U:A^O5U6.R?C�>�piER?>c:?EL>�R�8UE�PO5U6mB�>�MNMN\LMu8$:'EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@C�8U@'@ACL5(SqE|R?C�8$R'K 6x@A>�B�\L:?K R&^o5U6}8y`FKNef>�E|E�>cRiSm5U:?V78$:ABcCLK R?>�BcR?\L:?>KN@�EL5UR�]":?5F]�>c:?M ^OP">�@AKN`FEL>(Py60:?5FG~R?CL>nef>c:A^dJ�>�`FKNELE�KNEL`";�R?C�>�EyR?C�>@A><B�\L:AK Ri^1JL:?><8UB*C�>�@lSxK MNMQJ�>m>c�L]LMN5FK R?>(PnJ^�G�8UM KNB�KN5F\�@�\�@�>�:?@�a2�X5U:?>�[5$ef>c:<; K EQR�:?5QPL\�B�KNEL`I5$:}:?>�KNE"6Z5U:?B�KNE�`I@A>�B<\":?K R&^yGI>�B*C�8$E�KN@AGh@'�n�"�$�*����?�*� � �c� B<8UE�J�>T8qef>�:A^�]�8UK EL6Z\LML8UE�Pn>c�L]�>�EL@AKNef>.]":?5B<>�@A@�am4Q><B�\L:?K Ri^KNEwGI5FJLKNMN>{8UP�CL5B{E�>cRiST5U:AV"@�KN@2]�8$:AR?K B<\LMu8$:?M ^wPLK �hB�\�M R2R?5=8UB*C�K ><ef>U;E�5UR*8UJLM ^wJ�>�B(8$\�@A>x5U6 R?CL>xeQ\LMNE�>c:*8UJLKNMNK Ri^�5U6 R?CL>qMNKNELV"@c;R?C�>qM KNGIK R?><P]�C^L@�KNB<8UM{]L:?5UR?>�BcR?KN5FE�5$6=><8UB*C�5U6xR?C�>�E�5QP"><@�;-R?CL>W@A]�5$:*8FPLK BXE�8$[R?\L:?>{5U6�B�5FELE�>�B�R?K e"K Ri^f;FR?CL>qP"^"E�8$GIKNB<8UMNM ^�B*C�8UEL`FKNEL`�R?5F]�5FM 5F`U^;fR?C�>8UJ�@A>�E�B�>�5$6x8XB<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?KN5FE_8$\LR?CL5U:?K R&^;28UE�PoR?CL>wMu8UB*Vk5$6x8XB<>�EL[RA:*8UMNK v<><PyGI5UE�K R?5$:?KNE�`w5U:xGI8UE�8U`U><Gh><ER{]�5FK EQR�a

�TM >(8(:?M ^;F@A>�B<\":?K R&^�:?><z\�K :A><Gh><ER?@lP"><]�>�E�P�ef>�:�^�G�\�B*C=5FE1R?CL>.VQKNE�P5U6�GhKN@A@AK 5FE16Z5U:lSqC�K B*C1R?C�>-GI5FJLKNMN>-8FP1CL5QB-E�>cRiST5U:AV�C�8$@�J�><>�E1B�5FEL[B<>�KNef><P ;�8UE�PhR?CL>x><EQeQK :?5FELGI>�ERmKNEISqC�KNB*C�K R{C�[email protected]?5'5F]�>c:*8$R?>UaT�L5U:>��L8UGh]�MN>U;}8oGIK MNK R*8(:A^YGI5UJ�KNM >O8FPYC�5BOE�>cRiST5U:AV_B<>c:AR*8UK E�M ^_SqK MNMC�8(ef>yef>c:A^7@�RA:?KNEL`F>�EQRh:?><zQ\LK :?>�Gh><ER?@wKNE�R?>c:?Gh@I5U6=B�5FEL��PL>�ER?Ku8UM [K Ri^y8UE�Py:?>�@AKN@�R*8$E�B�>nR?5WP"><ELKu8UM�5U6.@�>�:?eQKNB�>�8$RAR*8$BcVQ@�a1�X>�B*C�8UELKN@AGh@R?5=>�E�B�5F\":*8U`F>{B<55F]�>�:*8$RAKN5FEwJ�>cRiST>�><E'EL5QPL>�@{rs8U@2]":?><@�><ER?><PnMu8$R?>c:ctB(8UE'J�>mC�KN`UC�M ^nPL>�@AK :*8UJLMN>TKNE�8qB�KNeQKNMNKN8UE�B<5FER?>c�QR<;FSqCL>�:?><8U@�R?C�>c^nP"5E�5URnGI8UVf>�G�\�B*CO@A>�E�@A>hKNEOR?CL><K :nGhKNMNK R?8$:A^gB<5F\LER?>�:A]�8$:AR<aI�X5U:?>�[5$ef>c:<;T8$E�5FE^"GIK Ri^OSqKNMNM{\L@A\�8UM M ^|J�>WP"><@AK :*8UJ�M >WKNE|J�5UR?C|GhKNM K R*8$:A^8UE�PXB�KNeQKNMNKN8UEdB�5FEQR?>c�QR?@�;�JL\LR{SqK R?CdP"K � >c:?>�EQR{��8(ef5U:?@c�mK EXR?C�>�B(8U@�>

5U6�R?CL>�J�8$RAR?MN>c��>�MuP�;LK RqKN@qKNGh]�5U:�R*8UERTR?5�C�KuP">=R?CL>�M 5QB<8$R?K 5FEy5U6�R?C�>CL>(8UP�z\�8$:ARA>�:?@�;FSqC�>c:?><8U@-K Eh8}B<5UGIGh>�:AB<KN8UM"@�B<>�E�8$:?K 5";L8xB<5FEL@A\�Gh>c:GI8<^wSqKN@AC�R?5�]L:?5URA><BcRqC�K @T]L:?KNeU8UB�^hSqK R?C�:?><@�]�><BcR{R?5�8'`FKNef>�EX@A>c:A[eQKNB�>q]L:?5(e"KNPL>c:.5U:.GI>c:?B*C�8$EQR<a��}EL5UR?C�>c:.>c�L8UGI]LMN>{KN@n�iv<>c:?5nB�5FE"��`U[\":*8$R?K 5FE���EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@gr9S{S{S�a v�>c:?5B<5FE"6&a 5U:A`t*;nSqCL>�:A>oEL5QPL>�@WG�\�@iRJ�>X8UJLMN>WR?5g8U\"R?C�>�ER?KNB<8$R?>X><8UB*C�5UR?CL>�:w>�ef><E|KNE|R?CL>X8UJL@A><ELB�>X5U68UE^YK EL60:*8U@�R�:?\�BcR?\L:A>Fa��m>cR�8UE�5UR?CL>�:�>c��8UGh]LMN>yKN@��i@A]�5FER*8UEL><5F\L@EL>�R&ST5U:?VQKNEL`F�Y� �$�(�s;TSqC�>c:?>X@A>�B<\":?K R&^_8U@A@A5B�Ku8$R?K 5FE�@�B(8UEYM ><ef>c:*8U`F>5FEdR?CL>1RA:?\L@�Rx:?><MN8$R?KN5FEL@AC�K ]�@=J�>�R&ST>�><EyR?CL>n]�>�5F]�M >'KNEQef5FMNef><P a=��K [E�8UMNM ^;.8yE�>cRiSm5U:?Vg5U6}@�><EL@A5U:?@'SqKNMNMm`F><EL>�:*8$MNM ^7C�8(ef>h@A>�B<\":?K R&^k:A>�[z\LK :?>�GI>�ER?@wRAC�8$R�8$:?>gz\�K RA>dPLK ��>�:?>�ERI60:A5FG�8FPYC�5ByEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@B�5FGh]L:?K @A>(P�5U6-]�>�:?@A5UE�8UMlB�5FGIG�\LE�KNB<8$R?K 5FEXP"><eQKNB�><@1� �f���sa

� >�ef>�:AR?CL><M ><@�@�;@A>�B�\L:?K R&^':?><zQ\LK :?>�GI>�ER?@28UE�P'Gh><B*C�8UE�KN@�GI@�>��"CLKNJ�K RK EQRA>�:?>�@�R?KNEL`7B�5FGhGI5UE�8UMNK R?KN>�@�8UBc:?5F@A@�GI5U@�RhGI5FJLKNMN>d8UPYCL5ByE�>cRA[Sm5U:?VQ@�;2SxCLKNB*C7Sm>W8$:?>IE�5<S�`F5FKNEL`ORA5d]L:?>�@A>�EQR�8$E�PkPLKN@AB�\L@A@�ag�]":?5F]�>c:ARi^gR?C�8$RnST>hSqKNMNMmGh>�EQRAKN5FEo@A><ef>c:*8UM.R?K GI>�@nKN@I� �*� � �i� �A  �$¡ � �¢ � �9� �$¡�;qE�8UGh>�M ^|R?CL>d8UJLKNMNK R&^_5U618oGh5FJ�K MN>d8FP_CL5QBXE�>cRiST5U:?V7R?5Sm5U:?VYSqK R?C�5U\LRd8UE^£>c�"RA>�:?E�8UM�GI8UE�8$`F><Gh>�EQR�5U:yB�5FEL��`F\L:?8$R?KN5FE a�xM R?CL5F\�`FCIE�5$Rq8UMNM Gh5FJ�K MN>�8UP�C�5B}E�>cRiST5$:?V"@{8(:?>=@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv�>(P�;RAC�KN@I]L:?5F]�>�:AR&^�KN@W8U@A@A\LGI><P�KNE£Gh5F@�RI5U6�R?CL>y5FE�`U5FKNE�`k:?>�@A>(8$:ABcC]":?5(¤�><BcR?@�a4Q><B�\":?K Ri^hB<8UEWJ�>}]�>c:?B�><KNef><PW8$E�P�K GI]LMN>�GI>�ER?>(Pw8$RxP"K � >c:?>�EQRTM ><e[>�MN@�aopiE7]�8$:AR?K B<\LMu8$:<;mK R�KN@�]�5F@A@AKNJLMN>WR?5O>�G�J�><Pk@A>�B<\":?K R&^7Gh>�BcC�8$[ELKN@AGh@=K EgRAC�>�8U]L]�MNK B(8$RAKN5FE�a�jTC�K @1]�8U]�>�:}SqKNMNM-E�5UR=B<5FEL@AKuP">�:=R?C�K @VQKNE�Pd5U6m@A>�B�\L:?K R&^�¥�:*8$R?CL>�:�;lK R}SqKNMNM�6Z5B<\L@�5FEOR?CL>'@A><B�\L:AK Ri^dGh>�B*CL[8UELKN@AGh@�SqCLKNB*Co8$:?>�:?><MN8$R?><PgR?5WRAC�>�ef>c:A^OE�8$R?\":?>�5U6TR?CL>�V"K E�PO5U6EL>�R&ST5U:?V�\�E�PL>c:{@AB�:A\LR?K EQ^fa

jTCL>n:?>�@�R15U62R?C�>']�8U]�>c:�KN@=5U:?`f8UELKNv�>(POKNEdR?CL>16Z5FMNM 5(SqKNEL`XS{8<^fa=piE4Q><BcR?K 5FEd�;LST>�SqK MNM :?>c��EL>=R?CL>�KuP"><ER?K ��B<8$R?KN5FEX5$6�R?CL>=R?C":?><8$R?@�a-piE4Q><BcR?K 5FE7¦Q;lST>wSqK MNM.@A>�>wC�5<S§R?C�>�J�8$@AKNBhGI>�B*C�8UELKN@AGh@=5$6{@A\�B*Co8EL>�R&ST5U:?VIB(8$EXJ�>�]":?5UR?>�B�RA>(P�a-piEd4Q><BcR?KN5FEW¨";LST>=SqK MNMl8FP�PQ:?>�@A@{R?C�>P"K �hB�\�M R}z\�>�@�R?KN5UEd5U6-]":?5UR?>�B�R?K E�`wR?C�>�@A><B�\":?K Ri^WGI>�B*C�8UELKN@AGh@�a.piE4Q><BcR?K 5FE�©;fST>{SqKNMNML]L:?>�@A>�EQR-5F\L:-@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEwR?5=R?C�>TMu8(RAR?>�:.]L:?5FJLMN>�Gyaª >=SqK MNMlB<5FELB�MN\�P">�R?CL>�]�8$]�>�:xK EO4">�B�R?K 5FEd«Qa

ª CL><Ek8U]�]":?5F]":?Ku8$R?>U;�ST>wSqKNMNM.:A>�6Z>c:'R?5d8W:?>�@A><8$:?B*C|]":?5F`U:*8UG¬ST>C�8(ef>n:?>�B�><ER?M ^X@�R*8$:AR?><P ; B<8UMNMN><P�­ �?�*®w� ¡��(¯ � �W� �F;2�<¨";�©(�s; 6Z5B<\L@A>(P5FEX@A><M 60[&5U:A`f8UE�K v<><PyGI5UJ�KNM >n8FPXCL5QB=E�>cRiST5$:?V"@ca

2. THREATSp&EWR?CLKN@{@A>�B�R?K 5FE�;LST>=SqKNMNMlP"><@ABc:?KNJ�>�R?C�>}Gh5F@�RqKNGh]�5U:AR*8UERTR?C":?><8$R?@RAC�8$R=GI5FJLKNMN>�8UPgCL5BwEL>cRiST5U:?VQ@}C�8(ef>nRA5�698UB�>Fa'°=EL>'B<8UEkP"KN@�R?K EL[

Permission to make digital or hard copies of part or all of this work or personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers, or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. MobiHOC 2001, Long Beach, CA, USA © ACM 2001 1-58113-390-1/01/10…$5.00

146

Some text in this electronic article is rendered in Type 3 or bitmapped fonts, and may display poorly on screen in Adobe Acrobat v. 4.0 and later. However, printouts of this file are unaffected by this problem. We recommend that you print the file for best legibility.
Page 2: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

`F\�KN@�Cy><@A@�><ER?Ku8UM M ^XR&ST5wMN>�ef><MN@q5U6-8$RAR*8UB*V��

� �TRAR?8UB*V"@'5FE7R?C�>��?�$� ���W®������ �$¡ � � ® �W5U6qR?CL>X8FP|CL5BWE�>cRA[Sm5U:?V�;�@�\�B*Cy8U@q:?5F\"R?KNEL`"a��:?><ef>�ER?KN5FEy5U6�R?CL><@A>18$RAR*8UB*VQ@{:?>�[z\LK :?>�@X@A>�B<\":?K R&^HGh>�B*C�8UELKN@AGh@IR?C�8$Rd8$:?>g5U60R?>�E J�8U@A><PH5UEBc:A^"]LRA5F`U:*8U]LC�KNB18UMN`F5U:?K R?C�Gh@�a

� �TRAR?8UB*V"@w5FE�R?CL>O� ����"�*�Z���7®���� � �$¡ � � ® �y8UE�P�EL5UR*8UJLM ^�5UERAC�>�� ���g® �$¡��  Q�*®�� ¡ ��®������ �$¡ � � ® �?a��1>c^kG�8UE�8U`F>�GI>�ERK @{B<>c:AR*8UK E�M ^�E�5UR{8�]":?5FJLMN>�G MNK GIK R?>(PhR?5�8FPWCL5B=EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�a� 5(Sm><ef>c:<;{J�><B<8U\�@�>y5U6=RAC�>X]�>�B�\�MNKN8$:?K R?K ><@I5U618UP_C�5ByE�>cRA[Sm5U:?VQ@�;�K R?@q@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEX:A>(z\�K :?><@q@A]�><B�K ��Bn8$RAR?>�ER?KN5FE a

2.1 Vulnerabilities of the basic mechanisms� ELMNKNVf>wE�5QP"><@n5$6xB�5FEQef>�EQR?K 5FE�8UMqr9SqK :?>�MNKNEL>$t1EL>cRiST5U:?VQ@�;�EL5QPL>�@n5U68FP�CL5QB=E�>cRiST5$:?V"@TB<8UELE�5UR{J�>=8U@A@A\LGI><PIRA5'J�>=@�><B�\L:?><PWK EWMN5B*Vf><PB(8UJLKNEL>�R?@�ahjTC�>c:?>�6Z5$:?>F;lR?C�>c^d:?KN@AVOJ�>�KNEL`��������������! "�$#� %��&('*)�+��&('-,/.0�1 .a.jTCL>qR?>c:?GhKNE�8UMN@-5$6 B<>�MNM \�Mu8$:mE�>cRiST5U:AV"@�;f6Z5U:m>c�L8UGI]LMN>U;C�8(ef>-J�>�><E160:?><z\�>�ER?M ^=@�R?5FMN>�E'5U:lR*8UGh]�>c:?>(P}SxK R?CnJ^=:?5U`F\�>m\L@A>c:?@�;><ER*8UKNM KNEL`�MN5F@A@�><@�R?5}R?CL>m5U:*P">�:25U6�C"\LE�PQ:?>(P"@l5U6�GhKNMNM KN5FEL@25U6�PL5FM Mu8$:?@6Z5U:}RAC�>�5F]�>�:*8(R?5U:?@�a

�}@q8UMNM�B<5FGhG�\�ELKNB<8$R?KN5FEL@{8$:?>�]�>�:A6Z5$:?GI><P2&134�5�6��78�9�$,:�f;�8FPWCL5QBE�>cRiST5U:?VQ@x8$:?>�e"\LMNE�>c:*8UJLMN>=RA5w8$RAR*8UB*VQ@q:?8UE�`FK E�`�60:?5FG ><8(ef>�@?PQ:?5F]L[]�KNEL`�R?5I8$B�R?K ef>1KNER?>c:A6Z>�:A><ELB<>Ua

�}EL5UR?C�>c:x]L:?5FJLMN>�G :?>�Mu8$RA>(PWR?5�R?CL>1]L:A><eQKN5F\L@q5FE�>1K @{R?C�8$RqR?CL>n8UM [`F5U:?K R?CLGI@W8$:?>o8U@A@A\LGI><P_R?5|J�>���&(&��;�5�<�!��,:34��a �L5U:X>c�L8UGI]LMN>U;KNE�8_�y�}� MN8<^>c:<;�E�5QPL>�@y8$:A>k>c�L]�><BcR?><P£RA5_B<55F]�>c:*8$R?>Ua piEH8B<5FER?>�ER?KN5FE"[&J�8U@A>(PdGh>�BcC�8UELKN@AGX; EL5QPL>�@�G�\�@iR}6Z5FM MN5(S§R?CL>']L:A>(P">�[��E�><P7:?\LMN>�@hRA5k8<ef5FKuP�B�5FMNM KN@AKN5FEL@W5U:w:?>�B<5(ef>�:w60:?5FG R?C�>�GXa�p&E_8B<5FER?>�ER?KN5FE"[�60:?>�>xGI>�B*C�8UELKN@AG r9SqCLKNB*CIK @TJ�>cRAR?>c:m@A\�K R?><PwR?5'8UPICL5QBE�>cRiST5U:?VQ@*t*;>(8$BcCwEL5"P">{G�\�@�R25FJ"R*8UKNEh8UEh8U`U:?>�><Gh>�EQR260:?5FG�8UMNM"R?C�>5UR?C�>c:?@{6Z5U:=8UEy>��"B�MN\L@AKNef>1\L@A>15U6�R?CL>1B*C�8UELE�>�M�:?>�@A5F\L:AB<>UaTp&EXJ�5URACB(8U@A>�@�;�K 628�E�5QPL>1PL5>�@}EL5UR{:?>�@A]�>�B�RqR?CL>�:?\�M ><@�;LRAC�>n8UM MN5B(8(R?KN5FEO5U6R?C�>XB�5FGhG�\�ELKNB<8$R?KN5FE7BcC�8UE�EL>�MmSxK MNMqJ�>X\LEL698UK :�8$E�P7R?CL>W]�>c:A6Z5U:A[G�8UELB<>=5U62RAC�>�EL>cRiST5U:?VIB<8UEyJ�>1@A>�ef>c:?><M ^X8$� >�BcR?>(P�a

= &4�8��,/#�>?'@�1�A78�$#�,/.<'@.18$:?>1Gh5U:?>=e"\LMNEL>�:*8$J�MN>=KNEd8FPXCL5B1E�>cRA[ST5U:?VQ@TR?C�8UEIKNE�B<5FEQef>�EQR?K 5FE�8UM�E�>cRiST5U:AV"@TJ�>�B<8U\�@A>}KNEW8FPICL5B�E�>cRA[ST5U:?VQ@q>(8UB*CyP"><eQKNB�>18$B�R?@x8U@x8n:?>�Mu8<^fa.jTC�KN@qGh><8UE�@�;"6Z5U:x>c�L8UGI]LMN>U;R?C�8$R28UE'8FP"ef>�:A@?8$:A^�SqCL5}CLK ¤A8UB*VQ@�8UE�8FP1C�5BmEL5QPL>mB�5F\LMuP1]�8$:*8UM ^"v�>R?C�>h><ER?K :?>IEL>�R&ST5U:?VOJ^oPLKN@�@A><GhKNE�8$R?KNEL`X698UMN@A>I:?5F\"R?KNE�`XKNEL6Z5U:AG�8$[R?KN5FE aT�HMN>�@A@xP":*8UGI8$R?K B�J�\"R{Gh5U:?>=@A\LJLRAMN>�GI8UMNK B<KN5U\�@{J�>�C�8<e"K 5U:qKN@E�5QPL>�� �*� B � � ¡ � �?�U��@A5FGh>wEL5QPL>�@�GI8<^XJ�>nR?>�GI]"R?>(PXR?5�E�5UR=:?>�Mu8<^]�8UB*Vf>cR?@1rs>Fa `"aN;�KNEX5U:?PL>c:qR?5h@A8(ef>�R?CL><K :q5(SqEyJ�8(RAR?>�:�^�t}� ��C$�sa

�X5U:?><5(ef>�:�;-Sm>(8UVQEL><@A@A>�@'KNEgR?CL>I]":?5UR?5B�5FMN@'B<8UE7J�>h>c�L]LMN5FK R?>(PgR?5]�>�:�6Z5U:?G G�8UM KNB�KN5F\�@D#��1,:>47(EF&$�� +,/.���&!3$�1��G2aI��5U:1>��L8UGh]�M >F; :?>�[@A>(8$:ABcCL>c:?@'C�8<ef>w:?>�B�><ER?M ^g@ACL5(SqEkC�5(S§RAC�KN@nVQKNE�Pg5U6q8$RAR*8UB*VgB(8$EJ�>1]�>c:A6Z5U:?Gh><PX8U`f8UKNEL@�R=8IHmM \�>cR?55UR?COP"><eQKNB�>w� �$©(�sa

2.2 Vulnerabilities of the security mechanismspiEge"K :AR?\�8$MNM ^g8UE^OE�>cRiSm5U:?V�;�R?CL>'6Z\�E�PL8UGh><ER*8UM�@A>�B<\":?K R&^OGI>�B*C�8$[E�KN@AGh@x:?>(z\LK :?>nR?C�8$R}RAC�>'\�@�>�:?@}GI8UVf>n\�@A>'5$6m8U]L]L:?5F]":?Ku8$R?>�Bc:A^"]L[R?5F`U:*8U]LC�KNBXV>c^"@�a_�}@wGh><ER?KN5FEL><P7KNE � �AJ$�s;TR?C�>W`U5f8UM}5$6�8g`F55QPB�:A^"]"R?5F`U:*8U]LC�KNBwP"><@AK `FEgKN@=R?5I:?><PL\�B�>�B�5FGI]LMN>c�y]L:A5FJ�MN>�Gh@}R?5IR?C�>]L:?5F]�>c:�G�8UE�8U`F>�GI>�ER�8UE�Pg@A8$6Z>�[�Vf>�><]LKNEL`W5U6T8I@AG�8$MNM2EQ\LGwJ�>�:}5U6B�:A^"]"R?5F`U:*8U]LC�KNBxVf>c^L@�a2j{CLKN@T5FJQ¤�>�BcR?KNef>}KN@TPLK �hB<\LM RmR?5�8UB�B�5FGI]LMNKN@�CKNE£8UE£8FP_C�5ByEL>�R&ST5U:?V£rsKNE_SqC�K B*C�R?C�>dP"K � >c:?>�EQRhEL5QPL>�@IGh5$ef>8$:?5F\�E�Py8UE�PWKNEXSqCLKNB*CXB�5FE�EL><BcR?KNeQK R&^WK @}EL5URq`F\�8$:?8UEQR?>�><P�t*a

K ��8$GI]LMN>�@W5U6'8$R�R*8UB*V"@X8U`f8UKNEL@�RXR?CL>O@A><B�\L:AK Ri^YGh>�BcC�8UE�K @AGh@W8$:?>RAC�>T6Z5FMNM 5(SqKNEL`"�.]�\LJ�MNK BxVf>c^"@-B<8UEwJ�>qG�8UM KNB�KN5F\�@�M ^�:?>�]�Mu8UB�><P ¥"@A5UGI>Vf>c^"@TB(8UEWJ�>=B�5FGh]L:?5UGIKN@�>(P�¥"K 6�R?C�>c:?>}KN@q8�r�PLK @�RA:?KNJL\LRA>(P�t-RA:?\�@iR?>(P@�>�:?ef>c:<;xK RXB<8UEY698UMNM�\LE�P">�:IR?C�>XB<5FERA:?5FM}5U6�8oG�8UM KNB�KN5F\L@W]�8$:�Ri^ajTCL><@�>hR?C":?><8$R?@n8$:?>wE�5$Rn@A]�>�B<K ��B�R?5y8FPgCL5QBwEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�;�JL\LR=R?C�>@�5FMN\LRAKN5FE�@wC�8(ef>IRA5OR?8UVf>WKNER?5g8UB�B<5U\�ER�R?C�>I]�>�B<\LMNKu8$:?K R?KN>�@I5$6�8FPCL5B1E�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@�a

3. PROTECTION OF THE BASIC MECHA-NISMSp&E1R?CLKN@l@A><BcR?KN5UE�;UST>.SqKNMNMQB�5FE�@�KuPL>c:28xB�>c:AR*8UKNE'EQ\�G�J�>c:�5U6L@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEL@

RAC�8$R�B<8UE�J�>�PL>�]�M 5(^><P7KNE75U:*PL>c:�R?5yR?CS{8$:AR�R?CL>W8$RAR?8UB*V"@'Gh>�EL[RAKN5FE�><PwKNE�4"\�JL@A>�B�R?K 5FEI�aN�Fa ª >{SqK MNM�EL5URm8FPLP":?>�@[email protected]?CL>{]L:?5$R?><BcR?KN5FE5U6lR?CL>q:*8FPLK 5wK EQRA>�:A698$B<>�rs>Fa `"aN;L]":?><ef>�ER?KN5FEI5U6�>(8<ef><@?PQ:?5F]L]�KNEL`�8UE�P¤A8$GIGhKNEL`t*;m8U@wRAC�KN@wKN@�@A\�>XK @hEL5UR�:?><8UMNM ^�@A]�>�B<K ��BWR?5OGh5FJ�K MN>y8FPCL5BxEL>cRiST5U:?VQ@�a.jTCLKN@.]":?5FJ�M ><G§C�[email protected]�>�><EhKNER?>�E�@�KNef><M ^':?><@�>(8$:?B*CL>(P6Z5$:1eQK :AR?\�8UMNM ^O8$MNM2SqK :?><M ><@A@�E�>cRiST5U:AV"@=8UE�PdGI8UE^y@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEL@�C�8(ef>J�><>�EW]":?5F]�5F@A><PW8UE�PWP"><]LMN5<^Q><P�;"@A\�B*C�8U@{@A]L:A>(8FPI@A]�>�B�RA:A\�G B<5FGw[G�\LE�KNB<8$R?K 5FEy8UE�P�60:?><zQ\L><ELBc^WC�5U]�]LKNE�`X� �F�c�sa

3.1 Tamper resistance�x@-8=PL>�eQKNB�>[email protected]$R2:?KN@AVn5U6�J�>�KNEL`�B<8U]LR?\":?><P'8UE�P�C�K ¤A8UB*Vf>(P�;fK R.G�\�@iRJ�>I]":?5UR?>�B�R?><PoKNEk@�5FGI>wS{8<^faXjTC�>hB<5UE"ef>�ER?KN5FE�8UM.@A5FM \LR?KN5UE|B�5FEL[@�KN@�R?@mK Eh]":?5UR?>�B�RAKNE�`=R?C�>qP"><eQKNB�>�rs5U:m]�8$:AR.5$6 K Rct�JQ^'K GI]LMN>�GI>�ER?KNEL`K RqKNEXR*8UGh]�>c:T:?>�@AKN@�R*8UERxC�8$:?P"S{8$:?>wr96Z5U:}8�B�:?K R?KNB<8UMl8U@A@A>�@A@AGh><ERx5U6R?8UGI]�>c:}:?><@�KN@�R*8UER'P"><eQKNB�>�@�;l@A>�>X� �;��U�(�Zt*ah� �L:?@�R�5F]LR?K 5FEgSm5F\�MuPB�5FEL@AKN@�RTK Eh>�G�J�><P�P"KNE�`}R?C�>{Bc:A^"]LR?5U`U:*8U]�CLKNBqKNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FEyr9R?CL>x@�>�[Bc:?>cRqVf>�^f;Ri^"]LKNB<8UMNM ^�tmKNEW8'@AG�8$:�R{B(8$:*P�;"SqC�K B*CWB�5F\�MuP�J�>=]LMN\L`F`F>(P8UE�PX:?>�GI5(ef>(PW8$R}SqK MNM2K EQRA5I8UE�PX60:?5FG R?CL>1EL5"P">nK RA@A><M 6&¥ R?CL>�4"p��B<8$:*PyJ�8U@A><PX@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEd5U6ML14L� ST5U:AV"@}8UB�B<5U:?PLKNEL`hRA5wR?CLKN@x]L:?K E�B�K []LMN>UawjTCL>I8UPLeF8UER*8U`F>�5U6T8I:?>�GI5(eF8UJLMN>�B(8$:?PgK @�R?C�8(R1K R18UMNMN5<Sq@'8\L@A>c:=R?5IB*C�8UEL`F>�PL>�eQKNB�><@xSqC�KNM >�Vf><>�]�K E�`IC�>c:=5<SqEg]":?KNeU8$R?>�P�8$R?8Qa�xEw8FP�P"K R?K 5FE�8UM�8FPLeU8UEQR*8$`F>TKN@-R?C�8$R-8UMNMLRAC�>T@A>�E�@�K R?KNef>{KNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FEK @1]L:A5UR?><BcR?><POJQ^dR?CL>�@AG�8(:AR1B<8$:*P awjTC�>c:?>h8$:?>h8UMN@A5dPQ:*8<SqJ�8UB*V"@c�J^�K [email protected]�8$RA\L:?>U;R?CL>q@AG�8$:�R.B<8$:*PIC�[email protected] :?><BcRmK E�]L\LRON$5F\"R?]L\LR.B<8$[]�8UJ�K MNK R?K ><@=R?5(S{8$:?PL@�R?CL>'\�@�>�:<;�K RnP"5><@=E�5UR�C�8<ef>'K R?@�5<SqEo]�5(ST>c:@�\�]�]LM ^wEL><K RAC�>c:TPL5>�@mK R.C�8<ef>xK R?@m5(SqEIB<M 5QB*V�a-jTCLKN@mGI8UVf><@-@AG�8(:ARB<8$:*P"@heQ\LMNE�>c:*8UJLMN>WR?5g8$R�R*8UB*V"@wGh5F\�ER?><Pk60:?5FG 8gB�5FGh]L:?5UGIKN@�>(PP"><eQKNB�>1K EWSqC�K BcCWR?C�>c^X8$:A>1]�M \�`F`F><PXKNE a�xEw8FP�P"K R?K 5FE�8UMLE�>�>(P�KN@�R?5�]":?5UR?>�BcR-R?CL>qEL>cRiST5U:?VQKNEL`�Gh>�BcC�8UE�K @AGh@>�G�J�><P�P">(PhKNEWR?CL>�EL5QPL>wr9>Fa `"aN;L:?5F\"R?KNEL`t*am� @A5FM \LR?KN5UEyKN@{R?5�@�R?5U:?>RAC�>I:A><MN8$R?>(Pk@A5U60RiST8$:?>XKNE78d@AG�8(:AR'B<8$:*P adp&6{R?CL>�@AGI8$:AR'B<8$:*P7K @EL5URq]�5(Sm>�:A6Z\LM >�E�5F\L`FC�;�8']�5F@�@AKNJLKNMNK R&^XB�5FE�@AK @�R?@qKNE�G�8UVQKNEL`'\�@A>=5U6@�><B�\L:?K Ri^w]L:A5QB�>�@A@A5U:?@�;"SqCLKNB*ChB<5FGh]L:AKN@A>x8�]L:A5QB�>�@A@A5U:<;L@A5UGI>qGh><Gw[5U:�^;{8UE�P_8U]L]L:?5U]L:?Ku8(R?>yR*8UGh]�>�:IP">�R?>�BcR?KN5FE_B�K :?B�\�K RA:A^ � �(�sa jTC�K @B<8UEY]":?5$eQKuP">XGI5U:A>W@A>�B<\":?K R&^�R?C�8UE�R?C�>W@AG�8$:�RhB<8$:*P�aDjTCL>�:?>yK @@iR?KNMNMT8�]L:?5FJLMN>�Gy;lC�5<ST><ef>c:<�'8X@A5U60RiST8$:?>�]�8UB*VF8U`F>h@A\LBcCk8U@1:?5U\LRA[K E�`wC�8U@TRA5hJ�>=\�]L`U:*8FP">(PI60:?5FG R?K GI>xR?5�R?KNGh>Fa.jTCL>�:?>c6Z5U:?>U;�R?C�>c:?>G�\L@�R�J�>X8dGh>�BcC�8UE�K @AG J^oSqC�KNB*C7R?C�>I5F]�>c:*8$R?KNEL`o@i^L@�RA><G B(8UEB*CL><B*VhR?C�8$Rx8�EL>�S ef>�:A@AKN5FEy5U62@A5U60R&S{8$:?>nKN@x8�MN>�`FK R?K G�8$RA>n5FE�>Ua�Y:?>�Mu8$R?><PIK @A@A\L>}KN@q� � � �i�*® �Z® � �c� ¡ �9� ¡   �28$RTKNELK R?Ku8$MNKNv<8$R?KN5FE ;�81@�^"@�[RA><G G�\L@�R-J�>{R?5FMNP�KNEw5FE�>{S{8�^�5U:T8UEL5UR?C�>c:-R?5=SqC�5FG�8UE�PwCL5(S_K RC�8U@qR?5w5FJ�>�^grsE�8$GI>�M ^ISxCL5I8$:?>nK R?@ � �*� �?;�SqC�8(R=KN@qR?CL>�KuP">�EQR?K Ri^5U:mR?C�>}B(8$RA><`F5U:�^�5U6lR?CL>}5URAC�>c:qPL>�eQKNB<>�@TK R{K @T><ER?K R?MN><PIR?5'B�5FGhGw\"[ELKNB<8$R?>nSqK R?C ;�SxC�8$R=8$:?>nR?CL>'8UB<B�>�@A@}:?K `FCR?@�;�>�R?B(t*a}jTCL>n@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEL@SqK MNMqef>�:A^kG�\�B*C|PL>�]�>�E�P75FE7R?C�> � � � ���$¡ ¯8P/Q�*�9�*� 5U6}RAC�>WGh5FJLKNMN>8FPhC�5BxE�>cRiSm5U:?V�a-��5U:{8UEI><ER?>c:AR*8UK E�KNEL`'8UE�PwR?CL5F\�`UCQRA[�]L:A5$ef5FVQKNEL`P"KN@AB�\�@A@�KN5FEk5U6TR?C�K @1KN@A@A\L>F;�@A><>y� �F©<�saWjTC�K @n]�8U]�>c:'8UM @A5OPLK @AB<\L@A@A>�@8UGh5FEL`h5$R?C�>c:?@{R?C�>=J�8$RARA>�:A^�>��"C�8U\�@�R?K 5FEd8$RAR*8UB*V�a

147

Page 3: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

� :A><MN8$R?>(Pd]":?5FJ�M ><G KN@=R?5IVQE�5(S SqC�5FG~RA5IRA:?\L@�R<a}p�6-R?CL>�PL>�e"K B<>KN@w>(z\�K ]�]�><PoSqK R?C_8yR*8UGh]�>c:':?><@�KN@�R*8UERw@A>�B<\":?K R&^7Gh5QPL\LMN>F;-CL5(SPL5�ST>1GI8UVf>=@�\L:?>=R?C�8$R{R?CL>�Mu8(RAR?>�:xC�8U@qE�5URxJ�>�><E�:?><]LMu8UB�><PXJQ^�8698UVf>(PO5FEL>�� K ef>�EOK 6TK R�KN@=R?C�>'M ><`FK R?KNGI8$R?>�5FE�>U;�RA5�SqC�8$R�>c�"R?>�ERPL5OST>�RA:A\�@�R�R?CL>WGI8UEQ\L698UBcR?\L:?>c:�� �mMN><8$:?M ^;mR?C�>�G�8UEQ\"698UB�RA\L:?>c:Gw\L@�R1J�>w:A><`F\LMu8$:?M ^k@ABc:?\"R?KNELKNv�>(PoJQ^g8UEk8U]L]L:?5F]":?Ku8$R?>I8U\"R?C�5U:AK Ri^faHm\LRxC�>c:?>�8U`f8UKNE ;�P"5'ST>�RA:?\L@�RqR?C�K @q8U\LR?CL5U:?K R&^��

3.2 Routing-based mechanismspiE1Gh5FJ�K MN>m8FP=C�5B.EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�;F8{MN5UR�5U6Q:?><@�>(8$:?B*CnC�8U@lJ�>�><E'P">�ef5UR?>(PR?5d:?5F\LR?K E�`g8UMN`U5U:?K R?CLGI@�a � 5(ST>�ef>c:<;-KNE�Gh5F@�R�B<8U@A>�@�;mRAC�>WEL5QPL>�@8$:?>�8$@A@A\�Gh><PoR?5XJ�>IB�55F]�>c:*8$R?KNef>UaXpiELK R?Ku8UM2ST5U:?Vg5FEoGIK RAKN`f8$R?K E�`:?5F\LR?K E�`hGIK @AJ�>�C�8<e"K 5U:}K EdGI5FJLKNM >n8FPXCL5QBnEL>cRiST5U:?VQ@qKN@x]L:?5U]�5F@A><PKNEd� ��C$�sa-p&EwRAC�KN@-]�8U]�>c:<;FR?C�>q8U\"R?C�5U:[email protected]<5UE�@AKuP">c:.R?C�>{B<8U@A>qKNEwSqC�K B*C@A5FGI>IGI8UMNKNB�KN5F\L@�E�5QPL>�@w8U`U:?>�>�R?5d6Z5U:�S{8$:*P|]�8UB*Vf>�R?@'JL\LR'698$KNMTR?5PL5k@A5"aHpiEY5U:?PL>c:�R?5oB<5U]�>ySqK R?C_R?CLKN@I]L:?5FJLMN>�Gy;mR?C�>c^�]":?5F]�5F@�>RiST5gGh><B*C�8$E�KN@AGh@��X8��T� � � � ¯�   ;{KNE�B*C�8$:?`F>y5U6}KuP"><ER?K 60^LK E�`OR?C�>GIKN@�J�><C�8(eQKNEL`gE�5QPL>�@�;T8UE�P_8d�"� ���� � ���?� ;xKNE�BcC�8$:?`F>y5U6=P">���E�KNEL`R?C�>1J�><@�R{:?5U\LR?>1B�K :AB<\LGwef>�ER?KNEL`nR?C�>�@A>1EL5QPL>�@�a

j{CL>1]�8U]�>c:q@AC�5<Sx@{R?C�8$R{R?C�>�@A>�R&ST5�Gh><B*C�8UE�KN@�GI@{GI8UVf>=K Rq]�5F@A@AK [J�MN>wR?5XGI8UKNER*8UK EgRAC�>�R?5UR*8UM2R?CL:?5F\L`FC�]L\LR�5U6TR?CL>hEL>�R&ST5U:?VO8$R�8$E8UB<B�>�]LR*8UJLMN>IMN><ef>�M9;2>�ef>�EkK EoR?CL>I]":?>�@A><ELB<>h5U6q8yCLKN`FCk8UGI5U\�ERn5U6GIKN@�J�><C�8(eQKNEL`XE�5QP"><@hrs>Fa `"aN;-¨ J��wt*a � 5<ST>�ef>�:<;lR?C�>w5F]�>c:*8$R?K 5FE|5U6R?C�>XS{8(R?B*C�P"5F`kK @IJ�8U@A>(P_5UEY8UE£8U@A@A\LGI]"R?KN5FE�SqCLKNB*CYKN@hE�5UR�8UM [S{8<^"@hR�:?\�>kr�8$@h:?>�B*Vf5FE�><P�J^7R?CL>y8U\"R?C�5U:A@*t*�dR?CL>W� � � ®w� � �� � �GI5QP">=5U6�R?C�>xSqK :?>�MN>�@A@xKNER?>�:�698UB<>Uam�}EL5UR?C�>c:{]":?5FJ�M ><G KN@TR?C�8$RTR?C�>@A><M ��@ACLE�>�@A@15U6-R?C�>'EL5QPL>�@1PL5>�@�EL5UR1@A>�>�G~R?5WJ�>nB(8U@�RAKN`f8$R?><P ¥�5UER?C�>wB�5FEQR�:*8$:A^;�JQ^dR?CL>wB<5FG�JLKNE�8(R?KN5FEk5U6TR?C�>�S{8$RABcC�PL5F`y8UE�POR?C�>]�8$R?C":*8$R?>c:<;2R?C�>hGhKN@AJ�>�C�8<e"K E�`yEL5QPL>�@nSqKNMNMTEL5UR�J�>hJ�5UR?CL>�:?><P7J^R?C�>qRA:*8UEL@AK RTRA:*8(�IBU;"SqC�K MN>}@�R?KNMNM >�E$¤�5(^"KNE�`nRAC�>x]�5F@A@AK J�KNM K Ri^hR?5'`F>�EL[>�:*8$RA>}8UE�PnR?5=:A><B�><K ef>TRA:*8$�hBFa-jTCL>{]L:?5F]�5F@A>(P�Gh><B*C�8UE�K @AGI@�B�5F\�MNPJ�>T><E":?KNB*CL>(P'KNE�@�\�B*Cw8xS{8�^'R?C�8(R-8}GIK @AJ�>�C�8(eQKNEL`xE�5QPL>mSm5F\�MuP�J�>MN5B*Vf>(Py5F\"RxJQ^�K R?@xE�>�KN`FCQJ�5U:A@�a{jTCL>�:?>�ST5F\�MNPX@�R?KNM M�J�>�RiST5w]":?5FJL[MN><Gh@�;FC�5<ST><ef>c:<�.rsK0t�R?C�>mM 5QB*Vf5F\"R�GI>�B*C�8UELKN@AGbB�5F\LMuPnJ�>T>c�"]�MN5FK R?><PR?5�Gh5F\�ER-PL>�E�Ku8$M [�5U60[&@A>c:?eQKNB�>x8$RAR*8UB*[email protected]�P�rsKNK0t�8=MN5B*Vf><P�5F\LR-E�5QPL>B<5F\LMuPO@AKNGh]�M ^dGI5(ef>'8<S{8�^;�KNEo8UEg8$:?><8�SqC�>c:?>�C�K @�GhKN@AJ�>�C�8<e"K 5U:C�8U@qE�5$Rx^>cRqJ�>�><E�:?><]�5$:AR?>(P�a°=E£R?C�>d5UR?CL>�:WC�8UE�P ;=8$@W]�5FK EQR?><P£5F\LRWKNE � �AC$�9;=B<>c:AR*8UKNED]":?5F]L[>�:AR?K ><@�5U6n8FPYCL5BdE�>cRiST5U:?VQ@IB(8UE£J�>X>��"]�M 5FK R?><P_R?5|8UB*CLKN>�ef>d@A>�[B<\":?>=:?5F\"R?KNEL`"a�}5F\"R?KNEL`�]L:?5URA5QB�5FMN@x5U6�8FPXCL5B�E�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@{C�8(ef>}R?5B<5F]�>nSxK R?Cd5F\LR?P�8$R?><PX:?5F\"R?KNEL`IKNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FEdR?5I8UB�B<5UGI5QPL8$R?>nR?C�>P"^"E�8UGhKNB<8UMNM ^7B*C�8UE�`FK E�`dR?5F]�5FM 5F`U^ao��8UMN@A>�:?5F\LRAKNE�`dK EL6Z5U:?GI8$R?K 5FE`F><EL>�:?8$R?>(PyJ^XB�5FGh]L:?5UGIKN@�>(PWEL5QPL>�@xB<5F\LMuP�;�R?5h@A5FGh>1>c�QR?><ER<;�J�>B<5FEL@AKuP">�:?><PY5F\LR?P�8$R?><P_KNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FE a �}@hMN5FEL`|8U@hR?CL>yE"\LG�J�>c:5U6.B�5U:A:?>�B�R=E�5QP"><@x:?>�G�8UK E�@xC�K `FCd><EL5F\�`FC ;�R?C�>1:?5U\LR?KNEL`h]L:?5UR?5B�5FM@AC�5F\LMuPgJ�>h8UJ�MN>wR?5W��E�Pd:?5F\"R?>�@�R?C�8$RnB�K :?B�\�G�ef>�EQR}R?C�>wB�5FGh]L:?5U[GIKN@�>(P£E�5QP"><@�a �}@�:?5F\LR?K E�`7]L:?5UR?5B�5FMN@yB<8UE PLKN@�B<5(ef>�:yG�\LM R?KN]LMN>:?5F\LR?>�@�;-EL5"P"><@nB(8UEk@�SqK R?B*C7RA5O8UE|8UM R?>�:?E�8$R?KNef>h:?5F\"R?>ISqCL><EoR?C�>]L:?KNGI8$:A^I:?5F\"R?>n8U]L]�>(8$:A@qRA5hC�8(ef>}698UKNMN><P a

�X\�M R?K ]�M >.:?5F\LRA><@�G�8�^=:A>(z\�K :?>-R?C�8$RlR?C�>-@?8UGI>-]�8UB*Vf>cR�KN@�@A><ER�@A>�eQ[>�:*8UM2R?KNGh><@c;�MN><8FPLK E�`WRA5y8�S{8U@�R?8U`F>�5U6.:?><@A5U\L:?B�><@ca � 5<ST><ef>c:<;�8$E8U]�]":?5F]L:?KN8$R?>wB<5QP"KNE�`W@�RA:*8$R?>�`U^OB<8UEo8(ef5FKuPOGh><@A@A8U`F>�:?>�RA:?8UE�@AGhKN@�[@AKN5FE ayjTCL>IJ�8U@AKNBhKuP">(8WKN@1R?5XRA:?8UE�@AGhK R1:A>(P"\�E�P�8UER1K EL6Z5U:?GI8$R?K 5FER?CL:?5F\L`FCh8FP�P"K R?K 5FE�8UM":?5F\LRA><@�6Z5U:.>c:A:?5U:mB�5U:A:?>�BcR?KN5FEI8UE�P�P">�RA><BcR?KN5FE ajTSm5�>c�L8UGI]LMN>�@}5U6�R?CLKN@}8U]�]":?5f8UB*Cg8$:?>W¯ ��f�?� � �Z����� �(¯ � ¡   � ¨U�28UE�P®6"� �s� � �u� ¯ � � �*�*� � �9� �$¡g� ���?�$¡�¯ � �(¯ � ¡   � �<¨U�9a

�}Ed8$RAR?8UB*Vf>�:xB<8UEd8UMN@A5hRA:A^IR?5IGh5QPLK 60^�R?CL>1B�5FER?><ERx5U62RAC�>=:A5F\LRA[KNE�`hR*8UJLMN>Fa1jTCL>'@AKNGh]�M ><@�R}S{8<^WR?5IR?CS{8$:�R�@A\LB*Co8$EO8$RAR*8UB*VyKN@}R?5

8<ef5FKuP�:?5U\LR?K E�`'R*8UJLMN><@c; 8$E�PIRA5wJ�8U@A>1]�8UB*Vf>�Rm6Z5U:AS{8$:*P"KNE�`h5FEX`U><5U[`U:?8U]�CLKNB{KNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FEW� �<¨Q;"©(�sa � 5(ST>�ef>c:<;FRAC�KN@�:?><zQ\LK :?>�@�RAC�8$R�>(8$BcC5U6-R?C�>'EL5QPL>�@�K @18<S{8(:?>�5U6mK R?@=5(SqEg`F>�5F`U:*8U]LC�KNBw]�5F@AK R?KN5FEo8UE�POK @8UJLMN>hR?5y@AC�8$:?>�K R'SqK R?C75$R?C�>c:?@�;2CL><ELB<>hBc:?>(8$RAKNE�`O5UR?CL>c:'V"K E�P"@n5U6eQ\LMNE�>c:*8UJLKNMNK R?KN>�@�ajl5_B�5FE�B�MN\�PL>gR?C�K @y@A\�JL@A>�B�R?K 5FE�;�K RyKN@XST5U:ARAC�Gh><ER?KN5UE�KNEL`|R?C�8$R:A><@A><8$:?B*C�>c:?@�8$:?>d8UM @A5|>c�L]LMN5U:?K E�`gR?C�>X8U]�]LMNKNB<8$R?KN5FE£5U6 � ¡ �9�� � � �$¡¯ �?�i���c�9� �$¡ ����� � ¡ � ���� �=R?5nR?CL>=]":?5UR?>�B�R?K 5FEW5U6�Gh5FJ�K MN>}8FP�CL5QB}E�>cRA[Sm5U:?VQ@n� ���(�sa{�X5U:?>�5$ef>c:<;�]L:?>�ef><ER?K 5FEW5U6�RA:*8$�hBn8UE�8UM ^"@AKN@qC�8U@}8$MN@A5J�><>�EXB�5FE�@AKNPL>c:?><Pk� �(«$�sa

3.3 Neighborhood�TRAR*8$BcVQ@1B<8UE|J�>hJ�8U@A><P75FEoR?C�>w]":?5UR?5B<5UMN@�J�>cRiST>�><EkE�>�KN`FCQJ�5U:?@c;@�\�B*C|8U@nRAC�>hC�>�MNMN5d]":?5UR?5B�5FM9a*H.^oR?CLKN@1RA><B*C�ELKuz\�>U;28UE|8$RAR*8UB*Vf>c:B<8UEo6Z5U:?B<>�8XeQKNBcR?KNG E�5QP">hR?5X\�EQef><K M-]":?KNeF8$RA>�PL8$R*8Q;�@A\LB*C|8U@nK R?@KNPL>�EQRAK Ri^fawp&Eg698UBcR<;�>�ef>�EkK EgR?CL>wGw\LB*CO@AKNGh]�M >�:nB<8U@A>h5U6TB�><M MN\LMu8$:EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�;xK E_SqC�KNB*C£\L@A>�:?@IB<8UE_:?><M ^Y5FE_R?C�>�K :�C�5FGh>yEL>�R&ST5U:?V5F]�>�:*8(R?5U:qR?5�]L:?5UR?>�BcR{R?C�>�K :q]":?KNeF8UBc^;QG�8UE^h@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEL@xC�8(ef>}J�>�><E]":?5F]�5F@�>(P�;�J�\LR{RAC�>1]":?5FJ�M ><G KN@xE�5UR{^>cR{:?><8UMNM ^X@A5FMNef><Pg� «$�9a

p&E'R?C�>m60:*8$GI>cST5U:?V'5U6(HmMN\�>cR?55UR?C ;fR?CL>q8U\LR?CL5U:?@25U6�� �$©<��@ACL5(S_CL5(SRAC�>'8UBcR?KNeQK R&^X5U6.8heQKNBcR?KNG~B<8UEdJ�>�5FJ�@A>c:?ef><PyJQ^X8h@�>�R=5U6.P">�e"K B<>�@K E�@�R*8$MNMN><PHK ED@iRA:*8$R?>�`FKNBo]�Mu8$B<>�@WJ^£8UEH8$RAR*8UB*Vf>c:<a piEYR?C�>O@?8$GI>]�8U]�>c:<;LR?C�>c^�@A\�`F`F>�@�R}8�@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEdJ�8U@A><PW5FEy]L@A><\�PL5FE^"GI@c�2K 6�R?C�>KNPL>�EQRAK Ri^15U6 8}PL>�e"K B<>TB*C�8UE�`F>�@26Z5$:-><8UB*Ch@�><@A@�KN5FE�;FR?C�>�E�K R2J�>�B<5FGh>�@G�\LB*CIGh5U:?>=PLK �hB�\�M RT6Z5U:x8UEWKNERA:?\�PL>c:mR?5nRA:?8UB<>=K R?@TM 5QB<8$R?K 5FEd8UE�PK R?@�8UBcR?K e"K R?KN>�@�a � 5(Sm><ef>c:<; RAC�KN@}KNE�PL\LB<>�@�8hC�K `FC�>c:�B�5FGh]�MN>c�"K R&^y5U6RAC�>18FPLP":A><@A@AK E�`h@AB*C�>�Gh><@�a

3.4 Service enforcementp�6�8UEy8FPWCL5B�E�>cRiSm5U:?V�K @{@A><M 60[&5U:A`f8UE�K v<><P ;�@A>c:?eQKNB�>18(eU8UKNMu8UJLKNMNK Ri^XK @8nGI8<¤�5U:T:?><zQ\LK :?>�GI>�ER<a2jTC�>c:?>=8$:?>=R&ST5'KN@A@�\�>�@��.��K :?@�R<;L>�E�PQ[&\L@A>c:?@G�\L@�RTJ�>}`FKNef>�EWKNELB�><ER?KNef>�@mR?5'B�55F]�>c:*8$R?>wr�8$E�P�EL5UR*8UJLM ^hR?5n:?>�Mu8<^]�8UB*Vf>�RA@16Z5U:nR?CL>IJ�>�EL>��LRn5U6{5UR?CL>�:n\�@A>c:?@*t*ay4">�B�5FE�P�;�R?CL>�^gG�\�@iRJ�>kP"KN@AB�5F\L:?8U`F>(P£60:?5FG 5$ef>c:?MN5f8UPLKNEL`|R?CL>oEL>�R&ST5U:?V�a p&EHGh5FJLKNMN>8FPYCL5BdE�>cRiST5U:AV"@I]L:?5F]�5F@A><PH8UE�P_KNGh]�MN>�Gh><ER?><P�@A57698(:<;qR?CL><@A>R&ST5W8$@A]�>�B�R?@xST>c:?>'K :A:?>�MN>�eF8UER}J�><B<8U\L@A>'5U6-R?CL>n@AGI8UMNM�@AKNv�>'5U62R?C�>EL>�R&ST5U:?V78UE�PoR?C�>I><Gh>c:?`F>�E�Bc^7@AK R?\�8$R?K 5FE�@wKNEkSqC�KNB*C7R?C�>c^kSm>�:?>>c�"]�>�B�R?><PyR?5WJ�>�PL>�]�MN5<^>(P�an�X5U:?>�5$ef>c:<;lR?CL>'E�5QPL>�@}J�><M 5FE�`F><PdR?5RAC�>�@A8UGI>18U\LR?CL5U:?K R&^X8UE�PW@AC�8$:?>(P�R?C�>=@?8UGI>�`F5f8UMN@�a

p&Ek5F\":1:?>�@A><8$:?B*C7]":?5F`U:*8UG � �F;.�<¨";.©(�s;�Sm>IC�8(ef>':?>�GI5(ef>(PdR?CL><@A>8U@�@A\�Gh]LR?K 5FE�@�a��x>�M ^"KNE�`�5FE�R?C�>=5FJ�@A>c:?eF8(R?KN5FEWR?C�8$Rq@A5F]LC�KN@iR?KNB<8$R?>(PR�:*8UE�@?8UBcR?K 5FE�@y8$:A>d\�@A\�8UMNM ^£J�8U@A><P£5UED@�5FGI>y6Z5U:AG�5U6nB�\L:A:?>�E�Bc^;Sm>�C�8(ef>hPL>�e"K @A>(Pk8yGh><B*C�8UE�KN@�G J�8U@A><Pk5FE|8XeQK :AR?\�8UM.B�\L:A:?>�E�Bc^B<8UMNM >(Pk8Y�iEQ\�`FM >�R?�k� �(�s�'E�5QPL>�@1:?>�G�\�EL>�:?8$R?>w>(8UB*Co5UR?CL>�:n6Z5U:1R?C�>@�>�:?eQKNB�>�@{RAC�>c^�]":?5$eQKuP">}R?5�><8UB*CW5URAC�>c:<a-piE�RAC�KN@TS{8�^;"8�EL5QPL>}B(8UEGI8UVf>I\�@A>I5U6}RAC�>IE�>cRiST5U:?Vk5FELM ^7K 6=K Rw8UMN@A5gB�5FEQR�:?KNJ�\"R?>�@'R?5dR?C�>J�><EL>��LRw5U6}RAC�>WB�5FGhG�\�ELK Ri^faopiEkR?C�>�B<5FER?>c�QRw5U6}R?CL>Wp&EQRA>�:?EL>�R<;8k@AKNGhKNMu8$:X>��L8UGh]�M >F;}8$KNGh>(P£8$RW6Z5U@�R?>�:AKNE�` ª >�J£]�\�JLMNK @AC�KNEL`|J^GhKNBc:?5U[sRA:*8UEL@?8UBcR?KN5FEL@�;�K @}�X5$¤�5 � 8$R?K 5FEor9S{S{S�a Gh5(¤�5FE�8$R?K 5FE�a E�>cRct*a

ª >OC�8<ef>d>��"]�M 5U:?><P£R?CL>g8U]�]LMNKNB<8$R?K 5FE 5U6'EQ\L`FMN>cR?@�R?57@�R?KNG�\LMu8$R?>RAC�>g]L:?5(e"K @AKN5FEH5U6'R?CL>g]�8UB*Vf>�R�6Z5U:AS{8$:?PLKNEL`Y@A>�:Ae"K B<>Ua ª >gC�8(ef>]":?5F]�5F@�>(PXR&ST5�B*C�8$:?`FKNEL`IGh5QPL>�MN@��mR?C�>��x� � � �*� � "� � ��� �(¯ �*� ;�KNESqCLKNB*C7R?CL>h@A5F\L:?B�>�K @'B*C�8$:?`F><P�;.8UE�PgR?C�>��x� � � �?� ­ � �f¯ ��� �<¯ �c� ;K EWSqC�K BcC�R?C�>�PL>�@�R?KNE�8$R?KN5FEWKN@qB*C�8$:?`U>(P�a.��KN`U\L:?>w��K MNMN\L@�RA:*8$R?>�@qR?C�>5F]�>�:*8(R?KN5FEk5U6mR?C�>6��8UB*Vf>�RD�-\":?@A>h�X5QPL>�M9a���5U:18WGh5U:?>wPL>cR*8UK MN>(PP"><@�B�:?K ]LR?K 5FEy5U62RAC�>�Gh5QPL>�MN@�;LSm>�:?>c6Z>�:qR?5X� C$�9a

jTCL>=]":?5UR?>�B�RAKN5FE�5$6lRAC�>xGI5QP"><M @T8U`f8UKNEL@�RqGhKN@A\�@�>}B�5F\�MNPIJ�>xJ�8U@A>(P

148

Page 4: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

5

41700

695

9798

681684

R1

R2source

destination

packet with packet purse containing 4 nuglets

node purse before and after packet transfer

4

681684

� ,:>$����������� ,:�����8����� �8�<�<�1#���G� ��78�I# �8>�:�1��. )�� 78�6.�&4�8�A����F�8��.� I# ��>��/�5��. ,/#���7�� �������$�5� �+�8�A.0���� 7����+�A.0� �<���:�1G8,/#8>#�& 8���n�*�A78�!�<>$�1.�� # ��>��:�1�����I7+,/�<7 ,/.������$�1#�� ��&(' ��7���+�����$�5�6�F�8�A.0����� 78�@.0�1��&4#� �����:�5G8,/#8> #8& ������ �A78���<>��!. # �8>�:�5��.!��� 7+,/. 7�,:>478�5� >��<�5�! �,/#8�!.�. ���$#?EF�*'@&���,:31���0�1 "�� &$�6,/#�.��0��#+������E G���7��#� ����� ��78�!�$�1� 78�$. �0&%� ����� ��7�,:>478�5��!#8�5�<>$G �'& �;�1#� �,/���8�<���0& �<���:�1G ��78�@�������$�5�%( ��G �+,/�����)�:G ,*���78�� +,/.0����#������0&-��78��#��'& �678&$� ,/. 7�,:>478�5�,+-�

5FE�8xR*8UGh]�>�:2:?>�@AKN@�R*8UERmC�8$:*PQS{8$:?>qGI5QP"\�M >TKNEh>(8UB*ChPL>�eQKNB�>Fa-jTCLKN@GI5QP"\�MN>dST5F\LMuP£GI8UE�8U`F>dR?CL>OE"\L`FMN>cR?@W5U61R?C�>OEL5"P">OKNED@A\�B*CD8S{8<^�R?C�8$RwR?C�>XE�5QPL>WB(8UELE�5URIKNELB�:?><8U@A>dK R?@I@iR?5BcV|5U6�EQ\�`UMN>�RA@IK E8UEHK MNMN>�`FK R?K G�8$RA>gST8<^a piED8FPLPLK R?KN5FE ;xR?C�K @WGh5QPL\�M >XST5F\LMuPD8UMN@A5J�>�\�@A><PyR?5W]":?5$eQKuP">'B�:A^"]"R?5F`U:*8U]LC�K Bw]":?5UR?>�B�RAKN5FEg6Z5U:�R?CL>']�8UB*Vf>cR]�\L:A@A><@ca7� ]L:A5UR?5B<5FMTRAC�8$RwB�5F\�MuPkJ�>W\L@A><Pk6Z5U:wR?C�K @�]�\":?]�5F@A>IKN@PL>�@AB�:AKNJ�><PXKNEk� C$�sa

4. PROTECTING THE SECURITY MECH-ANISMS�}@�ST>.C�8(ef>2GI>�ER?KN5FEL>(P=KNE'4Q\�J�@�><BcR?KN5FE'�a �;U]L:?5$R?><BcR?KNEL`xRAC�>-@�><B�\L[

:?K Ri^�Gh><B*C�8UE�KN@�GI@mK Ey8UEy8FP�C�5B�EL>�R&ST5U:?VhKN@x8'G�8<¤�5U:qB*C�8$MNMN>�E�`F>Uaª >{SqKNMNML6Z5B<\L@mC�>c:?>q5FE�SqC�8$RmKN@m8$:?`F\�8UJLM ^�R?C�>qGh5F@�R.Bc:?K RAKNB<8UM�8UE�PB<5FGh]�M >��XKN@A@A\L>F;�E�8UGh>�M ^yVf>c^X>�@�R*8UJLMNKN@ACLGh><ER<a}�x@xGI>�EQRAKN5FE�><PXK E� �AJ$�s;lVf>�^X><@�R*8$J�MNK @AC�Gh><ER}B(8$EgJ�>n:?>(8$MNKNv�>(POJ^yVf>c^XRA:*8UEL@A]�5U:AR=5U:Vf>�^d8$`U:?><>�Gh><ER<a=p&EgVf>c^XRA:?8UE�@A]�5$:AR<;�5FEL>']�8(:ARi^yBc:?><8$R?>�@�5U:=5UR?CL[>�:ASqK @A>}5FJ"R*8UKNEL@m8}@A><Bc:?>cRmeF8UM \�>U;Q8UE�P�@A><B�\L:A><M ^'RA:*8UE�@i6Z>�:?@mK R-R?5}R?C�>5UR?C�>c:(rs@*t*a�p&EdVf>�^y8U`U:?>�><Gh><ER<; 8�@AC�8$:?><PdVf>�^XKN@�P">�:AKNef>(PyJ^XR&ST5rs5U:�GI5$:?>$t�]�8$:AR?K ><@�8U@�8�6Z\�E�BcR?K 5FE|5U6qKNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FE7B<5FERA:?K J�\"R?>(PJQ^f;Q5U:q8U@�@A5B<Ku8(R?>(PISxK R?C�;Q>(8UB*CI5U6�R?C�>�@A>U;�rsKuP">(8UM M ^�t-KNEI@A\�B*C�81S{8<^R?C�8$R�EL5O]�8$:AR&^kB<8UE�]":?><PL>cR?>�:AGIK E�>wR?C�>h:?>�@A\�M RAKNE�`deU8UMN\�>Ua-Hm5URAC8U]�]":?5f8UB*C�>�@{B(8$EWJ�>}J�8U@A><P�5UEW@�^"GIGh>cRA:?KNBq5U:x8U@�^"GhGI>cRA:?KNBqR?>�B*CL[E�Kuz\L><@�;�8UE�PWR?C�>c:?>'8$:A>'8hEQ\LGwJ�>�:{5U6�ST>�MNM�PL>c��EL>(P�]L:?5UR?5B�5FMN@}R?58UB*C�KN>�ef>�R?CLKN@q`F5f8UM.� �AJ(�sa

j{CL>�KuP"><ER?K ��B(8(R?KN5FEg5U6mR?CL>�8U]�]":?5F]":?Ku8$R?>�@A5FM \LR?K 5FEkK Eo8UEo8FPOCL5QBE�>cRiST5U:?V�SqKNM M�PL>�]�>�E�Pw5FEW8nEQ\LG�J�>�:-5U6lB�:AK R?>c:?Ku8Q;L@A\LB*CW8U@c� ª C�8$R8$:?>xRAC�>q>��"]�>�BcR?>(P�@A>�B�\L:?K R&^�6Z\�ELB�R?K 5FE�@2R?51J�>qKNGh]�M ><Gh>�EQR?><P�rsB�5FEL[��PL>�ER?Ku8UM K Ri^f;=KNER?>�`U:?K R&^;=8U\"R?C�>�ER?KNB<8$R?KN5FE ;Na aNa t � p&@WR?C�>c:?>g8UE 8U\L[R?C�5U:?K Ri^f;l5U:18$:?>�R?C�>c:?>�@A>�ef>�:*8UM-8U\LRAC�5U:?K Ri^gPL5UG�8UK E�@ �£p&6.RAC�>c:?>�KN@8UE�8U\"R?C�5$:?K Ri^f;USxC�8$RmK @.K R?@2:?5FMN>qKNE�R?CL>{KNE�K R?Ku8UMNK v(8$RAKN5FEW]LC�8U@�>1r9>Fa `"aN;B(8UE�R?CL>q8U\LR?CL5U:?K R&^'KNEL@�R*8UMNM�8U]�]":?5F]L:AKu8$R?>{Bc:A^"]LR?5F`U:?8U]�CLKNB{G�8(R?>�:?KN8UMKNE|><8UB*C7EL5QPL>IJ�>�6Z5$:?>�\L@?8U`F>(t � p�6{R?C�>c:?>I8$:?>�@�><ef>c:*8UMT8U\"R?C�5U:AK Ri^PL5FGI8UKNEL@�;�SqC�8$R�K @}R?CL>nMN>�ef>�M�5$6-RA:?\L@�R=J�>�R&ST>�><EdR?CL><GX;�8UE�PyCL5(SPL5�RAC�>c^yJ�\LKNMuPd\L]g8IRA:?\L@�R=:A><Mu8(R?KN5FEL@AC�KN]��Yp&6-RAC�>c:?>�KN@18wRA:?\L@�R?><P

@�>�:?ef>c:'rs5U:=@�><ef>c:*8UMl5FE�>�@*t*;�KN@xK R=8UB�B<>�@A@AKNJLMN>�5FE"[&M KNE�> �Opi@qR?C�>c:?>'8UE\L]�]�>�:=J�5F\�E�Py5FEdR?C�>'EQ\LG�J�>�:}5U6m\L@A>c:?@�; V"EL5(SqEg8�]":?KN5U:?K �Y�x:?>R�:?\�@�R-:?><MN8$R?KN5FEL@AC�K ]�@mJ�>cRiSm><>�EI8UEQ^�R&ST51\L@A>�:?@.]�\LJ�MNK B<M ^hVQEL5(SqEw5U:8<eF8UKNMN8UJ�M >��Opi@qVf>c^X>�@�R*8UJ�M KN@ACLGI>�ERxM KNGhK R?><PWR?5�RiST5h]�8(:AR?KN>�@�;�5U:=K @8UM @A5dG�\�M R?K [�]�8$:AR&^dVf>�^O>�@�R*8UJLMNK @AC�Gh><ER1RA5XJ�>wB<5FEL@AKuP">�:A>(P �/.l8U@�RJL\LR�EL5UR-M >(8U@�R�;FSqC�8$R->c�L8UB�R?M ^nKN@�R?C�>.Vf>�^�MNK 6Z>TBc^"B<M >F¥fKNE']�8(:AR?KNB�\�MN8$:<;K @xVf>c^I:?><ef5B<8$R?KN5FEyRA5wJ�>1B�5FE�@AKNPL>c:?>(P �

�L5U:nMu8UB*VO5U6{@�]�8UB�>F;lST>hB<8UELE�5URnPLKN@AB�\�@�@1><8UB*Ck5U6TR?CL><@�>hBc:?K RA>�:?KN8Qaª >1SqKNM M-8U@A@�\�Gh>1R?C�8(R}R?CL>�:A>nKN@}E�5W8$\LR?CL5U:?K R&^krs5U:<;�KNEO8UEO><z\�KNe[8UM ><ERxS{8<^f;�R?C�8$Rx><8UB*CdE�5QPL>1KN@=K R?@}5<SqEO8U\LR?CL5U:?K R&^dP"5FG�8UK E�t*¥�ST>SqK MNM�8UMN@A5I8U@A@A\LGI>=R?C�8$R{R?CL>�:A>�KN@xE�5'�L�">(PW@�>�:?ef>c:<a

�x@�^"GIGh>cRA:?KNB{Vf>c^�B�:�^L]"R?5F`U:*8U]LCQ^wK @T8UEW8$]�]":?5F]L:?KN8$R?>xB<5FELB<>�]LR.6Z5U:RAC�KN@2B(8U@�>!0<;J�>�B<8U\�@A>{K RmPL5>�@-EL5UR2:A>(z\�K :?>{5FE�M KNE�>TRA:A\�@�R?><P'@A>c:?ef>�:?@ca� 5(ST>�ef>c:<;fR?CL>�:A>TKN@28�P":?8<SqJ�8UB*V1:A><Mu8(R?>(P'R?5=Vf>�^�:?><ef5B<8$R?KN5FE a-jTC�>\L@A\�8$MQ@�B(8UMN8UJ�MN>{Gh>�BcC�8UELKN@AG RA5=8UB*CLKN>�ef>.R?C�K @�K @�R?C�8$R�8UE�8U\"R?C�5U:?K Ri^GI8UKNER*8UK E�@�8qMNKN@�R�5U6":?><ef5UVf>(P�Vf>c^"@l5FE'8q@A>�:?ef>c:<;F8q@A5FMN\"R?KN5FE'B�MN><8$:?M ^EL5URI8FP�8U]"R?><P|R?5k5U\L:h]L:?5FJLMN>�GyaY�xEY8UM R?>c:?E�8(R?KNef>WST5U\�MuP_J�>�R?5:A>(z\�>�@�RWRAC�>d]L\�J�M KNBOVf>�^YPLK :?>�BcR?M ^Y60:?5FG K R?@W5(SqEL>�:�a Hm\LRIR?C�K @Sm5F\�MuPnC�8(ef>�R?5}J�>-:?><8UMNKNv�><P16Z5U:�>(8UB*CnEL>�S7KNER?>c:*8UBcR?KN5FE'KNEn8q@A>�B�\L:?>ST8<^;�8UE�PWR?CL>�:?>c6Z5U:?>1R?CL>n>c�L]�><BcR?><PWJ�>�E�>c��R?@q5U62R?C�>18U@�^"GIGh>�R�:?KNBRA><B*C�ELKuz\�>}ST5F\LMuPXJ�>=MN5F@�R<ap&Eo@�]�K RA>h5U6.R?C�KN@1P":*8�SqJ�8UB*V�;�KNEgR?CL>':?><@�R15U6T5F\":'PLK @AB<\L@A@AKN5FE ;�ST>SqK MNM�6Z5B<\L@x5UEXVf>�^I>�@�R*8UJLMNKN@ACLGI>�ER{\�@AK E�`h8U@�^"GIGh>cRA:?KNB}Vf>�^IBc:A^"]L[RA5F`U:*8U]�C^fa-piEX@A\LB*Cy8�@�^"@�R?><GX;L><8UB*CyE�5QP">1C�8$@}8�]L\�J�M KNB�N$]L:?K eF8$R?>Vf>c^_]�8UK :<a �-\LJ�M KNBdVf>�^"@hB(8UE£J�>OPLKN@�R�:?KNJ�\"R?><P�R?575UR?CL>c:WEL5"P"><@c;SqCLKNMN>O]":?KNeF8$RA>yVf>�^"@I@AC�5F\LMuPYJ�>yVf>�]LRIB<5UEL��PL>�EQR?KN8UMqR?5|KNE�PLK e"KNP"[\�8UM�E�5QPL>�@�a1� Bc:?\�B�Ku8UM�]L:?5UJ�MN>�G 6Z5U:18I`FK e>�EOE�5QP">21 KN@=C�5(S�R?55FJ"R*8UKNEWR?C�>n8$\LR?CL><ER?KNB=]�\LJ�M KNB�Vf>c^W5U6-8�E�5QP">�3ha.jTC�>1Gh5F@�RxKNGw[]�5U:AR*8UERqR?CL:?><8$R}KN@}8UE � ¡ �9�� ¯ �*� � � ¡�� �/��� � ®�� ¯f¯ �u� 8$RAR*8UB*Vg� �AJ$�sa ª >SqK MNM�PLKN@�B<\L@A@{R?C�K @xK @A@A\�>nK Ed4">�BcR?KN5FEO©fa

� S{8�^dR?5W\L@A>w8U@�^"GIGh>cRA:?KNB'Vf>c^dBc:A^L]"R?5F@�^"@�R?>�Gh@}6Z5U:=R?C�>'RA:*8$E�@�[]�5U:AR�5U6{R?C�>h@�^"GhGI>cRA:?KNBwVf>c^"@nKN@nR?5d>�E�Bc:A^"]LR�8y@�^"GhGI>cRA:?K BhVf>c^`F>�EL>�:*8$RA>(PDJQ^£5UE�>O]�8$:�Ri^YSqK R?CDR?C�>O]L\�JLMNKNBOVf>c^£5U6nR?CL>o5URAC�>c:]�8$:ARi^fa

�x@w6Z5U:WVf>c^�8U`U:A><>�GI>�ER<;54=K �h>d8UE�P � >�MNMNGI8UE_C�8(ef>y@A\L`F`F>�@�R?>(P8OR?>�B*C�ELKuz\�>W5$6 � � �_�76 � � �$¡  � � 8$�xJ�8U@A><PY5UEY8U@�^"GIGh>cRA:?KNBXVf>c^Bc:A^"]LR?5U`U:*8U]�C^fa piE�R?CLKN@o8U]L]L:?5f8UB*C ;'R&ST5H]�8$:AR?K ><@OS{8UER?KNEL`YR?5B�5FGhG�\�ELKNB(8(R?>W@A>�B<\":?>�M ^_J�>�`FKNE_RAC�>�K :IKNER?>�:*8$B�R?K 5FEYJQ^|>��"B*C�8$E�`U[K E�`yr�8U]�]":?5F]":?Ku8$R?>�M ^yB�5FEL@�RA:?\LB�R?><P�tT:*8UE�PL5FG eF8UMN\L><@c;�60:A5FG SqC�KNB*CJ�5UR?CdB<5UGI]L\LR?>nM 5B(8UM M ^dR?C�>1@?8UGI>'Vf>c^fa}jTC�>'J�8U@AKNB'ef>c:?@AKN5UEg]":?5U[eQKuP"><@}]L:A5UR?><BcR?K 5FEoK EgRAC�>n6Z5U:?G 5U6.@A>�B�:?>�Bc^O5U6.R?CL>n:?><@A\LM R?K E�`XVf>c^60:A5FG ]�8$@A@AKNef>'8FP"ef>�:A@?8$:?KN>�@�a{p&Ey5U:*P">�:qR?5�R?CS{8$:AR=8UBcR?KNef>n8(RAR*8UB*V"@c;@�\�B*Cy8U@{R?CL>1KNERA:?\�PL>c:A[�KNEL[sR?CL>�[�GIKNP�P"MN>x8$RAR*8UB*V�;�@A>�ef>�:*8UM�]":?5F]�5F@A8UMN@C�8(ef>xJ�>�><EIG�8UPL>Ua-jTCL:?>�>=]":?5FGhKNE�>�ERm>c��8$GI]LMN>�@.R?C�>c:?>�5U6�8$:?>xR?C�>9 � � �s� �$¡�� � �U�:9 � � �9� �$¡w� � � � � � � � � ��J$�9;R?C�> � ­<;M� � � �  $�*�?�?®�� ¡ � � � �U�� � � � � � �-8$�m8UE�P�� ��� �  U�?�?�*®�� ¡ � � � ¡   � �*� � � �*�?�*�9� ���$� ¡   � ��� �X� �(¦$�9ajTCL>�^O]":?5F]�5F@�>I8IS{8<^dR?5XJLKNE�PyR?C�>�>c�LB*C�8UE�`F><Pd:*8UE�P"5FG¬eF8UM \�>�@RA5oR?CL>XKuP"><ER?K RAKN>�@�5U6}R?C�>W]�8$:AR?K ><@�aHjTC�>y]":?5FJ�M ><G K @hRAC�8$RwR?C�K @:A>(z\�K :?><@�K E"ef5FM e"K E�`g8yRA:?\L@�R?><P|]�8$:AR&^£rZRi^"]�KNB<8UMNM ^7SqCL><E|8g`FK ef><E]�8$:ARi^�KN@lKNELK R?Ku8$MNKNv�>(Pn6Z5U:�R?CL>-ef>c:A^��L:?@�RlR?KNGh>(t*a�piE18x@�><M 60[�5U:?`f8$E�KNv�><PGh5FJLKNMN>w8FPOC�5B�EL>�R&ST5U:?V�; R?CLKN@}ST5F\�MNPO:A>(z\�K :?>'R?C�8$R}R?C�K @=:?5FM >hK @]LMu8<^><P�J^_8g\�ELKuz\�>X8U\LR?CL5U:?K R&^ rs>Ua `"aN;q8o@AK E�`FM >dG�8UEQ\"698UB�R?\":?>c:5U62R?CL>n@A><B�\":?K Ri^XGI5QP"\�MN>�5U6.><8UB*CdE�5QPL>(t*¥�ST>'B�5FE�@AKNPL>c:=RAC�8$RqR?C�K @

0?p&Eg]L:*8UBcR?KNB�>U;l6Z5U:n>c�hB<K ><ELB�^O:?><8U@A5FEL@�;�@�^"GhGI>cRA:?K B'Vf>�^d@AB*CL><Gh>�@8$:A>y\�@A><P7R?5g@A>�B<\":?>X6Z\":AR?C�>c:wB�5FGIG�\LE�KNB<8$R?K 5FE_8$60R?>c:IRAC�>WEL5QPL>�@C�8(ef>x8U\"R?C�>�EQRAKNB<8$R?>(Pw><8UB*CI5URAC�>c:T8UE�Pw>�@�R*8UJLMNKN@ACL>(PI8�@A>�Bc:?>�Rm@�^LGw[Gh>cRA:?KNB=Vf>�^�\�@AK E�`h8U@�^"GIGh>cRA:?KNB}Vf>�^�Bc:A^L]"R?5F`U:*8U]LC^a

149

Page 5: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

8U@A@A\�Gh]"R?KN5FEXK @xR?55�:?>�@�RA:?KNBcR?K ef>�6Z5U:}5F\L:qB<8U@A>Ua

;�¯ � ¡ �s�Z��� � �?�$� � ¯ �c��� � � �$� � � ���?® ��� �$¨$�=8$:A>y8gST8<^|RA5oB�K :?B�\�G�ef>�ERR?C�>2]L:?5FJLMN>�G�5U6"J�K E�P"KNE�`{]L\�JLMNKNB2Vf>�^"@ R?5qKuP"><ER?K R?KN>�@�a�piE=R?C�>�@A>-@�^"@�[R?><Gh@�;m8UE�>�ER?K Ri^�� @']L\�JLMNKNB�KuP"><ER?K ��B(8(R?KN5FE�K EL6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5UE rs\�ELKuz\�>E�8UGh>$th]�MN8<^"@�R?CL>O:A5FMN>g5U6�K R?@�]�\LJ�MNK BOV>c^f;xR?CQ\�@�8(ef5FKuP"KNEL`|R?C�>E�>�>(Pd6Z5U:n\L@A>c:?@�R?5�>��"B*C�8UEL`F>Xr�8UE�POB�>�:�R?K 60^OKNEg@A5FGh>�S{8<^�txR?CL>�K :]�\�JLMNK BXVf>�^"@�¥{8y6Z\L:AR?CL>c:�8FP"eF8UER*8U`F>�KN@�R?C�8$Rw]L\�JLMNKNBWPLK :A><BcR?5U:?KN>�@5U6nVf>c^_B<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>�@WP"57E�5$R�EL><><P_R?57J�>yVf><]"R<a � 5<ST>�ef>�:<;TR?C�>P":*8�SxJ�8UB*V7K @nR?C�8$Rw8yRA:A\�@�R?><P|8U\"R?C�5$:?K Ri^oKN@�EL><><PL><Pk6Z5$:wRAC�>I><@�[R*8UJ�M KN@AC�Gh>�EQRq5U6�R?CL>1]L:AKNeF8$R?>�Vf>�^"@{5U62RAC�>1\L@A>c:?@�ampiEXR?CL><5U:�^;LR?CLKN@RA:?\�@�RA>(Pd8U\"R?C�5U:AK Ri^XKN@q:?>(z\�K :?><Py5FE�M ^y8$R=@i^L@�RA><G @�>�R=\�] a Hm\"R=K E]L:*8UBcR?KNB�>U;�K R?@18UB�R?K eF8$R?K 5FEgSm5F\�MuPg@�R?K MNM-J�>wEL>�B<>�@A@?8$:A^gKNEgB<8U@A>w>Fa `"a81]L:?K eF8$R?>{Vf>c^�`F>�RA@mMN5F@�R.5U:TB<5UGI]":?5FGhKN@A><P a2�L5U:.R?CLKN@-:?><8U@A5FE ;QR?CLKN@8U]�]":?5f8UB*CdPL5>�@qE�5URx@A>�><G R?5wJ�>n8U]L]L:?5U]L:?Ku8(R?>�6Z5U:x5F\L:xB<8U@A>Ua

j{CL>c:?>I8(:?>h>�@A@A>�ER?Ku8UM M ^gR?CL:?>�>�698UGIK MNKN>�@15U6q8$]�]L:A5f8UB*C�>�@�6Z5U:n>�MNK Gh[KNE�8$RAKNE�`O8XB�>�EQR�:*8UMNKNv�><PkB�>�:ARAK ��B<8$R?K 5FE|8U\"R?C�5U:AK Ri^oKNEk8XGh5FJ�KNM >�8UPC�5B1EL>�R&ST5U:?V�a.jTC�>��L:?@�RqB�5FE�@AK @�R?@xKNE �?® L� � �s� ¡   8�B<5UE"ef>�ER?KN5FE�8UMB<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?KN5FE£8U\"R?C�5U:AK Ri^|JQ^|PLKN@iRA:?KNJL\LR?K E�`oK Rh5FE_@A>�ef>�:*8UMqEL5QPL>�@�¥R?C�>�@A>�B<5UE�PgB<5FEL@AKN@�RA@1KNEo8�R?5UR*8$MNM ^gP"KN@�RA:?K J�\"R?>(PO@A5FM \LR?KN5UE�;lSqCL>�:A>E�5QPL>�@xC�8(ef>=R?5h8U\LR?CL><ER?K B(8$R?>1>(8UB*Cy5URAC�>c:=J^�@A>�RARAKNE�`h\�]y8UEd8U]L[]L:?5F]":?Ku8$R?>WB<5FER?>c�QR<¥TST>�SqKNMNMxPL>�@ABc:?KNJ�>�R?C�>�@A>��L:?@�R�RiSm5o5U]LR?KN5UE�@C�>c:?>(8(60R?>�:<akj{CL>�R?CLK :*Pk5FE�>IKN@�5F\":h]":?5F]�5F@A8UM9¥TK RwKN@'J�8$@A>(P75FE�8@A><M 60[&5U:A`f8UE�K v<><P|]�\LJ�M KNBc[&Vf>c^gKNEL6u:*8U@�RA:?\LB�R?\":?>Ua ª >wSqKNMNMTP"KN@AB�\�@�@'K RKNEO4">�BcR?KN5FEO©a

4.1 Emulation of a certification authoritypiEg� �AC$�s;�R?CL>�8U\"R?C�5U:A@q]":?5F]�5F@�>18'Vf>c^�GI8UE�8U`U><Gh><ERT@A>c:?eQKNB�>F;�P"KN@�[RA:?KNJL\LR?><P�5(ef>�:q8nB�>�:�R*8UKNEXEQ\LGwJ�>�:.5U6�E�5QPL>�@TB<8UMNMN><PO� �?� f�?� �?a{jTC�>@A>�:?eQKNB�>U;Q8U@-8xSqCL5FMN>U;QC�8$@-8}]�\�JLMNK B<N$]":?KNeF8(R?>m]�8UK :�������a-jTCL>T]�\LJL[MNKNB=Vf>�^��¬KN@{VQE�5(SqEIR?5�8UMNM�EL5"P">�@TKNEWR?CL>=EL>�R&ST5U:?V�;"SqC�>c:?><8U@TR?C�>]L:?KNeU8$R?>1Vf>c^��XK @=P"KNeQKuP">(P�KNER?5o@AC�8$:?>�@�� 0� ��� �� ��� ��� ;�5FE�>�@AC�8$:?>6Z5U:�><8UB*Cd@A>c:?ef>�:<a K 8UB*Cd@A>c:?ef>c:��m8UMN@A5WC�8U@}8h]L\�JLMNKNB�N$]L:AKNeF8$R?>1Vf>�^����������;8UE�PnVQEL5(Sq@�RAC�>T]L\�J�M KNBmVf>c^"@�5U6�8UMNM"E�5QPL>�@�a2jTCL>��@A>c:?ef>c:?@8$:?>nB*C�5F@�><Ey8(:?J�K R�:*8$:?KNM ^d8UGh5FE�`'R?CL>1E�5QP"><@{5U6�R?C�>=E�>cRiSm5U:?V�a

piE'5U:*P">�:�R?5}]L:?5UR?>�BcR2K R?@A>�M 6 8U`f8UK E�@�R2R?C�>.]�5UR?>�EQRAKu8UMQB<5FGh]L:A5FGIK @A>m5U6@A5FGI>'5$6mR?C�>�k@A>c:?ef>�:?@c;�R?CL>'@�^"@�R?><G \�@A>�@ �/��*� � � � � ¯ �*�O� � � �  U� �U�� � � a-�}E�r� ���� �$t�R?C":?><@�C�5FMuP�B�:A^"]"R?5F`U:*8U]LCQ^}@AB*C�>�Gh>qr�! £¦ ��� �$t8UMNMN5<Sq@�H]�8$:AR?K ><@�R?5o@AC�8$:?>WR?CL>y8UJ�K MNK R&^|R?5g]�>c:A6Z5U:?G 8gBc:A^"]LR?5U[`U:*8U]�CLKNB=5F]�>�:?8$R?KN5FEgrs>Fa `"aN;�Bc:?>(8$RAKNE�`w8'P"KN`FK R?8UM�@AKN`FE�8$R?\L:?>(t.@A5'R?C�8$R8UEQ^ �"� �}]�8$:AR?KN>�@mB<8UEh]�>�:�6Z5U:?G�R?C�[email protected]]�>c:*8$R?KN5FE�¤�5FKNER?M ^f;QSqC�>c:?><8U@K R�KN@�KNEL6Z><8U@AK J�MN>T6Z5U:28$R�GI5U@�R � ]�8$:AR?K ><@lR?5}PL5x@A5x><ef>�EnJ^1B�5FMNMN\L@AKN5FE a

� � � �9�0� �f¯ f�?� ��� �*�&� �yrs@�]�><B�K ��B(8$MNM ^f;�8$RAR*8UB*Vf>c:?@=RAC�8$R=R?><Gh]�5U:*8(:?KNM ^B<5FGh]L:A5FGIK @A>'8h@�>�:?ef>c:=8UE�PXR?CL><EXGI5(ef>15FEyR?5wR?C�>nEL>c�"RxeQKNBcR?KNG�tB<5F\LMuPd]L:A5F`U:?><@�@AKNef>�M ^OB�5FGI]":?5FGhKN@A>'8UM M�R?CL>'@A>c:?ef>�:?@ca=piEd5U:*P">�:=R?5R?CQST8$:ARyR?CL><@A>oVQKNE�P"@y5U6h8$RAR*8UB*V�;1]L:?5F8UB�R?K ef>k@AB*CL><Gh>�@d8$:?>o]L:?5U[]�5F@A><P a jTCL>�^|G�8UVf>W\�@A>y5U6'� � � �*�y�*�0�*�*� � �� ¡   ;TSqC�K BcCY>�E�8$J�MN>�@@A>�:?ef>c:?@1R?5XB<5FGh]�\"R?>�E�>cS�@AC�8$:?><@�60:?5FG 5UMuPk5FEL>�@nKNEoB<5FM Mu8UJ�5U:*8([R?KN5FE ;FSqK RAC�5F\"R.P"KN@AB�MN5F@AKNEL`=R?CL>m@A>c:?eQKNB�>T]L:?K eF8$R?>mVf>c^�R?5=8UE^1@A>c:?ef>c:<aj{CL>{E�>cS_@AC�8$:?>�@-B�5FE�@�RAK R?\LRA>q8=E�>cS r� #��� �$t�@�C�8$:?K E�`�5$6�R?C�>T@�>�:A[e"K B<>�� @x]L:?K eF8$R?>=Vf>�^fa

j{CLKN@IGI>�B*C�8UELKN@AG B(8UEYJ�>Oef>c:A^7:?5FJ�\L@�R�8U`f8UKNEL@�RX@A5F]LC�K @�R?KNB<8$R?><P8$RAR*8UB*VQ@�;8$E�P1KN@�R?CL>�:A>�6Z5U:A>.ST><M M"@�\�K RA>(P�6Z5U:�GhKNMNK R*8$:A^n8$]�]�M KNB<8$R?KN5FEL@�a� 5(Sm><ef>c:<;"K Rm:?>(z\LK :?>�@mR?C�8$RT81@A\�JL@A>cRT5U6�R?C�>xEL5"P">�@}r9R?C�>x@A>c:?ef>c:?@*t]�Mu8�^d8w@A]�>�B<K ��B1:?5FM >�8$R�8w`FKNef>�Ed]�5FK EQR}KNEyR?K GI>U;�8UEy\LE�PL>�@AK :?8UJ�M >:?>(z\LK :?>�GI>�ER�6Z5U:y@�><M 60[&5U:?`F8UE�KNv�><P�B�KNeQKNMNKN8UE EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�;}KNEDSqC�K B*C>(8UB*Cy\L@A>c:}K @x>c�"]�>�B�R?><P�R?5wJ�>�C�8<ef>�KNEy8k�i@�><M ��@ACL�wS{8�^a

jTCL>XE�>c�QRw@A\�JL@A>�B�R?K 5FEYPLK @AB<\L@A@A>�@hS{8�^"@wR?5g>�MNKNGhKNE�8$R?>WR?CLKN@wB�5FEL[@iRA:*8UKNER<;�8$RqR?C�>=>c�L]�>�EL@A>15U628�@�RA:?5FE�`hMN5B<8UMNK Ri^y8U@�@A\�Gh]LR?K 5FE�a

4.2 Key agreement�x@{GI>�ER?KN5FEL>(P�KNEo� ¦$�s;�E�5QP"><@{SqKNMNM KNE�`wR?5w>�@�R*8UJLMNKN@ACd8�@A>�B<\":?>1@�><@�[@�KN5FEWG�\L@�RT@AC�8$:?>�81� �*� � � � �$¡ �i� 6$� a{jTCL>=@AB�>�E�8$:?K 5wB�5FEL@AKuP">�:?><PWJ^RAC�>m8U\"R?C�5$:?@�K @-8q@AGI8UMNM`U:?5F\L]n5U6�]�><5F]LMN>T8$R28qB<5UEL6Z>c:?><ELB�>TB<5FGhKNEL`RA5F`F>�R?CL>c:xK Ey8n:?55FG 6Z5$:}8$Ey8FP�CL5B�Gh><>cR?KNEL`w8UE�PhSqKNMNMNK E�`�R?5�@A>cR\L]�8}SqK :?>�MN>�@A@{E�>cRiST5U:AVw@�><@A@�KN5FEW8$GI5FEL`1R?C�>�K :.Mu8U]"R?5F]IB�5FGh]�\"R?>c:?@6Z5$:}R?CL>1P"\L:*8$R?K 5FEy5U6�R?C�>=GI>�>cR?KNE�`Qamp�RqKN@}8U@A@A\�Gh><P�R?C�8$RxRAC�>c^XP"5EL5URnC�8(ef>w8UB�B<>�@A@1R?5y]L\�JLMNKNB�Vf>c^OKNE"60:*8U@�RA:?\LB�RA\L:?>h5U:1R?CLK :*PO]�8(:ARi^Vf>c^dGI8UE�8U`U><Gh><ER}@A>c:?e"K B<>Ua'j{CL>�]L:?5U]�5F@A><Pg@A5UMN\LR?K 5FEgKN@�R?CL>n6Z5FM [M 5(SqKNEL`"�{8'60:?>�@ACd]�8U@A@�ST5U:*PWKN@xBcCL5F@A>�Ey8UE�PX@AC�8$:A>(Py8UGh5FEL`�RAC�5F@A>]":?>�@A><ERwKNEkR?C�>I:?55FG rs>Ua `"a ;TJ^gS{:?K R?KNEL`gK Rw5FE_8dJ�MN8UB*V"J�5f8$:*P�t?a� 5(ST>�ef>c:<;}K RIST5F\LMuPDJ�>g87GhKN@�R*8UVf>yR?57\�@A>dR?CLKN@I]�8U@A@�Sm5U:*P P"K [:A><BcR?M ^d8$@}R?CL>'Vf>�^f;�8U@}RAC�>n]":?5UR?5B<5UM�ST5F\LMuPyR?CL><EyJ�>'e"\LMNEL>�:*8UJLMN>RA5I¯ ���c�9� �$¡ � ��� � �s� � � �$�n� �AJ$�sa.jTC�>c:?>c6Z5U:?>U;QR?CL>{8U\LR?CL5U:?@�]L:?5F]�5F@A>TR?5GI8UVf>n\L@A>'5U6.�"�$�?� �T� � ¯U��� Q�/��� ¡ �9��� � �i� ¯�� ���d� 6 ��� �$¡  Q� J^ySqC�KNB*CRAC�>c^gPL>c:?KNef>h8X@�RA:?5FEL`X@AC�8$:?><PkVf>c^O@�R*8$:AR?K E�`X60:?5UG 5FELM ^o8�ST><8UV@�C�8$:?><P'Vf>�^fa�jTCLKN@2]":?5F]�5F@A8UML5FELM ^1Sm5U:?VQ@-K 6LR?C�>.]�8$:AR?K ><@�B(8$Ew@�C�8$:?>8�]�8U@A@�ST5U:*PyJ^IJ�>�KNE�`w]LCQ^"@AKNB<8UMNM ^X]":?><@A>�ERqKNEXR?CL>�@?8UGh>�:?55FGXa

5. SELF-ORGANIZED PUBLIC-KEYINFRASTRUCTUREjTCL>O]L:?5FJLMN>�G 5U6']L\�J�M KNBc[&Vf>c^YP"KN@�RA:?K J�\"R?KN5FE£KNED`F>�E�>c:*8UM}B(8UEDJ�>

@�\�GhG�8$:?K v<><P�KNEwR?C�>T6Z5FM MN5(SqK E�`wz\�>�@�R?KN5FE � � 5(SYB<8UEW8=\�@A>c:�$I5FJL[R?8UKNEyR?CL>n8U\LR?CL>�EQR?K Bn]�\LJ�M KNB1Vf>c^X5U6-8UE�5URAC�>c:=\L@A>c:�%�KNEyR?CL>1]L:?>�@�[>�E�B�>n5U6.8UEO8UBcR?KNef>'8$RAR?8UB*Vf>�:��kjTC�>'Gh5F@�RqST><M M [�V"EL5(SqEO8U]L]L:?5f8$BcCRA5�@A5FM ef>nR?C�KN@}]L:A5FJ�MN>�G~K @=J�8U@A>(Pd5FEO]L\�JLMNKNBc[&Vf>c^XB�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA><@�a1�]L\�JLMNKNBc[�Vf>�^_B�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA>gK @X8|PL8$R*8o@�RA:?\LB�R?\":?>dKNE£SqC�K BcCD8k]�\LJL[M KNB'Vf>c^XKN@}J�5F\LE�PWR?5�8UEdKuP"><ER?K R&^or�8UE�Py]�5F@A@AK J�M ^yR?5I@�5FGI>'5URAC�>c:8$R�RA:?KNJL\LR?>�@*tqJQ^�R?C�>'P"KN`FK R*8UM2@�KN`FE�8$RA\L:?>'5U6-R?C�>nK @A@A\�>c:=5U6.R?CL>nB<>c:A[RAK ��B<8$R?>Ua ª C�>�Ed\�@A>c:�$OS{8UER?@xR?5�5UJLR*8UK EORAC�>�8U\"R?C�>�ER?KNBn]L\�JLMNKNBVf>c^o5U6q\�@A>c:&%�;2K Rw8UB<z\�K :A><@�8yB*C�8UKNE75U6x]L\�JLMNKNBc[�Vf>�^gB�>�:ARAK ��B<8$R?>�@@�\�B*CnR?C�8(R�R?CL>m��:A@�R2B�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA>T5U6�R?CL>mB*C�8UK E�B(8UEwP"K :?>�B�R?M ^nJ�>mef>c:A[K ��><PgJ^!$o\�@�KNE�`W8W]�\LJ�M KNB'Vf>c^dR?C�8$R�$kCL5FMuP"@n8UE�PdR�:?\�@�R?@c¥�>(8$BcC:A><GI8UKNELKNE�`wB�>�:�R?K ��B<8$R?>�B(8UEWJ�>1ef>c:?K ��>(PW\L@AKNEL`�R?C�>=]�\�JLMNK B�Vf>c^WKNERAC�>�]":?>�e"K 5F\�@qB�>�:ARAK ��B<8$R?>n5U6�R?CL>�B*C�8$KNE�¥�8UE�P�R?CL>�Mu8U@�R}B�>�:�R?K ��B<8$R?>B�5FER*8UKNEL@=R?CL>�]�\LJ�MNK B'Vf>�^d5$6.R?C�>'R*8(:?`F>�R�%�anp�R1K @18U@A@A\LGI><PyR?C�8$R$yRA:A\�@�R?@{R?CL>�KN@�@A\�>c:x5U6-><8UB*CXB�>�:�R?K ��B<8$R?>nK EWR?CL>1B*C�8UK E�ap&E GI8UE^Y5U6'R?CL>oVQEL5(SqEDB<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?>kJ�8U@A><P @�^"@�R?>�GI@Ors>Ua `"aN;1KNE��:?KNeF8UBc^ K E�C�8UE�B�><P��y8UKNM�� ���(�Zt']�\LJ�M KNBc[&Vf>c^oB<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?><@w8$:?>�KN@�[@�\�><PoJ^yRA:?\L@�R?><PgR?CLK :*PO]�8$:AR?KN>�@�;�B<8UMNMN><Pk�m>�:AR?K ��B<8$R?KN5UE|�x\LR?CL5U:?K [RAKN><@ca�jTCLKN@1KN@=E�5UR18�@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv�>(Po8U]L]L:?5f8UB*CO6Z5U:n5UJ"eQKN5F\L@}:A>(8$[@�5FE�@�;28$E�PdR?C�>c:?>c6Z5U:?>U;�K R1K @nE�5UR18U]�]":?5F]":?Ku8$R?>�6Z5U:'@�><M 60[�5U:?`f8$E�KNv�><PGh5FJLKNMN>I8FP7CL5BIEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�aypiE75$R?C�>c:�@�^"@�R?>�GI@hr9>Fa `"aN;.KNE ��:?>cRARi^L}5Q5QP �2:?K eF8UB�^ r��ML �mtO� ��8$�Zt*;nB�>�:ARAK ��B<8$R?>�@d8$:?>oKN@A@A\L>(PHJ^YR?C�>\L@A>c:?@{R?C�>�GI@�><MNef>�@�¥�CL5(ST>�ef>�:<;�R?CL>1P"KN@�RA:?K J�\"R?KN5FEy5U62B�>�:ARAK ��B<8$R?>�@}K @J�8U@A><P15FE']�\LJ�M KNB�M ^18$B<B�><@�@AKNJ�M >{B<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>mP"K :?>�B�R?5U:AKN>�@�R?C�8$Rl:?><@�KuPL>5FE�B�>�EQRA:?8UMNM ^'GI8UE�8U`F>(P'@�>�:?ef>c:?@�a-�L5U:2R?CLKN@�:?>(8$@A5FE�;FR?C�K @-8U]L]L:?5f8$BcCK @xEL5URq6Z\�M M ^X@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv�><Pd>�K RAC�>c:<a

ª >W]":?5F]�5F@�>X8dE�>cS ]L\�JLMNKNBc[�Vf>�^kPLK @�RA:?KNJL\LRAKN5FE�@�^"@�R?>�G @�\�K R*8$J�MN>6Z5$:n@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UE�K v<><PkGh5FJLKNMN>w8FPgC�5B�EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�;lSqCLKNB*CoK @1@AKNGhKNMN8$:RA5 � L �gK EnR?C�>-@A><EL@A>mR?C�8$R�]�\�JLMNK B�[�Vf>�^=B�>�:AR?K ��B<8$R?>�@-8$:?>.KN@A@A\L>(P'J^RAC�>n\L@A>�:?@ca � 5<ST><ef>c:<;�8U@=5F]L]�5F@A><PyR?5 �ML ��;�ST>wPL5hE�5$R=:?>�M ^d5FEB�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA>nPLK :?><BcR?5U:?K ><@q6Z5U:xR?C�>�PLKN@iRA:?KNJL\LR?K 5FEy5U6�B<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?><@�amp&EL[@iR?>(8FP�;�KNEd5F\":}@�^"@�R?>�GX;�B<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?><@}8$:?>n@�RA5U:?>(Pd8$E�PyP"KN@�RA:?K J�\"R?>(PJ^XR?CL>n\L@A>�:?@ca K 8UB*CO\�@A>c:}G�8UK EQR?8UKNE�@=8IM 5B(8UM�B�>�:AR?K ��B<8$R?>n:?>�]�5F@�[K R?5U:A^WRAC�8$RxB�5FEQR?8UKNE�@x8wMNKNGhK R?><PWEQ\LGwJ�>�:{5U62B�>�:AR?K ��B<8$R?>�@}@�><MN>�BcR?>(PJ^}R?C�>-\�@A>c:�8UB<B�5U:*P"KNE�`xR?5q@A5FGh>m8UMN`U5U:?K R?CLGya ª CL><E1\�@A>c:'$nS{8UER?@

150

Page 6: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

R?5o5UJLR*8UK E|R?C�>I]�\LJ�M KNBWVf>c^75$6=\L@A>�: %�;-R?CL>�^kGI>c:?`F>IR?C�>�K :wMN5B<8UMB<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?>y:?><]�5F@AK R?5U:AKN>�@�;}8UE�P $_R�:?KN>�@IR?5g��E�P�8UE£8U]L]L:?5F]":?Ku8$RA>B<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?>hB*C�8UKNEO60:?5FG $gR?5 %yK EgRAC�>�Gh>�:?`F><Py:?>�]�5F@AK RA5U:A^a ª >]L:?>�@A>�EQRx8UM `F5U:?K R?CLGI@TRA5wB�5FEL@�RA:?\LB�RqMN5B<8UM�B<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>�:?>�]�5F@�K R?5U:?KN>�@@A\�B*CoR?C�8$R<;2K 6q\�@A><PkJ^g><8UB*C7\�@�>�:<;.8UE^g]�8$K :�5U6q\�@A>c:?@nB<8UE7��E�PB<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?>XB*C�8UK E�@'R?5O><8UB*C�5UR?CL>�:wKNE7R?C�>�K :wGh>�:?`U>(Po:?><]�5U@AK R?5U:A^SxK R?CoC�KN`FCg]":?5FJ�8UJLKNMNK Ri^g>�ef><EOK 6TRAC�>�@AKNv�>w5U6mR?CL>�MN5B(8UM2:?><]�5F@AK R?5U[:?KN>�@'KN@'@AGI8UMNM.B�5FGh]�8$:A>(POR?5yR?C�>�R?5UR?8UMmEQ\�G�J�>c:15U6q\L@A>�:A@n5U6{R?C�>@�^L@iR?><GXa-jTC�K @{GI><8UE�@-R?C�8$R{5F\":q8U]L]L:?5f8UB*C�KN@{@AB<8UMu8UJLMN>U¥�CL5(ST>�ef>c:<;K Rx]L:?5(e"KNPL>�@q5FE�M ^�]L:?5UJ�8UJLKNMNK @�R?KNBn`F\�8$:*8UER?>�><@�a

5.1 Model and frameworkª >n8$@A@A\�Gh>=R?C�8$RxK 6-8w\L@A>c: $dJ�><M KN>�e>�@{R?C�8(R=8�`FK ef><Ey]L\�JLMNKNB�Vf>�^J�><M 5FE�`F@qR?5h8'`FKNef>�Ey\�@�>�: %�;LR?C�>�E�$dK @A@A\�>�@x8�]�\�JLMNK B�[�Vf>�^IB�>�:ARAK ��[B(8$R?>�R?5 %�a_��\":AR?CL>�:?Gh5U:?>U;-ST>y8U@A@�\�Gh>�R?C�8$RI\L@A>c:?@h8$:?>XCL5FE�>�@�R8UE�P�P"5dE�5URwK @A@A\�>I698UMN@A>yB�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA><@�a ª >�J":?KN>c��^78FPLP":?>�@A@'R?C�>]L:?5FJLMN>�G 5U6-PLK @AC�5FEL><@�Rx\L@A>�:A@xK Ed4"\LJ�@A>�BcR?KN5FEO©a ¨"a

ª >.Gh5QPL>�MFR?CL>2:?>�Mu8$R?K 5FE�@ACLKN]L@2J�>cRiSm><>�En\�@�>�:?@�:?>�]L:A><@A>�ER?>(P�JQ^}R?C�>]�\�JLMNK B�[�Vf>�^7B�>�:AR?K ��B<8$R?>�@�8U@I8gPLK :?><BcR?><P�`U:*8U]LC���r�� �� t*;mSqCL>�:A>� 8UE�P � @�R*8UE�Pd6Z5U:�R?CL>'@A>�R=5U6Tef>c:AR?KNB�>�@�8UE�PyR?C�>'@A>cR15$6m>(P"`F>�@�;:?><@A]�><BcR?KNef>�M ^fa ª >mB(8UM MfR?C�KN@�`U:*8$]�CnR?CL> �9�� � �  $� �*� � a.jTC�>-ef>�:AR?K B<>�@5U6{R?C�>wRA:?\L@�R'`U:*8U]LCk:?>�]L:A><@A>�ER'\�@A>c:?@�8UE�PgR?CL>h>(P"`F><@n:A><]":?><@�><ER]�\�JLMNK B�[�Vf>�^kB�>�:ARAK ��B<8$R?>�@�a£�X5U:?>y]L:?>�B�KN@A>�M ^f;mR?CL>�:A>XKN@h8gPLK :A><BcR?><P>(P"`F>160:?5FG ef>�:AR?>c��$yRA5hef>c:AR?>c� %IK 62\�@A>c: $dKN@A@A\L>(PX8w]L\�JLMNKNBc[�Vf>�^B<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?>1R?5w\�@A>c: %�a� B�>�:�R?K ��B(8$R?>hB*C�8UK Eo60:A5FG \L@A>c: $7R?5W\�@A>c: %dKN@�:?><]":?>�@A><ER?><PoJ^8kP"K :?>�B�R?><P�]�8$R?C|60:?5FG ef>�:ARA>�� $_R?5oef>c:AR?>c� %kKNE��naY�L5U:�8$EQ^PLK :?>�BcR?>(PY`U:?8U]�C��o;qK 61RiST5kef>c:AR?KNB�><@�$H8UE�P %_8$:?>dK E��o;x8UE�PR?C�>c:?>1K @}8hPLK :?><BcR?><PW]�8$R?CX60:?5FG $yR?5�%hKNE�o;LR?CL>�EWST>1@?8�^WR?C�8$R% � � �*� � � � � � �u�T�*� � ® $ � ¡� 8UE�PXST>'P">�E�5UR?>1RAC�KN@xJ^�$��� %�aj{CQ\L@�;QR?CL>{>��"KN@�R?>�ELB<>x5U6l81B�>�:�R?K ��B<8$R?>xB*C�8UK Eh60:A5FG \L@A>c:�$IR?51\�@A>c:%�Gh>(8UEL@TR?C�8(R}ef>c:AR?>c� %hKN@q:?><8UB*C�8UJLMN>�60:?5UG ef>�:�R?>���$dKNE�� rsKZa >UaN;$���� %"t*a�}@{ST>1Gh>�EQR?K 5FE�><P�J�>�6Z5U:?>U;�KNEy5F\":q]�\LJ�MNK B�[�Vf>c^WP"KN@�RA:?K J�\"R?KN5FEy@�^"@�[R?><GX;x><8UB*CD\�@A>c:WGI8UKNER*8UK E�@X8oMN5B<8UM�:?>�]�5F@AK R?5U:A^£5U6n]L\�JLMNKNBc[�Vf>�^B<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?><@�axjTC�KN@q:?>�]�5F@AK R?5U:A^yC�8U@xR&ST5h]�8$:ARA@�ax��K :?@�R<;�><8UB*Cd\�@A>c:@�R?5U:?>�@XR?C�>OB�>c:AR?K ��B(8$R?>�@WR?C�8$RX@�C�>OKN@A@A\L><P a jTCLKN@XKN@WE�>�>(P"><PDK E5U:*PL>c:nR?5y@�RA5U:?>�8$MNM.R?CL>hB�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA><@'KN@�@A\�><PkK EoR?CL>w@�^L@iR?><G KNEk8PL>�B<>�ERA:*8UMNK v<><PIS{8�^am4Q><B�5FE�P�;"><8UB*C�\L@A>�:T@�R?5U:?>�@{8n@A>�RT5U6l@A><M ><BcR?><PB<>c:AR?K ��B(8(R?><@xKN@A@�\�><PXJ^W5UR?CL>�:x\L@A>�:?@qK EXR?C�>�@�^L@iR?><GXa-piE�R?>�:?Gh@{5U65F\L:}GI5QP"><MZ;�RAC�KN@qGh>(8$E�@{R?C�8(R}><8UB*Cd\�@A>c: $d@�R?5U:?>�@}RAC�>15F\"R?`F5FK E�`>(P"`F><@�rZSxK R?CkRAC�>wB<5U:�:?><@�]�5FE�P"KNEL`Oef>c:AR?K B<>�@*t=60:?5FG ef>c:AR?>c� $�8UE�P8UEg8FP�P"K R?KN5FE�8UM�@A>�R�5U6m@A>�MN>�B�RA>(Pd><PL`F>�@wr9SqK R?CdR?C�>'B�5U:A:?>�@A]�5FE�PLK E�`ef>�:AR?K B<>�@*tq5U6-R?CL>nRA:?\L@�R=`U:?8U]�C a ª >�:?>�6Z>c:�RA5IR?CL>n@A>cR�5U6-@A><M ><BcR?><P>(P"`F><@nr�8UE�PWef>c:AR?KNB�><@?tq8U@{R?CL>�@A\LJ�`U:?8U]�CXR?C�8$RqJ�>�MN5FEL`F@xR?5&$�a

ª CL><E£\L@A>c: $£S{8UER?@�R?5kef>�:AK 60^_R?CL>d]�\LJ�MNK ByVf>�^Y5$61\�@�>�: %�; $8UE�P�%hGh>c:?`F>}R?CL>�K :T:?>�]�5F@AK RA5U:?KN>�@x5$6�@�><MN>�BcR?>(PIB<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>�@�;�8UE�P�$RA:?KN>�@=R?5w��E�Pd8UEO8U]L]L:?5F]":?Ku8$R?>�B�>c:AR?K ��B(8$R?>'B*C�8UKNEy60:?5FG $OR?5%XK ER?C�>wGh>�:?`F><PO:?><]�5F@AK R?5U:�^a�piEgR?CL>hGh5QPL>�M9; $|8UE�P %OGh>�:?`U>wR?CL>�K :@A\�JL`U:*8U]�CL@�;8UE�P&$hR�:?KN>�@2R?5}��E�P'8=]�8(R?Cw6u:?5FG ef>�:�R?>���$wR?5=ef>�:ARA>��%nKNE'R?CL>TGI>c:?`F><Pn@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC�a-�xE'>��L8UGh]�MN>mKN@2@�C�5(SqEwKNEw��KN`F\":?>x�a

ª >=8U@A@A\LGI>xR?C�8$R{><8UB*CW\L@A>c:{\�@A>�@mR?CL>=@?8UGh>}@A\�JL`U:*8U]�C�@A>�MN><BcR?K 5FE8UMN`F5U:?K R?C�G�� R?5OJL\�KNMNP�C�>c:w@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC�a ª C�>�E�� KN@h>��">�B<\"R?>(P5FE��§J^y\L@A>c:�$�;�K Rx:?>�@A\�M R?@=K Eg8h@A\LJ�`U:*8$]�CyR?C�8$R=ST>nPL>�E�5UR?>'J^���}r�� $ t*adjTC�>I\�E�K 5FE75U6qR?CL>h@A\�JL`U:*8U]�CL@����}r�� $ t15U6q\L@A>c:&$8UE�P����}r�� %"tm5U6�\�@�>�: %hKN@xPL>�E�5URA>(PWJ^���xr�� $ %Lt?am4"KNELB<>}R?C�>\�E�K 5FEy5F]�>c:*8$R?K 5FEyKN@xB<5UGIG�\"R*8$R?KNef>U;����xr�� $ %"t������xr�� % $ t*a

uv

subgraph of usubgraph of vpath from u to v

� ,:>4�8�<�! �#"%�5�<>$,�#8> .��8E+>��<�!�F7�.!�%$ 7��1#*��.��5� $#� ��#(��.�0&3$�1�<,*� G?��7����+�8E�/,/� �$�5G &�� ��.��5� %�� $ ��#+ %@'@�5��>$����78�1,:��:& ����� ���5�<��, �;���!���%�<�5�;&4.�,:��&��A,:�1.!� ��#+ $ ���<,/�1.?�0& �;#� ����5�<��, �F�����0�"�<7���,/# ���<&(' $"�0& % ,/# ��78� '@�5�<>��1 ���5�;&4.O),:�0&$��G��'&0# &$��� �0�A��.�� >$�����+7 '@& 8��� ���/&(���������5�<��, �;���!������1�F&4.�,:��&��A,:�1.��!�<� ���5�+���!.0�1#(���1 "E G .��8E�>$�<�!�+7+.9��#+ %���1��)��, �F�����0�-�<7���,/#+.I�����*�<�5�+���!.0�1#(���1 ?E G?������7+.�� � 78�5�<�'� &��<���,/# ��7���'�& 8��� � $@�$#� %*'��1��>$����7��1,:�2.��8E+>��<�!�F7�.!�F��#� $.0�5���A�<7��1.2� &��2��������7�� �<&4' 3$�1�����'& $@�0&�34�5�<�0�'& %*,/# ��78�'��5�<>$�1 .��8E�>$�����+7"�

ª >=PL>c��EL>xR?CL>}� �*�Z� � �*® �$¡ �*�)( �xr��1t.5U6lR?CL>}@�\�JL`U:*8U]�C�@A><M ><BcR?KN5UE8UM `F5U:?K RAC�G*��5UEwR?CL>mRA:?\L@�R.`U:*8$]�C!�D8U@-R?CL>m:*8$R?KN5�5U6�R?CL>qEQ\LG�J�>�:5U6�\L@A>�:x]�8UK :?@1r�$ %"t.SqC�>c:?>�R?CL>�:A>�KN@x8wPLK :?><BcR?><PX]�8$RACW60:?5FG $XR?5%IKNEWRAC�>1Gh>c:?`F>(P�@A\�JL`U:*8U]LCX5U6 $O8UE�P�%wR?5�R?C�>=EQ\�G�J�>c:{5U6�\�@A>c:]�8UK :?@xr�$ %Lt�SqC�>c:?>xRAC�>c:?>qKN@T8nP"K :?>�B�RA>(Ph]�8$R?Cw60:?5FG $�RA5 %'KNEhR?C�>R�:?\�@�Rq`U:*8$]�C�am�L5U:?G�8$MNM ^��

( �qr��1t+�-,/. r�$ %"t�0�21� ��$3��465+7 �98 :;8 <>= %@?,!. r�$ %"t)0�*1� ��$3��� %@?

SqCL>�:A> , P"><EL5UR?>�@-R?C�>qB<8$:*P"KNE�8UM K Ri^h5U6l8�@A>�R<a K @A@A>�EQR?KN8UMNM ^f; ( �xr���t>c�"]L:?>�@A@A>�@�SqCLKNB*CY60:*8UBcR?KN5FEH5U61R?CL>d>��"KN@�RAKNE�`7PLK :?><BcR?><PD]�8$R?CL@�KNE� B<8UEyJ�>}:?>�B<5FEL@�RA:?\LB�R?><PXK 6�5FELM ^WR?CL>�@A\LJ�`$:*8U]�CL@%���qr�� $ t{8UE�P���xr�� %"tx8$:?>h8(eF8$KNMu8UJLMN>�SqC�>�Ek8I]�8$RACoJ�>cR&ST><>�E $78UE�P!%yKN@�:A>�[z\L><@�R?><P�a

Hm>�@AKuP">�@nK R?@1]�>�:A6Z5$:?G�8UELB<>U;A� C�8U@�5UR?C�>c:nKNGh]�5U:�R*8UER�B*C�8(:*8UB�RA>�:A[K @�R?KNB�@x8U@{ST><M M9a{°=E�>}5U6�R?C�>�@A>�K @{R?C�>=@AKNv�>15U6�R?C�>=@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC�@TR?C�8$RK R�@A><M ><BcR?@�ag�mMN><8$:?M ^f;�R?C�>I]�>c:A6Z5U:?GI8UE�B�>I5$6B� B(8UEkJ�>�K E�Bc:?><8U@A>(PJ^Y@A>�MN>�B�RAKNE�`|Mu8$:?`F>c:y@A\LJ�`U:*8$]�C�@c;}J�\"R�R?CL><E ;x\L@A>�:A@XE�>�>(PYGh5U:?>Gh>�GI5U:A^nR?5n@�R?5U:?>xR?C�>�K :m@A\�JL`U:*8U]�CL@�;L8UE�PwRAC�KN@TGI8<^�M >(8FPhR?5n@AB<8UM [8UJLKNM K Ri^g]":?5FJ�M ><Gh@�a'�}EL5UR?C�>c:1K GI]�5$:AR*8UER1B*C�8(:*8UB�RA>�:?K @�R?KNBw5U6)� K @RAC�>18UGh5F\LEQRx8UE�P�R&^L]�>}5U62V"EL5(SqMN><P"`F>�:?><zQ\LK :?><PWJ^hR?C�>=\�@A>c:?@{R?5>c�"><B�\LRA>IK R�aO�x`f8UKNE ;2R?C�>h]�>c:A6Z5U:?GI8UE�B�>�5$6B� B(8UEkJ�>�K E�Bc:?><8U@A>(PJ^g\�@�KNE�`yGh5U:?>hKNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FE|8UJ�5F\LR1R?C�>�RA:?\L@�R'`U:*8U]LC�;2JL\LR�R?C�>8UB<z\�K @AK R?KN5UE75U6TR?CLKN@nK EL6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5UEkGI8<^OJ�>IPLK �hB<\LM Rn5U:1><ef>�EkK EL[6Z><8U@AK J�MN>UaI��KNE�8UMNM ^f;lR?CL>w8UMN`F5U:?K R?C�G @ACL5F\�MuPOEL5URn8U@A@�KN`FE|8I@A]�>�B<KN8UM:A5FMN>�R?5�8UE^I5U6�R?C�>}E�5QP"><@{KNEIR?C�>xRA:?\L@�R{`U:*8U]LC�a.piE�]�8$:AR?K B<\LMu8$:<;LK RK @.E�5$RTPL>�@AK :?8UJ�MN>qR?C�8$R.><8UB*CI\L@A>c:�� @.@�\�J�`$:*8U]�ChB�5FEQR*8$KNE�@.8�@A]�>�B�K ��B

151

Page 7: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

E�5QPL>Xr�8WeQK :AR?\�8UM1�iB�><ER?>c:?�y5U6TR?CL>'RA:?\�@�R1`U:*8U]LC�t*aI�xM R?CL5F\�`FC ;�K ER?C�KN@{B<8U@A>U;�8UE^IR&ST5�@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC�@mST5F\LMuPWK EQRA>�:?@A>�BcRqKNEWR?CLKN@T@A]�>�B�K ��BE�5QPL>U;m8UE�PoR?CQ\�@�;�R?CL>�]�>�:A6Z5U:AG�8UELB<>�5U6 � ST5F\�MNP|J�>IC�KN`FC ;2R?C�>@A><B�\L:AK Ri^�5U6�R?C�>}@�^"@�R?><G ST5F\LMuP�:?>�M ^�5FEy8'@AK E�`FMN>�E�5QPL>U;�8UE�P�R?CLKN@@AC�5F\LMuPXJ�>�8(ef5FKNPL><P aj{CL>c:?>�6Z5U:A>F;�R?CL>nPL>�@AKN`FEd5UJ"¤i><BcR?KNef>�@}5$6-@A\LJ�`U:*8$]�Cy@A>�MN>�B�RAKN5FEg8UMN`F5U[:?K R?CLGI@q8$:?>=R?C�>=6Z5FMNMN5<SqKNE�`"�

� � �*�Z� � �*® �$¡ �*� � R?5�8UB*CLKN>�ef>OC�KN`FCD]�>c:A6Z5U:?GI8UELB<>d5FE£RA:?\L@�R`$:*8U]�CL@{R?C�8$RxGI8<^I5B<B�\L:xKNEXRAC�>=R?8$:?`F>cR?>(Py8$]�]�M KNB<8$R?KN5FE ¥� 9 � � � � � �9� �Z��� � R?51@A><M ><BcR{@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC�@2R?C�8$RTC�8(ef>x8�:?><8U@A5FE�8UJ�M >@�KNv�>wSqK R?Cg:A><@A]�><BcR�R?5�R?C�>'@AK v<>w5U6mR?CL>nSqC�5FM >wR�:?\�@�R�`U:*8U]LCr9K9a >UaN;�R?CL>�EQ\�G�J�>c:{5U6�\�@A>c:?@xKNEWR?CL>�@�^"@�R?>�G�t*¥

��� � � �9�*� � Q�9� �$¡ � R?5�:?><M ^X5FEyKNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5UEyR?C�8$RqKN@��iMN5B<8UMN�IR?5RAC�>=\�@A>c:qR?C�8$Rx>c�L>�B�\LR?>�@TR?C�>�8UMN`F5U:AK R?C�GX¥�8UE�P��� � � � � ¡ � �?� � R?5�8(ef5FKuPyR?C�8$R=RAC�>nB�5FGI]":?5FGhKN@A>'5U6.8�@AK E�`FMN>\L@A>c:n5U:�8W@�G�8UM M.EQ\�G�J�>c:�5$6{\�@A>c:?@1M >(8FP"@1R?5WR?CL>wB<5FM Mu8U]�@�>5$62R?CL>�@A>�B�\L:?K R&^W5U6�R?CL>=SqC�5UMN>n@�^"@�R?>�Gya

�TM >(8(:?M ^;�RAC�>c:?>wKN@nEL5y8UMN`F5U:AK R?C�G R?C�8$RnKN@n5U]LR?K G�8UM�SqK R?Cg:?><@�]�><BcRR?5I8$MNMl5FJQ¤�><BcR?KNef>�@�¥�5FEL>1C�8U@{R?5���E�PW8'RA:*8UPL>c[&5U��a

5.2 The Shortcut Hunter algorithmª >.>c�"]�>�B�R�R?C�8$RlRA:?\�@iRl`U:*8U]�CL@lR?C�8$RlGI8<^=5B<B�\L:�KNE1@A><M 60[&5U:A`f8UE�K v<><P@�^L@iR?><Gh@=>c�"C�K J�K R�� ® � �Z� �m� �c� ¯7� �$«$�.]":?5F]�>c:AR?KN>�@hrsKZa >Fa ;�R?CL>�^yC�8(ef>8O@�G�8UM M{8(ef>c:*8U`F>XP"Ku8UGh>�RA>�:w8UE�P ;.8$R�R?CL>�@?8$GI>hR?KNGh>F;2R?CL>c^78$:?>C�KN`FCLM ^kB<M \�@�R?>c:?><P�t*a 9 � � �*� �OQ� �y]LMu8�^|8UE7KNGh]�5U:AR*8UER':?5FM >WKNEk:?>�[PL\�B�KNEL`=R?CL>{8(ef>c:*8U`F>xP"Ku8UGh>�R?>c:-5$6 @AGI8UMNMQST5U:?MuP�`U:*8U]LC�@�a.�_@ACL5U:ARA[B<\"RqKN@xPL>c��EL>(P�8U@x8UEX><PL`F>U;�\�]�5FEISqC�5F@A>=:?>�GI5(eF8UM9;"R?CL>�@ACL5U:AR?>�@�R\�E�P"K :?>�BcR?>(Ph]�8$RACIJ�>cRiSm><>�EIRAC�>xE�5QPL>�@m]":?><eQKN5U\�@AM ^hB�5FE�EL>�B�R?><PIJ^R?C�8$Rl><PL`F>-J�>�B<5FGh>�@l@iRA:?KNBcR?M ^=Mu8$:?`F>c:�R?C�8UE}RiST5QaFH.^18UE1\�E�P"K :?>�BcR?>(P]�8$R?C ;lST>wGh>(8UEo8WB*C�8UKNEo5U6{8$:?JLK RA:*8$:?K M ^kPLK :?><BcR?><Po><PL`U><@�aI4"KNELB<>@AC�5U:ARAB<\"R?@x8$:?>1KNGh]�5U:AR?8UEQR{K EX@AGI8UMNM ST5U:AMuPX`U:*8U]LC�@�;LSm>nPL>�@AKN`FEL><P8=@A\LJ�`U:*8U]LC'@A>�MN>�B�R?K 5FE�8UM `F5U:?K RAC�GX;B<8UMNMN><P#9 � � �*� �OQ��� ¡ ���?� ;R?C�8$RR*8UVf><@qK EQR?5h8UB�B<5U\�ERq@AC�5U:�R?B<\"R?@{SqC�>�EyJ�\LKNMuP"KNEL`h8�@A\LJ�`U:?8U]�C aj{CL>I8UMN`F5U:?K R?C�G @A>�MN>�B�R?@'8W@A\�JL`U:*8U]�CgR?C�8$RnB�5FE�@AK @�R?@n5U6TR&ST5yMN5F`U[KNB(8$MNM ^�PLKN@�RAKNE�BcRw]�8$:�R?@��X8UE�� Q� � �?� ¡ ¯�8UE�P78UE � ¡�� �?� ¡�¯7]�8$R?C aj{CL>�]�8$RAC�@=8$:?>�@A><M ><BcR?><PgK EgGw\LM R?K ]�MN>1:A5F\�E�PL@�a ª C�>�EO@A>�MN><BcR?K E�`R?C�>q5F\"RA[&J�5F\�E�P�]�8$R?Cw5U6 \L@A>�: $l;RAC�>q8UMN`F5$:?K R?CLG @iR*8$:AR?@-60:A5FG ef>c:A[R?>���$l;l8$E�PyKNEO><8UB*Cd:?5F\�E�P ;�K R}@A>�MN>�B�R?@�8UEO5F\LR?`U5FKNE�`�>(P"`F>�r9SqK RACK R?@mR?>c:?GhKNE�8$RAKNE�`�ef>�:ARA>���t�R?C�8$RTJ�>�MN5FEL`F@mR?51R?CL>}MN8U@�R{@A>�MN>�B�R?><P�ef>c:A[R?>���a-piE�]L:*8UBcR?K B<>U;LR?C�K @{GI><8UE�@mRAC�8$R $yG�\L@�Rq8U@AVwR?C�>=\�@A>c:q5U6lR?C�>Mu8U@�R{@A>�MN>�B�RA>(Phef>�:ARA>���6Z5U:{8�MNKN@�R{5U6 C�>c:T5F\LRA`F5FKNEL`'>(P"`F><@�a.jTCLKN@mM KN@�RB(8UE'><8U@AKNM ^'J�>.]":?5$eQKuP"><P ;$J�>�B(8U\L@A>T><8UB*Cn\�@A>c:�@�R?5U:?>�@�C�>c:25F\"R?`F5FK E�`>(P"`F><@ca-j{CL>T@A>�MN>�B�R?K 5FEw5U6�R?CL>mKNE"[&J�5F\�E�P1]�8$R?C'5$6 $wKN@�@AKNGhKNMu8$:���R?C�>8UMN`F5U:?K R?C�G @�R*8$:AR?@m6u:?5FG ef>c:AR?>c� $l;L8UE�PIK E�><8UB*C�:?5F\LE�P�;QK RT@A><M ><BcR?@8UEyKNELB<5FGhKNEL`h><P"`F>Ir9SqK R?CyK R?@q5U:?KN`FK E�8$R?K E�`Ief>�:AR?>c��t.R?C�8$RxJ�>�MN5FEL`F@R?5WR?CL>wMN8U@�R'@A>�MN>�B�RA>(Pgef>�:�R?>���a'piEg5U:*PL>c:1R?5�G�8$V>'RAC�KN@=]�5F@A@AK J�MN>U;>(8UB*C_\L@A>�:wG�\L@�Rw8UMN@A5oVQE�5<S 8UJ�5F\LRwC�>c:wKNELB<5UGIKNEL`g>(P"`F><@ca_�L5U:R?C�KN@-:?>(8$@A5FE�;L5F\":{8UMN`U5U:?K R?CLG :A>(z\�K :?><@-R?C�8$RT><8UB*CI\�@A>c:TKN@mEL5UR?K ��><PSxCL>�E�>�ef>�:}8UEL5UR?C�>c:q\�@A>c:xKN@A@A\L>�@=8�B�>�:AR?K ��B<8$R?>�RA5hCL>�:�a

j{CL>n@A>�MN>�B�RAKN5FEO5U6-R?CL>1EL>��QRx>(P"`F>'8UE�PyK R?@qR?>c:?GIK E�8$R?K E�`h5U:}5U:?KN`FK [E�8$R?K E�`Wef>c:AR?>c���WK EO>(8UB*CO:?5F\LE�Py5U6mR?CL>�8UMN`F5$:?K R?CLG KN@�J�8U@A><Pg5UER?C�>1EQ\LG�J�>�:m5U6�"� @q@ACL5U:AR?B�\LR?@ca{�X5$:?>n]L:?>�B�KN@A>�M ^;�K Ey>(8$BcCW@�R?>�]�;�8ef>�:AR?>c�dR?C�8$RnC�8U@1R?C�>�CLKN`FCL><@�R'EQ\LG�J�>�:=5U6{@ACL5U:AR?B�\LR?@�KN@1B*C�5U@A><E a��\�@A>c: $dB<8UEyPL>cR?>c:?GIK E�>}R?C�>=E"\LG�J�>c:T5U6-CL>�:q@�C�5U:AR?B�\LRA@xJ^I5FJL[R*8UKNELKNE�`�K EL6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5UEy8UJ�5F\"R{R?C�>}5F\LR?`U5FKNE�`w8UE�P�K E�B�5FGIK E�`'><PL`F>�@

5U6-C�>c:=8FP$¤A8UB�>�EQR}\�@�>�:?@'rsK9a >Fa ;�R?CL>n\�@�>�:?@xR?C�8(R}J�><M 5FE�`hR?5Ief>c:AR?K B<>�@RAC�8$R�8$:?>�B<5UE�EL><BcR?><PoR?5def>c:AR?>c� $kSqK R?C|>�K R?CL>c:w8UE|5F\"R?`F5FKNEL`d5U:8UEXKNE�B�5FGhKNE�`�><PL`U>$t*aHm>�MN5<S�;�ST>�`FKNef>n8wP">�R*8$KNMN><PyPL>�@ABc:?KN]"R?KN5FEy5U6�R?CL>1@A>�MN>�B�R?K 5FEy5U6�R?C�>5F\"RA[�J�5F\LE�Py]�8(R?C�a=jTCL>�@A><M ><BcR?KN5FEg5U62R?C�>'K EL[�J�5F\�E�Py]�8(R?CyST5U:?VQ@K Eg8�@AKNGhKNMN8$:=S{8�^a ª >�PL>�E�5URA>1R?C�>'@A>cR15$6.ef>c:AR?KNB�><@�8UE�PyR?CL>n@A>cR5U6�><PL`F>�@q5U6lR?C�>=@A><M ><BcR?><PX5F\LR�[&J�5U\�E�PI]�8$RACWJ^�hr��2tT8UE�P � r��-t*;:A><@A]�>�BcR?KNef>�M ^fam�L\L:ARAC�>c:?GI5$:?>F;fST>�P"><EL5UR?>qR?C�>}@A>cR{5U6l>(P"`F>�@T5U6lR?C�>R�:?\�@�R1`U:*8U]�CoJ^ � r��1t�8$E�POST>�8$@A@A\�Gh>�R?C�8$R�R?C�>w8UM `F5U:?K R?CLG K @>c�"><B�\LRA>(POJ^d\�@A>c: $�ahjTC�>�M ><EL`UR?C �w5U6.R?C�>�@A>�MN>�B�R?><Pg]�8$R?COK @n8]�8$:*8UGh>�RA>�:<a-jTCL>T@A>cR� B�5FER*8UKNEL@2R?CL5F@A>Tef>c:AR?KNB�>�@-5U6��£R?C�8$R-C�8(ef>J�><>�EX]":?5B<>�@A@A><PyJ�\"RxEL5URq@A>�MN>�B�R?><PyKNER?5'R?CL>1]�8(R?C�a

�Faqp&E�K RAKu8UMNK v(8$R?K 5FE��3�wr��-tx� � . $�?f; � r��-tx� � �Q;� � � �Q;��§� �$�; �.� � J

�a�� � � . r�� �t 0 � r��1t.���!�0 �wr��2t{8UE�P�� �0��?¦Qaqp�6�� ���Q;LR?CL><E-�?� � � �s� � � � � ¡   �

r�8ftIp�6���� $l;LR?CL><EX`U5wR?5w@�R?>�]�8rsJ�tI�}P�P��HR?5�rsB(t�j�8UVf>�R?CL>�><PL`F>wr�% �=t 0 � r��2tr�P�t��x><Gh5$ef>7r % �=th60:?5FG � r��2t*;=8UE�P£:A><Gh5$ef>��¬60:?5FG�hr��2trs>(t���� � %�; �.� � ���_�rZ6*t L=5wR?5�@�R?>�]O�

¨"a}�mCL55F@A>{R?C�>m><PL`U>1r�� �t 0��|R?CL>mR?>c:?GIK E�8$R?K E�`}ef>�:ARA>����}5U6SqCLKNB*COC�8U@xR?C�>'CLKN`FCL><@iR�EQ\�G�J�>c: �n5U6m@ACL5U:AR?B�\LRA@�rsK 6.R?C�>c:?>8$:A>1@A>�ef>�:*8UM�@�\�B*Cy><PL`F>�@�;LR?C�>�EXB*CL55F@A>n5FEL>�:*8UE�P"5FGhM ^�t

©aqp�6�� � JQ;�R?CL><EoB*C�55F@A>hR?C�>h><PL`F>yr�� �t 0!�§R?CL>hR?>c:?GhK [E�8$R?KNEL`kef>c:AR?>c�!�o5U6�SqC�K B*CYC�8U@hR?C�>yCLKN`FCL><@�RIEQ\�G�J�>c:h5U65F\"R?`F5FK E�`g>(P"`F>�@Xr9K 6qR?C�>c:?>X8$:A>W@A>�ef>�:?8UM{@A\�B*C|><PL`U><@�;-R?CL><EB*CL5Q5U@A>n5FE�>}:*8UE�PL5FGhM ^�t

«Qax�}P�Pdr�� �tmR?5 � r��-t?;�8UE�Py8FPLP���R?5!�hr��-t�a"� � ���"; �2� � � � �CQaqp�6 ��# �F;LR?CL><EW`F5�R?5h@iR?><]O�8Qa}°}\LR?]L\LRTR?CL>�]�8$R?Cor��hr��2t � r��-tAtT8UE�PX@�R?5F]

5.3 Evaluation of Shortcut Hunterª >.C�8(ef>.K E"ef>�@�R?K `f8$R?><P�R?C�>-]�>�:�6Z5U:?G�8$E�B�>m5U6�4"C�5$:AR?B�\LR � \LER?>�:�5FE:A>(8UM�� L ��RA:?\�@�Rq`$:*8U]�CL@qRAC�8$RqST>1C�8(ef>=5FJLR*8UK E�><PW60:?5FG R?C�>}ST><J@�K R?>�@hS{S{S�a ]L`F]�KZa 5U:?`�8$E�P|S{S{S�a B�>�:�R<a 5U:?`"a �X5U:?>y]L:?>�B�KN@A>�M ^f;TST>>c�QRA:*8UBcR?>(P'R?CL>TMu8$:?`U><@�R.@�RA:?5FEL`FM ^wB�5FE�EL><BcR?><P�B�5FGh]�5FEL><ER-5$6�R?CL:A><>�ML �O]�\LJ�MNK B�[�Vf>c^1PL8$R*8UJ�8U@�><@�;8UE�P=ST>TB<5UE�@AKuP">�:A>(P1R?CL><@�>m@�RA:?5FEL`FM ^B�5FELE�>�B�R?><P1B�5FGh]�5FE�>�ER?@l8U@lRA:?\�@�R�`U:*8$]�CL@�6Z5U:�5F\":�]L\L:A]�5F@A>�@�a2jTC�>]�>�:A6Z5U:AG�8UELB<>�5U6�4"CL5U:AR?B�\LR � \�ER?>�:n5FE|R?CL><@A>IRA:?\�@iRh`$:*8U]�CL@'6Z5U:eU8$:?KN5F\L@q@A\�JL`U:*8U]�CW@AKNv�><@xKN@q@ACL5(SqEyKNEd��KN`F\":?>n¦Qa

p�R�B<8UEgJ�>'@A>�><EOR?C�8$Rn4QC�5U:�R?B<\"R � \�ER?>c:=]�>�:A6Z5$:?GI@}ef>�:�^yST><M M-5FERAC�>�R&ST5I@�G�8UM MN>c:}RA:?\L@�R}`U:*8U]LC�@q><ef>�EyK 62R?C�>�@AKNv�>n5U62R?C�>1@�><MN>�BcR?>(P@�\�J�`$:*8U]�CL@=K @}ef>c:A^y@AGI8UMNMZa=��5U:=KNEL@�R*8UE�B�>U;�SqCL><EyR?CL>n@AK v<>�5U62R?C�>@�><MN>�BcR?>(PI@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC�@mK @T5FE�M ^W�AJ;"R?C�>q]�>c:A6Z5U:?GI8UE�B�>}KN@mGh5U:?>qR?C�8UEJQa 8��a�jTC�K @IGh><8UE�@wR?C�8(RIK 61><8UB*CY\�@A>c:�@iR?5U:?>�@�5FELM ^Y�AJoB<>c:AR?K ��[B<8$R?>�@mr���J{5F\LRA[�J�5F\LE�P18$E�Pw��J{KNE"[�J�5F\�E�P�t�KNE1C�>c:lMN5B(8$MQ:?>�]�5F@AK R?5U:A^f;SqCLKNB*Ch8$:?>q@A><M ><BcR?><Ph\L@AKNEL`'4QC�5U:AR?B�\LR � \�ER?>c:<;fR?CL><Ew8UE^�\L@A>�:-B(8UE

152

Page 8: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

� ,:>4�8�<� ��� 78���;�5� ��&$�A'@�$#����*&���� 7�&��<��� �����9��#(���5� ,/# ���1��������� ���<�+.0� >��<�!�F7�.

5FJLR*8UK ED8UE�P�ef>c:?K 60^�RAC�>y]L\�JLMNKNByVf>c^�5U618UE^�5UR?CL>�:�\�@A>c:<;T\�@AK E�`5FE�M ^XR?C�>nM 5QB<8UM2B<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>n:?>�]�5F@AK R?5$:?KN>�@15U6-RAC�>nRiSm5�\L@A>�:?@c; SqK RAC8U]�]":?5(�"KNGI8$R?>�M ^9JQa 8��w]":?5FJ�8UJ�KNM K Ri^fa{j{CL>1]�>c:A6Z5U:?GI8UELB<>n5U6�R?CL>n8UM [`F5U:?K R?CLG 5FEHR?CL>OMu8$:?`F>�@�RyRA:A\�@�Ry`U:?8U]�CHKN@X@AK `FE�K ��B<8UER?M ^£ST5U:?@A>U¥C�5(Sm><ef>c:<;-K R�@ACL5(Sq@w8UE|K E�Bc:?><8U@AKNEL`gR?>�E�PL>�E�Bc^78$@nR?C�>I@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC@AKNv�>nKNELB�:?><8U@A>�@�a

j{CL>q]�\":?>x4"CL5U:AR?B�\LR � \LEQR?>c:m8$MN`F5U:?K R?C�G�J�\LKNMuP"@m8=@A\�JL`U:*8U]�C�R?C�8$RB<5FEL@AKN@�R?@'5$6q8X@AKNEL`FMN>h5F\LRA[�J�5F\LE�Pg8UE�P78W@AK E�`FM >�KNE"[�J�5F\�E�PO]�8$R?C aª >}GI5QP"K ��><PhK R{KNE�@A\�B*C�8'ST8<^hR?C�8$RTK R{J�\LKNMuP"@{8n@A\�JL`U:*8U]LC�R?C�8$RB<5FEL@AKN@�R?@q5U6�@A>�ef>c:*8UM ef>�:�R?>��IP"KN@Z¤�5FKNERq5F\"RA[&J�5F\�E�P�8UE�P�ef>c:AR?>c��P"KN@�[¤�5FKNER1KNE"[�J�5F\�E�PX]�8$RAC�@�a ª >'B<8UMNMlR?C�K @=Gh5QPLK ��>(Pd8$MN`F5U:?K R?C�G 4R*8$:4"C�5$:AR?B�\LR � \�ER?>c:Irs@AKNELB�>hR?CL>I@�\�J�`$:*8U]�CoR?C�8$RnK R'JL\�KNMNPL@n:?>�@A>�Gh[J�MN>�@I8g@�R?8$:ct*a£�X5U:?>y]L:A><B�KN@A>�M ^f;mSqCL><E�:?\LE�ELKNEL`g60:A5FG 8gef>�:ARA>��$l;{4QR*8$:�4QC�5U:AR?B�\LR � \�ER?>c:�J�\LKNMuP"@ (��� �¬GhKNE r� ��� �<t'ef>�:ARA>��PLKN@Z¤i5FKNER�5F\"RA[�J�5F\�E�Py8UE�P (�� � � GhKNE r� � � �(t{ef>c:AR?>c�yPLK @Z¤�5FKNER=KNEL[J�5F\�E�PO]�8$R?CL@=SqCL>�:?> ��� 8UE�P � � P">�E�5UR?>'R?CL>�E"\LG�J�>c:�5U6�$ � @5F\LR?`F5FK E�`O8UE�PkK E�B�5FGIK E�`X><P"`F><@�;�:A><@A]�><BcR?KNef>�M ^f;28UE�P �wKN@'8XB�5FEL[@�R*8UER<a.jTC�>xMN>�E�`UR?C��q5U6�><8UB*C�]�8$R?ChKN@T><zQ\�8UMLR?5�� � �Qr (��� � (�� � t��U;SxCL>c:?> �xKN@2R?C�>T:?><z\�K :A>(P�@AKNv�>x5U6�R?CL>{:A><@A\LM R?K E�`n@A\LJ�`U:*8$]�CXr9SqC�K B*CKN@}8UEdKNE�]L\LRx5U6�R?C�>18UMN`F5U:?K R?C�G�t*a � 5UR?>=R?C�8$R}K 6��#� �F;�R?C�>�EO4R*8$:4"C�5$:AR?B�\LR � \�ER?>c:}KN@�><z\�KNeU8UMN>�EQR}R?5hR?C�>']L\L:?>w4QC�5U:ARAB<\"R � \�ER?>c:8UMN`F5U:?K R?C�GXaj{CL>h5F]�>c:*8$R?KN5FEk5U6x4QR?8$:�4"CL5U:AR?B�\LR � \LEQRA>�:�KN@nJ�8U@A>(Pg5FEoR?C�>h8UM [`F5U:?K R?CLG P"><@ABc:?KNJ�>(P_KNE|R?C�>X]":?>�e"K 5F\�@h@A\�JL@A>�B�R?K 5FE�a£jTC�8$R�8UMN`F5U[:?K R?CLG~KN@�>c�"><B�\"R?>(P (��� R?KNGh>�@}R?5�J�\LKNMuP (��� 5F\"RA[&J�5F\�E�Py]�[email protected]>�E�`$R?C��UaqpiEd5U:*P">�:xR?5I><EL@A\L:A>1R?C�8$RxR?CL>n@A>�MN>�B�R?><Pd5F\LR�[&J�5F\LE�P]�8$R?CL@'8$:?>�PLKN@0¤�5FKNER<;-8$RnR?CL>IJ�><`FK E�ELKNE�`y5$6x><8UB*Ck>��"><B�\"R?KN5FE ;�R?C�>@A>�R K @'KNELK R?Ku8UM KNv�>(PoSxK R?C7R?CL>w@A>�R�5$6xef>c:AR?K B<>�@n@A>�MN>�B�R?><P7@�5y698$:<;KNE�@�RA>(8FPg5U6m:?>�@A>cRAR?KNEL`XK R�R?5��W><8UB*COR?KNGh>Fa�jTC�>�@A>�MN>�B�RAKN5FE75$6mR?C�>KNEL[�J�5F\LE�PO]�8(R?C�@1K @nJ�8U@�>(Po5FEk@�KNGIK Mu8$:']":?KNELB<K ]�MN>�@�aWjTC�>w]�>c:A6Z5U:A[G�8UELB<>W5U6'4R*8$:�4"CL5U:AR?B�\LR � \LER?>�:�SqCL><E!��� ��JkK @I@�C�5(SqEYK E��KN`U\L:?>n¨"a

p�R.B<8UEhJ�>{@A><>�EwR?C�8$Rm4QR*8(:T4"CL5U:AR?B�\LR � \LER?>�:2]�>c:A6Z5U:?Gh@-J�>cRAR?>c:m5FERAC�>�MN8$:?`F>�@�R}R�:?\�@�Rx`U:*8U]LCWR?C�8UEd4QC�5U:AR?B�\"R � \�ER?>c:xPL5>�@�a.p&R?@{]�>c:A[6Z5$:?G�8UELB<>�5FEo8UM M�R?C":?>�>�R�:?\�@�R=`U:*8U]LC�@=KN@�Gh5U:?>nR?C�8UE@JQa 8f©ISqCL><ERAC�>W@AK v<>X5U6=R?CL>W@A>�MN>�B�RA>(P�@A\LJ�`U:?8U]�C_K @I8$:A5F\�E�P|RiST5OR?KNGh>�@'R?C�>@AzQ\�8$:?>n:?55UR15$6-R?CL>'@AKNv�>�5U6-R?CL>nRA:?\�@iR=`U:?8U]�C a�j{CLKN@=@AC�5<Sq@=R?C�8$R4R*8$:w4QC�5U:ARAB<\"R � \LER?>�:1B(8UE78UB*C�K ><ef>I8XC�K `FC7]�>�:A6Z5U:AG�8UELB<>U;�^>cRK R{KN@{@AB<8UMu8UJLMN>UaTp&EW8FPLPLK RAKN5FE�;QR?C�>}\�@A>c:TSqC�5�>c�"><B�\LR?>�@TK R{EL>�>(P"@mR?5C�8(ef>'5FELM ^OMN5B<8UM-VQEL5(SqMN><PL`F>w5U6-R?C�>'RA:?\L@�R�`$:*8U]�C a � 8UGh><M ^;�R?C�>\L@A>c:=EL><><PL@qK EL6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5UEg5UE�M ^X8UJ�5F\"R}R?CL>1EQ\�G�J�>c:q5U62@AC�5U:ARAB<\"R?@5U6mR?C�>�E�>�KN`UC"J�5$:?@15U6TR?CL>�Mu8U@�R'@A>�MN>�BcR?>(Poef>�:�R?>���;lK Ek5U:?PL>c:1R?5X@�>�[M ><BcRxR?C�>nEL>��QRxef>c:AR?>���KNER?5wR?C�>n@�\�JL`U:*8U]�C a � 5(ST>�ef>c:<;�:A><`f8$:?PLKNEL`:A5FJ�\L@�R?E�>�@A@x5U6m4R*8$:=4"CL5U:AR?B�\LR � \�ER?>c:1r�8UE�Pd4QC�5U:�R?B<\"R � \LEQR?>c:ct*;K R}@�><>�GI@TRAC�8$Rq@A5FGh>�ef>c:AR?KNB�>�@x8$:?>1@A>�MN>�B�R?><PXGh5U:?>�5$60R?><EXKNER?5'R?C�>@�\�J�`$:*8U]�CL@{R?C�8UEX5$R?C�>c:?@�a

5.4 Dishonest users4Q5I698$:�;�ST>�C�8(ef>�8U@A@A\LGI><PXR?C�8$R�><8UB*Cg\�@A>c:�K @�CL5FE�>�@�R18$E�POPL5>�@EL5URdKN@A@�\�>g698UMN@A>7B<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?><@ca �x><MN8$�"KNE�`�RAC�KN@d8$@A@A\�Gh]LRAKN5FE :A>�[z\LK :?>�@xR?CL>nKNERA:?5QP"\�BcR?KN5FEd5U6-@A5FGh>1@A5U:AR=5U6m8$\LR?CL><ER?KNB<8$R?K 5FEdGI>cRA[:AKNBwKNER?5W5F\":1Gh5QPL>�M9aw�xEo8U\LR?CL>�EQR?K B(8$RAKN5FEgGI>cRA:?KNB�K @n8I6Z\LE�BcR?KN5FE� R?C�8$R=R*8UVf>�@=RiSm5W\�@�>�:?@�$78UE�P!%d8UE�Pg8IR�:?\�@�R=`U:*8U]LC � 8U@1K EL[]L\LR?@c;L8UE�Pw:?>cR?\L:?EL@T8nEQ\�Gh>�:AKNBxeF8UMN\L> � r $ % �1t2R?C�8$Rm:?>�]L:A><@A>�ER?@RAC�>18U@�@A\L:*8UELB�>�SqK R?CWSqCLKNB*C�$yB<8UEX5FJ"R*8UKNE�R?C�>=8U\LRAC�>�EQR?K B�]L\�JLMNKNBVf>c^d5U6�%W\�@AK E�`�RAC�>'KNE"6Z5U:?GI8$R?KN5FEgKNE��na'�L5U:1KNEL@�R*8UELB<>U; � B�5F\�MuP:A>�R?\":?EkR?CL>�EQ\LG�J�>�:15U6qef>�:ARA>��kPLK @Z¤�5FKNERw]�8$RAC�@160:?5FG $|R?5!%gKNE�naI��5U:n8UEk5(ef>�:?eQKN>cS§5U6{>c�"KN@�R?KNEL`y8U\"R?C�>�ER?KNB<8$R?KN5FEoGh>�RA:AKNB<@18UE�P8UEXKNE�@AK `FCR}K EQRA5�RAC�>�K :}PL>�@AKN`FEX]L:?KNELB<K ]�M ><@�;�ST>=:?>�6Z>c:qR?5X� �U¦$�9a

jTCL>qPL>c��ELK R?KN5UEw5$6�R?C�>m]�>�:A605U:?G�8$E�B�>T5U6 8=@�\�JL`U:*8U]�C�@A>�MN>�BcR?KN5FEh8UM [`F5$:?K R?CLG*��5FEh8}RA:A\�@�R-`U:*8U]�C/��� r�� � t�SqCL><Ew8U\"R?C�>�ER?KNB<8$R?KN5FEGh>cRA:?KNB � K @x\L@A><PXB(8UEWJ�>nP">���E�><PX8U@{6Z5FMNM 5(Sq@��

( �+8 ��r��1t � �,��

�7 :;8 <>=����

� r�$ % ���xr�� $ %"tAt� r�$ % ��t

153

Page 9: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

� ,:>4�8�<���<��� 78���;�5� ��&$��'��$#����*&����(���!� � 78&$�<��� �8���9��#(���5��� 78�1#��B�b��J ,/# ���1��������� ���<�+.0�6>$�<�!�F7�.

SxCL>c:?> � � . r�$ %"t)0��*1��� � r�$ % ��t���"J;?fa ( �+8 ��r��1tm:?>�]L[:?><@A>�ER?@1R?CL>w8(ef>c:*8U`F>h5U6TR?C�>�:*8$R?K 5F@n5U6TR?CL>h8U@A@A\L:?8UE�B�>I5FJ"R*8UKNEL><PSxCL>�EY5FE�M ^YK EL6Z5U:AG�8$R?K 5FE_60:?5FG R?CL>yMN5B<8UM}:?>�]�5F@�K R?5U:?K ><@�KN@�\L@A><PR?5nR?C�>}8U@A@A\":*8UELB<>}5FJLR*8$KNE�><PISqCL><EIKNE"6Z5U:?G�8(R?KN5FE�6u:?5FG RAC�>qSqC�5FM >RA:?\�@�R�`U:*8U]LCoK @1\�@�>(P�a'p�6 ( �+8 ��r��1txKN@1B�MN5F@A>�R?5�5FE�>U;�RAC�>�Eo>�@A@A>�EL[R?Ku8UMNM ^�R?CL>W@?8UGh>y8U@A@A\":*8UELB<>XB<8UE_J�>W5FJLR*8$KNE�><P�\�@�KNE�`OR?CL>WMN5B<8UM:?><]�5F@AK R?5U:?K ><@=8U@q\�@AK E�`�R?CL>�SqC�5FM >�RA:?\L@�Rq`U:*8U]�C a

� 5UR?>{R?C�8$R-R?CL>q8UJ�5$ef>qP">���E�K R?KN5FEw5U6�R?CL>q8UMN`F5U:AK R?C�G�]�>c:A6Z5U:AG�8UELB<>KN@�8X`F>�E�>c:*8UMNK v(8$RAKN5FE�5U6{5F\":']L:A><eQKN5F\L@'PL>c��E�K R?K 5FEk`UKNef><EkKNE74"\LJL[@A><BcR?KN5FE�©aN�FaXpiEg698UBcR<;2KNEgR?C�8$R'@A\�JL@A>�B�R?K 5FE�;�Sm>�KNGh]�M KNB�K R?M ^g\L@A><PR?C�>1JLKNE�8$:A^WGh>cRA:?KNB

��� r�$ % �1t+��� � K 6 $���� %J 5UR?C�>c:ASqKN@A>

8UE�P7K R�KN@'><8U@�^oR?5def>�:?K 60^kRAC�8$R ( �+8 ��r��1t�� ( �xr��1t�6Z5U:w8$EQ^��8UE�P�napiE�R?C�>T6Z\"R?\L:?>U;FST>qKNER?><E�PnR?5�\L@A>qGI5U:?>mB<5FGh]�M >��w8U\"R?C�>�ER?KNB<8$R?KN5UEGI>cRA:?KNB�@'R?C�8$RwJ�>�RARA>�:�Gh5QPL>�MmR?C�>�>���><BcRw5U6}PLKN@�C�5FEL><@�Rw\L@A>c:?@h5UER?C�>w]�\LJ�M KNBc[&Vf>c^gPLK @�RA:?KNJL\LR?K 5FEk@�^"@�R?>�GXa ª C�>cR?C�>c:1RAC�>�]L:?5U]�5F@A><P8UMN`F5U:?K R?C�Gh@-]":?5$ef>mR?5}J�>T>c�hB<K ><ER2SqK R?C�:?><@A]�><BcR2RA5=R?CL><@A>TGh>cRA:?KNB�@KN@}8hz\�>�@�R?K 5FEWR?C�8$R{ST>nKNER?>�E�PhR?5h>c�"]�M 5U:?>Fa

6. CONCLUSIONª >=C�8(ef>}@A\":?ef>�^><PhRAC�>}RACL:?><8$R?@q8UE�P�]�5F@A@�KNJ�M >1@A5FMN\"R?KN5FEL@{6Z5U:{R?C�>J�8U@AK BqGh>�B*C�8UELKN@AGh@�8UE�Pn6Z5U:�R?C�>.@A><B�\L:?K Ri^'Gh>�BcC�8UELKN@AGh@�K E�GI5FJLKNMN>8FPkCL5QBwEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�aW�x@16Z5U:nR?CL>hMN8$RAR?>c:<;�ST>IPL>�ef><M 5F]�><PgR?CL>wKuPL><85U6�87@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv�>(PH]�\LJ�M KNB�[�Vf>c^_KNE"60:*8U@�RA:?\LB�RA\L:?>Ua °}\L:W@i^L@�RA><GKN@w@AKNGhKNMu8$:�R?5��ML � KNE|R?CL>�@�><EL@A>WR?C�8$R�]�\LJ�MNK B�[�Vf>c^7B�>�:�R?K ��B<8$R?>�@8$:?>�K @A@A\�><PkJ^gR?CL>h\L@A>�:A@�a � 5(Sm><ef>c:<;-8U@'5F]L]�5F@A><PoR?5*�ML ��;lST>

P"5XEL5UR�:?>�M ^O5FEoB<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>hPLK :A><BcR?5U:?K ><@16Z5U:�R?C�>wP"KN@�RA:?K J�\"R?KN5FEo5U6B�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA><@�akp&E�@�RA>(8FP�;-KNE�5F\":�@�^"@�R?><GX;-B�>�:ARAK ��B<8$R?>�@w8$:?>W@�RA5U:?>(P8UE�PdPLK @�RA:?KNJL\LR?><PXJ^WR?CL>1\L@A>�:A@�a ª >1]L:?>�@A>�ER?>(PXR&ST5�8$MN`F5U:?K R?C�Gh@RAC�8$R�\�@A>c:?@�B(8UE�\L@A>mR?5}J�\LKNMuP1R?CL><K :-M 5QB<8UM"B<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>m:?>�]�5F@AK RA5U:?KN>�@�aª >�@�C�5(Sm>(PXR?C�8$R{R?C�>�8UMN`F5U:AK R?C�Gh@}8UB*C�KN>�ef>n8�CLKN`FCX]�>c:A6Z5U:?GI8UELB<>5FE=:?><8UM � L �XRA:?\L@�Rl`U:*8U]LC�@�;$SqCLKNB*C1Gh>(8UEL@ R?C�8$R�8$EQ^=]�8UK :l5U6L\L@A>c:?@B<8UEn��E�P1B�>�:�R?K ��B<8$R?>TB*C�8UKNEL@�R?5x><8UB*C'5UR?C�>c:�\�@AK E�`}5FE�M ^�R?C�>�K :�MN5B<8UMB�>c:AR?K ��B(8$RA>1:?><]�5F@AK R?5U:AKN><@}SqK R?CO8wC�K `FCd]L:?5FJ�8UJ�K MNK R&^aTpiEd8FPLPLK R?KN5FE ;RAC�>T@AKNv�>T5U6�R?C�>TM 5QB<8UM"B<>c:AR?K ��B<8$R?>T:?>�]�5F@AK R?5$:?KN>�@.KN@�@AGI8UMNMQB<5FGh]�8(:?>(PRA5wR?CL>=R?5$R*8UMlE"\LG�J�>�:m5U6-\L@A>c:?@xK EWR?CL>1@�^"@�R?>�Gyap�R=C�8U@xR?5�J�>1E�5UR?><PXR?C�8(R}R?CLKN@=8U]�]":?5f8UB*COKN@}E�5UR}B<5UEL��E�><PXR?5W8FPCL5B�EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�aypiE�P"><><P�;�K R�B<8UE7J�>�8U]L]�MNK >(PoKNE�8UM MmB<8U@A><@'SqCL><E@�><B�\L:?K Ri^dC�8U@=R?5�J�>'@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv<><P�a6��><>c:A[sR?5U[�]�><>c:�8U]�]LMNKNB<8$R?KN5FEL@8$:A>n8'ST5FE�P">�:�6Z\�Ml>c��8UGh]�M >}R?CL>c:?><5U6&a

jTCL>18UE�8UM ^"@AKN@qB<8$:A:?KN><PX5F\"RqKNEWR?CLKN@{]�8$]�>�:T:?8UKN@A>�@=8'Gh5U:?>}`F><EL>c:*8UM8UE�PW]LC�KNM 5F@A5F]LC�KNB<8UM�z\�>�@�R?KN5FE a.�}@{ST>=C�8(ef>=@A>�><E ;�K RxKN@{R?>�GI]"R?KNEL`RA5hR?CLKNELVW5U6.Gh5FJLKNMN>'8FPWC�5B'E�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@=8U@xJ�>�KNEL`I@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv�>(P�ajTCL>wGI5F@�R=:?>�MN><eU8UER1>c��8UGh]�M >�5U6T@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv<8$R?KN5FE7KNEoRAC�>w8$:?><85U6l@�><B�\L:?K Ri^IKN@� L �{¥LCL5(ST>�ef>�:<;1� L �|C�8U@m:?>�G�8$KNE�><PIB�5FE"��EL>(Ph@A5698(:=]":?KNGI8$:?KNM ^�R?5�R?CL>�B�5FGIG�\LE�K R&^h5U62B�5FGh]�\"R?>�:qM K R?>c:*8$R?>n\L@A>�:A@�ap&E�R?C�>q`FMN5FJ�8UM P"5FG�8$KNEw5U6�E�>cRiST5$:?V"K E�`";fR?C�>qGh5F@�RmKNGh]":?><@A@�KNef>{>��Q[8UGh]LMN>X5U6�8OSqKNPL>�@A]L:A>(8FP_@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv�>(PY@�^"@�R?>�G K @hR?CL> ª 5U:?MuPª KuP"> ª >�J�¥TKNE�P"><><P ;-SqK RAC|R?C�> ª >�J ;T8UE^k\�@A>c:wB(8$E�:?>(8UP�8UE�P]L\�JLMNKN@ACdK EL6Z5U:AG�8$R?K 5FE�;�8UE�PyB�5FERA:?KNJL\LR?>�R?5hRAC�>n>�ef5FMN\"R?KN5FEO5U62R?C�>B�5FER?>�EQR?@dK E 8�R?5UR*8UM M ^bPL>�B<>�ERA:*8UMNK v<><P S{8�^a 4QR*8UE�P�8$:*P"KNv<8$R?KN5FEJ�5"P"KN>�@TPL5n8UB<B�5FGh]�MNK @ACI8UE�KNGh]�5U:�R*8UEQR2ST5U:?Vw5U6 :?>c��E�Gh><ER.5U6�R?C�>JL\�K MuPLK E�`gJ�M 5QB*VQ@Xrs@A\LBcC�8U@�R?C�>I6Z5U:?G�8(RI5U6 � ��.�@�; � jq��. 8UE�P� j{j�mt*;�J�\"RxE�5h5U:?`f8UELKNv<8$R?KN5FE �� ¡��1R?C�> ª >�J�¥�R?C�>�\�E�PL>c:?M ^"KNEL`p �7EL>�R&ST5U:?V�KN@m5F]�>�:*8(R?>(P�;"J�\"R.R?CL> ª >�J�8$@T@A\�B*ChKN@mEL5UR<a.�T8UEW@�>�[B�\L:AK Ri^WJ�>nJL:A5F\�`FCRqR?5h@A><M 60[&5U:A`f8UE�K v<><POGI5FJLKNMN>'8UPXC�5BnEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@K E78U@nPL>�B<>�ERA:*8UMNK v<><P78IS{8<^o8U@1R?CL>wCQ^"]�>c:AR?>c�"R=S{8U@nJ":?5F\�`UCQR=R?5

154

Page 10: [ACM Press the 2nd ACM international symposium - Long Beach, CA, USA (2001.10.04-2001.10.05)] Proceedings of the 2nd ACM international symposium on Mobile ad hoc networking & computing

R?C�>=piER?>�:AE�>cR��Wp&6l^>�@�;L@A\LBcCX8']�5(ST>c:A6Z\LM�]L:?5F]�>c:AR&^�B�5F\�MNPy8UMN@A5wJ�>GIKN@�\�@A><P ¥ SqC�8$R�8$:?>'R?CL><EdR?CL>'GI>�B*C�8UELKN@AGh@qR?5�J�>']L\LR=KNEO]�MN8UB�>R?5h]":?>�ef><ERTR?CLKN@{R?5wC�8U]L]�>�E � Hm5UR?CyzQ\L><@�RAKN5FE�@x8$:A>1B<\":A:?>�EQRAM ^W5UE5F\L:q:?>�@A>(8(:?B*Cd8U`F>�E�P�8a

7. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSª >h>��"]":?><@�@n5F\L:'`U:?8$R?K R?\�PL>wR?5XR?CL>h@iR?\�P"><ER?@'�mCLKNELGI5<^�4=\LRAR?8Q;�=8$R?\LM�L=\�C�8Q;5L}KN\�@�><]L]�>x4"B*CLKu8(ef>�MNMN5�8UE�P��x>�E�8$R?5��=K Mu8UE'6Z5U:.R?CL>�K :B<5FERA:?K J�\"R?KN5FE'R?5qR?C�>m8UE�8UM ^L@AK @-5U6LR?C�> �ML �dRA:?\L@�R2`U:?8U]�CL@-8UE�P1R?C�>@�R?\�PQ^75U6qR?CL>W8UM `F5U:?K RAC�Gh@'R?5OJ�\�K MuPkRAC�>I@A\�JL`U:*8U]�CL@�aojTCL>��L:?@�R8U\LR?CL5U:lST5F\�MNP1MNKNVf>2R?5TR?C�8$E�V��f><8UE"[��=ef><@<.�>MHm5F\�P"><B26Z5U:2eU8UMN\�8UJ�MN>PLKN@AB�\L@A@AKN5FEL@}5FEWR?C�>=@A5B<K >�R*8UMlKNGh]LMNKNB<8$R?KN5FEL@q5U6-@�><M 60[�5U:?`f8$E�KNv<8$R?K 5FE�a

8. REFERENCES� ���njTCL>njl>�:?GhKNEL5QPL>�@ �2:?5(¤�><BcR<a�S{S{S�a R?>c:?GIK E�5QP"><@�a 5U:?`"a� �(���1a��xE�PL>c:?@A5FEX8UE�PX�oa���\�CLE�a�j�8UGh]�>�:{:A><@AK @�R*8UE�B�>1[.8

B<8U\"R?KN5FE�8$:A^XEL5UR?>Ua�p&E � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �w� �=�/��� 9 ��� �$¡ ¯���� � ¡ � 6� � � �(� � �*�|�$¡�� �u���c�9� �$¡ ���� � ®�®��?� �*� ;��-8!8F«Qa

� ¦$� � a��}@�5FVF8UEy8UE�P ��a4L=K E�v�J�55U:?`"a$�1>c^X8U`$:?><>�Gh><ERxKNEy8FPCL5B1E�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@�a � � ® � Q�i�*�� � ®�® ¡ ��� � �9� �$¡��?;�U¦�N�(«f�������<«F¦��;2�AJ�J�Ja

� ¨U� K a��x^Q8UEL5F`FMN\y>cRx8UM9a�4�K ef>�:A@AK Ri^�B<5QP"KNEL`w6Z5U:xRA:*8$E�@A]�8$:?><ER@A>�M 60[�CL>(8UM KNE�`�8UE�PI698U\�M RA[�RA5FMN>c:*8UER}B�5FGhG�\�E�K B(8(R?KN5FEEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�a ; ������­ � �$¡���� �*�s� �$¡L�w�$¡ � � ®�®6 ¡ ��� � �s� �$¡L�?;¨"�Fr��F�$t*;l� 8!8F¦Qa

� ©(��.2a$HmMu8��v<>�eQK��BF;�.2a$Hm\"RARi^��8UE ;�4�a ��T8U]LV"\LE�;�4�a$L=KN5$:*P�8UEL5";��"a [ ��a� \�J�8U\L��;�8UE�P��"a [s��a�.�> Hm5F\�P"><BUa�4">�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv<8$R?KN5FEOK EGh5FJLKNMN>n8UPWC�5B1EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@��mjTC�>�8U]�]":?5f8UB*Cy5U6-j�>c:?GhKNEL5"P">�@�a; ����� � � ®�® ¡ ��� � �s� �$¡L� � �   � ¢ � ¡ � ;��f\LE�>n�AJ�JQ�Fa

� «$�'�xa4Hm5<^�PX8$E�PX�1a��y8$R?CQ\L:?KN8Qa��1>c^W>�@�R*8UJLMNKN@ACLGI>�ER]":?5UR?5B�5FMN@q6Z5U:}@A><B�\L:A>1GI5UJ�KNM >�B�5FGIG�\LE�KNB<8$R?K 5FE�@��.8�Bc:?K R?K B(8UM@A\":?ef>c^a � � ® � Q�i�*�� � ®�® ¡ ��� � �9� �$¡��?; �U¦Q� ©��F©��"©AC��;��AJ�J�JQa

� �(��.2a$Hm\"RARi^��8UEy8UE�P��"a [ ��a � \�J�8$\L��a K E"6Z5U:?B�KNE�`h@A>c:?eQKNB<>8<eF8UKNMN8UJ�K MNK R&^yKNEXGh5FJLKNMN>n8FP�C�5B1EL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�a�piE � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �� � � � � � ����� ;��AJ�JAJQa

� C$��.2a$Hm\"RARi^��8UEy8UE�P��"a [ ��a � \�J�8$\L��a � \L`FMN>cR?@��m8�e"K :AR?\�8$MB�\L:�:?><ELB�^IR?5w@�R?KNG�\LMu8$R?>=B<55F]�>c:*8$R?K 5FEOKNEX@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8$E�KNv�><Pg8FPCL5B1E�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@�a�j�>�B*C�ELKNB<8UM �}>�]�5U:AR�414��NF�AJ�J�<NAJ�JQ�F;l4QSqKN@A@�L>(P">�:?8UM�piE�@iR?K R?\"R?>�5U6-jl><B*CLE�5FMN5F`$^��#.l8U\�@?8UELE�>U;��AJ�JQ�Fa

� 8$� ª a�4=K �h>n8UE�PX�ga � >�MNMNGI8UE a � >cSbP"K :?>�B�RAKN5FE�@qKNEBc:A^"]LR?5U`U:*8U]�C^fa; ������­ � �$¡L��� �c�9� �$¡����$¡�;?¡ � � �*® � �9� �$¡­ ��� � ��� ;�]�8U`F><@}«U¨F¨��«f©$¨";2�-8��U«Qa

� ��J$� ª a�4=K �h>F;$��a�eF8$Ed°=5U:?@AB*CL5UR<;�8UE�Py�ga ª K ><EL>�:�a�x\LR?CL>�EQR?K B(8$RAKN5FEy8UE�Py8U\"R?C�>�EQRAKNB<8$R?>(P�Vf>�^I>��"B*C�8UE�`F>�@�a� � � �u  ¡���� � �<¯ � �n�$¡ ¯ ���O� � � �  U� �*� � � ; ]�8U`F>�@1��J������$�F©;� 8�8f�a

� �F���'�1a K ]LCL:?>�GIKNPL>�@�;��"a ª KN>�@A>�M R?C�K >�:<;�8UE�P 4�a�Hm8UVf>�:<a��P"><@�KN`FEyB�5FE�B�>�]LRq6Z5U:q:?><M Ku8UJLMN>nGh5FJ�K MN>�:*8FP"KN5wE�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@qSqK R?C60:A>(z\�>�E�Bc^�C�5F]L]�KNEL`�@AKN`FE�8UMNKNEL`"a � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �w� ���/��� ; �����T;� 8AC��a

� �$�(�$.2a��ga���>�>�E�>c^;�Hxa��xC�MN`$:?><E ;�8UE�PX�na ª ><@iR?>�:?M \�E�P a4Q]�5FER*8UEL><5F\L@qE�>cRiST5U:?VQKNEL`"�.8UEd8U]L]�M KNB(8(R?KN5FE"[&5U:?K ><ER?><P8U]L]L:A5f8UB*CXR?5h8FPWC�5B�E�>cRiST5U:?VQK E�`"a ; ������ � ®�® ¡ ��� � �9� �$¡�� � �   � ¢ � ¡ � ;��F\�EL>n�AJ�J�Fa

� �(¦$���ga4L=K :*8U\�M R<a�4">�M 60[�B<>c:AR?K ��><PW]�\LJ�M KNB�Vf>c^"@�aLpiE � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   ��� �� Q� � �*�O� � � P "!(;�� 8!8Q�Fa

� �<¨U�#�"a [ ��a � \�J�8U\L��;�j}a4L}:?5F@A@c;$�"a [��'a�.�>DHm5F\�PL>�BF;�8UE�P�ga��.>cRAR?>c:?MNKZa�j�5<S{8$:*PX@A>�M 60[�5U:?`f8UELKNv�>(PdGh5FJ�K MN>n8FP�C�5BEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@��mjTC�>1jl>c:?GhKNE�5QP"><@ �2:A5$¤�>�B�R�a<; ������ � ®�® ¡ ��� � �9� �$¡�� � �   � ¢ � ¡ � ;��f8UEQ\�8$:A^X�AJ�JQ�Fa

� �$©(���ga��f8UB�5FJ�@�@A5FEg8UE�Py4�a ª >�R?v�>�M9a 4">�B<\":?K R&^ISm>(8UVQE�>�@A@A>�@xKNEHmMN\L>cR?55UR?C�a�jl><B*CLE�K B(8UM :?>�]�5U:AR�;$Hm><MNM .l8UJL@�;��f8UEQ\�8$:A^y�AJ�JQ�Fa

� �(«$��4�a��FKu8UE�`Q; � a%�m8UKNP"^Q8Q;�8UE�P ª a�&�C�8U5"a �x5F\"R?KNE�`�K Ey]�8UB*Vf>cR:*8FP"KN5wE�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@qR?5w]":?><ef>�ERTRA:*8$�hBn8UE�8UM ^"@AKN@ca p&E� � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �w� �=�/��� ;'����� ;?¡ � � �c® � �9� �$¡)(=�?� Q� �$¡ �*� �$¡ ¯9 ���OQ�*�Z� � � � � �$� � �*��; ª ><@�R ��5FKNER<; � ��;��F\LM ^d�AJAJ�JQa

� ���(�#�"a�.�KNELE�a$�2:AKNeF8UBc^W>�E�C�8UE�B�>�GI>�ERT6Z5U:=p&ER?>�:AE�>cRq><MN>�BcRA:?5FELKNBGI8UKNM9�M��8$:ARxp*�fp'�'a�p&ER?>�:?EL>�R �=�����<¨��+���<¨�$¨Q;2� 8!8F¦a

� ��C$��4�a��y8$:AR?K9;�j}a(L=K \�MNKZ;4��a�.l8UK9;�8UE�PX�ga(HT8$Vf>�:<a��XK R?KN`f8$R?K E�`:?5F\"R?KNEL`wGIKN@�J�><C�8(eQKN5U:qK EyGI5FJLKNM >18FPXCL5QB�E�>cRiST5U:AV"@�a�p&E� � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �w� � �,�.- ; �/�� ;��AJ�J�Ja

� � 8$�'j}a��y8$R?@A\LGI5$R?5";L��a�j�8UVF8U@�C�KNGI8Q;�8UE�P � a�p&G�8UKZa�°=E@A>�>�V"K E�`w@AGI8$:ARq]�\LJ�MNK B�[�Vf>c^WP"KN@�RA:?K J�\"R?KN5FEL@x@i^L@�RA><Gh@�a­ � �$¡L��� �c�9� �$¡��w� �=�/��� ; � � �10*2"�*�L�$¡"3<;�]�8U`F><@���J��4���$�F©;� 8�CF«a

� �AJ$�'�1a��X><EL><v�>�@�;4��a�eF8UEd°}5U:?@AB*C�5UR�;�8$E�Pd4�a%�m8UEL@�R?5FE�>Ua� �$¡ ¯ �?�<���X� � (m�f� � �&� ¯ ����� � � �  U� �*� � � a�� �x� �2:?>�@A@�;l� 8!8��a

� ����'�1a���>c:A:?K `"; �1a�4Qv<>cSTB�v�^"V�;%�'a ª ><E ;�4�a��m\LMNMu8$:�; 8UE�P��"a�4�aj-^"`f8$:<a 41�-p � 4��L4">�B<\":?K R&^W]":?5UR?5B<5UMN@x605U:=@A>�EL@A5U:xE�>cRiST5U:?VQ@�ap&E � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �w� � ���.- ; �/� � ;��AJ�JQ�Fa

� �F�(�'�1a��2�LR?v<GI8UELE�;�Hxa$�2�LR?v�G�8UELE�;�8UE�Py�ga ª 8UKuPLEL>c:<aj�:?\�@iR?KNE�`wGh5FJ�K MN>�\L@A>c:=P">�e"K B<>�@x8UE�PW@�><B�\L:?K Ri^XGh5QPL\LMN>�@�a; ����� � � ® � "�i�*� ;��L><J":?\�8$:A^d� 8!8��a

� �U¦$���ga �x><K R?>�:}8UE�Py4�a 4R?\LJ�J�M ><JLKNEL>Fa��x\LR?CL>�EQR?K B(8$RAKN5FEXGh>�R�:?KNB8UE�8UM ^"@AKN@}8UE�PXPL>�@AKN`FE a5( � � ­ � �$¡L��� �c�9� �$¡��'�$¡;?¡ � � �*® � �9� �$¡o�$¡ ¯ 9 � � ���?® 9 ����Q�*�9��� ;l�Qr&�Ut*�N�(¦�C6���(©ACQ;2� 8�8!8Qa

� �$¨U�'�1a�4"C�8UGIK :<aLp�P"><ER?K Ri^Q[&J�8U@A><P�Bc:A^"]LR?5F@�^"@�R?>�Gh@q8UE�P@AK `FE�8$R?\":?>1@AB*CL><Gh>�@�a�piE � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   ��� �7� �98 �1­ � P :6;";� 8�CU¨Qa

� �F©(�'�.a�4QR*8<¤A8UE�5I8UE�P �1a��}E�PL>c:?@A5FE a�j{CL>�:?>�@A\":A:?><BcR?K E�`P"\�B*VQMNKNEL`"�m4">�B<\":?K R&^WK @A@A\�>�@{6Z5U:=8FP"[�C�5B�SqK :?><M ><@A@xEL>�R&ST5U:?VQ@�ap&E � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �w� ���/���=<<�/� ;?¡ ���?� ¡ � �9� �$¡ � � � � � �(� � �*�|�$¡9 ���OQ�*�Z� � � � � � � � � � �?;�� 8!8!8Qa

� �U«$��4'a ª 8$RAR?@ca 9 ® � �Z� � � �c� ¯$�?a$��:?KNE�B�>cR?5FE � E�KNef>c:?@AK R&^ ��:?><@�@�;� 8!8!8a

� ���(�1�'a�&�C�8UEL`h8UE�P ª a�.�>�>Fa�p&EQRA:A\�@AKN5UEdPL>cR?><BcR?K 5FEXKNEXSqK :?><M ><@A@8FPQ[&CL5B1E�>cRiSm5U:?VQ@�a�piE � � � �*�?� ¯ � ¡   �'� � �,�.- ; �/� � ;��AJAJ�JQa

� �AC$�$.2a�&�C�5F\X8UE�P�&�a � 8F8U@�a�4Q><B�\L:AKNE�`h8FPWCL5B1E�>cR&ST5U:?VQ@�a ; �����> �*� �m� � �(;l�(¦"r�«ft*� �$¨��Q¦�JQ; � 5$ef>�G�J�>c:ON 4�>�B�><G�J�>c:}� 8!8�8Qa

� ��8$� ��a�&�K GIGh>c:?G�8UELE�a�­ ���=�$? �*� � � ��@��A��� �?� P ��@ Q� ¯ � a��Xp�j�2:A><@A@�;l� 8�8f©a

155