accommodations for statewide assessments: oral administration, transcribing, and supplemental aids...
TRANSCRIPT
ACCOMMODATIONS FOR STATEWIDE
ASSESSMENTS:
ORAL ADMINISTRATION,
TRANSCRIBING, AND
SUPPLEMENTAL AIDS2012 Texas Assessment Conference
Kim Brannan, Charity Riley-Rose, Lynn Franzen
TEA November 2012
2
Agenda
General Information about Accommodations
Oral Administration
Transcribing
Supplemental Aids
Questions?
3General Information about Accommodations
TEA November 2012
4
Accommodations…
Are changes to instructional materials, procedures, or techniques that allow a student with a disability to participate meaningfully in grade-level or course instruction Are not changes to the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills
(TEKS)
Should be effective in allowing a student access to the TEKS Should not be provided to a student without evidence of
effectiveness, because student need is likely to change from year to year
Must be individualized for each student Should not be provided to an entire group of students (e.g.,
all students in a classroom, all students within the same disability category)
5 TEA November 2012
Any accommodation may be appropriate for classroom use.
BUT some accommodations may not be appropriate or allowed for use on a statewide assessment.
TEA November 2012
6
Students needing accommodations due to a disability include… A student with an identified disability who receives
special education services and meets established eligibility criteria for certain accommodations
A student with an identified disability who receives Section 504 services and meets established eligibility criteria for certain accommodations
A student with a disabling condition who does not receive special education or Section 504 services but meets established eligibility criteria for certain accommodations (i.e., general education)
TEA November 2012
7
Accommodations Triangle
TEA November 2012
8
Type 1 Accommodations
Available for students who have a specific need and who routinely, independently, and effectively use the accommodation during classroom instruction and testing.
Local decision (e.g., ARD committee, Section 504 committee, RTI committee) based on specific eligibility criteria Do NOT submit an Accommodation Request Form
Specific need
Routinely, independently, effectively
9
Type 2 Accommodations
Includes the requirements of Type 1, along with additional specific eligibility criteria.
Local decision (e.g., ARD committee, Section 504 committee, RTI committee) based on specific eligibility criteria Do NOT submit an
Accommodation Request Form
Routinely, independently, effectively
Specific need
Specific eligibility criteria
TEA November 2012
10
Type 3 Accommodations
If it is locally determined that the student meets all of the specific eligibility criteria, an Accommodation Request Form must be submitted. Request must be approved by
TEA before student can use accommodation on a statewide assessment
Should be documented in student’s paperwork as “pending TEA approval” In the event that a request is
denied, the campus should be prepared to meet the student’s needs with allowable accommodations.
Specific need
IF the student meets these specific eligibility criteria, THEN submit an Accommodation Request Form
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
11
Type 3 Accommodations: Evidence of Need
Describe the disability that prevents the student from completing the test within four hours. Be specific about the characteristics of the condition, symptoms, and level of severity the student experiences. Phrases like “severe fatigue” and “shuts down” are not sufficient. The description should be specific and individualized.
Explain how the provision of an Extra Day accommodation has proven effective.
Does the student require frequent breaks? How long are the student’s breaks? How often are the student’s breaks? How much work does the student accomplish during periods of productivity?
Does the student have an alternate school schedule or location (e.g., attends school only two hours a day, is hospitalized, is homebound, has academic work in the A.M. and social skills in the P.M.)?
What Type 1 or Type 2 accommodations have been tried and what is the student’s level of success with these? Why are they not effective?
What Optional Test Administration Procedures and Materials have been tried and what is the student’s level of success with these? Why are they not effective?
Specific questions are now included on the online system to help districts complete the rationale section for Type 3 Accommodations. This information must be provided in the rationale section of the online Accommodation Request Form.
12
Accommodations in Unexpected or Emergency Situations
Unexpected or emergency situations may occur just prior to or on the day of the statewide assessment, and necessitate the use of a testing accommodation.
Procedures for testing coordinators to follow in these cases First review Optional Test Administration Procedures and
Materials to see if anything can meet student’s needs if so, use it… no need to contact TEA
Then review Accommodation Triangle to see if a Type 1 or 2 accommodation can meet student’s needs if so, use it… no need to contact TEA
Finally, review Type 3 accommodations if one of these will be effective, immediately contact TEA’s Accommodations Task Force for permission and additional instructions
TEA November 2012
13
Accommodations in Unexpected or Emergency Situations
Example Scenarios Student arrives at school without prescribed
eyeglasses try a Projection Device or Large Print before an Oral Administration
Student arrives at school with dominant arm broken see if student can write math computations on a white board with non-dominant hand (“scratch paper or another workspace” in Optional document) and dictate responses for the test administrator to transcribe (Basic Transcribing) before requesting Type 3 accommodation-Mathematics Scribe
Encouraging student
independence should
be a priority
TEA November 2012
14
Recording Accommodation Use on the Answer Document
After statewide testing, the accommodation type must be recorded in the ACCOMMODATIONS field on the student’s answer document or in the Assessment Management System for online administrations, if applicable. The accommodation type is indicated in the triangle at the top of each accommodation policy document.
Mark the accommodation type for each accommodation that is documented and made available to a student, even if the student did not use the accommodation during testing.
15 Oral Administration
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
16
Oral Administration: Eligibility
Student meets this criteria AND
ONE of these
TEA November 2012
17
Oral Administration: Eligibility
What does “evidence of reading difficulties” mean?
TEA November 2012
18
Oral Administration: Eligibility
Evidence of reading difficulty = a problem with reading The problem could be caused by a learning
disability in reading The problem could be caused by other conditions,
for example ADHD Emotional or behavioral disability Processing or memory issue
The ARD or Section 504 committee decides if the student exhibits evidence of a reading difficulty.
TEA November 2012
19
Oral Administration: Levels of Support
Two levels of reading support are availableRead questions and answer choices at
student requestRead all questions and answer choices
Remember to document the level of reading support.
TEA November 2012
20
Oral Administration: Grouping Students
Consider Level of reading support Pace at which students work Number of students one test administrator can
handle
Plan for mixtures of support level and pace Know what level of support each student
receives Remember the four-hour time limit Move around room and read aloud to students
individually or to small groups of students working at a similar pace
What may be read aloud during an Oral Administration?
Yes NoMath, Science, Social Studies
Test questions and answer choices (i.e., everything in the test booklet Required reference materials (as applicable) Allowable Supplemental Aids
Reading
Test questions and answer choices Required reference materials (as applicable) Allowable Supplemental Aids
Reading selections
Writing
Required reference materials (as applicable) Allowable Supplemental Aids
Revising and editing passages Revising and editing test questions and answer choices
21
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
22
How are test questions read aloud?
23
Items Containing Boxed Information (Mathematics, Science, Social Studies)
All parts of the question and answer choice may be read aloud.TEA November
2012
24
Items Containing Passage Excerpts (Reading)
All parts of the question and answer choice may be read aloud.
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
25
Items Containing Graphics
Read aloud the text. Do not interpret the graphics.
26
Items Containing Content-specific Terms and Symbols
Read aloud the terms and symbols the way the students hear them in class.
TEA November 2012
27
Required Reference Materials
Test administrators may read, but not interpret or help apply, the reference material.
Reference Material Example: Dictionary The student must independently locate the dictionary entry.
The test administrator may then read aloud the entry the student indicates.
The test administrator may not help the student find a word in the dictionary.
TEA November 2012
28
Allowable Supplemental Aids
Test administrators may read, but not interpret or help apply, the supplemental aid.
Supplemental Aid Example: List of grammar rules or Math Chart The student must point to the information (i.e., rule or
formula) and request that it be read aloud. The test administrator may then read aloud the
information the student indicates. The test administrator may not tell students which
rule/formula is needed to answer the question.
TEA November 2012
29
Basic Transcribing: Local Decision Complex Transcribing: Accommodation Request Form
Transcribing
TEA November 2012
Multiple-choice
Griddable
Short-answer
Writing prompt
Student Writes
Student Circles
Student Points
Student Dictates/ signs
Student Types
Student Uses Speech-to-text
Basic Transcribing: Examples/Types
30
TEA November 2012
31
Basic Transcribing: Eligibility
Student meets this criteria AND
ONE of these
32
Basic Transcribing: Eligibility
What are some examples of students who MAY or MAY NOT meet this criterion?
TEA November 2012
Student is not receiving Section 504 or special education services, but loses his place easily when reading or writing in small spaces
Student records his own answers, but uses a place marker to ensure accuracy
Teacher wants the student to mark his answers in the test booklet for her to record on the answer document to ensure accuracy.
“The student has a disabling condition…
that prevents him or her from independently and effectively recording responses on the lined pages of the answer document…
despite multiple unsuccessful attempts to indicate responses on a format similar to an answer document.”
Basic Transcribing Student Eligibility Criteria
Student Scenario #1
33
TEA November 2012
NO
Student is identified with an emotional disturbance
Student can physically write for short assignments, but types on a computer for longer writing assignments. Observational data shows that when given a long writing assignment to handwrite, student becomes loud and agitated, crumbles paper, and refuses to write.
“The student has a disabling condition…
that prevents him or her from… effectively recording responses… on the lined pages of the answer document despite multiple unsuccessful attempts to indicate responses on a format similar to an answer document.”
Basic Transcribing Student Eligibility Criteria
Student Scenario #2
34
TEA November 2012
YES
TEA November 2012
35
Complex Transcribing
This accommodation applies ONLY to the test administrator scribing an eligible student’s dictated or signed response to the writing prompts (including any prewriting or drafts). Grade 4 and 7 writing tests – written
composition English I, II, and III writing tests – written
composition
TEA November 2012
36
Complex Transcribing: Eligibility
Student meets this criteria AND
ONE of these
this criteria AND
Remember… IF the local decision is that the student meets all of the Student Eligibility Criteria for Complex Transcribing, THEN an Accommodation Request Form must be submitted to TEA for a determination.
37 TEA November 2012
38
Complex Transcribing: Denial Example #1
Rationale: A doctor has diagnosed this student with a developmental coordination and anxiety disorder. The developmental coordination disorder affects handwriting. The student has trouble properly forming letters and is slower at writing. The student uses a laptop daily in the classroom to produce written work. The student has high levels of anxiety when rushed with handwriting. Handwriting is very difficult to read. When asked to handwrite assignments, the student gets frustrated and slows down. The student reports hand hurting and/or getting tired if writing for extended amounts of time.
39
Complex Transcribing: Denial Example #1
Denied because every word in the student’s response can be identified. In addition, the student uses a laptop (Basic Transcribing) routinely, so the school should review the eligibility criteria for Basic Transcribing.
40
Complex Transcribing: Denial Example #2
Rationale: The student was recently evaluated by an occupational therapist and was found to have major deficits in fine motor skills and visual perceptual skills that severely impact the student's writing abilities. According to the -- Test of Motor Proficiency, this student has a 2 year 4 month delay in fine motor skills. On the -- Visual Perception Test, this student has a delay of 4 years 9 months. This affects letter/word formation, spacing, and writing in confined spaces. Basic Transcribing was used several times throughout the year, but with no success.
41
Complex Transcribing: Denial Example #2
Denied because individual letters are recognizable for the most part. Although the student produces strings of letters, the student can physically write. Complex Transcribing is not intended to address spelling deficits. Deficits in “spacing and writing in confined spaces” can be addressed by using the Optional Test Administration Material-scratch paper (i.e., large-lined paper) .
42
Complex Transcribing: Denial Example #3
Rationale: This student has significant developmental delays in gross motor, fine motor, and visual motor skills, and sensory processing. The student has been diagnosed with dysgraphia, autism, and speech impairment. The student has low tone overall with diminished hand strength bilaterally. Pencil grasp is weak and student tends to fatigue easily. The student demonstrates poor eye tracking skills and can localize on a target for approximately three seconds. Loss of target, blinking, and eye rubbing was present and remains present when attempting to write. Ability to type with text-to-speech and word prediction has helped somewhat. This student has significant difficulty with attention span and attention to detail. The student becomes easily frustrated and will avoid both typing and writing. However, when asked to give verbal responses, the student is much more productive and accurate.
TEA November 2012
43
Complex Transcribing: Denial Example #3
Denied because every letter/word in the student’s response can be identified. In addition, the rationale shows that Basic Transcribing (typing) is successful. If the student works slower when typing because of fatigue due to a physical disability, then the school should review eligibility criteria for Extra Time.
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
44
Complex Transcribing: Approval Example #1
This student has Muscular Dystrophy which severely limits his fine motor ability. The student has lost the use of all major muscle groups. His arms rest on his motorized wheelchair and he is only slightly able to move his fingers to manipulate the joy stick. This student is not able to hold a pencil or type and must dictate his responses to an adult on a daily basis. Without this accommodation this student is unable to complete any type of written assignment. The district has not tried any type of Basic Transcribing, since it is inappropriate.
TEA November 2012
45
Complex Transcribing: Approval Example #2
Student has a degenerative arthritic condition in bones and joints that is escalating. Doctor’s report indicates the student must “avoid repetitive and prolonged activities that involve use of her hands, wrists, fingers, elbows, and knees,” as bone deterioration has been detected and the arthritis is already spreading. Keyboarding is just as stressful to hands, etc. as handwriting. The student has not had sufficient practice in expressing her thoughts orally into any technical device (e.g., speech-to-text). Handwriting is limited to a few minutes at a time, during which the student must have breaks and may have to stop. The school’s attempts at using Optionals, Type I, and Type 2 accommodations have been unsuccessful due to the student’s degenerative condition.
TEA November 2012
46
Complex Transcribing: “Emergency” Approval Example #3
This 4th grade student has broken right arm and is unable to grasp pencil. The student is not proficient at typing yet and writing with the non-dominant hand was found ineffective. The student attempted to write with the left hand on large butcher paper and then a large white board, but the student’s left arm tired from raising it for the length of time it took to complete responses to the writing prompts. The student also tried to write on smaller surfaces, but this became too unwieldy due to the length of the required responses (up to 26 lines for each).
TEA November 2012
47
Special Instructions/Considerations for Transcribing Special features that should be disabled when transcribing for a
student using technology-based methods (e.g., word processor, software) Disable internet access
For example, an eligible student may use a tablet (i.e., iPad) to type responses, but the Wi-Fi/3G/4G internet access must be disabled and the student must be closely monitored to ensure that the internet cannot be accessed or the camera feature is not used. The student may need to complete the test in a separate setting to ensure the confidentiality of the test.
Disable spell check, word predictor, and all other special features (unless the student also meets the eligibility criteria for Spelling Assistance)
When transcribing a student’s responses to griddable questions, don’t forget that the test administrator MUST use the “Transcribing Griddable Questions” document so that the student is aware of the maximum number of boxes available for each answer.
48
Special Instructions/Considerations for Transcribing When transcribing a student’s responses to the writing
prompts and/or the short-answer reading questions, the test administrator must indicate to the student the space allowed. 26 lines for each written composition 10 lines for each short-answer reading question
What are some ways the test administrator can indicate to the student the space allowed? The test administrator or student can use a piece of scratch
paper with the correct number of lines or a sample lined page from the answer document (on TEA website) prior to having the response copied to the answer document.
Twenty-six lines of handwritten text is approximately 1,725 typed characters. Ten lines of handwritten text is approximately 675 typed characters. These numbers are based on average-sized handwriting.
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
49
Special Instructions/Considerations for Transcribing The student must be given the full time allotted to
complete the test. All of the student’s responses must be initially recorded (e.g., onto scratch paper, the student’s test booklet, typed) by the end of the 4-hour time limit.
If necessary, the test administrator may transfer the student’s final responses onto the answer document after the testing period has ended.
It is recommended that the test administrator ensure that the student is recording the responses clearly and completely. This must be done before the student leaves the testing room. Any interaction with the student regarding the intended responses is prohibited after the testing period has ended.
50 Supplemental Aids
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
51
Supplemental Aids: Eligibility
Student meets ALL of these criterion
TEA November 2012
52
Supplemental Aids: Eligibility
What types of disabilities could
meet this criterion?
TEA November 2012
53
Supplemental Aids: Eligibility Many disabilities can affect memory
retrieval, focus, or organization, for example ADHD Traumatic brain injury Other Health Impaired Learning disability
It is the ARD committee’s responsibility to document in the IEP how the student’s disability affects memory retrieval, focus, or organization and what is being done to address the student’s need.
54
Mnemonics
TEA November 2012
55
Clarification of Mnemonics Mnemonics can be an acronym or a
saying.
Mnemonics can be written in any direction (e.g., across, diagonal, upside-down, backwards).
Subject-specific words or symbols are NEVER allowed.
TEA November 2012
56
Allowable Mnemonics
Cats have paws.
HOFBrINCl or Help Our Needy Class Find Brains Immediately
FCV
Ray Michaels Irritated R o y G. B i v Using e-xtreme Games
57
Cations are pawsitive
Free Citizens Vote
ROYGBIV
Mnemonics that are NOT Allowed
This is not allowed because it uses the actual colors of the visible spectrum, which is subject specific, as the mnemonic.
This mnemonic is not allowed because it uses “cations,” which is subject specific, as part of the mnemonic.
TEA November 2012
Clarification of Graphics
Subject-specific words are NEVER allowed.
Symbols are Never allowed. Titles are NEVER allowed. Colors CAN be used to improve
tracking/contrast on a graphic, but CAN NOT be used if they represent a content-specific word or topic.
58
TEA November 2012
59
Blank Graphic Organizers
TEA November 2012
60
Allowable Blank Graphic Organizers
TEA November 2012
61
Blank Graphic Organizers that are NOT Allowed
This graphic is not allowed because the KWL columns are labeled.
This graphic is not allowed because it contains pictures.
TEA November 2012
62
Mathematics Graphics
63
Allowable Mathematics Graphics
A pictorial model of a geometric figure may be provided in either three-dimensional form or two-dimensional form (net), but NOT in both forms.
OR
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
64
Mathematics Graphics that are NOT Allowed
These graphics are not allowed because they contain symbols. These graphics are
not allowed because they use color to label the base of the 2 dimensional figures.
TEA November 2012
65
Science Graphics
66
Allowable Science Graphics
Colors are allowed in these graphics because they are used to improve tracking and not used as a label. If students were using the colors for specific parts (e.g., mitochondria, primary consumers, atomic radii) then they would not be allowed.TEA November
2012
67
Science Graphics that are NOT Allowed
This graphic is not allowed because it uses colors as a label for the families of elements.
These graphics are not allowed because they contain labels.
TEA November 2012
68
Social Studies Graphics
TEA November 2012
TEA November 2012
69
Allowable Social Studies Graphics
The lines that show rivers are allowed as long as they are not labeled.
This graphic is allowed because it uses color to improve the contrast between the water and land.
70
Social Studies Graphics that are
NOT allowed
This map is not allowed because it uses color to identify states allied together during the Civil War.
Labeling the events connected with dates in any way on a timeline is never allowed.
TEA November 2012
71
Special Instructions/Considerations for Supplemental Aids Supplemental aids, like all accommodations,
should be individualized for each student. Students have different strengths and needs, so it is not appropriate to provide all students the exact same set of supplemental aids.
The supplemental aid must be concise and well organized so that a student can easily access the information. The supplemental aid must not contain numerous pages, as this may be more cumbersome than helpful when used during the statewide assessment.
72
Schools must use the guidance about supplemental aids to determine if they are allowable or not.
DO NOT send supplemental aids to TEA for a determination. TEA November 2012