accelerated bridge construction - · pdf fileaccelerated bridge construction research, design...

56
Accelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f B ff l University of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Presented by: Carmen Swanwick, SE UDOT Chief Structural Engineer

Upload: phungthuan

Post on 29-Mar-2018

227 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Accelerated Bridge ConstructiongResearch, Design and Practice

U i it f B ff lUniversity of BuffaloApril 2011

Presented by:Presented by:Carmen Swanwick, SE

UDOT Chief Structural Engineer

Page 2: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Presentation OutlinePresentation Outline

ResearchAccelerated Bridge Construction (ABC) initial efforts– Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC) initial efforts

Design– Program implementation

Practice– Projects

Page 3: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchOutline

Perform scanning toursC d t il t j tConduct pilot project Identify a program of projectsy p g p jGet involved nationally

Page 4: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchScanning Tours

Market internally and externallyConduct workshopsConduct workshopsEngage industry

Page 5: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchPilot Project

Obtain senior leadership involvementP t k ti d di lPromote marketing and media planDevelop messagingp g gPrepare visual animationEvaluate project risksEvaluate project risksDefine scope, schedule and budget Identify procurement method

Page 6: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchMessaging

Page 7: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchVisual Animation

Page 8: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchVisual Animation

Page 9: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchProgram of Projects

Prescriptive projects – gain experienceDesign Bid Build– Design-Bid-Build

– Construction Manager General Contractor (CMGC)

Performance projects innovations led Performance projects – innovations led by contractor

– Design-Build

Page 10: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

ResearchGet Involved Nationally

Coordinate with FHWAParticipate in AASHTO SubcommitteespHost showcase projects

Sh l Share lessons learned and b ibest practices

Page 11: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignOutline

Educate and communicate with industryE l t j tEvaluate projects Implement standardizationp Improve based on lessons learned

Page 12: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignEducate and Communicate With Industry

ABC goalsRelentlessly pursue reducing traffic congestion during – Relentlessly pursue reducing traffic congestion during construction

– Add value by furthering Department themes and Add value by furthering Department themes and meeting project goals

– Improve worker safety and safety to the traveling public

– Improve quality

Page 13: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignEvaluate Projects

ScopeS h d lScheduleBudgetgQualityRiskRiskCommunicationsProcurement

Page 14: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesigngEvaluate Projects

Total Project CostTotal Project Cost

Page 15: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignEvaluate Projects

Page 16: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignImplement Standardization

Develop guidelines for ABC project inclusioninclusionDevelop typical details and manuals Include user costs in analysisEncourage innovationEncourage innovationProvide training and obtain feedback

Page 17: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignImplement StandardizationImplement Standardization

Page 18: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignImplement StandardizationImplement Standardization

Page 19: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesignImplement Standardization

ABC Manual and Standard Drawings

Page 20: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

DesigngLessons Learned

Perform program reviewFi d d fi i iFind program deficienciesRepair deficienciespReview design decisionsMeasure design assumptions vs realityMeasure design assumptions vs. reality

Page 21: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeOutline

Innovative elements and methodsTi li d hi tTimeline and historyProject highlightsj g gUpcoming projectsProgram evaluationProgram evaluation

Page 22: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeABC Components

Foundation & Wall Elements

Rapid Embankment C t ti

Prefabricated Bridge Elements

Structural Placement

Fast Track C t ti

Accelerated Bridge Construction Components

Construction g& Systems Methods Contracting

Continuous Flight Auger Piles

EPS Geofoam Prefabricated Elements- Superstructure

Self-Propelled Modular Transporters

Innovative Contracting- Best Value

GeosyntheticReinforced Soil (GRS) Integrated Bridge System

- Substructure

Prefabricated Systems- Superstructure- Substructure

p(SPMTs)

Longitudinal launching

H i t l lidi

- CMGC method- Design-Build- A+B- A+B+C- Warranties

- Substructure- Total Bridge

Horizontal sliding or skidding

Other heavy lifting equipment & methodsmethods

Conventional lifting equipment & methods

Page 23: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeDefinition of PBES

PBES consists of bridge structural elements & systems that are built off the elements & systems that are built off the bridge alignment to accelerate on-site

t ti ti l ti t ti l construction time relative to conventional practice.

Page 24: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeBenefits of PBES

Significant advantagesReduced on-site construction time– Reduced on-site construction time

– Minimized traffic disruption – months to days– Reduced environmental impact– Improved work zone & worker safety– Provides positive cost-benefit ratios when user costs

are consideredare considered– Improved product quality – controlled environment,

cure times, easier access, etc.

Page 25: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeInnovative Elements and Methods

Page 26: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeInnovative Elements and Methods

Precast Concrete Elements; I-80; Wanship Bridge

Page 27: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeInnovative Elements and Methods

Modular Construction; I-215 over 3670 South

Page 28: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeInnovative Elements and Methods

Structure Placement Methods

Page 29: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeInnovative Elements and Methods

Accelerated Geotechnical; Geofoam Embankment

Page 30: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeTimeline and History

Page 31: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeTimeline and History

Page 32: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

800 North over I-15; Precast Deck Panels; CMGC800 North over I 15; Precast Deck Panels; CMGC

Page 33: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

Ri d l R d I 84 L B id CMGCRiverdale Road over I-84 ; Lego Bridge; CMGC

Page 34: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

4500 South over I-215; SPMT; CMGC

Page 35: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

I-80; Lambs Canyon Bridge; SPMT; Design-BuildI 80; Lambs Canyon Bridge; SPMT; Design Build

Page 36: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

I-80; State Street to 1300 East; SPMT; CMGCI 80; State Street to 1300 East; SPMT; CMGC

Page 37: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

I-70; Eagle Canyon Bridge; Precast Deck Panels; CMGCI 70; Eagle Canyon Bridge; Precast Deck Panels; CMGC

Page 38: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

SR-66 Over Weber River; Slide-in; Design-Bid-Build

Page 39: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

I-80; Two Bridges Near Echo Junction; Slide-in; Design-Build

Page 40: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Practiceact ceProject Highlights

I 80 2300 E t Slid i D i B ildI-80 over 2300 East; Slide-in; Design-Build

Page 41: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

South Layton Interchange; Launch; Design-Buildy g ; ; g

Page 42: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Practiceact ceProject Highlights

U.S. 89 over I-15; SPMT; Design-BuildU.S. 89 over I 15; SPMT; Design Build

Page 43: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

I 15 CORE P t L I 15 SPMT D i B ildI-15 CORE Proctor Lane over I-15; SPMT; Design-Build

Page 44: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

I 15 CORE 200 South over I 15 SPMT Design BuildI-15 CORE 200 South over I-15; SPMT; Design-Build

Page 45: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeProject Highlights

I 15 CORE S Whit L I 15 SPMT D i B ildI-15 CORE Sam White Lane over I-15; SPMT; Design-Build

Page 46: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

PracticeUpcoming Projects

SPMT bridge moveI 15 CORE Provo Center Street; April 7– I-15 CORE Provo Center Street; April 7

Slide-in– I-80 over Weber River; Spring 2011– I-80 at Atkinson; Summer 2011

I 80 t S it P k S 2011– I-80 at Summit Park; Summer 2011

Prefabricated bridge elements– SR-193 over UPRR and UTA; Spring 2012

Page 47: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Program EvaluationgUtah ABC Costs; SPMT

$30,000,000 

Valued Added (includes user cost savings)

$20,000,000 

$25,000,000 

$10 000 000

$15,000,000 

$5,000,000 

$10,000,000 

$0 

I‐215; 4500 South I‐80; State St. to 1300 East

I‐80; Mt. Delle to Lambs Canyon

3300 South over I‐215

I‐15; Widening, 500 North to I‐

215

Pioneer Crossing

Page 48: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Program EvaluationgUtah ABC Costs; Slide-In

$2,500,000 

Valued Added (includes user cost savings)

$2,000,000 

$1,000,000 

$1,500,000 

$500,000 

$ , ,

$0 

SR‐66 Over Weber River I‐80; 2 Bridges near Echo Junction I‐80; 2300 East Bridge

Page 49: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Program EvaluationgABC Because…

Value added to the publicValue added to the publicSocietal costs minimizedPublic support for innovationPolitical capitalPolitical capital

Page 50: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Review

List 3 important aspects of implementing program change.

1. Research the innovation2. Educate and engage the industryg g y3. Have a plan

Page 51: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Review

What are key elements for communicating with the public?

1. Outreach programs2. Messagingg g3. Visual animation (Simplify the concepts)

Page 52: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Review

What are three major categories of accelerated bridge construction accelerated bridge construction components?

1. Foundation and wall elements2. Rapid embankment constructionp3. Prefabricated bridge elements and systems4. Structural placement methods5. Fast track contracting

Page 53: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Review

Wh t th b fit f i ABC What are the benefits of using ABC and PBES?1. Reduced on-site construction time2. Minimized traffic disruption – months to daysp y3. Reduced environmental impact4. Improved work zone & worker safety 5 P id iti t b fit ti h 5. Provides positive cost-benefit ratios when user

costs are considered6. Improved product quality – controlled p p q y

environment, cure times, easier access, etc.

Page 54: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Review

Why does innovative contracting support ABC?

Innovative contracting compliments ABC by allowing the contractor to work directly with the g ydesigner on constructibility and risk sharing.

Page 55: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Review

What is the major reason owners are choosing ABC?

Minimize impacts to the traveling public.

Page 56: Accelerated Bridge Construction - · PDF fileAccelerated Bridge Construction Research, Design and Practice Ui it f BfflUniversity of Buffalo April 2011 Presented by: Carmen Swanwick,

Thank you Questions?Thank you…Questions?