about eye spy

14
Eye Spy Intelligence Magazine is the world’s only independent publication dedicated to espionage and intelligence. First published in May 2001, the title is now available in 36 countries and read by over 100,000 people worldwide. Often described as the bridge between ‘officialdom’ and the public, Eye Spy is extremely popular with those who work in intelligence, security, defence and specialist wings of the armed forces. Indeed, it is subscribed to by hundreds of official intelligence agencies, government training academies, military forces and security colleges throughout the world. However, its non-political - visual editorial and easy-reading style ‘demystifies’ the intelligence subject, making it equally as popular with people from all walks of life - including the media. It is a constant provider of a certain type and quantity of information that is not found in any other publication. Readers are assured they will always find some- thing of interest within its 84 full colour pages; whether it’s the inside story of a lengthy government surveillance operation, an interview with a CIA polygraph examiner, MI6’s role behind the assassination of Rasputin, or the tradecraft used by those who ply their trade in the world’s second oldest profession, Eye Spy has become somewhat of a “must have” publication. The title can be found in Barnes and Noble, W. H. Smith, Borders and all good newsagents or subscribed to via Eye Spy. Reporting and Commentary Eye Spy dissects, publishes and provides comment on a variety of news stories, espionage case files, tradecraft, technology etc. All the world’s major happenings related to intelli- gence and espionage are reported upon. That’s not to say we don’t take a step back in THE WORLD OF INTELLIGENCE AND ESPIONAGE AS SEEN BY EYE SPY INTELLIGENCE MAGAZINE

Upload: eye-spy-magazine

Post on 23-Mar-2016

228 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Find out more about us....

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: About Eye Spy

Eye Spy Intelligence Magazine is the world’s only independent publication dedicated toespionage and intelligence. First published in May 2001, the title is now available in 36countries and read by over 100,000 people worldwide.

Often described as the bridge between ‘officialdom’ and the public, Eye Spy is extremelypopular with those who work in intelligence, security, defence and specialist wings of thearmed forces. Indeed, it is subscribed to by hundreds of official intelligence agencies,government training academies, military forces and security colleges throughout theworld. However, its non-political - visual editorial and easy-reading style ‘demystifies’ theintelligence subject, making it equally as popular with people from all walks of life -including the media. It is a constant provider of a certain type and quantity of informationthat is not found in any other publication. Readers are assured they will always find some-thing of interest within its 84 full colour pages; whether it’s the inside story of a lengthygovernment surveillance operation, an interview with a CIA polygraph examiner, MI6’srole behind the assassination of Rasputin, or the tradecraft used by those who ply theirtrade in the world’s second oldest profession, Eye Spy has become somewhat of a “musthave” publication. The title can be found in Barnes and Noble, W. H. Smith, Borders andall good newsagents or subscribed to via Eye Spy.

Reporting and Commentary

Eye Spy dissects, publishes and provides comment on a variety of news stories, espionagecase files, tradecraft, technology etc. All the world’s major happenings related to intelli-gence and espionage are reported upon. That’s not to say we don’t take a step back in

THE WORLD OF

INTELLIGENCE AND

ESPIONAGE AS SEEN BY

EYE SPY INTELLIGENCE

MAGAZINE

Page 2: About Eye Spy

time to look at famous case files, spy tricks (tradecraft), importantand defining moments, the history of the services, from theirdirectors to crests and the figures synonymous with the “espio-nage wheel”. If it’s necessary to draw parallels with events fromthe past, special features accompany articles; failing that, ourwriters will point readers in the right direction for further reading.There is a certain ‘timelessness’ about espionage events: likeAmerica’s Aldrich Ames and Robert Hanssen, to the ‘gentry’ andshadowy Cambridge spy ring in the UK. Counterespionage agen-cies still use such classic case files to teach today’s students thesecrets of espionage, dirty tricks and more importantly, the signswhich can identify people betraying their country, or who are onthe precipice of joining an enemy or adversary. It’s one reasonwhy Eye Spy insists on retaining and improving its links with menand women who have spent decades in the ‘industry’, from photographic interpreters totraining officers at some of the most secretive spy schools in the world. It helps us under-stand the often elaborate nature of a case file or event.

The public may learn of a breaking story via the television, radio, print press or Internet,but Eye Spy readers are content in the knowledge that they can view certain informationthat is simply not reported upon, or not fully understood by the media. Having an aware-ness of how the intelligence world works is a powerful tool for any individual. It’s not all‘silver screen’, and ‘gadgetry’, though many real-life happenings could be drawn from theimagination of some of the world’s best scriptwriters. In recent times, the public has been

- 2 -

Aldrich Ames

The strange case of Aleksander Litvinenko (centre) captured the imagination of the public and media alike.In reality, assassinations are not uncommon in the world of intelligence. It didn’t stop Litvinenko’s wife -

Marina (far right) placing the blame firmly on the door step of Russia’s intelligence services

© S

NAPP

ERJA

CK

COUR

TESY

DOS

© L

ITVI

NENK

O JU

STIC

E FO

UNDA

TION

Page 3: About Eye Spy

intimate with major news stories thatare typical of an industry that rarelyhangs its dirty washing out in public.Take for example the bizarre death offormer KGB officer AleksanderLitvinenko in London. Poisoned byPolonium-210 - a radioactive isotopeused to help detonate nuclear bombs,Litvinenko’s death was part of a wideroperation involving front companies,clandestine death lists, political andmilitary manoeuvring etc. His assassi-nation is most certainly connected tointelligence factions, industrial giants,the Russian mafia, and the settling ofold scores. But all are ultimately con-nected to the intelligence world, proofif ever needed of the enormity anddiversity of the subject.

As for the manner of Litvinenko’sdeath, the KGB are pastmasters at thiskind of skulduggery. Who can forgetthe demise of Georgi Markov? TheBulgarian dissident killed by a poisondart filled with ricin and fired from anumbrella in London in 1978. In 2004,

someone in the Russian security services posted a letter to a known Chechen terrorist.Inside the envelope flap the glue was painted with a substance lethal on skin contact. Theterrorist duly opened the package and died shortly after. But it’s not just the Russians whouse such deadly tradecraft. The CIA schemed for years to create all manner of plots toassassinate Cuban leader Fidel Castro - including lacing his shoes with deadly Thallium.And a few years ago, Richard Tomlinson, a renegade MI6 officer revealed he was aware ofan MI6 operation to kill Yugoslavian leader Slobodan Milosevic. In this case the alleged

plot involved blinding Milosevic’sdriver causing the vehicle to spin outof control. As one Eye Spy consultantkeeps on reminding us - “intelligencecan be a dirty business.”

What may seem like a simple murder,a case of spying, the loss of a secretcomponent or the demise of a regimeor government minister, is often justthe leading edge of a much widerevent.

- 3 -

Thames House, headquarters of MI5

Georgi Markov

Page 4: About Eye Spy

Closed Doors

It’s never easy trying to peak behind thefront doors of so many of the world’sleading intelligence services, but themagazine’s editorial staff, consultants,contacts, analysts and sources do haveaccess to places that are often beyondthe reach of journalists. Indeed, a quickglance at our consultancy board givesyou some indication of the calibre andprofession of the people who regularlyprovide material and qualified guid-ance.

Eye Spy consultants also feature ontelevision, radio and in the world’spress. They are often called upon bydocumentary and film makers for com-ment and advice on a scene or newsclip. Having first-hand knowledge of therole of an air marshal or an anti-terror-ist officer in New York, for example,helps our writers create a fact-basedfeature, or understand the mechanismof an intelligence operation. Some ofour consultants still perform analysisand have decades of experience dealingwith intelligence agencies, committeesand government think tanks. Otherconsultants and editors have partici-pated directly in special operations,from gathering intelligence in Afghani-stan, to training operatives in espionageand surveillance tradecraft.

The Elements of the World of Intelligence

The word ‘intelligence’ is simply a generic term forinformation - but it has evolved into something that isconsidered far more important. The subject of ‘intelli-gence’ is multifaceted and enormous, it can be com-plex or simple. It’s what makes Eye Spy different, inthat each issue is singularly unique. Unlike manytopics and subjects, intelligence and the stories itgenerates are never quite the same. Espionage is butone element of intelligence, though many esteemed

- 4 -

© E

YE S

PYThe media may learn of an anti-terroristoperation - Eye Spy reveals how it was

planned and achieved

Page 5: About Eye Spy

- 5 -

commentators consider it an integral part of the subject and they are cor-rect. But in truth, there are hundreds of ‘elements’, and all are deemedhighly important by the hundreds of thousands of men and women whowork in the business. However, espionage or spying is one subject that isparticularly popular with our readers, a fact not overlooked by our edito-rial.

Spy - an Emotive Word

Information collection comes from a multitude of sources: HUMINT forexample. Human Intelligence is considered vital in that it is often gleanedfrom first-hand sources, or as a result of spying. The word ‘spy’ is an emo-tive term that the media often uses to call anyone working in the intelli-gence industry: an analyst, case officer, photographic interpreter etc. Inreality, the word should only be used for those employed at the ‘leadingedge’ of information collection, and even then, it depends on your pointof view. An MI6 officer collecting intelligence in Russia is most certainlynot referred to as a spy by his superiors at Britain’s Foreign Office, but hisactions and role are not welcomed in Moscow. To Russia’s counterespio-nage or counterintelligence officers, he is a threat. But it’s easy to under-stand how everyone directly associated with an intelligence agency endsup being called a spy. To be called a ‘spy’, one must really be convicted ina court of law.

Intelligence Collection

Foreign-based intelligence officers often work within the confines of adiplomatic mission - are attached to a foreign embassy or legitimate com-

Page 6: About Eye Spy

pany and have carefullymanaged lifestyles and“created” backgrounds.Diplomatic immunityassured, such officersrarely conduct espionagedirectly. The role of acase or field officer iscovered extensively inEye Spy (tradecraft). Sotoo is the recruitment ofpeople, whether they areon the official payroll ornot. Case officers willhave a tour of duty andmost never outstay theirwelcome in foreigncountries. Selection isimportant as they willneed to speak and understand the foreign tongue, be familiar with local customs andtraditions etc. Case officers will use other people to gather intelligence - these are knownin the trade as agents. Within their respected embassies, MI6 and the CIA have createdfield stations. Often manned by a handful of officers, these important offices cementrelations between various ‘gogs’ in the espionage wheel and are charged solely with gath-ering intelligence, liaison and other duties.

This takes us into a rather murky area of theintelligence world. Using agents, couriers,assets and informants, a case officer will use allhis or her prowess to perform a particular task.Eventually information is sourced, secured,sent for processing, disseminated, analysed and‘boxed’. What’s produced is known as the‘product’. Depending on the type of case of-ficer, some operatives will simply monitorforeign press (in all its forms), attend trade fairsand military exhibitions, liaise or contribute tomissions. This intelligence is usually describedas ‘open source’, in that it is freely available.Others work in far more dangerous areas thatinevitably means tradecraft must be used.Sometimes case or field officers are attached tolegitimate businesses in an effort to obtainintelligence. These people are often dubbed‘persons of interest’ by counterintelligenceofficers and will themselves be monitored andsurveilled. Performing espionage at this level

- 6 -

Eye Spy’s tradecraft features reveal the secrets of therecruiters, informants and case officers

A suspected case officer may bemonitored even before he has

started his mission

Page 7: About Eye Spy

- 7 -

requires a steely resolve and it’s not forthe faint-hearted. This type of tradecraft isregularly featured in Eye Spy.

Intelligence gathering is often compli-cated, thrilling, manpower-intensive andvery expensive.

The ‘product’ is the lifeblood of diplo-matic and military machines. If it’s wrong,the results can prove disastrous. An exam-ple of poor product is the US and UKintelligence assessments on Iraq’s ‘weap-ons of mass destruction’ (those workingin the intelligence services connected tothis topic believe they were poorly treatedand manipulated by their political mas-ters). Politics, foreign and domestic affairs,industry, the armed forces and intelligencemust collide at some point, and the UKand USA, for example, do have specialadvisory or “oversight committees” to

make sure the product is not used incorrectly - at least that’s the theory.

However, intelligence work is also driven by events occurring worldwide. Within three orfour years Iran, for example, could have the capability to produce a nuclear bomb. Thathas implications not just for Middle East nations, butfor everyone. How so? Many intelligence agencies,including MI6, CIA and NSA, have been charged withtrying to obtain valid intelligence on Tehran’s nuclearprogramme. It’s a dreadfully difficult task in thatclosed borders exist and Westerners are not welcome.Even the world’s atomic bodies have found the Ira-nian government loathe to provide information. Withthis in mind, MI6 and others are feverishly working togather intelligence, trying to determine the day whenIran announces to the world it has a bomb. Ultimatelymany analysts fear it could be used against Israel, orthat certain parts of the programme could be deliv-ered to known terrorists - and that affects the safetyand security of everyone. Assessing the implications ofsuch a situation can only be achieved by obtaining accurate intelligence - this is calledIntelligence Estimate or Appreciation. It is the appraisal of all available intelligence relatingto a specific requirement of potential hostile actions or developments. Diplomatic meas-ures to stop the project have been put in place, but a secondary plan involving a tacticalmilitary strike have also been enabled. Analysts, (both political and intelligence) militarystrategists and key advisors must also assess the global implications for these two sce-

Headquarters of Britain’s MI6

Arak nuclear facility - Iran

Page 8: About Eye Spy

narios. This type of intelligenceoperation is both time consum-ing and menacingly dark. Thewider public seem oblivious tothe precarious nature of this singleissue. But there are hundreds, if notthousands of events taking place at thismoment in time which need to be moni-tored. All of these are assigned levels ofsensitivity. If deemed important, they will beraised higher on the ‘intelligence chart’ andmore resources assigned to the case. Others may fall off thegraph, then radar, and one day may come back to hauntthose persons making crucial decisions - as was the casewhen al-Qaida hijackers attacked the USA on 9/11 or Lon-don in 2005. The ‘product’ was undoubtedly there, it wassimply misread and not nearly enough of the jigsaw waspieced together to see the bigger picture. Since then, therehas been a huge recruitment drive by dozens of services,agencies have been overhauled, budgets increased andlaws changed to accommodate a very fluid situation. It’sone area Eye Spy examines constantly.

- 8 -

Intelligence officers can’t just board airliners and request information -occasionally they must resort to other methods - including espionage

Mohammad Atta -9/11 leader

Page 9: About Eye Spy

Technology

A few years ago govern-ments were limited in howthey could collect intelli-gence. The Cold War sawtwo powerful sides pullaway from total world de-struction at the very lastmoment. The USSR andNATO played a dangerousgame of ‘cat and mouse’.For years - both sides optedto match each others nu-clear warheads, warplanes,ships and manpower. Mu-tual assured destruction(MAD) was the doctrineoften cited by analysts. Bothsides had the ability todestroy each other, the onlyproblem was they would

destroy themselves in trying. MAD is basedon the theory of deterrence according towhich the deployment of strong weapons isessential to threaten the enemy in order toprevent the use of the very same weapons.

Because the USSR was shielded behind alengthy closed border dubbed the “IronCurtain”, electronic intelligence involvingreconnaissance aeroplanes, ships, subma-rines, and later satellites, came to the fore. Awhole new industry grew from the Cold Warthat still exists today, one that is helping andhindering today’s intelligence gatherers.The Cold War also prompted the develop-ment of a new range of tools for spies togather intelligence. But anyone caughtplying their trade in foreign lands was al-most always shot. Sometimes they werelucky - and “exchanged” at pre-arrangedlocations for other spies. The city of Berlin,divided both militarily and politically, wasoften the point of contact, and has a rightfulplace in spylore.

- 9 -

The New York Times reports upon the sentence ofCIA U-2 pilot Gary Powers - he was later

“exchanged” for a Soviet spy

It is still a game ofcat and mouse - butplayed out with farmore players on a

bigger field.

Page 10: About Eye Spy

Today’s spy satellites, unlike their pred-ecessors, have longer operational lifespansand are packed with even more high-endtechnology. Easily capable of reading theprint off a newspaper, some systems trackvehicles hundreds of miles, monitor terror-ist training camps and follow rogue vesselsacross oceans. It’s no longer essential tosend spy planes like the U-2 into nearspace across enemy territory to gatherintelligence on a weapons convoy or takephotos of a new military site; satellites canbe manoeuvred and controlled at will - andeven the public has the ability to view once

top secret sites on the Internet with certain software. What has not changed is the analysisof the information, and the way in which the product is used. Gathering electronic infor-mation has become easier, but no less important. And just like any element in intelligence,the counterintelligence wings work overtime to stop an adversary obtaining such data. It isstill a game of cat and mouse - but played out with far more players on a bigger field.

This massive technical revolution in informationgathering methods has brought about a drasticchange in the way intelligence is collected. Hugeradomes act like ‘giant nets’ catching signals,pictures and telephone calls from across theglobe. Diplomatic and military information maybe scrambled, but eventually it will be deci-phered. The difference is, it’s a lot faster.

Two decades ago the Internet and cell phoneemerged as “must have” products. They are greatproviders of information. For the intelligencecommunity they pose a problem. So rapid hasbeen the advance of this technology, that it hasbecome increasingly difficult for any government

- 10 -

© F

LIGH

T IM

AGES

Page 11: About Eye Spy

to keep a secret for long. Another major problem surrounding these instruments is thatthey can be used by anyone - including foreign spy rings, terrorists, organised crime gangsetc. With this in mind, some countries have dedicated agencies to intercept communica-tions and monitor e-mails. One major programme run jointly by the UK’s GCHQ (Govern-ment Communications Headquarters) and America’s NSA (National Security Agency), isECHELON. It’s a global network of special facilities and satellites with the capability ofintercepting e-mails, phone calls, faxes etc. One intelligence analyst said - “if it’s spoken orwritten - we know.” That may be rather simplistic and not altogether true, but withoutEchelon, terrorist organisations and rogue nations intent on supporting the activity ofgroups like al-Qaida, could act with impunity. Of course there are those who object tosuch a system, but there are numerous safeguards in place to monitor only suspicious‘traffic’. It’s just one of hundreds of topics covered in Eye Spy.

Tradecraft

With so many people having access to cell phones and the Internet, one would think thatthe old traits of a spy would soon be a thing of the past. Not so. Because signals are sentelectronically, they can be intercepted. With so many new forms of communication, it’s notsurprising that the ‘electronic spy’ has emerged. SIGINT (signal intelligence) and COMINT(communications intelligence) are as vital to an intelligence service as HUMINT. By acquir-ing intelligence on an adversary, at the very least, it gives military and political planners anedge or insight into what is taking place thousands of miles away.

Understanding the intelligence machineand the role it plays is indispensable forall who want to know the nature of the21st century. An intelligence officer ischarged with the collection and evalua-tion of information about foreign armystrengths, terrorist activity, motives andplans. It is true that these officers are thefirst line of defence in many arenas, oftensupported by a network of colleagues.Handling the ‘product’ allows analysts tomake decisions, in turn providing guid-ance to policy makers. The features in EyeSpy are often created by assessing whattranspired before an operation occurred,or the mechanism employed to achieve aspecific result, be that the culmination ofan anti-terrorist operation, or the discov-ery of an MI6 communications deviceburied inside a rock in a Moscow park. Our writers, all experienced in the field of intelli-gence, lift the important climatic information from reports. And while it is not alwayspossible to predict happenings or military conflict, Eye Spy did report on al-Qaida’s plansto carry out a huge destructive attack on the West - a full 16 weeks prior to 9/11.

- 11 -

This MI6 communications’ device wasdiscovered by Russian intelligence in a

Moscow Park

Page 12: About Eye Spy

Throughout its publication journey, Eye Spyhas endeavoured to provide readers with themost important and interesting news relatedto intelligence and espionage. One major‘tool’ used by the men and women working atthe ‘leading edge’ of intelligence collection isoften described as tradecraft. A number of ourwriters have worked in this fascinating area -an area that interests so many people and initself contains hundreds of special elements.

Tradecraft is used by different agencies togather information. Whether it’s a lengthysurveillance operation, the bugging of a sus-pected terrorist cell, or the passing of highlysecret components from an aviation project,Eye Spy typically provides a deep insight intohow this is carried out. Government agenciessuch as MI6, or to give it its proper title -Secret Intelligence Service (SIS), have dedi-cated training schools to teach employees thetradecraft necessary to carry out covert opera-tions, or ‘turn’ adversaries into informants andassets. MI6 - and its US counterpart - the Cen-tral Intelligence Agency (CIA), are masters atinfiltration and disinformation, though offi-cials are obviously reluctant to discuss suchmatters in public. Nevertheless, these twosubjects can also be described as tradecraftelements.

Eye Spy’s tradecraft series has become verypopular in that readers can discover some ofthe amazing methods used by the world’sleading operatives, though our respect fornational security is always a top priority. Fromdiscovering the methods used to install covertcameras in a target building, to the skills nec-essary to communicate via dead letter drops,performing surveillance, master disguisetechniques, infiltrating a spy ring, remainingsafe overseas, avoiding the lose of your iden-tity, to operating in hostile environments etc. -readers will soon learn the trade secrets usedby the world’s greatest spies and agencies.And by digesting the contents of our DIYsection, you will soon learn to build various

- 12 -

Page 13: About Eye Spy

tools used in the espionage world, from trans-mitters to parabolic microphones to manufac-turing plastics - all at a fraction of the cost.

Of course even experienced operatives canmake mistakes or countermeasures and foreignspies conspire to make things difficult for thoseattempting to gather intelligence. Counter-measures are an integral part of the work ofdomestic national agencies such as MI5 (Secu-rity Service) and the FBI (Federal Bureau ofInvestigation). In recent times, a greater em-phasis has been placed on countering the veryreal threat of terrorism, rather than attemptingto catch spies at work, though this is still para-mount. Indeed, 85% of MI5’s operationalbudget is now spent on monitoring and investi-gating al-Qaida - a huge menace for everyone.Eye Spy regularly features the work of MI5 andits partners - all determined to tackle the terrorgroup. It’s a fascinating area because operativesare required to use tradecraft in all its forms touncover plots, thwart operations and monitorevolving threats. Since its inception, Eye Spyhas produced an array of detailed features covering a multitude of terrorist attacks andfailed operations. However, much attention is given to the tradecraft and the extraordinarymanner in which intelligence analysts, anti-terrorist detectives and security services com-bine to piece together the data. Using our first-class sources, Eye Spy has gained a reputa-tion for accurate reporting and analysis.

Features

Because of its wide appeal to readers fromacross the world, Eye Spy is a recipient of hun-dreds of stories, case files, and rare intelligencesnippets, many from esteemed authors, writersand journalists. From authentic secret intelli-gence-led UK-USA Special Forces operations inAfghanistan, to new information on the RudolfHess mystery, MI6’s role in the building of thesecret spy tunnel under the Russian Embassy inBerlin, to female spies in the war of independ-ence, the features are both educational andfascinating. The ‘mix’ has been described byformer MI5 and MI6 legal director DavidBickford as “thoroughly informative” and makesfor “excellent reading.”

- 13 -

The failed 21/7 London bombgang caught on CCTV

Special Forces are an important andemerging tool in the intelligence war

Page 14: About Eye Spy

In six years of continuous publica-tion, Eye Spy has covered everymajor intelligence story, revealedsome of the secret tradecraft usedby operatives, published fascinat-ing case histories, photographicessays, special espionage cases,infiltration, surveillance, bugging,service histories, interviews etc.We have a dedicated book releasesection whereby readers canreview the latest releases, and atradecraft area where new equip-ment is tested and reviewed. Ourstore also stocks some popular equipment, from ordi-nary transmitters to entire surveillance systems.

Is it is magazine for “spies”? - No - though it is a firmfavourite with the ‘trade’. But it is a magazine totallydevoted to and about the work of the intelligence andsecurity services, Special Forces units, anti-terrorismofficers, intelligence and police forensic and detectiveagencies etc.

When covering a particular event, Eye Spy will endeavour to follow events to a conclusion- with regular updates in consecutive issues. It’s why the intelligence world track Eye Spyand why our back issues are as popular today as the day they were first published. Eachedition is a collector’s item and readers can keep their magazines in pristine conditionwith Eye Spy’s quality gold-finished binders. Ultimately they are a library in themselves - arecord of key moments in time garnished with the tradecraft and all the ‘elements’ thatmake up the spy world.

For those who work in the industry it is essential reading, but Eye Spy is for everyone andanybody remotely interested in this fascinating and secretive subject. Do join us for arevealing insight into the world of intelligence and espionage - it may just change youropinion of world events - and what takes place behind closed doors.

Mark Birdsall Editor

A subscription (eight issues a year) is just £25.00 (UK), $48.00 (USA), C$ 60.00 (Canada)or £30.00 anywhere in the world. This includes postage and airmail packing. It is incred-ible value for money.

For your interest we have produced a few selected high-resolution pdfs showing examplepages covering a number of topics....

- 14 -