abhijit ghosh dastidar vs

8/11/2019 Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar Vs

1/11

ABHIJIT GHOSH DASTIDAR Vs. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.Coram: K.G.

BALAKRISHNAN P. SATHASIVAM J.M. PANCHAL 22/!/2!!"

IT#M NO.$ COURT NO. S#CTION I%

SUPR#M# COURT OF INDIA

R#CORD OF PROC##DINGS

P'('(o)*s+ ,or S-(a La0 'o A--a *C(0(+ No*s+.211/2!!3

*From '4 5678m)' a)7 or7r 7a'7 29/!9/2!!3 () P No. ;92$/2!!$ o, T4

HIGH COURT OF BOMBA()8 o6)'r a?7a0('@ a)7 -ra=r ,or ()'r(m r(,+

Da': 22/!/2!!" T4(s P'('(o) as a7 o) ,or 4ar()8 'o7a=.

CORAM :

HONBL# TH# CHI#F JUSTIC#
http://__dopostback%28%27datagrid1%24_ctl12%24_ctl0%27%2C%27%27%29/http://__dopostback%28%27datagrid1%24_ctl12%24_ctl2%27%2C%27%27%29/http://__dopostback%28%27datagrid1%24_ctl12%24_ctl2%27%2C%27%27%29/http://__dopostback%28%27datagrid1%24_ctl12%24_ctl0%27%2C%27%27%29/http://__dopostback%28%27datagrid1%24_ctl12%24_ctl2%27%2C%27%27%29/http://__dopostback%28%27datagrid1%24_ctl12%24_ctl2%27%2C%27%27%29/


2/11

HONBL# MR. JUSTIC# P. SATHASIVAM

HONBL# MR. JUSTIC# J.M. PANCHAL

For P'('(o)r*s+ Mr. Sa)5a= Par4@ A70.

Mr. J('() Sa4)(@ A70.

Mr. A.N. S()84@ A70.

Mr. Ga6ra0 T=a8(@ A70.

M/s. M. Sa)a@ A70.

Ms. A)('4a S4)o=@A70.

For Rs-o)7)'*s+ Mr. As4o B4a)@ A70.

Mrs. Var6)a B4a)7ar( G68)a)(@ A70.

Mr. B.K. Prasa7@ A70.

For Mr. V.K. Vrma@A70.

UPON 4ar()8 o6)s '4 Co6r' ma7 '4 ,oo()8

ORD#R

La0 8ra)'7.

T4 a--a (s ao7 () 'rms o, '4 s(8)7 or7r.


3/11

No os's.

*R.K.DHAAN+ *V##RA V#RMA+

COURT MAST#R COURT MAST#R

*S(8)7 or7r (s -a7 o) '4 >+

IN TH# SUPR#M# COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APP#LLAT# JURISDICTION

CIVIL APP#AL NO.1229 OF 2!!"

* Ar(s()8 o6' o, S.L.P. *C+ NO. 211 OF 2!!3 +

AE4(5(' G4os4 Das'(7ar .... A--a)'

Vrs6s

U)(o) o, I)7(a & Ors. .... Rs-o)7)'*s+

ORD#R


4/11

+ La0 8ra)'7.

2+ T4 a--a)' as Pos' Mas'r G)ra 76r()8 '4 r0a)' -r(o7 a)7 as

(8(E 'o E -romo'7 'o '4 H(84r A7m()(s'ra'(0 Gra7 o, I)7(a) Pos'a

Sr0(

Gro6-A a)7 'o E -os'7 as C4(, Pos' Mas'r G)ra. H(s a(m ,or -romo'(o)

as o)s(7r7 E= '4 D.P.C. o) .2.;;; a)7 a8a() o) 2".!2.2!!. T4

a--a)'

as )o' ,o6)7 (8(E ,or -romo'(o) 'o '4 H(84r A7m()(s'ra'(0 Gra7A. H

>7

a) Or(8()a A--(a'(o) E,or '4 C)'ra A7m()(s'ra'(0 Tr(E6)a *4r()a,'r

r,rr7 'o as CAT+a' Pa')a a8()8 '4a' 4 as )o' o)s(7r7 ,or -romo'(o)

,or

'4 raso) '4a' '4r r 'o )'r(s () 4(s C.R. (.. o) o) 22.!;.;;9 a)7

a)o'4r

o) !".!2.;;". I' as -o()'7 o6' '4a' '4 CAT@ Pa')a B)4 E= or7r 7a'7

29.!.2!!2 7(r'7 '4 a6'4or('= )o' 'o 'a )o' o, '4 or7r o, a6'(o)


5/11

2

7a'7 22.!;.;;9 a)7 '4 or7r o, a70rs rmars 7a'7 !;.!1.;;" ,or '4

-r(o7 !.!3.;;9 'o $.!.;;9 4( o)s(7r()8 '4 a--a)' ,or -romo'(o).

I) '4

(84' o, '4 sa(7 or7r@ '4 a--a)' o)')77 '4a' '4s 'o a70rs )'r(s

s4o67

)o' 4a0 E) o)s(7r7 E= '4 D.P.C. H ,6r'4r o)')77 '4a' '4ro684 o6'

'4

-r(o7 4 as 8(0) )'r= o, 8oo7. T4 rs-o)7)'D-ar'm)' a87 '4a'

'4

a--a)' as )o' o)s(7r7 ,or -romo'(o) as 4 as )o' 4a0()8 '4 E)4mar

o,

0r= 8oo7. Aor7()8 'o '4 a--a)'@ '4 a70rs )'r(s )am= 8oo7 r

)o'

omm6)(a'7. T4 sa(7 as-' o684' )o' 'o 4a0 E) o)s(7r7 4(

o)s(7r()8

4(s -romo'(o). I) s6--or' o, '4 aEo0 a(m@ 4 r(7 o) '4 7(s(o) o, '4(s

Co6r'

() D0 D6'' 0s. U)(o) o, I)7(a & Ors.@ 2!!" *9+ Sa 3!$.

$+ P6rs6a)' 'o '4 7(r'(o) o, '4 CAT@ Pa')a B)4 o) !;.!;.2!!2 r0( o,


6/11

D.P.C. as 47 a)7 '4 a--a)' as )o' ,o6)7 s6('aE ,or -romo'(o). I) Mar4@

2!!$@ '4r as a r86ar D.P.C. a)7 '4 a--a)' as ,o6)7 >' ,or -romo'(o)

('4

'4 sam )'r(s a)7 aor7()8= -romo'7 'o H(84r A7m()(s'ra'(0 Gra7

Gro6-A

a)7 a'r r'(r7 ,rom sr0(.

3+ I' (s )o' () 7(s-6' '4a' '4 CAT@ Pa')a B)4 -ass7 a) or7r

romm)7()8

'4 a6'4or('= )o' 'o r= o) '4 or7r o, a6'(o) 7a'7 22.!;.;;9 a)7 '4 or7r

o,

a70rs rmars 7a'7 !;.!1.;;". I) 0( o, '4 sa(7 or7r@ o) oEs'a

$

ra'()8 'o 4(s -romo'(o) 8os. Com()8 'o '4 so)7 as-'@ '4a' '4o684

'4

E)4mar 0r= 8oo7 (s r6(r7 ,or E()8 o)s(7r7 ,or -romo'(o) a7m(''7=

'4 )'r= o, 8oo7 as )o' omm6)(a'7 'o '4 a--a)'. T4 )'r= o, 8oo7


7/11

s4o67 4a0 E) omm6)(a'7 'o 4(m as 4 as 4a0()8 0r= 8oo7 () '4

-r0(o6s

=ar. I) '4os (r6ms'a)s@ () o6r o-()(o)@ )o)omm6)(a'(o) o, )'r(s () '4

ACR o, a -6E( sr0a)' 4'4r 4 (s () (0(@ 567((a@ -o( or a)= o'4r sr0(

*o'4r '4a) '4 arm7 ,ors+@ (' 4as (0( o)s6)s Ea6s (' ma= a' 4(s

4a)s ,or -romo'(o) or 8' o'4r E)>'s. H)@ s64 )o)omm6)(a'(o)

o67

E arE('rar= a)7 as s64 0(oa'(0 o, Ar'( 3 o, '4 Co)s'('6'(o). T4 sam 0(

4as E) r('ra'7 () '4 aEo0 r,rr7 7(s(o) r(7 o) E= '4 a--a)'.

T4r,or@ '4 )'r(s 8oo7 (, a' a 8ra)'7 'o '4 a--a)'@ '4 sam s4o67

)o'

4a0 E) 'a) ()'o o)s(7ra'(o) ,or E()8 o)s(7r7 ,or -romo'(o) 'o '4

4(84r

8ra7. T4 rs-o)7)' 4as )o as '4a' '4 a--a)' 4a7 0r E) (),orm7 o,

'4

)a'6r o, '4 8ra7()8 8(0) 'o 4(m.

+ Lar)7 o6)s a--ar()8 ,or '4 a--a)' 4as -o()'7 o6' '4a' '4 o?r

4o as (mm7(a'= 56)(or () sr0( 'o '4 a--a)' as 8(0) -romo'(o) o)


8/11

2".!".2!!!. T4r,or@ '4 a--a)' aso E 7m7 'o 4a0 E) 8(0)

-romo'(o)

,rom 2".!".2!!!. S() '4 a--a)' 4a7 r'(r7 ,rom sr0(@ ma (' ar

'4a'

4 (s )o' )'('7 'o a)= -a= or aoa)s ,or '4 -r(o7 ,or 4(4 4 4a7 )o'

3

or7 () '4 H(84r A7m()(s'ra'(0 Gra7 Gro6-A@ E6' 4(s r'ros-'(0

-romo'(o) ,rom 2".!".2!!! s4a E o)s(7r7 ,or '4 E)>' o, r>a'(o) o,

4(s

-)s(o) a)7 o'4r r'r(a E)>'s as -r r6s.

1+ T4 a--a (s ao7 'o '4 aEo0 ')'. No os's.

......................................CJI.

*K.G. BALAKRISHNAN+


9/11

..............................................J.

*P. SATHASIVAM+


10/11

.............................................J.

*J.M. PANCHAL+

N# D#LHI

OCTOB#R 22@ 2!!".


11/11

abhijit ghosh dastidar vs

Documents