a woman on her bicycle pulled over in greenpoint

7/22/2019 A Woman on Her Bicycle Pulled Over in Greenpoint

1/4

A woman on her bicycle pulled over in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, on Thursdayto greet a couple of familiar faces. She jumped right into the conversation.

Are you getting good graffiti? she asked. Or bad graffiti?

Bad, replied Gina Argento, indicating some illegible scrawls across the street. It is a far cryfrom good, the 1970s-era murals that made artists of lanky youths with spray paint. Which,for the record, no one seems to want, either.

Greenpoints graffiti problem is as stubborn as unchecked mold. It is everywhere, evengreeting visitors to Brooklyn upon their arrival from Queens over the Pulaski Bridge. There isgraffiti on brick walls and painted walls and on glass doors and poles. Trees are tagged with

paint. Someone scrawled on a Stop Bed Bugs sign on a remote corner. In the mens roomof the Manhattan Three Decker diner, someone wrote Shy Guy on the plastic sign that saysemployees must wash their hands. And in a small room in St. Anthony of Padua Church,

people have been known to scratch names or short prayers (Please help me) into the feet ofthe statues of saints.

A sign outside Eli & Alis, a tomato wholesaler on Meserole Avenue, offers a $500 rewardfor information leading to a graffiti arrest. A manager said no one has called to collect.

Its generational, said Jeff Mann, president of the Greenpoint Chamber of Commerce,which he said had raised and spent more than $25,000 in paint since November in an effort tocover graffiti. Its everywhere. Its epidemic.

In one corner of Greenpoint, where the good-versus-bad conversation was taking place, thereare other, more welcome sights that have become commonplace. People who do not look likethey belong on gritty, graffiti-marked streets. Like Tom Selleck, Julianna Margulies and big-shot executives from CBS.

Ms. Argento and her brother, Tony, own Broadway Stages, a busy bunch of sound stagesused for television shows and films. They started out 30 years ago providing space formaking music videos for Hall & Oates and Billy Idol. Today, they sell space to shows likeMs. Marguliess The Good Wife and Mr. Sellecks Blue Bloods.

Nearly every episode of Blue Bloods ends with the family of Frank Reagan, the New York

City police commissioner played by Mr. Selleck, sitting down to a big dinner in his diningroom. In the show, the home is in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, but in reality, it is on a stage onCalyer Street in Greenpoint, on a block of corrugated metal strewn with graffiti.

This, Mr. Argento does not need.

Ive painted over graffiti on Saturday morning, and on Saturday night its back again, hesaid. He walked past a wall with a bright blue scribble of spray paint. This is a new guy, hesaid.

One day in the spring, Mr. Argento arrived at one of his offices, on Norman Avenue, to find

the glass front doors defaced by some sort of acid, and the brick interior marked in paint.


2/4

It was a group of seven kids, he told the precinct commanding officer later at a communitymeeting. Not kids. They were in their 20s.

Surveillance video showed young men arriving in two cars, with some acting as lookoutswhile others sprayed.

Bobby Mari, whose corner bar is called the Place, saw a new graffiti drawing outside onThursday. Who knows who did it, he asked, with a choice word tucked in for emphasis.

Mr. Mann said the conventional wisdom was that most of the graffiti drawers were local, butthere is another theory. Call it graffiti tourism. People from the Midwest come here just todo graffiti and then post pictures online,he said. Ive heard that.

He and the Argentos have helped organize several cleanups, drawing young men and womenfrom the Greenpoint Youth Court and other groups. Mr. Argento said he had stopped askinghis neighbors if theyd like him to paint their tagged wallshe just does it.

All the talk of graffiti was interrupted by another visitor on Thursday morning. Along cameBill de Blasio, the public advocate and a Democratic candidate for mayor, in a crisp blue shirtand striped tie He stopped before a couple of television cameras and reporters and spoke ofthe importance of the television industry in Greenpoint. Hearing him describe the growth arcof the studio, it is hard to imagine its owner slinging paint on Saturday mornings.

If Mr. de Blasio had looked over a reporters shoulder, he would have seen a signature ofsorts on the garage door across the street, one that seems less convincing the more times it

pops up: Shy Guy.

WASHINGTONPresident Obama on Friday sought to take control of theroiling debate over the National Security Agencys surveillance practices,releasing a more detailed legal justification for domestic spying and calling formore openness and scrutiny of the N.S.A.s programs to reassure a skeptical

public that its privacy is not being violated.

Its right to ask questions about surveillance, particularly as technology is reshaping everyaspect of our lives, Mr. Obama said, adding: Its not enough for me, as president, to haveconfidence in these programs. The American people need to have confidence in them as

well.

But at a time when leaks by the former N.S.A. contractor Edward J. Snowden have exposedthe agencys expansive spying both inside the United States and abroad to an unprecedenteddegree of scrutiny, Mr. Obama showed no inclination to curtail secret surveillance efforts.Rather, he conceded only a need for greater openness and safeguards to make the publiccomfortable with them.

In meeting threats to the country, Mr. Obama said, we have to strike the right balancebetween protecting our security and preserving our freedoms. And while he said that theprograms were valuable and that he was confident they had not been abused, he

acknowledged that people may want to jigger slightly that balance.
http://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381882/obama-on-surveillance-transparency.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381882/obama-on-surveillance-transparency.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381882/obama-on-surveillance-transparency.html


3/4

Mr. Obama made his remarks at a wide-ranging news conference on the eve of his departurefor a weeks vacation. He responded to questions on issues like the coming appointment of anew Federal Reserve chairman, the carrying out of his health care law, his relationship withPresident Vladimir V. Putin of Russia, and the current status of Al Qaeda. But he began witha lengthy statement about surveillance, and that was the focus of the nearly hourlong news

conference.

Critics of the electronic spying brought to light by Mr. Snowdens leaks said the presidentsapproach was insufficient. Anthony D. Romero, the executive director of the American CivilLiberties Union, said that a program that collects records of every domestic phone callwhich Mr. Obama made clear he intends to keep must be shut down.

Whats clear is that these surveillance programs have gone much further than the presidentor Congress have ever admitted, Mr. Romero said. These initial recommendations fromObama today, albeit welcome, are too little too late. They are not sufficient to address seriousconcerns about possible violations of the law and about dragnet surveillance.

A spokesman for Speaker John A. Boehner, Republican of Ohio, urged Mr. Obama not to letsuch criticism undermine the N.S.A.s fundamental capabilities.

Transparency is important, but we expect the White House to insist that no reform willcompromise the operational integrity of the program, said the spokesman, Brendan Buck.That must be the presidents red line, and he must enforce it. Our priority should continue to

be saving American lives, not saving face.

A clear theme of Mr. Obamas remarks was that he believed that the publics understandingof the surveillance programs had been distorted. He portrayed some of Mr. Snowdens leaksas having been reported in the most sensationalized manner possible and parceled out tomaximize attention in dribs and in drabs, sometimes coming out sideways. The result has

been misimpressions not merely among the American public, he said, but around the worlda reference to the widespread international criticism of the United States over reports of itssurveillance policies.

If you are the ordinary person and you start seeing a bunch of headlines saying U.S. BigBrother looking down on you, collecting telephone records, etc., well, understandably peoplewould be concerned, he said, while also addressing some of his reassurances to thoseabroad.

To others around the world, I want to make clear once again that America is not interested inspying on ordinary people, he said. Our intelligence is focused above all on finding theinformation thats necessary to protect our people and, in many cases, protect our allies. Itstrue we have significant capabilities. Whats also true is we show a restraint that manygovernments around the world dont even think to do.

In an effort to rebuild public trust, Mr. Obama said he wanted to work with Congress tomodify the phone log program, but in what he said would be an appropriate way. He listedas examples of those steps establishing more oversight and auditing how the database is used.

The president also threw his support behind a proposal to change the procedures of the secretcourt that approves electronic spying under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, saying
http://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381829/obama-on-the-federal-reserves-future.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381829/obama-on-the-federal-reserves-future.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381829/obama-on-the-federal-reserves-future.html


4/4

an adversarial lawyer should make arguments opposing the Justice Department when thecourt is considering whether to approve broad surveillance programs. The administration alsoreleased a22-page unclassified white paperexplaining in greater detail why thegovernment believes that its bulk collection of domestic phone logs is lawful. At the sametime, the N.S.A. released aseven-page paper outliningits role and authorities. The agency is

creating a full-time civil liberties and privacy officer, Mr. Obama said, and next week it willopen a Web site designed to explain itself better to the public.

We can and must be more transparent, Mr. Obama said.

In addition, Mr. Obama announced the creation of a task force that will include outsideintelligence specialists and civil liberties advocates to advise the government about how to

balance security and privacy as improving computer technology makes it possible to gatherever more information about peoples private lives.

In response to a reporters question, Mr. Obama obliquely acknowledged the terrorism alert

in the Middle East that in recent days has prompted thewithdrawals of embassy staffmembersin Yemen and other countries. He was asked how to square the apparent threat fromAl Qaeda with his previous portrayals of the core of the group as severely weakened.

Mr. Obama said that the original Al Qaedathe tightly organized, hierarchical group thatwas capable of spectacular homeland attacks like the ones on Sept. 11, 2001 was indeeddecimated. But its regional affiliates still pose a destabilizing and disruptive threat on thescale of potentially driving a truck bomb into an embassy wall, he said.

Weve got to continue to be vigilant and go after known terrorists who are potentiallycarrying out plots, he said, adding: This is an ongoing process. We are not going tocompletely eliminate terrorism. What we can do is to weaken it and to strengthen our

partnerships in such a way that it does not pose the kind of horrible threat that we saw on9/11.

The news conference also dwelled on Mr. Snowdens obtaining temporary refugee status inRussia, and thecooling relationshipwith the Putin government over that and several otherissues, including the conflict in Syria and Russias crackdown on gay rights. Earlier in theweek, Mr. Obama canceled a planned summit meeting with Mr. Putin in Moscow.

While Mr. Obama said he opposed calls to boycott the 2014 Winter Olympics in Russia, he

acknowledged emerging differences with his Russian counterpart.

Asked whether the steps on surveillance he was taking amounted to a vindication of Mr.Snowdens leaks, Mr. Obama rejected that notion. He said that M r. Snowden should havegone to the Congressional intelligence committees with any concerns he had aboutsurveillance, rather than putting at risk our national security and some very vital ways thatwe are able to get intelligence that we need to secure the country.

I dont think Mr. Snowden was a patriot, Mr. Obama said.
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p1http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p1http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p1http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p1http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p24http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p24http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p24http://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381875/obama-on-embassy-closures-and-drones.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381875/obama-on-embassy-closures-and-drones.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381875/obama-on-embassy-closures-and-drones.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381875/obama-on-embassy-closures-and-drones.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381810/obama-on-putin-snowden-and-the-olympics.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381810/obama-on-putin-snowden-and-the-olympics.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381810/obama-on-putin-snowden-and-the-olympics.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381810/obama-on-putin-snowden-and-the-olympics.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381875/obama-on-embassy-closures-and-drones.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/video/2013/08/09/us/politics/100000002381875/obama-on-embassy-closures-and-drones.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p24http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/08/10/us/politics/10obama-surveillance-documents.html?hp#document/p1

a woman on her bicycle pulled over in greenpoint

Documents