a noble noose of methods academia

Upload: rdsmayer

Post on 02-Jun-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    1/53

    OSTERREICHISCHE AKADEMIE DER WISSENSCHAFTENPHILOSOPHISCH-HISTORISCI{E KLAS SE

    DENKSCHRIFTEN, 449.8 AND

    CATHY CA}.{TWELL, ROBERT MAYER

    A h{cble Noose of }rlethods,The Lotus Garland Synopsis:

    A Mahayoga Tantra and its Commentary

    oste rre c n i u. r,"

    n [*[ii3 g?lder Wissenschaften

    ffiAW

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    2/53

    !"#$% !"'#()**+ ,-.),# /"%),

    " '0123 '0043 05 /367084+ 673 *0694 :;?=0@4A4B" /;7 ?0C; #;=6

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    3/53

    !"#$%%$&'(&"'($ *+*,$-&$ ,$% .&" "$/ "'(*0 #$/1(&23"31(&"'( 4(&"#3%&"'($ +2*""$

    ,$/+"'(%&0#$/ 566789*/ ,

    9:;?: @A= +AB

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    4/53

    !"#$%%$&'(&"'($ *+*,$-&$ ,$% .&" "$/ "'(*0 #$/1(&23"31(&"'( 4(&"#3%&"'($ +2*""$

    ,$/+"'(%&0#$/ 566789*/,

    '*#(: '*/#.$225 %39$%# -*:$%

    * /; /;;?> ;@ ->AB;C?5#B> 2;AD? EFG=FHC "IH;J?K?L

    * -FB I;MF #FHAGF FHC KA? ';NN>HAFGI

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    5/53

    !"#$%&%$' )"* +, -, ./012 12.304.550./ 6* 7%# 16'89*$ :; 9*6 ?@

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    6/53

    ! "#$% '( ) '*!%*!+

    "#$%&'()*+,)%-. /00

    1&-) &% 234%.(0-)34-0&% &5 206)-4% 07

    "663)/04-0&%. 4%* 80.- &5 90+(4 :.)* 0% -;) 4%* -;)03 90+%050#4%#) ?

    2;) @&%-)%-. &5 -;) !"#$% '"#(% 4%* -;)03 90+%050#4%#) 5&3 -;) A0.-&30#4( 9-:*B

    &5 -;) 31B0%+ ,4 C4 D

    2;) E:%;:4%+ F4%:.#30C- 4. 4 /4(:46() .&:3#) 53&, -;) G20,) &5 H34+,)%-.G I

    " 9:,,43B &5 -;) 94(0)%- J&0%-. &5 &:3 '&3$ &% -;) !"#$% '"#(% 2)7-:4( 234*0-0&% ?K

    F)-;&*&(&+0#4( =..:). 0% -;) 9-:*B &5 -;) !"#$% '"#(% 2)7-:4( 234%.,0..0&%. ?D

    2;) "%#0)%- 24%-34 @&(()#-0&% L1MNO ?P

    2)7-:4( Q6.#:30-B 4%* 9#3064( @&33:C-0&% 0% -;) )7-4%- "%#0)%- 24%-34 @&(()#-0&% ?R

    =%#3)4.0%+ -;) :.460(0-B &5 -;) "%#0)%- 24%-34 @&(()#-0&% -)7-. ?I

    A&' *& ') )*0- "%#0)%- 24%-34 @&(()#-0&% -)7-.S @4% ') .-),,4-0.) -;),S

    A&' *& ') 4##&:%- 5&3 -;)03 /4304-0&%.S ?T@&%#(:*0%+ U)5()#-0&%. &% -;) /4304-0&%. 0%!) VK

    !56.278 "-789:4:

    4O 2;)

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    7/53

    !"#$% '( )'*+%*+, -.

    !"#$%&'(#)%" #% #+, -&)#)%".%/ #+, !"#$%& ($ )#$*& +,- .#$%& ($ ($/ 0$ !(#123% %- /43 *&/5& ($ 0"& )#. 1%22,"#0$3 //

    !0% 12%,%*+"+.'* '( +0% )2.+.3"$ 45.+.'* '( !" 677

    !0% 12%,%*+"+.'* '( +0% 45.+.'* '( !"#$%% 676

    1$)#)(04 -&)#)%" %/ #+, 5%%# 6,7# 8 67 9:6+, !"#$%& ($ )#$*& +,- .#$%& ($ ($/ 0$ !(#123% %- /43 *&/5& ($ 678

    -&)#)%" %/ #+, 1%22,"#0$3 8 678400 9:6+, !"#$%& ($ )#$*& +,- .#$%& ($ ($/ 0$ !(#123% %- /43 *&/5& ($!- !%129 ($ 99/

    ;2"+0(;$

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    8/53

    "##

    ! "#$%&'()*+($,-

    &/ 01/ /231/4/56 7103/895 3: 3;/ !13> 0?@ A940?B3B/> C/>/01D; ":9?DB5 E!AC"FG H;: >:7/?/1:9>56 I1:JB@/@ 3;/ 89?@B?7 3;03 /?0K5/@ K:3; :8 9> 3: >I/?@ 0 8955 L9013/1 :8 :91 H:1MB?7 3B4/ /0D;G

    K/3H//? NOOP 0?@ NOQOG B? I91>9B?7 3;/ 1/>/01D; 8:1 3;B> K::MR &/ 01/ /L90556 7103/895 8:1 3;/ I03B/?D/G7/?/1:>B36G 0?@ B?3/55/D3905 B?>IB103B:? :8 :91 40?6 D:55/079/> 0?@ 81B/?@> 03 %28:1@ 3B393/G H;: ;0J/ K//? >: 9?80B5B?756 >9II:13BJ/ :8 055 :91 /88:13> >B?D/ :91 011BJ053;/1/ B? NOONR &/ H:95@ 05>: 5BM/ 3: 3;0?M 3;/ T:;? U/55 %28:1@ :8 310?>5B3/103/@ ,BK/30? B?3:,BK/30? >D1BI3G 0?@ >:4/ 0@@B3B:?05 D:5503B:? B? 3;/ I1:D/>> :8 103B:?05B>B?7 3;/ I1/>/?303B:? :8 3;/ 1::3 3/23/@B3B:?R S? 3;/ /0156 4:?3;> :8 3;/ I1:W/D3G 3;/ S?3/1?03B:?05 ,19>3 8:1 ,10@B3B:?05 +/@BDB?/ B? #05B4I:?7;/5I/@ HB3; @030 B?I93 81:4 3;/ *:5@/? ,/?W91 /@B3B:? :8 3;/ D:44/?3016R

    -:4/ >/D3B:?> :8 3;/ K::M K/70? 5B8/ 0> D:?8/1/?D/ I0I/1>G 7BJ/? B? X/1M/5/6G Y0?D:9J/1G -0?30 X01K010G!350?30G ':?@:?G X:?? 0?@ '94KB?BG H;B5/ :3;/1 >/D3B:?> >3013/@ 5B8/ 0> B?JB3/@ 79/>3 5/D391/> @/5BJ/1/@ 03

    3;/

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    9/53

    "###

    !"#$% ()%*+) *, )*-& -".%"$) ,#*- ./%) (*$0-& /"(& 1&&+ 201$%)/&3 2#&(%*0)$45 6 2#&70#)*# .* ./&)&7.%*+ 1&$*8 &+.%.$&3 9:&./*3*$*;%7"$ %))0&) %+ ./& ).034 *, ./&!"#$% '"#(% 8")

    201$%)/&3 %+ ./& ?@6 8%./ #&;"#3) .* 8/%7/ 8& -0). ./"+H "+ "+*+4-*0) 2&(%&8 8/* *,,&3 0)&,0$ 7*--&+.)5 I./ &"#$% ."H&) *+ -".%"$) ./". +*8 7*+.#%10.& .* ./%) 1**H"22&"#&3 %+ ./& I "+3 %+ ./& (*$0-&!)$*+#, -)+.#/ &3%.&3 14 ?*)M C"1&NO+ BC"+.8&$$ "+3 :"4 DELE"G5

    P& ./"+H ./& Q#%.%)/ R%1#"#4 ,*# 2-%))%*+ .* 3%).#%10.& ./&%# %-";&) *, ./& J0+/0"+; -"+0)7#%2. @IR 8/%7/ )/*0$3 &+"1$& #&"3) )8%,.$4 .* 7*+)0$. ./%) %-2*#."+. 8%.+&)) *, ./&7*--&+."#%"$ .&=.5

    T%+"$$4> 8& -0). "7H+*8$&3;& ./". 8/".&( )/*#.7*-%+;) ./& -%;/. 1& %+ ./%) (*$0-& "#& 8%./*0.&=7&2.%*+ ./& #&)0$. *, *0# *8+ ,"%$%+;)> "+3 ,*# ./%) 8& #&U0&). *0# #&"3)V ,*#1&"#"+7&5

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    10/53

    "#

    ! "#$ "! # &'!()*#$&'#*"! "+ # *,$#'!

    !"#$%&'()"#('*$ *, !'-)(#$ '$ (.'% /*"0 1*$,*"2% (* (.) '$()"$#('*$#&&3 /'4)&3 5%)4 %3%()2 *,()$ "),)"")4(* #% 63&') 7*$8)$('*$%9: #&(.*5;. /) 4* $*( 5%) (.) %'$;&) 1*$("'-5('*$ /.'1. 63&') .4-?"4,, 9R"5S)&&)% Q T$'*$ #1#4U2'V5) '$()"$#('*$#&)B=

    6) .#8) $*( $))4)4 (* 5%) !#0)51.'W% 1*2

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    11/53

    "!" $%&" %'() %**"* )+" ,-./$". 0)+&"+/1)+2

    # $%&'()&*'+ ,-&.*-'*/$& ('%01 2)&)%'++3 ('%0/&2 ' 4).*/$& )&5/&2 '&5 &)6 $,)&/&21 '&57'%3/&2 /& 5)4/2& 8%$( *6$ +'%2) 7)%*/.'++3 '%%'&2)5 ./%.+)4 *$ *6$ 5$*49

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    12/53

    "#

    !""#$%&!'&()* !), -&*' (. *&/-! 0*$, &) '1$ $ ,&'&()*

    !"#$%&"$%' '") *$$+, -) %.) '") /0&1232.)4 -$#4, 5/06%#, 7$# !2*)'/0 !"#$ $&'() , /04 !)06%#, 7$# !2*)'/0!*+#, $&'() 8

    9**#):2/'2$0. %.)4 /#); 7$# )-'.,& /#$. )&'(0 $!(/ ?9032)0' !/0'#/ @$11)3'2$0A 1234 7$# 1#, ,& 5+# 34)6,& 27 7$#$84#&* 3# 24#!* "'. 94#&* 3# 3#0/# $34)6,& &. 0:, !*0(* 3# 27;:// 7$#$84#&* 3# 24#!* "'. 94#&* 3# 3#0/# $34)6,& &. 0:, !*0(* 3#$. $&)65 3#

    B) 7$11$- '$ .$C) )D')0' '") .2&1/ ).'/*12.")4 *E F/##2.$0 /04 G2C)# ?HIIJA 7$# '") )42'2$0. $7 '")5/06%# /04 !)06%#8 !"2. 2. C$4272)4 *)3/%.) .$C) $7 '") 1)'')#. 7#$C '")2# 12.'. -)#) /1#)/4E %.)4 *E $%# 12.'7$# ')D'.8 K203) '") 24#!* 94#&* #$$' ')D' 2. 7$%04 20 *$'" '") /04 / 0%C*)# $7 5/06%#., /04 2'.3$CC)0'/#E 2. 7$%04 20 '"#)) !)06%#., /. -)11 /. *)20& #)L#).)0')4 20 / M%0"%/0& 4$3%C)0', 2' .))C)4 C$.'.'#/2&"'7$#-/#4 '$ N%/127E '") .2&1/ -2'" / 1$-)# 3/.) 1)'')#, +, 7$# 5/06%# ')D'., /04 ', 7$# !)06%# ')D'., -")0

    '")#) C2&"' $'")#-2.) *) 3$07%.2$08 !"%., M .'/04. 7$# '") .M) 4&) , /04 M+ 7$# '") .M) 4&) 5/06%#,-"21) O+ .'/04. 7$# '") P)+20& 5/06%#, /04 O' 7$# '") P)+20& !)06%#8 Q)3)0' -$#+ $0 1$3/1 5/06%#. "/. /1.$).'/*12.")4 '") L#2032L1) $7 %.20& C$#) '"/0 $0) 1)'')# 7$# '").) 7%#'")# )42'2$0., /04 '"%., -) 7$11$- F)1C%'G2C)# 20 %.20& R&1 7$# '") !/-/0& 5/06%# 7#$C R #&E/0 &120&, /04 >'" ?%.)4 )/#12)# 20 S23"/)1T2CC)#C/00U. -$#+ $0 '") 2#+4 +#)!4#* +)#A 7$# '") >/'"/0& 5/06%# ")14 20 '")

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    13/53

    "##

    ! # $%&'($& )*(+ ,-./ #

    - # &-(0+ &120+ ) ,-. 3-4( 5& 6&27 89* &-(0+ &120+ ( ,-.:/ # -* # 7-*( $27 *1&2 ,-./ #

    % # +%50+ &;7?50 ,-./ # @ # @(1'$(076 ,-./ # .1' # .(1'(0+ @(0A6*/ #

    B2 # B2$5&/ #

    C+D # %(E(0+ C*+

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    14/53

    !"#$%&'(#!%"

    !*+,-./01*2 +34 #45+/67 8-/,049: 6*. +341, 812*1;106*04!"#$ &'()*+ ,+-,+$+./$ /"+ ')/0'*+ '1 2 ,+$+2,0" -,'3+0/ '. 2 12*')$ ,45#.6 *2 72" 5'62 ,''/ /2./,28

    /"+ !"#$%& ($ )#$*& +,- .#$%& ($ ($/0$ !(#123% %- /43 *&/5& ($ 9"+,+21/+, 2::,+/+; 2$ )6 !"+ $),.6 $'),0+$ "2&+ (+1/ )$ .' 0(+2,(5 +$/2:(#$"+; ?2.$@,#/ /#/(+$8 A :)/ =+ /,2.$(2/+ /"+!#:+/2. /#/(+ '1 /"+ ,''/ /+B/ 2$ 7 84*92 844&2 4: ;2 M', .'=8 =+ *)$/ /2(@ '1 2 G")/2.+$+ :,2.0" #. 1',/5N$#B &'()*+$8 =#/"1'), 2&2#(2:(+ *2.)$0,#-/ &+,$#'.$8 2(( ,/)2((5 #;+./#02( /' '.+ 2.'/"+,g 2. X2$/+,. :,2.0" #. /=+./5N$#B &'()*+$8 $' 12,,+-,+$+./+; '.(5 :5 /"+ 0'.1(2/+; $#.6(+ =#/.+$$ $O+ ;6+ B5('6,2-" +;#/#'.g 2.; 2 ?')/" E+./,2( !#:+/2. :,2.0" =#/" /='$):;#$#'.$8 ,+-,+$+./+; :5 1'), 2&2#(2:(+ 0'*-(+/+ *2.)$0,#-/ &+,$#'.$8 /=' =#/" /"#,/5N/",++ &'()*+$ 2.; /=' =#/" /"#,/5N$+&+. &'()*+$> \#6 W;h#. 2.; 6!#.6 $@5+$ "2; /"#,/5N/",++ &'()*+$g 4):,# 2.; I2/"*2.;) "2; /"#,/5N$+&+. &'()*+$> ?++E2./=+(( 2.; 725+, HQQ^Y AA8 AbNA]>

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    15/53

    !"#$%&'(#)%" *

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

    L 5% ,9 /, (%88/(#)%".- F (%36 %4 #1/ N/=)"0 ?/"W'$

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    16/53

    !"# !#%&'() *+',-#. (/0 &"#1, *12/131-(/-# 4

    5'-" 6,1+, (7(,#/#.. +3 1&. #%1./-#8 9#& +/# 31/0. -1&(&1+/. 3,+5 !"#$%% 1/ &"# 7+,:. +3 .#;#,() #(,)- 5=-+3 ,?6 *=-(3 >- 9-3 H= 71&"+'& .6#-13

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    17/53

    !"#$%&'(#)%" *

    &,)#),- )- ." .&./#.#)%" %0 #1, #1)$#23-,4," &,)#2 5. .6. %0 #1, !"#$"%"%& '"%"%"%%$"(" '#"&" #1.# )- -% 7.-)( #% 8%9.#."#$.: 7'# )" )* : #1, 5.6, ."& 0,5.6, 0)9'$,- .$, "%; /.)$,& #%9,#1,$ .- (%"-%$#-: ."& ."'57,$ %0 0'$#1,$ 0,5.6, &,)#),- .$, .&&,& #% (%5/6,#, #1, -,#< =1, (,"#$.6 5.6, &,)#2 %0 #1, ;$.#10'65. .6. )- . 0,$%()%'- 0%$5 %0 $ >,$'?. ;)#1 ")", 1,.&- ."& ,)91#,," .$5-: @ 7'# ;, 1.4, "%# 2,# )&,"#)0),&

    #1)- ,A.(# 0%$5 )" 6.#,$ -%'$(,-< B,4,$#1,6,--: 4,$2 -)5)6.$ ."& (6,.$62 $,6.#,& 0%$5- %0 $ >,$'?. %$ C.1 $ >,$'?. &% -#)66 %(('$ ;)&,62 .- #1, (,"#$.6 0)9'$,- )" #1, ;$.#10'6 5. .6.- %0 -,4,$.6 )5/%$#."# ,A#."#$B2)"9 5. /. (2(6,-: -'(1 .- #1, )(&+'( -&./ 012( 3" ."& #1, (4#25 3" 56"0 5#'7"1 (2(6,-: %$ )" $%%# #."#$.-%'$(,- -'(1 .- #1, #4721 '("/' 5"08 (/78/' 3+

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    18/53

    !"# !#%&'() *+',-#. (/0 &"#1, *12/131-(/-# 4

    !"# #510#/-# +3 !"#$%% .'22#.&. &"(& 1/ (0+6&1/2 .'-" (/ +'&)++7 1/ "1. &'($)* ,-./0 %.1 *23 8 9"1-" :#-(;# .+ 0#31/1&15# 3+, ;'-" +3 &"# )(, ,)+/2 -"#/ 6( 9(. /+& 1//+5(&1/2? +/ &"# -+/&,(,=8.'-" 1/,6,#&(&1+/. 9#,# -',,#/& 315# "'/0,#0 =#(,. :#3+,# "1. &1;#@

    A/# #%(;6)# +3 "+9 .'-" 1/,1+,1.(&1+/ 9+,7. 1/ !"#$%% 1. &"# 0#.-,16&1+/ +3 #;6+9#,;#/& ,1.3+'/0 1/ 1&. B"(6, !",##@ C.'())=8 #;6+9#,;#/&. (,# 0#.-,1:#0 1/ ,;. +3 -+;6)#% ,1&'() 6,+-#0',#.'.1/2 5(,1+'. 1;6)#;#/&.@ D'& "#,#8 1/ &"# 5#,.# -1 3,+; &"# ,++& %&8 E(1,+-(/( .(=. &+ E(F,(.(&&5(8G45267 8201)9 2%:$;25%217* 652 $,76012< 7'5$.)' 7'2 2=:52**0>2 :$;25 $? $12/* $;1 011672 6;65212** @G HI !"# &1/= ;(,21/() /+. 1/ &"# J'/"'(/2 ;(/'.-,16& +3 !"#$%% +:.#,5#8 G @%:$;25%217 -61 ,2 $,760122 :$;25 $?6;65212** @GH4 !"#$%% 1&.#)3 #%6)(1/.8 GE'21 $12 0* 6;652 $? 7'2 *6%212** $? 633

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    19/53

    !"#$%&'(#)%" *

    ,-./ 0/11 213%, 45678 9:;96< =134 #% /=1& 3)>=# %" #=1 4$1;=)/#%$. %? #=1 $@.)"> A- #$-&)#)%"5 !" 4-$#)('3-$8#=1. A-B1 )# '"-A2)>'%'/3. (31-$ #=-# #=1 !"#$% '"#(% 3)#1$-#'$1 ,-/ /11" 2. #=1 -""%#-#%$ -/ /41()?)(-33.-//%()-#1& ,)#= C-&A-/-A2=-D-5 E1 (-" %"3. 1/#)A-#1 #=-# #=1. ,1$1 (%4)1& )"#% #=1 F'"='-">A-"'/($)4# GH )" #=1 A)& #% 3-#1 #1"#= (1"#'$.8 2'# #=1 &-#)"> %? F'"='-"> #1I#/ $1A-)"/ #%% 4$)A)#)D1 #%

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

    Q%,1D1$8 )# )/ ,%$#= 4%)"#)"> %'# #=-# #=1$1 -$1 /%A1 '"(1$#-)"#)1/ )" #=1 1I-(# 3)/# %? &1)#)1/ )" -33/'$D)D)"> D1$/)%"/ %? #=1 #1I#/5 !) /11A/ #% =-D1 /%A1 )"(%"/)/#1"()1/ 21#,11" )#/ A-"#$- 3)/# ?%$ #=1

    41-(1?'3 &1)#)1/ )" R=-4#1$ 98 -"& )#/ A'&$ 3)/# )" R=-4#1$ MH8 ,=)(= A%$1%D1$8 -441-$/ "%# #% 21 1"#)$13.(%A431#1 "%$ )" #=1 A%/# 3%>)(-3 %$&1$ #=$%'>=%'#5!)*+,, #% /%A1 1I#1"# ?)33/ )" #=1 >-4/ )" #=1 &1)#. 3)/#/81/41()-33. )" R=-4#1$ 7 ?%$ #=1 41-(1?'3 A- -3- -"& )" R=-4#1$/ MG -"& MS ?%$ #=1 ,$-#=?'3 A- -3-5 T1# )#-3/% -&&/ /3)>=#3. #% #=1 (%"?'/)%"8 /'>>1/#)"> /%A1 "-A1/ ?%$ #=1 41-(1?'3 &1)#)1/ ,=)(= /11A -# %&&/ #%#=%/1 >)D1" )" #=1 A-"#$- -"&U%$ A'&$ 3)/#/8 -"& /11A)"> #% )"#$%&'(1 - ?1, ?'$#=1$ )"(%"/)/#1"()1/ %? )#/%," 0/11 #=1 V441"&)I 213%, ?%$ #-231/ %? #=1 4$)"()4-3 &1)#)1/ D1$/)%"/8!)*+,, W/R=-4#1$ MS8 ,=)(= /41()?)1/ #=1 ?1A-31 &1)#)1/ %? #=1 ,$-#=?'3 A- -3-8 -441-$/ #% 21 $-#=1$ (%$$'4# )" 4-$#/8-"& )"(3'&1/ ?'$#=1$ ?1A-31 &1)#)1/ ,)#=%'# /41()?.)"> X')#1 =%, #=1. ?)# ,)#= #=%/1 4$1/'A1& #% 21 #=1 A-)"/1# 0-//'A)"> #=-# #=1 '/'-3 (%"/%$#/ -"& ?1A-31 -##1"&-"#/ %? #=1 #1" E$-#=?'3 F1)#)1/ Y -".+ $+ $/0 Z -$1)"#1"&1& #% (%"/#)#'#1 #=1 4$)"()4-3 ,$-#=?'3 ?1A-31/8 -" -//'A4#)%" (%"/)/#1"# ,)#= R=-4#1$ MGW/ 3)/# %? #=1A-31 &1)#)1/=# 21 #=1/1 '"(1$#-)"#)1/ -"& (%$$'4#)%"/ )" #=1 #1I#/ )"=1$)#1& 2. #=1 #$-&)#)%"5GG

    !"# %&'"&(') *('&+,-./0 (+ ( 1(2&(32# +4&-,# 5-46 0"# 7!.6# 45 8-()6#'0+7C1$=-4/ "%,=1$1 )" #=1 N'&&=)/# ,%$3& &% X'1/#)%"/ %? #=1 4$%&'(#)%" -"& $1(14#)%" %? #1I#/8 %? #1I#'-3

    -"& ('3#'$-3 #$-"/3-#)%"8 -"& %? #=1 =)/#%$)(-3 #$-"/A)//)%" %? N'&&=)/A -($%// #)A1 -"& 43-(18 -441-$ /%?-/()"-#)"> .1# A%$1 %2/('$1 -"& 31// '"&1$/#%%&8 #=-" )" #=1 %((-/)%" %? #=1 1-$3. #$-"/A)//)%" %? L-"#$)(N'&&=)/A #% L)21#5 L=)/ )/ 21(-'/1 ?%$ - ($'()-3 41$)%& %? %"1 ='"&$1& -"& ?)?#. .1-$/8 ?$%A #=1 A)&;")"#= #%#=1 /#-$# %? #=1 131D1"#= (1"#'$.8 A'(= %? #=1 L)21#-" =)/#%$)(-3 $1(%$& ,-/ %23)#1$-#1&8 ,)#=)" - 41$)%& %?()D)3 ,-$ -"& #=1 (%33-4/1 %? #=1 L)21#-" /#-#15

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

    GH E1 4$1/1"# 1D)&1"(1 213%, 0/11 45 SG;SS< ,=)(= /'>>1/#/ #=-# #=1. ,1$1 (%4)1& ?$%A - 4$1D)%'/ 1I1A43-$5GM L=)/ )/ 21(-'/1 #=1 F'"='-"> D1$/)%" -3$1-&. )"(%$4%$-#1/ )"&)(-#)D1 /($)2-3 1$$%$/ /=-$1& 2. #=1 L/=-3 4- ]-"P'$ -"&

    N='#-"1/1 @ON D1$/)%"/8 2'# -D%)&1& 2. #=1 #1I#/ %? #=1 _%'#= R1"#$-3 @ON -"& #=1 3%(-3 ]-"P'$/ 0/11 L1I#'-3 V"-3./)/8_1(#)%"3 213%,8 1/41()-33. 45:H;:` A-"'/($)4#8 -"& #=1 3%(-3 ]-"P'$ D1$/)%"/ #=-# %$)>)"-#1 ?$%A /'(= ?-$ ?3'"> $1>)%"/ %? L)21#5!) W/ #1I#'-3 4$%231A/ A)>=# =-D1 /11A1& 1D1" A%$1 )"#$-(#-231 )" #=1 4-/#8 21?%$1 /'(= #1(="%3%>)1/ 1I)/#1&5

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    20/53

    !"# !#%&'() *+',-#. (/0 &"#1, *12/131-(/-# 4

    5(6 &"#6 "(/0)#0 .+7# +3 &"# -+/&,+8#,.1#. 3+))+51/2 &"# 1/&,+0'-&1+/ +3 &"# 3+,#12/ ,#)121+/ &+ !19#&: ;#&(3, &"# 7101,#. +3 &"# !(/2= &"# ?12"',. (/0 &"# !19#&(/..17')&(/#+'.)6 .'33#,#0 >+)1&1-() -()(71&6= +', "1.&+,1-() ,#-+,0 1/ !19#& 9#-+7#. 7'-" &"1//#,: !19#& #/,.1&. /+&+,1+'. @&17# +3 3,(27#/&.@ A !"# %&'" (&!B C (/0 3+, (,+'/0 +/# "'/0,#0 (/0 313&6 6#(,. 5# D/+5 8#,6

    )1&&)# (9+'& 5"(& 5#/& +/:

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

    O& (>>#(,. &"(& (,2'(9)6 &"# 7+.& .12/131-(/& &,(/.3+,7(&1+/. 1/ !19#&(/ "1.&+,6 +--',,#0 51&"1/ ( +/#"'/0,#0 (/0 313&6 6#(, >#,1+0 3+, 5"1-" 5# "(8# +/)6 &"# .)#/0#,#.& ,#-+,0 +3 #8#/&.: S+,#+8#,= &"#&,(/.3+,7(&1+/. +3 &"1. >#,1+0 #.&(9)1."#0 3'/0(7#/&() -')&',() >(&,/. +3 2,#(& 17>+,&(/-# &"(& .&1)) >#,.1.&M&"1. 5(. &,')6 ( 3+,7(&18# >#,1+0 1/ !19#&(/ "1.&+,6= +'& +3 5"1-" -(7# &"# "12")6 1/3)'#/&1() ,T61/2 7( +,

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

    QW !"1. >+1/& >+1/& 1. 7(0# 8#,6 -)#(,)6 96 P`,

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    21/53

    !"#$%&'(#)%" *

    ,-. ./)&."(. 0%'"& 1% 02$ 1'33.1#1 #-2# ./." #-%'3- 1'(- ! " #$!%41#56. #.7#1 &)& .7)1# )" !"&)2 2# #-. #)8. %09-$) :$%"3 6;.I. -2/. 6)##6. &)$.(# ./)&."(. 0%$ #-)1H ='# #-.

    J%11)=)6)#5 (2""%# =. &)1(%'"#.&GH %$H 8%$. (.$#2)"65H )" #-. -'"&$.& 2"& 0)0#5 5.2$1 20#.$ #-. 0266 %0 .8J)$.H0%$ I-)(- I. -2/. J6."#)0'6 ./)&."(. 0$%8 ;'"-'2"3F ,-)1 8.2"1 )# 2(#'2665 %(('$.& 20#.$ #-. &'(% *%+ 21 J%J'62$65 &.0)".&H ='# =.0%$. #-. ",-$ *%+ 21 J%J'62$65 &.0)".&F ,-. $K5)"3 82 #2"#$2:2"N).G ]%"21#.$5F T%"3 ^)"N)2"3$.J%$#1 #-2# )" #-. #."#- (."#'$5H 2 8%"O %0 #-)1 8%"21#.$5 "28.& ;2%_-." (%66.(#.& (%"1)&.$2=6. 2&&)#)%"1#% -)1 8%"21#.$5;'&N%8 CAACB [@\4[CDGF

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    22/53

    !"# !#%&'() *+',-#. (/0 &"#1, *12/131-(/-# 4

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

    7#,1+0 1. 6(0# -)#(, 1/ &"# -+/&,15'&1+/. &+ &"# .(6# 9+)'6# +3 X'/&,(6 J(C+0: K!"# Y)'/0#,1/2 B3 !"# !15#&(/ Z+8()!+65.T U/ U/()8.1. +3 &"# S9#/& 1/ &"# D+/%& +3 &"# [7,1.1/2. 1/ D#/&,() !15#& +3 &"# 4&"\MP&" D#/&',8K: (/0 +3 U68J#))#,: KB5.#,9(&1+/. +/ Y(1/ D+331/ Y(/#). 3,+6 !15#&(/ !+65.K> U 6+,# -+67,#"#/.19# ,#91#= -(/ 5# 3+'/0 1/ &"# Y"@01..#,&(&1+/ +3 !(+ !+/2 EPPN>

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    23/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- #&./-0+ 1)/0+2 )* )$' 3)'4 )0 +,- !"#$% '"#(% 5-6+$&. 5'&7/+/)0

    !"#$%& $(#)%"*+ ,- %./ %/0%)12 31#"1*%$ ,- %./ %4/*%+5,*/ 6"--/#/*% 3/#$",*$ ,-!" 4/ (,*$)2%/6 /07,$/6 -,)#6"$%"*(%"3/ %/0%)12 8#,)7"*8$ 1*6 -,)# )*"9)/ $"*82/ 4"%*/$$/$:;*/ ,- %./ %/0%)12 8#,)7"*8$& 1*6 %.#// ,- %./ $"*82/ 4"%*/$$/$& 6/$(/*6 )*7#,

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    24/53

    !"#$%&' )*$&'+ *& ',%!"#$% '"#(% -%.'/"# -0"1$'$*& 22

    ',% ,$+'*0$3"# "&1 "#+* 4$4#$*50"6,$3"# $76#$3"'$*&+ *8 ',% $&'%0&"# %9$1%&3%: ;,$3, &*; +,*;+ ',"' " #%++? 1%0$9%1 80*7

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

    6"++"5%+ *8!*+,-- 3*&+'$'/'%1 ',% #%77"'" "33*/&' 8*0 "## +$5&$8$3"&' 0%3%&+$*&"# 1$88%0%&3%+ 4%';%%&',%+% ',0%% 3/00%&'#@ 6*6/#"0 9%0+$*&+ *8!* E R$0'/"##@ "## *',%0 9"0$"'$*&+ "0% '0"&+7$++$*&"# $& &"'/0%:

    6/0%#@ +30$4"# %00*0+ "88#$3'$&5 *&% 9%0+$*& *0 ',% *',%0: *0 7$&*0 +6%##$&5 3*00%3'$*&+ "&1 +* 8*0O/0',%07*0%: "#',*/5, ;% ,"9% 4%%& "4#% '* 3*&3#/1% ',0*/5, +'%77"'$3 "&"#@+$+ ',"' $' $+ ',% !*/', F%&'0"#

    =>? "&1 ',0%% #*3"# A"&B/0 0%3%&+$*&+ ;,$3, "33/0"'%#@ 0%8#%3' ',% *0$5$&"# 4*/&1"0$%+ *8!* : $' ;*/#1 ,"9% 4%%& ,"01 *0 $76*++$4#% '* "1B/1$3"'% 4%';%%& ',% 1$88%0%&' 0%3%&+$*&+ $& ',$+ ;"@ ;$',*/' +'%77"'$3"&"#@+$+N ;%0% $' &*' 8*0 +'%77"'$3+: ',% 1$88%0%&' 0%3%&+$*&+ *8!* ;*/#1 "## *+'%&+$4#@ *88%0 %S/"##@ 5**1 *0

    4"1 3#"$7+E Q%' +/3, /&0%+*#9"4#% $&1%'%07$&"3@ $& $'+%#8 *88%0+ " 9"#/"4#% 3#/% '* /&1%0+'"&1$&5 ',% 7"&&%0$& ;,$3, ',% 0=@$&5 7" '%.'/"# '0"1$'$*& ,"+ %.$+'%1 *9%0 ',% 3%&'/0$%+: "&1 ,*; $' 3"& "33*77*1"'% "3%0'"$& #%9%# *8 9"0$"'$*& ;$',$& $'+ '%.'+ "30*++ ',%$0 1$88%0%&' 0%3%&+$*&+ "&1 %1$'$*&+E

    O$8',: ',% +'"'%7%&'+ 8*/&1 $& ',% C/&,/"&5 7"&/+30$6' +/55%+'$&5 $'+ +'0*&5 3*&&%3'$*& ;$',)"17"+"74,"9" $&9$'%1 " 3*76"0"'$9% +'/1@ ;$', ',% .#/ /(#( 01# 2"34/( H 561" 7/%138)16,/% ,/ 1"49#30#/: ,;

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    25/53

    !"#$%&'(#)%" *+

    - .'/-" 0(.%1-$ (%/2%0)"3 - (%//4"#-$)-1 5%$67 8'# $-#.4$ -0 - $4-1)04& 84)"37 )" 0%/4 5-90 $4(%3")0-814:$%/ #.4 1-#4$ !"#$ &' #$-&)#)%"0;

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    26/53

    "# ! #$%%&'( )* +,- !"##$%&'() ). ! "#$%& "##(& #) *&+,#-(. +,& /#+0( 123%24- 564#7(8( / 9:,2;( 72 +,2$( 2 97,3&4; ;8 -#4 $(-0( 7298 9;3&% 72 0

    !"#$%&' ) *"& *+, *'-%".!"#$%% "#$%&' (%)* + )(,-,./ 0.+''%-%0+)%,& ,- )*# 1+* 2 &+ '3%4%)5+. 3+)*6 +' 0,&'%')%&$ ,- )*# 7#*%0.#,- 8*+4+0)#4%')%0'6 %&9,.9%&$ ",/*%'+))9+ 0,&/50)6 '3+&&%&$ + 3#4%,/ ,- )*4## +#,&'6 +&/ )*# 7+:4+ 7#*%0.#6%&9,.9%&$ )*# ;#04#) 1+&)4+6 +&/ "4%&$%&$ 4#+.%'+)%,& %& )*%' .%-#)%& )*%' 7+:4+ 7#*%0.#6 +.. /*+4

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    27/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- .)%%-/0&'( 12

    &'34- &4 0,- &55$%$6&03)/4 )* %-'30 &/7 8347)%9 :* )/- -/;&;-4 3/ -)8-' )* ;'-&0 5)%>&443)/9 :*5)/D)3/-7 830, -%>03/-44= 830,)$0 4-6*= 4-/03-/0 F-3/;4G 7340)'0-7 F-,&

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    28/53

    !"#$%&' )*&'+,-, ./

    !"#$%&' ) *++&',-.0$ -, 12%1-&' $3 %*4"2,$&*4 5$6" ,%72"8" ,&12"4 399"2-*:5; " 39 $6" 46&28&46$% ,&8"*",,? $6" +3:-* @63 -, &@&2" $6&$ $6"+ &2" *3$ ,"7&2&$" &*4 *3$4-99"2"*$-&$"4? 13*,$&*$'+ "*:&:", -* $6" 9-A" 4",-2&='" ,"*,%&' "*B3+8"*$,; !623%:6 :2&$-9+-*: 3*","'9? &''

    $6" *3='" 3*", &2" 4"'-:6$"4C &*4 =+ 13*,"12&$-*: ,& , 2& -* $6-, @&+? &'' ,"*$-"*$ ="-*:, &',3 ="138"'-="2&$"4 &*4 ='-,,9%'; !6%, ,63%'4 $6" +3:-* 7"29328 399"2-*:, &$ &'' $-8",;

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

    =+ "8="''-,68"*$,? ,63%'4 =" 8&4";

    !"#$%&' / 0"& 1#2 3", 2# #4#!3 "#7'&-* $6" 37"*-*: 39 $6" $62"" 8& &'&,? $6" 233$ $"#$ ,&+,F 5%&$'()*'+,'- /!* 0*1*2*'/!

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

    !6" 9-A" =%446&, &2-," 9238 $6" 9-A" ,+''&='",? &*4 $6" 9-A" 9"8&'" =%446&, &2-," 9238 $6" 9-A" 72-8324-&'@-,438 3=B"1$,? &*4 ,3 $33 &2-," $6" ,-#$""* 8&'" &*4 ,-#$""* 9"8&'" =346-,&$$A&,? $6"-2 $3$&' *%8="2 39

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

    !6" 233$ $"#$ 4",12-=", $6-, &,? 5 /!* 2,/$1 (**+ 2$D&$ I/!,- 1* &+" &D*J5; K"2"? 2,/$1 (**+ -, $6" 46&28&46 $%;L&B2& -, $6" 834" 39 &77"&2-*: &, $6" 8&'" &*4 9"8&'" 4"-$-",; !6" 4""7 8"&*-*: -, $6&$ -$ -, @6&$ -, >*3@*&, $6" 2$D&$+!/6 #$ $1$; !6-, ($# +!, #$ $1$ =2-*:, 2"&'-,&$-3* 39 $6" &=,"*1" 39 ,"'9 @-$6-* $6"

    7"2,3*; !6" +3:-*? @-$63%$ *""4-*: "9932$? 2"&'-,", @6&$"A"2 &2-,", &, $6" "#72",,-3*, 39 $6"," 8&'" &*49"8&'" 4"-$-",;

    !"#$%&' 5 0"& 6&$'&7&-%#%,8-#4 2# #4#!6" 233$ $"#$ &,,"2$, $6&$ $6" 9-A" "'"8"*$, &2" $6" $&$6:&$&,? &*4 $6&$ 832"3A"2? "&16 39 $6" 9-A" &2"

    @-$6-* "&16 3*"; !6" 1388"*$&2+ "'&=32&$", $6&$ ,7&1" -, L&-231&*&? "&2$6 -, )> 3=6+&? @&$"2 I32 9-2"J -,M&$*&,&8=6&A&? 9-2" I32 @&$"2J -, )8-$ =6&? @6-'" &-2 -, )83:6&,-446-; )',3? "&2$6 3* -$, 3@* 6&, 6&24*",,?136",-3*? 6"&$? &*4 83=-'-$+? &*4 "&16 39 $6" 9-A" &2" '&$"*$ @-$6-* ,7&1"; !6" 3$6"2 "'"8"*$, 1&* ="%*4"2,$334 ,-8-'&2'+; +&? 8-*4 -, $6" 46&28&> +&? &*4 ,7""16 -, $6" *-28 &> +&;

    !6" 233$ $"#$ ,&+,F 5/!* 5,2* =,(+"#( $'+ /!* 5,2* )1$((*( "5 3*,'-( $&* ,'+,(/,'-6,(!$31*EEE 3; /!* #$'/&$$'+ #6+& *#G"=**'/7 "'*B( *'/,&* 5,*1+ "5 *>G*&,*')* 3*)"#*( /!* #$ $1$5; E-*1" $6" !&$6 :&$& &*4

    3*","'9 &2" *3$ ,"7&2&$"? $6"2" -, *3 *""4 $3 -*A-$" $6"

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    29/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- .)%%-/0&'( 12

    34 /) 45-63&7 '-6303/8 )* -44-/6- %&/0'&49 :);3/8 0,- 4) 0,-'- 34 /) /--= 0) $5,)7=%$=' 49 +,- %&/0'& &/= %$=' 4 &'- -%5)?-'-= &603;-7( 5-';&=3/8 &/= 5-'*-603/8 309

    !557(3/8 0,- 0-6,/3M$- )* '-6)8/343/8 0,- 6)%57-0- 5$'30( )* 0,- ;&'3)$4 &45-604 )* 0,- %3/= &/=6)/463)$4/-44> 0,-( 0,-'- ?377 /)' $/=-'40&/=3/8 )* 0,- =,&'%&=, 0$ /&0$'-9 H)$ 4) =)$ $/%);3/8 3/ 0,- -S5&/4- )* 3/6)%5'-,-/43 )/- %-=30&0-4 3/ & &/= )/ 0,- $-0 $9', 4&% =,39 J* 0,-%3/= ?&/=-'4> )/- %-=30&0-4 )/ 0,- & 0,- &'- -/03'-7( 73B- @-?-74> 4) 0,&0 &77 -/738,0-/-= 5$'5)4-4 &/= =--=4 ?377 0,- @-?-7 *&%37( 34

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    30/53

    !"#$%&' )*&'+,-, ./

    $0" '1$%, 2&3-'+ -, 4"56 &*5 $0" 7&43& 2&3-'+ -, 84""*9 !0"+ &4" :'-7" ;"'"6 $0"4" -,,""-*8 -* $0" 315" 12 *1*C,""-*86 0"&4-*8 -* $0" 315" 12 *1*C0"&4-*86 &*5 ,1 1*6 &*5 -* $0-, 3&**"46 ,""-*8-, %*-A"4,&''+ &=$-A&$"56 &*5 ,1 $11 $0" 1$0"4 ,"*,%&' @"4="@$-1*,9 ),,1=-&$-1*, 12 $0" ,""5 ,+''&>'", &*5 $0"-4

    4"'&$-1*,0-@ $1 "&=0 1$0"4 &4" 8-A"*9

    !0" A&;4& 2&3-'+ 5"-$-", &4" 1* $0" 2-*8"4, 12 $0" 4-80$ 0&*56 0+& -* %*-1* '", "A"4+ *""5 &*5 "*&>'", 1*" $1 01'5 $1 $0" ,&=4"59 !0%,6 1*$0" 3-55'" 2-*8"4 -, H&$*&,&3>0&A& &*5 0-, =1*,14$6 %4*, %@ &>-5-*8 -* A-"'" @"4,1* -* & '"&@-*8 @1,$%4" =&%,", 1*" $1&44-A" &$ $0" 1$0"4 ,014"6 &*5 '-7"$&-*"59 I'$-3&$"'+6 =1*,"=4&$"5 >+ $0" =1*;%*=$-1* 12 &150-=-$$& &*5 $0-,-, F&;4&,&$$A&9 !041%80 $0-,6 ,%>;"=$ &*5 1>;"=$ 5%&'-,3 -, $4&*,="*5"5 &*5 $0" $0-4$""*$0 N>150-,&$$A&O '"A"'

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    31/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- .)%%-/0&'( 12

    34 &00&3/-56 0,- 4$7'-%- 4355,38 +,- !"#$% '( )#*!+,! -( 34 930-5 &4 4&(3/:; 30,3/ &>&'-/-448D30,3/ 0,- 0,$4/-44 )* &>&'-/-446 %&0-'3&A30( 34 ?&/E$34,-5 &/5 9)/4$%-58

    +,-/ 0,- ():3/ 7)44-443/: 0,- *-%&A- ?&@'& ,)A5-'46 9)/4-9'&0-4 0,- 4)$/54 )* 0,- 4)/:4 &/5 >)'54 &4 0,--44-/9- )* B$55,& 47--9,6 &/5 0,-( &'- 0'&/4*)'%-5 3/0) 0,- 4$7'-%- 4355,38 +,- 4)/:4 &'- ,-&'5 3/ 0,- 0-/53'-903)/4 )* 0,- >)'A56 &/5 % '&4 &'- 4$B5$-5 0,')$:, 47A-/5)$'8 +,34 %-&/4 0,&0 0,- 47&03&A *3-A5 )* 0,-3/4-7&'&BA- %&A- &/5 *-%&A- 5-303-4 7-'?&5-4 -?-'(>,-'- &/5 0,- &>&'-/-44 /&0$'- )* 0,- 47&03&A *3-A5 34 0,-4)$/5 >,39, 34 ,-&'58

    +,-/ 0,- ():3/46 %-530&03/: )/ 0,- %&A- &/5 *-%&A- 5-303-46 -%&/&0- )$0 &AA 0,- %)?-%-/04 )* 5&/9- &/55347A&( 3/ ?&'3)$4 A3:,0 '&(46 &/5 )/9- &:&3/ :&0,-' 0,-% 3/6 %-530&03/: )/ 0,- 5-303-4 &/5 0,-3' &44-%BA(

    BA&F3/: &/5 0$'/3/: 3/0) A3:,06 4) 0,&0 4$7'-%- 4355,3 34 &00&3/-58 G/ )0,-' >)'546 >,-/ &AA 0,- %&A- &/5*-%&A- 5-303-4 &'- 9)/@)3/3/: &0 )/- %)%-/06 -?-/ 0,- 3/53?35$&A *&%3A3-4 &'- 3/5-*3/&BA-8 !0 )/9-6 0,- ?&@'&&A4) 0'&/4*)'%4 3/0) & 7'-93)$4 @->-A8 H34$&A343/: 0,- 0'&/4*)'%&03)/4 BA&F3/: 3/ &%&44-5 A3:,06 0,-'-&A34&03)/ 34 0,- 4$7'-%- 4355,38

    !"#$%&' ) *#+%'#,+,- %&/0'&4 &'- :3?-/ *)' &AA 0,- 7-&9-*$A 5-303-4 5-49'3B-5 3/ .,&70-' 18 +,- %&/0'&4 9)%- *)'0, *')%

    0,- B$55,& B)5(6 47--9, &/5 %3/5 ?&@'&48 I3'40 9)%-4 0,- %&/0'& *)' H&3')9&/&6 0,-/ ,34 &99)%7&/(3/:*)$' %&A- 5-303-46 0,-/ !J )B,(&6 >30, ,34 *)$' %&A- B)5,34&00?&46 &/5 4) )/8 +,-/ 0,-'- &'- 0,- *3?- *-%&A-

    B$55,&46 *)AA)>-5 B( 0,- A340 )* *-%&A- B)5,34&00?& :)55-44-46 40&'03/: >30, 0,- *)$' 3/ 0,- *3'40 :')$769)/03/$3/: >30, 0,)4- 3/ 0,- 0,- 4-9)/56 0,3'56 *)$'0, &/5 *3*0, :')$746 &/5 -/53/: >30, *)$' 9)/9A$53/:%&/0'&48 #3/9- 0,- A340 34 4-A*C-=7A&/&0)'(6 0,- 9)%%-/0&'( &554 A300A-6 &A0,)$:, 0,- K$/,$&/: %&/$49'370L4&//)0&03)/4 &00&9, 0,- /&%-4 )* 0,- 5-303-4 0) 0,-3' %&/0'&48

    !"#$%&' -. */0' ,+,- '))0 0-=0 %&J-4 0,- 7)3/0 0,&0 >,-/ )/- 34 &90$&AA( 0,- %&A- &/5 *-%&A- 5-303-46 0,- B)5( 7)44-443/:

    0,-% &0 0,- *3?- A3%B4 M&4 5-49'3B-5 3/ .,&70-' 1 &B)?-N6 -?-'( %)?-%-/0 34 %$5' 8 O-530&03/: )/ 0,- ,&/54&4 %-&/4 &/5 >345)%6 0,- ?&'3)$4 ,&/5 %$5' 4 &'- %&5-8 ! 5-49'3703)/ 34 :3?-/ )* &AA 0,- %$5' 4 *)' 0,-

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

    7-&9-*$A 5-303-4 3/ 0,- !77-/53=6 &/5 -47-93&AA( /)0- 2N8

    !"#$%&' -- !/%%1+2 344 5106 *#+%'#,+,')$:,)$0 0,- ?&40 '-&9,-4 )* 0,- 0-/ 53'-903)/4 )* 0,- >)'A56 0,- 3/9)%7&'&BA- *3?- %&A- &/5 *-%&A-

    5-303-4L 9)/4-9'&03)/4 *)' &99)%7A34,%-/0 &'- 3/*3/30-8 +,- %&A- &/5 *-%&A- B)5,34&00?&4 &'- /)> @)3/-5 B(

    %&A- &/5 *-%&A- >'&0,*$A 5-303-4 >30, :'-&0 7)>-'4 )* 4)'9-'(6 >,) 7')0-90 0,- >)'A58 +,- :'-&0 ,-&'0 ?)>4

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    32/53

    !"#$%&' )*&'+,-, ./

    01 +02" &2" "#32",,"45 ,-*6" &'' &*4 "7"2+ 802'4 8-$90%$ "#6"3$-0* -, %*-1-"4 8-$9 $9" :0*;%"202&9 >%42 ? !90," 30,,",,-*@ $9" ,026"2+ 01 $9" @2"&$ ,3-2-$%&' 8&22-02, &2"2";%",$"4 $0 60*,"62&$" 0*""*$ $920%@9 $9" 60*,"62&$-0* 01 @2"&$60>3&,,-0*? B20,$2&$-0*, &2" >&4" $0 $9" A%449& ">&*&$-0*, %*-1-"4 8-$9 $9" $92"" 2"&'>,= &*4 & ,&>49-

    6&''"4= C82&$91%' 4-,3'&+C -, "*$"2"4 102 $9" 3%230," 01 4"&'-*@ 8-$9 $9" 9&2> 6&%,"4 A+ "7-' >&*$2&,? D$ -,"#3'&-*"4 $9&$ $9" $&$9@&$&,< A04+= ,3""69 &*4 >-*4 7&E2&, &'2"&4+ 4-,6%,,"4 8-'' A" "11"6$-7"?

    !9"* $9" F-6$02-0%, G*" "*$"2"4 -*$0 & ,&> 49- 6&''"4= C7&E2& 8"&30*C= &*4 120> 9-, A04+= ,3""69 &*4>-*4 7&E2&,= ,"62"$ >&*$2&, 8"2" ">-$$"4= 8"&30*, 1"'' &*4 F&E2&3- 60''&3,"4 8-$9 9-, 2"$-*%"? !9"F-6$02-0%, G*" 2"7-7"4 9-> &*4 "#3'&-*"4 $9" 2-$%&', $0 &660>3'-,9 $9-, ,"62"$ >&*$2& -* 1%$%2" $->",?

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

    )K 0A9+& -, 0* 9-, 2-@9$ ,90%'4"2= M&$*&,& A9&7& 0* $9" '"1$N )>0@9&,-449- -, 0* $9" 2-@9$ 100$= &*4)>-$ A9& 0* $9" '"1$?O

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

    -* $9" 4-11"2"*$ 4-2"6$-0*, 01 $9" 0%$"2 6-26'"= P-9&>%K9

    &*4 ,0 102$9 Q$9" '-0*J= $-@"2J= 10#J= &*4 40@J9"&4"4"$6?R S-7" ,""4 ,+''&A'", &2" $9"* $0 A" 2"6-$"4? T-$9 9 = $9" 32-*6-3&' 4"-$+ -, @"*"2&$"4N 8-$9 9&= $9" 10%2-**"2 @044",,", &2" @"*"2&$"4N 8-$9 9"= $9" 10%2 0%$"2 @044",,",N 8-$9 39&= &'' "*E0-*"4 $0 A" 82&$91%'N 89-'"8-$9 $9" 1-*&' 9 = &'' A'&U" 8-$9 +"''08 32->024-&' 8-,40> '-@9$?

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

    A",$08, $9" ,&>&+&? H044",,", ,$2-K" $9" 42%>, &*4 ,-*@ >"'04-",?

    !"#$%&' )* +"& ,# #-# ./ %"& 0'#%"/1- ,#-& 2&3%3&4VW0$" $9&$ $9" X%*9%&*@ >&*%,62-3$ 60*$&-*, & 3&,,&@" *"&2 $9" "*4 01 -$, :9&3$"2 OY 89-69 -* 1&6$ 8&,

    >-,3'&6"4= &6$%&''+ A"'0*@-*@ -* :9&3$"2 OZ?[

    !9" 69&3$"2 @-7", & 4",62-3$-0* 01 $9" 82&$91%' >&'" >& &'& 4"-$-",= 8-$9 @'0,,", $920%@90%$ 0* $9"->&@"2+-4&$-*@&*4 4",$20+-*@ $9" > 2&,= 0A,$&6'",= &*4 ,0 0*= &'' $9" 802'4'+ 2"&'>, A'&U"4 %3 -* & @2"&$ 1-2"A&''= &*4 '-@9$

    O W0$" $9&$ $9-, 3'&6">"*$ 1-$, 8-$9 $9" ,69">& 102 7-,%&'-,&$-0* 01 $9" 1-7" A%449&, &$ $9" 3&2$, 01 $9" A04+ -* :9&3$"2 . &A07"?

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    33/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- .)%%-/0&'( 12

    '&(3 '&45&0-4 *')% 506 +,- 7'&0,*$8 4-505-3 7-'- &9545/: 5/ 0,- %5448-; 3 & &5' )* ,&/43 9'&/453,7-&>)/3 7,58- )/ %&8- &/4 *-%&8- %&, 4-=&3; 0,- /-@0 >&5' )/ :&/- &3; &/4 0,- *5/&8 07) )/ =5/&(&C&36 +,530'&%>85/: )* 0,- -5:,0 7)'848( :)43 5/45)/ 0,- -5:,0 8-0- 859-'&05)/3; 0)

    %-450&0- )/ 0,- *)$' 4,( /&3 &/4 0,- *)$' -L$5859'5$%3; &/4 0) '-&853- 0,- 4,&'%&0 6

    +,- '))0 0-@0

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    34/53

    !"#$%&' )*&'+,-, ./

    01'' !"#$ !& , -* $2"-0 '13"0 2&*4,5 6"$ ,17" 18 $2" "#$0& -79'"7"*$, 81%*4 -* $2" '-,$ 2"0" &0" 90","*$ -* $2" '(&)* )*&) +&, -.&, !&-/ $*(#. 0"1) !2 '-,$5 !2"* $2" *&7", 18 $2" $"* 7&'" &$$"*4&*$ 7&:-;&' 2+ &0" :-?"*5 !2"+ ;100",91*4 "#&;$'+ $1 $2" '-,$ 18 7&'" 7&:-;&' 2+ 2&?" "#&;$'+ $2" ,&7" *&7", &, $21," 81%*4-* $2" %,%&' '-,$,C ,%;2 &, -* $2" @&A0&B '&+& $"#$, =,"" $2" 4-,;%,,-1* 18 $2" 7&'" ,"$ &99"&0-*: -* J2&9$"0 KL>C

    18 $2" N2&07& "+" 18 $2" "&,$"0* 30&$28%' 4"-$+C@-A&+&C -, ;1**";$"4 3-$2 $2" $-:"0Q2"&4"4 7&:-;&' 2+

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    35/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- .)%%-/0&'( 11

    $/23-'4&5 5)3- 24 0,- 46&02&5 *2-57 8)/4-8'&02)/ &/7 920, 0,- 6'2%)'72&5 9247)% 8)/4-8'&02)/: "#$%&' ()%*+,-./0,1 (22 /(#%)0(2 #$0,1- ; +,-( &'- &88)%6524,-7 2/ 0,- )'72/&'(

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    36/53

    !"#$%&' )*&'+,-, ./

    !"#$%&' )* +"& ,&-%'./%01& 20%.#3!0" ,"1-", 23 40&5$"1, 2* $0" 32%1 1-$%&', 6"7-*, $0" ,"8%"*4" 9-$0 $0" :",$1%4$-;" 1-$%&' &4$-2* ,"-A-*7 &*:233"1-*7 $0" ";-' ,5-1-$, $2 $0" 91&$03%' :"-$-", &, 322:B !0" 42??"*$&1+ ,%55'-", &* -**"1 -*$"151"$&$-2*> $0&$

    $012%70 $0" 1-$%&'> $0" ;-"9-*7 23 ,"*$-"*$ 6"-*7, &, ,%6,$&*$-&' -, 42*,%?": 6+ -$, 29* $1%" *&$%1"B !0"&4$-;" ,"*," 3&4%'$-", &1" 1"?2;": ,-*4" -* $0" 42*$"#$ 23 $0" ,-# 51-?21:-&' 9-,:2? "?5$-*",, 42*,"41&$-2*,>?&$"1-&' $0-*7, ,""* &, ,2'-: 902'", 42*$1&:-4$ $0"-1 ",,"*$-&' 7"*%-*" *&$%1"B !0%,> $0"-1 8%&'-$-", &1" ?&:"$2 :"7"*"1&$" 21 $0"+ &1" *&$%1&''+ 612%70$ -*$2 ,&?"*",,B

    "#$ %&'()&* #+,-(. .$(/($0 &1" ?":-$&$": %52* &, 0-*:"1-*7 $0" &4$-2*, 23 &*: -*4-$-*7 :-;-,-2*, 6"$9""*$0" 26@"4$, 23 $0" 1-$"> ,-*4" ?&$"1-&' &*: 2*"C,-:": &442?5'-,0?"*$ 42*$1&:-4$, $%1/(2$00 &2. ,&?"*",,>41"&$", :-;-,-2*, 9-$0-* $0" $&*$1-4 712%5 &*: 51";"*$, %'$-?&$" &442?5'-,0?"*$B

    !"#$%&' )4 +"& ,&-%'./%01& 567#D21 $0" :",$1%4$-;" 3-1" 1-$%&'> $0" $1-&*7%'&1 0"&1$0 -, 51"5&1": 9-$0 $01"" 6'&4E &,1" , &*: -12* 9-1" 21

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

    !"#$%&' 89 +"& :".' $# ;6' ,&-%'./%06 ?&:" 2%$ 23 -12* 21 6'&4E 922: &*: 3"&$%1-*7 & 0"&:>

    E*2$ &*: $01""C,-:": 6'&:"B !0" 42??"*$&1+ "#5'&-*, $0&$ H"1%E& &*: I&' 5& 74-7 ?& ";"* -3 $0" 26@"4$ -, & 72:B!012%70 /#$ 252 &*: *2$0-*7 -, *2$ 5"1?"&$": 6+ $0-,B

    !"#$%&' 8) +"& ,&-%'./%01& !"#$ &' !0" 1"4-5" 321 ?&E-*7 $0" :",$1%4$-;" $2'" .# -, 7-;"*> -*4'%:-*7 -12* 3-'-*7,> 52-,2* &*: 71&;"'> ?-#":

    9-$0 6'22: &*: ?&,0": 6"&*, 21 6'&4E 71&-*,B G* 233"1-*7 $0" $2'" .# > & ?"1" ,-70$ 23 -$ 4&%,", $0" ;2?-$-*723 6'22:B !0" 42??"*$&1+ "#5'&-*, $0&$ $0-, ?"&*, $0&$ 6+ ?":-$&$-*7 -* $0%,*",,> 9-$0 51-?21:-&' 9-,:2?"?5$-*",, 5"1;&:-*7 ";"1+90"1"> $0"1" 9-'' *&$%1&''+ 6" 1%-* &*: 12$B

    !"#$%&' 88 +"& ,&-%'./%01& 20%.#3 = $0%, 6"&$-*7 $0" 1-$"K, 26@"4$B !0" 42??"*$&1+ "#5'&-*, $0&$ $0":0&1?&:0 $% *&$%1" -, $0" ?21$&1> 9-$0 $0" ,5&$-&' 3-"': 23 5%1" &9&1"*",, $0" 6"&$-*7 0&??"1B ) 42*4'%:-*71"?&1E 2* :",$1%4$-;" 1-$%&', 7-;", $0" -*,$1%4$-2* $0&$ 6'&4E 4'2$0", ,02%': 6" 921* 321 $0"," 51&4$-4",B

    !"#$%&' 8> !6

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    37/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- .)%%-/0&'( 12

    3$430&/05&6 '-&650(7 8-9):/535/: 0,&0 ,&0'-; 5/ *&90 ,&3 /) '-&6 /&0$'-< 0,- %5/; )* ,&0'-; 53 /)0 4)'/< &/; 0,5396)3-3 0,- ;))'3 )* ,-667 +,- 3&%- '-&3)/5/: 53 &==65-; 0) 0,- )0,-' -%)05)/&6 &**65905)/3 &/; 45'0, 5/ 0,-)0,-' '-&6%37 +,- *5/&6 %-;50&05)/ 53 )* &905>&05/: 0,-"#$% #&' (%"#$% $/5)/ )* &?&'-/-33 ?50,5/ 0,-;,&'%&;, 0$ 3=&05&6 *5-6;< )/-@3 )?/ 4-66( &3 !A&/5,&< =');$95/: 4);,59500& 0,')$:, ?,59, )/-@3 )?/

    9)/395)$3/-33 4-9)%-3 &99)%=653,-;7

    !"#$%&' )* +"& !#$%,-#%,./ 0,%1#2+,- 9,&=0-'3 )/ 9&=05>&05/: '50$&63 &'- )=-/-; ?50, &/ 5/>50&05)/ 0) 0,- %&6- &/; *-%&6- ?'&0,*$6 ;-505-3 0)

    &65:,0 $=)/ 0,- -5:,0 3=)A-3 )* 0,- 3-%5B95'9$6&' %& &6&< &/; 0,-/ 0,- %&A5/: )* )**-'5/:3 )* 3)/:3< ;&/9-&/; '-; 50-%37 +,- '))0 0-C0 3&(3 0,&0 0,- >&D'& )* =&335)/< &6)/: ?50, 0,- '-05/$-< 9&=05>&0-3 0,- )4D-903 )* 0,-'50- ?50, =&335)/&0- &00'&905)/< &/; &3 & '-3$60< &66 0,- ?)'6;6( '-&6%3 &'- -/05'-6( 9&=05>&0-;7

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

    #5/9- ->-'(0,5/: 53 )/-3-6*< 50 9&/ 4- 3--/ &3< H0,- :'-&0 3-6*H< ?50, ->-'(0,5/: &3 )/-@3 )?/ -%&/&05)/7+,- 3-/3-3 &'- 0'&/3*)'%-;< &/; ->-'(0,5/: &==-&'3 4-&$05*$67 G50, 0,- &?&'-/-33 )* 0,53 5/3-=&'&45650( )*3-6* &/; )0,-'3< ->-/ 0,- 0,)$:,06-33 4-9)%- D)(*$6 &/; -C950-;7

    !"#$%&' )3 +"& !#$%,-#%,./ 4.5#I)' 0,- 9&=05>&05/: *5'- '50$&6< 0,- 3-%5B95'9$6&' ,-&'0, 53 ='-=&'-; ?50, *5>- '-; !"#$ !& 3 &/; '-; 4)$/;&'(

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

    !"#$%&' )6 +"& 7"1' $# 8.' !#$%,-#%,./+,- !"#$ !& /--;-; *)' 9&=05>&05)/ 53 ;-39'54-;< %&;- )$0 )* /011%* 0* *%':/0$03*%' 400' &/; *-&0$'5/:

    & ,-&;< A/)0 &/; & 3-%5B95'9$6&' 46&;-7 +,- ?'&0,*$6 ;-505-3 &'- >53$&653-; &')$/; 0,- !"#$ !& < &/; 0,- '50- )*30'5A5/: ?50, 50 9&=05>&0-3 &/; 4'5/:3 ->-'()/- $/;-' 9)/0')67 +,- 9)%%-/0&'( -C=6&5/3 0,&0 0,- =$'-&?&'-/-33@3 ='5%)';5&6 ?53;)% !"#$ !& ?566 30'5A- $/5>-'3&66(< &/; 35/9- 0,-'- 53 /) 3-=&'&05)/ 4-0?--/)/-3-6* &/; ->-'(0,5/: -63-< ->-'(0,5/: 53 /&0$'&66( 9&=05>&0-;7

    !"#$%&' )9 +"& !#$%,-#%,/: !"#$ &' +,- '-95=- *)' %&A5/: 0,- 9&=05>&05/: '()$ *& 53 :5>-/< 5/96$;5/: 9)==-' *565/:3< %)6&33-3< "#-5%' *%'

    *./% &/; )0,-' '-; :'&5/37 J/ )**-'5/: 0,- '()$ *& < & %-'- 35:,0 )* 50 9&$3-3 0,- )4D-903 0) 4-9)%- )4-;5-/07J* 50 53 -&0-/< 0,-( ?56607%; #&; /0""#&'- 45#,-0%&35>-7 +,-'- 53 /)0,5/: 0) 3-0 &=&'0 0,-:'-&0 3-6*B5;-/050(< &/; 50 ?566 /&0$'&66( 9&=05>&0- ->-'(0,5/:7

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    38/53

    !"#$%&' )*&'+,-, ./

    !"#$%&' )* +"& !#$%,-#%,./ 0,%1#2 3.,4.!0" 1&2$-3&$-*4 5-$%&' 67 %*-6* -, 8",15-9"8 -* $"5:, 67 %*-6* 67 $0" :& &'&, 67 $0" :&'" &*8 7":&'"

    ;5&$07%' 8"-$-",< ;0-10 :"&*, $0&$ &'' ;-'' 9" 1&2$-3&$"8 =6+7%''+> !0" 16::"*$&5+ "#2'&-*, $0&$ ,-*1" $0"80&5:&80 $% 0&, *6 10&5&1$"5-,$-1 :&5?,< -$ -, &''@2"53&,-3"< ,6 $0" 25-:65-8-&' ;-,86: &;&5"*",, %*-$", ;-$0

    -$ -* *6*@8%&'-$+> !0""#$%%' ("%$ )*)%$#$++ ,- ./&+ #,#01")2 +.).$ -, 9680-1-$$&< &*8 -$ ;-'' *&$%5&''+1&2$-3&$" 9'-,,7%''+>

    !"#$%&' )5 +"& 6.7',./ 0,%1#2!0" -*15"&,-*4 5-$%&', 9"4-* ;-$0 &* -*3-$&$-6* $6 $0" 8"-$-", $6 &'-40$ %26* $0" "-40$ ,26?", 67 $0" ,A%&5"

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

    !"#$%&' 9: +"& 6.7',./ !"#$ E65 $0" -*15"&,-*4 7-5" 5-$%&'< $0" ,A%&5" 0"&5$0 -, 25"2&5"8 ;-$0 76%5 +"''6; &'(" &! , &*8 +"''6; 96%*8&5+

    562"> !0" 677"5"8 ,%9,$&*1", &5" $0" 7-3" $+2", 67 =";"',< $0" 7-3" :"8-1-*",< $0" 7-3" 45&-*,< 96-'"8 5-1" 2%'2&*8 :"'$"8 9%$$"5> B* :&?-*4 $0" 9%5*$ 677"5-*4,< $0" :"8-$&$-6* -, $0&$ &'' 6*"C, ,%11",,", -*15"&,"> !0"-*$"525"$&$-6* -, $0&$ ;-$0 $0" 80&5:&80$% :-5565@'-?" 25-:658-&' ;-,86:< $0" 7-3" :&'" &*8 $0" 7-3" 7":&'"

    25-*1-2&' 8"-$-", &5-," &, 9%880& 968+F $0" ,-#$""* :&'" &*8 ,-#$""* 7":&'" 9680-,&$$3&, &5-," '-?" $0"

    9%880&C, :&=65 :&5?,< &*8 $0" 7-3"@76'8 8-&8":, 67 "&10 8"-$+ &5-," &, $0" :-*65 :&5?,> !0" 25-:658-&';-,86: 9%5*, %2 :&$"5-&' ,%9,$&*1" &*8 -$ -*15"&,", $056%40 -$, 6;* *&$%5&' A%&'-$-",>

    !"#$%&' 9; +"& %&'( *$

    !"#$%&' 9) +"& 6.7',./ +,"( #$ !0" 5"1-2" 765 :&?-*4 $0" -*15"&,-*4 *+," -! -, 4-3"*< -*1'%8-*4 46'8 8%,$< :&,0"8 +"''6; 5-1" 45&-*,

    !"#$%&' 99 =.1>?&'&@ 9; ,. %"& A1."1#./ B#.187',$%C +"& 6.7',./ 0,%1#2 3.,4.!0" -*15"&,-*4 5-$%&' 67 %*-6* -, 8",15-9"8 -* $"5:, 67 %*-6* 67 $0" :& &'&, 67 $0" :&'" &*8 7":&'"

    8"-$-",< &*8 :"8-$&$-*4 6* ":&*&$-*4 9680-1-$$&> !0" 16::"*$&5+ "#2'&-*, $0&$ -7 +6% :"8-$&$" 6* $&?-*4 2'"&,%5" &*8 -*15"&,-*4 "*=6+:"*$< -$ ;-'' 9" &116:2'-,0"8 &11658-*4'+> H-$0 %*-6* -* $0" ,&: 80- :& &'& +,- '))0 0-A0 5&(5 0,&0 0,- 8-=$56)/?&

    +,- *6?- 4,60- ;&'%-/05 &'- 4)'/ &/8 0,- 8-606-5: &=)/; 460, 0,-6' '-06/$-5: &'- %-860&0-8 $3)/ &5 3&96*(6/; &== 8650$'7&/9-5: ,&'% &/8 -?6=> B* 0,65 %-860&06)/ 65 8)/-: 3&96*69&06)/ 46== 7- 6/50&/0&/-)$5> +,-9)%%-/0&'(C5 6/0-'3'-0&06)/ 65 0,&0 0,- 8,&'%&8, 0$ -%306/-55 5&% 8,6 )* 3'6%)'86&= 4658)% 3&96*69&06)/46== 3&96*( -?-'(0,6/; 7( 3-'?&86/; &==>

    !"#$%&' )? +,-./&'&0 )) 2, %"& 3-,"-#,4 5#,-67'2$%8 9"& :#72; +,- 8-606-5 &'- ?65$&=65-8 &')$/8 0,- @/)0: &/8 0,- '60- )* 50'6@6/; 460, 60 4,6=-%-860&06/; )/ 0,- 8-606-5 3&96*(6/; 4)$=8 -?-/ 3&96*( & ;)8> +,- 9)%%-/0&'( -A3=&6/5 0,&0 0,- -=-%-/0&=/&0$'-C5 *&$=0=-55 -55-/06&= 3$'- &4&'-/-55 65 0,- 5&%8,6 "#$% "&: 5) 0,65 3&96*6-5 -?-'(0,6/; /&0$'&==(>

    !"#$%&' )B +,-./&'&0 )? 2, %"& 3-,"-#,4 5#,-67'2$%8 9"& :#72; +,- 9)%%-/0&'( -A3=&6/5 0,&0 0,-8,&'%&8, 0$ 65 6/ 605-=* 3&96*69&06)/: '-5-%7=6/; 0,- %&=- &/8 *-%&=- 8-606-5 6/ 9)%76/6/; 0,- 8,&'%&8,0$&/8 3'6%)'86&= 4658)% &4&'-/-55: &/8 /&0$'&==( 3&96*(6/;> +,$5: -?-'(0,6/; 65 3-'?&8-8 460, 6059)/5-9'&06)/: 5) -?-'(0,6/; 7-9)%-5 3-&9-*$=>

    !"#$%&' )E +,-./&'&0 )B 2, %"& 3-,"-#,4 5#,-67'2$%8 F-..2,4 -$ G#>>H %"& =2%-#>G6H+,- '))0 0-A0 5&(5 0,&0 0,- %$8' 4,69, ,&5 /) 9,&'&90-'65069 %&'@5 &/8 0,- 5$750&/06&= %$8' 5 &'65-/ )$0

    )* 60 &'- -A3=&6/-8 7( 0,- 4&''6)' 7)8,65&00?& &5 $/53-96*6&7=-: 5) 0,- 465- 46== 7- &99)%3=65,-8 6/ 8)6/;4,&0-?-' 0,-( -/ +,- 9)%%-/0&'( &885 0,&0 -?-'(0,6/; 65 0,- %$8' 460,)$0 9,&'&90-'65069 %&'@5 &/8-?-'(0,6/; ,&5 &'65-/ *')% 0,- 8,&'%&@ (&> #) 6* 0,-'- 65 &4&'-/-55 )* 0,- *=&4=-55 8,&'%&@ (&: &/8 0,-();6/ -/;&;-5 6/ &/( %-860&06)/5: %$8' 5 &/8 %&'@5 )* 4,&0-?-' 0(3- ,- =6@-5: &/8 9)%%-/9-5 0,- *)$''60$&= &906)/5: 0,-'- %$50 7- &99)%3=65,%-/0>

    !"#$%&' *I +,-./&'&0 )C 2, %"& 3-,"-#,4 5#,-67'2$%8 9"& J&,&;2%6 A; %"& K77A.$>26".&,%+,- '))0 0-A0 5&(5G H+#%)$'# ,-.(%$/(01- 2%0($&345 &33 &%- (&*-,6 (#%)$'# /&"(01&(0)75 (#- .$"%-*- $70)7

    0. &3.) &//)*"30.#-,8 9: 07/%-&.07'5 2(#0. &//)*"30.#*-7(4 0. 07/%-&.-, 07 (#- ;)%* ); *&

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    40/53

    !"#$%&' )*&'+,-, ./

    !012%30 4",$1%5$-6" 7"18219&*5": &'' 324, &*4 4"92*, ;-'' + 5&7$-6&$-*3 1-$%&',: ,%71"9""*?2+9"*$ ;-'' "& 9# #1# =. %"& D'%!#$%/B#%=' 8

    !0" 50&1&5$"1-,$-5, 28 $0" 9& &'& &1" $0&$ -$ -, $0" 9& &'& 28 $0" C1"&$ D&7$-6&$21 E!"#$% '()$ "*!+* ,# F: &*4 ;-$0-* -$: $0" 5-15%'&1

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    41/53

    ! #$%%&'( )* +,- .)%%-/0&'( 12

    &/3%&456 7( 0,- *)'8- )* 5$8, &9-'53)/: -9-'(0,3/; 35 $/3*3-< 3/ 0,- 5=&03&4 *3-4< 305-4*6 >/ 0,35 $/3)/: -9-/?,34- -/;&;3/; 3/ 0,-

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    42/53

    ! "#$"%"$&'"(" ) +', ! "#$% '"#(% "-# .+% / 0$$,-+"12

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

    (-./4= $%( $&$/(+ 4#6 $,* #(40 $%( (#6; T#3*0$2#4$(/: 3*0 2'+ $%( 4##*$4$*0 74U(' #* )/(40 '$4$(7(#$ 48*2$54674'478%494B' 0*/( $%( $(-$+ 04$%(0 4' $%*2=% %( 4''27(' $%( 0(46(0 4/0(46: U#*,' $%&'+ 4#6 $%( .*$*3 $%( 4##*$4$&*#' &' '&7./: $* 604, 4$$(#$&*# $* '*7( 4'.()$ *3 $%4$ 0*/(; 52$ $*=($%(0+ $%( $%0(( )*77(#$',*2/6 '((7 $* &)4$( !"#$%% + *0 .(0%4.' !" + 4' $%( ,*0U *3 54674'478%494 V *0 4$ $%( /(4'$+ 4'0(.0('(#$= %&' $(4)%='+ *0 4' %49= '*7( 4''*)&4$&*# ,&$% %&7;

    !345363578393:6 )*+, -./+012+*3./ 3. +,4 (5065.7 38 9*4:/

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

    P.()&3&)4//:+ 3!56 B' &$&4/ )4$(=*0&'4$&*# *3 (00*#(*2' 9&(,' &' #*$ .404//(//(6 !"#$%% + 4/$%*2=%*06(: 8(=' G 0&%0 :*. 56*+ 2* N 40( 7(#$&*#(6 !"#$%% B' \%4.$(0 CH; ]*$% $(-$' '$40$ ,&$% 4 $,*3*/6)/4''&3&)4$&*# *3 $%( .4$% $* $%( Y(%&)/( *3 \%404)$(0&'$&)' G%(06*. ./1< @/1 (6&4 5* N 4#6 $%( Y4Z04 Y(%&)/(

    G74/$*# GMFFJI `aH #*$( C`N+ '$4$(' 04$%(0 7*0( .*'&$&9(/: $%4$+ ^ $%($(0/(40 #*$(' $* $%( >2#%24#= 9(0'&*#' *3 $%(!6*20 @/1 C6*40 5* 5*< %$B1 B567&.4 2* )*77(#$40: G"

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    43/53

    !"#$"%"$&'"(") +', !"#$% '"#(% "-# .+% /0$$,-+"12 33

    +', +40506# #.(.%.0- .% %.$762 +'"+ 05 8"' 2 -" .- 90-+1"%+ +0 :";1"2 -" -'>"-? $%@A1@BCDE) %0 +'"+ .-!)*+,, ) +', :,'.96, 05 /'"1"9+,1.%+.9% 1,6"+,% +0 +', &0#'.%"++(" 7"+'@ F'.% .-96>#,%) 501 ,G"$76,) +', +,-

    - .#,/0 %) 1,?"1#.-? 4'.9' !)*+,, $,-+.0-% +', "%%09."+,# 60-? +.$, %9"6,%

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    44/53

    !"#$ &'(#)*+#",'( ,' #$- ./)0/'1 ,2 3"-4( !"

    #$ $%$ '( )'*+, -.//01 $2* #32*4 567$ -5..%3/- $ 6$267$ 036$63'2 8 2'6 32 61/ 7''6 6/96 68 )56 -3#3%$7 32$..7'$01 8 /:5$632; 61/ $2*1$ %3#)- ?361 61/ (3/ 567$ @- 036$63'2 61$6 $%% *1$7#$- $7/ 32 61/ #32*,#32* *?/%%- 32 -.$0/, $2* -.$0/ 2'F?1/7/4 W1/7/ 3- $%-' 2' 0%'-/ .$7$%%/% 32 689,:: 6' 567$ @- 036$63'2 61$6$%% *1$7#$- $7/ /#.6+ 32 61/37 /--/263$% 2$657/, 61$6 61/+ $7/ .73#'7*3$%%+ 6'6$%%+ .57/, /2637/%+ 0%/$7 %3;16,237< $ 32 2$657/, .7'#'7*3$%%+ 61/ 0'#.%/6/%+ ./7(/06/* )5**1$1''*4 I56 0%/$7%+, 613- 3- /2637/%+ 32 %32/?361 689,:: @- 6/$0132;4

    567$ */

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    45/53

    !"#$"%"$&'"(") +', !"#$% '"#(% "-# .+% /0$$,-+"12 34

    5- )!*" ) 67+.$"+, 8,19,:+.0- .- +',%, 9061 "%8,:+% +";,% 87":, +'106 0(4% *#5/ .#-( 0(4% *# ?@ N0-,+',7,%%) "7+'06 %;1 (%1-( ,"1(% +/ '#0 *# 6(.#- 994+*8/%"+7-, "-#?67#, >994+*8/%"+7-, "1, :0--,:+,# F.+' +', :0-%01+ 81":+.:,) "-# "1, " 7.++7, 1,$.-.%:,-+ 09 .$"

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    46/53

    !"#$ &'(#)*+#",'( ,' #$- ./)0/'1 ,2 3"-4( !"

    #$ &'() *+),- &', &,./ () )'+.,0 12& &', *3$&,$& () + 4(&&4, 0(55,.,$& ($ &'+& 567$ () )6,+7($8 35 &', 5.2(&+**3/64()',0 9',$ &', 8.,+& )(00'( () +&&+($,0- 9'(4, &', ,4+13.+&(3$ ($ 689,:: () 0()*2))($8 &', $+&2.+4

    6.,),$*, 35 5244 ,$4(8'&,$/,$&- +$0 &', +.()($8 35 &', 1200'+) 5.3/ &', ),,0 ):44+14,);

    567$ '+) + ),*&(3$ 63($&($8 32& &'+& 3$4: /,$&+44: )26,.(3. 6,.)3$) *+$ 2$0,.)&+$0 6.(/3.0(+4,$4(8'&,$/,$&- +$0 &'2)- 3&',.) )'3240 6.+*&(), /3., 8.+02+4 6+&')- +$0 &', &,+*'($8 () &+28'& +) &',

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    47/53

    !"#$"%"$&'"(") +', !"#$% '"#(% "-# .+% /0$$,-+"12 34

    (,12 ,-# 05 +', 67-'7"-8 $"-7%91.:+ .- +', %$";; ,-?71 (,1%.0-% "1, :;"9,# .- " %,9+.0- 05 +,@+% "%%09."+,# ,-?71 ,#.+.0-%)!,-+.. .$$,#."+,;2 50;;0,-?71L 25%S M MGI5( )869 9(#. (20) P&%>"- G8271L.# G(20) S 4#* .# P>,-?71L 4#*.#G5S)(2#3 4+ 25% P>,-?71L3#%S M M*6 $'"59 (%"6(% 4#G5 .#9 9(#( (%#9( H"69 )9#.%M M1309(P>,-?71L13+9( S9#% $1)+3 .*'#**6 3# 4"2#( G8%"#3 3+MM

    W >',

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    48/53

    !"# %&'(#)*# +,-. /"# 0-..#)/1,2 1)( '/3 45)"51)6 7'/)#33 89

    :-;;-7')6 5< /"# "')/ /"1/ /"# )1.#= >1(.1 ,?21; 1(.1 ,621; 1(.1 "16'-6,1

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    49/53

    !"#$"%"$&'"(") +', !"#$% '"#(% "-# .+% /0$$,-+"12 34

    560& #70- 8$"%+,1) 9:1:;< =:+ "% .- +', >:1:?% 6"+,1 '"9.091"7'.,%) $"-2 0@ +', .-A.#,-+% 1,6"+,# .- +', +,B+)"-# ,%7,A."662 .- +', @.1%+ 7"1+ 0@ +', +,B+ @0A:%.-9 0- +', >:1:?% +1".-.-9 "-# "A+.(.+.,% &,@01, +', 7,1.0# .-C.&,+) "1, @0660D,# &2 " -0+, +'"+ "+ +'"+ +.$, ', D"% A"66,# &2 %:A'E"-#E%:A' " -"$,< F- +', ,"16.,1#,%A1.7+.0- 0@ G.-9 F-#1"&0#'.?% #.%A0(,12 0@ +', 60+:%E&01- ,$"-"+.0- "-# '.% .-%+"66"+.0- "% +', H.-9?% %0-)

    +', -"$, ', .% 9.(,- .%) 1>2"6 70 $C%'0 %H2,% 1#0 1I, 8G.-9 J"H,E&01- K"I1"L 71,"+ >:1: !"#$"%"$&'"(") ,:609.%,# .- +', %"$, $"--,1 "% +'"+ :%,# .- +', %6.9'+626"+,1 '"9.091"7'.A"6 6.+,1"+:1,< OR F+ .% D01+' "##.-9 +'"+ +', @.1%+ 6.-, 0@ +', 71".%, 0AA:1% "6%0 I:%+ "&0(, .-

    S2"-9 1"6?% '"9.091"7'2 8FT>UOVMR) 1,,6 WXMRYZOR) @

    M C', -"$, $C%'0 %H2,% 1#0 1I, 8J"H,E&01- K"I1";) A0-+.-:,% +0 &, :%,# .- +', -"11"+.(,) &0+' .- 71".%,% 8 >7/ 6"0/ (.02 +*':*6"0/ +: K06:$, G"P 7:1: "%" $,#.+"+.0-"6 #,.+2) :%,# .- $"-2 A2A6,% 0@ 1.+:"6 $,#.+"+.(, 71"A+.A,%##) #?/-==#( ') /"# ;,#*#(')6 =')#3A B)-/"#, ;-33'>'='/2 '3 /"1/ /"#

    ;,1'3# '3 +-*53')6 )-/ -) /"# &$%'$()*)$+ -+ /"# /#?/ 13 35*"< >5/ ,1/"#, -) /"# #)='6"/#)')6 ;-/#)/'1= -+ '/3/#1*"')63< /#1*"')63 7"'*" 1,# C5')/#33#)/'1==2 /"-3# -+ /"# D,#1/ D5,5A !"'3 .'6"/ 3##. /- .1E# 1== /"#

    .-,# 3#)3# 7"#) 7# *-)3'(#, /"# *-)/#?/ +-, /"# ;1,1==#= ,3# ') F21)6 ,1=G3 "16'-6,1;"2A H#,#< +-==-7')6/"# #1,='#, ;,1'3# .#)/'-)#( 1>-< /"# E')6 ;123 ->#'31)*# 1)( /"# D5,5 /#1*"#3 "'. /"1/ -)#G3 -7) .')( '3/"# 5)>-,) ("1,.1E 21A I..#('1/#=2 ,#1='3')6 '/ 13 35*"< /"# E')6 1)( "'3 ,#/')5# 1//1') /"# 1**#;/1)*# -+/"# 5)>-,) )1/5,# -+ ("1,.13A !"# 1.1J#( E')6 /"#) ;,1'3#3 /"# D5,5 ') /"# 7-,(3 -+ -5, ,3#A I/ .12 )-/

    ># #)/',#=2 1,>'/,1,2 /"1/ /"# *-)/#?/ +-, /"# *=-3# -+ !"#$%% '3 3-.# 7-,(3 -+ *-)*=53'-) /"1/ ,#1='31/'-) '31**-.;='3"#( /",-56" /"# /#1*"')6< 1)( /"'3 +-==-73 /"# +')1= /#1*"')6 -+ /"# ,--/ /1)/,1 -) ('33-=&')6 /"#.1 1=1 ')/- /"# "#1,/A K+ *-5,3#< /"'3 '3 )-/ 1) #?1*/ ;1,1==#=< >5/ ;#,"1;3 3'.'=1, #)-56" /"1/ 7# *1) ,#+=#*//"1/ /"# ,3# '3 )-/ 3'.;=2 1 ;,1'3# -+ /"# D5,5G3 C51='/'#3< >5/ 1 *#=#>,1/'-) -+ 1.1J#.#)/ 1/ /"# 5=/'.1/#/1)/,'* /#1*"')63 "# #.>-('#3A

    L- +1,< 7# "1 *-)3'(#,#( -)=2 /"# .1') /#?/ -+ !"#$%% A I+ 7# /"#) /5,) /- /"# 1))-/1/'-)3< /7-:1(.131.>"1&1 ,#+#,#)*#3 1,# 6') ') /"'3 =13/ 3#*/'-) -+ /"# /#?/A !"# +')1= ,#+#,#)*# '3 ;=1*#( (',#*/=25)(#, /"# +',3/ =')# -+ /"# "-.16#< 1)( ,#1(3M !,- %/(*-0 +*)1/02/3 ,/4)+1 -5/%)+-6 /+6 78$9+6 )*:,)%;

    8L1. 213 1/ /"# 3/1,/ -+ 1.1)53*,';/ *-;2 -+ /"# )')/" *#)/5,2 LM,/+1 *,/+1 %/ ,#6'3/#, -+ /,1)3=1/'-)3 15/"-,'3#( >2 /"# !'>#/1)3/1/#ANS )/'61,>"1 *-)/')5#3 /- ;=12 1) '.;-,/1)/ ,-=# 1=-)63'(# :1(.131.>"1&1 ') =1/#, ,F2')6 .1='/#,1/5,# 13 -)# -+ /"# 3-T*1==#( %'6"/ U'(2 ("1,13 -+ I)('1< 7"-. /"# ,F2')6 .1 ;1 ,#,# 13 '.;-,/1)/+-5)(#,3 -+ /"#', V1" 2-61 /,1('/'-)< 1)( "#$#%&' -+ 7"-. +'65,# C5'/# &'3'>=2 ') /"# 45)"51)6 ='/#,1/5,#A NW

    B=/"-56" /"# 1))-/1/-, 3##.3 /- 1335.# 7# E)-7< '/ '3 )-/ *=#1, #?1*/=2 7"1/ "# '3 '.;=2')6 1>-5/)/'61,>"1G3 ,-=# ') !"#$%% A H# .12 ># ')('*1/')6 /"1/ )/'61,>"1 '3 /"# 15/"-, -+ !"#$%% 7"'*"

    ')*=5(#3 /"'3 +')1= ,3#A B=/#,)1/'=2< "# .12 ># 3566#3/')6 /"1/ )/'61,>"1G3 7-,(3 -+ ;,1'3# +,-.#=3#7"#,# 1,# ')3#,/#( "#,#< -, /"1/ )/'61,>"1 "13 1;;#)(#( 1 "-.16# /- /"# /#?/ -+ !"#$%% A !"'3 /"',( ;-33'>'='/2 '3 ,#)(#,#( 1 ='//=# 5)='E#=2 *-)3'(#,')6 /"1/ /"# "-.16# '3 ;=1*#( 7'/"') /"# /#?/ ,1/"#, /"1) 1+/#,/"# *-=-;"-)< 1)( 7# "1 )-/#( /"1/ /"# !#)@5, ,3'-) #) .-,# *=#1,=2 ')/#6,1/#3 /"# ,3#A I/ '3 "1,( /-

    @5(6# >#/7##) /"# -/"#, /7- ;-33'>'='/'#3A L')*# /"'3 '3 /"# +',3/ /'.# /"# 1))-/1/-, "13 .#)/'-)#()/'61,>"1 7"'=# 7,'/')6 )-/#3 -) 3-.# #'6"/2T+' +-='-3 -+ /#?/< 1)( 3')*# )/'61,>"1 '3 1=3- )-/ )1.#(

    ') 1) 15/"-,'1= *-=-;"-)< '/ 3##.3 5)='E#=2 /"# 1))-/1/-, '3 1335.')6 7# 7'== /1E# )/'61,>"1 13 !"#$%% G315/"-,A X5/ #) '+ "# '3 3566#3/')6 .#,#=2 /"1/ 3-.# =')#3 *-.;-3#( >2 )/'61,>"1 1,# >#')6 (,17) 5;-)

    NO (# ,#+#,,#( /- Y13 d;,1 ># 3#d[ ') :! WW Y01)/7#== 1)( V12#, O\\ZM ]\[< :1(.131.>"1&1 ') 3#,1= Y:! WW"1 ') IKb !'> c SON_ U'.1=1.'/,1 Y>2# .1 =1 .5 /,1< +AN[ ') IKb !'> c ]WW 1)( IKb !'> c]ZZ Y-) ,-31,'#3[_ V1a@5 , .'/,1< H E1,1 Y1)( X5(("165;/1[ ') IKb !'> c N^^W Y (

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    51/53

    !"#$"%"$&'"(") +', !"#$% '"#(% "-# .+% /0$$,-+"12 34

    "-# .-%,1+,# ',1,) 5, '"(, %,,- +'"+ +', 67"8,$,-+ 09 +', (,1%, "66,"1% +0 9.+ "661061."+,72 "% +', +,:+;% 05-9.-"7 970

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    52/53

    !"# %&'(#)*# +,-. /"# 0-..#)/1,2 1)( '/3 45)"51)6 7'/)#33 89

    :) /"# -/"#, "1)(; '+ /"# 1))-/1/'-) .#1)3; < !"#$"%"$&'"(" #*$+,%-."-*% /-'"- -'0%1 0% ,+- ",0#0+%2,3."-03 3.*"-0+,/#,)1/'>2; /"# 1))-/1/'-) .'6"/ )-/ =# 0,-*.7.*-0,8 /"# *-..#)/1,'1> 7-,(3; =5/')3/#1( #)>1,6')6 5?-) 1)( 1((')6 /- /"#', ')/#,?,#/1/'-) -+ !" 3 /#1*"')6B @1(.131.="1&1A3 (#.-)3/,1/'-)7-5>( /"#) =# #.=-('#( ') /"# 7-,(3 -+ !" 1=- *-)*#,)')6 /"# 7,1/" 7'/" /"# )1/5,1> *-)('/'-) -+31.#)#33; ?,-(5*')6 &1G,1 1=3-,?/'-) 1)( #.1)1/'-)B

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

    ?,-(5*#( ; ?1,/ -+ /"# *-..#)/ =#)#1/" /"# 7-,(; >8.*? 7"> D3+$$*,-".2 E; ,1/"#, /"1) 1??#)(')6 '/ /- /"# *-..#)/ *-))#*/#( 7'/" /"# 7-,(; &%#5% 7" D %5$$".0J*# EB C/

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

    0>#1,>2; K5#3/'-)3 3/'>> #J'3/ 1=-5/ /"#3# ,#+#,#)*#3 /- @1(.131.="1&1B 4- /"#2 3566#3/ /"1/

    @1(.131.="1&1 713 1 6,#1/ *-..#)/1/-, -, /"1/ "# ')3?',#( /"# /#1*"')63 6') ') ;#, -+ /1)/,13U H# 1,# 5)1=># +5>>2 /- ,#3-> /"#3# '335#3B :)#*-)*>53'-) +,-. /"'3 #J1.')1/'-) -+ @1(.131.="1&1A3 *-))#*/'-) 7'/" ;< 1)( ;1,;

    ?#,"1?3 #('/')6 1 /#J/ -, *-.?-3')6 '/3 *-..#)/1,2B V1/"#,; /"# +')1> ,3# -+ ;-6'3#( 13 1 +5>>2 ,#1>'3#( 1)( 7-)(,-53 /1)/,'* .13/#,; #5>-6'3#( ')

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

  • 8/10/2019 A Noble Noose of Methods Academia

    53/53

    !"#$"%"$&'"(") +', !"#$% '"#(% "-# .+% /0$$,-+"12 34

    +', %"$, +,1$% 5, 6.-# 7%,# 06 '.$ .- 82"-9 1":;% '"9.091"