a historical survey of indonesia’s maritime boundary ......the black sea case (romania v ukraine),...
TRANSCRIPT
-
A Historical Survey of
Indonesia’s Maritime Boundary Agreements
Symposium on Maritime Boundaries in the Timor Sea: Perspectives in International Law
Melbourne, 15 February 2016
I Made Andi Arsana, Ph.D Department of Geodetic Engineering
Universitas Gadjah Mada
Jointly organised by: Castan Centre for Human Rights,
the School of Social Sciences at Monash University
&
Swinburne University of Technology
-
A story from the Malacca Strait – 7 April 2011
I Made Andi Arsana © 2011
I Made Andi Arsana © 2011
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($,-"./,0"
-
Outline
• !(%1(&+)$"$(%"2/&"3$4"15"2/&"6&$"
• #$*)78&"91(&"15":;*)+%)"8$*)78&"?1;(%$*)&+"
• !(%1(&+)$B';+2*$=)$"$(%"!(%1(&+)$BC)81*"3&+2&"
#$*)78&"?1;(%$*)&+"
• D1("E&8$*F+""
-
Indonesia and
the Law of the Sea
-
International Negotiation
-
This presentation was developed by
I Made Andi Arsana
For the Government of Somalia
and was presented before the Somali President,
Prime Minister and Speaker of the Parliament
G$+&=)(&+"
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"HIJKLM"
NNO"
'*2,"PQ"IJJ"#"
D1(7(&(2$="
6/&=5"
C&**)21*)$="
6&$"
KI"#"
Maritime Zone of Jurisdiction pursuant to UNCLOS
-
Normal Baselines and Maritime Limits
R/S"%1"S1;"4$(2"21"2$F&"2/)+"1TU"R/$2"S1;"$*&"%1)(>")+"$"
-
A
Circle
at A
X X
Sea
Land Animation by Arsana & Schofield, 2014
Straight baselines and maritime limits
Tech
-
'*);1;+"O1(&"
NNO"
NNO"
NNO"
NNO"
W"3CN"G"
3CN"'"
!"#$
%#&'$
(&)*#+,&$-.$(/0#$1$!23,4"5'6$7897$
An Archipelagic State’s maritime zones pursuant to UNCLOS
-
State A
Imagine, a small State in the middle of the ocean. Alone
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"H
-
But !.
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"H
-
This presentation was developed by
I Made Andi Arsana
For the Government of Somalia
and was presented before the Somali President,
Prime Minister and Speaker of the Parliament
62$2&"'"
62$2&"G"
62$2&"D"
62$2&"0"
62$2&"'"
62$2&"G"
Principles & Methods of Maritime Boundary Delimitation
(/0#$789:$
;,/@,0"0$,&5.$$
NNOXD6"?1;(%$*S""
B1AA1+)2&B"
H'*2,"PYXZL"[\D3]6M"
C6"?1;(%$*S"
B$%:$
-
Malaysia
Malaysia
Philippines
Palau
Australia
India
Thailand
EEZ
EEZ
EEZ
EEZ
Archipelagic waters
Territorial Sea
Singapore
Timor Leste
R/S"%1"S1;"4$(2"21"2$F&"2/)+"1TU"R/$2"S1;"$*&"%1)(>")+"$"
-
Java, Christmas Island and Australia
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($,-"./,0"
-
Settled
Maritime Boundaries
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($,-"./,0"
-
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"H")+"$"
-
Indonesia
Australia
Indonesia-Australia-Timor Leste
'+/81*&"!+=$(%+"
6"*)>/2+"
1700s " ‘Indonesians’ came to fish
Official claim by the British (1878)
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"H
-
';+2*$=)$"
F"
!(%1(&+)$"
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"H(&%")(KdPJ$(M"
R/S"%1"S1;"4$(2"21"2$F&"2/)+"1TU"R/$2"S1;"$*&"%1)(>")+"$"&-"&)2/&*"$*&"
)881?)=&"1("1*";(%&*"2/&"+&$?&%"1*"
$*&";($?=&"21"81h&"&c
-
Philippines
Indonesia
23 May 2014
Indonesia-Philippines
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($,-"./,0"
A 20 year negotiation
Two Archipelagic States
Archipelagic Baselines
H&5.$IIJ6$$
&,
-
Q"^"Y"
L"
I"
K"
Q^̂YY
I
YYY
LLLL
III
K
E.j"IIY,IIK,^JZ"F8I"
E!j"IIY,LQZ-ZYY"F8I"
Indonesia-Philippines
-
Indonesia-Singapore
P1
P2
P3
P4
P5
P6
1A 1B 1C
I Made Andi Arsana © 2014
P7 P8
25 March 1973
10 March 2009
3 September 2014
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($,-"./,0"
-
Pending
Maritime Boundaries
-
k" I Made Andi Arsana © 2011
I Made Andi Arsana © 2011
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($,-"./,0"
.&(%)(>"NNO"?1;(%$*)&+"4/&*&"D1(7(&(2$="6/&=5"?1;(%$*)&+"&c)+2+"
-
#$=$S+)$"
F"
!(%1(&+)$"
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"H")+"$"0
-
Proposing a 3D EEZ Delimitation [?]
F"
a 3D EEE3D EProposing aa
!"#$%&"'(%)"'*+$($"H
-
Two different proposals & a negotiated line [?]
k" I Made Andi Arsana © 2011
R/S"%1"S1;"4$(2"21"2$F&"2/)+"1TU"R/$2"S1;"$*&"%1)(>")+"$"
-
!(%1(&+)$"#$=$S+)$"
Spratly Islands
6)(>$A1*&"
Cambodia Vietnam
Philippines
!>5>$!"#"
South China Sea (.0)0$#&'$(&)*#+,&$-.$G$O#'"$(&')$(/0#$
"
E&$==S?"
Indonesia and the complexity of the SCS
-
"
!(%1(&+)$BC)81*"3&+2&""
#$*)78&"G1;(%$*)&+"
-
#$*)"'=F$7*)j"f+;17$71(+-"&+A&
-
Recent Development
26 Aug 15 18 Sept 15
Jo
int
co
mm
un
iqu
é b
etw
een
Pre
sid
en
t Jo
ko
W
ido
do
an
d P
M R
ui M
ari
a d
e A
rau
jo
Fir
st
Co
nsu
ltati
on
Meeti
ng
, D
illi
Fir
st
tech
nic
al m
eeti
ng
29-30 Oct 15
Seco
nd
Co
nsu
ltati
on
Meeti
ng
, S
ura
baya
First quarter of 2016
• G$+&%"1("[\D3]6"
• Nc&"15"?$+&A1)(2+"
$(%"?$+&=)(&+"
• Rr6"KdZY"51*">&1%&7*&&%"
-
0)=)"HN$+2"C)81*M"
R&+2"C)81*"H!(%1(&+)$M"
]&
-
n,,,o"f(&)2/&*"15"2/&"241"62$2&+")+"&(72=&%-"5$)=)(>"$>*&&8&(2"?&24&&("2/&8"21"2/&"
-
"fC/&"%&=)8)2$71("15"&c
-
State A
The Three-stage Approach
State B
.*1h)+)1($="=)(&j""
&u;)%)+2$(
-
Issues in Indonesia-Timor Leste Maritime Boundaries
R/S"%1"S1;"4$(2"21"2$F&"2/)+"1TU"R/$2"S1;"$*&"%1)(>")+"$"
-
Delimitation option: Indonesia v Timor Leste
R/S"%1"S1;"4$(2"21"2$F&"2/)+"1TU"R/$2"S1;"$*&"%1)(>")+"$"
-
Batek Island
C$F&("5*18"r11>=&"N$*2/"
-
Options for Lateral Boundaries
!23,4"5'$#&'$(/0#$788P$
-
G$F1+;*2$($=-"IJKJ"G$G$G$G$G$F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1F1+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;+;*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2*2$($($=$=-"IJIJKJ"
Delimitation option: Indonesia v Timor Leste (RI)
BIG, 2015
-
Concluding Remarks
• !(%1(&+)$"/$+"2&("(&)>/?1;*+"21"%&$="4)2/"51*"8$*)78&"?1;(%$*S"%&=)8)2$71("
• 6&@=&%-"A$*7$==S"1*"5;==S-"4)2/"&)>/2"(&)>/?1;*+"
• Kd"$>*&&8&(2+-"K"S&2"21"*$75S"
• '=="$>*&&8&(2+"?S"(&>17$71("
• R)2/"';+2*$=)$-"$=="+&@=&%,"G1;(%$*S"$%8)()+2*$71(X8$($>&8&(2"51==14+"
• R)2/"C)81*"3&+2&-"(1"$>*&&8&(2"S&2,"\&>17$71(")+"1("A*1>*&++,"
-
THANK YOU