a guide to cases of possibility in syllogism

1
A Guide to Cases of Possibility in Syllogism =================================== Case I: When we know that All X are Y (i) No X is Y — not possible (ii) Some X are Y — certain (iii) Some X are not Y — not possible (iv) All X are not Y — not possible Case II: When we know that No X is Y (i) All X are Y — not possible (ii) Some X are Y — not possible (iii) Some X are not Y — certain (iv) All X are not Y — certain Case III: When we know that Some X are Y (i) All X are Y — possible (ii) No X is Y — not possible (iii) Some X are not Y — possible (iv) All X are not Y — possible Case IV: When we know that Some X are not Y (i) All X are Y — not possible (ii) No X is Y — possible (iii) Some X are Y — possible (iv) All X are not Y — possible Case V: When we have no conclusion between X and Y (i) All X are Y — possible (ii) No X is Y — possible (iii) Some X are Y — possible (iv) Some X are not Y — possible (v) All X are not Y — possible Note: Since certainty means 100% possibility, all cases of certainty also qualify to be considered as possible.

Upload: saketshourav

Post on 03-Dec-2015

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

syllogs

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Guide to Cases of Possibility in Syllogism

A Guide to Cases of Possibility in Syllogism

===================================

Case I: When we know that All X are Y

(i) No X is Y — not possible

(ii) Some X are Y — certain

(iii) Some X are not Y — not possible

(iv) All X are not Y — not possible

Case II: When we know that No X is Y

(i) All X are Y — not possible

(ii) Some X are Y — not possible

(iii) Some X are not Y — certain

(iv) All X are not Y — certain

Case III: When we know that Some X are Y

(i) All X are Y — possible

(ii) No X is Y — not possible

(iii) Some X are not Y — possible

(iv) All X are not Y — possible

Case IV: When we know that Some X are not Y

(i) All X are Y — not possible

(ii) No X is Y — possible

(iii) Some X are Y — possible

(iv) All X are not Y — possible

Case V: When we have no conclusion between X and Y

(i) All X are Y — possible

(ii) No X is Y — possible

(iii) Some X are Y — possible

(iv) Some X are not Y — possible

(v) All X are not Y — possible

Note: Since certainty means 100% possibility, all cases of certainty also qualify to be considered as possible.