a contract for the industry - iadc dredging€¦ · the fidic task group • john greenhalgh...

25
2 nd EDITION FIDIC BLUE BOOK: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY BY JOHN GREENHALGH & TIM MADDOCK 24 October

Upload: others

Post on 19-Oct-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

2nd EDITION FIDIC BLUE BOOK:

A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY

BY JOHN GREENHALGH & TIM MADDOCK

24 October

Page 2: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

GENESIS

1977

1987

1999 2001 (test), 2006 (1st)

2016

Page 3: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

THE FIDIC TASK GROUP

• John Greenhalgh (Chair).

• Edward Corbett (Lawyer).

• Roger Maddrell (Engineer).

• Tim Maddock (IADC).

• Marnix Vandenberghe (IADC).

The FIDIC Contracts Committee has the

ultimate decision on the form and content.

Page 4: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

GOALS

• To be an industry specific standard form of contract.

• To set a clear and balanced contracting basis.

• To promote efficient procurement, management and execution of

dredging projects.

Page 5: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

APPROACH

• Reflect current practice.

• Reinforce its specialist nature.

• Keep it simple and practicable.

• Follow FIDIC terms and styles:

• contract data;

• general risks;

• sub-clause referencing.

But not to make changes for changes sake

Page 6: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

RE-STATEMENT OF ORIGINAL GUIDELINES (1)

• “in dredging and reclamation work, the Contractor is not normally held

responsible for the maintenance of the dredging work after taking-over; and

the areas of dredging are usually taken over in Sections as they are

completed;

Page 7: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

RE-STATEMENT OF ORIGINAL GUIDELINES (2)

• the Contractor can only work economically if he is allowed to work continuously by

day and by night; and

• equipment costs (mobilisation, use and demobilisation) form a much higher

proportion of total cost in the case of a dredging contract than is generally the case

with construction contracts. The cost of delays can therefore be significant.”

Page 8: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

NOTES FOR GUIDANCE

• Longer than the Conditions (19 pages).

• Detailed industry specific guidance.

• Not part of the final contract.

Page 9: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

ESSENTIAL PRE-CONTRACT INFORMATION, SOIL & SITE

• Soils information:

• boreholes with testing;

• vibro cores;

• cone penetration testing;

• bed sampling and relevant testing;

• seismic, side scan & magnetometer surveys.

• Reclamation Information.

• Ordnance and obstructions.

• Environmental studies.

Page 10: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

PERMITS & LICENSES: SUB-CLAUSE 2.2

• Employer:

• planning;

• zoning and

• other similar permission required

for the permanent work.

• Contractor:

• all other.

Page 11: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

PRICING, MEASUREMENT AND PAYMENT

• Flexibility for lump sum or remeasurement.

• Method of measurement.

• Bill of Quantities.

• Idle rates.

Page 12: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

CONTRACT STRUCTURE

Engineer

Contractor

Employer

Page 13: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

CONTRACT DATA

• A title with meaning.

• An opportunity for the parties.

Page 14: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

PROJECT SPECIFIC DATA (1/2)

• Commencement Date.

• Documents forming the Contract.

• Name of the Engineer.

• Time for Completion.

• Dredging Works.

• Law & Language.

• Notices, fees and other charges by Employer.

• Contractor’s design (if any).

Page 15: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

PROJECT SPECIFIC DATA (2/2)

• Interruptions for ship movements.

• Climatic / hydrological conditions.

• Delay Damages.

• Working Hours restrictions (if any).

• Currency of payment.

• Valuation type (lump sum, remeasure ..).

• Limitation of Liability.

• Dispute Adjudication Board.

Page 16: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

INSURANCE

Page 17: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

GENERAL CONDITIONS: 15 CLAUSES

1. General Provisions.

2. The Employer.

3. The Engineer.

4. The Contractor.

5. Design.

6. Defined Risks.

7. Time for Completion.

8. Taking-Over.

9. Remedying Defects.

10. Variations and Claims.

11. Contract Price and Payment.

12. Default.

13. Risk and Responsibility.

14. Insurance.

15. Resolution of Disputes.

Page 18: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

DESIGN: CLAUSE 5 RESPONSIBILITY FOR DESIGN (1/2)

• “The Contractor shall be responsible for his tendered design

and design under Sub-Clause 5.1 [Contractor's Design],

every element of which shall be fit for the intended purposes

as specified in the Contract or, where no purposes are

specified, fit for their ordinary purposes.

Page 19: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

DESIGN: CLAUSE 5 RESPONSIBILITY FOR DESIGN (2/2)

• The Employer shall be responsible for

the Specification and Drawings.”

Page 20: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

DEFINED RISKS: CLAUSE 6.1

One list of Defined Risks:

• Clear allocation of risk and responsibility;

• Promotes effective budget management;

• Straightforward to modify.

Sub-Clause 10.3 - Early Warning:

• Each Party shall notify;

• Entitlement based on had prompt notice been given.

Notice is not a condition precedent.

Page 21: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

CHANGES TO DEFINED RISKS

• Munitions.

• Piracy.

• Exceptional Events.

• Change in law.

• Ship interruptions.

• Hydrological conditions.

Page 22: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

ALIGNMENT WITH RAINBOW SUITE

• Performance security.

• Employer’s financial arrangements.

• Limitation of liability:

• exclusion of so called indirect and consequential loss;

• cap on liability.

Page 23: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

USAGE OF THE FIRST EDITION

• Widespread in India, Indonesia, Nigeria and the Philippines.

• Growing usage in Central and South America.

• Low usage in UK and Europe.

Page 24: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

AIM FOR SECOND EDITION

• Wider usage.

• Translations in Spanish, Portuguese,

French, German and Russian.

“most beneficial distribution of risks is to allocate each risk to the party that is best able to deal with and handle that particular risk. Such risk distribution will in general lead to the lowest contract price” FIDIC Procurement Procedure Guide

Page 25: A CONTRACT FOR THE INDUSTRY - IADC Dredging€¦ · THE FIDIC TASK GROUP • John Greenhalgh (Chair). • Edward Corbett (Lawyer). • Roger Maddrell (Engineer). • Tim Maddock (IADC)

TIME FOR QUESTIONS

• We shall try to respond all questions immediately.

• Answers to complicated questions will be sent by e-mail.