7 buck morss walter benjamin between academic fashion and the avant-garde

9
8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 1/9 Walter Beniamin: Between Academic Fashion and the Avant Garde i L usan Buck-Mons* m 3 Abstract In the present context of the triumph of capitalisrn over real socialisrn,this article points out that, despite their ideological differentes, both Systems are bound to the same conception of history-as-progress. In contrast, it recalls Walter Benjamin s philosophy of history, marked by the critique of progress in the narne of a revoIutionary time, which interrupts history s chronological continuurn. Benjamin s perspective is used to study the contlict of ternporalities among the Soviet artists in the two decades after the October Revolution: on the one hand, the anarchic, autonomous and critical time of interruption -which is the time of avant gade - on the other hand, the synchronization with the ideas of a progressive time as ordeted y the Comrnunist Patty; this is the time o vanguard, whose capitalist Counterpart is fashion. Kcywords Philosophy of history; Walter Benjamin; Soviet Avant-Garde. Rcsumo Nestes ternpos de triunfo do capitalismo sobre o socialismo real, o presente artigo rnostra que, apesar de suas diferences ideologicas, ambos OS sistemas baseiam- se nurna concepcäo da hist6ria como progresso. Contrastivamente, lernbrada a filosofia da historia de Walter Benjamin, rnarcada pela critica do progresso e ? concepcäo de um ternpo revolucionirio, quc interrompe o continuurn histiirico. A luz da teoria benjaminiana estudado o conflito de concepgöes de tempo entre OS artistas soviiticos das duas dicadas posteriores Revolucäo de Outubr o de 19 17: de um lado, o tempo da interruppo, anirquico, autonomo e critico - ue 6 o tempo da i The author is ProfessorofPoliticalPhilosophy and SocialTheory at Cornell University, USA.

Upload: martel78

Post on 02-Jun-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 1/9

Walter Beniamin:

Between Academic Fashion and the

A v a n t G a r d e

i L

usan

Buck-Mons*

m

3

Abstract In the present con text of the trium ph o f capitalisrn over real socialisrn, this

article points ou t that, despite their ideological differentes, both Systems are bound to

the same conception o f history-as-progress. In contrast, it recalls Walter Benjamin s

philosophy of history, marked by the critique of progress

in

the

narne of a revoIutionary

time, which in terru pts history s chronological continuurn. Benjamin s perspective is

used to stu dy the contlict of ternporalities amo ng the Soviet artists in the two decades

after the October Revolution: on the one hand, the anarchic, autono mou s and critical

time of interruption -which is the time

of

avant gade - on the other hand, the

synchronization with the ideas of a progressive time as ordeted y the Comrnunist

Patty; this is the time o van gua rd, whose capitalist Counterpart is fashion.

Kcywords Philosophy of history; Walter Benjamin; Soviet Avant-Garde.

Rcsumo

Nestes ternpos de triunfo d o capitalismo sobre o socialismo real, o presente

artigo rnostra que, apesar de suas diferences ideologicas, ambos

OS

sistemas baseiam-

se nurna concepcäo da hist6ria como progresso. Contra stivamen te, lernbrad a a

filosofia da historia de Walter Benjamin, rnarcada pela critica do progresso e ?

concepcäo de

um

ternpo revolucionirio, quc interrompe

o

continuurn histiirico.

A

luz da teoria benjaminiana estudad o o conflito de concepgöes de tempo entre OS

artistas soviiticos das duas dicad as posteriores Revolucäo de Ou tu br o de 19

17:

de

um lado, o tempo da inter rup po, anirquico, autonomo e critico

-

ue

6

o tempo da

i

The author is Professor ofPolitica lPhilosophy and Socia lTheorya t Cornell University,

USA.

Page 2: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 2/9

Page 3: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 3/9

Page 4: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 4/9

Page 5: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 5/9

Page 6: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 6/9

Page 7: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 7/9

Page 8: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 8/9

Page 9: 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

8/10/2019 7 Buck Morss Walter Benjamin Between Academic Fashion and the Avant-Garde

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-buck-morss-walter-benjamin-between-academic-fashion-and-the-avant-garde 9/9